FIELD OF THE INVENTION
[0001] This invention pertains to agents and methods for treating Multiple Sclerosis.
[0002] The invention relates to the use of the peptide DENPVVHFFKNIVTPRTPP or a fragment
thereof in the manufacture of an oral pharmaceutical formulation for the treatment
of multiple sclerosis.
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
[0003] Multiple Sclerosis (MS) is a chronic inflammatory disease of the central nervous
system white matter of humans and is believed to be of autoimmune etiology. The disease
is characterized by prominent T-cell and macrophage infiltrates, demyelination and
neurological dysfunction. Myelin basic protein (MBP) has been extensively studied
as a potential autoantigen in the disease because of its role as an inducing agent
in the major animal model of MS, experimental allergic encephalomyelitis (EAE), as
well as its role in the human disease post viral encephalomyelitis.
[0004] A major hypothesis regarding the pathogenesis of MS is that T-cells reactive with
myelin basic protein in the white matter of the CNS initiate the inflammatory process.
The demonstration that activated T-cells specific for myelin basic protein (MBP) can
be isolated from MS patients (
Allegretta, M., et al., Science: 247: 778, 1990) implicates MBP-reactive T-cells in the pathogenesis of the disease.
[0005] Experimental allergic encephalomyelitis (EAE) is the primary animal model for MS.
EAE can readily be induced in small mammals by immunization with myelin basic protein
(MBP) in an appropriate adjuvant or by passive transfer of CD4+, MBP-reactive T-cells
(
Alvord Jr, E.C., et al. eds. in Experimental Allergic Encephalomyelitis: A Useful
Model for Multiple Sclerosis, A. R. Liss, N.Y., 1984;
Makhtarian, D.E., et al. Nature 309: 356, 1984;
Ben-Nun, A. et al. J. Immunol. 129:303, 1982). The T-cells that induce EAE in both mice and rats recognize specifically peptides
corresponding to species-specific immunodominant regions of MBP presented on antigenpresenting
cells by unique Major Histocompatibility Complex (MHC) class II molecules.
[0006] T-cell receptors are composed of two distinct chains of protein material. Certain
T-cell receptors (TCRs), composed of V-beta (VB) chains and V-alpha (VA) chains, are
known to recognize MBP. In SJL/PL mice, encephalitogenic (i.e., disease-inducing when
administered to mice) T-cells having these receptors recognize an N-terminal mouse
MBP peptide (residues 1-9) presented by an MHC molecule (
Zamvil, S.S. et al., Nature 324: 258, 1986) encoded by the mouse gene H-2. The majority of T-cell receptors recognizing this
peptide presented in connection with the MHC are encoded by the mouse TCR genes VB8.2
and VA2 or VA4. In Lewis rats, TCR gene segments that are homologous with the mouse
VB8.2 and TCR VA2 genes have been found in encephalitogenic T-cells which recognize
MBP residues 68-88 in the context of the Lewis rat MHC (
Burns, F.R., et al., J. Exp. Med. 169: 27, 1989). Administration of a VB8.2-specific monoclonal antibody (i.e., an antibody recognizing
the product VB8.2 expressed by the corresponding gene) to mice has been shown to be
effective in treating murine EAE. Immunization with peptides specifically corresponding
to the TCR VB8.2 amino acid sequence ameliorates EAE in the Lewis rat (
Vanderbark, A.A., et al., Nature 341: 541-544, 1989;
Howell, M.D. et al., Science: 246, 668; 1989). However, the regions of an autoantigen (such as MBP) that behave as immunodominant
regions are species specific. It has not heretofore been determined if common V-gene
usage in TCR V-genes exists in humans among T-cells recognizing immunodominant regions
of MBP nor have these immunodominant regions been positively identified in MS patients.
[0007] The current treatments for MS involve administration of drugs which act in a non-specific
fashion to suppress the immune response in the subject. Examples of such drugs are
cyclophosphamide, Imuran (azathioprine) and the cyclosporin A. Steroid compounds such
as prednisone and methylprednisolone are also employed in many instances. These drugs
have limited efficacy against MS. Use of such drugs is limited by toxicity and by
the fact that they induce "global" immunosuppression upon prolonged treatment, i.e.,
they down regulate the normal protective immune response to pathogenic microorganisms
thereby increasing the risk of infection. A further drawback is the increased risk
that malignancies will develop in patients receiving prolonged global immunosuppression.
[0010] A U.S. patent application filed March 3, 1990 entitled "Enhancement of the Down Regulation
of Autoimmune Diseases by Oral Administration of Autoantigens" discloses synergists
(enhancers) for use with oral administration of autoantigens, disease-suppressive
fragments and analogs thereof as effective treatments for T-cell mediated autoimmune
diseases.
[0011] In furtherance of the efforts and goals expressed in these prior applications, i.e.,
the design of effective, specific therapeutic treatments for MS, it is necessary to
determine the major immunodominant epitope domain present on human MBP, again
with a view towards exploiting all or part of such domain towards therapeutic ends.
[0012] Another object of the present invention is to provide compositions and pharmaceutical
formulations useful for treating humans suffering from autoimmune diseases having
the symptoms of MS.
[0013] A still further object of the invention is to provide compositions and pharmaceutical
formulations useful for administration to humans for the purpose of preventing or
attenuating to the manifestation (i.e., clinical symptoms) of autoimmune diseases
having the symptoms of MS. Another object of this invention is to provide reagents
useful in diagnosis of MS (or of another disease presenting with the same symptoms).
(For example peptides based on the immunodominant domain of the human MBP can constitute
such diagnostic reagents.)
[0014] These and other objects of the present invention will be apparent to those of ordinary
skill in the art in light of the present specification, drawings and claims.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0015] Figure 1 is an autoradiograph showing PCR amplification of cDNA's from 18 T-cell
lines which were generated from five MS patients and which were reactive with MBP
residues 84-102.
[0016] Figure 2 is an autoradiograph of a Southern blot analysis of TCR VB and JB gene usage
for MBP-reactive T-cell lines generated from peripheral blood of an MS patient.
[0017] Figure 3 is a bar graph showing the frequency of MBP reactive T-cells to different
human MBP peptides isolated from MS patients and controls.
[0018] Figure 4 is a series of bar graphs showing the reactivity of T-cells isolated from
MS patients and controls to different regions of the human MBP polypeptide in relationship
to whether these patients have certain MEC antigens.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
[0019] The invention relates to the use of the peptide DENPVVHFFKNIVTPRTPP or a fragment
thereof in the manufacture of an oral pharmaceutical formulation for the treatment
of multiple sclerosis.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION
[0020] All patent applications, patents and litetature cited in this specification are hereby
incorporated by reference in their entirety.
[0021] As used herein, "treatment" is meant to include both prophylactic treatment to prevent
an autoimmune disease having the symptoms of MS (or the manifestation of clinical
symptoms thereof) as well as the therapeutic treatment, i.e. the suppression or any
measurable alleviation of one or more symptoms after the onset of a disease presenting
the symptoms of MS.
[0022] The term "autoantigen" is defined as any substance normally found within a mammal
that, in an abnormal situation, is no longer recognized as part of the mammal itself
by the lymphocytes or antibodies of that mammal, and is therefore attacked by the
immunoregulatory system as though it were a foreign substance. Examples are MBP and
proteolipid peptide (ALP).
