Background of the invention
[0001] This invention relates to steam turbines, and especially is concerned with a superhigh
temperature and pressure steam turbine operating at a steam temperature of 600° to
650°C and under a steam pressure of 4000 to 5000 psi. (about 28000 to 35000 kPa.
[0002] Owing to petroleum shortage and a consequent rise in the price of petroleum, it has
been thought desirable to raise the temperature and pressure of steam used in generating
plants so as to increase efficiency. In steam generating plants, it is now usual practice
to operate the turbine at a steam temperature of 538°C, and the rotor shaft is formed
of a low alloy steel such as a Cr-Mo-V steel. However, in a high temperature and pressure
generating plant in which the turbine is operated at a steam temperature of over 600°C
and under a pressure of over 4000 psi, it has been revealed that the material now
used is not fit for use from the point of view of strength because it is markedly
low in creep rupture strength, thermal fatigue strength and strength at high temperatures.
Meanwhile steam turbines operating at a main steam temperature of over 600°C are disclosed
in "Transaction of the ASME", October 1960, for example. However, this type of steam
turbines are low in thermal fatigue resistant property, and not suitable for use as
steam turbines that only operate at peak load. More specifically, when a steam turbine
is repeatedly started up and shut down, the starting-up and shutting-down impose severe
thermal fatigue conditions. Thus it becomes necessary to provide a steam turbine having
a rotor and rotor blades having a fatigue life that can withstand this transitory
condition, high strength at elevated temperature and high ductility at elevated temperature.
Austenitic alloys are considered suitable from the point of view of strength as materials
for the rotor and rotor blades operating under conditions of a steam pressure exceeding
4000 psi (about 28000 kPa) and a steam temperature in the range over 600°C. However,
these alloys carry the risks that, since various deposit phases are precipitated at
high temperature, embrittlement thereof may be accelerated and their strength may
be markedly lowered at elevated temperature.
[0003] GB-A-912,814 discloses an austenitic nickel-chromium-iron-base alloy which is said
to be useful for gas turbine applications; mentioned are turbine wheels, buckets and
bolting and structural applications (but not rotor shafts and blades). The amount
of manganese present is below 0.50%, and use of high manganese content is discouraged.
The 1000 hour creep rupture strength of the material is not given.
Summary of the invention
[0004] An object of this invention is to provide steam turbine including a turbine shaft
having superior thermal fatigue resistant property at a -main steam temperature of
600° to 650°C.
[0005] Another object is to provide a superhigh temperature and pressure steam turbine of
high reliability, particularly a steam turbine of the type described including a rotor
shaft formed of austenitic forged steel-having high strength at elevated temperature,
high ductility- atelavated temperature and low thermal embrittlement under the steam
condition of a temperature range between 600°C and 650°C.
[0006] Still another object is to provide a steam turbine having a rotor shaft and rotor
blades of high thermal fatigue resistant property under the steam condition .of a
temperature range between 600° and 650°C.
[0007] The invention is set out in claim 1.
[0008] The blade sections of the rotor shaft are preferably equidistantly located axially
of the rotor shaft in the casing and are preferably unsymmetrical at the center position
with respect to the axial direction.
[0009] The outer casing member preferably has a substantially spherical external shape,
and is preferably formed of Cr-Ni austenitic cast steel or Cr-Mo-V cast steel having
a bainite structure.
[0010] The inner casing member is preferably formed of Cr-Ni austenitic cast steel.
[0011] The rotor shaft is preferably formed of an alloy which consists of

the balance being iron plus unavoidable impurities. More preferably 0.2-0.3% vanadium
is present.
[0012] The rotor blades of the superhigh temperature and pressure turbine according to the
invention are preferably made of an alloy consisting by weight of the following elements
in amounts within the following respective ranges

the balance Fe and unavoidable impurities, and having a microstructure in which a
y' phase is precipitated in austenite matrix. Most preferably the alloy of the rotor
blades consists by weight of

the balance being iron plus unavoidable impurities. More preferably 0.2―0,3% vanadium
is present.
[0014] The reasons why the elements are limited to the respective ranges of values in the
aforesaid composition are as follows:
Carbon
[0015] Strength at elevated temperature increases with an increase in C but a reduction
in toughness and thermal embrittlement are accelerated with an increase in C. The
carbon content in the material of the rotor shaft that increases strength at elevated
temeprature without reducing toughness nor thermal embrittlement is less than 0.04%,
preferably 0.015 to 0.03%, and the carbon content of the preferred material of the
rotor blades is 0.01-0.1 %, preferably between 0.04 and 0.07%.
