BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
[0001] The present invention is directed to a duplex composite member suitable for use in
lamps, as either an electrode and/or a filament element. This duplex composite member
has two component parts; (1) a core composed of one type of tungsten-based material,
and (2) a shell composed of a different tungsten-based material.
[0002] The duplex composite member of the present invention may have desirable surface properties
such as resistance to chemical attack and/or mechanical shock and vibration, making
it especially well suited for applications in incandescent lamps, metal halide discharge
lamps, and/or halogen incandescent lamps.
[0003] Electrode and/or filament failure due to mechanical shock and/or chemical attack
is a recognized problem in the lighting industry. For example, U.S. Patent No. 4,413,205
describes in detail how the tungsten conductors to the coiled filament of a halogen
incandescent lamp are locally pitted and chemically attacked by bromine in such a
manner that they break and the lamp fails.
[0004] The 4,413,205 patent suggests one method for reducing this chemical attack problem,
namely, modifying the conductor material to a tungsten - rhenium (Re) alloy containing
at least 0.1% Re.
[0005] Similarly, it is known that filament and/or electrode failure due to chemical attack
can also occur in metal halide high intensity discharge (HID) lamps, especially where
reactive halogens, including bromine, chlorine, and iodine have been used. See, for
example J. F. Waymouth, "Electric Discharge Lamps" pg. 210, (1971).
[0006] The chemical attack of thoriated tungsten electrode rods thus constitutes a recognized
obstacle in the application of the reactive halogens in metal halide discharge lamps.
[0007] Although such changes in electrode composition as those described in the 4,413,205
patent may overcome the problem of electrode failure due to chemical attack, such
alloys suffer from two major shortcomings:
(a) they do not possess the necessary emissive characteristics of the W - (usually
1 - 2%) Th0₂ materials typically used for electrodes and
(b) they introduce excessive Re emission into the light emitting plasma discharge
of metal halide lamps.
[0008] The present invention is directed to an alternate solution to the problems of chemical
attack and/or mechanical shock of electrodes and/or filaments, which does not suffer
the disadvantages discussed above.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
[0009] The present invention provides a tungsten-based duplex composite member, e.g., wire
or rod, which combines the emissive, nonsag, or other desirable qualities of an inner
tungsten-based core material with a different combination of properties, for example,
resistance to corrosive attack, by the presence of a different tungsten-based material
as an outer sheath or shell surrounding the core material.
[0010] One example of the benefits which may be conferred by the present invention is exemplified
by the manner in which the aforementioned difficulties of the prior art may be avoided.
In one embodiment of the present invention, an electrode is formed from a duplex composite
member, composed of a thoriated tungsten core (W - Th0₂) and a thin tungsten-rhenium
(Re) shell. In this embodiment, any rhenium emission is limited to an insignificant
amount (i.e., that vaporized from the thin shell, especially at the tip of the electrode).
[0011] Other embodiments of duplex composite members are provided by thoriated tungsten
discharge electrodes in which it is desirable to have two different concentrations
of thoria (ThO₂) in the element, a first concentration in the core of the duplex composite
member and a second concentration in the shell or surface of the member. In preferred
embodiments, the thoria concentration in the shell portion of the duplex composite
may be either lower or high than the thoria concentration in the core portion.
[0012] One desirable objective which can be facilitated by the use of the duplex composite
member of the present invention is the ability to draw thoriated core tungsten to
much finer sizes (i.e., smaller diameters) than heretofore feasible.
[0013] Prior to the present invention, the limit of wire sizes for thoriated tungsten (with
much greater than about 1% ThO₂) was no lower than about 0.020 inch in diameter. By
utilizing a duplex composite member of the present invention composed of a 2% thoriated
tungsten cure with a 1% thoriated tungsten shell, drawn wire of 0.017 inches in diameter
has readily been prepared. Unlike the 0.020 inch diameter wire previously prepared,
this 0.017 inch diameter wire is especially well suited for use in low wattage metal
halide lamps, i.e. 40 to 100 watts.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
[0014] As set forth above, the present invention provides a tungsten-based duplex composite
member, e.g., wire or rod, which combines the emissive, nonsag, or other desirable
qualities of an inner tungsten-based core material, with a different combination of
properties, for example, resistance to attack, by the presence of a different tungsten-based
material as an outer sheath or shell surrounding the core material.
[0015] As used herein, the term "tungsten-based material" is defined as tungsten-containing
compositions suitable for use as filament and/or electrode members in lamps, especially
incandescent lamps, metal halide discharge lamps, and halogen incandescent lamps.
Typically tungsten makes up at least about 95 percent (by weight), or more, of such
compositions. After careful consideration of the teachings of the present disclosure,
the skilled artisan will readily recognize suitable compositions for use herein.
[0016] Core materials may include thoriated tungstens, for example, tungsten compositions
containing thoria in the range of from about 0.5 to about 5.0 percent (by weight).
