[0001] The present invention concerns a method of forming an SOI structure and a semiconductor
memory device using the forming technique. SOI has been used as a structure for electronic
parts such as semiconductor devices and the present invention can be utilized as a
method of forming various kinds of SOI structures.
[0002] More specifically, it can be used, for example, to SRAM or EEPROM. In EEPROM, it
relates, in particular, to a method of manufacturing a non-volatile memory device
in which a control gate electrode layer is laminated by way of an insulator film on
a floating gate electrode layer.
Description of the Prior Art
[0003] The SOI (silicon on insulator) structure has been utilized mainly in the field of
electronic materials by a method of forming various kinds of semiconductor devices
to a silicon portion disposed on an insulator layer.
[0004] As one of means for forming the SOI structure, it has been known a technique for
bonding a substrate to another silicon substrate formed with an insulator portion
on the side of the insulator portion and polishing the silicon substrate thereby providing
a structure in which the silicon portion is present on the insulator portion. It is
generally referred to as a bonded SOI or the like.
[0005] Since the bonded polished type SOI structure and a process therefor enables high
integration of electronic materials and makes it possible to assemble devices above
and below the silicon portion, it contributes to increase of the integration degree
of IC or the like.
[0006] Description will now be made to a method of forming the bonded SOI structure with
reference to Fig. 1-A to Fig. 1-G (refer to M. Hashimoto et. al. "Low Leakage SOIMOSFETs
Fabricated Using a Wafer Bonding Method" in Extended Abstracts of the 21st Conference
on Solid State Devices and Material 15, Tokyo, 1989, pp. 89 - 92 n).
[0007] As shown in Fig. 1-A, one surface of a silicon substrate 1 (highly flattened silicon
wafer is generally used and referred to as a substrate A) is patterned by using photolithography
or etching technology to form a recess at a depth of 1500 A or smaller.
[0008] Then, an insulator portion 2 is formed by forming an SiO₂ film on the surface by
means of CVD or the like. Thus, a structure in which the insulator portion 2 is formed
on one side of the silicon substrate 1 is obtained as shown in Fig. 1-B. The insulator
portion 2 is formed as a film having unevenness as illustrated in the figure in accordance
with the surface shape of the patterned silicon substrate 1.
[0009] Further, a polysilicon film 3 is formed to a thickness of about 5 um on the insulator
portion 2, for example, by CVD. Thus the structure shown in Fig, 1-C is obtained.
The polysilicon film 3 is provided for forming a highly smooth bonding surface upon
bonding a separate substrate 4 (substrate 4 shown in B in Fig. 1-E) in the subsequent
step.
[0010] Then, the surface of the polysilicon film 3 is polished to flatten, to attain a highly
smooth surface. In this case, the thickness of the polysilicon film 3 as a remaining
film is made to a thickness of 3 um or less.
[0011] Another substrate 4 (hereinafter referred to as substrate B) is brought into a close
contact with the polished surface of the polysilicon film 3. Both of the surfaces
are joined in close pressure bonding to obtain a joined structure as shown in Fig.
1-E. It is generally said that firm joining is attained due to hydrogen bonds present
between both of the surfaces. Usually, they are thermally joined by heating to attain
an extremely firm bonding. The bonding strength is generally greater than 200 kg/cm²
and, sometimes, reaches as great as 2000 kg/cm², As another substrate 4 (substrate
B) to be bonded, the same silicon substrate as the substrate 1 (substrate A) is usually
employed, because a failure may be caused unless physical property such as thermal
expansion coefficient is equal between them since they are often put to a heating
step subsequent to the bonding. If there is no such problem, another substrate 4 is
not necessarily a silicon substrate since this functions only as a support bed in
the prior art, for example, shown in the drawing. However, in a case of forming a
device also on the another substrate 4 (substrate B) to be appended, it has to be
a semiconductor substrate capable of forming a device.
[0012] Then, the substrate 1 is ground so as to leave a silicon portion of the substrate
1 to about 5 um or less as the remaining film to attain a structure shown in Fig.
1-F. Fig. 1-F is turned from state in Fig. 1-E, because the structure is turned upside
to down to situate the substrate 1 above for this grinding or for the subsequent selective
polishing.
