[0001] This invention relates to apparatus for and a method of improving the sound quality
of loudspeakers.
[0002] Currently, several types of loudspeakers are manufactured including electrostatic,
magnetic film types and moving coil cones or domes mounted into open baffles, infinite
baffles (closed box types), reflex loaded infinite baffles and transmission line type
enclosures.
[0003] Of these, the most popular is the infinite baffle type and its reflex loaded variant.
Commercially, these account for the majority of speakers in use.
[0004] Typically, they consist of two or more moving coil type drive units each optimised
to give uniform output over a limited frequency range, an electrical crossover being
used to divide the incoming electrical signals to the appropriate drive unit. The
drive units are mounted in an enclosure, commonly referred to as a cabinet and typically
made of wooden panels, chipboard or medium density fibreboard (M.D.F.).
[0005] The purpose of the enclosure is to prevent the out of phase sound emitted from the
rear of the drive unit from cancelling that from the front whilst providing a correct
acoustic loading to the rear of the drive unit for optimum performance.
[0006] In use, the drive unit imparts vibrational energy to the cabinet from frame reaction
to the vibrating cone and from coincident sound energy emitted from the rear of the
drive unit. This results in vibration of the cabinet walls causing unwanted sound
to be emitted. The panel walls typically exhibit a series of resonances whose output
may only be a few decibels below of that of the frontal or drive unit output. As the
panels have mass their resonance may continue for several milliseconds after excitation.
The overall effect of this is to reduce system and sound clarity, dynamic definition
and accuracy.
[0007] This form of coloration has posed a challenge to speaker designers for many years.
The use of bracing, damping pads, and rigid floor coupling via spiked stands has been
used to reasonable effect. To advance the art a few specialist manufacturers have
used alternative specialist materials and construction methods for the enclosure including
concrete, mineral loaded resins, honeycomb cored panels, dense matrix bracing systems,
granite and slate panels and high mass lead seismic damping systems. Whilst effective
at reducing coloration and providing substantial benefits in terms of improved sound
quality these enclosures have the disadvantage of high cost, typically five to fifteen
times greater than a conventional enclosure, and using materials and production processes
not ideally suited to mass production.
[0008] The present invention seeks to overcome these problems whilst offering the additional
benefit of being retrofittable to existing loudspeaker systems.
[0009] According to a first aspect of the present invention there is provided apparatus
for improving the sound quality of loudspeakers, comprising a rigid shell having sound
absorbing material on its internal surface, the shell being adapted to fit over a
loudspeaker enclosure and the front of the shell being open or substantially open
or being covered by material which permits sound to pass therethrough in an undistorted
manner.
[0010] Preferred and/or optional features of the first aspect of the invention are set forth
in claims 2 to 7, inclusive.
[0011] According to a second aspect of the invention there is provided a method of improving
the sound quality of loudspeakers, the method comprising the steps of fitting apparatus
according to the first aspect of the invention over a loudspeaker enclosure.
[0012] The invention will now be more particularly described, by way of example, with reference
to the accompanying drawings, in which;
Figure 1 is a perspective view showing one embodiment of apparatus according to the
present invention, fitted over a loudspeaker enclosure, and
Figure 2 is a sectional view, on an enlarged scale, of one example of the sound absorbing
material of Figure 1.
[0013] Referring now to the drawings, apparatus for improving the sound quality of loudspeakers,
comprises a rigid shell 10 having a rear wall, two side walls 11 and 12, a top wall
13 and a base 14 all internally lined with sound absorbing material 15. The front
of the shell is open but this could be covered with a removable panel of material
which permits sound to pass therethrough in an undistorted manner.
[0014] The shell 10 is adapted to fit over an existing loudspeaker enclosure, typically
in the form of a cabinet 16, (housing one or more loudspeakers) preferably with a
clearance of typically 2 to 3 mm. between the inner surface of the sound absorbing
material 15 and the outer surface of the cabinet 16. The shell 10 may be mounted on
a speaker stand 17 or on the floor. A soft foam sealing strip may be used on the inner
edge of the shell to form a seal.
[0015] To give optimum performance, the shell 10 is ideally isolated from the loudspeaker
cabinet 16. However, in practice this is difficult to achieve and the loudspeaker
cabinet 16 will generally be supported on a plurality of support members, such as
pins or spikes, upstanding from the base 14 of the shell 10. Alternatively, particularly
with heavy speakers, the speaker cabinet could be mounted directly on the base 14
of the shell 10. In the case of a floor standing speaker cabinet, the shell may be
coupled to the floor either directly or via a sub-frame/floor spikes as necessary.
Typically, in this case, the shell 10 has no base.
[0016] The shell 10 is typically made from panels of wood, M.D.F. or chipboard.
[0017] The sound absorbing material typically comprises a single layer of sound absorbing
material, preferably a foam material such as melamine foam, polyurethane foam or polyether
foam. Alternatively the sound absorbing material may comprise at least two, and as
shown in Figure 2 three, layers 20 of compressible sound absorbing material, and a
barrier layer 21 between the or each pair of adjacent compressible layers 20. The
compressible sound absorbing material 20 is preferably a foam material. In this case,
the innermost foam layer absorbs high frequency sound energy. The inner barrier layer
minimises the low frequency sound. The middle foam layer absorbs vibration of the
inner barrier layer. The outer foam layer damps any vibration which may occur in the
panel to which it is fixed.
[0018] The barrier layer(s) 21 are denser than the compressible sound absorbing material
20 and are typically formed of "dead rubber" sheet or bituminous or lead damping material.
The particular make up of the absorbent material may be optimised to suit the speaker
system.
[0019] An angled or rounded moulding (not shown) may be fixed to the front edge of the shell
10 adjacent to the drive unit baffle of the loudspeaker. This is to ensure good sound
diffraction and to cover the exposed edge of the shell and sound absorbent material
whilst imparting additional edge stiffness to the shell panels.
[0020] The use of this system typically reduces cabinet wall sound output by 20 to 30 decibels
whilst dramatically reducing the effects of panel resonance resulting in a substantial
improvement in sound quality at a relatively low cost with the added benefit of being
retrofittable to existing systems.
1. Apparatus for improving the sound quality of loudspeakers, comprising a rigid shell
(10) having sound absorbing material (15) on its internal surface, the shell being
adapted to fit over a loudspeaker enclosure (16) and the front of the shell being
open or substantially open or being covered by material which permits sound to pass
therethrough in an undistorted manner.
2. Apparatus as claimed in claim 1, wherein the shell comprises a rear wall, two side
walls (11,12) and a top wall (13) all lined or substantially lined with sound absorbing
material (15).
3. Apparatus as claimed in claim 2, wherein the shell further comprises a base (14).
4. Apparatus as claimed in claim 3, wherein the base is also lined or substantially lined
with sound absorbing material (15).
5. Apparatus as claimed in any one of the preceding claims, wherein the sound absorbing
material (15) is a compressible foam material.
6. Apparatus as claimed in any one of the preceding claims, wherein the sound absorbing
material comprises at least two layers (20) of compressible foam material with a barrier
layer (21) therebetween.
7. Apparatus as claimed in claim 6, wherein the barrier layer (21) is denser than the
compressible sound absorbing material (20).
8. A method of improving the sound quality of loudspeakers, comprising the step of fitting
the apparatus of any one of the preceding claims over a loudspeaker enclosure (16).