FIELD OF INVENTION
[0001] This invention relates to a mouth hygienic composition, which is useful in preventing
or reducing bad breath, in particular for the treatment of halitosis, in the prevention
of plaque formation, gingivitis and calculus and thus suitably facilitate the development
of a healthy mouth hygiene. It also relates to the use of a particular metal chelate
in the composition and a method for using the composition.
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
[0002] It is widely accepted that for many people the affliction of halitosis (bad breath)
may constitute a serious problem, particularly in social encounters. The breath malodour
may be very severe and it may occur e.g. occasionally, regularly, or chronically and
at specific times of the day or month. For the purposes of this application, the terms
"bad breath", "halitosis" and "breath malodour" all mean an unpleasant breath odour
that is objectionable to others.
[0003] Public awareness and concern for this phenomenon are evidenced e.g. by the support
of an estimated $850 million mouth wash industry in the United States of America,
despite reports that commercially available products have no significant effect on
breath malodour. Recent public opinion polls (taken between 1994 and 1995) have for
example revealed that about 55 to 75 million Americans consider bad breath a principle
concern in social encounters (
J.L. Richter: Diagnosis and Treatment of Halitosis; Compendium 17 (1996); p. 370-386, and references quoted therein).
[0004] Studies on the etiologies of breath malodour agree that hydrogen sulphide (H
2S), methyl mercaptan (CH
3SH), and dimethyl sulphide (CH
3SCH
3)
, collectively referred to as volatile sulphur compounds (VSC) are the principal odourants
in bad breath. Volatile sulphur compounds (VSC) originate from the anaerobic bacterial
degradation of sulphur-containing amino acids within the oral cavity. It is now generally
accepted that volatile sulphur compounds (VSC) constitute the major component of halitosis
or bad breath originating from the oral cavity. It has also been shown that anaerobic,
Gram negative bacteria are responsible for this odour production.
[0005] Consequently, all conditions which favour the retention of such a microbial flora
predispose for the formation of VSC and thereby contribute to the development of halitosis.
As substrates for odour production, the bacteria mainly utilize the amino acids methionine
and cysteine present in e.g. proteins from a dietary intake. These amino acids contain
sulphur and are metabolized by the bacteria to yield volatile sulphur compounds. These
substances have an unpleasant odour, even in extremely low concentrations.
DESCRIPTION OF THE PRIOR ART
[0007] Several examples of compounds suggested to be effective as halitosis inhibitors are
described in the prior art. As an example,
Canadian patent application no. 2,154,860 relates to an oral care product which contains alkali metal pyrophosphate and a water-soluble
zinc polyamine complex capable of releasing zinc ions in an environment such as the
oral cavity. The zinc polyamine complex is formed from a polyamine and a normally
water-insoluble zinc compound such as zinc oxide or zinc citrate. The aim is to provide
a high-molecular weight water-soluble polyamine complex of a normally water-insoluble
zinc compound which has utility as an ingredient of improved palatability and reduced
astringency in oral care products. The water-soluble zinc polyamine complex is present
in an aqueous solution which has a clear transparency and is without any visible evidence
of a second phase which is distinct from the aqueous phase. Reference is made to the
fact that the polyamines cited in the above-mentioned Canadian patent application
have an average molecular weight of about 1,500 to 70,000. The invention described
in
Canadian patent application no. 2,154,860 is significantly different from the present invention, both in terms of the solubility
of the zinc compound and in terms of the molecular weight of the composition used.
[0009] US patent no. 4,814,163 relates to a solid antitartar and mouth deodorant composition comprising a physiologically
acceptable zinc compound, an ionone ketone terpene derivative, a mint flavour and
a sodium or potassium gluconate, and having an acidic pH, in a sugar-free carrier.
US patent no. 4,814,163 does not disclose a mouth hygienic composition comprising a chelate of a metal ion
with an amino acid.
[0010] In general, when metals such as zinc, manganese, magnesium, copper, non, cobalt and
others become surrounded by and bonded to amino acids, in a stable form, this is referred
to as chelation or chelate formation. Such chelates are referred to in the art as
e.g. metal amino acid chelates, mineral amino acid chelates and chelates comprising
a metal ion and one or more amino acids. Furthermore, chelates are also often referred
to in the art as socalled coordination compounds. The coordination compounds are very
often slightly soluble, non-ionic complexes. In the present description, the term
"metal amino acid chelate" is used in this meaning.
