[0001] The present invention relates to a composition for imparting flame retardant properties
to cellulosic fabrics and fibres. The invention also includes a method of making such
a composition and a process for applying the flame retardant composition to a textile.
[0002] Many methods of imparting flame retardant properties to fabrics are known. More recently,
awareness has increased of the fire hazard of various home furnishings such as curtains
and upholstery fabric and although there are many known methods for imparting flame
retardant properties to textiles, various problems are associated with them. In addition,
recent very high standards of performance have been set, including British Standard
Nos. 5852, 5651, 7176, 4303, 1006 and 5690. Many previously known methods do not fulfil
these requirements.
[0003] One of the most commonly used flame retarding materials for treating fabrics is decabromodiphenyl
oxide both in its own right, and in admixture with antimony trioxide which is also
a well known flame retarding material. Compositions including these compounds are
generally applied to fabric as a back-coating to produce a barrier effect. However,
this type of coating is not ideal because the back-coating is usually opaque and white,
the treated fabric is usually objectionably stiff and dry cleaning is not usually
possible without destroying the flame retardant properties of the fabric.
[0004] Such a composition is described in FR-A-2099391 where back coating flame retarding
coating compositions are described for use in vehicle security inflatable bodies.
Optional flame retarding materials for use in the composition comprise inorganic halides
and antimony trioxide but not in combination. The preferred flame retarding materials
are phosphates.
[0005] Antimony trioxide is also a well known flame retarding component. It is also known
to use antimony trioxide as the only flame-retardant component in a composition for
application to textile fabrics. One such composition is described in US 3,014,000.
The composition described comprises antimony trioxide, a composite plasticiser, and
a vinyl polymer such as vinyl chloride/vinylidene chloride copolymer. The plasticiser,
which contains at least 15% by weight chlorine is included for a soft feel on the
fabric and may be, for example, a chlorinated paraffin, an alkyl ester of an aliphatic
or aromatic dicarboxylic acid or phosphoric acid.
[0006] One other flame retarding composition commonly used is known as "Pyrovatex" (Trade
Mark) which is a dimethyl phosphonate type resin, usually cured using phosphoric acids.
Although this product results in finished fabrics which have a relatively soft finish,
its use has many disadvantages. During its application, toxic formaldehyde vapours
are produced and therefore its use is undesirable. In order to operate a flame retarding
treatment using such a composition, additional ventilation facilities are required,
and must be provided in the work place. Furthermore, the treated fabric is usually
acidic which results in a much reduced tear and tensile strength of the fabric.
[0007] In treating cellulosic materials with a flame retardant, one other undesirable result
which often occurs is that the flame retardants tend to discolour or darken the treated
cellulosic substrate and/or dyes/pigments. This observation is particularly noticeable
on printed metallics such as golds and silvers. The discolouring effects by the flame
retardant are particularly problematic because they are often dependent upon the type
of dyes/pigments used on the various fabrics. For example, the colour difference effect
on pigment print may not be the same as the effect on for example vat dyes.
[0008] A water soluble composition useful as a flame retardant for cellulosic material is
disclosed in US 4,888,136. The composition comprises ammonium bromide and a water-soluble
aluminium salt of an organic hydroxy acid. The composition is directed in particular
to the treatment of paper products although textiles are also mentioned. The invention
is based on the unexpected finding that a combination of aluminium salt with ammonium
bromide produces a synergistic effect.
[0009] In DD 146,069 flame proofing using an aqueous solution of ammonium bromide with borax
is described. However, this use is described as only being useful for articles which
are not normally washed. Although the finish obtained is flame proof and does not
leave a visible deposit or matt finish, which is detrimental to the appearance of
cellulosic articles, the flame retardancy is destroyed by washing the cellulosic article.
[0010] In GB 2,048,972, a PVC-free flame retardant for finishing mixed polyester/cellulose
articles is described which comprises a chlorine donor and antimony trioxide in a
specified ratio. The discussion of the prior art states that processes for providing
a "wash resistant" flame retardant finish on cellulosic material, using halogen donors
(such as chlorinated paraffins, polyvinyl chloride and bromide) in conjunction with
antimony trioxide have long been known. There is no description of any particular
particle size requirement and no description of specific compositions for providing
a successful fire retarding treatment for cellulosic materials.
