Background of the Invention
Field of the Invention
[0001] The present invention generally relates to articles of footwear, and more particularly,
to a sole construction that may be incorporated into athletic footwear or as an insert
into existing footwear and the like in order to store kinetic energy generated by
a person. The sole construction has a combination of structural features enabling
enhanced storage, retrieval and guidance of wearer muscle energy that complement and
augment performance of participants in recreational and sports activities.
Description of the Related Art
[0002] From the earliest times when humans began wearing coverings on their feet, there
has been an ever present desire to make such coverings more useful and more comfortable.
Accordingly, a plethora of different types of footwear has been developed in order
to meet specialized needs of a particular activity in which the wearer intends to
participate. Likewise, there have been many developments to enhance the comfort level
of both general and specialized footwear.
[0003] The human foot is unique in the animal kingdom. It possesses inherent qualities and
abilities far beyond other animals. We can move bi-pedially across the roughest terrain.
We can balance on one foot, we can sense the smallest small grain of sand in our shoes.
In fact, we have more nerve endings in our feet than our hands.
[0004] We literally roll forward, rearward, laterally and medially across the bony structures
of the foot. The key word is "roll." The muscles of the foot and ankle system provide
a controlled acceleration of forces laterally to medially and vise-versa across the
bony structure of the foot. In bio-mechanical terms these motions are referred to
as pronation and supination. The foot is almost never applied flat, in relative position
to the ground, yet shoe designers continue to anticipate this event.
[0005] The increasing popularity of athletic endeavors has been accompanied by an increasing
number of shoe designs intended to meet the needs of the participants in the various
sports. The proliferation of shoe designs has especially occurred for participants
in athletic endeavors involving rigorous movements, such as walking, running, jumping
and the like. In typical walking and running grafts, it is well understood that one
foot contacts the support surface (such as the ground) in a "stance mode" while the
other foot is moving through the air in a "swing mode." Furthermore, in the stance
mode, the respective foot "on the ground" travels through three successive basic phases:
heel strike, mid stance and toe off. At faster running paces, the heel strike phase
is usually omitted since the person tends to elevate onto his/her toes.
[0006] Typical shoe designs fail to adequately address the needs of the participant's foot
and ankle system during each of these successive stages. Typical shoe designs cause
the participant's foot and ankle system to lose a significant proportion, by some
estimates at least thirty percent, of its functional abilities including its abilities
to absorb shock, load musculature and tendon systems, and to propel the runner's body
forward.
[0007] This is because the soles of current walking and running shoe designs fail to address
individually the muscles and tendons of a participant's foot. The failure to individually
address these foot components inhibits the flexibility of the foot and ankle system,
interferes with the timing necessary to optimally load the foot and ankle system,
and interrupts the smooth and continuous transfer of energy from the heel to the toes
of the foot during the three successive basic phases of the "on the ground" foot travel.
[0008] Moreover, in vigorous athletic activities, the athlete generates kinetic energy from
the motion of running, jumping, etc. Traditional shoe designs have served merely to
dampen the shock from these activities thereby dissipating that energy. Rather than
losing the kinetic energy produced by the athlete, it is useful to store and retrieve
that energy thereby enhancing athletic performance. Traditional shoe construction,
however, has failed to address this need.
[0009] Historically, manufacturers of modem running shoes added foam to cushion a wearer's
foot. Then, gradually manufacturers developed other alternatives to foam-based footwear
for the reason that foam becomes permanently compressed with repeated use and thus
ceases to perform the cushioning function. One of the largest running shoe manufacturers,
Nike, Inc. of Beaverton. Oregon, has utilized bags of compressed gas as the means
to cushion the wearers foot. A German manufacturer, Puma AG, has proposed a foamless
shoe in which polyurethane elastomer is the cushioning material. Another running shoe
manufacturer, Reebok International of Stoughton, Massachusetts, recently introduced
a running shoe which has two layers of air cushioning. Running shoe designers heretofore
have sought to strike a compromise between providing enough cushioning to protect
the wearer's heel but not so much that the wearer's foot will wobble and get out of
sync with the working of the knee. The Reebok shoe uses air that moves to various
parts of the sole at specific times. For example, when the outside of the runner's
heel touches ground, it lands on a cushion of air. As the runner's weight bears down,
that air is pushed to the inside of the heel, which keeps the foot from rolling inward
too much while another air-fitted layer is forcing air toward the forefoot. When the
runners weight is on the forefoot, the air travels back to the heel.
[0010] In the last several years, there have been some attempts to construct athletic shoes
that provide some rebound thereby returning energy to the athlete. Various air bladder
systems have been employed to provide a "bounce" during use. In addition, there have
been numerous advancements and materials used to construct the sole and the shoe in
an effort to make them more "springy."
[0011] Furthermore, midsole and sole compression, historically speaking, can be very destabilizing.
This is because patching, tipping and lateral shear of the sole and midsole naturally
rebound energies in the opposite direction required for control and energy transfers.
Another perplexing problem for shoe engineers has been how to store energy as the
foot and ankle system rolls laterally to medially. These rotational forces have been
very difficult to absorb and control
[0012] No past shoe designs, including the specific ones cited above, are believed to adequately
address the aforementioned needs of the participant's foot and ankle system during
walking and running activities in a manner that augments performance. The past approachs,
being primarily concerned with cushioning the impact of the wearers foot with the
ground surface, fail to even recognize, let alone begin to address, the need to provide
features in the shoe sole that will enhance the storage, retrieval and guidance of
a wearer's muscle energy in a way that will complement and augment the wearer's performance
during walking, running and jumping activities.
[0013] U.S. Patent No. 5,595,003 to Snow discloses an athletic shoe with a force responsive sole. However, among the problems
with the Snow embodiments is that they teach very thick soles comprised of tall cleats,
a resilient membrane, deep apertures, and "guide plates." The combination of these
components is undesirable because they make up a very heavy shoe. Furthermore. Snow
shows numerous small parts that would be cost prohibitive to manufacture. These numerous
small cleats cannot affect enough rubber molecules through the resilient membrane
to provide a competitive efficiency gain without increasing the thickness of the membrane
to the point of impracticability. The heavier and taller midsole and sole of Snow
also position the foot further from the ground, providing less stability as well as
less neuro-muscular input. Moreover, it takes a longer period of time for Snow's cleats
to "cycle," i.e., penetrate and rebound. This produces a limiting effect for performance
and efficiency gain potential
[0014] Snow's cleats also require vertical guidance, i.e., anti-tipping, such as by Snow's
required guide plate. Snow also fails to provide appropriate points of leverage for
specific bone structures of the foot, control over the intrinsic rotational involvement
of the foot and ankle system, bio-mechanical guidance, and the ability to produce
tunable vertical vectors and transfer energy forward and rearward from heel, midfoot,
forefoot and toes and vice-versa.
[0015] In my earlier invention disclosed in
U.S. Patent No. 5,647,145 issued July 15,1997,I teach an athletic footwear, sole construction that enhances the performance of the shoe
in several ways. First, the construction described in the '145 patent individually
addresses the heel, toe, tarsal and metatarsal regions of the foot to allow more flexibility
so that the various portions of the sole cooperate with respective portions of the
foot. In addition, a resilient layer is provided in the sole which cooperates with
cavities formed at various locations to help store energy.
[0016] While the advancements in shoe construction described above, including the 145 patent,
have provided a great benefit to the athlete, there remains a continued need for increased
performance of athletic footwear. There remains a need for an athletic footwear sole
construction that can store an increased amount of kinetic energy and return that
energy to the athlete to improve athlete performance.
[0017] WO 93/03639 A discloses an athletic shoe with a sole, having a first sole portion with multiple
cleats, a second sole portion with corresponding apertures to receive the cleats.
It further discloses a membrane positioned between the sole portions covering the
apertures to separate the cleats from the apertures.
[0018] WO 90/12518 A is directed at a formation for a slot in the sole of a sports shoe, including an
upper plate, a lower plate, pegs spaced along margins of the upper plate, and sockets
on the lower plate. It discloses a membrane lying interposed between supports of the
upper plate and supports of the lower plate.
Summary of the Invention
[0019] It is an object of the present invention to provide a new and useful sole construction
that may be incorporated into footwear or used as an insert into existing footwear.
[0020] It is another object of the present invention to provide a structure for use with
footwear that stores kinetic energy when a compressive weight is placed thereon and
which releases that energy when the weight is taken off.
[0021] It is a further object of the present invention to provide footwear and, specifically,
a sole construction therefor, that enhances the performance of a person wearing the
footwear.
[0022] Generally speaking, the present invention provides an athletic footwear sole construction
designed to satisfy the aforementioned needs. In one aspect of the present invention,
the athletic footwear sole provides a combination of structural features under the
heel, midfoot and forefoot regions of the wearers foot that enable enhanced storage,
retrieval and guidance of muscle energy in a manner that complements and augments
wearer performance in sports and recreational activities. The sole construction of
the present invention enables athletic footwear for walking, running and jumping to
improve and enhance performance by complementing, augmenting and guiding the natural
flexing actions of the muscles of the foot The combination of structural features
incorporated in the sale construction of the present invention provides unique control
over and guidance of the energy of the wearer's foot as it travels through the three
successive basic phases of heel strike, mid stance and toe off.
[0023] Specifically, the present invention provides a support structure for providing energy
storage and return to at least a portion of a human foot, according to claim 1.
[0024] Accordingly, one aspect of the present invention is related to an athletic footwear
having an upper and sole with the sole having heel, midfoot, metatarsal, and toe regions
wherein the sole comprises a foundation layer of stiff material attached to the upper
and defining a plurality of stretch chambers, a stretch layer attached to the foundation
layer and having portions of elastic stretchable material underlying the stretch chambers
of the foundation layer, and a thrustor layer attached to the stretch layer and having
portions of stiff material underlying and aligned with the stretch chambers of the
foundation layer and with the portions of the stretch layer disposed between the thrustor
layer and foundation layer. Given the above-defined arrangement, interactions occur
between the foundation layer, stretch layer and thrustor layer in response to compressive
forces applied thereto upon contact of the heel and midfoot regions and metatarsal
and toe regions of the sole with a support surface so as to convert and temporarily
store energy applied to heel and midfoot regions and metatarsal and toe regions of
the sole by a wearer's foot into mechanical stretching of the portions of the stretch
layer into the stretch chambers of the foundation layer. The stored energy is thereafter
retrieved in the form of rebound of the stretched portions of the stretch layer and
portions of the thrustor layer. Whereas components of the heel and midfoot regions
of the sole provide temporary storage and retrieval of energy at central and peripheral
sites underlying the heel and midfoot of the wearer's foot, components of the metatarsal
and toe regions of the sole provide the temporary storage and retrieval of energy
at independent sites underlying the individual metatarsals and toes of the wearer's
foot.
[0025] In another aspect of the present invention, a sole is adapted for use with an article
of footwear to be worn on the foot of a person while the person traverses along a
support surface. This sole is operative to store and release energy resulting from
compressive forces generated by the person's weight on the support surface. This sole
is thus an improvement which can be incorporated with standard footwear uppers. Alternatively,
the invention can be configured as an insert sole which can be inserted into an existing
shoe or other article of footwear.
[0026] In one embodiment, the sole has a first layer of stretchable resilient material that
has opposite first and second surfaces. A first profile is formed of a stiff material
and is positioned on the first side of the resilient layer. The first profila includes
a fust profile chamber formed therein. This first profile chamber has an interior
region opening toward the first surface of the resilient layer. The first profile
and the resilient layer are positioned relative to one another so that the resilient
layer spans across the first interior region. A second profile is also formed of a
stiff material and is positioned on the second side of the resilient layer opposite
the first profile. This second profile includes a primary actuator element that faces
the second surface of the resilient layer to define a static state. The first and
second profiles are positioned relative to one another with the primary actuator element
being oriented relative to the-first profile chamber such that the compressive force
between the foot and the support surface will move the first and second profiles toward
one another. When this occurs, the primary actuator element advances into the first
profile chamber thereby stretching the resilient layer into the interior region defining
an active state. In the active state, energy is stored by the resilient layer, and
the resilient layer releases this energy to move the first and second profiles apart
upon removal of the compressive force.
[0027] Preferably, the second profile has a second profile chamber formed therein. This
second profile chamber has a second interior region opening toward the second surface
of the resilient layer so that the resilient layer also spans across this second region.
A plunger element is then provided and is disposed in the first interior region. This
plunger element moves into and out of the second interior region when the first and
second profiles move between the static and active states. Here, also, a plurality
of plunger elements may be disposed in the first interior region with these plunger
elements operative to move into and out of the second interior region when the first
and second profiles move between the static and active states. The plunger element
may be formed integrally with the first layer of resilient material.
[0028] A third profile may also be provided, with this third profile having a third profile
chamber formed therein. This third profile chamber has a third interior region. Here,
a second layer of stretchable resilient material spans across the third region. The
first profile then includes a secondary actuator element positioned to move into the
third interior region and to stretch the second layer of resilient material into the
third profile chamber in response to the compressive force. The first profile may
also include a plurality of second actuators, and these actuators may extend around
a perimeter thereof to define the first profile chamber. The third profile then has
a plurality of third chambers each including a second layer of resilient material
that spans thereacross. These third profile chambers are each positioned to receive
a respective one of the secondary actuators. The first profile in the second actuator
may also be formed as an integral, one-piece construction. The third profile and the
plunger element may also be formed as an integral, one-piece construction.
[0029] The sole according to the present invention can be a section selected from the group
consisting of heel sections, metatarsal sections and toe sections. Preferably, the
sole includes one of each of these sections so as to underlie the entire foot but
to provide independent energy storing support for each of the three major sections
of the foot Alternatively, the present invention may be used in connection with only
one or two sections of the foot. In any event, the invention allows either of the
first or second profiles to operate in contact with the support surface.
[0030] The present invention also contemplates an article of footwear incorporating the
sole, as described above, in combination with a footwear upper. In addition, the present
invention contemplates an insert sole adapted for insertion into an article of footwear.
[0031] In another aspect of the present invention, a support structure provides energy storage
and return to at least a portion of a human foot. This support structure comprises
a generally horizontal layer of stretchable material, at least one chamber positioned
adjacent a first side of the layer, and at least one actuator positioned adjacent
a second side of the layer vertically aligned with a corresponding chamber. Each actuator
has a footprint size smaller than that of the corresponding chamber. The support structure
when compressed causes the actuator to push against the layer and move the layer at
least partially into the corresponding chamber. Each actuator is selectively positioned
to provide individual support to a portion of the human foot selected from the group
consisting of a toe, a metatarsal bone, a midfoot portion and a heel portion.
[0032] In another embodiment, an energy storage and return system for footwear and the like
is provided. The system comprises at least two stretchable layer portions, each of
the portions having an upper side and a lower side. A plurality of actuator elements
is provided, wherein at least one of the actuator elements is positioned above a stretchable
layer portion and at least one of the actuator elements is positioned below a stretchable
layer portion. A plurality of receiving chambers is also provided, wherein each receiving
chamber corresponds to one of the actuator elements and is sized and positioned to
receive at least partially the corresponding actuator element therein when the actuator
elements are compressed toward the receiving chambers. Each of the receiving chambers
is preferably located opposite a corresponding actuator element across a stretchable
layer portion.
[0033] In another aspect of the present invention, an energy return system for footwear
and the like is provided. This system comprises at least one layer of stretchable
material having a first side and a second side. A plurality of chambers is positioned
on either the first side or the second side of the layer. A plurality of actuators
each vertically aligned with a corresponding chamber is positioned opposite the chambers
across at least one layer of stretchable material, each actuator having a footprint
size smaller than that of the chamber. When the footwear receives a generally vertical
compressive force, the actuator pushes against the layer and moves at least partially
into a chamber. The actuators are patterned according to the structure of the human
foot.
