Technical Field
[0001] The present disclosure relates to an audio processor and a method of processing an
audio signal.
Background
[0002] A problem that often occurs with sound reproduction apparatus is that some part of
the apparatus, such as a cabinet or casing or the like, vibrates during playback of
audio. Common solutions to this include fitting vibration dampeners, such as felt
or rubber pads or the like, tightening screws or the like that hold the cabinet together,
or simply turning down the playback volume. However, such solutions are often not
convenient for the manufacturer and/or user of the apparatus.
Summary
[0003] According to a first aspect disclosed herein, there is provided a method of processing
an audio signal, the method comprising:
receiving an audio signal as an input;
processing the input audio signal to provide an audio signal to be output to a loudspeaker,
in which the processing of the input audio signal reduces the power of the input audio
signal at a resonant audio frequency and increases the power of the input audio signal
at at least some other audio frequencies other than the resonant audio frequency.
[0004] The reduction of the power, in particular the instantaneous power, of the input audio
signal at the resonant audio frequency can reduce or even entirely eliminate the resonance
being caused to some sound reproduction apparatus and therefore the vibration or buzzing
that can occur. The increase of the power of the input audio signal at at least some
other audio frequencies can help to "disguise" the reduction of the power at the resonant
frequency, which makes the reduction in volume at the resonant frequency less noticeable
for the user.
[0005] In an example, the resonant frequency is a resonant frequency of a cabinet in which
the loudspeaker is mounted, the resonant frequency being identified using a vibration
sensor which is attached to a cabinet in which the loudspeaker is mounted.
[0006] In an example, the output of the vibration sensor is subject to a Fast Fourier Transform
FFT to identify the resonant frequency.
[0007] In an example, the total or average power of the output audio signal is substantially
the same as the total or average power of the input audio signal. For example, the
total or average power of the output audio signal may be within around 5% of the total
or average power of the input audio signal.
[0008] In an example, the other audio frequencies are frequencies that are within 5% of
the resonant frequency. In an example, the other audio frequencies are frequencies
that are within 2% of the resonant frequency.
[0009] According to a second aspect disclosed herein, there is provided an audio processor
for processing an input audio signal, the audio processor being arranged to:
process an input audio signal to provide an audio signal to be output to a loudspeaker,
wherein the processor is configured such that the processing of the input audio signal
reduces the power of the input audio signal at a resonant audio frequency and increases
the power of the input audio signal at at least some other audio frequencies other
than the resonant audio frequency.
[0010] In an example, the processor is arranged to obtain the resonant frequency from data
storage in which the resonant frequency is stored.
[0011] In an example, the processor is arranged to obtain the resonant frequency using a
vibration sensor which is attached to a cabinet in which said loudspeaker is mounted.
[0012] In an example, the output of the vibration sensor is arranged to be subject to a
Fast Fourier Transform FFT to identify the resonant frequency.
[0013] In an example, the processor is configured such that the total or average power of
the output audio signal is substantially the same as the total or average power of
the input audio signal.
[0014] In an example, the processor is configured such that the other audio frequencies
are frequencies that are within 5% of the resonant frequency.
[0015] There may also be provided a sound reproduction apparatus, the sound reproduction
apparatus comprising an audio processor as described above and at least one loudspeaker
which is arranged to receive an output audio signal which is output by the audio processor.
Brief Description of the Drawings
[0016] To assist understanding of the present disclosure and to show how embodiments may
be put into effect, reference is made by way of example to the accompanying drawings
in which:
Figure 1 shows a schematic block diagram of an example of an audio processing arrangement
according to the present disclosure;
Figure 2 shows schematically a first example of a sound reproduction apparatus;
Figure 3 shows schematically a second example of a sound reproduction apparatus; and
Figure 4 shows schematically examples of waveforms for an input audio signal and a
corresponding output audio signal produced by processing the input audio signal.
Detailed Description
[0017] Examples of the present disclosure are applicable to audio processors for various
types of sound reproduction apparatus as well as being applicable to various types
of sound reproduction apparatus. Such sound reproduction apparatus typically includes
one or more loudspeakers. Herein, the term "loudspeaker" is in general used to describe
an electroacoustic transducer which converts an electrical audio signal into a corresponding
sound. The loudspeaker may be of the "dynamic cone speaker" type having a diaphragm
or cone which is driven to move by a voice coil. In other examples, the loudspeaker
may be of another type, including for example a magnetostatic speaker, an electrostatic
loudspeaker, etc. The sound reproduction apparatus may be a standalone system, such
as a combination of one or more speakers with a separate sound processing unit, or
an integrated system of speakers and sound processing unit (often called a "sound
bar" or the like). In other examples, the sound reproduction apparatus may be provided
as part of some other equipment, such as a television set, a computer, especially
a laptop or notebook computer or the like, etc., which has integral and/or separate
speakers.
