[0001] This invention is concerned with manufacture of high grade viscous oil products from
crude petroleum fractions or other hydrocarbon materials. It is particularly directed
to the manufacture of high quality lube basestock oils from crude stocks of high boiling
point as opposed to using so-called light stocks. The latter crudes have lower boiling
points and for reasons which are not fully understood, do not show any advantage in
the novel process of this invention over commercially practiced technology. More specifically,
the invention is concerned with dewaxing of lube basestock oils having an initial
boiling point higher than 371°C (700°F) and a 50 volume percent boiling point of at
least 482°C (900°F).
[0002] High quality lube basestock oils are conventionally prepared by refining distillate
fractions or the residuum prepared by vacuum distilling a suitable crude oil from
which the lighter portion has been removed by distillation in an atmospheric tower.
Thus, the charge to the vacuum tower is commonly referred to as a "long residuum"
and residuum from theovacuum tower is distinguished from the starting material by
referring to it as the "short residuum".
[0003] The vacuum distillate fractions are upgraded by a sequence of unit operations, the
first of which is solvent extraction with a solvent selective for aromatic hydrocarbons.
This step serves to remove aromatic hydrocarbons of low viscosity index and provides
a raffinate of improved viscosity index and quality. Various processes have been used
in this extraction stage, and these employ solvents such as furfural, phenol, sulfur
dioxide, and others. The short residuum, because it contains most of the asphaltenes
of the crude oil, is conventionally treated to remove these asphalt-like constituents
prior to solvent extraction to increase the viscosity index.
[0004] The raffinate from the solvent extraction step contains paraffins which adversely
affect the pour point. Thus, the waxy raffinate, regardless of whether prepared from
a distillate fraction or from the short residuum, must be dewaxed. Various dewaxing
procedures have been used, and the art has gone in the direction of treatment with
a solvent such as methyl ethyl ketone/toluene mixtures to remove the wax and prepare
a dewaxed raffinate. The dewaxed raffinate may then be finished by any number of sorption
or catalytic processes to improve color and oxidation stability.
[0005] In recent years techniques have become available for catalytic dewaxing the petroleum
stocks. A process of that nature developed by British Petroleum is described in the
Oil and Gas Journal dated January 6, 1975, at pages 69-73. See, also, United States
Patent No. 3,668,113.
[0006] In United States Patent No. Reissue 28,398 is described a process for catalytic dewaxing
with a catalyst comprising zeolite ZSM-5. Such process combined with catalytic hydrofinishing
is described in United States Patent No. 3,894,938 for reducing the pour point of
a sulfur and nitrogen-containing gas oil boiling within the range of 204 to 482°C
(400 to 900°F).
[0007] United States Patent No. 3,755,145 discloses a process for preparing lube oil having
low pour points involving using a catalyst mixture comprising hydrogenation components,
a conventional cracking catalyst and a crystalline aluminosilicate zeolite of the
ZSM-5 type. At Column 8 there is specifically disclosed the use of an extrudate having
a 1/16th of an inch diameter.
[0008] United States Patent No. 3,894,938 discloses the catalytic dewaxing and desulfurization
of gas oils with a ZSM-5 zeolite containing a hydrogenation component. At Column 3
it is specifically pointed out that the ZSM-5 can be incorporated into a matrix and
that the catalyst particles can be sized between 0.8 and 3.2 mm (1/32nd and 1/8th
of an inch).
[0009] United States 3,846,337 discloses silica-bound silicate particles of improved strength
within the range of 0.8 to 3.2 mm (1/32 to about 1/8 inch) average extrudate diameter
and their use in various catalysts reactions.
[0010] These processes did not provide any guidance as to how to achieve a more stable operation
when processing heavy lubricating oil stocks, such as bright stock.
[0011] We discovered that more efficient dewaxing of these heavy stocks could be achieved
using a special dewaxing catalyst with certain physical properties.
[0012] Accordingly, the present invention provides a process for dewaxing a petroleum feedstock
having an initial boiling point of at least 371°C (700°F) and a 50 volume percent
boiling point of at least 482°C (900°F) wherein said hydrocarbon is contacted in the
presence of added hydrogen at a temperature of 232 to 427°C (450 to 800°F) with a
dewaxing catalyst comprising aluminosilicate zeolite having a silica-to-alumina ratio
of greater than 12 and a Constraint Index of 1 to about 12 and wherein said aluminosilicate
zeolite is composited with an inorganic oxide binder and characterized by using a
catalyst composite having a maximum diffusion distance of less than 0.6 mm (0.025
inch).