[0034] In another aspect of the present invention, a sole construction for underlying at
least a portion of a human foot is provided. This sole construction comprises a generally
horizontal layer of stretchable material having a first side and a second side. A
chamber layer having a chamber therein is positioned on the first side of the layer
of stretchable material, the chamber having at least one opening facing the first
side of the layer of stretchable material. An actuator is positioned on the second
side of the layer of stretchable material, the actuator having a footprint size that
is smaller than that of the opening of the chamber such that when the sole construction
is compressed, the actuator presses against the second side of the layer of stretchable
material and at least partially into the chamber of the chamber layer. The actuator
is at least partially tapered, which, as used herein, refers to a dimensional reduction
in the size of the actuator, either in a vertical or a horizontal direction. For instance,
the tapering of the actuator can refer to a vertical decrease in thickness of the
actuator, such as by giving the actuator a dome-like shape or sloping surfaces, or
by reducing the height or other dimension of the actuator horizontally, such as by
tapering or sloping the upper or lower surface of the actuator towards the front of
the foot.
[0035] In another aspect of the present invention, a sole construction for supporting at
least a portion of a human foot is provided. This sole construction comprises a generally
horizontal layer of stretchable material having a first side and a second side. A
profile piece having a primary chamber therein is positioned on the first side of
the layer of stretchable material, the primary chamber having at least one opening
facing the first side of the layer of stretchable material. A primary actuator is
positioned on the second side of the layer of stretchable material, the primary actuator
having a footprint size that is smaller than that of the opening of the primary chamber
such that when the sole construction is compressed, the primary actuator presses against
the second side of the layer of stretchable material and at least partially into the
primary chamber of the first layer. A secondary chamber is positioned within the primary
actuator, the secondary chamber having at least one opening facing the second side
of the layer of stretchable material. A secondary actuator is positioned on the first
side of the layer of stretchable material, the secondary actuator having a footprint
size that is smaller than that of the opening of the secondary chamber such that when
the sole construction is compressed, the secondary actuator presses against the first
side of the layer of stretchable material and at least partially into the secondary
chamber.
[0036] In another aspect of the present invention, a heel portion for a sole construction
is provided. The heel portion comprises a main thrustor, a first layer of stretchable
material positioned above the main thrustor, and a satellite thrustor layer positioned
above the first layer of stretchable material. The satellite thrustor has an upper
surface and a lower surface, the upper surface of the satellite thrustor layer preferably
having a plurality of satellite thrustors extending upwardly therefrom. The satellite
thrustor layer also has a central opening therein. The heel portion further comprises
a second layer of stretchable material positioned above the satellite thrustor layer
and a foundation layer positioned above the second layer of stretchable material.
The foundation layer preferably has an upper surface and a lower surface and a plurality
of satellite openings positioned to receive the satellite thrustors. The heel portion
when compressed causes the main thrustor to stretch through the first layer of stretchable
material at least partially into the central opening of the satellite thrustor layer
and the satellite thrustors to stretch through the second layer of stretchable material
at least partially into the satellite openings.
[0037] In another aspect of the present invention, a sole construction is provided comprising
a generally horizontal layer of stretchable material, a plurality of chambers positioned
adjacent a first side of the layer, and a plurality of interconnected actuator elements
positioned adjacent a second side of the layer. Each actuator element is vertically
aligned with a corresponding chamber and has a footprint size smaller than that of
the corresponding chamber. The support structure when compressed causes the actuator
element to push against the layer and move the layer at least partially into the corresponding
chamber.
[0038] These and other features and advantages of the present invention will become apparent
to those skilled in the art upon a reading of the following detailed description when
considered in connection with the drawings which show and describe exemplary embodiments
of the invention.
Brief Description of the Drawings
[0039]
FIG. 1 is a side elevational view of an athletic footwear sole construction in a first
exemplary embodiment of the present invention.
FIG. 2 is a front elevational view of the sole construction of FIG. 1.
FIG. 3 is an exploded top perspective view of heel and midfoot regions of the sole
construction.
FIG. 4 is an exploded bottom perspective view of heel and midfoot regions of the sole
construction.
FIG. 5 is a rear end view of the heel region of the sole construction shown in a relaxed
condition.
FIG. 6 is a vertical transverse sectional view of the sole construction of FIG. 5.
FIG. 7 is a rear end view of the heel region of the sole construction shown in a loaded
condition.
FIG. 8 is a vertical transverse sectional view of the sole construction of FIG. 7.
FIG. 9 is an exploded top perspective view of the metatarsal and toe regions of the
sole construction of the present invention.
FIG. 10 is a vertical transverse sectional view of the metatarsal region of the sole
construction shown in a relaxed condition.
FIG. 11 is a vertical transverse sectional view of the metatarsal region of the sole
construction shown in a loaded condition.
FIG.12 a side view in elevation of a second embodiment of an article of footwear incorporating
the heel portion of a sole.
FIG. 13 is an exploded perspective view of the heel portion of the article of footwear
shown in FIG. 12.
FIG.14A is a side view in cross-section showing the heel portion of FIGS. 12 and 13
in a static state.
FIG. 14B is a side view in cross-section, similar to FIG. 14A except showing the heel
portion in an active state.
FIG. 15 is a side view in elevation of an article of footwear having a sole constructed
according to a third exemplary embodiment of the present invention.
FIG. 16 is an end view in elevation of the article of footwear shown in FIG. 15.
FIG. 17 is an exploded perspective view of the heel portion of the article of footwear
shown in FIG. 15.
FIG. 18 is a side view in a partial cross-sectional and exploded view to show the
construction of the heel portion of FIG. 17.
FIG. 19A is a rear end view in cross-section showing the heel portion of the sole
of the article of footwear of FIG. 15 in a static state.
FIG.19B is a cross-sectional view, similar to FIG. 19A but showing the heel portion
in an active state.
FIG. 20A is a top plan view of the first profile used for the toe portion of the sole
of FIG. 15.
FIG. 20B is a top plan view of the resilient layer used to form the toe portion of
the sole of FIG. 15.
FIG. 20C is a top plan view of the second profile used to form the toe portion of
the sole of FIG. 15.
FIG. 20D is a perspective view of an alternative construction of the resilient layer
for the toe portion of the sole of FIG. 15.
FIG. 21A is a cross-sectiorral view of the toe portion of the sole of FIG. 20 shown
in a static state.
FIG. 21B is a cross-sectional view similar to FIG. 21A but showing the toe portion
in an active state.
FIG. 22A is a top plan view of the fast profile used to form the metatarsal portion
of the sole of FIG. 15.
FIG. 22B is a top plan view of the resilient layer used to form the metatarsal portion
of the sole of RG. 15.
FIG. 22C is a top plan view of the second profile used to form the metatarsal portion
of the sole of FIG. 15.
FIG. 23 is a side view in elevation showing a sole insert according to a fourth exemplary
embodiment of the present invention.
FIG. 24 is a cross-sectional view taken about lines 24-24 of FIG. 23.
FIG. 25A is a perspective view of the first profile used to form the toe portion of
the sok insert of HE. 23.
FIG. 25B is a perspective view of the second profile used to form the toe portion
of the sole insert of FIG. 23.
FIG. 26A is a perspective view of the first profile used to form the metatarsal portion
of the sole insert of FIG. 23.
FIG. 26B is a perspective view of the second profile used to form the metatarsal portion
of the sole insert of FIG. 23.
FIG. 27A is a perspective view of the first profile used to form the heel portion
of the sole insert of FIG. 23.
FIG. 27B is a perspective view of the second profile used to form the heel portion
of the sole insert of FIG. 23.
FIG. 28 is an exploded perspective view of the heel portion of an article of footwear
according to a fifth exemplary embodiment.
FIG. 29 is a side view in a partial cross-sectional and exploded view to show the
construction of the heel portion of FIG. 28.
FIG. 30 is a bottom elevational view of the sole of FIG. 28.
FIG. 31A is a top plan view of the first profile used for the additional metatarsal
support portion of the sole of FIG. 30.
FIG. 31B is a top plan view of the resilient layer used to form the additional metatarsal
support portion of the sole of FIG. 30.
FIG. 31 is a top plan view of the second profile used to form the additional metatarsal
portion of the sole of FIG. 30.
FIG. 32 is an exploded perspective view of the heel portion of an article of footwear
according to a sixth embodiment
FIG. 33 is a side view in a partial cross-sectional and exploded view to snow the
construction of the heel portion of FIG. 32
FIG. 34 is an exploded perspective view of a seventh exemplary and main preferred
embodiment of the sole construction of the present invention.
FIG. 35 is a perspective view of the main thrustor of the sale construction of FIG.
34.
FIG. 36 is a bottom plan view of the main thruster of the sole construction of FIG.
34.
FIG. 37 is cross-sectional view of the main thrustor of AG. 36, taken along line 37-37.
FIG. 38 is a cross-sectional view of the main thruster of FIG. 38, taken along line
38-38.
FIG. 39 is a perspective view of the first resilient layer of FIG. 34.
FIG. 40 is a bottom plain view of the first resilient layer of FIG. 34.
FIG. 41 is a cross-sectional view of the first resilient layer of FIG. 40, taken along
line 41-41.
FIG. 42 is a perspective view of the satellite thrustor layer of FIG. 34.
FIG. 43 is a bottom plan view of the satellite thrustor layer of FIG. 34.
FIG. 44 is a cross-sectional view of the satellite thrustor layer of FIG. 43, taken
along line 44-44.
FIG. 45 is a perspective view of the second resilient layer of FIG. 34.
FIG. 46 is a bottom plan view of the second resilient layer of FIG. 34.
FIG. 47 is a cross-sectional view of the second resilient layer of FIG. 46, taken
along line 47-47.
FIG. 48 is a perspective view of the secondary thrustor layer of FIG. 34.
FIG. 49 is a bottom plan view of the secondary thrustor layer of FIG. 34.
FIG. 50 is a cross-sectional view of the secondary thrustor layer of FIG. 49, taken
along line 50-50.
FIG. 51 is a cross-sectional view of the secondary thrustor layer of FIG. 49, taken
along line 51-51.
FIG. 52 is a perspective view of the toe actuator layer of FIG. 34.
FIG. 53 is a bottom plan view of the toe actuator layer of FIG. 34.
FIG. 54 is a cross-sectional view of the toe actuator layer of FIG. 53, taken along
line 54-54.
FIG. 55 is a cross-sectional view of the toe actuator layer of FIG. 53, taken along
line 55-55.
FIG. 56 is a perspective view of the toe chamber layer of FIG. 34.
FIG. 57 is a bottom plan view of the toe chamber layer of FIG. 34.
FIG. 58 is a cross-sectional view of the toe chamber layer of FIG. 57, taken along
line 58-58.
FIG. 59 is a cross-sectional view of the toe chamber layer of FIG. 57, taken along
line 59-59.
FIG. 60 is a perspective view of the forefoot actuator layer of FIG. 34.
FIG. 61 is a bottom plan view of the forefoot actuator layer of FIG. 34.
FIG. 62 is a cross-sectional view of the forefoot actuator layer of FIG. 61, taken
along line 62-62.
FIG. 63 is a cross-sectional view of the forefoot actuator layer of FIG. 61, taken
along line 63-63.
FIG. 64 is a cross-sectional view of the forefoot actuator layer of FIG. 61, taken
along line 64-64.
FIG. 65 is a perspective view of the forefoot chamber layer of FIG. 34.
FIG. 66 is a bottom plan view of the forefoot chamber layer of FIG. 34.
FIG. 67 is a cross-sectional view of the forefoot chamber layer of FIG. 65, taken
along line 67-67.
FIG. 68 is a cross-sectional view of the forefoot chamber layer of FIG. 65, taken
along line 68-68.
FIG. 69 is a perspective view of a toe traction layer.
FIG. 70 is a bottom plan view of the toe traction layer of FIG. 69.
FIGS. 71 and 72 are side views of the toe traction layer of FIG. 69.
FIG. 73 is a perspective view of a forefoot traction layer.
FIG. 74 is a bottom plan view of the forefoot traction layer of FIG. 73.
FIGS. 75 and 76 are side views of the forefoot traction layer of FIG. 73.
Detailed Description of the Preferred Embodiments
[0040] The description provided hereinbelow illustrates seven exemplary embodiments of a
sole construction according to the present invention. It should be appreciated that
each of these embodiments is merely exemplary. Therefore, features from one or more
of the embodiments may be added or removed from other embodiments without departing
from the scope of the invention. Furthermore, the energy storage and rebound characteristics
as described in one embodiment may also be applicable to the other embodiments when
similar mechanisms are involved. Moreover, as used herein, the terms "thrustor," "plunger,"
"lug" and "actuator" are substantially interchangeable and generally refer to actuators
used for the storage and rebound of energy.
[0041] In general, the embodiments described below provide chambered actuators patterned
according to the structure of the foot. In these embodiments, patterned rigidity ensures
a smooth transfer of energies (the energy "wave") across the foot. The chambers provide
holes for the energy to flow into. Energy always follows the path of least resistance.
The staggering of active support actuators and energy exchange chambers balances and
supports the intrinsic rolling action of metatarsal bones, toes and heel.
[0042] The controlled storing and rebound of energy as described herein do not force the
foot into undesired movement; rather it supplies superior position, force and speed
information to allow supination and pronation controlling musculature to store and
release energy from the energy "wave" process. This produces an efficiency gain, a
"tightening up" of the foot's rotational passes through the neutral plane. The resulting
sequential stability manages complex energy transfers and storing demands across the
foot, enabling the predictable specific vertical vector rebound or thrust of energy
required for measurable efficiency gains.
[0043] Multiple intrinsic rate limiting factors together control the speed at which the
human neuro-muscular system acts and reacts within its natural environment. Rate limiting
factors include the contractile proteins actin and myosin, the speed of neuro-muscular
input and feedback systems, the natural dash pot effect of involved musculature, the
genetic makeup, i.e., ratio of fast to slow twitch muscle fibers, the individual training
environment, etc.
[0044] With this in mind, there is an optimum speed at which muscles will receive the most
energy as well as force, position, perceived resistance and speed information from
the environment. Chambered actuators provide a tunable environment for energy and
environmental information to be provided to the neuro-muscular skeletal system. Tighter
tolerances and shorter drops produce sprint speed efficiency gains, while looser tolerances
and increased drops produce slower running speed efficiency gains.
[0045] Chambered actuators also resist tipping through the controlled stretching of the
membrane externally and more importantly internally, balancing the stretch producing
a lateral-to-medial cradling effect. As described below, chambered actuators can utilize
either a rigid or rubber internal pattern lug offering optional compression of a rubber
lug or the superior vertical guidance of a rigid, e.g., plastic, internal pattern
lug.
[0046] Raised nesting patterns on the elastic layers provide additional specifically placed
thickness while limiting additional weight. Chambered actuators produce a very small
footprint in relationship to the amount of surface area, "stretch zone," activated
by impact or weight bearing. This generates more power, less weight, less required
actuator penetration and faster cycle time.
[0047] With these general concepts in mind, the embodiments of the present invention are
described below.
