TECHNICAL FIELD
[0001] The present invention relates to a thick steel plate. In particular, the present
invention relates to a thick steel plate that is excellent in toughness in a weld
heat-affected zone (hereinafter, referred to as "HAZ"), that is used in marine structures
such as oil and natural gas drilling facilities at sea.
BACKGROUND ART
[0002] The requirements with respect to the toughness of a thick steel plate to be used
in various welded steel structures such as for architecture, bridges, shipbuilding,
line pipes, construction machinery, marine structures and tanks are becoming increasingly
stricter year by year to increase safety and reliability with respect to weld zones
fractures. In particular, securing excellent HAZ toughness is demanded in addition
to the toughness of the base metal steel plate.
[0003] In a HAZ, the heating temperature during welding increases at an area nearer to a
fusion line. In particular, in an area near the fusion line which is heated to 1400°C
or higher, austenite grains coarsen markedly. Consequently, the HAZ micro-structure
after cooling coarsens and the HAZ toughness deteriorates.
[0004] This tendency becomes more prominent as the welding heat input increases. In recent
years, high heat input welding operations that use a high-efficiency welding process
with an increased welding heat input are performed in order to reduce the number of
welding passes and lower the cost of the welding operation. Consequently, since a
reduction occurs in the HAZ toughness, various countermeasures are taken to improve
the HAZ toughness when performing high heat input welding.
[0005] The known methods for improving the HAZ toughness include, for example, methods that
control the grain diameter in a HAZ. Specifically, the methods that control the grain
diameter include a method that inhibits coarsening of austenite grains in the welding
heating process by dispersing a large amount of fine pinning particles in the steel,
and a method that promotes intragranular transformation in a cooling process of welding
by dispersing particles that act as nuclei for ferrite transformation in the steel
to thereby break up the interior of the grains.
[0006] For example, Patent Document 1 discloses a steel material in which oxides composed
of Mg, Mn and Al and composite inclusions which are composed of MnS and have a grain
diameter of less than 0.6 µm are dispersed and formed in an amount of 1×10
6 per mm
3 in steel materials. The steel material inhibits coarsening of prior-austenite grains,
and by this means secures excellent toughness even when high heat input welding with
input heat of 300 kJ/cm or more is performed.
[0007] Patent Document 2 discloses a thick steel plate in which a large amount of Mn oxides
and Al oxides that are liable to act as precipitation nuclei for MnS particles are
finely dispersed in the steel. The thick steel plate has favorable HAZ toughness even
when high heat input welding with input heat of 200 kJ/cm is performed.
[0008] In addition, Patent Document 3 discloses a steel plate having a plate thickness of
10 to 35 mm in which the particle size and number density of TiN particles, MnS particles
and composite particles having an equivalent circular diameter of 0.5 to 2.0 µm contained
in the steel plate are controlled to within predetermined ranges. The growth of austenite
grains in the steel plate is inhibited by a pinning effect when the steel plate is
heated by welding. In addition, when the steel plate is cooled after welding, the
micro-structure is refined by ferrite transforming to become nuclei. By this means,
the HAZ toughness during high heat input welding of the steel plate increases.
[0009] Patent Document 4 discloses a steel for a welded structure which includes the following
composition: by mass%, C at a C content [C] of 0.010 to 0.065%; Si at a Si content
[Si] of 0.05 to 0.20%; Mn at a Mn content [Mn] of 1.52 to 2.70%; Ni at a Ni content
[Ni] of 0.10% to 1.50%; Ti at a Ti content [Ti] of 0.005 to 0.015%; O at a content
[O] of 0.010 to 0.0045%; N at a N content [N] of 0.002 to 0.006%; Mg at a Mg content
[Mg] of 0.0003 to 0.003%; Ca at a Ca content [Ca] of 0.0003 to 0.03%; and the balance
composed of Fe and unavoidable impurities. A steel component parameter P CTOD is 0.065%
or less, and a steel component hardness parameter CeqH is 0.235% or less.
LIST OF PRIOR ART DOCUMENTS
PATENT DOCUMENT
SUMMARY OF INVENTION
TECHNICAL PROBLEM
[0011] In recent years, steel plates to be used in welded structures such as marine structures
are required to be thick-walled and have high strength. However, because such thick
steel plates are assembled by welding, ensuring the characteristics of weld zones
is a problem. In particular, if a thick steel plate having a plate thickness of 50
mm or more is welded by a single pass or a small number of passes, it is difficult
to secure the HAZ toughness because the heat input during welding increases.
[0012] An objective of the present invention is to provide a thick steel plate having excellent
HAZ toughness even when high heat input welding is performed.
SOLUTION TO PROBLEM
[0013] The present inventors conducted intensive studies to solve the above described problem,
and as a result obtained the findings described hereunder.
[0014] In a HAZ, grains grow by heating to the vicinity of 1400°C, and coarse austenite
grains grow. The growth of such coarse austenite grains is one cause of a decline
in the HAZ toughness. Therefore, refining the grains and decreasing a fracture unit
is effective as means for securing the HAZ toughness. As techniques for refining grains,
the known conventional techniques include (i) a technique that utilizes a pinning
effect which inhibits the growth of a prior-austenite grain boundary by means of TiN
or the like, and (ii) a technique that causes fine intragranular ferrite to grow using
inclusions that are present within prior-austenite grains as starting points, to thereby
refine the grains.
[0015] The present inventors found that by controlling balance between the contents of Ti,
Al, O and N during the steelmaking process, fine TiN particles that were caused to
be dispersed in the steel inhibit the growth of austenite grains in HAZs by a pinning
effect, and thereby inhibit the growth of coarse austenite grains.
[0016] On the other hand, because TiN particles melt easily in the vicinity of 1400°C, the
pinning effect decreases. As a result, coarse austenite grains are liable to grow.
Therefore, the present inventors conceived of also utilizing intragranular transformation
caused by inclusions in combination therewith.
[0017] Control of inclusions that act as formation nuclei for intragranular ferrite is effective
for effectively causing intragranular ferrite to grow within austenite grains during
welding. The following matters have been ascertained regarding the growth mechanism
of intragranular ferrite.
- [1] During welding cooling, a driving force that diffuses Mn from the matrix to the
inside of inclusions arises due to the gradient of the Mn concentration that is formed
when MnS compositely precipitates around the inclusions.
- [2] Mn is absorbed into atomic vacancies that are present inside Ti-based oxides.
- [3] An Mn-depleted zone in which the Mn concentration is reduced is formed around
the inclusion, and the ferrite growth-initiating temperature at that portion rises.
- [4] During cooling, ferrite grows with priority from the inclusions.
