[0001] The present disclosure relates to a quench-hardenable steel that provides excellent
cold formable properties and that can be reheat-quench hardened to provide a steel
having excellent impact strength and hardness. The steel has a reduced tendency to
hardening induced cracking even when using a very high cooling rate, such as water
quenching, and without any tempering. The quench hardening can be carried out over
the entire component formed from the steel, or only part of the component such as
only at the edge of a blade. The disclosure also relates to a method of quench hardening
steel.
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
[0002] Quench hardening is a process in which steel and cast iron alloys are strengthened
and hardened. During a typical reheat-quench hardening process, a steel is heated
to an austenization temperature (preferably around 900°C), soaked (i.e. equalized),
and then rapidly cooled (quenched) preferably with a liquid such as water or oil.
Quenched steels are typically brittle due to an overabundance of martensite. In these
cases, the steels can be tempered, i.e. heated to below the critical point (A
c1) to reduce the hardness and increase the toughness. Tempering however also increases
the processing steps and costs.
[0003] Quenching may be through the entire steel sample, or localised for example at a blade
edge. Targeted heating means such as induction heating may be used if only localised
or even surface hardening is required.
[0004] It is commonly understood that the hardness of the resulting martensite is dictated
by the carbon content. However, higher carbon contents in turn increase the risk of
crack formation during quench hardening. There are a multitude of factors that can
give rise to crack formation, such as from thermal stresses arising due to uneven
heating or quench cooling. This can particularly be an issue if a thick sample is
quench hardened, as the temperature differential between the core and surface can
cause significant thermal stresses through the material during the quenching process
itself. Transformational stresses can also arise due to volume changes that occur
when crystal phase transformations take place within the steel. This can particularly
be a problem when the cooling rates are uneven, such as may also occur with thicker
samples (e.g. above 6 mm in thickness) or with complex shapes. These localised concentrations
of high residual stress may act as points of weakness that give rise to cracks if
they are acting in the same direction as an applied load. Often, cracks originate
and propagate from certain weak points, such as corners of square shaped holes punched
out of a metal piece. This can lead to design restrictions for quench hardened components,
as the component piece may need to be modified to avoid any such weak points occurring.
[0005] The quench medium itself can also influence the tendency for crack formation to occur.
When water is used as the quench medium, the cooling rate is typically much higher
in comparison to oil. While this gives rise to harder steels, the likelihood of stress
cracking is higher. Transformational stresses can be reduced during tempering, but
this inevitably reduces the hardness of the steel.
[0006] Impact strength is related to the ability of the material to dissipate the energy
of an impact through its structure, which is a tendency favoured by softer, more malleable
materials. Hardened steels may be extremely resistant to wear at their surface, but
often this high hardness leads to a relatively brittle material with low impact strength.
Even so, the combination of high hardness and good impact strength is highly desirable
in some scenarios. For example, agricultural equipment such as ploughs are required
to have high wear resistance and high hardness to allow them to withstand the abrasion
they experience when in use. However, ploughs made from hardened materials with low
impact strength may be at risk of damage when they encounter stones or other hard
objects in the soil.
[0007] A reduced risk of hardening cracks is extremely important when the cooling rate is
higher than standard water quenching, as can occur when using powerful stirring and/or
when using salt water (brine) as the quenching bath.
[0008] There remains a need for quench hardenable steels that provide high hardness steels
with good impact strength and with a reduced risk of hardening cracks. Furthermore,
there remains a need for quench hardenable steels having good structural properties,
which allow localised quench hardening particularly using water as the quench medium.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
[0009] The present disclosure relates to a hardenable steel composition consisting of the
following, in terms of weight percent:
C |
0.36-0.55%, |
Mn |
0.1-0.7%, |
Si |
0-0.7%, |
Mo |
0.2-1.9%, |
Al |
≤ 0.2% (not including 0%), |
Cr |
optionally ≤1%, |
Ni |
optionally ≤1%, |
Cu |
optionally ≤1%, |
Nb |
optionally ≤0.1%, |
Ti |
optionally ≤0.2%, |
V |
optionally ≤0.2%, |
B |
optionally ≤0.01%, |
W |
optionally ≤1%, and |
Co |
optionally ≤1%, |
wherein

(when Cr is present)

and

the balance being iron, residual contents and unavoidable impurities.
[0010] Viewed in an alternative way, the present disclosure relates to a hardenable steel
that is capable of being reheat-quench hardened to form a steel satisfying the following
equation:

wherein
VJ is the Charpy V impact strength in J/cm2 at 20°C,
Hv10 is the Vickers Hardness,
AX = 95, and
HX = 0.125.
[0011] Preferably, the hardenable steel is capable of being reheat-quench hardened from
a temperature above A
c3 to a temperature below M
S at an average cooling rate of ≥50°C/s (more preferably ≥ 80°C/s) to form a crack-free
hardened steel.
[0012] Preferably, the hardenable steel consists of the following, in terms of weight percent:
C |
0.36-0.55%, |
Mn |
0.1-0.7%, |
Si |
0-0.7%, |
Mo |
0.2-1.9%, |
Al |
≤ 0.2% (not including 0%), |
Cr |
optionally ≤1%, |
Ni |
optionally ≤1%, |
Cu |
optionally ≤1%, |
Nb |
optionally ≤0.1%, |
Ti |
optionally ≤0.2%, |
V |
optionally ≤0.2%, |
B |
optionally ≤0.01%, |
W |
optionally ≤1%, and |
Co |
optionally ≤1%, |
the balance being iron, residual contents and unavoidable impurities.
[0013] More preferably, the hardenable steel satisfies the following relationships:

(when present)

and

[0014] The present disclosure also relates to a component formed from the hardenable steel
(or hardenable steel composition), wherein at least a region of the component has
been reheat-quench hardened to form a hardened region.
[0015] Preferably, the entire component has been reheat-quench hardened.
[0016] Preferably, the microstructure of the hardened region of the component is martensitic.
[0017] Preferably, the hardened region of the component has a Vickers hardness of ≥ 630
Hv10.
[0018] Preferably, the hardened region of the component has a Charpy V impact strength of
≥ 3 J/cm
2 at 20°C.
[0019] Preferably, the hardened region satisfies the following:

wherein
VJ is the Charpy V impact strength in J/cm2 at 20°C,
Hv10 is the Vickers Hardness,
AX = 95, and
HX = 0.125.
[0020] The present disclosure also relates to a method for producing hardened steel, comprising
the steps of:
- a. providing a component formed from a hardenable steel composition;
- b. heating at least a region of the component to a temperature (TS) above Ac3;
- c. quenching said region using a quenching fluid to form a hardened region; and
- d. optionally tempering the hardened region;
wherein
said hardenable steel composition consists of the following, in terms of weight percent,
C |
0.36-0.55%, |
Mn |
0.1-0.7%, |
Si |
0-0.7%, |
Mo |
0.2-1.9%, |
Al |
≤ 0.2% (not including 0%), |
Cr |
optionally ≤1%, |
Ni |
optionally ≤1%, |
Cu |
optionally ≤1%, |
Nb |
optionally ≤0.1%, |
Ti |
optionally ≤0.1%, |
V |
optionally ≤0.2%, |
B |
optionally ≤0.01%, |
W |
optionally ≤1%, and |
Co |
optionally ≤1%, |
wherein