First Exemplary Embodiment
[0048] Referring to the drawings and particularly to FIGS. 1 and 2, there is illustrated
a first exemplary embodiment of an article of athletic footwear for walking, running
and/or jumping, being generally designated 10. The footwear 10 includes an upper 12
and a sole 14 having heel and midfoot regions 14A, 14B and metatarsal and toe regions
14C, 14D wherein are provided the structural features of the sole 14 constituting
the present invention. The sole 14 incorporating the construction of the present invention
improves the walking, running and jumping performance of a wearer of the footwear
10 by providing a combination of structural features which complements and augments,
rather than resists, the natural flexing actions of the muscles of the foot to more
efficiently utilize the muscular energy of the wearer.
[0049] Referring to FIGS. 1 and 3 to 8, the heel and midfoot regions 14A, 14B of the sole
14 basically includes the stacked combination of a footbed layer 16, an upper stretch
layer 18, an upper thrustor layer 20, a lower stretch layer 22, and a lower thrustor
layer 24. The footbed layer 16 of the sole 14 serves as a foundation for the rest
of the stacked components of the heel and midfoot regions 14A, 14B. The footbed layer
16 includes a substantially flat foundation plate 26 of semi-rigid semi-flexible thin
stiff material, such as fiberglass, whose thickness is chosen to predetermine the
degree of flexion (or bending) it can undergo in response to the load that will be
applied thereto.
[0050] The foundation plate 26 has a heel portion 26A and a midfoot portion 26B. The foundation
plate 26 has a continuous interior lip 26C encompassing a central opening 28 formed
in the foundation plate 26 which provides its heel portion 26A with a generally annular
shape. The flat foundation plate 26 also has a plurality of continuous interior edges
26D encompassing a corresponding plurality of elongated slots 30 formed in the foundation
plate 26 arranged in spaced apart end-to-end fashion so as to provide a U-shaped pattern
of the slots 30 starting from adjacent to a forward end 26E of the foundation plate
26 and extending rearwardly therefrom and around the central opening 28. The slots
30 are preferably slightly curved in shape and run along a periphery 26F of the foundation
plate 26 but are spaced inwardly from the periphery 26F thereof and outwardly from
the central opening 28 thereof so as to leave solid narrow borders respectively adjacent
to the periphery 26F and the central opening 28 of the foundation plate 26. The slots
30 alone or in conjunction with recesses 32 of corresponding shape and position in
the bottom of the shoe upper 12 define a corresponding plurality of peripheral stretch
chambers 34 in the foundation plate 26.
[0051] The upper stretch layer 18 is made of a suitable elastic material, such as rubber,
and includes a flexible substantially flat stretchable body 36 and a plurality of
compressible lugs 38 formed on and projecting downwardly from the bottom surface 36A
of the flat stretchable body 36 at the periphery 36B thereof. The peripheral profile
of the flat stretchable body 36 of the upper stretch layer 18 generally matches that
of the flat foundation plate 26 of the footbed layer 16. In the exemplary embodiment
shown in FIGS. 1, 3 and 5 to 8, the compressible lugs 38 are arranged in a plurality
of pairs thereof, such as six in number, spaced apart along opposite lateral sides
of the flat stretchable body 36. Other arrangements of the compressible lugs 38 are
possible so long as it adds stability to the sole 14. For ease of manufacture, the
compressible lugs 38 are preferably integrally attached to the flat stretchable body
36.
[0052] The upper thrustor layer 20 disposed below and aligned with the upper stretch layer
18 includes a substantially flat support plate 40 preferably made of a relatively
incompressible, semi-rigid semi-flexible thin stiff material, such as fiberglass,
having a construction similar to that of the flat foundation plate 26 of the footbed
layer 16. The flat support plate 40 may have a heel portion 40A and a midfoot portion
40B. The support plate 40 also has a continuous interior rim 40C surrounding a central
hole 42 formed through the support plate 40 which provides its heel portion 40A with
a generally annular shape. The central hole 42 provides an entrance to a space formed
between the flat stretchable body 36 of the upper stretch layer 18 and the flat support
plate 40 spaced therebelow which space constitutes a main central stretch chamber
44 of said sole 14. The peripheral profile of the upper thrustor layer 20 generally
matches the peripheral profiles of the footbed layer 16 and upper stretch layer 18
so as to provide the sole 14 with a common profile when these components are in an
operative stacked relationship with one on top of the other.
[0053] The upper thrustor layer 20 also includes a plurality of stretch-generating thrustor
lugs 46 made of a relatively incompressible flexible material, such as plastics, and
being mounted on the top surface 40D of the flat support plate 40 and projecting upwardly
therefrom so as to space the flat support plate 40 below the flat stretchable body
36 of the upper stretch layer 18. The thrustor lugs 46 are arranged in a spaced apart
end-to-end fashion which corresponds to that of the slots 30 in the foundation plate
26 so as to provide a U-shaped pattern of the thrustor lugs 46 starting from adjacent
to a forward end 40E of the flat support plate 40 and extending rearward therefrom
and around the central opening 42. The thrustor lugs 46 run along a periphery 40F
of the support plate 40 but are spaced inwardly therefrom and outwardly from the central
opening 42 of the support plate 40 so as to leave solid narrow borders respectively
adjacent to the periphery 40F and the central opening 42 of the support plate 40.
[0054] The peripherally-located thrustor lugs 46 thus correspond in shape and position to
the peripherally-located slots 30 in the flat foundation plate 26 of the footbed layer
16 defining the peripherally-located stretch chambers 34. For ease of manufacture
the thrustor lugs 46 are attached to a common thin sheet which, in turn, is adhered
to the top surface 40D of the flat support plate 40.
[0055] The flat support plate 40 of the upper thrustor layer 20 supports the thrustor lugs
46 in alignment with the slots 30 and thus with the peripheral stretch chambers 34
of the foundation plate 26 and upper 12 of the shoe 10. However, the flat stretchable
body 36 of upper stretch layer 18 is disposed between the stretch generating thrustor
lugs 46 and flat foundation plate 26. Thus, with the footbed layer 16, upper stretch
layer 18 and upper thrustor layer 20 disposed in the operative stacked relationship
with one on top of the other in the heel and midfoot regions 14A, 14B of the sole
14, spaced portions 36C of the flat stretchable body 36 of the upper stretch layer
18 overlie top ends 46A of the stretch-generating thrustor lugs 46 and underlie the
peripheral stretch chambers 34. Upon compression of the footbed layer 16 and upper
thrustor layer 20 toward one another from a relaxed condition shown in FIGS. 5 and
6 toward a loaded condition shown in FIGS. 7 and 8, as occurs upon impact of the heel
and midfoot regions 14A, 14B of the sole 14 of the shoe 10 with a support surface,
the spaced portions 36A of the flat stretchable body 36 are forcibly stretched by
the upwardly movement of the top ends 46A of the thrustor lugs 46 upwardly past the
interior edges 26D of the foundation plate 26 surrounding the slots 30 and into the
stretch chambers 34. This can occur due to the fact that the thrustor lugs 46 are
enough smaller in their footprint size than that of the slots 30 so as to enable their
top ends 46A together with the portions 36A of the flat stretchable body 36 stretched
over the top ends 46A of the thrustor lugs 46 to move and penetrate upwardly through
the slots 30 and into the peripheral stretch chambers 34, as shown in FIGS. 7 and
8.
[0056] The compressible lugs 38 of the upper stretch layer 18 are located in alignment with
the solid border extending along the periphery 26F of the foundation plate 26 outside
of the thrustor lugs 46. The compressible lugs 38 project downwardly toward the support
base 40. The compressive force applied to the foundation plate 26 of the footbed layer
16 and to the support plate 42 of the upper thrustor layer 20, which occurs during
normal use of the footwear 10, causes compression of the compressible lugs 38 from
their normal tapered shape assumed in the relaxed condition of the sole 14 shown in
FIGS. 5 and 6, into the bulged shape taken on in the loaded condition of the sole
14 shown in FIGS. 7 and 8. In addition to adding stability, the function of the compressible
lugs 38 is to provide storage of the energy that was required to compress the lugs
38 and thereby to quicken and balance the resistance and rebound qualities of the
sole 14
[0057] As can best be seen in FIGS. 1 and 3, the stretch-generating thrustor lugs 46 are
generally greater in height at the heel portion 40A of the support plate 40 than at
the midfoot portion 40B thereof. This produces a wedge shape through the heel and
midfoot regions 14A, 14B of the sole 14 from rear to front, that effectively generates
and guides a forward and upward thrust for the user's foot as it moves through heel
strike to midstance phases of the foot's "on the ground" travel.
[0058] Referring to FIGS. 2, 3 and 8, the lower-stretch layer 22 is in the form of a flexible
thin substantially flat stretchable sheet 48 of resilient elastic material, such as
rubber, attached in any suitable manner, such as by gluing, to a bottom surface 40G
of the flat support plate 40 of the upper thruster layer 20. The lower thrustor layer
24 disposed below the flat stretchable sheet 48 of the lower stretch layer 22 includes
a thrustor plate 50, a thrustor cap 52 and a retainer ring 54. The thrustor plate
50 preferably is made of a suitable semi-rigid semi-flexible thin stiff material,
such as fiberglass. The thrustor plate 50 is bonded to the bottom surface of a central
portion 48A of the stretchable sheet 48 in alignment with the central hole 42 in the
support plate 40 of the upper thrustor layer 20. In operative stacked relationship
of the stretchable sheet 48 of the lower stretch layer 22 between the stretch-generating
thrustor plate 50 of the lower thrustor layer 24 and the support plate 40 of the upper
thrustor layer 20, the periphery 48B of the central portion 48A of the stretchable
sheet 48 overlies the peripheral edge 50A of the stretch-generating thrustor plate
50 and underlie the rim 40C of the support plate 40.
[0059] Upon compression of the lower thrustor layer 24 toward the upper thrustor layer 20
from a relaxed condition shown in FIGS. 5 and 6 toward a loaded condition shown in
FIGS. 7 and 8, as occurs upon impact of the heel and midfoot regions 14A, 14B of the
sole 14 of the shoe 10 with a support surface during normal activity, the periphery
48B of the stretchable sheet 48 is forcibly stretched by the peripheral edge 50A of
the thrustor plate 50 upwardly past the rim 40C surrounding the central hole 42 and
into the main central stretch chamber 44. This can occur due to the fact that the
thrustor plate 50 is enough smaller in its footprint size than that of the central
hole 42 in the support plate 40 so as to enable the thrustor plate 50 together with
the periphery 48B of the central portion 48A of the stretchable sheet 48 stretched
over the thrustor plate 50 to move and penetrate upwardly through the central hole
42 and into the main centrally-located stretch chamber 44, as shown in FIGS. 7 and
8.
[0060] The rigidity of the thrustor plate 50 of the lower thrustor layer 24 encourages a
stable uniform movement and penetration of the thrustor plate 50 and resultant stretching
of the periphery 48B of the central portion 48A of the stretchable sheet 48 into the
main central stretch chamber 44 in response to the application of compressive forces.
The thrustor cap 52 is bonded on the bottom surface 50A of the thrustor plate 50 and
preferably is made of a flexible plastic or hard rubber and its thickness partially
determines the depth of penetration and length of drive or rebound of the thrustor
plate 50. The ground engaging surface 52A of the thrustor cap 52 is generally domed
shape and presents a smaller footprint than that of the thrustor plate 50. The retainer
ring 54 is preferably made of the same material as the thrustor plate 50 and surrounds
the thrustor plate 50 and thrustor cap 52. The retainer ring 54 is bonded on the bottom
surface of the stretchable sheet 48 in alignment with the central hole 42 in the support
plate 40 and surrounds the thrustor plate 50 so as to increase the stretch resistance
of the central portion 48A of the stretchable sheet 48 and stabilize the lower thrustor
layer 24 in the horizontal plane reducing the potential of jamming or binding of the
thrustor plate 50 as it stretches the periphery 48B of the central portion 48A of
the stretchable sheet 48 through the central hole 42 in the flat support plate 40
of the upper thrustor layer 20.
[0061] The above-described centrally-located interactions in the heel and midfoot regions
14A, 14B of the sole 14 between the support plate 40 of the upper thrustor layer 20,
the flat stretchable sheet of the lower stretch layer 22 and flat thrustor plate of
the lower thrustor layer 24 of the heel and midfoot regions 14A, 14B occur concurrently
and interrelatedly with the peripherally-located interactions between footbed layer
16, the flat stretchable body 36 of the upper stretch layer 18 and the thrustor lugs
46 of the upper thrustor layer 20. These interrelated central and peripheral interactions
convert the energy applied to the heel and midfoot regions 14A, 14B of the sole 14
by the wearer's foot into mechanical stretch. The applied energy is thus temporarily
stored in the form of concurrent mechanical stretching of the central portion 48A
of the lower stretchable sheet 48 of the lower stretch layer 22 and of the spaced
portions 36C of the upper stretchable body 36 of the upper stretch layer 18 at the
respective sites of the centrally-located and peripherally-located stretch chambers
44, 34. The stored applied energy is thereafter retrieved in the form of concurrent
rebound of the stretched portions 36C of the upper stretchable body 36 and the thrustor
lugs 46 therewith and of the stretched portion 48A of the lower stretchable sheet
48 and the thrustor plate 40 therewith. The resistance and speed of these stretching
and rebound interactions is determined and controlled by the size relationship between
the retainer ring 54 and the rim 40C about the central hole 42 of the support plate
49 and between the top ends 46A of the thrustor lugs 46 and the continuous interior
edges 26D encompassing the slots 30 of the foundation plate 26. The thickness and
elastic qualities preselected for the lower stretchable sheet 48 of the lower stretch
layer 22 and the upper stretchable body 36 of the upper stretch layer 18 influence
and mediate the resistance and speed of these interactions. The stretching and rebound
of the lower stretchable sheet 48 also causes a torquing of the support plate 40.
The torquing can be controlled by the thickness of the support plate 40 as well as
by the size and thickness of the retainer ring 54.
[0062] Referring to FIG. 3, the midfoot region 14B of the sole 14 of the present invention
also includes a curved midfoot piece 56 and a compression midfoot piece 58 complementary
to the curved midfoot piece 56. The midfoot portion 26B of the foundation plate 26
terminates at the forward end 26E which has a generally V-shaped configuration. The
curved midfoot piece 56 preferably is made of graphite and is provided as a component
separate from the foundation plate 26. The curved midfoot piece 56 has a configuration
which is complementary to and fits with the forward end 26E of the foundation plate
26. The forward end 26E of the foundation plate 26 cradles the number five metatarsal
bone of the forefoot as the curved midfoot piece 56 couples the heel and forefoot
portions 14A, 14B of the sole 14 so as to load the bones of the forefoot in an independent
manner. The peripheral profiles of the upper stretch layer 18 and compression midfoot
piece 58 are generally the same as those of the foundation plate 26 and curved midfoot
piece 56.
[0063] Referring now to FIGS. 1, 2 and 9 to 11, the metatarsal and toe regions 14C, 14D
of the sole 14 basically include the stacked combinations of metatarsal and toe articulated
plates 60A, 60B, metatarsal and toe foundation plates 62A, 62B, a common metatarsal
and toe stretch layer 64, and metatarsal and toe thrustor layers 65A, 65B. The metatarsal
and toe thrustor layers 65A, 65B include metatarsal and toe plates 66A, 66B, metatarsal
and toe thrustor caps 68A, 68B and metatarsal and toe retainer rings 70A, 70B. Except
for a common stretch layer 64 serving both metatarsal and toe regions 14C, 14D of
the sole 14, there is one stacked combination of components in the metatarsal region
14C of the sole 14 that underlies the five metatarsals of the wearer's foot and another
separate stacked combination of components in the toe region 14D of the sole 14 that
underlies the five toes of the wearer's foot. Except for the upper articulated plates
60A, 60B, the above-mentioned stacked combinations of components of the metatarsal
and toe regions 14C, 14D of the sole 14 interact (stretching and rebound) generally
similarly to the above-described interaction (stretching and rebound) of the stacked
combination of components of the heel and midfoot regions 14A, 14B of the sole 14.
