TECHNICAL FIELD
[0001] This invention is directed to a hydrazine thruster, and particularly to apparatus
to control the temperatures of hydrazine as well as the decomposition catalyst located
at the nozzle by which the hydrazine is discharged into the hydrazine decomposition
catalyst bed.
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
[0002] Hydrazine is a thermally unstable compound that can decompose exothermically under
certain conditions to produce nitrogen gas, hydrogen gas and if not totally decomposed,
some ammonia vapor. In a well designed thruster, such as disclosed in Ellion and Donatelli,
U.S. Patent No. 4,069,664, the hydrazine decomposition is controlled as it flows over
the catalyst. The result of this controlled, orderly process is that the hydrazine
decomposes slowly as it flows over the catalyst towards the exit nozzle, generating
heat at a relatively steady pressure. In an old, loose catalyst bed, the hyrdrazine
does not flow smoothly over the catalyst grains, but rather forms puddles. Portions
of these relatively large, stagnant puddles of hydrazine vaporize and then explosively
thermally decompose the entire puddle, causing large pressure excursions and further
degradation of the catalyst. The same pressure excursions resulting from this thermal
explosive autodecomposition may occur in a new bed when the area where the hydrazine
enters the bed becomes too hot for some on/off firing cycles. A discussion of the
criteria involved in that process is found in U.S. Patent No. 4,324,096.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
[0003] In order to aid in the understanding of this invention, it can be stated in essentially
summary form that it is directed to a method and apparatus for controlling the temperatures
of the liquid hydrazine as well as the dissociation catalyst located in the area next
to the inlet of a hydrazine dissociation catalyst bed so that the temperatures are
below the saturation temperature corresponding to the pressure within the decomposition
chamber, to minimize explosive autodecomposition of the hydrazine.
[0004] It is a purpose and advantage of this invention to provide a hydrazine thruster which
has increased operating lifetime by preventing explosive autodecomposition of the
hydrazine in the catalyst bed by controlling the inlet temperature of the liquid hydrazine
and surrounding catalyst.
[0005] It is another purpose and advantage of this invention to provide a hydrazine thruster
which has a stable chamber pressure during firing to minimize catalyst breakdown and
extend the operating lifetime of the thruster for any on/off firing modes.
[0006] Other purposes and advantages of this invention will become apparent from a study
of the following portion of the specification, the claims and the attached drawings.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0007]
FIG. 1 is a side elevational view of a hydrazine thruster assembly, including a first
preferred embodiment of the thermal control structure of this invention.
FIG. 2 is an end elevational view, as seen along the line 2-2 of FIG. 1, with the
thruster removed.
FIG. 3 is a side elevational view, with parts broken away and parts taken in section
of a hydrazine thruster assembly of another preferred embodiment of the thermal control
structure of this invention.
FIG. 4 is an end elevational view, with parts broken away and parts taken in section,
of the thermal control structure of FIG. 3, as seen generally along line 4-4 of FIG.
3.
FIG. 5 shows oscilloscope displays of chamber pressure versus time of the disclosed
hydrazine thruster, with and without the thermal control structure in accordance with
this invention.
FIG. 6 shows test results of a conventional hydrazine thruster illustrating the typical
acceptable and unacceptable operational duty cycle regimes.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION
[0008] FIG. 1 illustrates hydrazine thruster 10 as carrying thermal control structure 12
in accordance with the first preferred embodiment of the hydrazine thruster of this
invention. Flange 14 is a mounting flange which may be part of the main structure
or may be a flange which mounts upon the main structure. The main structure may be
a spacecraft, or it may be any structure to which thrust is to be applied. Liquid
hydrazine inlet line 16 brings liquid hydrazine under pressure from a source thereof.
