[0001] This invention relates, in a first aspect, to a method of manufacturing an antenna
element; in a second aspect to an antenna element; and in a third aspect to a wide
band antenna comprising an array of antenna elements.
[0002] Wide band technology is increasingly being developed for communications and other
applications. Unlike narrow band systems, which operate at specific frequencies, wide
band systems can transmit and receive sequences of very short pulses, i.e. pulses
generated from a broad range or bandwidth of frequencies (typically several MHz to
several GHz) of the electromagnetic spectrum. The input to a wide band antenna is
typically from one or more pulsed sources, and the antenna is required to radiate
incident energy into free space.
[0003] Clearly, optimising performance is a key consideration in antenna design. Regardless
of the type and configuration of an antenna, its performance can be characterised
by (at least) the following metrics:
i) Impedance bandwidth
ii) Directive Gain
iii) Efficiency
[0004] Antenna impedance, and the radio frequencies over which that impedance is maintained,
are critical. It is essential that the antenna present an acceptable impedance match
over the frequency band(s) of operation. Antenna impedance and the quality of the
impedance match are most commonly characterized by either return loss (represented
by the scattering parameter S11) or Voltage Standing Wave Ratio (VSWR) - these two
parameters are simply different formats of exactly the same impedance data. S11 or
return loss, then, is a measure of how much power is reflected back at the antenna
port due to mismatch from the transmission line.
[0005] Bandwidth refers to the range of frequencies a given return loss can be maintained.
Since return loss is a measurement of how much power the antenna accepts from the
transmission line, the impedance of the antenna must match the impedance of the transmission
line for maximum power transfer. However, the impedance of the antenna changes with
frequency, resulting in a limited range (or ranges) that the antenna can be matched
to the transmission line.
[0006] In general terms, gain is a key performance figure that combines the antenna's directivity
and electrical efficiency. As a transmitting antenna, the figure describes how well
the antenna converts input power into radio waves headed in a specified direction.
The gain of an antenna will vary across its operating bandwidth, usually peaking at
the or each resonant frequency.
[0007] Antenna efficiency is a measure of what portion of the power supplied to the antenna,
including any reflection loss, is actually radiated by the antenna and it is well
known in the art that, in order to maximise transmission efficiency, the impedance
of the source can be matched, via the antenna, to that of the medium in which the
signals are to be transmitted. The medium in which signals are to be transmitted is
often free space.
[0008] Horn antennas have been used for many years as a means of matching the impedance
of a transmission line to that of free space and directing the radiated energy in
a controlled manner by virtue of their gain characteristics. The horn antenna can
be considered as an RF transformer or impedance match between the waveguide feed (supplying
the input signal) and free space which has an impedance of 377 Ohms.
[0009] An accepted method of broadening the range of frequencies over which a horn antenna
is impedance-matched is to introduce ridges within the horn. These are often combined
with a dielectric lens or tapered periodic surface in order to aid in limiting diffraction
from the horn edges, thus helping to limit the beamwidth at low frequencies. The use
of ridges essentially extends the upper frequency limit over which the antenna remains
well matched, since this is a function of the aperture dimensions.
[0010] A horn antenna of the types described above could be designed which permits a significant
proportion of the incident energy to be radiated over a broad band. However, for the
proposed application, which may involve several high-power input sources, for example,
several signal generators such as microwave frequency oscillators (MFOs), the inputs
may first need to be combined before being fed to the single horn antenna. This is
not generally considered to be feasible at high powers, principally due to the high
risk of dielectric breakdown at the combined high power, and losses in the combination
process. To overcome this problem, the available antenna aperture can instead be sub-divided
into a number of smaller regions, with sources attached to each region.
[0011] Alternative antenna designs comprise arrays of elements where the radiation from
a number of such elements can be coherently summed in a particular direction to form
a main beam. The aim in such an antenna design is to generate a single lobe from the
antenna array, substantially uncorrupted by so-called grating lobes, which are spurious
lobes resulting from standing waves in the elements. To minimise such grating lobe
corruption, it is common for such arrays to be constructed so as to maximise the element
spacing (thereby using a minimum number of elements whilst maintaining a sufficient
impedance match for a specified area or aperture, to avoid the onset of grating lobes
at particular scan angles. Such a spacing of elements tends to decrease efficiency
due to compromised impedance matching.