[0013] Then, selective polishing is applied. In this case, polishing of precious finishing
is applied till the insulator portion 2 is just exposed. This provides a structure
as shown in Fig. 1-G in which a silicon portion 10 is present on the insulator portion
2 being surrounded with undulating insulator portion 2. The silicon portion 10 forms
a SOI film. To a structure in which the silicon portion 10 is present on the insulator
portion 2 (SOI structure), various kinds of devices are formed to the silicon portion
10 (SOI film). As shown in Fig. 1-G, since each of the silicon portions 10 is surrounded
with the insulator portion 2, a structure in which device isolation is attained from
the first is provided.
[0014] Further, in a method of manufacturing the SOI substrate as described above, since
the film thickness 10 in Fig. 1-G varies within a wafer surface, the thickness of
an inland single crystal silicon thin film formed to or required pattern also varies.
[0015] Further, selective polishing is applied till the boundary between the silicon wafer
and the silicon oxide film is exposed in order to obtain a required pattern for the
single crystal silicon whin film. In this case, since an over polishing is required
to some extent, the surface of silicon is exposed to an alkaline polishing solution
for a long period of time, to roughen the silicon surface. If a TFT (thin film transistor)
is formed on the roughened silicon surface, a device with good characteristics can
not be obtained since the reliability of a gate insulator film is lowered.
[0016] Further, in the SOI process utilizing the bonding polishing method as described above
or an electrostatic pressure bonding method, since various kinds of devices can be
assembled to the surface and the rear face of the SOI portion (the silicon portion
10 in Fig. 1-G), the mounting density can be increased. By adopting this technology,
the size of a memory cell, for example, DRAM can be reduced. However, although the
density of a circuit such as a memory cell has been intended to increase in the prior
art, the merit of this technique is not effectively utilized for peripheral circuits.
For instance, referring to a memory device such as a DRAM or SRAM, although it has
been considered to reduce the size of the memory cell by using the SOI technology,
the SOI technology is not always utilized for other peripheral circuits and, for example,
it has not been conducted to increase the density for the transistor as the peripheral
circuit, thereby improving the performance (for example, increasing the operation
speed).
[0017] Further, for the method of forming a memory device such as EEROM, electric characteristics
can be improved outstandingly by applying the polishing method used for SOI.
[0018] That is, as shown in Fig. 2, when a floating gate electrode layer is formed, the
surface is not flattened but pointed protrusions 25 are formed. Then, an electric
field is concentrated to a portion where the protrusions 15 are present in this structure.
[0019] Accordingly, in a second gate insulator film between the floating gate electrode
13 and the control gate electrode 14, there is a portion where the thickness is decreased
by the protrusions 15. If LSI is manufactured in such a state and applied with a voltage,
the electric field is concentrated to a portion where the protrusions 15 are present.
Then, electrons in the floating gate electrode are extracted by the electric field
applied to the control gate electrode due to the concentration of the electric field,
to result in signal data possessing characteristic, thereby bringing about a problem
incapable of maintaining the threshold value of a memory transistor at a high level.
[0020] A first object of the present invention is to provide a method of manufacturing a
SOI substrate capable of improving the uniformity at the surface of a polished silicon
layer.
[0021] A second object of the present invention is to attain mounting at a further increased
density by using the SOI technique and provide a method of forming a SOI structure
that effectively utilizes the merit of the SOI technique, for example, also in peripheral
circuits.
[0022] A third object of the present invention is to provide a method of manufacturing a
non-volatile semiconductor memory capable of preventing the data possessing characteristics
from lowering and maintaining a threshold level of a memory transistor at a high level
in a memory device such as EEPROM using the technique used for the formation of SOI.
Fig. 1-A through Fig. 1-G show a conventional method of manufacturing bonding type
SOI;
Fig. 2 shows a structural view of a conventional EEPROM;
Fig. 3-A through Fig. 3-E show a process for producing a semiconductor device of a
SOI structure as a first example according to the present invention;
Fig. 4-A through Fig. 4-F show a process for producing a semiconductor device of a
SOI structure as a second example according to the present invention;
Fig. 5-A through Fig. 5-F show a process for producing a semiconductor device of a
SOI structure as a third example according to the present invention; and
Fig. 6-A through Fig. 6-F show a process for producing a EEPROM device for fabricated
by using the manufacturing process for the SOI device as a fourth example according
to the present invention.