[0011] Ammonium bromide is also described as a suitable flame retardant treatment in GB
1,291,133 for producing disposable fabrics for medical use or for clothing.
[0012] Historically, ammonium bromide and other halides have been much more commonly known
as flame proofing components for polymeric materials and in particular, for rubber.
In JP 62112639 a flame retardant for synthetic resin is obtained by a coating of ammonium
chloride or ammonium bromide with antimony trioxide. In JP 60235851 ammonium chloride
or bromide with antimony trioxide is used for manufacturing a flame resistant polyolefin.
[0013] There is still a need for a highly effective flame retarding composition which may
be applied to cellulosic based substrates without destroying the natural soft handle,
the strength of the fabric and which will retain the flame retardant properties after
repeated dry-cleaning or after being soaked in water.
[0014] The present invention comprises a novel composition which produces particularly effective
flame retardancy and which overcomes the problems of the prior art compositions.
[0015] In accordance with the present invention an aqueous composition for imparting flame
retardant properties to a cellulosic substrate is provided, which comprises an inorganic
halide, an oxide of antimony having an average particle size no greater than 2.0 µm,
a binding agent, a plasticiser and a surface modifier.
[0016] In addition, the present invention is particularly advantageous because use of an
aqueous based composition provides flame retardancy throughout the material and does
not act merely as a barrier. Furthermore, the composition of the invention provides
a clear finish flame retardancy treatment which does not significantly affect the
appearance of the fabric, unlike the known flame retardancy treatment compositions.
[0017] The inorganic halide is preferably an ammonium halide and most preferably is ammonium
bromide. The halide is generally included in the composition at a concentration of
from 50 to 500 g/ℓ and preferably from 100 to 300 g/ℓ. The inorganic halide may be
used as either a solid or as a suspension or solution.
[0018] The oxide of antimony may be antimony trioxide or tetraoxide but is preferably antimony
pentoxide. It may be in a hydrated or non-hydrated form. Although antimony oxide up
to a particle size of approximately 2 µm is still effective and economical, generally,
the particle size of the antimony oxide is no greater than 0.5µm as it has been found
that this prevents pigmentation of the fabric surface and ensures formation of a transparent
finish. Preferably the average particle size is no greater than 0.1µm and most preferably,
the particle size is from 0.01 to 0.05 µm because this ensures greater potential antimony
interaction. Antimony pentoxide is preferred because it can be obtained having the
very small particle size preferred for the present invention. It is well known that
to produce antimony trioxide to such small particle size incurs significant manufacturing
time and cost. The antimony oxide may be used as a solid powder but it is preferably
used as a colloidal suspension in water. Although colloidal antimony trioxide can
also be obtained, for best results, the antimony oxide is most preferably hydrated
antimony pentoxide, in the form of an aqueous colloidal suspension. Although antimony
pentoxide contains a lower relative amount of antimony then antimony trioxide and
therefore could be expected to be less favourable , we have found that it provides
especially good flame retardant properties, especially at the preferred low particle
sizes. Preferably, in order to ensure a transparent finish the refractive index of
the antimony oxide is as close to 1 as possible.
[0019] The antimony oxide is generally included in the composition in an amount of from
25 to 400 g/ℓ and preferably from 25 to 150 g/ℓ.
[0020] As the binding agent, one or more conventional binding agents which are well known
throughout the industry can be used. The binding agent can be one or more of a wide
variety of polymers and copolymers. However, we have found vinylidene chloride based
polymers and admixtures thereof, or for example copolymers of vinyl chloride and ethylene,
are eminently suitable. In addition to their primary role in binding other active
flame retardant components to the cellulosic material, they also contribute towards
the fire retardant effect of the composition by virtue of their halogen content. Other
binders may be used, for example acrylate based polymers, which may act solely as
film-forming agents and bind the active flame retardant components to the cellulose.
Generally, a 10-70% by weight aqueous emulsion of the binder is used for ease of handling,
but solid materials may be used if so desired. The proportion of binder used in the
composition would typically be in the amount of from 200 to 600 g/ℓ and preferably
in the range 300 to 500 g/ℓ.
[0021] The plasticiser, may be for example as described in US 3014000. It is preferably
a halogenated paraffin, and most preferably a chlorinated paraffin. Again, by virtue
of their halogen content, these chlorinated paraffins contribute to the flame retardant
effect. Particularly suitable chlorinated paraffins contain between 25 and 75% by
weight of chlorine, and more preferably between 35 and 50% by weight. Paraffins having
a carbon chain length of from C₈ to C₁₄ have been found to be particularly suitable.
