[0001] This invention relates to hard butters and their preparation from edible fats.
[0002] The eating quality of chocolate fat and other hard butter compositions containing
cocoa butter is attributable to the presence in this fat of a high proportion of symmetrical
disaturated triglycerides, principally the 2-oleyl glycerides of palmitic and stearic
acid. Various substitute fats which have been proposed as an alternative to this expensive
fat similarly contain more or less substantial quantities of these triglycerides.
Processes for the production of cocoa butter substitutes and extender fats from these
alternative sources generally include fractionation steps in which these more valuable
glycerides are separated from others with less desirable melting attributes, notably
trisaturated glycerides and mono-saturated and tri-unsaturated triglycerides, but
also asymmetric disaturated glycerides, where these can be separated. The separation
is usually effected by fractional crystallisation, particularly from a solvent such
as acetone or hexane, the more highly saturated glycerides being removed in a higher-melting
or stearin fraction, and the more highly unsaturated glycerides being removed in a
lower-melting or olein fraction. These less desirable fractions may constitute as
much as half the original fat and command a much lower premium than the hard butter
fraction.
[0003] Interesterification of fats and glyceride oils by methods using enzyme rearrangement
catalysts have been described in GB 1577933. EP 69599 discloses fractionation of fats
with rearrangement of the glycerides in the fractions obtained, followed if desired
with fractionation of the product, to recovery more highly symmetrical glycerides,
particularly for the preparation of cocoa butter replacement fats.
[0004] The present invention proposes a process for the recovery of hard butters from vegetable
fats, in which a vegetable fat containing substantial amounts of symmetrical disaturated
triglycerides of C
16 and C
18 fatty acids is fractionated to recover the said glycerides by separating at least
a more highly unsaturated, lower-melting olein fraction, which is mixed with a substantially
saturated C
16/C
18 triglyceride fat, preferably by re-combining with an upper-melting , stearin fraction
also separated from the vegetable fat, and the mixture interesterified in the presence
of an enzyme catalyst which is preferably selectively active in the outer positions
only of glycerides, i.e. the 1- and 1,3-positions or alpha-positions of the glycerides,
to yield further quantities of symmetrical disaturated glycerides.
[0005] Since the greatest proportion of the olein fraction consists of glycerides having
an unsaturated fatty acid residue in the 2-position, all these are theoretically capable
of conversion by interesterification under the influence of the enzyme catalyst to
symmetrical disaturated triglycerides, provided only that sufficient glycerides are
present in the blends, for example in the upper-melting or stearin fraction with which
it is preferably combined, containing saturated fatty acid residues in the alpha or
1,3-positions that are vulnerable to the catalyst for effecting interesterification
with the more highly unsaturated glycerides. For example, trisaturated glycerides
may undergo interesterification with tri-unsaturated glycerides to provide 1-saturated
di-unsaturated glycerides and these in turn to 1,3-disaturated glycerides, under the
influence of the selective action of the catalyst. The trisaturated glycerides themselves
convert correspondingly to asymmetric disaturated mono-unsaturated glycerides and
symmetric di-unsaturated glycerides, i.e. 1,3-diunsaturated, 2-saturated glycerides.
[0006] The interesterified glycerides may be separated as in conventional fractionation
processes, to recover a fraction consisting essentially of symmetrical disaturated
glycerides for use as a cocoa butter replacement fat. The more highly unsaturated
glycerides in the interesterification mixture, including in particular the symmetrical
1,3-di-unsaturated glycerides, form a lower-melting oleine fraction. Any unreacted
trisaturated glycerides may be separated if necessary in a top fraction, and recycled
for further interesterification with any asymmetric disaturated glycerides, whether
these appear in a stearin or olein fraction separated from the symmetrical disaturated
fraction.
[0007] The mixture of interesterified glycerides may be separately fractionated or recombined
with feedstock in the fractionation step of the process. In a continuous operation
in which feedstock is introduced to, and a symmetrical disaturated glyceride fraction
removed from, circulation through fractionation and interesterification units, the
feedstock may be introduced into either unit and may thus be fractionated first, in
admixture with the entire interesterification output, or interesterified first together
with the recycled interesterified fractions from which the symmetrical disaturated
glycerides have been removed. In continuous operations in which feedstock is introduced
and a symmetrical disaturated fraction removed, a purge may also be necessary of the
symmetrical di-unsaturated glycerides to avoid build-up of this intractable material
in the recycled composition. Rearrangement catalyst may also be used to convert this
material and return it in a more tractable form, for example, a non-selective catalyst,
a 2-selective catalyst, or one which is selectively active to saturated but not unsaturated
fatty acid residues. A particular advantage of continuous operation is that the interesterification
need be of relatively short duration since the interesterification can be incomplete
for each pass through the unit. Enzyme interesterification is generally substantially
slower than interesterification under the influence of inorganic catalysts which are
also used at much higher temperatures. By continuous recycling however, the residence
time in the interesterification step need be sufficient only to provide a significant
improvement in the yield of the desired glycerides, without necessarily reaching equilibrium.
[0008] The invention also includes recovery of the product from the rearrangement step,
without fractionation or recycle, particularly for the preparation of hardstock fat
which is then blended with liquid glyceride oils, to provide a composition suitable
for margarine or other emulsion food spreads, or the fat may be used in ice-cream.