[0013]
Figure 1 is a graph of actual experimental data illustrating the temperature requirements
to catalytically dewax a lube stock whose boiling range lies outside the scope of
the present invention, over a prior art catalyst.
Figure 2 is a graph of actual experimental data illustrating the temperature requirements
to catalytically dewax with the invention catalyst a lube stock whose boiling range
lies outside the scope of the invention.
Figure 3 is a graph of actual experimental data showing the effect of treating a heavy
neutral feedstock with an extruded catalyst having a particle diameter of 0.8 mm (0.03125
inch) compared to a prior art catalyst.
Figure 4 is a graph of actual experimental data showing the dewaxing of a heavy neutral
feedstock on the subsequent cycle to Figure 3 comparing the same reference and invention
catalysts.
Figure 5 shows experimental data on the dewaxing of a bright stock using the same
reference and invention catalysts shown in Figures 3 and 4.
Figure 6 shows experimental data on the dewaxing of bright stock comparing extruded
catalyst and finely crushed catalyst.
[0014] The wax base crudes (sometimes called "paraffin base") from which the chargestock
is derived by distillation constitute a well-recognized class of crude petroleums.
Many scales have been devised for classificaton of crude, some of which are described
in Chapter VII, "Evaluation of Oil Stocks of Petroleum Refinery Engineering, by W.
L. Nelson, McGraw Hill, 1941. A convenient scale identified by Nelson at page 69 involves
determination of the cloud point of the Bureau of Mines (key fraction #2) which boils
between 275°C (527°F) and 300°C (572°F) at 40 mm pressure. If the cloud point of this
fraction is above -15°C (5°F), the crude is considered wax base.
[0015] In practice of the present invention, a suitable chargestock such as a propane deasphalted
short residuum fraction or a fraction having an initial boiling point of at least
468°C (875°F), and preferably at least 482°C (900°F.) and a final boiling point greater
than 649°C (1200
0F) is prepared by distillation of such wax base crude. Such fraction can then be solvent
refined by counter current extraction with at least an equal volume (100 volume percent)
of a selective solvent such a furfural. It is preferred to use about 1.5-3.0 volumes
of solvent per volume of oil. The furfural raffinate has an initial boiling point
of greater than 371°C (700°F) and a 50 volume percent boiling point of at least 482°C
(900°F). It is then subjected to catalytic dewaxing by mixing in hydrogen and contacting
at 232 to 427°C (450 to 800°F), preferably at 260 to 371°C (500 to 700°F), with a
catalyst containing a hydrogenation metal, an inorganic oxide binder and zeolite ZSM-5
or other related silicate zeolites having a silica-to-alumina ratio of at least 12
and a Constraint Index of 1-12 and a liquid hourly space velocity (LHSV) of 0.1-2.0
volumes of charge oil per volume of catalyst per hour. The preferred space velocity
is 0.5-1.0 LHSV.
[0016] The catalyst is extruded or otherwise shaped so as to have a maximum diffusion distance
of less than 0.6 mm (0.025 inch).
[0017] The catalytic dewaxing reaction is preferably carried out at hydrogen partial pressures
of 1,100 to 21,000 kPa (150 to 3000 psig), at the reactor inlet, and preferably at
1,800 to 10,400 kPa (250 to 1500 psig). Dewaxing operates at a hydrogen circulation
of 90 to 900 volumes of liquid at standard conditions per volume of H
2 at standard conditions, v/v,(500 to 5000 standard cubic feet per barrel of feed (SCFB)j,
preferably 270 to 530 v/v (1500 to 3000 SCFB).
[0018] The solvent extraction technique is well understood in the art and needs no detailed
review here. The severity of extraction is adjusted to composition of the chargestock
to meet specifications for the particular lube basestock and the contemplated end-use;
this severity will be determined in practice of this invention in accordance with
well-established practices.
[0019] The catalytic dewaxing step is conducted at 232 to 427°C (450 to 800°F). However,
at temperatures above 357°C (675°F), bromine number of the product generally increases
and the oxidation stability decreases.
