[0001] This invention relates to coated articles comprising hard metals, refractories, and
especially cemented carbide substrates. More particularly, it relates to such coated
hard metal or coated cemented carbide products which are adapted to receive an aluminum
oxide or other oxide wear layer which is very firmly bonded to the substrate.
[0002] Such hard metal and/or cemented carbide substrates are used in tools for machining
and cutting metals. Their already high wear resistance can be significantly improved
by providing oxide wear layers, such as aluminum oxide wear layers, as described in
U.S. 3,736,107 and 3,836,392.. However, it has become apparent that proper steps must
be taken to adequately bond the oxide layer to the hard metal or cemented carbide
substrate if the superior wear resistance of the oxide layer is to be realized.
[0003] In U.S. 4,018,631, it is disclosed that a selective pretreatment of cemented carbides
before application of the oxide wear layer unexpectedly enhances and improves the
adherence of the subsequently applied oxide wear layer. While such a procedure results
in a tightly adherent surface layer of aluminum oxide or other oxide wear layer, and
is therefore extremely useful, the procedure requires a high temperature for the diffusion
step.
[0004] A novel coating procedure has now been discovered which provides aluminum oxide and
other oxides (e.g., hafnium oxide, zirconium oxide and the like) bonded to the substrates
with adherence equal to that obtained in the said '631 patent, which can be performed
at normal coating temperatures. Such a procedure in its broadest aspects comprises
providing a thin surface-oxidized bonding layer comprising an oxide, a carbide or
oxycarbide of at least one of tantalum, niobium and vanadium, optionally aluminiz-
ing the bonding layer, and finally providing an outer oxide wear layer. The present
bonding layer is thin, not useful as a barrier, and possesses a composition novel
in its chemical constituents. All of the foregoing patents and publications are incorporated
herein by reference.
[0005] According to the invention there is provided an article of manufacture comprising:
(i) a hard metal or cemented carbide substrate having a plurality of coatings thereon;
(ii) at least one of the coatings being a surface-oxidized bonding layer comprising
at least one of the carbides or oxycarbides of tantalum, niobium and vanadium; and
(iii) an oxide wear layer overlying said bonding layer.
[0006] In preferred features, the substrate is a cobalt cemented carbide; the bonding layer
is 0.1 to 0.5 microns thick; aluminum is added to the bonding layer by a process to
be described layer; the oxide wear layer is aluminum oxide; and the wear layer is
0.5 to 20 microns thick.
[0007] In one practice of the present invention a hard metal or cemented carbide substrate
is pretreated for the reception of a wear resistant oxide coating by treating the
substrate in a first atmosphere selected from carbide and oxycarbide forming atmospheres
to form a bonding layer of metal selected from at least one of tantalum, niobium or
vanadium on said substrate and heating the coated substrate in a second oxidizing
atmosphere until at least about 50% of the surface is oxidized.
[0008] In the preferred features of the process aspect aluminum will be added to the bonding
layer;' and an oxide outer wear layer, preferably an aluminum oxide wear layer, will
be deposited on the bonding layer, which optionally may contain aluminum. The bonding
layer may bond or form the oxide wear layer directly to the substrate or to other
layers with which the substrate is previously coated: One preferred previously coated
layer is TiC although broadly, this layer may comprise a carbide, nitride or carbonitride
of Ti, Zr, Hf, V, Cr, W, Si, B which is an intermediate layer.
[0009] Those skilled in this art will now the general techniques used to prepared the product
and carry out the process of the present invention.
[0010] One convenient way of proceeding is to provide a coating furnace held at a temperature
of from about 800° C to 1300°C., and to expose a substrate in the furnace to the following
sequential steps:
1. 5 to 60 minutes exposure, preferably at 1050°C., to a gaseous mixture of H2 and 0.5 to 20 volumes percent TaCl5 or NbCl 5, Ti Cl4, Al Cl3 and/or CH4 may be optionally added during either part or all of this period.
2. 1 to 60 minutes exposure, preferably at 1100°C., to a gaseous mixture consisting
of H2 and about 1 to 50 volume percent CO2 to oxidize and produce the pretreated substrate.
3. 5 to 60 minutes exposure, preferably at 1050°C., to a gaseous mixture of H2 and
about 0.5 to 20 volume percent AlCl3. This step for adding aluminum is optional but is preferred for best results.
4. 15 minutes' to 4 hours' exposure, preferably 1050°C., to gaseous mixture of H2, 1 to 40 (or 60 to 95) volume percent C02, and 2.5 to 20 volume percent AlCl3 to produce the aluminum oxide wear coating.
[0011] Other suitable treating atmospheres of varying proportions of constituents will occur
to those skilled in the art. Likewise, other well known deposition techniques can
be used such as physical vapor deposition, sputtering and pack diffusion.
