FIELD OF THE INVENTION
[0001] The present invention relates to a method for making a micro-emulsion that is suitable
as a cleaning liquid for recycling the lithographic substrate of a printing master.
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
[0002] In conventional lithographic printing, ink and an aqueous fountain solution are supplied
to the surface of a printing master that contains ink accepting (oleophilic) and water-accepting
(hydrophilic) areas. The inked image pattern is then transferred from the surface
of the master to a blanket cylinder having a compressible surface. From the blanket
cylinder the image is impressed onto paper. The master is typically a printing plate
that carries an image on a dimensionally stable substrate such as an aluminium sheet.
The imaged aluminium plate is secured to the plate cylinder of a printing press by
a mechanical lock-up mechanism that defines positional registration between the plate
and the surface of the cylinder. After the end of the press run, the mechanical lock-up
system is released so that the printing plate carrying the printed image can be removed
and discarded and another printing plate can be positioned and locked into place.
A new print job can then be started.
[0003] Printing masters are generally obtained by the so-called computer-to-film method
wherein each colour selection is transferred to graphic arts film using an image-setter.
After processing, the film can be used as a mask for the exposure of an imaging material
called plate precursor and after plate processing, a printing plate is obtained which
can be used as a master. These steps are usually performed in dedicated exposure and
processing equipment and the printing plates are then transported to the printing
press and attached to the printing cylinder by press operators using a lock-up mechanism
built into the cylinder itself. Although the attachment of the printing cylinder is
generally a manual operation, robotic means have been developed for positioning and
securing the printing plates.
[0004] In recent years the so-called computer-to-plate method has gained a lot of interest.
This method, also called direct-to-plate method, bypasses the creation of film because
the digital data are transferred directly to a plate precursor by means of a so-called
plate-setter. On-press imaging is a direct-to-plate method (also called direct-to-press),
wherein the image is exposed on the plate while said plate is mounted on the plate
cylinder of a printing press. The major advantage of the latter method compared to
off-press plate making is the improved registration between printing stations of a
multi-colour printing press.
[0005] Two types of such on-press imaging methods are known. According to a first type,
a printing plate precursor is mounted on a printing press, image-wise exposed, optionally
developed, and then used as a printing master and finally removed from the press and
disposed of, thus requiring a new plate material for each image. An example of this
technology is the Heidelberg Model GTO-DI, manufactured by Heidelberg Druckmaschinen
AG (Germany) which is described in detail in US 5,339,737. A drawback of this method
is the need to use a new plate for each press run, thus increasing the cost of the
printing process.
[0006] In a second type of on-press imaging systems, the same lithographic substrate is
used in a plurality of press runs (hereinafter called printing cycles). In each printing
cycle, a heat-sensitive or photosensitive layer is coated on the lithographic substrate
to make a printing plate precursor and after image-wise exposure and optional development
a printing master is obtained. After the press-run, the ink-accepting areas of the
printing master are removed from the lithographic substrate in a cleaning step so
that the substrate is recycled and can be used in a next cycle of coating, exposing
and printing without the need to mount a new plate on the cylinder. Examples of such
on-press coating and on-press imaging systems are described in e.g. US 5,188,033;
US 5,713,287; EP-A 786 337 and EP-A 802 457. The latter patent application describes
an apparatus comprising a printing member, means for applying a uniform coating, means
for scan-wise exposing said uniform coating in accordance with an image pattern and
means for developing said uniform coating to leave an image on said printing member,
the image consisting of ink-accepting areas on an ink-repellent background or ink-repellent
areas on an ink-accepting background. According to a preferred embodiment, the coating
comprises hydrophobic thermoplastic polymer particles in a hydrophilic binder.
[0007] Cleaning liquids for lithographic printing plates have been described in
EP-A-0200176, EP-A-0200177 and
EP-A-0200178 all filed on 18-01-2000 and
DE-A-42 16 636.
[0008] The known cleaning liquids typically contain solvents which are harmful to hoses,
pumps and sealings and/or require a very thorough rinsing with water because these
liquids are not compatible with the coating step in the next printing cycle.
