[0001] This invention relates to processes and products for effecting laser-induced thermal
transfer imaging. More specifically, the invention relates to thermally imageable
elements comprising thermally imageable compositions containing stabilizers and NIR
dyes.
[0002] Laser-induced thermal transfer processes are well-known in applications such as color
proofing and lithography. Such laser-induced processes include, for example, dye sublimation,
dye transfer, melt transfer, and ablative material transfer.
[0003] Laser-induced processes use a laserable assemblage comprising (a) a thermally imageable
element that contains a thermally imageable layer, the exposed areas of which are
transferred, and (b) a receiver element having an image receiving layer that is in
contact with the thermally imageable layer. The laserable assemblage is imagewise
exposed by a laser, usually an infrared laser, resulting in transfer of exposed areas
of the thermally imageable layer from the thermally imageable element to the receiver
element. The (imagewise) exposure takes place only in a small, selected region of
the laserable assemblage at one time, so that transfer of material from the thermally
imageable element to the receiver element can be built up one pixel at.a time. Computer
control produces transfer with high resolution and at high speed.
[0004] NIR (near infrared) dyes are present in the thermally imageable layers to improve
imaging characteristics of the thermally imageable element. A severe limitation present
in the use of NIR dyes in the thermally imageable layer is that they have demonstrated
instability through the manufacture and process of use steps. This narrow operating
window has precluded the use of many NIR dyes which would otherwise function effectively
in laser-induced thermal transfer processes.
[0005] A need exists for maintaining NIR stability, during manufacture and when the thermally
imageable layers containing them are used in thermal imaging processes.
[0006] The invention provides a thermal imaging process using a thermally imageable layer
which promotes stability of a thermal amplification additive.
[0007] In a first aspect of this invention, a thermally imageable element comprising a thermally
imageable layer, wherein the thermally imageable layer comprises a thermal amplification
additive and a stabilizer which is at least one of:
(a) a phenolic type compound having a structure:



or

or (b) an amine type compound having a structure:




or

wherein: each R
1 independently represents a hydrogen atom, an alkyl group having 1 to about 12 carbon
atoms or an alkyoxy group having 1 to about 12 carbon atoms;
n is an integer ranging from 0 to about 20;
m is an integer ranging from 1 to about 20;
each R
2 independently represents a hydrogen atom or alkyl group having 1 to about 12 carbon
atoms or an alkoxy group having 1 to about 12 carbon atoms;
R
3 is a hydrogen atom, alkyl group of 1 to about 20 carbon atoms or aryl group of 6
to about 20 carbon atoms;
R
4 is an alkyl group of 1 to about 12 carbon atoms or an aryl group of 6 to about 20
carbon atoms;
R
5 is a hydrogen atom, alkyl group of 1 to about 12 carbon atoms or hydroxy methyl group;
R
6 is an aryl group of 6 to about 20 carbon atoms;
R
7 is a hydrogen atom or an aryl group of 6 to about 20 carbon atoms; and
R
8 is a hydrogen atom or nitro group.
[0008] In the first aspect, the thermally imageable layer is present on a base element comprising
a support and a heating layer. Optionally, an ejection or subbing layer may be present
on the support between the support and the heating layer. In the first aspect, the
thermally imageable layer further comprises a colorant such as a pigment dispersion.
[0009] In a second aspect, the invention provides a method for making a color image comprising:
(1) imagewise exposing to laser radiation a laserable assemblage comprising:
(A) a thermally imageable element comprising a thermally imageable layer, wherein
the thermally imageable layer comprises a thermal amplification additive and a stabilizer
which is the: -
(a) phenolic type compound of structure (1), (2), (3) or (4) or the
(b) amine type compound of structure (1), (2), (3), (4) or (5)
(B) a receiver element comprising:
(c) a receiver support; and
(d) an image receiving layer provided on the surface of the receiver support; and
whereby the exposed areas of the thermally imageable layer are transferred to the
receiver element to form a colorant-containing image on the image receiving layer;
and
(2) separating the thermally imageable element (A) from the receiver element (B),
thereby revealing the colorant-containing image on the image receiving layer of the
receiver element.
[0010] The revealed colorant-containing image may then be transferred directly to a permanent
substrate such as paper or to a permanent substrate through an intermediate transfer
step using an image rigidification element.
[0011] In the second aspect, the surface of the image receiving layer may have an average
roughness (Ra) of less than about 1 µ and surface irregularities having a plurality
of peaks, at least about 40 of the peaks having a height of at least about 200 nm
and a diameter of about 100 pixels over a surface area of about 458 µ by about 602
µ;
[0012] Figure 1 illustrates a thermally imageable element (10) useful in the invention having
a support (11); a base element having a coatable surface comprising an optional ejection
layer or subbing layer (12) and a heating layer (13); and a thermally imageable colorant-containing
layer (14).
[0013] Figure 2 illustrates a receiver element (20), optionally having a roughened surface,
useful in the invention having a receiver support (21) and a image receiving layer
(22).
[0014] Processes and products for laser induced thermal transfer imaging are disclosed wherein
thermally imageable elements having improved imaging characteristics are provided.
The thermally imageable elements disclosed herein maintain shelf life stability of
the thermal amplification additive, such as an NIR dye, during manufacture of the
elements and also during process of use of these elements.
[0015] Before the processes of this invention are described in further detail, several different
exemplary laserable assemblages made up of the combination of a receiver element,
optionally having a roughened surface and a thermally imageable element will be described.
The processes of this invention are fast and are typically conducted using one of
these exemplary laserable assemblages.
Thermally Imageable Element
[0016] As shown in Figure 1, an exemplary thermally imageable element useful for thermal
imaging in accordance with the processes of this invention comprises a thermally imageable
colorant-containing layer (14) and a base element having a coatable surface which
comprises an optional ejection layer or subbing layer (12) and a heating layer (13).
Each of these layers has separate and distinct functions. Optionally, a support for
the thermally imageable element (11) may also be present. In one embodiment, the heating
layer (13) may be present directly on the support (11)
Support:
[0017] Typically, the support is a thick (400 gauge) coextruded polyethylene terephthalate
film. Alternately, the support may be a polyester, specifically polyethylene terephthalate
that has been plasma treated to accept the heating layer. When the support is plasma
treated, a subbing layer or ejection layer is usually not provided on the support.