[0012] Those features of the invention which are believed to be novel are set forth with
particularity in the claims appended hereto. The invention will, however, be better
understood from a consideration of the preferred embodiments.
[0013] The following examples are illustrative, and the claims are not be construed as being
limited thereto.
EXAMPLE 1
[0014] A commercial cemented carbide cutting tool insert of composition 85.5% WC, 6% TaC,
2.5% TiC and 6% Co was coated in the following manner:
1. Held 15 minutes at 1050°C in an atmosphere of H2 - 5% CH4 - 2% TiCl4 - 5% TaCl5 - 10% AlCl3.
2. Held 40 minutes at 1050°C in an atmosphere of H2 - 10% C02.
3. Held 10 minutes at 1050°C in an atmosphere of H2 - 10% AlCl3.
4. Held 60 minutes at 1050°C in an atmosphere of H2 - 10% C02 - 10% AlCl3.
[0015] This treatment resulted in a 4-micron A1
20
3 coating which was firmly bonded to the cemented carbide substrate, through a bonding
layer about 0.2 microns thick.
[0016] The coated insert was used to machine cast iron at 400 sfpm, .010 in./rev. feed rate,
and the wear resistance was compared with that obtained using a commercial insert
which requires a high temperature diffusion operation to make the coating.
[0017] The wear resistance of the insert coated by the above- described simplified process
was found to be nerarly equal to that of the commercial insert.
EXAMPLE 2
[0018] A cemented carbide insert having the same composition as Example 1 above was coated
with A1
20
3 in the following manner:
1. Held 15 minutes at 1050°C in a gaseous mixture of H2 - 2% TiCl4 - 5% NbCl5 - 10% AlCl3, then the TiCl4 was turned off and the insert was held an additional 10 minutes at 1050°C in the remaining
mixture of H2 - 5 % NbCl5 - 10% AlCl3.
2. Held 20 minutes at 1100°C in a mixture of H2 -5% C02.
3. Held 20 minutes at 1050°C in a mixture of H2 - 10% Al Cl3 .
4. Held 45 minutes at 1050°C in a mixture of HZ -5% CO2 - 10% AlCl3.
[0019] The resultant coated insert had a 3-micron Al
20
3 coating firmly bonded to the cemented carbide substrate, through a bonding layer
about 0.2 microns thick.
[0020] When used to machine cast iron (same conditions as Example 1 above), the wear resistance
was found to be equivalent to the commercial insert.
EXAMPLE 3
[0021] A cemented carbide insert having the same composition as Example 1 above was pretreated
then coated with Al
20
3 in the following manner at a furnace temperature of 1050°C, and l atmosphere pressure.
1. Held 10 minutes in a gaseous mixture of H2 -10% CH4.
2. Held 1 minute in a gaseous mixture of H2 - 2% TiCl4.
3. Held 25 minutes in a mixture of H2 and NbCl5 (which had been heated for about 8 minutes to 320°F., held 3 mintues, and cooled
with power off for 15 minutes).
4. Held 2 minutes in a gaseous mixture of H2 -2.5% C02.
5. Held 10 minutes in a gaseous mixture of H2 - 5% AlCl3.
6. Held 60 minutes in a gaseous mixture of H2 - 5% AlCl3 - 9% C02.
[0022] The resultant coated insert had a 3-4 microns Al
20
3 coating firmly bonded to the cemented carbide substrate, through a bonding layer
about 0.2 microns thick.
[0023] When used to machine cast iron (same conditions as Example 1 above), the wear resistance
is found to be equivalent to the commercial insert.
EXAMPLE 4
[0024] The procedure of Exanoke 3 was repeated, using the following conditions:
1. Held 1 minute at 1050°C.in a gaseous mixture of H2 - 3% Ti Cl4.
2. Held 1 minute at 1050°C. in a gaseous mixture of H2 - 3% Ti Cl 4 - 20% N2.
3. Held 30 minutes in H2 - 3% NbCl5; + 3% TiCl4 added for 20 seconds during middle of this period and temperature was 850°C. for
first 10 minutes of this period and then increased in a linear fashion to 1050°C.
by the end of the period.
4. Held 10 minutes at 1050°C. in H2 - 11% C02.
5. Held 10 minutes at 1050°C. in H2 - 7% A1C13.
6. Held 60 minutes in gaseous mixture of H2 - 11% C02 -7% AlCl3.
[0025] A coated insert according to this invention was obtained.
