[0001] The present invention relates to novel, aqueous-based, mobile, fluid detergent compositions
preferably containing effective quantities of detergent builder.
[0002] Except where the contrary is stated, or the context otherwise forbids, the following
terms in parenthesis, wherever used in this specification and claims, shall have the
meanings hereinafter ascribed to them in this Definitions section.
[0003] The term "builder" is sometimes used loosely in the detergent art to include any
non-surfactant whose presence in a detergent formulation enhances the cleaning effect
of the formulation. More usually, however, the term is restricted to those typical
"builders" -which are primarily useful as a means of preventing or ameliorating the
adverse effects on washing of calcium and magnesium ions, e.g. by chelation, sequestering,
precipitation or absorption of the ions, and secondarily as a source of alkalinity
and buffering. The term "Builder" is used herein in the more restricted sense, and
refers to additives which ameliorate the effects of calcium to a substantial extent.
It includes sodium or potassium tripolyphosphate and other phosphate and condensed
phosphate salts such as sodium or potassium orthophosphates, pyrophosphates, metaphosphates
or tetraphosphate, as well as phosphonates such as acetodiphosphonates, amino tris
methylene phosphonates and ethylenediamine tetramethylene phosphonates. It also includes
alkali metal carbonates, zeolites and such organic sequestrants as salts of nitrilotriacetic
acid, citric acid and ethylene diamine tetracetic acid, polymeric polycarboxylic acids
such as polyacrylates and maleic anhydride based copolymers.
[0004] For the avoidance of doubt, "Builder" is used herein to include water soluble alkali
metal silicates such as sodium silicate, but excludes additives such as carboxymethyl
cellulose, or polyvinyl pyrrolidone whose function is primarily that of soil suspending
or anti-redeposition agent.
[0005] "Electrolyte" is used herein to denote those ionic compounds which have a solubility
in water at 0°C, expressed as wt% of anhydrous compounds, of at least 5, which dissociate
at least partially in aqueous solution to provide ions, and which at the concentrations
present tend to lower the total solubility (including micellar concentration) of surfactants
in such solutions by a "salting out" effect. It includes water soluble dissociable,
inorganic salts such as, for example, alkali metal or ammonium chlorides, nitrates,
phosphates, carbonates, silicates, perborates and polyphosphates, and also certain
water soluble organic salts which desolubilise or "salt out" surfactants. It does
not include salts of cations which form water insoluble precipitates with the surfactants
present or which are only sparingly soluble in the composition, such as calcium chloride
or sodium sulphate.
[0006] References herein to the Electrolyte content or concentration refer to the total
dissolved Electrolyte, including any dissolved Builder, if such Builder is also an
Electrolyte, but excludes any suspended solid.
[0007] "Hydrotrope" denotes any water soluble compound which tends to increase the solubility
of surfactants in aqueous solution. Typical Hydrotropes include urea and the alkali
metal or ammonium salts of the lower alkyl benzene sulphonic acids such as sodium
toluene sulphonate and sodium xylene sulphonate.
[0008] Whether a particular compound is an Electrolyte or a Hydrotrope may sometimes depend
on the Active Ingredients present. Sodium chloride is normally considered a typical
Electrolyte, but in relation to sultaines; it behaves as a Hydrotrope. "Electrolyte"
and "Hydrotrope", as used herein, must therefore be construed in the context of the
particular Active Ingredients.
[0009] As used herein "Soap" means an at least sparingly water soluble salt of a natural
or synthetic aliphatic monocarboxylic acid, which salt has surfactant properties.
The term includes sodium, potassium, lithium, ammonium and alkanolamine salts of Cg
-22 natural and synthetic fatty acids, including stearic, palmitic, oleic, linoleic,
ricinoleic, behenic and dodecanoic acids, resin acids and branched chain monocarboxylic
acids.
[0010] The "Usual Minor Ingredients" includes those ingredients other than Water, Active
Ingredients, Builders and Electrolytes which may be included in laundry detergent
compositions, typically in proportions up to 5%, and which are compatible in the relevant
Formulation with a Pourable, chemically stable non-sedimenting composition. The term
includes antiredeposition agents, dispersants, antifoams,perfumes, dyes, optical brightening
agents, Hydrotropes, solvents, buffers, bleaches, corrosion inhibitors, antioxidants,
preservatives, scale inhibitors, humectants, enzymes and their stabilizers, bleach
. activators, and the like. As used herein "Functional Ingredients" means ingredients
which are required to provide a beneficial effect in the wash liquor and includes
ingredients which contribute to the washing effectiveness of the composition e.g.
surfactants, Builders, bleaches, optical brighteners, alkaline buffers, enzymes and
anti- redeposition agents, and also anti-corrosives and anti-foams, but excludes water,
solvents, dyes, perfume, Hydrotropes, sodium chloride, sodium sulphate, solubilisers
and stabilisers whose sole function is to impart stability, fluidity or other desirable
characteristics to a concentrated formulation. "Payload", means the percentage of
Functional Ingredients based on the total weight of the composition. "Active Ingredients",
means surface active materials.
[0011] All references herein to "Centrifuging", unless stated to the contrary, are to be
construed as referring to centrifugation at 25°C for 17 hours at 800 times normal
gravitational force;
[0012] All references to "High G Centrifuging" mean centrifugation at 20,OOOG at 25°C. Except
where stated to the contrary, High G Centrifuging was carried out for 5 minutes.
[0013] The expression "Separable Phase" is used herein to denote components, or mixtures
of components of a pourable detergent composition, which are each separable from the
composition to form a distinct layer upon Centrifuging. Unless the context requires
otherwise all references to the composition of Separable Phases are references to
the compositions of the centrifugally separated phases and references to the structure
of a composition relate to the uncentrifuged composition. A single Separable Phase
may comprise two or more thermodynamically distinct phases, which are not separable
from each other on Centrifuging as in, for example, a stable emulsion or floc.
[0014] "Dispersed" is used herein to describe a phase which is discontinuously distributed
as discrete particles or droplets in at least one other phase. "Co-continuous" describes
two or more interpenetrating phases each of which extends continuously or as a continuous
network through a common volume, or else is formed of discreet or Dispersed elements
which interact to form a continuous matrix tending to maintain the position of each
element in relation to the matrix when the system is at rest. "Interspersed" describes
two or more phases which are either Co-continuous or of which one or more is Dispersed
in the other or others.
[0015] References to "Solid Phases" are to substances actually present in the composition
in the solid state at ambient temperature, and including any water of crystallization
or hydration unless the context requires otherwise. References to solids include references
to microcrystalline and cryptocrystalline solids, i.e. solids whose crystals are not
directly observed by optical microscopy but whose presence can only be inferred. A
"Solid Layer" is a solid, pasty or non-pourable gelatinous layer formed on Centrifuging.
[0016] "Total Water" refers to water present as liquid water in a predominantly aqueous
phase, together with any other water in the composition, e.g. water of crystallisation
or hydration or water dissolved or otherwise present in any predominantly non-aqueous
phase. "Dry Weight" refers to residual weight after drying to constant weight at 1400
C.
[0017] The term "Formulation" is used to describe the combination of ingredients which make
up the Dry Weight of a composition. Thus the same Formulation may be exemplified by
a number of compositions, differing in their Percentage Dry Weight.
[0018] "Stable" means that no layer containing more than 2% of the total volume separates
from the bulk of the composition within 3 months at room temperature under normal
gravity.
[0019] The "Shear Test" means a test in which a sample is passed through a straight 40mm
tube having an internal radius of 0.25mm under a pressure of 500 p.s.i.g. The Shear
Test was carried out in the case of all measurements described herein, by sucking
a sample into a 500ml pressure vessel through a broad aperture tube, replacing the
broad aperture tube by the 0.25mm radius tube and applying a nitrogen pressure of
500 p.s.i.g. in the pressure vessel until the latter was empty. The 0.25mm tube was
then replaced by the broad aperture tube so that the cycle could be repeated. Typically,
the above method generates a shear rate of approximately 127,000 sec-
1.
[0020] "Shear Stable" means Stable after 3 passes through the Shear Test, "Shear Unstable"
means non-Stable after exposure to 3 or less passes through the Shear Test, or to
a lower shear rate.
[0021] "Non-Shear Sensitive" means not undergoing loss of stability or substantial increase
in Viscosity after exposure to moderate shear. Shear Sensitivity was determined using
a Contraves "Rheomat 30" viscometer, cone and plate measuring system 2, at 25°C, increasing
the shear linearly from 0 to 280 sec
-1 over 1 minute (the "upsweep") and immediately decreasing it linearly to 0 sec-
1 over 1 minute (the "downsweep"). A composition is adjudged Non-Shear Sensitive if
it is Stable after the cycle and if the Viscosity at 150 sec-
1 on the downsweep is not more than 10% greater than on the upsweep.
[0022] Temperature Stable" means that no layer containing more than 5% of the volume separates
from the bulk of the composition within 24 hours of being heated by immersing a 20
g. sample in a water bath maintained at 90°C for 110 minutes, followed by immediate
immersion in a water bath maintained at 100°C for 10 minutes.
[0023] References herein to the "pH" of detergent compositions, are to the pH as measured
by a Pye Unicam 401 combined glass/calomel electrode.
[0024] "Conductivity" refers to specific conductance measured at 25
0C at a frequency of 50 KHertz. The results quoted were measured on a CDM3 "RADIOMETER"
conductivity bridge using a CDC314 flow and pipette cell.
[0025] The "First Conductivity Minimum" refers to the graph of Conductivity against increasing
dissolved Electrolyte concentration in a liquid detergent composition containing a
fixed proportion of Active Ingredients to water, wherein the Conductivity, usually
having initially risen to a maximum value, declines to a minimum value and then rises
again. The term signifies the concentration of Electrolyte corresponding to this minimum
value, or the lowest concentration of dissolved Electrolyte corresponding to one of
a plurality of such minima.
[0026] All percentages, unless otherwise stated, are by weight, based upon the total weight
of the composition.
[0027] All references herein to "Viscosity" except where otherwise stated are to the viscosity
as measured on a cup and bob viscometer at 25
0C after two minutes running using a 20 mm internal diameter flat bottomed cup, 92
mm long, and a 13.7 mm diameter bob, 44 mm long, with conical ends having a 45° horizontal
angle, and 4mm diameter spindle. The tip of the bob was 23mm from the base of the
cup. This corresponds to Contraves "Rheomat 30" viscometer using measuring system
C.
[0028] "Pourable", as used herein, means having a Viscosity of less than 2 Pascal seconds
at a shear rate of 136 sec
-1.
[0029] "Viscosity Drop" means the difference between the Viscosity of a shear thinning composition
measured at 21 sec-
I and the Viscosity measured at 136 sec-
1.
[0030] "Yield Points" whenever referred to herein are as measured on an RML Series II Deer
Rheometer at 25
0C, using part No. MG7101.
[0031] "Li" phase denotes a clear, fluid, optically isotropic, micellar solution of surfactant
in water, which occurs at concentrations above the critical micellar concentration,
and wherein the surfactant molecules are believed to aggregate to form spherical,
oblate (disc) or prolate (rod) micelles.
[0032] "Bilayer" includes a layer of surfactant approximately two molecules thick, which
is formed from two adjacent parallel layers, each comprising surfactant molecules
which are disposed such that the hydrophobic portions of the molecules are located
in the interior of the Bilayer and the hydrophilic portions are located on its outer
surfaces. "Bilayer" is also used herein to include interdigited layers, which are
less than two molecules thick. An interdigited layer may be regarded as a Bilayer
in which the two layers have interpenetrated allowing at least some degree of overlap
between the hydrophobic portions of the molecules of the two layers.
[0033] "Spherulite" means a spherical or spheroidal body having dimensions, of from 0.1
to 50 microns. Spherulites may sometimes be distorted into prolate, oblate, pear or
dumbell shapes. "Vesicle" means a Spherulite containing a liquid phase bounded by
a Bilayer. "Multiple Vesicle" means a Vesicle which contains one or more smaller Vesicles.
[0034] "Lamellar Phase" means a hydrated solid, or liquid crystal phase in which a plurality
of Bilayers are arranged in a substantially parallel array, separated Dy layers or
water or an aqueous solution, and having a sufficiently regular lattice spacing of
from 25 to 70 A to be readily detectable by neutron diffraction when present as a
substantial proportion of a composition. As used herein the expression excludes concentric
Multiple Vesicles.