[0009] In the known on-press coating methods, the cleaning of the lithographic substrate
often fails because no suitable compromise can be found between the chemical reactivity
of the cleaning liquid versus the ink-accepting areas which have to be removed on
the one hand and the required inertness of said cleaning liquid versus the fragile
lithographic surface on the other hand. A typical lithographic surface is mechanically
as well as chemically quite vulnerable. A lithographic surface consists generally
of a micro-pore structure in order to obtain a good differentiation between the spreading
properties of the ink and the fountain. Anodised aluminium plates comprise a lithographic
surface containing one or more metal oxides on which absorption phenomena can take
place. These metal oxides are very susceptible to chemical conversion into forms that
are no longer lithographically active.
[0010] The above mentioned micro-porosity of a lithographic surface is also highly susceptible
to mechanical damage. The presence of solid particles in cleaning liquids, which is
often required for efficient mechanical cleaning of the lithographic surface, results
inevitably in a disturbance of the micro-structure of said surface. Because ink and
the coated imaging layer penetrate in the micro-pore structure, it is necessary to
carry out a vigorous cleaning so as to avoid ghost images in the subsequent printing
cycles, which are due to an incomplete removal of the previous image.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
[0011] It is an object of the present invention to provide a convenient method for making
a stable micro-emulsion that is suitable as a cleaning liquid for recycling the substrate
of a printing master. This object is obtained by the method of claim 1. It is another
object of the present invention to provide a method for removing ink-accepting areas
of a lithographic printing master using a stable cleaning liquid which has a low organic
volatile content to avoid environmental contamination and which does not attack the
hardware of the printing press. The above object is realised by the method of claim
9. The micro-emulsion defined in claim 1 effectively removes the ink-accepting areas
of the printing master. No ghost images are observed after several (>10) print cycles
of coating, exposure, printing and cleaning. Rubber hoses and seals are not affected
by the cleaning liquid.
[0012] Further objects of the present invention will become clear from the description hereinafter.
[0013] Preferred embodiments of the method of the present invention are defined in the dependent
claims.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION
[0014] With the term micro-emulsion as used herein an emulsion having a particle size of
less than 1µm and preferably less than 200nm is defined.
[0015] The micro-emulsion according to the present invention is obtained by stirring a mixture
of a cyclic organic compound containing at least one double bond, an alcohol, water
and an emulsifying agent. Preferably, the micro-emulsion is prepared by the following
method:
- mixing a cyclic organic compound having at least one double bond and an emulsifying
agent
- adding alcohol
- adding water
- stirring
[0016] The obtained micro-emulsion is very stable in a temperature range of 0°C to 50°C.
Suitable examples of cyclic organic compounds having at least one double bond are:
toluene, xylene, propylbenzene, 3-methyl-6-isopropyl-l,4-cyclo-hexadiene, 3-(1-methylpropylidene)-cyclohexene,
6-methyl-1-(1-methylethyl)-1,3-cyclohexadiene, 4-methyl-5-(1-methylethenyl)-cyclohexene,
o-mentha-4,6-diene, o-mentha-2(8),3-diene, o-mentha-1(7),4-diene, 6-methyl-1-(1-methylethenyl)-cyclohexene,
1-methyl-5-(1-methylethyl)-1,4-cyclohexadiene, isosylvestrene, 4-ethyl-3-ethylidene-cyclohexene,
1-ethyl-6-ethylidene-cyclohexene, o-mentha-3,6-diene, o-mentha-2,5-diene, o-mentha-1,4-diene,
3-methyl-4-isopropenyl-1-cyclohexene, 3-methyl-5-isopropenyl-l-cyclohexene, 2-methyl-3-propyl-1,3-cyclohexadiene,
1-methyl-6-propylidene-cyclohexene, tetranaphtalene and preferably dipentene (formula
II).

[0017] The alcohol used is preferably an aliphatic alcoholether. Suitable examples of such
aliphatic alcoholethers are: methoxypropanol, propoxyethanol, 2-butoxyethanol, propanol,
2-(propyloxy) ethanol, fenoxyethanol, benzylalcohol, butoxypropanol, ethoxypropanol,
1-isobutoxy-2-propanol, 1-isomethoxy-2-propanol, 1-propoxy-2-propanol, diacetone alcohol,
tetrahydrofurfuryl alcohol, cathechol, trimethylolpropane, ethanediol, propanediol,
and butanediol. Highly preferred is 2-butoxyethanol. The alcohol and cyclic compound
are preferably present in an amount of 5 to 50 wt.% each and most preferably in an
amount of 10 to 30 wt.% each.
