[0001] The present invention relates to a method of casting an article and more specifically
to a method of casting a metal article formed of a plurality of elongated crystals
having a desired orientation.
[0002] The concept of casting an article, such as a turbine blade, with elongated crystals
having a [001] direction parallel to the longitudinal axis of the article is disclosed
in U.S.-A-3,485,291. The method disclosed in this US-specification is characterized
by initial solidification of the molten metal occurring in a competitive growth zone
adjacent to a chill with the longitudinal direction of the article's mold cavity being
aligned perpendicular to the chill surface.
[0003] This competitive growth zone occurs because when a face-centered cubic metal is cast
against a chill, the initial crystals which are formed will not all have the desired
[001] orientation, but rather will be substantially randomly aligned. Since solidifying
dentrites in the molten metal grow most favorably in the [001] direction, as solidification
proceeds from the chill, those dentrites having an [001] orientation perpendicular
to the chill will grow preferentially along the longitudinal axis of the article.
Eventually, the preferred dentrites will emerge from the competitive growth zone and
result in a series of columnar grains or crystals having a [001 ] direction oriented
in the growth direction. The function of the growth zone from which the preferred
or [001] aligned columnar grains emerge is to eliminate from the cast article crystals
or grains having an off axis orientation.
[0004] After casting, the growth zone is cut off the article and is either discarded or
reused to make a new lot of melt stock or so-called master metal, for subsequent casting.
The growth zone contributes to casting costs through the use of additional metal,
wax material used in producing the pattern for mold making, and additional ceramic
material for the mold.
[0005] Although the [001 direction of crystallographic orientation which results from directional
solidification in the manner disclosed in the aforementioned US specification has
certain desirable characteristics, such as improved thermal fatigue resistance, it
is well known that other crystallographic directions of orientations can yield higher
creep strength and Young's modulus values. For certain applications, higher creep
strength and Young's modulus values can be important. However, the obtaining of the
crystallographic directions of orientation which yield the higher strength and Young's
modulus values cannot be done with conventional directional solidification techniques.
[0006] In the past, crystal orientation during the casting of a single crystal article has
been controlled through the use of seeds or solid pieces of single crystal material.
During casting, metal solidification proceeds from the single crystal seed and causes
propagation of a single crystal in an entire casting cavity. Control of the seed temperature
and suitable means of cooling the molds are needed to achieve the desired effect in
a manner which is further described in US-A-1,793,672; 3,139,653; 3,759,310; 3,857,436;
and 4,015,657. However, the methods disclosed in these specifications have used single
crystal seeds to cause the formation of single crystal articles rather than directionally
solidified articles having a plurality of elongated crystals with the desired crystallographic
orientation.
[0007] GB-A-1256348 and 1426805 drawn to our attention in the examination of the present
application disclose the casting of directionally solidified articles formed of elongated
metal crystals utilizing a chill and the casting of single crystal articles using
a single crystal seed located on a chill.
[0008] GB-A-2037200 also drawn to our attention in the examination of the present application,
discloses the use of a single crystal seed in the formation of a single article wherein
the seed crystal and mold are orientated in fixed orientation to the chill in order
to obtain a desired polar orientation of the single crystal of the cast article about
its longitudinal axis.
[0009] In an effort to obtain an article having an elongated crystal structure with oriented
grains or crystals, GB-A-870,213 teaches the use of a seed slab or starter in the
manufacture of ingots having preferred crystallographic properties. The seed slab
or starter element has elongated grains oriented so that the (100) crystallographic
planes, which correspond to the sides of body-centered unit cells, are substantially
perpendicular to the longitudinal axes of elongated grains or crystals of the seed
slab. The other sides of the unit cells, that is the sides which extended parallel
to the longitudinal axes of the grains or crystals, are randomly oriented and are
only occasionally parallel to similar crystal planes in other elongated grains or
crystals.
[0010] During a casting operation, the seed slab or starter element of GB-A-870213 is placed
at the bottom of a mold with the longitudinal axes of the crystals extending horizontally,
that is perpendicular to the longitudinal axis of the mold. Molten metal is then poured
into the mold cavity against the seed slab. The resulting directionally solidified
article is formed of elongated crystals or grains having unit cells oriented so as
to have a pair of side surfaces extending perpendicular to the longitudinal axes of
the crystals or grains and other side surfaces extending parallel to the longitudinal
axis of the crystals or grains. The crystallographic orientation along the longitudinal
axis is [001], the same as produced through directional solidification in the making
of aforementioned gas turbine articles by competitive crystal growth from a chill
surface. Hence, this art does not teach how directions other than (001) could be achieved
along the longitudinal axis of the article, cast perpendicular to the chill surface,
in order to obtain desired changes in strength or Young's modulus.