[0018] On the premise of the above facts, the present inventors found that the MnS composite
amount of an inclusion that serves as a nucleus of intragranular ferrite influences
the growth of the intragranular ferrite. In other words, when a large amount of MnS
is composited, the driving force that diffuses Mn increases because a larger Mn concentration
gradient is formed around the inclusion. As a result, an Mn-depleted zone is formed
more easily. On the other hand, when a small amount of MnS is composited, it is difficult
for a Mn concentration gradient to be formed around the inclusion. As a result, it
is difficult for an Mn-depleted zone to be formed.
[0019] In other words, by controlling the amount and number density of MnS that is composited
with inclusions, intragranular ferrite can be precipitated effectively.
[0020] In addition, the present inventors found that to obtain a grain refining effect,
it is necessary for the inclusions in the steel to satisfy the following requirements.
- (a) A composite inclusion in which MnS is present around a Ti oxide is contained in
the steel, with an area fraction of the MnS in a cross-section of the composite inclusion
being 10% or more and less than 90%, and the proportion that MnS accounts for in the
peripheral length of the composite inclusion being 10% or more.
- (b) The number density of the composite inclusions that have a grain diameter in a
range of 0.5 to 5.0 µm is in a range of 10 to 100 per mm2.
[0021] Based on the mechanism described above, according to the present invention the growth
of coarse grains is inhibited by TiN particles, the composite form of Ti-based composite
oxides is controlled, and the amount and number density of MnS that is composited
with inclusions is controlled to thereby effectively precipitate intragranular ferrite.
[0022] The present invention is based on the foregoing findings and is as enumerated hereunder.
- (1) A steel plate with a thickness of 50 mm to 100 mm, having a chemical composition
comprising, by mass%, C: 0.01 to 0.20%, Si: 0.10 to 0.25%, Mn: 1.30 to 2.50%, P: 0.01%
or less, S: 0.0010 to 0.0100%, Ti: 0.005 to 0.030%, Al: 0.003% or less, O: 0.0010
to 0.0050%, N: 0.0100% or less, Cu: 0 to 0.50%, Ni: 0 to 1.50%, Cr: 0 to 0.50%, Mo:
0 to 0.50%, V: 0 to 0.10%, Nb: 0 to 0.05%, and the balance: Fe and impurities, wherein:
a composite inclusion in which MnS is present around a Ti oxide is contained in the
steel; an area fraction of the MnS in a cross-section of the composite inclusion is
10% or more and less than 90%; a proportion that the MnS accounts for in a peripheral
length of the composite inclusion is 10% or more; and a number density of the composite
inclusions which have a grain diameter in a range of 0.5 to 5.0 µm is in a range of
10 to 100 per mm2.
- (2) The steel plate described in item (1) above, containing, by mass%, at least one
element selected from Cu: 0.01 to 0.50%, Ni: 0.01 to 1.50%, Cr: 0.01 to 0.50%, Mo:
0.01 to 0.50%, V: 0.01 to 0.10% and Nb: 0.01 to 0.05%.
- (3) The steel plate described in item (1) or (2) above, wherein a value X obtained
by formula (i) hereunder is in a range of 0.04 to 9.70:

where, the meaning of each symbol in the formula (i) is as follows.
Ti_TiO (mass%): Ti amount that becomes a Ti oxide among a total Ti content O (mass%):
O content in the steel
Mn_MnS (mass%): Mn amount that becomes MnS among a total Mn content
R1(%): average value of area fraction of MnS in a cross-section of a composite inclusion
R2(%): average value of proportion that MnS accounts for in a peripheral length of
a composite inclusion.
- (4) The steel plate according to any one of (1) to (3), wherein a lower limit of the
value X is 0.50 or more.
- (5) The steel plate according to any one of (1) to (4), wherein an upper limit of
the value X is 5.00 or less.
ADVANTAGEOUS EFFECTS OF INVENTION
[0023] According to the present invention, a thick steel plate is provided that has excellent
HAZ toughness even in a case where high heat input welding is performed.
DESCRIPTION OF EMBODIMENTS
[0024] The thick steel plate according to the present invention will now be described.
A. Chemical Composition
[0025] The operational advantages of each element as well as the reasons for limiting the
content of each element will now be described. The symbol "%" as used herein in relation
to the chemical composition or concentration means "mass%" unless specifically stated
otherwise.
[0026] First, essential elements will be described.
(A1) C: 0.01 to 0.20%
[0027] C has an action that enhances the strength of the base metal and a HAZ. In order
to secure strength of 400 to 500 MPa, the C content is 0.01% or more, and in order
to secure the strength of the base metal and a HAZ and to ensure the HAZ low-temperature
toughness, the C content is preferably 0.02% or more, more preferably is 0.05% or
more, and further preferably is 0.06% or more.
[0028] On the other hand, if the C content is more than 0.20%, a HAZ is liable to form a
hard micro-structure, and hence the HAZ toughness decreases. Therefore, the C content
is 0.20% or less, and in order to ensure the strength of the base metal and the HAZ
as well as the HAZ low-temperature toughness, the C content is preferably 0.15% or
less and more preferably is 0.08% or less.
(A2) Si: 0.10 to 0.25%
[0029] Si acts as a deoxidizer during production of the steel material, and therefore is
effective for controlling the oxygen amount, and also dissolves in the steel and increases
the strength. Therefore, the Si content is 0.10% or more, and in order to control
the oxygen amount to an appropriate amount and also secure the HAZ low-temperature
toughness the Si content is preferably 0.13% or more.
[0030] On the other hand, if the Si content is more than 0.25%, the toughness of the base
metal decreases and the HAZ is liable to form a hard micro-structure, and hence the
HAZ toughness decreases. Therefore, the Si content is 0.25% or less, and in order
to control the oxygen amount to an appropriate amount and also secure the HAZ low-temperature
toughness the Si content is preferably 0.18% or less.
(A3) Mn: 1.30 to 2.50%
[0031] Mn acts as an austenite stabilizing element, and inhibits production of coarse ferrite
at the grain boundary. Therefore, the Mn content is 1.30% or more, and in order to
inhibit production of coarse ferrite and also prevent segregation, the Mn content
is preferably 1.40% or more.
[0032] On the other hand, if the Mn content is more than 2.50%, Mn is liable to segregate,
and a HAZ is liable to partially form a hard micro-structure. As a result, the HAZ
toughness decreases. Therefore, the Mn content is 2.50% or less, and in order to inhibit
production of coarse ferrite and also prevent segregation, the Mn content is preferably
2.10% or less, and more preferably is 2.00% or less.
(A4) P: 0.01% or less
[0033] P is an impurity element. A decrease in the grain boundary strength in a HAZ is inhibited
by the P content decreasing. Therefore, the P content is 0.01% or less
(A5) S: 0.0010 to 0.0100%
[0034] S causes MnS to compositely precipitate. Therefore, the S content is 0.0010% or more.
In order to cause MnS to compositely precipitate and also secure the low-temperature
toughness of HAZs, the S content is preferably 0.0020% or more.