Manganese
[0016] This element is the most important deoxidizing component the manufacture of the alloy.
However, when the element is present in too large an amount, toughness and oxidation
resistance are adversely affected. Thus the amount in the alloy for the rotor shaft
67 the amount is chosen in the range 0,5 to 1,50%, while for the rotor blades it is
preferably not more than 2%, more preferably between 0.5 and 1.5%.
Nickel
[0017] This element is an important component for improving high temperature mechanical
strength of the steel according to the invention, particularly creep rupture strength
and thermal fatigue life thereof. More specifically, this element is conducive to
formation of a stable austenite structure and increased high . temperature strength.
However, in view of its high cost and the reduction of high temperature ductility
and yield strength of the steel when its amount is too high, the amount of Ni present
is limited between 20 and 30%, preferably between 24 and 28%.
Silicon
[0018] Similarly to manganese, this element is a deoxidizing component necessary for production.
When the amount present is over 1.5%, however, the forgeability of the steel diminishes
and its high temperature toughness is reduced. Thus the upper limit for the preferred
blade alloy is 1.5 wt%, the amount being preferably between 0.3 and 1%. For the rotor
shaft alloy, the range 0.3 to 1% is chosen.
Molybdenum
[0019] This element improves creep rupture strength by strengthening the austenite matrix
and forming a carbide. However, the steel has its high temperature ductility reduced
and its workability deteriorates when the amount of the element is too large. Thus
the amount is limited to between 0.5 and 3 wt%, preferably between 1 and 2%.
Chromium
[0020] This element is an important component for improving the high temperature oxidization
property of the material according to the invention. As shown in Fig. 1(b), no satisfactory
effect is achieved if the amount is under 10%. When the amount is over 20%, embrittlement
increases after prolonged holding at elevated temperature. The amount is thus preferably
between '14 and 17%.
Titanium
[0021] Besides being used as a deoxidizing agent, this element has the effect of hardening
alloys by the precipitation thereof. However, when its amount exceeds 3%, the element
reduces the ductility and toughness of the steel and accelerates notch deterioration.
To increase the high temperature strength of the steel, it is necessary that the amount
of this element be not less than 0.5%. Preferably the amount is between 1.5 and 2.5%.
For the alloy of the blades, the range preferred is 1.5 to 3%.
Aluminium
[0022] Aluminium is added as a deoxidizing agent in the amount of 0.1-0.5%, preferably in
the amount of 0.15-0.4%. This element is combined with titanium to cause precipitation
of an intermetallic compound, to thereby increase high temperature strength. However,
when the amount is too great, it tends to reduce strength. Thus the amount thereof
is limited to between 0.1-0.5%.
Boron
[0023] This element has the effects of markedly strengthening grain boundary and providing
high temperature ductility. However, workability deteriorates when the amount is too
large. Thus in the preferred alloy of the blades the amount is limited to between
0.002 and 0.01 %, preferably between 0.004 and 0.008%. In the alloy of the rotor shaft,
the amount is in the range 0.004 to 0.008%.
Vanadium
[0024] This element is optionally added to improve creep strength. When the amount thereof
is below 0.05%, no satisfactory effect is achieved. When the amount is over 0.5%,
however, ductility and toughness are both adversely affected. The amount is preferably
between 0.2 and 0.3%.
Nickel equivalent
[0025] Fig. 7a shows the relation between the nickel equivalent (% Ni+30x% C+0.5x% Mn) regarding
an austenite heat resisting steel now in use and the 1000 hour creep rupture strength
obtained at 650°C. As shown, an increase in the nickel equivalent is accompanied by
an improvement in creep rupture strength. This relation tends to be saturated when
the nickel equivalent is about 35%. If the 1000 hour creep rupture strength at 650°C
used as a target is made to agree with the scatter band value of 26-34 kg/mm
2 (1000 hour creep rupture strength at 550°C) now used for the currently used material,
then the optimum value of the nickel equivalent is between 23 and 29%. (1 kg/mm
2 can be written as 1 MPa).