[0020] The dewaxing catalyst is a composite of hydrogenation metal, such as nickel, cobalt,
molybdenum, chromium, tungsten, palladium, platinum or compositions thereof associated
with the acid form of a novel class of aluminosilicate zeolite having a silica-to-alumina
ratio of at least about 12, and a constrained access to the intracrystalline free
space, as more fully described hereinbelow.
[0021] An important characteristic of the crystal structure of this class of zeolites is
that it provides constrained access to and egress from the intracrystalline free space
by virtue of having a pore dimension greater than about 5 Angstroms and pore windows
of about a size such as would be provided by 10-membered rings of oxygen atoms. It
is to be understood, of course, that these rings are those formed by the regular disposition
of the tetrahedra making up the anionic framework of the crystalline aluminosilicate,
the oxygen atoms themselves being bonded to the silicon or aluminum atoms at the centers
of the tetrahedra. Briefly, the preferred type zeolites useful in this invention possesses,
in combination: a silica-to-alumina mole ratio of at least about 12; and a structure
providing constrained access to the crystalline free space.
[0022] The silica-to-alumina ratio referred to may be determined by conventional analysis.
This ratio is meant to represent, as closely as possible, the ratio in the rigid anionic
framework of the zeolite crystal and to exclude aluminum in the binder or in cationic
or other form within the channels. Although zeolites with a silica-to-alumina ratio
of at least 12 are useful, it is preferred to use zeolites having higher ratios of
at least 30. Such zeolites, after activation acquire an intracrystalline sorption
capacity for normal hexane which is greater than that for water, i.e., they exhibit
"hydrophobic" properties. It is believed that this hydrophobic characteristic is advantageous
in the present invention.
[0023] Rather than attempt to judge from crystal structure whether or not a zeolite possesses
the necessary constrained access, a simple determination of the Constraint Index may
be made by passing continuously a mixture of an equal weight of normal hexane and
3-methylpentane over a small sample, approximately 1 gram or less, of catalyst at
atmospheric pressure according to the following procedure. A sample of the zeolite,
in the form of pellets or extrudates, is crushed to a particle size about that of
coarse sand and mounted in a glass tube. Prior to testing, the zeolite is treated
with a stream of air at 538°C (1000°F) for at least 15 minutes. The zeolite is then
flushed with helium and the temperature adjusted to give an overall conversion between
10% and 60 percent. The mixture of hydrocarbons is passed at 1 liquid hourly space
velocity (LHSV) (i.e., 1 volume of liquid hydrocarbon per volume of zeolite per hour)
over the zeolite with a helium dilution to give a helium to total hydrocarbon mole
ratio of 4 to 1. After 20 minutes on stream, a sample of the effluent is taken and
analyzed, most conveniently by gas chromatography, to determine the fraction remaining
unchanged for each of the two hydrocarbons.
[0024] The Constraint Index is calculated as follows:

[0025] The Constraint Index approximates the ratio of the cracking rate constants for the
two hydrocarbons. Zeolites suitable for the present invention are those having a Constraint
Index in the approximate range of 1 to 12. Constraint Index (CI) values for some typical
zeolites are:

[0026] It is to be realized that the above Constraint Index values typically characterize
the specified zeolites but that such are the cumulative result of several variables
used in determination and calculation thereof. Thus, for a given zeolite depending
on the test temperature, the Constraint Index may vary within the indicated approximate
range of 1 to 12. Likewise, other variables such as the crystal size of the zeolite,
the presence of possible occluded contaminants and binders intimately combined with
the zeolite affect the Constraint Index. It will accordingly be understood by those
skilled in the art that the Constraint Index, as utilized herein, while affording
a highly useful means for characterizing the zeolites of interest is approximate,
taking into consideration the manner of its determination, with probability, in some
instances, of compounding variable extremes.
[0027] The class of zeolites defined herein is exemplified by ZSM-5, ZSM-11, ZSM-12, ZSM-23,
ZSM-35, ZSM-38, and other similar materials. U.S. Patent No. 3,702,886, describes
ZSM-5.
[0028] ZSM-11 is described in U.S. Patent No. 3,709,979.
[0029] ZSM-12 is described in U.S. Patent No. 3,832,449.
[0030] ZSM-23 is described in U.S. Patent No. 4,076,842.
[0031] ZSM-35 is described in U.S. Patent No. 4,016,245.
[0032] ZSM-38 is described in U.S. Patent No. 4,046,859.
