[0001] The present invention relates to a titanium alloy which excels in corrosion resistance,
particularly in intergranular corrosion resistance, in specific environments.
[0002] Titanium is known to show satisfactory corrosion resistance in chloride solutions
such as seawater and in oxidizing acids such as nitric acid. Titanium, however, may
not exhibit its satisfactory corrosion resistance when exposed to a non-oxidizing
environment such as hydrochloric acid or sulfuric acid in a high concentration at
high temperatures.
[0003] For improving the corrosion resistance in such specific environments, Ti-Pd alloys
containing palladium (Pd) in a content of about 0.12% to 0.25% (Japanese Industrial
Standards (JIS) H 4650 Types 11 to 13; ASTM Grade 7 and Grade 11) have been employed.
[0004] To overcome the drawback of expensiveness of the Ti-Pd alloys, there have been recently
developed corrosion-resistant titanium alloys containing Pd, which is an expensive
platinum-group element, in a less content; and corrosion resistant titanium alloys
corresponding to the Ti-Pd alloys, except for replacing part of Pd typically with
a more inexpensive element such as Ru, Ni, or Cr (hereinafter these titanium alloys
are also referred to as "inexpensive corrosion-resistant titanium alloys") (e.g.,
Japanese Examined Patent Application Publication No.
H04-57735, Japanese Unexamined Patent Application Publication No.
S61-127844, and Japanese Unexamined Patent Application Publication No.
H04-308051).
[0005] The inexpensive corrosion-resistant titanium alloys include Ti-0.4Ni-0.015Pd-0.025Ru-0.14Cr
alloys (nominal composition; hereinafter these alloys are also referred to as "Ti-Ni-Pd-Ru-Cr
alloys") newly standardized typically as JIS Type 14 and Type 15 (JIS H4650), and
ASTM Grade 33 and Grade 34.
[0006] Such novel inexpensive corrosion-resistant titanium alloys (Ti-Ni-Pd-Ru-Cr alloys)
are known to develop corrosion resistance according to a mechanism different from
that of existing inexpensive corrosion-resistant titanium alloys (e.g., "
Tetsu-to-Hagane (in Japanese; Iron and Steel)", vol. 80, No. 4 (1994), p.353-358). Specifically, the novel inexpensive corrosion-resistant titanium alloys contain
chromium (Cr) unlike the existing inexpensive corrosion-resistant titanium alloys.
When the novel alloys are exposed to a corrosive environment, chromium selectively
dissolves out during early stages of the exposure to allow Pd and Ru to be concentrated
on the surface, in which Pd and Ru are platinum-group elements contained in less contents
than those of the existing inexpensive corrosion resistant titanium alloys. As a result,
the novel alloy exhibits satisfactory corrosion resistance even though they contain
platinum-group elements in less contents.
[0007] The Ti-Ni-Pd-Ru-Cr alloys have been widely used typically in the chemical industry
and in heat exchangers using seawater because of their inexpensiveness and satisfactory
corrosion resistance. However, even the Ti-Ni-Pd-Ru-Cr alloys undergo corrosion in
the form of intergranular corrosion in certain specific environments. Exemplary specific
environments include severe use environments such that the Ti-Ni-Pd-Ru-Cr alloys are
disable to maintain their passive state and that the Ti-Ni-Pd-Ru-Cr alloys have to
be exchanged every several years; and environments typically in parts attached around
electrodes of electrolysis tanks such that an anode current also passes through the
Ti-Ni-Pd-Ru-Cr alloys.
[0008] Such corrosion-resistant titanium alloys are originally excellent in intergranular
corrosion resistance, and even pure titanium is resistant to intergranular corrosion
in regular environments. However, intergranular corrosion may proceed in the specific
use environments. The intergranular corrosion is abominated by users because it may
cause rapid fracture of apparatuses, unlike general corrosion which is a regular corrosion
form. Accordingly, demands are made to provide a Ti-Ni-Pd-Ru-Cr alloy that can minimize
the proceeding of intergranular corrosion even in the specific corrosive environments.
[0009] The present invention has been made under these circumstances, and an object thereof
is to provide a titanium alloy that may minimize the proceeding of intergranular corrosion
even in specific environments where the intergranular corrosion may easily proceed.
