[0001] This invention relates to cooking containers which can be used in microwave ovens,
and to methods of manufacturing such containers. More particularly, the present invention
relates to a container which provides improved microwave heating distributions when
used in a microwave oven.
[0002] The invention will be particularly described with reference to the microwave cooking
of foodstuffs, but it is to be understood that this invention in its broader aspect
embraces the provision of containers (and methods of using them) for the microwave
heating of bodies of any microwave-heatable material.
[0003] In our copending European patent application No. 0206811, the disclosure of which
is incorporated herein by this reference, there is described a container for containing
a material to be heated in a microwave oven, this container comprising an open-topped
tray for carrying the material and a lid covering the tray to form a closed cavity,
the container being characterized in that at least one surface of the container is
formed with microwave generating means for generating a mode of a higher order than
those of the fundamental modes of the container, the microwave generating means being
so dimensioned and positioned with respect to the material when in the container that
the mode so generated propagates into the material to thereby locally heat the material.
As will be understood, in a container holding a food article being heated in a microwave
oven, multiple reflections of radiation within the container or food article give
rise to microwave field patterns which can be described as modes. it will also be
understood that the word "generating" as used herein embraces both enhancement of
modes already existing in the container and superimposition, on existing modes, of
modes not otherwise existing in the container.
[0004] In a multi-compartment container, such as is used for heating several different foodstuffs
simultaneously, the term "container" as used herein should be interpreted as meaning
an individual compartment of that container. If, as is commonly the case, a single
lid covers all compartments, then "lid" as used above means that portion of the lid
which covers the compartment in question.
[0005] The container may be made primarily from metallic material, such as aluminium, or
primarily from non-metallic material such as one of the various dielectric plastic
or paperboard materials currently being used to fabricate microwave containers, or
a combination of both.
[0006] In a conventional microwave oven, microwave energy, commonly at a frequency of 2.45
GHz, enters the oven cavity and sets up a standing wave pattern in the cavity, this
pattern being at fundamental modes dictated by the size and shape of the walls of
the oven cavity. In an ideal cavity, only fundamental modes exist, but in practice
due to irregularities in the shape of the oven walls, higher order modes are also
generated within the cavity and are superimposed on the fundamental modes. Generally
speaking, these higher order modes are very weak, and in order to promote better distribution
of energy within the container, a "mode-stirrer" can be used to deliberately generate
or enhance the higher order modes.
[0007] If a container, such as a food container, is placed in the microwave oven, and microwave
energy is caused to propagate into the interior of that container, then a similar
situation exists within the container as exists within the oven itself: a standing
wave pattern is set up within the container, this pattern being primarily in the fundamental
modes of the container (as distinct from the fundamental modes of the larger oven
cavity) or, in certain circumstances, in the fundamental modes of the foodstuff within
the container. In addition to these fundamental modes, the container also contains
modes higher than those of the fundamental modes, which higher modes are, for example,
generated by irregularities in the interior shape of the container and/or its contents.
As before, these higher order modes are generally of much lower intensity than the
fundamental modes and contribute little to the heating of the material within the
container.
[0008] The various fundamental and higher order modes set up within the container will normally
have a pattern dictated by the physical geometry of the container. However, when the
shape of the foodstuff container within the container departs significantly from the
cross section of the container, and particularly if the container has microwave-transparent
side-walls, the fundamental modes of interest will be predominantly determined by
the food shape. If the container has metallic side walls, then fundamental modes due
to the container geometry will also exist and it is a matter of degree as to which
will predominate. In practice, in such circumstances, the geometry of the multi-moding
structures may correspond primarily to the container, primarily to the food shape
or to a blend of the two. Of course, in the more normal circumstance that the foodstuff
substantially fills and is therefore approximately the same shape as the horizontal
cross section of its container, then there is no distinction between the two geometries
- container and foodstuff - and it is then appropriate to discuss only the container
geometry. For the sake of clarity, this latter situation will be assumed throughout
the present specification and claims.
[0009] Attention will now be directed to the manner in which the material within the container
is heated by the microwave energy existing within the container. In doing this, it
is convenient to study only horizontal planes within the container. It is well known
that the standing wave pattern within the container consists of a combined electric
and magnetic field. However, the heating effect is obtained only from the electric
field and it is therefore of significance to examine the power distribution of the
electric field as it exists under steady-state conditions within the container. In
the fundamental modes - which, it should be recalled, are those predominantly existing
within the container - the pattern of power distribution in the horizontal plane is
confined to the edge of the container and this translates into a heating effect which
is likewise concentrated around the edge of the container. The material in the central
part of the container receives the least energy and therefore, during heating, its
centre tends to be cool. In conventional containers, this problem of uneven heating
is ameliorated by instructing the user to leave the material unattended for a few
minutes after the normal microwave cooking time in order for normal thermal conduction
within the food to redistribute the heat evenly. Alternatively, the material may
be stirred, if it is of a type which is susceptible to such treatment.
[0010] The shape of these "cold" areas varies according to the shape of the container.
For example, for a rectangular container the shape of the cold area in the horizontal
plane is roughly rectangular with rounded corners; for a container which is circular
in horizontal cross section, the cold area will be likewise circular and positioned
at the centre of the container. For an irregularly shaped container, such as is commonly
found in compartments of a multi-compartment container, the "cold" area will roughly
correspond to the outside contour of the container shape and will be disposed centrally
in the container.
[0011] In considering the heating effect of higher modes which may or may not exist within
the container, it is necessary to notionally subdivide the container into cells, the
number and arrangement of these cells depending upon the particular higher order mode
under consideration. Each of these cells behaves, from the point of view of microwave
power distribution, as if it were itself a container and therefore exhibits a power
distribution which is high around the edges of the cell, but low in the centre. Because
of the physically small size of these cells, heat exchange between adjacent cells
during cooking is improved and more even heating of the material results. However,
in the normal container, i.e. unmodified by the structures described in the aforementioned
copending application, these higher order modes are either not present at all or,
if they are present, are not of sufficient strength to effectively heat the central
regions of the food. Thus the primary heating effect is due to the fundamental modes
of the container - i.e. a central cold area results.
[0012] Recognising these problems, what the structures described in the aforementioned copending
application seek to do, in essence, is to heat this cold area by introducing heating
energy into the cold area. This can be achieved in two ways:-
(1) by redistributing the microwave field pattern within the container by enhancing
higher order modes which naturally exist anyway within the container due to the boundary
conditions set by the physical geometry of the container, but not at an energy level
sufficient to have a substantial heating effect or, where such naturally higher order
modes do not exist at all (due to the geometry of the container), to generate such
natural modes.
(2) to superimpose or "force" onto the normal field pattern - which, as has been said,
is primarily in the fundamental modes - a further higher order field pattern whose
characteristics owe nothing to the geometry of the container and whose energy is directed
towards the geometric centre of the container in the horizontal plane which is the
area where the heating needs to be enhanced.
[0013] In both the above cases, the net result is the same: the container can be notionally
considered as having been split into several smaller areas each of which has a heating
pattern similar to that of the fundamental modes, as described above. However, because
the areas are now physically smaller, normal thermal convection currents within the
food have sufficient time, during the relatively short microwave cooking period,
to evenly redistribute the heat and thus avoid cold areas. In practice, under certain
conditions higher order mode heating may take place due to both of the above mechanisms
simultaneously.
[0014] The process for generating the microwave field, as described in the aformentioned
copending application, may take one of two forms:-
(1) where said at least one surface of the container takes the form of a sheet of
microwave-transparent material, a plate of electrically conductive material which
is attached to or forms part of the sheet. Such a plate could be made for example
of aluminium foil which is adhered to the sheet, or could be formed as a layer of
metallisation applied to the sheet.