[0011] Chelation is the natural means for the body to transport minerals across the intestinal
wall as part of digestion. The body is very efficient at absorbing amino acids in
this way. In a priority list of nutritional substances crossing the intestinal wall
after digestion, amino acids rank highly. In fact, 95% of all amino acids are absorbed.
Chelating minerals such as metal ions to these amino acids facilitates the transport
of the mineral across the intestinal wall. In this respect it is very important for
the mineral to have a stable bond to the amino acid.
[0012] US patent no. 5,516,925 relates to mineral amino acid chelates specifically as supplementary mineral sources
for use in human or animal nutrition. It does not relate to a mouth hygienic composition,
but is concerned with facilitating the absorption in the gut and mucosal cells of
the amino acid chelate.
[0013] WO 94/26243 discloses an oral composition against diseases of the oral cavity comprising an effective
amount of copper bis-glycinate and a pharmaceutically acceptable carrier. However,
the structural formula of the copper bis-glycinate disclosed does not correspond to
that of a chelate comprising a metal ion and amino acids as described in the present
application.
[0014] US 4,425,325 discloses oral compositions comprising zink and glycine.
[0015] Water-soluble as well as water-insoluble zinc compounds have also been utilized as
physiologically active ingredients in oral care preparations. Water-soluble and highly
ionized zinc compounds, such as zinc chloride, would appear to provide a valuable
source of bioavailable zinc ions. However, zinc chloride in aqueous solution tends
to form oxychloride and zinc hydroxides of low solubility, which results in a two-phase,
cloudy solution. The pH of a conventional zinc chloride solution can be lowered to
less than 4.5 through the use of mineral or organic acid buffers to provide a stable
and clear solution. However, this method is not acceptable since the resultant oral
care product exhibits severe astringency and an undesirable sour taste.
[0016] Other zinc salts, such as e.g. zinc acetate and zinc citrate, have been used for
the prevention of halitosis. However, zinc acetate and zinc citrate also have a high
degree of astringency and an undesirable metallic taste. As a consequence of these
undesirable characteristics, there has been a long felt need for a zinc-containing
compound which is capable of reducing and/or eliminating halitosis. It would be desirable
to provide the zinc-containing compound as part of a mouth hygienic composition which
dissolves slowly and under controlled conditions in the environment of the oral cavity
so as to provide an effective contact between the zinc and the volatile sulphur compounds
present in this environment.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
[0017] It has now surprisingly been found that zinc provided to the oral cavity as part
of a metal amino acid chelate, is capable of effectively reducing or eliminating bad
or unpleasant breath caused by VSCs. Zinc amino acid chelates do not possess the undesirable
metal-like taste and high degree of astringency which are typical of the above-mentioned
zinc salts. Therefore the present invention provides an organoleptically acceptable
mouth hygienic composition which is effective in the treatment of halitosis and/or
bad breath resulting from VSC.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION
[0018] The present invention relates in one aspect to a mouth hygienic composition comprising
a carrier and a chelate comprising a zinc ion moiety and an amino acid moiety. The
zinc ion is one capable of forming a neutral coordination compound which is relatively
non-polar. This is important since it is preferred that the solubility is low in water
and generally aqueous environments, such as e.g. the saliva found in the environment
of the oral cavity.
[0019] In one embodiment, the chelate according to the present invention can exist in aqueous
solution up to a concentration of about 2%. At higher concentrations such a chelate
becomes colloidal.
[0020] The pH of a 1.0% solution of the chelate in distilled water is preferably in the
range of 7 to 10, such as in the range of 7.5 to 8.0, for example 8.0 to 8.5, such
as 8.5 to 9.0, for example 9.5 to 10.0, such as 7.5 to 9.5, for example 8.0 to 9.0.
Furthermore, the chelate can preferably be dispersed in water and will retain its
tastefree characteristics in water-based liquids.
[0021] Chelates of metal ions with amino acids generally result from the reaction of a metal
ion with one or more amino acids. The reaction is guided by e.g. the valence of the
metal ion in question and its ability to form so-called "coordination bonds" with
the amino group and the carboxy group of the amino acid. Coordination bonds are also
known in the art as coordinate covalent bonds.
[0022] It is desirable that the reaction leading to the chelate formation takes place under
conditions characterized by e.g. a molar ratio such as one mole of metal ion to one
to three, preferably two, moles of amino acids. The resulting molecule has two or
three five-membered heterocyclic ring structures containing a metal ion attached by
coordinate covalent bonds to two or more non-metals in the same molecule. Such chelates
differ from traditional salts by having different physical and chemical properties
such as e.g. the nature of the chemical bonds involved in forming the different chemical
structures.