(when Cr is present)

and

the balance being iron, residual contents and unavoidable impurities.
[0021] Viewed in an alternative way, the present disclosure relates to a method for producing
hardened steel, comprising the steps of:
a'. providing a component formed from a hardenable steel;
b'. heating at least a region of the component to a temperature (TS) above Ac3;
c'. quenching said region using a quenching fluid to form a hardened region; and
d'. optionally tempering the hardened region;
wherein
the hardened region satisfies the following:

wherein
VJ is the Charpy V impact strength in J/cm2 at 20°C,
Hv10 is the Vickers Hardness,
AX = 95, and
HX = 0.125.
[0022] Preferably, in step b. (or step b'.) the entire component is heated to a temperature
above A
c3, and more preferably in step c. (or step c'.) the entire component is then quenched
with the quenching fluid to form a hardened component.
[0023] Preferably, the hardenable steel in step a'. consists of the following, in terms
of weight percent:
C |
0.36-0.55%, |
Mn |
0.1-0.7%, |
Si |
0-0.7%, |
Mo |
0.2-1.9%, |
Al |
≤ 0.2% (not including 0%), |
Cr |
optionally ≤1%, |
Ni |
optionally ≤1%, |
Cu |
optionally ≤1%, |
Nb |
optionally ≤0.1%, |
Ti |
optionally ≤0.2%, |
V |
optionally ≤0.2%, |
B |
optionally ≤0.01%, |
W |
optionally ≤1%, and |
Co |
optionally ≤1%, |
the balance being iron, residual contents and unavoidable impurities.
[0024] More preferably, the hardenable steel in step a'. satisfies the following relationships:

(when Cr is present)

and

[0025] Preferably, the steel is crack-free after step c. (or step c'.).
[0026] Preferably, the cooling rate in step c. (or c'.) is ≥ 50°C/s, more preferably ≥ 80°C/s.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0027] The present disclosure will hereinafter be further explained by means of non-limiting
examples with reference to the appended figures where;
- Figure 1
- shows a scatter plot of Vickers hardness and impact strength for varying AX values;
- Figure 2
- shows the hardness vs depth profile of steel 1-A;
- Figure 3
- shows the hardness vs depth profile of steel 1-B;
- Figure 4
- shows the hardness vs depth profile of steel 1-C;
- Figure 5
- shows the hardness vs depth profile of steel 1-D;
- Figure 6
- shows the hardness vs depth profile of steel 1-D, 12 mm sample;
- Figure 7
- shows the effect of tempering on hardness for steel 1-D;
- Figure 8
- shows the effect of tempering on impact strength for steel 1-D; and
- Figure 9
- shows the blank used in the crack resistance testing.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION
[0028] The hardenable steel (composition) of the present disclosure provides excellent quench
hardening characteristics with reduced risk for quench cracking compared to standard
hardenable steels such as 51 CrV4, 38MnB5, 42MnV7, and the like. The steel is able
to provide hardness levels of >630 Hv10 when quench hardened using water, and can
typically be used even without tempering (i.e. the quench hardened steel is crack-free
without tempering). The excellent formability and structural properties of the steel
prior to quench hardening allows it to be hot or cold formed into a range of components,
quench hardened (optionally locally) to form a martensitic steel using a simple and
cost effective process, and then used without any additional tempering steps.
[0029] By "hardenable steel (composition)" is meant the hardenable steel composition set
out above, as well as the hardenable steel capable of being reheat-quench hardened
to form a steel satisfying the equation V
J + (H
X * Hv10) > A
X as set out above. The preferred aspects described herein, such as the preferred structural
limitations or properties of the steel as well as the preferred processing conditions,
apply to both the hardenable steel as well as the hardenable steel composition.
[0030] By "crack-free" is meant that the steel meets ISO 23278:2015, Class 2X. The IS023278:2015
standard specifies acceptance levels for indication from imperfections in ferromagnetic
steel welds detected by magnetic particle testing. This tolerance level means that,
when tested using magnetic particle detection according to the ISO23278:2015 standard,
any linear imperfections such as cracks/defects are below 1.5 mm in length, and non-linear
imperfections such as cracks/defects are below 3 mm in maximum dimension. In this
context, a linear imperfection is defined as having a length greater than three times
its width, while a non-linear imperfection is defined as having a length less than
or equal to three times its width.
[0031] Preferably, by "crack-free" is meant that the steel meets ISO23278:2015, Class 2X
when held at room temperature for 24 hours, more preferably for 1 week, after quench
hardening.
[0032] As used herein, the terms "martensite" and "martensitic" include martensite, self-tempered
(or auto-tempered) martensite and tempered martensite. Thus, within the meaning of
this disclosure a steel containing ≥95% martensite has ≥ 95% of is structure being
martensite, self-tempered martensite and tempered martensite.
[0033] As used herein, A
c1 is the temperature at which austenite (γ) begins to form during heating.
[0034] As used herein, A
r1 is the temperature at which austenite (γ) to ferrite (α) transformation is completed
during cooling.
[0035] As used herein, A
c3 is the temperature at which transformation of ferrite (α) to austenite (γ) is completed
during heating.
[0036] As used herein, A
r3 is the temperature at which austenite (γ) begins to transform to ferrite (α) during
cooling.
[0037] A
c1, A
c3, A
r1, A
r3 are well known parameters that would be known to the skilled person. They may be
estimated experimentally using standard methodology. Alternatively, the parameters
may be estimated theoretically, for example using the formulae from Brandis (
Rechnerische Bestimmung der Umwandlungstemperaturen von niedriglegierten Stählen.
TEW - Technische Berichte, Band 1, Heft 1, 1975, 8-10) or
Lutsenko (The Definition and Use of Technological Reserves - An Effective Way to Improve
the Production Technology of Rolled Metal. Abschlußbericht, Kommission der Europäischen
Gemeinschaften, Luxembourg, 1991, 136 p.), as set out below:

[0038] Where [%X] is the weight percent of element X.
[0039] As used herein, the term "hardenable" preferably means that a sample of the steel
with a thickness of 3 mm, when heated to and soaked at 950°C for a 1 hour and then
quenched with still water, has at least 90% martensitic microstructure at the centre
of the sample.
[0040] The key characterising features of the hardenable steel composition of the disclosure
is the relatively low Mn, Si and Cr content in combination with the relatively high
Mo content. The combination of these elements in these ratios provides a steel having
good structural properties that displays exceptional impact strength and quench hardenability
combined with the low risk of quench induced cracking.
[0041] The chemical composition of the hardenable steel (composition) is now described in
more detail. In this disclosure, all percentages in the compositions are percentages
by weight. Moreover, each of the preferred ranges for the various components mentioned
below may be combined with any the preferred ranges of the remaining components.
Carbon
[0042] Carbon is primarily present to ensure the hardenable steel (composition) is capable
of quench hardening to form martensite. A higher carbon content will provide a harder
steel. However, if the carbon content is too high, the resultant quenched steel can
become too brittle and the risk of quench induced cracking increases. A maximum carbon
content of 0.55% is therefore preferably used.
[0043] Preferably, carbon is used at levels of 0.38-0.52 %, more preferably 0.40-0.50 %,
even more preferably 0.41-0.48 %.
Silicon
[0044] Silicon is included in steels to improve cleanliness during the smelt processing
and it can have a positive effect on hardenability. However, too much silicon can
reduce the amount of self-tempering that occurs during quenching, as well as have
an impact on the surface quality of the finished steel. A maximum silicon content
of 0.7 is therefore preferably used.
[0045] Preferably, silicon is used at levels of 0.01-0.5 %, more preferably 0.05-0.35 %,
most preferably 0.10-0.25%.
Manganese, Chromium and Molybdenum
[0046] Manganese, chromium and molybdenum play an important role in controlling the quench-hardening
properties of the hardenable steel (composition). The importance of these three elements
is set out below.
[0047] Manganese has a significant effect on hardenability. It is also effective at sequestering
any oxygen and sulphur that may be present in the steel. However, manganese has a
strong tendency to segregate and also significantly reduces the martensite start temperature,
M
S. The overall manganese content is therefore quite low, with a preferable maximum
amount of 0.7 %, preferably a maximum of 0.65 %.
[0048] Preferably, manganese is used at levels of 0.10-0.50 %, more preferably 0.15-0.40
%, most preferably 0.20-0.30 %.
[0049] Chromium is optionally used to increase hardenability. However, it also significantly
reduces the martensite start temperature, which can negatively affect the amount of
self-tempering that occurs during quenching. The total chromium content is therefore
preferably less than 1 %, preferably less than 0.75 %.
[0050] Preferably, chromium is used at levels of 0-0.5 %, more preferably 0-0.3 %, most
preferably 0-0.20 %.
[0051] Molybdenum is included to provide hardenability and improve tempering resistance.
Advantageously, molybdenum does not have a significant impact on the martensite start
temperature, meaning that the use of molybdenum as the primary hardening agent ensures
the martensite start temperature remains high and self-tempering is promoted during
quenching.
[0052] Molybdenum also helps improve the impact strength of the hardened steel composition.
It is well known that impact strength increases with increasing temperature, with
lower temperature materials being more brittle and higher temperature materials being
more ductile. The plot of impact strength against temperature for steels is therefore
typically a sigmoidal shape, with a relatively steep transition region where the steel
changes from brittle to ductile behaviour and impact strength increases significantly.
[0053] For martensitic steels, the presence of alloying elements typically lowers the impact
strength. However, the applicant has found that molybdenum and nickel frequently increase
the impact strength of the steel, effectively lowering the temperature at which the
steel transitions from brittle to ductile behaviour, with the effect from molybdenum
being particularly significant. Molybdenum also helps retain hardness during tempering
at relatively high temperatures, such as from 500-650 or more preferably from 500
to 600°C.
[0054] Preferably, molybdenum is used at levels of 0.2-1.9 %. Preferably, molybdenum is
used at levels of 0.2-1.5 %, more preferably 0.30-1.2 %, more preferably 0.40-1.1
%, even more preferably 0.50-1.0 %.
[0055] The combination of manganese, chromium and molybdenum provide the hardenability in
the hardenable steel (composition). However, molybdenum is used in favour of the other
two to provide a steel with high hardenability and high impact strength, that retains
a high martensite start temperature, and which is more able to retain hardness and
impact strength during tempering after hardening.
[0056] Manganese, chromium and molybdenum respectively have decreasing influence on the
hardenability, with comparably more chromium and often even more molybdenum being
needed as compared to manganese to achieve the same hardenability. Consequently, the
hardenable steel (composition) disclosed herein preferably contains a relatively higher
level of molybdenum in comparison to chromium and manganese, and preferably satisfies
the following conditions:

(when Cr is present)

and

[0057] Preferably:

(when Cr is present)

and

[0058] Preferably:

and

[0059] Preferably:

[0060] Moreover, preferably:

[0061] More preferably:

[0062] The steel preferably contains enough manganese, chromium and molybdenum to ensure
a good level of hardenability. Typically, the hardenability is sufficient if the carbon
equivalent, C
eq, is > 0.60, preferably > 0.62, wherein:

[0063] If the steel contains niobium, then the hardenable steel (composition) preferably
