[0001] The present invention is concerned with improvements in or relating to fluid seals
and particularly, but not exclusively, to a method of manufacturing a part or component
that has a surface capable of providing a fluid seal in use and to a part manufactured
using such a method. The invention may find advantageous application in the manufacturing
of rotating parts for vehicle engines that provide such fluid sealing surfaces. Aspects
of the invention relate to a method, to a part, to a fluid seal surface, to a product,
to a sealing arrangement and to a vehicle.
[0002] There are many different situations with the automotive industry in which there is
a requirement to maintain a fluid seal, and particularly a liquid seal. Amongst these
varied applications, there are several examples of situations in which a moving, typically
rotating, part traverses a boundary between a liquid filled area and a non-liquid
filled, or dry, area or between areas containing dissimilar liquids that must be kept
separate. Examples of such parts are components for fluid pumps, crankshafts, engines
or transmissions, amongst others.
[0003] These parts are typically made by machining from a single billet of material. The
billet must have a minimum diameter that is at least equal to the maximum diameter
of the finished part. This process produces a considerable amount of wastage in the
form of scrap material. For complex shapes the machining process requires frequent
resetting of the machine because it has to be re-set for each new face. Each face
is then ground in order to give a sufficiently polished surface finish for a liquid
seal to be formed. This process is very time intensive and is therefore costly. By
way of example, the cost of grinding the part to produce the polished surface can
constitute more than 50% of the total cost of manufacturing the part.
[0004] In order to form a liquid seal within an engine sub-system, the connecting part is
typically provided with a sealing member or gasket typically formed from a plastics
or polymeric material such as rubber. Any unevenness on the surface abutting the sealing
member will result in the premature deterioration of the plastics or rubber seal.
Many engine sub-systems are supplied as sealed units and, in these circumstances,
it may not be possible to replace a damaged rubber seal. Instead, the entire sub-system
must be replaced. Unevenness on the surface abutting the rubber seal may therefore
decrease the effective lifetime of the sub-system as a whole. This may also adversely
affect other sub-systems or components of the engine due to oil or coolant loss.
[0005] Alternatively, it is known to use a soft metal pressed insert fabricated from copper,
phosphor-bronze or a similar material, in order to provide a sufficiently smooth surface
to form an effective seal.
[0006] It is an aim of the invention to improve upon such known technology and manufacturing
processes. Embodiments of the invention may provide a substantial reduction in the
complexity and cost of the process by which such parts are manufactured. Other aims
and advantages of the invention will become apparent from the following description,
claims and drawings.
[0007] In one aspect of the invention there is provided a fluid seal arrangement (17) comprising
a sealing member formed from a plastics or polymeric material and a part in sealing
cooperation therewith, wherein the part is characterised by a body (10) formed from
a sintered ferrous material having at least one surface (5) arranged to provide a
fluid seal (17), in use,
characterised in that the at least one surface (5)comprises an un-ground surface of the ferrous material
coated with a layer of Fe304 wherein the part comprises one of a coupling (10) for
a fuel injector (15), a viscous fan (70) for a cooling system of an internal combustion
engine, a water pump (80), an oil seal retainer (90) for use in sealing the ends of
a crankshaft (91), differential transmission, gearbox, axle, driveshaft (82, 92, 102),
hub (13) or transfer case; and a vacuum pump (110) for use in the braking system of
a vehicle.
[0008] The present applicant has identified that, contrary to established manufacturing
practices, a fluid seal with satisfactory performance characteristics can be achieved
simply by depositing a layer of Fe
3O
4 onto an un-ground surface of a sintered ferrous part without the need for grinding.
This surprising technical effect permits the elimination of the normal step of grinding
the surface to provide a polished surface and hence significantly reduces the complexity,
time and cost of manufacturing the part.
[0009] The term "un-ground surface" as used herein is intended to mean a surface of the
ferrous part which has been created by direct contact with the sintering tool and
has not been subject to any further smoothing or polishing process, such as grinding,
abrading or machining. This surface is also known as a raw surface or virgin surface
of the part.
