[0001] The present invention relates to a swirl tube separator for the separation of solids
from a mixture of fluid and solids.
[0002] The separation of solids from a mixture of fluid and solid particles using a swirl
tube separator is based on different centrifugal forces acting on the fluid and the
solids of the swirling mixture.
[0003] USA patent specification No. 2 890 764 discloses a swirl tube separator for separating
solids from a mixture of fluid and solids, the separator comprising:
- a housing having a cylindrical mid section;
- an inlet opening for the mixture arranged near a first end of the housing;
- a solids outlet opening arranged near a second end of the housing;
- a fluid outlet conduit being arranged concentrically within the housing, said outlet
conduit comprising a small diameter section, a large diameter section and a frustoconical
section for interconnecting the small diameter section and the large diameter section,
the small diameter section having a free end which is in direct fluid communication
with the interior of the housing and the large diameter section extending through
said first end of the housing; and
- a swirl zone which extends, when the separator is being used, through the interior
of the housing from near the inlet opening to a location near the solids outlet opening.
[0004] The lower end of the fluid outlet conduit coincides with the lower end of the swirl
zone.
[0005] As can be seen in Figures 10 and 14 of the prior art document the ratio of the distance
from said free end of the small diameter section of the fluid outlet conduit to the
location to which the swirl zone extends and the inner diameter of the cylindrical
mid section of the housing is much less than 1.
[0006] Applicants have now found that the separation efficiency of a swirl tube separator
can be improved by selecting a larger ratio between said dimensions.
[0007] Accordingly, it is an object of the present invention to provide a swirl tube separator
having a higher separation efficiency than the known separator.
[0008] To this end the swirl tube separator according to the invention is characterized
in that the specific distance from said free end of the small diameter section of
the fluid outlet conduit to said location near the solids outlet opening to which
the swirl zone extends is between 1.0 and 3.0.
[0009] Here the specific distance is referred to as the ratio of the above-mentioned distance
to the inner diameter of the cylindrical mid section of the housing.
[0010] Hereinafter in the specification and in the claims the expressions "specific distance",
"specific length" and "specific inner diameter" are used to refer to the ratio of
said distance, length and inner diameter to the inner diameter of the cylindrical
mid section of the housing.
[0011] The invention will now be described by way of example in more detail with reference
to the accompanying drawings, wherein:
Figure 1, shows schematically a cross-section of the swirl tube separator according
to the invention; and
Figure 2, shows schematically a cross-section of an alternative swirl tube separator
according to the invention.
[0012] Reference is made to Figure 1. The swirl tube separator comprises a housing 1 having
an inlet part 3 at its upper end and a solids outlet opening 5 at its lower end part.
The inlet part 3 is in communication with an inlet opening 9.
[0013] An open-ended fluid outlet conduit 11 extends concentrically into the housing 1.
The lower end of the fluid outlet conduit 11 is arranged between the inlet part 3
and the solids outlet opening 5. The fluid outlet conduit 11 comprises a large diameter
section in the form of a primary section 13, a downwardly tapering frustoconical section
15 joined to the lower end of the primary section 13, and a small diameter section
in the form of a secondary section 17 joined to the lower end of the frustoconical
section 15. The largest inner diameter of the frustoconical section 15 is equal to
the inner diameter of the primary section 13 and the smallest inner diameter of the
frustoconical section 15 is equal to the inner diameter of the secondary section 17.
[0014] Swirl imparting means in the form of swirl vanes 19 are arranged in the inlet part
3 and between the inner wall of the housing 1 and the outer wall of the primary section
13 of the fluid outlet conduit 11.
[0015] A swirl zone 20 extends in the housing 1 between the swirl imparting means in the
form of swirl vanes 19 and the solids outlet opening 5.
[0016] During normal operation a mixture of gas and solid particles is introduced into the
inlet part 3 through inlet opening 9. The mixture flows downwardly between the inner
wall of the housing 1 and the outer wall of the primary section 13 of the fluid outlet
conduit 11, and passes the swirl vanes 19, which swirl vanes 19 impart a swirl to
the mixture. The swirling mixture forms a vortex in the swirl zone 20.