[0012] Aspects of the present invention seek to provide an efficient wide band antenna that
radiates energy, possibly input from at least one high power pulsed source and fed
via a co-axial line, into free space, which can be designed to have a predetermined
cut-off frequency and its performance optimised over a specified frequency band of
operation.
[0013] In accordance with a first aspect of the present invention, there is provided a method
of manufacturing a wide band antenna comprising a signal generator coupled, via a
transmission line, to a feed region of at least one antenna element comprising an
upper loop and a lower loop, said upper loop comprising a first conductive loop element
defined by an upper conductor and a first conductive blade member that tapers outwardly
to form a flare portion adjacent a distal end of said upper conductor, said lower
loop comprising a second conductive loop element defined by a base conductor and a
second conductive blade member that tapers outwardly to form a flare portion adjacent
a distal end of said base conductor, said first and second conductive blade members
defining, between their facing edges, a notch which opens outwardly from said feed
region, the method comprising the steps of:
matching, at a desired operating frequency range, an impedance of said antenna element
to said transmission line;
selecting a cut-off frequency of said antenna element; and
selecting the length of the upper conductor according to said selected cut-off frequency.
[0014] In an exemplary embodiment, the upper loop comprises said upper conductor, said first
conductive blade member and a connecting portion between the proximal ends of said
upper conductor and said first blade member, and wherein the method comprises the
step of selecting the lengths of said upper conductor, said first blade member and
said connecting portion such that the combined lengths thereof are substantially equal
to a wavelength at said selected cut-off frequency.
[0015] Optionally, the upper loop of said antenna element may further comprise an elongate
conductive vane extending at an angle from a first location on said upper conductor
to a second location on said first conductive blade member to define a pair of loops
within said upper loop.
[0016] In accordance with another aspect of the present invention, there is provided a method
of manufacturing an antenna element for an antenna substantially as described above,
the method comprising:
selecting a desired operating frequency range;
matching, at said desired operating frequency range an impedance of said antenna element
to said transmission line;
selecting a predetermined performance characteristic of said antenna element; and:
selecting a minimum distance of said second location from said feed region at which
said impedance match is maintained and said performance characteristic is attained,
and placing said conductive vane within said upper loop such that it extends from
said selected second location on said first conductive blade to a first location on
said upper conductor; and/or
selecting an angle of inclination of said conductive vane within said upper loop at
which said performance characteristic is attained, and placing said conductive vane
at said selected angle of inclination between said first location on said upper conductor
and said second location on said first conductive blade.
[0017] The method may include the step of selecting the second location as a function of
the length of the upper conductor. Indeed, the second location on the first blade
member may be at least 1/6 of the length of the upper conductor. The distance of the
second location from the feed region may be between 1/6 and 4/5 of the length of the
upper conductor.
[0018] In an exemplary embodiment, the conductive vane may be inclined outwardly, away from
the feed region, such that the distance of the first location from the proximal end
of the upper conductor is greater than that of the second location from the feed region.
The conductive vane may be curved along at least a portion of its length.
[0019] In an exemplary embodiment, the method may comprise the step of selecting the distance
of the first location from the proximal end of the upper conductor as a function of
the length of the upper conductor and in accordance with the selected second location.
The distance of the second location from the feed region may be 1/6 of the length
of the upper conductor, and the distance of the first location from the proximal end
of the upper conductor may be 1/5 or ¼ of the length of the upper conductor. The first
location may be between 1/5 and 5/6 along the length of the upper conductor from its
proximal end.
[0020] In accordance with another aspect of the present invention, there is provided a wide
band antenna manufactured substantially as described above, comprising a signal generator
coupled, via a transmission line, to a feed region of at least one antenna element
comprising an upper loop and a lower loop, said upper loop comprising a first conductive
loop element defined by an upper conductor and a first conductive blade member that
tapers outwardly to form a flare portion adjacent a distal end of said upper conductor,
said lower loop comprising a second conductive loop element defined by a base conductor
and a second conductive blade member that tapers outwardly to form a flare portion
adjacent a distal end of said base conductor, said first and second conductive blade
members defining, between their facing edges, a notch which opens outwardly from said
feed region, wherein an impedance of said antenna element substantially matches, at
said desired operating frequency range, an impedance of said transmission line; and
a connecting portion is located between the upper conductor and first conductive blade
member of said upper loop, wherein the combined lengths of said upper conductor, said
first blade member and said connecting portion is substantially equal to a wavelength
of a selected cut-off frequency of said antenna element.
