BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
Field of the Invention
[0001] The present invention relates to bioassays, and more particularly, to the use of
metallized surfaces to enhance intensity of chemiluminescence species or reactions
in chemiluminescence assays thereby increasing sensitivity and detectability of same.
Background of the Related Art
[0002] The use of light-producing chemical reactions for quantitative detection in biotechnology
is increasing [1-7], especially with regard to chemiluminescence based ligand-binding
assays [1-7]. The attractiveness of chemiluminescence as an analytical tool lies primarily
in the simplicity of detection [8]; the fact that most samples have no unwanted background
luminescence, as is typically observed in fluorescence-based assays [9]; and the fact
that no optical filters are required to separate the excitation wavelengths and scatter
[8], as is also required for fluorescence-based detection [9].
[0003] However, chemiluminescent based detection is currently limited by the availability
of chemiluminescent probes, which is not a factor governing fluorescence based detection
[9]. Both fluorescence and chemiluminescence based technologies do however suffer
from an inherent need for increased sensitivity/detection limits [8, 9]. For fluorescence,
this is governed by the quantum yield of the tagging fluorophore, the level of unwanted
background fluorescence and the photostability of the fluorophore [9], where as for
chemiluminescence, detection is limited by the quantum efficiency of the chemiluminescence
reaction or probe, and the time before depletion of the reactants [8]. For both detection
systems, an increased luminescence yield would clearly benefit overall detectability
and therefore for bioassays, the sensitivity towards a particular analyte.
[0004] Recent developments have provided new technology to enhance fluorescence and that
can increase the system quantum yield [10-13], the photostability of the fluorophore
[10-13] and by using spatially localized excitation can readily remove unwanted background
fluorescence [14]. Specifically, techniques such as Metal-Enhanced Fluorescence (MEF)
[10-20] also called Radiative Decay Engineering [21] and Surface Enhanced fluorescence
(SEF) [22], have used nanosecond decay time fluorophores in close proximity to a variety
of different sized [15] and shape [16,17] noble metal nanostructures to overcome the
shortcomings of fluorescence technique. However, to date no one has found any comparable
systems to overcome the shortcomings of using chemiluminescent based reaction detection
methods.
[0005] US-A-2003/0082633 discloses a means for carrying out chemical preparations wherein reactions can be
accelerated on special chips using microwave energy. The chips contain materials that
efficiently absorb microwave energy, thereby causing chemical reaction rate increases
and the method finds application in protein chemistry and combinatorial chemistry.
[0006] Jian Zhang et al, First Observation of Surface Plasmon-Coupled Electrochemiluminescence",
Chemical Physics Letters, Vol. 393, No. 4-6, 1 August 2004, Pages 483-487, discuss electrochemiluminescence (ECL), which is often used for high sensitivity
detection, and describe a new approach to collecting the ECL signal, by coupling of
the excited state of [Ru(bpy)
3]
2+ with the surface plasmons in a thin gold film, such that the energy then radiates
into a substrate at a defined angle. The authors suggest that the technique may be
useful in chemical and biological assays.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
[0007] The present invention is defined by the scope of the claims and any information that
does not fall within the claims is provided for information only.
[0008] The present invention relates to surface plasmon-coupled chemiluminescence (SPCC),
where the luminescence from chemically induced electronic excited states couple to
surface plasmons in metallized particles or surfaces. Importantly, these plasmonic
emissions emitted from a metallic particle or surface are generated without an external
excitation source but instead from chemically induced electronically excited states.
[0009] The present invention relates to a method for measuring concentration of receptor-ligand
binding complex in a test sample, the method comprising:
providing a metallic surface having positioned thereon a receptor molecule having
affinity for a ligand of interest, wherein the metallic surface comprises metallic
islands, metallic nanostructures, or metallic colloids;
contacting the receptor molecule with the test sample suspected of comprising the
ligand of interest, wherein the ligand of interest will bind to the receptor molecule
to form a receptor-ligand complex;
contacting the receptor-ligand complex with a detector molecule having affinity for
the ligand to form a receptor-ligand-detector complex, wherein the detector molecule
comprises a chemiluminescent label, wherein the chemiluminescent label is positioned
about 5 nm to about 200 nm from the metallic surfaces;
triggering the chemiluminescent label to induce a chemically electronically excited
state to produce chemiluminescence that couples with metallic surface plasmons for
excitement thereof;
irradiating at least the test sample with microwave energy, wherein the microwave
energy has a power input of from about 100 to 150 watts; and
measuring the intensity of radiation emitted from at least the excited metallic surface
plasmons.
[0010] The present disclosure relates to bioassay systems comprising metallic surfaces for
the enhancement of effects of chemiluminescence based reactions positioned near the
metallic surfaces, wherein metallic surface plasmons are excited by a chemically induced
electronically excited state of a chemiluminescent species and radiation emitted therefrom
providing an enhanced signal.
[0011] The present disclosure relates to a bioassay for measuring concentration of receptor-ligand
binding in a test sample, the method comprising:
- (a) preparing metallic structures immobilized on a surface wherein the metallic structures
have positioned thereon a receptor molecule having affinity for a ligand of interest;
- (b) contacting the receptor molecule with the test sample suspected of comprising
the ligand of interest, wherein the ligand of interest will bind to the receptor molecule
to form a receptor-ligand complex;
- (c) contacting the receptor-ligand complex with a detector molecule having affinity
for the ligand to form a receptor-ligand-detector complex, wherein the detector molecule
comprises a chemiluminescent label;
- (d) exposing the chemiluminescent label to a trigger solution that will chemically
react with the chemiluninescent label metal complex to induce a chemically electronically
excited state; and
- (e) measuring the intensity of radiation emitted from exited metallic surface plasmons.
[0012] The metallic surfaces comprise metallic islands, metallic nanostructures, or metallic
colloids. The metallic element may include any form that exhibits surface plasmons
such as noble metals including silver, gold, platinum and copper, and more preferably
the metallic material is silver or gold.
[0013] The present disclosure relates to a method of metal-enhanced chemiluminescence sensing,
comprising:
- (a) applying a metallic material to a surface or within such surface used in a detection
system;
- (b) introducing a solution containing at least one biomolecule for disposing near
the metallic surface, wherein the biomolecule comprises a chemiluminescent label;
- (c) triggering the chemiluminescent label to induce a chemically electronically excited
state thereby generating metallic surface plasmons; and
- (d) measuring the chemiluminescence signal.
[0014] The present disclosure provides a method for detecting a targeted pathogen in a sample,
the method comprising:
- a) providing a system comprising:
- i) a metallic surface, wherein the metallic surface has attached thereto an immobilized
capture nucleic acid sequence probe complementary to a known nucleic acid sequence
of the target pathogen; and
- ii) a free capture nucleic acid sequence probe complementary to the known nucleic
acid sequence of the target pathogen, wherein the free capture nucleic acid sequence
probe has attached thereto a chemiluminescent label;
- b) contacting the sample with the immobilized capture nucleic acid sequence probe,
wherein the nucleic acid sequence of the target pathogen binds to the immobilized
capture nucleic acid sequence probe;
- c) contacting the bound nucleic acid sequence of the target pathogen with the free
capture nucleic acid sequence probe for binding therewith;
- d) introducing a trigger component to chemically react with the chemiluminescent label
thereby creating a chemically induce electronically excited state that induces excited
metallic surface plasmons; and
- e) measuring the chemiluminescence signal intensity, wherein the signal is enhanced
relative to system that does not include metallic surfaces.
[0015] The surface plasmon-coupled chemiluminescence signal may include unpolarized, p-polarized
and/or s-polarized signals.
[0016] The present disclosure relates to a system for measuring chemiluminescence, the system
comprising:
- a) a metallized surface positioned on a surface substrate;
- b) a connector molecule attached to the metallized surface for binding or capture
of a desired molecule in a testing sample;
- c) a detector molecule having an affinity for the desired molecule, wherein the detector
molecule comprises a chemiluminescence label;
- d) a triggering component that chemically reacts with the chemiluminescence label
to generate a chemically induced electronically exited state; and
- e) a measuring device to measure surface plasmon coupled emissions.
[0017] The present disclosure relates to an assay kit, wherein the assay kit comprises
- a) a substrate surface comprising a metallized surface;
- b) a connector component for attachment to the metallized surface having an affinity
for a target component to be determined;
- c) a detector molecule having an affinity for the target component, wherein the detector
molecule comprises a chemiluminescence label;
- d) a triggering component that chemically reacts with the chemiluminescence label
to generate a chemically induced electronically exited state.
[0018] A still further aspect of the present invention relates to the use of low power microwave
energy directed at the detection system comprising at least metallic particles for
heating of the metallic and/or chemical components therein to enhance the detection
system and increase the speed of chemical reactions therein.
[0019] The present disclosure relates to a method for increasing and enhancing chemiluminescence
signals, the method comprising;
- (a) applying a metallic material to a surface or within such surface used in a detection
system;
- (b) introducing a solution containing at least one biomolecule for disposing near
the metallic surface, wherein the biomolecule comprises a chemiluminescent label;
- (c) triggering the chemiluminescent label to induce a chemically electronically excited
state thereby generating metallic surface plasmons;
- (d) irradiating the system with microwave energy; and
- (e) measuring the chemiluminescence signal.
[0020] Other features and advantages of the invention will be apparent from the following
detailed description, drawings and claims.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE FIGURES
[0021]
Figure 1 shows Metal-Enhanced Chemiluminescence (MEC) on a silvered surface, Top,
and photographs showing the enhanced luminescence, Bottom.