(2) where said at least one surface of the container takes the form of a sheet of
electrically conductive material, such as aluminium foil, an aperture in the sheet
through which microwave energy incident on the sheet can pass. Preferably, the aperture
is covered by microwave-transparent material. In some instances, however, the aperture
may simply be a void (i.e. open), for example to permit venting of steam from within
the container.
[0015] It will be appreciated that the two alternatives listed above - i.e. the plate and
the aperture - are analogues of one another. For ease of understanding, in the first
alternative, the plate can be considered as a two-dimensional antenna, the characteristics
of which follow from well-known antenna theory. Thus, the plate can be considered
as receiving microwave energy from the oven cavity, whereupon a microwave field pattern
is set up in the plate, the characteristics of which pattern are dictated by the size
and shape of the plate. The plate then retransmits this energy into the interior of
the container as a microwave field pattern. Because the dimensions of the plate are
necessarily smaller than those of the container surface with which it is associated,
the order of the mode so transmitted into the interior will be higher than the container
fundamental modes.
[0016] In the second alternative, the aperture can be considered as a slot antenna, the
characteristics of which again follow from theory. The slot antenna so formed effectively
acts as a window for microwave energy from the oven cavity. The edges of the window
define a particular set of boundary conditions which dictate the mcirowave field pattern
which is formed at the aperture and transmitted into the interior of the container.
Once again, because the dimensions of the aperture are smaller than those of the container
surface with which it is associated, the shape and (particularly) the dimensions of
the aperture are such as to generate a mode which is of a higher order than the container
fundamental modes.
[0017] Several separate higher order mode generating means - be they plates of apertures
- may be provided on each container to improve the heat distribution. The higher order
mode generating means may all be provided on one surface of the container, or they
may be distributed about the container on different surfaces. The exact configuration
will depend upon the shape and normal (i.e. unmodified by the plates and/or apertures)
heating characteristics, the object always being to get microwave energy into the
cold areas, thus electrically subdividing the container down into physically smaller
units which can more readily exchange heat by thermal conduction. The considerations
which are to be given to the positioning of the higher order mode generating means
will depend upon which of the two mechanisms of operation it is desired to use: if
it is desired to enhance or generate a particular higher order mode which is natural
to the container, then the above-mentioned cell pattern appropriate to that mode should
be used to position the plates or apertures forming the higher order mode generating
means. In order to enhance or generate a natural mode, a plate/aperture of approximately
the same size as the cell will need to be placed over at least some of the cells -
the larger the number of cells which have a plate or aperture associated with them,
the better the particular mode chosen will be enhanced. In practice, a sufficient
space must be left between individual plates/apertures in order to prevent field interaction
between them - it is important that each plate/aperture is sufficiently far from its
neighbour to be able to act independently. If the spacing is too close, the incident
microwave field will simply see the plates/apertures as being continuous and, in these
circumstances, the fundamental mode will predominate, which will give, once again,
poor heat distribution. A typical minimum spacing between plates would be in the range
of 6 to 12 mm, depending upon the particular container geometry and size. A typical
minimum spacing between apertures (i.e. where the apertures are separated by regions
of foil or other metallised layer) is in the range of 6 to 12 mm, both to protect
the electrical integrity of the structure from mechanical damage such as scratches
and to avoid ohmic overheating which is likely to result from high induced currents
in narrower metal strips; a typical minimum width of metal border regions defining
the outer peripheries of apertures would be in the same range, for the same reasons.
[0018] If, on the other hand, it is desired to use the mechanism of "forcing" an unnatural
higher order mode into the container, then the plate/aperture forming the higher mode
generating means needs to be placed over the cold area or areas within the container.
In such circumstances, the plate/aperture, in effect, acts as a local heating means
and does not (usually) significantly affect the natural modes of the container. Thus
the "forced" mechanism utilises the heating effect of the container fundamental superimposed
onto its own heating effect. At certain cricital sizes and positioning of the plates,
both mechanisms - forced and natural - may come into play.
[0019] For convenience of explanation, the present discussion considers matters only in
the horizontal plane and for the same reason, the only surfaces which are formed with
the higher order generating means in the embodiments which follow are horizontal surfaces
- i.e. the bottom of the container or the lid of the container. However, there is
no reason why the teachings of the aforementioned copending application (and of the
present invention) should not be applied to other than horizontal surfaces since the
ambient microwave field in which the container is situated is substantially homogeneous.
[0020] Because the characteristics of the plate/aperture alternatives are analogous (indeed
a particular aperture will transmit an identical mode to that transmitted by a plate
of identical size and shape), it is possible to use them interchangeably - in other
words, whether a plate or aperture of particular dimensions is used, can be dictated
by considerations other than that of generating a particular microwave field pattern.
[0021] Clearly, the heating effect of the higher order mode generating means will be greatest
in the food immediately adjacent to it and will decrease in the vertical direction.
Thus, it may be an advantage to provide higher mode generating means both in the lid
and in the bottom of the container. Since the cold areas will be in the same position
in the horizontal plane whether the lid or the bottom of the container is being considered,
it is clearly convenient to make the higher mode generating means in the lid in registry
with those in the bottom of the container. By this means, better heat distribution
in the vertical direction can be achieved. It matters not which particular type of
higher mode generating means is used as between the lid and the bottom - in one embodiment,
for example, a plate or plates are formed on the lid, while in-registry aperture or
apertures are formed in the container bottom. In another embodiment, apertures are
provided in both lid and bottom surfaces.
[0022] The aforementioned copending application also contemplates a method of manufacturing
a container as described above for containing a material to be heated in a microwave
oven, comprising forming, on at least one surface of the container, microwave generating
means for generating a mode of a higher order than that of the fundamental modes of
the container, such generating means being so dimensioned and positioned with respect
to the material when in the container that the mode so generated propagates into the
material to thereby locally heat the material. Each higher order mode generating means
may be so configured and positioned on its surface as to generate or amplify higher
order modes which are natural to the container and dictated by its boundary conditions,
and/or to generate a mode which is of higher order than that of the fundamental of
the container but is not otherwise dictated by the boundary conditions of the container
and would not normally exist therein.
[0023] In accordance with a first aspect of the present invention there is provided a container
for holding a body of material to be heated in a microwave oven, said container including
a dielectric wall structure comprising at least a first and a second contiguous dielectric
wall portions of respectively different electrical thickness for co-operatively modifying
the microwave electric field pattern that would obtain in the body during such heating
if the wall structure were of uniform dielectric thickness or were absent in such
a way as to generate in the container a microwave electric field pattern having at
least one higher order mode than a fundamental mode of the container or its contents.
[0024] In an embodiment, the container comprises an open-topped tray for carrying the material
and a lid covering the tray to form a closed cavity, the container being characterized
in that at least one surface of the container is formed with said dielectric wall
structure which is so dimensioned and positioned with respect to the material when
in the container that the higher order mode so generated propagates into the material
thereby to locally heat the material.
[0025] Whereas the structures specifically described in the aforementioned copending application
utilise surface-defining combinations of electrically conductive (e.g. metal plate
or sheet) regions and dielectric (microwave-transparent) regions to constitute the
higher order mode generating means, the present invention embraces the discovery that
useful field-modifying or mode-generating effects can be achieved with a dielectric
(i.e. electrically nonconducting) wall structure by providing appropriately arranged
and configured adjacent or contiguous dielectric portions thereof that differ from
each other in electrical thickness. For example, referring to those embodiments of
structure described in the aforementioned copending application wherein the surface
comprises a sheet of microwave-transparent dielectric material having a conductive
metal plate disposed thereon, comparable field-modifying effects are attainable (in
accordance with the present invention) by substituting for the metal plate a dielectric
portion, in or on the sheet, having a greater electrical thickness than the surrounding
portion of the sheet. Again, where in the copending application the higher order mode
generating means is a metal sheet defining one or more apertures, in accordance with
the present invention comparable effects are attainable by substituting for the metal
sheet an "aperture"-defining dielectric wall portion of relatively high electrical
thickness, with the "aperture(s)" constituted of dielectric wall portions of lower
electrical thickness.
