Technical Field
[0001] The present invention relates to a steel pipe having superior workability and a method
of producing the steel pipe.
Background Art
[0002] For the purpose of reducing the weight and cost, the application of seam (electric
resistance) welded steel pipes to automobile parts has been considered. Conventional
seam welded steel pipes, however, have not been sufficient in workability. Bending
is employed to manufacture, e.g., undercarriage or suspension parts of automobiles.
When the conventional seam welded steel pipes are subjected to the bending, a problem
has been experienced in that a pipe wall is greatly thinned on the outer side of a
bent portion, and in the worst case a pipe is ruptured. Even in the case of not causing
a rupture, a large rate of thinning of the pipe wall requires the use of a material
having a greater thickness to satisfy the design stress, and therefore a sufficient
reduction in weight cannot be achieved.
[0003] As disclosed in Japanese Unexamined Patent Application Publication No. 55-56624,
for example, it is known that improving an r-value (Lankford value) of a pipe in the
axial direction is effective to overcome the problems described above. As a method
for increasing the r-value of a steel pipe, however, it is only known to increase
the r-value of strip steel as a base material of a steel pipe as disclosed in, for
example, Japanese Unexamined Patent Application Publication No. 6-41689. When producing
seam welded steel pipes, there has been a problem that the r-value is reduced in a
portion where melting or transformation of a steel material has occurred during seam
welding. Another problem has arisen in that the seam welding cannot be applied to
steel plates not having a high r-value, such as hot-rolled steel plates, high tensile
strength steel plates, and low, medium and high carbon steel plates.
[0004] Accordingly, it is an object of the present invention to provide a steel pipe being
superior in workability, particularly in bending workability, in which an r-value
of the pipe in the axial direction in a portion where melting or transformation of
a steel material has occurred during seam welding is as high as comparable to that
in a portion where melting or transformation of the steel material has not occurred,
and a method of producing the steel pipe.
Disclosure of Invention
[0005] With the view of overcoming the problems mentioned above, the inventors have conducted
studies based on a consideration that working and heat treatment of seam welded steel
pipes are required to improve the r-value in a welded portion near the seam. Then,
the inventors have studied a method of performing working and heat treatment of a
steel pipe evenly at any positions in the circumferential direction, the steel pipe
being produced by seam-welding cold-rolled steel having a high r-value. In the process
of the studies, the inventors have found that the r-value of the seam welded steel
pipe in the longitudinal direction (in the axial direction of the pipe) is noticeably
improved to 1.2 or above, in particular to 1.6 or above, at any positions in the circumferential
direction, including a seamed portion, by a method of performing diameter-reducing
rolling on the seam welded steel pipe in a temperature range of from 600°C to Ac
3 with a reduction in diameter of not less than 30% (referred to as a "method according
to the present invention" hereinafter).
[0006] As a result of applying the method according to the present invention to seam welded
steel pipes produced using various kinds of steel plates as base-material strip steel,
the inventors have also found that a high r-value can be obtained regardless of the
r-value of the original strip steel. Further, it has been found that with the method
according to the present invention, the restriction of ingredients which has hitherto
been employed to obtain a high r-value in steel sheets, i.e., a reduction of the C
and N contents and addition of stabilizing elements such as Ti and Nb, are not required.
As a result, seam welded steel pipes having a high r-value can also be produced using,
as base-material strip steel, hot-rolled steel, high tensile strength steel such as
dual phase steel, and low, medium and high carbon steel, which have a difficulty in
achieving a high r-value in the stage of strip steel.
[0007] The views of the inventors regarding the reason why a steel pipe having a high r-value
can be obtained from even a steel plate not having a high r-value are as follows.
