Technical field
[0001] The present invention is related to a manufacturing method of carbon nanofibers employing
a catalyst in which a predetermined amount of an active species including cobalt as
a chief component is carried on a carrier composed of a magnesium-containing oxide
having a predetermined specific surface area and carbon monoxide is used as a carbon
source, and to carbon nanofibers manufactured by the method.
Background
[0002] As a filler for providing electric conductivity to a resin or as an electric conductivity-providing
material in an electrode of various kind of batteries, especially lithium-ion battery,
acetylene black and carbon nanofibers (hereafter, referred to as CNFs), which are
electrically conductive carbon materials, as well as a mixture thereof are used. In
particular, using or adding CNFs leads to a preferable result that a high electric
conductivity is achieved with a relatively low content of the electrically conductive
carbon material, and thus, hopes are concentrated thereon. Here, a CNF generally has
a fibrous form having an external diameter of 5 to 100 nm and an aspect ratio, which
is a ratio of fiber length to external diameter, of 10 or more.
[0003] Conventionally, in manufacturing CNFs, an electrode discharging method, a catalytic
vapor-phase growth method, a laser method and the like are employed, among which the
catalytic vapor-phase growth method is recognized as most suitable for an industrial
manufacturing method. According to the catalytic vapor-phase growth method, transition
metal particles are used as a catalyst, which are brought into contact with a raw
material gas of a carbon source such as acetylene and benzene at an elevated temperature
of generally 900 °C or more, to grow CNFs from the catalyst particles. Particularly,
a method to manufacture CNFs, using as a catalyst a transition metal component such
as cobalt, from gas containing chiefly carbon monoxide as a raw material attracts
attention as a method to produce CNFs of high purity and high quality at a relatively
low temperature (Patent Documents 1 to 5).
Prior art documents
Patent documents
[0004]
Patent Document 1: Japanese Unexamined Patent Application Publication No. 2004-299986
Patent Document 2: Japanese Unexamined Patent Application Publication No. 2004-300631
Patent Document 3: Japanese Unexamined Patent Application Publication No. 2006-152490
Patent Document 4: Re-publication of PCT International Publication No. WO2009/110570
Patent Document 5: Re-publication of PCT International Publication No. WO2012/053334
Summary
Problems to be solved by the invention
[0005] However, conventional techniques disclosed in the above documents have room for improvement
in the following points.
[0006] In the technique of any document, yield and activity of CNFs are not sufficient and
higher activity is required as a catalyst. Further, in a case where obtained CNFs
are used as an electrically conductive material or an electric conductivity aid, CNFs
having higher electric conductivity (lower volume resistivity) are required.
[0007] Moreover, in a case where CNFs are used as a filler for providing electric conductivity
to a matrix such as resin or in a case where CNSs are used as an electric conductivity-providing
agent in a lithium-ion battery, dispersibility of CNFs is important, however, the
fine carbon fibers of conventional CNFs or the like get highly entangled forming a
secondary structure and thus are poor in dispersibility.
[0008] In view of the above-mentioned problems and the actual circumstances, an object of
the present invention is to provide a manufacturing method by which CNFs that are
excellent in crystallinity, electric conductivity and dispersibility are produced
at high activity. Further, providing CNFs having excellent crystallinity, electric
conductivity and dispersibility is another object.
Means to solve the problem
[0009] According to the present invention, a manufacturing method of carbon nanofibers described
below is provided.
- (1) A manufacturing method of carbon nanofibers, wherein an active species including
cobalt as a chief component is employed as a catalyst and carbon monoxide is used
as a carbon source, and manufacturing is performed under the conditions that said
catalyst has 3 to 150 mass % of said active species carried on a carrier composed
of a magnesium-containing oxide having a specific surface area of 0.01 to 5 m2/g, a reaction temperature is between 670 and 780 °C, partial pressure of carbon monoxide
is between 0.04 and 0.98 MPa, and a flow rate of carbon monoxide gas is 2 NL/g of
active species · min or more.
- (2) A manufacturing method of item (1) wherein, preferably, a carrying rate of said
catalyst is between 3 and 90 mass %, and partial pressure of hydrogen is between 1
to 100 % relative to the partial pressure of carbon monoxide.
According to the present invention, carbon nanofibers described below is provided.
- (3) Carbon nanofibers produced by a manufacturing method of item (1) or (2), wherein
volume resistivity measured under a load of 9.8 MPa is 0.030 Ω·cm or less and D/G
is between 0.5 and 1.3, and dispersed particles of 1 μm or less in toluene is 40 volume
% or more or a median diameter D50 is 5 μm or less.
- (4) Carbon nanofibers produced by a manufacturing method of item (2), wherein volume
resistivity measured under a load of 9.8 MPa is 0.030 Ω·cm or less and D/G is between
0.5 and 1.3, and dispersed particles of 1 μm or less in toluene is 70 volume % or
more or a median diameter D50 is 0.7 μm or less.
- (5) Carbon nanofibers wherein volume resistivity measured under a load of 9.8 MPa
is 0.030 Ω·m or less and D/G is between 0.5 and 1.3, and dispersed particles of 1
μm or less in toluene is 40 volume % or more or a median diameter D50 is 5 μm or less.
- (6) Carbon nanofibers of item 5 wherein, preferably, said dispersed particles of 1
μm or less in toluene is 70 volume % or more or said median diameter D50 is 0.7 μm
or less.
Advantageous effect of the invention
[0010] According to the present invention, in manufacturing CNFs with carbon monoxide being
used as a carbon source, by using a catalyst having, as an active species, metal including
cobalt as a chief component, which catalyst is carried on a carrier composed of a
magnesium-containing oxide having a specific surface area of 0.01 to 5 m
2/g, CNFs can be manufactured at higher activity, and a manufacturing method can be
provided for CNFs that have high crystallinity, excellent electric conductivity, and,
in addition, high dispersibility. Further, according to the present invention, CNFs
can be provided that have high crystallinity, excellent electric conductivity, and,
in addition, high dispersibility.
Brief description of drawings
[0011]
Fig. 1 is a TEM photograph of a CNF synthesized in Example 10.
Fig. 2 is a SEM photograph of CNFs synthesized in Example 3.
Fig. 3 is a diagram showing a particle size distribution of CNFs synthesized in Example
3.
Fig. 4 is a SEM photograph of CNFs synthesized in Comparative Example 7.
Fig. 5 is a diagram showing a particle size distribution of CNFs synthesized in Comparative
Example 7.
Detailed description of preferred embodiments
<Explanation of terms>
[0012] Definition of CNFs in the present description is a concept of CNFs having an average
external diameter of 5 to 100 nm and an aspect ratio showing a ratio of fiber length
to external diameter of 10 or more, and encompassing also multi-walled carbon nanotubes
(MWCNTs). CNFs in the present embodiment are not particularly limited but preferably
have multi-walled carbon nanotubes as a chief component, and are more preferably multi-walled
carbon nanotubes.
