Technical Field
[0001] The present invention relates to a brazing alloy for bonding in air, to a bonded
article, and to a current collecting material bonded with the brazing alloy. In particular,
the present invention relates to a technique for reducing the melting point and for
improving high-temperature durability of the brazing alloy for bonding in air.
Background Art
[0002] Bonded articles formed of a metal member and a metal member, bonded articles formed
of a ceramic member and a ceramic member, and bonded articles formed of a ceramic
member and a metal member, may be obtained by brazing. Recently, requirements for
improving accuracy, reliability, and function of products, have been increasing, and
bonded articles formed of ceramics and metal are utilized in order to satisfy these
requirements. In this regard, bonding methods for obtaining bonded articles have been
actively researched.
[0003] As a method for bonding a ceramic member and a metal member, it is necessary to develop
an air brazing technique, by which the production cost is decreased, and by which
a preferable bonded article is obtained by heating at relatively low temperatures
even in air.
[0004] As an air brazing technique, a flux brazing method, in which the brazing is performed
in air, is generally used. In this method, flux is applied on to a surface of a base
material, and the surface is bonded while the flux makes a reductive atmosphere and
cuts off oxygen at the bonded portion, whereby a preferable bonded article is obtained.
For example, in a case of using "BAg-8" of an Ag brazing alloy as a brazing alloy,
a flux with a lower melting point than 780 °C of the melting point of the "BAg-8"
is used so as to melt the flux before the brazing alloy melts. Thus, the bonding surface
is activated, and the oxidation of the brazing alloy is prevented, whereby a preferable
bonded article is obtained.
[0005] In the flux brazing method, the bonding is generally performed by local heating with
a torch. Therefore, this method is effective for bonding points or lines, but is not
suitable for bonding planes. In a case of bonding a ceramic member and a ceramic member
and bonding a ceramic member and a metal member by this method, thermal stress is
generated by the local heating, which may break the ceramic member. Accordingly, this
method is also not suitable for forming a bonded article that has a ceramic member.
Moreover, most fluxes themselves, or residues thereof, tend to corrode metals, and
in this case, the residues of the flux must be removed in an additional step after
the bonding.
[0006] Alternatively, as an air brazing technique which does not need flux, a reactive air
brazing method may be used (for example, Patent Documents 1 and 2). According to the
technique disclosed in Patent Document 1, a ceramic member and a heat-resistant metal
member that forms an aluminum oxide layer in air, are used as base materials. The
base materials are bonded in air by the reactive air brazing method using an Ag-Cu
brazing alloy in which CuO is added to Ag. In this technique, the primary component
of the brazing alloy is a noble metal component such as Ag, whereby flux is not necessary
in the brazing, and the above-described problems due to the flux do not occur.
[0007] In the technique disclosed in Patent Documents 1 and 2, the bonding temperature must
be higher than the melting point (approximately 961 °C) of Ag. Therefore, there is
a possibility that the metal member of the base material will be heavily oxidized.
In addition, in the case of bonding a metal member and a ceramic member, greater thermal
stress is generated due to the difference in thermal expansion coefficient therebetween
according to increase in the bonding temperature.
[0008] In view of this, in order to reduce the bonding temperature in the reactive air brazing
method, various alloys have been developed for reducing the melting point of Ag brazing
alloys. For example, an Ag-Ge-Si brazing alloy is disclosed in Patent Document 3.
[0009] Patent Document 1 is Japanese Patent Publication No.
4486820. Patent Document 2 is Japanese Unexamined Patent Application Publication No.
2010-531232. Patent Document 3 is Japanese Unexamined Patent Application Publication No.
2008-202097.
DISCLOSURE OF THE INVENTION
[0010] However, the Ag-Ge-Si brazing alloy disclosed in Patent Document 3 is not melted
at a temperature below the melting point of Ag, whereby the above problem that occurs
in the reactive air brazing method cannot be solved. In addition, when a bonded article
is made of a low melting brazing alloy, the high-temperature durability is deteriorated.
For example, when the bonded article obtained by using the low-melting-point brazing
alloy and bonding in the air at a heating temperature of 850 °C for 1 hour is subjected
to a leak test after holding in the air at a heating temperature of 800 °C for 100
hours, leakage occurs at a bonded portion. In this case, it is assumed that the leakage
is generated by volatilizing low-melting-point oxides.