Other types of tungsten-based materials which may constitute the core include nondoped,
i.e., commercially pure (CP) tungsten, potassium (K) doped nonsag tungsten (normally
used in incandescent filaments), and tungsten alloys. Such materials are known to
the skilled artisan in the lighting field.
[0017] Other core materials include tungsten modified with emissive materials such as CeO₂,
La₂O₃, Sc₂O₃, HfO₂, ZrO₂, and the like, in concentrations ranging up to about 5 percent
(by weight). Combinations of these emitters with and without thoria may also be employed
as a tungsten-based core material herein.
[0018] Another example of a useful tungsten-based core material is provided by Japanese
Patent No. 58-129741 which describes the use of a tungsten electrode containing 20
ppm aluminum (Al). This Al level substantially exceeds currently specified levels
of this element in wire).
[0019] As shell materials, any of the above described core materials may be employed, with
the proviso that the core material and the shell material of any given duplex composite
member are not the same.
[0020] In addition, attack and corrosion-resistant tungsten-rhenium alloys may also be used
as shell materials. Such (Re)alloys, containing up to about 5% Re (by weight) will
also promote mechanical shock and vibration resistance, making the duplex composite
member especially well suited for use as incandescent filaments for applications involving
such shock and vibration, while minimizing the amount of expensive Re which must be
used and enhancing the luminous efficacy by the use of a K-doped, nonsag core.
[0021] Such a combination with a tungsten-rhenium (W-Re) shell around a potassium (K)-doped,
nonsag core enables the composite to be used as the filament of a halogen incandescent
amp, in which separate internal conductors are not required.
[0022] In general, duplex composites are prepared by isostatically cold pressing the preblended
and preplaced powders together into a billet with the core preplaced concentrically
within the shell. The billet is then densified by sintering at a high temperature
and reduced to wire of the desired diameters by the usual tungsten processing methods
of rolling, swaging, and drawing.
[0023] The present invention will be further illustrated with reference to the following
examples which will aid in the understanding of the present invention, but which are
not to be construed as limitations thereof. All percentages reported herein, unless
otherwise specified, are percent by weight. All temperatures are expressed in degrees
Celsius.
EXAMPLE I
[0024] Duplex composite electrodes with a 2% thoria core inside a 1% thoria shell were prepared
for testing in both 100 watt and 400 watt metal halide lamps (Sylvania Metalarc lamps).
[0025] When viewed as a polished cross-section, the 2% thoria core is clearly revealed in
contrast to the 1% thoria shell, which has a much coarser grain structure, being attributed
to the larger grain size following the previous recrystallization-anneal.
[0026] The mold used in this example consisted of three main sections, a cylindrically shaped
outer PVC mold support tube (2.25 in. I.D. × 20 in.); a cylindrically shaped outer
mold member (2 in. I.D. × 24 in.) and a cylindrically shaped stainless steel inner
mold/fill tube (1 in. × 36 in.).
[0027] A portion of the upper section of the stainless steel inner mold/fill tube was flared
out to a diameter of 2 in. to act as a funnel for the introduction of powders. At
the bottom of the outer PVC mold support tube was placed a segment of hard rubber,
which acted as a shock absorber.
[0028] The three component parts were concentrically fitted together and filling was conducted
as described below.
[0029] The procedure used to prepare this duplex composite started by adding 3,000 grams
of W-2% ThO₂ powder to the central fill tube of the mold described above. At the same
time, 1,000 grams of W-1% ThO₂ powder was placed in the space between the mold and
the central fill tube.
[0030] The entire assembly was gently tapped during the filling operation until the prescribed
amounts of both powders were added to the mold. At the end of the filling operation
the levels of powder in the core and the outer shell were approximately the same.
One critical aspect of filling is that the powders are only loosely packed into the
mold since tight packing prevents the removal of the central filling tube.
[0031] After filling and the extraction of the fill tube, the mold was sealed, then cold
isostatically pressed at a pressure of approximately 45,000 lbs per square inch. The
pressed powder compact was then solid state sintered for about 12 hours at about 2,100°C
in a hydrogen atmosphere producing a composite ingot weighing about 13 kg with a density
of 17.6 g/cc, i.e., about 93% of the theoretical density.
[0032] The resulting ingot was about 1.5 inches in diameter by about 19 inches long. The
W-1% ThO₂ shell comprised about 70% of the ingot volume with the W-2% ThO₂ making
up the remainder, producing an ingot with an average ThO₂ content of 1.34% by analysis.
[0033] Reduction of the ingot began first by rolling on a two-high rolling mill from 1.5
to 1.0 inch in diameter in multiple-passes at a temperature above 1300°C. After recrystallization,
the ingot was rolled twice at a temperature above 1400°C on a multiple stand rolling
mill manufactured by Frederick Kocks Co., to a diameter of about 0.3 inch with an
intermediate recrystallization.
[0034] The ingot was further reduced to about 0.1 inch diameter by multiple-pass swaging
with three more recrystallization anneals. Because the diffusivity of ThO₂ in tungsten
is very low for all of the processing temperatures employed herein, the interface
between the W-1% ThO₂ outer shell and the W-2% ThO₂ core remains distinct, maintaining
the duplex composite structure. Below 0.1 inch diameter the ingot was drawn into wire
using conventional wiredrawing practices for W-ThO₂ wire.
