[0001] The present invention relates to an apparatus and method for noise suppression during
driving of support piles, and relates particularly, but not exclusively, to an apparatus
for noise suppression during driving of support piles of an offshore wind turbine
into the seabed.
[0002] Installation of offshore wind turbines is typically carried out by gradually hammering
a large monopile (generally 5 meters to 7 meters in diameter) into the seabed until
it forms a solid support base or foundation on which to install a wind turbine generator.
The hammering or piling operation generates large amounts of emitted energy, generally
in the form of sound energy propagated into the local environment, which can cause
harm to marine animals.
[0003] Bubble curtains have been used in an attempt to alleviate this problem. These entail
the deploying one or more perforated hoses around the pile and/or the ship. Air under
pressure is then pumped through the hoses causing a large number of bubbles of air
to escape the perforations in the hose. In theory the bubbles then rise to the surface
forming a barrier of high impedance spheres (air bubbles) around the pile/ship which
scatter, reflect, and refract the pile noise, thus damping the pulse and reducing
the peak intensity. However, this arrangement suffers from the disadvantage of the
cost of another ship to lay the hose/deploy the system, breakdown of various equipment,
waiting for suitable weather, causing downtime and thus very high cost), since the
second ship operates to a generally lower weather limit than the piling ship, but
waiting for one of them to be operable means that both are idle. Also, currents and
waves break up the current and cause bubbles to drift and the curtain to break down,
bubbles tend to chaotically join together creating larger bubbles as they progress,
thus changing the impedance of curtain, and water depth varies effectiveness so that
when operating well, noise suppression is typically insufficient at approximately
10-12dB.
[0004] Cofferdams have also been used in an attempt to alleviate the problem. A cofferdam
comprises a cylinder taller than the water depth and at least 1m wider than the monopile
on a supporting frame. It is lowered to the seabed, generally penetrating a short
distance in the sea bed to form a seal, with its top above the waves. Water is then
pumped out from the cofferdam prior to a pile being inserted within it. Piling of
the monopile is then undertaken in 'dry' conditions with an air gap between the monopile
and the cofferdam, thereby generating noise in air, the noise being poorly transmitted
through the cofferdam into the surrounding water. However, this arrangement suffers
from the disadvantage that it is very difficult to achieve an effective seal on the
sea bed in most soil conditions and without this, the cofferdam does not work effectively.
Also, it is usually necessary to carry out sea bed levelling prior to installation.
Furthermore, the cofferdam is a heavy construction and occupies a significant element
of the useable area of an installation vessel, and its weight requires 2 extra heavy
lifts per monopile installation (with risks associated) and significantly slows down
the installation process, thereby increasing costs.
[0005] Hydro sound dampers (also known as bubble nets) have also been used. These consist
of a series of balloons located periodically on a net or other supporting structure
draped around the monopile and extending to the seafloor. Each bubble can be designed
to absorb a specific wavelength of noise. However, these installations suffer from
the disadvantage that installation of these systems generally requires the use of
another vessel to wrap the net around the monopiles in situ, which takes considerable
time, effort and cost. The nets can also be subject to motion caused by waves and
currents, thus limiting their effectiveness, and the system to unwrap and install
the nets is generally complex, which in a dynamic environment causes tangles and thus
expensive delays. It is believed that when operating well, inadequate noise suppression
of typically 12dB is achieved.
[0006] One further attempt to alleviate the problem consists of isolation casings, which
are generally a casing around the piling operation comprising one or more shells.
Between adjacent shells air or sound absorbing material can be inserted to create
a high impedance barrier to noise transmission. Additionally within the casing an
additional air bubble release systems (similar to the bubble curtain discussed above)
can be introduced to create further noise mitigation. However, this arrangement suffers
from the disadvantage that these systems are very heavy (sometimes heavier than the
monopole itself), particularly where multiple skins are involved. As a result, 2 additional
heavy lifts per installation are required, with attendant risks and costs. The systems
are also generally very expensive, and the additional time (and thus vessel cost)
required for their use is significant. Also, many installation vessels may not be
able to lift and/or manoeuvre these devices, and thus their operations severely restrict
vessel choice and thus increase costs. Furthermore, each monopile diameter will require
a different size casing.
