Technical Field
[0001] The present invention relates to a thick steel plate having good ultralow-temperature
toughness, more specifically relates to a thick steel plate having good toughness
(in particular, toughness in a plate width direction (C direction)) at an ultralow
temperature of -196°C or lower even if the Ni content is decreased to about 5.0 to
7.5%. Although description is made mainly on a thick steel plate for liquefied natural
gas (LNG) (typically, a storage tank, a transport ship, and the like), which is to
be exposed to the ultralow temperature, the thick steel plate of the invention is
not limited thereto, and may be applied to general thick steel plates to be used for
applications exposed to the ultralow temperature of -196°C or lower.
Background Art
[0002] A thick steel plate for a LNG storage tank used as a storage tank of liquefied natural
gas (LNG) is required to have high strength and toughness high enough to withstand
the ultralow temperature of -196°C. A thick steel plate containing about 9% of Ni
(9% Ni steel) has been used as the thick steel plate to be used for such applications.
A thick steel plate, which has good ultralow-temperature toughness despite a low Ni
content of less than 9%, is now increasingly developed along with recent increase
in Ni cost.
[0003] For example, NPTL 1 describes an effect of heat treatment in a α-γ coexistence region
on low-temperature toughness of 6% Ni steel. In detail, NPTL 1 describes that the
6% Ni steel is subjected to heat treatment (L treatment) in the α-γ coexistence region
(between Ac1 and Ac3) before tempering, thereby the 6% Ni steel has the ultralow-temperature
toughness at -196°C higher than or equal to that of the 9% Ni steel subjected to normal
quenching and tempering; such heat treatment also increases toughness in a C-direction
(plate width direction) specimen; and such effects are caused by existence of a large
amount of fine retained-austenite that is stable to an impact load at ultralow temperature.
Such a technique provides good ultralow-temperature toughness in a rolling direction
(L direction). However, ultralow-temperature toughness is likely to be worse in the
plate width direction (C direction) than in the L direction. In addition, no description
is made on percent brittle fracture.
[0004] PTL 1 and PTL 2 each describe a technique similar to that in NPTL 1. PTL 1 describes
the following technique. That is, steel containing 4.0 to 10% of Ni, in which austenite
grain size is controlled to be within a predetermined range, is hot-rolled and then
heated to a temperature between Ac1 and Ac3 and is then cooled. Such treatment, which
corresponds to the L treatment described in NPTL 1, is repeated one or more time.
Subsequently, the steel is tempered at a temperature lower than or equal to the Ac1
transformation temperature. PTL 2 describes the following technique: steel containing
4.0 to 10% of Ni, in which size of AlN is controlled to be 1 µm or less before hot
rolling, is subjected to heat treatment similar to that described in PTL 1 (L treatment
followed by tempering). The impact value (vE-196) at -196°C in description of such
techniques is estimated to be a value in the L direction, and the impact value in
the C direction is not clear. Each of such techniques makes no consideration on strength.
In addition, no description is made therein on percent brittle fracture.
[0005] NPTL 2 describes development of 6% Ni steel for a LNG storage tank through a combination
of the above-described L treatment (two-phase region quenching) and TMCP. NPTL 2 describes
a high value of toughness in the rolling direction (L direction), but does not describe
a value of toughness in the plate width direction (C direction).
[0006] PTL 3 describes high-tensile steel of 570 MPa class or higher with high toughness,
which contains 0.3 to 10% of Ni and a predetermined amount of Mg, contains appropriately
dispersed Mg-containing oxide particles having a predetermined particle size, and
has good weld toughness. PTL 3 describes the following. That is, the Mg-containing
oxide is controlled to refine grain size of austenite, and thereby base metal and
a heat affected zone (HAZ) each have improved toughness. To achieve this, important
are the amount of O (oxygen) before adding deoxidizing elements, and adding order
of Mg and other deoxidizing elements. Specifically, Mg, Ti, and Al are added together
into molten steel having an amount of dissolved oxygen of 0.001 to 0.02%, and the
molten steel is then cast into billets. Alternatively, Mg, Ti, and Al are added in
such a manner that Al is added at the end, and then the molten metal is cast into
billets. In an embodiment of PTL 3, toughness values (fracture transition temperature
vTrs) in the C direction are described, showing that while 9% Ni steel is good in
the above-described properties (fracture transition temperature vTrs of -196°C or
less), around 5% Ni steel has the fracture transition temperature vTrs of -140°C and
is required to be further improved.
[0007] Furthermore, PTL 4 describes the following technique: 5.0 to 7.5% of Ni is added
to uniformly distribute austenite, which allows production of a thick steel plate
that is good in toughness (CTOD properties), arrestability, and unstable-fracture
inhibiting properties for each of base metal and a weld joint. However, evaluation
temperature in the CTOD test is slightly high, -165°C, showing that the disclosed
technique is not suitable for ultralow temperature of -196°C or lower. As a result
of scrutiny of PTL 4, no description has been found on percent brittle fracture in
a Charpy impact absorption test. In addition, the steel must be heated for long time
at high temperature, i.e., for 8 to 50 hr at 1250 to 1380°C in order to fabricate
the thick steel plate described in PTL 4, which is disadvantageous in light of manufacturing
cost.
[0008] WO 2012/005330 A1 discloses a Ni-added steel plate comprising, by mass% C: 0.03% to 0.10%; Si: 0.02%
to 0.40%; Mn: 0.3% to 1.2%; Ni: 5.0% to 7.5%; Cr: 0.4% to 1.5%; Mo: 0.02% to 0.4%;
Al: 0.01% to 0.08%; TO: 0.0001% to 0.0050%; P: limited to 0.0100% or less; S: limited
to 0.0035% or less; N: limited to 0.0070% or less; and the balance consisting of iron
and unavoidable impurities, wherein a Ni segregation ratio at a position of 1/4 of
a plate thickness away from a plate surface in a thickness direction is 1.3 or less,
a fraction of an austenite after a deep cooling is 2% or more, an austenite unevenness
index after the deep cooling is 5.0 or less, and an average equivalent circle diameter
of the austenite after the deep cooling is 1 pm or less (cf. for instance claim 1).
Citation List
Patent Literature
[0009]
PTL 1: Japanese Unexamined Patent Application Publication No. Sho49 (1974)-135813.
PTL 2: Japanese Unexamined Patent Application Publication No. Sho51 (1976)-13308.
PTL 3: Japanese Unexamined Patent Application Publication No. 2001-123245.
PTL 4: Japanese Patent No. 4975888.
Non-patent Literature
Summary of Invention
Technical Problem
[0011] As described above, although there have been provided techniques for improving ultralow-temperature
toughness at -196°C of Ni steel having the Ni content of about 5.0 to 7.5%, ultralow-temperature
toughness in the C direction is not sufficiently investigated. In particular, it is
strongly required to further improve ultralow-temperature toughness (improve ultralow-temperature
toughness in the C direction) under high strength (in detail, tensile strength of
more than 690 MPa and yield strength of more than 590 MPa) of base metal.
[0012] Any of the above-described literatures makes no description on percent brittle fracture.
The percent brittle fracture indicates the percentage of brittle fracture occurring
at load application in a Charpy impact test. In a region where brittle fracture occurs,
energy absorbed by steel before start of fracture becomes extremely small, and thus
fracture easily propagates. To reduce the fracture particularly at ultralow temperature,
therefore, it is an extremely important requirement that the percent brittle fracture
shown in a general Charpy impact test is controlled to a low level (10% or less).
However, since brittle fracture more easily occurs along with higher strength, it
is in general difficult to achieve percent brittle fracture of 10% or less under such
high strength of base metal. Hence, there has not been proposed a technique that allows
a high-strength thick steel plate with high strength of base metal to have high strength
and good ultralow-temperature toughness.
[0013] An object of the invention, which has been made in light of the above-described circumstances,
is to provide a high-strength thick steel plate of Ni steel having a Ni content of
about 5.0 to 7.5%, which is good in ultralow-temperature toughness (particularly the
ultralow-temperature toughness in the C direction) at -196°C is good and has percent
brittle fracture of 10% or less.