[0035] On the other hand, if the S content is more than 0.0100%, coarse singular MnS precipitates,
and consequently the HAZ toughness decreases. Therefore, the S content is 0.0100%
or less, and in order to cause MnS to compositely precipitate and also secure the
low-temperature toughness of HAZs, the S content is preferably 0.0050% or less.
(A6) Ti: 0.005 to 0.030%
[0036] Ti is essential for forming Ti-based oxides. The Ti content is 0.005% or more in
order to obtain a sufficient inclusion density, and in order to secure a sufficient
inclusion density and also ensure the HAZ toughness the Ti content is preferably 0.009%
or more.
[0037] On the other hand, if the Ti content is more than 0.030%, since carbides such as
TiC are easily formed, the HAZ toughness decreases. Therefore, the Ti content is 0.030%
or less, and in order to secure a sufficient inclusion density and also ensure the
HAZ toughness the Ti content is preferably 0.020% or less.
(A7) Al: 0.003% or less
[0038] Al is an impurity element. The formation of Ti-based oxides is inhibited by an increase
in the Al content. Therefore, the Al content is 0.003% or less.
(A8) O: 0.0010 to 0.0050%
[0039] O is essential for formation of Ti-based composite oxides. In order to obtain a sufficient
inclusion density, the O content is 0.0010% or more.
[0040] On the other hand, if the O content is more than 0.0050%, coarse oxides that can
become fracture starting points are easily formed. Therefore, the O content is 0.0050%
or less, and the O content is preferably 0.0030% or less in order to inhibit the formation
of coarse inclusions.
(A9) N: 0.0100% or less
[0041] N contributes to refining the grains by bonding with Ti to form TiN. However, if
the N content is more than 0.0100%, the Ti amount that is necessary for TiN precipitation
increases, and it is difficult for Ti oxides to be formed and the TiN also agglomerates
and becomes the starting point of fractures. Therefore, the N content is 0.0100% or
less, and in order to stably secure a Ti amount for forming Ti oxides the N content
is preferably 0.0080% or less, and more preferably is 0.0050% or less.
[0042] Next optional elements will be described.
(A10) Cu: 0 to 0.50%
[0043] Cu may be contained as required in order to increase the strength. However, if the
Cu content is more than 0.50%, hot embrittlement occurs and the quality of the slab
surface decreases. Therefore, the Cu content is 0.50% or less, and preferably is 0.30%
or less.
[0044] To reliably obtain the aforementioned effect, the Cu content is preferably 0.01%
or more, and more preferably is 0.25% or more.
(A11) Ni: 0 to 1.50%
[0045] Ni may be contained as required in order to increase the strength without lowering
the toughness. However, because Ni is an austenite stabilizing element, if the Ni
content is more than 1.50%, it is difficult for intragranular ferrite to be produced.
Therefore, the Ni content is 1.50% or less, and in order to promote production of
intragranular ferrite the Ni content is preferably 1.00% or less.
[0046] To reliably obtain the aforementioned effect, the Ni content is preferably 0.01%
or more, more preferably is 0.50% or more, and further preferably is 0.60% or more.
(A12) Cr: 0 to 0.50%
[0047] Cr may be contained as required in order to increase the strength. However, if the
Cr content is more than 0.50%, the HAZ toughness decreases. Therefore, the Cr content
is 0.50% or less, and preferably is 0.30% or less.
[0048] To reliably obtain the aforementioned effect, the Cr content is preferably 0.01%
or more, and more preferably is 0.10% or more.
(A13) Mo: 0 to 0.50%
[0049] Mo noticeably increases the strength when contained in a small amount, and hence
Mo may be contained as required. However, if the Mo content is more than 0.50%, the
HAZ toughness markedly decreases. Therefore, the Mo content is 0.50% or less, and
preferably is 0.30% or less.
[0050] To reliably obtain the aforementioned effect, the Mo content is preferably 0.01%
or more.
(A14) V: 0 to 0.10%
[0051] V is effective for improving the strength and toughness of the base metal, and hence
may be contained as required. However, if the V content is more than 0.10%, V forms
carbides such as VC, and the toughness decreases. Therefore, the V content is 0.10%
or less, and preferably is 0.05% or less.
[0052] To reliably obtain the aforementioned effect, the V content is preferably 0.01%
or more, and more preferably is 0.03% or more.
(A15) Nb: 0 to 0.05%
[0053] Nb is effective for improving the strength and toughness of the base metal, and hence
may be contained as required. However, if the Nb content is more than 0.05%, carbides
such as NbC are easily formed, and the toughness decreases. Therefore, the Nb content
is 0.05% or less, and preferably is 0.03% or less.
[0054] To reliably obtain the aforementioned effect, the Nb content is preferably 0.01%
or more.
(A16) Balance
[0055] The balance other than the above elements is Fe and impurities. The term "impurities"
refers to components which, during industrial production of the steel, are mixed in
from raw material such as ore or scrap or due to various factors in the production
process, and which are allowed to be contained in an amount that does not adversely
affect the present invention.
(B) Composite inclusion
[0056] A composite inclusion in which MnS is present around a Ti oxide is contained in the
steel. The area fraction of the MnS in a cross-section of the composite inclusion
is 10% or more and less than 90%. The proportion that MnS accounts for in the peripheral
length of the composite inclusion is 10% or more, and the number density of the composite
inclusions that have a grain diameter in a range of 0.5 to 5.0 µm is in a range of
10 to 100 per mm
2.
(B1) Area fraction of MnS in cross-section of composite inclusion in which MnS is
present around a Ti oxide: 10% or more and less than 90%
[0057] A composite inclusion which appears at an arbitrary cut section is analyzed. The
MnS amount in the composite inclusion is defined by measuring the area fraction of
MnS in the cross-sectional area of the composite inclusion. If the area fraction of
the MnS in the cross-section of the composite inclusion is less than 10%, the MnS
amount in the composite inclusion is small and a sufficient Mn-depleted zone cannot
be formed. Therefore, it is difficult to produce intragranular ferrite.
[0058] On the other hand, if the proportion that MnS accounts for in the cross-section of
the composite inclusion is 90% or more, the composite inclusion is mainly composed
of MnS, and the proportion that a Ti-based oxide accounts for decreases. Therefore,
because the Mn absorbability decreases and a sufficient Mn-depleted zone cannot be
formed, production of intragranular ferrite is difficult.
(B2) Proportion MnS accounts for in peripheral length of composite inclusion: 10%
or more
[0059] The MnS in the composite inclusion is formed around a Ti-based oxide. If the proportion
that MnS accounts for in the peripheral length of the composite inclusion is less
than 10%, an initial Mn-depleted zone that is formed at the boundary surface between
MnS and the matrix will be small. Therefore, since the amount of intragranular ferrite
that is produced will be insufficient even if welding is performed, favorable low-temperature
HAZ toughness will not be obtained. Therefore, the proportion that MnS accounts for
in the peripheral length with respect to the matrix of the composite inclusion is
10% or more.
