[0001] The present invention relates generally to fuel assemblies for nuclear reactors and,
more particularly, to a nuclear fuel rod having an improved end plug assembly.
[0002] As well known in the art, a fuel rod for use in fuel assemblies of a nuclear reactor
includes a plurality of cylindrical nuclear fuel pellets, such as pellets composed
of U0
2 enriched with U-235, disposed end-to-end within a tubular cladding member which is
an elongate thin-walled tube, preferably of a zirconium alloy, having its opposite
ends closed by means of end plugs formed preferably of the same material as the fuel
tube.
[0003] Likewise as well known, the overall efficiency of a nuclear reactor can be increased
and the useful life of its fuel rods prolonged if the fuel rods are internally pressurized.
Thus, during fabrication of a fuel rod, an inert gas, such as helium, is introduced
into the fuel tube under pressure after which the end plugs are welded in the tube
ends so as to seal the tube. During operation of the nuclear reactor, the internal
pressure of the tube increases due to the generation of gases, and it may reach as
high as 68 atmospheres toward the end of the life of the fuel rod.
[0004] During operation of the reactor, the higher pressure of the coolant (approximately
170 atmospheres) on the exterior of the fuel rods normally offsets the internal pressure
of the fuel rods. However, during shut down of the reactor, the external pressure
of the coolant decreases to zero, whereupon the internal pressure of the fuel rod
causes outward expansion of the tube. With a fuel rod having a solid end plug inserted
into the fuel tube end and welded thereto at the juncture of the tube end and the
plug periphery, such outward expansion of the tube results in the location of a stress
riser and the concentration of the point of maximum discontinuity stress at the weld
joint. As long as the tube material and stresses are within the fatigue life limits,
the weld joint will not fail. However, if the weld is imperfect or the material looses
ductility due to hydriding and/or irradiation hardening, the weld joint may fail.
[0005] One solution is to form a cavity within the end plug to provide extra space for fission
gas buildup, and to form the weld joint between the fuel tube end and a thin section
machined into the end plug. An end plug designed in this manner is disclosed in U.S.
patent specification No. 3,679,545. This design embodies advantages from a stress
standpoint as well as a welding standpoint. From the stress standpoint, additional
space provided by the cavity in the end plug reduces the pressure of gas buildup and
thereby relieves expansion of the fuel tube, to some degree, during reactor shut down.
Moreover, and although this design has the same discontinuity stress, the stress riser
due to the end plug-to-fuel tube junction does not occur at the point of maximum discontinuity
stress since the latter is located farther outwardly along the end plug within the
cavity. Therefore, the maximum discontinuity stress is not increased by a stress concentration
factor as was the case in the solid end plug design. From the welding standpoint,
parts of approximately equal thicknesses are easier to weld together than parts which
have a large difference in their respective thicknesses.
[0006] However, some of the advantages of this known design are offset by the substitution
of ceramic pellets for some of the fuel pellets done for the purpose of thermally
insulating the end plugs from the fuel pellets. These ceramic pellets take up valuable
fuel pellet space in the fuel tube. Furthermore, the known design fails to make provision
for preventing fuel pellet chips from falling into the end plug cavity at the lower
end of the vertically positioned fuel rod. Chips in the end plug cavity cause an additional
problem of how to remove the heat generated by them from the end plug.
[0007] It is the principal object of the invention to provide a fuel rod having improved
end plugs which enable the fuel rod to accommodate fission gas buildup without increasing
the length of the fuel rod or removing fuel pellets.
[0008] The invention accordingly resides in a nuclear fuel rod including a tubular member
which contains nuclear fuel and gas under pressure, and which tubular member has a
pair of end plugs affixed to its opposite ends in sealing relationship with respect
thereto, characterized in that at least one of said end plugs has an inner body portion
which is fitted within an adjacent end portion of said tubular member, an outer body
portion which extends outwardly of the tubular member, and an interior cavity which
communicates with the interior of the tubular member and includes an outer region
within said outer body portion and an inner region within said inner body portion,
said outer region being undercut relative to said inner region. Thus, the or each
end plug embodying the invention not only has a cavity which increases the available
space for fission gases and locates the point of maximum discontinuity stress well
away from the location of the weld joint between the end plug and the tubular member,
its cavity in addition is advantageously undercut to maximize fission gas space and
has a smooth contour in the region of maximum discontinuity stresses which distributes
them over a broader area. Furthermore, the end plug has a reduced wall thickness at
the region of the undercut cavity which provides a certain amount of flexibility alleviating
concentration of high stress at the weld joint.