However, whereas the stacked combination of components of the heel and midfoot regions
14A, 14B provide interrelated main and peripheral sites for temporary storage and
retrieval of the applied energy, the stacked combination of components of the metatarsal
and toe regions 14C, 14D provide a plurality of relatively independent sites for temporary
storage and retrieval of the applied energy at the individual metatarsals and toes
of the wearer is foot. The additional components, namely, the articulated plates 60A,
60B, of the metatarsal and toe regions 14C, 14D each has a plurality of laterally
spaced slits 72A, 72B formed therein extending from the forward edges 74A, 74B rearwardly
to about midway between the forward edges 74A, 74B and rearward edges 76A, 76B of
the articulated plates 60A, 60B. These pluralities of spaced slits 72A, 72B define
independent deflectable or articulatable appendages 78A, 78B on the metatarsal and
toe articulated plates 60A, 60B that correspond to the individual metatarsals and
toes of the wearer's foot and overlie and augment the independent characteristic of
the respective sites of temporary storage and retrieval of the applied energy at the
individual metatarsals and, toes of the wearer's foot.
[0064] More particularly, the metatarsal and toe articulated plates 60A, 60B are substantially
flat and made of a suitable semi-rigid semi-flexible thin stiff material, such as
graphite, while the metatarsal and toe foundation plates 62A, 62B disposed below the
metatarsal and toe articulated plates 60A, 60B are substantially flat and made of
a incompressible flexible material, such as plastic. Each of the metatarsal and toe
foundation plates 62A, 62B has a continuous interior edge 80A, 80B defining a plurality
of interconnected interior slots 82A, 82B which are matched to the metatarsals and
toes of the wearer's foot. The continuous interior edges 80A, 80B are spaced inwardly
from located inwardly from the peripheries 84A, 84B of the metatarsal and toe foundation
plates 62A, 62B so as to leave continuous solid narrow borders 86A, 86B respectively
adjacent to the peripheries 84A, 84B. The metatarsal and toe portions of the borders
86A, 86B encompassing or outlining the locations of the separate metatarsals and toes
of the wearer's foot and of the appendages 78A, 78B on the articulated plates 60A,
60B are also separated by narrow slits 88A, 88B. The pluralities of interconnected
interior slots 82A, 82B define corresponding pluralities of metatarsal and toe stretch
chambers 90A, 90B in the respective metatarsal and toe foundation plates 62A, 62B.
[0065] The common metatarsal and toe stretch layer 64 is made of a suitable elastic stretchable
material, such as rubber, and is disposed below the metatarsal and toe foundation
plates 62A, 62B. The peripheral profile of the common stretch layer 64 generally matches
the peripheral profiles of the articulated plates 60A, 60B and of the foundation plates
62A, 62B so as to provide the sole 14 with a common profile when these components
are in an operative stacked relationship with one on top of the other. The common
stretch layer 64 is attached at its upper surface 64A to the respective continuous
borders 86A, 96B of the foundation plates 62A, 62B between their respective continuous
interior edges 80A, 80B and peripheries 84A, 84B.
[0066] The metatarsal and toe thrustor plates 66A, 66B are disposed below and aligned with
the common stretch layer 64 and the pluralities of interconnected interior slots 82A,
82B in foundation plates 62A, 62B forming the metatarsal and toe stretch chambers
90A, 90B. The metatarsal and toe thrustor plates 66A, 66B are made of semi-rigid semi-flexible
thin stiff material, such as fiberglass. The metatarsal and toe thrustor plates 66A,
66B are bonded to the lower surface 64B of the common stretch layer 64 in alignment
with the pluralities of interconnected interior slots 82A, 82B of forming the metatarsal
and toe stretch chambers 90A, 90B of the foundation plates 62A, 62B. In the operative
stacked relationship of the common stretch layer 64 between the stretch-generating
metatarsal and toe thrustor plates 66A, 66B and the respective metatarsal and toe
foundation plates 62A, 62B, portions 92A, 92B of the common stretch layer 64 overlie
the peripheral edges 94A, 94B of the metatarsal and toe thrustor plates 66A, 66B and
underlie the continuous interior edges 80A, 80B of the metatarsal and toe foundation
plates 62A, 62B.
[0067] Upon compression of the lower metatarsal and toe thrustor plates 66A, 66B toward
the upper metatarsal and toe foundation plates 62A, 62B from a relaxed condition shown
in FIG.10 toward a loaded condition shown in FIG. 11, as occurs upon impact of the
metatarsal and toe regions 14C, 14D of the sole 14 of the shoe 10 with a support surface
during normal activity, the portions 92A, 92B of the common stretch layer 64 are forcibly
stretched by the peripheries 94A, 94B of the metatarsal and toe thrustor plates 66A,
66B upwardly past the continuous interior edges 80A, 80B of the metatarsal and toe
foundation plates 62A, 62B into the metatarsal and toe stretch chambers 90A, 90B.
This can occur due to the fact that the metatarsal and toe thrustor plates 66A, 66B
are enough smaller in their respective footprint sizes than the sizes of the slots
82A, 82B in the metatarsal and toe foundation plates 62A, 62B so as to enable the
metatarsal and toe thrustor plates 66A, 66B together with the portions 92A, 92B of
the common stretch layer 64 stretched over the respective thrustor plates 66A, 66B
to move and penetrate upwardly through the slots 82A, 82B and into the metatarsal
and toe stretch chambers 90A, 90B, as shown in FIG. 11.
[0068] The rigidity of the metatarsal and toe thrustor plates 66A, 66B encourages a stable
uniform movement and penetration of the thrustor plates 66A, 66B and resultant stretching
of the portions 92A, 92B of the common stretch layer 64 into the metatarsal and toe
stretch chambers 90A, 90B in response to the application of compressive forces. The
metatarsal and toe thrustor caps 68A, 68B are bonded respectively on the bottom surfaces
96A, 96B of the metatarsal and toe thrustor plates 66A, 66B and preferably is made
of a flexible plastic or hard rubber and their respective thicknesses partially determine
the depth of penetration and length of drive or rebound of the metatarsal and toe
thrustor plates 66A, 66B. The metatarsal and toe retainer rings 70A, 70B are preferably
made of the same material as the metatarsal and toe thrustor plates 66A, 66B and surround
the respective thrustor plates 66A, 66B and thrustor caps 68A, 68B. The metatarsal
and toe retainer rings 70A, 70B are bonded on the lower surface 64B of the common
stretch layer 64 in alignment with the interior slots 82A, 82B and surround the thrustor
plates 66A, 66B so as to increase the stretch resistance of the portion 92A, 92B of
the common stretch layer 64 and stabilize the metatarsal and toe thrustor plates 66A,
66B in the horizontal plane reducing the potential of jamming or binding of the thrustor
plates 66A, 66B as they stretch the peripheries of the portions 92a, 92B of the common
stretch layer 64 into the metatarsal and toe stretch chambers 90A, 90b in the metatarsal
and toe foundation plates 62A, 62B.
[0069] The above-described plurality of stretching interactions between the metatarsal and
toe foundation plates 62A, 62B, common stretch layer 64 and metatarsal and toe thrustor
plates 66A, 66B of the metatarsal and toe regions 14C, 14D in their stacked relationship
converts the energy applied to the metatarsals and toes by the wearer's foot into
mechanical stretch. The applied energy is stored in the form of mechanical stretching
of the metatarsal and toe portions 92A, 92B of the common stretch layer 64 at the
respective sites of the metatarsal and toe stretch chambers 90A, 90B. The applied
energy is retrieved in the form of rebound of the stretched portions 92A, 92B of the
common stretch layer 64 and the thrustor plates 66A, 66b therewith. The resistance
and speed of these stretching interactions is determined and controlled by the size
relationship between the retainer rings 70A, 70B and the continuous interior edges
80A, 80B in the metatarsal and toe foundation plates 62A, 62B. The thickness and elastic
qualities preselected for the common stretch layer 64 influence and mediate the resistance
and speed of these interactions. The peripheral profiles of the metatarsal and toe
thrustor plates 66A, 66B are generally the same. The previously described midfoot
pieces 56, 58 also provide a bridge between the components of the heel and midfoot
regions 14A, 14B of the sole 14 and the components of the metatarsal and toe regions
14C, 14D of the sole 14.
[0070] The metatarsal and toe regions 14C and 14D of the first preferred embodiment significantly
improve the Snow tipping problem by employing metatarsal and toe thrustor layers with
a single torsion armature. As shown in FIG. 9, the thrustor plates 66A and 66B and
the thrustor caps 68A and 68B each preferably include an armature 69 extending between
the lateral sides of the foot. This single torsion armature thereby interconnects
the actuator elements of the plates 66A, 66B and caps 68A, 68B, to give the plates
or caps the ability to conduct energy laterally to medially across the forefoot and
toes across individual actuator elements corresponding to each of the bones of the
toe or metatarsal region. This provides superior guidance and synergism between the
actuator elements, as well as the opportunity to provide specific leverage points
for the bony structure of the foot.
[0071] Further control over lateral to medial movement can be accomplished by increasing
the height of the lateral and medial borders of the plates 66A, 66B and caps 68A,
68B. Raising the outer edges guides the foot's natural lateral to medial movement.
[0072] Preliminary experimental treadmill comparative testing of a skilled runner wearing
prototype footwear 10 having soles 14 constructed in accordance with the present invention
with the same runner wearing premium quality conventional footwear, has demonstrated
a significantly improved performance of the runner while wearing the prototype footwear
in terms of the runner's oxygen intake requirements. The prototype footwear 10 compared
to the conventional footwear allowed the runner to use from ten to twenty percent
less oxygen running at the same treadmill speed. The dramatically reduced oxygen intake
requirement can only be attributed to an equally dramatic improvement of the energy
efficiency that the runner experienced while wearing the footwear 10 having the heel
construction of the present invention. It is reasonable to expect that this dramatic
improvement in energy efficiency will translate into dramatic improvement in runner
performance as should be reflected in elapsed times recorded in running competitions.
Second Embodiment
[0073] A second embodiment is directed to articles of footwear incorporating a sole either
as an integral part thereof or as an insert wherein the sole is constructed so as
to absorb, store and release energy during active use. Thus, it should be appreciated
that the invention includes such a sole, whether alone, as an insert for an existing
article of footwear or incorporated as an improvement into an article of footwear.
In any event, the sole is adapted to be worn on the foot of a person while traversing
along a support surface and is operative to store and release energy resulting from
compressive forces between the person and the support surface.
[0074] With reference first to FIGS. 12-14, the second embodiment is shown to illustrate
its most simple construction. The sole shown in FIG. 12, which is an assembly including
the components illustrated in FIGS. 13 and 14, does not show the invention as claimed.
As may be seen in FIG. 1, an article of footwear in the form of an athletic shoe 110
has an upper 112 and a sole 114. Sole 114 includes a heel portion 16 that is constructed
according to the second embodiment.
[0075] The structure of heel portion 116 is best shown with reference to FIGS. 13, 14A and
148. In these FIGS. , it may be seen that heel portion 16 includes a first profile
in the form of a heel piece 118 that is formed of a relatively stiff material such
as rubber, polymer, plastic or similar material. Heel piece 118 includes a first profile
chamber 120 centrally located therein with first profile chamber 120 being oval in
configuration and centered about axis "A". A second profile 122 is structured as a
flat panel 124 that is provided with a primary actuator 126 that is similarly shaped
but slightly smaller in dimension then first profile chamber 120. Second profile piece
122 is also formed of a stiff material, such as rubber, polymer, plastic or similar
material. Actuator 126 can be formed integrally with flat panel 124 or, alternatively,
affixed centrally thereon in any convenient manner.
[0076] The first layer 128 of a stretchable resilient material is interposed between heel
piece 118 and second profile piece 122 so that resilient layer 128 spans across first
profile chamber 120. To this end, it may be appreciated that heel piece 118 is positioned
on a first side 130 of first resilient layer 128 while the second profile piece 122
is positioned on a second side 132 of first resilient layer 128 with actuator 126
facing the second side thereof. Moreover, it may be seen that first profile chamber
120 has a first interior region 134 that is sized to receive actuator 128.
[0077] With reference to FIGS. 14A and 148, it may be seen that heel piece 118 and second
profile piece 122 are positioned so that a compressive force between the first and
the support surface 136 in the direction of vector "F" moves heel piece 118 and second
profile piece 122 toward one another. During this movement, the primary actuator element
128 advances into the first profile chamber 120. As this happens, resilient layer
128 is stretched into the first interior region 134 to define the active state shown
in FIG. 14B. In the active state, energy is stored by the stretching of resilient
layer 128. However, when the compressive force is removed, resilient layer 128 operates
to release the energy thereby to move heel piece 118 and second profile piece 122
apart from one another to return them to the static stage shown in FIG. 14A. Accordingly,
in operation, when a user places weight on the heel portion 116, either from walking,
running or jumping, the impact force is cushioned and absorbed by the stretching of
resilient layer 128. When the user transfers weight away from heel portion 116, this
energy is released thereby helping propel the user in his/her activity.
Third Exemplary Embodiment
[0078] The simple structure shown in FIGS. 12-14 can be expanded to make a highly active
sole, such as that shown in the third exemplary embodiment of the FIGS. 15-22. With
reference to FIG. 15, it may be seen that an article of footwear in the form of an
athletic shoe 150 has an upper 152 and a sole 154 with sole 154 being constructed
according to the third exemplary embodiment of the present invention. Sole 154 includes
a heel portion 156, a metatarsal portion 158 and a toe portion 160, all described
below in greater detail. Thus, when reference is made to a "sole" it may be just one
of these portions, a group of portions or a piece that underlies the entire foot or
a portion thereof.
[0079] Turning first, then, to heel portion 156, the structure of the same may best be shown
with reference to FIGS. 17-19. In these figures, it may be seen that heel portion
156 includes a first profile 162 formed by an annular heel plate 164 that has a plurality
of spaced apart auxiliary actuator elements 166 positioned around the perimeter. Actuator
elements 166 are formed of a stiff, fairly rigid material and define a first profile
chamber 168 which has an opening 170 formed in annular heel plate 164. A layer of
resilient stretchable material 172 is configured so that it will span across opening
170 with heel plate 164 and resilient layer 172 being secured together such as by
an adhesive or other suitable means. Thus, first profile piece 162 is positioned on
one side of resilient layer 172, and a second profile piece 174 is positioned on a
second side of resilient layer 172 and is affixed thereto in any convenient manner.
Second profile piece 174 is in the form of a heel piece but defines a primary actuator
element for interaction with chamber 170. Thus, when used in this application, the
phrase "second profile including a primary actuator element" can mean either that
a second profile is provided with an independent actuator element or that the profile
itself forms such actuator element.
[0080] In any event, it may further be appreciated that second profile piece 174 has a second
profile chamber 176 formed centrally therein with second profile chamber 176 being
an elongated six-lobed opening. Heel portion 156 then includes a third profile piece
178 that is provided with a plunger element 180 that is geometrically similar in shape
to second profile chamber 176 but that is slightly smaller in dimension. Third profile
piece 178 also includes a plurality of openings 182 that are sized and oriented to
receive secondary actuator elements 166 noted above. To this end, also, heel portion
156 includes a second resilient layer 184 which has an elongated oval opening 186
centrally located therein. Openings 182 define third profile chambers each having
a third interior region.