[0010] In addition, when a part is machined (for example by grinding), the performance of
the part depends critically on the tolerances of each individual face. As each face
has to be machined separately, each one could be subject to an error in the positioning
of the grinding machine. In contrast, the sintering process of the present invention
is a single step of sintering to produce the majority of the facets of the part. This
results in a much more reliable process.
[0011] According to another aspect of the invention for which protection is sought there
is provided a method of manufacturing a sintered ferrous part having at least one
surface configured to provide a fluid seal, in use, the method comprising depositing
a layer of Fe
3O
4 onto an un-ground surface of the part to as to form the at least one fluid sealing
surface.
[0012] According to yet another aspect of the invention for which protection is sought,
there is provided a method of forming a fluid seal surface on a sintered ferrous part,
the method comprising depositing a layer of Fe
3O
4 onto an un-ground surface of the sintered ferrous part so as to form the fluid seal
surface.
[0013] In an embodiment, the method comprises forming the part from a sintered ferrous material
before depositing the Fe
3O
4 layer.
[0014] In an embodiment, depositing the Fe
3O
4 layer comprises steam treating at least the un-ground surface of the part. Alternatively,
or in addition, the entire part may be subjected to steam treatment so as to deposit
the layer substantially fully thereover.
[0015] According to a further aspect of the invention for which protection is sought there
is provided a sintered ferrous part having at least one surface arranged to provide
a fluid seal, in use, wherein the at least one surface comprises an un-ground surface
of ferrous material coated with a layer of Fe
3O
4.
[0016] According to a still further aspect of the present invention for which protection
is sought there is provided a method of manufacturing a moving part capable of providing
a liquid seal, the method comprising the steps of forming the part from sintered steel
and forming a layer of Fe
3O
4 to provide a surface finish on the sintered part that is capable of providing a liquid
seal.
[0017] Furthermore, according to another aspect of the invention for which protection is
sought, there is provided a moving part providing a liquid seal for use in a vehicle
engine, the part comprising a sintered body and a steam treated surface finish for
providing the liquid seal. The moving part may be a rotating part.
[0018] The method may comprise the step of machining complex structures, such as keyways,
and screw threads within the part. These structures may be created separately from
the sintering step since they generally do not include the surfaces that provide a
liquid seal.
[0019] The part may be, inter alia, a coupling for an injection pump for a fuel injection
unit in a diesel engine, a viscous fan from a radiator system of an internal combustion
engine, a water pump for use in an internal combustion engine, an oil seal retainer
for use in closing the ends of a vehicle crankshaft, an oil seal retainer for sealing
a differential transmission, gearbox or transfer case or a vacuum pump for use in
the braking system of a vehicle. Other examples will be recognised by the skilled
person.
[0020] Within the scope of this application it is envisaged that the various aspects, embodiments,
examples, features and alternatives set out in the preceding paragraphs, in the claims
and/or in the following description and drawings may be taken individually or in any
combination thereof.
[0021] The present invention will now be described, by way of example only, with reference
to the accompanying drawings in which:
Figure 1 shows an axial view of a coupling for a fuel pump manufactured according
to the method of the present invention;
Figure 2 shows a cross sectional view of the coupling shown in Figure 1;
Figure 3 shows a perspective view of the coupling shown in Figures 1 and 2;
Figure 4 shows the coupling of Figures 1 to 3 in context with those parts to which
it is most closely attached, in use;
Figure 5 shows an exploded view of the relevant part of a diesel engine showing the
position of the coupling of Figures 1 to 3, in use;
Figures 6a to 6e show a series of 30X magnification view of sintered parts with and
without machining, pre- and post-durability testing;
Figure 7 shows a viscous fan from a radiator system of an internal combustion engine;
Figures 8a and 8b show exterior and interior views of a water pump for use in an internal
combustion engine;
Figure 9 shows an oil seal retainer for use in closing the ends of a vehicle crankshaft;
Figure 10 shows an oil seal retainer for sealing a differential transmission, gearbox
or transfer case; and
Figure 11 shows a vacuum pump for use in the braking system of a vehicle.
