Field of the Invention
[0001] This invention relates to pressure wave phenomena (acoustic and shock waves) and
more specifically to an assembly for providing attenuation of pressure waves traveling
generally at or above the speed of sound in ambient conditions in order to mitigate
undesirable effects of these waves (including fragments and thermal energy release).
Background of the Invention
[0002] Acoustic and shock waves are traveling pressure fluctuations which cause local compression
of the material through which they move. Acoustic waves cause disturbances whose gradients,
or rates of displacement are small ― on the scale of the displacement itself. Acoustic
waves travel at a speed determined by and characteristic of a given medium; thus,
one must speak of the speed of sound, or acoustic speed in that medium. An acoustic
wave regardless of its frequency (pitch) or amplitude (loudness), will always travel
at the same speed in a given substance.
[0003] Shock waves are distinguished from acoustic waves in two key respects. First, shock
waves travel faster than the speed of sound in any medium. Secondly, local displacements
of atoms or molecules comprising a medium caused by shock waves are much larger than
for acoustic waves. Together, these two factors produce gradients or rates of their
displacement much larger than the local fluctuations themselves.
[0004] Energy is required to produce pressure waves. This is related to the equation that
states that energy equals force multiplied by the displacement caused by the force.
Once the driving source ceases to produce pressure disturbances, the waves decay.
Attenuation involves acceleration of the natural damping process, which therefore
means removing energy from pressure waves.
[0005] All matter through which pressure waves travel naturally attenuates these waves by
virtue of their inherent mass. Materials possess different acoustic attenuating properties,
strongly affected by density and by the presence or absence of phase boundaries and
structural discontinuities. Porous solid materials, thus, are better attenuators of
sound waves than perfect crystalline solids. Gases are inherently poor pressure wave
attenuators.
[0006] All types of pressure waves can be reflected and diffracted by liquid and gas media.
They can also be deflected or, more generally, scattered and dispersed by phase boundaries,
such as liquid droplets or solid particulates suspended in air. These deflections
serve to increase the distance which the wave travels. Scattering and dispersion thus
produce more attenuation because they cause the transmitting pressure waves to displace
more mass by virtue of the longer path. Such deflections also reduce, or may altogether
eliminate the pressure waves originally traveling in a specific direction.
Acoustic Wave Attenuation
[0007] Documented efforts to reduce noise (attenuate acoustic waves) in enclosed spaces
extend to the early nineteenth century. Virtually all acoustic wave attenuation concepts
have been based upon layers of solid materials with significant sound absorbing properties
serving as linings, coatings, or loosely-packed fibrous or granular fillers between
solid layers. These sound-absorptive layers have been applied to or incorporated within
structural walls, floors, ceilings, and other types of panels and partitions when
acoustic attenuation is required. Several dozen patents have been granted in the United
States alone which fall into this category.
[0008] In 1910, Mallock introduced the idea of using aqueous foams for noise suppression,
and conducted experimental evaluation of foams in this role. See Mallock, A., "The
damping of sound by frothy liquids",
Proc. Royal Soc. A84; pp. 391-5, 1910. Aqueous foams are agglomerations of bubbles, with the gas phase
within each bubble completely separated from that in adjacent bubbles by aqueous liquid
film comprising the bubble walls. During the years following Mallock's research, aqueous
foams became widely used for fire suppression, in numerous chemical processes, and
for mineral ore separation.
[0009] Not until the 1960's did interest renew in using aqueous foams for pressure wave
attenuation. Research from that time and continuing to the present extended to their
use for suppressing jet engine noise and acoustic disturbances arising from artillery
muzzle blast, ordnance disposal, and "sonic boom" created by supersonic aircraft flight.
It was during this time that researchers discovered that aqueous foams dramatically
attenuate impinging shock waves.
Shock Wave Attenuation
[0010] Much more energy is required to produce shock waves compared to acoustic disturbances,
which makes their attenuation more difficult. Shock waves decay to form acoustic waves
when the source of the shock wave is removed or suppressed.
[0011] When traveling through gases, shock waves produce increases in pressure (often referred
to as "overpressure") and temperature; they also accelerate gas molecules and entrained
particulates in the direction of shock wave travel. Shock waves produced by combustion
processes, such as explosions and deflagrations, release substantial amounts of thermal
and radiant energy as well. For all shock waves, the shock wave speed, overpressure,
and temperature increase they induce in the local medium are mathematically linked.
Attenuation of shock waves is thus achieved through directly suppressing one of these
three parameters; if temperature is reduced, the overpressure and shock speed are
accordingly reduced, for example.
[0012] Mitigation of shock wave parameters has required different approaches than those
used for acoustic wave attenuation because of their relatively large impulse and pressure
magnitude. Mechanical mitigation methods can be applied in many situations where barriers
or confinement are allowable. When shock waves are produced by explosions or deflagrations,
chemical means as well can often be used for suppression. None of the structures or
materials described in existing patents or in technical literature similar to the
types of solid sandwich configurations discussed above for noise suppression can provide
significant attenuation of shock waves.
[0013] Two types of structures or mechanical arrangements have been employed in reducing
shock wave effects: solid barriers (including blast mats) and mechanical venting.
Solid barriers and blast mats have been used to deflect incident shock waves or remove
energy from incident waves through momentum transfer (to the high-inertia mats and
barriers), and to provide protection from fragments and thermal effects. Mechanical
venting has been employed to keep internal pressure below the level which would cause
structural failure for explosions in confined spaces.
[0014] Solid barriers for shock wave containment or protection suffer from several shortcomings.
Where protection of large areas from powerful shock effects is necessary, concrete
or earthen barriers must be employed. These structures must be massive and are thus
inherently immobile and expensive and time consuming to erect. They cannot, therefore,
be used in the majority of applications where explosion hazards are present: marine
transport of liquid and liquefied hydrocarbons, petrochemical storage and processing
facilities, aboard warships and munition-carrying vessels, or at hastily established
munitions transshipment points (which are common in military operations, for example).
They cannot be used within buildings or otherwise serve as partitions in structures.
[0015] Similarly, large numbers of bulky and heavy blast mats are required for blast overpressure
exceeding a 1-meter scaled distance (the equivalent blast wave intensity of a 1-kilogram
TNT detonation at a distance of 1 meter). When not being used, these mats must be
stored. Aboard ships, space is often critically limited, thus bulky items which provide
no essential or alternate use cannot be justified. Furthermore, blast mats can at
best provide only limited mitigation of blast effects in confined spaces and provide
little acoustic damping. Their bulk, weight, and limited utility in confined spaces
rule out their employment aboard aircraft. Blast mats cannot be easily or quickly
moved from storage to locations where needed for blast wave attenuation due to their
bulk and weight.
[0016] Mechanical venting is widely employed for mitigating blast overpressure in containment
structures (grain silos, explosive material handling rooms,
etc. ) These vents normally constitute part of the containment wall. Besides reliability
and response time problems, venting requires facilities to be designed such that overpressure
release will not endanger personnel or nearby structures. Venting cannot be employed
where hazardous materials may be released. Venting is also unacceptable aboard ships,
where openings to the sea and release of smoke and overpressure within the vessel
are dangerous. Mechanical venting cannot be used for noise attenuation.
[0017] Chemical agents suppress shock waves by extinguishing or interrupting the combustion
process which generates them (along with their thermal effects). Such agents include
carbon dioxide and halogenated carbon compounds ("halons"), which may either be gaseous
or liquid initially at the time of application, and dry powders, most of which are
salts of ammonium or alkali metals such as sodium and potassium.
[0018] Gaseous combustion-extinguishing agents are generally effective in confined spaces.
A number of constraints limit their utility, however. No gaseous agent is effective
in outdoor or well-ventilated areas. Within a confined space, effectiveness of gaseous
agents is rapidly lost as these agents quickly escape through leaks and penetrations
(including those caused by projectiles or weapons fragments which generate the need
for gas agent release). All of the gas and liquid (which become gaseous in use) chemicals
currently available for fire and explosion suppression have toxic effects upon humans
at the concentrations required to be effective.
[0019] The most effective and least toxic gaseous agents are halogenated carbon compounds.
However, these substances are quickly and irreversibly broken down while performing
their combustion-inhibiting function. Furthermore, these agents are being withdrawn
from use by international government agreements due to their profoundly adverse impacts
upon upper-atmospheric ozone.
[0020] Other considerations limit the capabilities of gas fire-extinguishing agents. They
cannot provide significant acoustic attenuation in and of themselves. Furthermore,
gases cannot provide cooling or quenching of the area surrounding a fire or explosion
due to their inherently low heat capacities, which enables hot surfaces to reignite
combustible materials. Gas supplies must be adequate for extinguishment and be capable
of reaching all spaces within a compartment, otherwise they have no effect. Gaseous
explosion suppression systems are totally dependent upon sensors to initiate release
(within 100 milliseconds), which has proven to be a problem because of false-alarm
activation or failure to activate, due to the vulnerability of their sensors to dirt
and contaminants. Sensors also require maintenance to ensure minimum reliability.
[0021] Powdered fire fighting agents (chemical extinguishants) can be effectively used in
both confined and unconfined areas for fire suppression ― and by virtue of their dissociation
and combustion interrupting tendency ― can suppress some deflagrations which could
produce shock waves. Again, however, they cannot provide acoustic attenuation or fragment
or missile-stopping capability. Furthermore, they require large quantities of agent
(with consequent bulk and weight) to provide significant extinguishing capability.
Flooding a space with powdered agents is blinding to personnel present during emergency
operations.