[0017] The swirling solid particles in the mixture are flung towards the inner wall of the
housing 1 by the centrifugal forces acting on them. At the inner wall of the housing
1 the solid particles flow downwardly by gravitational forces. The solid particles
are discharged from the swirl zone 20 through the solids outlet opening 5.
[0018] The gas in the vortex is withdrawn from the swirl zone 20 through the fluid outlet
conduit 11.
[0019] The alternative swirl tube separator shown in Figure 2 is additionally provided with
a vortex stabilizer 21 arranged at or near the solids outlet opening 5. The vortex
stabilizer 21 comprises a vortex stabilizer plate 23 arranged perpendicular to the
central longitudinal axis of the housing 1, and a vortex finder rod 25 arranged parallel
to the central longitudinal axis of the housing 1 and extending in the direction of
the fluid outlet conduit 11.
[0020] Normal operation of the alternative swirl tube separator is similar to normal operation
of the swirl tube separator with reference to Figure 1. The function of the vortex
stabilizer is to stabilize the vortex in the housing 1 and to delimit the lower end
of the vortex.
[0021] The inlet part 3 of the housing 1 may alternatively be provided with swirl imparting
means in the form of a tangential inlet (not shown).
[0022] Normal operation of a swirl tube separator provided with a tangential inlet is similar
to normal operation of the swirl tube separator provided with swirl vanes 19.
[0023] The swirl tube separator according to the invention is similarly operated when a
mixture of liquid and solid particles is introduced into the inlet part 3.
[0024] It has been found that the discharge of solid particles through the fluid outlet
conduit can be further reduced by choosing the dimensions of the swirl tube separator
according to each of the following specifications: the specific length of the secondary
section 17 of the fluid outlet conduit 11 to be between 0.25 and 1.0, the specific
length of the frustoconical section 15 of the fluid outlet conduit 11 to be between
0.20 and 0.30, the specific inner diameter of the secondary section 17 of the fluid
outlet conduit 11 to be between 0.20 and 0.40, the specific inner diameter of the
primary section 13 of the fluid outlet conduit 11 to be between 0.55 and 0.75, the
specific length of the primary section 13 of the fluid outlet conduit 11 to be between
1.0 and 1.4, and the specific length of the inlet part 3 to be between 0.50 and 0.70.
[0025] The following experiments 1-3 have been carried out to illustrate the swirl tube
separator according to the invention.
[0026] The expression "swirl number" is used to refer to the ratio of the tangential component
of the mixture velocity to the axial component of the mixture velocity.
Experiment 1
[0027] The swirl tube separator used in experiment 1 had the following characteristics:
specific distance between lower ends of the fluid outlet conduit and the swirl zone
= 2.18, specific length of the secondary section of the fluid outlet conduit = 0.57,
specific length of the frustoconical section of the fluid outlet conduit = 0.26, specific
length of the primary section of the fluid outlet conduit = 1.21, specific length
of the inlet part = 0.60, specific inner diameter of the secondary section of the
fluid outlet conduit = 0.38, specific inner diameter of the primary section of the
fluid outlet conduit = 0.65.
[0028] A mixture of gas and solid particles was supplied to the inlet part of the cylindrical
housing. The gas had a density of 1.23 kg/m³ and the pressure difference between the
gas at the inlet part and in the fluid outlet conduit was 1930 Pa. The swirl number
of the mixture in the swirl zone near the swirl imparting means was 1.73. The mixture
contained 0.092 kg/m³ solid particles having a mean diameter of 14 µm. As a result
it was found that 99.63% of the solid particles was discharged through the solids
outlet opening and 0.37% through the fluid outlet conduit.