[0035] "G" phase refers to a liquid crystal Lamellar Phase, of the type also known in the
literature as "neat" phase or "lamellar" phase. The "G" phase for any given surfactant
or surfactant mixture normally exists in a narrow range of concentrations. Pure "G"
phases can normally be identified by examination of a sample under a polarising microscope,
between crossed polarisers. Characteristic textures are observed in accordance with
the classic paper by Rosevear, JAOCS Vol. 31 P628 (1954) or in J. Colloid and Interfacial
Science, Vol. 30 No. 4, P.500 (1969).
[0036] "Spherical G Phase" means Multiple Vesicles formed from substantially concentric
shells of surfactant Bilayer alternating with aqueous phase with a "G" phase spacing.
Typically conventional G phases may contain a minor proportion of Spherical G Phase.
[0037] "Lye" means an aqueous liquid phase containing Electrolyte, which phase separates
from, or is Interspersed with, a second liquid phase containing more Active Ingredient
and less Electrolyte than the Lye phase.
[0038] "Lamellar Composition" means a composition in which a major part of the surfactant
is present as a Lamellar Phase, or in which a Lamellar Phase is the principal factor
inhibiting sedimentation. "Spherulitic Composition" means a composition in which a
major part of the surfactant is present as Spherulites, or which is principally stabilised
against sedimentation by a spherulitic surfactant phase.
TECHNICAL BACKGROUND
[0039] Liquid detergents have hitherto been used mainly for light duty applications such
as dish washing. The market for heavy duty detergents, e.g. laundry detergents, has
been dominated by powders, due to the difficulty of getting an effective amount of
surfactant and in particular of Builder into a stable liquid formulation. Such liquids
should in theory be cheaper than powder detergents since they would avoid the need
to dry and would in many instances replace the sulphate filler conventionally used
in powder detergents with water. They also offer the possibilities of greater convenience
and more rapid dissolution in wash water than powder. Attempts to provide solutions
of the Functional Ingredients have been relatively unsuccessful commercially. One
reason for this lack of success has been that the most commonly used and cost effective
Builders e.g. sodium tripolyphosphate are insufficiently soluble in aqueous compositions.
Moreover due to salting out effects, increasing the amount of dissolved Builder tends
to lower the amount of surfactant that can be dissolved and vice versa. Potassium
pyrophosphate Builders, together with amine salts of the Active Ingredients, which
are more soluble, have been tried as alternatives to the sodium salts but have not
been found cost effective.
[0040] Unbuilt liquid detergents containing high levels of surfactant have been marketed
for laundry use, but are unsuitable for hard water areas and have enjoyed only limited
success, mainly confined to markets where the use of effective builders is subject
to legal constraints, and the competition from powders is correspondingly less severe.
[0041] A different approach is to attempt to suspend the excess Builder as a solid in a
liquid micellar solution, or emulsion, of surfactant. The problem however has been
to stabilise the system to maintain the Builder in suspension and prevent sedimentation.
The literature has proposed numerous, relatively sophisticated formulations, including
the use of expensive potassium salts in place of cheaper sodium salts and of solubilisers
such as Hydrotropes, dispersants or solvents, all of which have prevented realisation
of the potential cost saving. Even with such extraneous additives it was considered
necessary to use relatively low concentrations of solid Builder, giving limited washing
effectiveness. This approach has been conditioned by certain assumptions: that the
Active Ingredient should as far as possible be in solution; that the amount of Active
Ingredient should be relatively high; that the amount of suspended solid should be
minimised to avoid difficulties in stabilising the suspension against sedimentation;
that special thickeners or stabillsers were essential to prevent sedimentation; and
that Electrolytes which would desolubilise the surfactant be omitted or kept at very
low levels.
[0042] A major feature of the art hitherto has been its empyrical nature. No acceptable
general theory has been proposed to account for the stability of some compositions
and the instability of others. There is thus no way of predicting which compositions
will be stable, and no general procedure for designing a novel Stable liquid detergent.
The art contains no generally applicable teaching, and even the specific examples
of most of the prior patents on liquid detergents, provide compositions which separate
within a few weeks. The relatively few exceptions have been apparently discovered
by chance and no extrapolation has been possible.
[0043] Products of this type have been introduced commercially in Europe and Australia,
but have suffered from certain serious drawbacks. The products have been relatively
poor washing performers, either due to low Builder : Active Ingredient weight ratio,
or to low alkalinity. They have also shown evidence of undesirable sensitivity to
mechanical and/or thermal stress, e.g. on shearing or storing under extreme climatic
temperature conditions. Thus some compositions separate on shearing, others become
excessively viscous. Most separate after storage at either 0 or 40
0C. However the art has not taught how to overcome the foregoing shortcomings.
[0044] In addition to the compositions which have been developed commercially, many compositions
have been proposed in the literature which are not suitable for commercial exploitation
in practice. Typically such compositions are unstable, or insufficiently stable to
withstand normal storage without undergoing sedimentation, or else are too expensive
to manufacture in relation to their washing effectiveness, to be considered for commercial
development.
[0045] There has recently been proposed a set of compositions in which the Active Ingredients
form a network of a Lamellar Phase, separable from the aqueous phase by Centrifuging,
which provides a gel structure capable of supporting suspended particles of solid
Builder. The gel structure is obtained by addition of sufficient Electrolyte to salt
out the Active Ingredient, so as to form an aqueous Lye phase and a Separable Lamellar
Phase, and by maintaining the solids content above a threshold for stability and below
a ceiling for Pourability. The amount of Electrolyte required depends upon the hydrophilicity
and melting point of the surfactant, and whether any solubilising additives such as
Hydrotropes or solvents are present. The aforesaid gel compositions tend to be higher
in Payload and in the ratio of Builder/Active Ingredient, and to be more cost effective
than known commercial liquid compositions. Indeed, the best of the aforesaid Lamellar
gel compositions are more cost effective soil removing agents than the best laundry
powders.
[0046] However, the Lamellar Compositions disclosed hitherto exhibit a mobility which is
lower than is desirable for some purposes.
INTRODUCTION TO THE INVENTION
[0047] We have now discovered a novel group of compositions comprising Electrolyte, Active
Ingredients and water which are capable of suspending solids, such as Builders to
form Stable compositions which combine improved washing performance with satisfactory
mobility. We believe that our novel compositions owe their stability to a previously
unreported spherulitic structure, and have discovered a general method of preparing
stable, mobile compositions with superior washing performance from a wide range of
different Active Ingredients.
[0048] Preferred embodiments of our invention exhibit at least some of the following advantages
compared with products marketed hitherto: High Payload; high Builder to surfactant
ratio; improved stability; lower cost due to use of cheaper ingredients and ease of
production; high mobility; improved washing performance; high pH and/or alkalinity;
good stability at high and/or low storage temperature; and satisfactory behaviour
on shearing.
[0049] We have discovered that when Active Ingredients, dissolved Electrolyte and water
are present in certain proportions, which depend upon the particular Active Ingredients
and Electrolytes which are selected, a Stable Spherulitic Composition is obtained
which is . capable of suspending solid particles, such as Builder. We have discovered
how to obtain such compositions and to identify them by a variety of physical characteristics.
We have further discovered how to optimise the proportions of Active Ingredients and
Electrolyte to obtain compositions that are stable to shear stress and to the variations
in temperature likely to be encountered in storage in a wide variety of climates and
to high pH or alkalinity, and which are highly mobile. Unlike the compositions exemplified
in the recent prior art relating to Lamellar Compositions, our novel compositions
appear to be stabilised by surfactant present in a spherulitic, rather than a Lamellar
Phase.
THE PRIOR ART
[0050] The prior art on liquid detergents is extremely voluminous. However, for the purpose
of this invention the numerous references to light duty liquids and to unbuilt or
built clear liquid laundry detergents in which all ingredients are present in solution
may be disregarded. The Builder level is substantially less than desirable.
[0051] Recent general summaries of the current state of the art include JAOCS (April 1981)
P356A - "Heavy Duty Laundry Detergents" which includes a review of the typical commercially
available liquid formulations, and "Recent Changes in Laundry Detergents" by Rutkowski,
published in 1981 by Marcel Dekker Inc. in the Surfactant Science Series.
[0052] Three principle avenues of approach to the problem of formulating fully built liquid
detergents, have been to emulsify a surfactant in an aqueous solution of Builder,
to suspend a solid Builder in an aqueous solution or emulsion of surfactant and to
suspend solid builder in a gel having a Lamellar matrix of surfactant.
[0053] The first approach is exemplified by U.S.P.3235505, U.S.P.3346503, U.S.P.3351557,
U.S.P.3509059, U.S.P.3574122, .U.S.P.3328309 and Canadian Patent 917031. In each of
these patents an aqueous solution of a water soluble Builder is sufficiently concentrated
to salt out the surfactant (usually a liquid non-ionic type) and the latter is dispersed
in the aqueous medium as colloidal droplets, with the aid of various emulsifiers.
In each case the system is a clear emulsion, which generally, contains relatively
low levels of Builder, and which is undesirably expensive due to the cost of using
soluble Builders.
[0054] The second approach is exemplified by G.B. 855893, G.B.948617, G.B.943271, G.B. 1468181,
G.B. 1506427, G.B.2028365, E.P.38101, Australian P.522983, U.S.P. 4018720, U.S.P.3232878,
U.S.P.3075922 and U.S.P.2920045. The compositions described in these patents are either
not stable or are not Temperature Stable or Shear Stable. Commercial products corresponding
to examples of two of these patents have been marketed recently in Australia and Europe.
In particular a composition corresponding to Australian Patent No. 522983 has enjoyed
a measure of commercial success, but has been Shear Sensitive.
[0055] The third approach is described in European Patent Specification No. 0086,614. The
compositions described exhibit a matrix of Lamellar, solid or liquid crystal surfactant
. Such compositions may have Viscosities higher than are desirable for certain uses.
[0056] A different approach is to suspend solid Builder in an anhydrous liquid non-ionic
surfactant e.g. BP 1600981. Such systems are costly, restrictive with regard to choice
of surfactant and give unsatisfactory rinsing properties. The level of Builder although
high in relation to the total composition is low in relation to the Active Ingredients,
and the cost effectiveness is therefore very low.
[0057] Several patents describe emulsions in which the Builder is in the dispersed phase
of an emulsion rather than in suspension. . U.S.P.4057506 describes the preparation
of clear emulsions of sodium - tripolyphosphate, and U.S.P.4107067 describes inverse
emulsions in which an aqueous solution of Builder is dispersed in a liquid crystal
surfactant system.
[0058] Reference may also be made to the numerous patents relating to hard surface cleaners,
in which an abrasive is suspended usually in an aqueous solution of surfactant, e.g.
G.B.2031455, U.S.P.3281367 U.S.P.3813349, U.S.P.3956158 and U.S.P.4302347. However,
the low levels of surfactant, absence of Builder and presence of high concentrations
of abrasive, generally preclude these patents from being of any assistance in the
formulating of laundry detergents.
[0059] Other publications of possible interest are: Australian Patent 507431, which describes
suspensions of Builder in aqueous surfactant, stabilised with sodium carboxymethyl
cellulose or clay as a thickening agent. However, the levels of Functional Ingredients,
and in particular of Builder, in the formulations exemplified, are not sufficient
for a fully acceptable commercial product and stability is inadequate to provide a
useful shelf life.
[0060] U.S.P.3039971 describes a detergent paste containing the Builder in solution;
[0061] Fr. Patent 2283951 describes suspensions of zeolite Builders in nonionic surfactant
systems; the compositions are, however, stiff pastes rather than Mobile fluids.
[0062] U.S.P.3346504 and U.S.P.3346873 describe the solubilising of sultaines with Hydrotropes,
which are referred to therein as "electrolytes".
[0063] A.C.S. Symposium series No. 194 "Silicates in Detergents" describes the effect of
silicates on liquid detergents.
[0064] It will be understood that each of the foregoing patent references was selected from
the very extensive prior art, and relevant aspects highlighted with the aid of hindsight,
using our knowledge of the invention as a guide to such selection and highlighting.
The ordinary man skilled in the art at the time of our first claimed priority, and
without foreknowledge of the applicant's invention, would not necessarily have selected
those patents as being particularly significant or those aspects as being of special
interest or relevance.
[0065] The foregoing summary does not therefore represent the overall picture of the art
possessed by the ordinary skilled man.
THE INVENTION
[0066] According to a first embodiment our invention provides a Stable, Pourable, fluid,
detergent composition consisting essentially of Active Ingredients, Electrolyte and
water and having solid-suspending properties, wherein the proportion of Electrolyte
is sufficient to provide a Temperature Stable, Non-Shear-Sensitive, substantially
non-Lamellar composition.