[0008] By performing the diameter-reducing rolling on a seam welded steel pipe in a temperature
range of from 600°C to Ac
3 with a reduction in diameter of not less than 30%, an ideal aggregation structure
due to the rolling, in which the <110> axis is parallel to the longitudinal direction
and the <111> to <110> axes are parallel to the radial direction, is formed and then
further developed through restoration and recrystallization. That aggregation structure
provides a high r-value. The aggregation structure due to the rolling produces very
great driving forces because crystals are rotated by working strains. Unlike an aggregation
structure that is created through recrystallization in the case of obtaining a high
r-value in steel sheets, the aggregation structure due to the rolling is less affected
by the second phase and solid solution C. Consequently, even for the type of strip
steel which has a difficulty in obtaining a high r-value in the stage of producing
steel plates, a high r-value can be obtained in the stage of producing steel pipes.
[0009] Also, the reason why a high r-value is not obtained by performing the diameter-reducing
rolling at low temperatures is that ideal crystal rotation is not caused because of
high work hardness, or that restoration and recrystallization are not developed at
a sufficient level because of low temperatures. Furthermore, the reason why a high
r-value is not obtained by a method of performing the diameter-reducing rolling on
a steel pipe at low temperatures and then annealing the rolled steel pipe for recrystallization
is that the desired aggregation structure is not developed through the cold rolling
and the recrystallization because of the effect of the second phase and solid solution
C.
[0010] In the field of producing steel sheets, there is known a method of producing a steel
sheet having a high r-value by rolling steel into a sheet in the hot ferrite range.
This method of producing a steel sheet having a high r-value is featured in that steel
containing C and N in reduced amounts and added with stabilizing elements such as
Ti and Nb is rolled at low temperatures and then recrystallized. That sheet rolling
at low temperatures differs from the diameter-reducing rolling at high temperatures
intended by the method according to the present invention. In fact, if the known sheet
rolling in the hot ferrite range is carried out at 600°C or above, the r-value is
not improved, but rather noticeably lowered on the contrary. This is because, in the
sheet rolling in which draft is applied in the thickness direction of a sheet, strain
occurs in a direction different from that in the diameter-reducing rolling of a steel
pipe in which draft is applied in the circumferential direction, and hence the aggregation
structure effective in increasing the r-value is not developed.
[0011] As a result of further continuing the studies, the inventors have found that, in
the method according to the present invention, the thickness deviation can be noticeably
reduced and the occurrence of wrinkles near the seam can be suppressed by heating
a seam welded steel pipe to temperatures of not lower than Ac
1 before the diameter-reducing rolling for austenitic transformation of a part or the
whole of a steel structure, because the difference in mechanical properties between
the hardened structure of the seam and the remaining portion is reduced. The present
invention has been accomplished based on the findings set forth above. The features
of the present invention are as follows.
(1) A high-workability steel pipe wherein an r-value in the longitudinal direction
is not less than 1.2, more preferably not less than 1.6, over an entire area in the
circumferential direction, including a seamed portion.
(2) A method of producing a high-workability steel pipe, the method comprising the
step of performing diameter-reducing rolling on a steel pipe in a temperature range
of from 600°C to Ac3 with a reduction in diameter of not less than 30%, the steel pipe being produced
by seam-welding strip steel.
(3) A method of producing a high-workability steel pipe, the method comprising the
steps of heating a steel pipe to temperatures of not lower than Ac1, the steel pipe being produced by seam-welding strip steel, and then immediately
or after cooling and reheating the steel pipe, performing diameter-reducing rolling
in a temperature range of from 600°C to Ac3 with a reduction in diameter of not less than 30%.
(4) In the method of producing a high-workability steel pipe defined in the above
(2) or (3), after the diameter-reducing rolling of the steel pipe, heat treatment
of holding the rolled steel pipe in a temperature range of from 600°C to 900°C for
a time of 1 second or longer is performed during cooling subsequent to the diameter-reducing
rolling or by reheating the rolled steel pipe after the cooling.
Brief Description of the Drawings
[0012]
Fig. 1 is a graph showing the relationship between an r-value in the longitudinal
direction of a steel pipe having been subjected to diameter-reducing rolling and a
reduction in diameter.
Fig. 2 is a graph showing the relationship between an r-value in the longitudinal
direction of a steel pipe having been subjected to diameter-reducing rolling and an
outgoing-side temperature in the rolling process.