[0026] In each case, the dielectric wall structure of the invention serves (generally like
the metal plate-dielectric sheet or metal aperture-defining sheet structures of the
aforementioned copending application) to establish or generate, within the container,
one or more modes of a higher order than a fundamental mode of the container or its
contents, so as to achieve a beneficially modified heating distribution in the body
of material being heated, as desired (for example) to provide enhanced uniformity
of heating throughout the body, or to effect localised intensification of heating
in or on selected postions of the body, as for browning or crispening. Thus, the present
invention affords a new way of overcoming the heat-distribution problems and limitations
of conventional microwave heating, wherein significant heating is produced predominantly
or exclusively by microwave energy in the fundamental mode(s) of the container holding
the body, or the body itself. Indeed, in at least some instances, the mode-generating,
heat-distribution-modifying effects of the present inventions may be superior to those
afforded by the structures of the aforementioned copending application.
[0027] The "electrical thickness" of a dielectric wall structure is a function of the actual
spatial thickness of the wall (measured, in conventional units of length, between
opposed surfaces thereof) and the dielectric constant of the wall material. Stated
with reference to microwave energy of a given frequency, having a free-space wavelength
W
o, and a wavelength W
m in the dielectric wall material, for a wall having an actual spatial thickness d
equal to n
o times the wavelength W
o (d being, of course, also equal to n
m times the wavelength w
m, i.e. d = n
oW
o = n
mW
m) the electrical thickness D may be defined as that spatial distance equal to the
number n
m of free space wavelengths W
o, which number n
m = d/W
m. Consequently,
D = n
mW
o = d (W
o/W
m) = d (k
m/k
o)
½ ,
since W
o/W
m is equal to the square root of the ratio of the dielectric constant k
m of the wall material to the free space dielectric constant k
o. It will therefore be seen that the electrical thickness D of a dielectric wall portion
increases with increasing spatial thickness d and/or increasing dielectric constant
k
m of the wall portion.
[0028] Preferably, in the structures of the invention, the dielectric wall portion(s) of
greater electrical thickness are constituted of material having a higher dielectric
constant than the material of the dielectric wall portion(s) of lesser electrical
thickness. The portion(s) of greater electrical thicness may also have a greater spatial
thickness than the portion(s) of lesser electrical thickness, although this is by
no means necessary in all cases. The term "dielectric" herein is to be understood
broadly as embracing conventional dielectric (nonconductive) materials and also so-called
artificial dielectrics, such as dispersions of metallic particles in a nonconductive
matrix, which are characterised by a dielectric constant significantly higher than
that of the matrix material alone.
[0029] As a further particular feature of the invention, in important embodiments thereof,
one or more of the aforementioned dielectric wall portions may be so constituted as
to undergo a change in dielectric constant when subjected to irradiation by microwave
energy. Typically or preferably, in these embodiments the portion (or one or more
of plural portions) of greater electrical thickness is made initially "lossy" (i.e.
absorptive of, and thus directly heatable by, microwave energy), and is of such a
nature that it exhibits a decrease in dielectric constant when heated, the decrease
being either progressive or occurring upon attainment of some particular elevated
temperature. Consequently, upon exposure to microwave energy in a microwave oven,
the wall portion thus constituted heats up, and its dielectric constant drops either
gradually or suddenly as it attains a predetermined elevated temperature, with the
result that its electrical thickness (and the difference in electrical thickness between
contiguous wall portions) decreases, reducing or terminating the effect of the dielectric
wall structure on microwave electrical field patterns within the container and thereby
altering the heat distribution within the body being heated.
[0030] In this way, desired changes in heat distribution during the course of heating or
cooking may be achieved. For example, the initially modified heating distribution
produced by the wall structure of the invention may be such as to cause locally intensified
heating to effect browning or crispening, and this local intensification may then
be shut off (by reduction in dielectric constant of the wall portion of greater electrical
thickness) while overall heating continues. It will be appreciated that where the
wall portion in question is lossy, its heating by microwave energy may be such that
it serves as a supplemental source of heat (through radiation and/or conduction) for
at least localised regions of the body being heated.
[0031] Illustratively, in such embodiments of the invention a dielectric wall portion of
initially greater electrical thickness may be constituted of a porous or other material
(e.g. a silica gel) having an initially high moisture (water) content, which enhances
its dielectric constant; as heating proceeds, the water volatilises, progressively
reducing the dielectric constant. Some edible materials, e.g. pie crusts or layers
of heterogeneous composition and/or varying thickness, may themselves be capable of
functioning as dielectric wall structures in such a manner if appropriately configured.
One specific embodiment of the invention, especially advantageous for use as frozen
food packaging, incorporates a dielectric wall portion of hygroscopic material which
takes up moisture when exposed to air at ambient temperatures so as to constitute
a or the wall portion of greater electrical thickness, though it may be substantially
dry while frozen.
[0032] Again, the material of the wall portion of greater electrical thickness may be a
ferroelectric substance having a high ambient-temperature dielectric constant but
underoging a marked drop in dielectric constant when its Curie temperature is reached.
For reasons of toxicity, some high-performance ferroelectric materials (e.g. titanates
based on heavy metals) would not be favoured for such use in cooking, though they
are suitable for the heating of non-food materials, but other, lower-performance ferroelectrics
(e.g. Rochelle salts) can be employed in cooking applications.
[0033] In currently preferred embodiments, the dielectric wall structure of the invention,
incorporating contiguous wall portions of respectively greater and lesser electrical
thickness, is the container lid, and may be associated with a container tray of any
convenient or desired type, e.g. fabricated of metallic and/or dielectric material.
In such case, the container bottom (for example) may have a higher-mode-generating
metal plate or aperture structure as described in the aforementioned copending application,
and may be designed to co-operate with the dielectric wall portions provided in the
lid, in a manner analogous to the co-operation between a plate or aperture-type bottom
and a plate or aperture-type lid described in that application. However, the dielectric
wall structure of the invention may alternatively be provided as or in the container
bottom, or as or in another wall of the container.
[0034] The contiguous portions of respectively greater and lesser electrical thickness,
in the dielectric wall structure of the invention, may be sharply demarcated; i.e.
there may be an abrupt discontinuity or stepwise variation in dielectric properties
between them. For simplicity and clarity of description, the specific embodiments
of the invention to be described will be shown as having such stepwise variation.
On the other hand, in a broader sense it is also contemplated that the variation between
the contiguous portions may be more or less smooth, gradual, and continuous, with
respect to spatial thickness and/or dielectric constant.
[0035] In an embodiment, the material of said first dielectric wall portion is the same
as the material of said second dielectric wall portion, and is integral therewith,
and that wall portion having the greater electrical thickness has a greater spatial
thickness than the said portion of lesser electrical thickness.
[0036] In a further embodiment, that dielectric wall portion having a greater electrical
thickness comprises a multilayer structure having a total spatial thickness greater
than said portion of lesser electrical thickness. Preferably, said dielectric wall
structure comprises a wall having attached to one surface thereof a block of dielectric
material, the arrangement being such that that part of the wall covered by the block
constitutes said dielectric wall portion having a greater electrical thickness, while
that part of the wall not covered by the block constitutes said dielectric wall portion
having a lesser electrical thickness.
[0037] According to a second aspect of the invention there is provided a method of heating
a body of microwave-heatable material, said method comprising disposing said body
in a container including a dielectric wall structure comprising at least first and
second dielectric wall portions of respectively greater and lesser electrical thickness
co-operatively configured and arranged to modify the microwave electric field pattern
within the body in such a way as to generate in the container a microwave electric
field pattern having at least one higher order mode than a fundamental mode of the
container or its contents; placing the container, with the body disposed therein,
in a microwave oven; and irradiating the container and body with microwave energy
in the oven.