Figure 2 shows the metal-enhanced chemiluminescence on a silvered surface as a function
of time, Top, and the intensity of luminescence in terms of seconds, Bottom.
Figure 3 shows the proposed model for Metal-Enhanced Chemiluminescence (MEC). The
chemically induced electronically excited luminophore (C) transfers energy to silver
plasmons (a resonance coupling interaction), which themselves radiate the photophysical
properties of the excited species. CL - Chemiluminescence, MEC - Metal-Enhanced Chemiluminescence,
Ag - Silver.
Figure 4 shows the experimental sample set-up wherein the chemiluminescence species
is placed between two glass slides comprising silver islands deposited thereon.
Figure 5 shows the chemiluminescence intensity measured on both SiFs and glass as
a function of time (Top) and the data normalized (Top-insert). Normalized chemiluminescence
intensity on both SiFs and a continuous silver film (Bottom). Photograph of the emission
from both the continuous silver film and the SiFs (Bottom - insert). Ag - Silver.
SiFs - Silver Island Film.
Figure 6 shows the Experimental geometry used for measuring and/or detecting surface
plasmon-coupled chemiluminescence (SPCC). Top, view from the top; bottom, side view.
Figure 7 shows surface plasmon-coupled chemiluminescence from 20-nm-thick aluminum
films. Top right, enlarged directional SPCC; top left, free-space chemiluminescence
and SPCC; bottom, emission spectra ofboth the free-space chemiluminescence and SPCC.
Figure. 8 shows surface plasmon-coupled chemiluminescence from 45-nm-thick silver
films. Top right, enlarged directional SPCC; top left, free-space chemiluminescence
and SPCC; bottom, emission spectra of both the free-space chemiluminescence and SPCC.
Figure 9 shows surface plasmon-coupled chemiluminescence from 42-nm-thick gold films.
Top right, enlarged directional SPCC; top left, free-space chemiluminescence and SPCC;
bottom, emission spectra of both the free-space chemiluminescence and SPCC.
Figure 10 shows photographs of the coupled emission at various polarizations for gold,
silver, and aluminum films, top to bottom, respectively, taken at their respective
SPCC peak angles. See location of camera in Figures 7-9 (top right).
Figure 11 shows surface plasmon-coupled chemiluminescence (SPCC) and free-space chemiluminescenoe
from a small sample chamber, top left, and the enlarged coupled region, top right.
Bottom, emission spectra of both free-space chemiluminescence and SPCC from the small
chamber.
Figure 12 shows that chemiluminescence intensity decays from aluminum films for both
free space and coupled (top) and normalized to the same initial intensity (bottom).
Figure 13 shows that chemiluminescence intensity decays from silver films for both
free space and coupled (top) and normalized to the same initial intensity (bottom).
Figure 14 shows a setup for HRP-acridan chemiluminescence assay on both glass and
silvered slides.
Figure 15 shows 3D plots of acridan assay emission as a function of time from glass
slides without (top) and with low-power microwave exposure/pulses (middle). (Bottom)
Photographs showing the acridan emission both before (a) and after a low-power microwave
pulse (b). Mw, microwave pulse. The concentration of BSA-biotin was 1.56 pM.
3D plots of the acridan assay chemiluminescence emission as a function of time from
silvered glass slides (Ag) without and with low-power microwave exposure/pulses were
generated (data not shown). Photographs showing the acridan emission both before (a)
and after a low-power microwave pulse (b) were also generated (not shown). Mw, microwave
pulse. The concentration of BSA-biotin was 1.56 pM.
Figure 17 shows 3D plots of the acridan assay chemiluminescence emission from both
glass (top) and silvered substrates (bottom). (Right) Emission spectra are the average
of 400 1-s time points. In both cases, BSA-biotin was not immobilized to the surfaces, which were exposed to microwave pulses at 100- and 200-s
time points. The final concentration of HRP-streptavidin in the assay was ∼10 µg/mL.
Figure 18 shows the acridan chemiluminescence emission intensity as a function of
time for different concentrations of surface-bound BSA-biotin. a, 156 pM BSA-biotin;
b, 15.6 pM BSA-biotin; c, 1.56 pM BSA-biotin; d, 156 fM BSA-biotin; and e, no BSA-biotin.
Figure 19 shows photon flux integrated over 500 s of the assay shown in Figure 18,
for different concentrations of BSA-biotin from both glass and silvered surfaces (Ag).
Baselines correspond to integrated photon flux over 500 s for glass and silvered surfaces
(Ag) incubated with 1% BSA solution and streptavidin HRP.
Figure 20 shows the procedure for the MT-MEC immunoassay (Mw, low-power microwave
heating).
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION
[0022] Surface plasmons are collective oscillations of free electrons at metallic surfaces.
When a metallic article or surface is exposed to an electromagnetic wave, the electrons
in the metal (plasmons) oscillate at the same frequency as the incident wave. Subsequently,
the oscillating electrons radiate electromagnetic radiation with the same frequency
as the oscillating electrons. It is this re-radiation of light at the same incident
wavelength that is often referred to as plasmon emission. In the present invention
chemically induced electronic excited states (chemiluminescence species) couple to
surfaces plasmons to produce emission intensities greater than from about 5 to 1000-fold,
as compared to a control sample containing no metallic surface. This approach is of
significance for optically amplifying chemiluminescence based clinical assays, potentially
increasing analyte/biospecies detectability.
[0023] The term "biomolecule" means any molecule occurring in nature or a derivative of
such a molecule. The biomolecule can be in active or inactive form. "Active form"
means the biomolecule is in a form that can perform a biological function. "Inactive
form" means the biomolecule must be processed either naturally or synthetically before
the biomolecule can perform a biological function. Exemplary biomolecules include
nucleic acids, aromatic carbon ring structures, NADH, FAD, amino acids, carbohydrates,
steroids, flavins, proteins, DNA, RNA, oligonucleotides, peptide, nucleic acids, fatty
acids, myoglobin, sugar groups such as glucose etc., vitamins, cofactors, purines,
pyrimidines, formycin, lipids, phytochrome, phytofluor, peptides, lipids, antibodies
and phycobiliproptein.
[0024] The term "receptor-ligand" as used herein means any naturally occurring or unnaturally
occurring binding couple wherein the components have affinity for each other. For
example, the binding couple may include an antibody/antigen complex, viral coat ligand/protein
cell receptor or any combination of probe and binding partner. The term "receptor"
refers to a chemical group, molecule, biological agent, naturally occurring or synthetic
that has an affinity for a specific chemical group, molecule, virus, probe or any
biological agent target in a sample. The choice of a receptor-ligand for use in the
present invention will be determined by nature of the disease, condition, or infection
to be assayed.
[0025] Embodiments of the present invention are applicable to chemiluminescence labels or
moieties which participate in light-producing reactions in the presence of a triggering
agent or cofactor. In the present application, for purposes of example and without.limitation,
a preferred embodiment will be discussed in terms of chemiluminescence labels and
triggering agent. The label affixed to the detector molecule will be referred to as
the "label" or "label agent". For purposes herein, "triggering agent or cofactor"
is broadly used to describe any chemical species, other than the chemiluminescence
labels which participates in a reaction and which produces a detectable response.
Chemiluminescence labels and triggering agents produce a light response.
[0026] Examples of suitable chemiluminescenee labels include but without limitation, peroxidase,
bacterial luciferase, firefly luciferase, functionalized iron-porphyrin derivatives,
luminal, isoluminol, acridinium esters, sulfonamide and others. A recent chemiluminescent
label includes xanthine oxidase with hypoxanthine as substrate. The triggering agent
contains perborate, an Fe-EDTA, complex and luminol. Choice of the particular chemiluminescence
labels depends upon several factors which include the cost of preparing labeled members,
the method to be used for covalent coupling to the detector molecule, and the size
of the detector molecules and/or chemiluminescence label. Correspondingly, the choice
of chemiluminescence triggering agent will depend upon the particular chemiluminescence
label being used.
[0027] Chemiluminescent reactions have been intensely studied and are well documented in
the literature [39]. For example, peroxidase is well suited for attachment to the
detector molecule for use as a chemiluminescence. The triggering agent effective for
inducing light emission in the first reaction would then comprise hydrogen peroxide
and luminol. Other triggering agents which could also be used to induce a light response
in the presence of peroxidase include isobutyraldehyde and oxygen.
[0028] Procedures for labeling detector molecules, such as antibodies or antigens with peroxidase
are known in the art. For example, to prepare peroxidase-labeled antibodies or antigens,
peroxidase and antigens or antibodies are each reacted with N-succinimidyl 3-(2-pyridyldithio)
proprionate (hereinafter SPDP) separately. SPDP-labeled peroxidase, or SPDP-labeled
antigen or antibody is then reacted with dithiothreitol to produce thiol-labeled peroxidase,
or thiol-labeled antigen or antibody. The thiol derivative is then allowed to couple
with the SPDF-labeled antigen or antibody, or SPDP-labeled peroxidase.
[0029] Techniques for attaching antibodies or antigens to solid substrates are also well
known in the art. For example, antibodies may be coupled covalently using glutaraldehyde
to a silane derivative of borosilicate glass.
[0030] Although chemiluminescence detection has been successfully implemented, the sensitivity
and specificity of these reactions require further improvements to facilitate early
diagnosis of the prevalence of disease. In addition, most protein detection methodologies,
most notably western blotting, are still not reliable methods for accurate quantification
of low protein concentrations without investing in high-sensitivity detection schemes.
