Field of application of the invention
[0001] The present invention relates to a liquid inhalation composition for electronic cigarettes
with reduced cytotoxicity.
Background art
[0002] Recognizing that cigarette smoking causes serious damage to health has long prompted
the industry to develop alternative forms of inhalation which can give smokers adequate
satisfaction and effectively replace traditional cigarettes in daily use.
[0003] Starting from the evidence that the intake of nicotine is a key factor which causes
the continuous desire to smoke in smokers, but that the greatest damage comes from
the substances of the high-temperature combustion of tobacco, such as polycyclic aromatic
hydrocarbons, tar and carbon monoxide, the art has followed two parallel paths. On
the one hand, systems have been developed which include heating tobacco at a controlled
temperature (generally no higher than 350°C), so as to avoid the harmful effects of
high-temperature combustion. On the other hand, so-called "electronic cigarettes"
have been created which vaporize a liquid comprising, in addition to a base capable
of providing a sufficiently dense body to the vapor released, also a controlled amount
of nicotine and various types of flavorings.
[0004] The heated-tobacco inhalation systems are those which are most similar to traditional
smoking for smokers, both in terms of the flavoring of the tobacco and of consumption
methods and times, similar to those of a cigarette. However, it should be remembered
that some toxic substances contained in tobacco are formed even before the combustion
thereof, such as, in addition to nicotine, nitrosamines. These substances are therefore
not eliminated by reducing the combustion temperature to no more than 350°C.
[0005] The compositions for electronic cigarettes, on the other hand, do not contain such
toxic or carcinogenic substances, apart from a controlled amount of nicotine, which
is essential to make the inhalation of the composition pleasant by the traditional
smoker. Furthermore, the possibility of flavoring the composition in various manners
forms a further attraction.
[0006] Therefore, electronic cigarettes largely solve the toxicity problems associated with
tobacco use, even if they are not completely safe. In fact, the base composition,
which consists for the most part of a mixture of propylene glycol and glycerol in
a volume ratio of 50:50, or for a denser vapor of 30:70, has an inherent toxicity,
albeit much more reduced than that of a traditional cigarette and the heated-tobacco
system described above.
[0007] Therefore, the problem of being able to further lower the toxicity of a composition
for inhalation by means of electronic cigarettes so as to make the prolonged consumption
thereof much safer is still felt.
Summary of the invention
[0008] The aforesaid technical problem is substantially solved by a composition comprising
the technical features set out in one or more of the appended claims, the definitions
of which form an integral part of the present description for the purpose of sufficiency
of description.
[0009] Therefore, the present invention relates to a composition for inhalation by means
of an electronic cigarette comprising:
- a glycerol/propylene glycol mixture in a percentage by volume between 80% and 99%;
- optionally, water in a percentage by volume less than or equal to 6%, preferably less
than or equal to 5%;
- optionally, nicotine in a percentage by weight/volume not exceeding 0.2%;
- optionally, flavorings in a percentage by volume less than or equal to 15%, preferably
less than or equal to 10%;
- a pH adjuster,
in which the composition has a pH between 7.0 and 7.6.
[0010] The invention also relates to a base composition comprising:
- a glycerol/propylene glycol mixture in a percentage by volume between 93% and 99%;
- optionally, water in a percentage by volume less than or equal to 6%, preferably less
than or equal to 5%;
- optionally, nicotine in a percentage by weight/volume not exceeding 0.2%;
- a pH adjuster, in which the base composition has a pH between 7.0 and 7.6.
[0011] The invention still further relates to a kit comprising:
- a) a container comprising a base composition comprising
- a glycerol/propylene glycol mixture in a percentage by volume between 93% and 99%;
- optionally, water in a percentage by volume less than or equal to 6%, preferably less
than or equal to 5%;
- optionally, nicotine in a percentage by weight/volume not exceeding 0.2%;
- a pH adjuster, in which the base composition has a pH between 7.0 and 7.6;
- b) one or more containers comprising flavorings in a percentage by volume less than
or equal to 10%.
[0012] Further features and advantages of the present invention will become more apparent
from the indicative and thus non-limiting description of a preferred, but not exclusive
embodiment of the invention.
Brief description of the drawings
[0013]
Figure 1 depicts a graph of cell viability vs composition concentration with a control
compound;
Figure 2 depicts a graph of cell viability vs composition concentration with a composition
according to the invention;
Figure 3 depicts a graph of cell viability vs composition concentration with a composition
for electronic cigarettes according to the prior art;
Figure 4 depicts a graph of cell viability vs composition concentration with a heated-tobacco
system according to the prior art.
