[0001] The present invention relates to a system for monitoring and predictive maintaining
the state of wear of mechanical components, in particular of rolling railway vehicles.
[0002] More in detail, the invention relates to a system of the aforementioned type, designed
and realized in particular to monitor the state of wear, and perform predictive maintenance
of the mechanical components that determine the vehicle dynamics of a rolling stock,
in particular of a railway vehicle, but which can be used for any vehicle including
mechanical components, for which wear status assessment is required.
[0003] In the following the description will be addressed to the monitoring of the state
of wear of mechanical components of railway vehicles, but it is clear that the same
should not be considered limited to this specific use.
[0004] As is well known, various methodologies are currently used for vehicle maintenance.
[0005] A known model, known as
model based, is based on the schematization of the real model in a mathematical model using differential
equations in such a way that the real and the simulated system respond in the same
way to external stresses.
[0006] This method allows the evaluation of the physical system through the comparison between
the two models and the analysis of the deviation between the results obtained and
those expected, obtained from the simulation.
[0007] A disadvantage of the
model based is due to the fact that it is necessary to write the differential equations that
best approximate the system, as a complex system can have many variables that make
the system highly non-linear.
[0008] A further model, known as
rules based, is based on rules or conditions, through which the operation of the system is described,
and requires a deep knowledge of the system and its design features.
[0009] This method, although conceptually simple, becomes non-trivial in practice as it
provides a very stable system and in the case of many variables and conditions the
rules become too many and not easy to manage.
[0010] A further model, known as
case based, is based on the analysis of the system conditions with respect to which the operating
status is identified, assumes a large number of data accumulated over time, and relating
to the various operating conditions that are processed and taken as a reference.
[0011] The system is useful in the case in which the mapped cases are many and cover all,
or a good part of the operating range of the system, the latter must be stable so
as to be able to work with the interpolations between the cases in the database, in
other conditions than those prescribed, one must be cautious in applying the model.
[0012] Yet another model, known as
pattern recognition, is based on the deterioration trends consolidated over time, represented by graphs,
which reproduce the deterioration status of the monitored characteristics and a point
is set, beyond which action must be taken by replacing the component before that the
curve reaches the end of the component's useful life.
[0013] In order to apply this method, it is necessary to have tested and validated the deterioration
curves through experiments and precise measurements on the generic system as the maintenance
times are fixed based on the calculation of the curve.
[0014] It is evident that each of these known models and systems have disadvantages, as
described above.
[0015] In light of the above, it is, therefore, object of the present invention to provide
a system for monitoring the dynamics of the railway vehicle, to which it is applied,
for detecting the wear state of mechanical components, and which is able to apply
even at the same time at least all four the previous models, evaluating even a few
essential elements, in order to be reliable.
[0016] A further object of the present invention is to provide the tools necessary for carrying
out the method and the apparatuses that carry out this method.
[0017] It is, therefore, the specific object of the present invention a system for monitoring
and predictive maintenance of the state of wear of mechanical components of a railroad
car, responsible for driving dynamics, of the type comprising a chassis, two wheel-axles,
a bogie frame and dampening, comprising a logic control unit comprising a signal processing
program, at least one plurality of sensors, which can be placed on said chassis, wheel-axles,
bogie frame and dampening, capable of detecting operation data of said railroad car
and sending corresponding signals to said logic control unit, said signal processing
program is capable of processing said signals so as to extract real characteristic
data of said mechanical components of said railroad car, comparing said real characteristic
data with nominal theoretical values in real time, emitting an alarm signal if the
result of said comparison is outside a predetermined range of values.
[0018] Further according to the invention, said signal processing program comprises a system
of differential equations capable of calculating an expected model of operation of
said mechanical components, starting from said nominal values, calculating a real
model of operation of said mechanical components, starting from said real characteristic
data, comparing said real model with said expected model, calculating the deviation
between the real model and the expected model, comparing the deviation with a predetermined
range of values.
[0019] Preferably according to the invention, said plurality of sensors comprises accelerometers,
inclinometers, gyroscopes and encoders.
[0020] Still according to the invention, said operation data detected are vibrations, triaxial
accelerometry, triaxial gyroscopy, triaxial inclinometry, speed and distance traveled
by said railroad car.