Pressure Wave Attenuation Using Aqueous Foams
[0022] Aqueous foams have been proven to be capable of providing more pressure wave attenuation
than any other medium on a mass basis. As noted above, initial research into the use
of aqueous foams for pressure wave damping was entirely devoted to noise abatement.
Subsequent research revealed that ― unlike any material used in acoustic attenuation
structures developed to date ― aqueous foams provide shock wave attenuation, regardless
of the origin of the shock.
[0023] All applications to date of aqueous foams for pressure wave attenuation have been
in two basic forms: unconfined deluge or massive foam flooding and employment of solid
confining walls in which aqueous foam is placed. Massive deluge or high-capacity foam
generation systems have been used for perimeter security and for flooding of buildings
to provide explosion protection from bombs. Aqueous foam-filled containers have also
been used for safe removal and disposal of explosives. Variants of the foam-filled
container concept have been developed as noise-attenuation devices ("silencers") for
the muzzles of firearms and large naval guns.
[0024] In spite of their successful application to date, current methods and systems for
using aqueous foams in pressure attenuating roles are inefficient and unnecessarily
bulky. Furthermore, such methods and systems prevent the full capabilities offered
by aqueous foams from being realized because they require that the foam attenuate
the incident shock or acoustic wave without mechanical augmentation or assistance.
Solid walls utilized in current approaches are used only for fluid confinement and
stopping fragments. Such usage requires much larger volumes of foam (foam agent and
water) along with larger pumps and foam generating equipment than are necessary to
provide a specified level of pressure wave attenuation.
Comparisons Between Solid and Aqueous Foams
[0025] Acoustic attenuation by both types of materials are comparable due to the fact that
both rely upon scattering and dispersion of sound waves at bubble/cell walls. Solid
foams are more compact, aqueous foams are more efficient on a mass basis. Major differences
appear in regard to shock wave attenuation, however.
[0026] Solid materials, including solid foams, used as rigid panels are unable to attenuate
shock waves because of two factors: the large amplitude of the displacements of atoms
or molecules during shock wave propagation and the overpressure created in the surrounding
fluid. Shock waves propagating through aqueous foams create turbulent flow fields,
which have been shown to dissipate substantial amounts of energy, particularly when
reflected waves travel through the turbulent medium See Khosla, A. "A study in shock
wave attenuation", Ph.D. thesis, pp. 229-30, U. of Calgary, 1974. Turbulent flow fields
cannot be generated within solid materials.
[0027] The relatively large displacement of the liquid mass contained within aqueous foam
bubbles is resisted by surface tension and viscous forces, removing considerable shock
wave energy as well. Again, such displacements cannot occur within solids, even elastomeric
foams. Most shock wave energy encountering solid layers of any kind ― including solid
foams ― is reflected, which produces overpressures exceeding the incident level. Furthermore,
shock wave overpressures can knock down solid panels and walls without expending much
energy.
[0028] Significant dissipation of shock wave energy can be accomplished with solid materials,
according to the present invention as discussed further below, when the solid materials
are used as loosely packed beads, in which form they are capable of relative displacement
in the nature of a fluid. In such a form, the beads act similarly to bubbles in an
aqueous foam. Specifically, transmitting shock waves are scattered and dispersed at
the bead surfaces, and the displacement of the bead mass absorbs substantial energy.
Substantially more shock wave energy can be absorbed when the beads are made to resist
displacement to a limited extend (below the degree where the bead mass would act more
as a rigid panel than a fluid). This can be accomplished by means of an adhesive surface
coating or by a surface texture which promotes friction or adherence.
[0029] Experimental work has shown that volcanic foam glass (vermiculite) beads have been
able to attenuate shock waves originating from small explosives comparable to the
extent achieved by some aqueous foams. Vermiculite, however, provides less acoustic
attenuation than solid organic foam materials such as natural rubber and polyurethane,
which are normally used in this role. Furthermore, neither vermiculite nor any solid
material used to date for acoustic attenuation has combustion extinguishing properties
in and of itself; indeed, most organic solid foam materials are serious contributors
to fire and toxic smoke generation.
[0030] Aqueous foams have additional mechanisms for dissipating shock energy which no solid
bead material can provide: elastic bubble walls which absorb energy when they are
deformed or ruptured, by uniquely and dramatically slowing shock waves propagating
through, and ― in the case of stronger shock waves ― by causing these shock waves
to separate into two separate waves, which are then more easily attenuated.
[0031] The references discussed above facilitate understanding of the present invention,
particularly in connection with the function and materials of aqueous foams.
[0032] US-A-4,964,329 relates to foamable compositions and in particular is concerned with
the sound attenuation properties, especially the shock wave attenuation properties
of liquid foams generated from such compositions. It discloses a composition comprising
a mixture of foamable liquid and a particular additive selected to be supported as
a dispersion in foam when generated from said liquid, which dispersion is effective
to enhance the sound attenuation capability of the foam.
[0033] US-A-2,132,642 discloses an acoustical unit comprising composited sheets provided
each with perforations adapted to admit incident sound and defining sound absorbing
spaces extending laterally in a direction approximately parallel to the face of the
unit, the said perforations in one layer of the said sheets being non-registering
with the perforations in adjacent layers of the sheets and adapted to cause distribution
of incident sound throughout the laterally extending spaces.
[0034] DE-A-2,433,795 discloses filling the interstitial space or spaces of the hollow wall
with a compression buffer having a minimal elasticity constant. In particular it discloses
partially or completely filling the interstitial space or spaces with a substance
or a mixture in vapor or liquid phase which is in equilibrium at ambient pressure
and temperature. A system of this type is characterized by a very minimal elasticity
constant, because a portion of the vapor phase condenses out when pressure is increased,
and vice versa. Condensation and evaporation occur relatively quickly, so that changes
in acoustic pressure may also be eliminated using the system according to the present
invention. The liquid phase may be introduced by means of an absorbent, impregnable
carrier material. To increase the system operating temperature, liquid mixtures are
favourable which evaporate within the relevant temperature range.
[0035] The present invention is as claimed according to the features of claim 1.
[0036] The present invention provides an improved assembly for more effectively attenuating
acoustic and/or shock waves. The present invention provides an assembly for attenuating
substantially all types of pressure waves, existing as either an acoustic or shock
wave, in generally all gaseous environments, particularly in ambient atmospheric conditions.
More specifically, the invention provides an assembly for substantial suppression
or attenuation of blast effects from either proximate or remote explosions as one
of the more severe examples of pressure wave or acoustic/shock wave conditions effectively
dealt with by the invention.
[0037] The term "acoustic level pressure condition" is employed herein to include both acoustic
waves at the acoustic speed of a selected medium and/or shock waves exceeding the
acoustic speed of a selected medium. Accordingly, that term is employed as a replacement
for either or both conditions of acoustic waves and/or shock waves.
[0038] As discussed in greater detail elsewhere, the invention contemplates sonic/shock
wave pressure conditions preferably traveling at or above the acoustic speed for a
given medium. However, it will be apparent that the invention is also effective for
pressure conditions generally approaching acoustic speeds in a given medium and thus
exhibiting pressure characteristics to be desirably attenuated in the same manner
as acoustic/shock wave configurations.
[0039] In view of the above summary, the invention has a number of objects and advantages
set forth as follows:
(a) to provide pressure wave attenuation capabilities in both confined spaces and
unconfined areas;
(b) to provide attenuation of all acoustic frequencies regardless of orientation with
respect to the source;
(c) to provide shock wave attenuation in confined spaces without requiring the space
to be completely filled by aqueous foam or any other agent or medium;
(d) to provide attenuation of shock waves for both proximate and remote explosions;
(e) to provide a specified level of pressure wave attenuation in less volume and with
lower weight than is possible through any other existing means;
(f) to provide shock wave attenuation in confined spaces without requiring the confining
walls to be gas-tight (free from leaks or penetrations);
(g) to provide pressure wave attenuation with a mechanical configuration which can
be quickly stowed or removed to provide passageway or space when the system is not
in use;
(h) to provide a pressure wave attenuation structure to which other means of augmenting
specific attenuating capabilities or to provide additional capabilities can be applied
or installed within (such as adding insulation to protect the system from fire or
radiation, providing intumescent coatings to provide additional thermal energy absorption
from proximate explosions, or to include chemical fire-suppressing power or gaseous
agents within); and
(i) to provide explosion protection using the same agent as employed for fire fighting
(aqueous foam fire suppressants).
[0040] The present invention provides an acoustic/shock wave attenuating assembly formed
by a flowable attenuating medium exhibiting aqueous foam characteristics and a confinement
means for containing and supporting the flowable attenuating medium, the confinement
means being porous with respect to the acoustic/shock wave for allowing the shock
wave to penetrate the flowable attenuating medium according to the features of claim
1. Porosity of the confinement means is more specifically characterized as macroscopic
or microscopic openings allowing the shock wave to pass therethrough but, at the same
time, absorbing considerable energy from the shock wave and creating turbulent zones
or large numbers of miniature shock waves as energy from the shock wave passes into
the flowable attenuating medium. With such porous material being preferably arranged
on opposite sides of the attenuating medium, similar energy absorbing conditions occur
as the shock wave penetrates and passes through both sides of the confinement means.
In addition, substantial energy from the shock wave is absorbed by the flowable attenuating
medium, particularly because of its containment and restriction by the confinement
means.
[0041] Preferably, the flowable attenuating medium is an aqueous foam known to have substantial
energy absorbing capabilities from the prior art as discussed above. However, the
flowable attenuating medium may also be formed, for example, from solid particulate
material preferably having bulk mechanical properties and flow properties of a fluid,
the solid particulates also preferably comprising means for resisting relative displacement
of the particulates in order to better simulate characteristics of an aqueous foam.