[0013] Note that single-walled carbon nanotubes (SWCNTs) are not included in the definition
of CNFs of the present description. Although single-walled carbon nanotubes have a
characteristic property of showing high electric conductivity, they are accompanied
by practical problems such that isomers exist due to chirality and they have bundle
structures, and thus, they are not in conformity with the object of the present application.
Note that a TEM photograph of a CNF synthesized in Example 10 is shown in Fig. 1 as
an example of a CNF of the present embodiment. From Fig. 1, it is known that a CNF
synthesized in Example 10 is a multi-walled carbon nanotube.
[0014] Synthetic activity in the present description means mass of CNF obtained per unit
mass of active species per unit time. Further, catalytic activity in the present description
means mass of CNF obtained per unit mass of catalyst per unit time. The active species
noted here is metal including cobalt as a chief component.
[0015] Further, a carrier is an oxide for carrying said active species.
[0016] In the present description, the phrase of "between A and B" and "A to B" means a
range including the values of both ends. For example, "between A and B" should be
understood as "greater than or equal to A and smaller than or equal to B".
[0017] Hereafter embodiments of the present invention will be described in detail.
[0018] A manufacturing method of carbon nanofibers in the present embodiment is a method
for manufacturing CNFs in which an active species including cobalt as a chief component
is employed as a catalyst, and carbon monoxide is used as a carbon source, and manufacturing
is performed under the conditions that said catalyst comprises 3 to 150 mass % of
said active species carried on a carrier composed of a magnesium-containing oxide
having a specific surface area of 0.01 to 5 m
2/g, a reaction temperature is 670 to 780 °C, partial pressure of carbon monoxide is
between 0.04 and 0.98 MPa, and a flow rate of carbon monoxide is 2 NL/g of active
species· min or more.
<Catalyst>
[0019] The manufacturing method of carbon nanofibers in the present embodiment employs a
catalyst in which an active species including cobalt as a chief component is carried
on a magnesium-containing oxide. Cobalt can be included not only as metal cobalt but
also in the form of a compound such as oxide, hydroxide, hydrous oxide, nitrate, acetate,
oxalate and carbonate.
[0020] In the active species, an element of groups 4 to 12 may be included as a component
other than cobalt. Examples of these elements include iron group such as iron and
nickel as well as manganese and molybdenum. However, thought not particularly limited,
at least 60 mole %, preferably 80 mole % or more, most preferably 90 mole % or more
is the cobalt component in the components of group 4 to 12 elements included as the
active species of the catalyst. As the components of the active species other than
the group 4 to 12 elements, a component of groups 1 to 3 or group 14 may be included.
Hereafter, an active species having cobalt as the chief component is referred simply
to as a cobalt active species.
<Carrier>
[0021] As the carrier on which the active species are carried is used a magnesium-containing
oxide having a specific surface area of 0.01 to 5 m
2/g. Magnesium-containing oxide includes, for example, magnesium oxide, a spinel-type
oxide and a perovskite-type oxide that contain magnesium oxide, or the like. Among
these compounds, magnesium oxide is the most preferable as the carrier.
[0022] A specific surface area of the magnesium-containing oxide is preferably 0.01 to 4
m
2/g and more preferably 0.01 to 3 m
2/g. If the specific surface area is less than 0.01 m
2/g, crystallinity and electric conductivity of CNFs obtained are sometimes decreased.
If the specific surface area is greater than 5 m
2/g, dispersibility of CNFs obtained is sometimes decreased. An oxide of metal other
than magnesium selected from groups 1 to 3 and group 14 may be contained in the carrier.
Taking the carrier as 100 mass %, a content of magnesium-containing oxide in the carrier
is preferably at least 50 mass %, more preferably 90 mass % or more, and most preferably
98 mass % or more. When the content of magnesium-containing oxide is 50 mass % or
more, decrease of synthetic activity can be suppressed more.
[0023] Carrying rate of the cobalt active species on the carrier is 3 to 150 mass % and
preferably 3 to 90 mass %. If the carrying rate is less than 3 mass %, crystallinity
of CNFs obtained is sometimes decreased causing electric conductivity to be low. If
the carrying rate is more than 150 mass %, particle size of cobalt particles is sometimes
increased lowering synthetic activity significantly. With the carrying rate being
90 mass % or less, CNFs having very high dispersibility can be manufactured at higher
activity.
[0024] Note that carrying rate is calculated based on the following equation.

[0025] When cobalt active species is carried on the carrier, the method of carrying is not
particularly limited. For example, it is possible to immerse a carrier in a non-aqueous
solution (e.g., ethanol solution) or an aqueous solution in which a salt of cobalt
has been dissolved and dispersion mixing is performed thoroughly, and then the carrier
is dried and heated in air at a high temperature (300 to 600 °C) to make a cobalt
active species carried on the carrier. Further, it may also be sufficient that a carrier
is immersed in a non-aqueous solution (e.g., ethanol solution) or an aqueous solution
in which a salt of cobalt has been dissolved, dispersion mixing is performed thoroughly,
and then water is simply removed to dry the carrier.
<Method and conditions for manufacturing CNFs>
· Carbon source
[0026] The manufacturing method of CNFs in the present embodiment is a method for manufacturing
carbon nanofibers in which carbon monoxide is used as a carbon source. Here, carbon
monoxide used as a raw material for a carbon source may be mixed gas with carbon dioxide
and may contain inert gas such as nitrogen. Note that in a case where carbon monoxide
gas used as the raw material is mixed gas with carbon dioxide, though not particularly
limited, at least 80 mole %, preferably 90 mole % or more, and most preferably 100
mole % component is carbon monoxide.
· Raw material gas
[0027] In the manufacturing method of CNFs of the present embodiment, it is preferable to
use carbon monoxide in the presence of hydrogen.
That is, in the manufacturing method of CNFs of the present embodiment, the raw material
gas contains carbon monoxide, and the raw material gas preferably contains hydrogen
as well as carbon monoxide. Further, the raw material gas may contain inert gas such
as nitrogen, and it may contain other substances. Partial pressure of carbon monoxide
is 0.04 to 0.98 MPa. Partial pressure of carbon monoxide is preferably 0.05 to 0.3
MPa and more preferably 0.05 to 0.11 MPa.
[0028] If partial pressure of carbon monoxide is less than 0.04 MPa, synthetic activity
is sometimes decreased or crystallinity and electric conductivity of obtained CNFs
are sometimes decreased. Further, if partial pressure of carbon monoxide is more than
0.98 MPa, dispersibility of obtained CNFs is sometimes decreased or deactivation of
catalyst sometimes becomes remarkable and thus synthetic activity is decreased.
