TECHNICAL FIELD
[0001] The present invention relates to a method for producing a thicker high-strength steel
plate having excellent brittle fracture arrestability and excellent toughness of the
heat affected zone (hereafter also abbreviated as HAZ) in high heat-input welding,
as well as a thicker high-strength steel plate having excellent brittle fracture arrestability
and excellent toughness of the heat affected zone in high heat-input welding. The
thicker high-strength steel plate according to the present invention is used mainly
for the construction of ships such as large container ships, but may also be used
for other welded structures such as buildings, bridges, tanks, and marine structures.
The present application claims priority on Japanese Patent Application No.
2007-315840, filed on December 6, 2007, the content of which is incorporated herein by reference.
BACKGROUND ART
[0002] Examples of the current needs for welded structures typified by boats and ships
include increased size for the structures, a high level of safety in terms of cracking,
improved welding efficiency during construction, and favorable economic viability
of the steel plate used as the structural material. In response to these trends, the
demands placed on the steel plate used in the welded structures, including (1) a high
degree of strength at large plate thickness values, (2) favorable brittle fracture
arrestability, (3) favorable HAZ toughness in high heat-input welding, and (4) low
production costs continue to become more stringent. As a result, large container ships
are now produced using hull construction steel plate having a yield strength in the
order of 390 MPa (a tensile strength in the order of 510 MPa) or a yield strength
in the order of 460 MPa (a tensile strength in the order of 570 MPa).
Specifically, as disclosed in Non-Patent Document 1 and the like, the steel plate
used in large ships such as large container ships are required to simultaneously satisfy:
(1) a yield strength in the order of 390 to 460 MPa (equivalent to a tensile strength
in the order of 510 to 570 MPa) for a thick steel plate having a plate thickness of
50 to 80 mm (hereafter referred to as a "thick material"), (2) a temperature T
kca=6000 (hereafter referred to as the "arrestability indicator T
kca=6000") at which the brittle fracture arrestability Kca reaches 6,000 N/mm
1.5 that satisfies T
kca=6000 ≤ -10°C, (3) an HAZ toughness (Charpy impact absorbed energy) vE (-20°C) of a weld
formed by welding at a heat input of at least 20 kJ/mm that satisfies vE (-20°C) ≥
47 J, and (4) a reduction in the amount of expensive alloy elements (such as a Ni
amount of ≤ 1%).
[0003] Patent Document 1 represents one example of a technique relating to a thicker high-strength
steel plate for use within ships, and this Patent Document 1 discloses a technique
for producing a steel plate that has a plate thickness of 50 to 80 mm, and is able
to partially satisfy the above requirements (1), (3) and (4). However, the thicker
high-strength steel plate disclosed in Patent Document 1 is unable to satisfy the
above requirement (2), as is evident from the examples disclosed in the document.
[0004] Further, Non-Patent Document 2 discloses a thick steel plate having a plate thickness
of 65 mm, which although having a satisfactorily high Charpy impact absorbed energy
of vE (-40°C) = 170 J for a small test piece, exhibits an unsatisfactory brittle fracture
arrestability of T
kca=6000 = 18°C that is confirmed in a large-scale crack test (see FIG. 7 of the Patent Document
2). These findings indicate that for a thick steel plate, by using the Charpy impact
absorbed energy vE (-40°C) for a small test piece, it is not possible to guarantee
that the brittle fracture arrestability obtained in a large-scale crack test satisfies
T
kca=6000 ≤ -10°C. In other words, it is not possible for conventional techniques to determine
the brittle fracture arrestability required for a thicker high-strength steel plate
for use within large ships by correlation with the Charpy impact properties measured
using a small test piece, and an accurate evaluation of the brittle fracture arrestability
cannot be made without conducting a large-scale crack test of a full thickness test
piece, typified by the ESSO test (compliant with WES 3003).
[0005] Conventionally, it has been considered that the brittle fracture arrestability is
dependent on the plate thickness, and the crack arrestability deteriorates as the
plate thickness increases. However, for thick materials having a thickness of 50 mm
or greater that represent the target for the present invention, experimental data
for this plate thickness effect is limited, and the degree to which the brittle fracture
arrestability deteriorates as a result of the increased thickness is unclear.
[0006] However, in a thick steel plate produced by a TMCP (Thermo Mechanical Control Process),
the addition of boron (B) has conventionally been used to increase the strength. One
example of the effect of this B addition is that solid solution B, which is segregated
at the austenite (γ) grain boundaries during the accelerated cooling conducted after
rolling, enhances the hardenability upon transformation. In Patent Document 1, increased
strength is targeted by the combined addition ofNb and B. As disclosed in the examples
of Patent Document 1, this technique is
characterized in that the rolling finishing temperature is in a range from 930 to 1,000°C which is high,
and the strength is increased by the combined addition ofNb and C to achieve superior
hardenability, with the essential condition that accelerated cooling must be conducted
from recrystallized austenite (recrystallized γ). In contrast, the Patent Document
1 also discloses that when a low-temperature rolling is conducted with a rolling finishing
temperature of lower than 930°C that is in the non-recrystallization region, although
the toughness is satisfactory, the resulting strength properties are unsatisfactory,
and it is difficult to realize the increasing of the strength due to a Nb-B combined
effect.
[0007] Furthermore, Patent Document 1 discloses a technique for using B in a high heat-input
HAZ, and describes the effectiveness of combining a grain boundary ferrite inhibiting
effect (a hardenability improving effect) due to solid solution B within the γ and
an intra-granular ferrite promoting effect (a hardenability reducing effect) due to
BN within the γ, at a Ceq value of 0.30 to 0.38%. In other words, B has two mutually
opposing roles in relation to the hardenability. To summarize the technique for using
B disclosed in Patent Document 1, the hardenability improvement effect provided by
the solid solution B within the γ is utilized in directly quenched base materials
and the high heat-input HAZ, while at the same time, the hardenability reducing effect
provided by the precipitated B (BN in this case) within the γ is utilized in the high
heat-input HAZ.
[0008] Furthermore, the inventors of the present invention have previously completed inventions
in which, in order to enhance the toughness of a high heat-input HAZ, the VN that
precipitates within the γ during the HAZ cooling step is subjected to a co-precipitation
with a pinning particle (an oxide or sulfide), and these VN composite particles act
as ferrite transformation nuclei, thereby reducing the size of the HAZ microstructure.
These inventions are disclosed in Patent Documents 2 and 3. Further, as disclosed
in Non-Patent Document 3, it is well known that the addition of V provides an effect
that improves the strength of the base material.
As described above, the addition of B or V is known to yield an improvement in the
base material strength and an improvement in the toughness of a high heat-input HAZ.
[0009] Ni is generally known as a rare element capable of improving the toughness of the
base materials or HAZ, and the effective use ofNi is typically considered in terms
of requirements (2) and (3) above. However, Ni is an extremely expensive element,
and the price of Ni has increased dramatically in recent years. Further, steels containing
added Ni tend to be prone to developing surface blemishes; therefore, steps must be
taken to avoid such blemishes. Accordingly, Ni addition produces conflicting interests
between satisfying the above requirement (4) and satisfying the requirements (2) and
(3). Furthermore, from the viewpoint of the above requirement (1), as increasing the
amount of added alloy elements, the carbon equivalent (Ceq) increases; thereby, the
HAZ becomes harder and more brittle during high heat-input welding, and therefore
another conflict of interest develops between the requirement (1) and the requirement
(3). Moreover, from the viewpoint of the requirement (2), if refinement of the pre-transformation
γ structures in a TMCP is pursued, then the hardenability deteriorates and the strength
decreases; thereby, another conflict of interest exists between the requirement (1)
and the requirement (2).
For these reasons, development of a steel plate that is able to simultaneously satisfy
the above requirements (1) to (4), which tend to represent mutually opposing interests,
has been keenly sought.
Patent Document 1: Japanese Patent No. 3,599,556
Patent Document 2: Japanese Unexamined Patent Application, First Publication No. 2005-298900
Patent Document 3: Japanese Unexamined Patent Application, First Publication No. 2007-262508
Non-Patent Document 1: "Guidelines on the Application of YP47 Steel for Hull Structures of Large Container
Carriers", published by Nippon Kaiji Kyokai (ClassNK) (October 2008)
Non-Patent Document 2: Journal of The Japan Society of Naval Architects and Ocean Engineers, 2006A-G4-10
Non-Patent Document 3: CAMP-ISIJ, 6 (1993), p. 684
DISCLOSURE OF INVENTION
PROBLEMS TO BE SOLVED BY THE INVENTION
[0010] The present invention takes the above circumstances into consideration, and aims
to provide a method for producing a thicker high-strength steel plate having excellent
brittle fracture arrestability and excellent toughness of the heat affected zone in
high heat-input welding, that is capable of realizing (1) high strength for thick
steel plate including a yield strength in the order of 390 to 460 MPa and a tensile
strength in the order of 510 to 570 MPa for a plate thickness of 50 to 80 mm, (2)
favorable brittle fracture arrestability indicated by an arrestability indicator T
kca=6000 ≤ -10°C, (3) favorable HAZ toughness in high heat-input welding indicated by vE (-20°C)
≥ 47 J even when the heat input during welding is ≥ 20 kJ/mm, and (4) reduced production
costs due to a reduction in the amount of expensive alloy elements (such as a Ni amount
of ≤ 1%), as well as to provide a thicker high-strength steel plate having excellent
brittle fracture arrestability and excellent toughness of the heat affected zone in
high heat-input welding.
MEANS TO SOLVE THE PROBLEMS
[0011] In order to achieve the above object, the present invention adopts the aspects described
below.
A method for producing a thicker high-strength steel plate having excellent brittle
fracture arrestability and excellent toughness of the heat affected zone in high heat-input
welding according to the present invention includes: cooling a continuously cast slab
containing, in mass % values, C: 0.05 to 0.12%, Si: not more than 0.3%, Mn: 1 to 2%,
P: not more than 0.015%, S: not more than 0.005%, B: 0.0003 to 0.003%, V: 0.01 to
0.15%, Al: 0.001 to 0.1%, Ti: 0.005 to 0.02%, N: 0.002 to 0.01%, and O: not more than
0.004%, with the remainder being iron and unavoidable impurities, to a temperature
of Ar
3-200°C or lower, and subsequently reheating the slab to 950 to 1,100°C; subjecting
the continuously cast slab to rough rolling at 900°C or higher with a cumulative reduction
ratio of at least 30%; subsequently performing finish rolling at 700°C or higher with
a cumulative reduction ratio of at least 50% under conditions that both of the finish
rolling start temperature and the finish rolling completion temperature are not higher
than a temperature represented by a formula: {-0.5 × (slab heating temperature (°C))
+ 1,325} (°C), thereby forming a rolled plate; and cooling the rolled plate to 500°C
or lower by accelerated cooling to obtain a steel plate. In the above continuously
cast slab, a calculated value of an amount of B {effective B amount: Bef (%)} which
is solid-solubilized into an austenite base material prior to transformation is not
more than 0%, and a carbon equivalent Ceq satisfies a range from 0.32 to 0.42%.
If the amount of residual oxygen O
Ti (%) that remains after deoxidation by strong deoxidizing elements and is able to
undergo deoxidation by Ti that is a weak deoxidizing element is an amount represented
by formula (1) shown below, then the effective B amount Bef (%) is represented by
formula (2) shown below. Further, the carbon equivalent Ceq (%) is represented by
formula (3) shown below, and the Ar
3 is represented by formula (4) shown below.