Valve 18 controls the flow of liquid hydrazine therethrough. As indicated, valve 18
is connectable to an electric signal source for control of the on/off function of
the valve. The outlet from valve 18 is through inlet line 20 connected to the inlet
flange 22 of thruster 10. The details of the internal construction of thruster 10,
including its catalyst chambers and injection nozzles, are shown in the above mentioned
U.S. Patents No. 4,069,664 and No. 4324,096 Those disclosures are incorporated herein
in their entirety by this reference.
[0009] Thruster 10 has chamber housing 24 which has the dissociation catalyst therein and
at its outlet it carries thrust nozzle 26. Thruster flange 28 is carried on the exterior
housing 24 and in the past has been mounted on stand-offs as is shown in U.S. Patent
No.4,324,096. Under those conditions, cyclic duty of the thruster results in the characterization
shown in FIG. 6. The data points marked with an X indicate rough pressure in the catalyst
chamber. The data points indicated with a dot show smooth pressure during the firing
cycle. The rough pressure surges indicated at 30 in FIG. 5 are illustrative of the
data points marked with the X while the straight pressure line 32 is indicative of
the data points marked with the dot. In FIG. 5, the abscissa is the pressure in the
chamber at 20 psi per division and the ordinate is time at 200 milliseconds per division.
The roughness in chamber pressure exceeds 30% when in the rough firing condition.
When operating in the smooth pressure mode, the line 32 represents a plurality of
firing pulses with the pressure traces superimposed.
[0010] In order to maintain smooth firing as indicated by line 32, the temperature of the
incoming hydrazine to the chamber housing 24, as well as the surrounding catalyst,
is controlled. When the incoming hydrazine is maintained as a liquid while in the
injector and as it enters the catalyst bed, the hydrazine cannot decompose if its
temperature is below the hydrazine saturation temperature corresponding to the pressure
in the bed. Vaporization of the hydrazine liquid is necessary before exothermic decomposition
is possible. The basic principle of this invention is to control the hydrazine temperature
so that it enters the bed below its saturation temperature corresponding to the pressure
within the decomposition chamber, and also to maintain the catalyst in the area also
below that temperature. This maintains the hydrazine as a liquid while within the
injector and as it flows into the catalyst bed. The catalyst in this area also being
maintained below the hydrazine saturation temperature allows the fluid to spread smoothly
through the bed to result in controlled decomposition. The result is that any puddles
of hydrazine will spread out smoothly before the hydrazine starts the rapid exothermic
decomposition.
[0011] Hydrazine cannot decompose exothermicallly until it is first transitioned from a
liquid to a vapor. For most injector designs there are void spaces within chamber
housing 24, where the catalyst contacts the injector. These void spaces allow a sufficient
amount of liquid hydrazine to collect in the void. Heat transfer from the hot catalyst
can then decompose all of it at one time to produce explosive decomposition and resultant
pressure pulses. The temperature of 300°F is a conservative lower limit of hydrazine
temperature which is required to permit rapid autodecomposition. The tendency for
explosive decomposition varies exponentially with temperature in an Arrhenius relationship.
If the hydrazine liquid is sufficiently heated to permit a portion of it to vaporize
before it can enter the catalyst bed, the vapor liquid mixture will explosively autodecompose.
Even with specially designed injectors, the explosive autodecomposition will occur
after substantial operation has loosened the catalyst bed to permit voids to form
therein if the surrounding catalyst temperature is above the hydrazine saturation
temperature. With injectors that do have voids in the region between the injector
and the catalyst, there is a very limited operating range with regard to on/off time
as well as life time as discussed in U.S. Patent No. 4,324,096.