Chromium equivalent
[0026] Chromium equivalent is 12≦(% Cr equivalent)

Fig. 7b shows the relation between the chromium content and the increment for high
temperature oxidation. Fig. 7b shows that the chromium content should be not less
than 12% if its addition is to have any effect in oxidization resistance at elevated
temperature. Fig. 7c shows the result obtained with the relation shown in Fig. 7b
and the optimum range of the aforesaid nickel equivalent as inserted in Shefla's diagram.
In Fig. 7c, if the upper limit of the chromium equivalent is set corresponding to
the nickel equivalent on condition that a stable austenite structure is obtained,
then the value is 7/10x(% nickel equivalent)+9 (see Fig. 7c) according to Shefla's
diagram. The hatching in Fig. 7c indicates the nickel equivalent and chromium equivalent
as limited by the invention.
[0027] For producing the alloys used in the present invention, it is preferred to effect
melting by use of argon-oxygen blowing decarburization process or vacuum decarburization
process.
[0028] Particular embodiments of the invention are given by way of example in the description
set forth hereinafter, in conjunction with the accompanying drawings.
Brief description of the drawings
[0029]
Fig. 1 is a schematic view of one example of the superhigh temperature and pressure
steam turbine according to the invention;
Fig. 2 is a diagrammatic representation showing a relation between absorbed energy
and the amount of C in the material according to the invention;
Fig. 3 is a diagrammatic representation of the working stress caused in the rotor
shaft according to the operation pattern of the steam turbine now in use;
Fig. 4a is a notional view of the turbine rotor surface temperature-strain (stress)
pattern of'the steam turbine in actual use;
Fig. 4b is a view showing a model of a high temperature low cycle fatigue pattern
simulating the thermal fatigue operation pattern of Fig. 4a which model is a strain-holding
type;
Fig. 4c is another model of the fatigue pattern simitarto Fig. 4b in which model the
strain-holding time is removed;
Fig. 5 is a diagrammatic representation of the results of high temperature lovv cycle
fatigue tests conducted on the materials according to the invention and material of
the prior art;
Fig. 6 is a diagrammatic representation of the influence of boron exerted on the high
temperature low cycle fatigue life;
Fig. 7a is a diagrammatic representation of the relation between creep rupture strength
and nickel equivalent;
Fig. 7b is a diagrammatic representation of the relation between high temperature
oxidization increment and the amount of chromium,
Fig. 7c is a Shefla's diagram;
Fig. 8 is a diagram showing the 103 hour creep rupture strength of the material according to the invention and the material
of the prior art as extrapolated by the Rallson-Mirror process;
Fig. 9 is a diagrammatic representation of the high temperature low cycle fatigue
of the material according to the invention and the material of the prior art; and
Fig. 10 is a microscopic photograph of a specimen structure.
[0030] Fig. 1 is a sectional view showing the essential portions of one embodiment of the
superhigh temperature and pressure steam turbine in conformity with the invention,
in which steam is introduced through a main steam line 1 into the turbine and is jetted
in a predetermined direction by static blades 3 attached to an inner casing member
2 to thereby rotate rotor blades 5 mounted on a rotor shaft 4. After doing work, the
steam flows through a gap between an outer casing member 6 and the inner casing member
2 and then is exhausted through a cooled steam outlet port 7, an exhaust outlet port
8 and an auxiliary exhaust outlet port 9. The exhausted steam is forwarded to a next
steam turbine operating at a lower temperature. 10 is the center of each bearing of
the rotor shaft 4. 11 and 12 are a gland and a intermediate gland leak outlet port
respectively. 13 is a nozzle box. Arrows indicate the direction of flow of the steam.
[0031] The embodiment of the invention of the aforesaid construction will be described in
detail with reference to the inner casing member 2 and the outer casing member 6 formed
of Cr-Ni austenite cast steel and Cr-Ni austenite forged steel, respectively.
Example 1
[0032] Table 1 shows the chemical composition of alloys for rotor shafts used in experiments.
Alloys 1 to 3 are according to the present invention. Alloy 4 is for comparison. Each
of the alloys 1 to 4 is prepared by the steps of vacuum arc melting, forging, solid-solution
treatment of holding it at 980°C for one hour with water-cooling thereafter, and aging
treatment of holding at 720°C for 16 hours with air-cooling being effected thereafter,
while each of the conventional alloys for comparison is prepared by the steps of vacuum
are melting, forging and succeeding necessary treatments shown hereinbelow. The alloys
used in the present invention have a microstructure in which a y' phase is precipitated
in the austenite matrix.
