[0001] The present invention relates to a tool for cutting solid material, said tool comprising
a tool body and a cutting insert of cemented carbide, said cutting insert being secured
to the tool body by brazing. The invention also relates to a cutting insert per se.
[0002] When a tool according to the present invention is cutting a relatively hard, solid
material, e.g sandstone, the cutting insert will be subjected to very high forces,
said forces creating a turning moment that gives rise to tensile stresses in certain
portions of the surface of the cutting tip. Also the turning moment will eventually
be transformed to the brazed joint.
[0003] Cutting inserts of cemented carbide that are subjected to high bending stresses must
have a high toughness, i.e. lower hardness compared to cutting inserts that are subjected
basically to compressive stresses. In mineral and asphalt cutting lateral forces are
present to a relatively high degree. Therefore, cutting inserts of the type having
a relatively low hardness and high Co-content are chosen for mineral and asphalt cutting.
A high Co-content is also favourable in reducing brazing stresses.
[0004] The wear resistance of a cutting insert as described above consequently is low and
in no way optimal as regards length of life. It is therefore common to choose big
cutting inserts having a big volume of cemented carbide for mineral and asphalt cutting.
By way of such an arrangement one can handle the bending stresses and the tool also
gets an acceptable length of life.
[0005] In conventional tools for mineral and asphalt cutting the big volume cutting inserts
are properly embedded in the tool blank made out of steel. Such an arrangement makes
sure that the cutting insert is not subjected to too high stresses.
[0006] However, such a design means that the steel of the blank surrounding the cutting
insert quite soon gets in contact with the mineral or asphalt that is worked. Especially
when minerals are worked the contact between minerals and steel will initiate sparking
that can be very dangerous, e.g. in mines having inflammable gases. Contact between
a cutting insert of cemented carbide and minerals will normally not initiate sparking.
[0007] Since the cemented carbide cutting insert for cutting mineral and asphalt has a relatively
big volume the tool itself is also voluminous. This means that very powerful machines
are needed to carry the tools.
[0008] As mentioned above the turning moment acting upon the cutting insert will be transferred
to the brazed joint. A conventional brazed joint between the cutting insert and the
tool body has normally a substantially constant thickness. This means that only a
peripheral part of the brazed joint will be active in absorbing the turning moment.
[0009] Especially in mineral cutting one speaks of technically cuttable material and economically
cuttable material. The technically cuttable material is the hardest material that
can be worked by a cutting action. The economically cuttable material is the hardest
material that can be worked by cutting action in economical superiority to other methods.
[0010] The aim of the present invention is to present a tool and a cutting insert for the
cutting of mineral or asphalt, said tool/cutting insert demanding a relatively low
energy to perform cutting and has a high wear resistance. A preferred embodiment of
the tool has a brazed joint that to a greater degree is active in absorbing the turning
moment acting upon the cutting insert. Consequently, harder material can thereby be
considered economically cuttable. The tool according to the invention also to a high
degree avoids sparking when working. The aim of the present invention is realized
by a tool/cutting insert that has been given the characteristics of the appending
claims.
[0011] Below an embodiment of the tool according to the invention will be described with
reference to the accompanying drawings, where Fig.1 discloses a cutting drum of an
excavating machine; Fig.2 discloses a detail in enlarged scale of a part of a tool
carried by the drum; Fig.3 shows a sectional view of a cutting insert according to
the invention; Fig.4 shows a diagram of how the compressive stresses in the surface
layer vary by varying cobalt content; Fig.5 shows a diagram of how the hardness varies
in relation to the distance from the surface of two cutting inserts; Fig.6 shows a
diagram of how the wear is related to the cutting length for a number of cutting inserts;
Fig.7 shows the head of a cutting insert of type B; Fig.8 shows a tool according to
the invention having a preferred design of the brazed joint; and Fig.9 shows a detail
in enlarged scale of Fig.8.
[0012] The cutting drum 10 (only partly shown) in Fig.1 carries a number of holders 11 that
each support a tool 12 for cutting solid material. The cutting drum 10 is rotated
in direction of the arrow 13. When a tool 12 is in engagement with the material to
be worked the cutting insert 14 of the tool 12 is subjected to a normal force F
N and a force parallell to chord F
T.
[0013] If very hard material is worked then the normal force F
N is considerably bigger than the force parallel to chord F
T. The force F
N can be up to four times the force F
T and in such a case it is at once realized that a portion of the surface of the cutting
insert 14 will be subjected to high tensile stresses.
