TECHNICAL FIELD
[0001] The present invention is directed to improvements in processes for bleaching and
delignification of wood pulp and other lignocellulosic material.
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
[0002] In the production of bleached pulp, unbleached brown pulp ("brown-stock") from the
pulp mill is directed to the bleach plant where it is subjected to a sequential series
of alternating delignifying/bleaching and extraction steps, each stage involving distinctively
different bleaching chemicals and/or process conditions. Whereas the process objective
of pulping is to chemically delignify wood or other lignocellulosic material (remove
the lignin "glue" that binds the cellulosic fibers together), the primary objective
of bleaching is to whiten the pulp, albeit some residual delignification occurs. In
pulping, the measure of effectiveness is the content of the remaining lignin and lignin
residues, which is commonly expressed as the Kappa or permanganate number. In bleaching,
one still determines the Kappa number, but the primary analytical parameters are the
pulp brightness and viscosity.
[0003] Essentially, all commercially practiced bleach processes are chlorine-based. A variety
of sequences are used to bleach pulp to the desired target bright- ness levels, typically
greater than 79 brightness units (ISO) and commonly 84-88. The latter stages tend
to involve milder, and more selective, and correspondingly more expensive bleaching
agents like ClO₂. The more common bleach sequences use molecular chlorine, chlorine
dioxide, or hypochlorite. Among the more common bleach sequences are CEDED, OCE
OD, CE
OD, CEDE
PD, CEHD, and CE
OHD with the first alkaline extraction stage (E) commonly reinforced with oxygen (E
O); where:
C =
Chlorination with chlorine (Cl₂), commonly accomplished with co-addition (C
D) or pretreatment (D/C) with chlorine dioxide.
E = Alkali
Extraction with NaOH.
E
P or E
O = Peroxide or oxygen-reinforced alkali extraction.
D =
Dioxide treatment with chlorine dioxide (ClO₂).
H = Alkaline
Hypochlorite bleaching, typically with sodium hypochlorite (NaOCl).
O -
Oxygen bleaching with molecular oxygen (O₂).
The actual sequence utilized by a given plant is a reflection not only of target brightness,
but also local process economics, brownstock species, end use of pulps, and age of
the bleach plant.
[0004] Concern over the negative implant on the environment of chlorine-based bleach plant
effluents has accelerated in recent years particularly since the discovery of the
highly toxic chlorinated dioxins and furans in some bleach plant effluents, sludge,
and pulp products. Today it is generally accepted that it is critical to reduce the
amount of chloro-organics in pulp and the plant effluent.
[0005] Formation of these chlorinated organics is strongly related to the use and consumption
level of molecular chlorine in the chlorination stage (Axegard, P., 1988 Pulping Conference,
page 307). Reduced Cl₂ dosage results in reduced organochlorides, commonly referred
to collectively as TOCl/AOX. However, in the absence of alternative technology, the
required Cl₂ dosage cannot be arbitrarily reduced without significant adverse effect
on pulp quality. It is of great importance to minimize formation of chloro-organics
through identifying a cost-effective means allowing a reduction in the required amount
of molecular chlorine utilized in the chlorination stage, rather than rely on post-treatment
technologies such as advanced wastewater treatment systems for the effluent.
[0006] The dominant cost items in the production of bleached pulps are chemical costs and
investment/capital costs, the latter due mainly to the number of chemical treating
stages involved. Accordingly any acceptable technology desirably would build on existing
process technology and be sensitive to capital requirements and chemical costs. Ideally
the technology would use existing onsite chemicals and equipment.
[0007] The two most accepted technologies for reduction in the required molecular chlorine
are oxygen pretreatment and partial substitution of chlorine with chlorine dioxide
in the chlorination stage. Both are being commercially implemented (L. Tench and S.
Harper,
TAPPI 55 (1987); G. E. Annergren, et al.,
Svensk Papperstripping,
90, 29 (1987). Oxygen bleaching preceding chlorination can reduce chlorine requirements
up to 45% before pulp strength properties are adversely affected. Significant chemical
cost savings are also realized. However, payback is very long due to the huge capital
investment in the oxygen prebleach stage (e.g., CEDED → OCEDED) and additional plant
retrofit requirements such as additional washers or new recovery boilers to accept
the added non-chlorine containing load from the oxygen stage.