{in formula (1), component elements that represent unavoidable impurities are also
included within the calculation.}

{in formula (2), when O
Ti ≤ 0, it is deemed that O
Ti = 0, when O
Ti > 0, it is deemed that Ti - 2O
Ti≥ 0.005 (%), and when N - 0,29(Ti - 2O
Ti) ≤ 0 (although when O
Ti≤ 0, O
Ti = 0), it is deemed that N - 0.29(Ti - 2O
Ti) =

In the method for producing a thicker high-strength steel plate having excellent brittle
fracture arrestability and excellent toughness of the heat affected zone in high heat-input
welding according to the present invention, the method may further include conducting
a tempering heat treatment at a temperature within a range from 350 to 700°C for 5
to 60 minutes after the accelerated cooling mentioned above.
In the continuously cast slab, the S content may be within a range from 0.0005 to
0.005%, and the O content may be within a range from 0.001 to 0.004%, and the continuously
cast slab may further contain, in mass % values, either or both of Ca: 0.0003 to 0.004%
and Mg: 0.0003 to 0.004%.
The continuously cast slab may further contain, in mass % values, one or more selected
from the group consisting of Ni: 0.01 to 1%, Cu: 0.01 to 1%, Cr: 0.01 to 1%, Mo: 0.01
to 0.5%, and Nb: 0.003 to 0.03%.
The continuously cast slab may further contain, in mass % values, either or both of
REM: 0.0003 to 0.02% and Zr: 0.0003 to 0.02%.
[0012] A thicker high-strength steel plate having excellent brittle fracture arrestability
and excellent toughness of the heat affected zone in high heat-input welding according
to the present invention contains, in mass % values, C: 0.05 to 0.12%, Si: not more
than 0.3%, Mn: 1 to 2%, P: not more than 0.015%, S: not more than 0.005%, B: 0.0003
to 0.003%, V: 0.01 to 0.15%, Al: 0.001 to 0.1%, Ti: 0.005 to 0.02%, N: 0.002 to 0.01%,
and O: not more than 0.004%, with the remainder being iron and unavoidable impurities,
wherein if an amount of residual oxygen that remains after deoxidation by strong deoxidizing
elements and is able to undergo deoxidation by Ti that is a weak deoxidizing element
is an amount represented by formula (5) shown below, then a calculated value of an
amount of B {effective B amount: Bef(%)} which is solid-solubilized into an austenite
base material prior to transformation is not more than 0%, a carbon equivalent Ceq
represented by formula (7) shown below satisfies a range from 0.32 to 0.42%, a plate
thickness is within a range from 50 to 80 mm, a yield strength is in the order of
390 to 460 MPa, a temperature T
kca=6000 at which the brittle fracture arrestability Kca reaches 6,000 N/mm
1.5 is -10°C or lower, and a Charpy impact absorbed energy vE (-20°C), which is an indicator
of high heat-input HAZ toughness with 20 kJ/mm or greater of heat input, is at least
47 J.

{in formula (5), component elements that represent unavoidable impurities are also
included within the calculation.}

{in formula (6), when O
Ti ≤ 0, it is deemed that O
Ti = 0, when O
Ti > 0, it is deemed that Ti - 20
Ti ≥ 0.005 (%), and when N - 0.29(Ti - 20
Ti) ≤ 0 (although when O
Ti ≤ 0, O
Ti = 0), it is deemed that N - 0.29(Ti - 20
Ti) = 0.}

In the thicker high-strength steel plate having excellent brittle fracture arrestability
and excellent toughness of the heat affected zone in high heat-input welding according
to the present invention, the S content may be within a range from 0.0005 to 0.005%,
and the O content may be within a range from 0.001 to 0.004%, and the steel plate
may further contain, in mass % values, either or both of Ca: 0.0003 to 0.004% and
Mg: 0.0003 to 0.004%.
The steel plate may further contain, in mass % values, one or more selected from the
group consisting ofNi: 0.01 to 1%, Cu: 0.01 to 1%, Cr: 0.01 to 1%, Mo: 0.01 to 0.5%,
and Nb: 0.003 to 0.03%.
The steel plate may further contain, in mass % values, either or both of REM: 0.0003
to 0.02% and Zr: 0.0003 to 0.02%.
EFFECTS OF THE INVENTION
[0013] The method for producing a thicker high-strength steel plate having excellent brittle
fracture arrestability and excellent toughness of the heat affected zone in high heat-input
welding, and the thicker high-strength steel plate having excellent brittle fracture
arrestability and excellent toughness of the heat affected zone in high heat-input
welding of the present invention are capable of realizing (1) high strength for a
thick steel plate including a yield strength in the order of 390 to 460 MPa (namely,
a tensile strength in the order of 510 to 570 MPa) for a plate thickness of 50 to
80 mm, (2) favorable brittle fracture arrestability indicated by an arrestability
indicator T
kca=6000 ≤ -10°C, (3) favorable HAZ toughness in high heat-input welding indicated by vE (-20°C)
≥ 47 J even when the heat input during welding is ≥ 20 kJ/mm, and (4) reduced production
costs due to a reduction in the amount of expensive alloy elements (such as a Ni amount
of ≤ 1%).
By using this thicker high-strength steel plate of the present invention in all manner
of welded structures including large ships, an increase in the size of the welded
structure, a high level of safety in terms of cracking, improved welding efficiency
during construction, and favorable economic viability of the steel plate used as the
structural material can all be achieved at the same time, and therefore the industrial
effect of the invention is immense.
BEST MODE FOR CARRYING OUT THE INVENTION
[0014] As follows is a description of embodiments of the method for producing a thicker
high-strength steel plate having excellent brittle fracture arrestability and excellent
toughness of the heat affected zone in high heat-input welding according to the present
invention, and the thicker high-strength steel plate having excellent brittle fracture
arrestability and excellent toughness of the heat affected zone in high heat-input
welding of the present invention.
In these embodiments, a detailed description is provided in order to facilitate better
understanding of the intent of the present invention, although unless specifically
stated, the embodiments in no way limit the scope of the present invention.
<Steel plate production conditions (production process)>
[0015] The demands placed on the steel plate used in welded structures such as ships, including
(1) a high degree of strength at large plate thickness values, (2) favorable brittle
fracture arrestability, (3) favorable HAZ toughness in high heat-input welding, and
(4) low production costs continue to become more stringent.
In response to these demands, a method for producing a thicker high-strength steel
plate having excellent brittle fracture arrestability and excellent toughness of the
heat affected zone in high heat-input welding according to the present invention includes:
cooling a continuously cast slab containing, in mass % values, C: 0.05 to 0.12%, Si:
not more than 0.3%, Mn: 1 to 2%, P: not more than 0.015%, S: not more than 0.005%,
B: 0.0003 to 0.003%, V: 0.01 to 0.15%, Al: 0.001 to 0.1%, Ti: 0.005 to 0.02%, N: 0.002
to 0.01%, and O: not more than 0.004%, with the remainder being iron and unavoidable
impurities, to a temperature of Ar
3-200°C or lower after a continuous casting, subsequently reheating the slab to 950
to 1,100°C; next subjecting the continuously cast slab to rough rolling at 900°C or
higher with a cumulative reduction ratio of at least 30%; subsequently performing
finish rolling at 700°C or higher with a cumulative reduction ratio of at least 50%
under conditions that both of the finish rolling start temperature and the finishing
rolling completion temperature are not higher than a temperature represented by a
formula: {-0.5 × (slab heating temperature (°C)) + 1,325} (°C), thereby forming a
rolled plate; and then cooling the rolled plate to 500°C or lower by accelerated cooling
to obtain a steel plate. In the above continuously cast slab, a calculated value of
an amount of solid solution B {effective B amount: Bef(%)} which is solid-solubilized
into an austenite base material prior to transformation is not more than 0%, and a
carbon equivalent Ceq satisfies a range from 0.32 to 0.42%.
If an amount of residual oxygen O
Ti (%) that remains after deoxidation by strong deoxidizing elements and is able to
undergo deoxidation by Ti that is a weak deoxidizing element is an amount represented
by formula (1) shown below, then the effective B amount Bef (%) is represented by
formula (2) shown below. Further, the carbon equivalent Ceq (%) is represented by
formula (3) shown below, and the Ar
3 is represented by formula (4) shown below.
Furthermore, the "slab heating temperature" refers to the temperature used when reheating
the continuously cast slab (namely, the reheating temperature).