[0010] The present invention has achieved the object and provides, in an aspect, a titanium
alloy which contains nickel (Ni) in a content of 0.35 to 0.55 percent by mass (hereinafter
contents will be simply expressed in"%"); palladium (Pd) in a content of 0.01% to
0.02%; ruthenium (Ru) in a content of 0.02% to 0.04%; and chromium (Cr) in a content
of 0.1% to 0.2%, with the remainder including titanium and inevitable impurities,
in which the titanium alloy includes nickel-rich phases, each nickel-rich phase being
a phase (other than titanium alpha phase) locally containing Ni in a content of 10
times or more the average Ni content of the titanium alloy, the nickel-rich phases
are aligned along a rolling direction to form a row, and a multiplicity of the rows
are aligned substantially in parallel in a cross direction.
[0011] The present invention also provides, in another aspect, a titanium alloy which contains
Ni in a content of 0.35% to 0.55%; Pd in a content of 0.01% to 0.02%; Ru in a content
of 0.02% to 0.04%; and Cr in a content of 0.1% to 0.2%, with the remainder including
titanium and inevitable impurities, in which the titanium alloy includes one or more
nickel-rich phases, each nickel-rich phase being a phase (other than titanium alpha
phase) locally containing Ni in a content of 10 times or more the average Ni content
of the titanium alloy, and the nickel-rich phases contain Ti
2Ni.
[0012] As used herein the term "nickel-rich phase" includes the beta phase and precipitates
as compounds between and Ni, each of which contains Ni in a content 10 times or more
the average Ni content of the matrix titanium alloy. It should be noted, however,
that titanium alpha phase is excluded from the "nickel-rich phase" herein, even when
the alpha phase contains Ni in a large content of 10 times or more the average Ni
content
[0013] The respective titanium alloys according to the present invention may be obtained
by performing final annealing at a temperature in the range of 600°C to 725°C after
rolling.
[0014] According to the present invention, the conditions for final annealing after rolling
of Ti-Ni-Pd-Ru-Cr alloys are suitably controlled, and whereby the titanium alloys
are allowed to have (1) a microstructure in which the nickel-rich phases are aligned
along a rolling direction to form a row, and a multiplicity of the rows are aligned
substantially in parallel in a cross direction; or (2) a microstructure in which the
nickel-rich phases mainly contain Ti
2Ni. The resulting titanium alloys excel in intergranular corrosion resistance in specific
environments and are thereby very useful as materials typically for apparatuses to
be used in such environments which are believed to cause intergranular corrosion.
FIG. 1 depicts photographs illustrating results of electron probe microanalysis (EPMA)
mapping of Ni in L-direction (longitudinal direction; rolling direction) sectional
structures of titanium alloys obtained through final annealing at different temperatures;
FIGS. 2A, 2B, and 2C depict scanning electron micrographs (SEMs) illustrating how
are corrosion forms of the titanium alloys obtained through final annealing at different
temperatures;
FIGS. 3A, 3B, 3C, and 3D depict scanning electron micrographs illustrating how are
corrosion forms of other exemplary titanium alloys obtained through final annealing
at different temperatures;
FIG. 4 depicts results of EPMA mapping of Ni and Cr in L-direction sectional structures
of titanium alloys obtained through final annealing at different temperatures;
FIG. 5 depicts photographs illustrating secondary electron images (SEM images) and
results of mapping of a specimen; and
FIGS. 6A and 6B depict photographs illustrating exemplary results in observation of
a specimen under a transmission electron microscope (TEM).
[0015] Ti-Ni-Pd-Ru-Cr alloys to which the present invention is applied are used as materials
for various apparatuses in the chemical industry and for heat exchangers. They are
generally in the form of hot-rolled plates or cold-rolled plates. These rolled plates
are subjected to final annealing to give products. In laboratory scale, the annealing
of titanium may be performed as vacuum annealing in a vacuum atmosphere or an atmosphere
obtained through evacuation and argon (Ar) purge, without subsequent acid wash. However,
in industrial scale where productivity is weighed, the annealing is generally performed
as continuous annealing in an air atmosphere, followed by acid wash. The final annealing
is generally performed at a relatively high temperature (final annealing temperature)
of about 750°C to 800°C, for obtaining satisfactory formability.
[0016] The present inventors made various investigations to improve intergranular corrosion
resistance of Ti-Ni-Pd-Ru-Cr alloys and, as a result, have found that titanium alloys
manufactured through final annealing at a temperature in the range of 600°C to 725°C
have distinct microstructures.