[0008] Chlorine reduction can also be achieved by substituting part of the chlorine requirements
by high levels of chlorine dioxide in the chlorination stage. Although not as common
as oxygen prebleaching, the chief advantage is that theoretically no significant capital
is involved. However most mills do not have sufficient ClO₂ capacity to handle the
additional load. Although one achieves the environmental objective of reduced chlorine
consumption, the chemical savings advantage of oxygen bleaching is lost since one
is substituting the considerably more expensive chlorine dioxide (45-50

/lb) for chlorine (8-10

/lb). Also, the increased consumption of chlorine dioxide may require investment in
additional on-site dioxide generators since the dioxide is unstable and must be made
on-site as needed. Furthermore, dioxide substitution technology is not as effective
in "short sequence" bleach processes arising from oxygen alkali extraction (E
O) technology when high brightness pulps are required (Annergren, G. E., et al., 1988
INTERNATIONAL PULP BLEACHING CONFERENCE PROCEEDINGS, pp. 37-46).
[0009] Oxygen-reinforced alkali extraction (E
O), is now commonly practiced in most bleach plants. E
O is a relatively low capital, chemical cost-savings technology that simply involves
mixing/injecting oxygen into the alkaline pulp of the first alkaline extraction stage
which results in reduced chemical requirements in the subsequent bleach stages. The
reduced chemical requirement to achieve brightness often allows the option of converting
a five stage bleach processes to only three stages ("short sequence bleaching"); e.g.,
C
DEDED → C
DE
OD (J. S. Enz, et al.,
TAPPI, 143 (1984) at optimal conditions of 60°C and 25 psig, an O₂ contact time of no more
than 5 minutes is required, and these systems are so designed. Higher pressures and
longer reaction times are of no benefit (B. Van Lierop, et al.,
TAPPI 75, December 1986); nor are they available in existing E
O processes. Similarly, there is no advantage to increase temperature above 50°C (B.
Van Lierop, et al.,
Proceedings 1985 International Pulp Bleaching Conference, 83); the E
O process is run at 50-70°C because that was the prior existing E-stage temperature.
Added reinforcement chemicals such as hypochlorite (E
O/H) or peroxide (E
O/P) can also be beneficial to incrementally attaining higher brightness pulps or further
reducing chemical consumption in the post-E
O bleach stages, (Nonni, U.S. Patent 4,568,420 (1986)).
[0010] E
O technology is optimized for and directed to saving bleach chemicals in the
subsequent (3rd stage and later) stages. Recently it was reported by Sjoblom, et al. (K. Sjoblom,
et al.,
1988 Int'l Pulp Bleaching Conference, pages 263-270) that a chlorine reduction in the chlorination stage could be achieved
by increasing the dosage of the very expensive chlorine dioxide to the chlorination
stage as previously disclosed by Annergren, et al., (
1988 Int'l Pulp Bleaching Conference, page 37) and also modifying the E
O stage conditions including increased temperature, pressure, oxygen contact time,
added MgSO₄ and optionally reinforcing the E
O stage with hydrogen peroxide. Pulp brightness could be maintained only with increased
chlorine dioxide dosages to the chlorination stage which was disclosed by Annergren,
et al.
1988 Int'l Pulp Bleaching Conference, page 37, and also by Axegard (
TAPPI Journal, 54, October 1986). Even so, the utility of the described process is severely limited.
To reduce required chlorine by this technology, an increase in bleach chemical costs
is required as well as additional reinvestment in new E
O process equipment to accommodate the required increased O₂ reaction times and additional
chlorine dioxide capacity. To reduce relatively inexpensive chlorine, as therein proposed,
one must incur the costs of the considerably more expensive chlorine dioxide, hydrogen
peroxide, MgSO₄ and added capital equipment.
[0011] The vast majority of E
O systems are of the upflow-downflow configuration and are sized for a 3-5 minute
reaction time at 25 psig. (B. VanLierop, et al.,
TAPPI 75, December 1986). The proposed "hot extraction" technology (K. Sjoblom, et al.,
op. cit.) requires greater pressures and considerably longer oxygen contact reaction
times approaching 30-40 minutes. Only in a system providing an upflow E
O stage, which is relatively uncommon, is sufficient residence time available to accommodate
the technology without a major reinvestment in new E
O process equipment, as well as additional ClO₂ capacity.
[0012] In summary, all approaches to significantly reduce the required amount of chlorine
require investment in significant new capital equipment or in additional and expensive
bleaching chemicals.