{in formula (1), component elements that represent unavoidable impurities are also
included within the calculation.}

{in formula (2), when O
Ti ≤ 0, it is deemed that O
Ti = 0, when O
Ti > 0, it is deemed that Ti - 2O
Ti ≥ 0.005 (%), and when N - 0.29(Ti - 2O
Ti) ≤ 0 (although when O
Ti ≤0, 0, O
Ti = 0), it is deemed that N - 0.29(Ti - 2O
Ti) = 0.}

In this description, element symbols used within the formulas each represent the amount
(mass % value) for that particular element within the continuously cast slab or the
thicker high-strength steel plate.
Further, in the present invention, there are no particular limitations on the method
used for producing the continuously cast slab. For example, after melting in a blast
furnace, converter furnace, electric furnace, or the like, a component adjustment
process can be conducted using any of the various secondary refining techniques to
achieve the targeted amount of each element, and the slab may then be produced via
a typical continuous casting method.
[0016] In the method for producing a thicker high-strength steel plate having excellent
brittle fracture arrestability and excellent toughness of the heat affected zone in
high heat-input welding according to the present invention, with regard to the elements
listed in the above chemical composition, the lower limit for the S content may be
set to 0.0005%, and the lower limit for the O content may be set to 0.001%. Moreover,
if required, one or more selected from the group consisting of Ca: 0.0003 to 0.004%,
Mg: 0.0003 to 0.004%, Ni: 0.01 to 1%, Cu: 0.01 to 1%, Cr: 0.01 to 1%, Mo: 0.01 to
0.5%, Nb: 0.003 to 0.03%, REM: 0.0003 to 0.02%, and Zr: 0.0003 to 0.02% may also be
added selectively.
The abbreviation REM refers to "rare earth mentals", and represents one or more elements
selected from Sc, Y, and the lanthanoid elements of La, Ce, Pr, Nd, Pm, Sm, Eu, Gd,
Tb, Dy, Ho, Er, Tm, Yb and Lu.
[0017] The main point of the present invention is a technique in which the combined addition
of B and V is conducted in order to simultaneously achieve favorable strength, brittle
fracture arrestability, high heat-input HAZ toughness, and low production costs for
a thick steel plate produced by a TMCP, and by strictly controlling the amount of
N that bonds to these nitride-forming elements B and V, the state in which the B and
V exist within the austenite (γ) can be optimized; thereby, enabling the transformation
structures of the base material or a high heat-input HAZ to be controlled.
Specifically, in terms of the existence state of B within the γ, the present invention
is based on the technical concept of ensuring that, within both of the base material
and the high heat-input HAZ, no solid solution B exists, and all of the B is precipitated
as BN. In terms of the existence state of V within the γ, the present invention is
based on the technical concept of employing solid solution V in the base material,
but employing precipitated V (such as VN) within the high heat-input HAZ.
[0018] A more detailed description is presented below.
First, in order to satisfy the demand for favorable brittle fracture arrestability,
which represents the major technical challenge for the present invention, various
TMCP conditions were investigated to determine the conditions that enable the crystal
grain size within the thick steel plate to be reduced as fine as possible.
Here, the smallest unit when brittle cracking occurs along a crystallographically
unique crystal plane (the cleavage plane: corresponding with the {100} plane in the
case of iron having a body-centered cubic structure) is termed the "fracture facet
unit", and in the present invention, the metal structural unit of a size corresponding
with this fracture facet unit is referred to as the "crystal grain size".
It became evident that if the low-temperature reheating and low-temperature rolling
during the TMCP were conducted at the lowest possible temperatures to enable the refinement
of the pre-transformation γ structures to be pushed to the limit, then the crystal
grain size was able to be satisfactorily reduced even for a thick steel plate having
a plate thickness of 50 to 80 mm; thereby, enabling the brittle fracture arrestability
to satisfy the target range. When Ar
3 (°C) is calculated using the formula: (910 - 310C - 80Mn -20Cu - 55Ni - 80Mo), the
conditions that yield favorable brittle fracture arrestability involve cooling the
continuously cast slab to a temperature of {Ar
3(°C) - 200(°C)} or lower, subsequently conducting low-temperature heating (reheating)
at a temperature of not more than 1,100°C, subjecting the continuously cast slab to
rough rolling at 900°C or higher with a cumulative reduction ratio of at least 30%,
subsequently performing finish rolling at 700°C or higher with a cumulative reduction
ratio of at least 50% under conditions that both of the finish rolling start temperature
(°C) and the finishing rolling completion temperature (°C) are not higher than the
temperature represented by the formula: {-0.5 × (slab heating temperature (°C)) +
1,325} (°C), and then conducting accelerated cooling to cool the rolled plate to 500°C
or lower.
[0019] The first TMCP condition for taking full advantage of the low-temperature heating
and low-temperature rolling requires that, after continuous casting, the slab (the
continuously cast slab) is cooled to a temperature of Ar
3 - 200°C or lower to effect a γ (austenite) → α (ferrite) transformation, and then
effecting a α → γ transformation by low-temperature heating (reheating) of the slab
to a temperature of not more than 1,100°C. The reason for specifying this production
condition is to ensure thorough grain size reduction (uniform grain refinement) of
the γ during heating.
If the slab is subjected to reheating from a higher temperature that exceeds {Ar
3(°C) - 200(°C)}, then the reheating occurs before complete γ → α transformation has
occurred within the interior of the slab; thereby, coarse γ structures remain within
the slab during casting. The formula (4) above is a relationship that applies only
for an extremely slow cooling rate when the slab is cooled after continuous casting,
and does not apply in cases such as thick plate rolling where the cooling rate is
comparatively large.
If the slab is reheated at a comparatively high temperature exceeding 1,100°C, then
Ostwald growth of TiN tends to begin; thereby, the pinning effect diminishes, and
it becomes difficult to generate uniformly refined γ grains in a stable manner. If
a thorough grain size reduction (uniform grain refinement) of the γ cannot be achieved
during heating, then under practical slab thickness restrictions (typically 200 to
400 mm), it is difficult for a steel plate having a plate thickness of 50 to 80 mm
to achieve a satisfactory reduction in the size of the pre-transformation γ structures,
regardless of any innovations that may be introduced in terms of rolling conditions.
[0020] The second TMCP condition for taking full advantage of the low-temperature heating
and low-temperature rolling requires that rough rolling is conducted at 900°C or higher
with a cumulative reduction ratio of at least 30%. The reason for specifying this
production condition is to ensure that by conducting rolling within the recrystallization
region, γ structures can be obtained that have an even finer grain structure than
that obtained upon heating.
If the rough rolling is conducted at a temperature less than 900°C or with a cumulative
reduction ratio of less than 30%, then the recrystallization is inadequate, strain-induced
grain growth tends to occur, and there is a possibility that the resulting grains
may actually be coarser than the initial γ generated during heating.
[0021] The third TMCP condition for taking full advantage of the low-temperature heating
and low-temperature rolling requires that finish rolling is performed at 700°C or
higher with a cumulative reduction ratio of at least 50% under conditions that both
of the finish rolling start temperature (°C) and the finishing rolling completion
temperature (°C) are not higher than the temperature represented by the formula: {-0.5
× (slab heating temperature (°C)) + 1,325} (°C). The reason for specifying this production
condition is to ensure that the recrystallized grains that have undergone satisfactory
grain size reduction (uniform grain refinement) during the rough rolling are rolled
within the non-recrystallization region; thereby, stretching the γ grains, increasing
the grain boundary surface area, and activating the grain boundaries, as well as introducing
deformation bands within the γ and maximizing the nucleation site density and the
nucleation frequency in the pre-transformation γ.
If the cumulative reduction ratio of the finish rolling is less than 50%, or the condition
requiring temperatures not higher than the temperature represented by the formula:
{-0.5 × (slab heating temperature (°C)) + 1,325} (°C) is not satisfied, then the grain
size reduction for the pre-transformation γ tends to be inadequate.
From a metallurgical perspective, the condition requiring temperatures not higher
than that represented by the formula: {-0.5 × (slab heating temperature (°C)) + 1,325}
(°C) means that the higher the heating temperature and the coarser the initial γ grains,
the greater the necessity to conduct the finish rolling at a lower temperature to
strengthen the non-recrystallization region rolling. For example, if the slab heating
temperature is 1,100°C, then finish rolling must be conducted at 775°C or lower, whereas
if the slab heating temperature is 1,000°C, then finish rolling must be conducted
at 825°C or lower. In this manner, if an extremely strict TMCP condition that restricts
the finish rolling temperature in conjunction with the slab heating temperature is
not specified, then it is impossible to ensure favorable brittle fracture arrestability
for thick steel plate in a stable manner.
If the finish rolling is conducted at a temperature lower than 700°C, then the surface
of the steel plate starts to undergo transformation, either during rolling or during
the standby period prior to accelerated cooling; thereby, causing a softening and
coarsening of the surface structure, and as a result, the strength and the brittle
fracture arrestability deteriorate.
[0022] The fourth TMCP condition for taking full advantage of the low-temperature heating
and low-temperature rolling requires that accelerated cooling is applied to cool the
rolled plate to 500°C or lower. The reason for specifying this production condition
is because even in the case where the pre-transformation γ grains are made as fine
as possible by applying the heating and rolling conditions outlined above, if the
subsequent cooling is an air cooling process, then the degree of supercooling during
the γ → α transformation is small; thereby, the crystal grain size cannot be adequately
reduced.
If the accelerated cooling is stopped at a temperature higher than 500°C, then within
the interior of the steel plate of which the temperature is higher than that of the
surface layer of the steel plate, the accelerated cooling stops and shifts to air
cooling partway through the transformation, and as a result, the crystal grain size
within the interior of the plate cannot be adequately reduced.
[0023] The above are the TMCP conditions required for ensuring a satisfactory reduction
in the crystal grain size in order to achieve the required level of brittle fracture
arrestability under the premise of a low Ni content, thus enabling the requirements
(2) and (4) listed above to be satisfied.
However, with the above TMCP conditions, the combination of maximizing the crystal
grain size reduction of the pre-transformation γ and the inherent slow cooling rate
for the thick steel plate causes a problem in that the hardenability upon transformation
tends to decrease dramatically. As a result, within bainite/ferrite mixed structures,
the bainite fraction tends to decrease while the ferrite fraction increases, and it
becomes difficult to ensure a predetermined level of tensile strength. At the same
time, the hardenability generated by the solid solution B within the γ tends to become
unstable under the above type of TMCP conditions; thereby, not only is the strength
inadequate, but the variation in strength also tends to increase. In this manner,
the above TMCP conditions raise a new problem in that the requirement (1) described
above cannot be satisfied.
A first reason for the variation in strength is that the amount of solid solution
B within the γ, which can be estimated by the effective B amount (Bef) described below,
increases or decreases with fluctuations in the steel composition during mass production
(including fluctuations in the amount of O, the amount of strong deoxidizing elements,