[0009] Fractionation steps carried out in accordance with the invention may be conventional,
either by solvent fractionation using acceptable solvent, for example acetone, hexane
or nitroparaffins or ambient gases in liquid condition under pressure. Fractionation
may also at least in part be dry without solvents and may then be aided as in the
so-called Lanza process, by the use of surfactant aqueous dispersions for facilitating
separation of liquid and solid phases during fractionation. Preferably the fractionation
is carried out however in acetone at temperatures from 15 to -5°C or in hexane at
temperatures from 10°C to -20
cC.
[0010] Suitable enzymes which are active to catalyse interesterification only in the outer
positions of glyceride molecules include, for example, Aspergillus niger and Mucor
michei. These enzyme catalysts ensure that the unsaturated fatty acid residue in the
2-position of the glycerides of the lower-melting fraction remain unaffected by the
interesterification, to provide a foundation for the production in that reaction of
the desired symmetrical disaturated glycerides for the mid-fraction. Enzyme catalysts
are particularly preferred for this process, but other catalysts may of course be
adopted provided they show selective interesterification at the alpha-positions only.
The interesterification reaction may be carried out in solvents which leave the catalyst
unaffected, particularly hexane for enzyme catalysts, or without solvent and the reaction
may be batchwise or continuous, the catalyst in the latter event being preferably
fixed in a reaction vessel through which the reaction burden comprising the mixed
upper- and lower-melting fractions are passed. Enzyme catalysts may be pre-activated
by contact with water and they may be supported on a suitable carrier, as described
in our patent specification GB 1577933. The water content may be obtained during the
reaction, to predetermined limits in accordance with our patent specification (GB
abandoned but EP 64855) by the use of humectants and/or other means for removing water
from the reaction phase. The water content is preferably not more than 2% of the reaction
mass, including solvent, and particularly not more than 1%. In particular, the water
activity A
w is preferably less than 50% during reaction. Enzyme catalysts may also however be
used in polyhydric alcohol solution to maintain a very low water content. The water
content is preferably low enough to minimise the extent of hydrolysis taking place
with the production of partial glycerides. These may however be removed by selective
adsorption means using silica-type adsorbents.
[0011] Suitable fats include in particular palm oil but also shea, sal, pentadesma oil and
of course cocoa butter itself, may all be processed in accordance with the present
invention. Vegetable oils and fats are used since these contain an abundance of unsaturated
fatty acid residues in the 2-position of their glycerides. Mixtures of oils and fats
may be used and a fat which is deficient in trisaturated glycerides may be mixed with
another containing them, or hydrogenated to provide sufficient for the interesterification
reaction. Preferably the oils are refined before use as feedstock in the present invention
and both neutralised and un-neutralised oils and fats may be used.
EXAMPLE
[0012] Equal parts by weight of olein and stearin fractions obtained by the acetone fractionation
of palm oil to remove a palm mid-fraction, were combined and the blend was dissolved
in 3 times its own weight of hexane and interesterified using as interesterification
catalyst a 1, 3-specific enzyme derived from a Mucor miehei organism supported on
a diatomaceous earth in a packed bed reactor and activated with water before use.
The miscella, containing 500ppm of water, was fed at 3 litres per hour through the
reactor which contained 0.7 kg of catalyst. The residence time in the reactor was
approximately 30 minutes and the reaction was carried out at 55°C.
[0013] Solvent was distilled from the product which was then recrystallised from acetone,
first at 20°C and then at 5°C to recover a mid-fraction, this is compared in the accompanying
Table with a sample of mid-fraction obtained by crystallisation from unmodified palm
oil. The composition is also given in the Table of the feedstock blend and its components.
The olein and stearin fractions derived from the reaction product were found to be
essentially similar in composition to these, the triglyceride analyses being determined
by silver-phase HPLC methods.

1. Process for the recovery of hard butter from vegetable fats wherein a vegetable
fat containing substantial amounts of symmetrical disaturated triglycerides of C16 and C18 fatty acids is fractionally crystallised to recover the said glycerides and at least
a more highly unsaturated oleine fraction, wherein the latter fraction is mixed with
a substantially saturated glyceride composition and the mixture interesterified in
the presence of an interesterification catalyst which is preferably a lipase enzyme
selectively active in the 1-and 3-positions only of glycerides, to yield further quantities
of symmetrical disaturated triglycerides and if desired separating these from the
product by fractional crystallisation.
2. Process according to Claim 1 wherein the substantially saturated glyceride composition
is recovered by fractional crystallisation from the said vegetable fat.
3. Continuous process according to Claim 1 or 2 comprising fractionation and interesterification
stages between which reaction burden is circulated, into which feedstock comprising
the said vegetable fat is introduced and from which a symmetrical disaturated glyceride
fraction is removed.
4. Continuous process according to Claim 2 wherein an additional fraction is removed
comprising 2-saturated mono- and di-unsaturated triglycerides.
5. Process according to any of the preceding claims at least part of which is carried
out in solution in an organic solvent.
6. Process according to Claim 5 the fractionation part only of which is carried out
in organic solvent.
7. Process according to Claim 5 or 6 wherein a solvent is used comprising acetone
or a lower paraffin.
8. Process according to any of the preceding claims wherein the vegetable fat comprises
aceituno, sal, shea, mango, kokum or phulwara fat.
9. Process according to claim 2 wherein the fat comprises palm oi.
10. Hard butters whenever prepared by a process as claimed in any of the preceding
claims.