[0018] As mentioned, a problem that often occurs with sound reproduction apparatus is that
some part of the apparatus, such as a cabinet or casing or the like, vibrates during
playback of audio, often giving rise to an audible buzzing of the equipment. This
is usually because of some resonance occurring at one or more resonant frequencies
during audio playback. This is often some resonance occurring in the cabinet or casing
in which the speakers are housed or some adjacent part of the cabinet or casing owing
to the natural frequency of the cabinet or casing or the like being excited.
[0019] Common solutions to this include fitting vibration dampeners, such as felt or rubber
pads or the like, or tightening screws or the like that hold the cabinet together.
This may be carried out by the manufacturer of the sound reproduction apparatus as
a final step in the manufacturing process. However, this is often not convenient and
is time-consuming, increasing the manufacturing cost. Moreover, the resonant frequency
may change over time and/or when the sound reproduction apparatus is deployed by the
end consumer or other user. End consumers or other users may try to fit vibration
dampeners or tighten up loose parts of the cabinet, etc., but this is inconvenient
and troublesome for the user. Another option for the end user is simply to turn down
the playback volume, but inevitably this spoils the enjoyment of the apparatus for
the user.
[0020] In examples of the present disclosure, an input audio signal is processed to provide
an audio signal to be output to a loudspeaker. The processing of the input audio signal
reduces the power of the input audio signal at a resonant audio frequency and increases
the power of the input audio signal at at least some other audio frequencies other
than the resonant audio frequency. The reduction of the power, in particular the instantaneous
power, of the input audio signal at the resonant audio frequency can reduce or even
entirely eliminate the resonance being caused to some sound reproduction apparatus
and therefore the vibration or buzzing that can occur. The increase of the power of
the input audio signal at at least some other audio frequencies can help to "disguise"
the reduction of the power at the resonant frequency, which makes the reduction in
volume at the resonant frequency less noticeable for the user. The other audio frequencies,
for which the power is increased, may be frequencies close to or adjacent to the resonant
frequency. The total or average power of the output audio signal is substantially
the same as the total or average power of the input audio signal.
[0021] Referring now to Figure 1, this shows a schematic block diagram of an example of
an audio processing arrangement 10 according to the present disclosure. The audio
processing arrangement 10 has an audio processor 12. The audio processor 12 receives
as an input an input audio signal 14. The audio processor 12 processes the input audio
signal 14 and outputs an output audio signal 16. The output audio signal 16 may then
be passed to a separate amplifier to be amplified as required before being passed
to one or more speakers for audio playback. Alternatively, the audio processor 12
may itself already amplify the output audio signal 16 as necessary.
[0022] The input audio signal 14 may be provided from one of a number of audio sources,
depending on for example the equipment in which the audio processor 12 is used. For
example, especially in the case that the audio processor 12 is part of a sound reproduction
apparatus used in conjunction with or as part of a television set, the input audio
signal 14 may be provided by a television broadcast signal (whether satellite, cable
or terrestrial), or by a DVD player or Internet source, etc., which is feeding the
television set. As other examples, especially in the case that the audio processor
12 is part of or used in conjunction with a computer, the input audio signal 14 may
be provided from files stored on the computer, such as video or audio files. As yet
other examples, the input audio signal 14 may be provided by a CD or MP3 or other
audio or media player. Other examples of sources for the input audio signal 14 are
possible.
[0023] Figure 1 also shows the audio processing arrangement 10 having a vibration sensor
18 which provides an output to a processing block 20 which in turn processes the output
of the vibration sensor 18 to identify one or more resonant frequencies. In some examples,
the processing block 20 may be provided as part of the audio processor 12. There may
be a single vibration sensor 18 or plural vibration sensors 18, located at different
positions, may be used.
[0024] As will become clear from the following discussion, the sensor 18 and the processing
block 20 in some examples are only used during a manufacturing stage to identify one
or more resonant frequencies at the time of manufacture. In such a case, of the components
shown in Figure 1, only the audio processor 12 needs to be incorporated into a sound
reproduction apparatus for end use by a user.