[0067] According to a second embodiment, our invention provides a Stable, Pourable, fluid,
detergent composition having solid-suspending properties and comprising water, Active
Ingredient and Electrolyte, wherein the proportion of Electrolyte is sufficient to
provide a space-filling Spherulitic floc which is Temperature Stable and Non-Shear
Sensitive.
[0068] According to a third embodiment, our invention provides a Stable, Pourable, fluid
detergent composition having solid suspending- properties and which comprises water,
Active Ingredient and sufficient Electrolyte to form a dispersed Stable phase containing
at least part of the Active Ingredients, corresponding to a trough in the graph of
Conductivity against Electrolyte concentration, which contains the First Conductivity
Minimum, the proportion of said Electrolyte being within the range at which the composition
is Temperature Stable and Non-Shear Sensitive.
[0069] Preferably in each of the foregoing embodiments the Electrolyte concentration is
sufficient to provide a Shear Stable composition.
[0070] Preferably the composition according to each of the foregoing embodiments contain
suspended solids, such as Builders and/or abrasives. The suspended solid may be insoluble
in the aqueous fluid medium, already present in saturation quantities, or encapsulated
in a material which prevents it dissolving in the medium.
[0071] According to a fourth embodiment, our invention provides a Stable, Pourable, fluid
detergent composition containing water, Active Ingredients, Electrolyte and suspended
solids, wherein the proportion of Electrolyte is sufficient to form a Shear Stable
Spherulitic composition having a Yield Point of from 1 to 15 dynes cm-
2.
[0072] Preferably, the Yield Point of the composition is greater than 1.5, more preferably
greater than 2, most preferably greater than 2.5, e.g. greater than 3, and preferably
less than 10 dynes cm-
2. Preferably the Viscosity at 136 sec-
1 is less than 1.5, more preferably less than 1, e.g. from 0.2 to 0.6 Pascal Seconds.
[0073] According to a fifth embodiment, our invention provides a Stable, Pourable, fluid,
detergent composition consisting essentially of water, from 5 to 25% based on the
weight of the composition of Active Ingredients, Electrolyte and suspended,solid Builder,
the total weight proportion of Builder to Active Ingredient being from 1.4:1 to 4:1
and the portion of Electrolyte being sufficient to provide a Shear Stable, Non-Lamellar
composition.
[0074] The composition may additionally contain the Usual Minor Ingredients. Preferably
the Active Ingredients are present in a proportion of 10 to 20%, more preferably 10
to 14% by weight and the total weight ratio and the builder to Active Ingredient is
from 1.5:1 to 3:1, e.g. 1.9:1 to 2.5:1.
[0075] According to a sixth embodiment, our invention provides a Stable, Pourable, fluid,
detergent composition comprising water, from 5 to 25% based on the weight of the composition
of Active Ingredients, Electrolyte and suspended solid Builder, and having a Pay Load
of at least 35% by weight, wherein the proportion of Electrolyte is sufficient to
provide a Shear Stable, Spherulitic composition.
[0076] According to a seventh embodiment, our invention provides a Stable, Pourable, fluid,
detergent composition containing water from 5 to 25% by weight of Active Ingredients,
Electrolyte and suspended solid Builder the total proportion by weight of Builder
to Active Ingredients being from 1.5:1 to 4:1-and the proportion of Electrolyte being
sufficient to provide a Spherulitic composition Stable to storage at 40
oC. Preferably the proportion of Electrolyte is sufficient to render the composition
Temperature Stable.
[0077] According to an eighth embodiment, our invention provides a Stable, Pourable, fluid,
detergent composition comprising water, 5 to 20% by weight of Active Ingredients,
Electrolyte and suspended solid Builder, the total weight ratio of Builder to Active
Ingredient being from 1:1 to 4:1 and the proportion of Electrolyte being sufficient
to provide a Temperature Stable, Non-Shear Sensitive composition, which on Centrifuging
separates into an aqueous layer, containing more than 50% of the total weight of Active
Ingredients, and a Solid Layer.
[0078] According to a ninth embodiment, our invention provides a Stable, Pourable detergent
composition consisting essentially of water, dissolved Electrolyte and from 8 to 14%
by weight of the composition of Active Ingredients, together with suspended solid
Builder, and optionally the Usual Minor Ingredients, which composition, on Centrifuging,
separates into a Solid Layer and a single liquid layer having a Yield Point of greater
than 1.5 dynes cm
-2.
[0079] According to a tenth embodiment, our invention provides a composition consisting
substantially of water, Active Ingredients and Electrolyte and having solid-suspending
properties, wherein the Active Ingredients are capable of forming a Stable composition
at the First Conductivity Minimum, and the amount of Electrolyte present is sufficient
to provide a composition having a Yield Point of greater than 1.5 dynes cm-
2 and a Viscosity measured at 136 sec-
I, of less than 0.28 Pascal Seconds.
[0080] According to an eleventh embodiment, our invention provides a Pourable, Stable, aqueous
based detergent composition consisting essentially of water, Electrolyte, Active Ingredient
and Builder and comprising a first predominantly aqueous liquid Separable Phase, containing
at least part of the Electrolyte in solution and from 50 to 80% of the total weight
of Active Ingredients, at least one Dispersed Solid Separable Phase comprising at
least part of the Builder as solid.
[0081] Preferably the predominantly aqueous Separable Phase comprises at least 40% usually
at least 50% e.g. at least 60% of the Total Water.
[0082] According to a twelfth embodiment, our invention provides a Pourable, Stable, aqueous
based detergent composition having a Pay Load greater than 35% by weight and a pH
greater than 9 and comprising water, a dissolved Electrolyte, at least 5% by weight
of Active Ingredients and at least 16% by weight of Builder, which Electrolyte is
present in a proportion sufficient to render the composition Shear Stable, but insufficient
for the Active Ingredients to form a substantial proportion of a Lamellar Phase.
[0083] According to a thirteenth embodiment, our invention provides an aqueous-based, liquid
detergent composition, comprising sufficient Active Ingredients to form a space-filling
floc of surfactant containing Spherulites Interspersed with an aqueous phase and an
amount of Electrolyte not less than that corresponding to the First Conductivity Minimum
of the graph of electrical Conductivity against . Electrolyte concentration, but below
that which corresponds to the formation of a Lamellar phase, and sufficient to render
the composition non-Shear Sensitive.
[0084] According to a fourteenth embodiment, our invention provides a Pourable, Stable detergent
composition comprising water, Electrolyte, Active Ingredient and Builder, which separates
on Centrifuging as defined herein into at least two layers including: a predominantly
aqueous layer containing dissolved Electrolyte, at least 10% by weight of the Total
Water, and from 80% to 50% by weight of the total Active Ingredient, and a Solid Layer
containing at least a proportion of the Builder.
[0085] According to a fifteenth embodiment our invention provides a Pourable, Stable, fluid,
detergent composition consisting essentially of: water; a concentration of from 5
to 25% by weight of the composition of Active Ingredients which consist essentially
of (i) at least one non-ethoxylated anionic surfactant and (ii) at least one cosurfactant
that is capable of forming stable foams, the proportions of (i) to (ii) being such
that if a soluble Electrolyte is added progressively to an aqueous mixture containing
said Active Ingredients at said concentration, a First Conductivity Minimum is reached
at which the mixture is turbid and Stable; suspended Solid Builder, the total weight
ratio of Builder to Active Ingredients being from 1:1 to 4:1; and dissolved Electrolyte
in a proportion sufficient to form a Stable composition corresponding to the Conductivity
trough containing said First Conductivity Minimum, and greater than any concentration
below which the composition is Shear Sensitive but below the maximum concentration
at which it is Temperature Stable.
[0086] According to a further embodiment our invention provides a Stable, Spherulitic Composition
comprising Active Ingredients, Electrolyte and water which does not exhibit a separate,
clear, aqueous phase after High G centrifuging, at 20,000 G for 90 minutes.
[0087] In further detail, our invention provides Stable, Pourable, . fluid detergent compositions
comprising water, Active Ingredients and Electrolyte, all of which compositions exhibit
at least some, but not necessarily all, of the following characteristics: they comprise
a Spherulitic phase Interspersed with a Lye or L
1 phase and preferably Co-continuous with the Lye or L
1 phase; they are substantially Non-Lamellar; they comprise a floc system which is
preferably space-filling; they comprise a floc system which is formed from particles
comprising the Active Ingredients which are preferably surfactant-containing Spherulites,
typically having concentric shells of surfactant alternating with an aqueous, e.g.
Lye, phase and having 0 a repeat spacing of from 60 to 100 A, prefered 70 to 90 A,
often 75 to 85, e.g. 80 A; they comprise Spherulites of from 0.5-to 5 microns, preferably
0.6 to 5 microns diameter, which show a so-called "Maltese Cross" texture when viewed
at suitable magnifications between crossed polarisers; they are shear thinning; they
have a Viscosity Drop greater than 0.35, usually greater than 0.4, often greater than
0.45 Pascal seconds, but preferably less than 2 Pascal Seconds, e.g. 0.475 to 1.5,
especially 0.48 to 1.1 Pascal seconds; they have a high Payload of Functional Ingredients,
typically greater than 20% by weight, e.g. 25 to 75%, more usually at least 30% preferably
at least 35% most preferably at least 40% by weight; they contain a high ratio of
Builder to Active Ingredient e.g. greater than 1:1 preferably 1.2:1 to 4:1, more preferably
1.4:1 to 4:1, most preferably 1.5:1 to 3.5:1; they contain more than 5 and preferably
more than 8% by weight of composition of Active Ingredients; they contain less than
25X, preferably less than 20%, usually less than 15%, more preferably less than 14.5%,
most preferably less than 14%, e.g. from 10 to 13.5% by weight of the composition
of Active Ingredients; they form a single aqueous layer and a Solid Layer on Centrifuging
wherein the aqueous layer usually has a Yield Point of at least 1, preferably at least
1.5 dynes cm-
2, e.g. 2 to 10 dynes cm-
2 and typically a Viscosity of less than 1.5 Pascal Seconds at 136 sec-
1; the proportion by weight of Active Ingredient in the predominantly aqueous layer
formed after Centrifuging based on total Active Ingredient in the composition is greater
than 50%, preferably greater than 55% e.g. greater than 60%,
.but is less than 90%, preferably less than 85% e.g. less than 80%, such as 75 to 65%;
No clear Lye layer is observed on High G Centrifuging for 90 minutes; The pH of the
composition is greater than 8.5, preferably 9 to 13, e.g. 9.5 to 12; The composition
produces a wash liquor on dilution with water to 0.5% Dry Weight having a pH greater
than 9.7, preferably greater than 10, e.g. 10.9 to 11.1; the alkalinity is sufficient
to require at least 0.8ml of N/10 HC to reduce the pH of 100mls wash liquor at 0.5%
Dry Weight to 9, preferably lm1 e.g. 4.7 to 8.6 mls; the at least one predominantly
aqueous liquid phase contains sufficient Electrolyte to provide a concentration of
at least 0.3 preferably at least 0.5, more preferably at least 1.2 e.g. 2.0 to 4.5
gram ions per litre of total alkali metal and/or ammonium cations; the concentration
of Electrolyte is greater than that corresponding to the First Conductivity Minimum
of the graph of Conductivity against Electrolyte concentration; the Conductivity is
no more than 2 mS greater than the Conductivity at the First Conductivity Minimum;
the concentration of Electrolyte is below that which causes the formation of a substantial
proportion of Lamellar phase; the Electrolyte concentration is above the minimum which
provides a Stable, and preferably above the minimum which provides a Shear Stable,
composition; the composition is Non-Shear Sensitive; the composition is Temperature
Stable; the composition is Stable at 40°C; the Conductivity of the composition is
below 15 millisiemens per cm; the compositions contain at least 15% by weight, preferably
more than 20% by weight of Builder; the Builder is at least predominantly sodium tripolyphosphate;
the Builder comprises alkali metal silicate and/or carbonate, preferably sodium silicate
and/or sodium carbonate; the Viscosity of the composition at a shear rate of 136-
1 is between 0.1 and 2 Pascal Seconds, preferably between 0.2 and 1 Pascal seconds
e.g. 0.3 to 0.6 Pascal seconds; the composition has a Yield Point preferably of at
least 1, more preferably at least 1.5; e.g. at least 2, preferably less than 30, e.g.
less than 20, most preferably less than 15, usually less than 10 dynes/sq cm; a phase
containing Builder comprises solid particles having a maximum particle size below
the limit at which the particles tend to sediment; the composition is Shear Stable;
the Active Ingredients include at least two components . one of which is a non-ethoxylated
anionic surfactant and the other a surfactant which forms stable foams such as an
ether sulphate, alkanolamide or amine oxide.