[0081] With reference now to FIGS. 18 and 19A, it may be understood that, when nested, the
various pieces which make up heel portion 156 form a highly active system for storing
energy. Here, it may be seen that plunger 180 of a selected height so that, when nested,
surface 188 of plunger 180 contacts the second side 190 of resilient layer 172. Simultaneously,
upper surfaces 192 of secondary actuators 166 just contact surface 194 of second resilient
layer 184. Each of secondary actuator elements 166 align with a respective opening
182 with openings 182 having a similar shape as the configuration of actuator 166
but slightly larger in dimension. Second profile piece 174 is then aligned so that
second profile chamber 176 is positioned to receive plunger 180 when second profile
piece 174 moves into the interior region of first profile chamber 168.
[0082] This movement, from the static state shown in FIG.19A is depicted in the active state
of FIG. 19B. Here it may be seen that resilient layer 172 is forced to undergo a dual
stretching wherein first profile piece 162, second profile piece 174 and plunger 180
counteract in a dual piston-like action. Resilient layer 172 is accordingly stretched
both into first profile chamber 168 (by second profile piece 174) and into the interior
region of second profile chamber 176 (by plunger 180).
[0083] At the same time, second resilient layer 184 undergoes a single deflection into each
of the third profile chambers formed by openings 182. It should now be appreciated
that by making the third profile chambers small in vertical dimension, the undersurface
153 of upper 152 provides a limit stop so that peripheral support is attained by second
actuator elements 166 while the primary energy storing occurs with the coaction of
plunger 180 and second profile piece 174 on resilient layer 172. To further assist
in lateral stability, auxiliary positioning blocks 196 may be employed along with
optional soft lugs 198 which extend downwardly between third profile piece 178 and
second resilient layer 184. Moreover, optional metatarsal support plates 200 may be
employed if desired.
[0084] With reference again to FIG. 15, it may be seen that sole 154 is constructed so as
to be oriented at a slight acute angle "a" relative to support surface "s" when in
the static state, with heel portion 156 being elevated relative to toe portion 160.
Preferably angle "a" is in a range of about 2 degrees to 6 degrees. By providing this
small angle, the release of the energy from the active state is not simply in the
vertical direction during mid-stance to toe-off. Rather, since sole 154 pivots about
the toe portion 160, the restorative force therefore is angled slightly forwardly
during this movement. This results in a component of the restorative force being transferred
to propel the user in a forward direction.
[0085] With reference now to FIGS. 20 and 21, the construction of toe portion 160 may be
seen in greater detail. Here, it may be seen that toe portion 160 is formed by a first
profile piece 208 that includes a first profile by an upstanding perimeter wall 212
that extends around the peripheral edge of first profile piece 208. As may be seen
with reference to FIG. 20A, perimeter wall 212 is configured so that chamber 210 has
five regions 216-220, that correspond to each of the human toes. A first resilient
layer 222 is shown in FIG. 20B and has a peripheral edge that is geometrically congruent
to first profile piece 208. When assembled, first resilient layer 222 spans across
first profile chamber 210. The structure of toe portion 160 is completed with the
addition of second profile piece 224 which is shown in FIG. 20A. Second profile piece
224 is shaped geometrically similar to the interior side wall 213 of perimeter wall
212 so that it can nest in close-fitted, mated relation into first profile chamber
210. Second profile piece 224 is provided with openings 226-229 that define second
profile chambers which correspond to toe regions 216-219. With reference again to
FIG. 20A, it may be seen that each of these toe regions is provided with an upstanding
plunger 236-239 which are sized for mated insertion into openings 226-229, respectively.
[0086] Accordingly, as is shown in FIGS. 21A and 21B, toe portion 160 provides a dual acting
energy storing system. When first profile piece 208 and second profile piece 224 are
moved from the static state shown in FIG. 21A to the active state shown in FIG. 21B,
resilient layer 222 undergoes a double deflection. Second profile piece 224, which
defines the primary actuator, moves into first profile chamber 210 thus stretching
resilient layer 222 into the interior region thereof. Simultaneously, each of the
plungers 236-239 move into the corresponding opening 226-229 in second profile piece
224 thus stretching resilient layer 222 into the interior region of openings 226-229.
[0087] For ease of manufacture, it is possible to provide plungers 236-239 as part of resilient
layer 222. Accordingly, this alternative structure is shown in FIG. 20D wherein resilient
layer 222 is shown to have plunger elements 236'-239' formed integrally therewith.
In FIG. 20D, the opposite side of resilient layer of 222' is revealed from that shown
in FIG. 20B.
[0088] The structure of metatarsal portion 158 is similar to that of toe portion 160. In
FIGS. 22A-22C, it may be seen that metatarsal portion 158 is formed by a first profile
piece 218 that includes a first profile chamber 250 formed therein. First profile
chamber 250 is thus bounded by an upstanding perimeter wall 252 that extends around
the peripheral edge of first profile piece 208. As may be seen with reference to FIG.
20A, perimeter wall 252 is configured so that chamber 250 has five regions 255-259,
that correspond to each of the metatarsal bones. A first resilient layer 262 is shown
in FIG. 22B and has a peripheral edge that is geometrically congruent to first profile
piece 248. When assembled, first resilient layer 262 spans across first profile chamber
250. The structure of metatarsal portion 158 is completed with the addition of second
profile piece 264 which is shown in FIG. 22C.
[0089] Second profile piece 264 is shaped geometrically similar to the interior side wall
253 of perimeter wall 252 so that it can nest in close-fitted, mated relation into
first profile chamber 250. Second profile piece 264 is provided with openings 265-270
that define second profile chambers. With reference again to FIG. 22A, it may be seen
that first profile chamber 250 is provided with upstanding plungers 275-280 which
are sized for mated insertion into openings 265-270, respectively. Plungers 275-280
are oriented to extend between the metatarsal bones of the human foot.
[0090] Here again when first profile piece 248 and second profile piece 264 move from the
static state to the active state, resilient layer 262 undergoes a double deflection.
Second profile piece 264 which defines the primary actuator, moves into first profile
chamber 250 thus stretching resilient layer 262 into the interior region thereof.
Simultaneously, each of the plungers 275-280 move into the corresponding chambers
265-270 in second profile piece 264 thus stretching resilient layer 262 into the interior
region of openings 265-270. The action, therefore, is identical to that described
with reference to FIGS. 21A and 21B.
[0091] The energy focal points for the toe profile piece 224 and the forefoot profile piece
264 center around the chambers 226-229 and 265-270, respectively. These chambers are
further stabilized by fore and aft torsion armatures which interconnect the actuator
portions of actuators 224 and 264 and conduct energy laterally and medially across
the forefoot and toe regions. As shown in FIG. 20C, a fore torsion armature 230 bounds
the fore portion of the profile piece 224, and an aft torsion armature 232 bounds
the aft portion of the profile piece 224. Similarly, as shown in FIG. 22C, a fore
torsion armature 272 bounds the fore portion of the profile piece 264, and an aft
torsion armature 274 bounds the aft portion of the profile piece 274.
Fourth Exemplary Embodiment
[0092] A fourth exemplary embodiment of the present invention is shown in FIGS. 23-27. In
these FIGS. a sole insert 310 is shown to include an upper 312 and a sole 314. Sole
314 includes a heel section 316, a metatarsal 318 and a toe portion 320. The structure
of heel portion 216 is best shown in FIGS. 24 and 27A and 27B. Heel portion 316 includes
a first profile piece 322 structured generally as flat plate 323 that has a plurality
of first profile chambers 324 formed therein. Chambers 324 are formed as cavities
in plate 323. Alternatively, chambers 324 could be formed by openings completely through
plate 323. A second profile piece 326 includes a plurality of actuator elements 328
which are sized for engagement into the interior region of a respective chamber 324.
First profile piece 324 and second profile piece 326 sandwich a resilient layer 330
therebetween so that, when compression forces are exerted, actuator elements 328 are
advanced into first profile chamber 324.
[0093] Toe portion 320 is formed by a first profile piece 344 and a second profile piece
346 that defines an actuator. The structure of profile pieces 344 and 346 are identical
to that described with respect to profile pieces 208 and 224, respectively, so that
this description is not repeated. Similarly, metatarsal portion 318 is formed by a
first profile piece 354 and a second profile piece 356 with the structure of profile
pieces 354 and 356 being the same as that of profile pieces 348 and 364. One difference
that may be noted in the structure of the sole insert 310, however, is that the resilient
layer 330 is a common resilient layer that extends along the complete sole of insert
310 so that resilient layer 330 provides the resilient layers for storing energy in
each of heel portion 316, metatarsal portion 318 and toe portion 320.
Fifth Exemplary Embodiment
[0094] FIGS. 28-30 illustrate a fifth exemplary embodiment of the sole of the present invention.
This embodiment is similar to the third exemplary embodiment described above, with
one difference being that the heel portion 456 does not have the optional soft lugs
198 shown in FIG. 17 above. Toe portion 460 and metatarsal portion 458, shown in a
bottom view in FIG. 30, are substantially the same as shown in 20A-20C and 22A-22C,
respectively, using like numerals in the 400 series rather than the 200 series.
[0095] FIGS. 28 and 29 show the heel portion 456 in an exploded perspective view and an
exploded partial cross-sectional view, respectively. The heel portion 456 includes
a first profile 462 formed by an annular heel plate 464 that has a plurality of spaced
apart auxiliary actuator elements 466 positioned around the perimeter in a U-shape.
Actuator elements 466 are formed of a stiff, fairly rigid material and define a first
profile chamber 468 which has an opening 470 formed in annular heel plate 464. Actuator
elements 466 are preferably tapered, as shown in FIG. 29, toward the front of the
sole, to provide additional support toward the rear of the foot. A layer of resilient
stretchable material 472 is configured so that it will span across opening 470 with
heel plate 464 and resilient layer 472 being secured together such as by an adhesive
or other suitable means. Thus, first profile piece 462 is positioned on one side of
resilient layer 472, and a second profile piece 474 is positioned on a second side
of resilient layer 472 and is affixed thereto in any convenient manner. Second profile
piece 474 is in the form of a heel piece but defines a primary actuator element for
interaction with chamber 470.
[0096] It may further be appreciated that second profile piece 474 has a second profile
chamber 476 formed centrally therein with second profile chamber 476 being an elongated
six-lobed opening. Heel portion 456 then includes a third profile piece 478 that is
provided with a plunger element 480 that is geometrically similar in shape to second
profile chamber 476 but that is slightly smaller in dimension. Third profile piece
478 also includes a plurality of openings 482 that are sized and oriented to receive
secondary actuator elements 466 noted above. To this end, also, heel portion 456 includes
a second resilient layer 484 which has an elongated oval opening 486 centrally located
therein. Openings 482 define third profile chambers each having a third interior region.
[0097] To assist in lateral stability, auxiliary positioning blocks 496 are provided between
the second resilient layer 484 and first profile piece 464. Additional support blocks
or motion control posts 502 are provided beneath the first profile piece substantially
underlying the forward pair of secondary actuator elements 466. The tripod configuration
of the support blocks 502 and second profile piece 474 provides improved stability.
The unit is capable of storing energies derived from rotational forces, producing
optimal vertical vectors. Shoes requiring additional stability can take advantage
of the ability to space the motion control posts further apart. For individuals having
flat feet or requiring full support of the midfoot region, an optional active foot
bridge is contemplated.
[0098] It should be understood that, when nested, the various pieces which make up heel
portion 456 form a highly active system for storing energy. In particular, the heel
portion 456 exhibits substantially similar behavior as the heel portion 156 depicted
in FIGS. 19A and 19B.
[0099] The bottom view of the sole portion shown in FIG. 30 depicts the arrangement of the
heel portion 456, metatarsal portion 458 and toe portion 460 comprising the exemplary
sole of the shoe. FIG. 30 also depicts an additional metatarsal support portion 500,
shown more particularly in FIGS. 31A-31C. As shown in FIG. 31A, the metatarsal support
portion 500 is formed by a first profile piece 504 that includes a first profile chamber
510 defined by an upstanding perimeter wall 512 that extends around the peripheral
edge of first profile piece 504. A resilient layer 506 is shown in FIG. 31B and has
a peripheral edge that is geometrically congruent to first profile piece 504. When
assembled, resilient layer 506 spans across profile chamber 510. The structure of
metatarsal support portion 500 is completed with the addition of second profile piece
508 which is shown in FIG. 31C. Second profile piece 508 is shaped geometrically similar
to the interior side wall 512 of first profile piece 504 so that it can nest in close-fitted,
mated relation into profile chamber 510. More particularly, second profile piece 508
and chamber 510 are positioned to cradle the first and second metatarsal bones.
Sixth Embodiment
[0100] FIGS. 32 and 33 depict an alternative embodiment of a heel portion 556 for a sole.
The sole shown in FIG. 32, which is an assembly including the components illustrated
in FIGS. 33, does not show the invention as claimed. The heel portion 556 comprises
a main thrustor 574, a first resilient layer 572, a first profile layer 562 with actuator
elements or satellite thrustors 566 thereon, interlocking rubber lugs 598 on a second
resilient layer 584, and a second profile layer 578 overlying the resilient layer
584. Additionally auxiliary support blocks 602 are positioned proximal to the resilient
layer 572 beneath the profile layer 562.
[0101] The embodiment shown in FIG. 32 is similar to the heel portion 156 shown in FIG.
17, with two differences being that the rubber lugs 598 are provided beneath the resilient
layer 584 instead of the profile piece 578, and that the embodiment in FIG. 32 does
not have a plunger similar to element 180 in FIG. 17.
[0102] With reference to FIGS. 32 and 33, it may be seen that heel portion 556 includes
a first profile 562 formed by an annular heel plate 564 that has a plurality of spaced
apart auxiliary or satellite actuator elements 566 positioned around the perimeter
in a U-shape. Actuator elements 566 are formed of a stiff, fairly rigid material and
define a first profile chamber 568 which has an opening 570 formed in annular heel
plate 564. A layer of resilient stretchable material 572 is configured so that it
will span across opening 570 with heel plate 564 and resilient layer 572 being secured
together such as by an adhesive or other suitable means. Thus, first profile piece
562 is positioned on one side of resilient layer 572, and a second profile piece 574
is positioned on a second side of resilient layer 572 and is affixed thereto in any
convenient manner. Second profile piece 574 is in the form of a heel piece but defines
a primary actuator element or main thrustor for interaction with chamber 570. As shown
in FIG. 33, second profile piece 574 preferably decreases or tapers in dimension in
a downward direction, and more preferably has a substantially lower dome-like shape
with sloping surfaces. This shape provides improved lateral support to the heel through
three basic phases of foot movement of heel strike, mid stance and toe off.
[0103] Heel portion 556 includes a third profile piece or foundation layer 578 that includes
a plurality of openings 582 that are sized and oriented to receive actuator elements
566 noted above. To this end, heel portion 556 includes a second resilient layer 584.
Openings 582 define second profile chambers each having a second interior region.
The upper surfaces of actuators 566 just contact the lower surface of second resilient
layer 584. Each of secondary actuator elements 566 align with a respective opening
582 having a similar shape as the configuration of actuator 566 but slightly larger
in dimension.
[0104] A pair of support blocks or motion control posts 602 are provided underlying the
forward pair of actuators 566. Like the second profile piece 574, these posts 602
are preferably convex downward in shape, and are more preferably dome-like in shape
and forwardly sloped to provide improved lateral stability to the sole.