the amount of Ti, the amount ofN, and the amount of B). A second reason is that for
low-temperature rolled γ in the non-recystallization region, the amount of strain-induced
precipitation of iron borocarbides (such as Fe
23(C,B)
6) varies depending on the rolling conditions and the length of the standby period
from the completion of roiling to the start of the accelerated cooling, and the reverse
side of this variation in precipitation is an increase or decrease in the amount of
solid solution B within the γ. As mentioned above, it is far from easy to ensure a
stable level of strength for the base material on the basis of the B hardenability
under the above TMCP conditions, and therefore, a strengthening technique other than
B hardenability must be utilized.
[0024] Accordingly, in the present invention, in order to satisfy the requirement (1) mentioned
above, the two techniques described below are employed to ensure a satisfactory and
stable base material strength.
The first technique involves precipitating all of the B as BN during the TMCP so that
no solid solution B exists within the γ; thereby, eliminating any instability in the
hardenability caused by fluctuations in the amount of solid solution B within the
γ. This technique represents the complete opposite thinking to conventional techniques
that utilize B, and is based on the technical concept of not using the property of
B hardenability to ensure base material strength. This enables variations in the strength
during mass production to be suppressed. Specifically, the effective B amount (Bef)
described below is controlled to a value of not more than 0%. In the present invention,
the significance of adding B applies only to the high heat-input HAZ, and a description
of this significance is presented below.
The second technique involves utilizing precipitate strengthening due to V carbides
to increase the strength of the base material.
Under the TMCP conditions described above, it was ascertained that by adding 0.01%
of V, the tensile strength of a material having a plate thickness of 70 mm could be
increased by approximately 10 MPa, and it became evident that the addition of V was
an extremely effective technique for strengthening the steel plate in a quantitative
manner. This is because bainite/ferrite mixed structures of which the grain size has
been satisfactorily reduced via application of low-temperature heating and low-temperature
rolling are ideal base materials for V carbides (such as VC and V
4C
3) to precipitate finely and in high density during the accelerated cooling and tempering
treatments. In the present invention, another significant reason for adding V relates
to the high heat-input HAZ, and a description of this reason is presented below.
[0025] As described above, in order to ensure satisfactory base material strength in the
TMCP by adding V but not employing B hardenability, the carbon equivalent Ceq value,
which is employed as an indicator of the hardenability of the steel components excluding
B, must be at least 0.32%, the effective B amount Bef must be restricted to not more
than 0%, at least 0.01% of V must be added, the heating temperature must be controlled
at a temperature of 950°C or higher, and the accelerated cooling must be continued
to a temperature of 500°C or lower.
If Ceq is less than 0.32%, then even if V is added, it is difficult to ensure a stable
base material strength. Moreover, softening of HAZ proceeds and there is a possibility
that the tensile strength of welded joints may be inadequate.
In those cases where the effective B amount calculated using the above formula (2)
is a numerical value exceeding 0%, solid solution B exists within the γ, and there
is a possibility of B hardenability manifesting; thereby, causing a variation in the
strength.
If the heating temperature is less than 950°C, then because the solubilization of
the V carbonitrides tends to be inadequate, and the amount of solid solution V within
the γ becomes unsatisfactory. As a result, the amount of V carbides that precipitate
during the accelerated cooling and tempering treatments may be inadequate; thereby,
stable base material strength cannot be ensured.
If air cooling is employed rather than accelerated cooling, then the cooling rate
is too slow, the ferrite grains tend to coarsen, and the bainite fraction decreases;
thereby, a satisfactory transformation strengthening cannot be achieved.
If the accelerated cooling is stopped at a temperature higher than 500°C, then the
accelerated cooling within the higher temperature interior of the plate stops partway
through the transformation, and as a result, satisfactory transformation strengthening
cannot be obtained within the plate interior.
During the accelerated cooling, it is preferable to ensure a water volume density
of at least 0.3 m
3/m
2/min in terms of obtaining fine bainite/ferrite structures that exhibit a combination
of strength and toughness.
The above description presents techniques that enable satisfactory strength to be
obtained under TMCP conditions that emphasize brittle fracture arrestability, and
under the premise of a low Ni content. These techniques enable the above requirements
(1), (2) and (4) to be satisfied simultaneously.
[0026] Furthermore, after the accelerated cooling, a tempering heat treatment may be conducted
at a temperature of 350 to 700°C for a period of 5 to 60 minutes. Although this increases
the production costs, it enables the strength, the elongation, and the Charpy impact
properties to be controlled precisely within predetermined ranges.
In those cases where the tempering heat treatment is performed at a temperature of
less than 350°C or the tempering heat treatment time is less than 5 minutes, the effects
of the tempering treatment do not manifest satisfactorily. Furthermore, if the temperature
of the tempering heat treatment exceeds 700°C or the tempering heat treatment time
exceeds 60 minutes, then the tempering phenomenon exceeds the optimal range and has
an excessive effect; thereby, a marked reduction in the strength and a marked deterioration
in the Charpy impact properties occur, and as a result, the optimum mechanical properties
cannot be obtained.
[0027] Next is a description of a technique for satisfying the above requirement (3) for
favorable HAZ toughness in high heat-input welding.
The main factors governing HAZ toughness in high heat-input welding in the present
invention can be broadly classified into the following three areas. The first factor
is hardness, the second factor is the MA (martensite-austenite mixed phase), and the
third factor is the effective crystal grain size.
In the present invention, for reasons of both of the hardness and the MA, the carbon
equivalent Ceq is restricted to not more than 0.42%. If the carbon equivalent exceeds
0.42%, then the HAZ becomes excessively hard and the MA increases; thereby, a significant
increase in the brittleness of the HAZ occurs.
Moreover, by restricting the effective B amount (Bef) to not more than 0%, B hardenability
can be prevented from occurring within the HAZ, and an increase in the hardness and
an increase in the amount of MA can be suppressed.
[0028] The inventors of the present invention discovered the advantage V addition offered
in terms of the hardness. Further, they also found that in cases such as the present
invention where the HAZ is mainly bainite, the HAZ is resistant to hardening even
when V is added.
In other words, if the base material is strengthened by addition of an element other
than V such as C or Mn, then the HAZ mainly containing bainite hardens dramatically,
and the brittleness of the HAZ significantly increases. In contrast, if the base material
is strengthened by adding V as per the present invention, then the hardening of the
HAZ mainly containing bainite is suppressed. Based on this new finding, if the amounts
of C and Mn are reduced so as to cancel out the increase in base material strength
provided by V, resulting in a lower Ceq value, then the hardness in the HAZ is reduced
by an amount equivalent to the reduction in the Ceq; thereby, the HAZ toughness is
improved. This type of technique in which the HAZ toughness is improved by utilizing
the difference in the V hardening behavior between the base material and the HAZ has
not existed conventionally.
[0029] In the present invention, from the viewpoint of the MA, the amount of Si must be
reduced as low as possible.
Further, under the TMCP conditions of the present invention, although the contribution
of Nb to the base material is small, it promotes MA growth. In the comparatively high
Ceq range of the present invention, although Mo is expensive, it promotes MA growth.
Accordingly, Nb and Mo must be reduced as low as possible in the present invention.
[0030] In the present invention, from the viewpoint of effective crystal grain size, two
techniques are employed to reduce the size of the HAZ structures.
The first technique involves simultaneously using the B precipitates and V precipitates
within the γ as transformation nuclei. By suitably increasing the N amount so that
the effective B amount {Bef (%)} represented by the above formula (2) is not more
than 0%, BN, VN and V(C,N) are precipitated at the γ grain boundaries and within the
γ grains during the cooling after high heat-input welding, and any one or more of
these precipitated particles function effectively as transformation nuclei for not
only ferrite, but also for bainite; thereby, ensuring a favorable reduction in size
of the HAZ structures.
Moreover, the second technique for reducing the size of the HAZ structures involves
appropriate addition of Ca and/or Mg to ensure dispersion of a multitude of very fine
oxides or sulfides; thereby, suppressing γ grain growth by a pinning effect and ensuring
a very fine bainite packet size. Co-precilaitation of B precipitates and V precipitates
occurs within a portion of the fine oxides and/or sulfides, and a transformation nucleus
function is imparted to the pinning particles; thereby, the effect can also be obtained
which enables the bainite that transforms from the γ grain boundaries to be made even
finer.
The HAZ structure size reduction techniques described above are able to effectively
lower the HAZ hardenability, and therefore contribute to reducing the amount of MA
and the hardness. The first technique ensures a favorable Charpy absorption energy
at -20°C, and if the second technique is used in combination with the first technique
to enable maximum reduction in the size of the HAZ structures, a favorable Charpy
absorption energy can be obtained at -40°C.
By adopting the measures described above for reducing the hardness, reducing the MA,
and reducing the size of the HAZ structures, a high heat-input HAZ according to the
present invention is able to achieve a high vE (-20°C) value. Accordingly, the above
requirement (3) can be satisfied in addition to the requirements (1), (2) and (4).
<Chemical element composition (thicker high-strength steel plate)>
[0031] As described above, in order to satisfy the above-mentioned requirements, namely
(1) a high degree of strength at large plate thickness values, (2) favorable brittle
fracture arrestability, (3) favorable HAZ toughness in high heat-input welding, and
(4) low production costs, a thicker high-strength steel plate having excellent brittle
fracture arrestability and excellent toughness of the heat affected zone in high heat-input
welding according to the present invention includes, in mass % values, C: 0.05 to
0.12%, Si: not more than 0.3%, Mn: 1 to 2%, P: not more than 0.015%, S: not more than
0.005%, B: 0.0003 to 0.003%, V: 0.01 to 0.15%, Al: 0.001 to 0.1%, Ti: 0.005 to 0.02%,
N: 0.002 to 0.01 %, and O: not more than 0.004%, with the remainder being iron and
unavoidable impurities, wherein if the amount of residual oxygen that remains after
deoxidation by strong deoxidizing elements and is able to undergo deoxidation by Ti
which is the weak deoxidizing element is an amount represented by formula (5) shown
below, then the calculated value of the amount of B {effective B amount: Bef(%)} which
is solid-solubilized into the austenite base material prior to transformation is not
more than 0%, the carbon equivalent Ceq represented by formula (7) shown below satisfies
a range from 0.32 to 0.42%, the plate thickness is within a range from 50 to 80 mm,
the yield strength is in the order of 390 to 460 MPa, the tensile strength is in the
order to 510 to 570 MPa, the temperature T
kca=6000 at which the brittle fracture arrestability Kca reaches 6,000 N/mm
1.5 is -10°C or lower, and the Charpy impact absorbed energy vE (-20°C), which is an
indicator of the high heat-input HAZ toughness with 20 kJ/mm or greater of heat input,
is at least 47 J.