[0021] In accordance with yet another aspect of the present invention, there is provided
a wide band antenna comprising a signal generator coupled, via one or more transmission
lines, to a feed region of each antenna element of an array of antenna elements manufactured
substantially as described above
[0022] Thus, more generally, the inventors have determined, through extensive innovative
input, that the dimensions of the upper and/or lower loops can be selected according
to a desired cut-off frequency of the antenna element, and the performance of the
resultant antenna element, in a specified frequency range or ranges, can be optimised
according to exemplary embodiments of the present invention. By changing the location
and/or inclination relative to the feed region of the conductive vane within the upper
loop, the performance of the antenna element can be optimised in respect of a predetermined
desired operating frequency range. More specifically, the inventors have determined
that by selecting the above-mentioned second location to be the minimum possible distance
from the feed region without degrading the impedance match, the performance of the
antenna element within the selected operating frequency range can be optimised. Furthermore,
they have determined that characteristics or parameters of the antenna element can
be influenced and optimised by selection of the inclination of the conductive vane
(and, therefore, its length within an upper loop of given dimensions).
[0023] These and other aspects of the present invention will be apparent from the following
specific description, in which embodiments of the present invention are described,
by way of examples only, and with reference to the accompanying drawings, in which:
Figure 1A is a schematic perspective view of an antenna element according to the prior
art;
Figure 1B is a close-up schematic view of the feed region of the antenna element of
Figure 1A;
Figure 2 is a schematic side view of an antenna element according to an exemplary
embodiment of the present invention;
Figures 3A to 3E illustrate schematically various configurations of an antenna element
according to an exemplary embodiment of the present invention, with progressively
increasing distances of the conductive vane from the feed region of the antenna element;
Figure 4 is a graphical representation of test results for each of the five configurations
illustrated in Figure 3;
Figure 5 is a graphical representation of calculations of performance from an antenna
element according to an exemplary embodiment of the present invention compared with
test results from two antenna elements according to the prior art;
Figures 6(i) to 6(v) illustrate various configurations of an antenna element according
to an exemplary embodiment of the present invention, with progressively increasing
inclinations of the conductive vane; and
Figure 7 is a graphical representation of calculations of performance for each of
the five configurations illustrated in Figure 6.
[0024] In the following exemplary embodiments, an antenna is configured to be driven by
microwave frequency oscillators (MFOs). However, it will appreciated that the present
invention is not intended to be limited in this regard and that other multi-frequency
pulsed energy sources can be used.
[0025] Throughout the specification, references are made to components being 'outward' or
'inward'. The term 'outward' has been used to indicate a direction that is towards
the medium into which the antenna radiates (often referred to as boresight), and 'inward
is used to indicate the opposite direction, i.e. away from the medium into which the
antenna radiates. Furthermore, relative terms such as 'upper' and lower, and row and
column, are used for convenience to distinguish between components so as to better
explain the invention, so no absolute orientation is intended from the use of such
terms alone.
[0026] Ultra Wide band (UWB) radiating systems with a peak power of around 10
10 W are necessary for many applications. As explained above, creation of this type
of radiating system has been achieved on the basis of multi element arrays with a
peak radiation power of a single array element of around 0.1 - 1GW.
[0027] An antenna element has been proposed for this purpose in
Koshelev, et al, "High-Power Ultrawideband Radiation Source with Multielement Array
Antenna", in Proceedings of the 13th International symposium on High Current Electronics,
Tomsk, Russia, July 2004. The described antenna element comprises an upper loop and a lower loop. The upper
loop comprises a conductive loop defined by a first elongate conductor and a first
conductive blade member that tapers outwardly to form a flare portion adjacent a distal
end of the first elongate conductor. The lower loop comprises a conductive loop element
defined by a second elongate conductor and a second conductive blade member that tapers
outwardly to form a flare portion adjacent a distal end of the second elongate conductor,
with the first and second conductive blade members defining, between their facing
edges, a notch which opens outwardly from a feed region. It is to be appreciated that
the term 'distal' used above and hereinafter is intended with reference to the feed
region, i.e. outward from the feed region, and the term 'proximal' used above and
hereinafter is intended with reference to the feed region, i.e. closer or closest
to the feed region. An antenna comprising a 4 x 4 array of such antenna elements is
described, wherein the source comprises a pulse generator feeding the antenna via
four co-axial transmission lines (i.e. one feeding each row of antenna elements).