Solution to Problem
[0014] To solve the above-described problem, according to the present invention, there is
provided a thick steel plate having good ultralow-temperature toughness and a thickness
of 6 to 50 mm, which is summarized by consisting of, by mass percent, C: 0.02 to 0.10%,
Si: 0.40% or less (not including 0%), Mn: 0.50 to 2.0%, P: 0.007% or less (not including
0%) S: 0.007% or less (not including 0%) Al: 0.005 to 0.050%, Ni: 5.0 to 7.5%, and
N: 0.010% or less (not including 0%); and optionally at least one selected from a
group consisting of Cu: 1.00% or less (not including 0%), Cr: 1.2% or less (not including
0%), Mo: 1.00% or less (not including 0%), Ti: 0.025% or less (not including 0%),
Nb: 0.10% or less (not including 0%), V: 0.50% or less (not including 0%), B: 0.0050%
or less (not including 0%), Ca: 0.0030% or less (not including 0%), REM: 0.0050% or
less (not including 0%), and Zr: 0.0050% or less (not including 0%), with the remainder
consisting of iron and inevitable impurities, in which average roundness (A) of inclusions,
each having an equivalent circle diameter of more than 1.0 µm, is 1.8 or less, the
average roundness (A) of inclusions being calculated according to the following formula
Roundness = L
2/4π/S wherein L is the perimeter (µm) of the inclusion, and S is area (µm
2) of the inclusion, a volume fraction (V) of a retained austenite phase existing at
-196°C satisfies 2.0 to 12.0%, and a value B represented by Formula (1) is 1.3 or
more.

wherein the steel plate has a percent brittle fracture at -196°C of 10% or less in
a Charpy impact test in the C direction in accordance with JIS Z 2242, a tensile strength
(TS) of more than 690 MPa and a yield strength (YS) of more than 590 MPa measured
in accordance with JIS Z 2241.
[0015] In a preferred embodiment of the invention, a retained austenite phase existing at
-196°C of the steel plate satisfies 4.0 to 12.0% in a volume fraction.
Advantageous Effects of Invention
[0016] According to the invention, there can be provided a high-strength thick steel plate
of low Ni steel having a low Ni content of about 5.0 to 7.5%, which has good ultralow-temperature
toughness at -196°C or less (particularly ultralow-temperature toughness in the C
direction) despite high strength of base metal (in detail, tensile strength TS of
more than 690 MPa and yield strength YS of more than 590 MPa), and specifically satisfies
percent brittle fracture at -196°C of 10% or less (preferably, percent brittle fracture
at -233°C of 50% or less) in a Charpy impact absorption test in the C direction.
Description of Embodiments
[0017] The inventors have conducted investigations to provide a technique for improving
ultralow-temperature toughness of a high-strength thick steel plate having a low Ni
content of 7.5% or less such that percent brittle fracture at -196°C of 10% or less
is satisfied in a Charpy impact test in the C direction while tensile strength TS
of more than 690 MPa and yield strength YS of more than 590 MPa are satisfied. As
a result, they have found that the desired object is attained by (a) controlling a
retained austenite (retained y) phase at -196°C to have a volume fraction V of 2.0
to 12.0% (preferably controlled to be 4.0 to 12.0% (in volume fraction)), and (b)
decreasing the average roundness A of inclusions each having an equivalent circle
diameter of more than 1.0 µm, to 1.8 or less, the inclusions promoting propagation
of brittle fracture (which may be simply referred to as inclusion hereinafter), and
controlling a value B represented by Formula (1) to be 1.3 or more.

[0018] The latter (b) is a distinctive characteristic in terms of the above-described existing
techniques. Details of achievement of the invention are now described.
[0019] The inventors have conducted various investigations to provide a thick steel plate
of Ni steel having a Ni content of 7.5% or less and having good ultralow-temperature
toughness at -196°C. Specifically, the inventors have first investigated a method
taught in a literature on the existing techniques from the viewpoint of providing
the high-strength thick steel plate having good ultralow-temperature toughness, the
steel plate satisfying all properties of percent brittle fracture of 10% or less in
the C direction, tensile strength TS of more than 690 MPa, and yield strength YS of
more than 590 MPa.
[0020] The literature teaches that the retained austenite (retained y) existing at -196°C
is importantly stabilized to improve ultralow-temperature toughness of 5% Ni steel.
In addition, a technique is recommended from comprehensive consideration of a manufacturing
method, in which the amount of dissolved oxygen is controlled before adding deoxidizing
elements in a stage of molten steel, and the molten steel is cast into a slab in such
a manner that Al is added therein at the end, and the slab is subjected to heat treatment
(L treatment) in the α-γ coexistence region (between Ac1 and Ac3) and then tempered
at a temperature of lower than or equal to the Ac1 transformation temperature, and
it is taught that the ultralow-temperature toughness is increased by the technique.
Through the investigation results, however, the inventors have found that such a technique
increases the ultralow-temperature toughness in the L direction, but does not sufficiently
increase the ultralow-temperature toughness in the C direction, and consequently the
above-described target level (the percent brittle fracture of 10% or less in the C
direction) cannot be achieved by the technique.
[0021] As a result of further investigations, the inventors have found that further requirements
must be added for a thick steel plate and a method of manufacturing the thick steel
plate while the above-described technique is basically adopted in order to produce
a desired thick steel plate having good ultralow-temperature toughness. In detail,
it has been found that (1) a thick steel plate is effectively designed such that a
retained-y phase at -196°C is allowed to exist in a range of the volume fraction V
of 2.0 to 12.0%, and while attention is focused on the inclusions each having the
equivalent circle diameter of more than 1.0 µm, the inclusions being found to promote
propagation of brittle fracture, the average roundness A of the inclusions is decreased
to 1.8 or less, and a value B, which is represented by the relational expression (1)
of the average roundness A of the inclusions and the volume fraction V (%) of the
retained-y phase existing at -196°C, is controlled to be 1.3 or more. In addition,
it has been found that (2), to fabricate such a thick steel plate, it is effective
to perform control of the amount of dissolved oxygen (the amount of free oxygen) before
adding Al in a stage of molten steel, and perform heat treatment (L treatment) between
Ac1 and Ac3 followed by tempering in a predetermined temperature range after hot rolling,
and it is effective to perform further control in the stage of molten steel in such
a manner that cooling time (t1) from 1450 to 1500°C in casting is controlled to be
300 sec or less (a value at a half position of the slab thickness t), and cooling
time (t2) from 1300 to 1200°C in casting is controlled to be 680 sec or less (a value
at a quarter position of the slab thickness t).
[0022] Furthermore, the inventors have found that (c), in the control described in (a),
the retained-y phase existing at -196°C is controlled to be 4.0 to 12.0% (in volume
fraction), thereby the percent brittle fracture can be maintained to a good level
of 50% or less even at a lower temperature of -233°C, and (d), to fabricate such a
thick steel plate, the steel is effectively held for a predetermined time in the heat
treatment (L treatment) between Ac1 and Ac3 after hot rolling, and eventually they
have completed the invention.
[0023] In this specification, "ultralow-temperature toughness is good" means that when percent
brittle fracture in a Charpy impact absorption test in the C direction (plate width
direction) is measured by a method described in the section of Examples described
later, the percent brittle fracture at -196°C of 10% or less is satisfied. In Examples
described later, percent brittle fracture in the L direction (rolling direction) is
not measured. This is based on the following empirical rule: if percent brittle fracture
in the C direction is 10% or less, percent brittle fracture in the L direction is
necessarily 10% or less.
[0024] In this specification, "thick steel plate" refers to a steel plate having a thickness
of roughly 6 to 50 mm.
[0025] The invention covers the high-strength thick steel plate satisfying tensile strength
TS of more than 690 MPa and yield strength YS of more than 590 MPa.
[0026] The thick steel plate of the invention is now described in detail.
[0027] As described above, the thick steel plate of the invention is characterized by containing
, by mass percent, C: 0.02 to 0.10%, Si: 0.40% or less (not including 0%), Mn: 0.50
to 2.0%, P: 0.007% or less (not including 0%), S: 0.007% or less (not including 0%),
Al: 0.005 to 0.050%, Ni: 5.0 to 7.5%, and N: 0.010% or less (not including 0%), with
the remainder consisting of iron and inevitable impurities, in which the average roundness
(A) of inclusions, each having an equivalent circle diameter of more than 1.0 µm,
is 1.8 or less, a retained austenite phase existing at -196°C has a volume fraction
(V) of 2.0 to 12.0%, and a value B represented by Formula (1) is 1.3 or more.

[0028] First, components in the steel are described.
C: 0.02 to 0.10%
[0029] C is an essential element to obtain strength and retained austenite. The lower limit
of the C content is defined to be 0.02% or more to allow such a function to be effectively
exhibited. The lower limit of the C content is preferably 0.03% or more, and more
preferably 0.04% or more. However, excessively large amount of C causes excessive
increase in strength, leading to reduction in ultralow-temperature toughness; hence,
the upper limit of the C content is 0.10% or less. The upper limit of the C content
is preferably 0.08% or less, and more preferably 0.06% or less.