[0023] Descriptions will now be made to preferred examples according to the present invention
with reference to the drawings.
[0024] The first example of the present invention will now be described.
[0025] This example concerns a method of manufacturing a SOI substrate by bonding a pair
of silicon wafers, in particular, a method of forming a p⁺ type impurity layer as
an etching stopping layer. This example will now be described in accordance with the
steps with reference of Fig. 3-A through Fig. 3-E.
[0026] At first, a p⁺ type impurity layer 22 is formed to a thickness
x on the surface of a (100) face of a p⁻ type single crystal silicon substrate 1. The
p⁺ type impurity layer 22 functions as an etching stopping layer. The p⁺ type impurity
layer 22 is formed, for example, by introducing impurities such as boron to the surface
of the silicon substrate 21 by means of ion implantation or thermal diffusion. The
impurity concentration of the p⁺ type impurity layer 22 is about 10²⁰ cm⁻³, while
the impurity concentration of the p⁻ type silicon substrate 21 is about 10¹⁴ cm⁻³.
Since the silicon substrate 21 is mirror finished from the first, the thickness
x of the p⁺ type impurity layer 22 less varies as well.
[0027] Then, as shown in Fig. 3-A, a p⁻ type silicon layer 23 is formed, by means of epitaxial
growing, to the surface of the silicon substrate 21 formed with the p⁺ type impurity
layer 22. Since this is formed by the epitaxial growing, the silicon layer 23 comprises
single crystals conforming the crystallinity of the substrate.
[0028] After forming the silicon layer 23 as the epitaxially grown layer, a step 24 along
with the inland pattern to be formed to the surface 23a of the silicon layer 23 is
formed. The height of the step 24 corresponds to the thickness of the single crystal
silicon thin film to be formed. After forming the step 24, a silicon oxide film 25
is deposited over the entire surface as shown in Fig. 3-B.
[0029] Another silicon substrate 26 is provided and, as shown in Fig. 3-C, bonded with the
silicon substrate 21 to which the silicon oxide film 25 is deposited to the surface
by way of a polysilicon layer 27 in accordance with an ordinary bonding method. It
is preferred to set the thickness of the silicon layer 23 such that impurities of
the p⁺ type impurity layer 22 do not diffuse to the bottom 24a of the step 24 by the
heat treatment till the bonding stage.
[0030] Then, grinding is applied from the rear face of the silicon substrate 21 to such
an extent as not expose the p⁺ type impurity layer 22 as the etching stopping layer,
to reduce the thickness of the silicon substrate 21. After the grinding, the silicon
substrate 21 is eliminated by etching using the difference of the impurity concentration
till the p⁺ impurity layer 22 appears. The etching is applied by using a solution
mixture of ethylene diamine - pyrocatechol - purified water. When the etching rate
for the p⁺ type impurity layer, relative to the (100) face silicon is set as 1, the
etching rate for the p⁻ type silicon substrate 21 is 400, so that etching at an extremely
high selection ratio is applied. Since the p⁺ type impurity layer 22 of high uniformity
has already been formed by utilizing the already mirror finished silicon substrate
21, etching is stopped at a state where the difference of the film thickness is extremely
small as shown in Fig. 3-D reflecting the p⁺ type impurity layer 22.
[0031] Since the etching speed ratio is 400:1, it may suffice that the film thickness
x of the p⁺ type impurity layer 22 is at least more than 1/400 of the distance
z from the surface of the p⁺ type impurity layer 22 to the bottom 24a of the step 24.
[0032] After stopping etching with a good uniformity at the surface of the p⁺ type impurity
22, the p⁺ type impurity layer 22 and the silicon layer 23 formed by epitaxial growing
are ground by selective grinding. In this case, since the variation within the plane
at the surface of the p⁺ type impurity layer 22 is suppressed, a single crystal silicon
thin film of excellent uniformity is formed also for the exposed surface 23b of the
silicon layer 23 obtained by the selective polishing.
[0033] As has been described above, in the method of manufacturing the SOI substrate according
to this example, since the etching is stopped at the uniform surface by the p⁺ type
impurity layer 22 as described above, variation for the thickness of the single crystal
silicon thin film in the inland region is suppressed even after the selective polishing.
Further, since this is excellent in uniformity, an excess polishing is no more required,
so that the exposed surface 23b of the silicon layer 23 is not exposed to an alkaline
polishing solution for a long period of time. Accordingly, the reliability of the
SOI device is also improved.
