[0001] This invention relates to loudspeaker cabinets. Many different designs of loudspeaker
cabinet have been proposed with a view to reducing the effect of resonances. It is
known for example that when considering the rigidity of a speaker cabinet one must
take into account bending resonances and also resonance effects resulting from the
interaction of the mass of the panels and the compliance of the enclosed volume of
air. It is known that one way to raise this resonance in frequency is to reduce the
mass of the panels from which the cabinet is made. Attempts have been made to find
panels which are both lighter and stiffer than wood. One proposal which has been made,
as mentioned for example in "Hi-Fi Answers", July 1982, is to use panels of a sandwich
construction, similar to that used for aircraft panels. Such sandwiches comprise two
thin sheets of aluminium or aluminium alloy separated by an aluminium or aluminium
alloy honeycomb structure. Panels made from such sandwich material have an extremely
high stiffness to mass ratio, and in theory are therefore well-suited for use as panels
for a loudspeaker cabinet. However, it has previously been considered that sandwich-type
material, although having a high stiffness to mass ratio, performs less well than
chipboard panels when one considers the effect known as critical frequency. Above
a particular frequency, known as the critical frequency, a panel becomes substantially
transparent to sound, and at frequencies above this critical frequency the panels
of the loudspeaker cabinet allow sound to escape through the panels. This can cause
colouration of the sound for example. Consequently, because of this lowering -of the
critical frequency, and also because of the considerable cost of the basic sandwich
material, the use of such material for the panels of loudspeaker cabinets has been
effectively dismissed.
[0002] The present invention is based upon the discovery that the problem of critical frequency
can be overcome, using panel material having a high stiffness to mass ratio, if one
includes acoustic absorbing means arranged appropriately within the cabinet.
[0003] It is of course well-known to provide sound-absorbing material within a loudspeaker
cabinet. Conventionally, this is achieved by filling the cabinet enclosure with fibreglass
for example, or by lining the cabinet walls.
[0004] In accordance with the present invention there is provided a loudspeaker cabinet
comprising walls of a material having a high stiffness to mass ratio at least one
drive unit, and sound-absorbing means within the enclosure defined by the walls, said
sound -absorbing means being of a composition and/or so arranged that its sound-absorbing
properties differ in dependence on its position in the cabinet.
[0005] The effect of the sound-absorbing means is to overcome, or at least substantially
reduce, the adverse effect of critical frequency, and to balance the effects of reflection
and absorption of sound and thus avoid or reduce the transparency of the cabinet to
sound.
[0006] Preferably, the sound-absorbing means comprises foam material positioned within the
cabinet. The sound-absorbing means may be positioned simply around the drive unit
or drive units, or alternatively, may be designed substantially to fill the cabinet
enclosure.
[0007] The absorbing material forms an acoustic "wedge", i.e. is acoustically graded so
that its frequency absorption characteristics gradually change as one moves further
away from the drive unit or units.
[0008] Various alternative embodiments of loudspeaker cabinet construction in accordance
with the invention will now be described by way of example, and with reference to
the accompanying drawings, in which:
Fig. 1 is a longitudinal view, partly in section, taken down through the centre of
a loudspeaker cabinet, illustrating the use of a honeycomb sandwich structure for
the panels, but not showing the internal sound-absorbing means;
Fig. 2 is a schematic side view of a loudspeaker cabinet, partly in section, and showing
one configuration of sound-absorbing material within the cabinet enclosure;
Fig. 3 shows an alternative disposition of the sound-absorbing material around a drive
unit within the cabinet enclosure; and,
Fig. 4 shows a further alternative configuration of sound-absorbing material for use
within the cabinet enclosure.
[0009] Referring first to Fig. 1, the loudspeaker cabinet is shown as comprising a top panel
10, a rear panel 12, two side panels (one of which is shown at 14), a base 16 and
a front panel 18. As is indicated at 20, all the panels are made of a sandwich material
having a high stiffness to mass ratio. One such material which is suitable for use
is a sandwich comprising two sheets of aluminium or aluminium alloy filled with a
honeycomb of aluminium or aluminium alloy foil. A typical material is that sold by
Ciba-Geigy and known by the trademark "Aeroweb". Such a sandwich has a honeycomb core
made by fastening ribbons of foil together in a layered slab by suitably spaced adhesive
stripes perpendicular to the long axis of the ribbons and then expanding the slab
to produce a hexagonal cell structure, as indicated at 20 in Fig. 1. The sandwich
is notably stiffer along -the long axis of the ribbons than perpendicular thereto.