Si: 0.40% or less (not including 0%)
[0030] Si is a useful element as a deoxidizer. However, excessively large amount of Si promotes
formation of a hard martensite island, leading to reduction in ultralow-temperature
toughness; hence, the upper limit of the Si content is 0.40% or less. The upper limit
of the Si content is preferably 0.35% or less, and more preferably 0.20% or less.
Mn: 0.50 to 2.0%
[0031] Mn functions as a deoxidizer, and is an austenite (y) stabilizing element and thus
contributes to increasing the amount of retained γ. The lower limit of the Mn content
is defined to be 0.50% to allow such a function to be effectively exhibited. The lower
limit of the Mn content is preferably 0.6% or more, and more preferably 0.7% or more.
However, excessively large amount of Mn causes temper brittleness, which prevents
desired ultralow-temperature toughness from being obtained; hence, the upper limit
of the Mn content is 2.0% or less. The upper limit of the Mn content is preferably
1.5% or less, and more preferably 1.3% or less.
P: 0.007% or less (not including 0%)
[0032] P is an impurity element causing grain boundary fracture. The upper limit of the
P content is therefore defined to be 0.007% or less to obtain desired ultralow-temperature
toughness. The upper limit of the P content is preferably 0.005% or less. Although
the P content is preferably as small as possible, it is industrially difficult to
decrease the P content to 0%.
S: 0.007% or less (not including 0%)
[0033] S is an impurity element causing grain boundary fracture as with P. The upper limit
of the S content is therefore defined to be 0.007% or less to obtain desired ultralow-temperature
toughness. As shown in Examples described later, a larger amount of S increases percent
brittle fracture, which prevents desired ultralow-temperature toughness (percent brittle
fracture at -196°C of 10% or less) from being obtained. The upper limit of the S content
is preferably 0.005% or less. Although the S content is preferably as small as possible,
it is industrially difficult to decrease the S content to 0%.
Al: 0.005 to 0.050%
[0034] A1 is a deoxidizing element. When the Al content is insufficient, free oxygen concentration
in molten steel increases, and secondary inclusions such as oxides or sulfides are
compositely formed on surfaces of inclusions originally existing in molten steel,
which makes a shape of each inclusion to be distorted, and increases the average roundness
of the inclusions each having the equivalent circle diameter of more than 1.0 µm;
hence, the lower limit of the Al content is defined to be 0.005% or more. The lower
limit of the Al content is preferably 0.010% or more, and more preferably 0.015% or
more. However, excessively large amount of Al promotes aggregation or coalescence
of the inclusions, which also increases the average roundness of that inclusions;
hence, the upper limit of the Al content is defined to be 0.050% or less. The upper
limit of the Al content is preferably 0.045% or less, and more preferably 0.04% or
less.
Ni: 5.0 to 7.5%
[0035] Ni is an essential element to provide retained austenite (retained y) useful for
improving ultralow-temperature toughness. The lower limit of the Ni content is defined
to be 5.0% or more to allow such a function to be effectively exhibited. The lower
limit of the Ni content is preferably 5.2% or more, and more preferably 5.4% or more.
However, excessively large amount of Ni causes increase in cost of material; hence,
the upper limit of the Ni content is defined to be 7.5% or less. The upper limit of
the Ni content is preferably 7.0% or less, more preferably 6.5% or less, and most
preferably 6.0% or less.
N: 0.010% or less (not including 0%)
[0036] N causes strain aging and thereby reduces the ultralow-temperature toughness; hence,
the upper limit of the N content is defined to be 0.010% or less. The upper limit
of the N content is preferably 0.006% or less, and more preferably 0.004% or less.
[0037] The thick steel plate of the invention contains the above-described components as
the essential components with the remainder consisting of iron and inevitable impurities.
[0038] The thick steel plate of the invention may contain the following optional components
in order to add further properties.
Cu: 1.00% or less (not including 0%)
[0039] Cu is a y stabilizing element, i.e., an element that contributes to increasing the
amount of retained γ. Cu is preferably contained 0.05% or more to allow such a function
to be effectively exhibited. However, excessively large amount of Cu causes excessive
increase in strength, which prevents the desired effect on the ultralow-temperature
toughness from being exhibited; hence, the upper limit of the Cu content is preferably
1.00% or less. The upper limit of the Cu content is more preferably 0.8% or less,
and most preferably 0.7% or less.
At Least One Selected from Group Consisting of Cr: 1.2% or less (not including 0%)
and Mo: 1.00% or less (not including 0%)
[0040] Cr and Mo are each an element that increases strength. Such elements may each be
contained singly or may be contained in combination. The Cr content and the Mo content
are preferably 0.05% or more and 0.01% or more, respectively, to allow such a function
to be effectively exhibited. However, excessively large amount of each of the elements
causes excessive increase in strength, which prevents the desired ultralow-temperature
toughness from being obtained. Hence, the upper limit of the Cr content is preferably
1.2% or less (more preferably 1.1% or less, further preferably 0.9% or less, and most
preferably 0.5% or less), and the upper limit of the Mo content is preferably 1.00%
or less (more preferably 0.8% or less, and most preferably 0.6% or less).
At Least One Selected from Group Consisting of Ti: 0.025% or less (not including 0%),
Nb: 0.10% or less (not including 0%), and V: 0.50% or less (not including 0%)
[0041] Ti, Nb, and V are each an element that precipitates as carbonitride and increases
strength. Such elements may each be contained singly or may be contained in combination.
To allow such a function to be effectively exhibited, it is preferred that the Ti
content is 0.005% or more, the Nb content is 0.005% or more, and the V content is
0.005% or more. However, excessively large amount of each of the elements causes excessive
increase in strength, which prevents the desired ultralow-temperature toughness from
being obtained. Hence, the upper limit of the Ti content is preferably 0.025% or less
(more preferably 0.018% or less, and most preferably 0.015% or less), the upper limit
of the Nb content is preferably 0.10% or less (more preferably 0.05% or less, and
most preferably 0.02% or less), and the upper limit of the V content is preferably
0.50% or less (more preferably 0.3% or less, and most preferably 0.2% or less).
B: 0.0050% or less (not including 0%)
[0042] B is an element that improves hardenability and thereby contributes to increasing
strength. The B content is preferably 0.0005% or more to allow such a function to
be effectively exhibited. However, excessively large amount of B causes excessive
increase in strength, which prevents the desired ultralow-temperature toughness from
being obtained; hence, the upper limit of the B content is preferably 0.0050% or less,
(more preferably 0.0030% or less, and most preferably 0.0020% or less).
At Least One Selected from Group Consisting of Ca: 0.0030% or less (not including
0%), REM: 0.0050% or less (not including 0%), and Zr: 0.0050% or less (not including
0%)
[0043] Ca, REM, and Zr are each a deoxidizing element. That is, when each of such elements
is contained, oxygen concentration in steel decreases and thus the amount of oxides
decreases, and thereby favorable influence is exerted on toughness. Such elements
may each be contained singly or may be contained in combination. To allow such a function
to be effectively exhibited, the Ca content of 0.0005% or more, the REM content, which
refers to the amount of one REM element when each of the following REM elements is
singly contained, or refers to the total amount of the REM elements when at least
two of them are contained together (the same applies to the following for the REM
content), of 0.0005% or more, and the Zr content of 0.0005% or more are preferred.
However, excessively large amount of each of such elements increases oxide size, and
thus reduces the ultralow-temperature toughness; hence, the upper limit of the Ca
content is preferably 0.0030% or less (more preferably 0.0025% or less), the upper
limit of the REM content is preferably 0.0050% or less (more preferably 0.0040% or
less), and the upper limit of the Zr content is preferably 0.0050% or less (more preferably
0.0040% or less).
[0044] In this specification, REM (rare earth elements) refers to an element group including
lanthanoid elements (15 elements from atomic number 57 (La) to atomic number 71 (Lu)
in a periodic table), Sc (scandium), and Y (yttrium). Such elements may each be contained
singly or may be contained in combination. Ce and La are preferred among the rare
earth elements. REM may be contained in any form without limitation, i.e., may be
contained in a form of misch metal mainly containing Ce and La (for example, Ce: about
70% and La: about 20 to 30%), or may be contained in a form of a simple substance
of Ce or La.
[0045] The components in the steel of the invention have been described.
[0046] Furthermore, the thick steel plate of the invention is designed such that the volume
fraction V of the retained-y phase existing at -196°C satisfies 2.0 to 12.0% (preferably
4.0 to 12.0%).