Fig. 3 is a graph showing the relationship between a seam thickness deviation in a
steel pipe having been subjected to diameter-reducing rolling and a heating temperature
before the diameter-reducing rolling.
Best Mode for Carrying Out the Invention
[0013] In a high-workability steel pipe according to the present invention, an r-value in
the longitudinal direction is not less than 1.2. The reason is that the bending workability
of the steel pipe is noticeably improved when the r-value is not less than 1.2. More
preferably, the high-workability steel pipe has an r-value of not less than 1.6 because
the bending workability is further improved when the r-value is not less than 1.6.
[0014] The high-workability steel pipe according to the present invention can be produced
by performing diameter-reducing rolling on a steel pipe in a temperature range of
from 600°C to Ac
3 with a reduction in diameter of not less than 30%, the steel pipe being produced
by seam-welding strip steel and having a seam. The r-value is affected by the reduction
in diameterand the temperature during the diameter-reducing rolling.
[0015] Fig. 1 is a graph showing the relationship between the r-value in the longitudinal
direction and the reduction in diameterresulted at circumferential positions 0°, 90°,
180° and 270° of each steel pipe which was produced by performing the diameter-reducing
rolling on a seam welded steel pipe under a condition of the outgoing-side temperature
being set to 730°C while changing the reduction in diameterthe seam welded steel pipe
being produced by an ordinary method from strip steel having the same composition
as steel A in Table 1 given below. The seam position is assumed to be at 0° (this
is similarly applied to the following description). From Fig. 1, it is understood
that, regardless of the circumferential positions, the r-value of not less than 1.3
is obtained at the reduction in diameterof not less than 30%, and the r-value of not
less than 1.6 is obtained at the reduction in diameterof not less than 50%.
[0016] Fig. 2 is a graph showing the relationship between the r-value in the longitudinal
direction and the outgoing-side temperature resulted at circumferential positions
0°, 90°, 180° and 270° of each steel pipe which was produced by performing the diameter-reducing
rolling on a seam welded steel pipe under a condition of the reduction in diameter
set to 30% while changing the outgoing-side temperature, the seam welded steel pipe
being produced by an ordinary method from strip steel having the same composition
as steel A in Table 1 given below. From Fig. 2, it is understood that the r-value
of not less than 1.2 is obtained at the outgoing-side temperature of not lower than
600°C.
[0017] Based on the experiment results mentioned above, a lower limit of the temperature
for the diameter-reducing rolling was set to 600°C and a lower limit of the reduction
in diameterwas set to 30%. Also, an upper limit of the temperature for the diameter-reducing
rolling was set to the same as an upper limit of the temperature range in which the
steel structure contains ferrite, i.e., the temperature Ac
3. The r-value is not improved even by the diameter-reducing rolling if it is performed
on steel whose structure contains no ferrite. The temperature Ac
3 depends on the chemical composition of steel, and can be determined based on experiments.
A range of temperature Ac
3 is approximately not higher than 900°C. In the present invention, so long as the
steel structure contains ferrite, the second phase (phase other than ferrite) is not
limited to particular one. For example, austenite may be the second phase. More preferably,
the diameter-reducing rolling is performed at temperatures where ferrite forms the
main phase (phase having a volume ratio of 50% or more).
[0018] The gist of the present invention resides in that a steel pipe is subjected to the
diameter-reducing rolling in a temperature range where the steel structure has the
ferrite phase. From the standpoint of improving the r-value, there is no particular
restriction upon the history prior to the diameter-reducing rolling. For example,
the heating temperature prior to the diameter-reducing rolling may be any of the temperature
at which the steel structure has the single austenitic phase, the temperature at which
the steel structure has the two austenitic and ferrite phases, and the temperature
at which the steel structure has the single ferrite phase. Further, prior to the diameter-reducing
rolling, the steel pipe may be rolled at such temperatures as forming austenite as
the single phase or the main phase.