[0022] Sintering is a known method for making objects from a suitable material, usually
a ceramic or metallic powder, by heating the material (below its melting point) until
its particles adhere to each other and then applying pressure to the material by compressing
it in a sintering tool. The sintering tool typically takes the form of a rigid metallic
block with an internal cavity or void corresponding in shape to the desired final
part. The sintering tool operates in a manner similar to that of a moulding tool whereby
the material is forced into the mould cavity at high pressure so as to ensure that
the material flows evenly into each void of the tool cavity. Once the material has
cooled and set, the sintering tool is opened and the part removed.
[0023] Sintering is traditionally used for manufacturing ceramic objects and sintered bronze
is frequently used as a material for bearings. Sintered bronze is suitable for use
in bearings since its porosity allows lubricants to flow through it. In the case of
materials with high melting points such as tungsten, sintering is used when there
is no alternative manufacturing technique.
[0024] The designer of a metallic part may decide to use sintering over casting or billet
machining for several reasons. The desired part may require a particular crystalline
structure which cannot always be achieved with casting. The part may be desired in
large numbers and so the percentage of material wastage associated with billet machining
may not be cost effective. The dimensional tolerance of the part may be critical between
two or more features of the part.
[0025] Sintering, on the other hand, produces parts with dimensional accuracy close to the
original sintering tool with excellent repeatability. Some design features may not
be created easily by sintering such as screw threads but once a part has been sintered
further processes may be employed to achieve the desired final shape. Once a part
has been sintered it may be machined, ground or cut as required to create surface
features that cannot be formed by sintering alone.
[0026] In some instances, the function of a part may be enhanced if it is porous. For example
if a part is bathed in lubricant, some of the lubricant will be trapped by the open
pores of the sintered part which reduces wear. However, the porosity of ferrous sintered
parts make them prone to corrosion if the part is exposed to water which may be unsuitable
for some applications.
[0027] The surface of the sintered ferrous part created by the direct contact between the
metallic powder forced into the tool and the surface of the tool cavity walls is known
as the raw or virgin surface. In other words, the raw or virgin surface of the sintered
part has not been subjected to any further smoothing and/or polishing treatment, such
as machining, abrading or grinding, after removal from the sintering tool, and for
this reason is referred to hereafter as the "un-ground surface". The un-ground surface
tends not to be particularly hard-wearing and may be porous. If the final part must
be non-porous or if greater durability is required then the ferrous part may require
further surface treatment after sintering.
[0028] One such surface treatment is known as steam treatment. Steam treatment is a term
of art referring generally to a coating technique that is typically employed when
a part needs to be hardened. When handling ferrous parts, the technique generally
results in the deposition of a uniform layer of Fe
3O
4, or "black iron" on the treated surface or surfaces of the part. Fe
3O
4 is a crystalline solid, meaning that a surface formed from Fe
3O
4 is hard and has a low porosity.
[0029] This deposition layer of Fe
3O
4 is typically 2 - 10 µm in thickness, but this may vary due to the quality of the
un-ground surface or production process parameters such as temperature and duration
of exposure to the steam. The resulting part has a black appearance and, in addition
to an increased hardness, is also more resistant to corrosion than a similar part
that has not been so treated.
[0030] The surface of a sintered ferrous part with a coating of Fe
3O
4 is far less porous as the Fe
3O
4 crystals are very fine and has the effect of uniformly filling the pores, especially
in the crystalline surface structure of the sintered part. Steam treatment does not
simply block the pores, but also increases the corrosion resistance and alters the
mechanical properties, thus increasing the density, the hardness and the tensile strength
of the sintered part and thus improving wear properties.
[0031] Conventional engineering practice requires that, for metallic parts, a fluid seal
surface on a rotating part should be machined and ground to achieve the desired surface
finish and fine dimensional tolerance required to provide a reliable fluid seal. However,
the present applicant has discovered that, by suitable design of the sintering tool
in the area of the fluid seal, the dimensional tolerances and surface finish of the
sintered part are capable of providing a fluid seal once the part has been steam treated,
without the need for an intermediate machining or grinding step.