INTERACTIONS OF ELECTROLYTE AND SURFACTANTS
[0088] When the concentration of dissolved Electrolyte in an appropriate aqueous surfactant
mixture is progressively increased from zero, the composition typically passes through
a series of easily recognised stages, as follows.
Stage I
[0089] At first the Conductivity rises to a maximum, during which stage the Viscosity rises
and the initially clear, optically isotropic L
l phase begins to show evidence of the formation of Spherulites. The latter are visible
under the microscope, and show the so-called "Maltese Cross" texture, normally associated
with spherulitic "G" phases, when viewed between crossed polarisers. However, neutron
diffraction shows no evidence of a "G" phase or any other liquid crystal phase, and
is consistent with a substantially micellar composition.
[0090] The compositions of Stage I are, in general, clear and stable, but have no capacity
to suspend solid particles.
Stage I
[0091] In the second stage the Conductivity falls with increasing Electrolyte concentration
and the composition becomes turbid. High G Centrifuging separates the composition
into a clear aqueous phase and an opaque "emulsion phase", the volume proportion of
the latter phase increasing with increasing Electrolyte concentration. Under the microscope,
Spherulites are observed to be increasingly numerous and smaller in size and to aggregate
into loose flocs separated by optically isotropic regions, which flocs become more
crowded as the Electrolyte concentration increases.
[0092] eutron diffraction studies are consistent with reduced micellar concentrations and
an increasing proportion of larger bodies, but not with the presence of any significant
proportion of "G" phase. The compositions of stage II are turbid, and unstable and
sediment rapidly.
Stage III
[0093] The Conductivity falls to a minimum and then begins to rise. The spaces between the
Spherulite flocs disappear and the Spherulites form a space-filling floc extending
throughout the liquid phase. High G Centrifuging does not separate an aqueous phase,
even when continued for 90 minutes. A Yield Point is observed, rising to a maximum,
and the composition becomes shear thinning with a marked Viscosity Drop.
[0094] Neutron diffraction provides no evidence of any substantial proportions of Lamellar
Phase. Nuclear magnetic resonance similarly provides no indication of any substantial
"G" phase content and indicates a low concentration of micellar surfactant. Electron
microscopy indicates that at least some of the Spherulites are Multiple Vesicles with
a substantially concentric arrangement of shells or overlapping partial shells, possibly
spaced more broadly than in a normal G phase.
[0095] Compositions in Stage III are Stable and capable of suspending solid particles to
form a Stable suspension. Such Stage III compositions constitute our invention.
Stage IY
[0096] Further addition of dissolved Electrolyte causes a progessive diminution in the size
of the Spherulites and an intensification in the brightness of the "Maltese Cross"
texture. The Spherulites cease to be space filling and form discrete flocs, separated
by optically isotropic regions. The Yield Point and Viscosity Drop decline and Conductivity
rises to a maximum or begins to level out. Neutron diffraction provides evidence of
substantial "G" phases. High G Centrifuging separates a clear Lye Phase from a turbid
layer. The composition is unstable, tending to sediment and is unable to suspend solid
particles.
Stage V
[0097] A Lamellar Composition is formed of the type described in E.P.0086614. Viscosity,
when the water content is adjusted to the extent required to give a Stable composition,
is relatively high.
[0098] The foregoing sequence is typical of the interactions of Electrolytes with a wide
variety of aqueous surfactant mixtures. Where the composition already contains some
dissolved Electrolyte, as in a built detergent containing suspended tripolyphosphate,
or where the initial surfactant mixture is not fully soluble in water, the first stage
may not be observed. Similarly, where the solubility of the Electrolyte is limited,
as, for example, in the case of sodium tripolyphosphate or sodium carbonate, addition
of further Electrolyte above its saturation limit will not take the composition any
further in the sequence.
[0099] The preferred compositions of the present invention lie within the third stage of
the above sequence. Between the third stage and the second and fourth stages, respectively,
there exist intermediate compositions which are semi-stable. Such compositions exhibit
a floc of surfactant Spherulites, which are not completely space-filling as evidenced
by the fact that High G Centrifuging continued for 90 minutes results in the formation
of a clear aqueous layer, or in which the Spherulites are capable of being irreversibly
disrupted. Such compositions, although they may be Stable when allowed to stand at
ambient temperature, are often unstable when exposed to various kinds of stress such
as high Shear stress, elevated or depressed temperatures or pH changes. Their capacity
to suspend particulate solids is often limited. A number of proposed prior art compositions
lie in these semi-stable areas.
[0100] We have discovered that in general compositions which lie within these semi-stable
"borderline" areas may be modified in accordance with the teaching of this patent,
by adjusting the Electrolyte and/or Active Ingredient content to bring them more closely
into line with the Stable areas of Stage III.
[0101] Usually, on Centrifuging, the Stage III compositions of the present invention separate
into an aqueous layer containing Electrolyte and from 90 to 50% by weight of the total
Active Ingredients, typically 80%-50%, more usually 75% to 55%, e.g. 70% to 55% of
the total Active Ingredients, and at least one other layer, said at least one other
layer preferably containing from 20% to 50% by weight of the total Active Ingredient
together with a substantial proportion of the Builder. Viscosities of our compositions
at a shear rate of 136 sec-
1 are typically between 0.1 and 2, preferably 0.2 and 1.5, e.g. 0.25 and 0.6 Pascal
Seconds, and the Viscosity Drop is typically between 0.4 and 2, e.g. 0.45 to 1.5 Pascal
Seconds.
[0102] Stage III compositions are Non-Shear Sensitive and usually Shear Stable. In contrast,
high shear forces tend to render the semi-stable borderline compositions unstable.
The viscosity is often substantially increased by even moderate shear and they may
undergo rapid sedimentation. This can present practical difficulties during manufacture
and bottling. Stage III compositions of our invention are generally stable to high
pH and to storage at temperatures around 40°C or below 5°C, unlike many semi-stable
compositions. They are typically Temperature Stable, when heated to 100°C.
[0103] Stage III compositions typically show no evidence of a Lamellar Phase on analysis
by neutron diffraction, although some compositions near the borderline with Stage
IV may show evidence of minor amounts of "G" phase.
PROPOSED STRUCTURE
[0104] We believe that the foregoing behaviour can most readily be explained on the assumption
that the surfactant is progressively transferred from the micellar to a spherulitic
phase with increasing Electrolyte concentration. We believe that the Spherulites initially
take the form of Multiple Vesicles in which a plurality of Bilayers are arranged substantially
concentrically, but with a wider and more irregular spacing than in a conventional
"G" phase.
[0105] It is possible that two aqueous phases exist, an L
1 and a Lye Phase, which latter phase may also be an L
l Phase containing fewer micelles and more Electrolyte than the former. One of these
phases, possibly the Lye Phase, may form the internal phase of the Vesicles.
[0106] We have found that increasing the Electrolyte content and decreasing the proportion
of Active Ingredients tends to provide compositions which are less viscous for equivalent
stability and solid Pay Load. We believe that this reduces the proportion of micellar
surfactant without substantially reducing the amount of the Spherulites. The lower
micellar content reduces the Viscosity, while the Spherulitic phase remains sufficient
to maintain stability.
[0107] We believe that in the preferred, Stable composition of our invention the Spherulites
are sufficiently closely packed to form an aggregated floe which is substantially
space-filling, that is it extends throughout the volume of the liquid. The Spherulites
probably interact to form a weak three dimensional matrix sufficiently strong to support
suspended particles, but weak enough to break down and flow readily under the influence
of shear forces, and to reform when they are withdrawn. The size of the Spherulites
appears to correlate with stability compositions with large Spherulites of 5 microns
and more being less stable than those in which the majority of surfactant is in Spherulites
of from 0.5 to 5 microns.
[0108] As the Electrolyte content increases the Spherulites become smaller and possibly
more compact, tending to the closer, more regular spacing of a Spherical "G" phase.
As a result the "G" phase . Spherulites are no longer space filling and the composition
becomes prone to sedimentation.
ACTIVE INGREDIENTS
[0109] The compositions of our invention preferably contain at least 5%, less than 30% and
generally less than 25% by weight of surfactants. More preferably the surfactant constitutes
from 5 to 20% by weight of the composition, e.g. 8 to 15% by weight, typically 10
to 14.5% especially preferably, less than 14, often less than 13%.
[0110] The concentration of Active Ingredients may be a critical factor in obtaining compositions
of our invention. Below a certain minimum which varies according to the particular
Active system, the composition cannot be stabilised by adding more Electrolyte, however,
the maximum is also important in order to avoid instability and/or excessively viscous
compositions.
[0111] Prior art semi-stable Spherulitic Compositions have often contained relatively high
amounts of Active Ingredients. This has resulted in a relatively high Viscosity of
the aqueous suspending medium, which in turn has severely limited the amount of Builder
which could be suspended for any given acceptable limit of Viscosity. Thus the overall
Builder to Active ratio has been low compared to powders, with consequent poor washing
performance.
[0112] It was highly unobvious that the Active Ingredients in such compositions could be
reduced without destabilising the systems totally. We have surprisingly discoverd
that if the Electrolyte concentration is sufficiently raised, the concentration of
Active Ingredient may be substantially reduced, to provide aqueous media of equivalent
or even greater stability and yet having lower Viscosity. Such media can suspend greater
amounts of Builder without losing adequate mobility and the resulting big increases
in the ratio of Builder to Active Ingredient produce equally substantial increases
in cost effectiveness.
[0113] In general it is substantially easier to prepare spherulitic flocs from mixed surfactants
than single surfactants. Thus mixtures of one or more non-ethoxylated anionic surfactant
such as alkyl benzene sulphonate and/or alkyl sulphate with one or more cosurfactants
which form stable foams such as alkyl ether sulphates and/or alkanolamides or amine
oxides, are generally more suitable than any of the surfactants on their own. Minor
amounts of ethoxylated non-ionic surfactants, or of amphoteric surfactants, or cationic
fabric softeners, may additionally be present.
[0114] The surfactant mixture may for example comprise one or more at least sparingly water-soluble
salts of sulphonic or mono esterified sulphuric acids e.g. an alkylbenzene sulphonate,
alkyl sulphate, alkyl ether sulphate, olefin sulphonate, alkane sulphonate, alkylphenol
sulphate, alkylphenol ether sulphate, alkyl ethanol amide sulphate, alkylethanolamide
ether sulphate, or alpha sulpho fatty acid or its esters each having at least one
alkyl or alkenyl group with from 8 to 22, more usually 10 to 20, aliphatic carbon
atoms. Said alkyl or alkenyl groups are preferably straight chain primary groups but
may optionally be secondary, or branched chain groups. The expression ether hereinbefore
refers to polyoxyethylene, polyoxypropylene, glyceryl and mixed polyoxyethylene-oxy
propylene or mixed glyceryl- oxyethylene or glyceryl-oxy propylene groups, typically
containing from 1 to 20 oxyalkylene groups. For example, the sulphonated or sulphated
surfactant may be sodium dodecyl benzene sulphonate, potassium hexadecyl benzene sulphonate,
sodium dodecyl dimethyl benzene sulphonate, sodium lauryl sulphate, sodium tallow
sulphate, potassium oleyl sulphate, ammonium lauryl monoethoxy sulphate, or monoethanolamine
cetyl 10 mole ethoxylate sulphate.
[0115] Other anionic surfactants useful according to the present invention include paraffin
sulphonates, olefin sulphonates, fatty alkyl sulphosuccinates, fatty alkyl ether sulphosuccinates,
fatty alkyl sulphosuccinamates, fatty alkyl ether sulphosuccinamates, acyl sarcosinates,
acyl taurides, isethionates, Soaps such as stearates, palmitates, resinates, oleates,
linoleates, and alkyl ether
' carboxylates. Anionic phosphate esters may also be used. In each case the anionic
surfactant typically contains at least one aliphatic hydrocarbon chain having from
8 to 22 preferably 10 to 20 carbon atoms, and, in the case of ethers one or more glyceryl
and/or from to 20 ethyleneoxy and or propyleneoxy groups.
[0116] Preferred anionic surfactants are sodium salts. Other salts of commercial interest
include those of potassium, lithium, calcium, magnesium, ammonium, monoethanolamine,
diethanolamine, triethanolamine and alkyl amines containing up to seven aliphatic
carbon atoms.