Protein detection methodologies are also limited by antigen-antibody recognition steps
that are generally kinetically very slow and require long incubation times; e.g.,
western blots require processing times in excess of 4 h. Thus, both the rapidity and
sensitivity of small-molecule assays are still critical issues to be addressed to
improve assay detection.
[0031] Thus, in one embodiment, the application of low level microwave heating of the sample
may be used to speed up any biological/biochemical kinetics within the system. Notably,
low level microwaves do not destroy or denature proteins, DNA, or RNA, but instead
heat the sample sufficiently to provide for accelerated kinetics such as binding or
hybridization. In addition, the microwaves are not scattered by the low density silver
metal, which is contrary to most metal objects, such as that recognized by placing
a spoon in a microwave oven.
[0032] Microwaves (about 0.3 to about 300 GHz) lie between the infrared and radio frequency
electromagnetic radiations. It is widely thought that microwaves accelerate chemical
and biochemical reactions by the heating effect, where the heating essentially follows
the principle of microwave dielectric loss. Polar molecules absorb microwave radiation
through dipole rotations and hence are heated, where as non-polar molecules do not
absorb due to lower dielectric constants are thus not heated. The polar molecules
align themselves with the external applied field. In the conventional microwave oven
cavity employed in this work, the radiation frequency (2450 MHz) changes sign 2.45
x 10
9 times per second. Heating occurs due to the tortional effect as the polar molecules
rotate back and forth, continually realigning with the changing field, the molecular
rotations being slower than the changing electric field. The dielectric constant,
the ability of a molecule to be polarized by an electric field, indicates the capacity
of the medium to be microwave heated. Thus, solvents such as water, methanol and dimethyl
formamide are easily heated, where as microwaves are effectively transparent to hexane,
toluene and diethylether.
[0033] For metals, the attenuation of microwave radiation arises from the creation of currents
resulting from charge carriers being displaced by the electric field. These: conductance
electrons are extremely mobile and unlike water molecules can be completely polarized
in 10-18 s. In microwave cavity used in the present invention, the time required for
the applied electric field to be reversed is far longer than this, in fact many orders
of magnitude. If the metal particles are large, or form continuous strips, then large
potential differences can result, which can produce dramatic discharges if they are
large enough to break down the electric resistance of the medium separating the large
metal particles.
[0034] Interestingly, and most appropriate for the new assay platform described herein,
small metal particles do not generate sufficiently large potential differences for
this "arcing" phenomenon to occur. However, as discuss hereinbelow, the charge carriers
which are displaced by the electric field are subject to resistance in the medium
in which they travel due to collisions with the lattice phonons. This leads to Ohmic
heating of the metal nanoparticles in addition to the heating of any surface polar
molecules. Intuitively, this leads to localized heating around the metallic nanostructures
in addition to the solvent, thereby rapidly accelerating assay kinetics.
[0035] In the present invention, microwave radiation may be provided by an electromagnetic
source having a power level in a range between about 100 watts to 150 watts. Any source,
known to one skilled in the art may be used, such as a laser having the capacity to
emit energy in the microwave range. The microwave radiation may be emitted continuously
or intermittently, as desired, to maintain the metallic particles at a predetermined
temperature such that it is capable of increasing the speed of chemical reactions
not only in the assay system but also the chemiluminescence species.
[0036] In the alternative, microwave energy can be supplied through a hollow wave guide
for conveying microwave energy from a suitable magnetron. The microwave energy is
preferably adjusted to cause an increase of heat within the metallic material without
causing damage to any biological materials in the assay system.
[0037] In one embodiment the present invention provides for a metallic surface and a biomolecule
capable of chemiluminescing, wherein the metallic surface and the biomolecule are
separated by at least one film spacer layer. The thickness of said film may be chosen
so as to enhance the chemiluminescence of the biomolecule by positioning the biomolecule
an optimal distance from the metallic surface. The film spacer layer may be one or
multiple layers of a polymer film, a layer formed from a fatty acid or a layer formed
from an oxide. In a preferable embodiment, the film spacer layers and the metallic
surface are chemically inert and do not bind to the biomolecules to be detected or
to intermediates that are bound to the compounds to be detected, for example covalently
bound. The layer formed from a fatty acid may be formed by a Langmuir-Blodgett technique.
The film spacer layer may be a spin coated polymer film. The oxide layer may be formed
from a deposition technique, such as vapor deposition.
[0038] Further, the metallic surface may be in the form of a porous three dimensional matrix.
The three dimensional matrix may be a nano-porous three dimensional matrix. The metallic
surface may include metal colloid particles and/or metal-silica composite particles.
The metallic surface may comprise agglomerated metal particles and/or binary linked
particles or metal particles in a polymer matrix. The three dimensional matrix may
be formed from controlled pore glasses or using matrices assembled from the aggregation
of silver-silica composites themselves. The matrices may be metallic nanoporous matrix,
through which species will flow and be both detected and counted more efficiently.
The ability to quantitatively count single flowing molecules under practical conditions
may have many implications for medical diagnostics, the detection of biohazard organisms
and new and quicker methods for DNA sequencing.
[0039] The emission enhancement may be observed at distances according to the type of chemiluminescence
species to be detected and the type of metal. For example, emission enhancement may
be observed when a chemiluminescence species is positioned about 5 nm to about 200
nm to metal surfaces. Preferable distances are about 5 nm to about 30 nm, and more
preferably, 5 nm to about 20 nm to metal surfaces. At this scale, there are few phenomena
that provide opportunities for new levels of sensing, manipulation, and control, In
addition, devices at this scale may lead to dramatically enhanced performance, sensitivity,
and reliability with dramatically decreased size, weight, and therefore cost.
[0040] Different effects are expected for mirrors, sub-wavelength or semi-transparent metal
surfaces, silver island films or metal colloids. More dramatic effects are typically
observed for islands and colloids as compared to continuous metallic surfaces. The
silver islands have the remarkable effect of increasing the emission intensity at
least 5-fold while decreasing the lifetime 100-fold.
[0041] Light from the chemiluminescence reaction generated by the random depopulation of
a chemically induced electronic state of a luminophore and/or the plasmons coupled
emissions from the metallic components can be detected using an optical detector,
positioned above and/or below reaction sites. Various optical detectors, such as photodiode,
charge-coupled device (CCD), photomultiplier tube (PMT), or photon counting detector,
have different degree of sensitivity. PMT and photon counting detectors can achieve
an electronic amplification factor as high as 10
6-10
8. Conventional PMTs require a
∼1 kV power source, but new miniaturized detector requires: only a 5 V. Most of the
chemiluminescence emission wavelengths are in the visible region. A narrow-band optical
filter may be used to ensure detecting luminescence wavelengths. The system may include
a microactuator, detector, microprocessor, electronics, a display, and translation
stage. The output of the detector may be interfaced to an analog to digital converter
and a microprocessor to calculate analyte concentration.
[0042] It is known that the extinction properties (C
E) of metal particles can be expressed as both a combination of both absorption (C
A) and scattering (C
S) factors, when the particles are spherical and have sizes comparable to the incident
wavelength of light, i.e. in the Mie limit[26].

where k
1 = 2πn
1 / λ
0 is the wavevector of the incident light in medium I and α is the polarizability of
a sphere with radius r, n
1 is the refractive index and λ
0 the incident wavelength. The term |α|
2 is square of the modulus of α.

where ε
1 and ε
m are the dielectric and the complex dielectric constants of the metal respectively.
The first term in equation 1 represents the cross section due to absorption, C
A, and the second term, the cross section due to scattering, C
S. Current interpretation of metal-enhanced fluorescence [23] is one underpinned by
the scattering component of the metal extinction, i.e. the ability of fluorophore-coupled
plasmons to radiate (plasmon scatter) [11]. Intuitively, larger particles have wavelength
distinctive scattering spectra (C
S) as compared to their absorption spectra (C
A) [26], facilitating plasmon coupled emission from the larger nanoparticles.
[0043] Surprisingly, the present invention shows that chemically induced electronic excited
states (chemiluminescence species) also couple to surface plasmons, producing emission
intensities from about 5 to about 1000 fold, as compared to a control sample containing
no surface silver nanostructures. Thus, the present invention further shows that surface
plasmons can be directly excited by chemically induced electronically excited luminophores.
[0044] The present invention provides enhanced emissions using metallized nanostructures,
islands of elliptical, spherical, triangular or rod-like forms. In exemplary cases,
the elliptical islands have aspect ratios of 3/2, and the spherical colloids have
diameters of 20-60 nm. However, the invention is not limited to any particular geometry.
Using known coating techniques, the placement of metallic islands could be controlled
precisely, as close as 50 nm apart.
[0045] Metal island particles may be prepared in clean beakers by reduction of metal ions
using various reducing agents [10-13 and 27]. For example, sodium hydroxide is added
to a rapidly stirred silver nitrate solution forming a. brown precipitate. Ammonium
hydroxide is added to re-dissolve the precipitate. The solution is cooled and dried
quartz slides are added to the beaker, followed by glucose. After stirring for 2 minutes,
the mixture is warmed to 30°C. After 10-15 minutes, the mixture turns yellow-green
and becomes cloudy. A thin film of silver particles has formed on the slides as can
be seen from their brown green color. The slides are rinsed with pure water prior
to use.
[0046] Alternative procedures for preparing metal particles are also available [28-32].
Silver is primarily used because of the familiar color from the longer surface plasmon
absorption of silver.
[0047] Colloids can be prepared as suspensions by citrate reduction metals. Preferred metals
are silver and gold. The size of the colloids and their homogeneity can be determined
by the extensive publications on the optical properties of metal particles available
and the effects of interface chemistry on the optical property of colloids [33].