In this regard, the term "flow properties of a fluid" and more specifically the term
"mechanical properties and flow properties of a fluid" refer to the ability of the
attenuating medium to act in the nature of a liquid mass to resist relative displacement
by surface tension and viscous forces and the ability to substantially scatter and
disperse pressure conditions transmitting therethrough by virtue of multitudinous
curved surfaces dividing gaseous and solid or liquid or solid phases, and enabling
the generation of turbulent flow fields by transmitting pressure conditions. More
briefly, these terms may be taken as referring to the ability to resist applied shear
forces in the nature of fluid viscosity. Finally, the above terms are also intended
to refer to a tendency of the flowable attenuating medium to assume the shape of the
confinement means while at the same time resisting applied shear forces in the nature
of viscosity.
[0042] Numerous configurations are possible for the attenuating assembly of the invention.
Preferably, the confinement means provides generally parallel side portions forming
a panel in combination with the flowable attenuating medium supported therebetween
for intercepting the acoustic/shock wave. More preferably, both side portions of the
confinement means are porous in order to achieve maximum attenuation in the manner
summarized above. It is even further contemplated that a plurality of such panel formations
can be arranged with intervening gaps whereby the acoustic/shock wave may be effectively
caused to successively penetrate the plurality of panel formations and intervening
gaps in order to even more effectively attenuate the acoustic/shock wave.
[0043] A further possible configuration of the invention provides for placing the acoustic/shock
wave attenuating panel combination between a structure and a surrounding liquid medium
such as sea water for the purpose of protecting the structure from shock waves or
other pressure wave phenomena arising from underwater explosions or seismic activity.
In this application, an acoustic/shock wave attenuating assembly of one of the above
mentioned configurations employs a rigid shell confinement means to isolate the surrounding
liquid from a liquid transmitting medium emplaced between the confinement means and
the acoustic/shock wave attenuating assembly. Preferably the flowable attenuating
medium is an aqueous foam and the transmitting liquid medium being a homogeneous liquid
without macroscopic gas bubbles or solid particulates in suspension.
[0044] It is also contemplated that the panel combination may be shaped to form a generally
enclosed chamber. With both side portions of the confinement means being porous to
the acoustic/shock wave, such a configuration is effective to attenuate the acoustic/shock
wave passing in either direction through the panels.
[0045] It is yet another object of an embodiment of the invention to provide such a flowable
attenuating medium in solid form, the attenuating medium being formed by solid particulates
which may be hollow or otherwise include a gaseous phase, the particulates preferably
being macroscopic and even more preferably have a dimension of at least about one
millimeter.
[0046] It is a still further object of an embodiment of the invention to provide a flowable
attenuating medium for the present invention in the form of an aerogel, a very light
weight material described in greater detail below,
[0047] It is also a further object of an embodiment of the invention to provide the attenuating
medium and related components for protective applications, particularly in connection
with ammunitions or devices of a type generally referred to as shaped-charge or hollow-charge
devices, as described in greater detail below.
[0048] It is a related object of an embodiment of the invention to also employ the attenuating
medium and related components of the invention for protecting explosive charges or
devices themselves from interaction or detonation, this phenomenon being commonly
referred to as "sympathetic detonation", "fratricide", "propagation" or "chain reaction",
as also described in greater detail below.
[0049] It is yet a further object of an embodiment of the invention to employ the attenuating
medium and associated components of the invention to provide a liner for containers,
either to protect the contents of the container from external blasts or to protect
the exterior of the container from blasts within the container. Accordingly, the invention
particularly contemplates use in connection with air cargo containers and the like.
[0050] It is also a further object of an embodiment of the invention to employ a shield
of a frangible material in combination with the attenuating medium for protecting
against weather and the like while still permitting the desired function of the attenuating
medium as also described in greater detail below.
[0051] It is another object of an embodiment of the invention to employ the attenuating
medium in combination with honeycomb, the honeycomb preferably providing at least
part of the support for the attenuating medium.
[0052] Additional objects and advantages of an embodiment of the invention are to provide
total reliability and effectiveness by using no moving or electrical components, and
by not depending upon materials which must be without flaws, imperfections, or other
defects. Operation of the invention is possible using materials in common use for
years, and is not dependent upon development of materials means of manufacture, or
analytical methods not currently available as defined by the features of claim 1.
Most significantly, the invention provides substantial attenuation of all types of
pressure waves on the source side as well as the remote side of the pressure wave
attenuating structure. In the case of proximate explosions, substantial reduction
of both overpressure and thermal effects have been experimentally verified on the
blast side as well as the opposite side of the pressure wave attenuating structure.
[0053] Further objects and advantages of embodiments of the invention will become apparent
form a consideration of the drawings and ensuing description.
Brief Description of the Drawings
[0054]
FIGURE 1 is a perspective view of a panel configuration for the attenuating assembly
of the invention. The panel assembly is preferably contemplated for containing an
aqueous foam as the flowable attenuating medium. Accordingly, the assembly of FIGURE
1 illustrates means for recycling and regenerating the aqueous foam within the confinement
means.
FIGURE 2 is a view taken along section lines II-II of FIGURE 1 and better illustrates
the interaction of the confinement means with the flowable attenuating medium.
FIGURE 3 is a view similar to FIGURE 2 and illustrates yet another embodiment of an
acoustic/shock wave attenuating assembly according to the present invention which
is placed between a structure to be protected from shock waves and other pressure
wave phenomena transmitting in a surrounding liquid medium.
FIGURE 4 illustrates a variation of the panel configuration wherein the side portions
of the confinement means are articulated or corrugated in order to provide increased
surface area and generate greater turbulence in the flowable attenuating medium, thereby
producing even more effective attenuation for the acoustic/shock wave.
FIGURE 5 is a view similar to FIGURE 2 while illustrating multiple panel assemblies
of similar construction with intervening gaps in order to even more effectively attenuate
the acoustic/shock wave.
FIGURE 6 illustrates yet another embodiment of an acoustic/shock wave attenuating
assembly according to the present invention wherein the confinement means and the
flowable attenuating medium contained therein are supported in common from a suitable
structure.
FIGURE 7 is a fragmentary view in section of a flowable attenuating medium for the
assembly of the present invention formed from solid particulates.
FIGURE 8 illustrates the arrangement of a plurality of panel assemblies each generally
similar to that of FIGURE 1 to form a generally enclosed prismatic chamber.
FIGURE 9 illustrates yet another embodiment of an acoustic/shock wave attenuating
assembly constructed according to the present invention wherein the panel combination
of the confinement means and flowable attenuating medium forms a generally enclosed
chamber. More specifically, the panel combination illustrated in FIGURE 9 forms a
cylindrical portion open at both ends.
FIGURE 10 similarly illustrates such a panel combination formed generally as a dome
to completely enclose a chamber therebeneath, with a section removed to show its construction.
FIGURE 11 also similarly illustrates yet another configuration wherein the panel combination
is arranged with an irregular shape to also form a chamber therebeneath open at one
end.
FIGURE 12 is a cross-sectional representation of an embodiment of the invention including
a frangible element on an exposed surface of the attenuating medium.
FIGURE 13 a cross-sectional representation of still another embodiment of the invention
illustrating its use in combination with armor plate or the like particularly for
enhancing the ability of the armor plate to resist explosive devices such as shaped-charge
devices.
FIGURE 14 is a perspective representation of another embodiment wherein the attenuating
medium is arranged in the cells of a honeycomb structure.
Description of the Preferred Embodiments
[0055] The various drawing figures accordingly illustrate a number of embodiments according
to the present invention. Those embodiments are summarized below followed by a more
detailed description of the respective figures.
[0056] FIGURE 1 is a perspective view of a basic version of the pressure wave attenuation
device. The device comprises two mesh or perforated solid screens which are parallel
or substantially parallel for planar configurations and concentric or substantially
concentric for cylindrical, spherical or other three dimensional forms which can be
generated by revolving a planar curve about an axis, with a pressure wave- attenuating
fluid, such as aqueous foam or vermiculite beads, emplaced and filling the space between
the mesh or perforated sheet screens. The screen elements may be flat or corrugated,
or a combination thereof. The screen elements are either held in place by a rigid
structural frame or by otherwise suspending and securing the lower edges of the screens
to prevent their displacement. The minimum spacing between screens is preferably the
least distance between perforations in perforated sheet screens or least dimension
of mesh openings in mesh screens.
[0057] Additional embodiments of the invention are shown in FIGURES 2-15. As illustrated,
the basic configuration can be modified with the addition of any combination of mesh
screen, perforated solid, or solid materials connecting to the mesh or perforated
sheet screens of the basic version of our invention, or to the frame members which
comprise the edge supporting members of the screen elements of the FIGURE 1 basic
version, which would then form top, bottom, and side surfaces as shown in FIGURE 2.
[0058] The invention may include one or more linings, as shown in FIGURE 2. These linings
may be connected or affixed to any of the mesh or perforated sheet screen elements,
or to the structural members holding the screens in place, or may be suspended. Said
linings may be in the form of a sealed enclosure or bag emplaced between the screen
elements of the basic version of the invention, into which the pressure wave attenuating
medium may be introduced.