[0007] In addition to the specific problems outlined above, generally none of these known
arrangements is capable of delivering the level of noise suppression required. They
are expensive to install, and slow down marine operations as their deployment lies
on critical path and thereby significantly increase operational cost.
[0008] Preferred embodiments of the present invention seek to overcome one or more of the
above disadvantages of the prior art.
[0009] According to the present invention, there is provided a noise suppression apparatus
for suppressing noise during driving of at least one support pile of an offshore structure
into the seabed, the noise suppression apparatus comprising at least one first vibration
damping member adapted to be mounted to at least one support pile of an offshore structure
and to at least partially attenuate transmission of vibrations generated in said support
pile, as a result of hammering of said support pile into the seabed, through water
adjacent said support pile.
[0010] By providing at least one first vibration damping member adapted to be mounted to
at least one support pile of an offshore structure and to at least partially attenuate
transmission of vibrations generated in the support pile, as a result of hammering
of the support pile into the seabed, through water adjacent the support pile, this
provides the advantage of providing a more cost effective system which is much easier
to install and handle, minimises delay in piling operations or handling, and does
not require power or air supply or an additional boat for deployment.
[0011] At least one said first vibration damping member may be adapted to at least partially
attenuate transmission of vibrations when in contact with a surface of at least one
said support pile.
[0012] At least one said first vibration damping member may include at least one respective
inflatable member.
[0013] At least one said first vibration damping member may be adapted to be brought into
contact with a surface of at least one said pile by means of inflation of at least
one said inflatable member.
[0014] The apparatus may further comprise constraining means for limiting expansion of at
least one said inflatable member.
[0015] This provides the advantage of enabling the apparatus to withstand higher inflation
pressures.
[0016] The constraining means may comprise at least one flexible member adapted to be brought
into engagement with a said support pile by means of inflation of at least one said
inflatable member.
[0017] The apparatus may further comprise fluid flow control means for controlling flow
of fluid into and/or out of the interior of said support pile.
[0018] This provides the advantage of enabling the amount of water in the interior of the
support pile to be controlled, thereby enabling the resonant frequencies damped by
the apparatus to be adjusted.
[0019] The fluid flow control means may comprise at least one valve.
[0020] At least one said first vibration damping member may be adapted to allow air to escape
therefrom.
[0021] This provides the advantage of enhancing the damping effect.
[0022] At least one said first vibration damping member may have at least one air outlet
for allowing adjustable quantities of air to escape therefrom.
[0023] At least one said first vibration damping member may be adapted to engage an external
surface of at least one said support pile.
[0024] At least one said first vibration damping member may be adapted to engage an internal
surface of at least one said support pile.
[0025] The apparatus may further comprise a plurality of said first vibration damping members
and at least one second vibration damping member adapted to be mounted to a pair of
said first vibration damping members.
[0026] This provides the advantage of enhancing the vibration damping effect.
[0027] At least one said second vibration damping member may comprise at least one sheet
of material.
[0028] At least one said second vibration damping member may comprise at least one pair
of sheets of material for receiving air therebetween.