[0033] The specific zeolites described, when prepared in the presence of organic cations,
are catalytically inactive, possibly because the intracrystalline free space is occupied
by organic cations from the forming solution. They may be activated by heating in
an inert atmosphere, followed by base exchange with ammonium salts followed by calcination.
[0034] Natural zeolites may sometimes be converted to this type zeolite catalyst by various
activation procedures and other treatments such as base exchange, steaming, alumina
extraction and calcination, in combinations. Natural minerals which may be so treated
include ferrierite, brewsterite, stilbite, dachiardite, epistilbite, heulandite, and
clinoptilolite. The preferred crystalline aluminosilicates are ZSM-5, ZSM-11, ZSM-12,
ZSM-23, ZSM-38 and ZSM-35, with ZSM-5 particularly preferred.
[0035] When synthesized in the alkali metal form, the zeolite is conveniently converted
to the hydrogen form, generally by intermediate formation of the ammonium form as
a result of ammonium ion exchange and calcination of the ammonium form to yield the
hydrogen form. In addition to the hydrogen form, other forms of the zeolite wherein
the original alkali metal has been reduced to less than about 1.5 percent by weight
may be used. Thus, the original alkali metal of the zeolite may be replaced by ion
exchange with other suitable ions of Groups IB to VIII of the Periodic Table, including,
by way of example, nickel, copper, zinc, palladium, calcium or rare earth metals.
[0036] In practicing the desired conversion process, it is desirable to incorporate the
above-described crystalline aluminosilicate zeolite in another material resistant
to the temperature and other conditions employed in the process. Such matrix materials
include synthetic or naturally occurring substances as well as inorganic materials
such as clay, silica and/or metal oxides. The latter may be either naturally occurring
or in the form of gelatinous precipitates or gels including mixtures of silica and
metal oxides. Naturally occurring clays which can be composited with the zeolite include
those of the montmorillonite and kaolin families, which families include the sub-bentonites
and the kaolins commonly known as Dixie, McNamee-Georgia and Florida clays or others
in which the main mineral constituent is halloysite, kaolinite, dickite, nacrite or
anauxite. Such clays can be used in the raw state as originally mined or initially
subjected to calcination, acid treatment or chemical modification.
[0037] In addition to the foregoing materials, the zeolites employed herein may be composited
with a porous matrix material, such as alumina, silica-alumina, silica-magnesia, silica-zirconia,
silica-thoria, silica-beryllia, silica-titania as well as ternary compositions, such
as silica-alumina-thoria, silica-alumina-zirconia, silica-alumina-magnesia and silica-magnesia-
zirconia. The relative proportions of zeolite component and inorganic oxide gel matrix
may vary widely with the zeolite content ranging from between 1 to 99 percent by weight
and more usually in the range of 55 to about 80 percent by weight of the composite.
[0038] The method of forming the particle or extrudate of the desired diameter size is accomplished
according to conventional techniques in the prior art, and no particular novelty is
claimed in the method of making the material. In general for forming cylindrical extrudates,
a mixture of a suitable zeolite such as ZSM-5 containing a hydrogenation component
and an inorganic oxide matrix such as alumina in a suitable weight ratio, i.e., 65
weight percent zeolite; 35 weight percent alumina; are mixed with water and extruded
through a .0625 inch to a conventional commercial extruder such as a California pellet
mill having the appropriate diameter hole, i.e., from 0.3 to 1.3 mm (.0125 to .05
inch). The extrudate is then dried and calcined at elevated temperatures, i.e., 538°C
(1000°F) for about 3 hours. Neither the drying nor the calcination time is particularly
critical, and it is the conventional time used in making extrudates.
[0039] Polylobes including trilobes and quadrulobes are known in the art and conventional
processes for their preparation are disclosed in U. S. Patent 4,447,314.
[0040] Extrusion is also useful for forming other shapes of particles that are desirable
for this catalyst. These are formed by using suitable shaped orifices in the die plate
of the extruder. U.S. Patent No. 3,674,680 to Hoekstra-et al. represents a suitable
extrudate shape; U. S. 3,674,680 uses small catalyst shapes wherein all points in
the particles are less than 0.4 mm (0.015 inch) from a surface of the particle. Shapes
having a configuration of cross, clover leaf, quadrulobe or trilobe such as in U.