displays sufficient hardenability if the following relationship is satisfied:

preferably

wherein

Aluminium
[0064] Aluminium is used as a deoxidation (killing) agent. However, too high levels of aluminium
should be avoided, as it can impact on the hardenability/self-tempering properties
of the steel. Consequently, the preferable maximum aluminium levels are 0.2 %.
[0065] Preferably, aluminium is used in the range 0.01-0.1 %, more preferably from 0.01-0.06
%, most preferably from 0.015-0.045 %. These low aluminium levels are particularly
preferred when good electric resistance welding properties are desired.
Niobium, Titanium and Vanadium
[0066] Niobium and titanium control the texture of the steel after hot-rolling, and prevent
grain growth during the heating step prior to quenching. They are therefore helpful
in controlling the retention of properties of the hot-rolled steel during quench hardening.
However, excessive amounts can lead to precipitates forming, such as large titanium
nitrides which can negatively affect impact strength.
[0067] Generally, steels with a larger grain size have better hardenability. However, larger
grain sizes will increase the tendency for cracking during quench hardening. Titanium
and niobium reduce the rate of grain size growth at the austenising temperature, which
can reduce hardenability. This effect can be compensated for by ensuring that sufficient
alloying elements to obtain good hardenability are included in the steel, for instance
by ensuring that X
H is suitably high. When suitably formulated, control over grain coarsening provided
by titanium and niobium (particularly niobium) during austenisation can be advantageous,
allowing longer austenisation soak times (T
s) and/or higher temperature without significantly increasing the risk of hardening
induced cracking.
[0068] This makes it possible to combine, for example, hot forming, stamping and hardening
in one process step (i.e. hot press-forming or die quench method), making production
more cost effective. When hot press-forming, the steel can cool down rapidly during
transfer to the die and the hot forming die, for instance at rates of around 20°C/s.
Due to this, it is usually necessary to use a very high start temperature, to ensure
the steel remains at a suitable temperature (e.g. above the austenite temperature
A
r3) until quenching.
[0069] Preferably, titanium is present in the range of 0-0.1%, more preferably 0.001-0.05%,
more preferably 0.005-0.02%.
[0070] Preferably, Ti/N < 3.42.
[0071] If boron is not alloyed in the steel composition, it is desirable to ensure that
Ti/N ≤ 3.42. This will ensure a higher amount of small TiN precipitates, so as to
ensure the advantages of titanium may be obtained without a significant deterioration
of the impact strength.
[0072] Preferably, niobium is present in the range of 0.001-0.05%, more preferably 0.005-0.02%,
most preferably 0.008-0.015%.
[0073] Preferably, the hardenable steel (composition) contains at least one of titanium
or niobium.
[0074] Preferably, the hardenable steel (composition) contains niobium.
[0075] Niobium can affect the ductility of the steel, reducing its cold-formability. If
very demanding cold forming is needed prior to reheat-quenching, the hardenable steel
(composition) preferably has a niobium content of < 0.005%.
[0076] Vanadium increases hardenability, but vanadium carbides can be difficult to dissolve
during austenisation prior to quench hardening. These carbides can act as nuclei for
ferrite crystals to grow during quenching. Consequently, vanadium content should preferably
be limited to ≤0.2 %.
[0077] Preferably, vanadium is optionally present at levels of ≤0.15%, more preferably ≤0.10%,
more preferably ≤0.06%, most preferably ≤0.04%.
[0078] Due to the difficulty of dissolving vanadium carbides, these lower vanadium contents
are particularly preferred when the soak temperature (T
S) is low and soak time (t
S) is relatively short.
Copper and Nickel
[0079] As noted above, nickel has a positive influence on the impact strength of the martensitic
steel.
[0080] Copper is preferably optionally present at ≤ 0.4%, more preferably ≤ 0.1%.
[0081] Nickel is preferably optionally present at ≤ 0.4%, more preferably ≤ 0.1%.
[0082] Preferably, Cu+Ni ≤ 0.4%, more preferably ≤0.1%.
[0083] Copper has a tendency to phase separate and migrate to the surface (under the scale)
during processing above the melt temperature of copper, which can be harmful to the
surface quality when the material is hot formed. Nickel mitigates this effect, and
as such the Ni content is desirably at least 0.33*%Cu, preferably at least 0.50*%Cu,
when the %Cu ≥ 0.2.
Boron, Tungsten and Cobalt
[0084] Boron and tungsten can improve hardenability. However, they are typically not needed
as the hardenability of the steel is primarily provided by other elements. Moreover,
boron has a smaller effect on the hardenability of steels with higher carbon levels,
such as those disclosed herein. In order for boron to have an effect on higher carbon
steels, typically the nitrogen level must be low and/or the titanium content must
be high enough, which increases the likelihood of TiN precipitates forming. Boron
is therefore not harmful to the steel, it is simply not essential to provide the desired
balance of properties if there are not any coarse TiN precipitates present. Cobalt
is very expensive and typically unnecessary.
[0085] Preferably, boron is present at levels of 0-0.003%, more preferably 0-0.0005%, even
more preferably 0-0.0002%.
[0086] Preferably, tungsten is present a ≤0.2%, more preferably ≤0.1%.
[0087] Preferably, cobalt is present a ≤0.2%, more preferably ≤0.1%.
[0088] Preferably, Co+W ≤0.5%, more preferably ≤0.3%, more preferably ≤0.1%.
Residual Contents and Unavoidable Impurities
[0089] Residual contents include contents that may unavoidably exist in the steel, i.e.
alloying elements having residual contents are not purposefully added.
[0090] Unavoidable impurities can be phosphorus (P), sulphur (S), nitrogen (N), hydrogen
(H), oxygen (O), calcium (Ca), and rare earth metals (REM) or the like. Their contents
are preferably limited as follows in order to ensure the properties of the hardenable
steel (composition):

