BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
1. Field of the Invention
[0001] This invention relates to compounds useful as antioxidants and detergents in lubricating
oils and methods for their manufacture and, more specifically, to overbased sulfurized
phenates.
2. Setting of the Invention
[0002] Lubricating oils tend to deteriorate under normal operating conditions encountered
in present-day diesel and automotive engines. Sludge, lacquer and residence materials
can form and adhere to engine parts (especially piston rings, grooves and skirts)
possibly having a deleterious effect on engine efficiency, operation and useful life.
Commonly, additives are added to lubricating oils to reduce the formation of such
harmful materials and/or to keep them suspended so that the engine parts are kept
clean and operating properly. Additives which reduce the tendency of lubricating oils
to form oxidation products are called antioxidants, while additives which tend to
suspend oxidation products and sludges are called detergents or dispersants. It is
not uncommon for certain additives to exhibit both antioxidant and detergency properties.
We have found that sulfurized metal phenates are quite useful as antioxidants as well
as dispersants. These phenates are generally formed with an alkaline earth metal base,
such as calcium, barium, magnesium, and strontium.
[0003] The manufacture of overbased sulfurized phenates has been accomplished by several
different processes. One such process involves the reaction of a phenol, sulfur and
an alkaline earth metal base with carbon dioxide. The present invention relates to
this type of process and is exemplified by U.S. Patents 3,036,971 and 3,194,761, which
are expressly incorporated herein by reference.
[0004] It has been found that in the manufacture of lubricating oil compositions which contain
overbased sulfurized metal phenates that a haze or gel can form when the phenate is
mixed with bright stock oils. We believe that this haze or gel is due to overcarbonating
the phenate. In the manufacture of the phenate product, carbon dioxide is added to
a reaction vessel and the amount of carbon dioxide leaving the vessel is closely monitored.
When the amount of carbon dioxide leaving the vessel suddenly increases this indicates
that the carbon dioxide absorption has ceased and carbonation is complete. In practice
it has been found that even if the injection of carbon dioxide is stopped immediately
at the end of carbon dioxide absorption, the products still tend to be overcarbonated
and this can cause bright stock solubility problems. We have discovered that by undercarbonating
the overbased sulfurized phenate that the bright stock solubility problems can be
eliminated. One method of undercarbonating is to limit the amount of carbon dioxide
absorbed. Various prior art patents disclose limiting the amount of carbon dioxide
absorbed; however, none of the patents disclose limiting the amount of carbon dioxide
absorbed to prevent bright stock solubility problems. Further, we have found that
if the alkaline earth metal is added in a single charge or stage and then carbonated,
the viscosity of the reaction product increases to a level where stirring of the reaction
mixture becomes difficult and the reaction may not be complete.
[0005] United States.Patent 2,916,454 to Bradley et al. discloses limiting the amount of
carbon dioxide absorbed to a molar ratio of 0.2-0.6 carbon dioxide:phenolic compound.
Bradley does not disclose the use of an inorganic earth metal base, such as calcium,
but requires the use of complex metal alcoholates, such as barium, magnesium or sodium.
U.S. Patent 3,036,971 to Otto discloses the reaction of an alkyl phenol, calcium hydroxide,
sulfur, and a mutual solvent. Otto discloses limiting the amount of carbon dioxide
absorbed to a molar ratio of 0.2-0.6 carbon dioxide:calcium. Nowhere is it disclosed
in Otto to conduct the carbonation in stages to prevent the reaction product from
becoming too viscous. Both of these patents fail to disclose the concept of limiting
the amount of carbon dioxide absorbed to control bright stock solubility.
[0006] U.S. Patents 3,178,368 to Hanneman and 3,336,224 to Allphin disclose the reaction
of calcium sulfonate, a phenolic compound, mutual solvent, and a high molecular weight
alcohol. The amount of carbon dioxide absorbed is limited to 0.1 to 3.0 moles of carbon
dioxide per mole of phenolic compound. Nowhere is it disclosed in these
' patents to undercarbonate to control bright stock solubility or to add an alkaline
earth metal base in stages to prevent an increase in the viscosity of the reaction
product. Further, both Hanneman and Allphin require the use of high molecular weight
alcohols in the reaction. The use of these alcohols is economically unattractive because
the alcohols are expensive and must be distilled out of the final product before blending.