[0023] "Immunodominant epitope" of an autoantigen (such as MBP) means an antigenic determinant
recognized by a majority (although not necessarily an absolute majority) of T-cells
of a sensitive species to which such T-cells will mount: or help mount an immune response.
[0024] "Immunodominant regions" or "immunodominant domains" of an autoantigen (MBP) are
defined herein as those regions of the autoantigen containing an immunodominant epitope.
The structures (and/or location within the MBP molecule) of immuno-dominant epitopes
(and regions) of MBP vary between species, and are, therefore, species-specific.
[0025] "Autoimmune suppressive agents" are defined herein as peptides having the amino acid
sequences of (or contained in) VB17 and/or VB12 of the T-cell receptor or analogs
thereof as well as other agents (such as attenuated VB17- or VB12-containing T-cells),
which when administered to a mammal suffering from a disease having the symptoms of
MS will suppress one or more of such symptoms. (The minimum sequence length of the
active peptides is about 20 amino acids. There is no particular maximum as long as
activity is preserved. For example, the entire TCR or even entire T-cells could be
used.)
[0026] "MHC" or "Major Histocompatibility Complex" is defined as a complex series of mammalian
cell surface proteins present on the surface of activated T-cells, macrophages and
other immune system cells. The MHC plays a central role in many aspects of immunity
both in presenting histocompatibility (or transplantation) antigens and in regulating
the immune response against conventional (foreign) antigens. There are two types of
MHC protein molecules, class I and class II. The human MHC genes are located on human
chromosome 6 and the mouse MHC genes are located in the H-2 genetic locus on mouse
chromosome 17.
[0027] "Class II MHC molecules" are membrane glycoproteins that form part of the MHC. Class
II MHC molecules are found mainly on cells of the immune system including B-cells,
macrophages, brain astrocytes, epidermal Langerhan's cells, dendritic cells, thymic
epithelium and helper T-cells. Class II MHC molecules are involved in regulating the
immune response during tissue graft rejection, stimulation of antibody production,
graft-versus-host reactions and in the recognition of "self" (or autologous) antigens,
among other phenomena. In the specification below, MHC shall be used interchangeably
with "Class II MHC". The MHC genes will be referred to as "MHC genes".
[0028] As used herein, "T-cells" or "T-lymphocytes" are defined as immune system cells,
derived from stem cells located within hematopoietic (i.e. blood forming) tissues.
There are three broad categories of T-cells: Helper, Suppressor and Cytotoxic. T-cells
express either the CD4 antigen (and are then called CD4+ T-cells) or the CD8 antigen
(in which case they are called CD8+ T-cells) on their cell surface. The expression
of CD4 or CD8 antigens by peripheral (circulating) T-cells correlates with the function
and specificity of the T-cell. "Helper T-cells" which are CD4+ recognized antigens
and Class II MHC molecules and perform helper or regulatory functions. "Cytotoxic"
and "Suppressor" T-cells (which are CD8+) recognize antigens and Class I MHC molecules
perform suppressor and cytotoxic functions.
[0029] "T-cell receptor" or "TCR" is defined herein as the antigen recognition receptor
present on the surface of T-cells. TCR is, therefore, the receptor that binds a molecule
which the immune system recognizes -- and presents -- as an antigen (whether the molecule
is foreign or autologous, the latter being the case in an autoimmune disease). A majority
of T-cells express a TCR composed of a disulfide-bonded heterodimer protein containing
one alpha (A) and one beta (B) chain whereas a minority of T-cells express two different
chains (gamma and delta). The TCR is composed of an A and a B chain, each of which
comprises a variable and a constant region. (
Tilinghast, J.P. et al., Science 233: 879, 1986;
Concannon, P. et al., Proc. Natl. Acad Sci USA 83: 6589, 1986,
Kimura, N. et al., J. Exp. Med. 164: 739, 1986;
Toyonaga, B. et al., Proc Natl. Acad. Sci USA 82: 8624, 1985.) The variable region in turn comprises a "variable", a "diversity" and "joining"
segment. The junction among the variable, diversity and joining segment is postulated
to be the site of antigen recognition by T-cells.
[0030] T-cells initiate the immune response when antigen presenting cells (APC), such as
mononuclear phagocytes (macrophages, monocytes), Langerhan's cells and follicular
dendritic cells, initially take up, process (digest) and present antigenic fragments
of the polypeptide on their cell surface (in connection with their MHC). CD4+ T-cells
recognize antigen molecules exclusively when the protein is processed and peptide
fragments thereof are presented by APCs that express Class II MHC molecules.
[0031] T-cell recognition of an antigen reflects a trimolecular interaction between the
TCR, MHC molecules and peptides processed by APCs via a cleft or pocket in the threedimensional
structure of the Class II MHC molecule. (
Bjorkman, P.J., et al., 1987, Nature, 329:506 and
329:512).
[0032] The present inventors have identified an immunodominant region of MBP resident within
a portion of the MBP amino acid sequence (residues 82-104) and two T-cell receptor
gene segments which correspond to VB17 and VB12. As shown in Example 2 below, the
present inventors have identified human MBP amino acid residues 84-102 as the basis
of an immunodominant domain of MBP recognized by a majority of peripheral T-cells
isolated from patients suffering from MS. In addition, the present inventors have
determined that T-cells reacting with the immunodominant epitope of MBP often also
posses the MHC Class II haplotype DR2 gene. The corresponding MHC antigen of such
T-cells binds MBP within immunodominant domain composed of residues 82-104 in association
with the DR2 phenotype. Since DR2 is most common in patients with MS, these cells
can be isolated, identified and used not only to diagnose but also to treat patients
with MS (as will be explained below).
[0033] In the animal model (EAE) T-cell receptors comprising a portion of the animal VB8.2
sequence have been used to treat the disease and shown to act by eliminating disease-inducing
T-cells. In particular, in the animal model, peptides comprising the sequences Thr-Leu-Cys-Ala-Ser-Ser
and Thr-Leu-Cys-Ala-Ser-Arg which may correspond to exposed (surface) portions of
mouse and rat VB8.2 have been determined (in mouse and rat models) to combat the autoimmune
disease model by eliminating Helper T-cells.
[0034] The present invention can be advantageously used in the design of specific therapeutic
agents useful for treating a human suffering from a disease with the symptoms of MS.
[0035] The present invention is directed to the use of the peptide DENPVVHFFKNIVTPRTPP or
a fragment thereof in the manufacture of an oral pharmaceutical formulation for the
treatment of multiple sclerosis.
[0036] The amino acid sequence for human VB12 (and one of the possible nucleic acids encoding
it) is set forth below:

[0037] The amino acid sequence for human VB17 (and one of the possible nucleic acids encoding
it) is set forth below:

(Notwithstanding the identity between mouse peptide TKCASS and the C-terminal human
VB17, peptides encompassing this amino acid sequence are not expected to be active
in humans because this sequence is a fairly common terminal sequence in human VB chains
and hence would not have as specialized a function as required for activity in suppressing
MS symptoms.)