[0047] The retained-y phase existing at -196°C is known to contribute to improvement in
ultralow-temperature toughness. To allow such a function to be effectively exhibited,
the volume fraction V of the retained-y phase in the entire microstructures existing
at -196°C is defined to be 2.0% or more. However, the retained y is relatively soft
compared with a matrix phase, and if the amount of the retained γ is excessive, the
predetermined value of YS cannot be obtained; hence, the upper limit of the retained
y is defined to be 12.0% (see No. 43 in Table 2B described later). The lower limit
of the volume fraction V of the retained-y phase is preferably 4.0% or more, and more
preferably 6.0% or more. The upper limit thereof is preferably 11.5% or less, and
more preferably 11.0% or less.
[0048] Furthermore, the volume fraction V of the retained-y phase in the entire microstructures
existing at -196°C is controlled to be 4.0% or more, thereby the percent brittle fracture
can be maintained to a good level of 50% or less even at -233°C that is lower than
-196°C described above. When such effects are intended to be further exhibited, the
lower limit of the volume fraction V of the retained-y phase is more preferably 6.0%
or more while the preferred upper limit thereof is the same as that described above.
[0049] In the thick steel plate of the invention, it is important to control the volume
fraction V of the retained-y phase in the microstructures existing at -196°C, and
any of microstructures other than the retained y may exist without limitation as long
as the microstructure normally exists in the thick steel plate. Examples of the microstructures
other than the retained y include bainite, martensite, and carbide such as cementite.
[0050] Furthermore, in the thick steel plate of the invention, inclusions, each having the
equivalent circle diameter of more than 1.0 µm, are controlled such that the average
roundness A of the inclusions satisfies A ≤ 1.8, and the value B represented by Formula
(1) satisfies 1.3 or more.

[0051] Here, "equivalent circle diameter" means a diameter that is obtained in such a manner
that size of each inclusion is focused, a circle having area equal to area of the
inclusion is assumed, and diameter of the circle is determined.
[0052] In the invention, inclusions each having the equivalent circle diameter of more than
1.0 µm are focused because it has been found that such inclusions promote propagation
of brittle fracture. Specifically, the inclusions that promote brittle fracture must
be decreased in order to improve the percent brittle fracture at ultralow temperature
while predetermined high-strength is maintained. From the results of investigation
of the inventors, however, it has been found that if the average roundness A of the
inclusions increases, the desired ultralow-temperature toughness cannot be obtained
even if the volume fraction V of the retained-y phase at -196°C is controlled to be
within the above-described range (see Nos. 33, 35, and 36 in Table 2B described later).
The average roundness A of the inclusions is better as it is smaller, and is preferably
1.7 or less, and more preferably 1.5 or less. The average roundness A is most preferably
1. In the invention, average size (average equivalent circle diameter) of the inclusions
each having the equivalent circle diameter of more than 1.0 µm is roughly 2.0 µm or
less.
[0053] The inclusions can be determined by the method mentioned in Examples described later.
The invention does not limit an inclusion type of each inclusion having the equivalent
circle diameter of more than 1.0 µm. This is because occurrence of brittle fracture
is greatly affected by size (equivalent circle diameter) of the inclusion rather than
a type of the inclusion. Examples of the type of the inclusion include particles of
a single substance of oxide, sulfide, nitride, or oxynitride, particles of a compound
of at least two of such single particle substances, and composite particles including
such single substance particles combined with another element.
[0054] As shown in the invention, the average roundness A of the coarse inclusions each
having the equivalent circle diameter of more than 1.0 µm is controlled to be 1.8
or less, thereby ultralow-temperature toughness is improved while the predetermined
strength is maintained. While the mechanism of this is not clear in detail, it is
estimated as follows. Each of inclusions typically has higher hardness than a matrix,
and therefore stress concentration tends to occur thereon. As a result, the inclusion
often serves as an origin of brittle fracture. It is thus considered that as a shape
of such an inclusion is more distorted, local stress concentration around the inclusion
is further promoted, and therefore brittle fracture is further easily induced. It
is therefore estimated that when the distorted inclusions are reduced (i.e., when
the average roundness A of the inclusions is controlled to be 1.8 or less and controlled
to be close to a round (A=1) as much as possible), occurrence of stress concentration
is avoided, and the ultralow-temperature toughness is improved.
[0055] Furthermore, in the invention, it is necessary that the average roundness A of the
inclusions is controlled as above, and that the value B represented by Formula (1)
satisfies value B ≥ 1.3.
[0056] The value B is a parameter to decrease the percent brittle fracture at ultralow temperature.
As shown in Formula (1), the value B is calculated in terms of a relationship between
the average roundness A of the inclusions and the volume fraction V of the retained
austenite (retained y) phase existing at -196°C. The details of introduction of the
value B are now described.
[0057] It is known that the percent brittle fracture increases with increase in number of
origins of brittle fracture or with decrease in resistance against propagation of
brittle fracture. A coarse inclusion in general tends to become an origin of brittle
fracture, and the inventors have found the following. That is, as the roundness of
the coarse inclusion increases, i.e., as the coarse inclusion has a shape more distorted
from the round (A=1), the coarse inclusion more easily serves as an origin of brittle
fracture. In addition, as the amount of the retained y increases, the retained γ further
acts as a resistance against propagation of brittle fracture. According to such findings,
the inventors have experimentally obtained a contribution rate of each of the average
roundness A and the volume fraction V to the percent brittle fracture in an ultralow
temperature range based on many basic experiments. As a result, they have found that
the value B represented by Formula (1) is a useful parameter to evaluate the ultralow-temperature
toughness. As shown in Examples described later, the value B is controlled to be 1.3
or more while the volume fraction V of the retained-y phase and a form (average roundness)
of each coarse inclusion having the equivalent circle diameter of more than 1.0 µm
are maintained. This exclusively allows both strength and percent brittle fracture
at each of -196°C and -233°C to be obtained at a high level.
[0058] The value B is preferably 1.6 or more, and more preferably 1.8 or more. The value
B is preferably larger in light of ultralow-temperature toughness, and the upper limit
thereof is not specifically limited. However, as described above, if the volume fraction
V of the retained γ excessively increases, the predetermined value of YS cannot be
obtained. Hence, the upper limit of the volume fraction V of the retained y is limited
to 12. 0%. In consideration of this, the upper limit of the value B is substantially
limited to 5.2 (= 12.0
2/3/1) (the volume fraction V of the retained y = 12.0% and the average roundness A =
1 are substituted into the computational expression of the value B). In consideration
of a balance of strength and toughness, the value B is more preferably 3.0 or less.
[0059] A method of manufacturing the thick steel plate of the invention is now described.
[0060] Distinctive characteristics of the manufacturing method according to the invention
are the following (A) and (B).
- (A) The amount of free oxygen [O] before adding Al is controlled to be 100 ppm or
less in a stage of molten steel, cooling time (t1) from 1450 to 1500°C in casting
is controlled to be 300 sec or less (a value at a half position of the slab thickness
t), and cooling time (t2) from 1300 to 1200°C in casting is controlled to be 680 sec
or less (a value at a quarter position of the slab thickness t). According to the
technique (A), particularly the average roundness A of the inclusions can be decreased
to a level within a predetermined range.
- (B) After hot rolling, a slab is heated and held within a temperature range from Ac1
to Ac3, and is then water-cooled. Subsequently, the slab is tempered for 10 to 60
min within a temperature range from 520°C to Ac1, and is then air-cooled or water-cooled.
According to the technique (B), particularly the volume fraction of the retained-y
phase existing at -196°C can be appropriately controlled.
[0061] The value B defined in the invention is a parameter on both the average roundness
of the inclusions and the volume fraction of the retained γ; hence, appropriately
controlling the techniques (A) and (B) makes it possible to control the value B to
be within a predetermined range.
[0062] In terms of comparison with the above-described existing techniques, it is the most
distinctive characteristic that t1 and t2 are each controlled in the technique (A).
[0063] Each step is now described in detail.
(Melting Step)
[0064] In the invention, a method of adding Al is particularly noticed. This is because
of the following fact. The inclusions, each having the equivalent circle diameter
of more than 1.0 µm, to be controlled in the invention are formed through composite
formation of secondary inclusions such as oxides or sulfides nucleating on Al-based
inclusions formed in molten metal during cooling. The Al-based inclusions are easily
coarsened through aggregation or coalescence, and thus each easily have a distorted
shape having a large roundness.
