[0001] Anodized aluminum has low resistance to alkalis and to acids. In domains such as
automotive and building there is a pressing need for anodized articles the surface
of which, while preserving their characteristic appearance, can withstand contact
with strong alkaline solutions, and possibly also with strong acid solutions.
[0002] In the present application when speaking of aluminum, this also encompasses usual
aluminum alloys.
[0003] The automotive industry recently imposed for anodized aluminum parts used in cars,
tests resistance to alkalis that, in practice, cannot be passed by aluminum that has
been anodized, even when "sealed" conventionally. Anodized articles are known to exhibit
porous surfaces. These pores made the surface more easily attacked notably by alkaline
or acid solutions. It is usual to have these porous surfaces sealed to improve their
resistance.
[0004] Treatments to improve this resistance are notably the subject of standards, such
as those of the European Aluminum Anodisers Association, these are referred as "Qualanod"
standards. But products treated in accordance to these standards, mainly directed
to buildings material, prove not to pass the tests of the automotive industry. These
tests, that are not yet unified, present in common the same goal that is to resist
with success, after a first acid contact, a strong alkali solution the pH of which
is as high as 13.5.
[0006] Example of the content such a standard appears in the FIAT documentation. Articles
are subject to the test cycle including:
- Immersion for 10 minutes in an acid solution at pH 1 (0.1 molar solution of HCl)
- Rinsing with running water and drying with compressed air
- Standing in a stove for 1h ±5 minutes at 40°C±3°C
- Immersion for 10 minutes in alkaline solution at pH 13.5 (aqueous solution of 12.7
g/l of NaOH+4.64g/l Na3PO4)
- Rinsing with running water and drying with compressed air.
At the end of the test there must not be any aesthetic change, relative to material
that has not been exposed.
[0007] Several attempts are reported in prior art to meet the requirements of automotive
industry. They are all failing in one or more criteria notably concerning the appearance
of the products. This is the case where electrophoretic coating is used. This may
allow passing the resistance tests but the coating is visible, and the required aesthetic
quality is not fully satisfied. When using sol-gel including silanes, another way
trying to reach the proper resistance, the resulting polymer film is not colorless
and the transparency may be altered.
[0008] Taking into account the deficiencies of prior art there is still a need for improved
anodized aluminum products, that allow to pass the very specific requirements recalled
above. The present invention aims at solving this problem. If in the first place the
products for automotive industry are concerned, the invention also applies to any
type of anodized product including those intended for building or domestic appliances.
[0009] Surprisingly the inventors have shown that such a goal could be reached according
to the invention, through specific treatments of these anodized products, part of
these treatments pertaining to prior art. More precisely according to the invention,
treatment of anodized aluminum products is carried out as claimed in the first appending
claim.
[0010] The anodized aluminum product treated first is one obtained that presents no prior
defects, to that effect the anodization must follow the best known practices.
[0011] Usual anodization is carried out in electrolytic solution that includes an inorganic
acid. Among those acids, most common is sulfuric acid. Other acids are also of interest
notably those that are less susceptible to dissolve the anodic oxide film created.
The anodization conditions such as voltage, temperature are well known from prior
art that gives products free of any defects but need a precise control especially
when using sulfuric acid solution. For example to low temperature corresponds a slow
rate forming of the oxide layer, but if the temperature is too high the dissolution
rate is increased. The temperature is usually not above 24°C.
[0012] At the end of the anodization step the anodic solution is immediately removed and
the product washed to prevent further dissolution of the oxide film.
[0013] The usual thickness selected must be sufficient to allow for the necessary resistance,
chemical and mechanical. This is normally above 5
µm, and preferably above 10
µm. The thickness is preferably not above 50
µm to prevent possible defect formation such as cracks.
[0014] Anodization leads to an oxide layer the structure resulting in a porous system that
has poor resistance notably to acids or alkaline solutions. It is common to prevent
these corrosive chemicals to penetrate the porous structure by sealing the pores.
The usual sealing is made by hydration of the aluminum oxide that swells and obstructs
the pores. Hydration may be made by way of hot water or steam. ("hot sealing"). This
is done at temperature above 95°C. Another possibility called "cold sealing" is starting
with an impregnation step that includes contact with a first solution e.g. of nickel
fluoride used for its properties to form insoluble complexes with aluminium and plug
the pores, producing a good sealing. Other metallic salts notably of chromium may
substitute to those of nickel. In this cold impregnation the temperature is not above
30°C. The impregnation is followed by ageing in a hot water treatment. Impregnation
needs also careful control notably of nickel and fluoride respective concentrations.