[0029] Note that when the raw material gas contains only carbon monoxide, partial pressure
of carbon monoxide noted above represents total pressure of the raw material gas.
[0030] Partial pressure of hydrogen is preferably 1 to 100 % relative to partial pressure
of carbon monoxide, and more preferably 10 to 100 %. If partial pressure of hydrogen
relative to partial pressure of carbon monoxide is more than 100 %, synthetic activity
is sometimes decreased or crystallinity and electric conductivity of obtained CNFs
are sometimes decreased. In the case that partial pressure of hydrogen is 1% or less,
deactivation of catalyst sometimes occurs promptly, resulting in lowered synthetic
activity. Also, dispersibility of CNFs is sometimes lowered.
[0031] Note that partial pressure of hydrogen relative to partial pressure of carbon monoxide
can be calculated based on the following equation.

[0032] For example, in the case, as shown in Table 1, that the raw material composition
is CO/H
2/N
2=85/15/0, partial pressure of hydrogen relative to partial pressure of carbon monoxide
is calculated as follows:

[0033] In the manufacturing method of CNFs of the present embodiment, total gas pressure
of the raw material gas is arbitrary but preferably 0.98 MPa or less. If total gas
pressure is more than 0.98 MPa, it is probable that costs for facilities against high
pressure and utilities become large in manufacturing. Further, if total gas pressure
is significantly lower than 0.1 MPa (atmospheric pressure), for example, less than
0.08 MPa, it is sometimes difficult to seal reactors of high temperature against entrance
of atmosphere (oxygen).
[0034] Further in the manufacturing method of CNFs of the present embodiment, a flow rate
of carbon monoxide gas is 2 NL / g of active species · min or more. By setting the
flow rate of carbon monoxide gas within this range, CNFs can be manufactured at high
synthetic activity. Here, high synthetic activity specifically means 10 g of CNF /
g of active species · h (time) or more. Though no upper limit is specified for the
flow rate of carbon monoxide gas, if it is more than 200 NL / g of active species
· min, the amount of flow is so large that utility costs for residual heat become
large, which is undesirable. Further, synthetic activity is sometimes decreased.
[0035] Note that "NL" represents an amount L (liter) of gas reduced into normal conditions
(0 °C, 1 atm), and "NL / g of active species · min" represents an amount of gas flow
in 1 minute in the presence of a unit of active species (per 1 g of active species).
[0036] In the manufacturing method of CNFs of the present embodiment, a reaction temperature
is between 670 and 780 °C, more preferably between 700 and 750 °C. If the reaction
temperature is lower than 670 °C, crystallinity, electric conductivity and dispersibility
of CNFs are sometimes decreased. Further, if the reaction temperature is higher than
780 °C, synthetic activity is sometimes decreased.
[0037] In the manufacturing method of CNFs of the present embodiment, known manufacturing
methods and known manufacturing apparatuses can be used. For example, a fixed-bed
reactor or a fluidized-bed reactor and a batch-type or batch-wise reactor or a continuous
reactor can be used.
[0038] It is preferable that the active species and the carrier are removed from the CNFs
manufactured by the manufacturing method of CNFs of the present embodiment in order
to increase purity. Removal of the active species and the carrier can be performed
by the method described in Japanese Unexamined Patent Application Publication No.
2006-69850 or the like, where CNFs are dispersed in acid such as hydrochloric acid, nitric acid
and sulfuric acid, and subsequently recovered by means of filtration, centrifugation
and the like.
<CNF>
[0039] By manufacturing CNFs in the presence of the catalyst and under the manufacturing
conditions of the present embodiment, CNFs of high crystallinity can be obtained.
Specifically, CNFs can be obtained whose D/G value obtained through Raman spectrometry
measurement of CNFs is 0.5 or more and 1.3 or less. Here, the D/G value can be obtained
from a ratio of a total area derived from a D-band peak to a total area derived from
a G-band peak in Raman spectrometry measurement of CNF powder. The smaller the D/G
value is, the higher crystallinity of CNFs is, and thus, the higher electric conductivity
of CNFs is.
[0040] By manufacturing CNFs in the presence of the catalyst and under the manufacturing
conditions of the present embodiment, CNFs of high electric conductivity, in other
words, low volume resistivity, can be obtained. Specifically, CNFs having volume resistivity
of 0.030 Ω·cm or less can be obtained. That is, CNFs obtained by the manufacturing
method of the present embodiment have a characteristic that a D/G value obtained through
Raman spectrometry measurement is 0.5 or more and 1.3 or less and volume resistivity
is 0.030 Ω·cm or less.
[0041] By manufacturing CNFs in the presence of the catalyst and under the manufacturing
conditions of the present embodiment, CNFs with good dispersibility can be obtained
for which an existence ratio of dispersed particles of 1μm or less in toluene, without
any dispersing process, is 40 volume % or more. Further, in the CNFs of the present
embodiment, electric conductivity network is increased due to improvement of dispersibility,
so that when used as an electric conductivity-providing material such as an electrically
conductive filler, the CNFs are able to improve electric conductivity. Further, it
is preferable that a median diameter (D50) in particle size distribution of the CNFs
of the present embodiment is 5.0 μm or less.
[0042] Here, a dispersing process means a dispersing or pulverizing process performed mechanically,
for example, by a mechanical homogenizer, ball mill or emulsifying disperser. Further,
high-power ultrasonic irradiation by an ultrasonic homogenizer, an ultrasonic disperser
or the like also falls in this category.
[0043] However, in the present description, a suspending or homogenizing process applied
to a liquid to be measured for 10 minutes or less by a commercially available bath-type
ultrasonic washing apparatus whose ultrasonic output is 100 W or less does not fall
in the category of the dispersing process mentioned above. That is, in examples of
the present application, irradiation of ultrasonic wave is performed for 5 minutes
using a commercially available bath-type ultrasonic washing apparatus as pretreatment
for measurement of dispersibility by a light scattering method, however, this process
is not included in the dispersing process mentioned above.
[0044] Further, in the present description, a suspending or homogenizing process performed
by a magnetic stirrer in such a degree that a rotation rate is 500 rpm or less and
duration is 60 minutes or less does not fall in the category of the dispersing process
mentioned above. That is, in examples of the present application, a suspending or
homogenizing process is performed by a magnetic stirrer at a rotation rate of 300
rpm for 30 minutes as a removing process of magnesium oxide and an active species
in CNFs synthesized at catalytic activity less than 3 g of CNF / g of catalyst · h,
however, this process is not included in the dispersing process mentioned above.