Backing layers may optionally be provided on the support. These backing layers may
contain fillers to provide a roughened surface on the back side of the support, i.e.
the side opposite from the base element (12). Alternatively, the support itself may
contain fillers, such as silica, to provide a roughened surface on the back surface
of the support.
Ejection or Subbing Layer:
[0018] The ejection layer, which is usually flexible, or subbing layer (12), as shown in
Figure 1, is the layer that provides the force to effect transfer of the thermally
imageable colorant-containing layer to the receiver element in the exposed areas.
When heated, this layer decomposes into gaseous molecules providing the necessary
pressure to propel or eject the exposed areas of the thermally imageable colorant-containing
layer onto the receiver element. This is accomplished by using a polymer having a
relatively low decomposition temperature (less than about 350°C, typically less than
about 325°C, and more typically less than about 280°C). In the case of polymers having
more than one decomposition temperature, the first decomposition temperature should
be lower than 350°C. Furthermore, in order for the ejection layer to have suitably
high flexibility and conformability, it should have a tensile modulus that is less
than or equal to about 2.5 Gigapascals (GPa), specifically less than about 1.5 GPa,
and more specifically less than about 1 Gigapascal (GPa). The polymer chosen should
also be one that is dimensionally stable. If the laserable assemblage is imaged through
the ejection layer, the ejection layer should be capable of transmitting the laser
radiation, and not be adversely affected by this radiation.
[0019] Examples of suitable polymers for the ejection layer include (a) polycarbonates having
low decomposition temperatures (Td), such as polypropylene carbonate; (b) substituted
styrene polymers having low decomposition temperatures, such as poly(alpha-methylstyrene);
(c) polyacrylate and polymethacrylate esters, such as polymethylmethacrylate and polybutylmethacrylate;
(d) cellulosic materials having low decomposition temperatures (Td), such as cellulose
acetate butyrate and nitrocellulose; and (e) other polymers such as polyvinyl chloride;
poly(chlorovinyl chloride) polyacetals; polyvinylidene chloride; pblyurethanes with
low Td; polyesters; polyorthoesters; acrylonitrile and substituted acrylonitrile polymers;
maleic acid resins; and copolymers of the above. Mixtures of polymers can also be
used. Additional examples of polymers having low decomposition temperatures can be
found in U.S. Patent 5,156,938. These include polymers which undergo acid-catalyzed
decomposition. For these polymers, it is frequently desirable to include one or more
hydrogen donors with the polymer.
[0020] Specific examples of polymers for the ejection layer are polyacrylate and polymethacrylate
esters, low Td polycarbonates, nitrocellulose, poly(vinyl chloride) (PVC), and chlorinated
poly(vinyl chloride) (CPVC). Most specifically are poly(vinyl chloride) and chlorinated
poly(vinyl chloride).
[0021] Other materials can be present as additives in the ejection layer as long as they
do not interfere with the essential function of the layer. Examples of such additives
include coating aids, flow additives, slip agents, antihalation agents, plasticizers,
antistatic agents, surfactants, and others which are known to be used in the formulation
of coatings.
[0022] Alternately, a subbing layer (12) maybe provided in place of the ejection layer resulting
in a thermally imageable element having in order at least one subbing layer (12),
at least one heating layer (13), and at least one thermally imageable pigment containing
layer (14). Some suitable subbing layers include polyurethanes, polyvinyl chloride,
cellulosic materials, acrylate or methacrylate homopolymers and copolymers, and mixtures
thereof. Other custom made decomposable polymers may also be useful in the subbing
layer. Specifically useful as subbing layers for polyester, specifically polyethylene
terephthalate, are acrylic subbing layers. The subbing layer may have a thickness
of about 100 to about 1000 A.
Heating Layer
[0023] The heating layer (13), as shown in Figure 1, is deposited on the flexible ejection
or subbing layer. The function of the heating layer is to absorb the laser radiation
and convert the radiation into heat. Materials suitable for the layer can be inorganic
or organic and can inherently absorb the laser radiation or include additional laser-radiation
absorbing compounds.
[0024] Examples of suitable inorganic materials are transition metal elements and metallic
elements of Groups IIIA, IVA, VA, VIA, VIIIA, IIB, IIIB, and VB of the Period Table
of the Elements (Sargent-Welch Scientific Company (1979)), their alloys with each
other, and their alloys with the elements of Groups IA and IIA. Tungsten (W) is an
example of a Group VIA metal that is suitable and which can be utilized. Carbon (a
Group IVB nonmetallic element) can also be used. Specific metals include Al, Cr, Sb,
Ti, Bi, Zr, , Ni, In, Zn, and their alloys and oxides. TiO
2 may be employed as the heating layer material.
[0025] The thickness of the heating layer is generally about 20 Angstroms to about 0.1 micrometer,
more specifically about 40 to about 100 Angstroms.
[0026] Although it is typical to have a single heating layer, it is also possible to have
more than one heating layer, and the different layers can have the same or different
compositions, as long as they all function as described above. The total thickness
of all the heating layers should be in the range given above.
[0027] The heating layer(s) can be applied using any of the well-known techniques for providing
thin metal layers, such as sputtering, chemical vapor deposition, and electron beam.
Thermally Imageable Colorant-containing Layer:
[0028] The thermally imageable colorant-containing layer (14) is formed by applying a thermally
imageable composition, typically containing a colorant, to a base element. The colorant-containing
layer comprises (i) a polymeric binder which is different from the polymer in the
ejection layer, and (ii) a colorant comprising a dye or a pigment dispersion.
[0029] The binder for the colorant-containing layer is a polymeric material having a decomposition
temperature that is greater than about 300°C and specifically greater than about 350°C.
The binder should be film forming and coatable from solution or from a dispersion.
Binders having melting points less than about 250°C or plasticized to such an extent
that the glass transition temperature is less than about 70°C are typical. However,
heat-fusible binders, such as waxes should be avoided as the sole binder since such
binders may not be as durable, although they are useful as cobinders in decreasing
the melting point of the top layer.
[0030] It is typical that the polymer of the binder does not self-oxidize, decompose or
degrade at the temperature achieved during the laser exposure so that the exposed
areas of the thermally imageable layer comprising colorant and binder, are transferred
intact for improved durability. Examples of suitable binders include copolymers of
styrene and (meth)acrylate esters, such as styrene/methyl-methacrylate; copolymers
of styrene and olefin monomers, such as styrene/ethylene/butylene; copolymers of styrene
and acrylonitrile; fluoropolymers; copolymers of (meth)acrylate esters with ethylene
and carbon monoxide; polycarbonates having higher decomposition temperatures; (meth)acrylate
homopolymers and copolymers; polysulfones; polyurethanes; polyesters. The monomers
for the above polymers can be substituted or unsubstituted. Mixtures of polymers can
also be used.