[0007] U.S. Patent 3,194,761 to Foy et al. discloses the reaction of a diluent oil, alkylphenol,
hydrated lime, sulfur and a mutual solvent. Carbon dioxide is bubbled through the
mixture until no more than 0.5 moles of carbon dioxide is absorbed per mole of calcium.
Thereafter, an additional amount of hydrated lime is added. U.S. Patent 3,350,210
to Herd et al. discloses the reaction of hydrated lime, methanol and carbon dioxide
at 10°-30°C. Thereafter phenol sulfide and a diluent are added. The amount of carbon
dioxide absorbed is limited to 0.4-0.8 moles of carbon dioxide per mole of calcium.
Both of these patents fail to disclose the concept of undercarbonating to control
bright stock solubility. The process of Foy et al. and Herd does not disclose the
addition of an alkaline earth metal base in stages to control viscosity. Further,
the process of Herd requires the use of methanol and a phenol sulfide.
[0008] U.S. Patent 3,923,670 to Crawford discloses the reaction of an alkyl phenol, sulfur,
an alkali metal hydroxide and ethylene glycol to which is added additional alkali
metal hydroxide and carbon dioxide. In Crawford there is no limit on the amount of
carbon dioxide absorbed, and thus there is no suggestion of undercarbonating to improve
bright stock solubility or to carbonate in stages to control viscosity.
[0009] There exists a need for a process to manufacture overbased sulfurized phenates which
can have multiple carbonation stages to control viscosity and which produces a product
that has no bright stock solubility problems.
Description of the Preferred Embodiments
[0010] The present invention provides a novel overbased sulfurized phenate produced by the
process comprising contacting at reaction conditions sulfur, a phenolic compound and
an alkaline earth metal base to produce a phenate intermediate. Thereafter, the phenate
intermediate is contacted at reaction conditions with an additional amount of the
alkaline earth metal base and carbon dioxide, wherein the amount of carbon dioxide
absorbed is in the ratio of about 0.75-0.95 moles per mole overbasing alkaline earth
metal. For the purposes of this invention, overbasing alkaline earth metal is defined
as the total moles of alkaline earth metal minus one-half of the moles of phenolic
compound. For example: if 1.04 moles of phenolic compound and 0.69 moles of Ca(OH)
2 are added in the production of the phenate intermediate and 0.89 moles of Ca(OH}
2 are added to the phenate intermediate, then the overbasing alkaline earth metal is
(0.69 + 0.89) - (1.04/2) or 1.06 moles.
[0011] Accordingly, patents that suggest that the amount of carbon dioxide added be dependent
upon the total moles of phenolic compound or the total moles of alkaline earth metal
base do not appreciate the novel concept of controlling bright stock solubility problems
by controlling the ratio of moles of carbon dioxide absorbed to overbasing alkaline
earth metal base present. In other words the present invention is not dependent upon
controlling the simple ratio of carbon dioxide to phenolic compound or alkaline earth
metal base but to a specific combination of phenolic compound, alkaline earth metal
base and carbon dioxide.
[0012] Briefly, the novel process of this invention comprises the reaction of sulfur, a
phenolic compound and an alkaline earth metal base which is, in an amount insufficient
to fully react with the phenolic compound, a mutual solvent and a diluent to produce
a phenate intermediate. The alkaline earth metal base added in the sulfurization step
to produce the phenate intermediate is from about 20% to 75% of the total amount added
and, preferably from about 40% to 60%. In certain circumstances it may be desirable
to calculate the amount of alkaline earth metal base added in the sulfurization step
based upon the phenolic compound. In this case the amount of alkaline earth metal
base added is from 0.40 to about 0.75 moles per mole of phenolic compound. The phenate
intermediate is contacted with additional alkaline earth metal base and carbon dioxide
bubbled into the mixture. The phenate intermediate can be contacted with the additional
amount of the alkaline earth metal base in stages to control the viscosity of the
reaction product. For example, the phenate intermediate can be contacted with two
additional charges of the alkaline earth metal base and carbon dioxide with the last
charge being about 1C per cent smaller in volume that the previous additional charge.
This procedure is especially useful in controlling the viscosity of the reaction mixture
in large reaction vessels or under already high viscosity conditions. Regardless of
the methods employed, the amount of carbon dioxide absorbed should be in the ratio
of about 0.70 to about 0:95 moles per mole of overbasing alkaline earth metal.