[0028] This type of antenna element was further explored by
Godard, A., et al, "A transient UWB Antenna Array Used with Complex Impedance Surfaces",
Hindawi, International Journal of Antennas and Propagation, Vol. 2010, wherein a modified antenna element is proposed that includes a conductive vane extending
at an angle from the first conductive blade member to the upper elongate conductor
so as to form a pair of adjacent loops. Such an antenna element is illustrated schematically
in Figure 1A of the drawings, in which it can be seen that the element comprises an
upper loop 1 comprising a first conductive loop element 2 and a lower loop 3 comprising
a second conductive loop element 4. The conductive loop element 2 of the upper loop
1 comprises an elongate upper conductor 9 and a first conductive blade member 10,
the first conductive blade member tapering outwardly from a feed region 7 to the distal
end of the upper conductor 9 to form a first flare 11. The conductive loop element
4 of the lower loop 3 comprises an elongate base conductor 5, oriented substantially
parallel to the upper conductor 9, and a second conductive blade member 6 which tapers
outwardly from the feed region 7 to the distal end of the base conductor 5 to form
a second flare 8.
[0029] A conductive vane 12 extends at an angle across the conductive loop of the monopole
member, between the second blade member and the upper conductor, the vane 12 being
inclined outwardly, i.e. away from the feed region 7. The feed region 7 is defined
at a back plate 13. The connection or transition between the first blade member 6
and the inner surface of the back plate 13 is designed to achieve a good impedance
match (S11 parameter lower the -10dB) over a desired frequency band (300MHz - 3GHz).
As shown in Figure 1B of the drawings, the transition is formed of two sections: a
first section 14 formed of metal and a second, central section 15 formed of, for example,
PTFE, that provides high-voltage resistance.
[0030] However, it will be appreciated, that the described antenna element is intended for
a specific use and frequency range, and has been developed and optimised for that
use and frequency range. In contrast, an object of aspects of the present invention
is to provide a method of antenna design that permits the design of an antenna element
with a specified cut-off frequency, and permits the performance of such an antenna
element or a wide band antenna comprising an array of such elements to be optimised
according to specified characteristics, without increasing the dimensions of the antenna
element to levels that would make it impractical for many applications.
[0031] The object of the above-mentioned reference (Godard) is to present a miniature antenna
element which can be shown to have a cut-off frequency of 363MHz. This characteristic
is determined by the external characteristics of the antenna element, i.e. height
H, length L and width W. In order to reduce the cut-off frequency of the element,
it would be necessary to increase the external dimensions significantly, with the
result that the antenna element, and any resulting multi-element array antenna would
have impractically large dimensions for many applications, and may have an inadequate
performance at various frequency ranges. Using the design calculations employed by
Godard
et al, a cut-off frequency of around 100MHz, would require an antenna element of dimensions:
W = 3000/10 = 300mm
H = 3000/5 = 600mm
L = 3000/3.85 = 780mm
[0032] Thus, the width of each antenna element would have to be 300mm. However, this also
has additional drawbacks in terms of heat dissipation and, therefore, a negative effect
on efficiency of the antenna element. Also, such dimensions may make it difficult
to impedance-match the antenna element, or a multi-element antenna, to the transmission
lines(s), which is a significant drawback as the feed design is, in many cases, critical
to driving the antenna. Furthermore, such dimensions would not provide an optimised
performance at specified frequencies and frequency ranges, and no methods or techniques
are proposed in the prior art for solving these issues.
[0033] It is, therefore, an object of optional aspects of the invention to provide a method
of antenna design, wherein its performance can be optimised at a specified operational
frequency range and with reduced dimensions compared with known techniques.