[0025] In other examples, the sensor 18 and the processing block 20 are incorporated with
the audio processor 12 into a sound reproduction apparatus for end use by a user.
[0026] In operation of an example, the vibration sensor 18 is fitted to some part of the
sound reproduction apparatus to allow one or more resonant frequencies of the sound
reproduction apparatus to be determined. The vibration sensor 18 outputs an electrical
signal that corresponds to vibration of the sound reproduction apparatus which occurs
when sound is being output. A particularly suitable vibration sensor for this purpose
is a piezoelectric transducer, though other vibration sensors, including other electroacoustic
transducers, may be used.
[0027] The processing block 20 receives the output of the vibration sensor 18 and processes
it to identify one or more resonant frequencies of the sound reproduction apparatus
when sound is being output. A number of techniques for this are possible. A suitable
technique is for the processing block 20 to carry out a Fast Fourier Transform (FFT)
to identify the resonant frequency or frequencies. An FFT samples a signal over a
period of time and divides it into its frequency components. These components are
single sinusoidal oscillations at distinct frequencies each with their own power or
amplitude (and phase). Large powers or amplitudes in any frequency or frequencies
of the output of the FFT processing block 20 indicate that the sound reproduction
apparatus, in particular part of the cabinet or housing or the like, is vibrating
a large amount, which can be taken to be vibration owing to resonance at the frequency
or frequencies having the large power.
[0028] In the case that the sensor 18 and the processing block 20 are used during a manufacturing
stage to identify one or more resonant frequencies, data concerning the identified
one or more resonant frequencies may be stored in some data storage associated with
or part of the sound reproduction apparatus so as to be accessible later by the audio
processor 12 during end use of the sound reproduction apparatus by the end user. An
example of such a sound reproduction apparatus is shown schematically in Figure 2.
In Figure 2, a sound reproduction apparatus 30, such as a television set, a computer,
a sound processing unit, etc., has a cabinet or casing 32 in which are mounted a main
processor 34 and data storage 36. In this example, the sound reproduction apparatus
30 has integral loudspeakers 38. In other examples, the loudspeakers 38 are provided
separately and connected to the sound reproduction apparatus 30 using wired and/or
wireless connections. The sound reproduction apparatus 30 also has an audio processor
12 as described herein. This may be a separate processor or its function may be provided
by the main processor 34. In such a case, the vibration sensor 18 and the processing
block 20 may be used during the manufacturing stage and are not (necessarily) provided
in the end product version of the sound reproduction apparatus 30 which is made available
to consumers or other end users.
[0029] Alternatively, the sensor 18 and the processing block 20 may be incorporated into
the sound reproduction apparatus for use by the end user. An example of such a sound
reproduction apparatus is shown schematically in Figure 3, in which the same reference
numerals are used for the same or corresponding parts as in the example of Figure
2 and the description thereof is not repeated here. In the example of Figure 3, the
sound reproduction apparatus 30 additionally has a vibration sensor 18 and a processing
block 20 as described herein. The processing block 20 may be a separate processor
or its function may be provided by the main processor 34 or the audio processor 12.
The vibration sensor 18 is fitted to the cabinet or casing 32 to detect vibrations
of the cabinet or casing 32. If the loudspeakers 38 are provided separately rather
than integrally in the cabinet or casing 32, a vibration sensor 18 may be fitted to
one or both loudspeaker cabinets instead of or in addition to a vibration sensor 18
fitted to the main cabinet or casing 32. In any event, in such a case the sensor 18
and the processing block 20 may be used during a preliminary set-up of the sound reproduction
apparatus when the sound reproduction apparatus is installed or deployed by the user
so as to identify one or more resonant frequencies. Again, the data concerning the
identified one or more resonant frequencies may be stored in the data storage 36 so
as to be accessible later by the audio processor 12 during end use of the sound reproduction
apparatus by the end user. Alternatively or additionally, the sensor 18 and the processing
block 20 may be used dynamically, in real time, when the sound reproduction apparatus
30 is being used by the end user.