[0038] Without wishing to be bound by theory, it is believed that administration of VB17-
or VB12-based peptides especially those incorporating the fragments previously identified
above or active analogs thereof to patients suffering from MS will block the TCR or
kill T-cells that express TCR and thereby block the induction or activation of Helper
T-cells involved in mounting an immune response against the myelin sheath of the central
nervous system (CNS) in patients suffering from MS. The mechanism of this may involve
the production of anti-VB (12 or 17) antibodies, i.e., native antibodies that will
recognize VB12 and/or VB17 and therefore bind to TCR. Whatever the mechanism of action,
these VB12- and VB17-based peptides are fully expected to be effective in attenuating
or eliminating symptoms of MS or of a disease presenting with the same symptoms and
are, therefore, expected to be useful therapeutic agents or adjuncts to MS therapy.
(For example, parenteral administration of such peptides may supplement or be supplemented
by oral and/or aerosol administration of MBP or fragments or analogs of MBP as disclosed
for example in
U.S. patent appls. Serial No. 487,732 filed March 2, 1990 and entitled "Enhancemen of the Down-Regulation of Autoimmune Diseases by Oral Administration
of Autoantigens", and Serial
No. 454,806 filed December 20, 1989.
[0039] In addition, healthy individuals susceptible to MS (i.e. individuals having the DR2
haplotype) and expressing VB17 or VB12 TCR on their T-cells, and therefore having
T-cells that proliferate (or that could be induced to proliferate) in response to
the presentation of the immunodominant region of human MBP may also benefit from prophylactic
administration of the peptide. In Example 2 below, VB17 was significantly less frequently
present (only in approximately 9.4% of the cell population collected) on T-cells isolated
from a normal individual than was present on the T-cell lines reactive with human
MBP amino acid residues 84-102 (53.9%) isolated from five MS patients. In addition,
VB12 was identified on 35% (7/20) of T-cell lines reactive with MBP amino acid residues
84-102 isolated from 4 MS patients (as opposed to 15% of T-cells from normal controls).
These results show that the VB17 and VB12 TCR peptides are selectively involved in
the recognition of the immunodominant (possibly encephalitogenic) human MBP region.
Therefore, it is anticipated that these peptides or fragments or analogs thereof will
provide safe, effective therapeutic agents for treatment or prophylaxis of humans
acainst MS symptoms.
[0040] Peptides based on the sequences of VB17 or VB12 for use in the present invention
can be synthesized using well-known solid phase methods (
Merrifield, R.B. Fed. Proc. Am. Soc. Ex. Biol. 21: 412, 1962 and
J. Am. Chem. Soc. 85: 2149, 1963;
Mitchel, A.R. et al, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 98: 7357, 1976;
Tam, J. et al., J. Am. Chem. Soc. 105: 6442, 1983). Alternatively, such peptides can be synthesized by recombinant DNA techniques,
as is now well-known in the art (
Maniatis et al. Molecular Cloning: A Laboratory Manual, Cold Spring Harbor Laboratories,
NY, 1982, see pp. 51-54 and pp. 412-30). For example, these peptides can be obtained as the expression products after incorporation
of DNA sequences encoding VB12 or VB17 (or fragments or analogs thereof) into expression
vectors and introduction of such vectors into suitable eukaryotic or prokaryotic hosts
that will express the desired peptides individually or as part of fusion peptides
or proteins.
[0041] Peptide analogs can be designed using the known amino acid sequences encoded by the
VB17 or VB12 genes as disclosed below, using the synthetic or recombinant techniques
described above and the methods of, e.g.,
Eyler, E.H., in Advances in Experimental Medicine and Biology 98: 259-281, 1978. For example, a peptide having a sequence based upon the amino acid sequence of VB12
or VB17 can be chemically synthesized using the above-described techniques. The peptide
can be tested for disease-suppressive activity when administered to a mammal using,
for example, the experimental protocol of
Howell, M.D. et al., Science, 246: 668, 1989 or
Vanderbark, A.A. et al., Nahire, 341: 541, 1989.
[0042] In addition, T-cells which are VB17+ or VB12+ can be isolated from patients suffering
from MS and identified using the techniques described in Examples 1 and 2 below. These
isolated VB17+ or VB12+ T-cells can be expanded, cloned, attenuated (as described
by
Lider, O., et al., 1986, Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sci., pp.267-273 and by
Weiner, H.L., et al. (Abstr.) Neurology (Suppl. 1) 69:172, 1989) and used as specific therapeutic agents/immunogens to treat patients suffering from
MS (preferably the same patents from whom the T-cells were originally isolated). T-cell
attenuation can be effected, for example, by exposing the T-cells to 0.1% glutaraldehyde
for 15 min. at room temperature. T-cell clones grown to 50 million cells in
vitro and attenuated (as described) can be stored in phosphate buffer saline (PBS). A dosage
of 50 million thus treated VB17+ and/or VB12+ cells can be injected e.g. subcutaneously.
[0043] Pharmaceutical formulations and dosage forms for use in treating mammals suffering
from diseases having the symptoms of MS are described. In general such dosage forms
contain one or more autoimmune-disease suppressive agents comprising peptides in turn
comprising (i) the sequence of human VB12 and/or VB17 and (ii) disease suppressive
fragments and analogs thereof, in an amount effective to treat or prevent one or more
clinical symptoms of MS.
[0044] The autoimmune disease suppressive agents may also encompass additional amino acids
in sequences leading or following the VB17 or VB12- based sequences as Long as these
additional sequences do not defeat the disease-suppressive function of 'such agents.
Testing of such constructs for disease-suppressive activity can be easily done using,
for example, one or more of the methods described below.
[0045] It will be appreciated that the unit content of active ingredient or ingredients
contained in an individual dose of each dosage form need not in itself constitute
an effective amount for treating MS since the necessary effective amount can be reached
by administration of a plurality of dosage units.
[0046] The pharmaceutical formulations of the present invention may include, as optional
ingredients, pharmaceutically acceptable vehicles, carriers, diluents, solubilizing
or emulsifying agents, and salts of the type that are well-known in the art. Nonlimiting
examples of such substances include 0.5N saline in distilled water for parenteral
use, lyophilized T-cell receptor or peptide diluted in lactose for oral use, adjuvants
such as alum or tenanus toxoid or MAPS (disclosed in
J.R. Tam et al., J. Exp. Med. 171:299-306, 1990; and
Tam, J.R. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 85:5409, 1988) for vaccination with peptides although larger peptide constructs such as whole TCR
may not need an adjuvant.
[0047] The preferred route of administration of the suppressive agents is in a parenteral
form including intraperitoneal, intravenous, intradermal and most preferably subcutaneous
administration routes. Preferred pharmaceutical formulations may comprise for example,
formulations containing between about 0.3 mg and about 200 mg of one or more of the
agents specific for MS.
[0048] In general, the VB12- or VB17-based peptide is introduced to a mammal in an amount
preferably ranging between about 0.3 mg per kg body weight of said mammal and about
200 mg per kg body weight of said mammal preferably administered once every 3 months
and may be administered in a single dosage form or multiple dosage forms. The exact
amount and frequency of administration to a patient is subject to optimization and
may vary depending on the stage, frequency of manifestation and severity of the patient's
disease and the physical condition of the patient, as is well known in the art. Such
optimization is preferably effected on a case-by-case basis. Customized therapy is
common for MS patients and thus, optimization of dosage represents ordinary experimentation.
One preferred method of optimizing dosage is as follows: T-cells are obtained from
a patient and cultured, the culture is expanded and T-cell DNA is collected.