[0015] Whatever the care taken to seal the pores of the oxide layer, the corrosion resistance
to strong acid and alkali solution is not enough to meet the levels required by the
automotive industry. Further treatments are necessary that are the subject of the
invention.
[0016] According to the invention a first post treatment is using a solution of silicates
in which the products are immersed under conditions that result in a further sealing
or coating with "silicates polymers". A second treatment is following that includes
using specific silanes solutions that adds another coating.
[0017] Treatment by silicates have been proposed in the prior art, and the products treated
supposed, at least, to present an increased resistance to corrosion without the need
for anything else. A treatment of this kind appears e.g. in
EP1873278 that contains restrictive conditions regarding the ratio SiO
2/Na
2O. But this treatment is not supposed to result in products that may resist solution
the pH of which is higher than 12.5. When having this sole additional treatment, even
if the products exhibit better resistance to high pH, they do not allow simultaneously
resistance to strong acid solution as needed to pass the tests stipulated by automotive
industry.
[0018] According to the invention this type of treatment using silicate, is still to be
improved. In sub-claims the invention provides for conditions to carry out this step,
that makes both more efficient control and prevent possible defects.
[0019] First before starting contact with a silicate solution the treated products must
be free of any powder deposit at the surface of the material that could alter the
final aesthetic appearance.
[0020] The products are thus immersed in the silicates solution. The silicate solution used
is preferably one of alkaline metal, sodium, potassium or lithium or mixture thereof.
These, notably sodium and potassium, are readily available in commerce and extensively
used in many industrial sectors, notably as thickening agents. The solutions are containing
an amount of silicate that depends on the stability. When increasing the concentration
there is a limit above which the solution turns a gel. The concentration that allows
remaining stable for long period of time are also depending on the nature of the silicate
including the molar ratio SiO
2/M
2O (M standing for Na, K or Li). The higher this ratio, the lower the possible amount
of silicate when trying to prevent the gel formation.
[0021] According to the invention having a relatively high SiO
2/M
2O ratio is preferable as it leads to product that present a better resistance. The
ratio is at least of 2.5, and preferably at least of 3.
[0022] The silicate solution is preferably at pH above 5 and preferably above 6.
[0023] To make the coating fast enough the concentration of the solution is as high as the
solubility permits. This concentration for sodium silicate is preferably higher than
lg/l and preferably from 10 to 30g/l.
[0024] The coating also depends on temperature of the solution. Faster deposition of silicates
is obtained with the highest temperature. For easiness of control over the process,
the temperature is preferably higher than 40°C and does not exceed 95°C. The best
temperature range according to the invention is from 60 to 80°C.
[0025] The processing time depends on the previous parameters and is most usually between
5 and 50 minutes.
[0026] Between each step of the process the articles are thoroughly washed and dried so
as not to disturb the composition of the following baths. The next step according
to the invention is a treatment with a solution of one or more silanes or silanols
that result from hydrolysis of these silanes.
[0027] The silanes used according to the invention are alkoxy-silanes that may be hydrolyzed
to give in silanols that may react with hydroxyl groups leading to covalent bonds
according to the known general mechanism:
Al-OH+R-SiOH → Al-O-Si-R +H
2O
[0028] The presence of aluminum oxides, partly hydrated by the sealing process, partly complexed
by reaction with the silicate solution, makes the surface very amenable to reaction
with silanols.
[0029] The silanols are seldom available as such for reason that, to be stable, they need
to be in greatly diluted solutions. For this reason it is most often necessary to
have the silanols prepared when needed.
[0030] The silanes used according to the invention are preferably of the general formula:
R'(CH
2)nSi(OR)
3
with
n at most equal to 4
where -OR is one of:
-OCH
3, -OC
2H
5, -OCOCH
3
and R' is a radical from: vinyl, epoxy, methacrylate, primary amine, di-amine, mercapto.
