[0001] This invention relates to protective toe-caps for use in safety shoes or boots which
are intended to provide the wearer with protection against damage to the toes arising
from accidental heavy impact on the toe portion of the shoe or boot.
[0002] Conventionally used metal toe-caps have the disadvantage that the resulting shoe
is heavy and uncomfortable to wear. In addition the metal insert is subject to corrosion
and expensive to manufacture. A toe-cap has now been devised which is lighter and
less expensive to manufacture than a metal toe-cap and is not subject to corrosion.
[0003] According to the invention there is provided a protective toe-cap comprising a domed
member adapted to lie over the toes of the wearer and having an open end to receive
the toes, said domed member comprising a formable polymeric composition, optionally
reinforced with randomly disposed fibres characterised in that the domed member is
reinforced with uniaxially aligned continuous fibres bonded to the formable polymer
of the dome member. Optionally the toe-cap may be provided with a flange extending
inwardly from at least part of the base of the domed member.
[0004] The presence of the aligned continuous fibres in the toe-cap permits substantial
improvement in the resistance to impact to be obtained.
[0005] The formable polymeric composition used to fabricate the toe-cap may be any polymeric
composition which is capable of being formed into the required shape in a mould. For
example, it may be a thermoplastics composition which can be melted and injection
moulded. Alternatively it may be a dough moulding thermosetting polymer composition
which is introduced into the mould in an uncured fluid state and is cured in the mould.
Yet again it may be a thermoplastics composition which is incompletely polymerised
when injected into a mould but is cured therein. The latter technique is termed "reaction
injection moulding". A preferred method of forming toe-caps from a formable polymer
composition is by compression moulding of a blank or sheet of a thermoplastics polymer,
preferably containing randomly disposed reinforcing fibres particularly continuous
fibres. Sheets of material made by thermoplastic polymer melt impregnation of glass
mats containing randomly disposed continuous fibres are particularly suitable.
[0006] The essential feature of the invention is the presence of the aligned, continuous
reinforcing fibres. Such fibres may be included in the toe-cap by a number of methods.
In a first method required lengths of continuous fibres may be positioned and restrained
in a mould prior to the introduction of the mouldable polymer composition. Introduction
of the mouldable composition into the mould and completion of any additional process
steps, for example curing, results in a finished article containing continuous, aligned
fibres embedded in a polymer matrix. The aligned fibre reinforcement will be in the
required position providing the introduction of the curable composition has not displaced
the continuous aligned fibres from the originally chosen position. This method has
the potential disadvantages that the continuous, aligned fibres will be displaced
from their chosen position during introduction of the mouldable composition. A more
important disadvantage is that the fibres may not be adequately wetted when the mouldable
polymer is introduced and the maximum benefit of the reinforcement may not be derived.
[0007] In a preferred method the continuous, aligned fibres are introduced in the form of
preformed reinforced polymer strips which consist of continuous, aligned fibres embedded
in a polymer matrix. A suitable method of forming such a product is described in European
patent publication No. 56703. Such a strip can be prepared under conditions which
ensure that the fibres are thoroughly wetted by the polymer to ensure that the reinforcement
properties are maximised. Strips reinforced with continuous fibres can be readily
located in a mould, particularly in a process in which the strip is used in conjunction
with a sheet containing randomly dispersed fibres in a compression moulding process
to form the toe-cap. The reinforcement may be provided by a single strip or a plurality
of strips.
[0008] The continuous, aligned fibres whether used as untreated fibres or as a preformed
strip are positioned in the mould so that their position in the finished toe-cap will
give a required level of protection to the wearer. The protection against impact provided
by the toe-cap is assessed according to British Standard No. BS 953:1979 which gives
levels of performance ranging from a 40 joule drop test up to a 200 joule drop test.
The quantity and placement of the continuous, aligned fibres in the domed member will
depend on the level of performance required of the toe-cap. The preferred disposition
of the fibres is with the fibres lying uniaxially across the toe-cap since this disposition
provides the most effective resistance to impact. For maximum effectiveness reinforcement
should be provided at least in a band extending up to the edge of the open end of
the domed member. The performance improves as the width of the band increases and
should extend inwardly from the open end for at least 10 mm and preferably at least
20 mm. Preferably, the continuous fibres should extend across the whole width of the
toe-cap, that is from the base of the side wall on one side of the cap to the base
of the side wall on the other side of the cap. The fibres may also extend into the
flange at the base of the toe-cap. The toe-cap may be provided with continuous fibres
aligned across the whole of the toe-cap but in general such a construction is expensive
and is not necessary for providing adequate protection.