S. 3,857,780 are operable here, so long as the maximum dimension of the cross section
of the lobes or shapes is such that the maximum diffusion distance is less than 0.6
mm (0.025 inches) from the particle surface.
[0041] Spherical or near-spherical particles within the specified dimension range of the
surface are also operable herein. These generally are formed from freshly extruded
material, for example, by a process where the extrudate is reshaped in a spinning
vessel or drum. Such equipment is available commercially as marumerizers from the
Eli Lily Company and others.
Examples 1 - 3
[0042] Three different lube basestocks were prepared from an Arabian Light crude. Typical
properties of the three materials are given in Table 1.
[0043] Charge stock A, a 345 bright stock, was prepared by propane deasphalting the vacuum
resid. The deasphalted oil was then furfural extracted to reduce the aromatics content.
[0044] Charge stock B, a 339 heavy neutral, was prepared by vacuum distillation. This heavy
vacuum distillate was then furfural extracted to reduce the aromatics content.
[0045] Charge stock C, a 318 light neutral, was also prepared by vacuum distillation. This
light vacuum distillate was also furfural extracted to lower the aromatics content.

EXAMPLE 4
[0046] A nickel ZSM-5 catalyst combined with an alumina matrix and extruded to a diameter
of 1.6 mm (0.0625 inch) was prepared as follows:
Dried sodium form ZSM-5 crystals and Kaiser SA alumina powder (alpha alumina monohydrate)
were blended in a ratio of 65 parts by wt ZSM-5 and 35 parts by wt Al
2O
3 (both on a dry basis), extruded to 1.6 mm (.0625 inch) diameter cylinders and calcined
for three hours at 538°C (1000°F). The calcined product was exchanged with NH
4NO
3 solution to low sodium and then with ni(N0
3)
2 solution. It was dried and then calcined at 538°C (1000°F). The nickel content was
1.3 weight percent and the sodium was 0.02 weight percent.
[0047] The calcined extrudate was then steamed at 482°C (900°F) for six hours. The measured
alpha activity was 68.
EXAMPLE 5
[0048] A nickel ZSM-5 catalyst combined with an alumina matrix and extruded to a diameter
of 0.8 mm (0.03125 inch) was prepared as follows:
This catalyst was pepared by the same procedure as Example 4, except that the extrudates
produced were 0.8 mm (1/32 inch) diameter.
[0049] The nickel content was 1.0 weight percent and the sodium was 0.03 weight percent.
The measured alpha activity was 75.
[0050] The physical properties of the catalyst prepared in accordance with Examples 4 and
Examples 5 are shown in Table 2.

It is to be understood that the catalyst can be employed in the fresh state or can
be subjected to a mild steaming treatment at elevated temperatures from 427 to 816°C
(800 to 1500°F) and preferably 427 to 649°C (800 to 1200°F). The treatment may be
accomplished in atmospheres of 100 percent steam or at atmospheres consisting of steam
and a gas which is substantially inert to the zeolites. A similar treatment can be
accomplished at lower temperatures and elevated pressures, e.g., 177 to 371°C (350
to 700°F) at 10 to about 200 atmospheres.
[0051] In the experiments which follow a catalyst of Examples 4 and 5 were treated with
steam at 482°C (900°F) for 6 hours.
EXAMPLE 6
[0052] In order to demonstrate that the novel process of this invention does not result
in increased benefit with all feedstocks, experiments were carried out using the raffinate
identified as Feed C in Table 1. As can be seen, this feedstock is outside the scope
of this invention since its 50 volume percent boiling point is below 482°C (900°F).
Catalysts of Examples 4 and 5 were used to process this feed material to a pour point
of -7°C (
+20
0F). The dewaxing conditions are as follows:

Figure 1 shows the results obtained utilizing the catalyst of Example 4 having a 1.6
mm (0.0625 inch) diameter extrudate. Figure 2 shows the results obtained using the
catalyst of the invention, 0.8 mm (0.03125 inch) diameter extrudate (Example 5). Both
catalysts had undergone previous dewaxing cycles with subsequent high temperature
hydrogen reactivations.
[0053] Following relatively rapid initial aging 2.8 to 3.9
0C (5 to 7°F) per day, both catalysts lined out and aged at about 0.56°C (1°F) per
day. Thus, no advantage is evident for dewaxing light stocks with catalysts having
maximum diffusion distances less than 0.8 mm (.03125 inch) i.e., 1.6 mm (.0625 inch)
diameter extrudate.