[0011] Therefore, an object of the present invention is to provide a brazing alloy for bonding
in air, which can be melted at a temperature below the melting point of Ag and in
which the high-temperature durability of the bonded article can be improved. In addition,
another object of the present invention is to provide a bonded article and a current
collecting material that are bonded with the brazing alloy and which have the high-temperature
durability.
[0012] The brazing alloy for bonding in air of the present invention, includes Ag (silver),
Ge (germanium), B (boron), and Si (silicon), as essential components, in which total
of constituent elements except for Ag is set to be more than 50% by volume and not
more than 90% by volume, Si content in the constituent elements except for Ag is set
to be more than 22% by volume, and B content in the constituent elements except for
Ag is set to be more than 14% by volume.
[0013] The brazing alloy for bonding in air of the present invention is an Ag-B-Si brazing
alloy containing Ag, B and Si as essential components. The component Ag is a material
that is not easily oxidized even when melted in air. The component B is a low-melting-point
material that is oxidized at not less than approximately 300 °C and that has oxides
with a relatively low melting point (approximately 577 °C). In a case of using this
brazing alloy for bonding members, the low melting point oxides are melted and are
spread as liquids on a base material, whereby oxidation of the base material is prevented,
even when the brazing is performed in air.
[0014] Since B of the low-melting-point material is included as an essential component,
the brazing alloy is melted at a temperature not greater than the melting point (approximately
961 °C) ofAg. Thus, the bonding temperature is reduced and is lower than that in a
case of using a conventional Ag brazing alloy for bonding in air. Therefore, when
a metal member is used as a base material, oxidation of the base material is prevented,
and deterioration of the metal member is prevented, since the bonding temperature
is low. Moreover, when a metal member and a ceramic member are used as base materials,
the thermal stress due to the difference in the thermal expansion coefficient therebetween
is decreased, since the bonding temperature is low.
[0015] Furthermore, since the brazing alloy for bonding in air of the present invention
contains Ag, B, and Si as essential components and the content of the constituent
elements except for Ag is set to the above range, the high-temperature durability
is improved. For example, the leakage does not occur at a bonded portion and superior
gas sealing characteristics are maintained, even if the bonded article is subjected
to the leak test after holding in air at a heating temperature of 800 °C for 100 hours.
Therefore, long reliability can be ensured.
[0016] Accordingly, a bonded article having superior high-temperature durability in addition
to preferable gas sealing characteristics and superior bonding strength is obtained
by the brazing without using flux even in air.
[0017] The brazing alloy for bonding in air of the present invention may include various
components. For example, at least one kind selected from the group consisting of Ge
(germanium), Ti (titanium), Zr (zirconium), Hf (hafnium), Cr (chromium) and Al (aluminum)
may be added as an additional component, and the content of the additional component
in the constituent elements except for Ag is set to be not more than 64% by volume,
may be used. In the case in which a ceramic member is used as a base material, reactivity
with the ceramic member is improved by adding Ge, Ti, Zr and Hf. When Ge is used in
a bonded article of, for example, a metal member and a ceramic member, Ge oxides are
precipitated on the ceramic member. In this case, since Ge acts as an active metal,
the wettability is improved. When Cr and Al are added, the oxygen is prevented from
dispersing in the brazing alloy in brazing in the air or in holding at a high temperature,
and as a result, oxidation resistance is improved.
[0018] In addition, when the brazing alloy for bonding in air of the present invention is
used for bonding members, an oxide containing at least one kind of the constituent
elements may be formed in brazing. Furthermore, when the brazing alloy for bonding
in air of the present invention is used for bonding members, a complex oxide containing
at least two kinds of the constituent elements may be formed in brazing.
[0019] The brazing alloy for bonding in air of the present invention has a melting point
that is lower as described above and may have a melting point of, for example, not
less than 650 °C and not more than 850 °C in air.
[0020] The present invention also provides a bonded article that is obtained by bonding
with the brazing alloy of the present invention. That is, the bonded article of the
present invention is formed of a set of a metal member and a metal member, a set of
a ceramic member and a ceramic member, or a set of a metal member and a ceramic member,
which are bonded with the brazing alloy of the present invention, and the bonded article
has gas sealing characteristics. For example, the bonded article may be used in a
fuel cell or in a solid oxide fuel cell.
[0021] The present invention further provides a current collecting material that is formed
of a set of a metal member and a metal member, a set of a ceramic member and a ceramic
member, or a set of a metal member and a ceramic member, which are bonded with the
brazing alloy of the present invention. The current collecting material has electrical
conductivity. For example, the current collecting material may be used for a fuel
cell or a solid oxide fuel cell.