[0023] For the purpose of this invention, a salt is understood to be any compound produced
when all or part of the hydrogen of an acid is replaced by an electropositive radical
or a metal ion. Salts are usually formed by treating a metal with an acid or by the
interaction of a base and an acid.
[0024] Accordingly, it should be noted that a chelate is not the same as a complex or, indeed,
a complex mixture of a mineral and a protein hydrolysate. Consequently, simply mixing
inorganic minerals with amino acids in a liquid or dry mixture does not fall into
the category of a true amino acid chelate. Such a simple ionic and hydrogen bonding
of minerals to amino acids does not produce a stable product. Special processing must
be performed to create a stable (covalent) bond, which is important for greater bioavailability.
[0025] In general, organic reagents yielding sparingly soluble coordination compounds typically
contain at least two functional groups, each of which is capable of bonding with the
metal ion by donation of a pair of electrons. The functional groups are located in
the molecule in such a way that the above-mentioned five- or six-membered ring structure
results from the chelate formation. Coordination compounds which form complexes of
this type are also referred to in the art as chelating agents. When forming a product
with e.g. a mineral, such as a metal ion, the complex is termed a chelate.
[0026] Neutral coordination compounds are relatively non-polar. As a consequence, their
solubilities are low in water. The low degree of solubility of a neutral coordination
compound can be exploited e.g. when providing a composition which is to be slowly
dissolved in an aqueous environment, such as in the saliva of the oral cavity.
[0027] As already mentioned, several definitions of a metal amino acid chelate are available
in the art. One such definition is concerned with the molecular' weight of the metal
amino acid chelate. The molecular weight of the chelate is determined partly by the
metal ion and partly by the amino acid moiety. It has been suggested that one such
definition should be that a metal amino acid chelate should have a molecular weight
of at the most 800 Daltons (g/mol). To determine the molecular weight of a chelate,
the atomic weight of all the atoms in the ligands plus the atomic weight of the metal
ion being chelated should be included.
[0028] For example, one of the heaviest metals normally chelated is molybdenum with an atomic
weight of 95.94 Daltons. In its +3 oxidation state, molybdenum can be bonded to three
amino acids. Tryptophane is the heaviest amino acid, having a molecular weight of
204.22 Daltons. An amino acid chelate of molybdenum and tryptophane with a 1:3 molar
ratio (metal:amino acid) would then have a molecular weight of 708.60 Daltons. This
illustrates why the upper limit for a true metal amino acid chelate can be set at
800 Daltons.
[0029] A metal amino acid chelate can be formed with one, two or three amino acids. It is
generally accepted in the art that it is physically impossible to chelate any more
amino acids to the metal ion. Additional amino acids must consequently be bonded to
other amino acids, which results in the product no longer being a chelate, as it is
no longer a coordination compound of a mineral to an amino acid.
[0030] Considering the molecular weight of selected metal ion amino acid chelates according
to the present invention, the chelated structure comprising e.g. a zinc ion moiety
and two tryptophane amino acid moieties would have the molecular weight 489.81 Daltons.
[0031] According to one embodiment of the present invention, it is particularly preferred
that the chelate comprises a zinc ion moiety and two lysine moieties. Such a chelate
will have a molecular weight of 369.25 Daltons. However, the present invention is
not limited to zinc lysine chelates. The present invention comprises chelates of a
zinc ion to preferably either one, two or three amino acids.
[0032] Accordingly, in one preferred embodiment of the invention, the mouth hygienic composition
comprises a chelate comprising a metal ion moiety and an amino acid moiety, said chelate
having a molecular weight of at the most 800 Daltons, such as at the most 750 Daltons,
e.g. 700 Daltons, such as 650 Daltons, e.g. 600 Daltons, such as 550 Daltons, e.g.
500 Daltons, such as 450 Daltons, e.g. 400 Daltons, or such as 350 Daltons.
[0033] Consequently, the zinc amino acid chelate used in the present invention is significantly
different from the compounds described in the prior art in terms of both molecular
weight and solubility. This difference may well account for the fact that the chelate
according to the present invention is particularly useful in treating, preventing
and/or eliminating halitosis while at the same time having pleasant organoleptic qualities
and being essentially tastefree in the absence of a flavouring agent.
[0034] The chelates used in the present invention may in preferred embodiments exist in
solution, i.e. be fully dissolved in an aqueous environment, at concentrations of
up to at the most 10%. It may be preferred, however, that the solubility is less than
10%, such as 9%, e.g. 8%, such as 7%, e.g. 6%, such as 5%, e.g. 4%, such as 3%, e.g.