[0022] On curing, the binding agent binds the antimony oxide and inorganic halide to the
cellulosic substrate, thereby providing the substrate with flame retardant properties.
[0023] The surface modifier can be any of a number of known compounds and is included in
the composition to impart a water resistant elastomeric finish to the substrate. Many
suitable elastomeric materials exist, for example, silicones and polyurethanes which
can be cross-linked. Preferably, the surface modifier comprises a blend of compounds,
for example based on polysiloxane(s) in which the silicon is substituted with two
groups which may be the same or different, chosen from alkyl, aralkyl, aryl or hydrogen
with the exception that where hydrogen is one substituent, the two groups must be
different. The blend may be based on polydialkyl siloxane(s). The alkyl, aryl or aralkyl
groups themselves may or may not be substituted. Preferred silicones are the compounds
where the alkyl group is either methyl, ethyl, propyl or butyl groups, which may be
substituted with one or more groups such as amino, hydroxy, alkoxy or cyano. Most
preferably, the surface modifier is a reactive amino siloxane in which the amino substituent
is positioned on the alkyl group i.e. the silicon is substituted with at least one
aminoalkyl group, in which the amino group(s) may be primary and/or secondary amino
groups, for example N(2-aminoethyl)-2-ethylamine groups.
[0024] It has been found that the addition of such a surface modifier significantly improves
the resistance to dry-cleaning and water soaking, of the treated cellulose. The addition
of a surface modifier also ensures that the final treated cellulosic substrate retains
a soft handle. Generally, the total amount of the surface modifier may be from 5 to
250 g/ℓ, but more preferably in the range 5 to 150 g/ℓ. Where the surface modifier
comprises more than one compound, for example, more than one type of siloxane, compounds
in the modifier may be in any ratio. Preferred ratios are dependant on the type and
amounts of the other ingredients in the flame retardant composition.
[0025] Other optional ingredients, in the composition, include afterglow inhibiting agents
such as zinc borate, aluminium trihydrate and boric acid esters, handle modifiers
such as silicone and non-silicone softeners, perfumes, lubricants, brightening agents,
resins, bleaching compounds, thickening additives, anti-bleed agents, anti-leaching
compounds, viscosity modifiers, water/oil repellant compounds such as fluorochemical
additives and colouring agents etc. These types of additives are well known in the
industry and thus are used routinely.
[0026] The cellulosic substrates which are to be treated by the composition of the present
invention include cotton, viscose and all other cellulosic materials, including fibre
blends. Blends including non-cellulosic material are also suitable substrates. For
example, polyester-cotton and/or polyester viscose blends comprising from 5 to 95%
by weight cellulosic material, preferably at least 20% cellulosic, most preferably
at least 50% cellulosic material. Typically blends contain up to 80% cellulosic material.
The flame retardancy treatment of the invention is particularly directed to treatment
of woven or other formed fabrics, but may also be used on suitable non-woven substrates.
In particular, it is intended for use on fixed and loose upholstery fabrics and covers.
[0027] The process for the manufacture of the flame retardant composition generally requires
high-shear mixing to intimately blend the individual ingredients. It has been found
that the order of addition of the ingredients can affect the performance of the flame
retardant effect, but is generally governed by ease of handling on the production
scale. However, pH control is an important factor during the manufacture.
[0028] The preferred method of manufacture of the composition according to the invention
comprises firstly, mixing a suspension of small particle size antimony oxide, preferably
antimony pentoxide with water. Secondly, the pH of the mixture is monitored and adjusted
to between 7.5 and 9.5, preferably approximately pH 8 to 9, using a base.
[0029] The inorganic halide is then mixed into the composition.
[0030] Following addition of the inorganic halide and mixing of the composition until a
substantially homogeneous composition results, the pH of the composition is preferably
once again monitored and adjusted to the final pH of 6.0 to 9.0, if necessary.
