TECHNICAL FIELD
[0001] The present invention relates to a method for producing Ti or Ti alloys through reduction
by Ca, in which a metallic chloride containing titanium tetrachloride (TiCl
4) is reduced by Ca to produce Ti metals or Ti alloys.
BACKGROUND ART
[0002] A Kroll method for reducing TiCl
4 by Mg is generally used as a method for industrially producing the Ti metals. TiCl
4 is obtained by chlorinating titanium oxide (TiO
2). In the Kroll method, the Ti metals are produced through a reduction step and a
vacuum distillation step. In the reduction step, TiCl
4 is reduced by Mg in a reactor vessel. In the vacuum distillation step, unreacted
Mg and MgCl
2 formed as a by-product are removed from the sponge metallic Ti produced in the reactor
vessel.
[0003] In the reduction step, the reactor vessel is filled with the molten Mg, and the TiCl
4 liquid is supplied from above on a liquid surface of the molten Mg. This allows TiCl
4 to be reduced by Mg near the liquid surface of the molten Mg to generate the particulate
metallic Ti. The generated Ti metals move sequentially downward. At the same time,
the molten MgCl
2 which is of the by-product is generated near the liquid surface. A specific gravity
of molten MgCl
2 is larger than that of the molten Mg. The molten MgCl
2 which is of the by-product moves downward due to the specific-gravity difference,
and the molten Mg emerges in the liquid surface instead. The molten Mg is continuously
supplied to the liquid surface by the specific-gravity difference substitution, and
the reducing reaction of TiCl
4 proceeds continuously.
[0004] In the production of Ti metals by the Kroll method, a high-purity product is produced.
However, the production cost is increased and the price of the product becomes remarkably
expensive. One of factors of increased production cost is the difficulty in enhancing
a feed rate of TiCl
4. The following items (a) to (c) are cited as the reason why the feed rate of TiCl
4 is restricted.
[0005] (a) In order to improve productivity in the Kroll method, it is effective to enhance
the feed rate of TiCl
4, i.e., to enhance a supply amount of molten Mg to the liquid surface per unit area
or unit time. However, when the feed rate of TiCl
4 is excessively enhanced, the rate of the specific-gravity difference substitution
cannot keep up with the reaction rate, so that while MgCl
2 remains in the liquid surface, TiCl
4 is supplied to the MgCl
2. As a result, the supplied TiCl
4 becomes lower grade chloride gases (referred to as "unreacted gas") such as an unreacted
TiCl
4 gas and a TiCl
3 gas, and the unreacted gas is discharged outside the reactor vessel, which reduces
utilization efficiency of TiCl
4. It is necessary to avoid the generation of the unreacted gas, because a rapid increase
in inner pressure of the reactor vessel is associated with the generation of the unreacted
gas. Thus, there is a limit of the feed rate of TiCl
4 because of the above reasons.
[0006] (b) When the feed rate of TiCl
4 is enhanced, Mg vapor generated from the liquid surface of the molten Mg reacts with
TiCl
4 vapor to increase a precipitation amount of Ti in the inner surface of the reactor
vessel above the liquid surface of the molten Mg. On the other hand, the level of
the liquid surface of the molten Mg rises as the reducing reaction proceeds. Therefore,
the precipitated Ti in the inner surface of the upper portion of the reactor vessel
is immersed in the molten Mg at a later stage of the reducing reaction, which causes
the effective area of the Mg liquid surface to be decreased to reduce the reaction
rate. In order to suppress the decrease of reaction rate, it is necessary that the
feed rate of TiCl
4 be restricted to prevent the Ti precipitation in the inner surface of the upper portion
of the reactor vessel.
Japanese Patent Application Publication No. 8-295955 proposes a method in which the reaction efficiency is enhanced by supplying liquid
TiCl
4 in a dispersive manner to the liquid surface in which the molten Mg exists, and thereby
the Ti precipitation is suppressed in the inner surface of the upper portion of the
reactor vessel. However, the method proposed in
Japanese Patent Application Publication No. 8-295955 is not enough to suppress the Ti precipitation.
[0007] (c) In the Kroll method, because the reaction is performed only near the liquid surface
of the molten Mg in the reactor vessel, an exothermic area is narrowed and the temperature
is locally elevated. Therefore, cooling becomes difficult, so that the feed rate of
TiCl
4 is restricted.