[0013] Among the objects of the present invention is to provide an improved bleaching process
comprising a simple and easily implemented chlorine-reduction technology that does
not simultaneously require significant capital investment and which results in net
chemical savings while achieving desired pulp brightness and strength (viscosity).
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
[0014] In accordance with the present invention the required dosage/charge of chlorine and/or
both chlorine and chlorine dioxide is reduced without detriment to final brightness
and viscosity, by heating the pulp to 85-100°C and addition of a small amount of hydrogen
peroxide to the pulp (without need of magnesium sulfate or other stabilizer) just
prior to or directly after the addition of oxygen in the existing E
O stage. The process of the invention is applicable to treatment of lignocellulosic
pulp in a multistage bleaching process comprising sequential chlorination and oxygen
alkali extraction stages in which the chlorination stage optionally contains either
or both chlorine (Cl₂) and/or chlorine dioxide (ClO₂), conventionally indicated as
a C, C
D or D/C stage.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0015] The invention will be more clearly understood and its several advantages appreciated
from the description which follows read in connection with the accompanying drawings,
wherein:
Figure 1 is a schematic flow diagram of a conventional 5 step multistage ing chlorination
(C).
Figure 2 is a schematic flow diagram of a modified bleaching system employing only
3 treating stages, having an oxygen reinforced alkali extraction stage (EO), that may be employed in practice of an exemplary embodiment of the present invention.
Figure 3 is a graphic representation of experimental data demonstrating loss of pulp
brightness observed as a result of arbitrarily reducing chlorine charge in the initial
chlorination stage of a short bleach sequence (CDEOD).
Figure 4 is a series of bar graphs demonstrating loss of brightness with reduced Cl₂
even at various EO reinforcement conditions based on data recorded in Examples 1 through 6.
Figure 5 is a series of bar graphs of experimental data demonstrating final brightness
can be maintained at reduced Cl₂ dosage only by increasing temperature and addition
of peroxide before excess oxygen introduction into underchlorinated pulp (Examples
7 and 8) as compared to control (conventional) conditions (Examples 1 and 2).
Figure 6 is a graphic representation of experimental data demonstrating effect of
modified EO stage conditions on final pulp brightness of underchlorinated pulp in a short sequence
(CDEOD), comparing Example 12 with a control under conventional Cl₂ and EO conditions (Example 9).
DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0016] Figure 1 illustrates an embodiment of a conventional system employing a five-stage
sequence for delignification and bleaching of wood pulp. The illustrated system comprises
5 consecutive treating towers designated C (chlorination), E (alkali extraction),
D (ClO₂ treatment), followed by E and D. The unbleached pulp is treated with Cl₂,
with or without ClO₂ reinforcement in the first C tower. The pulp enters at the bottom
of the first C tower, flowing upwardly through the tower and discharging at the top
of the tower into a washing section wherein it is washed with water. The washed pulp
is discharged from the washer via line 14, sodium hydroxide being added thereto. Line
14 discharges the thus alkalized pulp into a steam mixer 15 by which it is brought
to a temperature in the range of 40-70°C. The thus heated pulp is pumped at 15 into
the top of the E tower 16, where it is subjected to alkaline extraction followed
by water washing as indicated at 18.
[0017] The washed pulp is then pumped, at 20, into the bottom of the first D tower 22 and
flows upwardly through that tower in which it is treated with ClO₂. Following the
ClO₂ treatment, the pulp is again washed with water at 24 and pumped into the top
of the second E tower 25 with addition of sodium hydroxide. Discharged from the bottom
of tower 25 the pulp is again washed in water at 26 and introduced into the bottom
of the second D tower 28 for a second treatment with ClO₂; the thus bleached pulp
discharged from the top of tower 28 being water washed at 29.
[0018] The conventional 5 stage system (C
DEDED) of Figure 1 is often replaced by a short three stage sequence (C
DE
OD); see Enz, et al., TAPPI Proceedings, 1983 Pulping Conference, pages 309-313; Boussard,
et al., op. cit., pages 315-317). The three stage sequence without loss in pulp quality
was made possible by introduction of molecular oxygen into the pulp entering the thus
modified alkali extraction stage ("oxygen alkali extraction") designated by the symbol
E
O, illustrated in Figure 2, like parts bearing the same reference characters as in
Figure 1 wherein applicable. As shown in Figure 2, an O₂/pulp mixer or O₂ diffuser
30 is provided in the line feeding the E
O tower.