[0019] Fig. 3 is a graph showing the relationship between a heating temperature and a thickness
deviation resulted for each steel pipe which was produced by performing the diameter-reducing
rolling on a seam welded steel pipe under conditions of the reduction in diameter
set to 30% and the rolling temperature set to 700°C while changing the heating temperature,
the seam welded steel pipe being produced by an ordinary method from strip steel having
the same composition as steel A in Table 1 given below. From Fig. 3, it is understood
that the heating prior to the diameter-reducing rolling is preferably set to be not
lower than the temperature Ac
1 from the standpoint of suppressing the thickness deviation and wrinkles occurred
near the seam. The temperature Ac
1 depends on the chemical composition of the steel pipe, etc., and can be determined
based on experiments. A range of temperature Ac
1 is approximately not lower than 800°C. However, if the heating temperature is too
high, the crystal grain size would be excessively increased, thus resulting in a problem
of, for example, increasing surface roughness during the working. For that reason,
the heating temperature is preferably set to be not higher than 900°C.
[0020] There is no particular restriction upon the cooling after the heating of the steel
pipe. Subsequent to the heating, the diameter-reducing rolling may be performed, for
example, after cooling the steel pipe down to temperatures at which ferrite forms
the main phase, or by reheating the steel pipe after cooling it down to the room temperature.
[0021] Further, preferably, after the diameter-reducing rolling of the steel pipe, heat
treatment of holding the rolled steel pipe in a temperature range of from 600°C to
900°C for a time of 1 second or longer is performed in the present invention.
[0022] In the present invention, since the diameter-reducing rolling is performed at temperatures
of not lower than 600°C, the work hardness is low and a sufficient level of workability
is obtained with additional treatment. Even so, by performing heat treatment for holding
the rolled steel pipe at a certain temperature for a certain time in succession to
the diameter-reducing rolling, the elongation and the r-value are further improved.
This effect is developed by holding the rolled steel pipe at temperatures of not lower
than 600°C for a time of 1 second or longer. However, if the holding temperature exceeds
900°C, the steel structure would be transformed into the single austenitic phase and
the r-value would be reduced because of the randomized aggregation structure. For
that reason, the heat treatment is preferably performed on conditions of the holding
temperature in the range of from 600°C to 900°C and the holding time of 1 second or
longer. Additionally, the heat treatment may be performed during cooling subsequent
to the diameter-reducing rolling or by reheating the rolled steel pipe after the cooling.
(Example)
[0023] Seam welded steel pipes were produced by an ordinary method from various kinds of
hot-rolled steel plates having chemical compositions shown in Table 1, and the diameter-reducing
rolling was performed on each steel pipe under conditions shown in Table 2. Heating
of the steel pipe prior to the diameter-reducing rolling was not held at all or held
for a time of 1 to 600 seconds after reaching the temperature shown in Table 2. Tensile
specimens of JIS No. 12-A were sampled from circumferential positions 0°, 90°, 180°
and 270° of each steel pipe obtained. After bonding a strain gauge with a gauge length
of 2 mm to each specimen, a tensile test was carried out on the specimen by applying
a nominal strain of 6 to 7%. Then, a ratio of a true strain ε
w in the width direction to a true strain ε
L in the longitudinal direction was measured. From a gradient ρ of that ratio, the
r-value was calculated based on the following formulae:

r-value = ρ/(-1- ρ)
[0024] Further, a thickness deviation η was calculated by measuring a pipe wall thickness
ts of a seamed portion and an average pipe wall thickness
tb of the remaining portion. That is:

[0025] Moreover, the presence or absence of wrinkles was determined by observing an image
of an area near the seam in a cross-section perpendicular to the axis of the steel
pipe, the image being enlarged at a magnification of 50 times.
[0026] Those results are listed in Table 3 along with the tensile strength (TS) and the
elongation (El).
[0027] The r-value is 1.2 or above at any positions in the circumferential direction in
Examples of the present invention, whereas the r-value is below 1.2 in Comparative
Examples. Also, in the specimens heated to temperatures of not lower than Ac
1, the thickness deviation is smaller and wrinkles are not caused.