Among those silanes the most preferred ones of the formulas:

The silanes that are used may also be bis-silanes of the general formula:
(RO)
3-Si(CH
2)nR' (CH
2)n-Si(OR)
3
with R, R' and
n, having the same significance as indicated above. Among the bis-silanes preferred
ones are:
(C
2H
5O)
3Si(CH
2)Si(OC
2H
5)
3
(C
2H
5O)
3Si(CH
2)
3-S
4-(CH
2)
3Si(OC
2H
5)
3
(C
2H
5O)
3Si(CH
2)
3-NH-(CH
2)
3Si(OC
2H
5)
3.
[0031] As said above to allow reaction with hydroxyl groups of the substrate the silanes
are first to be hydrolysed in silanols following typical reactions:
R'-Si(OR)
3 + H
2O ↔ R'-Si(OR)
2OH + ROH
R'-Si(OR)
2OH + H
2O ↔ R'-Si(OR)(OH)
2 +ROH
R'-Si(OR)(OH)
2 + H
2O ↔ R'-Si(OH)
3 + ROH
These reactions are both ways and thus the equilibrium must be shifted on the right
side. Reaction with hydroxyl groups of the substrate is in competition with selfcondensation
of the silanols producing oligomer siloxanols. To prevent excess of this possible
reaction the silanes solutions are necessarily diluted.
[0032] Preferably the concentration in silanes is less than 8% by weight of the solution,
and most preferably less than 5% by weight. At these concentrations the hydrolysis
tends to get to completion. To limit the processing time the concentration is preferably
no less than 0.1% by weight.
[0033] Most of organo-silanes that are useful have a limited solubility as such in water.
Using a water alcohol mixture enhance the solubility to the necessary concentration.
The presence of alcohol may also regulate the hydrolysis of the silanes, and possibly
makes the final drying easier. Depending on the silanes the content of alcohol may
be up to 15% by weight of the mixture.
[0034] The hydrolysis of silanes needs time and depends on various factors notably the type
of organo-silanes, the medium of the reaction and the pH. Hydrolysis in water proceeds
more quickly than in mixture of water and organic solvent such as ethanol, and tends
to completion. Playing with pH may catalyze the hydrolysis and enhance its speed.
[0035] The hydrolysis is faster with the smallest alkoxy group of the silanes, e.g. hydrolysis
of methoxy-silanes is 6 to 10 times faster than ethoxy-silanes of the same structure.
[0036] The treatment may be started when the concentration of silanols is sufficient, this
corresponding to the solution becoming clear showing a true solution where before
it was mostly a suspension.
[0037] Application on the surface may be e.g. by dipping or by spraying. The necessary contact
time depends notably on the temperature. For example, at a temperature of 15 to 35°C,
this contact may be from 0.5 to 5 minutes.
[0038] Silanols reacts with hydroxyl groups linked to the metal, but may also give rise
to condensation reactions of the silanols themselves to forms silanes films. The former
are increasing the adhesion to the substrate when the silanols condensates are promoting
formation of a film the thickness of which depends on the concentration of the silanes
solutions. Typical thickness may be up to 400nm. The structure of the film is possibly
cross-linked depending on the specific silanes used (or mixture of silanes). The cross-linking
is normally high with bis-silanes and better protection is obtained.
[0039] When the necessary contact is over, the aluminum article is dried at temperature
that may be from ambient to as high as 120°C, preferably from 40 to 120°C. The above
mentioned reactions are going n during the drying step.
[0040] Anodized aluminum and aluminum alloys according to the invention exhibit specific
resistance to the corrosive action that are the subject of the tests specified by
the automotive industry. They notably have a weight loss at most of 10mg/dm
2 surface and preferably at most 5 mg/dm
2, and most preferably at most 1mg/dm
2 when submitted to acid followed by alkaline test according to the specifications
of the corrosion test 9.57448 from Fiat group. This weight loss is notably obtained
for corrosion tests in which the acid is at a pH 1 and the alkali solution is at pH
13.5.
[0041] The product according to the invention, their surface having been polished so that,
before being subject to these corrosion tests mentioned above, they exhibit a high
gloss measured with a "glossmeter". Their loss of gloss after these tests is less
than 10% and preferably less than 5%
[0042] The invention is further disclosed in details in the following examples.
[0043] Samples of aluminum profile are prepared prior to anodic oxidation by cleaning the
pieces and polishing up to a surface roughness
Ra of 0.6
µ.
[0044] Chemical pickling or electrochemical treatment of surface may be preferred to confer
another appearance, notably etched appearance to other samples.