[0059] Additional mesh or perforated sheet materials in any number or combination thereof
between the screens comprise outer surfaces of the basic version of the invention
to form interior screen elements in a sandwich configuration, thus forming a sandwich
arrangement of a plurality of acoustic/shock wave attenuating assemblies as shown
in FIGURE 5. Linings may be emplaced between one or more of these interior screens
and elements forming the outer surfaces of the invention. The preferred embodiment
of the invention uses corrugated mesh screens to form the outer surfaces, flat mesh
comprising the interior screen elements, waterproofed paper lining inside the screen
elements and with aqueous foam filling the sandwich formed by the above elements.
[0060] The pressure wave attenuating fluid may be emplaced in the volume formed between
an interior screen element and an outer screen, or between any two interior screen
elements where a plurality of interior screen elements is employed, or in any combination
of such spaces. This fluid may be aqueous foam, a gas emulsion, (wherein a gas is
entrained and dispersed through a liquid matrix in the form of bubbles, with the gas
bubble diameters generally commensurate with the thickness of the liquid bubble walls),
a gel (preferably with entrained gas), or granular or other solid particulates having
necessary flow characteristics. Gas may be emplaced and confined by an enclosing element
in one or more of the gaps between each sandwich assembly, with the gas pressure being
equal to, greater than, or less than atmospheric or ambient pressure. Vacuum conditions
may be generated in one or more of the gaps between each sandwich assembly.
[0061] The embodiments of the various figures are described in greater detail below.
[0062] Referring initially to FIGURE 1, an acoustic/shock wave attenuating assembly is generally
indicated at 10. Confinement means for the assembly comprises a screen or grid 12
arranged on four sides of the assembly to provide an enclosure for the flowable attenuating
medium 14.
[0063] As illustrated in FIGURE 1, the bottom of the assembly 10 is formed by a tray 16
while the top of the assembly is formed or enclosed by a plate 18. The tray 16 and
plate 18 function in combination with the screen 12 to completely enclose the flowable
attenuating medium 14 within the assembly 10.
[0064] The flowable attenuating medium 14 in the assembly of FIGURE 1 is preferably contemplated
as an aqueous foam of the type noted above. Since such aqueous foams are subject to
deterioration wherein the foam degenerates into a gaseous phase and a liquid phase,
the assembly 10 is adapted for recycling and regenerating the aqueous foam in order
to assure that it fills the space within the assembly 10. The tray 16 serves to receive
and collect the liquid phase from such deteriorated foam. The liquid is recycled through
a line 20 by a pump 22 to a manifold 24 having multiple connections 26 through the
upper plate 18 for returning regenerated foam to the assembly 10. Preferably, a source
of gas 28 is provided for regenerating the foam within the manifold 24 so that it
can flow downwardly into the assembly 10.
[0065] When aqueous foams are used as the flowable attenuating medium 14, they may be generated
from any foamable agents, preferably those which are normally used in fire suppression.
Such agents include hydrolyzed protein liquids, proteinaceous liquids with fluoropolymeric
additives, along with a large number of synthetic surfactant and stabilizing chemical
combinations. The foaming gas for use in the gas source 28 may be of a similarly wide
range so long as the gas is not chemically reactive in a destructive manner to the
stabilizing components in the bubble wall liquids. Foaming gases would preferably
include inert elements such as argon or fire extinguishing compounds such as carbon
dioxide, sulfur hexafluoride, or halogenated carbon agents (halons). Compressed air
is also an acceptable foaming gas.
[0066] Referring now to FIGURE 2, the screen 12 forming the confinement means for the flowable
attenuating medium may not be sufficient for maintaining an aqueous foam within the
assembly 10. Accordingly, FIGURE 2 illustrates a preferred embodiment wherein a liner
30 is arranged inside the screen 12. The screen 12 formed from metal, plastic or the
like thus remain very porous to the acoustic/shock wave. At the same time, the liner
30 serves to maintain the aqueous foam within the interior 32 of the assembly 10.
At the same time, the liner 30 is also porous to the acoustic/shock wave as defined
above. Preferably, the liner 30 is formed from paper or film which is resistant to
wetting by the aqueous foam. At the same time, the liner 30 tends to be readily ruptured
by the shock wave so that it does not interfere with penetration of the shock wave
into the attenuating medium 14 and thereby reduces the reflected overpressure that
inevitably develops when shock waves impinge upon a solid surface. The liner 30 thus
serves to even further attenuate the acoustic/shock wave in combination with the screen
12 and the flowable attenuating medium 14.
[0067] Referring now to FIGURE 3, another embodiment of an acoustic/shock wave attenuating
assembly is generally indicated at 10', and is placed in such an arrangement whereby
the structure 34 is situated on the side of the assembly 10' opposite the liquid surrounding
medium 36. A solid, non-porous membrane or rigid shell 37 provides confinement and
isolation from the surrounding liquid medium 36 for an acoustic/shock wave transmitting
liquid 38.
[0068] FIGURE 4 illustrates yet another embodiment of the invention 10' which is substantially
similar to that illustrated in FIGURES 1 and 2. However, the screen 12' in FIGURE
4 is corrugated or articulated or otherwise configured to have a substantially increased
surface area in order to more effectively attenuate the acoustic/shock wave. Additionally,
the corrugations or articulations serve to greatly increase turbulence and formation
of miniature shock waves, and thereby specifically and even more effectively attenuating
shock waves.
[0069] Referring now to FIGURE 5, another embodiment of an acoustic/shock wave attenuating
assembly is generally indicated at 10' and comprises panels 10A, 10B and 10C similar
to the overall panel assembly of FIGURES 1 and 2. The panels 10A, 10B, and 10C as
illustrated in FIGURE 3 are spaced apart to form intervening gaps indicated at 40.
Thus, an acoustic/shock wave approaching the assembly of 10' of FIGURE 5 laterally
would be caused to sequentially penetrate the panels 10A, 10B and 10C as well as the
intervening gaps in order to even more effectively attenuate the acoustic/shock wave.
Otherwise, the various components for the multiple panels in the embodiment of FIGURE
5 are indicated by similar primed numerals in FIGURES 1 and 2.
[0070] Referring now to FIGURE 6, yet another embodiment of an acoustic/shock wave attenuating
assembly is generally indicated at 50 and also includes components generally similar
to those described in FIGURES 1 and 2. Accordingly, corresponding components in FIGURE
6 are indicated by similar primed numerals. Generally, the screen or confinement means
12' in FIGURE 6 is in the configuration of one or more bags for containing the flowable
attenuating medium 14'. At the same time, the bags or confinement means 12' is suspended
from a fabricated structure 52. The fabricated structure 52 thus tends to provide
a panel configuration for the assembly even with the confinement means or bags 12'
being very flexible by themselves.
[0071] Referring now to FIGURE 7, another embodiment or variation of the flowable attenuating
medium 14' is illustrated. The flowable attenuating medium 14' of FIGURE 7 is formed
from solid particulates 62 preferably having both mechanical properties and flow properties
of a fluid. Also preferably, the solid particulates include means for resisting relative
displacement of the particulates in order to better simulate characteristics of an
aqueous foam. For such a purpose, the particulates 62 may be provided with a coating
64 to resist relative motion between the particulates while permitting flow in accordance
with the present invention. For example, the coating 64 may be a light adhesive or
may even comprise Velcro type hook and loop fasteners for resisting relative movement
between the particulates. It is noted that VELCRO is a trademark for such a hook and
loop type fastener.
[0072] Solid particulates 62 may be of any shape, including spherical and irregular forms.
The largest diameters or largest cross sectional dimensions of particulates used in
this invention should be generally less than half the distance between the generally
parallel screens 12. The solid particulates 62 should generally be macroscopic. These
particulates may be hollow with solid surfaces, solid shells with internal cavities
containing liquid phases, or may be comprised entirely of solid materials. The solid
material may be a solid foam, such as a polyurethane or elastomeric compound, or otherwise
be a sponge, whereby the gas and solid phases are both continuous, which thus distinguishes
sponges from foams, wherein the gas phase is entirely enclosed within a liquid or
solid continuous phase. Alternatively, the solid particulates may be comprised of
entrapped gas phases, for example, in the nature of volcanic foam glasses, perlite,
pumice or the like.
[0073] Any of the solid particulates of the invention may be flexible or elastic, or conversely
may be rigid in their mechanical properties.
[0074] Referring now to FIGURE 8, multiple panels 10D, 10E, 10F and 10G are formed in generally
the same manner as the assembly 10 of FIGURE 1. However, the panel assemblies 10D-10G
are suspended or otherwise supported to enclose and define a chamber 90 which may
also be used for a number of applications as described below.
[0075] With any of the embodiments of FIGURES 1-8, either the confinement means comprising
the screen 12 and liner 30 and/or the flowable attenuating medium 14 itself may be
formed from materials absorbing substantial additional energy from the acoustic/shock
wave. For example, intumescent and ablative materials may be employed either as coatings,
treatments for the lining 30, or as comprising materials of solid particulates 62
or coatings for these particulates 64. Alternatively, other materials which absorb
thermal energy through an endothermic chemical reaction may be used as linings 30
or as treatments for these linings, or otherwise or in addition to coatings of the
screen 12 and solid particulates 62 where these are employed.
[0076] FIGURES 9, 10 and 11 illustrate similar panel configurations, preferably multiple
panels with intervening gaps, formed as generally rigid structures with enclosed shapes
to substantially form a chamber therebeneath. These structures of FIGURES 9-11 may
be employed in a number of applications as described in greater detail below.
[0077] Referring initially to FIGURE 9, multiple panels 10A', 10B', and 10C' are commonly
formed as a portion of a cylinder to define the chamber 70 therebeneath. The chamber
is at the ends as illustrated.