[0105] The rubber lugs 598 are provided beneath the resilient layer 584 to substantially
mate and interlock with the actuators 566. Both the rubber lugs 598 and the actuators
566 are preferably tapered in a forward direction to allow for a more controlled lateral
displacement during compression. The side walls of lugs 598 and 566 are preferably
sloped approximately 3 to 6 degrees. Each of the lugs mirror each other to provide
elastically cradled interaction. The space between the rubber lugs 598 and thrustors
566 is preferably less than about 0.020 inches, to keep particles larger than 0.020
out. Too tight of a seal creates a vacuum, slowing the rebound process. The interlock
allows a sufficient air flow, particularly during rebound as a too-tight-of-a-seal
creates a vacuum slowing the rebound process. In anticipation, this design leaves
a large space between the motion control posts 602 to allow for the exit of air, water,
etc.
[0106] The actuators 566 preferably have a raised nesting pattern to better interlock with
the rubber lugs 598. The nesting effect creates a more adaptable environment, improving
the conversion of energies from rotational forces to vertical force storage and retrieval.
By specifically increasing the thickness of the plate 564 near the actuators 566,
- weight is also reduced. Nesting patterns also act as a relocator and stabilizer
for actuators fostering the energy wave to vertical vectors. Nesting patterns increase
the sensitivity of the main thrustor 574 maximizing the length of propulsion or drive
of the rebounding thrustor. They also provide additional force at the end of the thrust
cycle, and help keep actuators in place.
[0107] Varying the actuator rigidity increases the amount of control over the energy "wave"
and the neuro-muscular system's sensitivity to it. If the user's foot naturally supinates,
that action tends to put excessive motion control demands on the outer border of the
forefoot, metatarsal number five. This excessive undesirable motion is sequentially
captured by a chambered actuator, such as actuator 574 in the sixth embodiment described
above, stored and released quickly enough that the negative motion itself becomes
the energy for sending the foot laterally to medially enhancing neutral plane functioning.
A more rigid chambered actuator resists tipping or diving to the outer lateral or
medial borders, thereby stabilizing the interlocking energy staring process. Further
details regarding varying the actuator rigidity is described in the seventh exemplary
embodiment below.
Seventh Exemplary and Main Preferred Embodiment
[0108] FIGS. 34-68 illustrate a seventh exemplary and main preferred embodinent of a sole
construction according to the present invention. As used throughout this specification,
the term "sole construction" refers to both a whole or a portion of the sole used
to support a human foot. Furthermore, because the components described in the seventh
exemplary embodiment are similar to many of the components described in the embodiments
above, it should be appreciated that the terminology used to describe similar components
in the above embodiments may be interchangeable with the terminology used below.
[0109] FIG. 34 illustrates the preferred sole construction in an exploded perspective view,
with each of the components shown upside-down. More particularly, the sole construction
includes three regions, namely a heel portion 700, a toe portion 800, and a metatarsal
or forefoot portion 900. Heel portion 700 includes a main thrustor 702, a first layer
of resilient stretchable material 704, a satellite thrustor layer 706, a second layer
of resilient stretchable material 708 and a foundation or secondary thrustor layer
710. Toe portion 800 includes an actuator layer 802 and a chamber layer 804. Forefoot
or metatarsal portion 900 includes an actuator layer 902 and a chamber layer 904.
Each of the components comprising each portion of the foot is attached preferably
using chemical bonding during a molding process as would be known to one skilled in
the art. As described herein, the "top" of the sole construction as shown in FIGS.
34-68 is designated as being toward the secondary thrustor layer 710, and the "bottom"
of the sole construction is designated as being toward the main thruster 702. Correspondingly,
the heel portion 700 represents the back or rear of the sole construction and the
toe portion 800 represents the front of the sole construction.
[0110] As shown in FIGS. 35-38, the main thrustor 702 is preferably tapered downward and
has a substantially domed bottom surface 712 (shown toward the top of FIG. 35) which
slopes more in the forward direction, thereby providing lateral stability and allowing
rotational movement to the heel bone of the human foot that it substantially directly
underlies. The main thrustor 702 is substantially oval-shaped, as shown in FIG. 36,
being longer in the front-to-rear direction than side-to-side. As shown in FIGS. 37
and 38, the main thrustor 702 includes an upstanding wall 714, extending upwardly
away from the bottom surface and defining a chamber 716 within the main thrustor.
This chamber 716 preferably has a six-lobed shape, similar to thrustor 474 in the
fifth exemplary embodiment described above (see FIG. 30), but is enclosed by bottom
surface 712. The wall 714 preferably slopes slightly outward as the wall extends away
from the surface 712. The main thrustor 712 is preferably designed to be slightly
tapered toward the front of the foot, such that the height of the wall 714 at the
rear end 718 of the thrustor is larger than the wall at the front end 720 of the thrustor.
This design provides additional support to the rear of the heel while accommodating
the rolling motion of the heel. In particular, the curved bottom surface 712 allows
energy to spread out laterally when the sole construction is compressed and allows
for more efficient movement as the sole construction crosses the ground.
[0111] In the illustrated embodiment, the thrustor 702 has a rear wall height of about 0.324
inches, which decreases to a height of about 0.252 inches at the front of the wall
714. In this embodiment, the wall 714 is preferably sloped about 1.5 degrees. The
bottom surface 712 connecting the walls and defining the bottom of the chamber 716
preferably has a thickness of about 0.125 inches. The height of the entire main thrustor
702, from the top of the wall 714 to the bottommost point of the surface 712 is about
0.536 inches. As shown in FIG. 36, the length of the thrustor 702, as measured along
line 37-37, is about 2.101 inches, and the width of the thrustor 702, as measured
along line 38-38, is about 1.561 inches. It should be appreciated that these dimensions
are merely exemplary of one embodiment, and numerous variations can be made to the
dimensions of the sole construction. The preferred material for the thrustor 702 is
a plastic such as Dupont HYTREL
®, but other materials being more or less rigid may also be used. When greater rigidity
is desired, for instance, fiberglass may be used.
[0112] FIGS. 39-41 illustrate a first layer of resilient stretchable material 704 that is
disposed above the main thrustor 702 of the sole construction shown in FIG. 34. This
layer is preferably made out of rubber, and has a substantially oval shape similar
to but larger in footprint size than that of the main thrustor 702. The layer 704
also includes a tongue 722 extending from the front of the layer 704, and has corners
724 and 726 at the front of the layer 704.
[0113] As shown in FIGS. 40 and 41, the top surface 728 of the layer 704 is preferably planar.
The bottom surface 730 of the layer 704 preferably has a boundary region 732 which
extends around the perimeter of the layer 704 in a substantially oval shape. Within
this boundary region 732 is an intermediate region 734 also having a substantially
oval shape, the intermediate region having a greater thickness than that of the boundary
region. The increase in thickness between boundary region 732 and the intermediate
region 734 is preferably gradual, thereby providing a sloped surface 736 as shown
in FIG. 41. Within the intermediate region 734 is a central stretch region 738 that
is slightly recessed relative to the intermediate region 734, and is separated from
the intermediate region by a boundary ring 740. This central stretch region 738 is
sized to have substantially the same shape as the main thrustor 702 described above,
such that when the sole construction is compressed during a walking or running activity,
the thrustor 702 presses against the central region 738 causing it to stretch.
[0114] In the illustrated embodiment, the resilient layer 704 has a thickness of about 0.06
inches in the boundary region 732, increasing to about 0.135 inches in the intermediate
region 734, and decreasing to about 0.125 inches in the central stretch region 738.
The length of the layer 704, when measured from the front tip of the tongue 722 to
the back of the layer 704, is about 3.793 inches. The width of the layer 704 at its
widest portion is about 2.742 inches. The length of the layer 704, when measured from
the corners 724 and 726 to the back of the layer 704, is about 3.286 inches. When
measured from the back of the layer to the frontmost edge of the intermediate region
734, this length is about 3.098 inches. The width of the boundary region as it extends
around the oval shape of the layer varies from about 0.298 inches at the rear of the
layer to about 0.28 inches at the lateral sides of the layer. The slope of the surface
736 is preferably about 45°. Again, it should be appreciated that all of these dimensions
are merely exemplary of one particular embodiment.
[0115] FIGS. 42-44 illustrate the satellite thrustor layer 706 of the sole construction
of FIG. 34. As shown in FIGS. 42 and 43, the layer 706 comprises an annular heel plate
742 including an opening 744 which serves as a chamber through which main thrustor
702 and resilient layer 704 extend when the assembled sole construction is compressed.
Thus, the opening or chamber 744 has a substantially oval shape which is large enough
to contain the main thrustor 702.
[0116] The preferred shape of the heel plate 742 is substantially annular, further comprising
two extensions 746 and 748 toward the front of the foot. As shown in FIG. 34, the
shape of the extensions 746 and 748 depends on whether the sole construction is for
a right foot or a left foot. The design shown in FIG. 34 is for a left foot, and accordingly,
the left extension 748 preferably has a front surface 752 which is concave outward
while the right extension 746 preferably has a front surface 750 which is convex outward.
It will be appreciated, of course, that these shapes will be reversed for a sole construction
for a right foot. Simply put, for either foot, the front surface of the inner extension
is preferably convex outward and the front surface of the outer extension is preferably
concave outward.
[0117] The top side of the layer 706 is preferably provided with a plurality of satellite
thrustors 754 arranged substantially in a U-shape around the layer. As shown in FIG.
44, the top surfaces of these thrustors 754 are preferably tapered toward the front
of the layer, as indicated by angle α. Furthermore, each satellite thrustor 754 preferably
has a plurality of holes 756 extending partially therethrough. The holes 756 serve
to reduce the weight of the satellite thrustors. In the preferred embodiment, two
of the satellite thrustors are provided over the extensions 746 and 748, while four
thrustors are distributed around the opening 744.
[0118] At the front of the layer 706 and extending from the underside of the extensions
746 and 748 are support blocks 758 and 760 which are preferably integrally formed
with the layer 706. As shown in FIG. 42, these support blocks preferably have substantially
the same shape as the extensions 746 and 748, in that the front surface of the inner
support block 746 is preferably convex outward, while the front surface of the outer
support block 748 is preferably concave outward. As shown in FIG. 44, these support
blocks are preferably tapered toward the front of the layer 706, as indicated by angle
β, and have front and rear walls that are preferably sloped.
[0119] As shown in FIGS. 43 and 44, the satellite thrustors 754 and provided on the upper
side of the layer 706 on a raised nesting pattern 762. As shown in FIG. 44, the raised
nesting pattern 762 creates chambers 764 between the satellite thrustors having a
substantially trapezoidal shape as shown.
[0120] In the illustrated embodiment, the length of the layer 706 from the front surface
750 of extension 746 to the rear of the plate 742 is about 4.902 inches. The length
of the oval-shaped opening 744 along its major axis is about 2.352 inches. The width
of the layer 706, as measured laterally across its widest portion, is about 2.753
inches. The width of the layer, as measured laterally across its narrowest portion,
is about 1.776 inches. The satellite thrustors 754 are tapered, as shown in FIG. 44,
about 1.58 degrees, as indicated by angle α. The support blocks 758 and 760 are preferably
tapered about 3 degrees, as indicated by angle β, and have front and rear walls which
are sloped about 7 degrees. The height of the layer 706 as measured from the underside
of the plate 742 to the top of the tallest satellite thrustor, as indicated by plane
B in FIG. 44, is about 0.477 inches. The plate 742 itself has a thickness of about
0.1 inches at its thinnest point. For the tallest thrustor, the holes 756 as measured
from plane B preferably have a depth of about 0.427 inches. The height of the layer
706, as measured from the bottom of the support block 758, as indicated by plane C
in FIG. 44 to plane B, is about 0.726 inches. The layer 706, including the satellite
thrustors 754, are preferably made of a material similar to the layer 702, and in
one preferred embodiment, is Dupont HYTREL
®.
[0121] FIG. 45-47 illustrates the second layer 708 of resilient material. This layer is
preferably made of rubber, and is shaped substantially to correspond with the shape
of the satellite thrustor layer 706. More particularly, like the layer 706, layer
708 has a substantially annular shape with a substantially oval-shaped opening 766
therein and two extensions 768 and 770 protruding forward therefrom. The front surface
of the outer extension 770 is preferably concave outward, while the front surface
of the inner extension 768 is preferably convex outward.
[0122] Disposed around the opening 760 and on the extensions 768 and 770 are stretch regions
772 which correspond to the satellite thrustors 754 of layer 706. These stretch regions
772 are preferably integrally formed with the layer 708 and have an increased thickness
as shown in FIG. 47 as compared to the rest of the layer 708 to give them a raised
configuration. The stretch regions 772 are preferably substantially rectangular in
shape having curved corners to correspond with the shape of the satellite thrustors.
Each of these stretch regions 772 has a footprint size which is larger than that of
the satellite thrustors 754 in order to allow the satellite thrustors to press through
the stretch regions when the sole construction is compressed.
[0123] A plurality of compressible rubber lugs 774 and 776 is also provided around the layer
708, preferably disposed between each of the stretch regions 772. In the preferred
embodiment, five lugs 774 are provided between the six satellite thrustors, with two
additional lugs 776 provided at the front of layer 708 underlying extensions 768 and
770. These rubber lugs, 774 and 776 are preferably integrally formed with the layer
708. More preferably, the lugs 774 and 776 are substantially rectangular in shape
to conform to the shape of the stretch regions 772. More particularly, the walls of
the lugs 774 as between each of the stretch regions are preferably concave inward,
as shown in FIG. 47, such that they mate with the shape of the stretch regions 772.
As shown in FIG. 47, the lugs preferably extend substantially downward away from the
layer 708, and have sloped walls. These lugs are therefore shaped to mate with the
chambers 764 of the satellite thrustor layer 706, and provide energy storage and return
when the sole construction is compressed causing compression of the lugs 774 in the
chambers 764. The lugs 776 at the front of the layer 708 are shaped to correspond
with the shape of the extensions 768 and 770.
[0124] As shown in FIG. 46, for the illustrated embodiment the layer 708 has a length measured
from the back of the layer 708 to the front surface of extension 768 of about 5.17
inches. The width of the layer at its widest portion is about 3.102 inches, and at
its narrowest portion is about 2.236 inches. The width of the annular portion of layer
708 measured from the rear of the layer to the rear of the opening 766 is about 1.02
inches. The distance from the rear of the layer 708 to the front of the opening 766
is about 3.138 inches. The width of the opening as measured across its minor axis
is about 1.302 inches. The layer 708 along its outer edge has a thickness of about
0.05 inches. At the raised stretch regions 772 the thickness is about 0.120 inches,
and at the lugs 774 and 776 the thickness is about 0.319 inches. The lugs 774 are
preferably sloped about 7 degrees to mate with the chambers 764.
[0125] The foundation or secondary thrustor layer 710 is shown in FIGS. 48-51. The thrustor
layer 710 comprises a plate 778 having a plurality of openings or chambers 780 therein.
This plate 778 is shaped substantially the same as the resilient layer 708 and satellite
thrustor layer 706, in that it is substantially oval-shaped corresponding to the shape
of the heel with two extensions 782 and 784 extending from the front. The chambers
780 are arranged to correspond with the satellite thrustors 754 of layer 706, which
will move into the chambers 780 through resilient layer 708 when the sole construction
is compressed. Accordingly, chambers 780 have substantially the same footprint shape
as the satellite thrustors 754, but are sized slightly larger to accommodate the thrustors
754.