[0045] Further, an ultrasonic process performed by an accessary apparatus of a measuring
apparatus, for example, at 100 W for 5 minutes in measurement concerning to dispersibility,
i.e., measurement of a ratio and a median diameter of dispersed particles of 1 μm
or less in the present description, that is, a homogenizing and pre-dispersing process
necessary for the measurement (hereafter, pre-measurement process) is not included
in the dispersing process mentioned above. CNFs of the present embodiment, even when
the same pre-measurement process is applied, have higher dispersibility compared to
conventional CNFs and can satisfy the criterion on dispersibility of the present application.
[0046] Further, the present inventors studied intensively in view of higher dispersibility
of CNFs to find that, in the manufacturing method of CNF of the present embodiment,
when a synthesis condition is satisfied that a carrying rate of cobalt active species
on a carrier is preferable 3 to 90 mass % and partial pressure of hydrogen gas is
within a range of 1 to 100 % relative to partial pressure of carbon monoxide gas,
CNFs having excellent dispersibility can be obtained for which an existence ratio
of dispersed particles of 1 μm or less in toluene is 70 volume % or more in a state
where no dispersing process is applied. Further, in this case, a median diameter (D50)
in particle size distribution of CNFs obtained is 0.7μm or less.
<CNFs of the embodiment in another view of the present invention>
[0047] In another view of the present invention, the CNFs of the present embodiment has
characteristics that a D/G value obtained through Raman spectrometry measurement is
0.5 or more and 1.3 or less, volume resistivity is 0.030 Ω·cm or less, and in a state
where no dispersing process is performed, an existence ratio of dispersed particles
of 1 μm or less in particle size distribution obtained in toluene is 40 volume % or
more, and a median diameter (D50) in particle size distribution of CNFs is 5.0 μm
or less. Further, the existence ratio of dispersed particles of 1 μm or less in particle
size distribution obtained in toluene is preferably 70 volume % or more. Further,
the median diameter (D50) in particle size distribution of CNFs is preferably 0.7
μm or less. Further, specific surface area of CNFs is, though not particularly limited,
preferably 50 to 300 m
2/g and more preferably 70 to 200 m
2/g.
[0048] If a D/G value obtained through Raman spectrometry measurement is less than 0.5,
it is difficult to manufacture CNFs at high activity, and if the value is more than
1.3, crystallinity of CNFs is poor.
[0049] If a median diameter (D50) in particle size distribution of CNFs is more than 5.0
μm, dispersibility of CNFs can be said to be poor.
Examples
[0050] Hereafter, the present invention will be described based on examples, however, the
invention is not limited to these examples.
<Cobalt - magnesium oxide carried catalyst>
(Example 1 of Catalyst Preparation)
[0051] 0.62 g of cobalt nitrate hexahydrate (3N5, product of Kanto Chemical Co., Inc.) was
weighed out and dissolved in 30 g of a mixed solvent of distilled water and ethanol
at a mass ratio of 2 : 1. To the aqueous solution of cobalt nitrate 2.5 g of magnesium
oxide (DENMAG (registered trade mark) KMAOH-F, product of Tateho Chemical Industries)
with specific surface area of 0.61 m
2/g was added and stirred for 1 hour in a state of being kept at 50 °C in a water bath.
After stirring water was evaporated by an evaporator. A solid material obtained was
dried at 60 °C for 24 hours, and subsequently a sintering process was performed at
400 °C for 5 hours. After the sintering process the solid material obtained was pulverized
in an agate mortar and a cobalt - magnesium oxide carried catalyst carrying 5 mass
% of cobalt metal was obtained.
(Example 2 of Catalyst Preparation)
[0052] By a procedure similar to Example 1 of Catalyst Preparation except that the amount
of cobalt nitrate hexahydrate was changed to 2.47 g, a cobalt - magnesium oxide carried
catalyst with a cobalt carrying rate of 20 mass % was prepared.
(Example 3 of Catalyst Preparation)
[0053] By a procedure similar to Example 1 of Catalyst Preparation except that the amount
of cobalt nitrate hexahydrate was changed to 6.17 g, a cobalt - magnesium oxide carried
catalyst with a cobalt carrying rate of 50 mass % was prepared.
(Example 4 of Catalyst Preparation)
[0054] By a procedure similar to Example 1 of Catalyst Preparation except that the amount
of cobalt nitrate hexahydrate was changed to 4.74 g, that the solvent was changed
to 15 g of a mixed solvent of distilled water and ethanol at a mass ratio of 2:1 and
that the amount of magnesium oxide was changed to 1.2 g, a cobalt - magnesium oxide
carried catalyst with a cobalt carrying rate of 80 mass % was prepared.
(Example 5 of Catalyst Preparation)
[0055] By a procedure similar to Example 1 of Catalyst Preparation except that the amount
of cobalt nitrate hexahydrate was changed to 12.35 g, a cobalt - magnesium oxide carried
catalyst with a cobalt carrying rate of 100 mass % was prepared.
(Example 6 of Catalyst Preparation)
[0056] By a procedure similar to Example 1 of Catalyst Preparation except that the amount
of cobalt nitrate hexahydrate was changed to 18.52 g, a cobalt - magnesium oxide carried
catalyst with a cobalt carrying rate of 150 mass % was prepared.
(Example 7 of Catalyst Preparation)
[0057] By a procedure similar to Example 1 of Catalyst Preparation except that the amount
of cobalt nitrate hexahydrate was changed to 2.47 g and that magnesium oxide was changed
to 2.5 g of one (DENMAG (registered trade mark) KMAOH-H, product ofTateho Chemical
Industries) with specific surface area of 0.05 m
2/g, a cobalt - magnesium oxide carried catalyst with a cobalt carrying rate of 20
mass % was prepared.
(Example 8 of Catalyst Preparation)
[0058] By a procedure similar to Example 1 of Catalyst Preparation except that the amount
of cobalt nitrate hexahydrate was changed to 2.47 g and that magnesium oxide was changed
to 2.5 g of one (DENMAG (registered trade mark) SSP#3, product ofTateho Chemical Industries)
with specific surface area of 0.11 m
2/g, a cobalt - magnesium oxide carried catalyst with a cobalt carrying rate of 20
mass % was prepared.
(Example 9 of Catalyst Preparation)
[0059] By a procedure similar to Example 1 of Catalyst Preparation except that the amount
of cobalt nitrate hexahydrate was changed to 2.47 g, that magnesium oxide was changed
to 2.5 g of magnesium oxide (SMO-5, product of Sakai Chemical Industry Co., Ltd) with
specific surface area of 0.39 m
2/g and that the solvent was changed to 30 g of a mixed solvent of distilled water
and ethanol at a mass ratio of 5:1, a cobalt - magnesium oxide carried catalyst with
a cobalt carrying rate of 20 mass % was prepared.