[0034] In accordance with an exemplary embodiment of the present invention, this object
may be achieved by altering the location and/or the inclination of the conductive
vane defining the double loop in the upper loop of an antenna element of the type
described above.
[0035] Referring to Figure 2, in an exemplary embodiment of the invention, the antenna element
structure proposed is of the type described above, but having the following dimensions:
W = 200mm;
H = 600mm;
L = 1000mm;
which dimensions are selected to provide a cut-off frequency of ~100MHz.
[0036] In a method of manufacture according to an exemplary embodiment of the invention,
impedance matching is performed to match the impedance of the antenna element to the
transmission line of the desired radiation source (in a known manner) and the feed
region 7 is thus optimised. Next, a selected operating frequency range for which the
antenna element performance is to be optimised is selected. In this example, the frequency
range is 400 - 700MHz.
[0037] The inventors have determined that by selecting the location of the conductive vane
12, the performance of the antenna element in the operating frequency range 400 -
700MHz can be optimised (in terms of return loss and efficiency.
[0038] Referring to Figure 3 of the drawings, 5 possible locations of the conductive vane
are illustrated, as A, B, C, D and E respectively. The inventors have determined,
through extensive innovative input, that the key aspect of this element of the design
method is the distance from the feed region 7 of the end of the conductive vane 12
where it meets the blade member of 10. In each of the five illustrated tests A-E,
the inclination of the vane 12, outward, is substantially the same, at less than 10°
relative to a vertical axis defined by the back plate 13, and the above-mentioned
distance from the feed region 7 of the vane 12 where it meets the blade member 10
is made progressively larger.
[0039] As illustrated in Figure 4 of the drawings, it can be seen that if this distance
is too small, the impedance match is degraded and the return loss (S11) is increased
above an acceptable level at some frequencies. However, it can be seen that the performance
of the antenna in the frequency range 400 - 700MHz is significantly improved in tests
B, C and D at least (i.e. with the above-mentioned distance between about U6 and 5U8.
[0040] This performance can be seen in Figure 5 (reference 3) in comparison to that achieved
with a comparably sized antenna element having (1) a single loop (Koshelev) and (2)
a much larger double loop (Godard), wherein the above-mentioned distance is L/4 and
the inclination of the vane is such that the distance of the other end of the vane
from the proximal end of the upper conductor is U2.
[0041] Referring now to Figure 6 of the drawings, having determined the optimum distance
from the feed region of the conductive vane where it meets the blade member, the inventors
have determined that the performance of the antenna element can be further optimised
by changing the length of the inner loop (closest to the feed region). In effect,
this method step comprises selecting an inclination of the conductive vane (outward)
relative to the vertical axis defined by the back plate, or (equally) selecting the
distance from the proximal end of the upper conductor of the conductive vane where
it meets the upper conductor.
[0042] In the examples shown in Figure 6, each of the configurations tested has a 'bottom'
distance (from the feed region) of around L/6 (corresponding to Test B of Figure 3),
and each of the test configurations has a progressively larger loop length, ranging
from about L/5 in test (i) to around 4L/5 in test (v). Thus, as shown in the calculated
results illustrated in Figure 7 of the drawings, the performance of the antenna element
can be optimised for a specified operating frequency range (in this case, 400 - 700MHz)
by maintaining the minimum 'bottom' distance of the conductive vane (whilst maintaining
the required impedance match), but increasing the size of the inner loop by increasing
the 'top' distance (from the proximal end of the upper conductor) or inclination of
the conductive vane. In view of the increased length of the upper and/or lower loops
in comparison to the above-referenced Godard design, the antenna performance is further
optimised by the methods proposed herein.
[0043] Thus, more generally, the cut-off frequency of the antenna can be selected and the
loop length/dimensions selected to achieve that selected cut-off frequency. The performance
of the resultant antenna can then be optimised for a specified frequency range or
ranges using methods according to exemplary embodiments of the present invention.
[0044] It will be apparent to a person skilled in the art, from the foregoing description,
that modifications and variations can be made to the described embodiments without
departing from the scope of the invention as defined by the appended claims.