[0031] In choosing the base for adjusting the pH, the main consideration is whether the
particular base chosen will have an adverse effect on the dyes or resins in the cellulosic
substrate to be treated. For example, it has been found that sodium hydroxide may
produce a yellowing cast on the fabric and is therefore not preferred. The most preferred
base for adjusting the pH at one or stages is ammonia which may be in the form of
ammonia gas, by bubbling through the solution or, preferably, in the form of aqueous
solution of ammonia (ammonium hydroxide). Ammonia is preferred because it produces
substantially no discolouration on the final fabric.
[0032] The antimony oxide/ammonium halide mixture formed is then mixed with the binding
agent and plasticiser and surface modifier in any order of addition. Preferably, the
plasticiser and inorganic halide/antimony oxide mixture are mixed vigorously to obtain
a substantially homogeneous composition. This is because the halide/antimony oxide
mixture is viscous and addition of the plasticiser dilutes the mixture to promote
ease of handling of the composition. Because the aqueous antimony oxide/halide mixture
is not generally miscible with the plasticiser, an emulsion is formed. Additional
dispersants/surfactants may be included to further increase the stability of the emulsion,
if desired.
[0033] Preferably the binder is then added to the composition, preferably followed by high
shear mixing. As the binder is mixed in the composition some reaction occurs with
the plasticiser and the viscosity of the composition increases.
[0034] After addition and blending of all the ingredients, including any optional textile
performance auxiliaries, as described above, the composition will generally be a white,
slightly viscous liquid, having a pH preferably in the range 6.0 to 9.0, and most
preferably between 7.0 and 8.0. The application of the composition having a pH outside
the range of 6.0 to 9.0, to cellulosic substrates will have an adverse effect on the
substrate. This is usually exhibited in a reduced tear and tensile strength of the
substrate.
[0035] The present invention also includes a process for imparting flame retarding properties
to a cellulosic substrate comprising contacting the cellulosic substrate with a composition
comprising an inorganic halide, an oxide of antimony having particle size no greater
than 2.0 µm, a binding agent, a plasticiser and a surface modifier.
[0036] At present, the commonly used flame retardant compositions are usually applied to
fabrics in a separate process step, often following the printing, dyeing, drying or
finishing stages. Obviously, this increases manufacturing costs and in many instances,
the final dried fabric will be taken to a separate location for flame retardant treatment.
The present invention is highly advantageous in that it is compatible with the usual
finishing bath additives. Thus a separate treatment stage can be avoided as the flame
retardant composition can simply be included in the finishing bath, if so desired.
Following application, the cellulosic material is dried at temperatures normally associated
with textile flame retardant treatments, typically between 90°C and 160°C, depending
on fabric throughput speed. The drying step can also effect curing of the flame retardant
onto the fabric.
[0037] The invention also includes a process for imparting flame retardant properties to
a cellulosic substrate by contacting the substrate with a composition comprising an
inorganic halide, an oxide of antimony having a particle size of no greater than 2.0
µm, a binding agent, a plasticiser and a surface modifier in a finishing bath in the
printing process for the substrate.
[0038] If the composition is applied as a separate process step, it must also be followed
by a curing stage. Generally curing is effected by heating the treated substrate at
a temperature of at least 90°C, preferably from 120° to 160°C, most preferably 120°C
to 150°C.
[0039] Whether curing is in the drying stage or is a separate stage, usually the curing
time is from 0.2 to 10 minutes preferably 0.5 to 5 minutes most preferably 0.5 to
3 minutes at the curing temperature. This is a significant advantage over the curing
times of most known flame retarding compositions, for which longer curing times, for
example up to 20 minutes or even 30 minutes are required.
[0040] The amount of the flame retardant composition required on the finished fabric, in
order to give effective flame retardant properties is generally between 5 and 80%
by weight of the substrate, preferably from 10 to 30%. These amounts refer to added
dry weight of the composition on the substrate. The amount of the composition required
depends upon the type of the substrate and the degree of flame retardancy required.
[0041] If insufficient of the flame retarding composition is incorporated into the fabric
following one contact of the substrate with the composition, for example, by immersion
in a finishing bath, a further quantity can be applied in a second contact stage.
[0042] The method of application of the flame retardant composition is by any of the known
techniques in the industry including, pad-mangle, foam impregnation, vacuum impregnation,
spray and roller, etc. Although the composition can be used to provide a back coating,
the composition of the invention is advantageous as it is particularly suitable for
application by absorption into the substrate and curing to provide a flame retarding
composition impregnated throughout the substrate. The application process is particularly
suited to the pad-mangle method, when the composition is applied to woven cellulosic
fabrics.