[0030] In either case, when the sound reproduction apparatus is being used by the end user,
the audio processor 12 processes the input audio signal 14 based at least in part
on the identified one or more resonant frequencies and outputs the output audio signal
16. The audio processor 12 operates to reduce the power at the resonant frequency,
in particular the instantaneous power at the resonant frequency. The objective here
is to prevent resonance and therefore vibration of the sound reproduction apparatus
occurring at the resonant frequency. As such, the audio processor 12 may only operate
to reduce the power at the resonant frequency if the power was greater than some threshold.
The threshold may be preset, for example by the manufacturer who determines a suitable
threshold for the specific sound reproduction apparatus through testing, and/or may
be adjustable by the user so that the user can "fine-tune" this aspect of the operation
of the audio processor 12. Alternatively, the audio processor 12 may operate to reduce
the power at the resonant frequency regardless of its power in the input audio signal
14. The amount of reduction of the power at the resonant frequency may be by a fixed
amount (corresponding for example to a certain number of decibels, say 1 or 2 decibels,
or Watts of output power, say 3 to 5 mWatts) or a percentage or proportion of the
power at the resonant frequency (of say 5% or 10% or so say).
[0031] At the same time as reducing the power at the resonant frequency, the audio processor
12 processes the input audio signal 14 to increase the power of the input audio signal
14 at at least some other audio frequencies other than the resonant audio frequency.
The objective here is to "disguise" the reduction of the power at the resonant frequency,
which makes the reduction of volume at the resonant frequency less noticeable for
the user. In an example, the reduction of the power at the resonant frequency and
the increase of the power of the other frequencies is such that the total power (or,
equivalently, the average power) of the output audio signal 16 is the same, or at
least substantially the same, as the total (or average) power of the input audio signal
14 (to within 1% or within 5% or less say). Keeping the total (or average) power of
the output audio signal 16 to be (at least approximately) the same as the original
input audio signal 14 further helps to make the reduction at the resonant frequency
less noticeable to the end user.
[0032] The other frequencies which are increased in power may be frequencies that are adjacent
to or neighbouring to the resonant frequency. For example, the other frequencies which
are increased in power may be frequencies that are within say 1 % or somewhere in
the range of say 5% to 10% or so of the resonant frequency.
[0033] This is shown schematically in Figure 4, which show plots of power against frequency
of waveforms for audio signals. The upper part of Figure 4 shows schematically an
example of a waveform for an input audio signal 14. The lower part of Figure 4 shows
schematically an example of the waveform for the corresponding output audio signal
16 produced by processing the input audio signal 14.
[0034] Referring first to the waveform for the input audio signal 14, the output of the
processing block 20 shows that there is a large peak at a frequency f
R having a power P
R. The power P
R at this frequency f
R is used as a trigger in this example for the audio processor 12 to reduce the power
at that frequency f
R because otherwise it is likely to cause a resonance and therefore vibration or buzzing.
[0035] Referring now to the waveform for the output audio signal 16, this shows that the
power of frequency f
R has been reduced by the audio processor 12. In addition, the power of the neighbouring
frequencies that are adjacent to the resonant frequency f
R is increased. The neighbouring frequencies whose power are increased extend either
side of the resonant frequency f
R in this example.
[0036] The extent of the neighbouring frequencies whose power are increased is indicated
schematically by vertical dashed lines in Figure 4. The neighbouring frequencies may
extend out by say a percentage of the resonant frequency f
R, such as ±1% or ±2% or so. For example, the resonant frequency f
R may be say 500 Hz and the neighbouring frequencies may be 490 Hz to 510 Hz. In this
way, if the resonant frequency f
R is a low frequency, then the neighbouring frequencies whose power is also adjusted
extend over a relatively small range of frequencies, whereas if the resonant frequency
f
R is a high frequency, then the neighbouring frequencies whose power is also adjusted
extend over a relatively large range of frequencies. Alternatively or additionally,
the neighbouring frequencies may extend out by a fixed number of Hz, such as 10 Hz
or 20 Hz say.
[0037] As mentioned, the reduction of the power at the resonant frequency f
R and the increase of the power of the other, neighbouring frequencies is such that
the total (or average) power of the output audio signal 16 is the same, or at least
substantially the same, as the total (or average) power of the input audio signal
14 (to within 5% or less say). This may be regarded as increasing the bandwidth of
the signal at the resonant frequency f
R and decreasing its peak power so that the overall power is the same, or at least
substantially the same. If for example the resonant frequency f
R has an original peak power Po and a bandwidth of Δfo and is adjusted so that its
peak power becomes P and its bandwidth increases by Δf on both sides of the frequency
f
R, then:

or:

[0038] Moreover, in an example, the power of the neighbouring frequencies that are closest
to the resonant frequency f
R may be increased by a greater amount than the neighbouring frequencies that are further
from the resonant frequency f
R. The increase in power may for example vary linearly with the distance of the neighbouring
frequency from the resonant frequency f
R.