2%, or even less than 2%, such as 1,8%, e.g. 1,6%, such as 1,4%, e.g. 1,2%, or even
1%.
[0035] The solubility of the chelate according to the present invention will depend both
on the metal ion moiety and on the amino acid moiety employed to form the chelate.
The chelate may be dispersed in water and will retain its substantially tastefree
characteristics in water-based liquids.
[0036] The low degree of solubility of a neutral coordination compound of the present invention
can be exploited e.g. when providing a mouth hygienic composition which is to be slowly
dissolved in an aqueous environment, such as in the saliva of the oral cavity. It
is important that the active ingredient of the composition, the metal ion comprising
chelate, may suitably be released under controllable conditions which facilitate an
effective interaction of the zinc ion, with the volatile sulphur compounds present
in an oral cavity environment. This effective interaction desirably takes place without
the generation of any astringent taste or unpleasant smell. Preferably, the composition
according to the present invention is substantially tasteless unless deliberately
being supplemented with a desirable flavouring agent.
[0037] It is preferred that the composition according to invention comprises a chelate characterised
by having a molar ratio of zinc ion moiety to amino acid moiety which is in the range
of 1:1 to 1:3, and preferably 1:2. However, the molar ration may well depend both
on the individual metal ion moieties and the individual amino acid moieties employed,
and the invention is not limited to the molar ratios stated above.
[0038] Chelates which are useful in the present invention are commercially available and
can be prepared by following the techniques generally available in the art of chelate
preparation. As an example, reference can be made to the method of preparing amino
acid chelates disclosed by Ashmead in
US patent 4,830,716.
[0039] The zinc ion, Zn
2+, of the chelate is releasable under controllable conditions in the oral cavity and
thus readily available for reacting with volatile sulphur compounds (VSC) and other
malodourants.
[0040] Any biologically acceptable amino acid can be used in the preparation of metal amino
acid chelates according to the present invention. This includes e.g. naturally occurring
amino acids, essential amino acids, nutritionally valuable amino acids such as for
example glycine, alanine, valine, leucine, isoleucine, serine, threonine, aspartic
acid, asparagine, glutamic acid, glutamine, lysine, arginine, cysteine, methionine,
phenylalanine, tyrosine, tryptophan, histidine and proline.
[0041] Suitable amino acids of the present invention also comprise basic amino acids, acidic
amino acids, amino acids with aliphatic side chains, amino acids with aromatic side
chains, monoamino-monocarboxylic amino acids, hydroxy-monoamino-monocarboxylic amino
acids, monoamino-dicarboxylic amino acids, amidocarboxylic amino acids and diamino-monocarboxylic
amino acids. In general, the reactability of both the carboxy group and the amino
group of an amino acid with a metal ion moiety facilitates the formation of the chelated
structure. This readily explains why almost any biologically acceptable amino acid
will most likely be able to facilitate the formation of the chelated structures present
in the compositions according to the present invention.
[0042] Although any of the above-stated amino acids may contribute to the desirable formation
of chelates capable of releasing a metal ion under suitable conditions, lysine is
particularly preferred, as compositions comprising this amino acid chelated to a zinc
ion have been shown to be exceptionally effective in treating halitosis.
[0043] Accordingly, the present invention relates to mouth hygienic compositions comprising
a chelate of the general formula

alone or in an aqueous solvent,
wherein M is a zinc ion moiety, and R is a side chain of a biologically acceptable
amino acid moiety, preferably lysine or an amino acid with similar functional physico-chemical
properties as lysine. The side chain R may also include H, in which case the amino
acid is glycine.
[0044] Accordingly, in one particular interesting embodiment of the invention, the chelate
of the present invention comprises an amino acid residue wherein the side chain R
has the structure -CH
2-CH
2-CH
2-CH
2-NH
2 or is a functional derivative hereof. The term functional derivative shall be interpreted
to mean that the derivative has similar or substantially similar properties as compared
to the non-derivatised side chain.
[0045] In one embodiment of the invention, Zn
2+ is preferably present in the mouth hygienic composition in an amount of 0.05 to 2.0
weight per cent, such as 0.1 to 1.9 weight per cent, more preferably 0.2 to 1.8 weight
per cent, such as 0,4 to 1,7 weight per cent, even more preferably 0.6 to 1.6 weight
per cent, such as 0.8 to 1.4 weight per cent, and most preferably 1.0 to 1.3 weight
per cent, such as 1.2 weight per cent.