[0013] Carbon dioxide can be added in the carbonation step along with or after the addition
of the additional overbasing alkaline earth metal base. If the additional alkaline
earth metal base is added in stages the carbon dioxide can be added (a) continuously
while the alkaline earth metal base is added, (b) introduced after each addition is
completed, or (c) added only after the final addition of alkaline earth metal base.
[0014] The total base number (TBN) of the final overbased sulfurized phenate product of
this invention can vary over a wide range; however, the TBN should be between 200
and 300, and preferably close to 250 TBN.
[0015] The sulfur utilized is preferred to be elemental sulfur. Sulfur is used in an amount
from about 0.3 to about 2.5 moles of sulfur per mole of total alkaline earth metal
base incorporated. It is preferred to use from about 0.7 to about 1.25 moles of sulfur
per mole of alkaline earth metal base incorporated.
[0016] The phenolic compounds utilized are hydrocarbyl substituted phenols. The benzene
ring can contain various other substituents such as chlorine, bromine, nitro and others.
The most commonly used substituted phenols contain one or more hydrocarbyl groups
having about 1 to about 100 carbon
:atoms. Preferably, the hydrocarbyl groups contain about 8 to about 20 carbon atoms.
The hydrocarbyl groups can be alkyl, alkenyl, aralkyl or alkaryl. For reasons of cost
and availability monoalkyl- phenols are preferred. Nonoalkyl substitution in the para
position is preferred. Suitable hydrocarbon substitution can comprise low molecular
weight groups such as methyl, ethyl, propyl, isopropyl, butyl, isobutyl and the various
isomers of pentyl, heptyl, octyl, nonyl, decyl, undecyl, dodecyl and the like, including
low molecular weight polymers and copolymers. Commercially available substituted phenols
contain from 8 to 20 carbon atoms substituents from polypropylene or polybutene. The
hydrocarbyl substituted phenol can have other substituents, such as for example: chlorine,
bromine, nitro, and the like.
[0017] The alkaline earth metal base comprises a base of divalent metals such as calcium,
barium, magnesium, and strontium. The preferred metal bases are the oxides and hydroxides
of the various metals, such as calcium oxide, calcium hydroxide, barium oxide, barium
hydroxide, magnesium oxide, and the like. Calcium hydroxide, commonly called hydrated
lime, is most often used in the manufacture of these phenates. It is preferred to
use hydrated lime of good quality, relatively free of carbonates, which has not deteriorated
during storage. In certain cases, the carbonate, methoxides or other forms of base
may be used for certain metals such as magnesium.
[0018] Both the sulfurization and the carbonation reactions can be conducted in the presence
of a promoter or organic liquid which is sometimes referred to as a "mutual solvent."
The mutual solvent can comprise any stable organic liquid which has appreciable solubility
for both the alkaline earth metal base and the phenolic compound and intermediate
phenate. While a wide variety of mutual solvents can be used, suitable solvents are
glycols and glycol monoethers, such as ethylene glycol, 1,4-butene diol, and derivatives
of ethylene glycol, such as the monomethyl ether, monoethyl ether, etc. Vicinal glycols
are preferred and ethylene glycol is the most preferred since it serves to activate
the neutralization reaction in the process and to that extent typifies a catalyst,
although the exact characteristics describing its function are unknown.
[0019] Both the sulfurization and the carbonation reactions can be conducted in a diluent,
preferably a lubricating oil which remains unseparated from the final product. The
reaction diluent serves to reduce the viscosity of the intermediate phenate. to make
it readily transferable by pumping operations and the like. The amount of diluent
used can vary over a wide range, but is used in a concentration to achieve a suitable
intermediate or product viscosity for reaction and transfer while not unduly diluting
the final product when the diluent will not be separated from the final product. Mineral
lubricating oils are preferred as diluents since the ultimate use of the sulfurized
metal phenates is often in oil additives. However, any inert water-insoluble organic
medium which will not react or interfere with the reaction of the process is suitable.
Although hydrocarbon oils and particularly petroleum oils are generally utilized in
this process, other oils can also be used, such as synthetic, hydrocarbon, polymer
oils prepared by condensation .or other methods. Light lubricating oils are particularly
preferred and may be of a synthetic, animal, vegetable or mineral origin. Mineral
lubricating oils are preferred by reason of their availability, general excellence
and low cost. The lubricating oils preferred will be fluid oils, ranging in viscosity
from about 40 Saybolt Universal Seconds at 100°F (38°C) to about 200 Saybolt Universal
Seconds at 210°F (99°C).