[0043] The amount of flame retardant on the final treated fabric can be controlled by the
method of application as well as the concentration of the composition. Thus, to attain
a higher % of flame retardant, a higher wet amount of composition is applied so that
on drying a greater % of the flame retardant remains.
Example 1
[0044] A composition according to the present invention was made up in a stainless steel
reactor fitted with a high-shear mixer, temperature control, pH monitor, and cooling
facilities.
[0045] 203 Kg of Nyacol A1550 (Trade Mark: a 50% colloidal suspension of antimony pentoxide
in water) was charged to the vessel and high speed mixing was applied. To this was
charged 57 Kg water, followed by approximately 12.5 Kg of concentrated ammonia solution,
in order to adjust the pH to approximately 9.0. Once the pH had stabilised, 248 Kg
of ammonium bromide (38%) was added and blended. The pH was readjusted to approximately
8.0 using ammonia solution.
[0046] The resultant pre-mix was then added to 82 Kg Cereclor 50LV (Trade Mark; a chlorinated
paraffin), and mixed until homogeneous. As these two components were mixed, a change
in viscosity resulted and the composition thickened. To this mixture was added 466
Kg of Emulsion CE752 (Trade Mark): this is a 50% emulsion of vinyl chloride/ethylene
copolymer in water. Once intimately mixed 64 Kg of Emprimin LR28 (Trade Mark, a sodium
lauryl sulphonate anionic surfactant) was added, followed by 32 Kg Silicon VP1445E
(Trade Mark): an aqueous emulsion of polydimethylsiloxane. Finally there is added
54 Kg of Mykon 8430 (Trade Mark): a mixture of polyhydrogenmethylsiloxane and polydimethylsiloxane,
and the mixture was mixed well. The resulting product was a white, slightly viscous
liquid having pH between 7.0 to 8.0. No final adjustment of the pH was necessary.
Example 2
[0047] A composition was made up in the same manner as in Example 1 with the exception that
MYKON 8430 was replaced with DOW Emulsion Q2-7419, an amino-functional polyalkyl siloxane
containing surface modifier.
Example 3
[0048] A composition was made up as in Example 2 and in which 20 kg of zinc borate was also
incorporated.
Example 4
[0049] A sample of printed 52 x 44 (picks per inch, warp by weft) 100% cotton fabric was
passed through a finishing bath, containing 650 g/ℓ of the flame retardant composition
of example 1. With the aim of producing a treated fabric having 25% dry weight add-on
(a final substrate comprising flame retardant in an amount of approximately 25% of
the fabric weight), the pad-mangle expression was adjusted. The combination of concentration
of the composition and pad-mangle expression (determining how much wet composition
remains on the substrate), by throughput speed and mangle pressure, were used to load
the substrate with a wet amount of composition such that on drying, the required dry
weight add-on % flame retardant would remain.
[0050] Following pad application, the fabric was heat treated at 130°C to give a flame retardant
finish. No noticeable colour changes to either the fabric or the colouring agents
were observed, and the fabric had retained a soft feel, no significant stiffening
of the fabric having occurred.
[0051] The treated fabric was subjected to the fire retardant tests as stipulated in the
BS 5852 and BS 5651 documents. No flaming was observed in cover or interior which
did not cease with 120 secs of the removal of the burner tube. No externally detectable
amounts of smoking, heat or glowing was observed 15 min after removal of the burner
tube. This effectively resulted in a PASS certificate for BS 5852 Section 4 Ignition
Source 1 and Schedule 5 of the Furniture and Furnishings (FIRE) (SAFETY) Regulations
1988.
[0052] Equally good flame retardancy results were obtained using the compositions of examples
2 and 3. The finished fabric had slightly improved feel characteristics using the
compositions of examples 2 and 3.
1. An aqueous composition for imparting flame retardant properties to a cellulosic substrate
comprising an inorganic halide, an oxide of antimony having an average particle size
no greater than 2.0 µm, a binding agent, a plasticiser and a surface modifier.
2. An aqueous composition according to claim 1 in which the inorganic halide is an ammonium
halide, preferably ammonium bromide.
3. A composition according to claim 1 or claim 2 in which the halide is in a concentration
of from 50-500 g/l, preferably from 100-300 g/l.