[0126] A secondary thrustor 786 is provided on the underside of the plate 778 substantially
centered within the chambers 780 and extending downward therefrom. This secondary
thrustor 786 is positioned such that when the sole construction is assembled, the
thrustor 786 extends through the opening 766 in resilient layer 708 and the opening
744 in satellite thrustor layer 706. More particularly, the thrustor 786 preferably
has a six-lobe shape which corresponds with the six-lobe opening 716 of main thrustor
702. Thus, when the sole construction is compressed, the secondary thrustor 786 presses
against the stretch portion 734 of resilient layer 704 and into the opening 716. As
shown in FIGS. 49 and 51, the bottom surface 788 of secondary thrustor 786 preferably
has a curved or substantially domed shape, and preferably also has a pair of holes
790 extending partially therethrough to reduce the weight of the secondary thrustor.
[0127] The layer 710 of the illustrated embodiment shown in FIGS. 48-51 preferably has a
length measured from the rear of the plate 778 to the front of extension 782 of about
5.169 inches. The width of the layer 710 across its widest portion is preferably about
3.105 inches, and across its narrowest portion is about 2.239 inches. The width between
the outer lateral sides of extensions 782 and 784 is preferably about 2.689 inches.
The front pair of chambers 780 preferably each has a length of about 1.25 inches and
a width of about 0.63 inches. The plate 710 preferably has a thickness of about 0.06
inches, and the secondary thrustor preferably has a height as measured from the top
side of the plate of about 0.71 inches. The holes 790 in the secondary thrustor each
has a diameter of about 0.35 inches and a depth of about 0.5 inches. The layer 710
is preferably made of a material such as Dupont HYTREL
®, although other similar materials may also be used. For instance, when more rigidity
is required, materials such as fiberglass and graphite may also be used.
[0128] FIGS. 52-55 illustrate the toe actuator layer 802 of the sole construction of the
seventh exemplary embodiment. This layer 802 is preferably made of rubber, with all
of the elements described and shown in FIGS. 52-55 being preferably integrally formed.
The layer 802 preferably comprises a main resilient portion 806. Provided on the lower
side of the main portion 806 are the toe actuators 808, 810, 812, 814 and 816, corresponding
to each of the human toes. As shown in FIG. 54, the toe actuators are preferably raised
segments below the main portion 806. The first through fourth toe actuators 808-814
also contain chambers 818, 820, 822 and 824, respectively, within the actuators, which
are substantially oval in shape. As shown in FIGS. 54 and 55, the toe actuator layer
is preferably arched. Along the edges of the toe actuator layer 802 are upwardly-oriented
walls 826 to contain the toe chamber layer 804, described below.
[0129] The illustrated toe actuator layer 802 preferably measures about 4.165 inches from
side-to-side. The toe actuator layer 802 preferably has a width measured from its
frontmost point to its rearmost point of about 2.449 inches. The main portion 806
of the layer 802 preferably has a thickness of about 0.12 inches, with the actuators
808-816 having a height of about 0.12 inches measured from the underside of the main
portion 806. The walls 826 preferably extend about 0.16 inches away from the top side
of the main portion 806, and are preferably about 0.55 inches thick.
[0130] FIGS. 56-59 illustrate the toe chamber layer 804 that corresponds with the toe actuator
layer described above. The toe chamber layer 804 is also preferably made of Dupont
HYTREL
®, and is formed having an upstanding perimeter wall 828 that extends around the peripheral
edge of the layer 804 to define a chamber 830 therein. The toe chamber layer 804 is
shaped geometrically similar to the toe actuator layer and is also preferably arched
as shown in FIGS. 58 and 59. As may be seen with reference to FIG. 57, perimeter wall
828 is configured so that chamber 830 has five regions 832, 834, 836, 838 and 840,
that correspond to each of the human toes. Plungers 842, 844, 846 and 848 preferably
having a substantially oval shape are provided in each of the first four regions 832,
834, 836 and 838, respectively. The plungers are sized to be smaller than the corresponding
chambers of layer 802. Similarly, the actuators of the layer 802 press through the
main portion 806 into the chamber 830 when compressed. Thus, the toe actuator layer
and toe chamber layer together provide a dual action energy storage system. The energy
storage and return characteristics of the toe portion 800 is substantially as described
with respect to FIGS. 20A-20C, above.
[0131] In the illustrated embodiment, the perimeter wall 828 and the plungers 842-848 preferably
have a height of about 0.16 inches. The layer 804 has a thickness of about 0.03 inches
at its thinnest point within chamber 830. The side-to-side length of the layer 804
is preferably about 4.044 inches and the front-to-rear width of the layer from its
frontmost to rearmost point is about 2.326 inches.
[0132] The metatarsal or forefoot actuator layer 902 shown in FIGS. 60-64 is designed similar
to the toe actuator layer 802. More particularly, the layer 902 is preferably made
of rubber, with all of the elements described and shown in FIGS. 60-64 being preferably
integrally formed. The layer 902 preferably comprises a main resilient portion 906.
Provided below the main portion 904 are the metatarsal actuators 908, 910, 912, 916
and 918. As shown in FIG. 62, the metatarsal actuators are preferably raised segments
below the main portion 904. The metatarsal actuators each contain chambers 920, 922,
924, 926, 928 and 930 within the actuators, which are substantially oval in shape.
As shown in FIGS. 62-64, the metatarsal actuator layer is preferably arched. Along
the edges of the metatarsal actuator layer 904 are upwardly-oriented walls 932 to
contain the metatarsal chamber layer 904, described below.
[0133] The illustrated metatarsal actuator layer 902 preferably has a length of about 4.302
inches as measured across the side-to-side expanse of the metatarsals. The metatarsal
actuator layer 902 preferably has a width of about 3.03 inches as measured from the
frontmost to rearmost point of layer 902. The main portion 906 of the layer 902 preferably
has a thickness of about 0.12 inches, with the actuators 908-918 having a height of
about 0.12 inches measured from the underside of the main portion 806. The walls 932
preferably extend about 0.16 inches away from the top side of the main portion 906,
and are preferably about 0.55 inches thick.
[0134] FIGS. 65-68 illustrate the metatarsal chamber layer 904 that corresponds with the
metatarsal actuator layer 902 described above. The metatarsal chamber layer 904 is
also preferably made of Dupont HYTREL
®, and is formed having an upstanding perimeter wall 934 that extends around the peripheral
edge of the layer 904 to define a chamber 936 therein. The metatarsal chamber layer
is shaped geometrically similar to the metatarsal actuator layer and is also preferably
arched as shown in FIGS. 67 and 68. As may be seen with reference to FIG. 66, perimeter
wall 934 is configured so that chamber 936 has six regions 938, 940, 942, 944, 948
and 948. Plungers 950, 952, 954, 956, 958 and 960 preferably having a substantially
oval shape are provided in each of the regions 938-948 in the chamber 936, respectively,
which press downward through the main portion 906 of layer 902 into the chambers 920-930
when the sole construction is compressed. Accordingly, the plungers 950-960 are sized
to be smaller than the corresponding chambers 920-930 of layer 902. Similarly, the
actuators 908-918 of the layer 902 press through the main portion 906 of layer 902
into the chamber 936 when compressed to provide dual action energy storage and return.
This is substantially the same energy characteristic as described above with respect
to FIGS. 22A-22C.
[0135] In the illustrated embodiment, the perimeter wall 934 and the plungers 850-960 preferably
have a height of about 0.16 inches. The layer 904 has a thickness of about 0.03 inches
at its thinnest point within chamber 936. The length of the layer 904 is preferably
about 4.182 inches, with a width of about 2.908 as measured between the frontmost
and rearmost points of the layer 904.
[0136] The sole construction of the embodiments described above is preferably attached to
the underside of an upper of a shoe (not shown). The embodiments described above may
further include an outersole or traction layer chemically bonded to the bottom of
the sole construction for contact with the ground. FIGS. 69-76 illustrate toe and
forefoot traction layers designed for contact with the ground. As shown in FIGS. 69-72,
the toe traction layer 860 is sized and shaped to conform substantially to the shape
and size of the toe actuator layer 802. Similarly, the forefoot traction layer 962
is sized and shaped to conform substantival to the shape and size of the forefoot
actuator layer 902. Each of these traction layers is preferably formed from a rubber
material, and has lateral and medial borders that are approximately twice as tall
as at its center to encourage foot and ankle rotation within the neutral plane. In
one embodiment, the traction layers have a thickness of about 0.025 to 0,05 inches,
with the thickness at the borders being about 0.05 inches and the thickness at the
center being about 0.025 inches. It will be appreciated that traction layers may be
also be provided underneath the heel portion, motion control posts and other portions
of the sole construction. Furthermore, it is also contemplated that a single traction
layer be provided underneath the entire sole construction.
[0137] As illustrated above, the actuators of the sole construction may have a varying rigidity
to improve stability of the foot and to accommodate the foot's natural rolling motion.
As illustrated by the seventh exemplary embodiment, this varying actuator rigidity
may be provided by making the satellite thrustors 754 and secondary thrustor 786 out
of a more rigid material, such as 80 to 90 durometer Dupont HYTREL
®, and making the main thrustors 702 out of a less rigid material, such as 40 to 50
durometer Dupont HYTREL
®. Similarly, lugs 774 are preferably made of a less rigid material such as rubber.
Thus, the sole construction has alternating rigidity which allows for fine tuning
the energy storage and rebound provided by each of the actuators. Actuator rigidity
may also be varied according to the desired use of the shoe. For instance, more compliant
actuators may be desired to conform to uneven surfaces and for special use applications,
such as trail running, golf and hiking. More rigid actuators may be used where greater
performance is desired, such as for running and sprinting, vertical leaping, basketball,
volleyball and tennis. It should therefore be appreciated that numerous possibilities
exist for varying the rigidity of the actuators, in addition to varying their size,
shape and position, to provide desired performance characteristics.
[0138] Furthermore, the curved shape of the actuators with corresponding curved chambers
provides mechanical advantages to the performance of the sole construction. In particular,
a curved actuator surface, when loaded, is pressured to a flatter state, causing an
expansion of its footprint size into the stretchable layer. This expansion of the
actuator increases the amount of stretching that the stretchable layer experiences,
thereby leading to an increased storage and rebound of energy.
Experimental Results
[0139] The advantages of Applicant's invention are illustrated in the results of experimental
tests performed on the shoe described in accordance with the seventh exemplary embodiment
of the present invention ("Applicant's shoe"), as compared to a standard shoe. Unless
otherwise noted, Mizuno Wave Runner Technology was used for the standard shoe. The
results are presented below.
1. Whole Body Efficiency Results (VO2 Uptake Tests)
[0140] Whole body efficiency measures the consumption and expiration of gases. To determine
the improvement of Applicant's shoe as compared to the standard shoe, graded and steady
state exercise tests were performed to analyze the expired gases (determine VO
2) with 3 or 12 lead electrocardiography during treadmill running on athletes. Specifically,
VO
2 measures O
2 delivered by the heart/cardiac output.
[0141] Test subject athletes reported for testing on two occasions. On the first occasion
each subject wore the standard shoe and VO
2max was determined by a graded exercise test on a treadmill. On the second occasion the
standard shoe and Applicant's shoe were compared using a 75-90% VO
2max graded steady state intensity and absolute intensity protocol. The equipment used
was a Sensor Medics V
max 29 metabolic cart equipped with two calibration gas tanks, one laptop computer with
software installed, one printer, one VGA monitor and 12/3 lead EKG machines. Additionally,
sets of flow sensors, tubing, mouthpieces and headgears, as well as an ample supply
of EKG patch electrodes, were used.
[0142] In response to the same running protocol, Applicant's shoe demonstrated a reduced
O
2 consumption at the same relative (80%-90%) VO
2max and absolute intensity in all male athletes tested. This finding was notable at intensities
representing 80-90% VO
2max and at speeds of 9.5, 10, 10.5 and 11 miles/hr. This finding is consistent with an
improved whole body efficiency when running in Applicant's shoe relative to the standard
shoe at paces that are typical of those performed during racing and intense recreational
training. The average improvement in whole body efficiency at the aforementioned intensities
was 13%. However, at the higher absolute and relative intensities, the average improvement
in whole body efficiency was 15%. Individual variability was present, as certain individuals
demonstrated an average improvement of efficiency of 21% and 18%, respectively, at
the same absolute intensity of 10, 10.5 and 11 miles/hr. This individual variation
may be credited to initial differences in biomechanics, body mechanics or running
style. Interestingly, the least improvement was measured in the ultradistance runners,
whereas the greatest effect of the shoe was measured in shorter distance triathletes/duathletes.
This finding is consistent with the idea that the ultradistance runners demonstrated
improved mechanical or biomechanical efficiency initially when compared with the shorter
distance cross-trained athlete. The overall findings were that every subject received
whole body efficiency improvements using Applicant's shoe. Results varied between
subjects due to biomechanics, body mechanics and running style. In conclusion, Applicant's
shoe leads to improved running efficiency as demonstrated by the physiological data
of all male athletes tested.
[0143] The preliminary data to compare whole body efficiency during like protocol treadmill
running using Applicant's shoe and the standard shoe in a female elite athlete is
consistent with data previously collected on men. Although the magnitude of the effect
was less, the measured VO
2 was consistently lower at all measured workloads and the discrepancy between males
and one female runner may be credited to different running mechanics (specifically,
forefoot running in the female). To this effect, when mechanics were made more similar
by an imposed grade during very fast treadmill running, the whole body efficiency
was improved. It is likely that the improved whole body efficiency measured in an
elite female athlete when wearing the experimental is similar to that measured previously
in men.
[0144] As seen in male runners, in response to the same running protocol, Applicant's shoe
demonstrated a reduced O
2 consumption at the same relative (80-90%) VO
2max and absolute intensity in an elite female runner. This finding was notable at intensities
representing (80-95%) VO
2max and at speeds of 8.5, 9, 9.5 and 10 mph. This finding is consistent with an improved
whole body efficiency when running in the experimental shoe relative to the standard
shoe at paces that are typical of those performed during racing and intense recreational
training. Although the magnitude of the improvement measured at different intensities
was smaller than that measured in men, it is still a notable (around 3%) difference.
To this difference, it was noted that the elite female athlete landed primarily on
her forefoot. Hence, the total effectiveness of the shoe may not have been fully measured
due to the construction of the shoe which places the major mechanism in the heel of
the shoe. Of interest was the VO
2 measurement during exercise on the treadmill in response to a change in grade. Mechanically
for a forefoot runner this grade change at a 10.5 mph speed may force the athlete
to spring off from her heel and thereby explain the improvement in whole body efficiency
measured. Specifically, we measured a 5-7% decrease in whole body efficiency in the
light of an increase in workload. Therefore, this improvement in whole body efficiency
in response to grade is greatly underestimated. On the other hand, this preliminary
data offers insight as to more areas of investigation for the possibility of improved
whole body efficiency due to the mechanics of the experimental shoe.
2. Whole Body Kinematic Test
[0145] Applicant has also performed a whole body kinematic test to show how the whole body
receives benefits from Applicant's invention in particular, by providing more proper
angles at the ankle, knee and hip and less vertical body movements.
[0146] A running stride analysis was performed on the two subjects to determine running
temporal and kinematic parameters across varying shoes. The shoes tested were as follows:
a regular pair of running shoes, and two pairs of running shoes designed to return
energy to the runner ("Applicant's shoe"). The concept behind Applicant's shoe is
that it absorbs the energy of impact with the ground and is able to transfer that
energy back to the runner in the latter phases of stance, thus improving running economy.
It was hypothesized that there would be observable changes in the running kinematics,
notably, decreased stance time combined with an increased swing time (time in the
air) as well as increased leg extension in late stance as the shoe returned energy.