{in formula (5), component elements that represent unavoidable impurities are also
included within the calculation.}

{in formula (6), when O
Ti ≤ 0, it is deemed that O
Ti = 0, when O
Ti > 0, it is deemed that Ti - 20
Ti 0.005 (%), and when N - 0.29(Ti - 20
Ti) ≤ 0 (although when O
Ti ≤ 0, O
Ti = 0), it is deemed that N - 0.29(Ti - 20
Ti) = 0.}

With regard to the above formulas (5) to (7), formula (5) is the same as the aforementioned
formula (1), formula (6) is the same as the aforementioned formula (2), and formula
(7) is the same as the aforementioned formula (3).
[0032] Furthermore, in the thicker high-strength steel plate having excellent brittle fracture
arrestability and excellent toughness of the heat affected zone in high heat-input
welding according to the present invention, with regard to the elements listed in
the above chemical composition, the lower limit for the S content may be set to 0.0005%,
and the lower limit for the O content may be set to 0.001%. Moreover, if required,
the steel plate may also selectively include one or more selected from the group consisting
of Ca: 0.0003 to 0.004%, Mg: 0.0003 to 0.004%, Ni: 0.01 to 1%, Cu: 0.01 to 1%, Cr:
0.01 to 1%, Mo: 0.01 to 0.5%, Nb: 0.003 to 0.03%, REM: 0.0003 to 0.02%, and Zr: 0.0003
to 0.02%.
A description of the reasons for restricting the amounts of the chemical elements
within the steel (thicker high-strength steel plate) of the present invention is presented
below.
[C: carbon] 0.05 to 0.12%
[0033] C is an important element for increasing the steel strength. In a thick steel plate
prepared by a TMCP that takes full advantage of low-temperature heating and low-temperature
rolling, at least 0.05% of C must be added to ensure that a predetermined level of
strength is obtained in a stable manner. Further, for the reasons outlined below,
the amounts added of Nb, Ni and Mo within the present invention must be suppressed
to the minimum amounts required, and therefore it is problematic to strengthen the
steel by increasing the amounts of these elements. Accordingly, C becomes an extremely
important strengthening element. Moreover, C also has the effect of promoting precipitation
of V(C,N) transformation nuclei within a high heat-input HAZ. However, in order to
ensure favorable HAZ toughness is achieved in a stable manner, the amount of C must
be restricted to not more than 0.12%, and in order to enhance the HAZ toughness, an
amount of not more than 0.10% is preferred.
[Si: silicon] not more than 0.3%
[0034] Si has a deoxidizing action, but is unnecessary in those cases where Al which is
a powerful deoxidizing element is added in a sufficient amount. Si also has the effect
of strengthening the base material, but that effect is comparatively weak compared
with those of other elements. Moreover, in a high heat-input HAZ of the present invention
which requires a comparatively high carbon equivalent Ceq, there is a considerable
danger that Si may promote MA growth, and therefore the Si content must be suppressed
to not more than 0.3%. From the viewpoint of the HAZ toughness, the amount of added
Si is preferably suppressed as low as possible, to an amount of not more than 0.20%.
In terms of ensuring favorable strength and satisfactory deoxidation, Si is preferably
added in an amount of at least 0.01%.
[Mn: manganese] 1 to 2%
[0035] In order to ensure an economical improvement in the strength of the steel, the amount
of added Mn must be at least 1%, and is preferably 1.40% or greater. However, if Mn
is added in an amount exceeding 2%, then the harmful effects of center segregation
within the slab become quite marked, and hardening of the high heat-input HAZ and
promotion of MA generation are also promoted; thereby, embrittlement proceeds, and
therefore 2% is set as the upper limit. In order to prevent this embrittlement, the
amount of Mn is preferably restricted to not more than 1.60%.
[P: phosphorus] not more than 0.015%
[0036] P is an impurity element, and must be reduced to not more than 0.015% in order to
ensure that favorable brittle fracture arrestability and favorable HAZ toughness in
high heat-input welding can be achieved in a stable manner. In order to enhance the
HAZ toughness, the amount of P is preferably 0.010% or less.
[S: sulfur] 0.0005 to 0.005%
[0037] S must be suppressed to not more than 0.005%. If the amount of S exceeds 0.005%,
then it tends to cause a portion of the sulfides to coarsen and act as crack origins
which are harmful, and the toughness of both of the base material and the high heat-input
HAZ tend to deteriorate. In order to minimize these harmful effects, the S content
is preferably not more than 0.003%. On the other hand, in order to utilize the HAZ
pinning effect, the amount of S must be at least 0.0005%. The reason for this requirement
is to ensure that by appropriate addition of Ca and Mg, a multitude of fine sulfides
can be dispersed in the vicinity of the HAZ fusion line; thereby, strengthening the
pinning effect to enable better size reduction of the γ grains for the purpose of
increasing the HAZ toughness. If the amount of S is less than 0.0005%, then the number
of sulfides tends to be inadequate; thereby, a satisfactory pinning effect cannot
be obtained.
[B: boron] 0.0003 to 0.003%
[0038] B is a feature element within the present invention. As already described in detail,
in the present invention, in both of the base material and the high heat-input HAZ,
the calculated value of the effective B amount (Bef) represented by the above formula
(2) is controlled to a value of not more than 0% so as to precipitate all of the B
as BN in a state where no solid solution B exists within the γ; thereby, eliminating
any B hardenability. The BN particles precipitated within the γ function as transformation
nuclei, and improve the toughness by reducing the size of the HAZ structures, reducing
the hardness, and reducing the amount of MA. For this reason, B must be added in an
amount of not less than 0.0003%. However, if an amount of B exceeding 0.003% is added,
then coarse B precipitates are produced; thereby, a deterioration in the HAZ toughness
is caused, and therefore 0.003% is set as the upper limit. In order to ensure favorable
HAZ toughness in a stable manner, the B content is preferably not more than 0.0020%.
[V: vanadium] 0.01 to 0.15%
[0039] V is a feature element in the present invention. As already described in detail,
V effectively strengthens the base material under the TMCP conditions of the present
invention. On the other hand, V also suppresses the increasing of MA and the hardening
within the high heat-input HAZ of the present invention, and the VN and V(C,N) which
are precipitated within the γ act as transformation, nuclei; thereby, reducing the
size of the HAZ structures and enhancing the toughness. In order to ensure these effects
manifest satisfactorily, at least 0.01% of V must be added. However, if the amount
of V exceeds 0.15%, then the refinement effect of HAZ microstructure becomes saturated,
and at the same time, the HAZ hardness increases dramatically; thereby, a deterioration
in the HAZ toughness is caused. Accordingly, the upper limit for the V content is
0.15%, and this limit is preferably 0.10% or lower.
[Al: aluminum] 0.001 to 0.1%
[0040] Al is a deoxidizing element, and is necessary for reducing O and enhancing the cleanliness
of the steel. Elements other than Al such as Si, Ti, Ca, Mg, REM and Zr also exhibit
deoxidizing activity, but even in the case where these other elements are added, if
the Al content is not 0.001 % or greater, then it is difficult to stably suppress
the amount of O (oxygen) to 0.004% or less. However, if the amount of Al exceeds 0.1%,
then there is an increased tendency for coarse alumina-based oxides to form clusters;
thereby, blockages of the steelmaking nozzles are caused or the coarse alumina-based
oxides act as harmful crack origins, and therefore 0.1% is set as the upper limit.
In order to minimize the possibility of these harmful effects, the Al content is preferably
not more than 0.060%.
[Ti: titanium] 0.005 to 0.02%, [N: nitrogen] 0.002 to 0.01 %, and [effective B amount:
Bef (%)] not more than 0% (for the calculated value from formula (2))
[0041] Ti bonds with N to form TiN, and contributes to the pinning effect during slab reheating
and in the high heat-input HAZ, thus contributing to the reduction in the γ grain
size. As a result, Ti reduces the size of the structures of the base material and
the HAZ; thereby, enhancing the toughness. The remaining N after formation of the
TiN bonds with B to form BN; thereby, precipitating all of the B as BN so that no
solid solution B exists within the γ. As a result, the manifestation of B hardenability
is prevented.
In order to enable the above effects to be achieved simultaneously, the amount of
Ti must be 0.005 to 0.02%, the amount of N must be 0.002 to 0.01 %, and the calculated
value of the effective B amount (Bef) represented by the above formula (2) must be
not more than 0%.
If the amounts of Ti and N do not reach 0.005% and 0.002% respectively, then the pinning
effect due to TiN does not manifest satisfactorily, and the toughness of the base
material and the HAZ tend to deteriorate. If the amounts of Ti and N exceed 0.02%
and 0.01% respectively, then the TiC precipitates and the amount of solid solution
N increases; thereby, causing the toughness of the base material and the HAZ to deteriorate.
In order to better enhance the HAZ toughness, the amounts of Ti and N are preferably
not more than 0.015% and 0.007%, respectively. Moreover, even in the case where the
amounts of Ti and N are within the appropriate ranges, if the effective B amount exceeds
0%, then the amount of solid solution B within the γ increases and B hardenability
appears; thereby, causing variation in the base material strength and hardening (embrittlement)
of the HAZ.
[0042] A description of the thinking related to the effective B amount is presented below.
The Ti added as a chemical component may sometimes be consumed by the deoxidation
that occurs within the melted steel (this is more likely in cases where the amount
of A1 is low), and the residual Ti left after this deoxidation forms TiN within the
solidified γ. During this process, if N exists in excess relative to the amount of
Ti, then the N that remains after formation of TiN bonds with a portion of the B to
form BN. The residual B that is left after formation of the BN exists as solid solution
B that yields hardenability. In the present invention, the amount of this solid solution
B within the γ that contributes to the hardenability is referred to as the effective
B amount Bef(%).
[0043] A method of calculating the effective B amount Bef based on the added amount of each
element, the thermodynamic reaction sequence, and the stoichiometric composition of
the product is described below.
Firstly, the assumption is made that in order of deoxidizing power, Ca, Mg, REM (rare
earth metal elements), Zr and Al undergo bonding with O. The amount of deoxidized
O is calculated on the assumption that the deoxidation products are CaO, MgO, REM
2O
3, ZrO
2 and Al
2O
3, respectively.
In those cases where the deoxidation is not completed by these elements having a stronger
deoxidizing power than Ti, if the amount of residual oxygen O
Ti (%) that remains after deoxidation by the strong deoxidizing elements and is able
to undergo deoxidation by Ti which is the weaker deoxidizing element is an amount
represented by formula (1) shown below, then the formula.: {O
Ti (%) > 0} is satisfied.