[0029] Preferred embodiments of the invention will now be described, by way of example only
and not in any limitative sense, with reference to the accompanying drawings in which:-
Figure 1 is a schematic side cross sectional view of part of a support pile for an
offshore wind turbine having a noise suppression apparatus of a first embodiment of
the present invention mounted to an internal surface thereof;
Figure 2 is a side cross sectional view of the noise suppression apparatus of Figure
1;
Figure 3 is a side view of the noise suppression apparatus of Figure 1;
Figure 4 is a side view of a first embodiment of a vibration damping member of the
apparatus of Figures 2 and 3;
Figure 5 is a cross sectional view along the line A-A in Figure 4 in an uninflated
condition of the vibration damping member;
Figure 6 is a cross sectional view along the line A-A in Figure 4 in an inflated condition
of the vibration damping member;
Figure 7 is a plan view of the apparatus of Figure 2 in an uninflated condition thereof;
Figure 8 is a plan view of the apparatus of Figure 2 in an inflated condition therefore;
Figure 9 is a side view of a second embodiment of a vibration damping member of the
apparatus of Figure 2 in a first condition thereof;
Figure 10 is a side view of the vibration damping member of Figure 9 in a second condition
thereof;
Figure 11 is a schematic side cross sectional view of part of a support pile having
a noise suppression apparatus of a second embodiment of the present invention mounted
to an internal surface thereof;
Figure 12 is a plan view of the noise suppression apparatus of Figure 11; and
Figure 13 is a schematic side cross sectional view of part of a support pile having
a noise suppression apparatus of a third embodiment of the present invention mounted
to internal and external surfaces thereof.
[0030] Referring to Figures 1 to 8, a noise suppression apparatus 2 of a first embodiment
of the present invention is mounted to an internal surface 4 of a support pile 6 for
an offshore wind turbine (not shown) to attenuate transmission of vibrations, generated
as the pile 6 is driven into the seabed (not shown) through the water surrounding
the pile 6. The noise suppression apparatus 2 comprises a generally cylindrical body
8 containing a rigid framework 10 of square cross section and a plurality of horizontally
arranged first vibration damping members 12 arranged horizontally around the circumference
of the cylindrical body and vertically arranged first vibration damping members 14.
Each of the first vibration damping members 12, 14 is mounted to the external surface
of the cylindrical body 8 and has constraining means in the form of a rigid steel
housing 16 forming a gap 18, and a flexible member 20 of durable resilient material
located in the gap 18 and which can be urged into engagement with the internal surface
4 of the pile 6 by means of inflation of an inflatable member in the form of an inflatable
inner tube 22 arranged between the flexible member 20 and the rigid housing 16. This
enables the first vibration damping members 12, 14 to withstand higher inflation pressures
than would be the case if the inner tube 22 was not constrained. Such flexible member
20 may be comprised of material(s) which themselves have sound absorbing qualities.
Such inflatable inner tube 22 may be inflated with air, other gas, liquid or liquid
foam to further enhance its noise suppression qualities.
[0031] As shown in more detail in Figure 2, the first vibration damping members 12, 14 are
shown in various stages from the uninflated condition at the top of Figure 2 to the
fully inflated condition at the bottom of Figure 2. Wheels 24 are provided for engaging
the inner wall 4 of the pile 6 when the vibration damping members 12, 14 are in their
uninflated condition, and are prevented from coming into engagement with the inner
surface 4 of the pile 6 when the vibration damping members 12, 14 are in their fully
inflated condition.
[0032] A second embodiment of a first vibration damping member 26 is shown in Figures 9
and 10. Instead of being formed from a single piece of metal, as in the case of the
first vibration damping member 12, 14 of figure 4, the housing 28 of the vibration
damping member 26 in Figures 9 and 10 includes three metal body members 30 hinged
together so that differences in diameter of the cylindrical body 8 can be accommodated,
from the smaller diameter body 8 as shown in Figure 9 to the larger diameter body
8 as shown in Figure 10. A resilient rubber mount 32 is located between the metal
body members 30 and the outer surface of the cylindrical body 8 to accommodate differences
in curvature between the outer surface of the cylindrical body 8 and the adjacent
surfaces of the metal body members 30.
[0033] A noise suppression apparatus 102 of a second embodiment of the present invention
is shown in Figures 11 and 12, in which part common to the embodiment of Figures 1
to 10 are denoted by like reference numerals but increased by 100. The cylindrical
body 108 of the noise suppression apparatus 102 supports first vibration damping members
112 and is provided with a top plate 134 having a hole or valve 136 to allow controlled
flow of air and/or water through the monopile 6 as it is installed in the seabed.