[0009] Although the preferred disposition of continuous fibres is across the toe-caps, or
in other words parallel to the edge of the open end of the toe-cap, other dispositions
can be used. The continuous fibres may, at least in part, be disposed along the length
of the toe cap, that is lie in a direction along at least an upper part of the domed
member from the open end towards the toe end. In particular, woven, continuous, aligned
fibre structures may be used for insertion into the mould and may be disposed so that
none of the aligned fibre elements making up the woven structure is parallel to the
edge of the open end of the toe-cap.
[0010] When the reinforcement is introduced as a preformed reinforced polymer strip such
strips may be present in side-by-side relationship, indirectly superimposed relationship
or as part of a structure woven from the strips.
[0011] The essential requirements of the continuous fibres used are that they should be
continuous and should be substantially aligned in parallel manner. By the term "continuous"
is meant that the fibres should be at least 20 mm long. Preferably the fibres should
be at least 50 mm long. The fibres may be of any material which will provide reinforcement,
including inorganic fibres and synthetic polymer fibres. Particularly useful for increasing
the flexural modulus of the toe-cap are glass fibres and carbon fibres. Although the
latter give the better properties their present cost leaves glass fibres as the preferred
fibrous reinforcement.
[0012] The preferred formable polymer compositions are based on thermoplastic polymers because
of the versatility of such materials in being adaptable to a variety of forming processes.
The thermoplastic polymer used should have high flexural modulus for optimum performance.
Inexpensive polymers such as poly(ethylene terephthalate), nylons and polypropylene
are suitable. The compositions may contain additives to improve stiffness and toughness.
Randomly disposed glass fibres are a particularly useful additive.
[0013] When the continuous, aligned fibres are provided in the form of a preformed reinforced
polymer strip the polymer of the strip may be the same or different from the polymer
of the formable polymer composition. Where the two materials differ in chemical nature
they should nevertheless be compatible so that the preformed strip is strongly bonded
to the remainder of the toe-cap after the fabrication process is completed. In general,
it is preferred that the chemical nature of the polymers in the preformed strip and
the remainder of the toe-cap are the same, although they may differ substantially
in average molecular weight.
[0014] The toe-caps of the invention may be of substantially uniform thickness or may be
of varying thickness, the dimensions and profile of the toe-cap being defined by the
mould cavity in which the aligned continuous fibres are incorporated in the toe-cap.
For example, in the process of compression moulding a toe-cap male and female moulding
tools may define a die cavity of varying thickness as illustrated in Figures 1 to
4 of the accompanying drawings wherein:
Figure 1 is an end elevation of a toe-cap produced in accordance with the invention
looking from the open end thereof;
Figure 2 is a top plan view of the toe cap of Figure 1;
Figure 3 is a cross-section on the line A-A of Figure 2; and
Figure 4 is a cross-section on the line B-B of Figure 2.
[0015] Referring to the drawings, the toe-cap 10 has a generally curved shape for conforming
to the toe part of a safety boot or shoe so that, in use, it will bridge the toes
in front of and to the side of the toes. The toe cap is in the form of a single continuous
curve in three dimensions and is produced from a formable polymeric composition, optionally
reinforced with randomly disposed fibres, and a reinforcement of uniaxially aligned
continuous fibres bonded to the formable polymer as hereinbefore described.
[0016] The main area 12 of the toe-cap is of substantially uniform thickness but the front
part 14 and the forward part of the sides 16 are of increased thickness relative to
the main area 12 as will be seen from Figure 3. These thickened parts 14 and the forward
part of the sides 16 taper into and merge smoothly with the main area 12 as shown
in Figure 4 and taper further back to the edge area 18 at the open end of the toe-cap.
The sides 16 are also of increased thickness at the base of the toe-cap and taper
upwardly therefrom into the main area 12 as is clearly illustrated in Figure 1.
[0017] A flange 20 extends inwardly around the toe-cap 10 around the base thereof. As illustrated,
this flange 20 will provide additional stiffness to the toe-cap but it is not essential.
It may be necessary however to provide at least a small inwardly extending edge to
the base of the toe-cap for use in locating and securing the toe-cap in position in
the safety boot or shoe.
[0018] It will be appreciated that different relative thicknesses of the parts of the toe-cap
may be provided according to the size of the footwear within which it is to be secured.
For example, in a typical man's safety boot, the main area 12 of the toe-cap 10 may
be of the order of 3.5 millimetres thickness tapering down to 2.5 millimetres at the
edge area 18. The thickened front part 14 may be of the order of 6 millimetres thickness
whilst the sides 16 may be of the order of 4 millimetres thickness at their base tapering
into the main area 12.
[0019] This gradual merging and tapering of the thickness around the front-end of the toe-cap
helps to strengthen the whole of the toe-cap and thereby allows an acceptably thin
main area 12 to be utilised. It is important to avoid excessive thickness in the main
area 12 because this would adversely affect the appearance of the boot or shoe which,
for commercial reasons, may well have to be styled into a fashion product to some
extent as well as functioning as safety footwear. The limited thickening and gradual
taper of the front part of the toe-cap merely adds a requirement for a small increase
in length and does not detract significantly from the appearance of the footwear.