[0038] In order that the invention may be better understood, several embodiments thereof
will now be described by way of example only and with reference to the accompanying
drawings in which:-
Figures 1-10B are identical to the correspondingly numbered figures of the aforementioned
copending application, although as explained below, the showings of Figures 1-4 and
6-10B will also serve to illustrate embodiments of the present invention, depending
on the materials used.
Figures 1-4 are diagrammatic plan views showing four different patterns of the lid
or bottom surfaces of a microwave container constructed in accordance with the aforementioned
application or the present invention;
Figure 5 is a graph showing, in a container according to the aforementioned application
in which the higher mode generating means comprises a metal plate in the lid surface,
the variation of heating energy entering the container as the area of the plate with
respect to that of the whole lid is varied;
Figure 6 is an exploded perspective view of a container constructed in accordance
with the aforementioned application or the present invention;
Figure 7 is a view similar to that of Figure 6, showing a multi-compartment container;
Figures 8 and 9 are further views similar to Figure 6, showing further alternative
embodiments;
Figures 10A and 10B are, respectively, diagrammatic plan views of the container bottom
surface and top surface of a still further embodiment of the container of the aforementioned
application or the present invention;
Figure 11 is an enlarged fragmentary sectional elevational view of a microwave heating
container embodying the present invention in a particular form, taken as along the
line XI-XI of Figure 6;
Figure 12 is a view, similar to Figure 11, of another embodiment of the invention;
and
Figures 13 to 16 illustrate alternative embodiments, each of these figures showing
a fragment of a wall of the container illustrating a modified version of the dielectric
wall structure of the invention.
Detailed Description
I. Disclosure of the aforementioned copending application
[0039] For the sake of assured full understanding of the present invention, the detailed
description set forth in the aforementioned copending application will first be substantially
repeated, with reference to accompanying Figures 1-10B.
[0040] Referring to Figure 1, the circular surface shown may comprise the bottom surface
or the lid surface of circular cylindrical container 8. The surface, shown under reference
10, is made principally from microwave-transparent material and is substantially planar
(although this is not essential). The remainder of the container 8, which is not shown,
may be of metal, such as aluminium foil, or one of the microwave-transparent plastic,
cellulosic and composite materials currently available. Attached to the surface are
three similar segmental plates 12 of metal foil.
[0041] Each of the plates 12 acts as a source of a higher order mode wave pattern which
propagates into the container and acts to generate a higher order mode harmonically
related to the fundamental of the container and defined, in essence, by the boundary
conditions of the cylindrical wall of the container. The area 14 bounded by the three
plates 12 is of microwave-transparent material and is thus a route by which microwave
energy enters the container.
[0042] Figure 2 is similar to Figure 1, except that the plates now shown under reference
16, are substantially semicircular in plan view and are separated by a gap 18. This
embodiment operates in the same way as the Figure 1 embodiment in that it generates
a higher order mode harmonically related to the fundamental of the container and defined
by the boundary conditions of the container. The difference between Figures 1 and
2 is simply in the order of the particular higher order mode generated: in Figure
1 a third order mode is being generated; in Figure 2 a second order mode.
[0043] Figures 3 and 4 show a container bottom or lid surface 10 for a rectangular container
8. The two embodiments are the inverse of one another, but actually operate in an
analogous manner. In Figure 3, the surface 10 is made of conducting material such
as metal in which are formed two rectangular apertures 22 covered with microwave-transparent
material. As explained above, each aperture 22 acts as a window, allowing through
it microwave energy from the oven cavity. The shape and dimensions of the edge of
the aperture create boundary conditions which establish a microwave field pattern
which propagates into the container. The wave thus transmitted into the container
is of a higher order than that of the container fundamental and acts to accentuate
or amplify a higher (second) order mode - the E₁₂ or E₂₁ mode - which is almost certainly
already present within the container but at a low power level. Once again, this mode
is harmonically related to that of the container fundamental and is therefore essentially
determined by the geometry of the container. The amplification of the second order
mode effectively electrically splits the rectangular dish into two identical cells
divided roughly by the dividing line 24 between the two apertures 22. Each of these
cells can, as explained above, be considered as a notionally separate container operating
in the fundamental mode. Thus, although a relatively cool area is found at the centre
of each of the notionally separate containers, because the containers are physically
only half the size of the actual container, the problem of redistributing heat by
thermal conduction from the hotter areas into the cooler areas, is greatly reduced.
[0044] In a structure as shown in Figure 3, used as a lid, if modes entering are cut off
through selection of appropriate aperture sizes, the spacing between lid and contained
foodstuff can be selected advantageously to control the amount of power entering through
the apertures.
[0045] It will be seen that generating still higher modes and thereby electrically subdividing
the container into a larger number of smaller and smaller cells will result in this
problem of conductive exchange of heat being still further reduced, but this process
cannot be carried out to an unlimited extent. The reason for this is that the higher
the mode order, the more quickly it attenuates after having left the aperture 22 from
which it was generated. The same applied to retransmission from metal plates. Thus
there comes a stage, particularly when an air-gap exists between the food and the
surface 10, where the microwave energy may not even reach the surface of the food,
or may only just reach it. Thus it is important that the order of mode generated
is sufficiently low not to be attenuated too rapidly within the food being heated;
otherwise, the heating effect of the higher order mode will be negligible and the
heating characteristics will be those of the container fundamental.
[0046] The lower the order of the mode - i.e. the nearer the fundamental - the less pronounced
is the attenuation in the air gap (if any) between the surface 10 and the food and
the less abrupt the absorption within the food. An abrupt absorption profile within
the food will give a concentration of energy, and hence heating, near the food surface
which in turn results in browning or crispening of the food.
[0047] Thus, unless there is a specific requirement for browning or crispening, the preferred
higher order mode is that which is as low as possible consistent with giving an acceptable
distribution of heating within the food. The exact value of the order which is decided
on will also depend upon the physical size of the container in the horizontal plane
- clearly large containers will have to be operated in higher modes in order to keep
down the physical size of each heating cell. However it has been found that, under
most circumstances, container modes between the first order and the fifth order (the
fundamental being regarded as the zeroth order) will be used.
[0048] A further constraint on the dimensions of the plate or aperture which the higher
order mode generating means is connected with the single dimensional resonance of
the plate or aperture at the operating frequency of the oven (usually 2.45 GHz). Drawing
on the above-mentioned analogy with two-dimensional antennae, it will be apparent
that at a certain size the plate/aperture will resonate. As it happens, the expected
size for resonance is affected by the fact that the antenna - i.e. the plate or aperture
- does not exist in free space, but rather is affected by the nearby presence of lossy
material - in particular the material (usually food) being heated. The presence of
the food distorts the radiation pattern of the antenna and causes resonance to occur
at dimensions different from those which would be predicted by free space calculations.
It is necessary to keep the linear dimensions (length and width) away from those values
causing resonance and sub-multiples of those values. The reason for this is that,
at resonance, the antenna generates high field potentials which are capable of causing
electrical breakdown and overheating in adjacent structures. Also, the antenna radiates
strongly in the direction of the food, and can cause burning before the remainder
of the food is properly cooked.
[0049] The resonance of concern in this regard is "one-dimensional" resonance, as exemplified
by a plate, the longest dimension of which is close to one-half of the free-space
wavelength of the microwave energy (or close to an integral multiple of that half
wavelength value), and the shortest dimension of which is much smaller, e.g. (for
a microwave frequency of 2.45 GHz) a plate about 6 cm. long and 1 cm. wide. Two-dimensional
reasonance creates no problem, because the field intensity is much more distributed.
Also, even one-dimensional resonance is of less concern in the case of an aperture
because the effects of such resonance are much less severe than in the case of a plate,
but a very narrow aperture of half-wavelength long dimension should be avoided because
of the likelihood of arcing near the aperture midpoint, where the field is most intense.