EXAMPLE 7
[0054] The catalysts of Examples 4 and 5 were used to dewax the heavy neutral raffinate
identified as Feed B to a pour point of -7°C (+20°F). The dewaxing conditions were
identical to those used in Example 6.
[0055] The results of this experiment are shown in Figure 3.
[0056] As can be seen in Figure 3 the dotted line represents the results obtained with the
1.6 mm (0.0625 inch) diameter catalyst, i.e., Example 4, whereas the solid line represents
a plot of the catalyst of Example 5, i.e., 0.8 mm (.03125 inch) diameter. As can be
seen, a lower start of cycle temperature was obtained using the 0.8 mm (.03125 inch)
catalyst, i.e., 282°C (540°F) as opposed to the 1.6 mm (.0625 inch) catalyst, i.e.,
291°C (555°F). The 1.6 mm (.0625 inch) catalyst aged at 2.22°C (4°F) per day, whereas
the 0.8 mm (.03125 inch) catalyst aged at 2.44°C (4.4°F) per day, essentially equivalent.
As can be seen from the above data, although the 0.8 mm (.03125 inch) catalyst resulted
in a lower start-of-cycle temperature, its aging rate was equal to the 1.6 mm (.0625
inch) catalyst.
EXAMPLE 8
[0057] After reaching end of cycle conditions, both the catalysts used in Example 6 were
reactivated by treatment with hydrogen at about 482°C (900°F) for 24 hours. They were
then recontacted with the same feedstock used in Example 6 under the exact same operating
conditions, and the results are shown in Figure 4. As can be seen, during the second
cycle, the 0.8 mm (.03125 inch) diameter catalyst represented by the solid line had
a start-of-cycle temperature of 289°C (552°F) as compared to 293°C (560°F) for the
1.6 mm (.0625 inch) diameter catalyst. However, the 0.8 mm (.03125 inch) diameter
catalyst aged at 3.11°C (5.6°F) per day whereas the 1.6 mm (.0625 inch) diameter catalyst
aged at 5.56°C (10°F) per day.
[0058] Quite obviously, the above experimental results demonstrate the lower aging characteristics
of utilizing the smaller extrudate. This advantage was not observed with 318LN (Example
6). Moreover, the advantages of the invention become more pronounced with reactivated
catalysts.
EXAMPLE 9
[0059] Following the runs of Example 8 both catalysts were again reactivated by heating
the same in the presence of hydrogen at 482°C (900°F) for 24 hours. The two catalysts
were then used to dewax a bright stock having the properties set forth under Feed
A in Table 1. The results of the experimentation are shown in Figure 5. The base case
catalyst 1.6 mm (0.0625 inch) diameter extrudate, as shown by the dashed line, had
a 299°C (570°F) start-of-cycle activity and aged at 5°C (9°F) per day. The invention
catalyst 0.8 mm (0.03125 inch) diameter extrudate, as shown by the solid line, had
a 284°C (544°F) start-of-cycle activity and aged at only 2.33°C (4.2°F) per day. This
result demonstrates that lowering -the catalyst's maximum diffusion distance improved
performance for dewaxing bright stock lube material.
EXAMPLE 10
[0060] The previous examples have cited 0.8 mm (1/32nd inch) diameter extrudate catalyst.
This example demonstrates that a similar catalyst stability benefit can also be achieved
by crushing large extrudates to smaller particles having a diffusion length encompassed
in this invention. The catalyst of Example 4 was crushed and sieved to two sizes:
20/30 mesh and 60/80 mesh. The average particle sizes were 0.6 mm (0.025 inch) and
0.1 mm (.005 inch), respectively. Maximum diffusion distances were 0.3 mm (0.0125
inch) and 0.06 mm (0.0025 inch), respectively. These three catalysts were used to
dewax an Arabian Light bright stock (see Table 3 for properties) at 0.75 LHSV. The
results are shown in Figure 6. The catalyst of Example 4 extrudate catalyst had a
start-of-cycle activity of 278°C (533°F) and aged at 1.67°C (3°F) per day. The 20/30
mesh catalyst had a start-of-cycle activity of 278°C (532°F) and aged at only 0.83°C
(1.5°F) per day. Going to even smaller particles gave a slight start-of-cycle activity
benefit.