preferably ≤ 0.015%, more preferably ≤0.12%, most preferably

(lower levels are particularly required when the steel is tempered)

preferably ≤ 0.010%, more preferably ≤ 0.005%

preferably ≤ 0.006%,

(typically used to control sulphur and oxygen level)

[0091] The difference between residual contents and unavoidable impurities is that residual
contents are controlled quantities of alloying elements, which are not considered
to be impurities. A residual content is normally controlled by an industrial process
does not have an essential effect upon the alloy. The levels of residual contents
of hardenable steels are typically low.
[0092] The martensitic start temperature (M
S) of the hardenable steel (composition) is preferably ≥ 340°C, more preferably ≥ 350°C,
more preferably ≥ 360°C, more preferably ≥ 370°C, most preferably ≥ 375°C.
[0093] For the purposes of this disclosure, the martensite start temperature M
S may be calculated as:

Method for Producing the Hardenable Steel
[0094] The hardenable steel (composition) disclosed herein is formed by hot-rolling (e.g.
the above composition) and cooling to form a hardenable steel product. The actual
process steps used to form the steel product can vary, as can the microstructure of
the resultant steel prior to quench hardening. The steel product is preferably hot
rolled, though cold rolling (for instance skin rolling) can be carried out prior to
hardening.
[0095] Preferably, the steel product is hot rolled (i.e. no cold rolling is carried out).
[0096] Preferably, the hardenable steel (composition) is hot rolled.
[0097] Typical process steps for forming the hardenable steel product comprise the following
steps in the given sequence:
- i. providing a steel slab (e.g. consisting of the chemical composition disclosed herein)
at a temperature in the range of 950-1350°C;
- ii. hot-rolling in a temperature range of Ar1 to 1300°C (preferably Ar3 to 1300°C) to obtain a hot-rolled steel;
- iii. cooling and optionally coiling the hot-rolled steel to provide a hardenable steel
product;
- iv. optionally processing the hardenable steel product to form a component therefrom.
[0098] The step of providing a steel slab may comprise forming a melt (e.g. from suitable
components that combine to make the hardenable steel composition), and extruding the
melt directly into the hot rolling. Alternatively, the step may comprise providing
a preformed slab (or billet) of the hardenable steel composition and heating it to
the required temperature prior to hot rolling.
[0099] The conditions used in the hot rolling step may be adjusted accordingly to ensure
that the resultant steel has the desired balance of strength and flexibility. Likewise,
the cooling steps following hot rolling are not critical, and may be suitably adjusted
to provide the desired microstructure of the hot-rolled product.
[0100] The hardenability properties (hardness after quenching, tendency to form cracks)
are influenced by the grain size of the hardenable steel. Typical average austenite
grain size for the hardened steel is ≤ 25 µm, preferably around 5-20 µm, more preferably
around 5-15µm. A suitable hot rolling protocol to form a product with this grain size
is as follows:
- Rough rolling the heated steel slab e.g. for seven passes, the optional first pass
being a calibration pass then followed by (preferably) six rough rolling passes each
having about 20-40% (preferably 30%) size reduction. The slab start temperature during
rough rolling is preferably from 1100-1300°C, preferably 1230-1280°C
- Finish rolling through (e.g.) six rollers, the size reduction on the first roller
being about 25-60% (preferably 30-50%), which gradually reduces to about 5-20% (preferably
10-15%) on the final roller. The finish rolling temperature is preferably 800-950°C,
preferably 860-930°C
- Coiling at 580-750°C, preferably 650-720°C, then air cooling
[0101] The purpose of the rough rolling is to compress the slab and remove any porosity
that may still be present following the slab formation. The finish rolling refines
the grain sizes in the steel.
[0102] The coiling temperature influences the predominant phase in the final steel. Coiling
at 650-750°C (e.g. about 720°C) will promote ferrite and pearlite and provide a softer,
more malleable material. However, these higher coiling temperatures will typically
lead to more scale at the surface of the steel. Coiling at 580-650°C (e.g. about 630°C)
reduces the likelihood of scale formation and promotes some bainite growth giving
a favourable balance of properties.
[0103] Coiling at temperatures below 580°C (particularly below 500°C) promotes growth of
high levels of bainite, which will make the resultant product less formable and potentially
more difficult to process into a component prior to quench hardening. A high cooling
rate and coiling at a temperature below M
S promotes high levels of martensite, which increases the risk of cracks forming in
the coiled strip.
[0104] Typically, the hot-rolling comprises hot-rolling to form a steel strip having a thickness
of 2-15 mm, preferably 2-12 mm. Cold rolling may optionally be carried out, particularly
if a strip with thickness < 2 mm is desired. Alternatively, the hot rolling may form
a plate having thickness of from 3-80 mm, preferably from 4-50 mm, more preferably
5-15 mm. The issue of crack hardening is most problematic for thicker samples. Consequently,
the steel of the disclosure shows most significant advantages for thicker samples.
Preferably, the thickness of the steel is at least 5 mm, more preferably at least
6 mm, more preferably at least 6.5 mm, and even more preferably at least 7 mm.
[0105] Preferred thicknesses therefore include 5-15 mm, more preferably 6-12 mm.
[0106] These preferred thicknesses also relate to components formed from the steel. However,
in the case of the component, the thickness may vary across the component, for instance
if part of the component has been machined to form an edge. Preferably therefore the
component has a maximum thickness of at least 5 mm, more preferably at least 6 mm,
more preferably at least 6.5 mm, and even more preferably at least 7 mm.
[0107] Preferably the component has a minimum thickness of at least 5 mm, more preferably
at least 6 mm, more preferably at least 6.5 mm, and even more preferably at least
7 mm.
[0108] By "maximum thickness" is meant the thickness of the thickest part of the component.
[0109] By "minimum thickness" is meant the thickness of the thinnest part of the component.
[0110] If a strip product is formed, coiling the strip at around 700°C will typically form
a two-phase composition containing ferrite and pearlite. Coiling the strip at lower
temperatures, such as around 600°C, will typically promote bainite to form in addition
to ferrite and pearlite. Lower coiling temperatures also promote a finer grain size.
[0111] The microstructure of the hot-rolled product may therefore vary depending on the
process conditions used. The microstructure is typically tailored to provide the right
balance of properties to enable the material to be formed into the desired product
prior to quench hardening. The resultant steel is usually relatively soft (typical
Vickers hardness levels range from 200-300 Hv10, preferably from 200-250 Hv10), typically
with good flexibility (such as a bend radius of 2t when edges of the steel are machined),
and medium-high strength (tensile strength 600-1000 MPa) so as to allow easy processing
before quench hardening.
[0112] The properties of the hot rolled product may also be tailored by adjusting the microalloying
elements. For instance, if very good fold forming properties are required, then niobium
levels should be minimised, or preferably niobium should be avoided.
Processing the Steel
[0113] The optional processing steps can vary and may include machining, cutting (e.g. by
oxy-fuel, plasma, waterjet or laser cutting), grinding (e.g. sharpening of a tool
edge to form a blade), and cold forming (e.g. bending, flanging or the like).
[0114] Once formed into the final component, the material may be (reheat) quench hardened
to form the final product. Quench hardening is carried out using a process comprising:
- a. providing a component formed from a hardenable steel composition;
- b. heating at least a region of the component to a temperature (TS) above Ac3;
- c. quenching said region using a quenching fluid; and
- d. optionally tempering the quenched region.
[0115] An alternative process comprises the steps of:
a'. providing a component formed from a hardenable steel;
b'. heating at least a region of the component to a temperature (TS) above Ac3;
c'. quenching said region using a quenching fluid to form a hardened region; and
d'. optionally tempering the hardened region;
[0116] The step a. (or a'.) of providing a component can comprise any or all of the steps
i.-iv. set out above, and particularly step iv. set out above.
Reheat-Quench Hardening
[0117] In step b. (or b'.), the component or a region thereof is then heated to a temperature
(T
S) above A
c3, i.e. the austenisation temperature. At this temperature, the microstructure of the
steel becomes 100% austenite, although some carbides and/or nitrides such as VC, NbC,
MoC, and TiN may remain undissolved. To enable this reaction to take place, the process
preferably includes a soaking step (c. or c'.) after heating and before quenching,
in which the component is held at a temperature above A
r3 for a soak time t
S.
[0118] The heat temperature (T
S) will depend primarily on the composition of the hardenable steel. Generally speaking,
a lower Mo content allows a lower T
S to be used. Preferably, T
S is above 850°C, preferably above 900°C, more preferably above 950°C.
[0119] If T
S is ≥ 950°C, the hardenable steel (composition) preferably contains Ti and/or Nb.
[0120] If T
S is too high, the rate of decarburisation at the surface of the component can become