[0019] In practice of the present invention employing the short sequence of Figure 2, the
operating conditions of C and E
O stage are modified by:
(a) reduction in dosage of chlorine employed to KF 0.11 to 0.20,
(b) increasing the temperature of the alkaline under chlorinated pulp by adding more
steam to the pulp at the steam mixer in line 14, to raise exit pulp temperature to
85-100°C, and
(c) adding at least about 0.3% hydrogen peroxide to the pulp just before or after
introduction of the molecular oxygen thereto, which is also increased to about 0.8-1.2%
by weight on dry pulp. The peroxide may be added, for example, to the washed pulp
in line 14 together with or preceding the alkali addition, or subsequently thereto
at the steam mixer, but preferably at pump 15, or alternatively at a point in line
just prior or after the pulp/O₂ mixer or diffuser 30.
[0020] While in Figure 2, the practice of the invention is described as applied to the C
DE
OD sequence, it will be understood that the invention is not limited thereto but can
be employed to advantage in the 5 stage sequence or in any bleach sequence having
an oxygen alkali extraction stage following the chlorination stage with attending
reduction of the otherwise required amount of Cl₂ and/or ClO₂ needed to be employed.
The advantages of the invention are easily obtained without loss of desirable pulp
brightness, while achieving the benefits of oxygen bleaching, chlorine dioxide substitution,
and hot alkali extraction, without the attendant high capital and added chemical costs,
and without requiring any major change in the existing process configuration. Not
only are environmental benefits achieved such as reduced effluent TOCl/AOX due to
the reduced amount of applied Cl₂, net chemical savings are also realized by the invention
since the required amounts of both chlorine and also the more expensive chlorine dioxide,
are significantly reduced.
[0021] A primary objective of the present invention is to enable reduction in the required
amount of chlorinating agent needed to be employed in delignification and bleaching
of lignocellulosic pulp to obtain the desired product without adverse effect on pulp
brightness or viscosity, while avoiding the otherwise negative impact on environment
of chlorine-based bleach plant effluents.
[0022] There is generally a linear relationship between increasing chlorine application
(dosage) and the pulp lignin content, which may be expressed in terms of Kappa number.
The higher the Kappa number of the pulp the greater the chlorine dosage needed to
delignify the pulp. Typical for kraft softwood, for example, industry employs 6 to
8% chlorine by weight on dry pulp. The amount of molecular chlorine required for effective
delignification of the pulp of a given Kappa number is expressed by the Kappa factor
(KF), thus

[0023] Use of less chlorine results in unacceptable pulp of low brightness.
[0024] Since ClO₂ is frequently added to the pulp at the C stage, the quantity of actual
molecular chlorine can be reduced by substitution of the active chlorine equivalent
with ClO₂, so

[0025] In the delignification of unbleached lignocellulosic pulp a Kappa factor in the range
of 0.21 to 0.23 is typically advocated and employed in mill practice, based on actual
plant experience to provide a balance between sufficient delignification and minimizing
subsequent/downstream chemical requirement to achieve target brightness.
[0026] To demonstrate the advantages afforded by the present invention, results from several
bleaching sequences were compared. The basic C
DE
OD three-stage sequence was selected for demonstration purposes in all of the reported
runs since it is a common commercial sequence and it is an accepted laboratory standard
in the industry. The operating conditions employed in the demonstration are represented
by:
C
DE
OD which is representative of a common three-stage sequence with chlorine dioxide substituted
for some chlorine in the chlorination stage as is common practice in the art and employing
a conventional oxygen alkali extraction stage (3-5 minutes oxygen contact time, 20-25
psig, and 60-70°C).
This is the reference sequence in which it is demonstrated that total chlorine charge
(C+D) in the chlorination stage can be reduced by practice of the invention. In this
reference experiment, a total chlorine charge of 7.5% is used at 15% dioxide substitution
(6.38% Cl₂ + 1.13% D as active chlorine).

C

E
OD Also the reference three-stage sequence in which the chlorine in the chlorination
stage was reduced without obtaining benefit of the present invention.
C

E

D Also the reference three-stage sequence, except the reaction parameters of the
E
O stage are modified/enhanced in concert with a reduction in either or both chlorine
and chlorine dioxide in the chlorination stage.
[0027] In the experimental runs set out below, commercial, unbleached southern pine softwood
kraft pulp (brownstock) was used. The initial Kappa number was 32.7 and exhibited
a 0.5% CED viscosity of 20.6 centipoise (cp). The operating conditions employed are
summarized below.