(Example 10 of Catalyst Preparation)
[0060] By a procedure similar to Example 1 of Catalyst Preparation except that the amount
of cobalt nitrate hexahydrate was changed to 2.47 g and that magnesium oxide was changed
to 2.5 g of one (SMO-1, product of Sakai Chemical Industry Co., Ltd) with specific
surface area of 2.03 m
2/g, a cobalt - magnesium oxide carried catalyst with a cobalt carrying rate of 20
mass % was prepared.
(Example 11 of Catalyst Preparation)
[0061] By a procedure similar to Example 1 of Catalyst Preparation except that the amount
of cobalt nitrate hexahydrate was changed to 6.17 g and that magnesium oxide was changed
to 2.5 g of one (SMO-0.1, product of Sakai Chemical Industry Co., Ltd) with specific
surface area of 9.38 m
2/g, a cobalt - magnesium oxide carried catalyst with a cobalt carrying rate of 50
mass % was prepared.
<Cobalt - zinc oxide carried catalyst>
(Example 12 of Catalyst Preparation)
[0062] By a procedure similar to Example 1 of Catalyst Preparation except that the amount
of cobalt nitrate hexahydrate was changed to 6.17 g, that magnesium oxide was changed
to 2.5 g of zinc oxide (LPZINC-5, product of Sakai Chemical Industry Co., Ltd) with
specific surface area of 0.24 m
2/g and that the solvent was changed to 30 g of distilled water, a cobalt - zinc oxide
carried catalyst with a cobalt carrying rate of 50 mass % was prepared.
<Cobalt - aluminum oxide carried catalyst>
(Example 13 of Catalyst Preparation)
[0063] By a procedure similar to Example 1 of Catalyst Preparation except that the amount
of cobalt nitrate hexahydrate was changed to 6.17 g, that magnesium oxide was changed
to 2.5 g of aluminum oxide (Alumina DAW70, product of Denki Kagaku Kogyo Kabushiki
Kaisha) with specific surface area of 0.18 m
2/g and that the solvent was changed to 30 g of distilled water, a cobalt - aluminum
oxide carried catalyst with a cobalt carrying rate of 50 mass % was prepared.
<Iron - magnesium oxide carried catalyst>
(Example 14 of Catalyst Preparation)
[0064] By a procedure similar to Example 1 of Catalyst Preparation except that cobalt nitrate
hexahydrate was changed to 9.0 g of iron nitrate nonahydrate (product of Kanto Chemical
Co., Inc., special grade reagent), an iron - magnesium oxide carried catalyst with
an iron carrying rate of 50 mass % was prepared.
<Cobalt - magnesium oxide coprecipitated catalyst>
(Example 15 of Catalyst Preparation)
[0065] As a catalyst other than a carried catalyst, a coprecipitated catalyst composed of
cobalt oxide and magnesium oxide was prepared in the following procedure. Pursuant
to Japanese Patent No.
5003023, a catalyst was prepared in the following manner. To 25 mL of ion-exchanged water
was added 5.75 g (0.02mole) of cobalt nitrate [Co(NO
3)
2·6H
2O, molecular weight 291.03] and 5.10 g (0.02 mole) of magnesium nitrate [Mg(NO
3)
2·6H
2O, molecular weight 256.41] to prepare raw material solution (1). Further, to 55 mL
of ion-exchanged water was added 11 g (0.139 mole) of powdered ammonium bicarbonate
[(NH
4)HCO
3, molecular weight 79.06] to prepare raw material solution (2). Next, raw material
solution (1) was mixed with raw material solution (2) at a reaction temperature of
40 °C and then stirred for 4 hours. Precipitates formed were filtered, washed and
dried. Then the precipitates were sintered and pulverized in a mortar, and 2.48 g
of catalyst was obtained.
<Cobalt oxide - magnesium oxide mixture catalyst>
(Example 16 of Catalyst Preparation)
[0066] A mixture catalyst was prepared by mixing in a mortar 5 mg of cobalt nanoparticles
(cobalt nano powder APS 5-15nm, product of Alfa Aesar) and 100 mg of magnesium oxide
(SMO-5, product of Sakai Chemical Industry Co., Ltd, specific surface area 0.35 m
2/g).
<Removing process of carrier from synthesized CNFs>
[0067] Synthesized CNFs contain magnesium oxide used as a carrier and an active species.
Note that in a case where catalytic activity is less than 3 g of CNF / g of catalyst
· h, amounts of magnesium oxide and an active species in CNFs obtained by synthesis
are large and sometimes exert influence on electric conductivity and dispersibility.
Therefore, a removing process of magnesium oxide and an active species was performed
on CNFs having catalytic activity of less than 3 g of CNF / g of catalyst · h.
[0068] First, 300 mg of synthesized CNFs was placed in 150 mL of 1 mol/L hydrochloric acid,
and a suspending or homogenizing process was performed using a magnetic stirrer at
a rotation rate of 300 rpm for 30 minutes. Then toluene and the CNF-containing hydrochloric
acid was placed in a separatory funnel to separate CNFs into toluene, and CNF-containing
toluene was washed with distilled water three times.
[0069] After the removing process of magnesium oxide and an active species, volume resistivity,
specific surface area and an existence ratio of particles having a particle diameter
of 1 μm or less were measured on the obtained CNFs.
<Measurement of specific surface area>
[0070] Specific surface area of CNF powder was measured by a BET one point method according
to JIS K6217-2 using Macsorb HM model-1201 manufactured by Mountech Co., Ltd.
<Measurement of volume resistivity>
[0071] Volume resistivity of CNF powder was measured by a four-point probe method using
Loresta GP manufactured by Mitsubishi Chemical Analytech Co.,Ltd., under the conditions
of 23 °C, atmosphere of relative humidity 50 %, and load of 9.8 MPa. Correcting measurement
was performed using a material whose synthetic activity was 10g of CNF / g of active
species · h or more. 100 mg of CNFs was used in the measurement.
<Raman spectrometry measurement>
[0072] Raman spectrometry measurement of CNF powder was performed using a microscopic laser
Raman spectroscopic analyzer (Niolet Almega-XR type, manufactured by Thermo Fisher
Scientific Inc., laser 532 nm). After separating waveforms of D-band (D1: peak position
1330cm
-1, D3: 1500cm
-1, D4: 1150cm
-1) and G-band (G+: 1600cm
-1, G-: 1570cm
-1), a ratio of a total of areas derived from D-band peaks to a total of areas derived
from G-band peaks (D/G value) was obtained. The smaller the D/G value is, the higher
the crystallinity of the CNFs is. Note that if a D/G value is smaller than 0.5, it
is difficult to manufacture CNFs at high activity.