Industrial Applicability
[0028] According to the present invention, a high-workability steel pipe can be provided
which has a high r-value over an entire area in the circumferential direction, including
a seamed portion, and also has a good shape. Limits in bending and expanding work
of the steel pipe are noticeably improved, whereby omission of steps due to the integral
forming and a reduction in weight can be achieved. Further, seam welded steel pipes
having a high r-value can also be produced using, as base materials, hot-rolled steel,
high tensile strength steel such as dual phase steel, and low, medium and high carbon
steel, which have a difficulty in achieving a high r-value with a conventional method
of producing a steel pipe by simply seam-welding a steel plate. As a result, the present
invention is able to remarkably enlarge the applicable range of bending of steel pipes
and hence greatly contributes to development of the industry.
Table 2
| No . |
Steel |
Heating Temperature (°C) |
Incoming-side Temperature in Diameter-Reducing Rolling (°C) |
Outgoing-side Temperature in Diameter-Reducing Rolling (°C) |
Total Reduction in Diameter (%) |
Effective Reduction in Diameter* (%) |
Heat Treatment |
Remarks |
| 1 |
A |
800 |
780 |
730 |
50 |
50 |
- |
Example |
| 2 |
A |
900 |
880 |
830 |
50 |
5 |
- |
Comparative Example |
| 3 |
A |
630 |
610 |
560 |
50 |
10 |
- |
Comparative Example |
| 4 |
B |
800 |
780 |
730 |
50 |
50 |
- |
Example |
| 5 |
B |
800 |
780 |
730 |
50 |
50 |
- |
Example |
| 6 |
C |
800 |
780 |
730 |
50 |
50 |
73°c × 5 min. |
Example |
| 7 |
D |
900** |
720 |
680 |
50 |
50 |
- |
Example |
| 8 |
D |
850 |
720 |
680 |
50 |
50 |
- |
Example |
| 9 |
D |
800 |
780 |
730 |
50 |
50 |
- |
Example |
| 10 |
D |
800 |
720 |
680 |
50 |
50 |
- |
Example |
| 11 |
D |
750 |
720 |
680 |
50 |
50 |
- |
Example |
| 12 |
D |
735 |
720 |
680 |
50 |
50 |
- |
Example |
| 13 |
D |
720 |
720 |
680 |
50 |
50 |
- |
Example |
| 14 |
E |
800 |
780 |
730 |
50 |
50 |
- |
Example |
| 15 |
F |
800 |
780 |
730 |
0 |
0 |
- |
Comparative Example |
| 16 |
F |
800 |
780 |
730 |
15 |
15 |
- |
Comparative Example |
| 17 |
F |
800 |
780 |
730 |
30 |
30 |
- |
Example |
| 18 |
F |
800 |
780 |
730 |
40 |
40 |
- |
Example |
| 19 |
F |
800 |
780 |
730 |
50 |
50 |
- |
Example |
| 20 |
F |
800 |
780 |
730 |
60 |
60 |
- |
Example |
| 21 |
F |
800 |
780 |
730 |
70 |
70 |
- |
Example |