A. Standard Chlorination (CD) Stage:
[0028] Crumbled pulp was placed in a polyester bag and an amount of chlorine water and chlorine
dioxide added to make the charge 6.38% and 1.13%, respectively, as active chlorine.
Dilution water was then added to bring the pulp to a consistency of 3.5%. The bag
was heat sealed and the chlorination allowed to proceed at ambient temperature for
45 minutes. The pulp was filtered (effluent pH 1.7 to 1.8) and washed with water.
B. Conventional and Reinforced Oxygen Alkali Extraction (EO) Stage:
[0029] The oxygen reaction vessel was a direct steam-heated pressure vessel containing a
removable rack upon which seven circular stainless steel mesh trays are arranged,
one above the other. The trays allow thin layers of pulp to be dispersed within the
vessel so as to provide intimate contact with oxygen in order to simulate good O₂/pulp
contact available in the bleach plant.
[0030] While the reactor was preheating, sufficient water, chlorinated pulp, and alkali
(NaOH) were mixed to bring the consistency to 12% and alkali charge to 3.64%. When
peroxide, magnesium sulfate, or hypochlorite were to be added, these chemicals were
also mixed with the pulp at this time.
[0031] After the pulp samples were placed on the vessel's removable trays, the assembly
was placed in the preheated reactor which was then bolted closed and the temperature
raised immediately (<2 minutes) to 70°C. Oxygen was then added to the reactor at 25
psig. After 5 minutes' exposure to oxygen, the oxygen was vented and the extraction
was allowed to proceed an additional 55 minutes (total time never exceeded 60 minutes)
without oxygen to complete the extraction stage. The separate pulp samples were then
removed, washed with water, and prepared for the dioxide bleaching stage.
C. Chlorine Dioxide Bleach (D) Stages:
[0032] Each individual pulp sample removed from the trays of the extraction reactor was
subjected separately to different levels of dioxide charge in order to determine the
bleaching performance profile, i.e., brightness vs. dioxide charge.
[0033] The extracted pulp sample was placed in a polyester bag and a calculated amount of
aqueous chlorine dioxide added (usually 0.5 to 2.0% on pulp) followed by sufficient
water to bring pulp consistency to 10%. The bag was sealed and rapidly brought to
70°C and maintained at this temperature for 3 hours. At this time, typically an aliquot
of bleach liquor was also removed and analyzed for residual dioxide. The dioxide bleached
pulp was then treated with sulfur dioxide to bring the pH to 3 prior to forming handsheets
for brightness measurements.
[0034] Results are graphically represented as brightness versus dioxide charge which is
a measure of the ability of this sequence to achieve target brightness.
[0035] Kappa number (T236), viscosity (T230), handsheets (T218), and brightness (T217) determinations
were made in accordance with the respective TAPPI Standard Test Procedure identified
by the numbers in parentheses. Chemical charges are on a weight percent basis; pulp
weight is reported on an air dry basis.
Example 1: Control Experiment and Reference/Standard CDEOD Sequence with Conventional EO Stage
[0036] The purpose of this control example is to determine the required amount of dioxide
to achieve a given brightness level for conventionally chlorinated pulp at KF = 0.23,
and to show what maximum bright- ness level could be achieved at conventional C
DE
OD bleach conditions for this brownstock pulp.
[0037] Following the general procedures outlined above, commercial brownstock of Kappa number
32.7 and a viscosity of 20.6 cp was subjected to chlorination (6.38% Cl₂ + 1.13% ClO₂
as active chlorine, KF = 0.23) and conventional oxygen alkali extraction (3.64% NaOH,
70°C, 5 minutes O₂ at 25 psig, balance of 60 total minutes with no oxygen) stages.
The washed pulp from the C
DE
o stage was divided into 4 portions and subjected to different dosages of chlorine
dioxide at a pH of 3.8-4.3 to complete the C
DE
OD.
TABLE 1(a)
% D |
Brightness |
Viscosity |
0.5 |
72.5 |
20.7 |
0.8 |
79.8 |
21.0 |
1.0 |
83.9 |
20.5 |
1.3 |
85.6 |
20.1 |
Example 2: Demonstration of Loss of Final Brightness that would be Observed with and Reduction
in Chlorine Charge without any Modification of E
O Stage (C

E
OD)
[0038] The experiment described in example 1 was repeated except that the molecular chlorine
charge was reduced by 20%; the chlorine dioxide charge was maintained at the amount
used in example 1 so the effective ClO₂ substitution level was of course higher in
this experiment. The Kappa Factor (KF) was 0.18, or 22% lower than the conventional
chlorination of Example 1.