[0018] The emulsifying agent is preferably an anionic compound and/or comprises an alkylene
oxide chain. Suitable examples are Akypo OP80, Akypo RO90 (both commercially available
from Chem-Y), Empicol ESC70 (commercially available from Albright & Wilson), Aerosol
OT (commercially available from AM Cynamid). The emulsifying agent is preferably present
in an amount of 5 to 50 wt.% and most preferably in an amount of 10 to 30 wt.%. The
above described alcohol may also function as a co-emulsifying agent.
[0019] Furthermore the micro-emulsion can comprise a compound according to formula I:

wherein X is OH, O
- or a polymer backbone.
The counter ion can be, depending on the pH, H or a metal such as an alkali or alkaline
earth metal or a transition metal, e.g. chromium.
[0020] Suitable examples of the compound according to formula (I) are polyvinylphosphonic
acid, copolymers of vinylphosphonic acid with acrylic acid and vinyl acetate, acrylamidoisobutylene
phosphonic acid. Preferably the compound is phosphoric acid or a phosphate salt. The
compound is preferably present in an amount of 1.5 to 6 wt.%.
[0021] The micro-emulsion obtained by the method of the present invention can be used in
a method for removing ink-accepting areas of a lithographic printing master. The micro-emulsion
is capable of removing the ink remaining on the printing areas as well as the hydrophobic
coating itself that gives rise to the ink-accepting properties of the printing areas.
[0022] The above micro-emulsion is very suitable for removing the ink-accepting areas from
a printing master which is obtained by coating a hydrophilic substrate with a coating
solution containing hydrophobic thermoplastic polymer particles and a hydrophilic
binder. The imaging material thus obtained is negative-working, i.e. hydrophobic areas
are formed upon exposure. These areas define the printing areas of the master. It
is believed that the applied heat induces a coagulation of the hydrophobic polymer
particles, thereby forming a hydrophobic phase, whereas the hydrophobic polymer particles
remain unchanged in the non-heated areas. Coagulation may result from heat-induced
softening or melting of the thermoplastic polymer particles.
[0023] The imaging material which is preferably used in the present invention contains a
coating comprising hydrophobic thermoplastic polymer particles having an average particle
size between 40 nm and 2000 nm, and more preferably between 40 nm to 200 nm, so as
to improve sensitivity and throughput and to avoid scumming. Furthermore the polymer
particles preferably have a coagulation temperature above 50°C and more preferably
above 70°C. There is no specific upper limit to the coagulation temperature of the
polymer particles, however the temperature should be sufficiently below the decomposition
temperature of the polymer particles. Preferably the coagulation temperature is at
least 10°C below the temperature at which the decomposition of the polymer particles
occurs.
[0024] Preferred examples of thermoplastic hydrophobic polymer particles for use in the
present invention have a Tg above 80°C. The weight average molecular weight of the
polymers may range from 5,000 to 5,000,000 g/mol. Preferably the polymer particles
are selected from the group consisting of polyvinyl chloride, polyvinylidene chloride,
polyesters, polyurethanes, polyacrylonitrile, polyvinyl carbazole etc., and copolymers
or mixtures thereof. The most preferred examples are polystyrene and polymethylmethacrylate
or copolymers thereof.
[0025] The polymer particles are present as a dispersion in the coating solution and may
be prepared by the methods disclosed in US 3,476,937. Another method especially suitable
for preparing an aqueous dispersion of the thermoplastic polymer particles comprises:
- dissolving the hydrophobic thermoplastic polymer in an organic solvent which does
not mix with water,
- dispersing the thus obtained solution in water or in an aqueous medium and
- removing the organic solvent by evaporation.
[0026] Suitable hydrophilic binders for use in the present invention are preferably water-soluble
(co)polymers for example synthetic homo- or copolymers such as polyvinylalcohol, a
poly(meth)acrylic acid, a poly(meth)acrylamide, a polyhydroxyethyl(meth)acrylate,
a polyvinylmethylether or natural binders such as gelatine, a polysaccharide such
as e.g. dextran, pullulan, cellulose, arabic gum, alginic acid, inuline or chemically
modified inuline.