Detailed description of the invention
[0014] The present invention is directed to a composition for inhalation by means of electronic
cigarettes comprising:
- a glycerol/propylene glycol mixture in a percentage by volume between 80% and 99%;
- optionally, water in a percentage by volume less than or equal to 6%, preferably less
than or equal to 5%;
- optionally, nicotine in a percentage by weight/volume not exceeding 0.2%;
- optionally, flavorings in a percentage by volume less than or equal to 15%, preferably
less than or equal to 10%;
- a pH adjuster,
in which the composition has a pH between 7.0 and 7.6.
[0015] The glycerol/propylene glycol mixture is at a volume ratio between 50:50 and 70:30.
[0016] If the composition contains flavorings, the percentage by volume of the glycerol/propylene
glycol mixture will not be greater than 90%.
[0017] The glycerol is preferably vegetable glycerol.
[0018] The percentage of nicotine optionally present in the composition should not be greater
than the amount allowed by current legislation, in particular it should be less than
or equal to 20 mg/ml.
[0019] The water is preferably demineralized water.
[0020] The flavorings can be of any type normally used for electronic cigarettes, such as
fruit flavorings, tobacco flavorings, mentholates or mixtures thereof. The flavorings
can be added to a base composition which does not contain them directly by the smoker.
In this case, glycol-based flavorings are available to add to the composition as desired.
[0021] Therefore, the invention further relates to a base composition comprising
- a glycerol/propylene glycol mixture in a percentage by volume between 93% and 99%;
- optionally, water in a percentage by volume less than or equal to 6%, preferably less
than or equal to 5%;
- optionally, nicotine in a percentage by weight/volume not exceeding 0.2%;
- a pH adjuster, in which the base composition has a pH between 7.0 and 7.6.
[0022] The pH adjuster is preferably an organic or inorganic acid, more preferably selected
from orthophosphoric acid, lactic acid and citric acid.
[0023] The weight percentage of the pH adjuster in the composition depends on both the nature
of the pH adjuster and the percentage of the various components used in the composition.
For example, in a composition containing about 90% by volume of 50:50 glycerol/propylene
glycol mixture, about 5% water, about 10% flavorings (apple/kiwi), nicotine 8 mg/ml,
orthophosphoric acid in a weight percentage of 0.1% adjusted the pH of the composition
to 7.5.
[0024] The pH is preferably between 7.2 and 7.6, more preferably between 7.3 and 7.6 or
between 7.4 and 7.6 or is of about 7.5.
[0025] The invention still further relates to a kit comprising:
- a) a container comprising a base composition comprising
- a glycerol/propylene glycol mixture in a percentage by volume between 93% and 99%;
- optionally, water in a percentage by volume less than or equal to 6%, preferably less
than or equal to 5%;
- optionally, nicotine in a percentage by weight/volume not exceeding 0.2%;
- a pH adjuster, in which the base composition has a pH between 7.0 and 7.6;
- b) one or more containers comprising flavorings in a percentage by volume less than
or equal to 10%.
[0026] The present invention originates from the evidence that the known compositions for
electronic cigarettes have a basic pH. The present Applicant has conducted experiments
and has verified that such a basic pH is responsible for a certain cytotoxicity towards
lung cells (human lung fibroblasts). The Applicant has also discovered that by lowering
the pH of the composition to a pH between 7 and 7.6, such toxicity is substantially
reduced if not eliminated.
Experimental section
[0027] The cytotoxicity of a composition according to the invention towards compositions
of the prior art was evaluated through the MTT test: cell survival test with human
fibroblasts of pulmonary origin grown in monolayer for the evaluation of the biocompatibility
of smoke with mucous membranes.
[0028] The test aims at evaluating the cytotoxicity of the smoke condensate obtained with
electronic cigarettes with pH correction to neutrality according to the invention
on a cell culture of human lung fibroblasts, as described in the UNI EN ISO 10993-5
and ISO 4387:2019 standards related to the biological evaluation of medical devices,
appropriately modified for the purpose.
[0029] The cytotoxicity of the condensate obtained by simulating the exposure to which the
user of the electronic cigarette is subjected is an indicator of the safe use of the
device in hand and the overall toxicity thereof towards the respiratory epithelium.
[0030] The method used is that of MTT, which is simple and reproducible, originally developed
by Mossman.
[0031] An increase or decrease in viable cells results in a concomitant change in absorbance
which can be regarded as an indicator of the degree of cytotoxicity caused by exposure
to the test substances. The cells are also examined under a microscope after contact
with the sample to evaluate any changes in the morphology thereof, membrane integrity
or any lysis phenomena.
[0032] A line of Human Lung Fibroblasts (HPF) was used. Source: Innoprot. The cells are
cultured in MEM containing 10% FBS and antibiotics.