[0020] The molar ratios of the materials utilized in the present process can vary over a
wide range depending upon the desired level of sulfur to be present in the final product
and the desired TBN. The molar ratios for phenolic compound:alkaline earth metal base
are about 1:0.4-2. The final product can have molar ratios of phenolic compound:alkaline
earth metal base of about 1:0.5-0.7 for a low base material and about 1:1.5-1.8 for
high based materials. The molar ratios for phenolic compound:sulfur can be 1:8-1.2
for low base materials and about 1:1.5-1.8 for high based materials. The molar ratios
for phenolic compound:carbon dioxide can be about 1:0.5-1.3. However, it is critical
that the molar ratio of carbon dioxide to overbasing alkaline earth metals be about
0.70 to about 0.95.
[0021] The sulfurization and the carbonation reactions of this invention can be conducted
at temperatures from about 200°F to about 400°F (94°C-205°C). Preferably, the reactions
are conducted at temperatures from about 300°F to about 360°F (148.8°-182.2°C). Higher
temperatures within this range are preferred for several reasons. The higher temperatures
aid in reducing the harmful effect of water in the reaction, which will be discussed
in detail later, and to prevent phenate-sulfonate compatibility (PSC) problems. At
lower reaction temperatures PSC problems can manifest themselves by the formation
qf an insoluble, hazy substance in the product. By conducting the reactions at above
300°F the PSC problems can be eliminated or at least substantially reduced.
[0022] The overbased sulfurized phenates produced by the present process can be mixed with
any suitable lubricating oil bases or compositions. The concentration of the overbased
sulfurized metal phenates in the final lubricating oil composition depends upon the
type of base oil used and the particular properties desired. The concentration can
range from about 0.75 to about 15 weight per cent with the major portion of the lubricating
oil composition being the oil. Many different oils can be used such as naphthenic,
paraffinic and mixed base oils, coal oils and synthetic oils. Further, other additives
can be included in the final product to provide multifunctional properties, such as
stabilizers, extreme pressure agents, tackiness agents, antiodor agents, pour point
depressants, viscosity index improvers, antiwear agents, antioxidants, anticorrodants,
metal deactivators, etc.
[0023] In the preferred embodiment of the present invention, the method of undercarbonating
is accomplished by limiting the amount of carbon dioxide to about 0.7-0.95 moles of
carbon dioxide per mole of overbasing alkaline earth metal. None of the prior art
processes I know of contemplates (a) reacting sulfur, a phenolic compound and an amount
of alkaline earth metal base insufficient to react with the phenolic compound to form
a phenate intermediate, and (b) contacting the phenate intermediate with an additional
amount of the alkaline earth metal base and carbon dioxide, wherein the amount of
carbon dioxide absorbed is limited to 0.70-0.95 moles per mole of overbasing alkaline
earth metal. The amount of alkaline earth metal base should not be reduced when undercarbonating
because it is primarily the base which keeps the oxidation products suspended. It
should be noted that I have found that undercarbonating below the limits disclosed
can cause other problems. For example, if 0.5 moles of carbon dioxide per mole of
overbasing alkaline earth metal is used in the present process, the carbonization
would be incomplete and the final product would be unstable and not exhibit the required
antioxidant and dispersant characteristics.
[0024] As another embodiment of the present invention to prevent overcarbonation, I have
found that a solvent can be used in place of the diluent oil to make the observable
carbon dioxide absorption, the point at which no more carbon dioxide can be absorbed,
to coincide exactly with the point at which the carbon dioxide introduction should
be stopped to successfully undercarbonate the phenate product. I have discovered that
the use of an aromatic solvent, such as xylenes or C
9 aromatics in lieu of all or a significant portion of the diluent oil will coalesce
the observable and the optimum end points of the carbon dioxide absorption. Termination
of carbon dioxide introduction at the observed point while using those solvents has
resulted in overbased sulfurized phenates having excellent bright stock solubility.
The preparation of the overbased sulfurized phenates using these solvents is essentially
the same as has been described above; however, all or a portion of the diluent oil
can be left out of the process. It is desirable to retain up to about 46 per cent
of the normal amount of diluent oil to control the viscosity during the sulfurization
step. In the process using solvents the reaction mixture is cooled to under about
275°F when adding the xylene or C
9 aromatics, mutual solvent and calcium hydroxide. Carbonation is initiated when the
reaction mixture has been heated to about 300° to 310°F, which is the reflux temperature
of the C
9 aromatics or about 285°F for the xylenes. A mixture of water and mutual solvent,
such as ethylene glycol, can be removed during the carbonation step to prevent water
build up in the reaction vessel. When the carbonation reaction is complete, the introduced
solvents and other volatile materials are stripped from the reaction mixture as the
required amount of diluent oil is added. The use of these solvents can be particularly
helpful in undercarbonating the phenate product when utilizing very high viscosity
starting materials or when the viscosity of the reaction mixture needs to be - especially
low.