[0027] In addition, the coating solution may also contain surfactants that can be anionic,
cationic, non-ionic or amphoteric. Perfluoro surfactants are preferred. Particularly
preferred are non-ionic perfluoro surfactants. Said surfactants can be used alone
or preferably in combination.
[0028] The coverage of the coated layer ranges preferably from 0.3 to 20 g/m
2, more preferably from 0.5 to 5 g/m
2. The amount of hydrophobic thermoplastic polymer particles contained in the coated
layer is preferably between 50 and 90 wt.% and more preferably between 60 and 80 wt.%
of the total weight of said layer.
[0029] The coating solution is preferably applied to the substrate by spraying or jetting
but other coating techniques may also be used.
[0030] The substrate used in the present invention can be a plastic support or a ceramic
but is preferably a metal such as aluminium. The substrate has a hydrophilic surface
and is preferably characterised by a roughness value of at least 0.2 µm, more preferably
of at least 0.3 µm, e.g. electrochemically and/or mechanically grained and anodised
aluminium. The substrate can be a sheet-like material such as a plate but, alternatively,
the coating solution may be applied directly to the plate cylinder of a rotary printing
press, said cylinder thereby acting as the substrate. The lithographic substrate can
also be a seamless sleeve printing plate, obtained by e.g. soldering a plate into
a cylindrical form by means of a laser. The sleeve then can be slid around the plate
cylinder instead of mounting a conventional printing plate. More details on sleeves
are given in "Grafisch Nieuws" , 15, 1995, page 4 to 6.
[0031] The exposure of the imaging material obtained by coating the above coating solution
on the lithographic substrate can be carried out by means of direct thermal recording
using e.g. a thermal head, or by irradiation with high intensity light. In the latter
embodiment, the heat-sensitive material preferably comprises a compound capable of
converting light into heat, preferably a compound having sufficient absorption in
the wavelength range of the light source used for image-wise exposure. Particularly
useful compounds are for example dyes and in particular infrared dyes as disclosed
in EP-A 908 307 and pigments and in particular infrared pigments such as carbon black,
metal carbides, borides, nitrides, carbonitrides, bronze-structured oxides and oxides
structurally related to the bronze family but lacking the A component e.g. WO
2.9. It is also possible to use conductive polymer dispersions such as polypyrrole, polyaniline
or polythiophene-based conductive polymer dispersions. The lithographic performance
and in particular the print endurance obtained depends i.a. on the heat-sensitivity
of the imaging material. In this respect it has been found that carbon black yields
very good and favourable results.
[0032] Image-wise exposure in the method of the present invention is preferably an image-wise
scanning exposure involving the use of a laser or L.E.D. Preferably used are lasers
that operate in the infrared or near-infrared, i.e. wavelength range of 700-1500 nm.
Most preferred are laser diodes emitting in the near infrared.
[0033] The printing method of the present invention will be further described hereinafter
according to a preferred embodiment. First, a grained and anodised aluminium plate
is mounted on the plate cylinder of a rotary printing press. Then, the coating solution
described above is sprayed on the hydrophilic lithographic surface of the plate, so
as to form a continuous imaging layer. Preferred values of the spraying parameters
have been defined in EP-A no. 99203064 and EP-A no. 99203065, both filed on 15th September
1999. The imaging layer is then image-wise exposed by a laser device which is integrated
in the printing press e.g. as described in
US-P-5 163 368 and
US-P-5 174 205, whereby the exposed areas are converted to hydrophobic ink-accepting areas while
the unexposed areas remain hydrophilic. The hydrophobic areas define the printing
areas of the master. Subsequently, printing is started by applying ink and a fountain
solution to the printing master. In order to dissolve and remove the non-exposed areas
of the coated layer effectively, only fountain solution is preferably supplied during
a few revolutions of the press (about 10), and then also ink is fed to the plate.
After the press run, the lithographic substrate is recycled by treatment with a cleaning
liquid as described above. Finally, the substrate can be rinsed with water or an aqueous
solution and dried and then, a new printing cycle can be started by spraying the coating
solution to the recycled substrate.
[0034] The cleaning step can be executed in a cleaning unit similar to the known blanket
cleaning system. According to that embodiment, a cloth is preferably moistened with
the micro-emulsion, contacted with the printed plate during 1 to 50, more preferably
during 2 to 10 revolutions with a contacting pressure between 10 4 and 6x10 5 Pa at
a rotation speed in the range of 2 to 50 m/min. Afterwards the contact between the
printing surface and the cleaning cloth is disrupted and the cloth is transported
until a dry and clean part of the cloth is available.