[0065] First, in adding Al as a deoxidizer into molten steel, the amount of free oxygen
(the amount of dissolved oxygen, which may be abbreviated as [O] amount hereinafter)
before adding Al is controlled to be 100 ppm or less. If the [O] amount exceeds 100
ppm, an increased number of Al-based inclusions are formed during addition of Al,
and the roundness of each inclusion exceeds the predetermined range (see No. 33 in
Table 2B described later). The [O] amount, which is better as it is smaller, is preferably
80 ppm or less, and more preferably 50 ppm or less. The lower limit of the [O] amount
is not particularly limited in light of controlling the average roundness of the inclusions.
[0066] Examples of a method of controlling the [O] amount as described above include deoxidizing
the molten steel by adding deoxidizing elements of Mn and Si into the molten steel.
When deoxidizers such as Ti, Ca, REM, and Zr are contained as optional components
in addition to the above-described elements, the [O] amount can be controlled through
addition of such elements.
[0067] To control the Al-based inclusions, controlling the [O] amount before adding Al is
important regardless of adding order of Al and other deoxidizing elements. However,
if Al is added with high [O] amount, temperature of the molten steel increases due
to an oxidation reaction, which is dangerous in operation; hence, Si and Mn are preferably
added prior to Al. The optional components such as Ti are preferably added into the
molten steel after adding Al.
[0068] Subsequently, casting is started. While the temperature range in casting is roughly
1650°C or less, the invention has revealed that it is particularly important that
cooling time (t1) in a temperature range from 1450 to 1500°C is controlled to be 300
sec or less, and cooling time (t2) from 1300 to 1200°C is controlled to be 680 sec
or less, and thereby the average roundness of the inclusions each having the equivalent
circle diameter of more than 1.0 µm is appropriately controlled. This is described
in detail below.
[0069] First, the cooling time (t1) in the temperature range from 1450 to 1500°C is controlled
to be 300 sec or less. If the t1 exceeds 300 sec, composite formation of the secondary
inclusions nucleating on the Al-based inclusions is promoted, and each inclusion having
the equivalent circle diameter of more than 1.0 µm has a distorted shape, leading
to increase in average roundness and decrease in value B. As a result, the desired
ultralow-temperature toughness is not obtained (see Nos. 34 and 35 in Table 2B described
later). From such a viewpoint, t1 is better as it is shorter, and is preferably 290
sec or less, and more preferably 280 sec or less. The lower limit of t1 is not specifically
limited from such a viewpoint.
[0070] In the invention, attention is particularly focused on the temperature range from
1450 to 1500°C among temperature ranges in casting. This is because that temperature
range is a temperature region during which the molten steel is progressively solidified
and each component is increasingly segregated into the molten steel, so that growth
of the inclusions is accelerated.
[0071] The temperature range from 1450 to 1500°C corresponds to temperature of the center
(t/2) of the slab thickness t. The reason for this is as follows. As described before,
the oxide-based secondary inclusions are compositely formed mainly in molten metal;
hence, cooling time of a molten metal region must be controlled. However, since the
temperature range from 1450 to 1500°C is a temperature region during which the molten
metal is progressively solidified, cooling time of the molten metal region may not
be accurately measured due to solidification of the molten metal depending on temperature
measurement positions. In the invention, therefore, cooling time is measured at the
t/2 position at which the molten metal remains even at the lowest temperature. The
temperature of the center of the slab thickness can be measured by inserting a thermocouple
into a mold.
[0072] Subsequently, cooling time (t2) from 1300 to 1200°C is controlled to be 680 sec or
less. If the t2 exceeds 680 sec, composite formation of mainly the sulfide-based secondary
inclusions on the Al-based inclusions is promoted, and the average roundness of the
inclusions also increases (see No. 36 in Table 2B described later). From such a viewpoint,
t2 is more preferable as it is shorter since shorter t2 leads to a shape closer to
a round. Preferably, t2 is 650 sec or less. More preferably, t2 is 600 sec or less.
However, excessively short t2 increases a cooling load; hence, t2 is recommended to
be roughly 400 sec or more.
[0073] The temperature range from 1300 to 1200°C corresponds to the temperature of the quarter
part (t/4) of the slab thickness t. The reason for this is as follows. The cooling
time from 1300 to 1200°C is controlled to control the sulfide-based secondary inclusions
that are compositely formed mainly in solid iron. Since solidification has been substantially
completed in such a temperature region, measurement of cooling time is conducted at
the t/4 position at which the percent brittle fracture is measured. The temperature
of the t/4 part of the slab thickness can be measured by inserting a thermocouple
into a mold.
[0074] In the invention, the cooling time (t1) in the temperature range from 1450 to 1500°C
and the cooling time (t2) from 1300 to 1200°C should be controlled as described above,
and any approach may be taken to achieve this without limitation. For example, for
t1, the molten metal may be cooled at uniform velocity, i.e., at an average cooling
rate of about 0.17 °C/sec or less, in the above-described temperature range such that
cooling time in the temperature range is 300 sec or less. Alternatively, the molten
metal may be cooled at nonuniform velocity such that cooling time in the temperature
range is 300 sec or less. For t2, similar approach may be made.
[0075] In the invention, the molten metal may be cooled in any of temperature ranges in
casting other than the above-described temperature ranges in any method without limitation,
i.e., may be cooled by a typical method (air cooling or water cooling).
[0076] The molten steel is cast into a slab as described above, and then the slab is hot-rolled
and subjected to heat treatment.
[0077] The hot rolling step may be performed by any of typically used methods without limitation
so that a predetermined thickness is given. Specifically, the slab is heated for 1
to 4 hr at about 1100°C, and then (finish rolling) temperature and rolling reduction
are appropriately adjusted.
[0078] After the hot rolling, the slab is heated into the temperature range (TL) from the
Ac1 point to the Ac3 point and held therein, and is then water-cooled. This treatment
corresponds to the L treatment in the above-described existing technique, and allows
the retained y to stably exist at -196°C within a range of the predetermined amount.
[0079] In detail, the slab is heated to a temperature (TL) of the two-phase region [ferrite
(α)-γ] between the Ac1 point and the Ac3 point. The slab is heated into such a temperature
region, thereby alloy elements such as Ni are concentrated in the formed y phase,
resulting in formation of a metastable retained-y phase that exists metastably at
room temperature. A temperature less than the Ac1 point or more than the Ac3 point
eventually prevents the retained-y phase from sufficiently existing at -196°C (see
Nos. 37 and 38 in Table 2B described later). Preferred heating temperature is roughly
660 to 710°C.
[0080] The heating time at the two-phase region temperature (holding time, tL) is preferably
roughly 10 to 50 min. In the heating time of less than 10 min, the alloy elements
are not sufficiently concentrated into the y phase. In the heating time of more than
50 min, the α phase is annealed, and strength is lowered. A preferred heating time
is roughly 15 to 30 min.
[0081] Furthermore, the heating time is controlled to be 15 min or more, thereby at least
4.0% of the volume fraction of the retained-y phase at -196°C is obtained. Consequently,
the percent brittle fracture is 50% or less at -233°C, i.e., good toughness is obtained
even under a further ultralow temperature. The upper limit of preferred heating time
is the same as that described above (30 min or less).
[0082] Subsequently, the slab is water-cooled to room temperature and then tempered. The
tempering is performed for 10 to 60 min (t3) in a temperature range (T3) from 520°C
to A
c1. Consequently, C is concentrated in the metastable retained-y during tempering, which
increases stability of the metastable retained-y phase, resulting in formation of
the retained y phase that stably exists even at -196°C. If the tempering temperature
T3 is lower than 520°C, the metastable retained-y phase formed during holding of the
two-phase coexistence region is decomposed into the a phase and a cementite phase,
and thus the retained-y phase at -196°C cannot be sufficiently given (see No. 41 in
Table 2B described later). For the tempering temperature T3 of more than the Ac1 point
or the tempering time t3 of less than 10 min, C is not sufficiently concentrated in
the metastable retained-y phase, and the desired amount of retained y at -196°C cannot
be given (see No. 55 (an example of short t3) in Table 2 described later). For the
tempering time t3 of more than 60 min, the retained y at -196°C is excessively formed,
and the predetermined strength cannot be obtained (see No. 43 in Table 2 described
later).
[0083] A preferred tempering condition includes tempering temperature T3 of 570 to 620°C,
and tempering time t3 of 15 to 45 min (more preferably 15 to 35 min, and most preferably
15 to 25 min).
[0084] The slab is tempered as described above and then cooled to room temperature. The
slab may be cooled by any method without limitation, i.e., may be cooled by air cooling
or water cooling.
[0086] In the formulas, [] means concentration (mass%) of an alloy element in steel. In
the invention, As and W are not contained in the steel composition. In the Formulas,
therefore, calculation is made assuming that each of [As] and [W] is 0%.