[0031] Specific polymers for the binder of the colorant-containing layer include, but are
not limited to, acrylate homopolymers and copolymers, methacrylate homopolymers and
copolymers, (meth)acrylate block copolymers, and (meth)acrylate copolymers containing
other comonomer types, such as styrene.
[0032] The polymer of the binder generally has a concentration of about 15 to about 50%
by weight, based on the total weight of the colorant-containing layer, specifically
about 30 to about 40% by weight.
[0033] The colorant of the thermally imageable layer may be an image forming pigment which
is organic or inorganic. Examples of suitable inorganic pigments include carbon black
and graphite. Examples of suitable organic pigments include color pigments such as
Rubine F6B (C.I. No. Pigment 184); Cromophthal® Yellow 3G (C.I. No. Pigment Yellow
93); Hostaperm® Yellow 3G (C.I. No. Pigment Yellow 154); Monastral® Violet R (C.I.
No. Pigment Violet 19); 2,9-dimethylquinacridone (C.I. No. Pigment Red 122); Indofast®
Brilliant Scarlet R6300 (C.I. No. Pigment Red 123); Quindo Magenta RV 6803; Monastral®
Blue G (C.I. No. Pigment Blue 15); Monastral® Blue BT 383D (C.I. No. Pigment Blue
15); Monastral® Blue G BT 284D (C.I. No. Pigment Blue 15); and Monastral® Green GT
751D (C.I. No. Pigment Green 7). Combinations of pigments and/or dyes can also be
used. For color filter array applications, high transparency pigments (that is at
least about 80% of light transmits through the pigment) are typical, having small
particle size (that is about 100 nanometers).
[0034] In accordance with principles well known to those skilled in the art, the concentration
of pigment will be chosen to achieve the optical density desired in the final image.
The amount of pigment will depend on the thickness of the active coating and the absorption
of the colorant. Optical densities greater than 1.3 at the wavelength of maximum absorption
are typically required. Even higher densities are typical. Optical densities in the
2-3 range or higher are achievable with application of this invention.
[0035] A dispersant is usually used in combination with the pigment in order to achieve
maximum color strength, transparency and gloss. The dispersant is generally an organic
polymeric compound and is used to separate the fine pigment particles and avoid flocculation
and agglomeration of the particles. A wide range of dispersants is commercially available.
A dispersant will be selected according to the characteristics of the pigment surface
and other components in the composition as known by those skilled in the art. However,
one class of dispersant suitable for practicing the invention is that of the AB dispersants.
The A segment of the dispersant adsorbs onto the surface of the pigment. The B segment
extends into the solvent into which the pigment is dispersed. The B segment provides
a barrier between pigment particles to counteract the attractive forces of the particles,
and thus to prevent agglomeration. The B segment should have good compatibility with
the solvent used. The AB dispersants of utility are generally described in US 5,085,698.
Conventional pigment dispersing techniques, such as ball milling, sand milling, etc.,
can be employed.
[0036] The pigment is present in an amount of from about 25 to about 95% by weight, typically
about 35 to about 65% by weight, based on the total weight of the composition of the
colorant-containing layer.
[0037] Although the above discussion was directed to color proofing, the element and process
of the invention apply equally to the transfer of other types of materials in different
applications. In general, the scope of the invention is intended to include any application
in which solid material is to be applied to a receptor in a pattern.
[0038] The colorant-containing layer may be coated on the base element from a solution in
a suitable solvent, however, it is typical to coat the layer(s) from a dispersion.
Any suitable solvent can be used as a coating solvent, as long as it does not deleteriously
affect the properties of the assemblage, using conventional coating techniques or
printing techniques, for example, gravure printing. A typical solvent is water. The
colorant-containing layer may be applied by a coating process accomplished using the
WaterProof® Color Versatility Coater sold by DuPont, Wilmington, DE. Coating of the
colorant-containing layer can thus be achieved shortly before the exposure step. This
also allows for the mixing of various basic colors together to fabricate a wide variety
of colors to match the Pantone® color guide currently used as one of the standards
in the proofing industry.
Thermal Amplification Additive
[0039] A thermal amplification additive is typically present in the thermally imageable
colorant-containing layer, but may also be present in the ejection layer(s) or subbing
layer.
[0040] The function of the thermal amplification additive is to amplify the effect of the
heat generated in the heating layer and thus to further increase sensitivity to the
laser. This additive should be stable at room temperature. The additive can be (1)
a decomposing compound which decomposes when heated, to form gaseous by-products(s),
(2) an absorbing dye which absorbs the incident laser radiation, or (3) a compound
which undergoes a thermally induced unimolecular rearrangement which is exothermic.
Combinations of these types of additives may also be used.
[0041] Decomposing compounds of group (1) include those which decompose to form nitrogen,
such as diazo alkyls, diazonium salts, and azido (-N3) compounds; ammonium salts;
oxides which decompose to form oxygen; carbonates or peroxides. Specific examples
of such compounds are diazo compounds such as 4-diazo-N,N' diethyl-aniline fluoroborate
(DAFB). Mixtures of any of the foregoing compounds can also be used.
[0042] An absorbing dye of group (2) is typically one that absorbs in the infrared region.
Examples of suitable near infrared absorbing NIR dyes which can be used alone or in
combination include poly(substituted) phthalocyanine compounds and metal-containing
phthalocyanine compounds; cyanine dyes; squarylium dyes; chalcogenopyryioacrylidene
dyes; croconium dyes; metal thiolate dyes; bis(chalcogenopyrylo) polymethine dyes;
oxyindolizine dyes; bis(aminoaryl) polymethine dyes; merocyanine dyes; and quinoid
dyes. When the absorbing dye is incorporated in the ejection or subbing layer, its
function is to absorb the incident radiation and convert this into heat, leading to
more efficient heating. It is typical that the dye absorb in the infrared region.
For imaging applications, it is also typical that the dye have very low absorption
in the visible region.
[0043] Absorbing dyes also of group (2) include the infrared absorbing materials disclosed
in U.S. Patent Nos. 4,778,128; 4,942,141; 4,948,778; 4,950,639; 5,019,549; 4,948,776;
4,948,777 and 4,952,552.