[0022] According to the brazing alloy of the present invention, the brazing alloy for bonding
in air can be melted at a temperature below the melting point of Ag and the high-temperature
durability of the bonded article can be improved. According to the bonded article
and the current collecting material of the present invention, they are obtained by
using the brazing alloy of the present invention and thereby have superior high-temperature
durability in addition to preferable gas sealing characteristics and superior bonding
strength.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF DRAWINGS
[0023]
Fig. 1 is a perspective view that shows an approximate structure of a bonded specimen
formed in the Examples of the present invention.
Fig. 2 shows a bonded specimen for cross sectional observation used in the Examples
of the present invention and shows a side cross sectional structure taken along a
direction indicated by arrows 1A in Fig. 1.
Fig. 3 is an electron micrograph (500-times magnification) of a cross section of a
bonded specimen of the Sample 4 of the present invention after bonding.
Fig. 4 is an electron micrograph (500-times magnification) of a cross section of a
bonded specimen of the Sample 4 of the present invention after holding at a high temperature.
Fig. 5 is an electron micrograph (500-times magnification) of a cross section of a
bonded specimen of the Comparative Sample 2 of the present invention after bonding.
Fig. 6 is an electron micrograph (500-times magnification) of a cross section of a
bonded specimen of the Comparative Sample 2 of the present invention after holding
at a high temperature.
EXPLANATION OF REFERENCE NUMERALS
[0024] Reference numeral 10 denotes a bonded specimen, 11 denotes a metal member, 12 denotes
a ceramic member, 13 denotes a bonded layer, 14 denotes Ag-rich portion, 15 denotes
complex oxide, and 16 denotes a void.
EXAMPLES
[0025] The present invention will be described with reference to examples hereinafter. In
the Examples, bonded specimens were formed as Samples relating to the present invention
by using a brazing alloy for bonding in air, which includes elements at amounts within
the scope of the present invention. In addition, other bonded specimens were formed
as Comparative Samples by using a brazing alloy for bonding in air, which includes
elements in amounts outside the scope of the present invention. In order to evaluate
the bonded specimens of the Samples of the present invention and the Comparative Samples,
a leak test was performed on each of the specimens, and bonded portions of some of
the specimens were observed.
(1) Preparation of Samples of the Present Invention and Comparative Samples
[0026] The brazing alloys for bonding in air for forming the Samples of the present invention
may be in the form of, for example, a paste in which a metal mixed powder is added
to an organic solvent, an organic binder, or the like, an alloy powder paste, a foil,
a sol-gel form, etc. The form of the brazing alloy is not particularly limited.
[0027] As the material of the metal member for forming the Samples of the present invention,
for example, ferrite stainless steel, stainless steel, heat-resistant stainless steel,
FeCrAl alloy, FeCrSi alloy, heat-resistant Ni based alloy, etc. may be used. The material
of the metal member is not particularly limited. As the material of the ceramic member
for forming the Samples of the present invention, for example, oxide ceramics such
as yttria-stabilized zirconia, zirconia, alumina, magnesia, steatite, mullite, titania,
silica, sialon, etc., may be used. The material of the ceramic member is not particularly
limited.
[0028] A brazing alloy for bonding in air relating to each Sample of the present invention
was used in a paste form by mixing a metal mixed powder with an organic binder. The
metal mixed powder had a composition within the scope of the present invention, as
shown in Table 1. With respect to the brazing alloy for bonding in air, in Sample
1, a brazing alloy for bonding in air (Ag-B-Si brazing alloy) of the present invention
containing only essential components was used, in Samples 2 and 4, a brazing alloy
for bonding in air (Ag-B-Si-Ge brazing alloy) of the present invention containing
Ge as an additional component in addition to the essential components was used, and
in Sample 3, a brazing alloy for bonding in air (Ag-B-Si-Ge-Cr brazing alloy) of the
present invention containing Ge and Cr as additional components, in addition to the
essential components, was used.
[0029] Here, in Table 1, total volume ratio of the constituent elements except for Ag refers
to as content X, and for example, content of B in the content X is content of B in
the constituent elements except for Ag. The values shown in Table 1 are volume ratios
(unit: %).
[0030] As the metal member relating to each Sample of the present invention, a cylindrical
member made of ZMG232L (manufactured by Hitachi Metals, Ltd.) of a ferrite alloy with
an outer diameter of 14 mm and an inner diameter of 8 mm was used. As the ceramic
member relating to each Sample of the present invention, a stabilized zirconia sheet
made of yttria-stabilized zirconia (3YSZ) was used. The size of each sheet was 20
mm × 20 mm.