problematic, particularly if the soaking atmosphere is air. Likewise, crystal grain
growth can also occur, so excessively high T
S levels are to be avoided for steels that do not contain Nb and/or Ti.
[0121] Preferably, an upper value for T
S is 1050°C, preferably 1000°C. If higher temperatures are used, the soaking time should
be kept as short as possible and optionally a protective atmosphere (i.e. an inert
gas or vacuum) should be used.
[0122] The optional soak time t
S will vary depending on the shape size of the component. The soak time will typically
be long enough to ensure complete austenisation, but not too long so as to avoid excessive
grain growth. Excessive soak times beyond those needed to ensure complete austenisation
moreover increase the costs unnecessarily.
[0123] Nevertheless, by way of guidance, a soak time for a component having a maximum thickness
of 6mm would typically be around 12 minutes when the temperature of the soak furnace
is about 950°C. Most components are therefore completely austenised when the soak
time is 30 minutes or less, preferably 20 minutes or less.
[0124] The soak media is not critical, and air, inert gas or a vacuum may be used, preferably
air. For higher soak temperatures or very long soak times, an inert gas or vacuum
should be used as the soak media, to mitigate the risk of decarburisation.
[0125] Where only a portion of the component is being heated (for example only the surface
region or a particular part such as a blade edge), the soak time will be correspondingly
less, such as 2 minutes or less, preferably 1 minute or less. This ensures that only
the area of interest reaches the austenising temperature, and excessive heat transfer
to other regions is avoided.
[0126] The sample may be heated by any suitable means. When the entire component is being
heated, a furnace is typically used. When only part of the component is being heated,
only that part may be placed in the furnace. More typically, localised heating may
be used, such as induction heating or a flame.
[0127] Preferably, the furnace temperature and the temperature of the soak medium will be
above T
S. For instance, a component being heated to around 930°C will typically be heated/soaked
in a furnace set to 950°C.
[0128] Higher soak temperatures are typically used when the product is to be processed during
soaking to form the final component. For instance, the steel product may be in the
form of a blank which is heated then processed (e.g. by hot stamping) to form the
final component, which is then quench cooled. Since it is typically not possible to
carry out these processing steps in a heating furnace, higher soak temperatures are
required to ensure that the residual heat in the product keeps the temperature of
the final component above A
r3 throughout the processing steps prior to quenching. If multiple process steps are
to be carried out, the steel product may be placed in the furnace between processing
steps to ensure its temperature is maintained suitable high. In any event, the temperature
should be maintained above A
r3 prior to quenching.
[0129] Preferably, the steel is 100% austenite after step b. (or b'.) and optional step
c. (or c'.).
[0130] During soaking, any molybdenum carbide in the austenite dissolves to form free molybdenum
atoms. Preferably, after soaking, the heated region of the steel does not contain
any molybdenum carbide.
[0131] Other undissolved carbides can be desirable as they prevent grain ground and lower
the risk of hardening cracks forming. However, the can reduce hardness and also impact
strength. For instance, if the vanadium content is high, there can be a risk of having
a high amount of VC in the austenite, which can serve as a nucleation site for ferrite
when the steel is cooled. Consequently, after soaking the heated region of the steel
preferable does not contain any vanadium carbide.
[0132] After heating an optional soaking, the heated region is then quenched using a quenching
fluid. The purpose of quenching is to rapidly cool the austenised steel down to below
M
S, the martensite start temperature. The quenching (i.e. step d. or d'.) occurs directly
after steps b. and c. (or b'. and c'.), such that the temperature of the region does
not fall below A
r3 until the region is quenched.
[0133] Thus, in step d. (or d'.), the steel is quenched to below M
S. Preferably, the steel is quenched to below 100°C, more preferably the steel is quenched
to room temperature.
[0134] Without wishing to be bound by theory, the improved resistance to quench cracking
is believed to arise in part due to the influence the molybdenum has in promoting
self-tempering during the quenching. Once the steel is cooled below M
S, the majority of the austenite transforms into martensite very rapidly. The quenching
causes the steel to continue cooling, however there is a period where the steel is
at a temperature above room temperature but below M
S. During this time, the martensite undergoes self-tempering, that is tempering caused
by the residual heat retained in the steel rather than heat which is externally applied.
[0135] A higher M
S temperature will promote self-tempering at an earlier stage as the steel cools. Mn,
Cr and Ni have a bigger impact on M
S than Mo has, so the steel of the disclosure provides good hardenability in combination
with a relatively high M
S. Due to the relatively high M
S temperature in the steel of the disclosure, the steel undergoes more extensive self-tempering
during quenching. Moreover, the lower carbon levels at the surface due to decarburisation
raise the M
S in these regions, which further helps to lengthen the time that the surface undergoes
self-tempering.
[0136] The self-tempering promoted by molybdenum helps relieve internal stresses as the
steel is cooled. Moreover, molybdenum also helps improve the impact strength of the
quenched steel, decreasing the brittle to ductile transition temperature in a Charpy-V
impact test.
[0137] The quench media may be any suitable media to ensure rapid cooling of the component,
i.e. a cooling rate of > 20°C/s, preferably > 50°C/s, more preferably >80°C/s. Suitable
quench media include oil or water, with water being preferred.
[0138] Agitating (or mixing/stirring) the water will increase the cooling rate even further.
Suitable means for agitating the quench water include a propeller.
[0139] By "water" as the quench media is meant water or salt water (i.e. brine).
[0140] After quenching, the region of the component subjected to quench hardening has a
martensitic microstructure. Preferably, the microstructure of the region comprises
≥ 90 martensite, preferably ≥95% martensite, more preferably ≥98% martensite, more
preferably ≥99% martensite, more preferably ≥99.5% martensite, most preferably 100%
martensite.
[0141] The martensitic region can contain precipitates such as carbides including (for example)
MoC, NbC, TiC, NbTiC, and VC, and nitrides including (for example) TiN and VN, as
well as carbonitrides.
[0142] The hardened region is preferably crack-free, and advantageously crack-free without
the need for any tempering steps.
[0143] The Vickers hardness of the region is preferably ≥ 630 Hv10, preferably ≥650 Hv10,
more preferably ≥ 670 Hv10, even more preferably ≥700 Hv10.
[0144] Vickers hardness may be measured using standard SFS EN ISO 6507-1:2006, for instance
using a DuraScan 80 as a hardness meter.
[0145] The hardness of a steel can vary according to the depth from the surface. Typically,
the surface hardness is slightly lower, as the surface may decarburize during austenisation.
Likewise, the centre of the steel cools more slowly, so the hardness at the centre
is typically lower.
[0146] As used herein, the hardness of the steel is preferably the hardness at ¼ the sample
thickness or 4 mm from the surface, whichever is less.
[0147] Preferably, for samples <12 mm in thickness, the average hardness of the sample is
preferably ≥ 630 Hv10, preferably ≥650 Hv10, more preferably ≥ 670 Hv10, even more
preferably ≥700 Hv10.
[0148] As used herein, the "average hardness" corresponds to the mean of several hardness
measurements taken at points evenly spaced through the samples thickness, for instance
every 1 mm starting 0.5 mm from the surface, preferably starting 1 mm from the surface.
[0149] More preferably, for samples <12 mm in thickness, the entire thickness of the sample
is preferably ≥ 630 Hv10, preferably ≥650 Hv10, more preferably ≥ 670 Hv10, even more
preferably ≥700 Hv10.
[0150] To measure the hardness at a given depth, the steel sample is preferably cut in two
across its thickness (i.e. perpendicular to a surface), then the hardness is measured
on the exposed face which transverses the steel.
[0151] The hardened region (e.g. a ≥ 5mm sample quenched with water) preferably has a median
Charpy V impact strength of ≥ 3 J/cm
2 at 20°C, preferably ≥ 6J/cm
2 at 20°C, preferably ≥ 12 J/cm
2 at 20°C and more preferably ≥ 18 J/cm
2 at 20°C.
[0152] The Charpy V impact strength may be measured using standard ISO 148 at 20°C (e.g.
IS0148:2010). Any suitable sample size in accordance with the standard can in principle
be used (e.g. 5 mm, 7.5 mm or 10 mm), although a 5 mm sample is typical. Typically
at least three (preferably at least five) measurements are taken, with the test specimen
taken being longitudinal to the main hot rolling direction.
[0153] Tempering of the quenched steel reduces the hardness, but increases the impact strength.
Likewise, quenching with oil will produce a less hard steel with a higher impact strength.
The advantage of the steel of the disclosure is not merely the high hardness or high
impact strength, but the combination of both properties which may be optimised relative
to one another by tempering.
[0154] The applicant has found that the relationship between the hardness and impact strength
may preferably be characterised as follows:

where
VJ is the Charpy V impact strength in J/cm2
Hv10 is the Vickers Hardness
AX = 95, and
HX = 0.125.
[0155] Preferably, A
X is 97.5 and H
X is 0.125.
[0156] Preferably, A
X is 100 and H
X is 0.125.
[0157] More preferably, A
X is 165.8 and H
X is 0.2156.
[0158] More preferably, A
X is 192.5 and H
X is 0.2508.
[0159] More preferably, A
X is 218.8 and H
X is 0.2855.
[0160] Plots of these relationships are shown in Figure 1. Thus, the hardened steels according
to the disclosure have a combination of impact strength and hardness that falls to
the right (or above) the various plotted lines. It should be noted that the higher
values of A
X are typically only achievable when the steel is quenched with water and tempered
following hardening.
[0161] Preferably, the entire component is quenched in step d. (or d'.).
[0162] Preferably, the entire component is tempered in step e. (or e'.).
[0163] Preferably, the entire component is reheat-quench hardened.
[0164] Preferably, the entire component has a hardness of ≥ 630 Hv10, preferably ≥650 Hv10,
more preferably ≥ 670 Hv10, even more preferably ≥700 Hv10.
[0165] If just a region of the product such as the surface or a blade edge, the product
may need to be processed differently during the hot rolling stages to ensure the final
product has the desired properties. For instance, if the hot rolled product is air
cooled following hot rolling, the overall properties vary depending on the balance
of ferrite, pearlite and bainite. However, typically speaking the steel does not possess
suitable structural properties for end use, as the resultant steel is generally quite
brittle. One possible option is therefore to quench the steel following finish rolling
to provide a hardened product which may be further processed then reheat-quench hardened
to form the final product. In these embodiments, the resultant quenched hot rolled
steel is not coiled, since the coiling process would likely fracture the quenched
steel.
[0166] If this methodology is used, the quench hardening following hot rolling is preferably
carried out with a cooling rate of 20-50°C/s, for example by quenching with oil. This
will form a product having a hardness preferably in the region of 475-560 Hv10 with
good impact strength. The material is therefore hard enough for most final uses, but
not so hard that it cannot be processed (for example cut or sharpened) into a final
component. Tempering may optionally be carried out at this stage to lower the hardness
and improve impact strength. A region (such as a blade edge) may then be reheat-quench
hardened with a cooling rate of > 50°C/s (for example quenching with water) to form
a region having higher hardness.
[0167] Optionally, the component may be tempered following quench hardening. Tempering may
be carried out by heating the component to a tempering temperature T
Q (preferably at a temperature of from 150°C to 700°C), holding the component for a
tempering time t
Q, then cooling the component down to room temperature. Preferably, the cooling following
tempering is done in air, preferably still air.
[0168] Tempering of the component reduces the hardness, but increases tensile strength,
ductility and toughness of the component. The molybdenum provides tempering resistance
(i.e. it helps to retain the hardness during tempering), especially at temperatures
well above M
S.
[0169] An advantage of the steel of the disclosure is that tempering is not essential to
prevent hardening induced cracking. Likewise, the impact strength is typically sufficiently
high even without tempering. Preferably, the only tempering done may be the heat treatment
to fuse any powder paint coatings on the component following quench hardening. Such
treatments are preferably carried out at around 175-225°C (such as 175-200°C or 200-225°C),
which is typically well below M
S. Following these treatments, the steel retains its martensitic structure and typically
has a hardness of ≥ 575 Hv10 (more preferably ≥ 600 Hv10, more preferably ≥ 625 Hv10
and with a high carbon content even ≥ 650 Hv10) together with acceptable other properties
like high impact strength, low brittleness and good tensile strength.
[0170] The balance of hardness and impact strength achievable using the steels disclosed
herein is often very desirable. However, there may be a need to provide an extremely
hard region which has lower impact strength, for instance at the edge of a blade.
Such components may be formed using the double quenching method set out above.
[0171] The disclosure consequently provides a method comprising the following steps:
- 1) providing a hardenable steel (composition);
- 2) heating the hardenable steel (composition) to a temperature (TS) above Ac3;
- 3) quenching hardenable steel (composition) in a first quenching step using a first
quenching fluid to form a component;
- 4) optionally processing the component;
- 5) heating a region of the component to a temperature (TS) above Ac3;
- 6) quenching the region in a second quenching step using a second quenching fluid;
and
- 7) optionally tempering the component;
wherein
the region does not encompass the entire component, and
the cooling rate in the second quenching step is >50°C/s, preferably >80°C/s.
[0172] In this method, steps 1)-3) may form part of the hot rolling process used to form
the steel. In which case, step 4) preferably comprises the mechanical processing steps
such as stamping, cutting etc. to form a final component, followed by optional tempering.
Alternatively, steps 1)-3) may be carried out on a preformed component, in which case
the method is essentially a double reheat-quench method. Even so, optional step 4)
may still include tempering, as well as some mechanical processing such as sharpening
of an edge.
[0173] The cooling rate in the first quenching step is preferably > 20°C/s, though higher
rates such as > 50°C or even > 80 °C/s are possible. If higher rates are used (> 50°C/s),
preferably step 4) will involve tempering, preferably tempering at > 300°C.
[0174] Preferably, the hardness of the component after step 4) will be from 350 to 600 Hv10,
preferably from 475 to 560 Hv10.
[0175] Step 5) involves heating a localised region of the component, such as by induction
heating or flame heating. This localised region is then quench cooled in a second
quenching step with a very fast quenching rate (> 50°C/s, preferably > 80°C/s). The
hardness of the region is preferably >630 Hv10, preferably ≥650 Hv10, more preferably
≥ 670 Hv10, even more preferably ≥700 Hv10.
[0176] The first and second quenching fluid may be the same. However, in this case, step
4) will preferably comprise tempering so as to reduce the hardness of the overall
component before the second quenching step.
[0177] Preferably, the second quench fluid is water. Preferably, the first quench fluid
is oil.
EXAMPLES
Example 1 - Laboratory Scale, Plate Rolled
[0178] Steels were made having compositions as set out in the following table:
|
1-A |
1-B |
1-C |
1-D |
C |
0.453 |
0.463 |
0.387 |
0.433 |
Si |
0.183 |
0.190 |
0.191 |
0.205 |
Mn |
0.245 |
0.246 |
0.468 |
0.251 |
Mo |
0.002 |
0.001 |
0.001 |
0.063 |
Cr |
0.063 |
0.218 |
0.213 |
0.079 |
Ni |
0.021 |
0.022 |
0.021 |
0.022 |
Al |
0.036 |
0.036 |
0.038 |
0.045 |
S |
0.0039 |
0.0038 |
0.0034 |
0.0043 |
P |
0.005 |
0.005 |
0.005 |
0.005 |
Ti |
0.012 |
0.012 |
0.011 |
0.012 |
Nb |
0.013 |
0.014 |
0.013 |
0.014 |
V |
0.001 |
0.001 |
0.001 |
0.031 |
Cu |
0.008 |
0.008 |
0.008 |
0.011 |
N |
0.0036 |
0.0032 |
0.0032 |
0.0044 |
TS1/°C |
910 |
910 |
910 |
930 |
TS2/°C |
980 |
980 |
980 |
980 |
[0179] Four billets of the steel were direct quenched after hot rolling in a lab scale process.
The billets were then reheat-quench hardened (using water) at the soak temperatures
(T
S1 or T
S2) shown in the table, two billets at each temperature. All billets of steel 1-D were
defect and crack free after quench hardening. Three of the four billets of steel 1-C