[0032] The omission of the machining and grinding step for such a part represents a considerable
time and cost saving and can additionally enhance performance of the part. For example,
any machining or grinding process has to be carefully monitored to ensure sufficient
repeatability and dimensional tolerances between features of the part such as mounting
points and fluid seals. However, according to the present invention, the final shape
of the part is achieved directly from the tool, thereby requiring fewer manufacturing
operations and advantageously providing tighter dimensional tolerances.
[0033] Extensive testing by the applicant has been conducted to compare the fluid sealing
performance of conventionally-machined parts and parts formed in accordance with the
present invention and examples are shown in Figures 6a to 6e. This testing has shown
that, contrary to conventional belief that a surface must be machined and/or ground
in order to be suitable for a fluid seal, a reliable fluid seal may be produced by
depositing a layer of Fe
3O
4 directly onto the un-ground surface created by the sintering tool.
[0034] The applicant has further discovered that the surface finish created by the deposition
of Fe
3O
4 onto the raw sintered surface has been shown to be particularly suitable for use
with sealing members made from plastics or polymeric materials such as rubber.
[0035] Provided that the surface quality of the sintering tool cavity is sufficiently smooth,
the deposition of Fe
3O
4 directly onto the un-ground surface of the sintered ferrous part, for example by
means of steam treating, produces a surface that is sufficiently smooth, durable and
non-porous to form a reliable fluid seal without the need for additional machining
or grinding processes. This represents a significant improvement in production efficiency
as grinding a surface for a fluid seal represents a considerable proportion of the
manufacturing time and cost associated with each part.
[0036] Figures 1 to 5 show a coupling 10 for the type of fuel pump used in a diesel engine.
The coupling 10 is fabricated from, for example, M1040 steel. The grade of steel is
chosen to be suitable for the particular application. The choice is a compromise between
cost and weight to produce a part suitable for the mechanical loads whilst still providing
a sufficient safety margin.
[0037] The coupling 10 is shown in isolation in Figures 1, 2 and 3. The coupling 10 comprises
a flange 12 and a boss or hub 13. The flange and hub 13 both have a circular cross-section.
The manufacturing tolerance on the diameter of the hub 13 is extremely tight to ensure
that the coupling 10 is capable of interfacing to provide an effective seal. A fluid
seal surface 5 is provided around the outer surface of the hub 13.
[0038] Figure 4 shows the coupling 10 in the context of a fuel pump system 15 including
a fuel pump 18. Figure 5 contextualises the fuel pump system 15 within the engine
as a whole. The coupling 10 is driven to rotate by the insertion of a shaft 16 into
a keyed conical hole 11 with a keyway 19. The shaft 16 is also keyed and rotation
results when a key is provided in joining the respective keyways 19. The hole 11 tapers
through the hub 13 and at least partially through the flange 12. The coupling separates
a liquid filled area A from a non-liquid filled area B. The seal is provided on the
liquid filled side A of the coupling 10, by a rubber sealing member 17 which is seated
on the fluid seal surface 5 of hub 13. Holes 14 are provided through the flange 12
to enable the coupling 10 to interface with other engine parts in the non-liquid filled
area B.
[0039] The coupling 10 is manufactured in a three-step process: firstly, the body of the
part is formed by sintering; next, the holes 14 in the flange 12 are tapped in known
manner; finally, the entire part is steam treated to form the Fe
3O
4 coating. The steam treatment is used to harden the surface, reduce porosity and improve
the corrosion resistance of the part. According to conventional processes, an additional
grinding step would be performed on the part before the part is subjected to the steam
treatment in order to provide a surface that is sufficiently smooth to provide a liquid
seal. However, the present applicants have identified that the operation of steam
treating the surface obviates the need for any grinding.
[0040] Looking at a microscopic level the cross-section of a machined part consists of a
series of regularly spaced and shaped peaks. In contrast, the surface resulting from
the steam treatment has an almost completely smooth surface with occasional microscopic
peaks that result from random positioning of crystals. The smooth surface results
in a much larger proportion of the surface area being available for interfacing with
the seal. The occasional peaks are typically worn away by the interfacing part before
any damage occurs to that part. The smooth surface provides an advantage for the lifetime
of the seal.