[0017] Specifically, the present inventors have found that the titanium alloys manufactured
through final annealing at a temperature in the above-specified range include nickel-rich
phases, each nickel-rich phase being a phase (other than titanium alpha phase) locally
containing Ni in a content of 10 times or more the average Ni content of the titanium
alloy and have (1) a microstructure in which the nickel-rich phases are aligned along
the rolling direction to form a row, and a multiplicity of the rows are aligned substantially
in parallel in the cross direction; or (2) a microstructure in which the nickel-rich
phases contain Ti
2Ni. The present inventors have also found that the titanium alloys having these microstructures
may exhibit satisfactory intergranular corrosion resistance even in specific corrosive
environments where customary titanium alloys suffer from intergranular corrosion.
The present invention has been made based on these findings.
[0018] Of the microstructures of the titanium alloys according to the present invention,
the microstructure in which the nickel-rich phases are aligned along the rolling direction
to form a row, and a multiplicity of the rows are aligned substantially in parallel
in a cross direction may be verified by the mapping of the cross section in the rolling
direction (cross section in the L direction) with an electron probe microanalyzer
(EPMA).
[0019] The "nickel-rich phase" being a phase (other than titanium alpha phase) locally containing
Ni in a content of 10 times or more the average Ni content, and the microstructure
containing Ti
2Ni may be verified by observation under a transmission electron microscope (TEM) or
electron diffraction analysis of the crystal structure.
[0020] FIG. 1 depicts the results of EPMA mapping ofL direction sectional structures of
JIS Type 14 cold-rolled plates (Ti-0.4Ni-0.015Pd-0.025Ru-0.14Cr alloys) manufactured
through final annealing at different temperatures. The other conditions will be described
in Experimental Examples later. In FIG.1, whitish areas indicate the presence of nickel-rich
phases. The results demonstrate that rolled plates manufactured through final annealing
at temperatures of 650°C and 725°C, respectively, include nickel-rich phases, in which
a multiplicity of rows of the nickel-rich phases are aligned substantially in parallel
in the cross direction.
[0021] The results also demonstrate that a rolled plate manufactured through final annealing
at a temperature of 750°C includes nickel-rich phases which are somewhat aligned in
a row, but includes not so many rows of nickel-rich phases as in the cold-rolled plates
manufactured at final annealing temperatures of 650°C and 725°C; and that cold-rolled
plates manufactured through final annealing at temperatures of 800°C and 830°C include
nickel-rich phases, but the nickel-rich phases do not substantially form rows.
[0022] The titanium alloys according to the present invention, when manufactured through
final annealing at a temperature of 725°C or lower, include at least one of the above
microstructures and thereby show good intergranular corrosion resistance. The lower
limit of the final annealing temperature is preferably 600°C, because titanium alloys,
if manufactured through final annealing at a temperature of lower than 600°C, may
undergo insufficient recrystallization and may thereby fail to have minimum required
formability, although they have good intergranular corrosion resistance. The atmosphere
in the final annealing is generally air atmosphere, but it is naturally understood
that the atmosphere may be a vacuum atmosphere or an atmosphere which is obtained
by evacuation and subsequent argon purge. The time or duration for final annealing
(the time for which the article is exposed to the annealing temperature) is about
1 to 10 minutes in the case of continuous annealing (and acid wash) in an air atmosphere.
It generally takes about 1 to 8 hours to attain uniform heating of the entire coil
(plate) in the case of vacuum annealing.
[0023] The chemical compositions of the titanium alloys according to the present invention
are basically in accordance with public specification values, and the microstructures
of them are controlled based on the premise that they have these chemical compositions.
Reasons why the respective contents of the compositions are specified are as follows.
[Ni in a content of 0.35% to 0.55%]
[0024] Nickel (Ni) element is relatively inexpensive as compared to Pd and, when contained
in a content of 0.35% or more, is effective to impart corrosion resistance (corrosion
resistance in a non-oxidizing environment in an atmosphere at high temperature and
at a high concentration) to the titanium alloys even when Pd is contained in a lower
content. However, Ni, if present in a content of more than 0.55%, may cause the titanium
alloys to have poor workability. The lower limit of the Ni content is preferably 0.40%
or more, and more preferably 0.45% or more, from the viewpoint of corrosion resistance.
