FIELD OF THE INVENTION
[0001] The present invention relates to methods for processing ready-to-eat bacon with pan-fried
bacon characteristics comprising a combination of cooking in a microwave oven and
finishing in an infrared searing unit.
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
[0002] Continuous manufacturing processes for pre-cooking or cooking bacon comprise a method
where green bellies are received, optionally skinned, injected with brine/cure, hung,
thermally processed in a smokehouse where natural and/or liquid smoke is applied,
removed from the smokehouse and chilled, pressed, stored in a refrigerated cooler,
sliced, and deposited onto a cooking device including a conveyor belt. The slices
are transferred along a processing direction via a conveyor belt. A conveyor belt
feeds the slices into a continuous cooking device where they are cooked for a sufficient
time to obtain desired organoleptic properties. Examples of continuous cooking devices
include microwave ovens, belt grill ovens, and impingement convection ovens. The cooked
bacon slices are transferred via a conveyor belt to a packaging station.
[0003] Food packagers sell cooked bacon to restaurants (e.g., fast-food restaurants). The
restaurants use portion sized products such as the bacon on sandwiches. However, raw
bacon include long preparation time, a shorter shelf life, fat disposal issues, lower
efficiency, high labor costs, and an inconsistent cooking. In order to save time,
the products, such as bacon, can be pre-cooked thereby saving an employee time of
having to cook the product when preparing a meal. In the fast-food restaurant industry,
where time is important and the demand for portion sized products, such as bacon,
is high, cooking bacon wastes valuable time. Cost of cleanup and disposal of rendered
bacon fat are also concerns in the fast-food restaurant industry. Thus, there exists
in the industry a demand for pre-cooked bacon.
[0004] A method for pre-cooking sliced bacon is described in
US 6,045,841. A method for processing ready-to-eat bacon with pan fried bacon characteristics
is described in
WO 2014/089308. Pre-cooked bacon is currently produced using microwave energy to thermally process
bacon strips sliced from smoked de-rind bacon slabs. The processed bacon slabs are
sliced onto a microwave oven belt where the strips are moved into a microwave oven
cavity to be thermally processed into pre-cooked bacon. As the slices enter the microwave
oven cavity they are bombarded with microwave energy causing friction, and in return,
cooking the strips until the desired temperature or finished attributes are attained.
Finished pre-cooked bacon has to be cooked to a finished yield of less than 40% and
attain a finished temperature of greater than, or equal to, 71°C (160°F). The process
time varies based on the thickness and size of the product entering the microwave
oven cavity. Once the product has passed through the microwave it is sorted, sheeted,
and packaged. Although the pre-cooked bacon has advantages such as convenience and
time-saving value, one of the disadvantages of the current process is that the flavor
profile of pre-cooked bacon tends to be less intense and less desirable than that
of raw bacon that has been prepared on a griddle or in a frying pan. Consumer demand
for bacon slices with a "pan-fried" taste and consistency is not satisfactorily provided
by current methods of pre-cooking bacon slices. The use of infrared burners as restaurant
equipment is described in
Kimura (2014). "What's the deal with infrared burners?"eTUNDRA.com. Accordingly, there has been a long-felt need in the food service industry for a method
of simulating pan-fried bacon with the convenience and cost-savings of precooked bacon.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
[0005] The present invention is defined by the claims. Accordingly the present invention
relates to a method for preparing bacon, comprising: (a) cooking bacon slices in a
conveyor microwave oven; and (b) finishing the bacon slices in an infrared searing
unit by searing the bacon slices with the infrared searing unit, wherein the infrared
searing unit uses infrared energy with a wavelength of about 1 µm to 1 mm, wherein
the infrared searing unit uses infrared energy with a frequency of about 300 THz to
300 GHz, and wherein the infrared searing unit cooks the bacon slices for at least
about 3-20 seconds.
[0006] In accordance with a preferred embodiment the method comprises prior to step (a)
(a") providing a bacon slab; and (a') slicing the bacon slab into the bacon slices.
[0007] In accordance with a preferred embodiment the microwave oven cooks the bacon slices
to a temperature of 38°C-107°C (100-225°F), preferably 79°C-93°C (175-200°F).
[0008] In accordance with another preferred embodiment the infrared searing unit cooks the
bacon slices to a temperature of 93°C-149°C (200-300°F), preferably 74°C (165°F).
[0009] In accordance with a further preferred embodiment the infrared searing unit cooks
the bacon slices for 4-12 seconds, 6-9 seconds, or 12 seconds.
[0010] In accordance with a more preferred embodiment the infrared searing unit is a conveyor
searing unit the belt of which moves at 1.5 to 46 meters (5-150 feet) per minute.
[0011] In accordance with a preferred embodiment the conveyor microwave oven is coupled
to a thermal imaging device, vision system, near-infrared (NIR) imaging, vision systems,
inline checkweigher, infrared sensor, or a feedback control system.
[0012] In accordance with another preferred embodiment the infrared searing unit is coupled
to a thermal imaging device, vision system, near-infrared (NIR) imaging, vision systems,
inline checkweigher, infrared sensor, or a feedback control system.
[0013] In accordance with a preferred embodiment the method further comprises transferring
the sheets of bacon slices to a packaging machine for sealing in a modified atmosphere
package.
[0014] In accordance with another preferred embodiment the method further comprises casing,
taping, and palletizing packages.
[0015] In accordance with a preferred embodiment a series of parallel microwave oven-searing
unit assemblies are arranged.
[0016] In accordance with another preferred embodiment a multi-cavity microwave oven is
used, optionally a 2-6 cavity microwave oven or a 2-5 cavity microwave oven.
[0017] The invention is defined by the appended set of claims.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE FIGURES
[0018]
Figure 1 is a flow chart of exemplary method for making ready-to-eat bacon with pan-fried
bacon characteristics.
Figure 2 depicts an exemplary plant lay-out.
Figure 3 depicts a detail of a microwave oven including monitoring equipment.
Figure 4 depicts a detail of a searing unit, e.g., an open-flame unit (not according to the invention) or infrared searing unit, (according
to the invention). including monitoring equipment.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0019] In order that the invention herein described may be fully understood, the following
detailed description is set forth.