[0048] Silver island films can be formed by a chemical reduction of a silver salt on the
quartz surface and that are relatively simple to fabricate. However, this approach
does not provide a control of particle size, or distance of the chemiluminescent species
from the metallic surface.
[0049] Metal particles can be bound to a surface by placing functional chemical groups such
as cyanide (CN), amine (NH
2) or thiol (SH), on a glass or polymer substrate. Metal colloids are known to spontaneously
bind to such surfaces with high affinity [34-35].
[0050] Positioning of the biomolecule or metal particle at a desired distance can be achieved
by using a film. The film may be a polymer film, a Langmuir-Blodgett film or an oxide
film. Proper distances may be achieved by using Langmuir-Blodgett films with fatty
acid spacers. The fatty acids may be from natural sources, including concentrated
cuts or fractionations, or synthetic alkyl carboxylic acids. Examples of the fatty
acids include, but not limited to, caprylic (C
8), capric (C
10), lauric (C
12), myristic (C
14), palmitic (C
16), stearic (C
18), oleic (C
18), linoleic (C
18), linolenic (C
18), ricinoleic (C
18) arachidic (C
20), gadolic (C
20), behenic (C22) and erucic (C
22). The fatty acids with even numbered carbon chain lengths are given as illustrative
though the odd numbered fatty acids can also be used.
[0051] Also, metal-chemiluminescence species distances may be achieved by using polymer
films. Examples of the polymer include, but not limited to, polyvinyl alcohol (PVA).
Absorbance measurements and ellipsometry may be used to determine polymer film thickness.
One type of polymer films is spin coated polymer films. The technology of spin coated
polymer spacer films readily allows films to be coated onto a variety of surfaces,
with varied thickness from >0.1
um. The coating can be performed on a spin coater, which allows uniform surface thickness
by varying polymer concentration (viscosity) and spin speed. For example, Model P6700
spin coater (Specialty Coating Systems Inc.) allows uniform surface thickness by varying
polymer concentration (viscosity) and spin speed.
[0052] Metallic colloids (or various other non-spherical shapes/particles) may also be incorporated
into organic polymers, covalently or non-covalently, to form polymeric matrices, wherein
the distance from diffusing species affords an increase in radiative decay rate and
thus, an increase in quantum yield. Such polymeric matrices are ideal for sensing/flowing
sensing applications of low concentration species.
[0053] Any chemiluminescent species may be used in the present invention that provides for
a chemical reaction which produces the excited state responsible for the observed
emission including, but not limited to the following excitation mechanisms:
R● + R'● → R-R +
hv
(single bond formation (radical-radical reaction))
●R● + ●R●'→ R=R +
hv
(double bond formation (radical-radical reaction))
R
+ + e
- → R +
hv
(electron capture)
[0054] This embodiment of the present invention may have vast applications in clinical medicine,
environmental monitoring applications, homeland security such as rapid detection of
low concentration species, industrial processes, pharmaceutical industries such as
monitoring species, and sensors for use in reduced atmospheres such as biohazard clean
rooms and environments using space light.
Examples
1. Radiating Plasmons Generated from Chemically Induced Electronic Excited States
1.2 Materials
[0055] Silver nitrate (99.9%), sodium hydroxide (99.996%), ammonium hydroxide (30%), trisodium
citrate,
D-glucose and premium quality APS-coated glass slides (75×25 mm) were obtained from
Sigma-Aldrich (St. Loius, MO). The blue-glow chemiluminescence sticks used were the
"Color Bright" light sticks, obtained from Omniglow (West Springfield, MA).
1.3 Chemiluminescence
[0056] The chemiluminescent materials used in this study were obtained from commercial light
glow sticks. These glow sticks contain the necessary reacting chemicals encapsulated
within a plastic tube. The plastic tube contains a phenyl oxalate ester and a fluorescent
probe, where the choice of dye simply determines the color of the luminescence [9].
For the examples set forth herein, this choice is arbitrary as long as the luminophore
emits in the visible spectral region, consistent with previous reports [10-13]. Inside
the plastic tube lies a glass capsule containing the activating agent (hydrogen peroxide).
Activation of the chemicals is accomplished with a bend, snap, and a vigorous shake
of the plastic tube which breaks the glass capsule containing the peroxide and mixes
the chemicals to begin the chemiluminescence reaction. The hydrogen peroxide oxidizes
the phenyl oxalate ester to a peroxyacid ester and phenol. The unstable peroxyacid
ester decomposes to a peroxy compound and phenol, the process chemically inducing
an electronic excited state.
1.4 Formation of Silver Island Films (SiFs) on APS-coated Glass Substrates
[0057] The silver island films were made according to previously published procedures employing
the chemical reduction of silver nitrate on glass microscope slides using sodium hydroxide,
ammonium hydroxide and glucose [10-13].
1.5 Chemiluminescence from SiFs and glass
[0058] The chemiluminescence experiments were performed using a blue emission glow stick.
After chemiluminescence initiation, approximately 70 µl of the glow stick fluid was
placed between two APS-coated microscope glass slides, clamped together. The glass
slides contained silver island films on one end and were bare glass on the other end.
The bare end of the glass served as the control sample by which to compare the benefits
of using the metal-enhanced chemiluminescence phenomenon. Subsequently, the enhancement
ratio, the intensity from silver / intensity from glass, could be determined.
1.6 Chemiluminescence measurements
[0059] Chemiluminescence spectra were collected using an Ocean Optics spectrometer, model
SD 2000 (Dunedin, FL), connected to an Ocean Optics 1000 µm diameter fiber with an
NA of 0.22 (Dunedin, FL). The fiber was positioned vertically on top of the slides containing
the luminescening material. Spectra were collected with an integration time ranging
from between 4 and 10 seconds. The integration time was kept constant between the
control and silver island film sample measurements.
1.7 Results
[0060] Figure 1 top shows the luminescence emission spectra from between the silvered glass
and glass plates. The emission from the silvered portion of the slide was spatially
averaged to be about 4-5 times greater than the glass control side of the sample.
In addition, the volume between both the sandwiched glass and silver slides was identical.
Figure 1 - bottom shows the photographs of the slides, both before and after the addition
of the chemiluminescent material. Approximately 70 µL of fluid was enough to form
a thin coating across both portions of the slide, held by capillary action as the
slides were sandwiched as shown in Figure 4. The enhanced chemiluminescence is clearly
visible on the silvered portion as shown in Figure 1 (bottom). Interestingly, the
digital camera was not able to capture the blue emission from the thin fluid layer
of the glass region of the slide, the intensity quite weak as also shown in Figure
1-top.
[0061] Several control experiments were performed to determine the loss of chemiluminescent
intensity, due to the depletion of the reactants, Figure 2. After a period of 60 minutes,
most of the emission from the silvered plates had gone, Figure 2- Top. Interestingly,
the luminescence emission intensity changed very little in several tens of seconds,
Figure 2 - bottom, which was the time needed to measure both the intensity on silver
and glass shown in Figure 1, making the comparison between both silver and glass a
valid one. Finally, while not shown here, the
rate of loss of luminescence was measured from both the silvered and glass portions of the slide.
For both, the rate of chemiluminescence was almost identical, suggesting that no chemical
interaction between the chemiluminescent reagents and silver occurred, the enhanced
luminescence signals observed due to interactions with surface plasmons as discussed
below [23].
[0062] Several detailed control experiments were undertaken to ascertain whether silver
could catalyze the chemiluminescence reaction and account for the enhanced optical
signatures observed, as compared to an interpretation in therms of a chemiluminescence-based
radiating plasmon model. Figure 5 - top shows the luminescence intensity as a function
of time. Clearly the enhanced luminescence from the SiFs is visible, with the initial
intensity on silver ≈ 3100 a.u. (at t = 0) as compared to < 150 on glass. Subsequently
the rates of loss of luminescence were compared after the curves were normalized,
Figure 5 - top insert. The rate of loss of luminescence, which is due to the depletion
of solution reactants and therefore depletion over time of excited states, was found
to follow first order decay kinetics and could simply be modeled to an exponential
function of the form:

where C is the intensity at time t = ∞, B is a pre-exponential factor and k then
rate of luminescence depletion, units S
-1. From Figure 5 - Top insert, the rate of depletion on silver was found to be 1.7
times faster than on glass, 0.034 vs 0.019 s
-1 respectively. Two explanations could initially describe this observation: Firstly,
silver catalysis of the chemiluminescence reaction, or secondly, the high rate of
transfer / coupling of the chemiluminescence to surface plasmons, rapidly reducing
the excited state lifetime of the chemiluminescence species.
[0063] To eliminate silver based catalysis of the chemiluminescence reaction as an explanation
for the enhanced signals, the luminescence rates were measured on both SiFs and a
continuous silver strip. Interestingly, the rate of loss of luminescence was still
found to be greater on the SiFs as compared to the continuous silver strip, Figure
5 - bottom. In addition, the emission intensity was very low indeed from the continuous
strip of silver, Figure 5 - bottom insert. Given that the continuous strip is indeed
darker and that the rate is slower than on SiFs, then silver based catalysis can be
eliminated as a possible explanation of the observation of increased signal intensities
on the SiFs. Subsequently, these observations suggest that chemically induced electronic
excited states (chemiluminescence species) can readily induce/couple to surface plasmons,
facilitating metal-enhanced chemiluminescence.