[0044] When present in the colorant-containing layer, the thermal amplification weight percentage
is generally at a level of about 0.95-about 11.5%. The percentage can range up to
about 25% of the total weight percentage in the colorant-containing layer. These percentages
are non-limiting and one of ordinary skill in the art can vary them depending upon
the particular composition of the layer.
[0045] The colorant-containing layer generally has a thickness in the range of about 0.1
to about 5 micrometers, typically in the range of about 0.1 to about 1.5 micrometers.
Thicknesses greater than about 5 micrometers are generally not useful as they require
excessive energy in order to be effectively transferred to the receiver.
[0046] Although it is typical to have a single colorant-containing layer, it is also possible
to have more than one colorant-containing layer, and the different layers can have
the same or different compositions, as long as they all function as described above.
The total thickness of the combined colorant-containing layers are usually in the
range given above.
Stabilizer
[0047] A useful stabilizer is the substituted phenolic compound defined by the structures
(1), (2), (3) or (4) of group (a). Typically, stabilizers under structure (a)(1) as
defined above include 2,6-di-t-butyl-4-methyl-phenol and butylated hydroxyanisole
(BHA). Typically, stabilizers having structure (a)(2) as defined above include 4,4'-methylene-bis-2,6-di-t-butyl-4-methyl-phenol
and 4,4'-ethylene-bis-2,6-di-t-butyl-4-methyl-phenol. Typically, stabilizers having
structure (a)(3) as defined above include 5,5'-di-t-butyl-2,2',4,4'-tetrahydroxybenzophenone
and 2,2',4,4'-tetrahydroxybenzophenone. Typically, stabilizers having structure (a)(4)
as defined above include n-octadecyl 3-(3,5-di-tert-butyl-4-hydroxyphenyl)propionate.
[0048] Another type of stabilizer includes an amine type compound defined by the structures
(1), (2), (3), (4) or (5) of group (b). Typically, stabilizers having structure (b)(1)
as defined above include diethylhydroxylamine (DEHA) and dibenzylhydroxylamine (DBHA).
Typically, stabilizers having structure (b)(2) as defined above include 2,6-diisopropyl-N,N-dimethyl
aniline. Typically, stabilizers having structure (b)(3) as defined above include phenidone
A (1-pheny-3-pyrazolidinone) manufactured by Aldrich, phenidone B (4-methyl-1-phenyl-3-pyrazolidinone)
manufactured by Mallinckrodt, Dimezone® (4,4-dimethyl-1-phenyl-3-pyrazolidinone) manufactured
by Mallinclcrodt, and Dimezone® S (4-hydroxymethyl-4-methyl-1-phenyl-3-pyrazolidinone)
manufactured by Mallinckrodt. Typically, stabilizers having structure (b)(4) as defined
above include decanedioic acid, such as bis(2,2,6,6-tetramethyl-4-piperidinyl)ester
commercially available under the name TINUVIN® 770; bis(1,2,2,6,6-pentamethyl-4-piperidinyl)ester
commercially available under the name TINUVIN® 292, and bis(2,2,6,6-tetramethyl-1-(octyloxy)-4-piperidinyl)ester
commercially available under the name TINUVIN® 123 which are manufactured by Ciba
Specialty Chemicals. Typically, stabilizers under structure (b)(5) include 3,5-Pyridinedicarboxylic
acid, 1,4-dihydro-2,6-dimethyl-4-(2-nitrophenyl)-, dimethyl ester sold under the name
UVENP349PINA® and 3,5-Pyridinedicarboxylic acid, 1,4-dihydro-2,6-dimethyl-1,4-diphenyl-,
dimethyl ester sold under the name UV-DPP337PINA® by Honeywell Specialty Chemicals.
[0049] The stabilizer may serve to protect the thermal amplification additive, more typically
the NIR dye, by eliminating species in the thermally imageable element that would
prematurely bleach the NIR dye and/or by reducing the effects of ambient air as the
thermally imageable element ages.
[0050] The stabilizer is typically present in the amount of about 0.2 to about 2.0 % by
weight, more typically in the amount of about 0.3 to about 1.0 % by weight, based
on the total weight of the components of the thermally imageable layer. A mixture
of more than one of the phenolic stabilizers or a mixture of more than one of the
amine stabilizers or a mixture of phenolic and amine stabilizers may be used.
Additional Additives
[0051] Other materials can be present as additives in the colorant-containing layer as long
as they do not interfere with the essential function of the layer. Examples of such
additives include coating aids, plasticizers, flow additives, slip agents, antihalation
agents, antistatic agents, surfactants, and others which are known to be used in the
formulation of coatings. However, it is typical to minimize the amount of additional
materials in this layer, as they may deleteriously affect the final product after
transfer. Additives may add unwanted color for color proofing applications, or they
may decrease durability and print life in lithographic printing applications.
Additional layers:
[0052] The thermally imageable element may have additional layers. For example, an antihalation
layer may be used on the side of the flexible ejection layer opposite the colorant-containing
layer. Materials which can be used as antihalation agents are well known in the art.
Other anchoring or subbing layers can be present on either side of the flexible ejection
layer and are also well known in the art.
[0053] In some embodiments of this invention, a material functioning as a heat absorber
and a colorant is present in a single layer, termed the top layer. Thus the top layer
has a dual function of being both a heating layer and a colorant-containing layer.
The characteristics of the top layer are the same as those given for the colorant-containing
layer. A typical material functioning as a heat absorber and colorant is carbon black.
[0054] Yet additional thermally imageable elements may comprise alternate colorant-containing
layer or layers on a support. Additional layers may be present depending of the specific
process used for imagewise exposure and transfer of the formed images. Some suitable
thermally imageable elements are disclosed in US 5,773,188, US 5,622,795, US 5,593,808,
US 5,156,938, US 5,256,506, US 5,171,650 and US 5,681,681.
Receiver Element
[0055] The receiver element (20), shown in Figure 2, is the part of the laserable assemblage,
to which the exposed areas of the thermally imageable layer, typically comprising
a polymeric binder and a pigment, are transferred. In most cases, the exposed areas
of the thermally imageable layer will not be removed from the thermally imageable
element in the absence of a receiver element. That is, exposure of the thermally imageable
element alone to laser radiation does not cause material to be removed, or transferred.