[0117] The surfactant mixture may optionally contain nonionic surfactants. The nonionic
surfactant may be e.g. a C
IO-
22 alkanolamide of a mono or di-lower alkanolamine,such as coconut monoethanolamide.
Other nonionic surfactants which may optionally be present, include ethoxylated alcohols,
ethoxylated carboxylic acids, ethoxylated amines, ethoxylated alkylolamides, ethoxylated
alkylphenols, ethoxylated glyceryl esters, ethoxylated sorbitan esters, ethoxylated
phosphate esters, and the propoxylated or ethoxylated and propoxylated analogues of
all the aforesaid ethoxylated nonionics, all having a C
8-22 alkyl or alkenyl group and up to 20 ethyleneoxy and/or propyleneoxy groups, or any
other nonionic surfactant which has hitherto been incorporated in powder or liquid
detergent compositions e.g. amine oxides. The latter typically have at least one C
8-22, preferably C
10-20 alkyl or alkenyl group and up to two lower (e.g. C
1-4, preferably C
1-2) alkyl groups.
[0118] The preferred Active Ingredients or mixtures for our invention are for example those
having an HLB greater than 7, preferably greater than 8, more preferably greater than
10, most preferably greater than 12 and preferably less than 18, more preferably less
than 16, most preferably less than 15.
[0119] Certain of our detergents may contain cationic surfactants, - and especially cationic
fabric softeners and/or bactericides usually as a minor proportion of the total active
material. Cationic fabric softeners of value in the invention include quaternary amines
having two long chains (e.g. C
12-
22 typically C
16-20) alkyl or alkenyl groups and either two short chains (e.g. C
1-4) alkyl groups, or one short chain and one benzyl group. They also include imidazoline
and quaternised imidazolines having two long chain alkyl or alkenyl groups, and amido
amines and quaternised amido amines having two long chain alkyl or alkenyl groups.
The quaternised softeners are all usually salts of anions which impart a measure of
water dispersibility such as formate, acetate, lactate, tartrate, chloride, methosulphate,
ethosulphate, sulphate or nitrate. Compositions of our invention having fabric softener
character may contain smectite clays.
[0120] Compositions of our invention may also contain amphoteric surfactant, which may be
included typically in surfactants having cationic fabric softener, but may also be
included, usually as a minor component of the Active Ingredients, in any of the other
detergent types discussed above.
[0121] Amphoteric surfactants include betaines, sulphobetaines and phosphobetains formed
by reacting a suitable tertiary nitrogen compound having a long chain alkyl or alkenyl
group with the appropriate reagent,such as chloroacetic acid or propane sultone. Examples
of suitable tertiary nitrogen containing compounds include: tertiary amines having
one or two long chain alkyl or alkenyl groups, optionally a benzyl group and any other
substituent a short chain alkyl group; imidazoline having one or two long chain alkyl
or alkenyl groups and amidoamines having one or two long chain alkyl or alkenyl groups.
[0122] Those skilled in the detergent art will appreciate that the specific surfactant types
described above are only exemplary of the commoner surfactants suitable for use according
to the invention. Any surfactant capable of performing a useful function in the wash
liquor may be included. A fuller description of the principal types of surfactant
which are commercially available is given in the current edition of "McCutcheon's
Emulsifiers & Detergents", published by the McCutcheon division of Manufacturing Confectioners
Publishing Company.
ELECTROLYTE
[0123] Electrolyte is essential in order to interact with the surfactant to form a space-filling
spherulitic system. The Electrolyte concentration is preferably not, however, sufficient
to permit substantial stacking of any planar Bilayers, to form non- spherical Lamellar
Phases. Such Lamellar Phases may provide non-Stable or Shear Unstable compositions,
unless the Pay Load is sufficiently high for the Lamellar Phase to form a stable structure
according to E.P.008614A, The relatively strong matrix which characterises the latter
compositions, however, generally results in undesirably high Viscosity. For a suitable
surfactant system at a suitable concentration, we have found that it is possible to
stabilise the system in accordance with an our invention by including in the composition
a suitable quantity of Electrolyte.
[0124] Insufficient Electrolyte results in unstable, or shear, or temperature sensitive
systems and/or in systems having undesirably high Viscosity. The proportion of Electrolyte
must therefore be selected according to the nature of the surfactant and the amount
of any Hydrotrope present to provide compositions according to the present invention.
[0125] The optimum proportion of Electrolyte may generally be determined by making progressive
additions of Electrolyte to an aqueous, micellar solution of the Active Ingredients
(typically about 15 to 20% by weight Active) and observing one or more of several
characteristic properties of the system such as turbidity, Conductivity, Yield Point,
appearance under the polarising microscope or with phase contrast or differential
interference contrast, or behaviour on High G Centrifuging.
[0126] When the properties characteristic of Stage III as described hereinbefore are detected,
e.g. a turbid composition at, or near a First Conductivity minimum, with a Floc of
Spherulites showing no clear isotropic areas and showing no clear layer on High G
Centrifuging, then the spherulitic range has been identified.
[0127] The proportion may be optimised within this range by observing the amount required
to obtain no clear layer on High G Centrifuging for 90 minutes, and/or to provide
Temperature Stable and/or Shear Stable compositions. If the composition is intended
for a market in which low Viscosity is of primary importance, the optimised composition
may be progressively diluted until a suitable Viscosity is achieved or signs of instability
are observed. If the latter occurs, further additions of Electrolyte may be made until
a sufficiently stable composition has been obtained.
[0128] The amount of Electrolyte is preferably greater than that at the First Conductivity
Minimum in the Conductivity/Electrolyte concentration graph and corresponds to the
amount required to provide a composition having a Yield Point greater than 1.5 dynes
cm-
2.
[0129] We prefer to use Functional Electrolytes such as carbonates, silicates, pyrophosphates,
polyphosphates, nitriloacetates and citrates, all of which are Builders, but the effective
concentration of some such Electrolytes, e.g. carbonates, may be undesirably limited
by their solubility. In such cases it may prove necessary to add a more soluble Non-Functional
Electrolyte. Sodium chloride and sodium nitrate have been found particularly effective
in this respect.
[0130] Often, the proportion of Electrolyte in the at least one predominantly aqueous phase
is sufficient to provide a concentration of at least 0.3 preferably at least 1.2 e.g
2.0 to 4.5 gram ions per litre of alkali metal, alkaline earth metal and/or ammonium
cations.
BUILDERS
[0131] The Builder, in preferred compositions of our invention is
. believed to be normally present, at least partially, as discrete solid crystallites
suspended in the composition. The crystallites typically have a size of up to 60 eg
1 to 50 microns.
[0132] We have found that Formulations containing sodium tripolyphosphate as Builder, or
at least a major proportion of sodium tripolyphosphate in admixture with other Builders,
exhibit stability and mobility over a wider range of Dry Weight than corresponding
Formulations with other Builders. Such formulations are therefore preferred. Our invention,
however, also provides compositions comprising other Builders such as potassium tripolyphosphate,
carbonates, zeolites, nitrilo triacetates, citrates, metaphosphates, pyrophosphates,
phosphonates, EDTA and/or polycarboxylates, optionally but preferably, in admixture
with tripolyphosphate. Orthophosphates may be present, preferably as minor components
in admixture with tripolyphosphate, as may alkali metal silicates and carbonates.
[0133] Silicates and carbonates are particularly preferred since they perform several valuable
functions. They provide the free alkalinity desirable to saponify fats in the soil,
they have an effect as Builders, and in the case of silicates, they inhibit corrosion
of aluminium surfaces in washing machines. In addition, they are effective as Electrolytes
necessary to form a spherulitic system.
[0134] Typically, where silicate is used to prepare our compositions it has an Na
2O: SiO2 ratio of from 1:1 to 1:2 or 1:1.5 to 1:1.8. It will however be appreciated
that any ratio of Na
20 (or other base) to Si0
2, or even silicic acid, could be used to provide the silicate in the composition,
and any necessary additional alkalinity provided by addition of another base such
as sodium carbonate or hydroxide. Formulations not intended for use in washing machines
do not require silicates provided that there is an alternative source of alkalinity.
[0135] We do not exclude compositions wherein the Builder is present substantially entirely
in solution, e.g. sodium nitrilo triacetate, sodium citrate, sodium silicate or mixtures
thereof.
[0136] The Builder normally constitutes at least 15% by weight of the compositions, preferably
at least 20%. We prefer that the ratio of Builder to surfactant is greater than 1:1
preferably 1.2:1 to 4:1.
CATIONS
[0137] On economic grounds it is generally preferred that the cations present should consist,
at least predominantly, of sodium. Thus, for example, the preferred Builder is sodium
tripolyphosphate, the preferred anionic surfactants are sodium salts of sulphated
or sulphonated anionic surfactants and any anti-redeposition agent, e.g. carboxymethyl
cellulose, or alkali, e.g. silicate or carbonate are also preferably present as the
sodium salts. Sodium chloride, sodium nitrate or other soluble inorganic sodium salts
may be added to increase the Electrolyte concentration. Calcium is only normally present
when the Active Ingredients comprise surfactants, such as olefin sulphonates or non-ionics
which are tolerant of its presence. Magnesium salts may be present, and are more compatible
with surfactants than is calcium.
[0138] It is possible, alternatively, but less preferably to choose salts of potassium,
ammonium, lower amines, alkanolamines or mixed cations. Compositions containing high
proportions of such cations are, however, unlikely to be cost effective in comparison
with conventional laundry powders.
ALKALINITY
[0139] The compositions of our invention are preferably alkaline, being desirably buffered
with an alkaline buffer to provide a pH in the composition as measured on a glass
electrode, above 8.5 preferably above 9, most preferably above 9.2, e.g. 9.5 to 12
especially 10 to 11. We particularly prefer that our compositions should be adapted
to provide a pH of greater than 9.7, e.g. greater than 10, especially 10.5 to 11.5
in a wash liquor containing the composition diluted to 0.5% Dry Weight. They desirably
have sufficient free alkalinity to require at least 0.4 mls, preferably at least 0.8
mls, most preferably 1 to 12 mls, e.g. 3 to 10 mls, typically 4 to 9 mls of N/10 HC1
to reduce the pH of 100 mls. of a dilute solution of the composition, containing 0.5%
Dry Weight, to 9, although compositions having higher alkalinity may also be commercially
acceptable. In general, lower alkalinities are less acceptable in commercial practice,
although not excluded from the scope of our invention.
[0140] The alkaline buffer is preferably sodium tripolyphosphate and the alkalinity is preferably
provided at least in part by sodium carbonate. Other preferred alkaline buffers include
sodium silicate.
SOLUBILISERS
[0141] Hitherto, liquid detergent compositions have commonly contained substantial concentrations
of Hydrotropes and/or organic, water- miscible hydroxylic solvents such as methanol,
ethanol, isopropanol, glycol, glycerol, polyethylene glycol and polypropylene glycol.
They are, however, costly and not Functional Ingredients. They may, in certain circumstances
promote pourability or permit a surfactant to form a spherulitic phase more readily.
1e do not therefore totally exclude them from all compositions of our invention, but
we prefer that their presence be limited to the minimum required to ensure a Spherulitic
Composition of adequate Pourability. If not so required we prefer that they be absent.
Solvents may sometimes need to be accommodated as components of perfumes or other
of the Usual Minor Ingredients.
DRY WEIGHT
[0142] The Dry Weight of the composition affects stability and Pourability. Optimum Dry
Weight may vary considerably from one type of Formulation to another and may be selected
to provide the required Viscosity. Generally speaking it has not been found possible
to guarantee Stable compositions below about 35% by weight Dry Weight, although some
types of Formulation can be obtained in a Stable form below 30% Dry Weight, and sometimes
as low as 25% Dry Weight. We do not exclude the possibility of making Stable Compositions
at Dry Weights down to 20%.
[0143] For any given Formulation according to our invention a range of Dry Weights can be
identified within which the composition is both Stable and Pourable. Generally below
this range, sedimentation occurs and above the range, the Formulation is either unstable
or too viscous. The acceptable range may be routinely determined for any given Formulation
by preparing the suspension using the minimum water required to maintain a stirrable
composition, diluting a number of samples to progressively higher dilutions, and observing
the samples for signs of sedimentation over a suitable period. For some Formulations
the acceptable range of Dry Weights may extend from 30% or 35% to 60 or even 70% by
weight for others it may be much narrower, e.g. 40 to 45% by weight.