4. A composition according to any preceding claim in which the oxide of antimony is hydrated
antimony pentoxide, in the form of an aqueous colloidal suspension.
5. A composition according to any preceding claim in which the particle size of the antimony
oxide is from 0.01 to 0.05 µm.
6. A composition according to any preceding claim in which the antimony oxide is present
in an amount of from 25-400 g/l, preferably from 25 to 150 g/l.
7. A composition to any preceding claim in which the binding agent is a copolymer of
vinyl chloride and ethylene which is present in the composition in an amount of from
200 to 600 g/l and preferably in the range 300 to 500 g/l.
8. A composition according to any preceding claim in which the plasticiser is a halogenated
paraffin, the paraffin having a carbon chain length of from C₈ to C₁₄.
9. A composition according to any preceding claim in which the surface modifier is an
aminoalkyl substituted polysiloxane or mixture of polysiloxanes.
10. A process for manufacture of the composition according to any preceding claim comprising
mixing a suspension of small particle size antimony oxide with water, if necessary
adjusting the pH to between 8.5 and 9.5 by the addition of a base, mixing inorganic
halide into the composition until a substantially homogeneous composition results,
followed by mixing with binding agent, plasticiser and surface modifier.
11. A process according to claim 10 in which the base is ammonia in the form of ammonia
gas or preferably, aqueous solution of ammonia.
12. A process for imparting flame retardant properties to a cellulosic substrate comprising
contacting the cellulosic substrate with a composition according to any of claims
1 to 9, absorbing the composition throughout the cellulosic substrate, and curing
the composition into the substrate.
13. A process according to claim 12 in which contact with the cellulosic substrate is
by immersion in a finishing bath in the printing process for the substrate.
14. A method according to claim 12 or claim 13 in which the substrate is contacted with
the flame retardant composition by pad-mangle application.
15. A cellulosic substrate comprising a flame retardant composition obtainable by the
process according to any of claims 12 to 14.
Claims for the following Contracting State(s): ES
1. A process for preparing an aqueous composition for imparting flame retardant properties
to a cellulosic substrate comprising mixing an inorganic halide, an oxide of antimony
having an average particle size no greater than 2.0 µm, a binding agent, a plasticiser
and a surface modifier and water to form an aqueous composition.
2. A process according to claim 1 in which the inorganic halide is an ammonium halide,
preferably ammonium bromide.
3. A process according to claim 1 or claim 2 in which the halide is in a concentration
of from 50-500 g/l, preferably from 100-300 g/l.
4. A process according to any preceding claim in which the oxide of antimony is hydrated
antimony pentoxide, in the form of an aqueous colloidal suspension.
5. A process according to any preceding claim in which the particle size of the antimony
oxide is from 0.01 to 0.05 µm.
6. A process according to any preceding claim in which the antimony oxide is present
in an amount of from 25-400 g/l, preferably from 25 to 150 g/l.
7. A process to any preceding claim in which the binding agent is a copolymer of vinyl
chloride and ethylene which is present in the composition in an amount of from 200
to 600 g/l and preferably in the range 300 to 500 g/l.
8. A process according to any preceding claim in which the plasticiser is a halogenated
paraffin, the paraffin having a carbon chain length of from C₈ to C₁₄.
9. A process according to any preceding claim in which the surface modifier is an aminoalkyl
substituted polysiloxane or mixture of polysiloxanes.
10. A process according to any preceding claim in which a suspension of small particle
size antimony oxide is mixed with water, if necessary the pH is subsequently adjusted
to between 8.5 and 9.5 by the addition of a base, prior to mixing inorganic halide
into the composition until a substantially homogeneous composition results, followed
by mixing with binding agent, plasticiser and surface modifier.
11. A process according to claim 10 in which the base is ammonia in the form of ammonia
gas or preferably, aqueous solution of ammonia.
12. A process for imparting flame retardant properties to a cellulosic substrate comprising
contacting the cellulosic substrate with a composition formed according to any of
claims 1 to 11, absorbing the composition throughout the cellulosic substrate, and
curing the composition into the substrate.
13. A process according to claim 12 in which contact with the cellulosic substrate is
by immersion in a finishing bath in the printing process for the substrate.
14. A process according to claim 12 or claim 13 in which the substrate is contacted with
the flame retardant composition by pad-mangle application.