1.8 Discussion
[0064] With the chemiluminescence species shown here, it is theorized that excited chemiluminescence
species couple to surface plasmons, which is turn radiate the photophysical properties
of the chemically excited state, as shown in Figure 3. Interestingly, the chemiluminescent
system described herein, wherein there is no external excitation source for direct
illumination and no direct mode of excitation of the surface plasmons suggests that
the surface plasmons are indeed excited from a chemically induced electronically excited
state of a luminophore. It is believed that this is the first observation of the chemically
induced electronic excitation of surface plasmons.
2. Directional and Polarized Emission of the Luminescence
[0065] The experimental geometry used for the surface plasmon-coupled chemiluminescence
(SPCC) studies is shown in Figure 6.
2.1 Materials and Methods
[0066] Premium quality APS-coated glass slides (75 × 25 mm), silver wire (99.99+% purity),
aluminum evaporation slugs (99.999% purity), and silicon monoxide pieces (99.99% purity)
were obtained from Sigma-Aldrich (St. Loius, MO). Gold evaporation slugs (99.999%
purity) were obtained from Research and PVD Material Corporation (Wayne, NJ). CoverWell
imaging chamber gaskets with adhesive (20-mm diameter, 1-mm deep) were obtained from
Molecular Probes (Eugene, OR). The smaller imaging chambers were built in-house using
electrical black tape, double sticky tape, and microscope coverslips. Several standard
chemiluminescence kits from Omnioglow (West Springfield, MA) and Night Magic (Union
City, OH) were used as the source of chemiluminescence.
2.2 Chemiluminescent Dyes
[0067] The chemiluminescent materials used in this study were obtained from commercially
available kits and previously described in Example 1.
2.3 Formation of Continuous Thin Films of Metal on APS-Coated Glass Substrates
[0068] Twenty nanometers of aluminum, 45 nm of silver, and 40 nm of gold were deposited
on separate APS-coated glass slides using an Edwards Auto 306 Vacuum Evaporation chamber
(West Sussex, U.K.) under ultrahigh vacuum (<3 × 10
-6 Torr). In each case, the metal deposition step was followed by the deposition of
5 nm of silica via evaporation without breaking vacuum. This step served to protect
the metal surface from attack by the various chemical species present in the chemiluminescence
assay.
2.4 Surface Plasmon-Coupled Chemiluminescence (SPCC) of Dyes on Continuous Metal Films
[0069] The surface plasmon-coupled chemiluminescence (SPCC) experiments were performed using
several different colors of the chemiluminescent dyes ranging from blue to red. They
were carried out by first bending the plastic tube of the chemiluminescence kit and
shaking it vigorously. This allowed the reaction mixtures to mix and begin to luminesce.
The tubes were then cut with a scissor, and the reacting fluid was poured into a glass
vial. Approximately 150 µL of the reacting fluid was then placed in an imaging chamber
gasket with adhesive (20-mm diameter, 1-mm deep). This gasket was then pressed against
an (APS-coated) continuous metal-coated and silica-capped microscope glass slide until
they were stuck together creating a chamber containing the chemiluminescent dyes on
the surface of the metal-coated glass slide. For smaller samples, approximately 50
µL of the reacting fluid was placed in an imaging chamber built in-house attached to
an (APS-coated) continuous metal-coated and silica-capped microscope glass slide.
2.5 Surface Plasmon-Coupled Chemiluminescence (SPCC) Measurements
[0070] The metal-coated slides containing the chemiluminescent dyes were attached to a hemicylindrical
prism made with BK7 glass (
n = 1.52), and the refractive index was matched using spectrophotometric grade glycerol
(
n = 1.475) between the back of the glass slide (uncoated side) and the prism. This
unit was then placed on a precise 360° rotatory stage which was built in-house. The
rotatory stage allowed the collection of light at all angles around the sample chamber.
An Ocean Optics low OH 1000
µm diameter optical fiber with NA of 0.22 (Dunedin, FL) used for collecting the chemiluminescence
signals was mounted on a holder that was screwed onto the base of the rotatory stage.
A pictorial representation of the top and side view of the setup is presented in Figure
6. Surface plasmon-coupled chemiluminescence (SPCC) spectra were collected using a
model SD 2000 Ocean Optics spectrometer (Dunedin, FL) connected to the above-mentioned
optical fiber. The spectra were collected with an integration time between 0.5 and
2 s (depending on the intensity of the various SPCC signals). Both unpolarized and
p- and s-polarized signal information was collected for the SPCC signal (from 0 to
180° with respect to the front of the prism) and for the free-space signal (from 180
to 360° with respect to the front of the prism). A separate time-dependent decay study
was performed on each chemiluminescent dye to study the comparative time-dependent
decay profile of the SPCC signal and the free-space signal.
2.6 Results
[0071] Figure 7 (top left) shows the surface plasmon-coupled chemiluminescence (SPCC) and
the free-space emission from the blue chemiluminescent dye on a 20-nm aluminum layer.
It can be seen that the free-space emission is of much higher magnitude than the SPCC
signal. This is because the sample chamber is 1-mm thick and only the luminophores
within approximately 250 nm of the surface of silver are known to excite surface plasmons
[36, 24]. Hence, the majority of the luminophores in the chamber do not couple to
plasmons and so radiate their energy in the form of free-space emission. Subsequently
there was an attempt to use very thin films of liquid to alleviate this effect. However,
the hydrophobic nature of the surface globulated the chemiluminescence liquid, preventing
films <250 nm thick to be produced.
[0072] Figures 7 (top right) is an enlarged figure showing the highly directional and predominantly
p-polarized SPCC emission only, suggesting that the observed signal is due to surface
plasmons. This is in stark contrast to the free-space emission which does not show
any polarization or directional preference. However, the signal at the SPCC peak angle
is not entirely p-polarized. The camera located at the SPCC peak angle of the figure
depicts the approximate angular position where photographs of the coupled emission
at various polarizations were taken. These photographs are shown in Figure 10. Figure
7 (bottom) is the normalized SPCC and free-space emission spectra showing a high degree
of overlap between the spectra. This suggests the plasmon-coupled chemiluminescence
has not undergone any changes in its spectral properties because of the interaction
between the luminescent species and the metal surface.
[0073] Figure 8 (top left) shows the surface plasmon-coupled chemiluminescence (SPCC) and
the free-space emission from the green chemilummescent dye on a 45-nm silver layer.
Similar to the case of the blue dye on aluminum, it can also be seen here that the
free-space emission is of greater magnitude than the SPCC signal. Figure 8 (top right)
is an enlarged figure showing the highly directional and predominantly p-polarized
SPCC emission only, suggesting that the observed signal is due to surface plasmons.
This again is in stark contrast to the free-space emission which does not show any
polarization or directional preference. Figure 8 (bottom) is the normalized SPCC and
free-space emission spectra showing a high degree of overlap between the spectra,
suggesting no additional interaction between the luminescent species and the metal
surface.
[0074] Figure 9 (top left) shows the surface plasmon-coupled chemiluminescence (SPCC) and
the free-space emission from the red chemiluminescent dye on a 42-nm gold layer. Figure
9 (top right) is an enlarged figure showing the highly directional and predominantly
p-polarized SPCC emission only, suggesting that the observed signal is due to surface
plasmons. The SPCC again is in stark contrast to the free-space emission which does
not show any polarization or directional preference. Figure 9 (bottom) is the normalized
SPCC and free-space emission spectra showing a high degree of overlap between the
spectra, suggesting no other interaction between the luminescent species and the metal
surface.
[0075] Figure 10 shows photographs of the coupled emission (from the prism side) at the
respective SPCC peak angle from the various dyes at both s- and p-polarizations as
well as with no polarization. The approximate angular location of the camera used
obtaining these photographs is marked in Figures 7-9 (top right). This figure clearly
shows that the emission at the SPCC peak angle is predominantly p-polarized for all
three dyes (on all three metals) thus suggesting that surface plasmons are responsible
for the SPCC signal. It can be seen that the p-polarized signal intensity at the SPCC
peak angle is lower in magnitude than the unpolarized signal. This occurs because
the entire SPCC signal consists of both p- and to a lesser degree s-polarized light,
and also because the sheet polarizers used in the experiment have only 30-40% peak
transmission efficiency for both polarizations.
[0076] Initially, the broadness of the SPCC peak angles for all three dyes which varied
between 20 and 25 degrees. Hence, to investigate whether the broadness of the SPCC
peak angle is a function of the surface area of the sample, the experiments were repeated
on silver using the green chemiluminescent dye with a sample chamber that had approximately
half the surface area when compared to the samples made with commercially available
imaging chambers that had been used thus far. Figure 11 (top left) shows the surface
plasmon-coupled chemiluminescence (SPCC) and the free-space emission from the green
chemiluminescent dye on a 45-nm silver layer for the small imaging chambers. Figure
11 (top right) is an enlarged figure showing the highly directional and predominantly
p-polarized SPCC emission only. Here, the broadness of the SPCC peak angle is approximately
20 degrees. It is clear from this figure that the broadness of the SPCC peak angle
is not significantly affected by the surface area of the sample. An interesting observation
in Figure 11 (top right) is the decay in the SPCC signal in the region between 90
and 180 degrees when compared to that in the 0-90 degrees. This is because the data
was collected sequentially from 0 through 360 degrees. As a result, for the small
chamber with a lower volume of reactants, by the time the data in the region between
90 and 180 degrees was collected, a signal reduction is observed because of the depletion
of reactants (depletion of excited states) over time. The broad angle distribution
shown in Figures 7-9 and 11 is attributed to the waveguide effect, given that our
solution of chemiluminescence occupied a sample chamber of 1-mm thickness. Figure
11 (bottom) is the normalized SPCC and free-space emission spectra showing a high
degree of overlap between the spectra, suggesting no additional interaction between
the luminescent species and the metal surface in the smaller imaging chambers built
in-house.