Definitions
[0020] Unless defined otherwise, all technical and scientific terms used herein have the
same meaning as those commonly understood by one of ordinary skill in the art to which
this invention belongs.
[0021] As used in the description herein and throughout the claims that follow, the meaning
of "a," "an," and "the" includes plural reference unless the context clearly dictates
otherwise.
[0022] "Bacon," as used herein, refers broadly to cured meat of several parts of a pig.
In America, bacon most commonly refers to the cured and smoked pork belly. The pork
is cured by applying a curing agent to the meat via a dry rub, immersion in a brine
solution, or injection with a brine solution. The curing agent, such as sodium nitrite
and/or saltpeter, is a color fixative that gives cured meat its pink color. The bacon
is, then, usually smoked or dried. Other ingredients and flavors can be added during
the injection process. Common smoke flavors are that of different types of wood; with
applewood and hickory being two popular smoke flavors.
[0023] Bacon can be made from several different cuts of meat. Streaky bacon, pancetta, and
American bacon come from the pork belly. Middle bacon comes from the side of the pig.
Back bacon is made from the loin of the pig. Also called Irish Bacon or Canadian bacon,
it is meatier and leaner than other bacon. Cottage bacon is thinly sliced lean pork
meat from the shoulder of a pig. Jowl bacon is the cured and smoked cheeks of a pig.
[0024] "Finishing," as used herein, refers broadly to the second process of cooking a food
product, after an initial cooking period. For example, "finishing" may refer to cooking
a partially cooked food product by a different method than the first method (e.g.,
cooking in a searing unit, namely infrared searing unit (according to the invention)
or a gas searing unit (not according to the invention) after microwaving a food product).
[0025] "Pan-fried bacon," as used herein, refers broadly to bacon prepared by frying. Bacon
prepared in this manner has a smoky flavor, a brown color, and crispy texture. Pan-frying
is a popular method of preparing bacon in the United States.
Simulating Pan-Fried Bacon
[0026] The disclosure provides methods and systems to simulate the taste of pan-fried bacon
using a combination of microwave oven cooking and a searing process. Pan-fried bacon
has a distinct flavor, odor, appearance, texture, and color. Bacon prepared in a microwave
does not share these same properties and is also considered less desirable by consumers
than pan-fried bacon. Further microwave bacon generally does not get the desired brown
appearance or the crispy texture of pan-fried bacon. In order to achieve a pan fried
flavor, food service operators and consumers must cook raw bacon on a grill or in
a pan. This method produces grease that must be collected and disposed. Precooked
bacon that delivers pan fried attributes will only need to be heated with no appreciable
grease generated. This would reduce the cost of preparing bacon for food service operators,
and also provide convenience for in home consumers.
[0027] In an aspect not part of the present invention, the inventors surprisingly discovered
that the combination of microwave oven cooking at about an internal temperature of
71-82°C (160-180°F), optionally about 71°C (about 160°F), and finishing in a searing
unit, the flame temperature is about 260-538°C (about 500-1000°F) depending on flame
setting, results in a rapid method for preparing bacon that has strong characteristics
of pan-fried bacon. The success in simulating the taste, texture, appearance, and
odor of pan-fried bacon using combination of microwave oven cooking and a searing
unit was unexpected because searing the bacon was expected to char the bacon and not
finish the bacon in such a manner as it satisfactory simulated the flavor, odor, and
texture of pan-fried bacon. Further, microwave oven cooking has failed to generate
bacon with satisfactory appearance, odor, texture, and flavor characteristics similar
to those of pan-fried bacon.
[0028] According to the invention the inventors also surprisingly discovered that the combination
of microwave oven cooking the bacon to a temperature of about 66-104°C (about 150-220°F),
optionally about 79-93°C (about 175-200°F), and finishing in an infrared searing unit
at a temperature of about 93-149°C (about 200-300°F), optionally about 110-127°C (about
230-260°F), results in a rapid method for preparing bacon that has strong characteristics
of pan-fried bacon. Preferably, 4-20 second in the infrared searing unit. For examples,
8, 9, or 10 seconds,
e.g., 8-10 seconds in the infrared searing unit. The bacon in the infrared searing unit
is cooked to a temperature of from about 93-149°C (about 200-300°F), preferably about
110-127°C (230-260°F). The success in simulating the taste, texture, appearance, and
odor of pan-fried bacon using combination of microwave oven cooking and an infrared
searing unit was unexpected because searing the bacon was expected to char the bacon
and not finish the bacon in such a manner as it satisfactory simulated the flavor,
odor, and texture of pan-fried bacon. Further, microwave oven cooking has failed to
generate bacon with satisfactory appearance, odor, texture, and flavor characteristics
similar to those of pan-fried bacon.
Process for development of simulation of pan-fried bacon
[0029] A demand exists in the market for pre-cooked bacon with similar savory notes found
in pan-fried bacon. The inventors made a number of attempts to simulate this pan-fried
flavor in pre-cooked bacon via numerous tests using different pickle formulations
and ingredients, but with no success.
[0030] Among the attempts to develop bacon with pan-fried notes, the inventors made a test
pickle using Red Arrow
® "Caramelized Butter" attempting to duplicate some of the caramelized-type flavor
present in pan-fried bacon. Additionally, they made a test pickle using a Red Arrow
® "Butter Flavor." Neither of these attempts successfully captured the flavor notes
of pan-fried bacon.
[0031] Moving on, the inventors performed a product cutting using pre-cooked bacon samples
prepared with Red Arrow
® "Bacon Enhancer/Pan-Fried Bacon" flavor. Bacon cheeseburgers, without condiments,
were used for a sandwich build. The pre-cooked bacon prepared with the "Bacon Enhancer/Pan-Fried
Bacon" flavor was compared to standard pre-cooked bacon and to an applewood raw bacon
prepared on a griddle. The applewood raw bacon was preferred and the flavor of the
"Pan-Fried" flavored bacon did not carry strongly on a sandwich build. Again, the
attempt was not successful.