[0035] The micro-emulsion can also be applied by spraying, coating or jetting the liquid
on the lithographic substrate or on the cloth. The removal of the ink-accepting areas
can also be effected with another absorbing medium than a cloth. Cleaning can also
be effected by combining the treatment with the micro-emulsion of the present invention
with other means of mechanical cleaning such as a rotating brush or by jetting water
or a volatile medium such as air, a solvent or dry ice pellets. Also vacuum extraction
can be used during the cleaning treatment.
[0036] All the steps of the method of the present invention are preferably performed on-press.
Alternatively, the lithographic substrate can also be mounted on a drum in a dedicated
coating apparatus (off-press coating) and subsequently be mounted on a plate setter
for image-wise exposure (off-press exposure). Then, the printing master thus obtained
can be mounted on a press cylinder and printing is started by supplying ink and a
fountain solution. After the press run, the plate can be cleaned as described above,
either on-press or in a dedicated cleaning apparatus, and the recycled substrate can
then be used again in a next printing cycle.
Examples
[0037] The following examples illustrate the present invention without limiting it thereto.
All parts and percentages are by weight unless otherwise specified.
Example 1: Comparative example
Preparation of the lithographic base
[0038] A 0.30 mm thick aluminium foil was degreased by immersing the foil in an aqueous
solution containing 5 g/l of sodium hydroxide at 50°C and rinsed with demineralized
water. The foil was then electrochemically grained using an alternating current in
an aqueous solution containing 4 g/l of hydrochloric acid, 4 g/l of hydroboric acid
and 5 g/l of aluminium ions at a temperature of 35°C and a current density of 1200
A/m
2 to form a surface topography with an average centre-line roughness Ra of 0.5 µm.
[0039] After rinsing with demineralized water the aluminium foil was then etched with an
aqueous solution containing 300 g/l of sulphuric acid at 60°C for 180 seconds and
rinsed with demineralized water at 25°C for 30 seconds.
[0040] The foil was subsequently subjected to anodic oxidation in an aqueous solution containing
200 g/l of sulphuric acid at a temperature of 45°C, a voltage of about 10 V and a
current density of 150 A/m
2 for about 300 seconds to form an anodic oxidation film of 3.00 g/m
2 of Al
2O
3 then washed with demineralized water, posttreated with a solution containing polyvinylphosphonic
acid and subsequently with a solution containing aluminium trichloride, rinsed with
demineralized water at 20°C during 120 seconds and dried.
Preparation of spray solution
[0041] A 2.61 wt.% solution in water was prepared by mixing polystyrene latex, a heat absorbing
compound and a hydrophilic binder. After spraying and drying, the resulting layer
contained 75 wt.% of the polystyrene latex, 10 wt.% of the heat absorbing compound,
presented in formula (I) and 15 wt.% polyacrylic acid (Glascol E15, commercially available
at N.V. Allied Colloids Belgium) as hydrophilic binder.

Preparation of the heat-mode imaging element
[0042] The spray solution was sprayed on the above mentioned lithographic base. Therefore,
the lithographic base was mounted on a drum, rotating at a line speed of 164 m/min.
The imaging element was coated by a spray nozzle moving in transverse direction at
a speed of 1.5 m/min. The spray nozzle was mounted on a distance of 80mm between nozzle
and receiving substrate. The flow rate of the spray solution was set to 7 ml/min.
During the spray process an air pressure of 90 psi was used on the spray head. This
layer was dried on a temperature of 70°C during the spraying process and additionally
during 30 s.
[0043] The spray nozzle was of the type SUJ1, an air assisted spray nozzle, commercially
available from Spraying Systems Belgium, Brussels.
Printing step
[0044] The above mentioned heat mode imaging element was imaged with different screen rulings/renderings
in a Creo 3244™ external drum platesetter at 2400 dpi at 150 rpm with a power setting
of 15.5 Watt. The imaged plates were printed on a GTO46 printing press with K+E 800
Skinnex ink, fountain (Combifix XL from Hostman-Steinberg (4 wt.%) - isopropylalcohol
(10 wt.%) in water) to a run length of 5000. The print quality was evaluated.