[0008] Although the feed rate of TiCl
4 is not directly affected, in the Kroll method, Ti is generated in the particulate
form near the liquid surface of the molten Mg, and aggregated because of wetting properties
(adhesion properties) of the molten Mg, and the Ti particles is made move downward
while aggregated, and then the Ti particles are sintered to grow the Ti particles
by the heat generated from the molten liquid during the downward travel. Therefore,
it makes difficult to recover the generated Ti by taking out Ti as fine particles
to the outside of the reactor vessel, whereby the continuous production is difficult
to perform and the improvement of the productivity is fettered. By reason of this,
the Ti is produced in the batch process in the form of the sponge titanium.
[0009] With reference to the Ti production methods except for the Kroll method, for example,
US Patent No. 2205854 describes that, in addition to Mg, for example, Ca can be used as the reducing agent
of TiCl
4.
US Patent No. 4820339 describes a method for producing Ti through the reducing reaction by Ca, in which
the molten salt of CaCl
2 is held in the reactor vessel, the metallic Ca powder is supplied into the molten
salt from above, Ca is dissolved in the molten salt, and TiCl
4 gas is supplied from below to react the dissolved Ca with TiCl
4 in the molten salt of CaCl
2.
[0010] In the reduction by Ca, the Ti metals are generated from TiCl
4 by the reaction of the following chemical formula (1), and CaCl
2 as the by-product is also generated at the same time:

Ca has an affinity for Cl stronger than that of Mg, and Ca is suitable to the reducing
agent of TiCl
4 in principle. Particularly, in the method described in
US Patent No. 4820339, Ca is used while dissolved in the molten CaCl
2. When the reducing reaction by Ca is utilized in the molten CaCl
2, an area (reaction field) where the reaction is created is enlarged compared with
the Kroll method in which TiCl
4 is supplied to the liquid surface of the reducing agent in the reactor vessel. Therefore,
because the exothermic area is also enlarged to facilitate the cooling, the feed rate
of TiCl
4 can be largely enhanced, and the remarkable improvement of the productivity can be
also expected.
[0011] However, the method described in
US Patent No. 4820339 is hardly adopted as the industrial Ti production method. In the method, because
the highly expensive metallic Ca powder is used as the reducing agent, the production
cost is higher than that of the Kroll method.
US Patent No. 2845386 describes another Ti production method (Olsen method) in which TiO
2 is directly reduced by Ca not through TiCl
4. The method described in
US Patent No. 2845386 is a kind of oxide direct-reduction method and is highly efficient. However, the
oxide direct-reduction method is not suitable to the production of the high-purity
Ti because it is necessary to use high-purity TiO
2.
DISCLOSURE OF THE INVENTION
[0012] It is an object of the present invention to provide a method for economically producing
a high-purity Ti metals or high-purity Ti alloys with high efficiency, without using
an expensive reducing agent.
[0013] In order to achieve the above object, the present inventors consider it indispensable
that TiCl
4 be reduced by Ca, and the present inventors look into the method for utilizing Ca
dissolved in the molten salt of CaCl
2 described in
US Patent No. 4820339.
In the method described in
US Patent No. 4820339, Ca in the molten salt is consumed in the reducing reaction reactor vessel as the
reaction expressed by the chemical formula (1) proceeds, and it is necessary to continuously
supply the metallic Ca powder to the reduction reactor vessel. However, in order to
industrially establish the method for producing Ti through reduction by Ca, the present
inventors propose a method for controlling a dissolved Ca concentration in the molten
salt by electrolysis, in consideration of the fact that it is necessary that the consumed
Ca of the molten salt in the reducing reaction is economically replenished.
[0014] That is, when the molten CaCl
2 is electrolyzed in a reactor cell, electrode reactions expressed by the following
chemical formulas (2) and (3) proceed to generate a Cl
2 gas near the surface of a anode electrode while generating Ca near the surface of
a cathode electrode , which allows the Ca concentration to be increased in the molten
salt. Therefore, when TiCl
4 is supplied to CaCl
2 so as to react with Ca generated on the cathode electrode side, because Ca consumed
in the Ti generation is replenished as needed, the replenishment of metallic Ca from
the outside or extraction of metallic Ca becomes unnecessary, which allows the Ti
metals to be economically produced.