[0050] Turning now particularly to Figure 4, the higher order mode generating means is now
formed of a pair of plates 26. These act in the same way as the windows 22 of the
Figure 3 embodiment and will amplify the E₁₂ or E₂₁ mode already in the container.
[0051] The following are actual examples of test results carried out on circular and rectangular
metal foil containers. In each instance, the plates comprised metal foils attached
to thermoformed 7 mil polycarbonate lids. The test oven was a 700 watt Sanyo (trademark)
microwave oven set at maximum power. A thermal imager was an ICSD model No. 320 thermal
imaging system and video interface manufactured by ICSD (trademark) Corporation. The
load to be heated was water saturated into a cellular foam material.
[0052] Using a 190 gram water load, without the cellular material, an unmodified 12.7 cm
diameter foil container was tested. After 60 seconds an average temperature rise of
13°C was observed. A 6 cm diameter foil disk was then centrally located on the lid
and the test repeated. The temperature rise was determined to be 15.5°C. A 1.5 cm
aperture was made in the 6 cm foil disk, approximating the configuration shown in
Figure 1, and a 17.5°C temperature rise was observed.
[0053] Using the cellular foam material containing a 175.5 gram water load, the test container
was heated for 40 seconds and its thermal images recorded. Heating was concentrated
around the edge of the load with a temperature differential of about 10° between the
edge and the centre of the container. With a 6 cm foil disk on the cover as described
above, the thermal images indicated heating both at the centre and edge of the container,
showing a better thermal distribution. With the 1.5 cm diameter aperture, a slightly
more even thermal image was obtained for a 40 second test.
[0054] Tests using actual foodstuff showed that the disk and disk-aperture configuration
browned the upper surface of the foodstuff.
[0055] A 17 × 12.7 cm rectangular foil container was then tested. A 390 gram water load
was raised 10.5°C in 60 seconds. Two transversely positioned foil rectangles were
mounted on a cover, approximating Figure 4. The following table shows the results:-

[0056] Thermal imaging results for the smaller structures showed regions of most intense
heating which appear to correspond in shape to the metal plates. The use of the dual
rectangular shape of Figure 4 clearly improves the uniformity of heating of the foodstuff.
Once again, using an actual foodstuff the top surface of the foodstuff was browned.
[0057] Reference will now be made to Figures 5 and 6 which relate to an embodiment in which
the container comprises a generally rectangular metal foil tray 40 having a lid 42
of microwave-transparent material located thereon. A skirt 44 elevates the top surface
46 of the lid above the top of the tray 40 and therefore above the top surface of
the foodstuff contained within the container. A plate 48 of conducting material is
centrally located on the top surface 46 of the lid 42. The plate 48 has a shape approximately
corresponding to the shape of the top surface 46 of the lid, although strict conformity
of shape is not essential.
[0058] Using the Figure 6 arrangement, the size of the plate 48 was varied in relation to
the size of the surface 46 and the results plotted graphically (Figure 5). In Figure
5, the Y-axis represents the amount of microwave energy entering the container from
the oven cavity, with an unmodified lid (i.e. no plate 48 present) shown as a datum.
The X-axis represents the ratio of the area of surface 46 to that of plate 48. The
size of plate 48 was reduced in steps by increasing the width of the microwave-transparent
border area by equal amounts. When the size ratio is 100%, the energy entering the
container is substantially zero because energy can only enter via the skirt 44 and
is greatly limited. As the size of area 48 is reduced, a high peak is produced at
a particular size, which is the size at which the heating effect of the fundamental
modes of the container superimposes most favourably on that of the plate 48. Note
that the heating effect of this is still very akin to that of the container above,
only stronger, because of the superposition of the fundamental mode of the plate -
there is still a significant cool area in the centre.
[0059] As the size of plate 48 is reduced further, the effect of the higher order mode generated
by the plate becomes more distinct from that of the container fundamental and thus
more significant. The most favourable area is reckoned to be a ratio of between 40%
and 20%. Below 20% the order of the mode generated by the plate becomes high and the
wave transmitted from the plate is, as explained above, attenuated so quickly in the
vertical direction as to have little effect on the overall heatig characteristic,
which thus returns to being that of the fundamental mode within the container.
[0060] In fact, at most sizes, the plate 48 of the Figure 6 embodiment operates by a different
mechanism to that of each of the areas, be they plates or apertures, in the embodiments
of Figures 1 to 4. Instead of generating or amplifying a higher order mode which the
container would naturally possess due to the boundary conditions set by its physical
characteristics, as in the embodiments of Figures 1 to 4, the plate 48 of Figure
6 "forces" into the container a mode in which the container, due to its physical characteristics,
would not normally operate. The mode in this case is dictated by the size and shape
of the plate 48 which in essence sets up its own fundamental mode within the container.
[0061] Of course, a fundamental mode of the plate 48 is necessarily of a higher order than
the fundamental modes of the container itself, because the plate 48 is physically
smaller than the container. This fundamental mode (of the plate 48) propagates into
the interior of the container and has a heating effect on the adjacent food. Note
that the central location of the plate 48 causes this heating effect to be applied
to that part of the container which, when operating simply in the fundamental modes
of the container, would be a cool area. Thus, in this case, the object is not, as
in Figures 1 to 4, to accentuate the higher modes at the expense of the fundamental
of the container, but rather to give a uniform heating by utilising the aforementioned
fundamental mode of the plate 48 in conjunction with the fundamental modes of the
container. No attempt is made to generate or amplify naturally higher order modes
of the container. However, it is likely that in some circumstances both mechanisms
will operate together to provide an even distribution of microwave power within the
container.
[0062] At one particular size of plate 48, the mechanism which utilises amplification of
naturally higher order modes of the container becomes predominant. If we notionally
divide the rectangular top surface 46 into a 3 × 3 array of equal size and shape (as
far as is possible) rectangles, then a plate 48 positioned over the central one of
these, having an area of approximately one ninth of the area of surface 46 will have
a size and shape such that it will generate a third order mode (E₃₃) with respect
to the fundamental of the container. This is a mode which may well be naturally present
within the container, but at a very low power level. The power distribution pattern
of the mode in the horizontal plane comprises a series of nine roughly rectangular
areas corresponding to each of the nine areas notionally mapped out above. The presence
of a single plate 48 of a size and shape corresponding to the central one of these
areas will encourage the presence of this natural higher order mode within the container
and will indeed give a very even distribution of heating. A further (and better) method
of generating this same mode is described below.
[0063] Figure 7 shows a multi-compartment container 40 in which each compartment is treated
separately. The container has a series of metallic walls (not shown) which form compartments
directly under regions 50, 52, 54 and 56 in a lid 58. The lid is made of a microwave
dielectric material and is basically transparent to microwave energy. Each compartment
has a corresponding top surface area in lid 58 and each top surface area has an approximately
conformal plate of metallic foil. Such conformal plates are shown in Figure 7 at 60,
62, 64 and 66. The area of each conformal plate is dimensioned so as to provide the
proper cooking energy and distribution to the foodstuff located in the compartment
in question. For example, conformal plate 60 is large with respect to this compartment
and shields the foodstuff located in region 50. The foodstuff in that compartment
does not need much heating, and distribution is not a consideration. On the other
hand, the foodstuff in region 56 requires an even distribution of heating and so conformal
plate 66 is appropriately dimensioned.
[0064] Referring to Figure 8, there is shown a can-type cylindrical container 80 which
has metallic side walls 82 and a metallic lid 84 and a metallic bottom 86. The container
can be made from any metallic material such as aluminium or steel.