[0032] In another attempt, the inventors injected pork bellies with a second variation of
"Bacon Enhancer/Pan-Fried Bacon" flavor. Subsequently, another cutting was performed
using bacon cheeseburgers. Although the test product was excellent as a center of
the plate product, the flavor did not have the intensity or savory notes that pan-fried
bacon had in a sandwich build; resulting in an another failed attempt.
[0033] The inventors also used microwave packaging technology, utilizing susceptors, to
enhance the reheating of pre-cooked bacon in order to deliver a "pan-fried" flavor.
The inventors purchased microwavable prepared foods that had packaging that utilized
susceptor technology. A trial was performed to determine whether susceptors would
intensify the cook and create a pan-fried texture and flavor upon microwave heating.
The inventors prepared bacon using the microwave packaging from these products. Some
improvement in flavor and savory notes was achieved, but it still did not satisfactorily
simulate a pan-fried flavor. The cooking was inconsistent and the product was burnt
at contact points.
[0034] In yet another attempt, the inventors ran a series of four different pickle formulations
utilizing a third variation of "Bacon Enhancer/Pan-Fried Bacon" flavor. The formulations
contained differing levels of the "Pan-Fried Bacon" flavor, as well as smoke flavorings.
Later, a fifth pickle formulation was run utilizing this same variation of "Bacon
Enhancer/Pan-Fried Bacon" flavor. None of these attempts were successful in simulating
a pan-fried flavor.
[0035] None of the formulation, packaging, or ingredient modifications attempted, utilizing
only microwave oven cooking methods, were successful; and the inventors turned to
the combination of microwave oven cooking with a searing cooking period to simulate
pan-fried bacon. The combination of cooking by microwave oven and finishing by searing
produced the unexpected result of simulating the flavor, consistency, color, appearance,
and aroma of pan-fried bacon. Accordingly, the inventors varied numerous parameters
and tried several possible choices until they arrived at a successful result, although
the prior art gave no indication of which parameters were critical or no direction
as to which of the many possible choices was likely to be successful.
Process for Simulating Pan-Fried Bacon
[0036] In the process of this disclosure, processed slabs are sliced onto a microwave belt
were the product is moved into the microwave oven cavity to be processed into pre-cooked
bacon. As the slices enter the microwave oven cavity they are bombarded with microwave
energy causing friction, and in return, cooking the strips until the product attains
a 30-60% yield (
e.g., 36-42% yield). The product then exits the microwave oven cavity and transitions onto
a stainless steel belt entering into a searing machine,
e.g., an open flame unit (not according to the invention) or infrared searing unit (according
to the invention) reducing the cook yield (70-95%) and increasing the cook temperature.
Both the cook temperature and yield will be achieved before exiting the searing chamber.
Upon exiting the searing chambers,
e.g., an open-flame unit (not according to the invention) or infrared searing unit (according
to the invention), the strips are transitioned back onto a takeaway conveyor to be
sorted, sheeted, and packaged.
Description of Bacon Products
[0037] Bacon prepared by microwave alone is flat with uniform appearance. The current method
of microwave alone looks and tastes nothing like frying bacon in a pan. In contrast,
the methods described herein replicates pan fried preparation results in a product
with a wavy appearance, non-uniform color with some darker edges (similar to pan fried
preparation), and flavor notes that convey similar caramelization as found in pan
frying. The cooked color of bacon slices prepared in accordance with the methods described
herein is a medium to dark reddish brown with golden brown fat. Texture has crisp,
firm bite. Product has aroma of fresh cooked bacon. The bacon products made by the
methods described herein exhibit a wavy pan - fried appearance with a dark ring around
the external edge of the strip. Texture has crisp firm bite with a charred smoky flavor.
Thus, the pan-fried bacon slice product exhibits a slight dark ring around the perimeter
of the strip. The product is light brown with a wavy appearance as if the product
was cooked in a frying pan. The bacon prepared by the methods described herein carry
a savory smoke flavor with notes of sweetness and salt similar to pan-fried bacon.
[0038] Thickness-The bacon slices may have a thickness of about 0.73 mm, 1.59 mm, 1.81 mm, 2.82 mm
or 3.18 mm (about 1/32", 1/16", 1/14", 1/9", or 1/8"). The bacon slab may be cut to
a thickness of about 3.1-3.5 slices per cm (about 8-9 slices per inch). The bacon
slab may be cut to a thickness of about 5.5-6.3 slices per cm (about 14-16 slices
per inch). The bacon slab may be cut to a thickness of about 2.8-7.9 slices per cm
(about 7-20 slices per inch). The bacon slab may be cut to a thickness of about 2.8,
3.1, 3.3, 3,5, 3.9, 4.3, 4.7, 5.1, 5.5, 5.9 or 6.3 slices per cm (about 7, 8, 8.5,
9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, or 16 slices per inch).