TABLE 1(b)
% D |
Brightness |
Viscosity |
0.5 |
57.4 |
19.0 |
0.8 |
69.0 |
20.3 |
1.0 |
73.4 |
20.3 |
1.3 |
78.6 |
19.6 |
[0039] These results are graphically presented in Figure 3 along with those of the control
experiment (example 1). It is clearly seen that commercially unacceptable pulp (severe
brightness loss) results from the environmentally desirable act of reducing the chlorine
consumption in the chlorination stage, even if one increases the level of dioxide
substitution in the chlorination stage.
Example 3-6: Demonstration That Pulp Brightness Cannot be Maintained at Reduced (20%) Cl₂ Charge
Even at Increased Dioxide Substitution and Several Common Enhancements to the Conventional
E
O Stage (C

E

D)
[0040] The purpose of this series of experiments, the results of which are summarized in
Figure 4 along with the control tests of examples 1 and 2 for comparison, is to demonstrate
that at a reduced chlorine dosage of only 20%, one cannot maintain target/acceptable
pulp brightness even at higher chlorine dioxide substitution levels, simply by modifying
conventional E
O stage process conditions to longer oxygen contact times (5 minutes to 20 minutes)
or, even at this extended contact time, by increased E
O stage temperature (70-100°C), or addition of hypochlorite or hydrogen peroxide to
the E
O stage.
[0041] Examples 3-6 were performed as described in example 2 where the chlorine charge alone
was reduced by 20% with the chlorine dioxide level maintained at the same (example
1) chlorination stage level so, in effect, to increase the dioxide substitution level
to greater than the initial 15%. Otherwise, only the E
O stage parameters were changed as described below, with the results compared in Table
2.
TABLE 2
|
|
Brightness at Respective Dioxide Dosage |
|
Example |
0.5% |
0.8% |
1.0% |
1.3% |
Ex. 3 graph 4c |
Extend O₂ contact time of EO stage from conventional 5 to 20 minutes. |
62.5 |
73.2 |
76.2 |
81.7 |
Ex. 4 graph 4d |
EO stage temperature increased from conventional 70°: |
|
|
|
|
|
(1) to 100°C, O₂ contact time - 20 minutes. |
68.6 |
78.2 |
81.5 |
84.2 |
|
(2) to 110°C, O₂ contact time - 20 minutes. |
63.6 |
75.0 |
79.4 |
82.0 |
NOTE: Higher temperature (above 100°C) gives poorer results. |
|
|
|
|
|
Ex. 5 graph 4e |
0.7% sodium hypochlorite added to EO stage; O₂ contact time - 20 minutes. |
59.5 |
70.0 |
73.4 |
78.4 |
Ex. 6 graph 4f |
0.7% hydrogen peroxide added to EO stage; O₂ contact time - 20 minutes. |
69.4 |
77.2 |
81.5 |
83.8 |
[0042] As seen in Figure 4, bar graphs 4a and 4b show the brightness of pulp after receiving
treatment under conditions of Examples 1 and 2, respectively, (83.9 at full chlorine
dosage and 73.4 at 20% reduction in chlorine dosage). Bar graph 4c shows that the
loss in brightness at lowered chlorine dosage is not compensated by extension of the
time of exposure to added oxygen (Example 3). Bar graph 4d shows that some further
increase in brightness is had by raising the temperature of the E
O stage to 100° or 110°C (Example 4) while maintaining the oxygen exposure at 20 minutes.
Example 5 (bar graph 4e) carried out at the conventional E
O temperature (70°C) at extended time of O₂ exposure (20 minutes) but with addition
of hypochlorite to the E
O stage does not achieve acceptable brightness. Nor is desired brightness achieved
by using hydrogen peroxide additive in the E
O stage (Example 6). The results of Examples 3 to 6 are summarized in Table 2.
Example 7-8: Demonstration that Pulp Brightness can be Maintained with 20% Less Chlorine by Both Adding Peroxide and Increasing Alkaline Pulp Temperature Prior to Addition of Oxygen in the EO Stage
[0043] The experiment described in example 2, which reduced chlorine by 20% while maintaining
the same dioxide level in the chlorination stage, was repeated except 0.7% hydrogen
peroxide was added to the alkaline pulp which was then heated to 100°C prior to contacting
with pressurized oxygen at 25 psig for 5 minutes (example 7) and 20 minutes (example
8).