[0046] In another embodiment of the present invention, the composition comprises Zn
2+ in an amount of less than 4.0 weight per cent, such as less than 3.0 weight per cent,
for example less than 2.5 weight per cent, such as less than 2.0 weight per cent,
for example less than 1.5 weight per cent, such as less than 1.3 weight per cent,
for example less than 1.1 weight per cent, such as less than 0.9 weight per cent,
for example less than 0.7 weight per cent, such as less than 0.5 weight per cent,
for example less than 0.3 weight per cent, such as less than 0.1 weight per cent.
[0047] In another useful embodiment of the present invention, the mouth hygienic composition
comprises a chelate comprising a biologically acceptable amino acid, said biologically
acceptable amino acid having an isoelectric point in the range of pH=8.0 to pH=12,
such as the range of pH=9.0 to pH =11.5, for example the range of pH = 9.5 to pH=11.0.
[0048] In yet another embodiment of the present invention, the mouth hygienic composition
comprises a chelate comprising a biologically acceptable amino acid which has an isoelectric
point in the range of pH=4.0 to pH=8.0, such as the range of pH=4.5 to pH=7.5, for
example the range of pH=5.0 to pH=7.0, such as the range of pH=5.5 to pH=6.5.
[0049] The composition of the present invention may be flavoured with a flavouring agent
to make it more palatable. Suitable flavouring agents are those generating a flavour
of e.g. lemon, strawberry, raspberry, peach, black-current, orange or cherry. Raspberry
flavouring agents are particularly preferred due to their ability to provide particularly
pleasing organoleptic qualities and their ability to reduce and/or eliminate any traces
of an astringent taste associated with the metal amino acid chelate.
[0050] It is very important that the composition has desirable organoleptic qualities and
is substantially free from any metallic and/or astringent taste. Accordingly, the
composition in one particularly useful embodiment is substantially tasteless, i.e.
free from any metallic and/or astringent taste.
[0051] Apart from being palatable, it is also desirable that the composition is capable
of releasing the chelate in an aqueous environment, such as e.g. the oral cavity,
under controllable conditions, such as e.g. slowly and/or at a steady rate. To facilitate
the formation of such an environment the composition may comprise a saliva-inducing
agent such as e.g. sorbitol and/or xylitol in a suitable ratio in order to stimulate
the production of saliva in the oral cavity. This stimulation will facilitate the
slow and/or controlled release of the chelate from the composition mainly due to the
largely insoluble nature of the metal amino acid chelate.
[0052] In another aspect of the invention, there is provided a composition for use in the
reduction and/or elimination of halitosis. The successful treatment of halitosis will
be demonstrated in the practical examples provided below. The composition according
to the present invention may also effective for use in the prevention, reduction and/or
elimination of plaque formation. This aspect of the invention is largely due to the
fact that plaque formation in the oral cavity is due to a microbial growth and activity.
However, by reacting with the sulphur-containing amino acids in the oral cavity, the
metal ion moiety of the chelate significantly reduces the microbial growth potential
which in turn is likely to lead to a reduced plaque formation. Consequently, there
is, in effect, also provided a composition for use in oxidizing volatile sulphur compounds
(VSC) in the oral cavity.
[0053] Additional aspects of the invention relate to the treatment of gingivitis and calculus,
relief from garlic odours in the breath following the intake of a garlic-containing
diet, or following the intake of tablets containing garlic as e.g. a supplement to
an already healthy diet. Garlic odours typically result from dimethyl sulphide.
[0054] The composition of the present invention is preferably in the form of a preparation
suitable for controlled release of the metal amino acid chelate in the oral cavity.
Such a preparation or formulation is a lozenge.
[0055] A lozenge can be prepared by blending the mouth hygienic composition or the chelate
of the present invention with conventional ingredients routinely used for the preparation
of lozenges. Such ingredients comprise e.g. sorbitol, xylitol, sucrose, fructose,
hydrolysed starch, magnesium stearate, a flavouring agent, a binding agent, a sweetener,
a gelling agent, an abrasive, and the like, such as the e.g. the ingredients listed
above. The lozenge can be prepared according to established procedures and lozenge
preparations traditionally used in the art for the preparation of lozenges. In one
preferable embodiment, the preparations described above do not contain sugar so as
to eliminate the risk of causing calculus and caries.
[0056] According to the present invention there is also provided a method of reducing and/or
eliminating halitosis by means of oral administration to the oral cavity of the composition
according to the present invention.