The exposed areas of the thermally imageable layer, are removed from the thermally
imageable element only when it is exposed to laser radiation and the thermally imageable
element is in contact with or adjacent to the receiver element. In one embodiment,
the thermally imageable element actually touches the surface of the image receiving
layer of the receiver element.
[0056] The receiver element (20) may be non-photosensitive or photosensitive. The non-photosensitive
receiver element usually comprises a receiver support (21) and a image receiving layer
(22). The receiver support (21) comprises a dimensionally stable sheet material. The
assemblage can be imaged through the receiver support if that support is transparent.
Examples of transparent films for receiver supports include, for example polyethylene
terephthalate, polyether sulfone, a polyimide, a poly(vinyl alcohol-co-acetal), polyethylene,
or a cellulose ester, such as cellulose acetate. Examples of opaque support materials
include, for example, polyethylene terephthalate filled with a white pigment such
as titanium dioxide, ivory paper, or synthetic paper, such as Tyvek® spunbonded polyolefin.
Paper supports are typical for proofing applications, while a polyester support, such
as poly(ethylene terephthalate) is typical for a medical hardcopy and color filter
array applications. Roughened supports may also be used in the receiver element.
[0057] The image receiving layer (22) may comprise one or more layers wherein optionally
the outermost layer is comprised of a material capable of being micro-roughened. Some
examples of materials that are useful include a polycarbonate; a polyurethane; a polyester;
polyvinyl chloride; styrene/acrylonitrile copolymer; poly(caprolactone); poly(vinylacetate),
vinylacetate copolymers with ethylene and/or vinyl chloride; (meth)acrylate homopolymers
(such as butyl-methacrylate) and copolymers; and mixtures thereof. Typically the outermost
image receiving layer is a crystalline polymer or poly(vinylacetate) layer. The crystalline
image receiving layer polymers, for example, polycaprolactone polymers, typically
have melting points in the range of about 50 to about 64°C, more typically about 56
to about 64°C, and most typically about 58 to about 62°C. Blends made from 5-40% Capa®
650 (melt range 58-60°C) and Tone® P-300 (melt range 58-62°C), both polycaprolactones,
are particularly useful as the outermost layer in this invention. Typically, 100%
of CAPA 650 or Tone P-300 is used. However, thermoplastic polymers, such as polyvinyl
acetate, have higher melting points (softening point ranges of about 100 to about
180°C). Useful receiver elements are also disclosed in US Patent 5,534,387 wherein
an outermost layer optionally capable of being micro-roughened, for example, a polycaprolactone
or poly(vinylacetate) layer is present on the ethylene/vinyl acetate copolymer layer
disclosed therein. The ethylene/vinyl acetate copolymer layer thickness can range
from about 0.5 to about 5 mils and the polycaprolactone layer thickness from about
2 to about 100 mg/dm
2. Typically, the ethylene/vinyl acetate copolymer comprising more ethylene than vinyl
acetate.
[0058] One preferred example is the WaterProof® Transfer Sheet sold by DuPont under Stock
# G06086 having coated thereon a polycaprolactone or poly(vinylacetate) layer. This
image receiving layer can be present in any amount effective for the intended purpose.
In general, good results have been obtained at coating weights in the range of about
5 to about 150 mg/dm
2, typically about 20 to about 60 mg/dm
2.
[0059] In addition to the image receiving layer or layers described above, the receiver
element may optionally include one or more other layers between the receiver support
and the image receiving layer. A useful additional layer between the image receiving
layer and the support is a release layer. The receiver support alone or the combination
of receiver support and release layer is referred to as a first temporary carrier.
The release layer can provide the desired adhesion balance to the receiver support
so that the image-receiving layer adheres to the receiver support during exposure
and separation from the thermally imageable element, but promotes the separation of
the image receiving layer from the receiver support in subsequent steps. Examples
of materials suitable for use as the release layer include polyamides, silicones,
vinyl chloride polymers and copolymers, vinyl acetate polymers and copolymers and
plasticized polyvinyl alcohols. The release layer can have a thickness in the range
of about 1 to about 50 microns.
[0060] A cushion layer which is a deformable layer may also be present in the receiver element,
typically between the release layer and the receiver support. The cushion layer may
be present to increase the contact between the receiver element and the thermally
imageable element when assembled. Additionally, the cushion layer aids in the optional
micro-roughening process by providing a deformable base under pressure and optional
heat. Furthermore, the cushion layer provides excellent lamination properties in the
final image transfer to a paper or other substrate. Examples of suitable materials
for use as the cushion layer include copolymers of styrene and olefin monomers; such
as, styrene/ethylene/butylene/styrene, styrene/butylene/styrene block copolymers,
ethylene-vinylacetate and other elastomers useful as binders in flexographic plate
applications.
[0061] Methods for optionally roughening the surface of the image receiving layer include
micro-roughening. Micro-roughening may be accomplished by any suitable method. One
specific example, is by bringing it in contact with a roughened sheet typically under
pressure and heat. The pressures used may range from about 800 +/- about 400 psi.
Optionally, heat may be applied up to about 80 to about 88°C (175 to 190°F) more typically
about 54.4°C (130°F) for polycaprolactone polymers and about 94°C (200°F) for poly(vinylacetate)
polymers, to obtain a uniform micro-roughened surface across the image receiving layer.
Alternatively, heated or chilled roughened rolls may be used to achieve the micro-roughening.
[0062] It is typical that the means used for micro-roughening of the image receiving layer
has a uniform roughness across its surface. Typically, the means used for micro-roughening
has an average roughness (Ra) of about 1 µ and surface irregularities having a plurality
of peaks, at least about 20 of the peaks having a height of at least about 200 nm
and a diameter of about 100 pixels over a surface area of about 458 µ by about 602
µ.
[0063] The roughening means should impart to the surface of the image receiving layer an
average roughness (Ra) of less than about 1 µ, typically less than about 0.95 µ, and
more typically less than about 0.5 µ, and surface irregularities having a plurality
of peaks, at least about 40 of the peaks, typically at least about 50 of the peaks,
and still more typically at least about 60 of the peaks, having a height of at least
about 200 nm and a diameter of about 100 pixels over a surface area of about 458 µ
by about 602 µ These measurements are made using Wyco Profilometer (Wyko Model NT
3300) manufactured by Veeko Metrology, Tucson, AZ.
[0064] The outermost surface of the receiver element may further comprise a gloss reading
of about 5 to about 35 gloss units, typically about 20 to about 30 gloss units, at
an 85° angle. A GARDCO 20/60/85 degree NOVO-GLOSS meter manufactured by The Paul Gardner
Company may be used to take measurements. The glossmeter should be placed in the same
orientation for all readings across the transverse direction orientation.