[0020] A further feature which may be provided as an improvement in the appearance of the
footwear, the ease of building the toe-cap into a boot or shoe, and the comfort of
the wearer, is that the rear edge area 18 of the toe-cap may be provided with a lip
tapered in thickness relative to the main area 12 to facilitate a smooth transition
of the toe-cap with the remainder of the boot or shoe. The decreased thickness in
this lip extending beyond edge area 18 does not significantly affect the strength
of the toe-cap as a whole. This lip will normally comprise a material which does not
include significant amounts of uniaxially disposed fibres.
[0021] The invention is further described with reference to the following example.
EXAMPLE 1
[0022] Samples of a glass mat reinforced polypropylene sheet (supplied as 'Symalit' GM40PP,
containing 40% by weight of glass fibres) having a thickness of 3 mm were cut into
blanks having dimensions 13 cm x 7 cm. Samples of uniaxially glass-reinforced polypropylene
pultrusion prepared according to the disclosure of Example 7 of European Patent Publication
No. 56703 having a cross-section of 12.5 mm x 2 mm, were cut to lengths of 13 mm.
The polypropylene used had a low molecular weight, exhibiting a melt viscosity of
5 Ns/m
2 at 260°C. Both the reinforced sheet and the reinforced pultrusions were placed in
an infra-red preheat oven, maintained at 300°C, for 1 minute. A toe-cap was moulded
from the heat softened components using a toe-cap mould comprising male and female
moulding tools defining a cavity of uniform thickness. The male and female components
of the toe-cap mould were bolted to opposite platens of a press to provide mating
engagement when the press was closed. The press platens were maintained at 70°C. Two
pultruded strips were removed from the oven and located in superimposed relationship
in the male tool of a toe-cap mould so that in the finished moulding they would be
located around that part of the toe-cap defining the open end of the toe-cap. The
sample of sheet was placed in the female tool of the mould. The press was closed to
give a pressure of 30 kg/cm
2 of platen and was maintained for 1 minute. The operation produced a smooth surfaced
toe-cap with the pultrusion strips embedded in the toe-cap. When using other polymeric
materials in the uniaxially reinforced insert or the randomly reinforced sheet the
conditions of temperature and pressures used should be sufficient to unite the uniaxially
reinforced member with the randomly reinforced member.
EXAMPLE 2
[0023] The procedure of Example 1 was repeated except in that the toe-cap was formed from
a glass mat reinforced polypropylene sheet containing 50% by weight of glass fibres
(supplied as 'Symalit' GM50PP). The same pultrusion was used as in Example 1 and all
other conditions remained the same.
1. A protective toe cap for use in safety foot wear comprising a domed member adapted
to lie over the toes of the wearer and having an open end to receive the toes, said
domed member comprising a formable polymeric composition optionally reinforced with
randomly disposed fibres characterised in that the domed member is reinforced with
uniaxially aligned continuous fibres bonded to the formable polymer of the domed member.
2. A protective toe cap as claimed in Claim 1 wherein the said uniaxially aligned
continuous fibres are present in a polymer matrix in a pre-formed strip bonded to
the formable polymer of the domed member.
3. A protective toe cap as claimed in Claim 2 wherein the formable polymer is a sheet
of randomly disposed continuous reinforced fibres.
41 A protective toe cap as claimed in any one of Claims 1 to 3 wherein said uniaxially
aligned continuous fibres are-bonded to the domed member at or adjacent the said open
end thereof.
5. A protective toe cap as claimed in any one of the preceding claims wherein said
uniaxially aligned continuous fibres lie in a direction across at least an upper part
of the domed member from side to side thereof.
6. A protective toe cap as claimed in any one of Claims 1 to 4 wherein said uniaxially
aligned continuous fibres lie in a direction along at least an upper part of the domed
member from the said open end thereof towards the toe end.
7. A method of manufacturing a protective toe cap for use in safety foot wear wherein
the toe cap comprises a domed member adapted to receive the toes of the wearer and
having an open end to receive the toes comprising the steps of moulding said domed
member from a formable polymeric composition optionally reinforced with randomly disposed
fibres between male and female moulding tools characterised in that uniaxially aligned
continuous fibre reinforcement is located between the moulding tools prior to the
moulding of the domed member and is bonded to the polymeric compositions during the
moulding operation.
8. A method as claimed in Claim 7 wherein said uniaxially aligned continuous fibre
reinforcement is in the form of a preformed polymer matrix strip.
9. A method as claimed in Claim 8 wherein the polymeric composition comprises a sheet
thereof and the polymer matrix strip is bonded to said sheet during the moulding of
the domed member from said sheet.