[0077] The next round of experiments was performed to determine the rate of decay of luminescence
for the blue and green chemiluminescent dyes as a function of time for both the free-space
emission and the SPCC emission (with p-polarizers so that only plasmon-coupled emission
was measured). By decay rate, it is meant the decrease in intensity because of depletion
of reagents. The results of these experiments for the blue dye on aluminum and green
dye on silver are shown in Figures 12 and 13, respectively. Figure 12 (top) shows
the decay of free-space and SPCC emission as a function of time for the blue dye on
aluminum, with Figure 12 (bottom) image showing both the decay intensities normalized
to their respective values at t = 0. The rate of loss of luminescence, which is due
to the depletion of solution reactants and therefore a depletion over time of excited
states, was found to follow first-order decay kinetics as shown herein above in formula
(3).
[0078] The rate of depletion of the SPCC signal for the blue dye on aluminum was found to
be only minimally greater than the free-space emission, 0.0003 versus 0.0002 s
-1, respectively. Since both the SPCC signal and the free-space emission signal decay
are highly dependent on the rate of depletion of the same reactants (depletion of
excited states) in the sample chamber over time, it is not surprising that the measured
decay rates for both the signals as shown in Figure 12 are almost identical. However,
this finding does indicate that there are no localized catalytic effects of the aluminum
on the chemiluminescence reaction, as this would be expected to manifest in a larger
difference in the SPCC luminescence decay rate (from the free-space decay rate) than
is currently observed.
[0079] Figure 13. (top) shows the decay of free-space and SPCC emission as a function of
time for the green chemiluminescent dye on silver, and Figure 13 (bottom) shows both
the decay intensities normalized to their respective values at
t = 0. The rate of depletion of the SPCC signal for the green dye on silver was found
to be only minimally smaller than the free-space emission, 0.0005 versus 0.0006 s
-1, respectively. It is again not surprising that the measured decay rates for both
the signals as shown in Figure 12 are almost identical, since both the SPCC signal
and the free-space emission signal decay are highly dependent on the rate of depletion
of the same reactants in the sample chamber over time. This finding again indicates
no localized catalytic or chemical effects of the silver on the chemiluminescence
reaction studied.
2.7 Conclusions
[0080] The results of this study lead us to conclude that chemically induced electronic
excited states of luminophores can excite surface plasmons on thin films of continuous
metal, producing highly polarized and directional emission. This phenomenon is not
restricted to the commercially available kits that were used in this study but rather
can be extended to the myriad of chemiluminescent reactions employed in biotechnology
today to increase signal collection efficiency and hence the sensitivity of such assays.
The typical thickness of the functional surface of such assays are compatible with
an approximately 250-nm coupling region, potentially alleviating unwanted background
signals caused by spontaneous reaction of reagents or unwanted enzymatic activity
and therefore increasing assay sensitivity.
[0081] Another interesting observation is that SPCC occurs with gold films. Since luminophores
within approximately 250 nm of the surface of metal are known to excite surface plasmons,
which is longer than the distances required for nonradiative quenching of luminescence,
the potential of using gold as the metal surface becomes an advantage. This is because
gold is chemically more stable than silver and the surface chemistry of gold is well-known
and characterized [37]. Also, since gold films are widely used in surface plasmon
resonance (SPR), this provides a robust technology base for the mass production of
suitable gold films.
3. Microwave Triggered Metal Enhanced Chemiluminescence
3.1 Materials
[0082] Bovine-biotinamidocaproyl-labeled albumin (biotinlyated BSA), HRP-labeled avidin,
silver nitrate (99.9%), sodium hydroxide (99.996%), ammonium hydroxide (30%), trisodium
citrate, D-glucose, and premium quality APS-coated glass slides (75 × 25 mm) were
obtained from Sigma-Aldrich. CoverWell imaging chamber gaskets with adhesive (20-mm
diameter, 1 mm deep) were obtained from Molecular Probes (Eugene, OR). Steptavidin-HRP
prediluted solution was obtained from Chemicon International Inc. Chemiluminescence
materials were purchased from Amersham Biosciences, (ECL Plus Western blotting detection
kit, RPN2132). ECL Plus utilizes a new technology, developed by Lumigen Inc., based
on the enzymatic generation of an acridinium ester, which produces intense light emission
at ∼430 nm.
3.2 Formation of Silver Island Films on APS-Coated Glass Substrates
[0083] In a typical SiF preparation, a solution of silver nitrate (0.5 g in 60 mL of deionized
water) in a clean 100-mL glass beaker, equipped with a Teflon-coated stir bar, is
prepared and placed on a Corning stirring/hot plate, While stirring at the quickest
speed, 8 drops (∼200
µL) of freshly prepared 5% (w/v) sodium hydroxide solution are added. T his results
in the formation of dark brown precipitates of silver particles. Approximately 2 mL
of ammonium hydroxide is then added, drop by drop, to redissolve the precipitates.
The clear solution is cooled to 5° C by placing the beaker in an ice bath, followed
by soaking the APS-coated glass slides in the solution. While keeping the slides at
5 C, a fresh solution of D-glucose (0.72 g in 15 mL of water) is added. Subsequently,
the temperature of the mixture is then warmed to 30°C. s the color of the mixture
turns from yellow-green to yellow-brown, and the color of the slides become green,
the slides are removed from the mixture, washed with water, and sonicated for 1 min
at room temperature. SiF-deposited slides were then rinsed with deionized water several
times and dried under a stream of nitrogen gas. Prior to assay fabrication and subsequent
chemiluminescent experiments, imaging chamber gaskets with adhesive (20-mm diameter,
1 mm deep) were pressed against the silver-coated and silica-capped microscope glass
slides until they were stuck together, creating a chamber.
3.3 Preparation of the Model Protein Assay (Biotin-Avidin) on Silver Island Films
and on Glass
[0084] The model assay used in the present experiment is based on the well-known interactions
of biotin and avidin. Biotin groups are introduced to the glass and silvered surfaces
through biotinylated BSA, which readily forms a monolayer on the surfaces of glass
and SiFs. Biotinylated BSA is bound to SiFs and the glass by incubating 20
µL of biotinylated BSA solutions with different concentrations in the imaging for ∼1
h. Chambers were washed with water to remove the unbound material. Imaging chambers
were then incubated with 20
µL of 1% aqueous BSA (w/v) for 1 h to minimize nonspecific binding of HRP-streptavidin
to surfaces. Chambers were again washed with water to remove the BSA blocking solution.
Stock solutions of HRP-streptavidin were diluted 1:10 to a final concentration of
100
µg/mL. Twenty microliters of the HRP-streptavidin solution was subsequently added into
the biotinylated BSA-coated glass and SiF-coated imaging chambers and typically microwaves
for 20 s in the microwave cavity (0.7 ft
3, GE compact microwave model JES735BF, max power 700 W). The power setting was set
to 2, which corresponded to 140 W over the entire cavity. In all the experiments performed
with low-power microwaves, there was no evidence of surface drying. Following incubation,
imaging chambers were again washed with water to remove unbound HRP-streptavidin material
prior to the chemiluminescence experiments.
3.4 Chemiluminescence Reagents
[0085] The ECL Western blotting detection kit contained two reagents that yield a bright
chemiluminescent emission at 430 nm upon mixing. Solution A contained the substrate
solution (peroxide formulation), and solution B contained the solution of the luminescent
compound, acridan in dioxane and ethanol. HRP and hydrogen peroxide solution (solution
A) catalyze the oxidation of the acridan substrate (solution B). As a result, acridinium
ester intermediates are formed and further react with peroxide to generate light emission
with a maximum wavelength centered around 430 nm.
3.5 Chemiluminescence from Reagents on SiFs and Glass Surfaces
[0086] The chemiluminescence experiments were performed with and without microwave heating
inside the microwave cavity. During microwave heating, 30-s pulses were applied at
three 100-s intervals. The pulses were applied at 30% power, which corresponded to
210 W over the entire cavity. In order to obtain the same initial chemiluminescence
emission for all measurements, all chemiluminescent assays were undertaken by combining
40µL of solution A with 2.0µL of solution B and immediately adding the entire solution
to the imaging chamber.
[0087] Data collection commenced immediately following addition of reagents and terminated
when the photon count returned to baseline. Since the rate of photon emission is directly
proportional to enzyme concentration, the photon flux was summed for a fixed time
interval to determine the relationship between protein concentration and signal intensity,
cf. Figures 19 and 20.
3.6 Chemiluminescence Detection
[0088] Chemiluminescence spectra were collected using an Ocean Optics spectrometer, model
SD 2000 (Dunedin, FL), connected to an Ocean Optics 1000-mm-diameter fiber with an
NA of 0.22. The fiber was positioned vertically on top of the slides containing the
chemiluminescent reagents inside the microwave cavity. Chemiluminescent spectra and
time-dependent emission intensities were collected with an integration time of 1000
ms for -500 s unless otherwise noted. The integration time was kept constant between
the control and silver island film sample measurements. The
real-color photographs were taken with an Olympus Digital camera (C-740, 3.2 Mega Pixel, 10×
Optical Zoom) without the need for optical filters.