[0065] The topography of the surface of the image receiving layer may be important in obtaining
a high quality final image with substantially no micro-dropouts.
[0066] The receiver element is typically an intermediate element in the process of the invention
because the laser imaging step is normally followed by one or more transfer steps
by which the exposed areas of the thermally imageable layer are transferred to the
permanent substrate.
PERMANENT SUBSTRATE
[0067] One advantage of the process of this invention is that the permanent substrate for
receiving the colorant-containing image can be chosen from almost any sheet material
desired. For most proofing applications a paper substrate is used, typically the same
paper on which the image will ultimately be printed. Most any paper stock can be used.
Other materials which can be used as the permanent substrate include cloth, wood,
glass, china, most polymeric films, synthetic papers, thin metal sheets or foils,
etc. Almost any material which will adhere to the thermoplastic polymer layer (34),
can be used as the permanent substrate.
PROCESS STEPS
Exposure:
[0068] The first step in the process of the invention is imagewise exposing the laserable
assemblage to laser radiation. The exposure step is typically effected at a laser
fluence of about 600 mJ/cm
2 or less, most typically about 250 to about 440 mJ/cm
2. The laserable assemblage comprises the thermally imageable element and the receiver
element.
[0069] The assemblage is normally prepared following removal of a coversheet(s), if present,
by placing the thermally imageable element in contact with the receiver element such
that colorant-containing layer actually touches the image receiving layer on the receiver
element. Vacuum and/or pressure can be used to hold the two elements together. As
one alternative, the thermally imageable and receiver elements can be held together
by fusion of layers at the periphery. As another alternative, the thermally imageable
and receiver elements can be taped together and taped to the imaging apparatus, or
a pin/clamping system can be used. As yet another alternative, the thermally imageable
element can be laminated to the receiver element to afford a laserable assemblage.
The laserable assemblage can be conveniently mounted on a drum to facilitate laser
imaging.
[0070] Various types of lasers can be used to expose the laserable assemblage. The laser
is typically one emitting in the infrared, near-infrared or visible region. Particularly
advantageous are diode lasers emitting in the region of about 750 to about 870 nm
which offer a substantial advantage in terms of their small size, low cost, stability,
reliability, ruggedness and ease of modulation. Diode lasers emitting in the range
of about 780 to about 850 nm are most typical. Such lasers are available from, for
example, Spectra Diode Laboratories (San Jose, CA). The device used for applying an
image to the image receiving layer is the Creo Spectrum Trendsetter, which utilizes
lasers emitting near 830 nm.
[0071] The exposure may take place through the optional ejection layer or subbing layer
and/or the heating layer of the thermally imageable element. The optional ejection
layer or subbing layer or the receiver element having a roughened surface, must be
substantially transparent to the laser radiation. The heating layer absorbs the laser
radiation and assists in the transfer of the colorant-containing material. In some
cases, the ejection layer or subbing layer of the thermally imageable element will
be a film that is transparent to infrared radiation and the exposure is conveniently
carried out through the ejection or subbing layer. In other cases, these layers may
contain laser absorbing dyes which aid in material transfer to the image receiving
element.
[0072] The laserable assemblage is exposed imagewise so that the exposed areas of the thermally
imageable layer are transferred to the receiver element in a pattern. The pattern
itself can be, for example, in the form of dots or line work generated by a computer,
in a form obtained by scanning artwork to be copied, in the form of a digitized image
taken from original artwork, or a combination of any of these forms which can be electronically
combined on a computer prior to laser exposure. The laser beam and the laserable assemblage
are in constant motion with respect to each other, such that each minute area of the
assemblage, i.e., "pixel" is individually addressed by the laser. This is generally
accomplished by mounting the laserable assemblage on a rotatable drum. A flat bed
recorder can also be used.
Separation:
[0073] The next step in the process of the invention is separating the thermally imageable
element from the receiver element. Usually this is done by simply peeling the two
elements apart. This generally requires very little peel force, and is accomplished
by simply separating the thermally imageable support from the receiver element. This
can be done using any conventional separation technique and can be manual or automatic
without operator intervention.
[0074] Separation results in a laser generated color image, also known as the colorant-containing
image, typically a halftone dot image, comprising the transferred exposed areas of
the thermally imageable colorant-containing layer, being revealed on the image receiving
layer of the receiver element. Typically the colorant-containing image formed by the
exposure and separation steps is a laser generated halftone dot color image formed
on a crystalline polymer layer, the crystalline polymer layer being located on a first
temporary carrier which may or may not have a layer present directly on it prior to
application of the crystalline polymer layer.
Additional Steps:
[0075] The so revealed colorant-containing image on the image receiving layer may then be
transferred directly to a permanent substrate or it may be transferred to an intermediate
element such as an image rigidification element, and then to a permanent substrate.
Typically, the image rigidification element comprises a support having a release surface
and a thermoplastic polymer layer.
[0076] The so revealed colorant-containing image on the image receiving layer is then brought
into contact with, typically laminated to, the thermoplastic polymer layer of the
image rigidification element resulting in the thermoplastic polymer layer of the rigidification
element and the image receiving layer of the receiver element encasing the colorant-containing
image. A WaterProof® Laminator, manufactured by DuPont is preferably used to accomplish
the lamination. However, other conventional means may be used to accomplish contact
of the colorant-containing image carrying receiver element with the thermoplastic
polymer layer of the rigidification element. It is important that the adhesion of
the rigidfication element support having a release surface to the thermoplastic polymer
layer be less than the adhesion between any other layers in the sandwich. The novel
assemblage or sandwich is highly useful, e.g., as an improved image proofing system.
The support having a release surface may then removed, typically by peeling off, to
reveal the thermoplastic film. The colorant-containing image on the receiver element
may then be transferred to the permanent substrate by contacting the permanent substrate
with, typically laminating it to, the revealed thermoplastic polymer layer of the
sandwich. Again a WaterProof® Laminator, manufactured by DuPont, is typically used
to accomplish the lamination. However, other conventional means may be used to accomplish
this contact.