[0044] The results are tabulated below in Table 3 and summarized in Figure 5 along with
the control tests of examples 1 and 2 for comparison. The results clearly show this
unique and specific condition allows a reduction in chlorine charge without resorting
to long oxygen contact times unavailable to existing conventional E
O systems. Furthermore, if longer O₂ contact times were made available, only incrementally
higher brightness levels could be achieved at the reduced chlorine charge.
Example 9-11: Demonstration that the Pulp Properties of Brightness, Viscosity, Cleanliness, and
the Quality of the E
O Stage Effluent can be Maintained with a 30% Reduction in Chlorine and 100% Reduction/Elimination
of Chlorine Dioxide in the Chlorination Stage (C
DE
OD vs. C
O
)
[0045] For purposes of this demonstration, a new control (base case, example 9) was simultaneously
completed along with two experiments (examples 10 and 11) that demonstrate the technology
at 0.4 and 0.5% hydrogen peroxide charges (prior examples used 0.7% peroxide). The
results are tabulated below and summarized in Table 7 showing that within experimental
error, final pulp quality (brightness, viscosity, and shives) and effluent quality
from the E
O stage are maintained at 30% reduction of chlorine and with elimination of the ClO₂
in the chlorination stage. The data also suggests 0.3% peroxide will be minimum required
dosage.
Example 9 - New Control
[0046] The bleach sequence experiment described in example 1 was repeated except at a molecular
chlorine charge of only 6.19% and a dioxide charge of only 0.414% (KF = .20). Results
are reported in Table 4.
Table 4
|
Eo Stage |
D-Stage |
|
|
0.5% |
0.8% |
1.0% |
1.3% |
1.6% |
2.0% |
Viscosity |
20.5 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Color |
35,250 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
BOD-5 |
158 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
COD |
1,424 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Brightness |
|
71.7 |
82.4 |
85.4 |
87.3 |
88.2 |
88.5 |
Viscosity |
|
20.2 |
--- |
19.0 |
19.6 |
19.4 |
18.2 |
Shives |
|
--- |
--- |
--- |
425 |
400 |
325 |
Example 10
[0047] Experiment/example 9 was repeated except with 30% less Cl₂ (4.33% Cl₂) and no chlorine
dioxide in the chlorination stage. The Kappa Factor was only 0.13, or 35% less than
the conventional chlorination in Example 9. The temperature of the E
O stage was increased to only 90°C and only 0.4% peroxide added prior to the oxygen.
Oxygen contact time and pressure were maintained at 5 minutes and 25 psig. Results
are reported in Table 5.
Table 5
|
Eo Stage |
D-Stage |
|
|
0.5% |
0.8% |
1.0% |
1.3% |
1.6% |
2.0% |
Viscosity |
20.9 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Brightness |
|
60.8 |
73.1 |
78.2 |
83.1 |
85.1 |
85.6 |
Viscosity |
|
18.9 |
19.3 |
19.0 |
19.0 |
17.6 |
16.8 |
Shives |
|
--- |
--- |
--- |
--- |
375 |
575 |
Example 11
[0048] Experiment/example 10 was repeated except with 30% less Cl₂ and no chlorine dioxide
in the chlorination stage (KF = 0.13). The temperature of the E
O stage was increased to only 90°C and only 0.5% peroxide added prior to the oxygen.
Oxygen contact time and pressure were maintained at 5 minutes and 25 psig. Results
are reported in Table 6.
Table 6
|
Eo Stage |
D-Stage |
|
|
0.5% |
0.8% |
1.0% |
1.3% |
1.6% |
2.0% |
Viscosity |
21.3 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Color |
36,375 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
BOD-5 |
161 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
COD |
1,478 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Brightness |
|
66.3 |
79.1 |
81.9 |
84.6 |
86.0 |
86.9 |
Viscosity |
|
18.3 |
18.0 |
18.6 |
17.7 |
16.1 |
16.4 |
Shives |
|
--- |
--- |
--- |
300 |
225 |
225 |
[0049] The results of Examples 9-10 are compared in Table 7. Final brightness is shown after
2% ClO₂ treatment in the D stage as well as shives count.