[0011] An object of the present invention is to provide a method of casting a directionally
solidified article formed of elongated metal crystal having generally parallel longitudinal
axes utilising a starter element in which the formation of a competitive growth zone
is avoided and which is suitable for forming articles with any desired unit cell orientation.
[0012] In accordance with the invention such a method comprises the steps of providing a
one-piece starter element which has a plurality of elongated metal crystals disposed
in a side-by-side relationship with longitudinal axes which are substantially perpendicular
to first and second sides of the starter element and with the second side of the starter
element being formed by ends of the elongated metal crystals, providing a chill, providing
a mold having an open end portion and a cavity in which the article is to be cast,
positioning the starter element in the open end portion of the mold with the first
side of the starter element exposed to the chill and the second side of the starter
element exposed to the mold cavity, pouring molten metal into the mold cavity, and
initiating the formation in the mold cavity of a plurality of elongated metal crystals
having longitudinal axes extending substantially parallel to the longitudinal axes
of the elongated metal crystals in the starter element, said step of initiating the
formation of metal crystals in the mold cavity including the step of engaging the
ends of the elongated metal crystals at the second side of the starter element with
the molten metal while the first side of the starter element is exposed to the chill.
[0013] By having the elongated crystals in the starter element oriented with their longitudinal
axes extending parallel to the direction of crystal growth in the mold cavity, molten
metal which is poured into the mold cavity comes into contact with the ends of the
longitudinally extending grains or crystals in the starter element. This results in
the nucleation of a multiplicity of crystals having the same orientation as the crystals
in the starter element. The nucleation of directionally oriented crystals at the starter
element eliminates the competitive growth zone which characterizes most prior directional
solidification casting processes.
[0014] The longitudinally extending crystals which are nucleated at the ends of the crystals
in the starter element have unit cells which are disposed in the same orientation
as the unit cells of the starter element. By providing a starter element having elongated
crystals with unit cells having their side surfaces skewed or extending at an acute
angle to the longitudinal axes of the crystals of the starter element, longitudinally
extending crystals with unit cells having a similar orientation will be formed in
the cast article. It is preferred to orient the unit cells in the starter element
in various preselected longitudinal directions to effect the solidification of a cast
article having an elongated crystal structure with the unit cells oriented in the
same direction. The choice of orientation depends on the specific performance characteristics
desired in the article.
[0015] As an example of how change in crystal direction can be used to change Young's modulus
in the case of a nickel-base superalloy, a casting directionally solidified with elongated
crystals having a (001) direction parallel to the longitudinal axis of the crystals
will have an ambient temperature Young's modulus of approximately 18,000,000 pounds
per square inch (124,000,000 kPa). The same nickel-base superalloy casting would have
an ambient temperature Young's modulus in a direction along the casting axis of about
44,000,000 pounds per square inch (303,000,000 kPa) if the longitudinal orientation
of elongated crystals were to lie in the (111) direction. Although the method of the
present invention can be used in casting many different types of products, the method
is advantageously used to cast airfoils with the elongated crystals or grains having
longitudinal axes extending substantially parallel to a longitudinal direction of
the airfoil.
[0016] In order that the invention may be well understood, an embodiment thereof, which
is given by way of example only, will now be described, reference being had to the
accompanying drawings, in which:
Fig. 1 is a schematic illustration depicting the manner in which a mold is supported
on a chill with starter elements exposed to the chill and to mold cavities prior to
pouring of molten metal into the mold;
Fig. 2 is an enlarged fragmentary sectional view illustrating the relationship between
a starter element, a mold cavity, and chill of Fig. 1;
Fig. 3 is an enlarged, somewhat schematicized, illustration of the starter element
of Fig. 2;
Fig. 4 is an illustration of an airfoil cast with the starter element of Fig. 3 and
schematically illustrating the orientation of a unit cell of an elongated grain or
crystal in the airfoil; and
Fig. 5 is an enlarged schematic illustration further illustrating the orientation
of a unit cell of one of the elongated grains or crystals of the airfoil of Fig. 4,
the structure of the unit cell being simplified in Fig. 5 for purposes of clarity
of illustration.