were defect and crack free. However one small crack occurred in one of the billets
of steel 1-C quench hardened from a soak temperature of 910°C. The remaining steels
all formed cracks during quench hardening.
[0180] Hardness tests to determine Vickers hardness were carried out according to standard
SFS EN ISO 6507-1:2006 using a DuraScan 80 as a hardness meter.
[0181] Figure 2 shows the plot of hardness vs. depth for an 8mm thick sample of steel 1-A,
with the hardness plotted as Vickers (Hv10) hardness, with the corresponding Rockwell
C hardness levels being shown. The measurements were taken by cutting the steel into
two and measuring the hardness on the exposed cut face which transverses the steel.
Figure 3 shows a similar plot for steel 1-B, while Figure 4 shows a similar plot for
steel 1-C.
These plots show the steels have relatively low hardness when quench hardened at 910°C.
Steel 1-B is able to obtain reasonable hardness at the surface when quench hardened
at 980°C, although the hardness is not retained through the entire thickness of the
sample. Steel 1-C obtains a similar hardness throughout the entire thickness of the
sample, but the hardness obtained is approximately 600 Hv10 (55 HRC).
[0182] Figure 5 shows the equivalent plot for steel 1-D according to the disclosure. The
plot clearly shows significantly higher hardness values which are retained through
the entire sample thickness. Figure 6 shows an equivalent result is obtained for a
12 mm thick sample.
[0183] Figure 7 shows the Vickers hardness at 2mm depth for samples of steel 1-D quenched
from T
S 980°C after tempering at temperatures of 150-600°C. The plot shows the steel shows
good hardness retention during tempering, retaining Rockwell hardness values of ≥
55 HRC when tempering at 200°C.
[0184] Impact tests were carried out according to standard ISO 148-1:2010 at a temperature
of + 20°C. The thickness of the specimens was 8 mm (6 mm thickness accounting for
the notch), and the values reported at then converted to J/cm
2. The results are shown in the table below:
Steel |
TS |
s/mm |
V-Notched |
Initial J |
Ave. |
Hv10 |
AX (HX = 0.125) |
1-A |
910 |
8 |
Yes |
300 |
47 |
260 |
80 |
1-A |
980 |
8 |
Yes |
300 |
9 |
325 |
50 |
1-B |
910 |
8 |
Yes |
300 |
52 |
280 |
87 |
1-B |
980 |
8 |
Yes |
300 |
9 |
560 |
79 |
1-C |
910 |
8 |
Yes |
300 |
23 |
310 |
62 |
1-C |
980 |
8 |
Yes |
300 |
11 |
600 |
86 |
1-D |
930 |
8 |
Yes |
300 |
7.3 |
740 |
100 |
1-D |
980 |
8 |
Yes |
300 |
7.3 |
740 |
100 |
[0185] The results show that steel 1-D has excellent impact toughness at both quench temperatures,
whereas the remaining steels only achieve good impact toughness in the notched test
at the higher quench temperature. Steel 1-D according to the disclosure achieves A
X values in line with the preferred ranges above for each value of H
X.
The impact strength of steel 1-D is relatively low, but it is still very good considering
the hardness. Tempering the steel reduces the hardness and increases the impact strength
Example 2 - Full Scale, Strip Rolled
[0186] Steels with similar compositions to 1-D were produced in a large scale (commercial)
facility. The steel compositions and their corresponding rolling conditions are summarised
in the following tables:
|
2-D |
3-D |
C |
0.4300 |
0.4140 |
Si |
0.200 |
0.186 |
Mn |
0.255 |
0.250 |
Mo |
0.699 |
0.664 |
Cr |
0.059 |
0.055 |
Ni |
0.050 |
0.061 |
Al |
0.034 |
0.034 |
S |
0.006 |
0.0011 |
P |
0.0070 |
0.0070 |
Ti |
0.0130 |
0.0120 |
Nb |
0.0130 |
0.0120 |
V |
0.0400 |
0.0400 |
Cu |
0.0140 |
0.0160 |
N |
0.0028 |
0.0046 |
Ca |
0.0018 |
0.0016 |
Steel |
Rough Rolling Temp (°C) |
Finish Rolling Temp (°C) |
Coiling Temp (°C) |
Rp0.2 Roll./Trav. (MPa) |
RM Roll./Trav. (MPa) |
2-D |
1085 |
890 |
725 |
436/437 |
680/654 |
2-D |
1095 |
875 |
630 |
528/552 |
737/730 |
2-D |
1085 |
890 |
720 |
431/447 |
682/673 |
3-D |
1090 |
870 |
630 |
489/532 |
696/699 |
3-D |
1090 |
890 |
720 |
407/451 |
644/660 |
[0187] To show the relationship between the hardness and impact strength of the reheat-quench
hardened steels, steel billets (8 mm x 65 mm x 150 mm) of steel 2-D were heated in
an air furnace at 980°C for 40 minutes then quenched with water. The resultant steels
were then tempered for 120 minutes at various temperatures. The hardness and impact
strength of the resultant hardened and tempered steels are shown in Figures 7 and
8. These values are summarised in the following table:
Tempering Temp. (°C) |
Hv10 |
Impact Strength (J/cm2) |
Ax (Hx = 0.125) |
- |
650 |
23 |
104 |
175 |
615 |
37 |
114 |
300 |
510 |
39 |
103 |
400 |
445 |
59 |
115 |
500 |
405 |
74 |
125 |
600 |
400 |
77 |
127 |
[0188] As shown in the table, the steel retains the high A
X value for all tempering temperatures, with a particularly good combination of values
being obtained for tempering at 175°C.
Example 3
[0189] Several quench hardenable steels with the following formula were compared to steel
2-D:
|
51CrV4 |
38MnB5 |
42MnV7 |
2-D |
C |
0.52 |
0.396 |
0.395 |
0.4300 |
Si |
0.233 |
0.183 |
0.159 |
0.200 |
Mn |
0.828 |
1.27 |
1.67 |
0.255 |
Mo |
0.010 |
0.001 |
0.007 |
0.699 |
Cr |
0.911 |
0.207 |
0.050 |
0.059 |
Ni |
0.044 |
0.034 |
0.046 |
0.050 |
Al |
0.028 |
0.039 |
0.037 |
0.034 |
S |
0.0025 |
0.0029 |
0.0069 |
0.006 |
P |
0.010 |
0.013 |
0.010 |
0.0070 |
Ti |
0.002 |
0.034 |
0.017 |
0.0130 |
Nb |
0.002 |
0.001 |
0.001 |
0.0130 |
V |
0.111 |
0.010 |
0.091 |
0.0400 |
Cu |
0.055 |
0.006 |
0.023 |
0.0140 |
N |
0.031 |
0.0014 |
0.0060 |
0.0028 |
[0190] Samples of these steels (5 mm thick, 8 mm thick for steel 2-D water quenched) were
reheat-quench hardened under various conditions, and the resulting hardness and impact
strengths are summarised in the table below:
Steel |
Quench Temp (°C) |
Quench medium |
Hardness* (HV10) |
Impact Strength (J/cm2) |
Ax (Hx = 0.125) |
51CrV4 |
1000 |
Oil |
704 |
5 |
93 |
38MnB5 |
1000 |
Oil |
603 |
13 |
88 |
42MnV7 |
1000 |
Oil |
621 |
10 |
88 |
42MnV7 |
1000 |
Water |
658 |
5 |
87 |
2-D* |
980 |
Oil |
523 |
43 |
108 |
2-D** |
980 |
Water |
650 |
23 |
104 |
2-D*** |
980 |
Water |
615 |
37 |
115 |
*Average measured hardness Hv10 through the thickness starting from 0.5 mm from the
surface (1 mm from the surface for 42MnV7)
** 8 mm thick sample
*** 8 mm thick sample, tempered for two hours at 175°C |
[0191] The 51 CrV4 and occasionally 38MnB5 steels could not be successfully water quenched
due to quench cracks forming. When oil quenched, both steels provided good hardness,
but relatively poor impact strengths.
[0192] 42MnV7 can be quenched with either water or oil, but the resultant steel has relatively
poor impact strength. Also, the water quenched steel has a high tendency to form cracks.
[0193] Steel 2-D can be quenched with either water or oil to give a steel with a better
combination of hardness and impact strength. Tempering the quenched steel reduces
the hardness, but increases the impact strength. No hardening induced cracks were
observed.
Example 4
[0194] Several 6 mm thick blanks were made from steel 2-D having dimensions of 310 mm in
the rolling direction (1010), and 300 mm in the longitudinal direction. To joining
edges were cut by flame cutting (1020), and two edges by mechanical cutting (1030).
Multiple 20 mm diameter holes were stamped in the test pieces, four holes 20 mm apart
in the centre forming a square, and two holes 10 mm from the edges at the corners
of the mechanically cut edges and flame cut edges, as shown in Figure 9.
[0195] 18 blanks were heated for 30 minutes at 980°C and quenched using still water to room
temperature (approx. 20-30°C). 9 samples were tempered within 5 minutes at 175°C for
2 hours. The samples were visually checked for cracks following quenching and optional
tempering, with no cracks being detected.
[0196] After five weeks, the samples were visually inspected again, with both sides of the
samples also being checked by magnetic-particle testing. Again, no cracks were detected
when assessed to standard ISO 23278:2015, Class 2X.