[0077] Another embodiment includes the additional step of removing, typically by peeling
off, the receiver support resulting in the assemblage or sandwich comprising the permanent
substrate, the thermoplastic layer, the colorant-containing image, and the image receiving
layer. In a more typical embodiment, these assemblages represent a printing proof
comprising a laser generated halftone dot color thermal image formed on a crystalline
polymer layer, and a thermoplastic polymer layer laminated on one surface to said
crystalline polymer layer and laminated on the other surface to the permanent substrate,
whereby the color image is encased between the crystalline polymer layer and the thermoplastic
polymer layer.
Formation of multicolor images:
[0078] In proofing applications, the receiver element can be an intermediate element onto
which a multicolor image is built up. A thermally imageable element having a thermally
imageable colorant-containing layer comprising a first pigment is exposed and separated
as described above. The receiver element has a colorant-containing image formed with
the first pigment, which is typically a laser generated halftone dot color thermal
image. Thereafter, a second thermally imageable element having a thermally imageable
colorant-containing layer different than that of the first thermally imageable element
forms a laserable assemblage with the receiver element having the of the first pigment
and is imagewise exposed and separated as described above. The steps of (a) forming
the laserable assemblage with a thermally imageable element having a different pigment
than that used before and the previously imaged receiver element, (b) exposing, and
(c) separating are sequentially repeated as often as necessary in order to build the
multi-colorant-containing image of a color proof on the receiver element.
[0079] The rigidification element may then be brought into contact with, typically laminated
to, the multiple colorant-containing images on the image receiving element with the
last colorant-containing image in contact with the thermoplastic polymer layer. The
process is then completed as described above.
EXAMPLES
[0080] These non-limiting examples demonstrated the processes and products described herein
wherein images of a wide variety of colors were obtained. All temperatures throughout
the specification were in °C (degrees Centigrade) and all percentages were weight
percentages unless indicated otherwise.
Example 1:
[0081] This example shows the effectiveness of the stabilizers in combination with an NIR
dye when a film is aged in a roll storage environment.
[0082] The following control cyan solution was made and coated to 15 mg/sq dm using a #9
wire round rod onto 60% T Chrome on 4 mil Melinex® 573 (DuPont):
Ingredients |
% Solids |
% Dispersant |
%Pigment |
Control Cyan Donor Solution (100 g sol'n) |
Distilled Water |
0 |
0 |
0 |
73.6 |
Polymer 11 |
37.4 |
100 |
0 |
22.2 |
Penn Color 30S330 |
40 |
16 |
24 |
3.53 |
G/S2,6 |
|
|
|
|
Crysta Lyn 5511433 |
100 |
100 |
0 |
0.145 |
PEG 68004 |
100 |
100 |
0 |
0.415 |
Zonyl® FSD(43%FC)5 |
100 |
100 |
0 |
0.103 |
Total (per 100g of solution) |
10.38 |
NA |
NA |
100 |
1 is an acrylic latex copolymer of 74% methyl methacrylate and 24% butyl methacrylate |
2 is manufactured by Penn Color, PA. |
3 is an NIR dye, CAS# 162093-14-3, λmax = 819 nm, ε = 229,0003 CAS Name: H-Indolium, 2-[2-[3-[(1,3-dihydro-1,3,3-trimethyl-2H-indol-2-ylidene)ethylidene]-2-(2-pyrimidinylthio)-1-cyclopenten-1-yl]ethenyl]-1,3,3-trimethyl-,
salt with trifluoromethanesulfonic acid (1:1) |
4 is polyethylene glycol, MW 6800 |
5 is a fluorocarbon surfactant |
[0083] A film size of 23.25" x 31.25' was prepared for each sample tested.
[0084] Additional cyan films were made the same way using the control composition, but with
a given percentage of stabilizer replacing a proportionate amount of polymer 1. The
resulting films in Table 1 were compared for aging properties:
TABLE 1
Film |
Additive |
% Additive |
1 (Control) |
none |
0 |
2 |
DEHA1 |
0.4 |
3 |
Phenidone2 |
0.4 |
4 |
Dimezone S3 |
0.5 |
5 |
DBHA4 |
0.5 |
1Diethylhydroxylamine |
21-Phenyl-3-pyrazolidone |
34-Hydroxymethyl-4-methyl-1-phenylpyrazolidone |
4Dibenzylhydroxylamine |
[0085] A VIS-NIR spectrum of each film coated fresh revealed that the starting dye quantity
in each film (maximum at 848 nm) was roughly the same using the cyan pigment maximum
of 613 nm as an internal standard. The optical density ratio of maximum at 848nm to
maximum at 613 nm averaged 0.61 +/-0.01 (std dev). Each film was rolled lengthwise
to a diameter of roughly 2 inches and suspended in the dark in a 40 F/40 RH controlled
temperature/humidity oven for 4 days and then removed.
[0086] The aged films were compared through spectral analysis and by evaluating the image
quality of a 50% tint when exposed under control conditions on the CREO Trendsetter.
The % NIR dye remaining was calculated by determining the percentage change in NIR
dye in each aged film relative to its corresponding fresh film. The 50% tint image
quality rated on a numerical scale: 0 = poor, 1 = fair, 2 = good. Table 2 shows these
results.
TABLE 2
Aged Film Comparison |
Film |
% NIR Dye Remaining |
Image Quality |
1 (Control) |
6 |
0.5 |
2 |
59 |
1.5 |
3 |
48 |
2.0 |
4 |
53 |
2.0 |
5 |
63 |
2.0 |
[0087] Films 2-5 which possess stabilizer additives exhibit improved dye survival relative
to the no additive control film 1. This improved dye survival is correlated to the
preservation of image quality of the imaged film that is aged.
Example 2:
[0088] This example shows the effectiveness of stabilizers to improve NIR dye stability
when a film is aged where stale/stagnant air is present and the film is passively
exposed to this air. This condition could be typical of what a film experiences in
a packaged environment.
[0089] The same control cyan solution.from Example 1 was made and coated to 14 mg/sq dm
using a #8 wire round rod onto 60% T Chrome on 4 mil Melinex® 573 (DuPont). A film
size of 23.25" x 31.25' was prepared for each sample tested.