Examples
[0087] Although the invention is now described in detail with some Examples, the invention
should not be limited thereto, and modifications or alterations thereof may be made
within the scope without departing from the gist described before and later, all of
which are included in the technical scope of the invention.
Example 1
[0088] Test steel samples having compositions shown in Table 1, in each of which the remainder
consists of iron and inevitable impurities and the unit is mass percent, were each
melted using a vacuum induction furnace (150 kg VIF) and cast, and then an ingot 600
mm long, 150 mm wide, and 150 mm high was fabricated through hot forging. In Example
1, mish metal containing about 50% Ce and about 25% La was used as REM. Adding order
of the deoxidizing elements was as follows. That is, when the optional components
were not contained, Si and Mn were added together (simultaneous adding) and then Al
was added. When the optional components of Ti, REM, Zr, and Ca were contained, Si
and Mn were added together (simultaneous adding), and then Al and Ti were added in
this order, and then REM, Zr, and Ca were added together (simultaneous adding). In
Example 1, time from addition of Al to start of casting was about 10 min in each case
(not shown in Tables).
[0089] In Table 2, [O] denotes the amount of dissolved oxygen (ppm) before adding Al, t1
denotes cooling time (sec) from 1450 to 1500°C in casting, and t2 denotes cooling
time (sec) from 1300 to 1200°C in casting. Each type of steel was cooled in each of
such temperature regions by air cooling or water cooling while cooling time was controlled
to be the above-described cooling time.
[0090] Subsequently, each of the ingots was heated for 1 to 4 hr at 1100°C, and then the
ingot was rolled into a thickness of 75 mm at a temperature of 830°C or more, and
was rolled at a final rolling temperature of 780°C and then water-cooled, thereby
a thick steel plate having a thickness of 25 mm was produced. The steel plates produced
in this way were heated at respective temperatures (TL in Table 2) shown in Table
2, and were then held for 5 to 60 min while being heated (see tL in Table 2), and
were then water-cooled to room temperature. Subsequently, the steel plates were tempered
as shown in Table 2 (T3 is tempering temperature, and t3 is tempering time), and were
then air-cooled or water-cooled to room temperature.
[0091] According to the procedures described below, the thick steel plates produced in this
way were each evaluated in average roundness A of the inclusions each having the equivalent
circle diameter of more than 1.0 µm, volume fraction (%) of the retained-y phase existing
at -196°C, tensile properties (tensile strength TS and yield strength YS), and ultralow-temperature
toughness (percent brittle fracture in the C direction at -196°C or -233°C).
(1) Measurement of average roundness A of Inclusions Each Having Equivalent Circle
Diameter of More Than 1.0 µm
[0092] Each of the steel plates was mirror-polished at its t/4 position (t: thickness),
and was subjected to photography in four viewing fields at 400 magnifications with
a light microscope. Area of one viewing field was 0.04 mm
2, and the total area of the four viewing fields was 0.15 mm
2. Inclusions observed in the four viewing fields were subjected to image analysis
with "Image-Pro Plus" from Media Cybernetics. In addition, roundness of each inclusion
having an equivalent circle diameter of more than 1.0 µm was calculated according
to the following formula, and an average of the calculated values was defined as the
average roundness A of the inclusions. When an inclusion has a round shape, the roundness
calculated by the formula is 1. As the inclusion has a more distorted shape, the roundness
calculated by the formula has a larger value.

In the formula, L is the perimeter (µm) of the inclusion, and S is area (µm
2) of the inclusion.
[0093] In Example 1, the inclusions each having an equivalent circle diameter of more than
1.0 µm were observed in number density of about 200 to 300 per square millimeter.
(2) Volume Fraction of Retained-y phase Existing at -196°C
[0094] A test specimen 10 by 10 by 55 mm was taken from the t/4 position of each steel plate.
The test specimen was held for 5 min at liquid nitrogen temperature (-196°C), and
was then subjected to X-ray diffraction measurement by a two-dimensional micro-part
X-ray diffractometer "RINT-RAPID II" from Rigaku Corporation. Subsequently, an integrated
intensity ratio was obtained on each of peaks of the lattice planes of (110), (200),
(211), and (220) of the ferrite phase, and on each of peaks of the lattice planes
of (111), (200), (220), and (311) of the retained-y phase. Based on such integrated
intensity ratios, the volume fraction of each of the lattice planes of (111), (200),
(220), and (311) of the retained-y phase was calculated, and an average of such volume
fractions was obtained and defined as "volume fraction (%) of retained y".
(3) Measurement of Tensile Properties (Tensile Strength TS and Yield Strength YS)
[0095] A JIS Z 2241-4 test specimen was taken parallel to the C direction from the t/4 position
of each steel plate, and was subjected to a tensile test by a method according to
JIS Z 2241 to determine tensile strength TS and yield strength YS. In Example 1, steel
having TS of more than 690 MPa and YS of more than 590 MPa was determined to be good
in strength of base metal.
(4) Measurement of Ultralow-Temperature Toughness (Percent Brittle Fracture in C Direction)
[0096] Three Charpy impact test specimens (JIS Z 2242 V-notch test specimens) were taken
parallel to the C direction from the position of t/4 (t: thickness) at W/4 (W: width)
and from the position of t/4 at W/2, and were subjected to measurement of percent
brittle fracture (%) at -196°C by the method according to JIS Z 2242, and an average
of the three measured values was calculated for each position. One average having
worse properties (i.e., larger percent brittle fracture) was selected from the two
averages calculated in this way. In Example 1, when the selected average has a value
of 10% or less, the relevant steel plate was determined to have good ultralow-temperature
toughness.
[0097] Table 2 collectively shows results of such measurements. Tables 1 and 2 also show
the Ac1 point and the Ac3 point for reference.
Table 2A
| No. |
Al → Casting → Hot rolling → Tempering |
Average roundness (A) |
Retained γ(%) V |
Ultralow-temperature toughness |
Tensile properties |
| [o] (ppm) |
t1 (sec) |
t2 (sec) |
TL (°C) |
tL (min) |
Ac1 |
Ac3 |
T3 (°C) |
t3 (min) |