[0021] Always according to the invention, said system comprise an acquisition data device
capable of receiving said signals detected by said plurality of sensors and digitizing
and converting said signals.
[0022] Further according to the invention, said system may comprise a predictive maintenance
management device of said railroad car, capable of receiving said alarm signal and
activating maintenance operations.
[0023] Preferably according to the invention, said system may comprise an energy recovery
system capable of taking vibrational, and/or acoustic, and/or electromagnetic, and/or
solar, and/or photovoltaic, and/or wind and/or micro-wind energy and converting it
into electrical energy.
[0024] It is further object of the present invention an operation method of a system for
monitoring and predictive maintenance of the state of wear of mechanical components
of a railroad car, of the type comprising a chassis, two wheel-axles, a bogie frame
and dampening, comprising the following steps:
- a. detecting operation data of said railroad car and sending corresponding signals to
said logic control unit;
- b. carrying out a pre-processing on said signals, such as digitization and conversion;
- c. processing said signals to extract real characteristic data of said mechanical components
of said railroad car;
- d. comparing said real characteristic data with nominal values of said mechanical components,
in real time;
- e. checking if the result of said comparison falls within a predetermined range of values;
- f. emitting an alarm signal if the result of said comparison is outside said predetermined
range of values;
- g. storing said pre-processed signals and said compared data in said step d.
[0025] 9. Method according to the preceding claim, characterized in that said it comprises
the following step:
h. estimating the time interval in which the monitored mechanical component can pass
through an anomaly condition, in order to manage the predictive maintenance activities
related to it.
[0026] Further according to the invention said method may comprise the following step:
h. estimating the time interval in which the monitored mechanical component can pass
through an anomaly condition, in order to manage the predictive maintenance activities
related to it.
[0027] The present invention will be now described, for illustrative but not limitative
purposes, according to its preferred embodiments, with particular reference to the
figures of the enclosed drawings, wherein:
figure 1 shows a block diagram of the monitoring and predictive maintenance system
of the wear state of the mechanical components, object of the present invention;
figure 2 shows a schematic view of the installation of the system object of the present
invention, on a vehicle;
figure 3 shows a schematic view of the vehicle;
figure 4 shows a top view of the components of the vehicle of figure 3, on which the
system is installed;
figure 5 shows a schematic view of a portion of the vehicle of figure 3;
figure 6 shows a block diagram of the method of operation of the system object of
the present invention;
figure 7 shows a schematic top view of the components shown in figure 4;
figure 8 shows a schematic view of a part of the components shown in figure 7; and
figure 9 shows a flow diagram of the method of operation of the system object of the
present invention.
[0028] In the various figures, similar parts will be indicated by the same reference numbers.
[0029] With reference to figures 2, 3, 4, 5, and 7, the structure of a railroad car R, on
which said system is installed, is first described.
[0030] A railroad car R generally consists of seven masses, a chassis, two bogie frames
and four wheel-axles or axles.
[0031] The chassis C is the outer casing of the railroad car R, which contains things and/or
people.
[0032] Each mass is coupled to the others by means of dampenings with suitable damping and/or
stiffness.
[0033] The wheel-wheel-axles A are connected to the bogie frame T via the primary dampening
D1, while the bogie frame T is connected to the chassis C via the secondary dampening
D2.
[0034] The bogie frame T is the backbone of the railroad car R and consists of two longitudinal
members connected by crossbars.
[0035] The wheel-axles A rest with the wheels on the railway line.
[0036] With reference to figure 1, the system S for monitoring and predictive maintenance
of the wear state of the mechanical components, object of the present invention, essentially
comprises a plurality of sensors 1, a data acquisition device 2, a logic control unit
U, and a maintenance management device 3.
[0037] The system S is powered by a further energy recovery system S
E, as will be described in detail below.
[0038] The system S is able to monitor the state of wear of the components that influence
the vehicle dynamics of a railroad car R and to predict the need to replace a component.
[0039] By analyzing motion and how it is influenced by the state of a component, the system
S recognizes which component and to what extent is wearing, in order to promptly intervene
in the replacement or maintenance of the latter or not intervene at all if, despite
the end of the component's theoretical useful life, it is still in good condition.