[0049] The techniques described below in Examples 1-3 can be used to monitor the effectiveness
of the methods of the present invention and optimize the amount and frequency of administration
of the disease suppressive agents.
[0050] T-cells can be isolated from a patient's peripheral blood, amplified and cloned as
described in Examples 1-3 below (before and/or after treatment according to the present
invention) and probed for the presence of VB12+ and/or VB17+ T-cells using PCR amplification
with the specific VB primers shown in Table 2 below. A reduction or elimination of
VB12+ or VB17+ T-cells after treatment with VB12 and/or VB17 based peptides will provide
an objective measurement of a patient's disease status. Therefore, the exact amount
and frequency of administration of the agents of the present invention can be optimized.
[0051] Alternatively, antibodies (either polyclonal or monclonal) can be obtained directed
against the VB12 and/or VB17 polypeptides (using conventional techniques well known
and used in the art) to assay for the presence of VB12+ and/or VB17+ T-cells in a
patient's peripheral blood before and/or after treatment according to the present
invention.
[0052] When isolated, attenuated VB17+ or VB12+ T-cells are administered to a patient, either
prophylactically or for the treatment of active disease, the effective amounts can
be easily determined, for example as follows: An amount of such T-cells, e.g., 50
million, is administered to a patient. Two weeks later, T-cells are collected from
the patient and probed for the presence of T-cells expressing VB12 or VB17. If such
T-cells have been significantly reduced, the dosage is effective. The preferred route
of administration for this embodiment of the present invention is parenteral, and
most preferably subcutaneous.
[0053] As shown in the Examples below, reactivity with MBP residues 84-102 is associated
with the DR2 gene. The TCR VB gene used in three healthy DR2+ individuals was examined
(controls 1-3, Table 3). 5/5 cell lines from a normal DR2+ subject were VB17+, whereas
one of the two cell lines from another normal DR2+ was VB12+. These data show that
VB17 and VB12 are TCR recognition elements for this immunodominant region in MS patients
and in healthy DR2+ individuals.
[0054] The present invention is described further below in specific examples which are intended
to illustrate the present invention but not to determine the scope of protection.
EXAMPLE 1: TECHNIQUES
[0055] MBP was extracted from human brain tissue and purified on a CM-52 column using the
highest molecular weight peak (18kD) as described (
Chou, F.C.-H. et al J. Biol. Chem. 251: 2671, 1976). MBP peptides were synthesized using a solid phase method and were obtained from
a commercial laboratory (Bio-search Lab Inc., San Raphael, CA) and were purified by
high pressure liquid chromatography. The MBP peptide fragments used are set forth
below in Table 1.
TABLE 1
| MBP Amino Acid Residues |
Sequence |
MBP Amino Acid Residues |
Sequence |
| 1-20 : |
ASQKRPSQRHGSKYLATAST |
11-30 : |
GSKYLATASTMDHARHGFLP |
| 21-40 : |
MDHARHGFLPRHRDTGILDS |
31-50 : |
RHRDTGILDSIGRFFGGDRG |
| 41-60 : |
IGRFFGGRGAPKRGSGKDS |
51-70 : |
APKRGSGKDSHHPARTAHYG |
| 61-82 : |
HHPARTAHYGSLPQKSHGRT |
71-92 : |
SLPQKSHGRTQDENPVVHFF |
| 84-102 : |
DENPVVHFFKNIVTPRTPP |
93-112 : |
KNIVTPRTPPPSQGKGRGLS |
| 113-132 : |
LSRFSWGAEGQRPGFGYGGR |
124-142 : |
RPGFGYGGRASDYKSAHKG |
| 143-168 : |
FKGVDAQGTLSKIFKLGGRD |
|
|
[0056] T-cell receptor TCR VB gene usage was determined by polymerase chain reaction (PCR)
amplification using a panel of TCR VB primers followed by Southern blotting. T-cell
lines were established from peripheral blood mononuclear cells by two rounds of stimulation
with MBP followed by stimulation with an immunodominant human MBP peptide (amino acid
residues 84-102), immunodominance of which had been determined by proliferation assays
(as described in Example 2) using the Table 1 panel of 13 overlapping MBP peptides.
Following a third round of stimulation with their specific MBP peptide, RNA was extracted
from MBP-reactive T-cell culture pellets (20,000-50,000 cells) by extraction with
guanidium-isothiocyanate/phenol-chloroform and isopropanol precipitation in the presence
of carrier tRNA. Single-stranded cDNAs were synthesized using oligo-dT and AMV-reverse
transcriptase (both available commercially from Bethesda Research Laboratories, Gaithersburg,
MD). PCR (polymerase chain reaction as disclosed in
U.S. Patent Nos. 4,800,159 issued January 24, 1989;
4,683195 issued July 28, 1987; and
4,683,202 issued July 28, 1987) amplification was performed using a panel of 19 oligonucleotides (specific for published
TCR VB families -- VB 1-20, Table 2) corresponding to the CDR2 region of the TCR B-chain
and a CB (constant region of B chain) primer (Table 2) (as disclosed in
Tilinghast, J.P. et al., Science 233: 879, 1986;
Concannon, P. et al., Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 83: 6598, 1986;
Kimura, N. et al., J. Exp. Med. 164: 739, 1986;
Toyonaga, B. et al. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 82: 8624, 1985;
Kimura, N. et al., Eur. J. Immunol. 17: 375, 1987). Amplifications were done for thirty cycles (94°C 1 min., 55°C 2 min., 72°C 3 min.)
using 1 microgram of each primer in 50 microliter reactions. Amplified products were
separated in 1% agarose gels, transferred to nitrocellulose and Southern blots were
hybridized with an internal oligonucleotide TCR-CB probe (Table 2). Probes were endlabeled
with
32p gamma-ATP and T4 polynucleotide kinase (Bethesda Research Labs.) to a specific activity
of 10
8cpm/ug and hybridized in 6xSSC/5xDenhardt's/0.05% pyrophosphate/100ug/ml denatured
DNA/0.5% SDS for 18 hours at 37°C. Blots were washed at a final stringency of 6xSSC/70°C
and autoradiographed for 2-18 hours. T-cell lines that were positive for more than
two VB segments were considered not to be derived from a single MBP reactive T-cell
and therefore excluded from analysis.
[0057] For sequencing, amplifications of cDNAs were performed with a VB17 primer (Table
2) specific for the leader segment containing an internal Pst I restriction site.
Amplified DNA was treated with proteinase K, phenol/chloroform extracted, ethanol
precipitated and digested with restriction endonucleases Bgl II and Pst I (available
commercially, e.g., from Bethesda Research Labs.,
supra). Gel-purified DNA was ligated into M13 mp18 and single-stranded DNA was sequenced
by the dideoxy-method (
Sanger, F., et al., 1977, Proc. Nat'l. Acad. Sci., 74:5463). Negative controls were included during the procedure to test for possible contamination
of RNA samples or reagents used for cDNA synthesis and amplification. The VB, CB and
JB2.1 primer sequences used are set forth below in Table 2.
[0058] Amplified and non-amplified samples were handled separately, reagents were aliquoted
and tested for the presence of amplified material and negative controls were included
for different experimental steps (RNA isolation, cDNA synthesis, PCR amplification).