[0065] Circular aperture 88, which is coaxial with the circular bottom 86, is centrally
located in bottom 86. The aperture 88 is covered with a microwave-transparent material
90. A similar aperture 92 and microwave-transparent covering 94 is located on the
lid 84. The apertures 88 and 92 will be seen to act as windows to a particular higher
mode of microwave energy, the order of this particular mode being dictated by the
diameter of the apertures. Because the apertures are located top and bottom, the vertical
heat distribution is improved, as explained above. The vertical height "h" of the
container can be large and still result in good heating of the foodstuff. Here again,
the diameter of each of the apertures in relation to that of the adjacent top or bottom
surface dictates the mechanism of operation - i.e. whether natural container modes
are generated or enhanced, or whether a "forced" mode, dictated solely by the characteristics
of the aperture 88 or 92, is force into the container to heat, in conjunction with
the heating effect of the container fundamental.
[0066] Figure 9 is a further embodiment in which higher mode generating sources are located
both in the lid and in the bottom of the container for better vertical heat distribution.
The container consists of a metal foil tray 100 having a bottom 102 and sides 104.
Bottom 102 includes two rectangular apertures 106 and 108. the container also includes
a microwave-transparent lid 110 which has two metallic plates 112 and 114 located
thereon. The plates 112 and 114 are located in registry with apertures 108 and 106,
respectively. This embodiment operates essentially in the same manner as Figures 3
and 4 above and further explanation is thus omitted.
[0067] Figure 10A and 10B are plan views of, respectively, the container bottom 120 and
lid 140 of a further embodiment. From the microwave point of view, it will be understood
that the lid and bottom could in fact be interchanged as between Figures 10A and 10B.
[0068] In Figure 10A, the bottom is shown as being primarily metallic which is obviously
convenient if the rest of the container tray is metallic. The bottom is formed with
a 3 × 3 array of nine apertures 122 to 138, each of which is covered with microwave-transparent
material. The lid 140 is primarily of microwave-transparent material and is formed
on its surface with a 3 × 3 array of nine plates 142 to 158 of conductive material
such as metal. It will be seen from the pattern of plates/apertures in this embodiment
that the mechanism of operation is by way of amplification of the third order (E₃₃)
mode. In fact, presence of any one or more of the nine plates/apertures in the appropriate
position will enhance the mode, as has already been seen above in the discussion of
a single centrally-located plate, but the presence of all nine plates will provide
still greater enhancement of this mode and thus particularly even heating. Figures
10A and 10B also illustrate the "tailoring" of the plate sizes to improve heat input
to particularly cold areas: in this invention it will be noted that the size of the
central aperture 130/plate 150 is slightly greater than that of the remainder. The
reason for this is to cause the central plate aperture, overlying the coldest central
area of the container, to operate not only to encourage amplification of the third
order mode of the container, but also to act by the "forcing" mechanism by imposing
its own field pattern on the central area. Such tailoring and shaping of particular
areas is particularly useful for irregularly shaped containers or, as here, to enhance
the heat input to particularly cold areas.
[0069] Typical dimensions for the embodiment of Figure 10 are as follows:-
container overall width 115 mm
container overall length 155 mm
container overall depth 30 mm
length of central aperture 130/plate 150 41 mm
width of central aperture 130/plate 150 27 mm
length of remaining apertures/plates 35 mm
width of remaining apertures/plates 22 mm
The distance between adjacent apertures/plates is 12 mm, except for the central aperture/plate
which is 9 mm.
[0070] While Figures 10A and 10B have been described as showing, respectively, a container
bottom and lid for use together, it will be appreciated that either could be used
alone. Thus, for example, the lid 140 of Figure 10B could be used with a metallic
container wherein the bottom has no apertures, or with a container of a dielectric
plastic material.
[0071] In the case of the apertured bottom 10B, since the apertures are closely proximate
to the contained food article, the aperture dimensions are not such as to cut off
the propagation of the modes so formed, but this array of apertures could not be effectively
used in a lid if there is substantial spacing between the apertures and the contained
foodstuff.
[0072] Various other shapes of metal plate can be used to generate higher modes. For example,
a ring-shaped plate of metal on a microwave-transparent surface will result in the
generation of two higher-order modes, one due to the exterior perimeter of the plate,
and one still higher mode due to the interior perimeter of the plate. It is even possible
to conceive a whole series of coaxial rings each one smaller than the last, and each
generating two modes. Such ring-shaped plates could be circular, or could be rectangular
or square. Other shape and configurations of plate/aperture will be apparent to those
skilled in the art.
[0073] In further exemplification of certain preferred features, stated with reference to
arrangements of plates and/or apertures on the top and/or bottom surfaces of a container,
it may be observed that advantageously superior results (in terms of effectiveness
of localised heating produced by generation of a mode or modes of higher order than
the container fundamental modes) may be attained by observance of one or more of the
following preferred criteria, i.e. in addition to the spacing minima and avoidance
of one-dimensional resonance discussed above:-
1. The plates and/or apertures should preferably be regular geometric figures within
a co-ordinate system defined by the container geometry. For example, in the case of
a container with a periphery of rectangular shape in plan projection, the defined
co-ordinate system is a Cartesian co-ordinate system, and the plate(s) or aperture(s)
should preferably be at least approximately rectangular in shape, with sides parallel
to the axes of that co-ordinate system (viz. the geometric axes of the plan projection
of the container); in the case of a container with a periphery of circular shape in
plan projection, the defined co-ordinate system is cylindrical, and the plates or
apertures should preferably (a) coincide approximately with sectors therein or (b)
should have circular boundaries concentric with but differing in radius from the plan
projection of the container periphery.
2. If only one plate or aperture is used, it should preferably be centred with respect
to the container periphery as viewed in plan projection, and should preferably be
at least approximately conformal in shape to the plan projection of the container
periphery (circular, for a circular container periphery; rectangular, for a rectangular
container periphery, with the same aspect ratio and orientation as the container periphery;
elliptical, for an elliptical container periphery, with foci coincident with those
of the container periphery, or with the same aspect ratio as the container periphery).
3. For enhancement of "naturally existing" modes in a container, the plates and/or
apertures should preferably be at least approximately in register with "cells" corresponding
to a selected higher-order mode which is a harmonic of the fundamental modes defined
by the container geometry. By way of example, in Figure 10B, the E₃₃ mode is a harmonic
of the fundamental modes in the illustrated rectangular container and the nine plates
shown are respectively positioned for register with the nine cells corresponding
to this mode. In the case of a container of circular periphery with its cylindrical
co-ordinate system, the angularly harmonic mode cells will be sectors of the container
periphery circle (as exemplified by the arrangements of Figures 1 and 2) and the
radially harmonic mode cells will be regions bounded by circles concentric with the
container periphery (exemplified by Figure 8, or by an arrangement of concentric
annular plates or apertures).
4. For "forced mode" operation, the plate(s) and/or aperture(s) should still preferably
conform in shape to the container co-ordinate system (circular or sectoral, for a
circular container; rectangular, for a rectangular container) though they may be nonproportional
to the container outline and in register with a "cell" which is not an element of
a harmonic mode of the container fundamental. Thus a centred rectangular plate for
"mode forcing" in a rectangular container may correspond in shape to a central "cold"
area (i.e. an area not effectively directly heated by microwave energy in the container
fundamental modes) which is not proportional in dimensions with the container periphery
or coincident with a cell corresponding to a harmonic of the container fundamental
modes.
5. The sides of the plates should preferably not meet at acute angles, to avoid arcing,
although if it is necessary that the sides of a plate converge at an acute angle (e.g.
as in the case of plate 64 in Figure 7) the apex should be radiused. Also, preferbly,
when plural plates having right-angled corners are fairly closely spaced (as in Figure
10B), it is preferred for the same reason that their corners be radiused; in the example
of dimensions given for the embodiment of Figure 10B, a corner radius of 2 to 3 mm
is convenient or preferred.