[0078] FIGURE 10 illustrates yet another arrangement of multiple panels, 10A', 10B' and
10C' configured as a dome configured as a dome forming a chamber 80 which is completely
enclosed therebeneath. FIGURE 10 provides a fragmentary section of the multiple panel
assemblies 10A', 10B' and 10C' comprising the dome chamber 80.
[0079] FIGURE 11 illustrates a relatively irregular configuration for similar panels 10A',
10B' and 10C' to form a chamber 90 which is substantially enclosed therebeneath while
being open at one end. Here again, such a configuration may be used to advantage in
particular applications.
[0080] The invention may operate as a partition, lining, container, barrier or barricade,
wall element, or structure standing independent of any exterior need of support or
attachment. The invention may operate as an acoustic or shock wave barrier, simultaneously
be employed for attenuation of all types of pressure waves, or for protection exterior
to the invention or on either side of the invention when employed as a partition or
wall structure. The invention may also operate as an acoustic wave absorber for protection
of spaces either formed by the invention or in which partitions or lining elements
of which variants of the invention comprise a part are situated. The invention may
serve a secondary purpose as reservoir of fire fighting aqueous foam agents.
[0081] The basic version of the invention becomes operable when the pressure wave attenuating
fluid is emplaced between two adjacent screen elements. Pressure waves impinging on
the invention from any angle are reflected when they encounter screen and solid elements
of the invention, and are admitted into the flowable attenuating medium when the incident
waves encounter the porous openings. Pressure waves transmitting through the outer
screen element are substantially slowed and scattered as they travel through the flowable
attenuating medium, particularly where this medium is an aqueous foam.
[0082] Portions of the transmitting waves are reflected upon encountering the second, or
rear, screen of the acoustic/shock wave attenuating assembly and the gas (or vacuum,
as may be employed)/fluid interface, and remaining portions of transmitting pressure
waves are dispersed as they encounter the interface between the pressure wave attenuating
fluid and contiguous gas or solid. A substantial fraction of the initially incident
pressure wave will thus undergo multiple reflections within the fluid confined between
screen elements, in essence, substantial portions of the incident pressure wave are
trapped within the screen/fluid sandwich. With a plurality of screen/fluid sandwich
layers, this effect will be magnified.
[0083] When aqueous foams are used, substantial energy is removed from the incident pressure
wave by scattering at the multitudinous interfaces presented by bubble wall liquids
and the gas entrapped which comprise the basic units of aqueous foam structures, and
through the displacement of the liquid in the aqueous foam. A similar effect is obtained
when solid bead materials are employed -- particularly solids with entrained gas,
such as vermiculite and organic solid foams. For the particular case of aqueous foams,
substantial energy is also removed from pressure waves reflected back into the attenuating
fluid from screen components due to turbulent flow fields established by passage of
the initial pressure wave. This is impossible for solid foam materials.
[0084] Additional energy and thus attenuation of transmitting pressure waves is accomplished
by cancellation as scattered, slowed and reflected waves become coincident. A further
contributor toward energy removal by the invention is that propagation paths of pressure
waves through the foam are substantially lengthened by their scattering and dispersion.
[0085] Incident shock waves are attenuated by additional phenomena generated by the invention.
Shock and blast waves consist of an initial overpressure, or positive pressure phase
(in excess of the ambient initial pressure) followed by a negative, or rarefaction,
phase. The rarefaction phase is typically longer in duration unless the shock wave
undergoes reflections. Because shock waves transmitting through aqueous foams are
substantially slowed and thereby further expanding the rarefaction wave duration relative
to the overpressure portion, and at different values due to random dispersion within
the foam, destructive interference by coincidence of positive and negative pressure
waves is substantially increased with respect to unconfined aqueous foams or foams
in simple containers.
[0086] Another substantial factor related to destructive interference between pressure wave
components is that weaker (slower) shock waves have been shown to separate into two
components when transmitting through aqueous foams. The precursor wave is lower in
amplitude but propagates at a higher velocity. The main wave follows, it is larger
in magnitude but tends to lose velocity with respect to the precursor wave during
passage through aqueous foam. The present invention uniquely utilizes this phenomenon
in two ways, by slowing strong shock wave propagation until the wave separates into
precursor and main wave components, then causing reflecting of the two components
in such a manner as to promote destructive interference or cancellation.
[0087] Additionally, shock waves displace bubbles and accelerate liquids in bubble walls
of the aqueous foam, causing the bubbles to shrink and many to collapse. This displacement
of the liquid, the breaking of bubble walls against the cohesive force of their surface
tension, and the acceleration of liquid droplets formed from shattered bubble walls
all serve to absorb substantial energy from the transmitting shock wave. Substantial
parts of the transmitting shock wave are reflected back into the aqueous foam at the
interface between the foam and contiguous gas or solid, a process which is repeated
numerous times by part of the original incident pressure wave, in essence trapping
part of the original incident pressure wave.
[0088] Yet another substantial contributor to energy removal from the incident shock wave,
thus attenuating such waves, is that the incident wave creates choked flow conditions
within the mesh or perforated sheet openings, which serves to reflect a portion of
the incident shock wave. In this manner, only a fraction of the energy carried by
the incident shock wave is allowed to pass through the first screen encountered. Where
the transmitted shock encounters another screen, another fraction of this shock wave
is reflected back. When the reflected wave must travel through aqueous foam dispersion
and attenuation of the wave is greatly increased through the phenomena described in
the preceding paragraph. Turbulent flow fields are also established in the vicinity
of screen elements by shock wave passage through screen openings, which significantly
contribute to scattering of pressure waves within the foam and by transmitting pressure
waves beyond.
[0089] Employment of an intervening evacuated space, a space filled by gas, or a space filled
with solid particulates in which a vacuum or gas is present between spaces filled
with aqueous foam or other flowable attenuating media will greatly increase pressure
wave attenuation. Evacuated or vacuum spaces will not transmit pressure waves. Incident
pressure waves will reflect at the solid surface which confines the vacuum or gas
unless sufficiently intense as to rupture the confining surface. Upon rupture of the
confining surface, the pressure wave would be transmitted by the flowable attenuating
medium accelerated through the rupture, and the ambient gas able to leak into the
formerly evacuated space. However, only a small portion of the incident pressure wave
could be conveyed in this manner due to the small mass and irregular structure of
accelerated, unconfined flowable attenuating medium. Further reflection and scattering
of the transmitted pressure wave occurs upon encountering successive screens, linings,
and foam interfaces.
[0090] Employment of corrugated screens in any location of the invention provides additional
scattering and turbulence, which therefore further increases attenuation. Pressure
waves impinging on the flowable attenuating medium from a gaseous medium arrive at
the corrugated interface at differing times and at different angles. Scattering and
dispersion of the transmitting pressure waves is thus enhanced. Furthermore, the path
through the flowable attenuating medium is thus greater for a fraction of the transmitting
pressure wave from the instant of first encounter with the foam. Since aqueous foam
is known to substantially reduce the propagation velocity of pressure waves, further
dispersion and destructive interference of transmitting wave components is accomplished
when they are.
[0091] Linings serve to provide confinement for aqueous foams, and for solid particulate
materials when these are employed. Some reflection of incident pressure waves will
occur upon impingement, and such linings may provide additional acoustic barrier capabilities.
Where the invention is employed primarily for blast and shock wave attenuation, linings
and any other materials used to confine gases or maintain vacuum conditions must rupture
or otherwise provide openings upon the impingement of shock waves at a pressure substantially
below that of the impinging shock wave in order to avoid substantial pressure rise
as is inevitably created by solid obstructions in these situations.
[0092] Coatings or chemical additions which serve to absorb thermal and radiant energy may
be used on any element or combination of elements comprising the invention. Such chemicals
reduce the energy of incident blast waves due to the mathematical linkage between
blast wave temperature, overpressure, and propagation velocity, which serves to enhance
attenuation of the incident blast wave. The invention operates with or without the
presence of an increase in temperature, however, so that thermal energy absorbing
materials only serve to enhance capabilities in certain applications.
[0093] Accordingly, the pressure wave attenuating device can be used for any type of pressure
wave transmitted in a gaseous medium. The invention requires no electric power source
or sensor to operate since aqueous foam generation and filling can be accomplished
using only a compressed gas source with which to create and mechanically place the
foam within the desired space or spaces. There are no electronic or mechanically sensing
components which can prevent the invention from functioning. An additional advantage
of the pressure wave attenuating device is that other energy absorbing or protective
features may be added to enhance its attenuating capabilities or to provide additional
capabilities, such as stopping fragments from explosions. Typical applications would
enable the same aqueous foam agents and generating equipment as are commonly used
in fighting fires to be employed in the invention.
[0094] Attenuation of acoustic waves is accomplished without regard to intensity, directionality,
or frequency. This device operates regardless of orientation with respect to impinging
pressure waves or, where present, confining walls defining an enclosure in which the
invention is placed. Because of the light weight of aqueous foams and the structural
elements required by the attenuating assembly described above, this invention is easily
made portable in sizes useful for noise suppression around aircraft with jet or gas
turbine engines. When protected from heat and sunlight, aqueous foams are stable for
prolonged periods enabling the pressure wave attenuating device to be employed as
acoustic walls in anechoic chambers or other applications requiring acoustic wave
damping in enclosures.
[0095] Simultaneous attenuation of all types of pressure waves affords the invention the
capability to serve as means to dispose of explosives and ordnance near structures
or inhabited areas. By mitigating blast energy, noise and shock waves are attenuated.
Bomb fragments are stopped by a combination of reducing propelling energy and by multiple
layers of high strength screen materials. These same capabilities enable this device
to be employed to provide protection of artillery crews exposed to enemy artillery
and air dropped munitions from both blast effect and from the noise produced by their
own guns.