[0144] If no Stable Pourable range can be determined by the above methods, the Formulation
should be modified according to the teaching herein e.g. by the addition of more sodium
carbonate, sodium silicate solution or other Electrolyte if the composition exhibits
Stage or II properties, or by reducing the Electrolyte content or adding Hydrotrope
if the composition exhibits Stage IV or V properties. Alternatively, if difficulty
is encountered in finding a Stable Spherulitic system by merely altering the Electrolyte
content, the Active Ingredients may be modified by adding a foam stabilising surfactant,
such as alkyl ether sulphate, alkanolamide or amine oxide, if the composition tends
to form Stage IV or V, or by adding alkyl benzene sulphonate or alkyl sulphate or
other non-ethoxylated anionic surfactant if Stage I or Stage II properties predominate.
PREPARATION
[0145] Compositions of our invention can, in many instances be readily prepared by normal
stirring together of the ingredients. It is a characteristic of our preferred compositions,
however, that they are not destabilised or thickened by subjection to high shear forces.
[0146] The order and conditions of mixing the ingredients are sometimes important in preparing
a stable structured mixture according to our invention.
[0147] Compositions according to our invention may be typically obtained for any suitable
Active Ingredients by first preparing a clear aqueous L
1 solution of the Active Ingredients at a suitable concentration (e.g. 15 to 30% by
weight Active) with warming, if necessary, and dissolving Electrolyte in the L
1 solution or adding concentrated Electrolyte solution (preferably Functional Electrolyte)
until the mixture becomes opaque. A sample of the mixture is then centrifuged at 20,OOOG
for 5 minutes. If a clear aqueous phase is observed, more Electrolyte is added to
the mixture until High G Centrifuging no longer gives evidence of a separate, substantially
clear, aqueous phase. The weight ratio of Active Ingredient to dissolved Electrolyte
is then noted.
[0148] A composition containing all the desired Ingredients and having the Active Ingredient
to Electrolyte weight ratio already determined may then be prepared at the desired
Percentage Dry Weight (typically 40 to 50%). Formation of a clear aqueous Lye phase
on High G Centrifuging indicates the presence of Lamellar or non-space filling Spherical
"G" Phase and the amount of Electrolyte is then reduced until no clear phase is observed
on High G Centrifuging. Samples of the latter Formulation at different Dry Weights
may be prepared to determine the optimum balance of Pay Load/mobi
lity/stabi
lity characteristics. If, on dilution to a desired, low Viscosity, the stability is
inadequate, it may often be restored by adding more Electrolyte. If difficulty is
experienced locating a suitable Active/ Electrolyte ratio in the first stage of the
above operation the -procedure may be repeated using a more soluble Electrolyte, e.g.
a non-Functional Electrolyte such as sodium chloride or sodium nitrate. Alternatively,
the Active system may be modified by addition of surfactants which favour stable dispersions
according to our invention, e.g. ether sulphates, amine oxides or alkanolamides, if
Stage IV or V properties are observed, or a non-ethoxylated anionic surfactant if
Stage I or II properties are more readily obtained. The proportions of surfactant
may be adjusted until a mixture is obtained that forms a Stable, turbid, mixture at
the First Conductivity Minimum.
[0149] Typically, mixing is carried out at ambient temperature where consistent with adequate
dispersion, certain ingredients, e.g. non- ionic surfactants such as coconut monoethanolamide
require gentle warming e.g. 400 for adequate dispersion. This degree of warming may
generally be achieved by the heat of hydration of sodium tripolyphosphate. To ensure
sufficient warming we prefer to add the tripolyphosphate in the anhydrous form containing
a sufficiently high proportion of the high temperature rise modification commonly
called "Phase I". The foregoing procedure is only one of several methods that may
be satisfactorily used for all or most of the compositions of our invention. Some
Formulations are more sensitive to the order and temperature of mixing than others.
We have found that it is sometimes advantageous to premix solid components, such as
tripolyphosphate and carbonate.
FORMULATIONS
[0150] Formulations are typically based on mixtures of one or more non-ethoxylated anionic
surfactant, preferably a sulphated or sulphonated surfactant, with one or more cosurfactant
which forms a stable foam such as an ethoxylated anionic surfactant, an amine oxide
or a fatty alkanolamide. The first component of the Active Ingredients, i.e. the the
non ethoxylated anionic surfactant may for example be a C
lo
- 18 alkyl sulphate and/or C
10-14 alkyl benzene sulphonate. The second component or cosurfactant may be a sodium C
10-20 straight or branched chain alkyl C
1-10 mole ether sulphate or an alkyl phenol ether sulphate, amine ether sulphate, alkanolamide
ether sulphate or fatty acid ether sulphate. Alternatively or additionally, the second
component may comprise an amine oxide or fatty alkylolamide. The total proportion
by weight of non-ethoxylated anionic to cosurfactant may typically be from 5:1 to
1:3, preferably 4:1 to 1:2, e.g. 3:1 to 1:1. Small amounts (e.g. up to 1% of the weight
of the compositions) of Soap may be present to aid rinsing of the fabric. Nonionic
ethoxylates may be present in minor proportions, typically up to 20% by wt. of the
total Active Ingredients, preferably less than 15%, usually less than 10%.
[0151] The sodium alkyl sulphate or alkyl benzene sulphonate may be totally or partially
replaced, in the above Formulations by other sulphonated, non-ethoxylated surfactants
including fatty alkyl xylene or toluene sulphonates, or by paraffin sulphonates, olefin
sulphonates, sulphocarboxylates, and their esters and amides, including sulphosuccinates
and sulphosuccinamates. The alkyl ether sulphate may be wholly or partially replaced
by other ether sulphates such as alkyl phenyl ether sulphates, fatty acyl monoethanolamide
ether sulphates or mixtures thereof.
[0152] According to a specific embodiment, therefore, our invention provides a Stable, Pourable,
Non-Shear Sensitive Spherulitic Composition having a Pay Load of at least 35% by weight
and comprising: water; from 12 to 40% Dry Weight of Active Ingredient based on the
Dry Weight of the composition and from 20 to 80% Dry Weight of Builder based on the
Dry Weight of the composition, at least partly present as suspended solid and partly
as at least part of said dissolved Electrolyte, in a total weight ratio of Builder
to Active Ingredients of 1.3:1 to 4:1; and wherein said Active Ingredients consists
of (A) from 30 to 80% by weight thereof of a non-alkoxylated anionic sulphated or
sulphonated surfactant, and (B) from 20% to 70% by weight of the total surfactant
of at least one foam stabilising cosurfactant such as an alkoxylated anionic surfactant,
an alkanolamide or an amine oxide.
[0153] Optionally, the aforesaid composition may additionally contain up to 6% by Dry Weight
of the composition of Soap. Preferably the non-alkoxylated sulphated or sulphonated
anionic surfactant consists substantially of alkyl sulphate or alkyl benzene sulphonate,
. preferably sodium alkyl benzene sulphonate, e.g. C
10-
14 alkyl benzene sulphonate. Alternatively, the anionic surfactant may comprise a mixture
of alkyl benzene sulphonate, and/or alkyl sulphate with alkyl ether sulphate and/or
alkyl phenol ether sulphate in weight proportions of e.g. from 1:3 to 5:1 typically
1:2 to 4:1 preferably 1:1 to 3:1 e.g. 2:1.
[0154] Low foaming compositions according to our invention may be prepared by using suitable
foam-inhibitors. The choice of foam-inhibitor requires some care, since certain commercially
available foam-inhibitors may lose their effectiveness on storage in compositions
of our invention, while others are only effective at concentrations high enough to
affect the Viscosity or Stability of the composition. We have found mixtures of organopolysiloxane
and hydrophobic silica particularly effective.
[0155] Our invention provides, according to another specific embodiment, a Stable, Pourable,
fluid, aqueous-based, detergent composition, comprising: from 12 to 40% based on Dry
Weight ther of of Active Ingredients which comprise from 30 to 90% based on the Dry
weight of the Active Ingredients of non-alkoxylated sulphated and/or sulphonated anionic
surfactant and the balance of alkyl ether sulphate, alkanolamide and/or amine oxide;
an aqueous phase containing sufficient Electrolyte in solution to form a space-filling
Spherulitic floc comprising at least part of said Active Ingredients and Interspersed
with said aqueous phase; suspended particles of Builder; an effective amount of at
least one foam inhibitor and optionally the Usual Minor Ingredients.
[0156] According to a further specific embodiment our invention provides a Pourable, Stable,
Non-Lamellar detergent composition having a Payload of from 30% to 50% consisting
essentially of from 12 to 40% Dry Weight, based on the Dry Weight of the composition,
of Active Ingredients, at least 30% Builder, based on the Dry Weight of the composition,
a ratio of Builder to Active Ingredient greater than 1.1 to 1, said Active Ingredient
consisting essentially of alkyl benzene sulphonate having 8 to 18 aliphatic carbon
atoms and an alkyl ethanolamide selected from Cio
-18 alkyl monoethanolamides and diethanolamides, in a weight ratio of alkyl benzene sulphonate
to ethanolamide of from 1.5:1 to 4:1, said Builder being selected from sodium tripolyphosphate,
sodium carbonate, zeolite, sodium nitrilo triacetate, sodium silicate and mixtures
thereof, such that the amount of dissolved Builder is sufficient to provide a Yield
Point of greater than 1.5 dynes cm-
2.
[0157] A particularly preferred embodiment of our invention provides a Pourable, Stable,
liquid detergent composition, consisting essentially of:
A - A mixture of (i) a sodium alkylbenzene sulphonate having 10 to 18, preferably
10 to 14 aliphatic carbon atoms with (ii) a sodium alkyl ether sulphate having an
alkyl group with an average of from 8 to 18, preferably 10 to 14 carbon atoms, and
from 1 to 20, preferably 2 to 10, e.g. 3 to 5 ethylene-oxy and/or propylene-oxy groups;
in ratio of (i):(ii), between 10:1 and 1:10, especially 10:1.5 to 10:5, e.g. 10:2
to 10:4;
B - A Builder selected from sodium tripolyphosphate, zeolite, sodium nitrilotriacetate
and mixtures thereof in a weight ratio of B:A of from 1.1:1 to 4:1, preferably 1.2:1
to 3.5:1, e.g. 2:1 to 3:1;
C - An Electrolyte selected from sodium carbonate, sodium silicate, sodium nitrate,
sodium chloride and mixtures thereof in a concentration of from 2 to 20% by weight,
preferably 3 to 18% by weight, especially 7 to 15% by weight of the composition; said
composition having a Pay Load of 30 to 50% by weight, preferably 35 to 50% by weight,
e.g. 38 to 45% by weight; and said composition preferably containing minor but effective
amounts of anti-redeposition agents, preferably sodium carboxymethyl cellulose, perfume,
colouring and optical brightener.
[0158] The sodium cation in the above composition may optionally, but less preferably, be
replaced wholly or in part by potassium, lithium or ammonium. Preferably the sodium
tripolyphosphate constitutes from 40 to 95% of the total weight of Builder, e.g. 45%
to 80%. Preferably, the composition contains at least one foam-inhibitor if required
for automatic washing.
[0159] The above composition may optionally contain minor proportions of alkanolamide, such
as coconut monoetholamide or diethanolamide, or of ethoxylated non-ionic surfactant,
e.g. up to 15% of the total Active Ingredients, preferably less than 10%.
MINOR INGREDIENTS
[0160] Compositions of the invention may contain the Usual Minor Ingredients. Principal
of these are antiredeposition agents, dispersants, optical brightening agents and
bleaches.
[0161] The most commonly used antiredeposition agent in making detergents is sodium carboxymethyl
cellulose (SCMC), which may be present in compositions of this invention e.g. in effective
amounts consistent with desired Viscosity and Stability. Generally speaking SCMC is
effective at concentrations of about 1% and we prefer not to exceed the normal effective
concentrations, since SCMC in greater amounts can raise the Viscosity of a liquid
composition very considerably and may also affect stability.
[0162] Alternative antiredeposition and/or soil releasing agents include potassium, ammonium
and other soluble CMC salts, phosphonates, methylcellulose, poiyvinylpyrrolidone,
carboxymethyl starch and similar poly electrolytes, including synthetic polycarboxylates
such as polyacrylates all of which may be used in place of SCMC.
[0163] Optical Brighteners (OBA's) are optional, but preferred, ingredients of the compositions
of our invention. Unlike some prior art formulations, our compositions are not dependent
on OBA's for stability and we are therefore free to select any convenient and cost
effective OBA, or to omit them altogether. We have found that any of the fluorescent
dyes hitherto recommended for use as OBA's in liquid detergents may be employed, as
may many dyes normally suitable for use in powder detergents. The OBA may be present
in conventional amounts. Typically concentrations of OBA between 0.05 and 0.5% are
sufficient e.g. 0.075 to 0.3% typically 0.1 to 0.2%. Lower concentrations could be
used but are unlikely to be effective, while higher concentrations, while we do not
exclude them, are unlikely to prove cost effective and may, in some instances give
rise to problems of compatibility.