[0039] Examples of the present disclosure help to prevent or eliminate vibration or buzzing
that can occur in a sound reproduction apparatus, whilst at the same time reduce the
likelihood that the user will notice that the audio signal has been treated to prevent
vibration occurring.
[0040] It will be understood that the processor or processing system or circuitry referred
to herein may in practice be provided by a single chip or integrated circuit or plural
chips or integrated circuits, optionally provided as a chipset, an application-specific
integrated circuit (ASIC), field-programmable gate array (FPGA), digital signal processor
(DSP), graphics processing units (GPUs), etc. The chip or chips may comprise circuitry
(as well as possibly firmware) for embodying at least one or more of a data processor
or processors, a digital signal processor or processors, baseband circuitry and radio
frequency circuitry, which are configurable so as to operate in accordance with the
exemplary embodiments. In this regard, the exemplary embodiments may be implemented
at least in part by computer software stored in (non-transitory) memory and executable
by the processor, or by hardware, or by a combination of tangibly stored software
and hardware (and tangibly stored firmware).
[0041] Reference is made herein to data storage for storing data. This may be provided by
a single device or by plural devices. Suitable devices include for example a hard
disk and non-volatile semiconductor memory (e.g. a solid-state drive or SSD).
[0042] The examples described herein are to be understood as illustrative examples of embodiments
of the invention. Further embodiments and examples are envisaged. Any feature described
in relation to any one example or embodiment may be used alone or in combination with
other features. In addition, any feature described in relation to any one example
or embodiment may also be used in combination with one or more features of any other
of the examples or embodiments, or any combination of any other of the examples or
embodiments. Furthermore, equivalents and modifications not described herein may also
be employed within the scope of the invention, which is defined in the claims.
1. A method of processing an audio signal, the method comprising:
receiving an audio signal as an input;
processing the input audio signal to provide an audio signal to be output to a loudspeaker,
in which the processing of the input audio signal reduces the power of the input audio
signal at a resonant audio frequency and increases the power of the input audio signal
at at least some other audio frequencies other than the resonant audio frequency.
2. A method according to claim 1, wherein the resonant frequency is a resonant frequency
of a cabinet in which the loudspeaker is mounted, the resonant frequency being identified
using a vibration sensor which is attached to a cabinet in which the loudspeaker is
mounted.
3. A method according to claim 2, wherein the output of the vibration sensor is subject
to a Fast Fourier Transform FFT to identify the resonant frequency.
4. A method according to any of claims 1 to 3, wherein the total or average power of
the output audio signal is substantially the same as the total or average power of
the input audio signal.
5. A method according to any of claims 1 to 4, wherein the other audio frequencies are
frequencies that are within 5% of the resonant frequency.
6. An audio processor for processing an input audio signal, the audio processor being
arranged to:
process an input audio signal to provide an audio signal to be output to a loudspeaker,
wherein the processor is configured such that the processing of the input audio signal
reduces the power of the input audio signal at a resonant audio frequency and increases
the power of the input audio signal at at least some other audio frequencies other
than the resonant audio frequency.
7. An audio processor according to claim 6, wherein the processor is arranged to obtain
the resonant frequency from data storage in which the resonant frequency is stored.
8. An audio processor according to claim 6 or claim 7, wherein the processor is arranged
to obtain the resonant frequency using a vibration sensor which is attached to a cabinet
in which said loudspeaker is mounted.
9. An audio processor according to claim 8, wherein the output of the vibration sensor
is arranged to be subject to a Fast Fourier Transform FFT to identify the resonant
frequency.
10. An audio processor according to any of claims 6 to 9, wherein the processor is configured
such that the total or average power of the output audio signal is substantially the
same as the total or average power of the input audio signal.
11. An audio processor according to any of claims 6 to 10, wherein the processor is configured
such that the other audio frequencies are frequencies that are within 5% of the resonant
frequency.
12. A sound reproduction apparatus, the sound reproduction apparatus comprising an audio
processor according to any of claims 6 to 11 and at least one loudspeaker which is
arranged to receive an output audio signal which is output by the audio processor.