[0050] Effect of both increased temperature and peroxide addition before oxygen on the final
pulp properties and E
O stage effluent in C
DE
OD bleaching at reduced Cl₂ and ClO₂ in chlorination stage (35% lower Kappa Factor),
is seen in Table 7 below:
Table 7
|
(Ex. 9) |
(Ex. 10) |
(Ex. 11) |
|
CDEOD |
CEOD |
|
Conventional EO at 70°C, 5 min O₂ No Peroxide |
30% Cl₂ Reduction Elimination of ClO₂ |
|
|
EO at 90°C, 5 min O₂ |
|
|
0.4% Peroxide |
0.5% Peroxide |
EO Stage |
|
|
|
Pulp Viscosity |
20.5 |
20.9 |
21.3 |
Effluent, Color |
35,250 |
-- |
36,375 |
BOD-5 |
158 |
-- |
161 |
COD |
1,424 |
-- |
1,478 |
D-Stage at 2% ClO₂ |
|
|
|
Pulp Brightness |
88.5 |
85.6 |
86.9 |
Pulp Viscosity |
18.2 |
16.8 |
16.4 |
Pulp Shives |
325 |
375-575 |
225 |
Example 12: Demonstration that Observed Results are not a Tradeoff on the Benefits to Conventional
E
O (C
DE
OD vs. C
DE

D)
[0051] This experiment follows Nonni, U.S. 4,568,420 of reinforcing the conventional E
O stage with H₂O₂, except that the temperature of the E
O stage is increased to 90°C.
[0052] The experimental bleach sequence described in example 9 (full charge of Cl₂ + ClO₂
in chlorination stage) was repeated except the temperature of the E
O stage was increased to 90° and 0.5% peroxide added. The results are tabulated below
and summarized in Figure 6 along with the control, example 9, accomplished at conventional
E
O conditions. The similarity of this brightness vs. dioxide dosage and bleaching curve
show, as expected, that this proposed new chlorine reduction technology is different
and not simply a variation on reinforced oxygen alkali extraction, as seen in Table
8.
Table 8
% D |
Control Ex. 9 |
This Example 12 |
|
|
Brightness |
Viscosity |
0.8 |
82.4 |
85.2 |
20.4 |
1.0 |
85.4 |
86.8 |
20.1 |
1.3 |
87.3 |
87.8 |
19.3 |
1.6 |
88.2 |
88.2 |
18.1 |
2.0 |
88.5 |
88.6 |
16.9 |
[0053] No advantage is gained in brightness at the elevated temperature as expected from
the Nonni examples and B. Van Lierop, et al. Proceedings
1985 International Pulp Bleaching Conference, page 83, which states there is no advantage to operating an E
O system above 50°C.
[0054] As demonstrated in our invention, a surprising temperature effect is observed only
when chlorinating agent is reduced.
[0055] The beneficial advantages of the present invention are realized when the herein advocated
process conditions are utilized in the treatment of unbleached pulp (CE
O... sequence) as well as in the delignification/bleaching of a pulp which has been
oxygen prebleached (OCE
O...). Moreover, the addition of a magnesium compound (MgSO₄) or other stabilizer deemed
essential in prior pulp treatment to avoid pulp degradation, may be omitted when practicing
the present invention.
[0056] In general, the desired reduced chlorination bleach process of the present invention
can be achieved by reducing the needed chlorinating agent (molecular chlorine with
or without chlorine dioxide) dosage to that required to maintain a Kappa factor in
the range of 0.11 to 0.20, employing selected operating conditions not conventional
in the oxygen alkali extraction stage (E
O) following the initial under chlorination at reduced KF, said conditions including:
(1) increasing oxygen to the total amount of 0.8 to 1.2 percent by weight of pulp
(dry basis) and at a pressure of 20 to 70 psig; higher oxygen dosage (beyond about
1.5%) can be used without added advantage. Oxygen contact time should be 3 to 5 minutes
at 20-25 psig.
(2) use of temperatures above that commonly employed in the art, preferably above
85°C and up to about 100°C. Temperature above 100°C obtain no added advantage, and
can have adverse effect on pulp quality.
(3) addition of at least 0.3% and no more than about 1% hydrogen peroxide by weight
of pulp (dry basis).
[0057] All of the above conditions (1) higher oxygen dosage, (2) higher temperature, (3)
minimum peroxide dosage indicated, must be observed to maintain desired brightness
at the reduced chlorination dosage (reduced Kappa Factor). No benefit is observed
in bleaching without reduced chlorine dosage as shown in Example 12.