[Pd in a content of 0.01% to 0.02%]
[0025] Palladium (Pd) element is a noble metal element added for improving basic corrosion
resistance of the titanium alloys and is contained in a relatively small content due
to synergistic effects with other elements. To exhibit the effects, Pd should be contained
in a content of 0.01% or more. However, Pd, if present in an excessively high content
of more than 0.02%, causes higher material cost, thus being undesirable. The lower
limit of the Pd content is preferably 0.012% or more, and more preferably 0.015% or
more, from the viewpoint of corrosion resistance.
[Ru in a content of 0.02% to 0.04%]
[0026] Ruthenium (Ru) element is, as with Ni, relatively inexpensive as compared to Pd and,
when contained in a content of 0.02% or more, is effective to impart corrosion resistance
(corrosion resistance in a non-oxidizing environment in an atmosphere at high temperature
and at a high concentration) to the titanium alloys even when Pd is contained in a
lower content However, Ru, if present in a content of more than 0.04%, causes excessively
high material cost, thus being undesirable. The lower limit of the Ru content is preferably
0.025% or more, and more preferably 0.03% or more, from the viewpoint of corrosion
resistance.
[Cr in a content of 0.1% to 0.2%]
[0027] Chromium (Cr) element contributes to improvements of corrosion resistance and crevice
corrosion resistance of titanium alloys without adversely affecting the workability.
By using in combination with the above-mentioned elements, Cr further improves the
corrosion resistance of titanium alloys. To exhibit these effects, Cr should be contained
in a content of 0.1% or more. However, the Cr content should be 0.2% or less, because
Cr, if contained in excess, may adversely affect the workability. The lower limit
of the Cr content is preferably 0.12% or more, and more preferably 0.15% or more,
from the viewpoint of corrosion resistance.
[0028] The titanium alloys according to the present invention contain the above components
with the remainder including titanium and inevitable impurities. As used herein the
"inevitable impurities" refer to impurity elements inevitably contained in raw material
titanium sponges. Representative examples thereof include oxygen, iron, carbon, nitrogen,
hydrogen, chromium, and nickel Examples of inevitable impurities further include elements
which may be incorporated into products during production process, such as hydrogen.
[0029] In this connection, amounts of elements such as oxygen, iron, nitrogen, carbon, chromium,
and nickel may be intentionally controlled for controlling the strength level of titanium
alloys. These elements, whose amounts are controlled for this purpose, are also included
in the "inevitable impurities" herein. Contents of these inevitable impurities are
approximately as follows. It should be noted, however, that the titanium alloys according
to the present invention are intentionally added with, of these impurities, chromium
(Cr) and nickel (Ni) in specific contents, and that their contents are total contents
including the amounts of such inevitable impurities mentioned below.
Oxygen: 100 to 3000 parts by mass per million (hereinafter such contents of inevitable
impurities will be simply expressed in "ppm")
Iron: 100 to 3000 ppm
Nitrogen: up to 500 ppm
Carbon: up to 800 ppm
Hydrogen: up to 150 ppm
Chromium: 10 to 300 ppm
Nickel: 10 to 300 ppm
[0030] Although the mechanism remains partially unknown, the titanium alloys according to
the present invention have improved intergranular corrosion resistance by having the
above-mentioned microstructures, probably because the coexistence of Ni and Cr, main
added elements of the titanium alloys, affects the intergranular corrosion resistance
in some manner or other.
[0031] Regular corrosion (general corrosion) of titanium alloys is known to occur according
to a mechanism through the following reactions. Specifically, on the free surface
of the titanium alloys, there simultaneously occur an anodic reaction represented
by following Formula (1) (metal dissolving reaction) and a cathodic reaction represented
by following Formula (2) (reduction reaction of dissolved oxygen in the presence of
the dissolved oxygen; or reduction reaction of hydrogen ion in an acidic solution):
Ti→Ti
3++3e
- (1)
O
2+2H
2O+4e
-→4OH
- (2)
[0032] Independently, in the case of a crevice structure, the anodic reaction and the cathodic
reaction occur simultaneously inside and outside of the crevice at early stages, but
dissolved oxygen or hydrogen ion is hardly fed into the crevice from the outside of
the crevice, and this causes a difference in concentration of oxidizing agent between
inside and outside of the crevice. Accordingly, an oxidizing-agent concentration cell
is formed between the inside and outside of the crevice, in which the anodic reaction
occurs inside the crevice and the cathodic reaction occurs outside the crevice. Inside
the crevice, the H
+ concentration increases due to the anodic reaction, and the pH decreases. In addition,
for satisfying electroneutrality with respect to H
+ ion, anions such as Cl
- migrate from the outside of the crevice to form a high-concentration hydrochloric
acid. This impedes the maintenance of passive state to lead to active dissolution,
namely, crevice corrosion.