[0057] A socalled Halimeter may be used for testing the mouth hygienic effects of composition
and the chelate comprised herein. The "cysteine challenge method" is suitably used
for this form of testing. Consequently, after initial measurement of a VSC base-line
value, a mouthwash or rinse is performed with a cysteine solution (6mM, pH = 7.2),
and the VLC value is measured again. After approximately 30 minutes the potential
halitosis inhibitor is tested. The test takes place in the form of an oral administration
of the inhibitor in a suitable form. Repeated mouthwashes at suitable time points
after the administration make it possible to test the effect of the potential halitosis
inhibitor over time, as indicated in Figure 1 outlining the experimental model used
in the present study.
[0058] By using the cysteine challenge method it was possible to test the inhibitory effect
of the mouth hygienic composition of the present invention. It was found that an average
reduction of VSC production of almost 50% was observed after three hours. Importantly
however, immediately after intake of the tablet, a reduction in VSC of more than 80%
was measured. One hour after intake of the tablet, a reduction of more than 65 % was
observed. After two hours, a reduction in the amount of VSC of 56% was measured. The
experimental results are listed in Table 3, and the percentage reduction of VSC is
illustrated in Figure 2.
[0059] It is clear from the results that the mouth hygienic composition of the present invention
is capable of significantly reducing VSC in the oral cavity. It should also be noted
that the cysteine challenge method is a very harsh method since it initially generates
VSC in an amount of around 1000.ppb. This level corresponds to a very severe bad breath.
It is therefore remarkable that a reduction of more than 80% is observed immediately
after intake of the mouth hygienic composition of the present invention, as illustrated
in Table 3. The reduction of more than 80% is remarkable in so far as the traditional
treatment of halitosis has in many cases only been able to generate reductions of
40% to 50% in the concentration of VSC.
[0060] In another embodiment of the invention there is provided a method comprising the
steps of
- i) oral administration of the composition to the oral cavity,
- ii) allowing the composition to be in contact with volatile sulphur-containing compounds
of the oral cavity for at least 30 seconds.
[0061] A socalled Halimeter is an instrument widely used in the field of halitosis research
and treatment, which quantifies breath measurement in parts per billion (ppb) of volatile
sulphur compounds (VSC). The ability of the Halimeter to measure VSC is based on the
fact that the Halimeter is initially calibrated with an accurately known sulphide
gas standard. Because of the ability of the Halimeter to quantify VSC concentrations
at the parts per billion level, these instruments have been used in academic studies
of halitosis. The Halimeter gives a digital read-out in parts per billion, which is
not only quantitative, but also more accurate than the subjective organoleptic methods
also used in the art. The Halimeter is specifically designed to serve as a reliable
monitor for the measurement of VSC concentrations The Halimeter used for measuring
VSC concentrations were used according to the instructions provided by the manufacturer.
[0062] The Halimeter consists of a sensing device and a pump to draw the oral sample through
the sensor. The sensing device is a highly sensitive electrochemical voltametric sensor
which generates a signal when exposed to sulphide and mercaptane gases. The result
of the Halimeter measurement can easily be compared to a standard curve or to the
peak values regarded as normal and acceptable levels of VSC, which are generally regarded
not to constitute a bad breath problem.
[0063] Dental practitioners and researchers generally consider peak values of less than
150 to 200 ppb as normal levels of VSC. Such levels of VSC are not normally associated
with bad breath problems. It has been reported that, based on Halimeter data of several
hundred patients, the average range of bad breath readings is 300 to 500 ppb, although
levels as high as 1000 ppb have been encountered.
[0064] The so-called "cysteine challenge method" was used in order to test the effectiveness
of the mouth hygienic composition of the present invention in the treatment of halitosis.
The cysteine challenge method is a standardized method routinely used for the analysis
of potential inhibitors of halitosis. The method is based on the fact that repeated
mouthwashes with an aqueous cysteine solution result in a significantly increased
VSC production. This, in effect, simulates halitosis and makes it possible to test
a potential inhibitor hereof.
[0065] Following oral administration of the composition it is possible by halimetric determination
to directly measure the reduction in the concentration of VSC in the breath. It is
preferred that the amount of VSC detectable after oral administration of the composition
is reduced at least 50 % , preferably at least 60%, even more preferably at least
70%, such as at least 80%, and most preferably at least 90 % , such as at least 95%,
as compared to the amount of VSCs detectable prior to the oral administration of the
composition.