Experiment 2
[0029] The swirl tube separator used in experiment 2 had the following characteristics:
specific distance between lower ends of the fluid outlet conduit and the swirl zone
= 2.43, specific length of the secondary section of the fluid outlet conduit = 0.31,
specific length of the frustoconical section of the fluid outlet conduit = 0.26, specific
length of the primary section of the fluid outlet conduit = 1.21, specific length
of the inlet part = 0.60, specific inner diameter of the secondary section of the
fluid outlet conduit = 0.38, specific inner diameter of the primary section of the
fluid outlet conduit = 0.65. A mixture of gas and solid particles was supplied to
the inlet part of the cylindrical housing. The gas had a density of 1.23 kg/m³ and
the pressure difference between the gas at the inlet part and in the fluid outlet
conduit was 2000 Pa. The swirl number of the mixture in the swirl zone near the swirl
imparting means was 1.73. The mixture contained 0.092 kg/m³ solid particles having
a mean diameter of 14 µm. As a result it was found that 99.47% of the solid particles
was discharged through the solids outlet opening and 0.53% through the fluid outlet
conduit.
Experiment 3
[0030] The swirl tube separator used in experiment 3 had the following characteristics:
specific distance between lower ends of the fluid outlet conduit and the swirl zone
= 1.96, specific length of the secondary section of the fluid outlet conduit = 0.78,
specific length of the frustoconical section of the fluid outlet conduit = 0.26, specific
length of the primary section of the fluid outlet conduit = 1.21, specific length
of the inlet part = 0.60, specific inner diameter of the secondary section of the
fluid outlet conduit = 0.38, specific inner diameter of the primary section of the
fluid outlet conduit = 0.65.
[0031] A mixture of gas and solid particles was supplied to the inlet part of the cylindrical
housing. The gas had a density of 1.23 kg/m³ and the pressure difference between the
gas at the inlet part and in the fluid outlet conduit was 1980 Pa. The swirl number
of the mixture in the swirl zone near the swirl imparting means was 1.73. The mixture
contained 0.093 kg/m³ solid particles having a mean diameter of 14 µm. As a result
it was found that 99.57% of the solid particles was discharged through the solids
outlet opening and 0.43% through the fluid outlet conduit.
[0032] The following experiments 4-6 have been carried out as comparison.
Experiment 4
[0033] The swirl tube separator used in experiment 4 had the following characteristics:
specific distance between lower ends of the fluid outlet conduit and the swirl zone
= 1.53, specific length of the secondary section of the fluid outlet conduit = 1.21,
specific length of the frustoconical section of the fluid outlet conduit = 0.26, specific
length of the primary section of the fluid outlet conduit = 1.21, specific length
of the inlet part = 0.60, specific inner diameter of the secondary section of the
fluid outlet conduit = 0.38, specific inner diameter of the primary section of the
fluid outlet conduit = 0.65.
[0034] A mixture of gas and solid particles was supplied to the inlet part of the cylindrical
housing. The gas had a density of 1.23 kg/m³ and the pressure difference between the
gas at the inlet part and in the fluid outlet conduit was 1920 Pa. The swirl number
of the mixture in the swirl zone near the swirl imparting means was 1.73. The mixture
contained 0.095 kg/m³ solid particles having a mean diameter of 14 µm. As a result
it was found that 99.49% of the solid particles was discharged through the solids
outlet opening and 0.51% through the fluid outlet conduit.
Experiment 5
[0035] The swirl tube separator used in experiment 5 had the following characteristics:
specific distance between lower ends of the fluid outlet conduit and the swirl zone
= 1.86, specific length of the secondary section of the fluid outlet conduit = 0.56,
specific length of the frustoconical section of the fluid outlet conduit = 0.56, specific
length of the primary section of the fluid outlet conduit = 1.21, specific length
of the inlet part = 0.60, specific inner diameter of the secondary section of the
fluid outlet conduit = 0.38, specific inner diameter of the primary section of the
fluid outlet conduit = 0.65.
[0036] A mixture of gas and solid particles was supplied to the inlet part of the cylindrical
housing. The gas had a density of 1.23 kg/m³ and the pressure difference between the
gas at the inlet part and in the fluid outlet conduit was 1830 Pa. The swirl number
of the mixture in the swirl zone near the swirl imparting means was 1.73. The mixture
contained 0.093 kg/m³ solid particles having a mean diameter of 14 µm. As a result
it was found that 99.53% of the solid particles was discharged through the solids
outlet opening and 0.47% through the fluid outlet conduit.