[0014] In order to handle these high tensile stresses it is necessary to use a special type
of cemented carbide disclosed in EP 0 182 759 and EP 0 247 985. Therefore these publications
are included in this specification by way of reference.
[0015] The cutting insert 14 in Fig.3 has a core 15 of cemented carbide containing eta-phase.
The core 15 is surrounded by aa intermediate layer 16 of cemented carbide free of
etaphase and having a high content of cobalt. The surface layer 17 consists of cemented
carbide free from eta-phase and having a low content of cobalt. An intermediate part
of the cutting insert 14 includes a concave portion 18 extending circumferentially
around the cutting insert 14.
[0016] The thickness of the surface layer 17 is 0,8 - 4, preferably 1 - 3, of the thickness
of the intermediate layer 16.
[0017] The core 15 and the intermediate, cobalt rich layer 16 have high thermal expansivity
compared to the surface layer 17. This means that the surface layer 17 will be subjected
to high compressive stresses. The bigger the difference in thermal expansivity, i.e.
the bigger the difference in cobalt content between the surface layer 17 and the rest
of the cutting insert 14, the higher the compressive stresses in the layer 17. The
content of binder phase in the surface layer 17 is 0,1 - 0,9, preferably 0,2 - 0,7,
of the nominal content of binder phase for the cutting insert 14. The content of binder
phase in the intermediate layer 16 is 1,2 - 3, preferably 1,4 - 2,5, of the nominal
content of binder phase for the cutting insert 14.
[0018] From what is said above it can be realized that a higher nominal cobalt content of
the cutting insert gives higher compressive stresses in the surface layer. This is
shown by a diagram in Fig.4.
[0019] It should be pointed out that the core 15 of cemented carbide containing eta-phase
is stiff, hard and wear resistant. Said core 15 in combination with an intermediate
layer 16 free of eta-phase and having a high content of cobalt and a surface layer
17 free of eta-phase and subjected to high compressive stresses presents a cutting
insert 14 that fulfils the requirements discussed above for cutting of mineral and
asphalt, i.e. a cutting insert demanding relatively low cutting forces and having
a relatively high wear resistance.
[0020] In Fig.5 a diagram is disclosed showing the hardness distribution of a cutting insert
according to the present invention and a cutting insert of standard cemented carbide,
both inserts having a nominal content of cobalt of 15 % by weight. The measurments
are carried out from the surface up to the centre of the cutting inserts. By studying
Fig.5 it is at once noticed that the surface layer 17 of a cutting insert according
to the invention has a relatively seen very high hardness up to about 1.5 mm from
the surface, said layer 17 having a low content of cobalt. The layer 16 having a high
content of cobalt has a relatively low hardness. The core 15 again has a relatively
high hardness.
[0021] The cutting insert of standard cemented carbide has a constant hardness, as can be
seen in Fig.5.
[0022] Tests have been made of the parameter wear relative to the parameter cutting length
for three different cutting inserts. Said tests are shown in a diagram in Fig.6.
[0023] The cutting insert of type A has a geometrical design in accordance with Fig.3. However,
the material in said cutting insert is cemented carbide of standard type. The cutting
insert of type B is of conventional geometrical design for cutting mineral, see Fig.7,
and the cutting insert of type C is a cutting insert 14 according to the present invention,
i.e. in accordance with Fig.3.
[0024] As can be seen from Fig.7 the cutting insert of type A is worn out to 100% after
a cutting length of about 190 m. The cutting insert of type B is worn out to about
80% after a cutting length of about 375 m. The cutting insert of type C is worn out
to about 50% after a cutting length of about 940 m. In this connection it should also
be pointed out that the cutting inserts of type A and C have a weight of 80 g while
the cutting insert of type B has a weight of 150 g, i.e. the volume of the cutting
insert of type B is almost twice the volume of the cutting inserts of type A and C.
[0025] For a man skilled in the art the results presented in Fig.7 are very surprising.
Compared to conventional cutting inserts for cutting mineral or asphalt the cutting
insert according to the present invention has a relatively big axial projection, see
e.g. Fig.2. The composition of the cutting insert 14 according to Fig.3 makes it possible
to handle the relatively big tensile stresses and bending moments that act upon the
cutting insert 14 due to its relatively big axial projection.