[0041] In particular, the smooth outer surface of the hub 13 provides the fluid seal surface
5 and ensures that damage to the seal 17 is reduced, thus increasing the effective
life of the fuel pump system 15.
[0042] Figures 6a to 6e show a series of 30X magnification view of sintered parts with or
without machining, pre- and post-durability testing.
[0043] Figure 6a shows a sintered part at 30X magnification. The porous surface is readily
apparent. This surface can be made more uniform by machining, as shown in Figure 6b.
This provides a good surface finish, but the surface is porous and is therefore unsuitable
for providing a liquid seal.
[0044] Figure 6c shows a non-machined sintered part that has been subjected to durability
testing. The wear apparent on the surface is typical of that expected in such a test.
[0045] Figure 6d shows the sintered part of Figure 6a when it has been steam treated, i.e.
in accordance with an embodiment of the present invention. The surface is very smooth
and non-porous. The surface also has a very high surface hardness. Figure 6e shows
the part from Figure 6d once it has been subjected to a durability test. It will be
readily apparent that the wear is reduced in comparison with the sintered part shown
in Figure 6c which had not been steam-treated.
[0046] Figure 7 shows a viscous-drive 70 for a cooling fan for an internal combustion engine
cooling system. The viscous-drive 70 transmits drive to a cooling fan (not shown)
from the engine in response to changes in the ambient air temperature surrounding
the body of the viscous-drive. The viscous-drive 70 comprises a housing 71, a bi-metallic
controller (not shown), an input shaft (not shown) and an output shaft 72. The input
and output shafts 72 are separated by the viscous-drive 70. The housing 71 is secured
to the engine or radiator by means of a suitable bracket. The housing 71 is positioned
so as to be in the direct path of the air-flow from the cooling fan mounted to the
radiator. The housing 71 is designed to transmit any changes in the air temperature
to the bi-metallic controller housed within the housing 71. The periphery of the housing
is typically provided with a plurality of fins 73 to increase the surface area to
optimise the controller's response to air temperature change.
[0047] The housing 71 further comprises at least two internal chambers (not shown), one
accommodating the input shaft and one accommodating the output shaft 72. Fluid communication
between the two chambers is via a valve (not shown) which is operated by the controller
and a return orifice.
[0048] The input shaft has a first input or driven end and distal from the input end a plurality
of vanes. The output shaft 72 has a driven end surrounded by a plurality of vanes.
Distal from the driven end there is a drive end which is connected to the cooling
fan. The vanes of the input and output shafts are surrounded by a viscous fluid contained
within the housing. Fluid communication between the first and second chamber is permitted
only via the control valve and the return orifice.
[0049] The input shaft is driven by the engine, typically via a belt and pulley. There is
no communication of drive from the input shaft to the output shaft if the engine temperature
is too low as the bi-metallic controller holds the valve closed.
[0050] Once the ambient air temperature exceeds a given threshold the bi-metallic controller
opens the valve, allowing a circuit of fluid communication between the two chambers.
A viscous fluid in the first chamber may then pass from the first chamber to the second
via the valve, applying a force to the drive vanes on the output shaft and causing
the fan to turn. Oil returns to the first chamber via the return orifice thus creating
a fluid circuit.
[0051] A reliable seal must be provided between the housing and the input and output shafts
to prevent a loss of fluid which would be detrimental to performance.
[0052] Figures 8a and 8b show, respectively, the exterior and interior of a water pump 80
for an internal combustion engine cooling system. The water pump 80 is used to pump
coolant around the engine and between the engine and the heat exchanger or radiator.
The water pump 80 comprises a housing 81, a drive shaft 82 and an impeller 83. The
impeller 83 is connected to the drive shaft 82 which is driven by the engine. The
drive shaft 82 rotates on bearings and must have a reliable fluid seal between the
drive shaft 82 and the housing 81 to prevent loss of coolant or the fluid communication
of coolant on one side of the housing 81 and engine lubricant on the other side of
the housing 81 which would be detrimental to the engine.