II THE PRESENT INVENTION
[0074] In the specific embodiments now to be described, the container of the present invention
are generally of the types shown in Figures 1-4 and 6-10B, but in place of lids or
other surfaces constituted of microwave-transparent sheets bearing metal plates or
metal sheets defining apertures covered with microwave- transparent sheet material,
there are provided dielectric lid or other wall structures having contiguous dielectric
wall portions of respectively different electrical thicknesses. More particularly,
in accordance with the invention, the metal plates or sheets in the lids of the containers
of Figures 1-4 and 6-10B are replaced with similarly configured dielectric wall portions
of electrical thickness substantially greater than that of the microwave-transparent
dielectric sheet material extending over the apertures or around and/or between the
plates. Similarly, where combinations of metal plates or aperture-defining metal sheets
and microwave-transparent material are provided in the base or bottom of these containers,
the same substitution is made.
[0075] Thus, referring to Figures 1-4, if the elements or regions 12, 16, 20 and 26 are
considered to be constituted of dielectric wall portions of relatively high electrical
thickness, in the lids 8 therein shown, while the regions 14, 18, 22 and 28 are constituted
of dielectric wall portions of relatively low electrical thickness (such as the mcirowave-trnasparent
dielectric sheet materials already described as used for these latter regions), containers
8 having such lids or bottoms 10 represent embodiments of the present invention, provided
that the difference in electrical thickness between the contiguous wall portions (12
and 14, or 16 and 18, or 20 and 22, or 26 and 28), and the electrical thicknesses
of the portions 12, 16, 20 and 26, are sufficiently large to effect modification of
the microwave electric field patterns (i.e. to generate higher order modes) within
the container.
[0076] Similarly, in a container as shown in Figure 6, in accordance with the present invention
the region 48 is a dielectric wall portion of relatively high electrical thickness
and the surrounding part of lid surface 46 is constituted by a dielectric wall portion
of relatively low electrical thickness. In like manner the remaining containers illustrated
in Figures 7-10B may be regarded as embodiments of the present invention if the regions
identified in the above description of these figures as metal plates or aperture-defining
metal sheets are deemed to be constituted instead of dielectric wall portions of electrical
thickness substantially greater than that of the microwave-transparent dielectric
material of the regions which surround, or are surrounded by them.
[0077] Also, referring particularly to Figures 8-10B, wherein plates and/or apertures are
shown in both the lid and bottom of the container, either the lid or bottom may be
a dielectric wall structure in accordance with the present invention (i.e. constituted
of contiguous dielectric wall portions of respectively greater and lesser electrical
thickness) and the other co-operating higher-mode-generating means (bottom or lid)
may utilise metal plates or aperture-defining metal sheets as set forth in the initial
description of these features above.
[0078] A more specific illustration of an embodiment of the present invention, generally
corresponding in arrangement to the container of Figure 6, is shown in Figure 11.
Metal foil tray 40 in Figure 11 contains a body of foodstuff 160 to be heated, and
is convered by a lid 161 of dielectric material which is spaced by a gap 162 above
the upper surface of the foodstuff body. The upper surface 163 of this lid is divided
into a centrally disposed region 165 and a second region 164 contiguous to and completely
laterally surrounding region 165, i.e. in the same manner that region 48 of Figure
6 is surrounded by the remaining area of surface 46. The region 165 is defined by
a first dielectric wall portion 166, while the region 164 is defined by a second dielectric
wall portion 168 contiguous to and completely laterally surrounding portion 166. The
wall portion 166 has a substantially greater dielectric thickness than the wall portion
168.
[0079] A modification of this structure is shown in Figure 12, wherein like reference numerals
designate like parts. The lid 161 is similar to lid 161 of the Figure 11 embodiment,
but has a central wall portion 166 of relatively high electrical thickness that is
somewhat differently positioned, in a vertical sense, relative to the surrounding
low-electrical-thickness wall portion 168. Also, in this embodiment the foil tray
40 is replaced by a tray 170 of dielectric material, having a bottom wall structure
constituted of a central dielectric wall portion 172 (in register with wall portion
166, and conforming thereto in plan outline) completely laterally surrounded by a
contiguous dielectric wall portion 174. In this tray, the surrounding wall portion
174 has a substantially greater electrical thickness than the central wall portion
172.
[0080] It is found that containers incorporating the described dielectric lid and/or other
dielectric wall structure in accordance with the present invention function, like
the containers described in the aforementioned copending application, to modify microwave
electric field patterns within the container, i.e. when the container, holding a body
of material to be heated, is placed in a microwave oven and irradiated with microwave
energy. Specifically, these dielectric wall structures comprising appropriately arranged
contiguous wall portions of respectively different electrical thicknesses generate
modes of a higher order than the fundamental modes of the container, and the higher
order mode or modes so generated propagate into the body of material to thereby locally
heat the material. In this way, desired heating distributions may be achieved in the
body.
[0081] Referring again particularly to Figures 11 and 12, as exemplifying the structures
of the invention, the dielectric wall portions 168 and 172 which have relatively low
electrical thickness may, like the microwave-transparent sheets in the structures
of the aforementioned copending application, be fabricated of conventional electrically
nonconductive container lid or packaging materials such as paperboard or plastic.
Typically, such materials have a dielectric constant less than 10, e.g. a dielectric
constant in a range of about 3 to about 7.
[0082] Preferably, the dielectric wall portions 166 and 174, which have relatively high
electrical thicknesses, are so constituted that their dielectric constants are substantially
greater than the dielectric constant of the low-electrical-thickness material constituting
wall portions 168 and 172. A useful exemplary (but non-limiting) range for the dielectric
constant of the higher-electrical-thickness wall portions is about 25 to 30, where
the dielectric constant of the low-electrical-thickness wall portions is below 10.
The portions 166 and 174 of greater electrical thickness may also have a spatial (physical)
thickness greater than the wall portions of low electrical thickness; this is true
of portions 166 in Figures 11 and 12, which exemplify two of the possible relative
vertical dispositions of the thicker and thinner wall portions in a dielectric wall
structure extending substantially horizontally. However, since the dielectric constant
as well as the physical thickness contributes to electrical thickness, the wall portions
of greater electrical thickness need not be physically thicker than the portion or
portions of lesser electrical thickness, provided that there is a sufficient difference
in dielectric constant, as exemplified by the bottom wall structure constituted of
portions 172 and 174 in Figure 12.
[0083] The material of the electrically thicker dielectric wall portions 166 and 174 may
be homogeneous dielectric material with an appropriately high dielectric constant.
Alternatively, it may be a so-called artificial dielectric, such as a dispersion
of metal particles in a plastic or other dielectric matrix, wherein the metal particles
serve to enhance significantly the effective dielectric constant of the material;
such aritificial dielectrics are known in the art and accordingly need not be further
particularised.
[0084] Very advantageously, the dielectric wall portion or portions of greater electrical
thickness (166 and 174 in Figures 11 and 12), or some of them, may be more or less
lossy in character, at least initially (i.e. absorptive of microwave energy, and heatable
thereby), and may further be so constituted as to undergo a gradual or abrupt decrease
in dielectric constant during the course of a microwave heating operation. In a container
according to the invention incorporating one or more dielectric wall portions of this
character, the change in dielectric constant that occurs in the latter portion or
portions during heating in a microwave oven reduces or substantially eliminates the
higher-mode-generating differences in electrical thickness between contiguous dielectric
wall portions. As a result, the effect of the dielectric wall structure in modifying
the field pattern within the container is self-limiting. This enables the distribution
of heating in the contained body of material to be altered, at an intermediate stage
of the microwave heating operation, as is frequently desirable for particular cooking
or other heating purposes.