[0066] In yet another aspect of the present invention there is provided the use of a chelate
comprising a zinc ion moiety and an amino acid moiety as a component of a composition
for the treatment of halitosis and/or in the prevention of plaque formation. Additional
uses of such a chelate is in the prevention and/or treatment of gingivitis and calculus.
The chelate used in this way may preferably have a molar ratio of a metal ion moiety
to a amino acid moiety of 1:1 to 1:3, even more preferably a moiety of 1:2.
[0067] Zn
2+ preferably present in an amount of 0.05 to 2.0 weight per cent, such as 0.1 to 1.9
weight per cent, more preferably 0.2 to 1.8 weight per cent, such as 0,4 to 1,7 weight
per cent, even more preferably 0.6 to 1.6 weight per cent, such as 0.8 to 1.4 weight
per cent, and most preferably 1.0 to 1.3 weight per cent, such as 1.2 weight per cent.
In another embodiment the zinc ion of the chelate of the present invention is preferably
present in an amount of less than 4.0 weight per cent, such as less than 3.0 weight
per cent, for example less than 2.5 weight per cent, such as less than 2.0 weight
per cent, for example less than 1.5 weight per cent, such as less than 1.3 weight
per cent, for example less than 1.1 weight per cent, such as less than 0.9 weight
per cent, for example less than 0.7 weight per cent, such as less than 0.5 weight
per cent, for example less than 0.3 weight per cent, such as less than 0.1 weight
per cent.
[0068] There is also provided the use of a chelate according to the invention wherein the
amino acid moiety is a naturally occurring amino acid, such as e.g. an essential amino
acid, such as e.g. a basic amino acid, such as e.g. glycine or lysine or a functional
derivative hereof, such as e.g. functional derivatives having an altered side chain
albeit similar or substantially similar physico-chemical properties.
[0069] There is also provided the use of a chelate wherein the biologically acceptable amino
acid present herein preferably has an isoelectric point in the range of pH=8.0 to
pH=12, such as the range of pH=9.0 to pH=11.5, for example the range of pH=9.5 to
pH=11.0. In one particularly preferred embodiment, this biologically acceptable amino
acid is a diaminomonocarboxylic acid, or a monoamino-monocarboxylic acid.
[0070] In yet another preferred embodiment of the invention there is provided the use of
a zinc amino acid chelate for binding volatile sulphur compounds (VSC) in the oral
cavity.
EXAMPLES
[0071] The following examples illustrate the invention.
EXAMPLE 1
[0072] It was initially decided to analyse various zinc-containing compounds for their ability
to reduce and/or eliminate halitosis. The zinc-compounds are listed in Table 1 below.
Table 1. Zinc-compounds analysed for their inhibitory effect on halitosis. The solubility
is calculated as the amount in grams of the compound which can be dissolved per gram
solvent (H
2O).
Compound |
Source |
Solubility (g/g H2O) |
Zinc acetate |
Merck Index |
0.43 |
Zinc chloride |
Merck Index |
4.3 |
Zinc citrate |
Merck Index |
< 0.1 |
ZnSO4(H2O)6 |
Merck Index |
1.7 |
Zinc gluconate |
Martindale Akzo |
0.12 |
Zinc amino acid chelate, TF |
Albion Lab. |
0.02 |
[0073] More than 16 different experiments were carried out with these compounds. With the
exception of the zinc amino acid chelate TF (tastefree) 10% Zn, product no. 3463,
(Albion Laboratories, Inc., Clearfield, Utah 84015, USA), zinc acetate, zinc chloride,
zinc citrate, ZnSO
4(H
2O)
6 and zinc gluconate all had very poor organoleptic qualities, particularly a pronounced
metallic taste, effectively preventing these compounds from being used commercially
as an effective inhibitor of halitosis. It was not possible to find a way in which
to reduce or eliminate this metallic taste.
[0074] It was generally found that a treatment for halitosis was most effective when a high
concentration of Zn was employed and when the zinc compound had a high degree of solubility.
[0075] The results obtained by using the zinc amino acid chelate TF (product no. 3463 from
Albion Laboratories) was, however, very encouraging, as the results showed that this
compound was able to reduce VSC to a degree comparable to the reduction observed when
using zinc gluconate. Importantly, the zinc amino acid chelate TF was substantially
tastefree and thus an ideal candidate for an effective inhibitor of halitosis. It
was subsequently decided to analyse the effect of the zinc amino acid chelate on halitosis
more thoroughly.