[0035] The duplex composite wire made thereby was drawn to 0.039 inch diameter. Cathode
rods for 400 watt metal halide lamps were prepared therefrom by centerless grinding
to 0.0365 inch diameter and sectioning the ground rods into 1/2 inch lengths. These
members were used to prepare seventeen 400 watt Metalarc-type lamps (having an arc
tube fill comprising Na, Sc, I, and Hg) each of which lighted and operated normally
in accordance with their design ratings.
[0036] The remainder of the 0.039 inch wire was drawn further to a diameter of 0.017 inch
and this drawn wire was sectioned into 0.0295 inch segments. These small segments
were used to prepare five 100 watt metal halide lamps, also having an arc tube fill
comprising Na, Sc, I, and Hg. These lamps operated normally after burning for over
2000 hours. They were also found to start slightly faster than the standard lamps
having a 1% thoria cathode, in this case 91 seconds versus 95 seconds.
EXAMPLE II
[0037] A duplex composite member is also prepared, using essentially the same procedures
set forth in Example I, but with a non-thoriated core of tungsten encased in a shell
of 2% thoria. 100 Watt Metalarc type amps made therefrom are found to start much faster
than the standard Metalarc amps having a 1% thoria electrode. The lamps will also
demonstrate improved lumen maintenance, especially when compared to prior art lamps
with the same rapid starting characteristics, but wherein 2% thoriated tungsten makes
up the entire electrode.
[0038] The present invention has been described in detail, including the preferred embodiments
thereof. However, it will be appreciated that those skilled in the art, upon consideration
of the present disclosure, may make modifications and/or improvements on this invention
and still be within the scope and spirit of this invention as set forth in the following
claims.
1. A tungsten-based duplex composite member, comprising a core composed of a first
tungsten-based material and an outer sheath or shell surrounding the core composed
of a second, different tungsten-based material.
2. The tungsten-based duplex composite member of claim 1, wherein the core is composed
of thoriated tungsten.
3. The tungsten-based duplex composite member of claim 2, wherein the thoria concentration
in the core material is from about 0.5 to about 5 percent.
4. The tungsten-based duplex composite member of claim 2, wherein the thoria concentration
in the core material is from about 1 to about 3 percent.
5. The tungsten-based duplex composite member of claim 2, wherein the thoria concentration
in the core material is about 2 percent.
6. The tungsten-based duplex composite member of claim 1, wherein the shell is composed
of thoriated tungsten.
7. The tungsten-based duplex composite member of claim 6, wherein the thoria concentration
in the shell material is from about 0.5 to about 5.0 percent.
8. The tungsten-based duplex composite member of claim 6, wherein the thoria concentration
in the shell material is from about 1 to about 3 percent.
9. The tungsten-based duplex composite member of claim 6, wherein the thoria concentration
in the shell material is about 1 percent.
10. The tungsten-based duplex composite member of claim 1, wherein the thoria concentration
in the shell material is lower than the thoria concentration in the core material.
11. The tungsten-based duplex composite member of claim 10, comprising a 2 percent
thoriated tungsten core and a 1 percent thoriated tungsten shell.
12. The tungsten-based duplex composite member of claim 11, which is in the form of
an electrode rod.
13. The tungsten-based duplex composite member of claim 11, which is in the form of
a filament wire.
14. The tungsten-based duplex composite member of claim 13, which has a diameter of
about 0.017 inches.
15. The tungsten-based duplex composite member of claim 1, wherein the core and/or
the shell are composed of a potassium doped nonsag tungsten.
16. The tungsten-based duplex composite member of claim 15, wherein the dopant concentration
in the core material is from about 0.001 to about 0.1 percent (10 to 100 parts per
million).
17. The tungsten-based duplex composite member of claim 15, wherein the dopant concentration
in the shell material is from about 0.001 to about 0.01 percent.
18. The tungsten-based duplex composite member of claim 1, wherein the either the
core or the shell is composed of commercially pure (undoped) tungsten.
19. The tungsten-based duplex composite member of claim 1, wherein the core and/or
the shell are composed of a tungsten alloy.
20. The tungsten-based duplex composite member of claim 1, wherein the core and/or
the shell are composed of tungsten and an emitter material.
21. The tungsten-based duplex composite member of claim 20, wherein the emitter concentration
in the core material is from about 0.5 to about 5.0 percent.
22. The tungsten-based duplex composite member of claim 20, wherein the emitter concentration
in the shell material is from about 0.5 to about 5.0 percent.
23. The tungsten-based duplex composite member of claim 1, wherein either the core
or the shell is composed of tungsten and about 20 ppm aluminum.
24. The tungsten-based duplex composite member of claim 1, wherein the shell comprises
a tungsten-rhenium alloy.
25. The tungsten-based duplex composite member of claim 24, wherein the rhenium concnetration
is up to about 5 percent.