TABLE 2
| VB1 |
5'AAGAGAGAGCAAAAGGAAACATTCTTGAAAC3' |
| VB2 |
5'GCTCCAAGGCCACATACGAGCAAGGCGTCG3' |
| VB3 |
5'AAAATGAAAGAAAAGGAGATATTCCTGAG3' |
| VB4 |
5'CTGAGGCCACATATGAGAGTGGATTTGTCA3' |
| VB5 |
5'CAGAGAAACAAAGGAAACTTCCCTGGTCGA3' |
| VB6 |
5'GGGTGCGGCAGATGACTCAGGGCTGCCCAA3' |
| VB7 |
5'ATAAATGAAAGTGTGCCAAGTCGCTTCTCA3' |
| VB8 |
5'AACGTTCCGATAGATGATTCAGGGATGCCC3' |
| VB9 |
5'CATTATAAATGAAACAGTTCCAAATCGCTT3' |
| VB10 |
5'CTTATTCAGAAAGCAGAAATAATCAATGAG3' |
| VB11 |
5'TCCACAGAGAAGGGAGATCTTTCCTCTGAG3' |
| VB12 |
5'GATACTGACAAAGGAGAAGTCTCAGATGGC3' |
| VB14 |
5'GTGACTGATAAGGGAGATGTTCCTGAAGGG3' |
| VB15 |
5'GATATAAACAAAGGAGAGATCTCTGATGGA3' |
| VB16 |
5'CATGATAATCTTTATCGACGTGTTATGGGA3' |
| VB17 |
5'TTTCAGAAAGGAGATATAGCTGAAGGGTAC3' |
| VB18 |
5'GATGAGTCAGGAATGCCAAAGGAACGATTT3' |
| VB19 |
5'CAAGAAACGGAGATGCACAAGAAGCGATTC3' |
| VB20 |
5'ACCGACAGGCTGCAGGCAGGGGCCTCCAGC3' |
| CB |
5'GGCAGACAGGACCCTTGCTGGTAGGACAC3' |
| C-probe |
5'TTCTGATGGCTCAAACACAGCGACCTCGGG3' |
| VB17-Leader |
5'AGCAACCAGGTGCTCTGCAGTGTGGTCCTT3' |
| JB2.1 |
5'CCCTGGCCCGAAGAACTGCTCATTGTAGGA3' |
EXAMPLE 2: IDENTIFICATION OF VB GENE USAGE IN T-CELLS ISOLATED FROM MS PATIENTS
[0059] Two series of experiments were performed to test the validity of the above-described
approach. First, it was demonstrated that all Table 2 primers except VB20 were able
to amplify cDNA from peripheral blood T-cells (Figure 1). Secondly, the specificity
of PCR amplifications was examined by analysis of VB gene usage in 69 independent
T-cell clones previously established by single cell cloning with mitogen (such as
phytohemagglutin, -- "PHA" -- and interleukin-2). Due to the high cloning efficiencies
obtained, these clones provided a representative analysis of VB gene usage among peripheral
blood T-cells. TCR VB gene usage could be determined for 65/69 (94.2%) of these T-cell
clones indicating that a large proportion of the TCR VB repertoire was covered by
the VB primers. While 58 of these clones (84%) were positive for a single VB, 7 clones
(10.1%) were double-positive, possibly due to the presence of two rearranged and expressed
TCR VB genes.
[0060] The TCR VB gene usage was then analyzed in sixty-five MBP-specific T-cell lines established
from five patients with clinically-defined relapsing-remitting MS. Representative
Southern blots from MBP reactive T-cell lines are shown in Figure 1 and VB genes usage
for all cell lines analyzed are set forth in Table 3 below.
TABLE 3
| MBP PEPTIDE 84-102 REACTIVE T-CELL LINES |
| MULTIPLE SCLEROSIS |
| CELL LINE |
TCR VB |
CELL LINE |
TCR VB |
CELL LIME |
TCR VB |
| Patient 1 (DR2.DR7) |
HY.2C12 |
VB17,VB1 |
Cy.2C2 |
VB12 |
| HY.1B12 |
VB17 |
Hy.2E2 |
VB17,VB1 |
Cy. 3F6 |
VB12 |
| Hy.1G9 |
VB17 |
Hy.2E11 |
VB17,VB2 |
Cy.4C1 |
VB12 |
| Hy.1H7 |
VB17 |
Hy.3A11 |
VB17,VB2 |
Patient 3 (DR2,DR4) |
| Hy.2C9 |
VB17 |
Hy.2C8 |
VB17,VB11 |
Ns.2A5 |
VB1 |
| Hy.2E4 |
VB17 |
Hy.3B7 |
VB4 |
Ns.2C10 |
VB3,VB14 |
| Hy.2E6 |
VB17 |
Hy.3C3 |
VB4 |
Ns.2D11 |
VB5,VB7 |
| Hy.2F10 |
VB17 |
Hy.3C6 |
VB4 |
Ns.1G11 |
VB12,VB17 |
| By.2G5 |
VB17 |
Hy.2F11 |
VB7 |
Ns.2E2 |
VB12,VB17 |
| Hy.2G11 |
VB17 |
Hy.3B12 |
VB7 |
Patient 4 (DR2,DR7) |
| Hy.3A8 |
VB17 |
Hy.1H3 |
VB14 |
Fn.1M7 |
VB4 |
| Hy.3A10 |
VB17 |
Hy.2B2 |
VB14 |
Fn.3E17 |
VB3,VB5 |
| Hy.3B9 |
VB17 |
Hy.2H9 |
VB14 |
Fn.1E6 |
VB6,VB8 |
| Hy.3C7 |
VB17 |
|
|
Fn.1G6 |
VB17 |
| Hy.3G10 |
VB17 |
Patient 2 (DR2,DRw11) |
Patient 5 (DR3,DR4) |
| Hy.3F6 |
VB17 |
Cy.2H11 |
VB1,VB7 |
Tw.1B11 |
VB12 |
| Hy.3F7 |
VB17 |
Cy.3D2 |
VB1,VB7 |
Tw.2F3 |
VB12,VB17 |
| Hy.3F10 |
VB17 |
Cy.2C6 |
VB2 |
Tw.E10 |
VB17 |
| By.1A8 |
VB17 |
Cy.2G5 |
VB17 |
Tw.2E2 |
VB14 |
| CONTROLS |
| CELL LINE |
TCR VB |
CELL LINE |
TCR VB |
CELL LINE |
TCR VB |
| Control 1 (DR2,DR4) |
Control 2 (DR2) |
Control 4 (DR7, DRw11) |
| Rt.1A9 |
VB17 |
Hr.1B7 |
VB12 |
An.3E1 |
VB1,VB8 |
| Rt.3C1 |
VB17 |
Hr.1C9 |
VB5 |
An.3H3 |
VB8 |
| Rt.3G11 |
VB17 |
Control 3 (DR2) |
An.3C12 |
VB2 |
| Rt.3A3 |
VB17, VB14 |
Md.2A4 |
VB6,VB8 |
Control 5 (DR1,DR9) |
| Rt.3F1 |
VB17, VB14 |
Md.2F1 |
VB8,VB18 |
Cr.1B12 |
VB17,VB12 |
| MBP PEPTIDE 143-168 REACTIVE T-CELL LINES |
| MULTIPLE SCLEROSIS |
| CELL LINE |
TCR VB |
CELL LINE |
TCR VB |
| Patient 2 (DR2, DRw11) |
Patient 3 (DR2, DR4) |
| Cy.1E6 |
VB14 |
Ns.2D6 |
VB3 |
| Cy.2B12 |
VB14 |
Patient 4 (DR2, DR7) |
| Cy.2E2 |
VB14 |
Fn.1H5 |
VB4 |
| Cy.3G10 |
VB14 |
Fh.2A10 |
VB4 |
| Cy.3H10 |
VB14,VB8 |
Fn.2A5 |
VB2 |
| Cy.4C10 |
VB14,VB17 |
Patient 5 (DR3, DR4) |
| Cy.1C12 |
VB12 |
Tw.2C9 |
VB12 |
| Cy.1E9 |
VB7 |
|
|
| Cy.3F9 |
VB1 |
|
|
| CONTROLS |
| CELL LINE |
TCR VB |
CELL LINE |
TCR VB |
| Control 3 (DR2) |
Control 6 (DR1, DR7) |
| Hr.2E10 |
VB3, VB5 |
Bn.2G1 |
VB12 |
| Hr.3E9 |
VB7 |
Bn.3D6 |
VB12 |
| |
|
Bn.3C10 |
VB5,VB8 |
[0061] Fifty-one of these lines reacted with MBP residues 84-102, while fourteen T-cell
lines were specific for MBP residues 143-168. Thirty-one MBP T-cell lines reactive
to MBP amino acid residues 84-102 were analyzed from MS patient Hy (patient 1, Table
3). Twenty-three of these T-cell lines (74%) were found to use the VB17 gene segment,
while eight other cell lines were restricted by either VB2, VB7 or VB14 gene segments.