1. A method of manufacturing a wide band antenna comprising a signal generator coupled,
via a transmission line, to a feed region of at least one antenna element comprising
an upper loop and a lower loop, said upper loop comprising a first conductive loop
element defined by an upper conductor and a first conductive blade member that tapers
outwardly to form a flare portion adjacent a distal end of said upper conductor, said
lower loop comprising a second conductive loop element defined by a base conductor
and a second conductive blade member that tapers outwardly to form a flare portion
adjacent a distal end of said base conductor, said first and second conductive blade
members defining, between their facing edges, a notch which opens outwardly from said
feed region, the method comprising the steps of:
matching, at a desired operating frequency range, an impedance of said antenna element
to said transmission line;
selecting a cut-off frequency of said antenna element; and
selecting the length of the upper conductor according to said selected cut-off frequency.
2. An antenna according to claim 1, wherein said upper loop comprises said upper conductor,
said first conductive blade member and a connecting portion between the proximal ends
of said upper conductor and said first blade member, and wherein the method comprises
the step of selecting the lengths of said upper conductor, said first blade member
and said connecting portion such that the combined lengths thereof are substantially
equal to a wavelength at said selected cut-off frequency.
3. An antenna according to claim 1 or claim 2, wherein said upper loop of said antenna
element further comprises an elongate conductive vane extending at an angle from a
first location on said upper conductor to a second location on said first conductive
blade member to define a pair of loops within said upper loop.
4. A method of manufacturing an antenna element for an antenna according to claim 3,
the method comprising:
selecting a desired operating frequency range;
matching, at said desired operating frequency range an impedance of said antenna element
to said transmission line;
selecting a predetermined performance characteristic of said antenna element; and:
selecting a minimum distance of said second location from said feed region at which
said impedance match is maintained and said performance characteristic is attained,
and placing said conductive vane within said upper loop such that it extends from
said selected second location on said first conductive blade to a first location on
said upper conductor; and/or
selecting an angle of inclination of said conductive vane within said upper loop at
which said performance characteristic is attained, and placing said conductive vane
at said selected angle of inclination between said first location on said upper conductor
and said second location on said first conductive blade.
5. A method according to claim 4, including the step of selecting the second location
as a function of the length of the upper conductor.
6. A method according to claim 5, wherein the second location on the first blade member
is at least 1/6 of the length of the upper conductor.
7. A method according to claim 6, wherein the distance of the second location from the
feed region is between 1/6 and 4/5 of the length of the upper conductor.
8. A method according to any of claims 4 to 7, wherein the conductive vane is inclined
outwardly, away from the feed region, such that the distance of the first location
from the proximal end of the upper conductor is greater than that of the second location
from the feed region.
9. A method according to any of claims 4 to 8, wherein the conductive vane is curved
along at least a portion of its length.
10. A method according to any of claims 4 to 9, comprising the step of selecting the distance
of the first location from the proximal end of the upper conductor as a function of
the length of the upper conductor and in accordance with the selected second location.
11. A method according to claim 10, wherein, when the distance of the second location
from the feed region is 1/6 of the length of the upper conductor, the distance of
the first location from the proximal end of the upper conductor is 1/5 or % of the
length of the upper conductor.
12. A method according to claim 10, wherein the first location is between 1/5 and 5/6
along the length of the upper conductor from its proximal end.
13. A wide band antenna manufactured in accordance with any of claims 1 to 3, comprising
a signal generator coupled, via a transmission line, to a feed region of at least
one antenna element comprising an upper loop and a lower loop, said upper loop comprising
a first conductive loop element defined by an upper conductor and a first conductive
blade member that tapers outwardly to form a flare portion adjacent a distal end of
said upper conductor, said lower loop comprising a second conductive loop element
defined by a base conductor and a second conductive blade member that tapers outwardly
to form a flare portion adjacent a distal end of said base conductor, said first and
second conductive blade members defining, between their facing edges, a notch which
opens outwardly from said feed region, wherein an impedance of said antenna element
substantially matches, at said desired operating frequency range, an impedance of
said transmission line; and a connecting portion is located between the upper conductor
and first conductive blade member of said upper loop, wherein the combined lengths
of said upper conductor, said first blade member and said connecting portion is substantially
equal to a wavelength of a selected cut-off frequency of said antenna element.
14. A wide band antenna comprising a signal generator coupled, via one or more transmission
lines, to a feed region of each antenna element of an array of antenna elements manufactured
in accordance with any of claims 4 to 12.