[0026] A further advantage with a tool according to the present invention is that compared
to conventional tools less dust is produced when cutting is effected, i.e. the grain-size
distribution is displaced towards bigger grain-size for the cutting insert of the
present invention than for a cutting insert of type B, see Fig.7. The reason for that
is the geometry in combination with the high wear resistance of the cutting insert
according to the invention.
[0027] In Fig.8 and 9 a preferred embodiment of a brazed joint 19 is disclosed. The brazed
joint 19 is located between the tool body 12 and the cutting insert 14. The tool body
includes a recess 20 adapted to receive the cutting insert 14.
[0028] In the described embodiment the recess 20 has a flat bottom portion 21 located in
a plane perpendicular to the longitudinal centre axis 22 of the tool. The recess also
includes a conical surface portion 23 extending from the bottom portion 21 towards
the periphery of the tool body 10.
[0029] The conical portion 23 is symmetrical in respect of the longitudinal centre axis
22.
[0030] The recess 20 also includes an annular surface portion 24 having an extension in
the longitudinal direction of the tool.
[0031] In the conical surface portion 23 an annular groove 25 is provided, said groove 25
being used for fixation of the cutting insert 14 in the recess.
[0032] The cutting insert 14 according to the described embodiment has a flat bottom surface
26 adapted to be located above the bottom surface 21 of the recess in mounted position
of the cutting insert 14.
[0033] The cutting insert 14 further includes a conical surface portion 27 extending from
the bottom surface 26 up to a cylindrical periphery surface 28 of the cutting insert
14, said surface 28 defining the biggest diameter of said cutting insert 14.
[0034] The conical surface portion 27 of the cutting insert is provided with a number of
spacing buttons 29 cooperating with the groove 25 in mounted position of the cutting
insert 14. The buttons 29 and the groove 25 make sure that the cutting insert is in
correct position before brazing takes place.
[0035] As is indicated in Fig.8 the conical surface portion 23 of the recess 20 and the
conical surface portion 27 of the cutting insert between them include an angle α that
preferably has a value of 2-4°. The surface portions 23 and 27 resp., diverge in direction
towards the periphery of the tool.
[0036] From Fig.9 it can be learnt that the bottom surfaces 29 and 26 resp., are at a small
distance from each other in the disclosed embodiment.
[0037] When brazing is about to take place the tool body 10 and the cutting insert 14 are
oriented relative to each other as is shown in Figs. 8 and 9, i.e. they have a common
longitudinal centre axis 22.
[0038] Brazing is then effected and preferably a copper based brazing alloy is used. It
is also preferred to use vacuum brazing. The upper surface of the brazed joint 19
is marked by 30 in Fig.9.
[0039] Due to the included angle α between the conical surface portions 23 and 27 resp.,
the brazed joint 19 has generally Wedge-like cross-sections in an axial plane through
the tool according to the invention. The thickness of the brazed joint 19 is increasing
towards the periphery of the cutting insert 14.
[0040] This described design of the brazed joint I₉ is very effective in that almost the
entire portion of the brazed joint 19 located between the conical surface portions
23 and 27 resp., is active in absorbing the turning moment acting upon the cutting
insert 14. At one side the brazed joint 19 will be subjected to tension forces while
the diametrically opposed side will be subjected to compression forces. The most difficult
forces to handle are of course the tension forces.
[0041] In order to describe the function of the brazed joint according to the present invention
it could be looked upon as a number of elastical springs 31, 32, and 33. In such a
case the in radial direction outer portion of the brazed joint will be more extended/compressed
than the inner portions. Although the springs 31-33 are extended/compressed to a different
degree they exert substantially the same force due to their different lengths. This
is illustrated by the diagram in Fig.9. The vertical axis indicates the force F and
the horizontal axis indicates the extension E. The disclosed brazed joint of Fig.9
is subjected to a turning moment M and it is realized at once that the springs 31-33
are subjected to tension forces that in a conventional way are negative in the diagram.
The tension force in each spring 31-33 is the same while the extensions are different.
Of course this theory will not be fulfilled completely in practice but the principle
is important.
[0042] A preferred but non-limiting dimensional example of the brazed joint can be given.
In the area of spring 31 the brazed joint can have a thickness of 0.7 mm and in the
area of spring 33 the thickness is 0.3 mm. The diameter of the cutting insert 14 is
24 mm measured at the cylindrical periphery surface 28.
[0043] In this connection it should be pointed out that the brazed joint described above
is not limited to be used with a cutting insert 14 according to the present invention.
Also the rest of the invention is of course not restricted to the described embodiments
but can be varied freely within the scope of the appending claims.