3.7 Results
[0089] To demonstrate protein detection with microwave triggered metal enhanced chemiluminescence
(MT-MEC) on silver island films (SiFs), commercially available chemiluminescent reagents
(acridan and peroxide) from Amersham Biosciences was used. The model protein assay
was constructed with biotinylated BSA surface-modified substrates (SiFs or glass),
horseradish peroxidase-streptavidin (HRP-avidin) and chemiluminescent reagents, as
demonstrated in Figure 14.
[0090] Biotinylated BSA was incubated on silvered or glass substrates fort ∼1 h. A 1% aqueous
BSA solution was subsequently added to minimize nonspecific binding of HRP-streptavidin
to the surfaces. HRP-streptavidin was then added to the surfaces with bound biotinylated
BSA. The strong binding affinity of streptavidin for biotin served as the basis for
the quantitative determination of the BSA-biotin species on the glass and silvered
surfaces. As a result, chemiluminescent reaction rates for these experiments are proportional
to the quantity of bound biotinylated BSA HRP-streptavidin complexes, [38] where the
dynamic range of protein concentration is proportional to the total luminescent photon
flux for a defined time interval.
[0091] Following surface modification of glass and silver surfaces, a comparison was made
between traditional chemiluminescence reaction yields with microwave (Mw) "trigger"
reaction yields. With the addition of the chemiluminescent mixtures to the functionalized
surfaces, the emission data was collected for the MT-MEC assays within the microwave
cavity using a fiber optic that is connected to a spectrofluorometer and a computer
(not shown). The microwave cavity power was ∼140 W. Detection was accomplished through
a fiber delivered through a small opening on the top of the microwave cavity. Imaging
chambers were placed in the microwave, and wells of interest were aligned with the
tip of the fiber to optimize collection efficiencies.
[0092] Figure 15 top shows the first 500 s of collection time for the chemiluminescence
emission from the glass surfaces. Figure 15, bottom, shows the chemiluminescence emission
from the glass substrate under the same initial conditions, but the sample is subjected
to 30-s microwave pulses at ∼100-s intervals. These results clearly show the "on-demand"
nature of microwave-triggered chemiluminescence reactions. The most striking feature
of Figure 15 is the enhancement of the photon flux upon the application of discrete
microwave pulses. In essence, these results demonstrate the feasibility of increasing
reaction rates of chemiluminescent reactions and dramatically improving photon flux
for finite time intervals. As a result, chemiluminescent reactions that typically
generate limited light emission over extended periods of time can be subsequently
accelerated with the addition of low-power microwave pulses.
[0093] Significant enhancement with microwave pulses from silver island films was observed
(data not shown). As compared to the
results of Figure 15 top, it was evident that there is a pronounced increase in photon
flux from the metal surfaces; cf. Figure 15, top, a 3-fold enhancement in signal is
observed from the silvered surfaces (data not shown). These results are further demonstrated
with the insets in Figure 15 that show the real-color photographs of the chemiluminescent
reagents (before and after Mw exposure) on glass and the SiF surfaces. When subjected
to low-power microwaves (data not shown), chemiluminescence from the silver island
films is even further enhanced for the microwave pulse time intervals. It is theorized
that the high photon flux evident upon delivery of microwave pulses to the metal surface
is attributed to localized heating of the metal surfaces. The local temperature increase
not only accelerates the rate of the chemiluminescence reactions, but the proximity
to the silver allows for metal-enhanced chemiluminescence. Thus, a reaction that traditionally
is followed over extended periods of time can be "triggered" in short discrete time
intervals with low-power microwaves.
[0094] The microwave heating of the whole sample (SiFs, HRP, and bulk solution) affects
the enzyme-catalyzed chemiluminescence reactions in two ways: (1) since the enzyme
is only on the surface of the silver nanoparticles, the chemiluminescence reactions
only happen on SiFs, and the dissipated energy by SiFs is thought to lower the energy
required for these reactions; (2) the heating of the solution increases the diffusion
of chemiluminescent species so that the chemiluminescence reactions go faster. Although,
the percent contribution of these factors to the overall reaction rate is unknown,
it is believed that the localized heating effect is more dominant.
[0095] The chemiluminescent reactants and HRP-streptavidin were mixed in solution (100 µg/mL)
to demonstrate that the localized chemiluminescent enhancement in the presence of
silver island films is no longer observed. Data were collected for 400 s, and solutions
were pulsed with low-power microwaves for 30 s at the 100- and 200-s time points during
the course of the reaction. Figure 17, top and bottom, depict a fast signal decay
for the reactions in solution above both glass and silver. In addition, upon application
of the first microwave pulse, a small signal enhancement was evident, which is due
to the few HRP molecules and chemiluminescent reactants that have settled close to
the surfaces. For the second microwave pulse, very little signal enhancement is seen
and, eventually, no signal observed at longer times. It is theorized that this result
affirms the assertion that preferential heating of the nanostructures by microwaves
affords for MT-MEC to be localized in proximity to the silvered surfaces, alleviating
unwanted emission from the distal solution.
[0096] In order to demonstrate the "on-demand" nature of MT-MEC and induce the higher sensitivity
of detection, the amount of biotinylated BSA incubated on the substrate surfaces was
varied to demonstrate the concentration dependence for MT-MEC. Figure 18 shows the
time-dependent chemiluminescent emission of the chemiluminescence reaction on SiFs
and glass surfaces with multiple microwave exposures (four 30-s exposures, 100-s intervals).
As previously observed in Figure 15, the intensity "spikes" correspond to the microwave
pulses that trigger enhanced chemiluminescence from the HRP functionalized substrates.
Each curve (a-e) corresponds to a different concentration of biotinylated BSA incubated
on a silver substrate.
[0097] From Figure 18, it can be determined that the chemiluminescence intensity is proportional
to the concentration of HRP bound to BSA-functionalized surfaces. Thus, this result,
enables the surface protein concentration to be determined. It is important to explain
the characteristics of the chemiluminescent intensity versus time plot, as shown in
Figure 18. In order to determine the concentration of surface proteins without microwave
heating, the change in chemiluminescent intensity was monitored after the chemiluminescent
reactions were initiated (no microwave heating) in the first 100 s. It is seen that,
without microwave heating, the chemiluminescent intensity is slightly increased as
the concentration of BSA is increased but little difference between them is observed,
which proved to be a not useful method. On the other hand, to show the benefits of
microwave heating to increase the detected chemiluminescent signal, four 30-s exposures
(after 100 s) were performed with 100-s intervals to drive the chemiluminescent reactions
to completion within 400 s (without microwave heating the reactions studies here are
completed longer than 30 min). The photon flux (in counts), area under the intensity-time
plot, is an indication of the extent of the HRP-catalyzed reaction and thus provides
information about the presence of surface-bound BSA. The two "peaks" seen after each
microwave exposure, in Figure 18, are a result of the microwave magnetron pulsing.
During the 10- and 5-s runs, the chemiluminescent intensity increases and decreases,
respectively triggered by the magnetron pulsing and the localized heating of the microwaves.
The peak height and the area under one of the peaks could be increased by using shorter
exposure times (<10 s) and higher initial microwave power settings. However, it was
found that higher initial power setting causes surface drying and was not found reliable
for use here, as surface drying causes protein denaturation. In all the experiments
performed with low-power microwaves, using both SiFs and glass, there was no evidence
of surface drying. This is attributed to the previously made observations [20] that
the temperature increase of the aqueous solution on the surfaces due to microwave
heating is only ∼8 ° C (to ∼28 °C) for 30 µL of aqueous sample [20].
[0098] It is interesting to compare the results of the protein concentration-dependent assays
on both silvered and glass surfaces, Figure 19. The overall signal enhancement shown
in Figure 18, for assays performed on silver substrates versus those on glass substrates,
serves to confirm the benefits of using silver nanostructures, for MEC. By combining
the use of low-power microwaves and metal substrates to increase the rapidity of streptavidin
binding to biotinylated BSA surfaces, decrease nonspecific background, and enhance
and accelerate chemiluminescent reactions, Figure 19 shows that it is possible to
detect approximately femtomoles of biotinylated BSA on surfaces in less than 2 min,
with a signal-to-noise ratio (S/N) greater than 8. Signal-to-noise ratio is obtained
from Figure 19, and is equal to the ratio of the lowest counts (y-axis) obtained using
HRP divided by the counts without HRP (horizontal lines): for Ag, S/N = 7200/900 counts
> 8.
[0099] As compared to traditional western blot approaches. Figure 20, MT-MEC offers protein
quantification with ultrafast assay times, i.e., <2-min total assay time versus ∼80
min.
3..8 Conclusions
[0100] Using low-power microwaves, it has been demonstrated as an inexpensive and simplistic
approach to overcome some of the classical physical constraints imposed by current
protein detection platforms, namely, assay rapidity, sensitivity, specificity, and
accurate protein quantification. With the MT-MEC approach, the sensitivity of detection
(<0.5 pg) is 1 order of magnitude greater than that available with currently standard
commercially available methodologies (i.e., ECL Plus Western Blotting Detection Kit,
RPN2132, Amersham Biosciences). In addition to the improved detection sensitivity,
it is demonstrated herein that that these assays can be performed in a fraction of
the time (in fact, less than 1 min) typically required with standard methodologies.
With the application of microwaves and the subsequent acceleration of the chemiluminescent
reaction, the on-demand nature of light emission not only increases the detectability
of low concentrations of proteins, but photon flux is also proportional to the concentration
of the protein on a surface. Thus, for immunoassays in the clinical setting, the MT-MEC
approach offers a potentially powerful approach to protein detection because it substantially
decreases current assay times to minutes, potentially decreases false positives due
to increased specificity, and increases assay sensitivity by at least 1 order of magnitude
(see Figure 19).