[0039] Heat- The bacon slices may be cooked in a microwave oven to an internal temperature of
about 38-99°C (about 100-210°F), optionally about 71-82°C (about 160-180°F), optionally
about 71°C (about 160°F). The bacon slices may be cooked in a microwave oven to an
internal temperature of about 71-99°C (about 160-210°F), optionally about 71-82°C
(about 160-180°F), optionally about 71-74°C (about 160°F or 165°F). The bacon slices
may be cooked in a microwave oven to an internal temperature of about 37.8, 43.3,
48.9, 49.4, 50, 50.6, 51.1, 51.7, 52.2, 52.8, 53.3, 53.9, 54.4, 55, 55.6, 56.1, 56.7,
57.2, 57.8, 58.3, 58.9, 59.4, 60, 60.6, 61.1, 61.7, 62.2, 62.8, 63.3, 63.9, 64.4,
65, 65.6, 66.1, 66.7, 67.2, 67.8, 68.3, 68.9, 69.4, 70, 70.6, 71.1, 71.7, 72.2, 72.8,
73.3, 73.9, 74.4, 75, 75.6, 76.1, 76.7, 77.2, 77.8, 78.3, 78.9, 79.4, 80, 80.6, 81.1,
81.7, 82.2, 82.8, 83.3, 83.9, 84.4, 85, 85.6, 86.1, 86.7, 87.2, 87.8, 90.6, 93.3,
96.1, and 98.9°C (about 100, 110, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 125, 126, 127, 128, 129,
130, 131, 132, 133, 134, 135, 136, 137, 138, 139, 140, 141, 142, 143, 144, 145, 146,
147, 148, 149, 150, 151, 152, 153, 154. 155, 156, 157, 158, 159, 160, 161, 162, 163,
164, 165, 166, 167, 168, 169, 170, 171, 172, 173, 174, 175, 176, 177, 178, 179, 180,
181, 182, 183, 184, 185, 186, 187, 188, 189, 190, 195, 200, 205, and 210°F). The bacon
slices may be cooked in a microwave oven to an internal temperature of about 71°C
(about 160°F). The bacon slices may be cooked in a microwave oven to an internal temperature
of about 74, 77, 79, or 82°C (about 165, 170, 175, or 180°F). The bacon slices may
be cooked in a microwave oven to a temperature of about 79°C (about 175°F). The bacon
slices may be cooked in a microwave oven to a temperature of about 77, 79, 82, 85,
88, 91, 93, 96, 99, or 104°C (about 170, 175, 180, 185, 190, 195, 200, 205, 210, or
220°F).
[0040] The bacon slices are finished in a searing unit,
e.g., an open-flame unit (not according to the invention) or infrared searing unit (according
to the invention). In an aspect not according to the invention, the bacon slices may
be cooked in a searing unit at a flame temperature at about 121-538°C, 177-538°C,
or 260-538°C (about 250-1000°F, 350-1000°F, or 500-1000°F). The bacon slices may be
cooked in a searing unit with an air temperature of about 232-260°C (about 450-500°F).
[0041] According to the invention the bacon slices may be cooked in an infrared searing
unit at a temperature at about 93-149°C (about 200-300°F). Air temperature in infrared
is 149-316°C (300-600°F) and the IR emitter is 93-593°C (200-1 100°F). The bacon slices
may be cooked in an infrared searing unit with an air temperature of 149-316°C (about
300-600 °F).
[0042] Time-The bacon slices may be cooked in microwave oven for about 40-240 seconds, for example
about 40, 45, 40, 55, 60, 65, 70, 75, 80, 85, 90, 95, 100, 105, 110, or 120 seconds.
The bacon slices may be cooked in microwave oven for about 80-90 seconds. Preferably,
the bacon slices may be cooked in microwave oven for about 30-150 seconds. More preferably,
the bacon slices may be cooked in microwave oven for about 60-105 seconds. The bacon
slices may be cooked in a microwave oven for about 1 minute, 1 minute 30 seconds,
2 minute, 2 minute 30 seconds, or 3 minutes. For example, the bacon slices may be
cooked in a microwave oven for about 80-120 seconds,
e.g., 80 seconds.
[0043] In an aspect not part of the present invention, the bacon slices may be seared in
searing unit for about 3-20 seconds, 4-12 seconds, 6-12 seconds, or about 6-9 seconds.
The bacon slices may be seared in a searing unit about 3, 4, 6, 9, 12, or 20 seconds.
The bacon slices may be seared in a searing unit about 12 seconds. The bacon slices
may be seared in a searing unit for about 1, 1.5, 2, 2.5, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, or
10 minutes.
[0044] According to the invention the bacon slices are finished in an infrared searing unit
for about 3-20 seconds, 4-12 seconds, 6-12 seconds, or about 6-9 seconds. For example,
the bacon slices may be finished in an infrared searing unit for about 3, 4, 5, 6,
7, 8, 9, 10, 15, seconds. Preferably, the bacon slices may be finished in an infrared
searing unit about 3, 4, 6, 9, 12, or 20 seconds. More preferably, the bacon slices
may be finished in an infrared searing unit about 8, 9, 10, 11, or 12 seconds.
[0045] Flame intensity (not part of the present invention)-The searing unit may be arranged to apply flame
directly to the bacon slices. The flame may be arranged as to indirectly apply the
flame to the bacon slices. The searing unit flames may be adjusted for varying angles
relative to the bacon slices. For example, the flames may be applied at an angle of
30°, 60°, 90°, 120°, 150° to the bacon slice. The flames may engulf the top side of
the bacon slices. The flames may engulf the bottom side of the bacon slices. The flames
may engulf both the top and the bottom side of the bacon slices. The searing unit
may be run at about 1.5 to 2.2 million BTU.
[0046] Infrared Energy- According to the invention the infrared searing unit may be arranged to apply infrared
heat directly to the bacon. The infrared (IR) heat may be generated by gas-fired and/or
electrical components. A gas-fired searing unit may be configured to provide direct
flame heat to a product. Alternatively, a gas-fired searing unit may be configured
to provide infrared heating. Infrared energy has a wavelength of 1 µm -1 mm with a
frequency of 300 THz-300 GHz. The infrared searing unit may heat the bacon using IR
wavelength for 4-20 seconds. The infrared searing unit may be electric or gas-fired.
[0047] Cure- The bacon may be treated with a dry cure. A cure may comprise the following ingredients:
(1) sugar including but not limited to sucrose, raw sugar, natural sugar, organic
sugar, brown sugar, organic cane syrup, organic cane sugar, white sugar, natural brown
sugar, muscovado sugar, refined sugar, molasses, confectioners' sugar (powdered sugar),
fruit sugar, milk sugar, malt sugar, granulated guar, beet sugar, and superfine (castor)
sugar; (2) salt including but not limited to natural salt, natural sea salt, natural
rock salt, sea salt, sodium chloride, table salt, natural hand-harvested salt, rare
artisan salt, smoked sea salt, and gourmet sea salt); (3) water; (4) a nitrite source
including but not limited sodium nitrate, potassium nitrate, sea salt, and vegetable
juice powder; (5) liquid smoke; (6) spices (in liquid or powder form); (7) seasonings
(in liquid or powder form); (8) sodium erythorbate; and/or (9) any combination of
(1)-(8) to form a dry cure. The cure may be injected into a bacon slab using mechanical
injector.