| 22 |
F |
900 |
890 |
850 |
30 |
2 |
- |
Comparative Example |
| 23 |
F |
850 |
840 |
780 |
30 |
30 |
- |
Example |
| 24 |
F |
750 |
730 |
680 |
30 |
30 |
- |
Example |
| 25 |
F |
700 |
680 |
600 |
30 |
30 |
- |
Example |
| 26 |
F |
630 |
610 |
560 |
50 |
10 |
- |
Comparative Example |
| 27 |
G |
900 |
780 |
730 |
50 |
50 |
- |
Example |
| 28 |
G |
850 |
780 |
730 |
50 |
50 |
- |
Example |
| 29 |
G |
800 |
780 |
730 |
30 |
30 |
- |
Example |
| 30 |
G |
800 |
780 |
730 |
40 |
40 |
- |
Example |
| 31 |
G |
800 |
780 |
730 |
50 |
50 |
- |
Example |
| 32 |
H |
800 |
780 |
730 |
50 |
50 |
- |
Example |
| 33 |
I |
800 |
780 |
730 |
50 |
50 |
- |
Example |
| 34 |
J |
800 |
780 |
730 |
50 |
50 |
- |
Example |
| 35 |
K |
800 |
780 |
730 |
50 |
50 |
- |
Example |
| 36 |
L |
760 |
740 |
700 |
60 |
60 |
- |
Example |
| * effective reduction in diameter: reduction in diameter in temperature range of 600°C
to Ac3 |
| ** rolling after cooling and reheating (for other types of steel, rolling immediately
after heating) |
Table 3
| No |
0° (Seam) |
90° |
180° |
270° |
Seam Thick ness Devia tion /% |
Wrinkles ○ not occurred × occurred |
Remarks |
| |
TS/MPa |
E1* /% |
r-value |
TS/MPa |
E1* /% |
r-value |
TS/MPa |
E1* /% |
r-value |
TS/MPa |
E1* /% |
r-value |
|
|
|
| 1 |
300 |
55 |
2.0 |
303 |
54 |
2.0 |
307 |
54 |
2.1 |
301 |
55 |
2.1 |
0.3 |
○ |
Example |
| 2 |
300 |
45 |
0.8 |
309 |
45 |
0.9 |
307 |
45 |
0.8 |
308 |
45 |
0.8 |
0.3 |
○ |
Comparative Example |
| 3 |
450 |
35 |
1.0 |
450 |
35 |
1.1 |
459 |
36 |
1.0 |
451 |
34 |
1.1 |
10.0 |
× |
Comparative Example |
| 4 |
350 |
50 |
2.0 |
356 |
51 |
2.0 |
356 |
50 |
2.0 |
350 |
51 |
2.0 |
0.5 |
○ |
Example |
| 5 |
350 |
50 |
2.4 |
358 |
51 |
2.4 |
351 |
49 |
2.5 |
356 |
49 |
2.4 |
0.5 |
○ |
Example |
| 6 |
620 |
25 |
1.8 |
624 |
24 |
1.8 |
625 |
25 |
1.8 |
629 |
25 |
1.9 |
0.3 |
○ |
Example |
| 7 |
640 |
27 |
1.7 |
646 |
27 |
1.7 |
641 |
27 |
1.7 |
647 |
26 |
1.7 |
0.5 |
○ |
Example |
| 8 |
631 |
25 |
1.7 |
651 |
26 |
1.6 |
641 |
25 |
1.8 |
641 |
25 |
1.8 |
1.0 |
○ |
Example |
| 9 |
620 |
28 |
1.8 |
626 |
29 |
1.8 |
621 |
29 |
1.9 |
627 |
28 |
1.9 |
0.5 |
○ |
Example |
| 10 |
640 |
24 |
1.6 |
659 |
24 |
1.7 |
632 |
24 |
1.7 |
636 |
24 |
1.7 |
2.0 |
○ |
Example |
| 11 |
644 |
22 |
1.6 |
650 |
22 |
1.7 |
635 |
22 |
1.7 |
632 |
22 |
1.8 |
3.0 |
○ |
Example |
| 12 |
653 |
20 |
1.6 |
657 |
21 |
1.6 |
640 |
21 |
1.8 |
623 |