These results indicate that VB17 is the major recognition element in T-cell lines
from this MS patient reactive with MBP residues 84-102. VB17 usage was also found
among 6/20 T-cell lines examined from four other patients (patients 2-5, Table 3).
The second TCR VB that was used by T-cell lines among these four patients was VB12
which was found in 7/20 T-cell lines reactive with MBP residues 84-102 (Table 3, Figure
1). This VB happens to be homologous to the mouse VB8.2 which is the predominant TCR
used among encephalitogenic T-cells in mice and rats (
Burns, F.R. et al., J. Exp. Med. 169: 27, 1989).
[0062] MS patient Cy expressed both the DR2 and DRw11 antigens and thus had T-cells that
recognized either the immunodominant MBP region (84-102 residues) or the MBP 143-168
residues. This provided the opportunity to compare TCR VB usage among T-cells reacting
to different MBP determinants (Figure 1). Of seven lines proliferating to MBP residues
84-102, three expressed VB12 and one expressed VB17 (Table 3). In contrast, 6/9 T-cell
lines recognizing the MBP residues 143-168 used VB14 and only one line each used the
TCR VB12 and VB17 TCR genes (Table 3). Southern blot analysis of five T-cell lines
reactive with MBP residues 84-102 (VB12: Cy.2C2, Cy.3F6) or MBP residues 143-168 (VB14:Cy.1E6,
Cy.2B12, Cy.2E2) are shown in Figure 1.
[0063] While VB12/VB13 is relatively common among normal peripheral blood T-cells (approximately
18%), VB17 is significantly less frequent (approximately 3%), as assessed by quantitative
PCR. In contrast, VB17 was found in 34/63 (53.9%) of T-cell lines reactive with MBP
residues 84-102, while it was only present in 3/32 (9.4%) of TCR VB genes in random
mitogen derived T-cell clones obtained by single-cell cloning from a normal individual
(
Moretta, A. et al., J. Epp. Med. 157: 743, 1983;
Hafler, D. A., et al., J. Exp. Med. 167: 1313, 1988). These data indicate that the VB17 TCR is selectively involved in the recognition
of the immunodominant MBP 84-102 region.
[0064] In order to show that the TCR gene segment identified by PCR was the VB encoding
gene used to recognize the MBP peptide, two VB17 positive T-cell lines (Hy.2H9 and
Hy.2G5) were cloned by limiting dilution (Moretta,
supra.). 11/11 individual clones established from these two cell lines, which were reactive
with both MBP and MBP residues 84-102, were VB17+. Three of these clones were further
analyzed using the complete panel of VB primers and were all found to be negative
for the other VB segments.
[0065] The VB sequences of four T-cell lines from patient Hy were found to be 100% homologous
to the published VB17 sequence (as disclosed in
Kimura, N., et al., Eur. J. Immunol. 17: 375, 1987). This sequence analysis confirms that specific VB segments were indeed amplified
using this approach. Analysis of the VDJ (diversity-junctional) sequence indicated
that all four of these T-cells used the same junctional JB2.1 segment and that 3/4
of them had the same VDJ sequence (Table 2). To determine how frequently the JB2.1
gene segment was used by VB17+ T-cells, the DNAs from 20 cell lines from MS patient
Hy were amplified using the VB17 primer combination with a CB primer or a JB2.1 primer
(Figure 2). All of these lines were found to be positive for VB17 as well as JB2.1
gene segments, while the negative controls (RNA extracted from all cell lines and
not converted to cDNA, and reagents used for cDNA synthesis and amplification) were
negative by PCR and Southern blotting. These data show a strong selection for the
VB17-JB2.1 sequence elements in with MBP residues 84-102 reactive T-cell lines derived
from patient By.
[0066] Two other T-cell lines using the VB17 TCR identified by PCR analysis and recognizing
MBP residues 84-102 from MS patients Fn and Ns were sequenced and compared to sequences
of TCR VB from MS patient Hy (Table 3). While the VB17 gene segment sequence was identical
among T-cells reactive MBP residues 84-102 from the three patients, different JB sequence
elements were found. Three results show a shared VB gene usage in T-cells recognizing
an immunodominant MBP peptide between different individuals. In contrast, shared JB
gene segment usage was found among T-cells derived from the same individual but not
between different individuals.
[0067] Four of the five patients studied were positive for the disease-associated DR2 allele,
while patient Tw was HLA-DR3, DR4. Nevertheless, three VB12/VB17 restricted cell lines
were present among four lines analyzed from this MS patient (Table 3), indicating
that shared MHC Class II antigens may not be mandatory for shared TCR VB gene usage
with respect to recognition of MBP peptide 84-102.
EXAMPLE 3: IDENTIFICATION OF THE MAJOR IMMUNODOMINANT REGION OF HUMAN MBP
[0068] A rapid T-cell cloning technique was used to examine whether there were immunodominant
epitopes on human MBP reactive with Class II MHC phenotypes and the frequency of such
reactivity. A total of 15,824 short term T-cell lines were generated from 51 subjects
by culturing peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PMN) with purified MBP (obtained
as in Example 1 above) followed 3 days later, and then every 3-4 days, by the addition
of Interleukin-2 (IL-2) and Interleukin-4 (IL-4) (Genzyme, Boston, MA). On Day 13
of culture, an aliquot from each line was tested for reactivity to MBP. Lines reactive
to MBP were then tested for reactivity to overlapping oligopeptide 20-mers encompassing
the human MBP sequence as shown in Table 1 above. For MHC restriction experiments,
lines reactive to an MBP peptide were restimulated for two more cycles, first with
MBP and then with the specific MBP fragment recognized by that line. In a subgroup
of patients, the frequency of T-cells recognizing proteolipid protein (PLP), another
major encephalitogenic central nervous system antigen, was investigated.