[0048] Meat-Although the description refers to bacon it understood that this is not intended
to limit the scope or applicability of the disclosure. As used herein, the term "bacon"
may be made from red meat
(e.g., beef, pork, veal, buffalo, and lamb or mutton) and/or poultry meat (e.g., chicken,
turkey, ostrich, grouse, goose, guinea, and duck). The meat used in the present disclosure
can be "organic," "natural," "Kosher," and/or "Halal." In one case, the bacon may
be pork, preferably cured pork. The meat can be certified "organic" and/or "natural"
by the appropriate state or Federal authorities (
e.g., FDA and USDA) and/or by meeting the appropriate standards set forth by said authorities.
[0049] Cook vield-The cook yield refers broadly to the weight of the food product at the end of the
process compared to the beginning of the process [
e.g., (end weight/beginning weight)*100%]. The cook yield of the bacon slices exiting
the microwave may be about 35-60%, 45-50%, 35-65%, 35-45%, 30-40%, or 45-50%. The
cook yield of the bacon slices exiting the searing unit after microwave cooking may
be about 70-95%, 85-90%, 85-88%, 83-93%, 83-88%, or 82-89%. The final cook yield,
after microwave and searing, may be 25-40%.
Equipment
[0050] The method for simulating pan-fried bacon may comprise an assemblage of equipment
comprising a slicer (
e.g., a Grote
® slicer) with a slicer speed of about 120-400 slices per minute,
e.g., 160-210 slices per minute, coupled to a microwave oven
(e.g., a Microdry
® microwave oven) with a belt speed of about 0.9-45.7 meter per minute (about 3-150
feet per minute),
e.g., 0.9-15.2 meter per minute (3-50 feet per minute), preferably 12.2 or 12.8 meter
per minute (40 or 42 feet per minute), coupled to a searing machine (
e.g., Cook King
® searing unit (not according to the invention) or Afoheat Infrared Searing
[0051] Oven (according to the invention)) with a belt speed of about 0.3-18.3 meter per
minute (about 1-60 feet per minute), coupled to an interleaver (
e.g., American Machine Works
® interleaver) coupled to a packaging machine (
e.g., Multivac) to package the bacon slices.
[0052] A number of different types of ovens may be used with the present invention, including
microwave ovens, belt grills, and convection ovens. Multiple ovens and combinations
of different oven types also may be used with the present invention. In order to provide
rapid control of product quality (as described herein) and to eliminate unnecessary
handling steps, it is preferred that the oven(s) be a continuous cooking oven rather
than being a batch cooking oven. Continuous cooking ovens can process a substantially
continuous supply of uncooked bacon into a substantially continuous supply of cooked
bacon without interruption of the process. Continuous cooking ovens may comprise a
continuously moving conveyor to carry the bacon into and out of the oven. Furthermore,
in order to reduce the complexity of the cooking operation and apparatus and increase
the safety of the system, it is also preferred that the oven(s) be able to cook without
the addition of fat or oil (or any other supplemental liquid heating medium), agitating
the bacon or the use of a pressure or vacuum chamber.
[0053] Microwave ovens have been found to provide good control of the cooking rate and quality
of the final product, and are preferred. Preferably, a series of microwave ovens are
placed end-to-end along the path of the cooking belt. In some cases, multiple ovens
may be integrated into a single oven structure containing multiple cooking "cavities"
that each contain a cooking unit. These cavities can be thought of as individual ovens,
and single "ovens" having multiple cooking cavities are referred to herein as a series
of ovens. In a preferred embodiment, a 5-cavity or 2-cavity microwave oven is used,
such as those available from Amana Commercial Products Division of Amana, Iowa under
the designation QMP2103 RADARLINE. A microwave oven with about 1-6 cavities may be
used,
e.g., a microwave oven with 2-5 cavities.
[0054] The cooking temperature in each cavity (i.e., oven) preferably may be adjusted individually
to provide an appropriate cooking rate, and the use of microwave ovens provides relatively
fast adjustments to cooking parameters. For example, in one case, earlier cavities
operate at a higher energy level (typically measured in units of kilowatts) to heat
the bacon, while later cavities operate at a lower energy level to prevent overcooking.
In a typical operation, the ovens operate to produce a meat temperatures of about
38-99°C (about 100-210° F), although other temperatures may be used to accelerate
or slow the cooking rate It has been found that factors important to properly adjusting
the microwave cavities include,
inter alia: bacon slice temperature, weight of product per unit area of the belt, and most importantly,
the moisture content of the product (often correlated to the leanness of the meat)
which can vary greatly from one pork belly to the next.
[0055] In order to ensure that the bacon obtains the desired final weight reduction, an
iterative, feed-forward or feedback quality control process may be used to measure
the bacon slice quality and make corresponding adjustments to the oven(s) performing
the cooking. Such quality control steps are desirable because raw bacon slices typically
have variable properties, such as moisture content, fat content, and the like, that
necessitate periodic or continuous adjustment of the oven(s) to ensure continued high
quality output.
[0056] The quality control process may comprise weighing a sample of cooked bacon and adjusting
the cooking parameters, if the weight is not suitable. Later weight measurements may
be used to determine whether additional adjustments are necessary. Of course, any
other quality control measurements also may be made to determine whether the bacon
slice has the desired weight, color, flavor, texture and the like. Advantageously,
the quality control process may be used in conjunction with a continuous cooker to
provide relatively rapid control of the output. If the output is found to be unsatisfactory,
the oven or ovens may be adjusted to provide better results without sacrificing a
large amount of product. This benefit is not possible with batch cooking ovens such
as kettle cookers, because the final quality of the bacon is unknown until all of
the bacon in the batch is cooked. In another embodiment, the quality control process
may also include a pre-cook diagnostic apparatus that determines the amount and/or
other characteristics of the bacon that is entering the ovens and automatically adjusts
the oven output accordingly. An example of such a device and process is described
in
U.S. Patent No. 6, 157,074. The use of multiple ovens also may allow quality control measurements of the bacon
to be taken between the ovens to further improve the quality of the final product.