[0033] As is described above, the anodic reaction and cathodic reaction are involved in
general corrosion and crevice corrosion of titanium alloys. However, the grain boundary
segregation of impurities and alloy elements may be probably involved in corrosion
principle of intergranular corrosion. It is considered that, in the titanium alloys
according to the present invention underwent annealing at relatively low temperatures,
nickel-rich phases remain in the specific forms and are thus prevented from segregation
at grain boundaries.
[0034] The present invention will be illustrated in further detail with reference to several
working examples below. It should be noted, however, that these examples are never
intended to limit the scope of the present invention; various changes and modifications
may be made without departing from the scope and spirit of the invention, and it is
intended in the appended claims to cover all such changes and modifications as fall
within the true spirit and scope of the invention.
EXPERIMENTAL EXAMPLE 1
[0035] A commercially available Ti-Ni-Pd-Ru-Cr alloy, i.e., JIS Type 14 cold-rolled annealed
plate (Ti-0.4Ni-0.015Pd-0.025R.u-0.14Cr alloy) was subjected to cold rolling at a
rolling reduction of 40% to a plate thickness of 1.1 mm, the resulting plate was divided
in small necessary quantities, subjected sequentially to the following air annealing
(final annealing), salt immersion, and acid wash treatments simulating continuous
annealing and acid wash processes, and thereby yielded corrosion specimens.
[Air Annealing]
[0036]
Temperature: 670°C, 700°C, 725°C, 750°C, 775°C, 800°C, and 830°C
Annealing Time: 165 seconds
Salt Immersion: immersion in a commercially available salt for descaling of titanium
(trade name: "Kolene DGS" supplied by Nihon Parkerizing Co., Ltd.) heated at about
500°C for one minute
Acid Wash: acid wash with nitric hydrofluoric acid by a thickness of about 0.1 mm
[0037] The manufactured corrosion specimens were subjected to corrosion tests under the
following conditions, and corrosion resistance of the specimens was determined. The
test conditions simulate such a severe use environment that Ti-Ni-Pd-Ru-Cr alloys
to which the present invention is applied do not maintain their passive state.
[Corrosion Test Conditions]
[0038] Each of the specimens was immersed in a boiling 10% hydrochloric acid for 24 hours,
and a corrosion rate per year (mm/year) was calculated based on the area of the specimen
before test, and the change in mass between before and after test. The results are
shown as the relation between the final annealing temperature and the corrosion rate
in Table 1 below.
TABLE 1
Test No. |
Final annealing temperature (°C) |
Corrosion rate (mm/year) |
1 |
670 |
7.04 |
2 |
700 |
8.19 |
3 |
725 |
7.94 |
4 |
750 |
6.67 |
5 |
775 |
9.23 |
6 |
800 |
6.93 |
7 |
830 |
8.90 |
[0039] The surfaces of the specimens after the test were observed under a scanning electron
microscope (SEM), and whether intergranular corrosion was present or not was determined.
The corrosion forms of the specimens are shown in FIGS. 2A, 2B, 2C, 3A, 3B, 3C, and
3D (photographs). Of the photographs, FIG. 2A depicts one obtained at an annealing
temperature of 670°C, FIG. 2B depicts one obtained at an annealing temperature of
700°C, FIG. 2C depicts one obtained at an annealing temperature of 725°C, FIG. 3A
depicts one obtained at an annealing temperature of 750°C, FIG. 3B depicts one obtained
at an annealing temperature of 775°C, FIG. 3C depicts one obtained at an annealing
temperature of 800°C, and FIG. 3D depicts one obtained at an annealing temperature
of 830°C, respectively.