wherein in the formula (1), component elements that represent unavoidable impurities
are also included within the calculation.
[0044] In this case, the residual O (=O
Ti) undergoes deoxidation by Ti. Assuming the production of Ti
2O
3, the amount of residual Ti obtained by subtracting the amount of Ti consumed as a
result of deoxidation is represented by Ti - 2O
Ti ≥ 0.005 (%), and this value must be at least 0.005%. Here, the reason that the amount
of residual Ti obtained by subtracting the Ti consumed as a result of deoxidation
must be at least 0.005% is to ensure that, as described above, the amount of TiN required
for the present invention is obtained.
If the amount of residual Ti obtained by subtracting the Ti consumed as a result of
deoxidation is less than 0.005%, then the pinning effect due to TiN does not manifest
satisfactorily, and the toughness of the thick base material and the high heat-input
HAZ tend to deteriorate.
[0045] Furthermore, the 0.005% or more of Ti that remains after the deoxidation forms TiN,
and if any N remains after this TiN formation, then the following formula yields a
positive value, whereas if no N remains, the formula yields either 0 or a negative
value.
N - 0.29(Ti - 2OTi) > 0 : in cases where N remains
N - 0.29(Ti - 2OTi) ≤ 0 : in cases where no N remains
[0046] Furthermore, in those cases where the above formula {N - 0.29(Ti - 20
Ti)} yields a positive value, a portion of the B is consumed as BN; thereby, the effective
B amount Bef can be calculated using formula (2) shown below.

wherein in the formula (2), when O
Ti ≤ 0, it is deemed that O
Ti = 0, when O
Ti > 0, it is deemed that {Ti - 2 O
Ti ≥ 0.005 (%)}, and when {N - 0.29(Ti - 20
Ti) ≤ 0 (although when O
Ti ≤ 0, O
Ti = 0)}, it is deemed that {N - 0.29(Ti - 20
Ti) = 0}.
[0047] Furthermore, in those cases where the formula {N - 0.29(Ti - 2O
Ti)} yields 0 or a negative value and no N remains, the effective B amount Bef is represented
by simply by Bef (%) = B.
[0048] In terms of the coefficients for Ca, Mg, REM, Zr and Al within the above formula
for the amount of residual oxygen O
Ti, if the assumption is made that the products (oxides) of the deoxidation reactions
(oxidation reactions) within the melted steel are CaO, MgO, REM
2O
3, ZrO
2 and Al
2O
3 respectively, then the amount of O that exists as each of these oxides can be calculated
as a mass % value. For example, in the case of CaO, because the atomic weight of Ca
is 40 and that of O is 16, relative to the mass % of Ca, 16/40 = 0.4 of O is bonded.
In the case of Al
2O
3, the atomic weights are 27 for Al and 16 for O, and therefore relative to the mass
% of Al, (16 × 3)/(27 × 2) = 0.89 of O is bonded. Using similar calculations, the
coefficients for each of the elements in the above O
Ti formula (0.66 for Mg, 0.17 for REM, and 0.35 for Zr) can be determined.
[0049] Furthermore, if the derived formula concept for the effective B amount is represented
in a backward manner from the low-temperature side to the high-temperature side, then
the following sequence is obtained.
Effective B amount Bef (%) = amount of component B - B as BN
→ B as BN = 0.77(N - N as TiN)
→ N as TiN = 0.29(Ti - Ti as Ti2O3)
→ Ti - Ti as Ti2O3 = 2(O - O as CaO - O as MgO - O as REM2O3 - O as ZrO2 - O as Al2O3)
→ O as CaO = 0.4Ca
→ O as MgO = 0.66Mg
→ O as REM2O3 = 0.17REM
→ O as ZrO2 = 0.35Zr
→ O as Al2O3 = 0.89Al
[0050] Next, if the derived formula concept for the effective B amount is represented in
the reaction sequence from the high-temperature side to the low-temperature side,
then the following sequence is obtained. In other words, in the steps from refining
→ solidification during the steelmaking process, the reaction sequence is as follows.
[1] Deoxidation reaction within liquid phase (melted steel) (in the vicinity of 1,600°C)
[0051] The deoxidation reactions occur in the order of the strength of the chemical affinity
of each element for O, namely CaO → MgO → REM
2O
3 → ZrO
2 → Al
2O
3; thereby, reducing the dissolved O within the melted steel. In those cases where
these reactions complete the deoxidation process, the formula O
Ti ≤ 0 satisfies. In those cases where the deoxidation is not complete and residual
dissolved oxygen still exists, the formulas O
Ti > 0 and Ti - 2O
Ti ≥ 0.005 (%) satisfy, so that Ti which is a weaker deoxidizing element than Al contributes
to deoxidation via formation of Ti
2O
3, and the amount of residual Ti obtained by subtracting the amount of Ti consumed
as Ti
2O
3 from the amount of the component Ti is at least 0.005%.
[2] Denitrification reaction within solid phase (solidified γ) (near 1,300°C to near
800°C)
[0052] The denitrification reactions occur in the order of the strength of the chemical
affinity of each element for N, namely TiN → BN → AlN; thereby, reducing the amount
of solid solution N within the solid phase γ. First, the residual Ti left after consumption
by the deoxidation undergoes a denitrification reaction. In those cases where this
reaction completes the denitrification process, the formula N - 0.29(Ti - 2O
Ti) ≤ 0 satisfies and no solid solution N exists within the γ; thereby, B does not form
BN but rather exists entirely as solid solution B. In contrast, in those cases where
the denitrification is not completed by Ti and therefore, residual solid solution
N still exists, the formula N - 0.29(Ti - 2O
Ti) > 0 satisfies and a portion of the B generates BN, while the remainder exists as
solid solution B.
[0053] On the other hand, in those cases where the deoxidation is completed by one or more
elements having a stronger deoxidizing power than Ti, the formula below is satisfied.