[0033] Cigarette smoke is sampled using a smoke machine consisting of a vacuum system and
a 100 ml flask connected to an electronic cigarette. The electronic cigarette is positioned
vertically on an inert plastic fitting. The positioning allows the metal resistance
inside the tank and used to heat the liquid to always remain in contact with the liquid
itself, as indicated by the manufacturer.
[0034] The electronic cigarette loaded with the appropriate liquid was left to rest about
20 minutes before aspiration, so that the cotton inside the tank was correctly moistened
with liquid, after which the first 2/3 puffs were discarded.
[0035] The flask is connected by silicone tubes to a flow meter inside the instrument, which
is in turn connected to a vacuum pump and to a PC with control software. The presence
of a flow meter allows the constant setting of the aspiration flow. 30 ml of sterile
medium were used for the preparation of the condensates. An aspiration/inhalation
simulation is performed with a duration of 3" with a pause lasting 45" between one
aspiration and the other, to facilitate the collection of the condensate in the medium,
keeping the flask constantly under stirring during the experiment, in accordance with
ISO 4387:2019.
[0036] The aspiration flow is regulated at 1 L/min. 150 aspiration/inhalation cycles are
performed, equal to 25 traditional cigarettes. The smoke from the electronic cigarette,
loaded with the special liquid at the beginning of the session, is continuously sampled
for the expected number of cycles. The medium with the condensate obtained from such
an experiment was brought to pH 7.5 with lactic acid and subjected to cytotoxicity
tests.
[0037] Human lung cells were seeded in 96-well plates and allowed to grow for 24h at 37°C
and 5% CO
2. On the second day, the medium was removed and replaced by the freshly prepared condensate
from the cigarette to be tested.
[0038] In order to determine the IC
50 value (Inhibiting Concentration 50) at the end of the experiment, the tested concentrations
are the condensate as is and the subsequent serial 1:2 dilutions thereof in medium.
[0039] Each sample was tested in sixfold. Untreated cells were used as blank and as positive
control the cells were treated with a surfactant of known toxicity (Sodium Lauryl
Sulfate - SLS) dissolved in the culture medium at concentrations between 0.5 mg/ml
and 0.03 mg/ml.
[0040] After 24 hours of incubation with the sample and the control, the cytotoxicity test
(MTT) was then performed to evaluate the cell survival percentage.
MTT cell viability tests
[0041] The culture medium is aspirated and the cells incubated in 100 µl/well of a 1 mg/ml
solution of MTT, for 2 hours at 37°C. The solution is removed and replaced by 200
µl/well of DMSO with subsequent 30' of incubation at room temperature and stirring
at medium speed.
[0042] The absorbance at 570 nm is read with a colorimeter (Tecan INFINITE F200) provided
with a plate reader by subtracting the background reading at 650 nm.
[0043] The result is expressed as a percentage of cell viability according to the formula:

[0044] In case it is possible to calculate the IC
50 value (Inhibiting Concentration 50) which indicates the concentration of the product
which inhibits cell viability by 50%.
%>50 = first cell viability obtained above 50%
%<50 = first cell viability obtained less than 50%.
[0045] The following acceptability criteria of the method were adopted:
for the blank: the mean OD value of the replicates should be ≥ 0.2, the standard deviation should
be ≤ 18%, the mean of two columns of blanks should not differ by more than 15%;
for the positive control (CP): the IC50 of the SLS positive control should be 0.10 mg/ml ± 0.03, the standard deviation should
be ≤ 18%;
for the sample: standard deviation should be ≤ 18%.
[0046] A reduction in cell viability > 30% is considered a cytotoxic effect.
[0047] The samples used were:
- composition for electronic cigarettes according to the invention, comprising 90% by
volume of 50:50 glycerol/propylene glycol mixture, water about 5%, flavorings (apple/kiwi)
about 10%, nicotine 8 mg/ml, pH adjuster: acid lactic up to pH 7.5;
- composition for electronic cigarettes of the prior art, comprising 90% by volume of
50:50 glycerol/propylene glycol mixture, water about 5%, flavorings (apple/kiwi) about
10%, nicotine 8 mg/ml, pH 8.9;
- HEETS Turquoise selection cigarette 3172 /20-06 (heated-tobacco cigarette), pH 7.9.
[0048] Figure 1 shows the graph of cell viability vs concentration for the positive control
(SLS).
[0049] Figure 2 shows the graph of cell viability vs concentration for the composition of
the invention at pH 7.5.
[0050] Figure 3 shows the graph of cell viability vs concentration for the electronic cigarette
composition of the prior art (pH 8.9).
[0051] Figure 4 shows the graph of cell viability vs concentration for the HEETS Turquoise
selection heated-tobacco cigarette.