(Reference)
[0073]
D 1: deriving from point defects within graphite crystal structure and defects at
end point of crystal
D3: deriving from amorphous carbon
D4: deriving from polyene and ionic impurity
G+: crystalline peak of graphite: longitudinal optical mode
G-: crystalline peak of graphite: transverse optical mode
<Ratio and median diameter of dispersed particles of 1 μm or less>
[0074] A toluene solution of 0.1 mass % of CNFs was prepared, and ultrasonication was performed
for 5 minutes using a commercially available ultrasonic bath (US Cleaner US-2A, manufactured
by AS ONE Corporation, ultrasonic output 80 W) to suspend or homogenize.
[0075] For measurement of a ratio and a median diameter of dispersed particles, a particle
size analyzer (LS 13 320 universal liquid module, manufactured by Beckman Coulter,
Inc.) was used. The optical model was set to the refractivity of toluene, filled with
toluene, and offset measurement, optical axis alignment and background measurement
were performed under the condition of a pump speed of 50 %, and subsequently, a prepared
toluene solution was added to the particle size analyzer such that a relative concentration,
which is indicative of a percentage of light diffused out of the beam by the particles,
is 8 to 12 %, or PID is 40 to 55 %, then, ultrasonic irradiation was performed at
100 W for 2 minutes by an accessary apparatus of the particle size analyzer (pre-measurement
process), and circulation was performed for 30 minutes to remove air bubbles, and
thereafter, measurement of particle size distribution was performed. A graph of volume
% to particle size (particle diameter) was prepared, and an existence ratio and a
median diameter D50 of particles of 1μm or less were obtained.
[0076] Measurement was performed as follows: for one test specimen of CNFs, three samples
for measurement were collected from different locations, and three measurements of
particle size distribution mentioned above were performed for each sample, then, an
average value was calculated of seven values, excluding the maximum and minimum values,
among the nine values for each of the existence ratio and the median diameter D50
of dispersed particles of 1 μm or less.
<Synthesis of CNFs>
(Example 1)
[0077] Carbon monoxide as the raw material was purchased from Suzuki Shokan Co., Ltd. G1
grade (high quality, 99.95 %) was used.
[0078] In a reaction tube made of quartz a catalyst holder was disposed in which a cobalt
- magnesium oxide catalyst obtained in Example 1 of Catalyst Preparation with a carrying
rate of 5 % was loaded such that a content of the active species was 5 mg, and nitrogen
gas was flown sufficiently through the tube to achieve nitrogen substitution. Further,
reducing gas containing 80 % of nitrogen and 20 % of hydrogen was heated under atmospheric
pressure (101 kPa) to a reaction temperature shown in Table 1, and the reaction temperature
was kept for 30 minutes to perform reduction of the catalyst. Immediately thereafter,
raw material gas was passed through the catalyst layer, under full pressure of the
raw material gas of 101 kPa, with a composition of the raw material gas and a flow
rate of carbon monoxide gas shown in Table 1 to perform reaction for 1 hour. Then
the raw material gas was changed to nitrogen gas for immediate cooling. Synthetic
activity was calculated from mass of the CNFs obtained, mass of the active species
used and the reaction time. Further, catalytic activity was calculated from mass of
the CNFs obtained, an amount of the catalyst used and the reaction time. Then, Raman
spectrometry measurement was performed and a D/G value was obtained, and further,
volume resistivity, specific surface area, and a ratio and a median diameter of the
dispersed particles were measured. The results are shown in Table 1. Note that as
a result of synthesis, the catalytic activity was less than 3 g of CNF / g of catalyst
· h, so that the removing process of carrier was performed, and subsequently, the
measurement of volume resistivity, specific surface area, a ratio and a median diameter
of the dispersed particles was performed.

(Example 2)
[0079] By a procedure similar to Example 1 except that a catalyst prepared in Example 2
of Catalyst Preparation with a carrying rate of 20 mass % was loaded such that a content
of the active species was 5 mg, CNFs were synthesized, synthetic activity and catalytic
activity were calculated similarly to Example 1, and a D/G value, volume resistivity,
specific surface area, a ratio and a median diameter of the dispersed particles were
measured. The results are shown in Table 1. Note that as a result of synthesis, the
catalytic activity was 3 g of CNF / g of catalyst · h or more, so that the removing
process of carrier was not performed.
(Example 3)
[0080] By a procedure similar to Example 1 except that a catalyst prepared in Example 3
of Catalyst Preparation with a carrying rate of 50 mass % was loaded such that a content
of the active species was 5 mg, CNFs were synthesized, synthetic activity and catalytic
activity were calculated similarly to Example 1, and a D/G value, volume resistivity,
specific surface area, a ratio and a median diameter of the dispersed particles were
measured. The results are shown in Table 1. Note that as a result of synthesis, the
catalytic activity was 3 g of CNF / g of catalyst · h or more, so that the removing
process of carrier was not performed.
(Example 4)
[0081] By a procedure similar to Example 1 except that a catalyst prepared in Example 4
of Catalyst Preparation with a carrying rate of 80 mass % was loaded such that a content
of the active species was 5 mg, CNFs were synthesized, synthetic activity and catalytic
activity were calculated similarly to Example 1, and a D/G value, volume resistivity,
specific surface area, a ratio and a median diameter of the dispersed particles were
measured. The results are shown in Table 1. Note that as a result of synthesis, the
catalytic activity was 3 g of CNF / g of catalyst · h or more, so that the removing
process of carrier was not performed.
(Example 5)
[0082] By a procedure similar to Example 1 except that a catalyst prepared in Example 10
of Catalyst Preparation with a carrying rate of 20 mass % was loaded such that a content
of the active species was 5 mg, CNFs were synthesized, synthetic activity and catalytic
activity were calculated similarly to Example 1, and a D/G value, volume resistivity,
specific surface area, a ratio and a median diameter of the dispersed particles were
measured. The results are shown in Table 1. Note that as a result of synthesis, the
catalytic activity was 3 g of CNF / g of catalyst · h or more, so that the removing
process of carrier was not performed.
(Example 6)
[0083] By a procedure similar to Example 1 except that a catalyst prepared in Example 9
of Catalyst Preparation with a carrying rate of 20 mass % was loaded such that a content
of the active species was 5 mg, CNFs were synthesized, synthetic activity and catalytic
activity were calculated similarly to Example 1, and a D/G value, volume resistivity,
specific surface area, a ratio and a median diameter of the dispersed particles were
measured. The results are shown in Table 1. Note that as a result of synthesis, the
catalytic activity was 3 g of CNF / g of catalyst · h or more, so that the removing
process of carrier was not performed.