In these cases, the Ti is not consumed by deoxidation. The Ti forms TiN, and if any
N remains, the following formula is satisfied.

The effective B amount Bef in such cases is calculated using the following formula.

If the Ti forms TiN and no residual N remains, then the formula below is satisfied.

The effective B amount Bef in such cases is calculated using the following formula.

[0054] In each of the above formulas, the expression 0.29Ti within the formula (N - 0.29Ti)
represents N as TiN. Here, the atomic weights are 48 for Ti and 14 for N, and therefore
relative to the mass % of Ti (strictly speaking, relative to the mass of residual
Ti after subtraction of the mass of Ti consumed by deoxidation), 14/48 = 0.29 of N
is bonded. Further, if N - 0.29Ti ≤ 0, then all of the N is fixed as TiN, and no solid
solution N exists within the γ base material. On the other hand, if N - 0.29Ti > 0,
then solid solution N exists in the γ base material in addition to TiN, and therefore
this solid solution N bonds with B to generate BN; thereby, reducing the effective
B amount.
[O: oxygen] 0.001 to not more than 0.004%
[0055] O must be suppressed to not more than 0.004%. If the amount of O exceeds 0.004%,
then it tends to cause a portion of the oxides to coarsen and act as crack origins
which are harmful, and the toughness of both of the base material and the high heat-input
HAZ tend to deteriorate. On the other hand, in order to utilize the HAZ pinning effect,
the amount of O must be at least 0.001%. The reason for this requirement is to ensure
that by appropriate addition of Ca and Mg, a multitude of fine oxides can be dispersed
in the vicinity of the HAZ fusion line; thereby, strengthening the pinning effect
to enable better size reduction of the γ grains for the purpose of increasing the
HAZ toughness. If the amount of O is less than 0.001%, then the number of oxides tends
to be inadequate; thereby, a satisfactory pinning effect cannot be obtained.
[Ca: calcium] 0.0003 to 0.004%, and [Mg: magnesium] 0.0003 to 0.004%
[0056] By adding at least 0.0003% of either one or both of Ca and Mg, with due consideration
of the order of addition to the molten steel, oxides and/or sulfides containing Ca
and/or Mg and having a particle size of 10 to 500 nm can be generated in an amount
of at least 1,000 particles/mm
2. If the amount(s) of Ca and/or Mg are less than 0.0003%, then there is a possibility
that the number of oxides or sulfides that function as pinning particles for the high
heat-input HAZ may be insufficient. Furthermore, if each of the added amounts exceeds
0.004%, then the oxides and/or sulfides tend to coarsen, and not only may the number
of pinning particles be insufficient, but there is a strong possibility that the coarse
particles may act as crack origins which are harmful; thereby, there is a possibility
that favorable HAZ toughness cannot be obtained.
[Ni: nickel] 0.01 to 1%
[0057] Ni is an element that is effective in suppressing deterioration in the toughness
while ensuring the strength of the steel. For this reason, at least 0.01% of Ni must
be added. However, the alloy cost ofNi is extremely high, and may cause the introduction
of surface blemishes. Accordingly, the Ni content must be suppressed to not more than
1%. Further, in order to avoid surface blemishes, the Ni content is preferably reduced
as low as possible, and it is preferable to restrict the Ni content to not more than
0.7% or to not more than 0.5%.
[Cu: copper] 0.01 to 1%, [Cr: chromium] 0.01 to 1%, and [Mo: molybdenum] 0.01 to 0.5%
[0058] Cu, Cr and Mo are effective in ensuring favorable strength, and each exhibits a satisfactory
effect at an added amount of 0.01 % or more. On the other hand, in terms of avoiding
a deterioration in the HAZ toughness in high heat-input welding, the upper limits
for these elements are 1%, 1% and 0.5% respectively, and the amounts are preferably
restricted to not more than 0.4%, 0.3% and 0.1% respectively. Cr and Mo are particularly
expensive elements similar to Ni, and there is also a significant risk that they may
promote MA growth in the HAZ, and therefore Cr and Mo are preferably not added.
[Nb: niobium] 0.003 to 0.03%
[0059] Nb is effective in promoting non-recrystallization region rolling during finish rolling.
For this reason, at least 0.003% of Nb is preferably added. However, Nb is harmful
in terms of the HAZ toughness in high heat-input welding. Accordingly, in the present
invention, a very small amount ofNb of not more than 0.03% may be added to promote
non-recrystallization region rolling. From the viewpoint of the HAZ toughness, the
amount ofNb is preferably suppressed to not more than 0.02%, or more preferably to
not more than 0.01%. Furthermore, in those cases where a large cumulative reduction
ratio can be achieved during finish rolling, a satisfactory size reduction in the
base material structures is realized; thereby, favorable brittle fracture arrestability
can be achieved even without adding Nb. Therefore, in terms of the HAZ toughness,
not adding Nb is particularly desirable.
[REM: rare earth metal elements (lanthanoid-based elements)] 0.0003 to 0.02%, and
[Zr; zirconium] 0.0003 to 0.002%
[0060] REM (rare earth metal elements) and Zr contribute to deoxidation and desulfurization,
suppress the generation of coarse stretched MnS in the center segregation zone and
convert sulfides to harmless spherical forms; thereby, improving the toughness of
the base material and the high heat-input HAZ. In order to realize these effects,
the lower limits for both of REM and Zr are 0.0003%. However, if the added amounts
of these elements are increased, then the effects are soon saturated, and therefore
from the viewpoint of economic viability, the upper limits for REM and Zr are set
to 0.02% in both cases. The REM added in the present invention refers to lanthanoids
such as La, Ce, and the like.
[0061] As described above, according to the method for producing a thicker high-strength
steel plate having excellent brittle fracture arrestability and excellent toughness
of the heat affected zone in high heat-input welding, and the thicker high-strength
steel plate having excellent brittle fracture arrestability and excellent toughness
of the heat affected zone in high heat-input welding of the present invention, by
adding the steel components so that each element is included in an amount that satisfies
the range described above and the element composition satisfies the relational formulas
listed above, and by setting each of the production conditions in the manner described
above, a thicker high-strength steel plate can be obtained that realizes (1) high
strength for the thick steel plate including a yield strength in the order of 390
to 460 MPa (namely, a tensile strength in the order of 510 to 570 MPa) for a plate
thickness of 50 to 80 mm, (2) favorable brittle fracture arrestability indicated by
an arrestability indicator T
kca=6000 ≤ -10°C, (3) favorable HAZ toughness in high heat-input welding indicated by vE (-20°C)
≥ 47 J even when the heat input during welding is ≥ 20 kJ/mm, and (4) reduced production
costs due to a reduction in the amount of expensive alloy elements (such as a Ni amount
of ≤ 0.5%).
By using this type of thicker high-strength steel plate of the present invention in
all manner of welded structures, including large ships, an increase in the size of
the welded structure, a high level of safety in terms of cracking, improved welding
efficiency during construction, and favorable economic viability of the steel plate
used as a structural material can all be achieved at the same time, and therefore
the industrial effect of the invention is immense.
EXAMPLES
[0062] A description of specifics of the present invention is presented below, using examples
of the method for producing a thicker high-strength steel plate having excellent brittle
fracture arrestability and excellent toughness of the heat affected zone in high heat-input
welding of the present invention, and examples of the thicker high-strength steel
plate having excellent brittle fracture arrestability and excellent toughness of the
heat affected zone in high heat-input welding of the present invention. However, the
present invention is in no way limited by the examples presented below, and various
modifications may be made within the scope of the invention described above and below,
and such modifications are all deemed to be included within the technical scope of
the present invention.
[Sample preparation]
[0063] By performing deoxidation and desulfurization of the melted steel and controlling
the chemical element composition during the steelmaking process, and then conducting
continuous casting, slabs (continuously cast slabs) were prepared with the chemical
component compositions shown below in Tables I to 4. Subsequently, using the production
conditions shown below in Tables 5 to 10, each slab was reheated and subjected to
thick plate rolling to realize a finished plate thickness of 50 to 80 mm, and was
then subjected to accelerated cooling, and if necessary, further subjected to off-line
tempering, thus completing preparation of a thick steel plate sample.
[0064] In these examples, lists of the chemical element compositions for thick steel plates
according to the steel of the present invention are shown in Tables 1 and 2, and lists
of the chemical element compositions for comparative steels are shown in Tables 3
and 4. Further, lists of the production conditions for the steel plates of the steels
according to the present invention are shown in Tables 5 and 6, whereas lists of the
production conditions for the steel plates of the comparative steels are shown in
Tables 7 and 8. Furthermore, lists of the conditions for comparative steels in which
the steel plate is produced using the chemical element composition of "Steel No. 1"
of the present invention shown in Tables 1 and 2, but with altered values for various
production conditions, are shown in Tables 9 and 10.
[0065] In Tables 2 and 4, Ceq, formula A, formula B, formula C, formulas D, and Ar
3 are each defined as follows.