For example, a series of parallel microwave oven-searing unit assemblages may be physically
separated for quality control purposes (e.g., different rooms in the same plant).
In this manner, any possible problems may be contained to a single unit and not interfere
with the operation of the entire plant.
[0057] In contrast to prior methods of cooking bacon, the current method cooks the bacon
slices two-step process to a lower internal temperature (
e.g., 71-82°C (160-180°F)) and includes a further searing step where the bacon slices,
after cooking by microwave the bacon slices are sear cooked at a flame temperature
of about 260-538°C (about 500-1000°F). This imparts a crispy texture and a "pan-fried
flavor" which is desirable to consumers and has eluded the art in the past. Imparts
a "crispy bite" similar to pan-fried bacon.
[0058] Infrared (IR) searing unit uses a type of radiant heat in the infrared portion (
i.e., 1 µm 1000 µm) of the electromagnetic spectrum to heat a product surface that is in
the "line-of-sight" to the emitter. One advantage of IR is the transfer of heat energy
directly to the product rather than air. In general, this allows IR to heat products
3-4 times quicker than convection, allowing a smaller physical footprint. The high
emitter face may reach a temperature of 427°C to 982°C (800°F to 1800°F). IR ovens
are available in electric or gas-fired types and each type has a variety of emitters.
The infrared searing unit may have 1-10 emitters, preferably 2 emitters.
[0059] In contrast to prior methods of cooking bacon, the current method cooks the bacon
slices in a two-step process to first temperature (
e.g., 79-93°C (175-200°F)) and includes a further infrared searing step where the bacon
slices, after cooking by microwave the bacon slices are finished in an infrared searing
oven to a second temperature of about 110-127°C (about 230-260°F). This imparts a
crispy texture,
e.g., "crispy bite" similar to pan-fried bacon, and a "pan-fried flavor" which is desirable
to consumers and has eluded the art in the past.
[0060] Texture Analyzers and analytical instrumentation for testing and measuring the textural
and physical characteristics of foods are known in the art. For example Texture Technologies
of Scarsdale, NY has a number of probes and fixtures that may be used to test parameters
of food characteristics including but not limited to crunchiness, crispness, brittleness,
hardness, fracturability, shelf life, and packaging effectiveness. Further, texture
may be evaluated using a texture analysis system, such as those available from TexVol
instruments of Hägersten Sweden. These devices may be used to analyze the texture
of the cooked bacon.
[0061] Proceeding now to a description of the drawings,
FIG. 1 shows an exemplary flowchart for carrying out steps of the process of the present
invention. The production of the bacon slab-which may be provided upstream of the
shown equipment-is not shown, as such equipment and methods for making a bacon slab
are well known in the art. For example, green pork bellies may be received, optionally
skinned, injected with brine/cure, hung, thermally processed in a smokehouse where
natural and/or liquid smoke is applied, removed from smokehouse and chilled, pressed,
stored in a refrigerated cooler, and then sliced. In
FIG. 1, the slicing
100 is shown to include one or more slicing machines
100, each of which deposits sliced bacon onto a loading conveyor
200. A single slicing machine
100 is shown, but other slicing machines may deposit bacon slices onto the loading conveyor
or other conveyors leading to the microwave oven
300. The loading conveyor terminates at a traversing conveyor where product is uniformly
distributed onto a continuous conveyor
201 of the microwave oven
300. A microwave oven may be used, such as Model No. QMP2103 manufactured by Amana, located
in Iowa. Examples of continuous manufacturing processes for cooking bacon are described
in
U.S. Patent No. 5,999,925.
[0062] The method comprises includes placing the bacon slices in file onto a conveyor belt
200. The slices are arranged in single file, one behind another, or preferably, in three
to six slices per lane. The conveyor belt transfers the bacon slices to microwave
oven
300. The positioning of the slices may be done by the Grote slicer
100. Positioning of the cooked bacon slices in file on the conveyor belt
200 can also be accomplished manually, for example, by an operator placing the cooked
bacon slices onto marked areas on a conveyor belt. For example, double 3-lane Grote
horizontal bandsaws may be used for slicing. A bacon trimmer may be included and can
be sized to accommodate the width of the conveyor belt of various types and sizes
of cooking devices. The bacon trimmer can be equipped with one or more tractors or
similar transferring means, one for each file or line of bacon slices. Further, the
equipment assemblages may be vertically tiered (
e.g., stacked on top of each other in different levels) to allow a maximization of the
use of plant space.
[0063] The energy used in the microwave oven
300 may be generated by a remote microwave generator. In other cases, the loading conveyor
may terminate at a buffer, collator, shaker deck, or retractable loader. The output
from the microwave oven is deposited on another transfer conveyor for being moved
toward searing unit
400, e.g., an open-flame unit (not according to the invention) or infrared searing unit (according
to the invention). The microwave oven cooks the bacon to a temperature of about 79-93°C
(about 175-200°F). Additionally, thermal imaging, near-infrared (NIR) imaging, sensors,
or vision systems may coupled with the microwave oven to allow control of microwave
power, belt speed, air flow, and air temperature. Sensors and other control systems
may also be coupled with the infrared searing unit
400 to allow monitoring of the production process (
e.g., temperature, flame intensity, air flow).
[0064] As product passes through the searing unit
400, e.g., an open-flame unit (not according to the invention) or infrared searing unit (according
to the invention) it is seared as discussed herein. The searing unit
400, e.g., an open-flame unit (not according to the invention) or infrared searing unit (according
to the invention), finishes the microwaved bacon , preferably to a temperature of
about 71-74°C or 110-127°C (about 160-165°F or 230-260°F). In an open-flame searing
unit (not according to the invention), the microwave bacon may be finished over an
open flame at a temperature of about 71-74°C (about 160-165°F). This imparts a "pan-fried"
flavor and creates a crispy bite similar to pan-fried bacon. Additionally, thermal
imaging, sensors, or vision systems may be coupled with the searing unit
400, e.g., an open-flame unit (not according to the invention) or infrared searing unit (according
to the invention), to allow control of flame intensity, belt speed, air flow, and
air temperature.