[0096] The ability of the pressure wave attenuating device to operate in a variety of configurations
enables it to be employed to provide blast protection on board aircraft which may
carry explosive devices meant to destroy the aircraft, and for protecting personnel
sent to remove or disarm such devices when discovered. The invention can be configured
to operate in curved spaces such as missile launchers used aboard warships, around
machinery in hazardous environments such as in petrochemical refining and production
facilities, or as protective barriers around rescue equipment. Our pressure wave attenuating
device is unique in its ability to operate effectively in unconfined environments.
Furthermore, our invention operates effectively without a requirement to be located
close to the source of the pressure wave, or without a specific orientation thereto.
[0097] Furthermore, the variety of configurations allowed by this invention enable the acoustic/shock
attenuating assembly to be employed for protecting ships and offshore structures from
shock effects arising from underwater explosions when aqueous foams are employed as
the flowable attenuating medium. The invention can similarly be used for protecting
offshore and coastal structures from seismic shock effects as well as aquatic life
from any type of shock waves in water. This can be accomplished by using a lining
which confines a fluid which serves to transmit the pressure wave between the outer
screen and a lining which confines aqueous foam in the manner of sonar type acoustical
detection devices wherein a membrane is filled with water or other fluid to conduct
acoustic waves.
[0098] The invention preferably employs aqueous foam agents which have neither toxic qualities
nor produce toxic compounds as a result of operation. It is light in weight and may
easily be stowed in most of its configurations when not needed or when being transported.
When used in confined spaces, the invention occupies a small fraction of the enclosed
volume and does not involve flooding. The acoustic/shock wave attenuating assembly
enables personnel to occupy and work in that space, which only explosion vents allow
among all possible blast pressure mitigating means in current use. Unlike explosion
vents however, the invention uniquely is usable in situations which proscribe opening
confined spaces to adjoining spaces. This is critical aboard ships, which cannot be
opened to the sea, and within any structure where smoke and combustion products must
be confined to avoid harm to trapped individuals and to facilitate emergency crew
operation.
[0099] In addition to the use of solid and liquid attenuating mediums as described elsewhere,
the invention further contemplates that substantially all embodiments of the invention
are adapted for use with a class of very light weight materials generally referred
to as "aerogels". These materials are similar in structure, at least in certain aspects,
to the filamentary materials described in one of the preceding embodiments of the
invention. However, the aerogels differ in their formation by the inclusion of multitudinous
small cavities filled with a gaseous phase. Such aerogels can be manufactured with
extremely low densities, almost down to that of atmospheric air at sea level, and
have long been know to those skilled in the art of low density structures,
etc.
[0100] Rather than describing such aerogels in greater detail herein, it is noted that the
structure and typical compositions of such aerogels are described in a number of references,
particularly an article by Jochen Fricke, entitled "Aerogels",
Scientific American, Vol. 258, No. 5, May 1988, pp. 92-97. This reference is incorporated herein as though
set forth in its entirety.
[0101] It is to be understood that such aerogels, because of their extremely low density,
are desirable for forming variations of substantially any of the embodiments of the
invention where minimum weight is important. It is further noted that a flowable attenuating
medium formed from aerogels may use generally the same support structures disclosed
for the attenuating medium in different embodiments of the invention. Accordingly,
the attenuating medium described in substantially all of the embodiments of the present
invention may be replaced partially or entirely by such aerogel materials.
[0102] A further embodiment of the invention is described immediately below with reference
to FIGURE 12 which illustrates the use of an attenuating medium in combination with
a frangible element or covering.
[0103] Referring to FIGURE 12, an attenuating assembly generally similar to that indicated
at 10 and 10' elsewhere, is indicated at 130. The assembly 130 includes a confinement
means or support medium 12' in combination with a flowable attenuating medium 14'.
The attenuating medium may be any of the forms described elsewhere herein.
[0104] A frangible element 132 is provided as a protective covering for the assembly 130
and particularly for the attenuating medium 14'. The frangible element 132 is arranged
on the blast side or exposed side 136 of the assembly and opposite the protected side
138 of the assembly.
[0105] A stiffener 134 is preferably associated with the frangible element 132 if necessary
or desired for further support.
[0106] This embodiment with the frangible element enables the attenuating assembly to withstand
severe outdoor weather environments and to otherwise isolate the environment on one
side of the attenuating assembly from the other.
[0107] The frangible element 132 is preferably formed as a part of the assembly 130 in order
to prevent gas movement or diffusion through or across the assembly 130.
[0108] Frangible materials suitable for forming the element 132 are well known to those
skilled in the art and may be formed, for example, from scored metal, composites of
plastics and glass, plastics, glasses and other polymeric materials. Alternatively,
they may also be formed from agglomerations of organic and/or inorganic materials
held together by binders and pressed or molded into any desired shape.
[0109] The frangible element 132 is preferably designed to withstand wind loads or other
common environmental conditions. At the same time, the frangible element 132 is adapted
for shattering into small pieces when impinged upon by acoustic level pressure conditions
including acoustic waves and/or shock waves as discussed elsewhere herein. Accordingly,
when such pressure conditions arise, the shattering of the frangible element 132 immediately
exposes the attenuating medium 14' to accomplish its function as described herein.
[0110] Still another embodiment of the invention contemplates its use for protecting structures
and/or people from the harmful effects of explosive devices including ammunitions,
bombs and other types of explosive devices. A particular type of ammunition against
which the present invention can provide protection is generally referred to as either
a shaped-charge or hollow-charge device. By a combination of substantially reducing
the velocity of the shock wave created by the detonation of the explosive component
and which forms the penetrating slug, dispersing and scattering elements of the shock
wave so as to disrupt the uniform shape of the shock front, suppressing the evolution
of blast gases by the explosive charge which provides the motive force for the penetrating
slug, and by causing entrainment of low mass components, with the possible inclusion
of volatilizing components into the penetrating slug, the penetrating ability of the
slug formed by the shaped-charge munition or device is greatly reduced.
[0111] Such shaped-charge devices and their use are well known to those skilled in the art
and a detailed description of such devices is not believed necessary within the scope
of the present invention. It is noted that such shaped-charges and their functions
are described by a large number of references, such as the publication
Fundamentals of Shaped-Charges by William P. Walters, published 1989 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc. (see pp. 13-14,
et al.). This reference is also incorporated herein as though set forth in its entirety.
[0112] The use of the present invention in such applications is illustrated in FIGURE 17.
Referring to FIGURE 13, an attenuating assembly is generally indicated at 140 including
a confinement means or support medium 12' in combination with a flowable attenuating
medium 14' as described elsewhere herein.
[0113] In the embodiment of FIGURE 13, the attenuating assembly 140 is arranged upon an
otherwise exposed surface 142 of typical armor plate generally indicated at 144.
[0114] The attenuating assembly 140 preferably and optionally includes an actuating element
or support surface 146 arranged either within or opposite the attenuating medium 14'
from the exposed surface 142 of the armor plate.
[0115] When used to protect against the penetration and subsequent harmful effects from
shaped-charge munitions, the assembly 140 can be used as an exterior armor or barrier
element for a wide variety of implements or structures (not shown) including armor
plate such as that indicated at 144 in FIGURE 13. The incorporation of combustion-extinguishing
agents, particularly those with rapid reaction times, greatly interferes with the
formation of an effective penetrating slug, as shaped-charge munitions are intended
to produce, and further reduces the damage possible behind the armor or barrier should
it be pierced, particularly due to hot spall and blast gases under pressure.
[0116] These mitigating events are produced by reducing the velocity of the shock wave which
forms the penetrating slug, dispersing and scattering elements of the shock wave so
as to disrupt the uniform shape of the shock wave front, to suppress to a substantial
degree the evolution of blast gases which constitute the motive force of the slug,
and the subsequently formed jet to entrain materials of low mass into the slug and
thus accelerate the disruption of the jet's mechanical integrity, and to suppress
to a substantial degree the thermal energy component which comprises a substantial
portion of the deleterious effects generated by the shaped-charge munition. Incorporation
of a low-boiling point or flashing liquid within the attenuating assembly is possible
with the present invention, which can further accelerate disruption of the slug as
vapor bubbles are entrained.
[0117] Accordingly, it is particularly contemplated that this embodiment of the invention
be employed in military or terrorist applications or the like.
[0118] Shaped-charges of the type referred to above generally fit the definition of the
present invention in exceeding sonic or shock wave speeds.
[0119] Generally, the present invention can be useful against shaped-charges including only
the attenuating medium 14' in combination with the armor plate as illustrated in FIGURE
13. In such a combination, the shaped-charge may or may not be actuated upon contact
with the medium 14' itself. In any event, the shaped-charge device is detonated upon
contact with the exposed surface 142 of the armor plate 144. Assuming actuation upon
contact with the armor plate, the shaped-charge device is generally surrounded by
the attenuating medium 14' upon detonation so that the attenuating medium interferes
with proper operation of the shaped charge as described above.
[0120] It is also possible to employ the attenuating medium 14' together with the actuating
element or surface 146 which may form a portion of the confinement means or support
medium 12'. In this regard, the actuating element 146 is selected with sufficient
mass or resistance in order to assure actuation of the shaped-charge device. Thus,
with the actuating element 146 in place, actuation of the shaped-charge device is
assured as it approaches the attenuating medium 14' prior to engagement with the armor
plate 144.