[0031] A brazing alloy for bonding in air relating to each Comparative Sample was used in
a paste form by mixing a metal mixed powder with an organic binder. The metal mixed
powder had a composition outside the scope of the present invention, as shown in Table
1. The same cylindrical member as for each Sample of the present invention was used
for the metal member of each Comparative Sample. As shown in Table 1, a stabilized
zirconia sheet was used for the ceramic member. With respect to the brazing alloy
for bonding in air, in Comparative Sample 1, a brazing alloy for bonding in air in
which the content X deviated from the range of the present invention (50% or less)
was used, in Sample 2, a brazing alloy for bonding in air in which content of Si in
the content X deviated from the range of the present invention (22% or less) was used,
and in Sample 3, a brazing alloy for bonding in air in which content of B in the content
X deviated from the range of the present invention (14% or less) was used.
[0032] In the Examples, the brazing alloy for bonding in air in the paste form was coated
on an end surface of the metal member, and the ceramic member was placed on the coated
surface. Then, the metal member and the ceramic member were bonded in air by heating
at 850 °C for 1 hour. Thus, bonded specimens as Samples of the present invention and
the Comparative Samples were formed.
[0033] Fig. 1 is a schematic view that shows a structure of a bonded specimen 10. The reference
numeral 11 denotes a metal member formed of a cylindrical member, the reference numeral
11A denotes an opening of the metal member, the reference numeral 12 denotes a ceramic
member which is a sheet, and the reference numeral 13 denotes a bonded layer. Fig.
2 is a schematic view of a cross section of a bonded portion including the bonded
layer 13 for observation (a perspective view that shows a side cross sectional structure
taken along a direction indicated by the arrows 1A in Fig. 1).
Table 1
|
Composition of Brazing Alloy (volume ratio) |
Content X (volume ratio) |
B content in Content X |
Si content in Content X |
Ge content in Content X |
Cr content in Content X |
Leak Test Result |
|
After Bonding |
After Holding at High Temperature |
|
Ag |
B |
Si |
Ge |
Cr |
Sample 1 |
48 |
25 |
27 |
- |
- |
52 |
48 |
52 |
0 |
0 |
No Leak |
No Leak |
Sample 2 |
46 |
25 |
27 |
2 |
- |
54 |
46 |
50 |
4 |
0 |
No Leak |
No Leak |
Sample 3 |
43 |
24 |
26 |
2 |
5 |
57 |
42 |
46 |
4 |
9 |
No Leak |
No Leak |
Sample 4 |
47 |
13 |
28 |
12 |
- |
53 |
25 |
53 |
23 |
0 |
No Leak |
No Leak |
Comparative Sample 1 |
50 |
13 |
29 |
3 |
5 |
50 |
26 |
58 |
6 |
10 |
No Leak |
Leak |
Comparative Sample 2 |
68 |
16 |
7 |
3 |
6 |
32 |
50 |
22 |
9 |
19 |
No Leak |
Leak |
Comparative Sample 3 |
56 |
6 |
31 |
3 |
4 |
44 |
14 |
70 |
7 |
9 |
Leak |
Untested |
(2) Evaluation of Samples of the Present Invention and Comparative Samples
[0034] First, the bonded specimen 10 after bonding was subjected to a helium leak test by
sealing the opening 11A of the metal member 11 and evacuating the air inside the metal
member 11. Next, the bonded specimen 10 was heated in the air at 800 °C for 100 hours.
Then, the bonded specimen 10 after holding at high temperature was subjected to a
helium leak test in the same manner as the above test. The results are shown in Table
1. The results of the helium leak test are shown in Table 1, in which "No leak" indicates
that helium was not detected, and "Leak" indicates that helium was detected. When
helium was detected in the helium leak test of the bonded specimen 10 after bonding,
a helium leak test of the bonded specimen 10 after holding at high temperature was
not carried out. In each of the Sample 4 of the present invention and the Comparative
Sample 2, the bonded specimen 10 was cut at the center portion, and the bonded portion
including the bonded layer 13 was observed.