[0040] Said plurality of sensors 1 is installed on said railroad car R.
[0041] In particular, four sensors are installed on the four bushings, then a first sensor
11 on a first bushing, a second sensor 12 on a second bushing, a third sensor 13 on
a third bushing and a fourth sensor 14 on a fourth bushing.
[0042] Two other sensors are installed on the center line of the wheel-axles A, in particular
a fifth sensor 15 on a wheel-axle A, and a sixth sensor 16 on another wheel-axle A.
[0043] A seventh sensor 17 is installed on the chassis C.
[0044] Said plurality of sensors 1 comprises accelerometers, inclinometers, gyroscopes and
an encoder, and is capable of detecting signals such as vibrations, triaxial accelerometry,
triaxial gyroscopy, triaxial inclinometry, speed and distance traveled.
[0045] In particular, there are detected: acceleration, speed, displacements along the X,
Y, Z axes, measured in the center of gravity of the wheel-axles A, of the bogie frame
T and of the chassis C.
[0046] In particular, the first X-axis is the running direction of the railroad car R along
the tracks, with a direction concordant with the advancement, the second Y-axis is
perpendicular to the tracks, therefore to said first X-axis, the third Z-axis is orthogonal
to the plane passing through said first X and second Y axis, so as to form a left-handed
triad.
[0047] Speed and displacements are calculated by integrating acceleration and filtering
to eliminate errors.
[0048] The gyroscopy in rad/s is also measured around the rotation axes around the center
of gravity of the wheelset, the bogie frame T and the body and the speed of the railroad
car R in m/s.
[0049] Signals are pulses or voltage changes.
[0050] Said data acquisition device 2 is a microcontroller or an acquisition card, which
is able to receive the signals detected by said plurality of sensors 1 and to digitize
and convert said signals.
[0051] Said control logic unit U is able to receive said digitized and converted signals
from said data acquisition device 2.
[0052] Said control logic unit U is able to process said signals by means of a reference
model based on the differential equations that define the model physical and relative
dynamic behavior, as will be described in detail below.
[0053] Said maintenance management device 3 essentially comprises a remote maintenance server
and/or a
cloud maintenance, for remote consultation, a maintenance program or application that can
be used in remote devices such as
smartphones, and an operator interface for the assisted execution of the maintenance intervention.
[0054] Said system S is also powered by a further energy recovery system S
E of an energetic, and/or vibrational, and/or acoustic, and/or electromagnetic, and/or
solar, and/or photovoltaic, and/or wind, and/or or micro-wind, as described below.
[0055] As regards thermal energy, the energy produced or dispersed in the form of heat by
the engine and/or by the heating elements or by the generation of heat from friction
and/or thermal dispersion, is transformed into electrical energy and stored to power
the electronics of the system S.
[0056] As regards the vibrational or dynamic energy, the mechanical energy that can be used
during the movement of the railroad car R can be used to be transformed into electrical
energy which, once accumulated, can be used for power supply the electronic devices
of the system S.
[0057] As for the acoustic or electromagnetic energy, the energy related to the acoustic
and electromagnetic pollution present on board the train can be suitably converted
into electrical energy which, once accumulated, can be used for power supply of the
electronic devices of said system S.
[0058] As regards solar energy, solar-photovoltaic, wind, micro-wind, from all these sources
it is possible to recover both when the train is stopped, by means of solar sources,
and when the train is in motion, by means of wind sources, the energy which, suitably
transformed into electrical energy, can be appropriately accumulated and used to power
the electronics of the system S.
[0059] The energy is accumulated through the use of a battery, or in some cases by at least
one supercapacitor, it is then distributed to all electronic devices of the system
S.
[0060] This allows a continuity to the measurements also in the moments in which the main
energy system, called
energy harvesting, is unable to power system S directly.
[0061] The operation of the monitoring and predictive maintenance system S of the wear status
of mechanical components described above is as follows.
[0062] In a first step, said plurality of sensors 1 acquires the signals described above.
[0063] In a second step, said signals are pre-processed by said data acquisition device
2.