[0009] The end plug which, when in use, is the lower end plug includes an insert which keeps
nuclear fuel out of the cavity but permits gas flow communication between the latter
and the interior of the tubular member.
[0010] Preferred embodiments of the invention will now be described, by way of example only,
with reference to the accompanying drawings, in which:
Fig. 1 is a partially sectioned elevational view, with parts being broken away for
clarity, of a nuclear fuel assembly including fuel rods;
Fig. 2 is an enlarged, fragmentary sectional view of one of the fuel rods embodying
the invention;
Fig. 3 is an enlarged perspective view of an insert as employed with the fuel rod
of Fig. 2; and
Fig. 4 is a fragmentary sectional view of a lower end portion of a fuel rod representing
a further embodiment of the invention.
[0011] In the following description, like reference characters designate like or corresponding
parts throughout the several views of the drawings, and terms such as "forward", "rearward",
"left", "right", "upwardly", "downwardly", and the like are used as words of convenience
not to be construed as limiting terms.
[0012] Referring now to the drawings, and particularly to Fig. 1, the fuel assembly illustrated
therein and generally designated with the numeral 10 comprises a lower end structure
or bottom nozzle 12 for supporting the assembly on the lower core plate (not shown)
in the core region of a reactor (not shown); an organized array of control rod guide
tubes or thimbles 14 projecting upward from the bottom nozzle 12; a plurality of transverse
grids 16 axially spaced along the guide thimbles 14; a plurality of elongate fuel
rods 18 (only one of which is shown for clarity) transversely spaced and axially supported
by the grids 16; an instrumentation tube 20 located at the center of the fuel assembly
10; and, attached to the upper ends of the guide thimbles 14, an upper end structure
or top nozzle 22 with hold-down means. It should be noted that, although the lower
ends of the fuel rods 18 are shown herein as spaced above the bottom nozzle 12, they
could rest and be supported thereon.
[0013] To form the fuel assembly 10, the transverse grids 16 are attached to the guide thimbles
14 at predetermined axially spaced locations; the fuel rods 18 are inserted from below
through the grids 16; the lower nozzle 12 is then suitably affixed, such as by means
of machine screws 24, to the lower ends of the guide thimbles; and then the top nozzle
subassembly 22 is attached to the upper end portions of the guide thimbles 14. To
control the fission process, a plurality of control rods (not shown) are reciprocally
movable in the control rod guide thimbles 14 of the fuel assembly 10.
[0014] Referring now to Fig. 2, the nuclear fuel rod 18 shown therein comprises a tubular
cladding member 28, and a plurality of cylindrical nuclear fuel pellets 26, such as
UO enriched with U-235, disposed therein end-to-end. The cladding 28 is an elongate
thin-walled tube, preferably of a zirconium alloy, having its opposite ends closed
with end pugs 30 and 32 embodying the invention. Preferably, the end plugs 30, 32
are formed of the same material as the fuel tube 28, and they seal the nuclear fuel
as well as an inert gas under pressure within the fuel tube 28. A plenum chamber 34
is provided within the fuel tube 28 between the stack of fuel pellets 26 and one of
the end plugs, such as the upper end plug 30, and a helical spring 36 is disposed
within the plenum chamber 34 to hold the pellets 26 compactly stacked and firmly in
place against the other, i.e. the lower, end plug 32.
[0015] The upper end plug 30 of the improved end plug assembly comprises an outer body portion
38 with its maximum outside diameter substantially the same as the outer diameter
of the fuel tube 28 to which the plug 30 is attached, and an inner body portion 40
with an outer diameter slightly less than the inner diameter of the tube 28. About
the circumferential region of the plug 30 where the outer and inner body portions
38, 40 merge together, there is defined an external annular shoulder 42 against which
the upper end 44 of the fuel tube 28 abuts when the upper end plug 30 is press-fitted
into the upper end portion 46 of the fuel tube. A girth weld 48 rigidly connects and
seals the upper end portion 46 of the tube 28 to the upper end plug 30 at the shoulder
42. An axial bore 50 extends through the end wall of the outer body portion 38. In
a pressurized weld chamber, an inert gas is injected into the fuel tube 28 through
the axial bore 50, whereupon the outer end of the bore is sealed by welding.