[0034] In the method of manufacturing the SOI substrate in accordance with the present invention,
the etching stopping layer is formed uniformly on the surface of the silicon substrate,
and etching from the rear face of the silicon substrate after bonding can be stopped
while reflecting the uniformity thereof. Accordingly, it is excellent in the uniform
thickness of the single crystal silicon thin film to save the time required for selective
polishing. Accordingly, the reliability of the device formed on the SOI substrate
can be improved remarkably by applying the method of manufacturing the SOI substrate
according to the present invention.
[0035] Descriptions will now be made to a second example according to the present invention
with reference to Fig 4-A through Fig. 4-F.
[0036] As shown in Fig. 4-A, one of the surfaces of a silicon substrate 31 is patterned.
[0037] Then, an insulator portion 32 is formed and the first conductive portions 43a, 43b
(a first gate electrode in this example) are formed at one position on the surface
of the silicon substrate 31 formed with the insulator portion 32, that is, at a position
to form a transistor as a peripheral circuit in this example, to provide a structure
as shown in Fig. 4-B.
[0038] Then, a connection hole 44 is formed to define a filled connection portion 45 at
the other position on the same surface of the silicon substrate 31, that is, at a
position to form a cell portion of a semiconductor memory device such as DRAM in this
example to provide a structure as shown in Fig. 4-C.
[0039] Then, a groove 46 is formed on the connection portion 45 and a trench function portion
(a memory capacitor comprising a storage electrode 47 and a capacitor insulator film
48 in this illustrated example) is formed to provide a structure shown in Fig. 4-D.
[0040] Subsequently, a polysilicon film 33 is properly formed and polished (refer to Fig.
4-E) and with another substrate 52 is bonded. Although the substrate 52 is not particularly
illustrated in Fig. 4, it is the same as that in the case of Fig. 1.
[0041] Further, the silicon substrate 31 is polished on the surface of the other side to
form a silicon portion 40 and, subsequently, a second electroconductive portion (second
gate electrodes 49a, 49b of the transistor on the side of the peripheral circuit and
the second gate electrode 49c on the side of the cell as the word electrode) is formed
on one and the other positions to form a SOI structure as shown in Fig. 4-F.
[0042] Specifically, this example comprises steps (1) - (7) described below as actual constitutions.
[0043] The process for the steps is shown successively.
(1) Silicon RIE is applied for forming inter-device isolation regions to the silicon
substrate 31. The etching depth is set to about 100 nm or less. Thus, a structure
shown in Fig. 4-A is obtained.
(2) An insulator portion 32 comprising SiO₂ is formed by surface oxidation. This also
serves as a first gate insulator film 41 of the transistor in the peripheral circuit.
Further, a first gate electrode as the first conduction portion 43a, 43b is formed
with polysilicon or the like.
(3) An inter-layer film 50 is formed over the entire surface, for example, by CVDSiO₂.
A contact as a connection hole 44 is perforated for leading out a storage electrode
in the cell portion and filled with polysilicon to form a connection portion 45 (polysiiicon
plug). This can be obtained by entirely forming polysilicon and then etching back
it. A structure shown in Fig. 4-C is thus obtained.
(4) Further, after depositing SiO₂ as an inter-layer film 51 by a CVD process, a groove
46 is formed to the cell portion as a groove for forming the storage electrode. After
perforating the groove 46, polysilicon or the like is formed over the entire surface
(refer to a portion shown by the dotted line in Fig. 4-D) and, subsequently, etched
back to form a storage electrode 47.
(5) A capacitor insulator film 48 is formed by using a silicon nitride film or the
like. A structure shown in Fig. 4-D is obtained.
(6) Then, a plate electrode 33 is formed, for example, with polysilicon and the surface
is flattened by grinding. A structure as shown in 1-E is thus obtained.
(7) Polished surfaces of the support substrate 52 (not illustrated) and the plate
electrode 33 are adhered by a bonding or electrostatic press bonding process to conduct
bonding. Then, the silicon substrate 31 on the side of the device is ground using
SiO₂ as the insulator portion 32 as a stopper. Further, the surface is oxidized to
form a SiO₂ film 42. Second conduction portions 49a, 49b, 49a are formed, for example,
with polysilicon thereover to form a gate electrode. This constitute a word line (second
conduction portion 49c) in the cell, and a second electrode (second conductive portions
49a, 49b) of the double gate in the peripheral circuit. The second electrode is previously
connected with the first electrode by means of a contact hole.