[0069] MBP and PLP frequency analysis was performed on patients with definite, relapsing-remitting
MS (as diagnosed by Magnetic Resonance Imaging -- "MRI" -- and clinical examination),
as well as on subjects with other neurologic diseases and normal subjects (all age
and sex matched to the MS patients).
[0070] The results are shown in Table 3A below.
TABLE 3A
| |
|
SEX(%) |
MHC(%) |
#Ag REACTIVE LINES/ TOTAL # LINES |
MEAN FREQUENCY OF Ag REACTIVE LINES |
| |
AGE |
(M/F) |
CR2 |
DR4 |
DRw11 |
DQw1 |
MBP |
PLP |
MBP |
PLP |
| MULTTPLE SCLEROSLS (n=23) |
34.2+1.4 |
35/65 |
60.9 |
26.1 |
13.0 |
78.2 |
554/7746 |
20/432 |
7.18±2.38 |
3.34±1.56 |
| OTHER NEUROLOGIC DISEASE (n=10) |
38.7±3.2 |
43/57 |
14.3 |
0.0 |
42.9 |
85.7 |
118/2880 |
3/384 |
4.10±1.04 |
0.90±4.62 |
| NORMAL (n=6) |
30.3±1.5 |
50/50 |
16.7 |
0.0 |
50.0 |
66.6 |
73/1742 |
ND |
4.70±1.58 |
ND |
| DR2+ CONTROLS (n=6) |
32.0±2.9 |
50/50 |
100 |
16.7 |
0.0 |
100 |
53/1728 |
ND |
3.08±2.06 |
ND |
[0071] Patients with MS were caucasian and had well- characterized relapsing remitting disease
with at least two exacerbations within the previous 24 months and positive lesions
on Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) at the time of blood drawing. Subjects with other
central nervous system diseases had the following diagnoses: 1-3 weeks after either
cerebrovascular accident [4] or brain trauma with CNS hemorrhage [4]; metastatic brain
tumor [2]. The total number of T-cell lines reactive with either MBP or PLP and the
total number of T-cell lines generated are shown in Table 3A ("Ag" means "antigen").
In addition, the frequencies of MBP- and PLP- reactive lines were calculated separately
for each subject by dividing the number of MBP-reactive lines by the total number
of lines generated and the mean value ± SEM are given.
[0072] While the frequency of MBP reactive lines was slightly higher in subjects with MS
as compared to the other subjects, this was not statistically significant. There was
more reactivity to PLP in patients with MS as compared to subjects with other neurologic
diseases, but this did also not reach statistical significance.
[0073] Of a total of 302 cell lines from patients with MS that could be expanded and confirmed
to react with MBP on repeated analysis, 140 (46.4%) reacted with MBP residues 84-102.
In the control groups, 11 of a total of 100 MBP reactive T-cell lines (11.0%) recognized
this MBP peptide. The actual frequency of T-cells derived from the peripheral blood
that reacted with each MBP peptide for each individual subject was calculated. The
mean values for patients with MS and the control subjects are shown in the next-to-rightmost
column of Table 3A.
[0074] 50,000 T-line cells were plated in triplicate with 50,000 irradiated APC, MNC (mononuclear
cells) (
Hafler, D. A., et al., J. Exp. Med. 167: 1313, 1988) for 72 hours in round bottom 96-well microtiter plates and wells were pulsed with
[
3H]-thymidine for the last 18 hours of culture. APC MNC were either cultured alone,
pulsed with 100 micrograms/ml of synthetic MBP peptide 84-102, (determined to be the
optimal concentration of peptide to induce proliferation), or pulsed with 100 micrograms/ml
of MBP. The average counts per minute (CPM) value for triplicate wells are shown in
Table 4. DR and DQw haplotypes are given and haplotypes common with the patient (top
line), who was positive for DR2, DR7, DQw1, DQw3, are underlined.
[0075] Proliferation of T-cell lines using a panel of different mononuclear cells (MNC)
as antigen presenting cells (APC) are shown. Five T-cell lines reactive to MBP amino
acid residues 84-102 from subject Hy were expanded by repeated cycles of stimulation
with autologous irradiated MNC, pulsed with synthetic MBP peptide 84-102 and examined
for recognition of this region of MBP.
[0076] For these studies, the panel of five T cell lines reactive with MPB residues 84-102
were plated with autoautologous APC MNC, as above, in the presence of monoclonal antibodies
(mAbs) (final concentration of 1:100) recognizing different MHC Class II gene products.
(The nomenclature used for the antibodies is from the Tenth International Histocompatibility
Workshop; their specificity is also given). The results are set forth in Table 5 below.
TABLE 4
| |
|
T cell lines from patient Hy |
| MHC of |
Phenotype APC |
1A8 |
2C9 |
2E11 |
2H9 |
3A10 |
| DR |
DQw |
APC |
MBP |
peptide 84-102 |
APC |
MBP |
peptide 84-102 |
APC |
MBP |
peptide 84-102 |
APC |
MBP |
peptide 84-102 |
APC |
MBP |
peptide 84-102 |
| 2.7 |
1.3 |
32 |
21,192 |
10,747 |
83 |
3,263 |
14,991 |
148 |
18,593 |
30,368 |
169 |
2,797 |
10,444 |
139 |
6,887 |
24,411 |
| 2 |
1 |
83 |
56 |
32 |
82 |
78 |
112 |
217 |
52,939 |
49,399 |
636 |
327 |
548 |
23 |
28 |
26 |
| 4.7 |
2.3 |
32 |
26 |
53 |
45 |
55 |
142 |
37 |
167 |
81 |
226 |
258 |
263 |
306 |
719 |
915 |
| 3 |
2 |
46 |
32 |
52 |
43 |
44 |
110 |
101 |
98 |
349 |
769 |
402 |
1,973 |
23 |
31 |
100 |
| 3.10 |
1.2 |
35 |
30,737 |
49,144 |
158 |
25 |
80 |
36 |
58 |
42 |
49 |
54 |
46 |
42 |
22,823 |
31,121 |
| 2.7 |
1.2 |
38 |
40 |
47 |
43 |
39 |
43 |
78 |
53,441 |
32,357 |
261 |
190 |
289 |
33 |
19 |
36 |
| 7.wll |
2.7 |
44 |
39 |
54 |
57 |
124 |
259 |
34 |
25 |
33 |
51 |
58 |
97 |
967 |
1,214 |
2,744 |
[0077] The frequency of peptide specific cell lines from normal subjects and other neurologic
disease controls were virtually identical and thus combined for analysis. The mean
frequency of T-cell lines from subjects with MS that were selectively reactive to
MBP residues 84-102 was higher as compared with controls (Figure 3). Significant but
less striking increases in reactivity to MBP residues 61-82 and 124-142 were also
observed in MS patients, while both MS and control subjects showed high frequencies
of T-cell lines reactive with MBP residues 143-168. The DR2, DQw1 haplotype was very
infrequent in the control subjects and more common in patients with MS (Table 4).
An association was observed between the DR2 phenotype and both the proportion or the
frequency of T-cell lines reactive to MBP residues 84-102 (Figure 4).