[0164] Typical examples of OBA's which may be used in the present invention include : ethoxylated
1, 2-(benzimidazolyl) ethylene; 2- styrylnaphth[1,2d-loxazole; 1,2-bis(5' methyl-2-benzoxazolyl)
ethylene; disodium-4,4'-bis(6-methylethanoiamine-3-anilino-1,3,5-triazin-2"-yl)-2,2'-stilbene
sulphonate; N-(2-hydroxyethyl-4;4'-bis (benzimidazolyl)stilbene; tetrasodium 4,4'-bis
[4"-bis(2"- hydroxyethyl)-amino-6"(3"-sulphophenyl) amino-1", 3", 5"-triazin-2"-yl
amino]-2,2'-stilbenedisulphonate; disodium-4-(6"-sulphonaphtho[1',2'-d]triazol-2-yl)-2-stilbenesulphonate;
disodium 4,4'-bis [4"-(2"'- hydroxyethoxy)-6"-amino-1",3",5"-triazin-2"-yl amino]_2,2'-
stilbenedisulphonate; 4-methyl-7-dimethyl aminocoumarin; and alkoxylated 4,4'-bis-(benzimidazolyl)
stilbene.
[0165] Bleaches may optionally be incorporated in liquid detergent compositions of our invention
subject to chemical stability and compatibility. Encapsulated bleaches may form part
of the suspended solid. The action of peroxy bleaches in compositions of our invention
may be enhanced by the presence of bleach activators such as tetra acetyl ethylenediamine,
in effective amounts. Photoactive bleaches such as zinc or aluminium sulphonated phthalocyanin,
may also be present.
[0166] Perfumes and colourings are conventionally present in laundry detergents in amounts
up to 1 or 2%, and may similarly be present in compositions of our invention. Care
is sometimes necessary in selecting a suitable perfume since the solvents present
may modify the behaviour of the Active Ingredients.
[0167] , Proteolytic and amylolitic enzymes may optionally be present in conventional amounts,
together optionally with enzyme stabilizers and carriers. Encapsulated enzymes may
be suspended in the composition.
[0168] Other Minor Ingredients include defoamers, alkalis, buffers, germicides such as formaldehyde,
opacifiers such as vinyl latex emulsion, inert abrasives, such as silica and anticorrosives
such as benzotriazole.
[0169] Compositions of our invention are, in general, suitable for laundry use and our invention
provides a method of washing clothes by agitating them in a wash liquor containing
any composition of the invention as described herein. Low foam compositions herein
described are in particular of use in automatic washing machines. The compositions
may also be used in the washing of dishes, or the cleaning of hard surfaces, the low
foam products being particularly suitable for use in dishwashing machines. High foaming
compositions may be of value for shampoo formulations. These constitute a further
aspect of the invention.
[0170] Compositions of our invention may, generally, be used for washing clothes in boiling
water, or for washing at medium or cool temperatures, e.g. 50 to 80°C, especially
55 to 68
0C, or 20 to 50°C especially 30 to 40°C, respectively. Typically the compositions may
be added to the washwater at concentrations of between 0.05 and 3% Dry Weight based
on the wash water preferably 0.1 to 2%, more usually 0.3 to 1% e.g. 0.4 to 0.8%.
[0171] The invention is illustrated by the examples set out in the following Tables. The
Examples were stable and Pourable. They were stable to storage at 40°C and were Non-Shear
Sensitive. They were Temperature Stable and, except for Example 83, were Shear Stable.
[0173] The drawings illustrate variations in Conductivity, Yield Point and Viscosity with
variations in Electrolyte concentration and in Active Ingredient.
[0174] Figure 1 is a graph showing conductivity of an aqueous 20.6% solution of Active Ingredients
consisting of 2 parts by weight sodium dodecyl benzene sulphonate and 1 part sodium
C
12-18 alkyl 3 mole ethoxy sulphate, with various concentrations of added sodium silicate
of Na
2O:SiO
2 mole ratio 1:1.6. The figures on the horizontal axis refer to the amount of silicate
in the composition expressed as weight percent of solids.
[0175] Between 0 and 7%, added silicate solution produces a substantially clear, optically
isotropic composition typical of Stage I as described hereinbefore. Between the points
marked "A" and "B", Stage II compositions are obtained, which are turbid, unstable
and comprise non-Space Filling Flocs of Spherulites. Between "B" and "C", Stage III
compositions are obtained, according to the invention. These are turbid, Stable compositions
containing substantially Space Filling Flocs of Spherulites, exhibiting a Yield Point
and showing only a single liquid phase on High G Centrifuging. Beyond "C", Stage IV
compositions are obtained, containing non-Space Filling Flocs of Spherical G Phase,
which are non-Stable. It will be seen that the Stable Stage III compositions are obtained
in the Conductivity trough around the First Conductivity Minimum.
[0176] Figure 2 shows the effect of adding sodium nitrate to the same aqueous Active system.
Beyond the point "C" in Stage IV a second Conductivity Maximum is passed, followed
by a Second Conductivity Minimum, corresponding to the formation of a Lamellar composition
according to Stage V at approximately "D".
[0177] Figure 3 shows variations in Viscosity, Conductivity and Yield Point when sodium
carbonate is added to the same Active system.
[0178] The left-hand axis indicates Viscosity at 136 sec-
l in Pascal Seconds, the figures in parenthesis referring to Conductivity in millisiemens
cm-
1; the right-hand scale refers to Yield Point in dynes cm-
2; the horizontal axis represents the total percentage of sodium carbonate present
expressed as Dry Weight of sodium carbonate based on the total weight of the composition
[0179] In the case of sodium carbonate, no minimum is observed in the Conductivity curve
(dotted line). This is because the solubility limit of sodium carbonate has been reached,
so that further additions of carbonate go into suspension and do not increase the
dissolved Electrolyte concentration. No Stage IV can therefore be observed. The sharp
rise in Yield Point (right-hand peak), coincides with the onset of Stage III at point
"B". This is typical of compositions of our invention.
[0180] Figure 4, illustrates the effect of varying the relative proportions of sodium dodecyl
benzene sulphonate and coconut monoethanolamide in a composition containing sodium
dodecyl benzene sulphonate, sodium tripolyphosphate, sodium carbonate and water in
a ratio of 0.2:0.5:0.1:1.0. The horizontal scale represents the Wt. ratio of coconut
monoethanolamide to sodium dodecyl benzene sulphonate. The vertical scale represents
Conductivity in mS cm-
1 (circles) and also Viscosity in Pascal Seconds X 10 (triangles) .
[0181] Figure 5 shows a similar relationship wherein the cococnut monoethanolamide is replaced
with sodium C
12-18 alkyl 3 mole ethoxy sulphate. The horizontal scale is the weight ratio of the ether
sulphate to the alkyl benzene sulphonate.
[0182] Figures 4 and 5 illustrate how it is possible to prepare compositions of the invention
by modifying the Active Ingredients.
[0183] Figure 6 shows the variation in Conductivity in mS cm
-1 when sodium nitrate is added in various proportions to a detergent composition containing
suspended Builder and having the formulation:
[0184]

[0185] Because of the dissolved tripolyphosphate already present Stage L is not observed
in this curve. The Conductivity falls from a maximum at "A" until the commencement
of Stage III at "B".
[0186] Figure 7 shows the Yield Point for the same system, in dynes cmr2 and Figure 8 shows
the Viscosity at 136 cmr
1 (lower curve), 21 curl (upper curve) and the Viscosity drop (middle curve) in Pascal
Seconds X10.
[0187] Figure 9 illustrates the change in Conductivity with varying proportions of sodium
silicate in a 20.6% by wt. aqueous solution of sodium dodecyl benzene sulphonate in
admixture with coconut monoethanolamide in a weight ratio of 10:4.
[0188] Again no Stage I is observed this time because the Active Ingredients are not fully
soluble in water at room temperature. The composition is thus turbid and unstable
in the absence of Electrolyte.
[0189] Figures 10 and 11 are transmission micrographs of Pt/C replicas, after freeze fracturing,
at magnifications of X78,000 and X150,000 (lin) respectively.
[0190] The micrographs which were prepared on the Lancaster University transmission electron
microscope both represent a sample having the composition:

[0191] The micrograph shows Spherulites of between 0.2 and 1 micron diameter, which show
evidence of being Multiple Vesicles with a concentric structure, having a repeat spacing
(including the thickness of one surfactant shell and one adjacent aqueous layer) of
80 + A.
1. A Stable, Pourable, fluid, detergent composition consisting essentially of Active
Ingredients, Electrolyte and water and having solid-suspending properties, wherein
the proportion of Electrolyte is sufficient to provide a Temperature Stable, Non-Shear-Sensitive,
substantially Non-Lamellar Composition.
2. A Stable, Pourable, fluid, detergent composition having solid-suspending properties
and comprising water, Active Ingredients and Electrolyte, wherein the proportion of
Electrolyte is sufficient to provide a space filing Spherulitic floc which is Temperature
Stable and Non-Shear Sensitive.
3. A Stable, Pourable fluid detergent composition having solid suspending properties
which comprises water, Active Ingredients and sufficient Electrolyte to form a Stable
dispersed phase containing at least part of the Active Ingredients, corresponding
to a trough in the graph of Conductivity against Electrolyte concentration, which
contains the First Conductivity Minimum, the proportion of Electrolyte being within
the range at which the composition is Temperature Stable and Non-Shear Sensitive.
4. A composition according to any of claims 1 to 3 wherein the proportion of Electrolyte
is sufficient to render the composition Shear Stable.
5. A composition according to any foregoing claim containing suspended solid.
6. A composition according to claim 5 wherein the solid is a Builder or abrasive.
7. A Stable, Pourable fluid detergent composition containing water, Active Ingredients,
Electrolyte and suspended solids, wherein the proportion of Electrolyte is sufficient
to form a Shear Stable Spherulitic composition having a Yield Point of from 1 to 15
dynes cm-2.
8. A Stable, Pourable, fluid, detergent composition consisting essentially of water,
from 5 to 25% based on the weight of the composition of Active Ingredients, Electrolyte
and suspended solid Builder, the total weight proportion of Builder to Active Ingredient
being from 1.4:1 to 4:1 and the portion of Electrolyte being sufficient to provide
a Shear Stable, Non-Lamellar composition.
9. A Stable, Pourable, fluid detergent composition comprising water, from 5 to 25%
based on the weight of the composition of Active Ingredients, Electrolyte and suspended
solid Builder, and having a Payload of at least 35% by weight wherein the proportion
of Electrolyte is sufficient to provide a Shear Stable, Spherulitic Composition.
10. A Stable, Pourable, fluid, detergent composition containing water, from 5 to 25%
by weight of Active Ingredients, Electrolyte and suspended solid Builder the total
proportion by weight of Builder to Active Ingredients being from 1.5:1 to 4:1 and
the proportion of Electrolyte to being sufficient to provide a Spherulitic Composition
Stable to storage at 40°C.
11. A Stable, Pourable, fluid, detergent composition comprising water 5 to 20% by
weight of Active Ingredients, Electrolyte and suspended solid Builder, the total weight
ratio of Builder to Active Ingredient being from 1:1 to 4:1 and the proportion of
Electrolyte being sufficient to provide a Temperature Stable, Non-Shear-Sensitive
composition, which on Centrifuging separates into an aqueous layer, containing more
than 50% of the total weight of Active Ingredients, and a Solid Layer.
12. A Stable, Pourable detergent composition consisting essentially of water, dissolved
Electrolyte and from 8 to 14% by weight of the composition of Active Ingredients,
together with suspended solid Builder, and, optionally the Usual Minor Ingredients
which composition, on Centrifuging, separates into a Solid Layer and a single liquid
layer having a Yield Point of greater than 1.5 dynes cm-2.
13. A composition consisting substantially of water, Active Ingredients and Electrolyte
and having solid-suspending properties, wherein; the Active Ingredients are capable
of forming a Stable composition at the First Conductivity Minimum, and the amount
of Electrolyte present is sufficient to provide a composition having a Yield Point
of greater than 1.5 dynes cm-2 and a Viscosity measured at 136 sec'1, of less than 0.28 Pascal Seconds.