[0015] The method for replenishing Ca, consumed in the reduction of TiCl
4, with Ca generated by the electrolysis can also be achieved by respectively performing
the reduction and the electrolysis in a reduction cell and an electrolytic cell to
circulate the molten CaCl
2 between the cells. However, when TiCl
4 is supplied to the molten CaCl
2 in the reactor cell so as to react with Ca generated on the cathode electrode side
by the electrolysis, the reactor cell can commonly be used as the reduction cell and
the electrolytic cell. Therefore, because it is not necessary to separately provide
the reduction cell and the electrolytic cell, there is also a great advantage from
a viewpoint of installation cost compared with the case in which the molten CaCl
2 is circulated between the reduction cell and the electrolytic cell.
[0016] The present invention is made based on the above conception, and the gist of the
present invention pertains to a method for producing Ti or Ti alloys.
That is, a method for producing Ti or Ti alloys through reducing reaction by Ca includes:
a reduction electrolysis step comprising holding a molten salt in a reactor cell to
perform electrolysis in the molten salt in the reactor cell, the molten salt containing
CaCl
2 and having Ca dissolved in the molten salt and generating Ti or Ti alloys in the
molten salt by supplying a metallic chloride containing TiCl
4 to the molten salt so as to react with Ca generated on a cathode electrode side by
the electrolysis; and a Ti separation step of separating Ti or the Ti alloy from the
molten salt in the reactor cell or outside the reactor cell.
[0017] The method of the present invention for producing Ti or Ti alloys through reduction
by Ca is a method of reducing TiCl
4 in which a high-purity material is easily obtained, so that the method of the present
invention can produce high-purity Ti metals or high-purity Ti alloys.
Ca is used as the reducing agent to cause the metallic chloride containing TiCl
4 to react with Ca in the molten salt containing CaCl
2, so that the feed rate of TiCl
4 can be increased. Because the Ti particles or Ti alloy particles are generated in
CaCl
2, the aggregation of the particles and the particle growth caused by the sintering
are significantly lessened, whereby it becomes possible to discharge these particles
outside reactor cell, thus enabling the continuous operation to be performed. The
reducing reaction and the electrolytic reaction are simultaneously caused to proceed,
and Ca is replenished by the electrolytic reaction while consumed in the reducing
reaction, which allows Ca to be utilized in the state in which Ca is always dissolved
in the molten salt.
Accordingly, the production method of the present invention can efficiently and economically
produce high-purity Ti metals or high-purity Ti alloys.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0018]
Fig. 1 is a block diagram showing a Ti metal production apparatus which exhibits an
embodiment mode according to the present invention.
BEST MODE FOR CARRYING OUT THE INVENTION
1. Contents of Ti or Ti Alloy Production Method according to the Invention
[0019] In the method according to the present invention for producing Ti or Ti alloys through
reduction by Ca, for example, when the molten CaCl
2 is held as the molten salt in a reactor cell to supply TiCl
4 to the molten salt in the reactor cell, TiCl
4 is reduced by Ca dissolved in the molten salt to generate Ti metals in the form of
the particulate or powder (hereinafter referred to as "Ti particles"). Although the
Ca dissolved in the molten salt is consumed in association with the generation of
the Ti particles, Ca is generated on the cathode electrode side to replenish the consumed
Ca dissolved in the molten salt because the electrolysis of the molten CaCl
2 proceeds simultaneously with the reducing reaction in the reactor cell.
[0020] One of the reasons why the Ca is not conventionally used in the industrial production
of the Ti metals is the difficulty in separating Ca and CaCl
2. Mg is produced by electrolyzing MgCl
2, and the generated Mg can efficiently be recovered because Mg is hardly dissolved
in MgCl
2. Similarly to Mg, Na can efficiently be produced by electrolyzing NaCl. On the other
hand, Ca is produced by electrolyzing CaCl
2, and it is difficult to efficiently separate only Ca because the generated Ca is
dissolved in CaCl
2 by about 1.5%. There is also a phenomenon in which the dissolved Ca generates CaCl
2 by a back reaction (reaction in which Ca generated on the cathode electrode side
is combined with Cl
2 generated on the anode electrode side to return to CaCl
2). Therefore, the production efficiency of Ca becomes worse. In this regard, although
a recovery factor of Ca is improved by applying the contrivance such as cooling the
electrod, the production cost of Ca inevitably remains to be still high.