Furthermore, the effective B amount is defined as follows.
(i) When the value of formula A < 0
- (a) when the value of formula B > 0, effective B amount = B - 0.77(N - 0.29Ti)
- (b) when the value of formula B ≤ 0, effective B amount = B
(ii) When the value of formula A ≥ 0
The value of formula C ≥ 0.005
- (a) when the value of formula D > 0, effective B amount = B - 0.77{N - 0.29[Ti - 2(O
- 0.4Ca - 0.66Mg - 0.17REM - 0.35Zr - 0.89Al)]}
- (b) when the value of formulas D ≤ 0, effective B amount = B
[0066]

[0067]

[0068]

[0069]

[0070]

[0071]

[0072]

[0073]

[0074]

[0075]

[Evaluation tests]
[0076] The thick steel plate samples prepared using the above method were each subjected
to the following evaluation tests.
The tensile properties and Charpy impact properties of the base material were evaluated
by taking a test piece from the mid-thickness of steel plate sample - in a rolled
longitudinal (L) direction, and then testing this test piece.
The brittle fracture arrestability of the base material was evaluated by conducting
a crack test of a full thickness test piece using the temperature gradient ESSO test
(compliant with WES 3003) to determine the value of the arrestability indicator T
kca=6000.
The joint HAZ toughness was investigated by performing one-pass butt welding using
electro-gas welding (EGW), and then inserting a notch in the HAZ 1 mm, from the weld
line in a 1/2 plate thickness portion. In this case, three samples were subjected
to Charpy impact tests at -20°C, and the average absorption energy value was determined.
For reference purposes, the Charpy impact properties were also evaluated at -40°C.
[0077] In terms of the mechanical properties of the thick steel plates and the welded joints,
a list of the mechanical properties for the steels of the present invention produced
under the production conditions shown in Tables 5 and 6 are shown in Table 11, whereas
a list of the mechanical properties for the comparative steels produced under the
production conditions shown in Tables 7 and 8 are shown in Table 12.
A list of the mechanical properties for thick steel plates and welded joints for comparative
steels in which the steel plate was produced using the chemical element composition
of "Steel No. 1" of the present invention, but with altered values for various production
conditions shown in Tables 9 and 10, are shown in Table 13.
[0078]

[0079]

[0080]

[Evaluation results]
[0081] The steels No. 1 to 16 shown in Tables 1 and 2 represent steels of the present invention,
and it is evident from the results that by optimizing the chemical composition of
the steel and maximizing the effects of the low-temperature heating and low-temperature
rolling in the TMCP, a steel plate is obtained which, as shown in Table 11, despite
being a thick steel plate, exhibits a yield strength in the order of 390 to 460 MPa,
a tensile strength in the order of 510 to 570 MPa and a favorable brittle fracture
arrestability T
kca = 6000 of less than -10°C, and which despite undergoing high heat-input welding, yields
a favorable HAZ toughness at -20°C while suppressing the amount of added Ni to not
more than 1%.
[0082] In contrast, the comparative steels No. 17 to 36 shown in Tables 3 and 4 do not have
an optimized chemical composition for the steel, whereas the comparative steels 1A
to 1I shown in Tables 9 and 10 are produced with steel production conditions that
are not optimal, and therefore as is evident from Tables 12 and 13, one of the yield
strength, the tensile strength, the T
kca = 6000 value or the HAZ toughness in high heat-input welding deteriorates, and this plurality
of required properties is unable to be satisfied in the same manner as the thicker
high-strength steel plates of the present invention.
[0083] Steel No. 17 has low values for C and Ceq, and steel No. 20 has a low Mn content,
and therefore the hardenability is unsatisfactory. As a result, a deterioration in
the yield strength and tensile strength occurs.
Steel No. 18 has a high C content, steel No. 19 has a high Si content, steel No. 21
has a high Mn content, and steel No. 22 has a low B content, and therefore each steel
has poor toughness of the high heat-input HAZ.
Steel No. 23 has a low V content, and therefore has a lower strength than steel No.
1 that has the same plate thickness but a lower Ceq value. Further, although the Ceq
value of steel No. 23 is higher than that of steel No. 1, the steel No. 23 is unable
to satisfy the yield strength in the order of 460 MPa and the tensile strength in
the order of 570 MPa which are satisfied by steel No. 1. Moreover, the high heat-input
HAZ toughness is also inferior.
Steel No. 24 has a high V content, and therefore has a considerably higher strength
than steel No. 11 that has the same plate thickness and Ceq value, but the high heat-input
HAZ toughness is inferior.
Steels No. 25, 26, 27, 30, 31, 34 and 35 have the same Ceq and plate thickness values,
and the TMCP conditions shown in Tables 7 and 8 are also the same. However, because
the effective B amount is within a range from 8 to 10 ppm, the yield strength is from
440 to 600 MPa, and the tensile strength is from 550 to 700 MPa, these results indicate
that there is large variation in the strength. Moreover, the high heat-input HAZ toughness
is inferior.
[0084] Steel No. 28 has a high P content and steel No. 29 has a high S content, and therefore
the base material toughness and the high heat-input HAZ toughness are inferior in
both cases.
Steel No. 31 has a low Al content and therefore the O content becomes hgher, and steel
No. 32 has a very high Al content and therefore contains alumina clusters. In both
cases, the amount of coarse harmful oxides increases; thereby, causing a deterioration
in the toughness of both of the base material and the high heat-input HAZ.
Steel No. 33 has a low Ti content and steel No. 35 has a low N content, and therefore
the production of TiN is insufficient in both steels; thereby, the crystal grains
within the base material and the HAZ are unable to be adequately reduced in size.
As a result, inferior results for the base material toughness, the arrestability,
and the high heat-input HAZ toughness are obtained.
Steel No. 34 has a high Ti content and steel No. 36 has a high N content, and therefore
in both steels, TiC embrittlement and solid solution B embrittlement result in inferior
base material toughness and inferior high heat-input HAZ toughness.
[0085] Steel No. 1A is produced with a high start temperature for the slab reheating, and
steel No. 1B is produced using a high heating temperature. Therefore, in both cases,
the γ grains coarsen during heating; thereby, causing a deterioration in the brittle
fracture arrestability T
kca = 6000.
In steel No. 1C, the heating temperature is too low, and therefore the solubilization
of V carbonitrides is inadequate. As a result, the amount of V carbides which operate
for the precipitate strengthening is insufficient; thereby, the base material strength
is reduced. As a result, the yield strength and the tensile strength are each 20 MPa
lower than that of steel No. 1, and the strength advantage of adding 0.02% of V is
unable to be realized. Moreover, because the finishing temperature of the rough rolling
is too low, the size of the recrystallized grains is unable to be reduced sufficiently
(uniform grain refinement is not conducted sufficiently); thereby, the T
kca = 6000 value is inferior.
In steel No. 1D, the finishing temperature of the rough rolling is too low, whereas
in steel No. 1E, the cumulative reduction ratio for the rough rolling is too low,
and therefore in both steels, the size of the recrystallized grains is unable to be
reduced sufficiently (uniform grain refinement is not conducted sufficiently); thereby,
a T
kca = 6000 value is inferior.
In steel No. 1F and steel No. 1G, both of the start temperature and the completion
temperature of the finish rolling are too high, and the above formula {-0.5 × (slab
heating temperature (°C)) + 1,325} is not satisfied. As a result, the size reduction
of the crystal grains of the base material is inadequate; thereby, the T
kca = 6000 value is inferior.
In steel No. 1H, the cumulative reduction ratio for the finish rolling is too low,
and therefore the size reduction of the crystal grains of the base material is inadequate;
thereby, the T
kca = 6000 value is inferior.
In steel No. 1I, the stop temperature for the accelerated cooling is too high, and
therefore the transformation strengthening and crystal grain size reduction within
the interior of the plate are unsatisfactory, resulting in inferior tensile strength
and an inferior T
kca = 6000 value.
[0086] Based on the results of the examples described above, it is clear that the thicker
high-strength steel plate having excellent brittle fracture arrestability and excellent
toughness of the heat affected zone in high heat-input welding according to the present
invention is capable of realizing (1) high strength for thick steel plate including
a yield strength in the order of 390 to 460 MPa (namely, a tensile strength in the
order of 510 to 570 MPa) for a plate thickness of 50 to 80 mm, (2) favorable brittle
fracture arrestability indicated by an arrestability indicator T
kca=6000 ≤ -10°C, (3) favorable HAZ toughness in high heat-input welding indicated by vE (-20°C)
≥ 47 J even when the heat input during welding is ≥ 20 kJ/mm, and (4) reduced production
costs due to a reduction in the amount of expensive alloy elements (such as a Ni amount
of ≤ 1%).
INDUSTRIAL APPLICABILITY
[0087] By using the thicker high-strength steel plate of the present invention in all manner
of welded structures, including large ships, an increase in the size of the welded
structure, a high level of safety in terms of cracking, improved welding efficiency
during construction, and favorable economic viability of the steel plate used as a
structural material can all be achieved simultaneously. Accordingly, the thicker high-strength
steel plate of the present invention can be applied to the construction of ships including
large container ships, as well as other welded structures such as buildings, bridges,
tanks and marine structures.