[0025] I have also found that the formation of water during the process of this invention
can have a harmful effect on the bright stock solubility of the final phenate product.
Water is continuously produced in the process and can be removed by conducting the
process under a vacuum or by refluxing any introduced solvents, such as xylene. When
5-weight oil is used as the diluent, the concentration of water in the reaction vessel
appears to reach a steady state and no additional water can be removed from the reaction
vessel about two-thirds of the way through the carbonation step. If carbonation is
allowed to continue beyond this point, poor bright stock solubility can result from
overcarbonation. In contrast, finished products utilizing xylene as a solvent with
continuous water removal range from only slightly hazy to bright and clear in the
bright stock solubility tests. I know that aromatic solvents, such as xylenes and
C
Q aromatics, are excellent solvents for preparing overbased sulfurized phenates when
using bright stock base oils. Paraffinic solvents, such as 5-W oil and dodecane, do
not have as good solvent characteristics as the aromatic solvents. We also know that
the two azeotropes, H
20 + xylenes and H
20
+ dodecane, have about the same composition and boiling points while 5-W oil + H
20 do not form an azeotrope and water removal is poor. Therefore, since xylenes and
dodecane form similar types of azeotropes, the nature of the solvent used (polar vs.
nonpolar) probably has an effect on micelle structure and hence on the ability to
remove water from the process.
[0026] Various methods can be undertaken to minimize the production of water, during the
reaction, such as a purge of the reaction mixture with nitrogen gas during the carbonation
step, the use of insulated jackets around the upper portions of the reactor vessel,
and carbonating at higher temperatures. Also, substituting calcium oxide for the calcium
hydroxide should assist in dehydrating the reaction mixture. Although no stoichiometry
of the calcium oxide process should not require the removal of water, the system can
be easily overcarbonated at 300°F if the carbon dioxide absorption is allowed to continue
to the observable break point when not using xylene or C
9 aromatics. Conducting'the carbonation under dehydrating conditions using a 360°F
carbonation temperature and insulating the reaction vessels has significantly decreased
the amount of water generated in the reaction mixture.
[0027] I have found that the concentration of water should be reduced to a minimum approximately
two-thirds of the way through the carbonation. At this point, the reaction mixture
becomes extremely hydroscopic and the undesired side reaction leading to overcarbonation
takes place. It should be noted that a dehydrating step can generate a viscous mass
which cannot be easily carbonated at lower mixing efficiencies, so the stepwise carbonation
of the present process'is most useful in controlling the viscosity of the reaction
mixture.
[0028] The following examples are provided only to aid in illustrating the invention and
are not to limit or restrict the invention in any way.
Example I--Process Conducted Using A Reduced Amount of Carbon Dioxide
[0029] Into a two liter flask was added a mixture of 272
g (1.04m) of dodecylphenol, 260 g of 5-weight oil as diluent, 47 g (1.47m) of elemental
sulfur, 51 g (0.69m) of Ca(OH)
2 and 80 g (1.29m) of ethyene glycol. The mixture was heated at 149°C for two hours.
Thereafter, 66 g (0.89m) of Ca(OH)
2 was added and the reaction mixture was treated with carbon dioxide gas injected at
1.2 liters/min. at 149°C until 18.3 liters (0.82m) of carbon dioxide was absorbed
(in about 23 min.). The resulting product was stripped by injection of nitrogen gas
(N
2) at
232°C and then filtered through diatomaceous earth. The physical properties of the
final product are shown in Table 1.
Example II--Process Conducted Using An Increased Amount of Carbon Dioxide
[0030] The same procedure was followed as in Example I except that carbon dioxide injection
was continued until 1.08m were absorbed. The physical properties of the final product
are shown in Table I.
Example III--Process Conducted Using An Increased Phenate Concentration
[0031] Into a two liter flask were added 403 g (1.54m) of dodecylphenol, 260 g of 5-weight
oil as diluent, 68 g (2.14m) of elemental sulfur, 65 g (0.88m) of Ca(OH)
2 and 80 g (1.29m) of ethylene glycol. The mixture was heated to 149°C for two hours.