[0064] In this step any errors due to the imperfect installation of the sensors 1 or to
installation limits, are eliminated, such as for example considering the eccentricity
from the center of gravity, or applying the transport theorem to transfer a force
calculated to a point other than the optimal one because the installation of sensor
1 was impossible, due to lack of space or because it was physically impossible, for
example if the center of gravity is inside the wheelset, and finally, elimination
of noise and disturbances, through digital filters or correction coefficients.
[0065] The data are: acceleration, speed and displacements along said first X, second Y
and third Z axis, measured in the center of gravity of the wheel-axles A, of the bogie
frame T and of the chassis C, gyroscopy in rad/s around the rotation axes around the
center of gravity wheelset, bogie frame T, and chassis C, vehicle speed in m/s.
[0066] Speed and displacements are not directly measured parameters, but are calculated
from the integration of the acceleration and filtered to compensate for possible errors.
[0067] The data are stored for a certain instant of time or space so the integration carried
out to obtain the displacements can take place in two different ways, based on the
form of the adopted acquisition, for example acquisition based on time or acquisition
based on the distance traveled from the railroad car R.
[0068] For the acquisition based on time, the data are collected at constant intervals,
for example every 8 milliseconds, while based on the distance traveled the time is
not constant, and the movements are obtained by integrating each time with respect
to the value of the time resulting from the displacement, for example every cm the
instant of time is acquired, which therefore can vary according to the speed at which
it moves so that the integration takes place with a value indirectly obtained.
[0069] This temporal acquisition step is also spatially scanned by means of the encoder
and a clock, in case an absolute time is desired or the time can be acquired by the
system S in a relative manner, resetting the timer at start-up.
[0070] The displacement data is of two types.
[0071] The displacements entered in the input data are the relative micro-displacements
calculated between one time instant and another of the parts of the railroad car R,
which must be distinguished from the movement data of the whole railroad car R.
[0072] In a third step, the data so processed are sent to said logic control unit U, which
comprises a processing program.
[0073] This processing program is based on a model of differential equations that exactly
describe the dynamics of the railroad car R.
[0074] To generate a model it is necessary to establish a set of differential equations
that define the physical model and the relative dynamic behavior.
[0075] It is proceeded by measuring the accelerations, which will then be used as input
in the inverse differential equation system while at the output there are the characteristics
of the components.
[0076] To validate the model, it is verified that the nominal parameters of the model determined
by the
Rules Based approach coincide with those obtained from the inversion.
[0077] If the mechanical characteristics detected at the output of the system coincide with
the nominal ones, then the railroad car R has components that are still functioning,
in the case in which the system returns values out of range, where the ranges are
initially predetermined, then it will be necessary to replace, or maintain the component
as its mechanical characteristics are deteriorating.
[0078] It is proceeded by steps, at the beginning some closed-loop elaborations are done
in order to determine the parameters that characterize the differential equations,
and which give rise to the optimal reference model, as well as to verify the validity
of the differential equations and its inversion, namely, taken the nominal characteristics,
the direct system of equations is solved, with the determination of the characteristic
parameters using the
Rules Based approach, and the output values are evaluated, checking that they are acceptable
results, or if possible the theoretical results can be compared produced by the optimal
model directly with the real data measured by the system.
[0079] Then, there is the inversion of the system, taking as input the output values from
the direct system and inserting them into the inverse system, it is necessary to obtain
the starting inputs at the output.
[0080] This allows verifying the differential equations that describe the system and it
is subsequently possible to insert them in an open-loop model, which, by measuring
the real values of the dynamics of the railroad car R, such as acceleration, gyroscopy,
speed, returns through concurrent processing in the characteristics of the components
in real time.
[0081] Therefore, the difference between the real behavior of the system and the expected
one determined through the optimal model is analyzed in real time, as shown in figure
6, and the detachment threshold is defined, beyond which intervening with a direct
maintenance intervention, on condition.
[0082] It is also possible to estimate the remaining life time of the physical component,
i.e., to perform a prediction, basing this result using an approach on a degradation
"
pattern"
, obtained from the difference over time between the theoretical behavior of the system
obtained from the optimal model, and the real measured behavior from the system, as
indicated in figure 6, where the decision support processing element (DSS) estimates
this time.
[0083] Based on the data to be monitored, these equations are inverted according to the
parameter, after which the system is solved by entering the input data, in particular
the displacements and the speed of the railroad car R.