EXAMPLE. 5
[0026] A commercial cemented carbide cutting tool insert comprising 85.5% WC; 6%-TaC 2.5%
TiC and 60% Co and coated with TiC of five microns thickness is subjected to the following
sequence of steps in a furnace at temperature of 1050°C. and 1 atmosphere pressure:
1. 2 minutes in an atmosphere of H2 and approximately 2% TiCl4
2. NbCl5 vaporizer on 8 min. to 225°F., 3 min. hold - 15 min. power off-cool.
3. 1 minute in an atmosphere of hydrogen - 3.5% C02 to surface oxidize.
4. 10 minutes in an atmosphere of hydrogen - 5% AlCl3-
5. 60 minutes in an atmosphere of hydrogen - 5% AlCl3 - 7% CO2.
[0027] This treatment resulted in a 3-4 microns A1
20
3 coating which was firmly bonded to the TiC coated cemented carbide substrate, through
a bonding layer approximately 0.2 microns thick.
[0028] The coating adhesion of this insert was sufficient to meet the requirements of commercial
A1
20
3 - coated substrates, without a TiC layer. Direct deposit of Al
20
3 on inserts coated with TiC fail to meet these requirements.
EXAMPLE 6
[0029] Iron was incorporated into the surface of a TiC coated cemented carbide cutting tool
insert by rubbing its cutting surfaces with a piece of soft iron. The general procedure
of Example 1 was then used to deposit a very thin coating of niobium carbide by the
exposure of the treated surface to a mixture of H
2 and CbCl
5 gases for about 10 minutes at 1050°C. The resultant CbC coating was allowed to diffuse
with the Fe (and TiC) for about 20 minutes and then this surface was lightly oxidized
by exposure to a mixture of H
2 - 5% C0
2 at 1050°C. for about 15 minutes. When subsequently A1
20
3 - coated, a very strong bond was obtained between the A1
20
3 coating and the TiC-coated surface, noticeably better than the adhesion obtained
using the same process without the Fe treatment.
[0030] The use of tantalum or niobium chloride in the steps of the. above examples is critically
specific for the achievement of the desired high level of coating adherence in a single
furnace operation. While titanium chloride may be used in these steps in addition
to tantalum or niobium chloride, the adherence is not as good if only titanium chloride
is used. Since vanadium belongs to the same group as tantalum and niobium (Group
.VB), its effectiveness is probable. The bonding layer may be treated with Al, Fe,
Co, Ni, to improve the bond with the
A1
20
3 outer layer.
[0031] Many variations will suggest themselves to those skilled in the art in light of the
above-detailed description. All obvious such variations are within the full intended
scope of the invention as defined by the apppended claims.
1. An article of manufacture comprising:
(i) a hard metal or cemented carbide substrate having a plurality of coatings thereon,
at least one of said coatings being a surface-oxidized bonding layer comprising at
least one of the carbides or oxycarbides of tantalum, niobium and vanadium; and
(ii) an oxide wear layer overlying said bonding layer.
2. An article as claimed in claim 1 wherein the substrate is a cemented carbide, and
the bonding layer is 0.1 to 0.5 microns thick.
3. An article as claimed in claim 1 or claim 2 wherein oxide wear layer (ii) is 0.5
to 20 microns thick.
4. An article as claimed in any one of claims 1 to 3 wherein bonding layer (i) includes
aluminium.
5. An article as claimed in any one of the preceding claims wherein oxide wear layer
(ii) comprises aluminium oxide.
6. An article as claimed in any one of claims 1 to 3 wherein said substrate has a
first coating of a carbide, nitride, or carbonitride, of titanium, zirconium, hafnium,
vanadium, columbium, tantalum, chromium molybdenum, tungsten, silicon or boron, to
which said bonding layer is attached.
7. An article as claimed in claim 6 wherein said first coating comprises TiC.
8. An article as claimed in any one of the preceding claims where said intermediate
bonding layer is aluminized.
9. A process of pretreating a hard metal or cemented carbide substrate for the reception
of wear resistant oxide coatings which comprises:
(a) treating the substrate in a first atmosphere selected from carbide and oxycarbide
forming atmospheres to form a bonding layer of metal selected from at least one of
tantalum, niobium or vanadium on said substrate; and
(b) heating the coated substrate of (a) in a second oxidizing atmosphere until at
least portions of the surface are oxidized.
10. A process as claimed in Claim 9 including the step of treating the oxidized coated
substrate of (b) in a reducing atmosphere with a reducible aluminium compound to diffuse
alluminium into the coating.
11. A process as claimed in claim 9 including the step of superimposing an oxide wear
layer on the surface-oxidized coated substrate.
12. A process as claimed in claim 9 including the step of superimposing an oxide wear
layer on the surface-oxidized, aluminium- containing coated substrate.
13. A process as claimed in claim 9 wherein said oxide wear layer is an aluminium
oxide wear layer.