Cooling method after tempering |
Percent brittle fracture at-196°C (%) |
YS |
TS |
| 1 |
45 |
261 |
500 |
660 |
10 |
622 |
775 |
600 |
20 |
Air cooling |
1.5 |
3.8 |
5 |
641 |
721 |
| 2 |
34 |
268 |
530 |
660 |
15 |
598 |
762 |
580 |
20 |
Water cooling |
1.4 |
5.4 |
0 |
633 |
722 |
| 3 |
45 |
258 |
500 |
660 |
15 |
620 |
784 |
600 |
20 |
Air cooling |
1.5 |
6.5 |
0 |
639 |
731 |
| 4 |
42 |
255 |
530 |
660 |
15 |
633 |
784 |
600 |
30 |
Water cooling |
1.4 |
7.8 |
0 |
628 |
728 |
| 5 |
45 |
260 |
530 |
660 |
10 |
632 |
779 |
600 |
30 |
Water cooling |
1.5 |
3.8 |
7 |
625 |
742 |
| 6 |
40 |
271 |
500 |
660 |
15 |
617 |
775 |
600 |
20 |
Air cooling |
1.5 |
5.5 |
0 |
630 |
725 |
| 7 |
42 |
255 |
500 |
660 |
10 |
613 |
777 |
600 |
20 |
Air cooling |
1.5 |
3.6 |
5 |
621 |
715 |
| 8 |
48 |
246 |
600 |
660 |
15 |
618 |
778 |
600 |
20 |
Water cooling |
1.6 |
6.1 |
0 |
638 |
721 |
| 9 |
38 |
195 |
530 |
700 |
15 |
632 |
780 |
620 |
35 |
Air cooling |
1.3 |
7.2 |
0 |
645 |
750 |
| 10 |
42 |
268 |
530 |
700 |
15 |
611 |
782 |
600 |
20 |
Air cooling |
1.4 |
6.6 |
0 |
638 |
746 |
| 11 |
41 |
236 |
650 |
660 |
15 |
633 |
796 |
600 |
20 |
Air cooling |
1.5 |
6.3 |
0 |
650 |
778 |
| 12 |
37 |
165 |
500 |
700 |
15 |
599 |
757 |
580 |
40 |
Air cooling |
1.3 |
10.1 |
0 |
622 |
749 |
| 13 |
32 |
213 |
530 |
660 |
15 |
622 |
771 |
600 |
20 |
Water cooling |
1.3 |
5.7 |
2 |
673 |
796 |
| 14 |
83 |
244 |
530 |
660 |
10 |
618 |
817 |
600 |
40 |
Air cooling |
1.8 |
3.9 |
8 |
619 |
695 |
| 15 |
29 |
241 |
500 |
660 |
50 |
614 |
802 |
600 |
20 |
Air cooling |
1.4 |
11.6 |
0 |
608 |
716 |
| 16 |
61 |
255 |
530 |
660 |
15 |
622 |
796 |
600 |
15 |
Air cooling |
1.7 |
3.5 |
7 |
681 |
750 |
| 17 |
31 |
220 |
530 |
660 |
15 |
618 |
792 |
570 |
15 |
Air cooling |
1.4 |
5.3 |
3 |
659 |
751 |
| 18 |
45 |
286 |
530 |
660 |
15 |
610 |
804 |
600 |
15 |
Air cooling |
1.7 |
4.1 |
5 |
736 |
791 |
| 19 |
36 |
245 |
530 |
660 |
15 |
621 |
787 |
580 |
40 |
Water cooling |
1.5 |
8.9 |
2 |
634 |
715 |
| 20 |
41 |
190 |
530 |
660 |
10 |
638 |
809 |
600 |
25 |
Air cooling |
1.8 |
3.8 |
3 |
681 |
758 |
| 21 |
35 |
269 |
530 |
710 |
10 |
630 |
805 |
600 |
20 |
Air cooling |
1.4 |
2.7 |
8 |
655 |
747 |
| 22 |
41 |
257 |
600 |
710 |
10 |
627 |
808 |
620 |
20 |
Air cooling |
1.5 |
3.9 |
0 |
652 |
752 |
| 23 |
39 |
287 |
530 |
660 |
15 |
594 |
754 |
570 |
50 |
Water cooling |
1.8 |
11.8 |
2 |
606 |
793 |
| 24 |
30 |
275 |
660 |
710 |
15 |
615 |
825 |
600 |
20 |
Water cooling |
1.7 |
7.0 |
3 |
664 |
783 |
| 25 |
35 |
249 |
530 |
660 |
15 |
631 |
792 |
600 |
40 |
Water cooling |
1.5 |
8.4 |
2 |
661 |
762 |
| 26 |
40 |
216 |
480 |
660 |
15 |
630 |
804 |
600 |
55 |
Air cooling |
1.4 |
11.6 |
0 |
603 |
770 |
| 27 |
36 |
254 |
530 |
660 |
15 |
644 |
795 |
600 |
20 |
Air cooling |
1.4 |
4.6 |
0 |
684 |
774 |
| 28 |
38 |
255 |
530 |
700 |
15 |
636 |
798 |
600 |
20 |
Water cooling |
1.5 |
5.3 |
0 |
738 |
801 |
| 29 |
42 |
273 |
480 |
660 |
15 |
611 |
781 |
600 |
30 |
Water cooling |
1.3 |
7.2 |
0 |
744 |
805 |
| 30 |
46 |
258 |
530 |
660 |
15 |
636 |
826 |
600 |
20 |
Water cooling |
1.5 |
5.9 |
0 |
759 |
819 |
| 31 |
34 |
210 |
530 |
660 |
15 |
608 |
760 |
600 |
25 |
Air cooling |
1.4 |
6.8 |
2 |
699 |
790 |
| 32 |
42 |
260 |
500 |
660 |
15 |
593 |
775 |
570 |
20 |
Water cooling |
1.5 |
7.3 |
0 |
648 |
736 |
Table 2B
| No. |
Al → Casting → Hot rolling → Tempering |
Average roundness (A) |
Retained γ (%) V |
Ultralow-temperature toughness |
Tensile properties |
| [O] (ppm) |
t1 (sec) |
t2 (sec) |
TL (°C) |
tL (min) |
Ac1 |
Ac3 |
T3 (°C) |
t3 (min) |
Cooling method after tempering |
Percent brittle fracture at -196 C (%) |
YS |
TS |
| 33 |
103 |
259 |
500 |
660 |
15 |
623 |
795 |
600 |
20 |
water cooling |
2.0 |
4.9 |
15 |
631 |
721 |
| 34 |
39 |
303 |
530 |
660 |
10 |
629 |
795 |
570 |
40 |
Air cooling |
1.8 |
3.0 |
12 |
635 |
722 |
| 35 |
36 |
310 |
530 |
660 |
15 |
626 |
796 |
570 |
20 |
Air cooling |
1.9 |
6.3 |
18 |
649 |
720 |
| 36 |
34 |
266 |
720 |
660 |
15 |
612 |
751 |
600 |
15 |
Water cooling |
1.9 |
8.2 |
17 |
671 |
803 |
| 37 |
40 |
268 |
600 |
590 |
15 |
611 |
765 |
600 |
20 |
Water cooling |
1.5 |
1.8 |
17 |
692 |
762 |
| 38 |
31 |
265 |
530 |
760 |
15 |
598 |
755 |
570 |
25 |
Air cooling |
1.4 |
1.8 |
20 |
731 |
780 |
| 39 |
42 |
244 |
660 |
660 |
5 |
620 |
778 |
600 |
25 |
Air cooling |
1.4 |
1.9 |
13 |
646 |
715 |
| 40 |
45 |
258 |
500 |
660 |
60 |
621 |
771 |
600 |
20 |
Air cooling |
1.5 |
12.3 |
0 |
545 |
672 |
| 41 |
36 |
266 |
500 |
660 |
15 |
607 |
774 |
500 |
25 |
Air cooling |
1.5 |
1.4 |
22 |
670 |
718 |
| 42 |
29 |
239 |
500 |
660 |
15 |
581 |
762 |
580 |
20 |
Air cooling |
1.3 |
1.8 |
18 |
732 |
776 |
| 43 |
41 |
262 |
500 |
660 |
15 |
622 |
791 |
600 |
65 |
Water cooling |
1.5 |
12.9 |
0 |
585 |
735 |
| 44 |
78 |
271 |
530 |
660 |
15 |
635 |
783 |
620 |
20 |
Water cooling |
1.8 |
1.6 |
22 |
633 |
692 |
| 45 |
42 |
240 |
450 |
660 |
15 |
604 |
787 |
600 |
25 |
Air cooling |
1.5 |
5.6 |
12 |
671 |
763 |
| 46 |
45 |
212 |
530 |
660 |
15 |
636 |
859 |
620 |
25 |
Air cooling |
2.0 |
1.4 |
28 |
635 |
678 |
| 47 |
43 |
238 |
530 |
660 |
15 |
610 |
762 |
600 |
40 |
Water cooling |
1.9 |
11.3 |
25 |
702 |
821 |
| 48 |
30 |
245 |
530 |
660 |
15 |
608 |
770 |
600 |
20 |
Water cooling |
1.4 |
8.2 |
23 |
672 |
795 |
| 49 |
47 |
197 |
530 |
660 |
15 |
645 |
785 |
620 |
20 |
Air cooling |
1.4 |
4.7 |
25 |
715 |
790 |
| 50 |
39 |
259 |
500 |
660 |
15 |
592 |
760 |
570 |
20 |
Water cooling |
1.5 |
10.0 |
28 |
710 |
804 |
| 51 |
38 |
270 |
600 |
700 |
15 |
621 |
821 |
600 |
20 |
Water cooling |
1.5 |
6.1 |
12 |
702 |
818 |
| 52 |
40 |
251 |
450 |
710 |
15 |
599 |
771 |
570 |
15 |
Air cooling |
1.6 |
4.2 |
13 |
733 |
789 |
| 53 |
42 |
263 |
530 |
660 |
15 |
633 |
848 |
600 |
35 |
Water cooling |
1.5 |
8.8 |
12 |
728 |
812 |
| 54 |
45 |
247 |
530 |
660 |
15 |
619 |
778 |
600 |
20 |
Water cooling |
1.5 |
7.6 |
13 |
712 |
800 |
| 55 |
34 |
259 |
530 |
660 |
15 |
613 |
767 |
610 |
5 |
Water cooling |
1.4 |
1.5 |
12 |
642 |
741 |
[0098] The following consideration can be made from Table 2.
[0099] Nos. 1 to 32 in Table 2A are examples satisfying all the requirements of the invention,
in each of which the resultant steel plate had good ultralow-temperature toughness
(in detail, the average of the percent brittle fracture in the C direction of 10%
or less) even if base metal had high strength.
[0100] In contrast, Nos. 33 to 41, 43, and 55 in Table 2B each dissatisfy at least one of
the preferred manufacturing conditions of the invention, each of which is therefore
a comparative example that did not satisfy a requirement of the invention, and failed
to have the desired properties.