[0060] The larger the proportion of MnS is, the larger the initial Mn-depleted zone becomes,
and the easier it becomes to produce intragranular ferrite. Therefore, although an
upper limit of the proportion of MnS is not defined, normally the proportion of MnS
is 80% or less.
(B3) Grain diameter of composite inclusion: 0.5 to 5.0 µm
[0061] If the grain diameter of a composite inclusion is less than 0.5 µm, the Mn amount
that can be absorbed from the area surrounding the composite inclusion will be small,
and as a result it will be difficult to form Mn-depleted zones that are necessary
in order to produce intragranular ferrite. On the other hand, if the grain diameter
of the composite inclusion is larger than 5.0 µm, the composite inclusion will become
a starting point for a fracture. As used herein, the term "grain diameter" refers
to a circle-equivalent diameter.
(B4) Number density of composite inclusion: 10 to 100 per mm2
[0062] To cause stable intragranular ferrite to be produced, it is necessary that at least
one composite inclusion is contained within prior-austenite. Therefore, the number
density of the composite inclusions is 10 per mm
2 or more. On the other hand, if the number of composite inclusions is excessively
large, the composite inclusions are liable to become starting points for fractures.
Therefore, the number density of the composite inclusions is 100 per mm
2 or less.
(C) Value X obtained by above formula (i): 0.04 to 9.70
[0063] In formula (i), the first term that is indicated by (Ti_TiO/O) represents the balance
between the Ti content and the O content that become Ti oxides. The first term is
calculated by deducting a Ti amount required for TiN formation that is calculated
based on the N content in the steel from the total Ti content. The larger the value
of the first term is, the easier it is for Ti oxides to form. When the first term
is a negative value, Ti oxides are not formed.
[0064] The second term that is indicated by (Mn_MnS) in formula (i) represents the Mn amount
that becomes MnS. The second term is calculated based on the S content in the steel.
The larger the value of the second term is, the easier it is for a large amount of
MnS to be composited.
[0065] In the third term that is indicated by [(R1+R2)/100] in formula (i), the symbol R1
represents the average value of the area fraction of MnS in a cross-section of composite
inclusions, and the symbol R2 represents the average value of the proportion that
MnS accounts for in the peripheral length of the composite inclusions. The larger
the value of the third term is, the greater the amount of inclusions in which a large
amount of MnS is composited is.
[0066] The value X obtained by formula (i) indicates the ease with which Ti oxides that
composite with MnS are formed, and also the degree of MnS compositing of the composite
inclusions that are formed. The larger the value X is, the greater the number of composite
inclusions in which a large amount of MnS is composited that are formed is, and the
easier it is for a fine micro-structure to form at a weld zone. Thus, the steel material
exhibits excellent toughness.
[0067] When the value X obtained from formula (i) is less than 0.04, the Ti amount required
to form Ti oxides, the S amount and Mn amount required for formation of MnS, or the
proportion that MnS accounts for is insufficient. In other words, the state is one
in which inclusions that are effective for intragranular transformation are not formed.
Therefore, in order to form effective Ti oxides, the value X is 0.04 or more, and
preferably is 0.50 or more, and more preferably is 1.00 or more.
[0068] On the other hand, when the value X obtained from formula (i) is more than 9.70,
agglomeration is liable to occur due to an excess of Ti oxides being formed. As a
result, inclusions become starting points for fractures due to coarse inclusions being
formed. In addition, since inclusions that are almost singular MnS inclusions are
liable to be formed, intragranular transformation is no longer promoted. Consequently,
coarse micro-structure increases, and CTOD properties deteriorate. Therefore, the
value X is 9.70 or less, more preferably is 5.00 or less, and further preferably is
4.00 or less.
(D) Plate thickness: 50 to 100 mm
[0069] Because the thick steel plate according to the present invention has composite inclusions
as described above, and the plate thickness is 50 mm or more, the HAZ low-temperature
toughness is excellent. In other words, in order to weld a thick steel plate having
a plate thickness of 50 mm or more with a low number of passes, it is necessary to
increase the heat input during welding. However, even when welding is performed with
a high heat input, the thick steel plate according to the present invention has excellent
HAZ low-temperature toughness.
[0070] However, when the plate thickness is too large, it is difficult to control the composite
inclusions, and producing a thick steel plate satisfying the aforementioned conditions
regarding composite inclusions that are defined by the present invention is difficult.
Therefore, the plate thickness of the thick steel plate is 100 mm or less.
[0071] Note that, the yield stress of the thick steel plate according to the present invention
is 400 to 500 MPa.
(E) Production Method
[0072] A method for producing the thick steel plate according to the present invention is
not particularly limited. For example, the thick steel plate can be produced by heating
a slab having the chemical composition described above, and thereafter subjecting
the slab to hot rolling, and finally performing cooling.
[0073] In the hot rolling process, the ausform rolling reduction, that is, the rolling reduction
at 950°C or less before accelerated cooling is preferably 20% or more. If the rolling
reduction at 950°C or less before accelerated cooling is less than 20%, depending
on the rolling the majority of dislocations introduced immediately after rolling may
disappear due to recrystallization, and therefore not function as nuclei for transformation.
As a result, the micro-structure after transformation coarsens, and in many cases
embrittlement caused by dissolved nitrogen is a problem. Therefore, the rolling reduction
at 950°C or less before accelerated cooling is preferably 20% or more.
EXAMPLE 1
[0074] The present invention will now be described more specifically by way of examples.
<Production of rolled base metal>
[0075] Steels having the chemical compositions of test number examples 1 to 28 and comparative
examples 1 to 18 shown in Table 1 were melted by an actual production process. In
the production process, Ar gas was blown into the molten steel from an upper portion
before a RH vacuum degassing process to cause a reaction between the slag on the surface
of the molten steel and the molten steel and thereby adjust the total Fe amount in
the slag.
[0076] The flow rate of the Ar gas was regulated within the range of 100 to 200 L/min, and
the blowing time period was regulated within the range of 5 to 15 min.
[0077] Thereafter, the respective elements were added in an RH vacuum degassing apparatus
for component adjustment, and a 300 mm slab was cast by continuous casting. After
casting, the slab was heated within a range of 1000 to 1100°C in a heating furnace.
After heating, hot rolling at 760°C or higher was performed until becoming a thickness
of 2t (t: final finishing plate thickness), and thereafter the slab was subjected
to hot rolling in a temperature range of 730 to 750°C until becoming the final finishing
plate thickness t. After hot rolling, the water cooling was performed at -2 to -3°C/sec
until the temperature became 200°C or less, and a specimen was prepared.