14. A Pourable, Stable, aqueous based detergent composition consisting essentially
of water, Electrolyte, Active Ingredient and Builder and comprising a first predominantly
aqueous liquid Separable Phase, containing at least part of the Electrolyte in solution
and from 50 to 80% of the total weight of Active Ingredients, at least one Dispersed
solid Separable Phase comprising at least part of the Builder as solid.
15. A Pourable, Stable, aqueous based detergent composition having a pH greater than
9 and comprising water, a dissolved Electrolyte, at least 5% by weight of Active Ingredients
and at least 16% by weight of Builder, which Electrolyte is present in a proportion
sufficient to render the composition Shear Stable, but insufficient for the Active
Ingredients to form a substantial proportion of a Lamellar Phase.
16. An aqueous-based, liquid detergent composition, comprising sufficient Active Ingredients
to form a space-filling floc of surfactant-containing Spherulites Interspersed with
an aqueous phase and an amount of Electrolyte not less than that corresponding to
the First Conductivity Minimum of the graph of electrical Conductivity against Electrolyte
concentration, but below that which corresponds to the formation of a Lamellar phase,
and sufficient to render the composition Non-Shear-Sensitive.
17. A Pourable, Stable detergent composition comprising water, Electrolyte, Active
Ingredient and Builder, which separates on Centrifuging as defined herein into at
least two layers including: a predominantly aqueous layer containing dissolved Electrolyte,
at least
10% by weight of the Total Water, and from 85% to 50% by weight of the total Active
Ingredient, and a Solid Layer containing at least a proportion of the Builder.
18. A Stable, Spherulitic Composition comprising Active Ingredients, Electrolyte and
water which does not exhibit a separate, clear, aqueous phase after High G centrifuging,
at 20,000 G for 90 minutes.
19. A composition according to any foregoing claim having a Viscosity Drop greater
than 0.35 pascal Seconds
20. A composition according to claim 19, having a Viscosity Drop from 0.45 to 2 Pascal
Seconds.
21. A composition according to any foregoing claim having a Pay Load of 25 to 75%
by weight.
22. A composition according to any foregoing claim having a weight ratio of Builder
to Active Ingredients of greater than 1.2:1.
23. A composition according to claim 22 having a weight ratio of Builder to Active
Ingredient of 1.4:1 to 4:1.
24. A composition acording to any foregoing claim containing from 10 to 13.5% based
on the weight of the composition of Active Ingredients.
25. A composition according to any foregoing claim which, on Centrifguing, provides
a Solid Layer and a single aqueous layer having a Yield Point of from 2 to 10 dynes
cm-2.
26. A composition according to any foregoing claim which, on Centrifuging, provides
a Solid Layer and a single aqueous layer containing from 60 to 90% of the total weight
of the Active Ingredients.
27. A composition acording to any foregoing claim having a pH of 9 to 13.
28. A composition according to any foregoing claim having sufficient alkalinity to
require at least 0.8 ml N/10 HCL to reduce the pH of 100 mls of an aqueous solution
of said composition, diluted to 0.5% Dry Weight, to 9.
29. A composition according to claim 28, which when diluted to 0.5% Dry Weight, requires
from 4.7 to 8.6 mls N/10 HCL to reduce 100 mls to pH 9.
30. A composition according to any foregoing claim having a Conductivity no more than
2 millisiemens cm-1 greater than that corresponding to the First Conductivity Minimum.
31. A composition according to any foregoing claim having a Conductivity less than
10 milliSiemens per cm.
32. A composition according to any foregoing claim, wherein the Electrolyte is a water
soluble carbonate, silicate, tripolyphosphate, pyrophosphate, nitrilotriacetate, citrate,
chloride and/or nitrate.
33. A composition according to any foregoing claim, wherein the Active Ingredients
comprise a mixture of (A) a non-alkoxylated anionic surfactant with (B) a cosurfactant
that forms stable foams.
34. A composition according to claim 33, wherein the component (A) comprises an alkyl
benzene sulphonate having from 8 to 22 aliphatic carbon atoms. .
35. A composition acording to either of claims 33 and 34, wherein the component (A)
comprises an alkyl sulphate having from 8 to 22 carbon atoms.
36. A composition according to any of claims 33 to 35 wherein component (A) comprises
an olefin sulphonate, alkane sulphonate, alkylphenol sulphate, alkylethanolamide sulphate,
sulphocarboxylic acid and/or sulphocarboxylic ester, having from 8 to 22 carbon atoms.
37. A composition according to any of claims 33 to 36, wherein the component (B) is
an alkyl polyethoxy sulphate having a C8-22 alkyl group and up to 20 ethyleneoxy group.
38. A composition according to any of claims 33 to 37, wherein component (B) comprises
an alkylphenol polyethyleneoxy sulphate, and/or an alkylethanolamide polyethyleneoxy
sulphate having a C8-22 alkyl group and up to 20 ethyleneoxy groups.
. 39. A composition according to any of claims 33 to 38, wherein the component (B)
comprises a C10-22 alkyl monoethanolamide or diethanolamide.
40. A composition according to any of claims 33 to 39, wherein component (B) comprises a mono C8-22 di C1-4 alkyl amine-oxide.
41. A composition according to any of claims 33 to 40, wherein the Active Ingredients
additionally comprise a polyethoxylated C8-22 alcohol, carboxylic acid, amine, alkylolamide, glyceryl ester, having in each case
up to 20 ethyleneoxy groups in a proportion of up to 20% of the total weight of Active
Ingredients.
42. A composition according to any of claim 33 to 41, wherein the ratio of (A):(B)
is from 5:1 to 1:3.
43. A composition according to claim 42, wherein the ratio of (A):(B) is from 4:1
to 1:2.
44. A composition according to claim 43, wherein the proportion of (A):(B) is from
3:1 to 1:1.
45. A composition according to claim 41, wherein the proportion of ethoxylated non-ionic
is from 2 to 10% of the total weight of Active Ingredients.
46. A composition according to any of claims 1 to 44 containing a foam inhibitor.
47. A composition according to claim 46, wherein the foam inhibitor comprises a mixture
of an organopolysiloxane foam inhibitor and fumed silica.
48. A composition according to any foregoing claim containing suspended particles
of sodium tripolyphosphate and/or zeolite.
49. A Stable, Pourable, Non-Shear-Sensitive, Spherulitic compositioi having a Payload
of at least 35% by weight and comprising: water; from 12 to 40% of Active Ingredients
based on the Dry Weight of the composition; dissolved Electrolyte; and from 20 to
80% Dry Weight total of Builder based on the Dry Weight of the composition at least
partly present as suspended solid, and partly as at least part of sai dissolved Electrolyte,
in a total weight ratio of Builder to Active Ingredient of 1.3:1 to 4:1; wherein said
Active Ingredients consist essentially of (A) 30 to 80% by weight thereof of at least
one non-alkoxylated anionic sulphated or sulphonated surfactant; and (B) fron 20 to
70%, by weight of the total Active Ingredient, of at least one alkoxylated anionic
surfactant, alkanolamide and/or amine oxide.
50. A Stable, Pourable, fluid, aqueous-based, detergent compositior comprising: from
12 to 40% based on the Dry Weight thereof of Active Ingredients which comprise from
30 to 90% based on the Dry weight of the Active Ingredients of non-alkoxylated sulphated
and/or sulphonateanionic surfactant and the balance of alkyl ether sulphate, alkanolamide
and/or an amine oxide; an aqueous phase containing sufficient Electrolyte in solution
to form a space-filling Spherulit floc comprising at least part of said Active Ingredients
and Interspersed with said aqueous phase; suspended particles of Builder; an effective
amount of at least one foam inhibitor and optionally the Usual Minor Ingredients.
51. A Pourable, Stable, Non-Lamellar detergent composition having a Payload of from
30% to 50% consisting essentially of from 12 to 40% Dry Weight, based on the Dry Weight
of the composition, of Active Ingredients, at least 30% Builder, based on the Dry
Weight of the composition, a ratio of Builder to Active Ingredient greater than 1.1
to 1, said Active Ingredient consisting essentially of alkyl benzene sulphonate having
8 to 18 aliphatic carbon atoms and an alkyl ethanolamide selected from C10-18 alkyl monoethanolamides and diethanolamides, in a weight ratio of alkyl benzene sulphonate
to ethanolamide of from 1.5:1 to 4:1, said Builder being selected from sodium tripolyphosphate,
sodium carbonate, zeolite, sodium nitrilo triacetate, sodium silicate and mixtures
thereof, such that the amount of dissolved Builder is sufficient to provide a Yield
point of greater than 1.5 dynes cm-2.
52. A Pourable, Stable, liquid detergent composition, consisting essentially of:
A - A mixture of (i) a sodium alkylbenzene sulphonate having 10 to 18, aliphatic carbon
atoms with (ii) a sodium alkyl ether sulphate having an alkyl group with an average
of from 8 to 18 carbon atoms, and from 1 to 20, ethylene-oxy and/or propylene-oxy
groups; in a ratio of (i):(ii), of between 10:1 and 1:10;
B - A Builder selected from sodium tripolyphosphate, zeolite, sodium nitrilotriacetate
and mixtures thereof in a weight ratio of B:A of from 1.1:1 to 4:1; \
C - An Electrolyte selected from sodium carbonate, sodium silicate, sodium nitrate,
sodium chloride and mixtures thereof in a concentration of from 2 to 20% by weight
of the composition; said composition having a Pay Load of 30 to 50% by weight.
53. A composition according to claim 52, wherein the proportion of (i):(ii) is from
10:1.5 to 10:5.
54. A composition according to claim 53, wherein the proportion of (i):(ii) is from
10:2 to 10:4.
55. A composition according to any of claims 52 to 54, wherein the ratio of B:A is
from 1.2:1 to 3.5:1.
56. A composition according to claim 55, wherein the ratio of B:A is from 2:1 to 3:1.
57. A composition according to any of claims 52 to 56, wherein C is present in a concentration
of 3 to 18% by weight based on the weight of the composition.
58. A composition according to claim 57, wherein C is present in concentration of
from 7 to 15% by weight.
59. A composition according to any of claims 52 to 58, wherein the Pay Load is from
38 to 45%.
60. A composition according to any of claims 52 to 59 containing minor, but effective
amounts of carboxymethyl cellulose, perfume, colouring and optical brightener.
61. A composition according to any of claims 52 to 60, wherein (ii) has a C10-14 alkyl
group and from 3 to 6 ethylene-oxy groups.
62. A composition according to any of claims 52 to 61, wherein the Electrolyte is
sodium carbonate and/or sodium silicate together with dissolved sodium tripolyphosphate,
and the Builder comprises sodium tripolyphosphate in suspension.
63. A composition according to any of claims 52 to 62, wherein the proportion of Electrolyte
is sufficient to provide a Temperature Stable composition.
64. A composition according to any foregoing claim which contains encapsulated bleaches
and/or enzymes in suspensions.
65. A composition according to any foregoing claim wherein a majority of the Active
Ingredients are present as Spherulites of from 0.1 to 5 microns diameter.
66. A composition according to claim 65 wherein a major proportion by weight of the
Active Ingredient is present as Spherulites of from 0.2 to 2 microns diameter.
67. A composition according to claim 66 wherein a major proportion by weight of the
Active Ingredient is present in Spherulites of 0.2 to 1 microns diameter.
68. A composition according to any foregoing claim comprising Spherulites which are
Multiple Vesicles having a concentric structure with an average Latice spacing of
60-1000A.
69. A composition according to claim 68 wherein the average latice spacing is 70 to
90oA.
70. A Pourable, Stable, fluid, detergent composition consisting essentially of: water;
a concentration of from 5 to 25% by weight of the composition of Active Ingredients
which consist essentially of (i) at least one non-ethoxylated anionic surfactant and
(ii) at least one cosurfactant that is capable of forming stable foams, the proportions
of (i) to (ii) being such that if a soluble Electrolyte is added progressively to
an aqueous mixture containing said Active Ingredients at said concentration, a First
Conductivity Minimum is reached at which the mixture is turbid and Stable; suspended
Solid Builder, the total weight ratio of Builder to Active Ingredients being from
1:1 to 4:1; and dissolved Electrolyte in a proportion sufficient to form a Stable
composition corresponding to the Conductivity trough containing said First Conductivity
Minimum, and greater than any concentration below which the composition is Shear Sensitive
but below the maximum concentration at which it is Temperature Stable.
71. A composition according any foregoing claim substantially as herein described
with reference to any one of the examples.
72. A method of washing fabric which comprises agitating the fabric in a wash liquor
containing a composition according to any foregoing claim.