Preferably, the panel material is arranged so that the ribbons of the honeycomb structure
run parallel to the longer sides of each panel. In the embodiment shown, the line
of the ribbons runs vertically for the two side panels 14, and for the front panel
18 and rear panel 12, and from side to side of the cabinet for the top panel 10 and
base 16. Preferably, the base 16 of the cabinet is formed in two pieces, joined at
the centre of the base, with each base portion being a continuation of the respective
side panel. The top panel 10, the two side panels 14 and the two portions of the base
16 can be made from one length of sandwich material suitably machined, folded and
wrapped around to form the desired rectangular configuration. The front panel 18 and
the rear panel 12 can then be fitted into the open-ended box defined by the other
panels, and can be suitably secured in place, for example by adhesive.
[0010] As shown in Fig. 1, the front panel 18 has cutouts 22 to receive the loudspeaker
drive units (not shown). A rebated panel 24 is laminated to the front panel 18 to
enable flush mounting of the drive units.
[0011] Although reference is made herein to the use of an aluminium sandwich/honeycomb material,
it should be clearly understood that the invention is not limited to the use of such
a material. The advantage of such a sandwich material is that it has a very low mass
per unit area, and a very high stiffness to mass ratio. Any material having comparable
parameters, or indeed better performance in terms of stiffness to mass ratio, could
equally well be used as a panel material for the cabinet.
[0012] A particularly preferred "Aeroweb" material is that known as Type 3003. This has
a minimum compression strength of 2.76 MN/m
2, a nominal longitudinal beam shear strength of 2.2 MN/m
2, a nominal transverse beam shear strength of 1.6MN/m
2. a nominal thickness of 12.5mm. and an average weight of 4.6Kg/m
2.
[0013] The essence of the present invention lies in the appreciation that, coupled with
the use of such materials for the cabinet shell, one can achieve vastly improved performance
by incorporating within the cabinet appropriately arranged sound-absorbing means which
will raise the critical frequency, or even substantially eliminate critical frequency
as a phenomenon which has to be catered for.
[0014] Fig. 2 illustrates one way in which a sound-absorbing means can be incorporated within
the cabinet enclosure. Here, a plurality of blocks 28 of sound- absorbent material,
preferably a foam material, are positioned around the drive unit 29 and are appropriately
secured in place. Depending upon the degree of sound absorption which one wishes to
achieve within the cabinet enclosure, one can provide the blocks either just around
the drive unit itself, or alternatively to fill the whole cabinet enclosure.
[0015] Fig. 3 shows an alternative arrangement in which layers 30 of flexible sound-absorbing
material are wrapped around the drive unit 29. Again, the layers 30 may be provided
only in the immediate vicinity of the drive unit, or can be arranged substantially
to fill the cabinet enclosure.
[0016] Fig. 4 shows yet another way of providing a sound-absorbing means within the cabinet
shell. Here, the sound-absorbing material comprises a plurality of generally triangular
cross-section pieces 32 of sound-absorbing material, such as a foamed material, formed
as wedges or prisms and suitably arrayed to form a sound-absorbing barrier. These
triangular cross-section elements 32 need not necessarily all be of the same material
or all have the same sound-absorbing characteristics. For example, one could make
up the barrier from two different materials, designed to absorb different frequency
ranges, and positioned alternately, as indicated for example by the cross-hatching
in Fig. 4. The individual blocks or wedges 32 could either be fitted piece- by-piece
into the cabinet enclosure, or alternatively the pieces could be glued on to a fabric
backing in an appropriate configuration so that the fabric with the pieces glued thereon
could then simply be folded and inserted as a unit into the cabinet enclosure.
[0017] It is necessary, whatever the actual form of the sound-absorbing material, to arrange
it in the form of an acoustic "wedge" or transmission line. In other words, the sound-absorbing
material is appropriately graded in relation to its position within the cabinet enclosure
so that there is a change in its sound-absorbing properties as one moves away from
the drive unit towards the cabinet panels.