[0033] Conventional Cr-Mo-V steel serving as a comparative material was cooled by air-blowing
after heating at 970°C for 15 hours, and then reheated at 670°C for 48 hours before
being cooled in the furnace.
[0034] 12 Cr steel also serving as another comparative material was cooled by spraying of
water in atomized particles after heating at 1050°C for 24 hours, and then subjected
to tempering at 650°C for 20 hours. These steel alloys were subjected to V-notch Charpy
impact tests and creep rupture tests.
[0035] Fig. 2 shows the results of impact tests conducted on the influences of the amount
of C on thermal embrittlement by heating at 650°C for 1500 hours. The results show
that, whereas absorbed energy of non-heat treated blanks is substantially constant
irrespective of the amount of C, the absorbed energy reduces as the amount of C increases
in the material heated at 650°C for 1500 hours, showing a marked thermal embrittlement
in material with high C content. The values of absorbed energy at 20°C for 12 Cr steel
and Cr-Mo-V steel which are now in use for producing rotors are specified as not less
than 1.1 kg-m and 0.69 kg-m respectively. Particularly, in a case where the amount
of C is not more than 0.03% by weight, the absorbed energy becomes not less than 1.5
kg-m, that is,'superior thermal embrittlement resistant property can be obtained.
The thermal embrittlement resistant property of each alloy used as a material of the
turbine shaft in the present invention is larger than those of the conventional 12%
Cr steel and Cr-Mo-V steel.
[0036] In the rotor shaft material for the steam turbine according to the invention, intracrystalline
rupture (white triangle) prevailed when the material had a C content of below 0.04
wt%. However, when the C content had a value not less than 0.04 wt%, the rupture form
has transferred to a grain boundary rupture type (black triangle). The results of
analysis have shown that this change in rupture type is accounted for as the deterioration
of the grain boundary due to precipitation of the Mx type and M
23C
s type carbides in the grain boundary. Thus, to diminish thermal embrittlement in interrelation
with thermal fatigue, the amount of C is limited to be less than 0.04o/ci, preferably
between 0.015 and 0.03% in the material for rotor shafts according to the invention.

[0037] Fig. 3 shows an operation pattern of the severest condition for conventional steam
turbines that is operated at a steam temperature of 566°C, that is, the starting-up
and shutting-down of the turbine is repeated every 12 hours. When this operation pattern
is applied to the superhigh temperature and pressure steam turbine according to the
invention, the rotor shaft would be subjected to harsh low cycle fatigue due to high
stress at the time of startup and shutdown as shown. Particularly the rotor shaft,
unlike the rotor blades, would be subjected to harsh low cycle fatigue due to the
combined actions of thermal stress and centrifugal stress because a rise in temperature
is gradual in the rotor. Also, it would be subjected to creep due to centrifugal forces
in steady-state operation. In Fig. 3, working stress represents thermal stress combined
with centrifugal stress.
[0038] Table 2 shows the results of tension tests, creep rupture tests and low cycle fatigue
tests conducted on the steels 1 and 2 according to the invention at 650°C and on the
steel of the prior art at 550°C. It will be seen in the table that the material according
to the invention is equal to or higher than the Cr-Mo-V steel in tensile strength
and 0.2% yield strength, and that the rate of elongation thereof is 1.5 to 1.75 times
as high as in the Cr-Mo-V steel. Creep rupture strength is 1.1 to 1.20 times as high
in the material according to the invention as in the Cr-Mo-V steel and low cycle fatigue
is equal to or slightly higher in the former than in the latter in spite of the difference
of test temperature.
[0039] The results of the low cycle fatigue tests represent the number of repetitions continued
until rupture occurs at a strain rate of 0.1 %/second and strain amounts of 1.0% and
0.65% without holding of the strain (that is, in the same manner as shown in Fig.
4c).

[0040] From the foregoing, it will be appreciated that the material according to the invention
which is used at a temperature of 650°C meets requirements regarding mechanical strength
required in the case of Cr-Mo-V steel used at present at 550°C. Thus it has been made
clear that the material described above can be used for forming the rotor shaft of
a superhigh temperature and pressure steam turbine operating at a steam temperature
of 600°-650°C and under a steam pressure of 4000-5000 psi (about 28000 to 35000 kPa).