21 |
1.8 |
8.0 |
× |
Example |
| 13 |
644 |
19 |
1.7 |
650 |
19 |
1.7 |
637 |
19 |
1.9 |
614 |
19 |
1.8 |
15.0 |
× |
Example |
| 14 |
650 |
25 |
1.8 |
652 |
25 |
1.9 |
651 |
25 |
1.8 |
651 |
26 |
1.9 |
0.5 |
○ |
Example |
| 15 |
500 |
25 |
0.7 |
508 |
26 |
0.8 |
503 |
24 |
0.8 |
501 |
25 |
0.8 |
0.3 |
○ |
Comparative Example |
| 16 |
590 |
28 |
1.0 |
593 |
28 |
1.1 |
599 |
29 |
1.1 |
595 |
28 |
1.0 |
0.3 |
○ |
Comparative Example |
| 17 |
610 |
28 |
1.3 |
610 |
28 |
1.3 |
618 |
28 |
1.3 |
614 |
29 |
1.3 |
0.9 |
○ |
Example |
| 18 |
610 |
29 |
1.4 |
619 |
29 |
1.4 |
611 |
30 |
1.4 |
611 |
28 |
1.4 |
0.9 |
○ |
Example |
| 19 |
610 |
30 |
1.6 |
617 |
31 |
1.7 |
611 |
30 |
1.6 |
615 |
31 |
1.6 |
0.9 |
○ |
Example |
| 20 |
610 |
32 |
2.0 |
616 |
31 |
2.0 |
612 |
33 |
2.1 |
610 |
31 |
2.1 |
0.9 |
○ |
Example |
| 21 |
610 |
35 |
2.5 |
615 |
35 |
2.6 |
613 |
35 |
2.6 |
618 |
36 |
2.6 |
0.8 |
○ |
Example |
| 22 |
590 |
28 |
0.8 |
593 |
27 |
0.8 |
599 |
28 |
0.8 |
593 |
28 |
0.9 |
0.2 |
○ |
Comparative Example |
| 23 |
610 |
29 |
1.4 |
612 |
30 |
1.4 |
614 |
30 |
1.5 |
616 |
29 |
1.5 |
0.2 |
○ |
Example |
| 24 |
610 |
28 |
1.3 |
613 |
29 |
1.3 |
615 |
28 |
1.4 |
612 |
28 |
1.4 |
0.0 |
○ |
Example |
| 25 |
650 |
27 |
1.2 |
651 |
26 |
1.2 |
650 |
27 |
1.2 |
658 |
26 |
1.2 |
3.0 |
× |
Example |
| 26 |
630 |
22 |
0.9 |
680 |
21 |
1.0 |
687 |
22 |
1.0 |
685 |
23 |
0.9 |
15.0 |
× |
Comparative Example |
| 27 |
630 |
30 |
1.3 |
638 |
30 |
1.3 |
639 |
31 |
1.4 |
640 |
31 |
1.3 |
0.7 |
○ |
Example |
| 28 |
630 |
33 |
1.4 |
636 |
33 |
1.4 |
630 |
33 |
1.5 |
638 |
33 |
1.5 |
0.5 |
○ |
Example |
| 29 |
630 |
30 |
1.3 |
638 |
30 |
1.3 |
639 |
31 |
1.4 |
640 |
31 |
1.3 |
0.3 |
○ |
Example |
| 30 |
630 |
33 |
1.4 |
636 |
33 |
1.4 |
630 |
33 |
1.5 |
638 |
33 |
1.5 |
0.3 |
○ |
Example |
| 31 |
630 |
35 |
1.8 |
637 |
34 |
1.9 |
635 |
35 |
1.8 |
633 |
34 |
1.9 |
0.4 |
○ |
Example |
| 32 |
600 |
30 |
1.8 |
606 |
30 |
1.8 |
609 |
30 |
1.9 |
600 |
30 |
1.8 |
0.5 |
○ |
Example |
| 33 |
600 |
30 |
1.8 |
604 |
29 |
1.8 |
605 |
31 |
1.9 |
601 |
29 |
1.9 |
0.8 |
○ |
Example |
| 34 |
820 |
24 |
1.6 |
823 |
25 |
1.6 |
821 |
25 |
1.7 |
825 |
24 |
1.7 |
0.3 |
○ |
Example |
| 35 |
820 |
22 |
1.6 |
821 |
22 |
1.6 |
823 |
23 |
1.7 |
830 |
22 |
1.7 |
0.8 |
○ |
Example |
| 36 |
695 |
28 |
1.8 |
595 |
28 |
1.8 |
595 |
28 |
1.8 |
595 |
28 |
1.8 |
0.3 |
○ |
Example |
| * sheet thickness = 1.6 mm |