[0044] Subsequently, by way of the same steps as those of various kinds of steps employed
so far for forming the memory cell and the peripheral circuit thereof (source, drain
injection or formation of aluminum wires), to form a semiconductor memory device.
[0045] According to this example, since the peripheral transistor circuit can also be constituted
with the double gate, high speed performance of the peripheral circuit can also be
realized.
[0046] Description will then be made to the third example according to the present invention.
[0047] Fig. 5 shows a process flow of this example. The method of forming the SOI structure
in this example, comprises forming an insulator portion 62 on one side of a silicon
substrate as shown in Fig. 5-B, bonding another substrate 80 on the side thereof formed
with the insulator portion 62 (bonding on the upper surface in Fig. 5-E), and polishing
the other side of the silicon substrate 61, thereby obtaining an SOI structure in
which a silicon portion 70 is present on the insulator layer 62 as shown in Fig. 5-F.
The method comprises each of the following steps.
[0048] One of the surfaces of the silicon substrate is patterned as shown in Fig. 5-A.
[0049] Then, the insulator portion 62 is formed on the patterned surface and, further, openings
66a, 66b at the positions on one side of the surface of the silicon substrate 61 formed
with the insulator layer 62, that is, at the position to form a transistor as the
peripheral circuit in this example, while a connection hole 75 is formed at the other
position on the same surface of the silicon substrate 61, that is, at the position
to form a cell portion of a semiconductor memory device such as DRAM in this example
to attain a structure as shown in Fig. 5-D.
[0050] Then, the openings 66a, 66b are filled with polysilicon or the like to form first
conduction portions 72a, 72b, that is, the conduction portions 72a, 72b as the first
gate electrode of the peripheral transistor in this example. At the same time, the
connection hole 75 is filled to form a connection portion 76 to attain a structure
as shown in Fig. 5-C.
[0051] Then, a groove 77 is formed on the connection portion 76 and a trench function portion
(same memory trench capacitor as in Example 2) to the groove 71 to attain a structure
as shown in Fig. 5-D.
[0052] Subsequently, by way of the structure shown in Fig. 5-E in the same manner as in
Example 2, another substrate (not illustrated) is bonded, the other surface of the
silicon substrate 61 is polished to form a silicon portion 70 and then the same second
conduction portions 74a - 74c as in Example 1 are formed at one and the other positions
to attain a SOI structure as shown in Fig, 5-F.
[0053] The method of forming the first conduction portions 72a, 72b (first electrode) in
this example is different from that in Example 2, in which the conduction material
(polysilicon) upon forming the polysilicon plug in the cell portion as the connection
portion 76 is used also as the double gate first electrode of the peripheral transistor.
The first gate oxide film 71 in the peripheral circuit is removed by etching using
a diluted fluoric acid in the cell portion by using a resist mask in the step before
Fig. 5-B to attain a structure as shown in Fig. 5-B. The subsequent steps are the
same as those in Example 2.
[0054] The insulator portion 62 can be formed by applying CVD to SiO₂. Further, 68 in Fig.
5 denotes an inter-layer film which in formed from SiO₂ by CVD or the like.
[0055] This example can also provide the same effect as that in Example 2.
[0056] Both in Examples 2 and 3, the first conduction portion is formed as the first electrode
for constituting the double gate of the peripheral transistor of the memory device
but the present invention is not restricted only thereto. For instance, the present
invention is also applicable to the formation of a MOS transistor structure, in which
the first conduction portion can be constituted as a connection wiring for connecting
NMOS and PMOS. In addition, it can be used also for various kinds of other wiring
structures.
[0057] As has been described above according to the present invention, further increased
density can be attained by using the SOI technique. For instance, it can be embodied
also in the peripheral circuit as a method of forming the SOI structure effectively
utilizing the merit of the SOI technique.
[0058] Further, in the second and the third examples, the p⁺ impurity layer 22 and the p⁻
silicon layer 23 are formed on the p⁻ silicon substrate 21 shown in the first example
of the present invention and the silicon portion (SOI film) 70 in Fig. 4-F and the
silicon portion (SOI film) 70 in Fig. 5-F can also be formed in the same manner at
a high accuracy.