Example 2
[0041] Table 3 shows the chemical composition (wt%) of various materials for forming the
rotor blades used in the super-high temperature and pressure steam turbine according
to the preferred aspect of the invention. Each material has been obtained by performing
vacuum arc melting, forging, and grain size regulation into a range of ASTM G.S. 2.5―4
was effected by holding it at 1050°C for 3 hours. Then each material was water-cooled
to room temperature in the same manner as in Example 1 after having been subjected
to solid solution treatment of holding it at 899°C for 2 hours. Then, each material
was subjected to aging treatments of two steps, i.e. the first step was holding it
at 760°C for 16 hours with air-cooling thereafter and the second step was holding
it at 718°C for 6 hours with air-cooling thereafter. The blanks obtained by processing
the materials through the aforesaid treatments had a microstructure having a y' phase
precipitated in the austenite matrix. The blanks were machined to provide test pieces
of predetermined dimensions.
[0042] Generally, the blades of a steam turbine are directly subjected to the jetted steam,
so that their temperatures rise relatively quickly after the steam turbine is actuated
and becomes equal to that of steam. Meanwhile a rise in the temperature of the rotor
shaft is relatively slow after the commencement of actuation of the steam turbine
because it has a high thermal capacity and austenite steel has a low thermal conductivity.
Thus the relatively large difference in temperature between the blades and rotor shaft
exists for a substantial period of time. Because of this, the working stress (thermal
stress plus centrifugal stress) to which the rotor shaft is subjected is very high
at starting-up or shutting-down (or when transferring to idling) as shown in Fig.
3, with the result that the thermal fatigue suffered by the blades is relatively lower
than that suffered by the rotor shaft. Thus the amount of C for the materials of the
blades is limited between 0.01 and 0.1 %, preferably between 0.04 and 0.07%.
[0043] Fig. 4a shows a conceptual pattern of a relation between temperature and strain (stress)
to which the surface of the rotor is subjected in the steam turbine of superhigh temperature
and pressure according to the invention having the blades referred to hereinabove
and the rotor shaft described by referring to Example 1. To assess the thermal fatigue
life experimenarily, the operation conditions shown in Fig. 4a were converted to a
trapezoidal strain cycle (constant temperature) with strain-holding (Fig.- 4b), and
a tension-compression triangular wave form (constant temperature) without -strain-holding-
(Fig. 4c). The. aforesaid conversion has been made on the basis of the hypothesis
that there is a correlation between a thermal fatigue phenomenon (varying temperature)
and a low cycle fatigue phenomenon (constant temperature).
[0044] Fig. 5 is a diagram showing the results of high temperature low cycle fatigue tests
conducted by controlling strain or gauge length at a strain rate of 0.1 %/sec and
at a temperature of 650°C. As shown, it will be seen that the materials of the invention
containing 0.002-0.008% B has about twice as long service life as a conventional material
containing no B in a low cycle region having a strain range of 0.5-1.2%, indicating
that the addition of B has the effect of improving thermal fatigue resistant property.

[0045] Fig. 6 shows the influences exerted on fatigue life by the amount of B at a temperature
of 650°C and a strain speed of 0.1%/sec in a strain region of 1.0%. As shown, fatigue
life has a peak in the vicinity of 0.006% B and is about twice as long as that of
material containing B in an amount outside the range of the invention.
[0046] From the foregoing, it will be appreciated that the preferred blades for steam turbines
according to the invention have a superior thermal fatigue resistant property and
a prolonged service life.
Example 3
[0047] Materials were subjected to vacuum arc melting, forging and regulating of grain size
under the same conditions as described in Example 1. Then the materials were subjected
to solid solution treatment and aging under the heat treating conditions shown in
Table 7, and machined to produce materials for blades and rotor shafts. The materials
Nos. 10 and 11 are those used for producing blades, and the materials Nos. 12 and
13 are those used for producing rotor shafts. Tables 5 and 6 show the results of creep
rupture tests and fatigue tests conducted on these materials, respectively.
[0049] Fig. 8 shows the results of extrapolation of the creep rupture strength of 105 hours
conducted by the Rollson-Mirror process. According to this relation, the materials
Nos. 10, 11, 12 and 13 covered by the claims of the invention have strength of about
133 MPa at 650°C which is similar to mean creep rupture strength of 127 MPa of the
conventional Cr-Mo-V steel tested at 550°C for comparison.