[0040] These results demonstrate that the final annealing temperature does not so affect
the corrosion rate but significantly affects the corrosion form. Specifically, the
specimens prepared at final annealing temperatures of 725°C or lower underwent corrosion
predominantly in the form of general corrosion [FIGS. 2A, 2B, and 2C]; but the specimens
prepared at final annealing temperatures of 750°C or higher underwent corrosion in
the form of intergranular corrosion. This demonstrates that the proceeding of intergranular
corrosion may be effectively prevented by performing final annealing at a temperature
of 725°C or lower. In this experimental example, the lower limit of the final annealing
temperature was set to be 670°C. However, it was verified that intergranular corrosion
does not occur even when final annealing is performed at a temperature equal to or
lower than this temperature.
[0041] FIG. 4 depicts results of EPMA mapping ofNi and Cr in cross section (L direction
cross section) of the specimens used in the corrosion tests (also see FIG. 1 regarding
the Ni mapping of specimens prepared at annealing temperatures of 650°C to 830°C).
The results demonstrate that the titanium alloys containing both Ni and Cr include
Ni and Cr which are distributed in coexistence; and that the specimens prepared through
final annealing at temperatures of 750°C or higher include Ni and Cr which are distributed
in remarkable coexistence (namely, Ni and Cr are distributed in the same manner).
This indicates that the coexistence of Ni and Cr adversely affects intergranular corrosion
resistance.
EXPERIMENTAL EXAMPLE 2
[0042] Secondary electron images (SEM images) and results of mapping of a corrosion specimen
(annealed at a final annealing temperature of 700°C) manufactured by the procedure
of Experimental Example 1 are shown in FIG. 5 (photographs). White precipitation areas
in the SEM images are present at positions substantially corresponding to portions
with high concentrations of Ni, Cr, and Fe; and, particularly regarding Ni, the difference
in concentration between the matrix (alpha phase) and precipitation areas is significant
Based on these, the precipitation areas can be said as nickel-rich phases. In contrast,
the data demonstrate that Pd and Ru are distributed approximately uniformly.
[0043] Independently, the specimen was subjected to observation under a transmission electron
microscope (TEM), and exemplary images in 14-µm square fields of view are shown in
FIGS. 6A and 6B (photographs). Precipitates with a size of 0.2 µm or more are circled
in the TEM images, and by spot-spectrometry of these precipitates in TEM, the Ni content
may be measured. FIG. 6A depicts an image where the nickel-rich phase is Ti
2Ni; and FIG. 6B depicts an image where the nickel-rich phase is the beta phase.
[0044] In the sample given in FIGS. 6A and 6B, the raw-material ingot for the samples had
Ni contents of 0.49% and 0.43% at the top and the bottom, respectively. Accordingly,
the matrix (base metal) had an average Ni content of 0.46%.
[0045] Whether the precipitates are nickel-rich phases or not could be determined by the
Ni contents of the precipitates determined through spot spectrometry. It should be
noted that "nickel-rich phases" defined in the present invention are phases each having
a Ni content of 10 times or more the average Ni content of the matrix. In this connection,
the mapping indicated that most of the precipitates are nickel-rich phases.
[0046] In addition, whether the precipitates are Ti
2Ni or the beta phase can be determined by applying electron beams to each of the precipitates,
and analyzing the crystal structures of the precipitates through electron diffraction
analysis. Exemplary results of the analysis of nickel-rich phases are also illustrated
in FIGS. 6A and 6B.
[0047] In the above manner, specimens were manufactured through final annealing (in the
air) at different temperatures of 650°C, 700°C, 725°C, 750°C, 800°C, and 830°C, and
the forms or phases (Ti
2Ni or beta phase) of precipitates were examined. The results are shown in Table 2
below.
TABLE 2
Test No. |
Final annealing temperature (°C) |
Ti2Ni |
8 |
650 |
present |
9 |
700 |
present |
10 |
725 |
present |
11 |
750 |
absent |
12 |
800 |
absent |
13 |
830 |
absent |
[0048] The results demonstrate that specimens prepared through final annealing at temperatures
of 650°C, 700°C, and 725°C included Ti
2Ni in nickel-rich phases; but other specimens prepared through final annealing at
temperatures of 750°C, 800°C, and 830°C did not include Ti
2Ni but included the beta phase alone in nickel-rich phases. In consideration also
of the results given in Table 1, the intergranular corrosion can be suppressed by
allowing nickel-rich phases to contain Ti
2Ni.