(Example 7)
[0084] By a procedure similar to Example 1 except that a catalyst prepared in Example 8
of Catalyst Preparation with a carrying rate of 20 mass % was loaded such that a content
of the active species was 5 mg, CNFs were synthesized, synthetic activity and catalytic
activity were calculated similarly to Example 1, and a D/G value, volume resistivity,
specific surface area, a ratio and a median diameter of the dispersed particles were
measured. The results are shown in Table 1. Note that as a result of synthesis, the
catalytic activity was 3 g of CNF / g of catalyst · h or more, so that the removing
process of carrier was not performed.
(Example 8)
[0085] By a procedure similar to Example 1 except that a catalyst prepared in Example 7
of Catalyst Preparation with a carrying rate of 20 mass % was loaded such that a content
of the active species was 5 mg, CNFs were synthesized, synthetic activity and catalytic
activity were calculated similarly to Example 1, and a D/G value, volume resistivity,
specific surface area, a ratio and a median diameter of the dispersed particles were
measured. The results are shown in Table 1. Note that as a result of synthesis, the
catalytic activity was 3 g of CNF / g of catalyst · h or more, so that the removing
process of carrier was not performed.
(Example 9)
[0086] By a procedure similar to Example 1 except that a catalyst prepared in Example 3
of Catalyst Preparation with a carrying rate of 50 mass % was loaded such that a content
of the active species was 10 mg and that a flow rate of carbon monoxide gas was set
at 26 NL / g of active species · min, CNFs were synthesized, synthetic activity and
catalytic activity were calculated similarly to Example 1, and a D/G value, volume
resistivity, specific surface area, a ratio and a median diameter of the dispersed
particles were measured. The results are shown in Table 1. Note that as a result of
synthesis, the catalytic activity was 3 g of CNF / g of catalyst · h or more, so that
the removing process of carrier was not performed.
(Example 10)
[0087] By a procedure similar to Example 1 except that a catalyst prepared in Example 3
of Catalyst Preparation with a carrying rate of 50 mass % was loaded such that a content
of the active species was 20 mg, that reducing gas with a composition of 67 % of nitrogen
and 33 % of hydrogen was used and that a flow rate of carbon monoxide gas was set
at 14 NL / g of active species · min, CNFs were synthesized, synthetic activity and
catalytic activity were calculated similarly to Example 1, and a D/G value, volume
resistivity, specific surface area, a ratio and a median diameter of the dispersed
particles were measured. The results are shown in Table 1. Note that as a result of
synthesis, the catalytic activity was 3 g of CNF / g of catalyst · h or more, so that
the removing process of carrier was not performed.
(Example 11)
[0088] By a procedure similar to Example 1 except that a catalyst prepared in Example 3
of Catalyst Preparation with a carrying rate of 50 mass % was loaded such that a content
of the active species was 20 mg, that reducing gas with a composition of 67 % of nitrogen
and 33 % of hydrogen was used and that a flow rate of carbon monoxide gas was set
at 7 NL / g of active species · min, CNFs were synthesized, synthetic activity and
catalytic activity were calculated similarly to Example 1, and a D/G value, volume
resistivity, specific surface area, a ratio and a median diameter of the dispersed
particles were measured. The results are shown in Table 1. Note that as a result of
synthesis, the catalytic activity was 3 g of CNF / g of catalyst · h or more, so that
the removing process of carrier was not performed.
(Example 12)
[0089] By a procedure similar to Example 1 except that a catalyst prepared in Example 3
of Catalyst Preparation with a carrying rate of 50 mass % was loaded such that a content
of the active species was 40 mg, that reducing gas with a composition of 67 % of nitrogen
and 33 % of hydrogen was used and that a flow rate of carbon monoxide gas was set
at 3 NL / g of active species · min, CNFs were synthesized, synthetic activity and
catalytic activity were calculated similarly to Example 1, and a D/G value, volume
resistivity, specific surface area, a ratio and a median diameter of the dispersed
particles were measured. The results are shown in Table 1. Note that as a result of
synthesis, the catalytic activity was 3 g of CNF / g of catalyst · h or more, so that
the removing process of carrier was not performed.
(Example 13)
[0090] By a procedure similar to Example 1 except that a catalyst prepared in Example 3
of Catalyst Preparation with a carrying rate of 50 mass % was loaded such that a content
of the active species was 3.2 mg, that reducing gas with a composition of CO/H
2/N
2 = 50/50/0 was used and that a flow rate of carbon monoxide gas was set at 31 NL /
g of active species · min, CNFs were synthesized, synthetic activity and catalytic
activity were calculated similarly to Example 1, and a D/G value, volume resistivity,
specific surface area, a ratio and a median diameter of the dispersed particles were
measured. The results are shown in Table 1. Note that as a result of synthesis, the
catalytic activity was 3 g of CNF / g of catalyst · h or more, so that the removing
process of carrier was not performed.
(Example 14)
[0091] By a procedure similar to Example 1 except that a catalyst prepared in Example 3
of Catalyst Preparation with a carrying rate of 50 mass % was loaded such that a content
of the active species was 5 mg, that reducing gas with a composition of CO/H
2/N
2 = 70/30/0 was used and that a flow rate of carbon monoxide gas was set at 43 NL /
g of active species · min, CNFs were synthesized, synthetic activity and catalytic
activity were calculated similarly to Example 1, and a D/G value, volume resistivity,
specific surface area, a ratio and a median diameter of the dispersed particles were
measured. The results are shown in Table 1. Note that as a result of synthesis, the
catalytic activity was 3 g of CNF / g of catalyst · h or more, so that the removing
process of carrier was not performed.
(Example 15)
[0092] By a procedure similar to Example 1 except that a catalyst prepared in Example 3
of Catalyst Preparation with a carrying rate of 50 mass % was loaded such that a content
of the active species was 5 mg, that reducing gas with a composition of CO/H
2/N
2 = 90/10/0 was used and that a flow rate of carbon monoxide gas was set at 56 NL /
g of active species · min, CNFs were synthesized, synthetic activity and catalytic
activity were calculated similarly to Example 1, and a D/G value, volume resistivity,
specific surface area, a ratio and a median diameter of the dispersed particles were
measured. The results are shown in Table 1. Note that as a result of synthesis, the
catalytic activity was 3 g of CNF / g of catalyst · h or more, so that the removing
process of carrier was not performed.
(Example 16)
[0093] By a procedure similar to Example 1 except that a catalyst prepared in Example 3
of Catalyst Preparation with a carrying rate of 50 mass % was loaded such that a content
of the active species was 5 mg, and that reaction temperature was set at 750 °C, CNFs
were synthesized, synthetic activity and catalytic activity were calculated similarly
to Example 1, and a D/G value, volume resistivity, specific surface area, a ratio
and a median diameter of the dispersed particles were measured. The results are shown
in Table 1. Note that as a result of synthesis, the catalytic activity was 3 g of
CNF / g of catalyst · h or more, so that the removing process of carrier was not performed.