[0065] Next the seared product is deposited on a interleaver
500 for transport to a packaging machine
600 then to a metal detector
700 and post-packaging
800. The bacon slices may be placed on parchment paper at about 2-50 slices per sheet,
e.g., about 10-12 slices per sheet. The sheets may be manually stacked in groups of about
2-50 sheets,
e.g., about 10-30 sheets. The stack may be transported to a Multivac packaging machine
for sealing in a modified atmosphere package. The packaging machine may be a vertical
or horizontal packaging machine including but not limited to a vertical Form/Fill/Seal
(VFFS) packaging machine, horizontal Form/Fill/Seal (HFFS) packaging machine, or a
premade pouch packaging machine. The packages may be cased, taped, and palletized.
Further, the packaging may be modified atmosphere (MAP) or vacuum packed. The cooking
area is illustrated in schematic form only, as that equipment, in and of itself, is
conventional.
[0066] Accordingly, the inventor surprisingly discovered that the combination of the use
of microwave oven cooking and finishing in a searing unit (
e.g., infrared searing unit (according to the invention) or open-flame searing unit (not
according to the invention)) unexpectedly produced a bacon slice with similar flavor,
odor, color, texture, and flavoring to pan-fried bacon.
[0067] FIG. 2 shows an exemplary plant lay-out for carrying out steps of the process of the present
invention. The production of the bacon slab-which may be provided upstream of the
shown equipment-is not shown, as such equipment and methods for making a bacon slab
are well known in the art. In
FIG. 1, the slicing
100, loading conveyor
200, microwave oven
300, searing unit
400, e.g., an open-flame unit (not according to the invention) or infrared searing unit (according
to the invention), interleaver
500, and packaging unit
600 is shown to include one or more slicing machines
100, each of which deposits sliced bacon onto a loading conveyor
200. A single slicing machine
100 is shown, but other slicing machines may deposit bacon slices onto the loading conveyor
or other conveyors leading to the microwave over
200. The loading conveyor terminates at a traversing conveyor where product is uniformly
distributed onto a continuous conveyor of the microwave oven
200. The energy used in the microwave oven
300 may be generated by a remote microwave generator. In other embodiments, the loading
conveyor may terminate at a buffer, collator, shaker deck, or retractable loader.
The output from the microwave oven is deposited on another transfer conveyor for being
moved toward the searing unit
400,
e.g., an open-flame unit (not according to the invention) or infrared searing unit (according
to the invention).
[0068] unit. As product passes through the searing unit
400, e.g., an open-flame unit (not according to the invention) or infrared searing unit (according
to the invention), it is seared as discussed herein. Finally, seared product is deposited
on a interleaver
500 for transport to a packaging machine
600 then to a metal detector
700 and post-packaging
800. The packaging machine may be a vertical or horizontal packaging machine including
but not limited to a vertical Form/Fill/Seal (VFFS) packaging machine, horizontal
Form/Fill/Seal (HFFS) packaging machine, or a premade pouch packaging machine. Further,
the packaging may be modified atmosphere (MAP) or vacuum packed. The cooking area
is illustrated in schematic form only, as that equipment, in and of itself, is conventional.
Additionally, thermal imaging, sensors, or vision systems may coupled with the microwave
oven to allow control of microwave power, belt speed, air flow, and air temperature.
The bacon slices in the microwave oven may be cooked to a temperature of about 79-93°C
(about 175-200°F). The microwave energy may be from a generator and supplied in top
of the oven.
[0069] Referring to
Figure 3, the microwave energy may be controlled by utilizing inline checkweighers
301 (
e.g., at the entrance, middle, and discharge of oven), and/or infrared sensors to monitor
the product leaving the oven and feedback to control system to adjust microwave power
and/or time the bacon slices are cooked. Additionally, thermal imaging, near-infrared
imaging devices, sensors, or vision systems may coupled with the microwave oven to
allow control of microwave power, belt speed, air flow, and air temperature. For example,
a "pre-dried" product checkweigher
301 may check the weight of the bacon slice after slicing but before cooking in the microwave
oven. A vision/camera system
302 may be used prior to entry of the product in the microwave oven for monitoring the
product load. After the product exits the microwave oven, thermal monitoring system
303 may be used for monitoring bacon slice quality. A "post-dried" product checkweigher
304 may be used for yield verification prior the bacon slice to be conveyed to the searing
unit.
[0070] In
FIG. 4, the parameters, operating conditions, and product quality in the searing unit may
be controlled by utilizing inline checkweighers
401 (
e.g., at the entrance, middle, and discharge of searing unit), and/or infrared sensors
to monitor the product leaving the searing unit and feedback to control system to
adjust flame height, temperature, and/or intensity. Additionally, thermal imaging,
sensors, near-infrared (NIR) imaging devices, or vision systems may coupled with the
microwave oven to allow control of flame intensity, belt speed, air flow, and temperature.
For example, a "pre-dried" product checkweigher
401 may check the weight of the bacon slice after slicing but before finishing in the
searing unit. A vision/camera system
402 may be used prior to entry of the product in the searing unit for monitoring the
product load. After the product exits the searing unit, thermal monitoring system
403 may be used for monitoring bacon slice quality. A "post-dried" product checkweigher
404 may be used for yield verification prior the bacon slice to be conveyed to the interleaver
500.
The examples contained herein are offered by way of illustration and not by any way
of limitation.
EXAMPLES
EXAMPLE 1
SIMULATING SEARING OPERATION (comparative)
[0071] A process for the simulating of a searing operation was tested. Using a sample size
of approximately 15 pieces with a slice thickness of about 8-9 slices per inch, the
microwave product was cooked down to about 45% cook yield. The 45% cooked product
was finished in a COOK KING
® searing unit. The product was returned for evaluation with times and temperatures.
The times ranged from 1 minute to 1 minute and 45 seconds in microwave, 30 seconds
to 2 minutes 30 seconds in microwave with 4 seconds to 20 seconds in searing machine,
for a total cooking time of about 1 minute to almost three minutes combined (e.g.,
120 seconds in the microwave and 6-12 seconds in the searing unit). The product was
sampled for taste profile as well as visual appearance. All finished product attributes
simulate those of pan-fried bacon.