[0045] Before anodic treatment, the pieces are thoroughly washed with running water.
[0046] The anodization bath is containing 200 ±10g/l sulfuric acid. This solution is maintained
at about 15°C. The current density is about 1.8 A/dm
2.
[0047] The anodization is carried out till the oxide layer is 20
µ. At the indicated current density this needs about 45 minutes. The anodized article
is thoroughly washed in deionized water to remove any adhering solution.
[0048] A sealing process is then made to close the pore of the oxide layer. The sealing
is of the "cold sealing" type including an impregnation with nickel ions.
[0049] The example is made with Ni2+ at 1.2g/l and fluoride ions at 0.250g/l.
[0050] The temperature selected is 28°C and treatment is maintained for 20 minutes.
[0051] To prevent possible deposit of powdery material that alters the surface appearance,
the solution is continuously filtered to remove any precipitate.
[0052] These sealing are the usual treatments proposed by the standard "
QUALANOD" published by European Anodisers Association, standard followed for pieces that are intended to be used in less corrosive conditions
such as the ones prevailing for buildings. These are not sufficient to pass successfully
tests as such required by automotive industry whatever the sealing ratio of the pores.
[0053] When the sealing is completed and the samples properly washed and dried, they are
ready to the silicate treatment.
[0054] According to this treatment, the anodized samples are immersed in an aqueous solution
of sodium silicate. The solution is prepared by diluting to 11, 10ml of a sodium silicate
solution containing by weight:
Na2O 9%
SiO2 29%
The molar ratio SiO
2/Na
2O is thus 3.2.
[0056] Treatment of the samples is by immersion at a temperature of 70°C. The immersion
time is 10 minutes.
[0057] The various parameters are selected so that no precipitation occurs during the treatment.
In addition continuous filtration of the solution is carried out.
[0058] The samples are washed in tap water then in demineralized water and dried.
[0059] Careful examination of the product is done to control that no defects such as spots
or powdery appearance of the surface may be detected.
[0060] The conditions recited in table 1 for anodization and sealing and silicate treatment
are other possible examples substitutes to the ones indicated above.
Table 1.
It includes various conditions relating to the steps: anodization, sealing and treatment
with silicates. |
|
Preliminary treatment |
Anodizing parameters |
Coloring |
Sealing |
Additional treatment |
Application |
A |
Chemical polishing |
H2SO4200g/l A1 dissolved 7g/l 20±1°C 1.5 A/dm2 45 minutes |
Organic dying "Black MLW"1 10g/l 45°C 10 minutes |
Impregnation Sealing Ni2+ 1.2 g/l F- 0.250g/l 28°C 20 minutes |
Sodium silicate sol. (waterglass) 10ml/l 70 °C 20min |
Automotive |
B |
Chemical polishing |
H2SO4200g/l A1 dissolved 7g/l 20±1°C 1.5 A/dm2 45 minutes |
None |
Medium Temp. sealing. Commercial specialty2 |
Sodium silicate sol. (waterglass) 10ml/l 70 °C 20min |
Automotive |
C |
|
H2SO4200g/l A1 dissolved 7g/l 20±1°C 1.5 A/dm2 45 minutes |
None |
Hot. sealing. Commercial specialty3 |
Sodium silicate sol. (waterglass) 10ml/l 70 °C 20min |
Architectural |
D |
|
H2SO4200g/l A1 dissolved 7g/l 20±1°C 1.5 A/dm2 45 minutes |
Electrocolouring SnSO4 16g/l H2SO4 20g/l Additives4 10g/l 10 minutes |
Hot. sealing. Commercial specialty3 |
Sodium silicate sol. (waterglass) 10ml/l 70 °C 20min |
Architectural |
E |
Chemical polishing |
H2SO4 150g/l A1 dissolved 7g/l 15±1 °C 2.5 A/dm2 20 minutes |
Organic "Black MLW" 10g/l 45°C 20 minutes |
Ni2+ 1.2 g/l F 0.250g/l 28°C 20 minutes |
Sodium silicate sol. (waterglass) 10ml/l 70 °C 20min |
Automotive |
1 - Black MLW from Clariant.
2 - Medium Temperature sealing chemical specialties available on the market are based
on a solution of about 10 g/nickel acetate and 0.2-05 g/l of a surfactant acting as
a "bloom preventer" (i.e. it avoid the formation of powder on the anodic layer surface).