[0012] It is the thermal control structure 12 of this invention that controls the temperatures
of the hydrazine and the catalyst at the inlet to the catalyst bed. Thermal control
structure 12 is a high conductivity solid mass which closely fits between flanges
14 and 28, and is clamped between those flanges by the three thruster mounting bolts,
of which two are seen at 32 and 34. As is seen in FIG. 2, the thermal control structure
12 is a triangular shaped solid metallic mass with bolt holes 36 and 38 therethrough,
respectively, for bolts 32 and 34, and another bolt hole 40 for the mounting bolt
hidden in FIG. 1. Central opening 42 permits the inlet line 20 to pass through the
center of the thermal control structure mass and recess 44 receives inlet flange 22
of thruster 10. Thus, the substantial mass of structure 12 is conductively coupled
to both flanges 14 and 28 to act both as a thermal sink to receive heat from the thruster
from flange 28 and to more slowly dissipate this heat into flange 14 and then to the
incoming hydrazine and the main frame structure. Thermal control structure mass 12
is solid except for the required openings for inlet line 20, in the front end of the
thruster including inlet flange 22, and the openings 36, 38 and 40 for the bolts which
secure the structure together. A maximum thermal sink and a maximum conductive area
is thus presented by this structure. This embodiment is effective when the hydrazine
can absorb some of the heat and still remain below its saturation temperature. In
the event it is necessary to cool both the hydrazine and the catalyst, embodiment
illustrated in FIGS. 3 and 4 is preferred.
[0013] FIGS. 3 and 4 show a similar structure including thruster 10 mounted on flange 14
which represents the main frame or a subframe of the device on which thruster 10 is
mounted. Thruster 10 is supplied with liquid hydrazine through supply line 16 and
the hydrazine flow is controlled by liquid hydrazine valve 18. The liquid hydrazine
passes through inlet line 20 which is secured to inlet flange 22 mounted on chamber
housing 24. Thrust nozzle 26 discharges hot gases which result from the liquid hydrazine
dissociation to produce thrust.
[0014] In order to control the temperature of the catalyst, as well as the hydrazine in
inlet line 20, and in the injector nozzles, in order to maintain the hydrazine liquid,
thermal control of the chamber housing 24 is necessary. As indicated above, in the
preferred embodiment of FIG. 1, the thermal conduction mass 12 was supplied to control
this temperature by transferring heat from the catalyst to the flange and then to
the incoming hydrazine and main frame structure. In the preferred embodiment of FIG.
3, thruster flange 28 is mounted on three stand-offs with respect to flange 14. Two
of the stand-offs are shown at 46 and 48 in FIG. 3. Mounting bolts 32 and 34 have
their heads on thruster flange 28, their shanks pass through the tubular stand-offs
46 and 48, and their threads engage in suitable threaded holes in flange 14. The size
and material of the mounting bolts and stand-offs is chosen to transfer the correct
amount of heat to flange 14, for heating of the spacecraft. If there is more heat
available which must be disposed of to prevent vaporization of the hydrazine, it must
be disposed of in another way. In the preferred embodiment of FIG. 3, thermal control
structure 50 is in the form of a thermal mass which is clamped over inlet flange 20
and the forward end of chamber housing 24. Opening 52 accepts inlet line 20 and recess
54 accepts inlet flange 22 and the forward part of chamber housing 24, see FIGS. 3
and 4. The mass of thermal control structure 50 is a generally rectangular mass which
extends away from the center line of thruster 10 in a direction where it does not
contact the stand-offs 46 and 48 which support the thruster. The structure 50 has
a central slot 56 and a clamp screw 58. When the clamp screw is tightened, slot 56
is closed down and the thermal control structure is clamped on the front end of the
thruster in good thermal relationship in order to act as a thermal conductor. The
heat entering into the thermal mass 50 cools the incoming hydrazine and surrounding
catalyst and is conducted by a mechanical high conductivity attachment into the spacecraft
structure and then radiated to space.
[0015] FIG. 5 shows extreme pressure fluctuations and rough pressure surges 30 for a similar
thruster operating with an on/off duty cycle within the rough firing zone 60, see
FIG. 6. The principle reason for the oscillation is that a mass of hydrazine liquid
forms around the hot catalyst. Because of the heat that was transferred to the hydrazine
from the hot catalyst, some of the liquid vaporizes and, since this vapor exceeded
the autodecomposition temperature, it explosively decomposed all of the surrounding
hydrazine, causing the chamber pressure to rise. The higher pressure raised the value
of the incoming hydrazine saturation temperature, therefore preventing vaporization.