EXAMPLE 2
SIMULATING SEARING OPERATION (comparative)
[0072] A process for the simulating of a searing operation was tested. Using a sample size
of approximately 15 pieces with a slice thickness of about 8-9 slices per inch, the
microwave product was cooked down to about 45% cook yield. The 45% cooked product
was finished in a COOK KING
® searing unit. The product was returned for evaluation with times and temperatures.
The time for cooking was reduced and the flame intensity was increased with the times
ranging from 6-9 seconds with intensified flame coverage. The flame engulfs the top
side of the product. The product was sampled for taste profile as well as visual appearance.
All finished product attributes simulate those of pan-fried bacon. The test was completed
to determine feasibility of placing searing cavity in line with microwave oven cavity
from a capacity analysis. The test proved that searing cavity length would be capable
of running in line with microwave oven cavity. The samples were sent for cutting and
found to achieve desired outcome.
EXAMPLE 3
SIMULATING SEARING OPERATION (comparative)
[0073] A process for the simulating of a searing operation was tested. Using a sample size
of approximately 15 pieces with a thinner slice thickness of about 14-16 slices per
inch, the microwave product was cooked down to about 45% cook yield. The 45% cooked
product was finished in a COOK KING
® searing unit. The product was returned for evaluation with times and temperatures.
The searing cavity was adjusted to accommodate a thinner product. All finished product
attributes simulate those of pan-fried bacon.
EXAMPLE 4
PAN FRIED BACON TEST (comparative)
[0074] Three packages of 100 count pre-cooked bacon ran through the microwave at a facility
to a cook level of approximately 45%. The product was sent to simulate the proposed
process and establish run rates based on real time data collection. The following
tests were performed over the two day experimental trial.
[0075] Pre-cooked bacon off the microwave was reheated in a small conventional microwave
to simulate the product coming off an industrial microwave. The product was cooked
to an internal temperature of 82°C (180°F). The product was then weighed and placed
onto the searing machine conveying system. The conveying system was adjusted to a
number of different speeds ranging from 18.3 meter-per-minute (mpm) down to 12.2 mpm
(60 feet-per-minute (fpm) down to 40 fpm). The flame intensity was adjusted with the
different speeds to determine the optimal product temperature and conveying speeds.
Flame intensity ranged from about 260-538°C (about 500 to 1,000°F). Burner configuration
was four upper burners and one lower burner. The production yields were calculated
to determine shrink for finished product at different flame intensities and dwell
times. Flavor profiles were identified and able to be duplicated through the cooking
process using dwell times and flame intensities.
[0076] This test run established that the simulation of the pan fried bacon flavor was repeatable.
The different belt speeds and flame intensities influenced the intensity of the flavor.
The placement of the burners may be placed closer together to shorten the length of
the searing machine. The inventors found that the searing machine belt speeds were
adequate to maintain the current microwave throughput. Also, the current product yields
could be maintained by adjusting the flame intensity and dwell time. The inventors
also found that the bottom burners were not needed to attain desired flavor profile.
These results were unexpected because over the last ten years persons working in the
field, including the assignee, have made a number of attempts to duplicate the flavor
profile associated with pan fried bacon. This process is the most representative of
the flavor associated with pan fried bacon and is applicable to industrialization.
EXAMPLE 5
INFRARED SEARING OPERATION (according to the invention)
[0077] A process for the simulating of a searing operation was tested using an infrared
(IR) searing unit, an AfoHeat Oven, which combines two methods of heat transfer when
grilling or coloring meat products. The AfoHeat oven utilizes infrared irradiation
complemented by classic convective heat. Direct flamer burn with infrared screen.
The dwell time in the IR searing about 4-20 seconds. The air temperature about 260-538°C
(about 500-1100°F) inside the IR searing unit.
[0078] Each test was distinguished by slice thickness, with five tests run for 2.8, 3.3,
3.5, 3.9, or 4.3 slices/cm (7, 8.5, 9, 10, or 11 slices/inch). For all six tests,
one microwave lane and one AfoHeat burner was run. The AfoHeat test unit was run at
a belt speed of 4.3 m/min (14ft/min). The AfoHeat oven belt was set at a 62 mm height
for all tests, allowing the AfoHeat oven to properly mesh with the height of the microwave
oven. 8-10 second. Temperature 260-316°C (500-600°F) belt temperature in Infrared
Searing Unit.
[0079] Using a sample size of approximately 2.8, 3.3., 3.5, 3.9, or 4.3 slices per cm (7,
8.5, 9, 10, or 11 slices per inch), the product was cooked in a microwave product
to a product temperature of about 85-93°C (about 175-200°F). The microwaved bacon
was then fed into an AfoHeat oven and finished to a product temperature of about 110-127°C
(about 230-260°F). The product was then placed on parchment paper and packaged with
an UltraVac.
TABLE 1: Cook Yields
| Slices per inch |
AfoHeat burner running at |
Microwave Cook Yield |
AfoHeat Cook Yield |
Overall Yield |
| 7 |
70-85% |
38-56% (38-41%) |
83-92% |
25-40% |
| 8.5 |
70-80% |
36-42% (34-36%) |
85.7-88.5% (85-88%) |
25-40% |
| 9 |
65-75% |
35-52% (35-41%) |
84-89% |
25-40% |
| 10 |
60-75% |
35-54% (35-43%) |
85-88% |
25-40% |
| 11 |
60-70% |
38-49% (38-39%) |
83-85% |
25-40% |
[0080] The bacon product cured with high sugar content and LFBN smoke tended to char more
than light sugar/no LFBN. In all five tests, the texture, color, and flavor at appropriate
yields met "pan-fried" attributes. These results were unexpected because over the
last ten years persons working in the field, including the assignee, have made a number
of unsuccessful attempts to duplicate the flavor profile associated with pan fried
bacon. This process is the most representative of the flavor associated with pan fried
bacon and is applicable to industrialization (
e.g., scaling up).