Thereafter, 72 g (0.97m) of Ca(OH)
2 were added and the reaction mixture was treated with carbon dioxide gas injected
at 1.2 liters/min. at 149°C' until 23.9 liters (1.00m) of carbon dioxide were absorbed
(in about 30 min.). The resulting product was stripped by injection of nitrogen gas
(N
2) at 232°C and then filtered through diatomaceous earth. The physical properties of
the final product are shown in Table I.
Example IV--Process Conducted Using An Increased Temperature of Reaction
[0032] The same procedure was followed as in Example I except that the sulfurization was
conducted at 182°C and 40 g (0.65m) of ethylene glycol were added prior to the second
addition of Ca(OH)
2. The physical properties of the final product are shown in Table I.

Example V--Use of 5-W Oil and C
9 Aromatics
[0033] Into a two liter flask was added a mixture of 272 g (1.04m) of dodecylphenol, 120
g 5-weight oil (about 46 per cent of that normally used), 80 g (1.30m) of ethylene
glycol, 47 g (1.47m) of elemental sulfur and 51 g (0.69m) of Ca(OH)
2 and was heated to 149°C for 2 hours. The reaction mixture was cooled to about 12
1-
135°C by adding 160 g of C
9 aromatics, 40 g (0.65m) of ethylene glycol and 75 g (1.0m) of Ca(OH)
2. The reaction mixture was heated to reflux (14
9-154°C) and thereafter carbonated with carbon dioxide injection at 0.79 liters/min.
until absorption ceased at 23 liters absorbed. One hundred and forty grams (140 g)
of 5-weight oil were added as the product was stripped by a purge of nitrogen gas
(N
2) at
232°
C. The product was then filtered through diatomaceous earth. The physical properties
of the final product are shown in Table II.
Example VI--Use of 5-W Oil and Xylenes
[0034] Into a two liter flask was added a mixture of 272 g (1.04m) of dodecylphenol, 120
g of 5-weight oil, 80 g (1.28m) of ethylene glycol, 40 g (1.25m) of elemental sulfur
and 51 g (0.69m) of Ca(OH)
2 and was heated to 149°C for 2.5 hours. The reaction mixture was cooled to about 121-135°C
and 100 g of xylenes and 60 g (0.97m) of ethylene glycol were added. The mixture was
heated to reflux (137-141°C) and 75 g (1.0m) of Ga(OH)
2 were added. Carbon dioxide injection was initiated at 1.22 liters/min. and continued
until absorption ceased at 25.3 liters absorbed. One hundred and forty grams (140
g) of 5-weight oil were added as the product was stripped by a purge of nitrogen gas
(N
2) at 232°C The product was then filtered through diatomaceous earth. The physical
properties of the final product are shown in Table II. Example VII--Use of CaO and
Sulfurization at
182°
C
[0035] Into a 5 liter flask were added 179 g of CaO, 952 g of dodecylphenol, 910 g of 5-weight
oil as diluent, 224 g of ethylene glycol, and 165 g of elemental sulfur. This reaction
mixture was heated with a spherical heating mantle to '182°C and maintained at 182°
C for 2 hours. Water was removed from the flask in a Dean Stark trap. A total of 127
g of distillate was removed which contained 73 g of water (as determined by the Karl
Fisher method). The flask with the phenate intermediate was maintained at 182°C' and
carbon dioxide was bubbled into the mixture at 1.68 1/min. until 7 liters were absorbed.
One hundred grams (100 g) of calcium oxide and 63 ml of ethylene glycol were added.
The carbon dioxide injection was reinitiated at 1.68 1/min. until 33 liters were absorbed
(31 min.). During carbonation, 81 g of distillate containing 14 g of water were collected.
The product was then stripped by injection of nitrogen gas (N
2) at
232°
C and then filtered through diatomaceous earth. The physical properties of the final
product are shown in Table II.

[0036] As can be seen from the above examples various methods can be used singularly or
in combination to improve the bright stock solubility of overbased sulfurized metal
phenates. The most important of these methods being undercarbonating the phenate product
which yields a product which has excellent antioxidant and dispersant qualities.
[0037] Whereas the present invention has been described in particular relation to the examples
and embodiments disclosed herein, it should be understood that other and further modifications
of the present invention, apart from those shown·or suggested herein, may be made
within the scope and spirit of the invention.