Since there was no new vapor, there was no explosive decomposition. There follows
a progressive, orderly, decomposition, since there no longer is a pool of hydrazine.
The lower chamber pressure results from less hydrazine decomposition. This lower pressure
allowed the incoming hydrazine to once again exceed the saturation temperature and
once again vaporize, resulting again in an explosive decomposition. This cycle resulted
in the wild pressure fluctuation shown at 30. When the thermal control structure 12
or 50 was supplied, heat was removed therethrough, thus lowering the temperature and
consequently eliminated the explosive decomposition and the chamber pressure became
smooth as indicated by line 32.
[0016] In summary, hydrazine must vaporize and must be at a temperature exceeding about
300°F before it can rapidly decompose, and any liquid present will add a large source
of energy in a small volume. Both conditions are required for the rough pressure surges
to occur. A well designed thruster allows orderly flow of hydrazine, starting as liquid
and then vaporizing through the catalyst bed to produce a smooth, steady operating
hydrazine dissociation process on the catalyst in the decompositon chamber. For an
old, loose catalyst bed (or for most injectors even with a new bed) if the injected
hydrazine and catalyst temperatures are sufficiently high so that a sufficiently large
mass of hydrazine vapor can form in the injector-catalyst region along with some liquid,
explosive decomposition will occur. This vapor mass will autodecompose explosively,
supplying the energy to vaporize the large mass of liquid and results in further large
energy release, causing large pressure surges that damage the catalyst and severely
limit the useful life of the thruster. To prevent these undesirable pressure surges,
it is only necessary to prevent the hydrazine from forming vapor liquid masses in
the catalyst voids that exceed the 300°F. This can be accomplished by preventing the
hydrazine liquid from contacting the catalyst whose temperature exceeds its saturation
temperature until it is safely flowing in the catalyst bed. In accordance with this
invention, the liquid hydrazine is prevented from reaching its saturation temperature
in the injector and the catalyst in the area of the incoming hydrazine is cooled to
a temperature below the hydrazine saturation point. The saturation temperature is
the boiling temperature at that pressure. It must be noted that the injector can be
above the saturation temperature as long as insufficient heat is transferred from
the injector to the liquid hydrazine to cause vaporization. The critical wall temperature
that will cause 100% vaporization and results in pressure surges can be calculated
from the followng heat balance relationship:

where:
q = heat transfer rate per unit area
h = heat transfer coefficient (calculate by Sieder-Tate Equation and boiling heat
transfer as given in standard heat transfer texts)
A = heat transfer area
Tw = injector wall temperature
T = hydrazine temperature in the injector
w = mass flow rate of hydrazine
C = specific heat of hydrazine
Tsat = saturation temperature of hydrazine at chamber pressure
Tin = hydrazine temperature entering the injector
a = latent heat-of vaporization for hydrazine at chamber pressure.
[0017] Using this relationship and employing the data for a typical injector, such as shown
in FIGS. 1 and 3 without their respective thermal control structures, the critical
wall temperature is found to be almost 1000°F. Since not all of the incoming hydrazine
must be vaporized to cause explosive decomposition, wall temperature below this calculated
value could vaporize sufficient hydrazine to cause explosive decomposition and pressure
surges. As a result, it is desirable to be conservative and limit the injector and
surrounding catalyst temperatures to the saturation temperature, thus insuring no
vaporization until the hydrazine is flowing smoothly in the bed.
[0018] The thermal control structure 12 transfers heat from the catalyst in the area of
the incoming hydrazine to both the main structure and to the hydrazine. The thermal
control structure 50 transfers heat from both the hydrazine and the catalyst in the
entrance area to the main structure.