[0017] A mold 10 (Fig. 1) is preheated in a known furnace assembly 12 prior to pouring of
molten metal into the mold. The known furnace assembly 12 is provided with a refractory
outer wall 16 which is surrounded by an induction heating coil 18. A graphite susceptor
wall 20 is enclosed by the outer wall 16 and is heated by the induction effect of
the coil 18. The furnace assembly 12 has a top plate 22 with an opening which may
be provided with a funnel 24 through which molten metal is poured into the mold 10.
It is contemplated that the entire furnace assembly 12 will be disposed within a vacuum
furnace.
[0018] The mold 10 has a pouring basin 32 through which molten metal enters a plurality
of runners or passages 34 which are connected with a plurality of mold cavities 38
which are disposed in a circular array around the pouring basin 32. A cylindrical
heat shield 40 may be provided on the inside of the circular array of mold cavities-38.
[0019] The mold 10 is disposed on a copper chill plate 42. The chill plate 42 promotes the
directional solidification of molten metal in the mold cavities to provide a casting
having a columnar grain structure with a grain orientation extending generally parallel
to the longitudinal central axes (vertical axes) of the mold cavities 38. It should
be noted that although the furnace 12 and mold 10 could have many different constructions,
they have the same general construction as the furnace and mold disclosed in US-A-3,680,625.
[0020] A starter element 50 (see Fig. 2) is positioned in the lower end portion of the mold
cavity 38. The cylindrical starter element 50 is exposed both to the chill 42 and
to the mold cavity 38. Thus, a lower or bottom side surface 54 of the starter element
50 is disposed in abutting engagement with an upper or top side surface 56 of the
chill 42. The opposite side surface 58 of the starter element 50 is directly exposed
to the mold cavity 38.
[0021] When molten metal is poured into the funnel 24 and basin 32 to the runners 34 and
mold cavity 38, the molten metal flows downwardly against the upper side surface 58
of the starter element 50. Due to the rapid conduction of heat from the starter element
50 to the chill 42, solidification of the molten metal in the mold cavity 38 is initiated
at the upper side surface 58 of the starter element 50. As solidification of the molten
metal proceeds upwardly in the mold cavity 38, the chill 42 and mold 10 are advantageously
lowered to withdraw the mold from the furnace 12 in a known manner.
[0022] The starter element 50 is formed of a plurality of elongated metal crystals or grains
62 (see Fig. 3) disposed in a side-by-side relationship with longitudinal axes which
are substantially perpendicular to the opposite side surfaces 54 and 58 of the starter
element which are formed by ends of crystals 62. The large majority of the crystal
62 extend completely through the starter element 50.
[0023] Generally in the embodiments, the elongated grains 62 have one transverse end disposed
in the circular side surface 54 and the opposite transverse end disposed in the circular
side surface 58. A few of the longitudinally extending grains 62 may terminate between
the two side surfaces 54 and 58. However, all of the grains which end at the side
surface 58 have an opposite end at the side surface 54. The elongated grains or crystals
62 have longitudinal axes which extend perpendicular to the side surfaces 54 and 58
and which are disposed in a parallel relationship with a longitudinal central axis
66 (Fig. 2) of the mold cavity 38.
[0024] Since the elongated crystals 62 (Fig. 3) have ends disposed in the upper surface
58 of the starter element 50, each of the starter element crystals can effect nucleation
of a corresponding longitudinally extending crystal or grain in the molten metal in
the mold cavity 38 upon initiation of solidification of the molten metal. This results
in the molten metal in the cavity 38 solidifying in a multiplicity of longitudinally
extending crystals or grains having their origin at the surface 58 of the starter
element 50 and extending parallel to a longitudinal central axis 66 of the mold cavity
38. The elongated crystals which are solidified in the mold cavity 38 have longitudinal
axes which extend parallel to the mold axis 66 (Fig. 2) and the longitudinal axes
of the grains 62 in the starter element 50. Due to nucleation of the grains in the
cast product in the desired orientation at the end surface 58 of the starter element,
the competitive growth zone which characterizes many known directional solidification
processes where the desired longitudinal direction is [001] can be eliminated.