Temperature 85-90 °C, dipping time 1 minute / micron (i.e. 20 min)
3 - Hot sealing chemical specialties available on the market contains essentially
a mixture of surfactant used at a concentration of 1-2 ml/l acting as a "bloom preventer"
(i.e. it avoid the formation of powder on the anodic layer surface). Temperature >
95 °C, dipping time 2 minute / micron (i.e. 40 min)
4 - Additives known to stabilize the tin ions solution, hampering its oxidation and/or
precipitation. |
[0061] To go on with the samples having been anodized, sealed and treated with silicates
solutions, these are subject to a silane treatment. In this case the selected silanes
composition is the one sold by the company CHEMETAL under the name "OXILAN MM 0706".
The solution contains 3% by weight of this composition of silanes in water with addition
of ethanol (5% by weight).
[0062] The samples are immersed in the solution at room temperature during 2 minutes. After
this the samples are removed from the tank and without washing directly dried in a
hot air flow at 60°C for 20 minutes.
[0063] These samples are then tested according to the specification recalled above. As a
result it is found that the weight loss measured at each stage of the preparation
is:
- anodized samples prior to other treatment 692mg/dm2
- after sealing 97,2mg/dm2
- after silicate treatment 11,5mg:dm2
- after silane treatment 0,7mg/m2
[0064] The product made according to the invention was analyzed at each stage of the preparation.
This allows to confirm that the product in itself may be the subject of identification
without having recourse to the process for making it. A possible investigation includes
an X-ray photoelectron spectrometry (XPS). This method allows for identification of
the elements entering in the surface layer of the product. The method permit analysis
of very thin layers (around 20-30Å) preventing a possible confusion with elements
from under-layers. Nevertheless when the layers considered exhibit average thicknesses
that are less than these figures, and/or the roughness of the surface is noticeable,
part of the measurements may indicate a limited amount of elements from under-layers.
[0065] The results are included in the following table.
|
C |
N |
O |
Al |
S |
Si |
Ni |
F |
1 Anodized |
52,5 |
5,55 |
33,97 |
6,44 |
1,3 |
|
|
|
2 Sealing |
49,7 |
0,57 |
32,85 |
6,83 |
0,98 |
|
5,41 |
3,5 |
3 Silicate |
59,5 |
0,45 |
28,26 |
1,44 |
0,83 |
6,13 |
1,99 |
0,27 |
4 Silane |
79,9 |
2,04 |
13,98 |
|
|
3,77 |
|
|
[0066] It is significant that each analysis is distinct according to the stage of the preparation.
This confirm that the method definitely permits analysis of each top layer whatever
the layers located underneath. This is notably the case of the silane top layer (4)
including nitrogen (the starting silane is an amino-silane). It also contains an amount
of carbon that clearly exceeds the amount of the previous layers, as the silane contains
organic parts. The anodized part (1) includes carbon and nitrogen corresponding to
the black coating part. Sealing in (2) appears notably through the presence of Ni
and F. These elements are also appearing but definitely at a lower concentration in
the product at the silicate treatment step (3) making clear that the layer of silicate
is a thin one and possibly intervening to further sealing the pores. This layer also
indicates that Al content is less than in sub-layers (2).
[0067] In the following table 2 various other sets of conditions are proposed to the silicate
treatment described above. These are only given as examples, lots of others are possibly
used according to the invention, notably through various mixtures of silanes.
Table 2
n° |
|
Compound preparation |
Solution operating parameters |
|
1 |
A |
bis[triethoxysilyl]ethane (BTSE) added directly and mixed |
BTSE 30g/l, ethanol 50ml/l 24°C 4 minutes |
|
2 |
A |
γ-aminopropyl-trimethoxysilane (AMPTS) added directly and mixed |
AMPTS 30g/l ethanol 70ml/l 24°C 4 minutes |
|
3 |
D |
bis[triethoxysilylpropyl]-tetrasulphane(bis-sulphosilane) added directly and mixed |
...bis-sulphosilane 30g/l ethanol 70ml/l 24°C 4 minutes |
|
4 |
E |
Composition 4: 3 parts γ-aminotriethoxysilane (in water) 1 part vinyl-triethoxysilane
24 °C mixing 1 hour |
Composition 4 50g/l ethanol 50ml/l 24°C 4 minutes |
|
5 |
B |
Composition 5 : 5 parts "Dynasylan HS 2776" 1 part "Dynasylan D-VTEO" 24 °C mixing
1 hour |
Composition 5 50g/l |
from Degussa-Evonik |
6 |
C |
"Dynasylan HS 2627" |
"Dynasyl HS 2627" 30g/l ethanol 50ml/l 24°C 4 minutes |
from Degussa-Evonik |
7 |
A |
"Oxsilan MM 0706" |
"Oxsilan MM 0706" ethanol 50ml/l 24°C 4 minutes |
from Chemetall |
[0068] Silanes of 4-7 above are sold pre-hydrolyzed and thus directly water soluble.