[0050] Fig. 9 shows the results of high temperature low cycle fatigue tests effected by
controlling strain of gauge length, at a strain rate of 0.1 %/sec. The results show
that in the entire strain range the fatigue life of the materials according to the
present invention at 650°C is equal to or longer than that of the Cr-Mo-V steel at
550°C.
[0051] Fig. 10 is a microscopic photograph at a magnification 1000x of the No. alloy having
a microstructure in which a y' phase is precipitated in the austenite matrix.
[0052] The alloy according to the invention has high temperature strength required of the
materials for the blades and the rotor operating at a steam temperature of 600°-650°C
and is suitable for use as materials for the rotor blades and the rotor.
Example 4
[0053] Alloys having chemical compositions shown in Table 8 were produced in the same manner
as Example 1.

[0054] Figs. 11 and 12 show a relation between aging temperature and tensile strength and
another relation between aging temperature and creep rupture time at 650°C regarding
the above-described alloys of the present invention, respectively. As apparent from
Figs. 11 and 12, low aging temperature not more than 740°C is preferred for obtaining
improved creep rupture strength and tensile strength. Further, the amount of carbon
does not have much influence regarding the enhancement of mechanical strength; however,
the lower the amounts carbon and titanium in the alloys, the higher the elongation
and reduction of area thereof become.
Example 5
[0055] Table 9 shows the chemical composition of another alloy for the rotor shaft 4 of
a superhigh temperature and pressure steam turbine according to the invention.
[0056] Raw materials for constituting the aforesaid composition were subjected to vacuum
induction melting under a vacuum of 10
-3 to produce electrodes of about 1000 mm in diameter. The electrodes were remelted by
an electro-slag-remelting process (ESR) by use of flux consisting of CaF
2 of 55%, A1
20
3 of 35% and Ti0
2 of 10% and cast into columnar ingots. The ingots were diffusion-annealed at a temperature
of 1100°-1500°C and forged at a temperature below 1050°C to produce a columnar blank
of 850 mm in diameter and 6000 mm in length. The blank was held for 3 hours at a temperature
of 1050°C to control the grain size into a range of ASTM G.S. 2.5-4 while rotating
the blank at a rate of 3 times per one minute.

[0057] After subjecting the blank to solution treatment by holding same at a temperature
in the range between 900 and 1000°C for 1 hour, it was water-cooled by jetting water
thereagainst while vertically holding and rotating it at a rate of three revolutions
per minute to room temperature. Thereafter, the blank was held at a temperature between
700° and 730°C for 16 hours to effect aging while rotating it in the same manner,
to provide a microstructure in which a y' phase is precipitated in austenite matrix.
The blank was then machined to obtain a rotor shaft having predetermined dimensions
shown in Fig. 13. Specimens for experiments were taken from the left hand end of the
rotor shaft as shown in Fig. 13 and were subjected to the tests of tensile strength
and creep rupture strength, with the result that there were obtained strength and
elongation both substantially similar to those of the specimen No. 17 described above.
Example 6
[0058] Table 10 shows the chemical composition (wt%) of a blade used in a superhigh temperature
and pressure steam turbine of the present invention.

[0059] Raw materials for constituting this chemical composition were subjected to vacuum
induction melting to produce electrodes (600 mm in diameter) for ESR. The electrodes
were remelted by ESR process by use of flux consisting of CaF
2 of 50%, CaO of 25%, Ti0
2 of 15% and A1
20
3 of 10%, and the molten metal was cast into blanks. Then, each of the blanks was heat-treated
to control the grain size thereof. After that, there was effected the solution heat
treatment of holding the blank at 899°C for 2 hours and of water-cooling thereafter.
Then, the blank was subjected to aging treatment of two steps, i.e., in the first
step the blank was held at 760°C for 16 hours with air-cooling being effected thereafter
and in the second step the blank was held at 718°C for 6 hours with air-cooling thereafter,
so that there was obtained a blank having microstructure in which y' phase is precipitated
in austenite matrix. Such blank was subjected to mechanical working to obtain the
blade having predetermined dimensions. Specimens were picked from the blade, which
specimens were subjected to the test of evaluating tensile strength, creep rupture
strength and high temperature lower cycle fatigue resistant property, with the result
that there were obtained values in a degree approximately similar to those of the
specimen No. 1 shown in Table 2.