[0101] Specifically, No. 33 is an example in which No. 33 steel in Table 1B was used, the
steel having a composition satisfying the requirements of the invention, but since
a large amount of dissolved oxygen [O] existed before adding Al, the average roundness
A of the inclusions was also large. As a result, the percent brittle fracture was
high, and the desired ultralow-temperature toughness was not obtained.
[0102] No. 34 is an example in which No. 34 steel in Table 1B was used, the steel having
a composition satisfying the requirements of the invention, but since the cooling
time (t1) from 1500 to 1450°C in casting was long, the value B was below the predetermined
range. As a result, the percent brittle fracture was high, and the desired ultralow-temperature
toughness was not obtained.
[0103] No. 35 is an example in which No. 35 steel in Table 1B was used, the steel containing
a large amount of P, and the cooling time (t1) from 1500 to 1450°C in casting was
long, and therefore the average roundness A of the inclusions was large. As a result,
the percent brittle fracture was high, and the desired ultralow-temperature toughness
was not obtained.
[0104] No. 36 is an example in which No. 36 steel in Table 1B was used, the steel containing
a large amount of C, and the cooling time (t2) from 1300 to 1200°C in casting was
long, and therefore the average roundness A of the inclusions was large. As a result,
the percent brittle fracture was high, and the desired ultralow-temperature toughness
was not obtained.
[0105] No. 37 is an example in which No. 37 steel in Table 1B was used, the steel having
a composition satisfying the requirements of the invention, but since the steel plate
was heated at a temperature below the two-phase region temperature (TL), the amount
of retained y was insufficient. As a result, the percent brittle fracture was high,
and the desired ultralow-temperature toughness was not obtained.
[0106] No. 38 is an example in which No. 38 steel in Table 1B was used, the steel containing
a large amount of Si, and the steel plate was heated at a temperature above the two-phase
region temperature (TL), and therefore the amount of retained y was insufficient.
As a result, the percent brittle fracture was high, and the desired ultralow-temperature
toughness was not obtained.
[0107] No. 39 is an example in which No. 39 steel in Table 1B was used, the steel having
a composition satisfying the requirements of the invention, but since the heating
and holding time (tL) at the two-phase region temperature (TL) was short, the amount
of retained y was insufficient. As a result, the percent brittle fracture was high,
and the desired ultralow-temperature toughness was not obtained.
[0108] No. 40 is an example in which No. 40 steel in Table 1B was used, the steel having
a composition satisfying the requirements of the invention, but since the heating
and holding time (tL) at the two-phase region temperature (TL) was long, the amount
of retained γ was too large. As a result, yield strength YS and tensile strength TS
were lowered, and the desired base metal strength was not obtained.
[0109] No. 41 is an example in which No. 41 steel in Table 1B was used, the steel having
a composition satisfying the requirements of the invention, but since tempering temperature
(T3) was low, the amount of retained γ was insufficient. As a result, the percent
brittle fracture was high, and the desired ultralow-temperature toughness was not
obtained.
[0110] No. 43 is an example in which No. 43 steel in Table 1B was used, the steel having
a composition satisfying the requirements of the invention, but since tempering time
(t3) was long, the amount of retained y was too large. As a result, yield strength
YS was lowered, and the desired base metal strength was not obtained.
[0111] No. 55 is an example in which No. 55 steel in Table 1B was used, the steel having
a composition satisfying the requirements of the invention, but since tempering time
(t3) was short, the amount of retained y was insufficient. As a result, the percent
brittle fracture was high, and the desired ultralow-temperature toughness was not
obtained.
[0112] Nos. 42 and 44 to 54 are each a comparative example in which the steel plate was
fabricated according to the method of the invention except that used steel did not
satisfy the requirements of steel composition.
[0113] In detail, No. 42 is an example in which No. 42 steel in Table 1B was used, the steel
containing a large amount of Mn, and therefore the amount of retained y was insufficient.
As a result, the percent brittle fracture was high, and the desired ultralow-temperature
toughness was not obtained.
[0114] No. 44 is an example in which No. 44 steel in Table 1B was used, the steel containing
a small amount of Mn, and therefore the amount of retained y was insufficient. As
a result, the percent brittle fracture was high, and the desired ultralow-temperature
toughness was not obtained.
[0115] No. 45 is an example in which No. 45 steel in Table 1B was used, the steel containing
a large amount of S. Hence, the percent brittle fracture was high, and the desired
ultralow-temperature toughness was not obtained.
[0116] - No. 46 is an example in which No. 46 steel in Table 1B was used, the steel containing
a small amount of C, a large amount of Al, and a small amount of Ni, and therefore
the average roundness A of the inclusions was large, and the amount of retained y
was insufficient. As a result, the percent brittle fracture was high, and the desired
ultralow-temperature toughness was not obtained. Furthermore, TS was low.
[0117] No. 47 is an example in which No. 47 steel in Table 1B was used, the steel containing
a small amount of A1 and a large amount of N, and therefore the average roundness
A of the inclusions was large. As a result, the percent brittle fracture was high,
and the desired ultralow-temperature toughness was not obtained.
[0118] No. 48 is an example in which No. 48 steel in Table 1B was used, the steel containing
a large amount of each of Cu and Ca as the optional components. As a result, the percent
brittle fracture was high, and the desired ultralow-temperature toughness was not
obtained.
[0119] No. 49 is an example in which No. 49 steel in Table 1B was used, the steel containing
a large amount of each of Cr and Zr as the optional components. As a result, the percent
brittle fracture was high, and the desired ultralow-temperature toughness was not
obtained.
[0120] No. 50 is an example in which No. 50 steel in Table 1B was used, the steel containing
a large amount of each of Nb and REM as the optional components. As a result, the
percent brittle fracture was high, and the desired ultralow-temperature toughness
was not obtained.
[0121] No. 51 is an example in which No. 51 steel in Table 1B was used, the steel containing
a large amount of Mo as the optional component, and therefore the percent brittle
fracture was high, and the desired ultralow-temperature toughness was not obtained.
[0122] In No. 52, No. 52 steel in Table 1B was used, the steel containing a large amount
of Ti as the optional component, and therefore the percent brittle fracture was high,
and the desired ultralow-temperature toughness was not obtained.
[0123] In No. 53, No. 53 steel in Table 1B was used, the steel containing a large amount
of V as the optional component, and therefore the percent brittle fracture was high,
and the desired ultralow-temperature toughness was not obtained.
[0124] In No. 54, No. 54 steel in Table 1B was used, the steel containing a large amount
of B as the optional component, and therefore the percent brittle fracture was high,
and the desired ultralow-temperature toughness was not obtained.
Example 2
[0125] In Example 2, part of steel plate (each being an example of the invention) used in
Example 1 were evaluated in percent brittle fracture at -233°C.
[0126] Specifically, for each number of steel plate in Table 3 (No. in Table 3 corresponds
to No. in each of Tables 1 and 2), three specimens were taken from the position of
t/4 at W/4, and were each subjected to a Charpy impact test at -233°C by a method
described below, and an average of the percent brittle fracture was determined. In
Example 2, a steel plate showing a percent brittle fracture of 50% or less was determined
to have good percent brittle fracture at -233°C.
[0128] Table 3 shows results of such determination.
Table 3
| No. |
Retained γ (%) |
Ultralow-temperature toughness |
| Percent brittle fracture at -196°C (%) |
Percent brittle fracture at -233°C (%) |
| 1 |
3.8 |
5 |
53 |
| 3 |
6.5 |
0 |
43 |
| 4 |
7.8 |
0 |
28 |
| 5 |
3.8 |
7 |
55 |
| 6 |
5.5 |
0 |
38 |
| 7 |
3.6 |
5 |
53 |
| 14 |
3.9 |
8 |
70 |
| 15 |
11.6 |
0 |
12 |
| 19 |
8.9 |
2 |
40 |
| 20 |
3.8 |
3 |
52 |
| 21 |
2.7 |
8 |
67 |
| 22 |
3.9 |
0 |
60 |
| 24 |
7.0 |
3 |
40 |
[0129] Each of Nos. 3, 4, 6, 15, 19, and 24 is an example in which the heating and holding
time (tL) at the two-phase region temperature was controlled to be 15 min or more
(see Table 2A), and at least 4.0% of retained-y phase was given. As a result, good
percent brittle fracture was shown not only at -196°C but also at a further low temperature,
-233°C, i.e., extremely good ultralow-temperature toughness was obtained.
Industrial Applicability
[0130] The thick steel plate of the invention is good in ultralow-temperature toughness,
and is particularly useful as steel for a storage tank, a transport ship, and the
like for liquefied natural gas (LNG).