<Calculation of MnS area fraction in cross-section of composite inclusion, and proportion
MnS accounts for in peripheral length of composite inclusion>
[0078] The test specimen used for composite inclusion analysis was taken from a portion
that, when the plate thickness of the specimen is taken as "t", was at a plate thickness
of 1/4t. The MnS area fraction and the proportion that MnS accounted for in the peripheral
length of the composite inclusions were measured from a mapping image obtained by
performing area analysis of composite inclusions using an electron probe microanalyzer
(EPMA).
[0079] Specifically, the MnS area fraction was calculated by measuring the cross-sectional
area of the entire composite inclusion and the cross-sectional area that an MnS portion
accounted for in the entire composite inclusion from an image. The proportion that
an MnS portion accounted for in the peripheral length of the composite inclusion was
calculated by measuring the peripheral length of the Ti oxide in the composite inclusion
and the length of an MnS boundary surface that contacted the Ti oxide from an image.
To reduce variations in the measurements, the MnS area fraction and the proportion
that MnS accounted for in the peripheral length of the composite inclusions was determined
by performing analysis by EPMA for twenty composite inclusions per specimen, and calculating
the average values. The results are shown in Table 1.
<Calculation of number density of composite inclusions>
[0080] The number density of the composite inclusions was calculated by calculating the
number of composite inclusions whose grain diameter was in the range of 0.5 to 5.0
µm by means of an automatic inclusion analyzer combined with SEM-EDX, and from shape
measurement data of the detected composite inclusions. The results are shown in Table
1.

<Tension test>
[0081] A JIS No. 4 tensile test specimens was taken from a 1/4 t position when taking the
plate thickness of the prepared specimen as "t", and a tension test was performed
at room temperature, and the yield stress (YP) and tensile strength (TS) of the rolled
base metal were measured.
<CTOD test>
[0082] Test specimens for a CTOD test of a number n = 3 were taken from each of the prepared
specimens. Each test specimen was subjected to the preparation of a weld groove, and
multi-layer welding was performed with heat input of 5.0 kJ/mm by submerged arc welding
(SAW). The HAZ of the prepared welded joint was subjected to notching, and a CTOD
test was performed in conformity with the BS 7448 standard at a test temperature of
-20°C. A decision regarding whether the test result was a pass or fail was made based
on the criteria described below. Among the criteria described below, a test specimen
for which the decision was ⊙ or ○ was regarded as having passed the test. The results
are shown in Table 2.
⊙: All of the three test specimens were over the gauge
[0083] ○: Among the three test specimens, 0 to 2 of the test specimens were over the gauge,
and all of the test specimens that were not over the gauge had a CTOD value of 0.4
mm or more
×: Among the three test specimens, the CTOD value of at least one test specimens was
less than 0.4 mm
Note that, the term "over the gauge" means that an attached grip gauge could be fully
opened to the limit. Further, since the CTOD property of a joint at a typically required
temperature of -20°C is a CTOD value of 0.4 mm or more, the standard for the CTOD
value was made 0.4 mm.
[0084] The test results are shown in Table 2.
[Table 2]
[0085]
Table 2
| Test No. |
Strength (MPa) |
CTOD Test Result |
| YP |
TS |
n=1 |
n=2 |
n=3 |
Decision |
| Example 1 |
430 |
620 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
⊙ |
| Example 2 |
438 |
631 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
⊙ |
| Example 3 |
442 |
635 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
⊙ |
| Example 4 |
422 |
611 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
⊙ |
| Example 5 |
436 |
624 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
⊙ |
| Example 6 |
434 |
639 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
⊙ |
| Example 7 |
440 |
645 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
⊙ |
| Example 8 |
426 |
614 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
⊙ |
| Example 9 |
421 |
605 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
⊙ |
| Example 10 |
421 |
607 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
⊙ |
| Example 11 |
420 |
603 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
⊙ |
| Example 12 |
431 |
621 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
⊙ |
| Example 13 |
440 |
635 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
1.256 |
○ |
| Example 14 |
438 |
629 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
1.113 |
○ |
| Example 15 |
461 |
670 |
>1.4 |
0.681 |
1.052 |
○ |
| Example 16 |
463 |
671 |
>1.4 |
0.658 |
0.956 |
○ |
| Example 17 |
462 |
668 |
>1.4 |
0.551 |
0.638 |
○ |
| Example 18 |
431 |
622 |
>1.4 |
0.692 |
0.63 |
○ |
| Example 19 |
435 |
622 |
>1.4 |
1.029 |
0.79 |
○ |
| Example 20 |
440 |
632 |
>1.4 |
0.657 |
0.482 |
○ |
| Example 21 |
441 |
635 |
>1.4 |
0.784 |
0.821 |
○ |
| Example 22 |
442 |
635 |
0.893 |
0.742 |
0.691 |
○ |
| Example 23 |
441 |
630 |
0.998 |
0.851 |
0.744 |
○ |
| Example 24 |
445 |
640 |
0.759 |
0.846 |
0.951 |
○ |
| Example 25 |
451 |
681 |
0.567 |
0.513 |
0.612 |
○ |
| Example 26 |
440 |
635 |
0.511 |
0.419 |
0.425 |
○ |
| Example 27 |
435 |
661 |
0.564 |
0.558 |
0.981 |
○ |
| Comp. Ex. 1 |
469 |
681 |
>1.4 |
0.201 |
0.159 |
× |
| Comp. Ex. 2 |
470 |
680 |
0.156 |
0.264 |
0.258 |
× |
| Comp. Ex. 3 |
491 |
701 |
>1.4 |
0.269 |
0.357 |
× |
| Comp. Ex. 4 |
483 |
696 |
0.246 |
0.331 |
0.249 |
× |
| Comp. Ex. 5 |
461 |
668 |
0.229 |
0.344 |
0.094 |
× |
| Comp. Ex. 6 |
431 |
623 |
>1.4 |
0.321 |
0.249 |
× |
| Comp. Ex. 7 |
430 |
620 |
>1.4 |
0.194 |
0.106 |
× |
| Comp. Ex. 8 |
451 |
665 |
>1.4 |
0.173 |
0.167 |
× |
| Comp. Ex. 9 |
421 |
613 |
>1.4 |
0.153 |
0.154 |
× |
| Comp. Ex. 10 |
432 |
611 |
>1.4 |
0.142 |
0.268 |
× |
| Comp. Ex. 11 |
462 |
685 |
0.23 |
0.154 |
0.65 |
× |
| Comp. Ex. 12 |
469 |
700 |
0.124 |
0.223 |
0.315 |
× |
| Comp. Ex. 13 |
470 |
701 |
0.11 |
0.112 |
0.223 |
× |
| Comp. Ex. 14 |
471 |
703 |
0.134 |
0.168 |
0.226 |
× |
| Comp. Ex. 15 |
469 |
681 |
0.162 |
0.187 |
0.364 |
× |
| ">1.4" in the table indicates that the relevant result is over the gauge. |
[0086] The test specimens of examples 1 to 27 satisfied all conditions with respect to the
ranges of the present invention, and hence the result of the CTOD test for these examples
was "pass".