[0121] It is to be noted that shaped-charge devices of the type described above may include
sequential charges. The embodiment of FIGURE 13 with the actuating element 146 may
be desirable in connection with such devices since an initial smaller charge would
be actuated by the actuating element 146. Thereafter, the main charge of the device
would be actuated upon engagement with the armor plate with the device being surrounded
by the actuating medium as described above. It is further contemplated that spaced
apart layers of the attenuating medium, either alone or in combination with suitable
support structure (not shown) may be employed for even further protection against
shaped-charge devices including sequential charges.
[0122] Another embodiment or concept of the invention is similarly contemplated for protecting
people and/or structures from the harmful effects of explosions where explosive ammunitions
or devices, for example, may be detonated due to shock wave over-pressure and/or thermal
energy release from the detonation of another explosive charge or device. This phenomenon
is commonly referred to as "sympathetic detonation", "fratricide", "propagation" or
"chain reaction". Any of the embodiments of the present invention may be employed
in such applications as a barrier, buffer or ramp of one explosive munition or device
in order to protect it from external overpressure and/or thermal energy generated
by another explosive device arranged external of the invention.
[0123] Accordingly, in this embodiment or concept, the attenuating medium is used in generally
the same manner described elsewhere herein. However, it is contemplated that one explosive
element or device (not shown) be sheltered or arranged within the attenuating medium
assembly of the invention in order to protect it from another explosive element or
device (not shown) which is external to the attenuating medium assembly.
[0124] A still further embodiment or variation of the invention involves its use in forming
air cargo containers or the like. Here again, generally all of the above described
embodiments of the invention are suitable for this application with the air cargo
container forming the interior of the attenuating medium assembly. Preferably, the
assembly is formed as a complete enclosure or lining for the container. It is also
particularly contemplated that the invention be used in fabricated panels to form
the lining for such containers.
[0125] In any event, a container including such a lining can provide substantial protection
against blasts occurring within the container, the invention thereby protecting the
areas surrounding the container. Similarly, the lining could also protect the interior
of the container from external blasts.
[0126] Referring particularly to FIGURE 14, the invention also contemplates use of the attenuating
medium of any of the preceding embodiments in combination with conventional honeycomb
which may preferably provide support for the attenuating medium. A preferred configuration
is indicated at 150 in FIGURE 8 wherein the attenuating medium 14' is preferably arranged
in all of the cells 152 of a honeycomb structure 154. The attenuating medium is illustrated
only in selected cells of the honeycomb structure in FIGURE 18 for simplicity.
[0127] The attenuating medium may be a solid or liquid as described elsewhere above.
[0128] Preferably, the configuration 150 includes porous confinement means 30' arranged
on opposite sides of the honeycomb structure 154. The cells 152 of the honeycomb structure
are arranged with their axes 156 intersecting the porous confinement means 30'. The
configuration 150 is preferably arranged with one of the porous confinement means
30' facing a shock wave source as indicated by the arrow 158.
[0129] With this arrangement, the cells of the honeycomb are exposed to the shock wave as
it penetrates porous confinement means 30' Thus, the attenuating medium is free to
react in generally the same manner described above. Preferably, the cells of the honeycomb
are sufficiently large to permit the contemplated function of the attenuating medium.
[0130] More preferably, the honeycomb structure 154 is provided with a large number of openings
160 in the walls 162 of the cells. The openings 160 permit lateral propagation of
the shock wave between adjacent cells to further facilitate the function of the attenuating
medium as discussed elsewhere herein.
[0131] There have accordingly been described a number of embodiments of attenuating assemblies
and/or mediums constructed according to the present invention. Variations and modifications
in addition to those described above are believed obvious from the description. Accordingly,
the scope of the invention is defined only by the following appended claims.
1. Anordnung (10) zum Dämpfen von Druckzuständen des akustischen Pegels, die ein fließfähiges
Dämpfungsmedium (14) umfasst, das Charakteristiken eines wässrigen Schaums aufweist,
nämlich die Fähigkeit nach Art einer flüssigen Masse zu wirken, um einer relativen
Versetzung durch Oberflächenspannung und Zähigkeitskräfte zu widerstehen, und die
Fähigkeit, dort hindurch übertragende Druckzustände auf Grund von zahlreichen gekrümmten
Oberflächen, die gasförmige und feste oder flüssige and feste Phasen trennen, im Wesentlichen
zu streuen und zu verteilen, und die Erzeugung von Feldern turbulenter Strömungen
durch Übertragung von Druckzuständen zu ermöglichen, und ein Einschlussmittel (12,
16, 18) zum Enthalten und Tragen des fließfähigen Dämpfungsmediums umfasst, wobei
die Kombination aus dem Einschlussmittel und dem fließfähigen Dämpfungsmedium so eingerichtet
ist, dass die zu dämpfenden Druckzustände aufgefangen werden, wobei das Einschlussmittel
hinsichtlich der Druckzustände durchlässig ist, um zu gestatten, dass die Druckzustände
in das fließfähige Dämpfungsmedium eindringen, wobei das durchlässige Einschlussmittel
auch eine wesentliche Druckabnahme der durch die durchlässigen Einschlussmittel dringenden
Druckzustände bewirkt.
2. Dämpfungsanordnung nach Anspruch 1, bei dem das fließfähige Dämpfungsmedium (14) ein
wässriger Schaum ist.
3. Dämpfungsanordnung nach Anspruch 2, der ferner Mittel umfasst zum Regenerieren des
wässrigen Schaums aus einer Flüssigkeit, die vom wässrigen Schaum im Einschlussmittel
(12, 16, 18) abfließt, und dadurch Aufrechterhalten des wässrigen Schaums (14), so
dass sein Volumen im Wesentlichen das Einschlussmittel ausfüllt.
4. Dämpfungsanordnung nach Anspruch 1, bei der das fließfähige Dämpfungsmedium (14) feste
Teilchen (62) umfasst, die mechanische Bulk-Eigenschaften und Fließeigenschaften eines
Fluids aufweisen, nämlich die Fähigkeit nach Art einer flüssigen Masse zu wirken,
um einer relativen Versetzung durch Oberflächenspannung und Zähigkeitskräfte zu widerstehen,
und die Fähigkeit, dort hindurch übertragende Druckzustände auf Grund von zahlreichen
gekrümmten Oberflächen, die gasförmige und feste oder flüssige und feste Phasen trennen,
im Wesentlichen zu streuen und zu verteilen, und die Erzeugung von Feldern turbulenter
Strömungen durch Übertragung von Druckzuständen zu ermöglichen, und ferner mit den
festen Teilchen (62) verbundene Mittel (64) umfassen, um ihre Widerstandsfähigkeit
gegen eine relative Versetzung zu erhöhen und dadurch zu bewirken, dass die festen
Teilchen (62) die Charakteristiken eines wässrigen Schaums besser simulieren.
5. Dämpfungsanordnung nach Anspruch 4, bei dem die festen Teilchen (62) eine Abmessung
von wenigstens etwa einem Millimeter aufweisen und in Kombination eine Tendenz zeigen
die Form das Einschlussmittels (12) anzunehmen während sie ausgeübten Scherkräften
nach Art der Fluidviskosität widerstehen.
6. Dämpfungsanordnung nach Anspruch 1, bei dem das Einschlussmittel im Allgemeinen parallele
Seitenabschnitte (12) umfasst, die sich verbinden, um eine Platte zu bilden mit dem
fließfähigen Dämpfungsmedium (14), das dazwischen gehalten ist, um Druckzustände aufzufangen,
die sich einem der Seitenabschnitte nähern.
7. Dämpfungsanordnung nach Anspruch 6, bei dem beide Seitenabschnitte des Einschlussmittels
(12) hinsichtlich der Druckzustände durchlässig sind, um deren Dämpfung zu erhöhen.
8. Dämpfungsanordnung nach Anspruch 7, der ferner eine Vielzahl von Platten (12), die
jeweils durch im Allgemeinen parallele Seitenabschnitte gebildet sind, wobei das fließfähige
Dämpfungsmedium (14) dazwischen gehalten wird, und dazwischenliegende Lücken zwischen
den Platten umfasst, wodurch die Druckzustände wirksam dazu gebracht werden, nacheinander
durch die Mehrzahl von Platten und dazwischenliegenden Lücken zu dringen, um die Dämpfung
zu erhöhen.
9. Dämpfungsanordnung nach Anspruch 7, bei dem das fließfähig Dämpfungsmedium (14) ein
wässriger Schaum ist.
10. Dämpfungsanordnung nach Anspruch 1, bei der das fließfähige Dämpfungsmedium feste
Teilchen (62) umfasst, die mechanische Bulk-Eigenschaften und Fließeigenschaften eines
Fluids aufweisen, nämlich die Fähigkeit, nach Art einer flüssigen Masse zu wirken,
um einer relativen Versetzung durch Oberflächenspannung und Zähigkeitskräfte zu widerstehen,
und die Fähigkeit, dort hindurch übertragende Druckzustände auf Grund von zahlreichen
gekrümmten Oberflächen, die gasförmige und feste oder flüssige und feste Phasen trennen,
im Wesentlichen zu streuen und zu verteilen, und die Erzeugung von Feldern turbulenter
Strömungen durch Übertragung von Druckzuständen zu ermöglichen und ferner mit den
festen Teilchen (62) verbundene Mittel (64) umfassen, um ihre Widerstandsfähigkeit
gegen eine relative Versetzung zu verbessern und dadurch zu bewirken, dass die festen
Teilchen (62) die Charakteristiken eines wässrigen Schaums besser simulieren, und
ferner mit den festen Teilchen verbundene Mittel umfassen, um ihre Widerstandsfähigkeit
gegen eine relative Versetzung zu verbessern und dadurch zu bewirken, dass die festen
Teilchen die Charakteristiken eines wässrigen Schaums besser simulieren.