[0016] The upper end plug 30 is hollow, having therein a cavity 52 which increases the space
for fission gas expansion from the plenum chamber 34. The outer region 54 of the cavity
52 within the outer body portion 38 is undercut relative to inner region 56 of the
cavity within the inner body portion 40 so as to maximize the fission gas space in
the end plug 30 and to locate the region A of maximum discontinuity stress outwardly
from the stress riser created at the weld 48 upon reduced expansion of the fuel tube
28 during reactor shut down. Also, the internal contour of the upper end plug 30 defining
the cavity 52 contains smooth transitions in the region of maximum discontinuity stresses,
allowing a broader distribution of the stresses as opposed to concentration of them
at one point. Additionally, the reduced wall thickness of the end plug 30 at the outer
region 54 of the undercut cavity 52 provides a certain amount of flexibility in the
end plug which alleviates concentration of high stress at the weld 48.
[0017] The end plug assembly embodying the invention includes further the lower end plug
32 and an insert 58. The lower end plug 32 basically comprises an outer body portion
60 having a generally V-shaped cross-sectional configuration, and an inner body portion
62 of a generally cylindrical shape having a reduced diameter relative to the maximum
diameter of the outer body portion 60. The outer diameter of the inner body portion
62 is slightly less than the inside diameter of the fuel tube 28 such that, when the
lower end plug 32 is press-fitted into the lower end portion 68 of the tube 28, the.
lower end 64 of the tube abuts an external annular shoulder 66 formed about the circumference
of the lower end plug 32 at the region of merger between the outer and inner body
portions 62, 64. A girth weld 70 joins and seals the end plug 32, at the shoulder
66, to the lower end portion 68 of the fuel tube 28.
[0018] Similar to the upper end plug 30, the lower end plug 32 is hollow having a cavity
72 which likewise increases the space for expansion of fission gas generated by the
pellets 26. The outer region 74 of the cavity 72 within the outer body portion 60
is undercut relative to the inner region 76 of the cavity 72 within the inner body
portion 62 so as to maximize the fission gas space in the lower end plug 32 and to
locate the region B of maximum discontinuity stresses outwardly from the stress riser
created at the weld 70 due to expansion of the fuel tube 28 during reactor shut down.
Also, the internal contour of the lower end plug 32 defining the cavity 72 contains
smooth transitions in the region of the maximum discontinuity stresses, thereby allowing
a broader distribution of the stresses as opposed to concentration of them at one
point. Additionally, the reduced wall thickness of the end plug 32 at the outer region
74 of the undercut cavity 72 provides a certain amount of flexibility in the lower
end plug 32 which alleviates concentration of high stress at the weld 70.
[0019] The insert 58 associated with the lower end plug 32 is adapted to prevent fuel chips
from falling from the fuel tube 28 into the cavity 72 of the lower end plug. As will
be explained below, although the insert 58 is substantially closed at one end thereof
to prevent entry of the fuel chips, it does have means enabling fission gas to pass
from the fuel tube into the cavity 72 of the end plug.
[0020] In its preferred form shown in Figs. 2 and 3, the insert 58 has a cylindrical side
wall 78 which is open at its lower or outer end 80, and an end wall 82 which connects
with and closes the upper or inner end of the insert side wall and is disposed adjacent
to the fuel pellets 26 contained within the fuel tube 28. The insert 58 is fit into
the inner region 76 of the cavity 72 within the inner body portion 62 of the lower
end plug 32, its open outer end 80 rotating on an internal annular ledge 84 formed
within the end plug 32 adjacent the circumferential region of merger of the inner
body portion 62 with the outer body portion 60.
[0021] The insert side wall 78 has a slightly larger outside diameter than the inside diameter
of the inner body portion 62 of the lower end plug 32. Also, the side wall 78 has
a slot 86 which splits the side wall in an axial direction. Due to this construction,
when the insert 58 is inserted into the end plug 32, it is subject to a radial spring
force which holds the insert 58 in place as the end plug 32 is being installed in
the fuel tube 28.