1. Chemical treatment applied to products made of aluminum or aluminum alloys, that have
been first submitted to anodic oxidation and pore sealing according to known prior
technics, comprising two additional steps:
- a treatment with an alkali-silicate solution;
- a treatment with silanes solutions.
2. Treatment according to claim 1 wherein the thickness of the anodic oxide layer is
not less 5µ.
3. Treatment according to claim 1 wherein the treatment in alkaline solution is carried
out in a stable aqueous solution containing one or more silicates of sodium, potassium
or lithium, or mixtures thereof.
4. Treatment according to claim 3 wherein the molar ratio of SiO2/M2O is such that the solution is at a pH above 6, preferably above 8, M standing for
either Na, K or Li.
5. Treatment according to claim 4 wherein the alkali-silicate is sodium silicate, the
molar ratio SiO2/Na2O being at least 3.
6. Treatment according to one of the preceding claims the solution containing from 1.0
g/l, up to the solubility limit, preferably from 10 to 30g/l, of alkali silicate.
7. Treatment according to one of the preceding claims wherein the alkali-silicate treatment
is carried out at a temperature from 40 to 95 °C, preferably from 60 to 80°C.
8. Treatment according to one of the preceding claims wherein the product is maintained
in the alkali silicate solution from 5 to 50 minutes.
9. Treatment according to any of the preceding claims wherein the product is treated
in an aqueous or aqueous-alcoholic solution of a silane or a mixture of silanes.
10. Treatment according to claim 9 wherein the silanes are mono-silanes of the general
formula:
R'(CH2)nSi(OR)3
with n at most equal to 4
where -OR is one of:
-OCH3, -OC2H5, -OCOCH3
and R' is a radical from: vinyl, epoxy, methacrylate, primary amine, di-amine, mercapto.
11. Treatment according to claim 10 wherein the silanes are one or several of:
12. Treatment according to claim 9 wherein silanes are bis-silanes of the general formula:
(RO)3-Si(CH2)nR'(CH2)n Si(OR)3
with R, R' and n, having the same significance as in claim 10.
13. Treatment according to claim 12 wherein the bis-silanes are one of:
(C2H5O)3Si(CH2)Si(OC2H5)3
(C2H5O)3Si(CH2)3-S4-(CH2)3Si(OC2H5)3
(C2H5O)3Si(CH2)3-NH-(CH2)3Si(OC2H5)3.
14. Treatment according to one of claims 9 to 13 wherein the solution contains from 0.1
to 5 weight % of silanes.
15. Treatment according to one of claims 9 to 14 wherein the solution contains from 0.1
to 15 weight % of an aliphatic alcohol.
16. Treatment according to one of the claims 9 to 15 wherein the contact time with the
solution is from 0.5 an 5mn, and the temperature from 15 to 35°C.
17. Treatment according to one of the claims 9 to 16 wherein the product is dried at a
temperature from ambient to 120°C.
18. Anodized aluminium or aluminium alloy product, the surface of which having been sealed
and further treated in silicates solutions, and silanes solutions, exhibiting a weight
loss of at most 10mg/dm2 surface, and preferably at most 5mg/dm2 when submitted to acid followed by alkaline test according to the specifications
of the corrosion test.
19. Product according to claim 18 in which the acid is at a pH 1 and the alkali solution
is at pH 13.5.
20. Product according to claim 18 or 19 the surface of it is polished prior to the full
treatment, including anodic oxidation, such that its loss of gloss when subjected
to the corrosion test of claim 19 or 20 is less than 10% and preferably less than
5%.