[0090] Additional cyan films were made the same way using the control composition, but with
a given percentage of additive replacing a proportionate amount of polymer 1. The
resulting films in Table 3 were compared for aging properties:
TABLE 3
Film |
Additive |
% Additive |
6 (Control) |
none |
0 |
7 |
DEHA |
0.4 |
8 |
Uvinul® 30501 |
0.5 |
9 |
Helisorb® 202 |
0.67 |
10 |
DBHA |
0.5 |
11 |
UV-ENP 3493 |
0.7 |
12,2',4,4'-Tetrahydroxybenzophenone |
25,5'-Di-t-butyl-2,2',4,4'-tetrahydroxybenzophenone |
33,5-Pyridinedicarboxylic acid, 1,4-dihydro-2,6-dimethyl-4-(2-nitrophenyl)-, dimethyl
ester |
[0091] A VIS-NIR spectrum of each film coated fresh revealed that the starting dye quantity
in each film (maximum at 848 nm) was roughly the same using the cyan pigment maximum
of 613 nm as an internal standard. The OD ratio of maximum at 848nm to maximum at
613 nm averaged 0.61 +/-0.02 (std dev). Each film was rolled lengthwise into a tube
having a diameter of roughly 2 inches so that the coated side of the film faced the
interior of the tube. The tube was then suspended in the dark in a 40 F/40 RH controlled
temperature/humidity oven for 4 days and then removed.
[0092] The aged films were sampled only at the interior portion of the tube (roughly an
area of 6" x 31.25") and compared through spectral analysis. The % NIR dye remaining
was calculated by determining the percentage change in NIR dye in each aged film relative
to its corresponding fresh film. Table 4 shows these results.
TABLE 4
Aged Film Comparison |
Film |
% NIR Dye Remaining |
6 (Control) |
66 |
7 |
82 |
8 |
82 |
9 |
79 |
10 |
83 |
11 |
77 |
[0093] Films 7-11 which possess stabilizer additives exhibit improved dye survival relative
to the no additive control film 6.
1. A thermally imageable element comprising a thermally imageable layer, wherein the
thermally imageable layer comprises a thermal amplification additive and a stabilizer
which is at least one
amine type compound having a structure:

or

wherein:
m is an integer ranging from 1 to about 20; each R2 independently represents a hydrogen atom or alkyl group having 1 to about 12 carbon
atoms or an alkoxy group having 1 to about 12 carbon atoms;
R4 is an alkyl group of 1 to about 12 carbon atoms or an aryl group of 6 to about 20
carbon atoms;
R5 is a hydrogen atom, alkyl group of 1 to about 12 carbon atoms or hydroxy methyl group;
R6 is an aryl group of 6 to about 20 carbon atoms;
R7 is a hydrogen atom or an aryl group of 6 to about 20 carbon atoms; and
R8 is a hydrogen atom or nitro group.
2. The thermally imageable element of Claim 1 further comprising a base element comprising
a support and a heating layer.
3. The thermally imageable element of Claim 2 further comprising an ejection or subbing
layer present on the support, between the support and the heating layer.
4. The thermally imageable element of Claim 1 wherein the thermally imageable layer further
comprises a colorant
5. The thermally isnageable element of Claim 4 wherein the colorant is a pigment dispersion.
6. The thermally imageable element of Claim 1 wherein the amine type compound is diethylhydroxylamine,
dibenzylhydroxylamine, 2,6-diisopropyl-N,N-dimethylaniline, diethylhydroxylamine,
dibenzylhydroxylamine, 1-pheny-3-pyrazolidhione, 4-methyl-1-phenyl-3-pyrazolidinone,
4,4-dimethyl-1-phenyl-3-pyrazolidinone, 4-hydroxymethyl-4-methyl-1-phenyl-3-pyrazolidinone,
or 3,5-pyridinedicarboxylic acid, 1,4-dihydro-2,6-dimethyl-4-(2-nitrophenyl)-, dimethyl
ester.
7. The thermally imageable element of Claim 1 wherein the stabilizer is present in the
amount of about 0.2 to about 2.0% by weight, based on the total weight of the thermally
imageable layer.
8. The thermally imageable element of Claim 1 wherein the thermal amplification additive
is an absorbing dye.
9. The thermally imageable element of Claim 8 wherein the absorbing dye is selected from
the group consisting of poly(substituted) phthalocyanine compounds; metal-containing
phthalocyanine compounds; cyanine dyes; squarylium dyes; chalcogenopyryioacrylidene
dyes; croconium dyes; metal thiolate dyes; bis(chalcogenopyrylo) polymethine dyes;
oxyindolizine dyes; bis(aminoaryl) polymethine dyes; merocyanine dyes; and quinoid
dyes.
10. A method for making a color image comprising:
(1) imagewise exposing to laser radiation a laserable assemblage comprising:
(A) a thermally imageable element comprising a thermally imageable layer, wherein
the thermally imageable layer comprises a thermal amplification additive and a stabilizer
which is at least one
amine type compound having the generic structure:




or

wherein:
m is an integer ranging from 1 to about 20;
each R2 independently represents a hydrogen atom or alkyl group having 1 to about 12 carbon
atoms or an alkoxy group having 1 to about 12 carbon atoms;
R4 is an alkyl group of 1 to about 12 carbon atoms or an aryl group of 6 to about 20
carbon atoms;
R5 is a hydrogen atom, alkyl group of 1 to about 12 carbon atoms or hydroxy methyl group;
R6 is an aryl group of 6 to about 20 carbon atoms;
R7 is a hydrogen atom or an aryl group of 6 to about 20 carbon atoms;
R8 is a hydrogen atom or nitro group;
and
(B) a receiver element comprising:
(c) a receiver support; and
(d) an image receiving layer provided on the surface of the receiver support; and
whereby the exposed areas of the thermally imageable layer are transferred to the
receiver element to form a colorant-containing image on the image receiving layer;
and
(2) separating the thermally imageable element (A) from the receiver element (B),
thereby revealing the colorant-containing image on the image receiving layer of the
receiver element.
11. The method of Claim 10 wherein the thermal amplification additive is an absorbing
dye.
12. The method of Claim 11 wherein the absorbing dye is selected from the group consisting
of poly(substituted) phthalocyanine compounds; metal-containing phthalocyanine compounds;
cyanine dyes; squarylium dyes; chalcogenopyryioacrylidene dyes; croconium dyes; metal
thiolate dyes; bis(chalcogenopyrylo) polymethine dyes; oxyindolizine dyes; bis(aminoaryl)
polymethine dyes; merocyanine dyes; and quinoid dyes.
13. The thermally imageable element of Claim 1 in which the stabilizer comprises a combination
of a phenolic type compound of formula (a) and an amine type compound of formula (b).
14. The method of Claim 10 in which the stabilizer comprises a combination of a phenolic
type compound of formula (a) and an amine type compound of formula (b).