[0147] Data was collected on one male (Subject 1) and one female (Subject 2). Eighteen joint
markers were placed bilaterally on the following landmarks: the lateral aspect of
the head of the 5
th metatarsal, the lateral malleolus, lateral approximation of the axis of rotation
of the knee, lateral approximation of the axis of rotation of the hip, iliac crests,
lateral approximation of the shoulder axis of rotation, lateral elbow, wrist, forehead
and chin. Subject 1 was filmed with 3 video cameras at a frame rate of 30 frames per
second while running on a treadmill at 10.0 mph (4.47 m/s). The trial order was: regular
shoes, energy return shoes, lightweight energy return shoes. Subject 2 was filmed
while running at 8.6 mph (3.84 m/s) and 10.0 mph (4.47 m/s). The video data was analyzed
using the Ariel Performance Analysis System (APAS) to generate a three-dimensional
image of the subject for each of the three trials. Trial information is provided below:
| Subject |
Trial |
Speed (m/s) |
Shoe |
| 1 |
1 |
4.47 |
Regular |
| 1 |
2 |
4.47 |
Energy Return |
| 1 |
3 |
4.47 |
Light Energy Return |
| 2 |
1 |
3.84 |
Regular |
| 2 |
2 |
4.47 |
Regular |
| 2 |
3 |
3.84 |
Light Energy Return |
| 2 |
4 |
4.47 |
Light Energy Return |
The temporal measure of the running stride were determined to be as follows:
Table 1: Temporal Stride Measurements
| Subject |
Speed (m/s) |
Trial Number |
Stance Time(s) |
Swing Time(s) |
Stride Rate(s) |
| 1 |
4.47 |
1 |
0.207 |
0.420 |
0.627 |
| 1 |
4.47 |
2 |
0.207 |
0.426 |
0.633 |
| 1 |
4.47 |
3 |
0.207 |
0.413 |
0.620 |
| 2 |
3.84 |
1 |
0.217 |
0.450 |
0.667 |
| 2 |
4.47 |
2 |
0.206 |
0.440 |
0.647 |
| 2 |
3.84 |
3 |
0.206 |
0.440 |
0.647 |
| 2 |
4.47 |
4 |
0.203 |
0.437 |
0.640 |
[0148] The general sagittal plane-kinematic variables of stride length, vertical displacement
and R foot travel are shown below. Stride length was determined from the stride rate
determined above and the treadmill velocity, which was assumed to remain constant.
The vertical displacement is the measure of the sagittal plane travel of the forehead
marker. The travel of the right foot is the measure of the foot's sagittal displacement
through one complete stance and swing cycle.
Table 2: General Kinematic Measurements
| Subject |
Speed (m/s) |
Trial Number |
Stride Length (m) |
Vertical Displacement (cm) |
R Foot travel during one running stride (m) |
| 1 |
4.47 |
1 |
2.80 |
6.0 |
1.95 |
| 1 |
4.47 |
2 |
2.83 |
5.8 |
2.01 |
| 1 |
4.47 |
3 |
2.77 |
5.0 |
1.94 |
| 2 |
3.84 |
1 |
2.56 |
6.9 |
1.91 |
| 2 |
4.47 |
2 |
2.89 |
5.8 |
2.00 |
| 2 |
3.84 |
3 |
2.48 |
6.4 |
1.86 |
| 2 |
4.47 |
4 |
2.86 |
5.8 |
2.01 |
The lower extremity sagittal plane kinematics were determined for the right side.
This included the hip, knee and ankle angles. Hip angle was calculated as the angle
between the thigh and the pelvis and an increasing angle equals hip extension. Knee
angle was calculated as the angle between the thigh and the shank segments and an
increasing angle equals extension. Ankle angle was calculated as the angle between
the shank and the foot and an increasing angle equals plantarflexion.
[0149] The maximum hip extension was observed just prior to toe off and maximum hip flexion
was observed just prior to heel strike.
Table 3: Hip Kinematics
| Subject |
Speed (m/s) |
Trial Number |
Maximum hip extension (degrees) |
Maximum hip flexion (degrees) |
Range of motion of the hip (degrees) |
| 1 |
4.47 |
1 |
171.2 |
130.4 |
40.8 |
| 1 |
4.47 |
2 |
166.8 |
128.2 |
38.6 |
| 1 |
4.47 |
3 |
171.2 |
131.0 |
40.2 |
| 2 |
3.84 |
1 |
157.2 |
108.5 |
48.7 |
| 2 |
4.47 |
2 |
151.0 |
96.2 |
54.8 |
| 2 |
3.84 |
3 |
157.0 |
113.6 |
43.4 |
| 2 |
4.47 |
4 |
158.2 |
108.9 |
49.3 |
Knee angles indicated a yielding phase of knee flexion during the beginning of stance
followed by knee extension through toe-off. During swing the knee rapidly flexed and
then extended prior to heel strike. Range of motion of the yielding phase and the
extension phase of stance are shown below, as is the maximum knee flexion observed
during swing.
Table 4: Knee Kinematics
| Subject |
Speed (m/s) |
Trial Number |
Knee Flexion during stance (degrees) |
Knee Extension during stance (degrees) |
Maximum knee flexion during swing (degrees) |
| 1 |
4.47 |
1 |
14.7 |
16.1 |
75.5 |
| 1 |
4.47 |
2 |
14.2 |
12.2 |
81.6 |
| 1 |
4.47 |
3 |
19.7 |
27.2 |
78.2 |
| 2 |
3.84 |
1 |
13.4 |
27.2 |
76.8 |
| 2 |
4.47 |
2 |
22.1 |
28.7 |
69.4 |
| 2 |
3.84 |
3 |
18.2 |
26.1 |
78.0 |
| 2 |
4.47 |
4 |
18.5 |
26.7 |
75.0 |
[0150] Ankle angle ranges of motion are shown in Table 5. The ankle plantarflexed during
the initial phase of stance. Ankle dorsiflexion was observed through mid-stance and
then plantarflexion from late stance through the initial phase of swing.
Table 5. Ankle Kinematics
| Subject |
Speed |
Trial Number |
Ankle Range of Motion (degrees) |
| 1 |
4.47 |
1 |
29 |
| 1 |
4.47 |
2 |
27 |
| 1 |
4.47 |
3 |
42 |
| 2 |
3.84 |
1 |
43 |
| 2 |
4.47 |
2 |
39 |
| 2 |
3.84 |
3 |
53 |
| 2 |
4.47 |
4 |
45 |
[0151] This study attempted to quantify kinematic and temporal changes in running mechanics
at two speeds with two subjects across different types of footwear. General observations
from this study can be made.
[0152] There were few changes in the temporal measures of stride rate, stance and swing
times. Subject 1 had a slightly shorter stride rate in the third trial, meaning turnover
had increased. The lack of differences may in part be due to the frame rate used in
this study. The frame rate of 30 frames per second is inadequate to determine the
precise moments of foot strike and toe off. This study did not use a mechanical foot
switch to determine heel strike more accurately.
[0153] Subject 1 had a lower vertical displacement during trial 3 compared to trials 1 and
2. This could be an indication of better running economy. A lower vertical displacement
may indicate less energy being expended to raise the body's center of mass, which
could result in lower physiological costs.
[0154] There was an interesting difference in the kinematic parameters of the knee and ankle
when comparing the trials 1 and 2 with trial 3 of Subject 1. There was a relatively
higher degree of knee flexion during the yield phase of stance followed by a greater
degree of knee extension. This could indicate that energy is being stored during the
yield phase of trial 3 and returned to the lower extremity during the push off phase.
The energy transfer might be observed as a greater knee extension during push off.
The ankle kinematics followed a similar pattern. The range of motion of the ankle
was greater in trial 3 than in the other two trials. These differences were not noted
in Subject 2 across the same speeds.
[0155] It is interesting to note that the "original" energy return shoe showed few differences
from the regular running shoe of trial 1. The patterns described above should be examined
with a more complete study to determine if the shoe in trial 3 is significantly different
than the other shoes.
3. F-Scan Tests
[0156] Two F-Scan Tests were performed to show how Applicant's shoe tends to spread out
high pressure areas of the feet from the ground up. Applicant's shoe was tested against
Mizuno Wave Rider Technology, which claims to have 22% more shock absorbency than
any current midsole technology.
[0157] Applicant's invention had a profound ability to spread out high-pressure areas of
the foot from the ground up. A close comparison can be drawn to the effect an orthotic
gives to the foot. Orthotics correct negative foot movements from the ground up to
stabilize the foot in a neutral position instead of over-pronation or over-supination.
In the forefoot, or ball of the foot, each metatarsal head gets a more equal share
of the load placed upon it. As the biomechanics place heavy loads on certain metatarsals,
the load will get shared by the others. The F-scan tests particularly demonstrated
the equal loading of the metatarsals, significantly less amount of heel pressure when
wearing Applicant's shoe.
4. Shock Absorption Tests
[0158] Shock absorption tests were performed on Applicant's shoe and the standard shoe.
The shock absorption test uses a heel impact test machine constructed by ARTECH, featuring
a one-inch diameter steel rod guided by a pair of linear ball bearings. The rod weighs
eight pounds and a three pound weight is clamped to the rod to give a total weight
of eleven pounds. A five hundred pound load cell placed under the specimen measures
force produced during impact. Force and displacement are recorded by a computer using
a 12-bit data acquisition system, for 256 milliseconds at millisecond intervals.
[0159] The ARTECH system uses a load cell under the specimen rather than an accelerometer
on the drop shaft. G-force is calculated by subtracting the weight of the drop shaft
and the spring force from the peak load force, which may offer a more direct measure
of comfort.
[0160] The computer software calculates peak load and g-force as indicated above, and calculates
energy return by comparing the height of the first rebound to the drop height at full
compression.
[0161] The test data is the average of 10 drops for each style of footwear. In general,
lower loads and shock (g value) suggest more comfort to the wearer. High-energy returns,
while not as critical for comfort, may provide an appealing "spring" in the step,
may reduce energy expenditure, and may indicate a resistance to packing down of the
cushion material.
[0162] To provide a general comparison to the attached test results, a very comfortable
athletic shoe produced a g value of 5.4, which included the rubber sole, EVA midsole
and sockliner. A very uncomfortable athletic shoe had a g value of 8.7 and a men's
loafer 16.2 fees.
[0163] The test procedure was slightly modified while testing these shoes. The submitted
shoes were tested with the normal eleven pond weight and then with an added weight
to total twenty-two pound weight. The shoes were also tested on a flat surface and
at a 30° angle.
[0164] The test results are shown in the table below.
| Sample ID |
Applicant's Shoe |
Mizuno Shoe |
| Property Assessed |
|
|
| Heel Drop |
11 lb. Load |
22 lb. Load |
11 lb. Load |
22 lb. Load |
| Shock Absorption |
|
|
|
|
| Avg. (R&L shoes) |
|
|
|
|
| "g" Value |
1.12 |
1.09 |
1.13 |
1.10 |
| Energy Returned % |
83.3 |
86.2 |
82.9 |
79.0 |
| Drop Height |
.7683 |
0.6111 |
0.8314 |
0.8107 |
| |
30° angle |
30° angle |
| Heel Drop |
11 lb. Load |
22 lb. Load |
11 lb. Load |
22 lb. Load |
| Shock Absorption |
|
|
|
|
| Avg. (R&L shoes) |
|
|
|
|
| "g" Value |
1.10 |
1.00 |
1.11 |
1.12 |
| Energy Returned % |
84.0 |
70.75 |
83.4 |
88.0 |
| Drop Height (in.) |
.5808 |
0.8438 |
0.5407 |
0.7675 |
5. Physics Testing
[0165] Three general phenomenon are observed with Applicant's invention:
- 1. VERTICAL ENERGY RETURN - the shoe vertically returns or rebounds from where the
user started.
- 2. GUIDANCE - the shoe actually moves vertically without the side-to-side movement.
- 3. CUSHIONING UPON IMPACT - the shoe continues to move for a longer duration than
conventional athletic footwear, creating greater shock absorption.
[0166] When the shoe strikes the ground while running, the user decelerates and loses energy.
Then, energy is needed to lift the foot and leg up against gravity to start the next
stride. Because Applicant's invention returns a quantifiable amount of energy to assist
in lifting the foot, heel and lower leg, less work (energy) is needed to run, and
less oxygen is required to perform. This energy return can be defined as an "unweighing"
of an individual.
[0167] A device was utilized that could hold any brand of athletic shoe, impacting the wall
vertically and measuring recorded data from the length of rebound off the wall, the
distance each shoe returned from the wall (measurements taken at 12" and 18") and
weighted (117 lbs) giving us the energy return data used in the testing. Shoes used:
Nike Air Tailwind, Nike Air Triax, Asics Gel Kayano, Asics Gel 2030, Brooks Beast,
Saucony Grid Hurricane and Applicant's shoe. Applicant's shoe returned up to 22% more
energy than current athletic shoe offerings.
6. Vertical Leap Testing & Measurement
[0168] Two different methods of testing vertical leap may be performed to compare vertical
leaping ability of Applicant's shoe with current athletic footwear.
[0169] For the first test, at the University of Colorado Boulder campus, the athletic department
training room uses a vertical leap-measuring device called a
VERTECK. This device is commonly found in university, college and selected high school athletic
training centers. The VERTECK is a free-standing, movable, vertically adjustable pole-like
device with colored plastic strips representing various measurements.
[0170] First, a standing vertical reach is established. Standing flat-footed, with one or
both arms extended vertically and stretching the fingertips, the subject tries to
move the plastic strips out of the way. The mark where the strips are moved - or height
- represents that subject's vertical reach. This height also represents the starting
point for measurement vertically.
[0171] The subject then warms up by stretching, running, bounding and jumping. Tests may
be performed by a minimum of 2 subjects each sequence.
[0172] The first subject stands directly under the VERTECK device, crouches down, then leaps
vertically, knocking away the plastic strips. The measurement between standing vertical
reach (or zero) and the highest plastic strip to move is the vertical leap measurement.
The test may then proceed as follows.
- Round 1: Subject 1 uses File footwear - 2 attempts (jumps) would be measured.
Subject 2 uses Applicant's shoe - 2 attempts would be measured.
- Round 2: Subject 1 uses Applicant's shoe.
Subject 2 uses File footwear.
- Continue the Rounds by the subjects until exhausted.
- Record and compare all Rounds and attempts by each subject.
A comparative test has not yet been conducted using a prototype of Applicant's invention
and the VERTECK device.
[0173] If the VERTECK device is not available, a second measuring protocol may be used.
As in method 1, vertical reach may be established by chalking the middle finger-tip
of the subject and standing flat-footed, sideways to a vertical wall or 45 degree
angle to a vertical wall, or facing the wall. Reaching vertically, the top of the
chalk mark is determined to be the vertical reach. By re-chalking the finger-tip with
each vertical leap attempt, and measuring the distance from the vertical reach to
the top of the finger-tip chalk mark, the vertical leap is determined. For this test,
Applicant recorded subjects, number of attempts and scores with each leap. An average
of 10% vertical leap improvement was exhibited using Applicant's shoe versus the Fila
shoe in multiple attempts.
[0174] It should be appreciated that various elements from the different embodiments described
herein may be incorporated into other embodiments without departing from the scope
of the invention. It should also be understood that certain variations and modifications
will suggest themselves to one of ordinary skill in the art. In particular, any dimensions
given are purely exemplary and should not be construed to limit the present invention
to any particular size or shape. The scope of the present invention is not to be limited
by the illustrations or the foregoing description thereof, but rather solely by the
appended claims.