[0087] In example 9, although the CTOD test result was "pass", the YP and TS were low because
the C content was close to the lower limit value of the range of the present invention.
[0088] In example 10, although the CTOD test result was "pass", the YP and TS were low because
the Si content was close to the lower limit value of the range of the present invention.
[0089] In example 11, although the CTOD test result was "pass", the YP and TS were low because
the Mn content was close to the lower limit value of the range of the present invention.
[0090] In example 12, although the P content was small, the small P content did not influence
the result of the CTOD test.
[0091] In example 13, because the S content was close to the lower limit value of the range
of the present invention, the MnS composite amount decreased, and the MnS area fraction
in a cross-section of the composite inclusions as well as the proportion that MnS
accounted for in the peripheral length of the composite inclusions decreased. As a
result, in the CTOD test, only one test specimen was not over the gauge.
[0092] In example 14, because the Ti content was close to the lower limit value of the range
of the present invention, the number density of the composite inclusions was low.
As a result, in the CTOD test, only one test specimen was not over the gauge.
[0093] In example 15, because the C content was close to the upper limit value of the range
of the present invention, the amount of hard micro-structure increased. Consequently,
in the CTOD test, although two test specimens were not over the gauge, the CTOD values
were 0.4 mm or more.
[0094] In example 16, because the Mn content was close to the upper limit value of the range
of the present invention, segregation occurred. As a result, in the CTOD test, although
two test specimens were not over the gauge, the CTOD values were 0.4 mm or more.
[0095] In example 17, because the P content was close to the upper limit value of the range
of the present invention, the toughness decreased. As a result, in the CTOD test,
although two test specimens were not over the gauge, the CTOD values were 0.4 mm or
more.
[0096] In example 18, because the S content was close to the upper limit value of the range
of the present invention, the toughness decreased. As a result, in the CTOD test,
although two test specimens were not over the gauge, the CTOD values were 0.4 mm or
more.
[0097] In example 19, because the Ti content was close to the upper limit value of the range
of the present invention, the toughness decreased due to an increase in carbides such
as TiC. As a result, in the CTOD test, although two test specimens were not over the
gauge, the CTOD values were 0.4 mm or more.
[0098] In example 20, because the Al content was close to the upper limit value of the range
of the present invention, inclusions that act as intragranular ferrite formation nuclei
decreased, and as a result the toughness decreased. Consequently, in the CTOD test,
although two test specimens were not over the gauge, the CTOD values were 0.4 mm or
more.
[0099] In example 21, because the N content was close to the upper limit value of the range
of the present invention, TiN increased and, as a result, the toughness decreased.
Consequently, in the CTOD test, although two test specimens were not over the gauge,
the CTOD values were 0.4 mm or more.
[0100] In example 22, because the Cu content was within the range of the present invention,
the result of the CTOD test was "pass". Note that, because the Cu content was more
than 0.3%, the surface quality of the slab decreased, and it was necessary to repair
the surface during production.
[0101] In example 23, although the Ni content was within the range of the present invention,
because the Ni content was more than 0.4%, even though the result of the CTOD test
was "pass", there was little intragranular ferrite in the micro-structure and the
toughness was comparatively low.
[0102] In example 24, although the Cr content was within the range of the present invention,
because the Cr content was more than 0.3%, even though the result of the CTOD test
was "pass", the toughness was comparatively low.
[0103] In example 25, although the Mo content was within the range of the present invention,
because the Mo content was more than 0.30%, even though the result of the CTOD test
was "pass", the toughness was comparatively low.
[0104] In example 26, although the V content was within the range of the present invention,
because the V content was more than 0.05%, even though the result of the CTOD test
was "pass", a relatively large amount of VC precipitated and the toughness was comparatively
low.
[0105] In example 27, although the Nb content was within the range of the present invention,
because the Nb content was more than 0.03%, a relatively large amount of NbC precipitated
and, consequently, the toughness was comparatively low.
[0106] In comparative example 1, because the C content was outside the range of the present
invention, the amount of hard micro-structure increased, and as a result the toughness
decreased. Consequently, in the CTOD test, there was a test specimen for which the
CTOD value was less than 0.4 mm.
[0107] In comparative example 2, because the Si content was outside the range of the present
invention, the amount of hard micro-structure increased, and as a result the toughness
decreased. Consequently, in the CTOD test, there was a test specimen for which the
CTOD value was less than 0.4 mm.
[0108] In comparative example 3, because the Mn content was outside the range of the present
invention, segregation increased, and as a result the toughness decreased. Consequently,
in the CTOD test, there was a test specimen for which the CTOD value was less than
0.4 mm.
[0109] In comparative example 4, because the Ti content was outside the range of the present
invention, the toughness decreased due to an increase in coarse TiC. Consequently,
in the CTOD test, there was a test specimen for which the CTOD value was less than
0.4 mm.
[0110] In comparative example 5, because the Al content was outside the range of the present
invention, the toughness decreased due to an increase in coarse Al
2O
3. Consequently, in the CTOD test, there was a test specimen for which the CTOD value
was less than 0.4 mm.
[0111] In comparative example 6, because the O content was outside the range of the present
invention, coarse oxides increased, and as a result the toughness decreased. Consequently,
in the CTOD test, there was a test specimen for which the CTOD value was less than
0.4 mm.
[0112] In comparative example 7, because the Mn content was outside the range of the present
invention, the MnS area fraction in a cross-section of the composite inclusions was
lower than the range defined in the present invention. Consequently, intragranular
ferrite did not grow sufficiently and the toughness decreased. Therefore, in the CTOD
test, there was a test specimen for which the CTOD value was less than 0.4 mm.
[0113] In comparative example 8, because the Mn content was outside the range of the present
invention, the MnS area fraction in a cross-section of the composite inclusions was
more than the range of the present invention. Consequently, intragranular ferrite
did not grow sufficiently and the toughness decreased. Therefore, in the CTOD test,
there was a test specimen for which the CTOD value was less than 0.4 mm.
[0114] In comparative example 9, because the Mn content was outside the range of the present
invention, the MnS proportion at a boundary surface of the composite inclusions was
less than the range of the present invention. Consequently, intragranular ferrite
did not grow sufficiently and the toughness decreased. As a result, in the CTOD test,
there was a test specimen for which the CTOD value was less than 0.4 mm.