Experiment 6
[0037] The swirl tube separator used in experiment 6 had the following characteristics:
specific distance between lower ends of the fluid outlet conduit and the swirl zone
= 1.74, specific length of the secondary section of the fluid outlet conduit = 1.07,
specific length of the frustoconical section of the fluid outlet conduit = 0.26, specific
length of the primary section of the fluid outlet conduit = 1.21, specific length
of the inlet part = 0.60 specific inner diameter of the secondary section of the fluid
outlet conduit = 0.46, specific inner diameter of the primary section of the fluid
outlet conduit = 0.65.
[0038] A mixture of gas and solid particles was supplied to the inlet part of the cylindrical
housing. The gas had a density of 1.23 kg/m³ and the pressure difference between the
gas at the inlet part and at the fluid outlet conduit was 1260 Pa. The swirl number
of the mixture in the swirl zone near the swirl imparting means was 1.73. The mixture
contained 0.093 kg/m³ solid particles having a mean diameter of 14 µm. As a result
it was found that 98.92% of the solid particles was discharged through the solids
outlet opening and 1.08% through the fluid outlet conduit.
1. A swirl tube separator for separating solids from a mixture of fluid and solids,
the separator comprising:
- a housing having a cylindrical mid section;
- an inlet opening for the mixture arranged near a first end of the housing;
- a solids outlet opening arranged near a second end of the housing;
- a fluid outlet conduit being arranged concentrically within the housing, said outlet
conduit comprising a small diameter section, a large diameter section and a frustoconical
section for interconnecting the small diameter section and the large diameter section,
the small diameter section having a free end which is in direct fluid communication
with the interior of the housing and the large diameter section extending through
said first end of the housing; and
- a swirl zone which extends, when the separator is being used, through the interior
of the housing from near the inlet opening to a location near the solids outlet opening;
characterized in that the specific distance from said free end of the small diameter
section of the fluid outlet conduit to said location near the solids outlet opening
to which the swirl zone extends is between 1.0 and 3.0.
2. Swirl tube separator of claim 1 wherein said location near the solids outlet opening
to which the swirl zone extends is defined by the location at which a vortex stabilizer
is mounted within the housing.
3. Swirl tube separator of claim 1 wherein the solids outlet opening is formed by
a tapered frustoconical end section of the housing and said location to which said
swirl zone extends is formed by the downstream end of said frustoconical end section
of the housing.
4. Swirl tube separator of claim 1, wherein swirl imparting means are arranged in
an inlet part of the housing, which inlet part is arranged near the first end of said
housing.
5. Swirl tube separator according to any one of claims 1-4, wherein the specific length
of the small diameter section of the fluid outlet conduit is between 0.25 and 1.0.
6. Swirl tube separator according to any one of the claims 1-5, wherein the specific
length of the frustoconical section of the fluid outlet conduit is between 0.20 and
0.30.
7. Swirl tube separator according to any one of the claims 1-6, wherein the specific
inner diameter of the small diameter section of the fluid outlet conduit is between
0.20 and 0.40.
8. Swirl tube separator according to any one of the claims 1-7, wherein the specific
inner diameter of the large diameter section of the fluid outlet conduit is between
0.55 and 0.75.
9. Swirl tube separator according to any one of the claims 1-8, wherein the specific
length of the large diameter section of the fluid outlet conduit is between 1.0 and
1.4.
10. Swirl tube separator according to any one of the claims 4-9, wherein the specific
length of the inlet part of the housing is between 0.50 and 0.70.
11. Swirl tube separator according to any one of the claims 1-10, wherein the largest
inner diameter of the frustoconical section is equal to or smaller than the inner
diameter of the large diameter section of the fluid outlet conduit.
12. Swirl tube separator substantially as described in the specification with reference
to Figures 1 and 2.