EXAMPLE 2
[0076] The below Table shows the ingredients used for preparing a lozenge, which was subsequently
used in a "cysteine challenge test" in order to analyse its effectiveness in inhibiting
halitosis. The zinc amino acid chelate was initially granulated with P.V.P. in isopropanol
according to standard procedures. Xylitol was dried at 35°C and added to the granulate
along with the other ingredients in the amounts indicated in the Table. The lozenge
produced in accordance with standard preparation techniques had a weight of approximately
0.5 g.
Table 2. Ingredients used in preparing 100,000 lozenges for inhibiting halitosis according
to the present invention.
Ingredient |
Amount |
zinc amino acid chelate TF (Albion Labs. no. 3463) |
6800 g |
Polyvinylpyrrolidone |
800 g |
Xylitol |
10.576 g |
Sorbitol |
39.650 g |
Talcum |
4.550 g |
Saccharin sodium |
170 g |
Raspberry flavouring agent |
1.665 g |
Mg stearate |
250 g |
[0077] The lozenge was used in a "cysteine challenge test", and volatile sulphur compounds
were detected by using a Halimeter, as described in the below Example 3.
EXAMPLE 3
[0078] The use of a Halimeter for testing the mouth hygienic effects of the lozenge having
the composition as described in Example 2 showed that the lozenge is remarkably effective
in reducing and inhibiting halitosis.
[0079] After initial measurement of a VSC base-line value, a mouthwash or rinse was performed
with a cysteine solution (6mM, pH = 7.2), and the VSC value was again measured. After
approximately 30-40 minutes the lozenge was administered to the oral cavity, and the
VSC value was measured immediately after this administration.
[0080] Repeated mouthwashes at suitable time points after the administration, as indicated
in Table 3 and Figure 1, facilitated the analysis of the effect of the lozenge as
an effective inhibitor of Halitosis.
TABLE 3
TREATMENT WITH TABLET X |
|
ppb VSC Basis |
ppb VSC Cysteine |
ppb VSC Tablet X |
ppb VSC Cysteine |
% reduction after treatment |
ppb VSC + 1 h Cysteine |
% reduction after 1 h |
ppb VSC +2 h Cysteine |
% reduction after 2 h |
ppb VSC after +3 h Cysteine |
% reduction after 3 h |
A |
230 |
1165 |
252 |
300 |
74.25 |
521 |
55.28 |
613 |
47.38 |
647 |
44.46 |
S |
265 |
2600 |
270 |
288 |
88.92 |
840 |
67.69 |
1112 |
57.23 |
1470 |
43.46 |
G |
250 |
1043 |
248 |
266 |
74.50 |
390 |
62.61 |
489 |
53.12 |
620 |
40.56 |
SM |
189 |
1472 |
159 |
172 |
88.32 |
450 |
69.43 |
604 |
58.97 |
545 |
62.98 |
SJ |
291 |
1500 |
279 |
330 |
78.00 |
400 |
73.33 |
546 |
63.60 |
635 |
57.67 |
Average |
245 |
1556 |
241.6 |
271.2 |
80.80 |
520.2 |
65.67 |
672.8 |
56.06 |
783.4 |
49.82 |
max |
291 |
2600 |
279 |
330 |
88.92 |
840 |
73.33 |
1112 |
63.6 |
1470 |
62.98 |
min |
189 |
1043 |
158 |
172 |
74.25 |
390 |
55.28 |
489 |
47.38 |
545 |
40.56 |
[0081] The results show that an average reduction of VSC production of almost 50% was observed
three hours after administration of the lozenge. Importantly however, immediately
after intake of the lozenge, a reduction in VSC of more than 80% was measured. One
hour after intake of the lozenge, a reduction of more than 65% was observed. After
two hours, a reduction in the amount of VSC of 56% was measured. The experimental
results are listed in Table 3, and the percentage reduction of VSC measured by the
Halimeter is illustrated in Figure 2.
[0082] It is clear from the results that the mouth hygienic composition of the present invention
is capable of significantly reducing VSC in the oral cavity. It should also be noted
that the cysteine challenge method is a very harsh method since it initially generates
an amount of VSC of around 1000 ppb. This level corresponds to a very severe bad breath.
It is therefore remarkable that a reduction of more than 80% is observed immediately
after intake of the mouth hygienic composition of the present invention, as illustrated
in Table 3. The reduction of more than 80% is remarkable in so far as the traditional
treatment of halitosis has, in many cases, only generated VSC reductions of 40% to
50%.
LITERATURE REFERENCES