[0101] With the decreased reaction times, increased sensitivity, increased specificity,
and signal enhancement achieved with MT-MBC, it is shown here a dramatically
decreased the: volume of reagents required to perform these assays. Thus, by using MT-MEC into
standard protein detection methodologies, reagent waste and overall experimental costs
will be decreased. Further, with this technology, both ultrafast and ultra bright
chemiluminescence assays can be realized.
References
[0102] All references cited herein are hereby incorporated by reference herein for all purposes.
- [1] O. Hofmann, P. Miller, P. Sullivan, T.S. Jones, J.C. deMello, D.D.C. Bradley, A.J.
deMello (2005). Thin-film organic photodiodes as integrated detectors for microscale
chemiluminescence assays. Sensors and Actuators BChemical 106 (2), 878-884.
- [2] O. Myhre, J.M. Andersen, H. Aarnes, F. Fonnum (2003). Evaluation of the probes 2',7'-dichlorofluorescin
diacetate, luminol, and lucigenin as indicators of reactive species formation. Biochemical
Pharmacology 65(10), 1575-1582.
- [3] I. Bronstein, C.S. Martin, J.J. Fortin, C.E.M. Olesen, J.C. Voyta (1996). Chemiluminescence:
Sensitive detection technology for reporter gene assays Clinical Chemistry 42 (9),
1542-1546.
- [4] P. Moris, I. Alexandre, M. Roger, J. Remacle (1995). Chemiluminescence Assays of
Organophosphorus and Carbamate Pesticides. Analytica Chimica Acta 302 (1), 53-59.
- [5] Ä.M. Garcia-Campana, Willy R, Baeyens (2001). Chemiluminescence in Analytical Chemistry,
Marcel Dekker. New York.
- [6] J.E. Wampler (1985). Instrumentation: Seeing the Light and Measuring It, in Chemi-
and Bioluminescence, J.G. Burr, Ed. Marcel Dekker, New York. pp. 1-44.
- [7] F. Berthold (1990). Instrumentation for Chemilunescence Immunoassays, in Luminescence
immunoassays and Molecular Applications, K. Van Dyke and R. Van Dyke, eds., CRC Press,
Boca Raton, pp.11-25.
- [8] T. Nieman (1995). Chemiluminescence: Theory and Instrumentation, Overview, in Encyclopedia
of Analytical Science, Academic Press, Orlando, pp. 608-613.
- [9] J.R. Lakowicz (1999). Principles of Fluorescence Spectroscopy, Kluwer, New York.
- [10] K. Aslan, L Gryczynski, J. Malicka, E. Matveeva, J.R. Lakowicz, C.D. Geddes (2005).
Metal-enhanced fluorescence: an emerging tool in biotechnology. Current Opinion in
Biotechnology. 16(1), 55-62.
- [11] K. Aslan, J.R, Lakowicz, C.D. Geddes (2005). Plasmon Light Scattering in Biology and
Medicine: New Sensing Approaches, Visions and Perspectives, Current Opinions in Chemical
Biology: Analytical Techniques, 9, 538-544.
- [12] C.D. Geddes, K. Aslan, I. Gryczynski, J. Malicka, J.R. Lakowicz (2005). Radiative
Decay Engineering, Review Chapter for Topics in Fluorescence Spectroscopy, Eds. C.D.
Geddes and J.R. Lakowicz, Kluwer Academic / Plenum Publishers, New York, USA, pp.
405-448.
- [13] C.D. Geddes, K. Aslan, I. Gryczynski, J. Malicka, E. Matveeva, J.R. Lakowicz (2005).
In Topics in Fluorescence in Fluorescence Spectroscopy, C.D. Geddes, J.R. Lakowicz,
Eds; Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers, New York, USA; pp. 401-448.
- [14] J.R. Lakowicz, I. Gryczynski, J. Malicka, Z. Gryczynski, C.D. Geddes (2002). Enhanced
and localized multiphoton excited fluorescence near metallic silver islands: metallic
islands can increase probe photostability J.Fluoresc., 12, 299-302.
- [15] C.D. Geddes, H. Cao, I. Gryczynski, Z. Gryczynski, J. Fang, and J.R. Lakowicz (2003).
Metal-enhanced fluorescence due to silver colloids on a planar surface: Potential
applications of Indocyanine green to in vivo imaging. J. Phys. Chem. A. 107, 3443-3449.
- [16] K. Aslan, J.R. Lakowicz, C. D. Geddes (2005). Rapid deposition of triangular silver
nanoplates on planar surfaces: Application to metalenhanced fluorescence. J. Phys.
Chem. B. 109, 6247-6251.
- [17] K. Aslan, Z. Leonenko, J.R. Lakowicz, C.D. Geddes (2005). Fast and slow deposition
of silver nanorods on planar surfaces: Application to metalenhanced fluorescence J.
Phys. Chem. B. 109(8), 3157-3162.
- [18] C.D. Geddes, A. Parfenov, D. Roll, J. Fang, and J. R. Lakowicz (2003). Electrochemical
and laser deposition of silver, for use in metal enhanced fluorescence. Langmuir 19,
6236-6241.
- [19] K. Aslan, R. Badugu, J.R. Lakowicz, C.D. Geddes (2005). Metal-enhanced fluorescence
from plastic substrates. J. Fluoresc., 15(2), 99-104.
- [20] K. Aslan, C.D. Geddes. Microwave-Accelerated Metal-Enhanced Fluorescence (MAMEF):
A New Platform Technology for Ultra Fast and Ultra Bright Assays. Anal. Chem. 77(24),
8057-8067.
- [21] J.R. Lakowicz (2001). Radiative decay engineering: Biophysical and biomedical applications.
Anal. Biochem. 298, 1-24.
- [22] J.R. Lakowicz, C.D. Geddes, I. Gryczynski, J. Malicka, Z. Gryczynski, K. Aslan, J.
Lukomska, E. Matveeva, J. Zhang, R. Badugu, J. Huang (2004). Advances in surface-enhanced
fluorescence, J. Fluoresc., 14(4), 425-441.
- [23] K. Aslan, Z. Leonenko, J.R. Lakowicz, C.D. Geddes (2005). Annealed Silver-Island Films
for Applications in Metal-Enhanced Fluorescence: Interpretation in Terms of Radiating
Plasmons, J. of Fluores., 15(5), 643-654.
- [24] I. Gryczynski, J. Malicka, Z. Gryezynski, J.R. Lakowicz, (2004). Radiative Decay Engineering
4. Experimental studies of surface plasmon-coupled directional emission. Anal. Biochem.,
324, 170-182.
- [25] C.D. Geddes, I. Gryczynski, J. Malicka, Z. Gryczynski, J.R. Lakowicz, (2004). Directional
surface plasmon coupled emission, J. Fluoresc., 14, 119-123,
- [26] J. Yguerabide; W Yguerabide; (1998) Anal Biochem. 262,137-176.
- [27] L. Rivas, S. Sanchez-Cortes, J.V. Garcia-Ramos and G. Morcillo G., (2001) Growth of
Silver Colloidal Particles Obtained by Citrate Reduction to Increase the Ramen Enhancement
Factor, Langmuir, 17(3), 574-577.
- [28] N. Shirtcliffe, U. Nickel and S. Schneider, (1999) Reproducible preparation of silver,
sols with small particle size using borohydride reduction: For use as nuclei fox preparation
of large particles, J. Colloid Interface Sci., 211(1), 122-129.
- [29] I. Pastoriza-Santos, and L.M> Liz-Marzan, (2000) Reduction of silver nanoparticles
in DMF. Formation of monolayers and stable colloids, Pure Appl. Chem., 72(1-2), 83-90
(2000).
- [30] Pastoriza-Santos, C. Serra-Rodriquez and L.M. Liz-Marzan, (2000) Self-assembly of
silver particle monolayers on glass from Ag.sup.+ solutions in DMF, J. Colloid Interface
Sci., 221(2), 236-241.
- [31] R. Bright, M.D. Musick. and MJ. Natan, (1998) Preparation and characterization of
Ag colloid monolayers, Langmuir, 14(20), 5695-5701.
- [32]. F. Ni and T.M., (1986) Chemical procedure for preparing surface-enhanced Roman scattering
active silver films, Anal. Chem., 58(14), 3159-5163.
- [33] U. Krelbig, M. Gartz and A. Hilger, (1997) Mie resonances: Sensors for physical and
chemical cluster interface properties, Ber. Bunsenges, Phys. Chem., 101(11), 1593-1604.
- [34] R.G. Freeman, K.C, Grabar, K.J. Allison, R.M. Bright R., J.A. Davis, A.P. Guthrie,
M.B. Hommer, M.A. Jackson, P.C. Smith, D.G Walter and M.J. Natan, (1995) Self-assembled
metal colloid monolayers: An approach to SERS substrates, Science, 267, 1629-1632.
- [35] K.C. Grabar, R.G Freeman, M.B. Hommer and M.J. Natan, (1995) Preparation and characterization
of Au colloid monolayers, Anal. Chem., 67, 735-743.
- [36] Lakowicz, J. R. Anal. Biochem. 2004, 324, 153-169.
- [37] Aslan, K., Pérez-Luna, V. H. Langmuir 2002, 18, 6059-6065.
- [38] Cormier, M. J.; Prichard, P. M. J Biol. Chem. 106.8, 243, 4706-4714,
- [39] Methods in Enzymology, Vol. VLII, M. A. Deluca (Ed.), 1978.