[0025] In the event it is desired to provide the cast article being formed in the mold cavity
38 with a fine grained structure, the starter element 50 has a fine grain structure
so that an array of closely packed and relatively small crystal end portions are provided
in the surface 58. This results in the formation of a corresponding number of longitudinally
extending crystals or grains in the mold cavity 38. Since these grains nucleate at
the end surface 58 of the starter element 50, the molten metal solidifies in the mold
cavity 38 with a fine grained structure extending substantially throughout the entire
length of the mold cavity and with the grains or elongated crystals extending parallel
to the axis 66.
[0026] Although it is contemplated that the mold 10 could be constructed with the cavities
38 to form different types of articles, the mold 10 is advantageously used to form
a directionally solidified airfoil 70 (see Fig. 4). The airfoil 70 has a leading edge
portion 74 and a trailing edge portion 76 which extend between a root end portion
78 and a tip end portion 80 of the airfoil. It should be understood that the configuration
of the airfoil 70 has been indicated schematically in Fig. 4 and is merely representative
of many known airfoil configurations.
[0027] When the airfoil 70 is to be cast, molten metal is poured into the mold cavity 38.
Although many different types of metal could be utilized, it is contemplated that
the molten metal may be a nickel-base superalloy. When the molten metal engages the
upper side surface 58 of the starter element 50, elongated columnar crystals or grains
86 (see Fig. 4) are nucleated at the end surfaces of the elongated crystals or grains
62 in the starter element 50. This results in the airfoil 70 having a multi-grained
elongated crystal structure which corresponds to the multi-grained elongated crystal
structure of the starter element 50.
[0028] The elongated grains or crystals 86 in the directionally solidified airfoil 70 have
longitudinal axes which extend parallel to the longitudinal axes of the grains 62
in the starter element 50 and to a longitudinal central axis 88 of the airfoil 70
(see Fig. 4). Although a few of the grains or crystals 86 which are nucleated at the
upper face 58 of the starter element 50 may terminate part way through the airfoil
70, the vast majority of the grains 86 extend completely through the airfoil 70 from
the root end 78 to the tip end 80 of the airfoil. This results in the airfoil 70 having
a multi-grained structure throughout its axial length. Although the airfoil 70 may
have a leading edge 74 with a twisted and/or bowed configuration, the elongated crystals
86 extend substantially parallel to the leading edge 74 of the airfoil 70 to enhance
the operating characteristics of the airfoil 70 in a known manner.
[0029] Each of the elongated crystals or grains 86 in the airfoil 70 is formed of a plurality
of cubic unit cells 94 (Figs. 4 and 5) having the same orientation relative to the
longitudinal axis of the crystal. In addition, the unit cells 94 in each elongated
crystal 86 have the same longitudinal orientation relative to the unit cells in adjacent
crystals. Thus, adjacent longitudinally extending crystals 86 have unit cells which
have the same longitudinal orientation relative to the longitudinal central axis 88
of the airfoil 70.
[0030] The unit cell, the fundamental building block of the crystal, has an atomic arrangement
which, when repeated in three dimensions, gives the total structure of the crystal.
The configuration of the unit cell will vary depending upon the material from which
the crystal is formed. For the nickel-base superalloy forming the airfoil 70, the
unit cell 94 has a face-centered cubic configuration which consists of an atom at
each cube corner and one at the center of each face, as depicted in Fig. 4. The orientations
within each unit cell is specified in terms of its coordinates relative to orthogonal
X, Y and Z axes. When specifying directions in a crystal the notation [XYZ] is used
to indicate the direction of a line from the origin to a point the coordinates are
X, Y and Z. By custom, brackets are utilized and fractional coordinates are avoided.
[0031] Thus, a direction along one of the edges of the cubic cell would also be parallel
to one of the three axes and would be denoted as [100], [100], [010], [010], [001],
or [001]. In each case, the minus notation above the numeral denotes a negative direction
from the origin. Each of these directions is said to be equivalent and of the <100>
family. Crystals whose longitudinal axes are vertically aligned and which one of the
unit cell axes is also vertically aligned are said to have a [001] orientation, reflecting
the convention of denoting the vertical axis as Z. The spatial position of the unit
cell may be simply visualized as that of a cube lying flat on one of its faces with
the longitudinal central axis 88 being perpendicular to the horizontal plane on which
the cube rests.