[0021] In contrast, in the method of the present invention for producing Ti or Ti alloys
through reduction by Ca, Ca dissolved in the molten CaCl
2 is used and the separation of Ca is not necessary, so that the electrolysis production
cost of Ca can be decreased.
When the reduction by Ca is utilized in the molten CaCl
2, the reducing reaction field is expanded and the heat generation/exothermic area
is also enlarged. Mg has vapor pressure of 6.7 kPa (50 mmHg) at 850 °C while Ca has
extremely small vapor pressure of 0.3 kPa (2 mmHg). Therefore, in the case where Ca
is used for the reduction, the Ti precipitation amount becomes dramatically lessened
in the inner surface of the upper portion of the reactor cell compared with Mg. Accordingly,
in the method of the present invention for producing Ti or Ti alloys through reduction
by Ca, the feed rate of TiCl
4 can largely be increased.
In addition, Ca is inferior in wetting properties (adhesion properties) to Mg, and
Ca adhering to the precipitated Ti particles is dissolved in CaCl
2, so that the aggregation in the generated titanium particles and the particle growth
caused by the sintering are significantly lessened. Therefore, the generated Ti can
be taken out from the reactor cell in the form of particles, and the Ti production
can continuously be operated.
[0022] For a supply mode of TiCl
4 to the molten CaCl
2 liquid, it is particularly desirable that TiCl
4 be directly supplied in the gaseous state inside the molten CaCl
2 liquid, because the contact efficiency of TiCl
4 to Ca in the molten CaCl
2 liquid is enhanced. Alternatively, it is also possible that TiCl
4 is supplied in the gaseous or liquid state to the liquid surface of the molten CaCl
2 liquid, or it is also possible that the liquid or gaseous TiCl
4 is supplied to the liquid surface or inside the molten Ca liquid held on the molten
CaCl
2 liquid.
In the case where the reducing reaction is performed by supplying the TiCl
4 liquid to the liquid surface of the molten Ca held on the surface of the molten CaCl
2 liquid, it is desirable that the molten Ca liquid be held in a thin state to an extent
in which Ca in the molten CaCl
2 liquid can be utilized. When the Ca layer is thin, because Ca in the molten CaCl
2 liquid is also involved in the reaction, the reaction is rendered to take place at
the molten Ca layer as well as at the molten CaCl
2 layer, and the Ti can continuously be generated even if the specific-gravity difference
substitution cannot keep up with the reaction rate due to the increase in feed rate
of TiCl
4.
[0023] With reference to the supply of the TiCl
4 gas, an advantage of the method of the present invention for producing Ti or Ti alloys
through reduction by Ca over the Kroll method will be described as below.
In the Kroll method, the TiCl
4 liquid is supplied to the liquid surface of the molten Mg liquid. It is tried that
the TiCl
4 gas is supplied into the molten Mg liquid in order to enlarge the reaction field.
However, as described above, because the Mg has the high vapor pressure, the Mg vapor
intrudes in a supply nozzle of the TiCl
4 gas to react with TiCl
4, which causes a supply nozzle to be choked.
On the other hand, it is also tried that the TiCl
4 gas is supplied inside the molten MgCl
2 liquid. Although a choking frequency of the supply nozzle is decreased, the supply
nozzle choking problem still remains. This is attributed to the fact that the melt
is agitated by bubbling of the TiCl
4 gas and sometimes the molten Mg reaches the supply nozzle. As much as anything, even
if TiCl
4 is supplied inside the molten MgCl
2 liquid, the reducing reaction is difficult to occur because Mg is hardly dissolved
in the molten salt.
[0024] On the contrary, in the method of utilizing the reduction by Ca, the nozzle choking
is hardly generated and the TiCl
4 gas can be supplied inside the molten CaCl
2 liquid. One of the reasons why the nozzle choking is hardly generated is the small
vapor pressure of the molten Ca.
That is, in the method of the present invention for producing Ti or Ti alloys through
reduction by Ca, it is particularly desirable that TiCl
4 be directly supplied in the gaseous state inside the molten CaCl
2 liquid, and this supply mode can be applied without any problem in the actual operation.
It is also possible that the liquid or gaseous TiCl
4 is supplied to the liquid surface of the molten CaCl
2 liquid, or it is also possible that the liquid or gaseous TiCl
4 is supplied to the liquid surface or inside the molten Ca liquid held on the molten
CaCl
2 liquid.