[0084] At the same time, the simulation results are compared with the solution of the equations
in which the displacements that the railroad car R should have had in ideal conditions
have been inserted.
[0085] The differential equations have been written considering the X, Y, Z reference system
described above.
[0086] The symbols used in the equations are shown below:
- 1) yw1: transverse displacement of the front wheelset;
- 2) ψw1: Rotation around the vertical axis of the front wheelset;
- 3) yw2: transverse displacement of the upper mount;
- 4) ψw2: Rotation around the vertical axis of the rear wheelset;
- 5) yb: Transversal displacement of the bogie frame T;
- 6) ψb: Rotation around the vertical axis of the bogie frame T;
- 7) yb,d: Transversal displacement of the chassis C.
[0087] The following table shows all the parameters of the model to be able to elaborate
the differential equations.
| Massa of the mounted wheel set |
mw1.2 |
| Mass of the frame of the chassis |
mb |
| Mass of the chassis |
mbd |
| Mass moment of inertia of the front and rear wheelset around z |
Jzw1.2 |
| Mass moment of inertia of the bogie frame around z |
Jb |
| Longitudinal stiffness coefficient of the primary dampening |
Kx |
| Transverse stiffness coefficient of the primary dampening |
ky |
| Longitudinal rigidity coefficient of the secondary dampening |
Kdx |
| Transverse stiffness coefficient of the secondary dampening |
kdy |
| Longitudinal damping coefficient of the primary dampening |
rx |
| Transversal dampening coefficient of the primary dampening |
ry |
| Longitudinal dampening coefficient of the secondary dampening |
Cdx |
| Transversal dampening coefficient of the secondary dampening |
Cdy |
| Dampening coefficient of the anti-swaying dampening |
Cady |
| Load per axle |
P |
| Equivalent conicity |
γ |
| Distance between the primary dampening attachment point and the bogie frame center
of gravity |
a |
| Distance between the attachment point of the primary suspension and the center of
gravity of the wheelset |
b |
| Average radius of the wheel |
R0 |
| Longitudinal Kalker coefficient |
f11 |
| Transversal Kalker coefficient |
f22 |
| Track gauge |
2s = 1435 mm |
| Semi-gauge |
s |
[0088] These constants may vary according to the dynamics equations used since each railroad
car R has its own dynamics, some constants may be missing, for example if a damping
is missing, this value is zero.
[0092] In a fourth step, the simulation is validated.
[0093] The two simulations are compared in absolute value, the difference of the values
instant by instant or the "delta", that is the deviation, if the delta of the two
simulations is low, it means that the difference between the real system and the ideal
or expected one is minimal, the system is behaving correctly and there are no anomalies
regarding that parameter, otherwise, if the delta of the two simulations is high,
the difference indicates that there is an anomaly on that parameter, it is also possible
to determine the extent of the variation.
[0094] The model outputs are therefore:
- inverted parameter value;
- delta or deviation of the simulations.
[0095] It is possible to evaluate any parameter contained in the equations, if they are
invertible, some of these are:
- gamma angle (conicity);
- springs stiffness (k);
- damping (r);
- wheel radius;
- lowering of the dampening.
[0096] Other parameters can be indirectly evaluated starting from these, such as:
[0097] Also in this case the output data are stored in memory together with the other acquisitions.
[0098] When the entity of the anomaly exceeds a certain threshold, an alert is activated,
which sends a signal to said maintenance management device 3.
[0099] Said maintenance management device 3 is capable of sending an alarm signal in order
to activate the maintenance.
[0100] In particular, a reservation is made to the magazine of the spare parts necessary
for the maintenance intervention, otherwise the automated purchase procedure is managed,
a time is set for carrying out the maintenance intervention, the maintenance staff
qualified/certified to perform the maintenance intervention, the equipment necessary
for the maintenance intervention is booked, and augmented reality tools are used to
provide support for the execution of the intervention.