[0115] In comparative example 10, the Ti content was small and the number density of the
composite inclusions was less than the range of the present invention. Consequently,
intragranular ferrite did not grow sufficiently and the toughness decreased. Therefore,
in the CTOD test, there was a test specimen for which the CTOD value was less than
0.4 mm.
[0116] In comparative example 11, because the Cu content was outside the range of the present
invention, the strength increased, and as a result the toughness decreased. Consequently,
in the CTOD test, there was a test specimen for which the CTOD value was less than
0.4 mm.
[0117] In comparative example 12, because the Cr content was outside the range of the present
invention, the strength increased, and as a result the toughness decreased. Consequently,
in the CTOD test, there was a test specimen for which the CTOD value was less than
0.4 mm.
[0118] In comparative example 13, because the Mo content was outside the range of the present
invention, the strength increased, and as a result the toughness decreased. Consequently,
in the CTOD test, there was a test specimen for which the CTOD value was less than
0.4 mm.
[0119] In comparative example 14, because the V content was outside the range of the present
invention, in addition to the strength increasing, a large amount of VC was precipitated.
As a result, the toughness decreased. Consequently, in the CTOD test, there was a
test specimen for which the CTOD value was less than 0.4 mm.
[0120] In comparative example 15, because the Nb content was outside the range defined by
the present invention, a large amount of NbC precipitated, and as a result the toughness
decreased. Consequently, in the CTOD test, there was a test specimen for which the
CTOD value was less than 0.4 mm.
EXAMPLE 2
[0121] Similarly to Example 1, steels having the chemical compositions of test number examples
31 to 61 and comparative examples 21 to 32 shown in Table 3 were melted by an actual
production process, and specimens were prepared. Further, in a similar manner to Example
1, calculation of the MnS area fraction at a cross-section of composite inclusions
as well as the proportion that MnS accounted for in the peripheral length of the composite
inclusions, and calculation of the number density of the composite inclusions was
performed. The results are shown in Table 3.

[0122] Further, a tension test and a CTOD test were performed similarly to Example 1. The
test results are shown in Table 4.
[Table 4]
[0123]
Table 4
| Test No. |
Strength (MPa) |
CTOD test result |
| YP |
TS |
n=1 |
n=2 |
n=3 |
Decision |
| Example 31 |
420 |
630 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
⊙ |
| Example 32 |
412 |
621 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
⊙ |
| Example 33 |
431 |
642 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
⊙ |
| Example 34 |
412 |
620 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
⊙ |
| Example 35 |
425 |
621 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
⊙ |
| Example 36 |
435 |
644 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
⊙ |
| Example 37 |
431 |
641 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
⊙ |
| Example 38 |
430 |
627 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
⊙ |
| Example 39 |
400 |
600 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
⊙ |
| Example 40 |
402 |
603 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
⊙ |
| Example 41 |
403 |
606 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
1.28 |
○ |
| Example 42 |
446 |
652 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
⊙ |
| Example 43 |
441 |
655 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
1.13 |
○ |
| Example 44 |
443 |
651 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
1.16 |
○ |
| Example 45 |
437 |
649 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
1.19 |
○ |
| Example 46 |
445 |
654 |
>1.4 |
>1.4 |
1.11 |
○ |
| Example 47 |
432 |
651 |
0.84 |
0.94 |
1.23 |
○ |
| Example 48 |
431 |
647 |
0.71 |
0.88 |
1.03 |
○ |
| Example 49 |
452 |
661 |
0.56 |
0.61 |
0.84 |
○ |
| Example 50 |
441 |
641 |
0.66 |
0.88 |
0.91 |
○ |
| Example 51 |
438 |
635 |
0.55 |
0.58 |
0.62 |
○ |
| Example 52 |
436 |
637 |
0.86 |
0.88 |
0.98 |
○ |
| Example 53 |
435 |
641 |
0.67 |
0.77 |
0.98 |
○ |
| Example 54 |
425 |
635 |
0.51 |
0.72 |
0.82 |
○ |
| Example 55 |
439 |
647 |
0.56 |
0.63 |
0.71 |
○ |
| Example 56 |
416 |
625 |
0.55 |
0.63 |
0.74 |
○ |
| Example 57 |
442 |
635 |
0.97 |
1.36 |
>1.4 |
○ |
| Example 58 |
445 |
640 |
0.43 |
0.46 |
0.58 |
○ |
| Example 59 |
451 |
681 |
0.41 |
0.43 |
0.52 |
○ |
| Example 60 |
440 |
635 |
0.74 |
0.88 |
0.91 |
○ |
| Example 61 |
435 |
661 |
0.47 |
0.66 |
0.67 |
○ |
| Comp. Ex. 21 |
418 |
628 |
0.29 |
0.36 |
0.41 |
× |
| Comp. Ex. 22 |
413 |
615 |
0.21 |
0.23 |
0.36 |
× |
| Comp. Ex. 23 |
490 |
664 |
0.16 |
0.22 |
0.26 |
× |
| Comp. Ex. 24 |
419 |
617 |
0.25 |
0.34 |
0.41 |
× |
| Comp. Ex. 25 |
443 |
642 |
0.21 |
0.22 |
0.34 |
× |
| Comp. Ex. 26 |
424 |
634 |
0.31 |
0.36 |
0.37 |
× |
| Comp. Ex. 27 |
425 |
621 |
0.22 |
0.36 |
0.39 |
× |
| Comp. Ex. 28 |
462 |
685 |
0.28 |
0.61 |
0.99 |
× |
| Comp. Ex. 29 |
469 |
700 |
0.31 |
0.62 |
0.87 |
× |
| Comp. Ex. 30 |
470 |
701 |
0.09 |
0.22 |
0.34 |
× |
| Comp. Ex. 31 |
471 |
703 |
0.24 |
0.35 |
0.97 |
× |
| Comp. Ex. 32 |
469 |
681 |
0.22 |
0.31 |
0.91 |
× |
| ">1.4" in the table indicates that the relevant result is over the gauge. |
[0124] Examples 31 to 61 satisfied all conditions with respect to the ranges of the present
invention, and hence the result of the CTOD test for these examples was "pass".
[0125] In example 39, although the CTOD test result was "pass", the YP and TS were low because
the C content was close to the lower limit value of the range of the present invention.
[0126] In example 40, although the CTOD test result was "pass", the YP and TS were low because
the Si content was close to the lower limit value of the range of the present invention.
[0127] In example 41, although the CTOD test result was "pass", the YP and TS were low because
the Mn content was close to the lower limit value of the range of the present invention.
[0128] In example 43, because the S content was close to the lower limit value of the range
of the present invention, the MnS composite amount decreased, and the MnS area fraction
in a cross-section of the composite inclusions as well as the proportion that MnS
accounted for in the peripheral length of the composite inclusions decreased. As a
result, in the CTOD test, only one test specimen was not over the gauge.