[0025] In separating the Ti particles generated in the molten CaCl
2 liquid, it is possible to separate the Ti particles from the molten CaCl
2 liquid either in the reactor cell or outside the reactor cell. However, the separation
becomes the batch process when the separation is performed in the reactor cell. In
order to improve the productivity, the Ti particles and the molten CaCl
2 liquid may be separated from each other outside the reactor cell by utilizing the
Ti generated in the particulate form to discharge the Ti particles outside the reactor
cell along with the molten CaCl
2 liquid. The Ti particles can simply be separated from the molten CaCl
2 liquid by a squeezing operation and the like by means of mechanical compression.
[0026] In the case where Ti is produced by the method of the present invention, usually
TiCl
4 is used as a raw material. The Ti alloy can also be produced by using a mixture of
TiCl
4 and other metallic chloride. Because TiCl
4 and other metallic chloride are simultaneously reduced by Ca, the Ti alloy can be
produced by this method. Said other metallic chloride may be used either in the gaseous
or liquid state.
[0027] In the method of the present invention for producing Ti or Ti alloys through reduction
by Ca, the back reaction and the wearing of the reactor material become of issues.
In the back reaction, Ca (Ca generated on the cathode electrode side or unreacted
Ca) in the molten CaCl
2 is combined with Cl
2 generated on the anode electrode side to return to CaCl
2. The wearing of the reactor material is caused by high reactivity of Ca.
When the back reaction is generated, the electrolytic current is consumed for the
back reaction, which decreases current efficiency. Particularly, for the back reaction
in which Ca generated on the cathode electrode side is combined with Cl
2 generated on the anode electrode side, it is desirable to separate the inside of
the cell into the anode electrode side and the cathode electrode side by providing
a partition wall (see Fig. 1) whose lower portion is opened.
[0028] For the problem of the wearing of the reactor material, the molten salt is formed
not by single CaCl
2 but by the mixed salt, and a melting point of the molten salt is decreased to effectively
decrease the temperature of the molten salt (namely, bath temperature).
That is, in the method of the present invention for producing Ti or Ti alloys through
reduction by Ca, basically CaCl
2 having the melting point of 780 °C is used as the molten salt. However, a binary
system molten salt such as CaCl
2-NaCl and CaCl
2-KCl and a ternary system molten salt such as CaCl
2-NaCl-KCl can also be used such that at least one kind of other salts (for example,
NaCl, KCl, LiCl, and CaF
2) is mixed to CaCl
2 to form a multiple system molten salt. Therefore, because the melting point of the
salt is decreased, the temperature of the molten salt (bath temperature) can be decreased.
For example, when CaCl
2 and NaCl (having the melting point of about 800 °C) are mixed together, the melting
point can be decreased to about 500 °C at the lowest.
As a result, the extension of reactor material life and the reactor material cost
reduction can be achieved, and further the vaporization of Ca or the salt can be suppressed
from the liquid surface.
2. Embodiment mode of Ti or Ti Alloy Production Method of the Invention
[0029] An embodiment mode of the present invention will be described below with reference
to the drawing.
Fig. 1 is a block diagram showing a Ti metals production apparatus according to an
embodiment mode of the present invention. A reactor cell 1 in which the reducing reaction
and the electrolytic reaction are concurrently generated is used in the embodiment.
The reactor cell 1 holds the Ca-rich molten CaCl
2 in which a relatively large amount of Ca is dissolved. CaCl
2 has the melting point of about 780 °C, and the molten salt of CaCl
2 is heated to the temperature of the melting point or more.
[0030] In the reactor cell 1, the molten CaCl
2 which is of the molten salt is electrolyzed by passing the electric current between
a anode electrode 2 and a cathode electrode 3, the Cl
2 gas is generated on the side of anode electrode 2, and Ca is generated on the side
of cathode electrode 3. In the example, the inside of the reactor cell 1 is divided
into the anode electrode side and the cathode electrode side by a partition wall 4.
However, in the partition wall 4, the lower portion is opened in order that the transfer
of the molten salt is not prevented.