[0019] The thermal control structures 12 and 50 are thus respectively employed to maintain
the incoming liquid hydrazine and surrounding catalyst below the saturation temperature.
The type of thermal control structure 12 or 50 is chosen so that with the desired
on/off operating ratio, the temperatures remain in the safe region for smooth thruster
operation. For any injector design, the thermal control structure 12 or 50 lowers
the injector and surrounding catalyst temperatures to conservative values below the
saturation temperature corresponding to the chamber pressure, to result in a long
operating life at any firing duty cycle.
[0020] This invention has been described in its presently contemplated best mode and it
is clear that it is susceptible to numerous modifictions, modes and embodiments within
the ability of those skilled in the art and without the exercise of the inventive
faculty. Accordingly, the scope of this invention is defined by the scope of the following
claims.
1. A hydrazine hot gas producer comprising:
a hydrazine chamber housing for containing hydrazine dissociation catalyst therein;
an outlet structure connected to said chamber for discharging from said chamber the
hot gas products of hydrazine exothermic dissociation;
hydrazine supply means connected to said chamber for supplying hydrazine to be exothermically
decomposed in said chamber; and
a thermal control structure connected to said chamber for receiving heat from said
chamber which is generated by exothermic decomposition of hydrazine within said chamber
so that incoming hydrazine supplied by said hydrazine supply means and surrounding
catalyst are at a temperatures no higher than the saturation temperature for hydrazine
at the pressure of said chamber.
2. The hydrazine hot gas producer of Claim 1 wherein said thermal control structure
is a heat sink for receiving heat from said chamber housing for use as a transient
control.
3. The hydrazine hot gas producer of Claim 2 wherein said hydrazine supply means cyclically
supplies hydrazine to said chamber housing so that cyclic thermal decomposition takes
place within said chamber housing.
4. The hydrazine hot gas producer of Claim 3 wherein said thermal control structure
comprises a metallic heat sink which is clamped onto said chamber housing adjacent
said supply means.
5. The hydrazine hot gas producer of Claim ? wherein there is support means for supporting
said chamber housing and said heat sink is clamped between said chamber housing and
said support means in order to transfer heat from the catalyst in the area of the
incoming hydrazine to the incoming hydrazine and also to the main frame structure.
6. The hydrazine hot gas producer of Claim 3 wherein there is support means for supporting
said chamber housing and said heat sink is clamped between said chamber housing and
said support means in order to transfer heat from the incoming hydrazine and the catalyst
in the entrance area to the main frame structure.
7. The hydrazine hot gas producer of Claim 1 wherein said outlet structure is a thrust
nozzle so that the structure is a thruster whereby thrust is produced when hydrazine
is dissociated.
8. The hydrazine thruster of Claim 7 wherein said thermal control structure is a heat
sink for receiving heat from said chamber housing.
9. The hydrazine thruster of Claim 7 wherein said hydrazine supply means cyclically
supplies hydrazine to said chamber housing so that cyclic thermal decomposition takes
place within said chamber housing and wherein said thermal control structure comprises
a metallic heat sink which is clamped onto said chamber housing adjacent said supply
means.
10. The hydrazine thruster of Claim 9 wherein there is support means for supporting
said chamber housing of said hydrazine thruster and said heat sink is clamped between
said chamber housing and said support means.
11. The method of producing hot gas at steady pressure from a hydrazine catalyst bed
in a hydrazine chamber comprising the steps of:
supplying liquid hydrazine through a supply line to the chamber for exothermic decomposition
of the hydrazine on catalyst within the chamber; and
withdrawing sufficient heat from the hydrazine hot gas producer so that hydrazine
is delivered as liquid from the hydrazine supply line into the chamber and so that
the surrounding catalyst is below the hydrazine saturation temperature.
12. The process of Claim 11 wherein the step of withdrawing heat is accomplished by
attaching a thermally conductive heat sink to the thruster chamber adjacent the supply
line.