[0129] In example 44, because the Ni content was close to the lower limit value of the range
of the present invention, the toughness decreased. As a result, in the CTOD test,
only one test specimen was not over the gauge.
[0130] In example 45, because the Ti content was close to the lower limit value of the range
of the present invention, the number density of the composite inclusions was low.
As a result, in the CTOD test, only one test specimen was not over the gauge.
[0131] In example 46, because the O content was close to the lower limit value of the range
of the present invention, the number density of the composite inclusions was low.
As a result, in the CTOD test, only one test specimen was not over the gauge.
[0132] In example 47, because the C content was close to the upper limit value of the range
of the present invention, the amount of hard micro-structure increased. Consequently,
in the CTOD test, although all of the test specimens were not over the gauge, the
CTOD values were 0.4 mm or more.
[0133] In example 48, because the Si content was close to the upper limit value of the range
of the present invention, the amount of hard micro-structure increased. Consequently,
in the CTOD test, although all of the test specimens were not over the gauge, the
CTOD values were 0.4 mm or more.
[0134] In example 49, because the Mn content was close to the upper limit value of the range
of the present invention, segregation occurred. Consequently, in the CTOD test, although
all of the test specimens were not over the gauge, the CTOD values were 0.4 mm or
more.
[0135] In example 50, because the P content was close to the upper limit value of the range
of the present invention, the toughness decreased due to segregation. Consequently,
in the CTOD test, although all of the test specimens were not over the gauge, the
CTOD values were 0.4 mm or more.
[0136] In example 51, because the S content was close to the upper limit value of the range
of the present invention, the toughness decreased due to segregation. Consequently,
in the CTOD test, although all of the test specimens were not over the gauge, the
CTOD values were 0.4 mm or more.
[0137] In example 52, because the Ni content was close to the upper limit value of the range
of the present invention, the toughness decreased due to formation of intragranular
transformation ferrite being inhibited. Consequently, in the CTOD test, although all
of the test specimens were not over the gauge, the CTOD values were 0.4 mm or more.
[0138] In example 53, because the Ti content was close to the upper limit value of the range
of the present invention, the toughness decreased due to an increase in carbides such
as TiC. Consequently, in the CTOD test, although all of the test specimens were not
over the gauge, the CTOD values were 0.4 mm or more.
[0139] In example 54, because the Al content was close to the upper limit value of the range
of the present invention, inclusions that act as intragranular ferrite formation nuclei
decreased, and as a result the toughness decreased. Consequently, in the CTOD test,
although all of the test specimens were not over the gauge, the CTOD values were 0.4
mm or more.
[0140] In example 55, because the N content was close to the upper limit value of the range
of the present invention, TiN increased and, as a result, the toughness decreased.
Consequently, in the CTOD test, although all of the test specimens were not over the
gauge, the CTOD values were 0.4 mm or more.
[0141] In example 56, because the O content was close to the upper limit value of the range
of the present invention, the toughness decreased due to an increase in coarse oxides.
Consequently, in the CTOD test, although all of the test specimens were not over the
gauge, the CTOD values were 0.4 mm or more.
[0142] In example 57, although the result of the CTOD test was "pass" because the Cu content
was within the range of the present invention, the toughness was comparatively low.
[0143] In example 58, although the result of the CTOD test was "pass" because the Cr content
was within the range of the present invention, the toughness was comparatively low.
[0144] In example 59, although the result of the CTOD test was "pass" because the Mo content
was within the range of the present invention, the toughness was comparatively low.
[0145] In example 60, although the result of the CTOD test was "pass" because the V content
was within the range of the present invention, the toughness was comparatively low.
[0146] In example 61, although the result of the CTOD test was "pass" because the Nb content
was within the range of the present invention, the toughness was comparatively low.
[0147] In comparative example 21, because the C content was outside the range of the present
invention, the amount of hard micro-structure increased, and as a result the toughness
decreased. Consequently, in the CTOD test, there was a test specimen for which the
CTOD value was less than 0.4 mm.
[0148] In comparative example 22, because the Si content was outside the range of the present
invention, the amount of hard micro-structure increased, and as a result the toughness
decreased. Consequently, in the CTOD test, there was a test specimen for which the
CTOD value was less than 0.4 mm.
[0149] In comparative example 23, because the Mn content was outside the range of the present
invention, segregation increased, and as a result the toughness decreased. Consequently,
in the CTOD test, there was a test specimen for which the CTOD value was less than
0.4 mm.
[0150] In comparative example 24, because the Ti content was outside the range of the present
invention, the toughness decreased due to an increase in coarse TiC. Consequently,
in the CTOD test, there was a test specimen for which the CTOD value was less than
0.4 mm.
[0151] In comparative example 25, because the Al content was outside the range of the present
invention, the toughness decreased due to an increase in coarse Al
2O
3. Consequently, in the CTOD test, there was a test specimen for which the CTOD value
was less than 0.4 mm.
[0152] In comparative example 26, because the N content was outside the range of the present
invention, agglomeration of coarse TiN occurred, and as a result the toughness decreased.
Consequently, in the CTOD test, there was a test specimen for which the CTOD value
was less than 0.4 mm.
[0153] In comparative example 27, because the O content was outside the range of the present
invention, coarse oxides increased, and as a result the toughness decreased. Consequently,
in the CTOD test, there was a test specimen for which the CTOD value was less than
0.4 mm.
[0154] In comparative example 28, because the Cu content was outside the range of the present
invention, the strength increased, and as a result the toughness decreased. Consequently,
in the CTOD test, there was a test specimen for which the CTOD value was less than
0.4 mm.
[0155] In comparative example 29, because the Cr content was outside the range of the present
invention, the strength increased, and as a result the toughness decreased. Consequently,
in the CTOD test, there was a test specimen for which the CTOD value was less than
0.4 mm.
[0156] In comparative example 30, because the Mo content was outside the range of the present
invention, the strength increased, and as a result the toughness decreased. Consequently,
in the CTOD test, there was a test specimen for which the CTOD value was less than
0.4 mm.
[0157] In comparative example 31, because the V content was outside the range of the present
invention, in addition to the strength increasing, a large amount of VC was precipitated.
As a result, the toughness decreased. Consequently, in the CTOD test, there was a
test specimen for which the CTOD value was less than 0.4 mm.
[0158] In comparative example 32, because the Nb content was outside the range of the present
invention, a large amount of NbC precipitated, and as a result the toughness decreased.
Consequently, in the CTOD test, there was a test specimen for which the CTOD value
was less than 0.4 mm.
INDUSTRIAL APPLICABILITY
[0159] According to the present invention, a thick steel plate can be provided that is excellent
in low-temperature toughness for a HAZ when high heat input welding is performed.
Therefore, the thick steel plate of the present invention can be favorably used for
welded structures such as marine structures, and particularly for thick steel plates
that have a plate thickness of 50 mm or more.