[0053] Figure 9 shows an oil seal retainer 90 designed to be affixed to an end of the crankshaft
91 of a vehicle. An engine crankshaft 91 is provided with a primary output end (not
shown) and distal from the primary output end is a secondary output end 92 or ancillary
drive end. The output from the engine is taken from the primary output end of the
crankshaft 91 which drives the vehicle via a gearbox.
[0054] Additionally, engine ancillaries such as power steering pumps, cooling fans, alternators,
air conditioning compressors and vacuum pumps are driven by the crankshaft 91 via
a pulley and serpentine belt system from the secondary output 92.
[0055] The crankshaft 91 is supported by bearings within a crankcase (not shown) which contains
lubricating oil for the crankshaft 91 and the other moving parts of the engine. The
pulley for the ancillary drive is mounted on the end 92 of the crankshaft 91 that
is supported by bearings in the crankcase and protrudes through the crankcase to outside
of the engine.
[0056] A reliable oil seat is vital at the point where the crankshaft 91 protrudes through
the end bearings of the crankcase to support the pulley, to prevent the loss of lubricating
oil from the crankcase.
[0057] Figure 10 shows an oil seal retainer 100 for sealing differential transmission systems,
gearboxes and transfer cases. These devices supply drive torque from an engine to
the road wheels of a motor vehicle.
[0058] Such devices typically comprise a housing 101, gears mounted on rotating shafts 102
supported by bearings set into the housing 101. The rotating parts require lubrication
which is typically provided by a lubricant such as oil contained within the housing
101.
[0059] Rotating shafts 102 often need to protrude from the housing 101 in order to receive
drive from the engine or another gear drive, or to output drive to the road wheels
or another gear drive.
[0060] The housing 101 not only provides suitable support for the bearings that carry the
rotating shafts 102, but also serves to contain lubricating oil and keep out foreign
bodies such as dirt that could damage the gears.
[0061] It is vital to provide a reliable oil seal at the point where the rotating shafts
102 protrude from the housing 101 to prevent loss of lubricating oil or the ingress
of dirt which would adversely affect the performance of the device.
[0062] Figure 11 shows a vacuum pump 110 for the braking system of a motor vehicle. The
vacuum pump 110 is typically driven via a pulley driven by a serpentine belt on the
side of the vehicle engine. The vacuum pump 110 typically comprises a housing 111,
a drive shaft 112 and an impeller (not shown). The impeller is connected to the drive
shaft 112 which is driven by the drive pulley on the outside of the housing 111. The
drive shaft 112 rotates on bearings and must have a reliable fluid seal between the
drive shaft 112 and the housing 111 to prevent loss of vacuum or lubricant. The loss
of vacuum or lubricant would be detrimental to the performance of the braking system.
[0063] The rotating parts designed to provide liquid seals in each of the systems illustrated
in Figures 7 to 11 respectively can be made using a two-step process of creating the
part by sintering and then steam treating the sintered part in order to deposit a
layer of Fe
3O
4 that creates a surface that is sufficiently smooth, non-porous and durable to provide
the liquid seal without requiring machining or any additional surfaces to create the
seal. A third, machining step is required only to create any internal shapes such
as screw-threads or keyways that cannot be created using sintering, which step can
be carried out before or after the step of steam treating the part.
[0064] Although the embodiments described herein relate to rotating parts, the skilled man
will appreciate that parts designed to execute, for example, reciprocating or linear
motion also require the smooth surface finishes provided by the method of the present
invention. In addition to the disclosed embodiments, therefore the skilled person
will recognise numerous other parts or components to which the present invention may
be applied. The present application is intended to cover all such additional, non
described embodiments and applications with express reference to applications within
the field of engines and transmissions for vehicles such as automobiles, aircraft
and watercraft. Furthermore, the present invention is equally applicable to non-moving
parts wherein a fluid sealing surface is required between relatively moving parts.
[0065] The present invention provides a surface quality on the steam treated sintered part
that greatly enhances the service life of the sealing member, this is especially the
case for polymeric sealing members. The present invention provides a durable sealing
surface as shown in Figure 6. The improvement in durability of both the fluid seal
surface of the sintered part and the sealing member greatly enhances reliability and
reduces service cost and complexity.