[0078] To determine if T-cell reactivity to MBP residues 84-102 was associated with DR2,
DQw1 expression in non-MS subjects, an additional 6 normal subjects with DR2, DQw1
phenotype were investigated. The results are shown in Figure 4.
[0079] A DR2 association was also observed among controls in terms of the proportion of
T-cell lines reactive with MBP residues 84-102 (DR2+ controls, 31.0±10-.8%; DR2-,
10.1±0.4%), though the total frequency of lines reactive with this region of MBP was
less than that in patients with MS (Figure 4). Though DQw1 is in linkage dissociation
with DR2 as well as with DR1 and DRw10, independent analysis of peptide reactivity
revealed no association with DQw1 phenotype expression.
[0080] The DRw11 phenotype was more common in controls than in subjects with MS (Table 3A).
DRw11 was positively associated with the frequency of lines reactive to MBP residues
142-168 in patients with MS and controls, but not with the frequency of lines reactive
with MBP residues 84-102 (Figure 2). Reactivity to MBP residues 31-50, which was predominantly
observed in control subjects, was associated with DRw11. Other MEC associations were
not observed.
[0081] The MHC association with residues of the T-cell lines reactive with an immunodominant
MBP epitope was determined. The results are set forth in Table 5 below. More specifically,
it was determined whether the MHC haplotypes were used to present antigen in the T-cell
lines reactive with an immunodominant MBP epitope.
Table 5
| |
T-cell lines from patient Hy |
| |
|
1A8 |
2C9 |
2E11 |
2H9 |
3A10 |
| |
APC alone |
32 |
83 |
39 |
50 |
139 |
| |
no mAb |
10,747 |
14,991 |
3,325 |
8,659 |
24,411 |
| mAb specificity |
control mAb |
11,375 |
15,322 |
4,131 |
8,156 |
27,363 |
| anti-DR |
PL8 |
11,051 |
41 |
31 |
142 |
25,016 |
| |
L.243 |
16,792 |
586 |
22 |
36 |
21,148 |
| |
65P4.1 |
19,119 |
405 |
46 |
92 |
26,412 |
| anti-DQ |
1A3 |
4,851 |
11,444 |
2,102 |
5,446 |
15,714 |
| |
Tu22 |
1,189 |
13,442 |
1,073 |
7,661 |
13,488 |
| |
Leu10 |
1,128 |
14,924 |
2,255 |
7,678 |
13,090 |
| anti-DP |
B7121 |
7,917 |
15,922 |
2,337 |
6,689 |
23,452 |
| anti-DR+DP |
Tu35 |
13,606 |
75 |
21 |
42 |
27,104 |
[0082] Monoclonal antibody blocking studies of five T-cell lines reactive with MBP residues
84-102 suggested that both DR and DQ molecules could function as restricting elements.
Among clones blocked by anti-DR mAb, clone 2E11 proliferated in response to MBP residues
84-102 with the panel of DR2+ APC while 2C9 and 2H9 proliferated only with autologous
APC (Table 5). The recognition of peptide by clones 1A8 and 3A10, which were partially
blocked by anti-DQ mAbs was restricted to APC from the responder and one of two APC
donor subjects expressing DQw1.
[0083] To investigate further the relationship between MHC expression and frequency of T-cell
reactivity to immunodominant MBP epitopes, a family with one afflicted sibling expressing
both DR2 and DRw11 phenotypes was studied.
[0084] The family members of an MS patient expressing the DR2, DQw1; DRw11, DRw52, DQw1
Class II MHC haplotypes were examined for the frequency of T-cell lines reactive with
MBP residues 84-102 and 143-168.
[0085] A total of 1,728 individual T-cell lines were generated from both parents and 4 siblings
and the number of lines reactive with either MBP peptide 84-102 or 143-168 were determined.
[0086] 2x10
5 MNC in each of 288 wells (three 96 well round bottom plates) were cultured with MBP
(10 micrograms/ml) as outlined above for each subject. On day 16, each T-cell line
was analyzed for reactivity to synthetic peptides corresponding to the MBP residues
84-102 and 143-168. The number of lines reactive with each peptide (stimulation index
SI>3, delta CPM>500) generated per subject are shown. The actual stimulation indices
were generally >20. P1 and P2=parents; S1-S3=siblings. The results are set forth in
Table 6 below.
TABLE 6
| |
PATIENT |
P1 |
P2 |
S1 |
S2 |
S3 |
| |
|
DR4 |
|
DR4 |
DR4 |
|
| |
DR2 |
DRw53 |
DR2 |
DRw53 |
DRw53 |
DR2 |
| |
DQw1 |
DQw3 |
DQw1 |
DQw3 |
DQw3 |
DQw1 |
| |
DRw11 |
DRw11 |
DRw6 |
DRw6 |
DRw6 |
DRw4 |
| |
DRw52 |
DRw52 |
DRw52 |
DRw52 |
DRw52 |
DRw53 |
| |
DQw1 |
DQw1 |
DQw1 |
DQw1 |
DQw1 |
DQw3 |
| MBP peptide |
|
|
|
|
|
|
| 84-102 |
49 |
1 |
4 |
6 |
1 |
7 |
| 143-168 |
41 |
14 |
0 |
3 |
2 |
2 |
[0087] The DR2+, DRw11+ patient had a high frequency of T-cell lines reactive to both MBP
residues 84-102 and 143-168. The DRw11+ parent preferentially recognized MBP residues
143-168, while the DR2+ parent preferentially recognized MBP residues 84-102. The
frequency of MBP peptide reactive lines, however, was lower than that of the patient.
One sibling was DR2+ and preferentially recognized MBP residues 84-102. Of two HLA
identical siblings with DR4, DQw3/DRw6, DQw1, one reacted to MBP peptide 84-102 whereas
the other did not. Although DQw1 may restrict recognition of MBP residues 84-102,
other factors such as inherited TCR polymorphism may have influenced T-cell reactivity
to the MBP autoantigen in one of the DR4, DQw3/DRw6, DQw1 siblings. This family linkage
analysis suggested that optimum recognition of immunodominant MBP epitopes requires
specific Class II MHC alleles both in patients with MS and in controls. In total,
these studies indicate that although control subjects expressing DR2 appear to preferentially
recognize the same MBP determinant as compared to DR2+ MS patients, their frequency
in the blood is less than that of patients with MS.
EXAMPLE 4: SEQUENCING OF VB17 TCR
[0089] It should be noted above that the VB17 sequence of all 4 T-cell lines established
from MS patient By were 100% homologous to the published VB17 sequence.
[0090] The following is a concordance between the 3-letter and the 1-letter codes for aminoacids.
It is provided for convenience.
Aspartic acid
(Asp, D)
Glutamic acid
(Glu, E)
Lysine
(Lys, K)
Arginine
(Arg, R)
Histidine
(His, H)
Tyrosine
(Tyr, Y)
Cysteine
(Cys, C)
Asparagine
(Asn, N)
Glutamine
(Gln, Q)
Serine
(Ser, S)
Threonine
(Thr, T)
Glycine
(Gly, G)
Alanine
(Ala, A)
Valine
(Val, V)
Leucine
(Leu, L)
Isoleucine
(Ile, I)
Methionine
(Met, M)
Proline
(Pro, P)
Phenylalanine
(Phe, F)
Tryptophan
(Trp, W)