[0052] The following IC
50 values were calculated from the data of such experiments:
- positive control IC50 = 0.09 ml/ml
- composition for electronic cigarettes according to the invention IC50»1 ml/ml (non-cytotoxic at the highest concentration tested)
- composition for electronic cigarettes of the prior art IC50 = 0.93 ml/ml
- IC50 heated-tobacco cigarette = 0.19 ml/ml.
[0053] From the above it is apparent that the composition for electronic cigarettes according
to the invention is much less cytotoxic than both the composition of the prior art
without acidity adjuster and, to an even greater extent, the heated-tobacco cigarette.
[0054] Therefore, the invention further relates to a pH adjuster acid for use in preventing
pulmonary cytotoxicity in subjects intaking vapors by means of electronic cigarettes,
in which said pH adjuster acid is added to an electronic cigarette composition comprising
a glycerol/propylene glycol mixture in a percentage by volume between 80% and 99%,
optionally water in a percentage by volume less than or equal to 6%, preferably less
than or equal to 5%, optionally nicotine in a percentage by weight/volume not exceeding
0.2%, optionally flavorings in a percentage by volume less than or equal to 15%, preferably
less than or equal to 10%, and in which said pH adjuster acid gives said composition
a pH between 7.0 and 7.6.
[0055] Said pH adjuster acid is preferably selected from orthophosphoric acid, lactic acid
and citric acid and the composition for electronic cigarettes is preferably as defined
above.
[0056] It is apparent that only some particular embodiments of the present invention have
been described, to which those skilled in the art will be able to make all changes
required to adapt it to particular applications, without departing from the scope
of protection of the present invention.
1. A composition for inhalation by means of an electronic cigarette comprising:
- a glycerol/propylene glycol mixture in a percentage by volume between 80% and 99%;
- optionally, water in a percentage by volume less than or equal to 6%, preferably
less than or equal to 5%;
- optionally, nicotine in a percentage by weight/volume not exceeding 0.2%;
- optionally, flavorings in a percentage by volume less than or equal to 15%, preferably
less than or equal to 10%;
- a pH adjuster,
wherein the composition has a pH between 7.0 and 7.6.
2. The composition according to claim 1, wherein the glycerol/propylene glycol mixture
is at a volume ratio between 50:50 and 70:30.
3. The composition according to claim 1 or 2, wherein, when the composition contains
flavorings, the percentage by volume of the glycerol/propylene glycol mixture is no
greater than 90%.
4. The composition according to any one of claims 1 to 3, wherein the flavorings are
selected from fruit, tobacco, mentholated flavorings or mixtures thereof.
5. The composition according to any one of claims 1 to 4, wherein the pH adjuster is
an organic or inorganic acid.
6. The composition according to claim 5, wherein the pH adjuster is selected from orthophosphoric
acid, lactic acid and citric acid.
7. The composition according to any one of claims 1 to 6, wherein the pH is between 7.2
and 7.6, or between 7.3 and 7.6, or between 7.4 and 7.6, or is of about 7.5.
8. The composition according to any one of claims 1 to 7, wherein the pH adjuster is
orthophosphoric acid in a percentage by weight of about 0.1%.
9. A base composition comprising:
- a glycerol/propylene glycol mixture in a percentage by volume between 93% and 99%;
- optionally, water in a percentage by volume less than or equal to 6%, preferably
less than or equal to 5%;
- optionally, nicotine in a percentage by weight/volume not exceeding 0.2%;
- a pH adjuster, wherein the base composition has a pH between 7.0 and 7.6.
10. A kit comprising:
a) a container comprising a base composition comprising
- a glycerol/propylene glycol mixture in a percentage by volume between 93% and 99%;
- optionally, water in a percentage by volume less than or equal to 6%, preferably
less than or equal to 5%;
- optionally, nicotine in a percentage by weight/volume not exceeding 0.2%;
- a pH adjuster, wherein the base composition has a pH between 7.0 and 7.6;
b) one or more containers comprising flavorings in a percentage by volume less than
or equal to 10%.
11. A pH adjuster acid for use in preventing pulmonary cytotoxicity in subjects intaking
vapors by means of electronic cigarettes, wherein said pH adjuster acid is added to
an electronic cigarette composition comprising a glycerol/propylene glycol mixture
in a percentage by volume between 80% and 99%, optionally water in a percentage by
volume less than or equal to 6%, preferably less than or equal to 5%, optionally nicotine
in a percentage by weight/volume not exceeding 0.2%, optionally flavorings in a percentage
by volume less than or equal to 15%, preferably less than or equal to 10%, and wherein
said pH adjuster acid gives said composition a pH between 7.0 and 7.6.
12. The pH adjuster acid for use according to claim 11, wherein the composition is as
defined in any one of claims 2 to 9.