[0085] In a broad sense, any dielectric body (e.g. having the shape of wall portion 166
in Figure 11) which initially has a relatively high dielectric constant (e.g. above
20), which is initially lossy in character and which through physical and/or chemical
changes in response to heating undergoes an abrupt or progressive decrease in dielectric
constant, is suitable for use in these embodiments of the invention. for instance,
the wall portion 166 may be formed of a porous plastic material that absorbs water,
and may initially be provided with a relatively high moisture content, which imparts
to the portion 166 a relatively high dielectric constant. When the container of Figure
11, having wall prtion 166 thus constituted, is placed in a microwave oven and irradiated,
the water in portion 166 absorbs and is heated by the irradiated microwave energy,
and is thereby progressively volatilised. As the water is driven off, reducing the
moisture content of the portion 166, the dielectric constant of this portion decreases,
and its electrical thickness approaches that of the surrounding portion 168 of initial
low (and unchanging) electrical thickness. Hence the initial higher-mode-generating
effect of the lid structure is effectively shut off, at an intermediate stage during
the continued heating of the contained body 160 in a microwave oven, and the initial
heating pattern in the contained body of foodstuff 160 is concomitantly altered without
operator intervention, while cooking continues uninterrupted.
[0086] As alternatives to porous plastic, instead of being formed of a porous plastic material,
the body portion 166 may comprise a silica gel or other gel structure, or a plastic
with glycol or material to hold water, such that again, upon heating, an initially
high water content is reduced progressively by volatilisation with resultant decrease
in dielectric constant. As a further alternative, the portion 166 may be formed of
a hygroscopic material, initially substantially dry (e.g. if the container of Figure
11 is a frozen food package, stored in a freezer); this material, when exposed to
ambient temperatures before heating, takes up atmospheric moisture sufficient to initially
elevate its dielectric constant and to achieve the requisite decrease in water content
upon heeating.
[0087] As another illustration of an initially high-electrical-thickness, variable dielectric
wall portion 166, such portion may incorporate a suitable ferro-electric material
having a dielectric constant which is high (e.g. 150) at ambient temperature but drops
to a low value (e.g. 7 or 8) upon heating of the ferro-electric to its Curie temperature.
Some ferro-electrics, such as titanites based on heavy metals, may present toxicity
problems precluding their use in or on food containers, though they would be suitable
for use in accordance with the invention to heat bodies of material not intended for
human consumption. Other ferro-electrics, such as Rochelle salts, are acceptable for
the described use in food packaging.
[0088] A gradual or abrupt change in electrical thickness may also be achieved where the
wall portions 166 in the embodiments of Figures 11 and 12 have an equal dielectric
constant to the surrounding wall portions 168. This is illustrated in the arrangements
of Figures 13 to 15 which all show container wall surfaces incorporating structures
exhibiting a different electrical thickness to that of the surrounding wall portions.
[0089] In Figure 13 there is shown an integral stepped structure 826 filled with material
827. The arrangement shown may be oriented so that the structure protrudes either
out of or, preferably, into the container. Although this filling material 827 can
be different from the material of the surrounding wall portion 824, it may be convenient
to use the same material for both purposes, thus enabling the filling material and
the surrounding wall to be moulded as a unitary structure, in the manner shown. Hence,
the structure 826 will have a different electrical thickness (due to its greater spatial
thickness) than the surrounding material of the wall 824.
[0090] The local heating effect of the structure 826 can be enhanced by choosing as the
filler a material having a dielectric constant greater than 10. Some local heating
effect can nevertheless be obtained with material having a dielectric constant below
10. For example, if the container and the filling material were to be formed integrally
and made of glass or ordinary ceramics, the dielectric constant of such material would
typically be in the region of 5 to 10.
[0091] If the practical advantages of moulding the entire container out of the same material
are of dominant importance, and are combined with a desire for the filler material
to have a dielectric constant somewhere in the range of 10 to 30, the entire container
can be made out of a material having such a relatively high dielectric constant, that
is a material that is non-standard as far as the usual manufacture of such containers
is concerned. Such a non-standard material might be a foam or a gel material containing
water; a ceramic material, including titamates; or a plastic or ceramic material impregnated
with metal particles, e.g. polyethylene terephthalate impregnated with small particles
of aluminium.
[0092] Alternatively, the container can be made of a standard plastic material, e.g. having
a dielectric constant less than 10, while the filler material has a higher dielectric
constant, i.e. achieving a different electrical thickness from two sources, the different
spatial thickness and a different dielectric constant (see the description relative
to Figure 11 above). The above-mentioned upper limit of 30 for the dielectric constant
has been chosen somewhat arbitrarily, having been determined primarily by the fact
that some materials with still higher dielectric constants tend to be more exotic
and expensive. However, from the electrical point of view, materials with dielectric
constants above 30 would be desirable, and such materials may prove economically viable,
especially if the container is a utensil, i.e. a container that is designed to be
re-used many times, in contrast to a disposable, single-use article.
[0093] Figure 14 shows a modification to this latter arrangement, wherein an integral stepped
structure 926 is filled, while protruding both into and out of the surrounding container
wall 924. The foregoing remarks in relation to Figure 13 apply equally to this embodiment,
as far as its electrical performance and the choice of materials are concerned. Figure
14 provides an example of an arrangement in which, by arranging for the filler material
to project both upwards and downwards simultaneously, each projection can be kept
relatively slight.
[0094] Figure 15 shows a sloping wall feature with the use of filler material 1127 to form
a stepped structure 1126. The foregoing remarks in relation to Figure 13 apply equally
to this embodiment, as far as its electrical performance and the choice of materials
are concerned. Figure 15 shows the sloping sidewalls 1132, 1134 inclined at about
60° to the plane of the wall 1124, but this angle can be increased or decreased as
desired, including being reduced to about 45° or below while still achieving the desired
electrical effect of acting as higher order mode generating means. However, a slope
of less than about 45° would make the walls so gradual in their inclination, that
the electrical performance would fall of appreciably. Therefore this angle of 45°
can be taken as an arbitrary preferred lower limit, although lower angles (e.g. 30°
or even lower) may be operable.
[0095] Figure 16 shows a modification of Figure 13 wherein the filling material 827 is replaced
by a block 1227 that is formed separately from the wall 1224 of the container and
secured in place by suitable means, e.g. glue, or even by the material in the container,
assuming that the latter will be rigid, e.g. by freezing, and hence able to retain
the block 1227 in the desired locations on the container wall 1224 where it will constitute
a structure in the same manner as that of Figure 13. This use of a separate block
could also be used to provide a downwardly projecting stepped structure. The block
1227 may have a dielectric constant which is the same as or different to that of the
surrounding wall 1224, as circumstances dictate.
[0096] All of the above-described embodiments can employ a cover or lid for the container.
[0097] Moreover, the higher order mode generating means in the form of the structures described
herein need not necessarily be located in the bottom wall of the container. Subject
to suitable dimensioning and positioning in relation to the contents of the container,
such means can be located in any surface of the container, e.g. in a lid or in one
or more of the side walls, with due regard to the avoidance of entrapment of the food
or other contents.
[0098] By way of further illustration of the invention, reference may be made to the following
specific exmple:-
Example
[0099] A microwave cooking container (circular in plan view) for a pot pie of 5-inch nominal
diameter, with a plastic lid having a nominal height of 1/2 inch, is provided (in
accordance with the aforementioned copending application) with an aluminium foil disc
of 5.5 cm diameter centrally mounted on the lid. This arrangement has been found highly
effective for browning and cooking a pot pie.
[0100] In accordance with the present invention, in a pot pie container as just described,
the metal foil disc was replanced with a "Polyfoam" porous plastic disc 0.24 inch
thick and 5.5 cm in diameter, mounted on the lid in the same centred location. The
"Polyfoam" disc was used as a matrix to hold water. A plurality of such containers
were prepared, and the "Polyfoam" discs were loaded with water. Initial microwave
heating tests demonstrated that for discs with an initial moisture content corresponding
to an initial estimated dielectric constant at or below 30, evaporation losses of
water would decrease the dielectric constant to less than 10 over reasonable heating
times.
[0101] When used to cook pastry, these containers having lids with water-loaded "Polyfoam"
discs not only improved heating distribution but also browned the pastry as effectively
as containers with lids having the aforementioned foil discs. Results, for containers
having "Polyfoam" discs with various different initial moisture contents (and, consequently,
various different initial estimated dielectric constants) are summarised below:-