[0035] With respect to results of the helium leak test, as shown in Table 1, in the Comparative
Sample 1 using a brazing alloy for bonding in air in which the content X was deviated
from the present invention and the Comparative Sample 2 using a brazing alloy for
bonding in air in which the Si content in the content X deviated from the present
invention, after holding at high temperature, helium was detected and the leakage
occurred. In the Comparative Sample 3 using a brazing alloy for bonding in air in
which the B content in the content X deviated from the present invention, after bonding,
helium was detected and the leakage occurred.
[0036] In contrast, in the bonded specimens of Samples 1 to 4 using a brazing alloy for
bonding in air in which the composition was in the range of the present invention,
in both cases after bonding and after holding, helium was not detected and the leakage
did not occur.
[0037] With respect to results of the cross sectional observation, in the Comparative Sample
2, after bonding in which the leak was not generated, the Ag-rich portion 14 and the
complex oxide 15 were observed and void was not observed, as shown in Fig. 5. However,
in the bonded specimen after holding at high temperature in which the leakage was
generated, the complex oxide 15 was not observed and the void 16 was observed, as
is apparent from Fig. 6. In contrast, in the bonded specimen of the Sample 4 after
bonding and after holding at high temperature in which the leakage was not generated,
the Ag-rich portion 14 and the complex oxide 15 were observed and void was not observed,
as shown in Figs. 3 and 4.
[0038] As described above, in the Samples 1 to 4, the complex oxide existed and the void
was not formed, even after holding at high temperature. Therefore, in the Samples
1 to 4, the brazing alloy for bonding in air was sufficiently melted by heating in
air at 850 °C, and the bonded article formed of a set of a metal member and a ceramic
member having preferable gas sealing characteristics and superior durability at high
temperature was formed.
[0039] As is apparent from comparison of the Samples 1 to 4 and the Comparative Samples
1 to 3, it was necessary that the brazing alloy for bonding in air contain Ag, B,
and Si as essential components and total content of constituent elements except for
Ag be set to be more than 50% by volume and not more than 90% by volume, in order
to have preferable gas sealing characteristics and superior high-temperature durability.
In this case, as is apparent from the comparison of the Sample 1 and the Comparative
Sample 2, it was necessary that Si content in the constituent elements except for
Ag be set to be more than 22% by volume, and as is apparent from the comparison of
the Sample 1 and the Comparative Sample 3, it was necessary that the B content in
the constituent elements except for Ag be set to be more than 14% by volume.
[0040] In particular, as is apparent from the results of the Samples 2 to 4, it was preferable
that when at least one kind selected from the group consisting of Ge, Cr, Al, Ti,
Zr and Hf be further added as an additional component, the additional component content
in the constituent elements except for Ag be set to less than 64% by volume.
1. A brazing alloy for bonding in air, comprising Ag, B, and Si, as essential components,
wherein the total of constituent elements except for Ag is set to more than 50% by
volume and not more than 90% by volume,
Si content in the constituent elements except for Ag is set to more than 22% by volume,
and
B content in the constituent elements except for Ag is set to more than 14% by volume.
2. The brazing alloy for bonding in air according to claim 1, wherein at least one kind
selected from the group consisting of Ge, Cr, Al, Ti, Zr, and Hf is further added
as an additional component, and the additional component content in the constituent
elements except for Ag is set to less than 64% by volume.
3. The brazing alloy for bonding in air according to claim 1 or 2, wherein when the brazing
alloy is used for bonding of members, an oxide containing at least one kind of the
constituent elements is formed in brazing.
4. The brazing alloy for bonding in air according to any one of claims 1 to 3, wherein
when the brazing alloy is used for bonding of members, a complex oxide containing
at least two kinds of the constituent elements is formed in brazing.
5. The brazing alloy for bonding in air according to any one of claims 1 to 4, wherein
the brazing alloy has a melting point of not less than 650 °C and not more than 850
°C in air.
6. A bonded article formed of a set of a metal member and a metal member, a set of a
ceramic member and a ceramic member, or a set of a metal member and a ceramic member,
which are bonded with the brazing alloy recited in any one of claims 1 to 5, and the
bonded article having gas sealing characteristics.
7. The bonded article according to claim 6, wherein the bonded article is used in a fuel
cell or in a solid oxide fuel cell.
8. A current collecting material formed of a set of a metal member and a metal member,
a set of a ceramic member and a ceramic member, or a set of a metal member and a ceramic
member, which are bonded with the brazing alloy recited in any one of claims 1 to
5, and the current collecting material having electrical conductivity.
9. The current collecting material according to claim 8, wherein the current collecting
material is used in a fuel cell or in a solid oxide fuel cell.