[0059] Description will then be made to a fourth example of the present invention.
[0060] At first, as shown in Fig. 6-A, a surface of silicon substrate 81 is oxidized to
form a first gate insulator film 82 and then a pure polysilicon layer 83 not containing
the impurity of first layer as the floating gate electrode layer is formed. When the
first polysilicon layer 83 is formed, protrusions 86 are already formed as shown in
Fig. 6-A. Subsequently, P (phosphorus) is diffused into the polysilicon layer 83 in
order to make the floating gate electrode layer electroconductive.
[0061] Then, a PSG (phosphorus glass) film 87 is formed, for example, by diffusion, in which
the protrusions 86 are not removed but rather grown spontaneously further also on
the PSG film 87 or the like as shown in Fig. 2, and the height of the protrusions
86 reaches as large as 500 - 1000 A.
[0062] Then, the protrusions 86 are removed. The protrusions 86 are removed by etching the
PSG (phosphorus glass) film 87 formed upon diffusion of P (phosphorus).
[0063] Then, before patterning the first polysilicon layer 83, the protrusions 86 grown
as described above are polished by using the device to be described below.
[0064] The device used for polishing the protrusions 86 comprises, as shown in Fig. 6-D,
an upper disc and a lower disc, The upper disc 90 is made of a ceramic plate and the
lower disc 89 has a polishing cloth 88 bonded on the surface thereof. The polishing
cloth 8 of the lower disc 89 is made of a soft polishing cloth (soft cloth).
[0065] A silicon substrate 81 in which the protrusions 86 are grown on the first polysilicon
layer 83 is placed on the upper disc 90 of the ceramic plate, with the silicon substrate
81 being directed downward. Then, at least the lower disc 89 having the polishing
cloth 88 is rotated.
[0066] In an experiment conducted by the present inventor, the circumferential speed of
the disc was set to 50 m/sec and the pressure applied was set to 140 g/cm², respectively.
[0067] Then, a polishing solution was caused to flow on the polishing cloth 88 of the lower
disc 89. The polishing solution was incorporated with an abrasive (a strong alkaline
solution having colloidal silica dispersed therein) and the solution was caused to
flow at a rate of 5 cc/min.
[0068] Under the condition as described above, the lower disc 89 was rotated to polish the
protrusions 86 of the first polysilicon layer 83 as the floating gate electrode layer.
[0069] Then, as shown in Fig. 6-F, the surface was polished and the protrusion was removed
to form a flattened first polysilicon layer 83. In this way, polishing was applied
by the combination of chemical polishing using the abrasive and mechanical polishing
using the polishing cloth and it was confirmed in the experimental example conducted
by the present inventor that the surface of the first polysilicon layer 83 could be
polished at a high accuracy.
[0070] Subsequently, a second polysilicon layer 85 for the control gate electrode layer
was caused to grow by way of the second insulator film 84.
[0071] Then, as shown in Fig. 6-C, since the surface of the floating gate electrode layer
83 was already flattened, the thickness of the oxide film was not reduced locally
in the second gate insulator film 84. Accordingly, voltage withstand of the floating
gate electrode layer 83 and the control gate electrode layer 85 could be improved.
[0072] Then, when LSI was manufactured and a voltage was applied, there was no localized
concentration of an electric film between the floating gate electrode layer 83 and
the control gate electrode layer 5 as in usual cases. Accordingly, the data possessing
characteristic can be improved.
[0073] In this example, a non-volatile semiconductor memory of EEPROM is used but it is
applicable also to CCD or the like.
[0074] According to the present invention, protrusions on the surface of the floating gate
electrode layer can be eliminated by the polishing to the surface as described above.
Therefore, partial reduction of the thickness of the oxide film in the second gate
insulator film can be avoided and, as a result, when a working voltage is applied
to the non-volatile memory device, there is no worry that electrons are drawn out
from the floating gate electrode by the electric field to lower the data possessing
characteristic.
[0075] That is, when the device is stored for a long period of time after initial writing,
the number of electrons emitted by heat energy from the floating gate electrode can
be reduced to improve the data possessing characteristic. Therefore, the threshold
value of the memory transistor can be maintained at a high level.