In the reactor cell 1, the gaseous TiCl
4 is injected in the dispersive manner inside the molten salt on the cathode electrode
side in parallel with the electrolysis of the molten salt. Therefore, the injected
TiCl
4 is reduced to generate the particulate metallic Ti by the Ca dissolved in the molten
salt. The generated Ti particles moves downward by the specific gravity difference
and accumulated at the bottom on the cathode electrode side in the reactor cell 1.
[0031] The Ti particles accumulated at the bottom of the reactor cell 1 are discharged from
the reactor cell 1 along with the molten salt existing at the bottom of the reactor
cell 1, and the Ti particles and the molten salt are sent to the Ti separation step
(not shown). In the Ti separation step, the Ti particles discharged along with the
molten salt from the reactor cell 1 are separated from the molten salt. Specifically,
the Ti particles are compressed to squeeze the molten salt. The Ti particles obtained
in the Ti separation step is melted to yield Ti ingots.
On the other hand, the molten salt separated from the Ti particles in the Ti separation
step is the molten salt after use, in which Ca is consumed to decrease the Ca concentration.
It is desirable to reuse the molten salt after use by returning it to the reactor
cell. Usually, both the above separated molten salt and the molten salt after use
separately discharged from the reactor cell 1 are introduced to the anode electrode
side in the reactor cell 1.
[0032] Ca in the molten salt is consumed on the cathode electrode side in the reactor cell
1 as the Ti particles are generated by the reducing reaction. However, Ca is generated
near the surface of the cathode electrode 3 in the cell by the electrolysis which
proceeds simultaneously in the cell, and a consumed amount of Ca is replenished by
the Ca generated by the electrolysis. That is, TiCl
4 supplied into the molten salt is sequentially reduced in a direct manner by Ca generated
near the surface of the cathode electrode 3.
[0033] On the other hand, in the desirable mode, the molten salt after use is sent from
the Ti separation step onto the anode electrode side in the reactor cell 1. Therefore,
a unidirectional flow of the molten salt is formed from the anode electrode side toward
the cathode electrode side in the reactor cell 1 to avoid the flow of Ca generated
on the cathode electrode side into the anode electrode side. When the partition wall
4 shown in Fig. 1 is provided, the flow of Ca into the anode electrode side is effectively
prevented by the combination of the partition wall 4 and the formation of the unidirectional
flow. Thus, the molten salt introduced onto the anode electrode side in the reactor
cell 1 is moved onto the cathode electrode side to be replenished with Ca and to become
as the Ca-rich molten salt, thereby enabling to be reused for the reducing reaction.
It is desirable that the Cl
2 gas generated on the anode electrode side in the reactor cell 1 be reused in a chlorination
step (not shown). In the chlorination step, TiCl
4 which is of the raw material of Ti is generated by the chlorination of TiO
2. The generated TiCl
4 is introduced to the reactor cell 1, and TiCl
4 is circularly used to generate the Ti particles by the Ca reduction.
[0034] As described above, in this embodiment mode, the generation of the Ti particles by
the Ca reduction, i.e., the Ca consumption and the Ca replenishment by the electrolysis
are concurrently performed in the reactor cell 1. Therefore, it is not necessary to
replenish or take out Ca in the solid state, and the high-quality Ti particles are
continuously and economically produced by the Ca reduction. The reactor cell 1 is
commonly used as the reduction cell and the electrolytic cell, which contributes largely
to an economical merit from the viewpoint of installation. The flow of Ca generated
on the cathode electrode side into the anode electrode side is avoided in the reactor
cell 1, so that the back reaction in which Ca reacts with the Cl
2 gas generated on the anode electrode side can be prevented.
During the operation, the molten salt is managed at a temperature higher than the
melting point (about 780 °C) of CaCl
2 in the reactor cell 1.
INDUSTRIAL APPLICABILITY
[0035] According to the method of the present invention for producing Ti or Ti alloys through
reduction by Ca, the feed rate of TiCl
4 which is of the raw material can be enhanced, and the continuous production can be
realized. Further, the reducing reaction and the electrolytic reaction are simultaneously
caused to proceed in the reactor cell, and Ca consumed in the reducing reaction can
be replenished by the electrolytic reaction, so that it is not necessary to independently
handle Ca by itself.
Accordingly, the production method of the present invention can effectively be used
as means for efficiently and economically producing high-purity Ti metals or high-purity
Ti alloys, so that the production method of the present invention can widely be applied
as the industrial method for producing Ti or Ti alloys.