Preparation of micro-emulsion A:
[0045] 10 g of dipentene (commercially available from Sigma-Aldrich) was mixed with 20 g
of Akypo OP80. While stirring, 14 g of butoxyethanol as added. In the next step, 50
g of water was added while stirring.
Cleaning step:
[0046] 10 ml/m
2 of micro-emulsion A was sprayed on the plate which still contained the adhered ink,
using a manual pressure sprayer commercially available from Premal Sprayer Division
of Precision Valve corporation, New York.
[0047] After a time lapse of 30 s during which the micro-emulsion was allowed to interact
with the coating, the plate was cleaned by with a standard high pressure washer, using
a volume of water of 10 litre/m
2.
[0048] Finally, the plate is dried by pressurised air of room temperature until the plate
surface seems dry visually.
Next cycle
[0049] The procedure of spraying, imaging, printing and cleaning was repeated. In the second
cycle, the plate was imaged with a full plane of a 50% screen. Afterwards, the plate
cleanliness and print characteristics were evaluated.
Example 2
Preparation of micro-emulsion B:
[0050] 10 g of dipentene was mixed with 20 g of Akypo OP80. While stirring, 14 g of butoxyethanol
as added. In the next step, 50 g of water was added. Additionally, 5.9 wt.% of a 85%
phosphoric acid solution was added.
[0051] The same procedure as mentioned in example 1 was repeated however with micro-emulsion
B.
Example 3
Preparation of micro-emulsion C:
[0052] 25 g of dipentene was mixed with 25 g of Akypo OP80. While stirring, 10 g of butoxyethanol
as added. In the next step, 37 g of water was added. Additionally, 3 wt.% of a 85%
phosphoric acid solution was added.
[0053] The same procedure as mentioned in example 1 was repeated however with micro-emulsion
C.
Example 4
Preparation of micro-emulsion D:
[0054] 10 g of dipentene was mixed with 10 g of Aerosol OT. While stirring, 10 g of butoxyethanol
as added. In the next step, 67 g of water was added. Additionally, 3 wt.% of a 85%
phosphoric acid solution was added.
[0055] The same procedure as mentioned in example 1 was repeated however with micro-emulsion
D.
Example 5
Preparation of micro-emulsion E:
[0056] 20 g of dipentene was mixed with 10 g of Aerosol OT (commercially available from
AM Cynamid). While stirring, 10 g of butoxyethanol as added. In the next step, 57
g of water was added. Additionally, 3g of a 30 wt.% dispersion of colloidal silica
(Syton X30, commercially available at Dupont) in water was added.
[0057] The same procedure as mentioned in example 1 was repeated however with micro-emulsion
E.
Thermal stability of cleaner compositions:
[0058] The lower and upper cloud point of the above micro-emulsions were determined as the
temperature at which the emulsion segregates (gets cloudy) while cooling down or heating
a sample in a water bath.
Micro-emulsion |
Lower cloud point (°C) |
Upper cloud point (°C) |
A |
-2 |
24 |
B |
-1 |
28 |
C |
14 |
31 |
D |
-1 |
51 |
E |
Nd |
Nd |
Nd. The cloud points of cleaner composition E could not bedetermined because of the
presence of silica (always cloudy). |
Particle size of micro-emulsions:
[0059]
cleaner |
Particle size 25C Dyn. Light scattering |
A |
Nd. |
B |
34 |
C |
16 |
D |
29 |
E |
107 |
Nd. The particle size of cleaner composition A could not be determined (e.g. particle
size <10nm, out of the measurement range of the used method). |
[0060] The particle size of the different cleaner compositions was determined with Dynamic
light scattering on a Brookhaven BI90 apparatus based on photon correlation spectroscopy
.
[0061] The above mentioned diameter is the so called effective or PCS diameter based on
an cumulant analysis algorithm, a lognormal distribution and is a mean intensity weighted
diameter.
Results of recoat and lithographic quality.
[0062] After the first cleaning step mentioned above, the quality of the cleaned plate was
determined by visual inspection. For all examples perfectly cleaned materials were
obtained and after recoating according to the same method as described above, a very
good print quality in respect to staining behaviour and ghost images was observed.
Also after multiple cycles of coating, printing and cleaning with the same substrate
(up to 20), a good lithographic quality was maintained.