[0032] An extreme form of unit cell orientation occurs in a direction joining the diagonally
opposite corners of the cube. This may be visualized as a cube so positioned that
one corner makes point contact with a horizontal surface and the other, diagonally
opposite, corner falls on a line that both joins the two corners and is perpendicular
to the supporting horizontal surface. There are several such equivalent directions
in a cubic unit cell, all part of the <111> family. A crystal in which a direction
of this family is parallel to the longitudinal central axis 88 is said to have a [111]
] orientation. Intermediate between these two extreme orientations of [001] and [111],
numerous others are possible. The notation accorded these is well known in the field
of crystallography and is not essential to delineating the features of this invention.
[0033] Turbine engine blades and vanes produced by the process of directional solidification
wherein metal is solidified in contact with a horizontally disposed copper chill typically
involve the use of nickel-base superalloys having a face-centered cubic crystal structure.
The resulting orientation of elongated crystals in this process [001]. The side surfaces
or faces of the unit cells lie either perpendicular or parallel to the longitudinal
central axis 88 of the airfoil 70. This orientation is recognized as superior from
the standpoint of thermal fatigue resistance. However, other orientations, particularly
the [111], offer the possibility of greatly improved Young's modulus without sacrifice
in creep strength. Such a combination of properties may be attractive in applications
where particular vibrational and high temperature strength characteristics are desired
and thermal fatigue resistance is not a pacing concern.
[0034] The airfoil 70 is cast with each cubic unit cell 94 in the same orientation with
respect to the longitudinal axis 88 and with each side surface of a unit cell extending
at an acute angle relative to the longitudinal axis of the crystals 86. In one extreme
case, this results in a cube diagonal corner to corner orientation of the unit cells
denoted above as [111]. Thus, each of the side surfaces of the unit cells 94 extends
at an acute angle to the longitudinal axes of the crystals 86 and corresponding longitudinal
central axis 88 of the airfoil 70. Although the side surfaces of the unit cells 94
are skewed relative to the longitudinal axes, each cell within an individual crystal
has the same orientation.
[0035] The skewed relationship of the side surfaces of the unit cell 94 relative to the
central axis of a crystal 86 has been illustrated schematically in Fig. 4. Thus, the
face centered cubic unit cell 94 has side surfaces 96, 98 and 100 all of which extend
at acute angles relative to the longitudinal central axis of the crystal 86. Although
only three of the six side surfaces of the cubic cell 94 have been identified in Fig.
4, it should be understood that the other three side surfaces of the cubic cell also
extend at acute angles to the longitudinal axis of the crystal 86.
[0036] Although the unit cells 94 of the crystals 86 could be oriented with the side surfaces
of the cubic cells skewed in many different angles relative to the longitudinal axes
of the crystals, in one specific preferred embodiment the [111] direction of the unit
cells is parallel to the longitudinal axis of the crystals 86 and corresponding longitudinal
central axis 88 of the airfoil 70.
[0037] A unit cell 94 having this orientation has been illustrated schematically in Fig.
5. It should be noted that, although the unit cell 94 is of the face-centered cubic
construction, only the lattice points at the corners of the unit cell 94 have been
illustrated in Fig. 5, the lattice points at the center of each face being omitted
for purposes of clarity of illustration. In Fig. 5, the [111] direction, parallel
to the longitudinal axis of the crystals 86 and longitudinal central axis 88 of the
airfoil 70, is denoted by the arrow 106.
[0038] When the unit cell has the [111] orientation shown in Fig. 5, each of the side surfaces
of the unit cell 94 extends at an acute angle relative to the longitudinal central
axis 88 and a line extending between one pair of diagonally opposite corners of the
unit cell is parallel to the axis 88. Although only a single unit cell 94 has been
shown in Figs. 4 and 5, it should be understood that other unit cells of the elongated
crystals 86 have the same longitudinal orientation. Within an individual crystal 86
all unit cells also share a common rotational orientation about the longitudinal central
axis 88 such that the corresponding side surfaces of all unit cells are parallel.
Although other crystals 86 need not share the same rotational orientation, a common
longitudinal orientation of [111] exists, imparting within the airfoil 70 a common
set of Young's modulus and other mechanical behavior characteristics along the longitudinal
central axis 88.