(Example 17)
[0094] By a procedure similar to Example 1 except that a catalyst prepared in Example 5
of Catalyst Preparation with a carrying rate of 100 mass % was loaded such that a
content of the active species was 5 mg, CNFs were synthesized, synthetic activity
and catalytic activity were calculated similarly to Example 1, and a D/G value, volume
resistivity, specific surface area, a ratio and a median diameter of the dispersed
particles were measured. The results are shown in Table 1. Note that as a result of
synthesis, the catalytic activity was 3 g of CNF / g of catalyst · h or more, so that
the removing process of carrier was not performed.
(Example 18)
[0095] By a procedure similar to Example 1 except that a catalyst prepared in Example 6
of Catalyst Preparation with a carrying rate of 150 mass % was loaded such that a
content of the active species was 5 mg, CNFs were synthesized, synthetic activity
and catalytic activity were calculated similarly to Example 1, and a D/G value, volume
resistivity, specific surface area, a ratio and a median diameter of the dispersed
particles were measured. The results are shown in Table 1. Note that as a result of
synthesis, the catalytic activity was 3 g of CNF / g of catalyst · h or more, so that
the removing process of carrier was not performed.
(Example 19)
[0096] By a procedure similar to Example 1 except that raw material gas with a gas composition
of CO/H
2/N
2 = 100/0/0 was used, that a catalyst of Example 3 of Catalyst Preparation was used
and that a flow rate of carbon monoxide gas was set at 62 NL / g of active species
· min, CNFs were synthesized, synthetic activity and catalytic activity were calculated
similarly to Example 1, and a D/G value, specific surface area, a ratio and a median
diameter of the dispersed particles were measured. The results are shown in Table
1. Note that as a result of synthesis, the catalytic activity was 3 g of CNF / g of
catalyst · h or more, so that the removing process of carrier was not performed.
(Comparative Example 1)
[0097] By a procedure similar to Example 1 except that a catalyst of Example 11 of Catalyst
Preparation, which fell out of the range of specific surface area of the manufacturing
method of the present embodiment, was loaded such that a content of the active species
was 5 mg, CNFs were synthesized, synthetic activity and catalytic activity were calculated
similarly to Example 1, and a D/G value, volume resistivity, specific surface area,
a ratio and a median diameter of the dispersed particles were measured. The results
are shown in Table 2. Note that as a result of synthesis, the catalytic activity was
3 g of CNF / g of catalyst · h or more, so that the removing process of carrier was
not performed.

(Comparative Example 2)
[0098] By a procedure similar to Example 1 except that a catalyst of Example 12 of Catalyst
Preparation, which has zinc oxide as the carrier, was loaded such that a content of
the active species was 5 mg, CNFs were synthesized. Synthetic activity was too low
to reach a predetermined value, therefore volume resistivity and the like were not
measured.
(Comparative Example 3)
[0099] By a procedure similar to Example 1 except that a catalyst of Example 13 of Catalyst
Preparation, which has alumina as the carrier, was loaded such that a content of the
active species was 5 mg, CNFs were synthesized. Synthetic activity was too low to
reach a predetermined value, therefore volume resistivity and the like were not measured.
(Comparative Example 4)
[0100] By a procedure similar to Example 1 except that a catalyst of Example 14 of Catalyst
Preparation, whose active species was iron, was loaded such that a content of the
active species was 5 mg, CNFs were synthesized. Synthetic activity was too low to
reach a predetermined value, therefore volume resistivity and the like were not measured.
(Comparative Example 5)
[0101] By a procedure similar to Example 1 except that synthesis was performed at 650 °C,
which fell out of the reaction temperature range of the manufacturing method of the
present embodiment, and that a catalyst of Example 3 of Catalyst Preparation was used,
CNFs were synthesized, synthetic activity and catalytic activity were calculated similarly
to Example 1, and a D/G value, volume resistivity, specific surface area, a ratio
and a median diameter of the dispersed particles were measured. The results are shown
in Table 2. Note that as a result of synthesis, the catalytic activity was 3 g of
CNF / g of catalyst · h or more, so that the removing process of carrier was not performed.
(Comparative Example 6)
[0102] By a procedure similar to Example 1 except that synthesis was performed at 800 °C,
which fell out of the reaction temperature range of the manufacturing method of the
present embodiment, and that a catalyst of Example 3 of Catalyst Preparation was used,
CNFs were synthesized. Synthetic activity was too low to reach a predetermined value,
therefore volume resistivity and the like were not measured. The results are shown
in Table 2.
(Comparative Example 7)
[0103] By a procedure similar to Example 1 except that in a reaction tube made of quartz
a catalyst holder was disposed in which 5 mg of a catalyst obtained in Example 15
of Catalyst Preparation was loaded and that a flow rate of carbon monoxide gas was
set at 103 NL / g of active species · min, CNFs were synthesized, and various kinds
of estimation were performed. The results are shown in Table 2. Note that as a result
of synthesis, the catalytic activity was 3 g of CNF / g of catalyst · h or more, so
that the removing process of carrier was not performed.
(Comparative Example 8)
[0104] By a procedure similar to Example 1 except that a catalyst of Example 16 of Catalyst
Preparation, which was not a cobalt - magnesium carried catalyst of Examples, was
used, CNFs were synthesized. Synthetic activity was too low to reach a predetermined
value, therefore volume resistivity and the like were not measured. The results are
shown in Table 2.
(Comparative Example 9)
[0105] Volume resistivity, a D/G value, specific surface area and particle size distribution
of commercially available CNFs (Flotube9000, product of Cnano Technology Limited)
were measured. The results are shown in Table 2.
<Discussion on results>
[0106] CNFs obtained in each of Examples were confirmed to be multi-walled carbon nanotubes
through TEM observation (a TEM photograph of a CNF of Example 10 as a representative
is shown in Fig. 1). CNFs of Examples 1 to 19 had high crystallinity, electric conductivity
and dispersibility.
[0107] Further, CNFs having high crystallinity, electric conductivity and dispersibility
could be manufactured at high activity, as shown in Examples 1 to 19. Especially,
high activity cannot be achieved with catalysts of different constitutions (Comparative
Examples 2 to 4, 6 and 8). Further, activity was decreased also in the case of a temperature
higher than the reaction temperature condition (Comparative Example 6).
[0108] In cases where synthesis was performed at the reaction temperatures shown in Examples
1 to 19, CNFs having a lower D/G value, i.e., higher crystallinity than Comparative
Example 9 could be synthesized.
[0109] When synthesis was performed with the catalysts and under the conditions shown in
Examples 1 to 19, CNFs having higher dispersibility than Comparative Examples 1, 5,
7 and 9 could be synthesized.
[0110] In Examples 1 to 16, CNFs having still higher dispersibility than Examples 17 to
19 could be synthesized.