In this way, the weight or buoyancy of the monopile 6 in water can be controlled,
as a result of which the pile dominant frequency can be adjusted to enable resonant
peaks to be avoided. It is also possible to provide two apparatus 102 as shown in
Figures 11 and 12, one at the top and one at the bottom of the monopile 6, to seal
both ends of the monopile 6 to enable it to be floated and towed to its desired location
prior to installation in the seabed.
[0034] Referring to Figure 13, a noise suppression apparatus 202 of a third embodiment of
the present invention, in which parts common to the embodiment of Figures 1 to 10
are denoted by like reference numerals but increased by 200, includes first noise
suppression members 212 which can be brought into engagement with the inner surface
4 of the pile 6 (four viscoelastic rings 4 are shown in Figure 3) and outer inflatable
viscoelastic rings 138 which can be brought into engagement with an outersurface 7
of the pile 6. The external viscoelastic rings 138 are connected together by second
noise suppression members in the form of pairs of sheets 140 of material having apertures
allowing air bubbles 142 to pass therethrough, and weights 144 are attached to the
lowermost external viscoelastic ring 138
[0035] In order to install the pile 6 to provide a support for an offshore wind turbine
generator (not shown), the pile 6 is supported by a crane (not shown) and maneuvered
by means of a manipulator arm (not shown) to its desired position over the seabed.
An anvil 146 is then located in position at the top of the pile 6 and the pile 6 is
hammered into the seabed by means of a suitable hammering apparatus (not shown). As
the pile 6 is hammered into the seabed, transmission of noise through the water is
suppressed by the noise suppression apparatus 202.
[0036] It will be appreciated by persons skilled in the art that the above embodiment has
been described by way of example only and not in any limitative sense, and that various
alterations and modifications are possible without departure from the scope of the
invention as defined by the appended claims.
1. A noise suppression apparatus for suppressing noise during driving of at least one
support pile of an offshore structure into the seabed, the noise suppression apparatus
comprising at least one first vibration damping member adapted to be mounted to at
least one support pile of an offshore structure and to at least partially attenuate
transmission of vibrations generated in said support pile, as a result of hammering
of said support pile into the seabed, through water adjacent said support pile.
2. An apparatus according to claim 1, wherein at least one said first vibration damping
member is adapted to at least partially attenuate transmission of vibrations when
in contact with a surface of at least one said support pile.
3. An apparatus according to claim 1 or 2, wherein at least one said first vibration
damping member includes at least one respective inflatable member.
4. An apparatus according to claim 3, wherein at least one said first vibration damping
member is adapted to be brought into contact with a surface of at least one said pile
by means of inflation of at least one said inflatable member.
5. An apparatus according to claim 3 or 4, further comprising constraining means for
limiting expansion of at least one said inflatable member.
6. An apparatus according to claim 5, wherein the constraining means comprises at least
one flexible member adapted to be brought into engagement with a said support pile
by means of inflation of at least one said inflatable member.
7. An apparatus according to any one of the preceding claims, further comprising fluid
flow control means for controlling flow of fluid into and/or out of the interior of
said support pile.
8. An apparatus according to claim 7, wherein the fluid flow control means comprises
at least one valve.
9. An apparatus according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein at least one said
first vibration damping member is adapted to allow air to escape therefrom.
10. An apparatus according to claim 9, wherein at least one said first vibration damping
member has at least one air outlet for allowing adjustable quantities of air to escape
therefrom.
11. An apparatus according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein at least one said
first vibration damping member is adapted to engage an external surface of at least
one said support pile.
12. An apparatus according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein at least one said
first vibration damping member is adapted to engage an internal surface of at least
one said support pile.
13. An apparatus according to any one of the preceding claims, further comprising a plurality
of said first vibration damping members and at least one second vibration damping
member adapted to be mounted to a pair of said first vibration damping members.
14. An apparatus according to claim 13, wherein at least one said second vibration damping
member comprises at least one sheet of material.
15. An apparatus according to claim 14, wherein at least one said second vibration damping
member comprises at least one pair of sheets of material for receiving air therebetween.