[0018] Absorbent materials which have low sound-absorbing properties are also substantially
non-reflective of sound waves, i.e. the sound waves pass easily through them. Similarly,
highly absorbent materials are more reflective of sound waves. In accordance with
the present invention the absorbing material within the enclosure is graded so that
the material nearer to the drive unit is lightly absorbent and therefore substantially
non-reflective, while the material most remote from the drive unit is strongly absorbent
and therefore more reflective. This has the advantageous result that the sound waves
within the enclosure are not reflected back to the drive unit by the first absorbing
material which they encounter, and additionally the subsequent absorbing material
absorbs most of the waves, thereby to prevent them reaching the cabinet walls. In
other words both the drive unit and the cabinet walls are substantially freed from
direct or reflected sound waves.
[0019] If an air space is left within the cabinet, this is preferably adjacent to the walls,
not next to the drive unit.
[0020] Although in the embodiment described above one is working with a panel-form cabinet
shell which is then filled or partially filled with a sound-absorbing material, one
could, within the scope of the present invention, construct a cabinet in the reverse
sense. In other words, one could start from a block for example of foamed material,
and then enclose this sound-absorbing material within an outer shell or skin which
could be formed by panels, moulding, spray-coating, etc., provided that the outer
shell has the high stiffness to mass ratiocharac- teristics discussed earlier. More
generally, although a panel-form construction has been referred to above in relation
to the presently preferred embodiment, any other method of or materials for producing
a "shell" having a high stiffness to mass ratio could alternatively be used.
[0021] Also, although panels of metal honeycomb structure have been described as advantageous,
other panel structures having a high stiffness to mass ratio could alternatively be
used, for example sandwich panels of porous or cellular material between strong skins.
The core material could be stiff foam plastics, cellulose fibre, paper, etc., and
the skins could be of metal, plastics or hardboard for example.
[0022] Furthermore, although it is conventional to make loudspeaker cabinets of box shape,
the present invention is also applicable to cabinets having alternative configurations.
One could for example construct a shell of spherical or cylindrical configuration
from a high stiffness to mass ratio material, and then incorporate appropriate sound-absorbing
material within the shell to achieve the object of the present invention. As yet a
further alternative configuration one could have a shell structure of upright generally
cylindrical form, with the wall of the cylinder being inwardly concave and with an
inwardly concave top and bottom to the enclosure. If this is not considered aesthetically
attractive then such a structure could be incorporated within a conventional box-shaped
outer enclosure.
I. A loudspeaker cabinet comprising walls of a material having a high stiffness to
mass ratio, at least one drive unit, and sound-absorbing means within the enclosure
defined by the walls, said sound-absorbing means being of a composition and/or so
arranged that its sound-absorbing properties differ in dependence on its position
in the cabinet.
2. A loudspeaker cabinet according to claim 1, in which the sound-absorbing means
is graded in relation to its distance from said drive unit or units, being more lightly
absorbent of sound waves adjacent to the drive unit or units and more strongly absorbent
of sound waves remote from the drive unit or units.
3. A loudspeaker cabinet according to claim 1 or 2, in which the sound-absorbing means
comprises layers of material having different acoustic absorbing properties.
4. A loudspeaker cabinet according to claim 3, in which the layers are of a foam plastics
material.
5. A loudspeaker cabinet according to any preceding claim, in which the walls comprise
a metal sandwich structure comprising two skins with a honeycomb cellular array therebetween.
6. A loudspeaker cabinet according to claim 5, made of rectangular wall panels, in
which the honeycomb cells are made by securing elongate ribbons of foil together in
a layered slab and expanding the slab, and wherein the walls of the cabinet are arranged
so that the ribbons of the honeycomb structure run parallel to the longer sides of
the side panels.
7. A loudspeaker cabinet according to claim 6, in which the ribbons of the honeycomb
structure also run parallel to the longer sides of the rear panel.
8. A loudspeaker cabinet according to claim 6 or 7, in which the cabinet has two side
walls, a top wall and a base all formed from one piece of material with the ends joined
at the centre of the base.
9. A loudspeaker cabinet according to any preceding claim, in which the sound-absorbing
means only partially fills the cabinet enclosure, with an air gap between the sound-absorbing
means and at least the rear wall of the cabinet.