11. Dämpfungsanordnung nach Anspruch 6, der strukturelle Mittel zum Halten der Kombination
aus dem Einschlussmittel und dem fließfähigen Dämpfungsmedium umfasst.
12. Dämpfungsanordnung nach Anspruch 11, bei dem die Kombination aus dem Einschlussmittel
und dem fließfähigen Dämpfungsmedium (14) so gestaltet ist, dass sie eine im Allgemeinen
eingeschlossene Kammer (90) bildet.
13. Dämpfungsanordnung nach Anspruch 1, bei dem das fließfähige Dämpfungsmedium (14) ein
Aerogel ist.
14. Dämpfungsanordnung nach Anspruch 1, der an einer freiliegenden Oberfläche (142) einer
Panzerplatte (144) angeordnet ist, um die Fähigkeit der Panzerplatte (144) Sprengeinrichtungen
zu wiederstehen zu verbessern.
15. Dämpfungsanordnung nach Anspruch 14, bei dem der Aufbau dafür ausgelegt ist, die Widerstandsfähigkeit
der Panzerplatte (144) gegen Hohlladungseinrichtungen zu erhöhen und ferner ein Betätigungselement
(146) zu umfassen, das mit einem Abstand von der Panzerplatte (144) angeordnet ist.
16. Dämpfungsanordnung nach Anspruch 1, der ferner einen mit dem fließfähigen Dämpfungsmedium
verbundenen zerbrechlichen Schild (132) umfasst, um normalerweise die Umgebungsbedingungen
auf den gegenüberliegenden Seiten des Dämpfungsmediums zu trennen, wobei der zerbrechliche
Schild (132) dazu neigt, durch Druckzustände des akustischen Pegels zu zerspringen,
um eine Reaktion des fließfähigen Dämpfungsmediums auf die Druckzustände zu erleichtern.
17. Dämpfungsanordnung nach Anspruch 16, der ferner ein mit dem zerbrechlichen Schild
(132) verbundenes Versteifungselement umfasst.
18. Dämpfungsanordnung nach Anspruch 1, der eine Auskleidung für wenigstens einen Oberflächenabschnitt
eines Behälters bildet.
19. Dämpfungsanordnung nach Anspruch 1, bei dem das Einschlussmittel eine Wabenstruktur
(154) zum Enthalten und Tragen des fließfähigen Dämpfungsmediums (14') umfasst.
1. Ensemble (10) pour atténuer les conditions de niveau de pression acoustique, comprenant
un milieu d'atténuation fluide (14) présentant les caractéristiques d'une mousse aqueuse,
à savoir la capacité d'agir à la manière d'une masse de liquide pour s'opposer à un
déplacement relatif au moyen d'une tension de surface et de forces visqueuses et l'aptitude
à sensiblement diffuser et disperser des conditions de pression, qui sont transmises
à travers ce milieu, sous l'effet de multiples surfaces courbes séparant les phases
gazeuse et solide ou liquide et solide, et permettant la production de zones d'écoulement
de turbulence au moyen de la transmission de conditions de pression, et des moyens
de confinement (12, 16, 18) destinés à contenir et supporter le milieu d'atténuation
fluide, la combinaison des moyens de confinement et du milieu d'atténuation fluide
étant agencée de manière à intercepter les conditions de pression devant être atténuées,
les moyens de confinement étant poreux en rapport avec les conditions de pression
de manière à permettre aux conditions de pression de pénétrer dans le milieu d'atténuation
fluide, les moyens de confinement poreux entraînant également une réduction sensible
des conditions de pression pénétrant dans les moyens de confinement poreux.
2. Ensemble d'atténuation selon la revendication 1, dans lequel le milieu d'atténuation
fluide (14) est une mousse aqueuse.
3. Ensemble d'atténuation selon la revendication 2, comprenant en outre des moyens pour
régénérer une mousse aqueuse à partir du liquide s'évacuant de la mousse aqueuse dans
les moyens de confinement (12, 16, 18) et maintenir de ce fait la mousse aqueuse (14)
de telle sorte que son volume remplit sensiblement les moyens de confinement.
4. Ensemble d'atténuation selon la revendication 1, dans lequel le milieu d'atténuation
fluide (14) comprend des particules solides (62) ayant globalement des propriétés
mécaniques et des propriétés d'écoulement d'un fluide, à savoir la possibilité d'agir
en tant que masse liquide pour s'opposer à un déplacement relatif par une tension
de surface et des forces visqueuses et l'aptitude à sensiblement diffuser et disperser
des conditions de pression transmises par le milieu, au moyen de multiples surfaces
courbes séparant les phases gazeuse et solide ou liquide et solide et permettant la
production de zones d'écoulement turbulent moyennant la transmission de conditions
de pression, et comprenant en outre des moyens (64) associés aux particules solides
(62) pour améliorer leur résistance à un déplacement relatif et de ce fait amener
les particules solides (62) à mieux simuler les caractéristiques d'une mousse aqueuse.
5. Ensemble d'atténuation selon la revendication 4, dans lequel les particules solides
(62) possèdent une dimension d'au moins environ 1 mm et, en combinaison, présentent
une tendance à prendre la forme des moyens de confinement (12), tout en s' opposant
à des forces de cisaillement appliquées, à la manière de la viscosité d'un fluide.
6. Ensemble d'atténuation selon la revendication 1, dans lequel les moyens de confinement
comprennent des parties latérales (12), qui sont d'une manière générale parallèles
et qui se combinent pour former un panneau et entre lesquelles est supporté le milieu
d'atténuation fluide (14), pour intercepter les conditions de pression se rapprochant
de l'une des parties latérales.
7. Ensemble d'atténuation selon la revendication 6, dans lequel les deux parties latérales
des moyens de confinement (12) sont poreuses par rapport aux condition de pression
afin d' améliorer l'atténuation de ces conditions.
8. Ensemble d'atténuation selon la revendication 7, comprenant en outre une pluralité
de panneaux (12) formés chacun par des parties latérales d'une manière générale parallèles
entre lesquelles est supporté un milieu d'atténuation fluide (14), et des interstices
intercalaires situés entre les panneaux, ce qui a pour effet que les conditions de
pression sont amenées à pénétrer effectivement dans la pluralité de panneaux et d'interstices
intercalaires pour amplifier l'atténuation.
9. Ensemble d'atténuation selon la revendication 7, dans lequel le milieu d'atténuation
fluide (14) est une mousse aqueuse.
10. Ensemble d'atténuation selon la revendication 7, dans lequel le milieu d'atténuation
fluide comprend des particules solides (62) possédant globalement des propriétés mécaniques
et des propriétés d'écoulement d'un fluide, à savoir la possibilité d'agir en tant
que masse liquide pour s'opposer à un déplacement relatif par une tension de surface
et des forces visqueuses et l'aptitude à sensiblement diffuser et disperser des conditions
de pression transmises par le milieu, au moyen de multiples surfaces courbes séparant
les phases gazeuse et solide ou liquide et solide et permettant la production de zones
d'écoulement turbulent moyennant la transmission de conditions de pression, et comprenant
en outre des moyens (64) associés aux particules solides (62) pour améliorer leur
résistance à un déplacement relatif et de ce fait amener les particules solides (62)
à mieux simuler les caractéristiques d'une mousse aqueuse, et comprenant en outre
des moyens associés aux particules solides pour améliorer leur résistance à un déplacement
relatif et de ce fait amener lesdites particules solides à mieux simuler les caractéristiques
d'une mousse aqueuse.
11. Ensemble d'atténuation selon la revendication 6, comprenant des moyens structurels
pour supporter la combinaison des moyens de confinement et du milieu d'atténuation
fluide.
12. Ensemble d'atténuation selon la revendication 11, dans lequel la combinaison des moyens
de confinement et du milieu d'atténuation fluide (14) est conformée de manière à former
une chambre (20) qui d'une manière générale est fermée.
13. Ensemble d'atténuation selon la revendication 1, dans lequel le milieu d'atténuation
fluide (14) est un aérogel.
14. Ensemble d'atténuation selon la revendication 1, disposé sur une surface exposée (142)
d'une plaque de renfort (144) pour accroître l'aptitude de la plaque de renfort (144)
à résister à des dispositifs explosifs
15. Ensemble d' atténuation selon la revendication 14, dans lequel l'ensemble est adapté
pour accroître la résistance de la plaque de renfort (144) à des dispositifs à charge
creuse et comporte en outre un élément d'actionnement (146) disposé dans une disposition
écartée par rapport à la plaque de renfort (144).
16. Ensemble d'atténuation selon la revendication 1, comprenant en outre un bouclier apte
à être rompu (132) associé au milieu d'atténuation fluide pour séparer normalement
des conditions d'environnement sur des côtés opposés du milieu d'atténuation, le bouclier
apte à être rompu (132) étant soumis à un effet de brisance par les conditions de
niveau de pression acoustique pour faciliter la réaction du milieu d'atténuation fluide
aux conditions de pression.
17. Ensemble d'atténuation selon la revendication 16, comprenant en outre un élément de
rigidification associé au bouclier pouvant être rompu (132).
18. Ensemble d'atténuation selon la revendication 1, formant un garnissage pour au moins
une partie de la surface d'un récipient.
19. Ensemble d'atténuation selon la revendication 1, dans lequel les moyens de confinement
comprennent une structure en nid d'abeilles (154) destinée à contenir et supporter
le milieu d'atténuation fluide (14').