[0039] The extreme cornerwise or skewed, cube diagonal, [111], orientation of the unit cell
94 provides the highest value of Young's modulus. At ambient temperature this value
is approximately 44,000,000 psi (724,000,000 kPa) versus approximately 18,000,000
psi (303,000,000 kPa) for an [001] orientation. High creep strength has also been
reported for the [111] orientation as measured by creep rates and stress rupture lives
at elevated temperatures on tests performed using individual crystals of nickel-base
superalloys. Depending on the alloy and specific test conditions of stress and temperature,
the [111] orientation has been found to provide considerably less primary creep versus
that of an [001] orientation and stress rupture lives that are comparable to and,
in some cases, superior to those seen with an [001] orientation. Using available data
for two nickel-base superalloys, one published study postulates that the [111] orientation
provides the highest creep resistance and rupture lives in comparison with [001] or
other orientations.
[0040] In order to form the airfoil 70 with elongated crystals or grains 86 in which the
unit cells 94 are oriented with their side surfaces extending at an acute angle relative
to the central axis of the crystal, the crystals 62 in the starter element 50 have
unit cells which are disposed in the same orientation as the unit cells in the crystals
86 of the airfoil 70. Thus, the unit cells of each crystal 62 in the starter element
50 has a face-centered cubic construction. Each of the side surfaces of the cubic
unit cells of the starter crystals 62 extends at an acute angle relative to the longitudinal
axes of the crystals 62 and relative to the mold axis 66. Since the airfoil 70 is
formed of elongated crystals or grains 86 in which each of the unit cells has a [111]
orientation, the longitudinally extending starter crystals 62 have unit cells which
also have a [111] orientation.
[0041] During a casting operation molten metal is poured into the mold 10. The molten metal
engages the upper side surface 58 of the starter element 50. The starter crystals
62 having unit cells located in the [111] orientation then nucleate airfoil crystals
86 in which the unit cells have a corresponding [111] orientation. As the crystals
86 continue to grow from the upper side surface 58 of the starter element 50 to the
tip end 80 of the airfoil 70, the orientation of the unit cells 94 in the crystals
86 remains constant. Therefore, all of the unit cells in each of the airfoil crystals
86 have the same [111] orientation.
[0042] In view of the foregoing description, it is apparent that the described embodiment
of the present invention utilizes a directionally solidified seed or starter element
50 having elongated crystals or grains 62. The starter element or seed 50 is oriented
in a mold 10 with the longitudinal axes of the crystals 62 in the starter element
50 extending parallel to the preferred direction of grain growth in the mold cavity
38. This results in the initiation or formation of elongated metal crystals or grains
86 in the mold cavity 38 at the starter element 50 with the longitudinal axes of these
grains 86 extending parallel to the longitudinal axes of the elongated metal crystals
62 in the starter element.
[0043] By having the elongated crystals 62 in the seed or starter element 50 oriented with
a longitudinal axis extending parallel to the direction of grain or crystal growth
in the mold cavity 38, molten metal which is poured into the mold cavity comes into
contact with the ends of the longitudinally extending grains or crystals 62 in the
starter element. This results in the nucleation of a multiplicity of crystals or grains
86 having the same orientation as the grains or crystals 62 in the starter element
50. The nucleation of directionally oriented crystals 86 at the starter element 50
eliminates the competitive growth zone which characterizes most prior directional
solidification casting processes in which the [001] orientation is a natural outgrowth
of the early stages of the solidification near the chill surface.
[0044] The longitudinally extending crystals or grains 86 which are nucleated at the ends
of the grains 62 in the starter element have unit cells 94 which are disposed in the
same orientation as the unit cells of the starter element. By providing a starter
element 50 having elongated grains or crystals 62 with unit cells having their side
surfaces skewed or extending at an acute angle to the longitudinal axes of the crystals
or grains of the starter element, longitudinally extending crystals or grains 86 with
unit cells having a similar orientation will be formed in the cast article. In one
specific preferred embodiment it is advantageous for the unit cells in the starter
element to have a [111] orientation to effect the solidification of a cast article
70 having an elongated crystal structure with the unit cells 94 having the same [111]
orientation. When the unit cells 94 are oriented with all of their side surfaces extending
at an acute angle relative to the longitudinal central axis of the grains of the cast
product 70, the Young's modulus and creep resistance of the cast product is improved.
[0045] Although the method the present invention can be used in casting many different types
of products, the method is advantageously used to cast airfoils 70 with the elongated
crystals or grains 86 having longitudinal axes extending substantially parallel to
a leading edge 74 of the airfoil.