[0022] The distance from the ledge 84 to the inner edge 88 of the end plug inner body portion
62 is less than the length of the slot 86 in the insert side wall 78 and the height
of the side wall; thus, as seen in Fig. 2, an inner marginal edge portion 90 of the
insert side wall 78 extends inwardly beyond the inner edge 88 of the inner body portion
62, and a corresponding inner end 92 of the slot 86 is exposed to the interior of
the fuel tube 28. This creates a gap through which fission gas can expand into the
cavity 72 in the lower end plug 32. Since the gas is under pressure, it can also pass
into the cavity 72 between the external surface 94 of the insert side wall 86 and
the internal surface 96 of the end plug inner body portion 62. The inner marginal
edge portion 90 of the insert side wall 78 also maintains the adjacent fuel pellet
26 out of contact with the lower end plug 32 so as to minimize heat transfer thereto.
[0023] Fig. 4 depicts an alternate insert 98 adapted to be pressed into the inner region
76 of the cavity 72 within the inner body portion 62 of the lower end plug 32. The
insert 98 is preferably formed from zirconium oxide material and has a small-diameter
central opening 100 which allows passage of fission gases from the fuel tube 28 into
the cavity 72 while preventing passage of fuel chips.
[0024] Since both inserts 58 and 98 fit within the lower end plug 32, they act to minimize
end plug length which, in turn, maximizes active fuel and plenum length within the
fuel tube 28. Also, use of either insert to space the adjacent pellet out of contact
with the end plug makes it unnecessary to use ceramic pellets to thermally insulate
the end plug from the fuel pellets. Thus, replacement of a fuel pellet is avoided.
The extra fission gas space added by the use of the end plug assembly of the invention
is approximately equivalent to the space occupied by one fuel pellet.
1. A nuclear fuel rod including a tubular member which contains nuclear fuel and gas
under pressure, and which tubular member has a pair of end plugs affixed to its opposite
ends in sealing relationship with respect thereto, characterized in that at least
one of said end plugs (30, 32) has an inner body portion (40 or 62) which is fitted
within an adjacent end portion of said tubular member (28), an outer body portion
(38 or 60) which extends outwardly of the tubular member, and an interior cavity (52
or 72) which communicates with the interior of the tubular member and includes an
outer region (52 or 74) within said outer body portion and an inner region (56 or
76) within said inner body portion, said outer region being undercut relative to said
inner region.
2. A nuclear fuel rod according to claim 1, characterized in that said outer body
portion (38 or 60) has a maximum outside diameter substantially equal to the outside
diameter of said tubular member (28), and said inner body portion (40 or 62) has a
smaller diameter than said outer body portion.
3. A nuclear fuel rod according to claim 1 or 2, wherein the fuel rod is in an upright
position and said at least one end plug is at the lower end of the fuel rod when in
use, characterized in that the inner region (76) of said cavity (72) has fitted therein
an insert (58 or 98) which permits gas flow communication between said tubular member
(28) and the cavity while preventing nuclear fuel in the tubular member from entering
said cavity (72).
4. A nuclear fuel rod according to claim 3, characterized in that said insert (58)
comprises a hollow cylindrical portion (78) fitted into said inner body portion (62)
of the end plug (32), an inner end wall (82) substantially closing the cylindrical
portion toward the interior of the tubular member (28), and opening means (92) permitting
gas flow between the interior of the tubular member (28) and said cavity (72).
5. A nuclear fuel rod according to claim 4, characterized in that said hollow cylindrical
portion (78) has an inner margin (90) which extends inwards of the tubular member
(28) beyond said inner body portion (62) of the end plug (32), and has formed therein
a slot (86) which extends axially from the outer end of the cylindrical portion and
into said inner margin thereof.
6. A nuclear fuel rod according to claim 5, characterized in that said hollow cylindrical
portion (78) having the axial slot (86) therein has an outer diameter which slightly
exceeds the inner diameter of said inner body portion (62) prior to being fitted into
the latter.
7. A nuclear fuel rod according to any of the claims 3 to 6, characterized in that
said inner body portion (62) of the end plug has an internal ledge (84) which axially
supports said insert (58).