[0101] As is evident from the above description, the advantages of the system object of
the present invention are many, for example, the proximity of the processing to the
data generating source, as it is performed directly on board of the railroad car R,
the transmission of only the information connected to the 'detected anomaly, with
the enormous reduction in the amount of data to be transmitted to remote storage and
processing devices, reduced times of anomaly detection, immediate
early warning, thanks to concurrent processing/in real time, during the running of the rolling stock,
with direct communication to the maintenance manager, without going through the current
intermediate stages, elaboration and operational/management, additional, the prediction
of the condition of the equipment failure, the automatic correlation of anomalies
detected directly to the maintenance intervention, without further additional operational/management
steps, the automatic correlation of anomalies detected on board of the train due to
any causes dependent/induced by the infrastructure state, the management of information
related to failures for the validation of the parameters.
[0102] This allows the reduction of the machine downtime, the optimization of magazine stocks
and the management of maintenance personnel and the reduction of maintenance management
costs, due to interventions carried out after the occurrence of the fault condition.
[0103] The present invention has been described for illustrative but not limitative purposes,
according to its preferred embodiments, but it is to be understood that modifications
and/or changes can be introduced by those skilled in the art without departing from
the relevant scope as defined in the enclosed claims.
1. System (S) for monitoring and predictive maintenance of the state of wear of mechanical
components of a railroad car (R), responsible for driving dynamics, of the type comprising
a chassis (C), two wheel-axles (A), a bogie frame (T) and dampening (D1, D2), comprising:
a logic control unit (U) comprising a signal processing program,
at least one plurality of sensors (1), which can be placed on said chassis (C), wheel-axles
(A), bogie frame (T) and dampening (D1, D2), capable of detecting operation data of
said railroad car (R) and sending corresponding signals to said logic control unit
(U), said system (S) being characterized in that said signal processing program is capable of
processing said signals so as to extract real characteristic data of said mechanical
components of said railroad car (R),
comparing said real characteristic data with nominal theoretical values in real time,
emitting an alarm signal if the result of said comparison is outside a predetermined
range of values.
2. System (S) according to the preceding claim,
characterized in that said signal processing program comprises a system of differential equations capable
of
calculating an expected model of operation of said mechanical components, starting
from said nominal values,
calculating a real model of operation of said mechanical components, starting from
said real characteristic data,
comparing said real model with said expected model,
calculating the deviation between the real model and the expected model,
comparing the deviation with a predetermined range of values.
3. System (S) according to any one of the preceding claims, characterized in that said plurality of sensors (1) comprises accelerometers, inclinometers, gyroscopes
and encoders.
4. System (S) according to any one of the preceding claims, characterized in that said operation data detected are vibrations, triaxial accelerometry, triaxial gyroscopy,
triaxial inclinometry, speed and distance traveled by said railroad car (R).
5. System (S) according to any one of the preceding claims, characterized by comprising an acquisition data device (2) capable of receiving said signals detected
by said plurality of sensors (1) and digitizing and converting said signals.
6. System (S) according to any one of the preceding claims, characterized by comprising a predictive maintenance management device (3) of said railroad car (R),
capable of receiving said alarm signal and activating maintenance operations.
7. System (S) according to any one of the preceding claims, characterized by comprising an energy recovery system capable of taking vibrational, and/or acoustic,
and/or electromagnetic, and/or solar, and/or photovoltaic, and/or wind and/or micro-wind
energy and converting it into electrical energy.
8. Operation method of a system (S) for monitoring and predictive maintenance of the
state of wear of mechanical components of a railroad car (R), of the type comprising
a chassis (C), two wheel-axles (A), a bogie frame (T) and dampening (D1, D2),
characterized in that it comprises the following steps:
a. detecting operation data of said railroad car (R) and sending corresponding signals
to said logic control unit (U);
b. carrying out a pre-processing on said signals, such as digitization and conversion;
c. processing said signals to extract real characteristic data of said mechanical components
of said railroad car (R);
d. comparing said real characteristic data with nominal values of said mechanical components,
in real time;
e. checking if the result of said comparison falls within a predetermined range of values;
f. emitting an alarm signal if the result of said comparison is outside said predetermined
range of values;
g. storing said pre-processed signals and said compared data in said step d.
9. Method according to the preceding claim, characterized in that said it comprises the following step:
h. estimating the time interval in which the monitored mechanical component can pass
through an anomaly condition, in order to manage the predictive maintenance activities
related to it.