1. A tool for cutting solid material, said tool including a tool body (10) having
a supporting surface, and a cutting insert (14) having a generally conical tip portion
and a shoulder portion that is intended to rest against the supporting surface, said
cutting insert being secured to the tool body, e.g. by brazing,
characterized in that an intermediate portion of the cutting insert (14), seen in axial direction
of the cutting insert (14), includes a concave portion (18) extending circumferentially
around the cutting insert (14), that the cutting insert (14) comprises a core (15)
of cemented carbide, an intermediate layer (16) of cemented carbide surrounding said
core (15) and a surface layer (17) of cemented carbide, that the surface layer (17),
the intermediate layer (16) and the core (15) contain WC (alpha-phase) with a binder
phase (beta-phase) based upon at least one of cobalt, nickel or iron, that the core
(15) further contains eta-phase, that the intermediate layer (16) and the surface
layer (17) is free of eta-phase, that the content of binder phase in the surface layer
(17) is lower than the nominal content of binder phase for the cutting insert (14),
and that the content of binder phase in the intermediate layer (16) is higher than
the nominal content of binder phase for the cutting insert (14).
2. A tool according to claim 1,
characterized in that the content of eta-phase in the core (15) of the cutting insert (14) is 2
- 60 % by volume, preferably 10 - 35 % by volume.
3. A tool according to claim 1 or 2,
characterized in that the nominal content of binder phase in the cutting insert (14) is 8 - 20
% per weight, preferably 11 - 16 %.
4. A tool according to any one of the preceding claims,
characterized in that the content of binder phase in the surface layer (17) is 0,8 - 4, preferably
1 - 3, of the nominal content of binder phase for the cutting insert (14), and that
the content of binder phase in the intermediate layer (16) is 1,2 - 3, preferably
1,4 - 2,5, of the nominal content of binder phase for the cutting insert (14).
5. A tool according to any one of the preceding claims,
characterized in that the thickness of the surface layer (17) is 0,8 - 4, preferably 1 - 3, of
the thickness of the intermediate layer (16).
6. A tool according to any one of the preceding claims,
characterized in that the brazed joint (19) between the cutting insert (14) and the tool body (12)
has at least partially an increasing thickness in direction from the centre of the
cutting insert (14) towards the periphery of the cutting insert (14).
7. A tool according to claim 6,
characterized in that the brazed joint (19) has generally wedge-like cross-sections in an axial
plane of the tool.
8. A cutting insert of cemented carbide adapted to be fastened to a supporting surface
of a tool body (12), preferably by brazing, said cutting insert (14) having a generally
conical tip portion and a shoulder portion that is intended to rest against the supporting
surface, characterized in that an intermediate portion of the cutting insert (14), seen in axial direction
of the cutting insert (14), includes a concave portion (18) extending circumferentially
around the cutting insert (14), that the cutting insert (14) comprises a core (15)
of cemented carbide, an intermediate layer (16) of cemented carbide surrounding said
core (15) and a surface layer (17) of cemented carbide, that the surface layer (17),
the intermediate layer (16) and the core (15) contain WC (alpha-phase) with a binder
phase (beta-phase) based upon at least one of cobalt, nickel or iron, that the core
(15) further contains eta-phase, that the intermediate layer (16) and the surface
layer (17) is free of eta-phase, that the content of binder phase in the surface layer
(I₇) is lower than the nominal content of binder phase for the cutting insert (14),
and that the content of binder phase in the intermediate layer (16) is higher than
the nominal content of binder phase for the cutting insert (14).
9. A cutting insert according to claim 8,
characterized in that the content of eta-phase in the core (15) is 2 - 60 % by volume, preferably
10 - 35 % by volume.
10. A cutting insert according to claims 8 or 9,
characterized in that the nominal content of binder phase is 9 - 20 % per weight, preferably 11
- 16 %.
11. A cutting insert according to any one of claims 8 - 10,
characterized in that the content of binder phase in the surface layer (17) is 0,8 - 4, preferably
1 - 3, of the nominal content of binder phase for the cutting insert (14), and that
the content of binder phase in the intermediate layer (16) is 1,2 - 3, preferably
1,4 - 2,5, of the nominal content of binder phase for the cutting insert (14).
12. A cutting insert according to any one of claims 8 - 11,
characterized in that the thickness of the surface layer (17) is 0,8 - 4, preferably 1 - 3, of
the thickness of the intermediate layer (16).