Technical Field
[0001] The present invention relates to a method for extracting a flavor component and a
method for producing a constituent element of processed tobacco leaves.
Background Art
[0002] There has been proposed a technique in which a flavor component (e.g., an alkaloid
including a nicotine component) is extracted from a tobacco raw material and the extracted
flavor component is supported on a constituent element of processed tobacco leaves.
[0003] For example, Patent Documents 1 and 2 disclose a technique related to a method for
extracting a flavor component from a tobacco raw material, the method including a
step A of heating an alkali-treated tobacco raw material and a step B of bringing
a released component that is released into a gas phase in the step A into contact
with a collecting solvent at normal temperature until a specific timing to prepare
a collecting solution. Patent Documents 1 and 2 also disclose a technique related
to a method for producing a constituent element of a luxury grocery item (processed
tobacco leaves), the method including the above steps A and B and a step C of adding
the collecting solution to the constituent element.
Citation List
Patent Literature
[0004]
Patent Document 1: International Publication No. 2015/129679
Patent Document 2: International Publication No. 2015/129680
Summary of Invention
Technical Problem
[0005] In the techniques disclosed in Patent Documents 1 and 2, the steps A and B, which
are conducted for extracting a flavor component from a tobacco raw material, require
at least a certain amount of extraction treatment time for collecting a certain amount
of flavor component from a tobacco raw material. For example, the amount of extraction
treatment time required for the nicotine concentration in a tobacco raw material to
reach 0.4% by weight is 180 minutes. Therefore, there is room for improvement in terms
of reduction in the amount of extraction treatment time, in consideration of the efficiency
of production of a constituent element of processed tobacco leaves.
[0006] Patent Documents 1 and 2 also disclose that, when the amount of extraction treatment
time in the steps A and B is equal to or more than a certain amount, the amount of
tobacco-specific nitrosamine (hereinafter, also referred to simply as "TSNA") released
from a tobacco raw material, which is a component that causes unwanted effects on
a flavor or the like, is likely to increase. Thus, it is considered that a reduction
in the amount of extraction treatment time enables the TSNA concentration in the collecting
solution to be maintained at a further low level.
[0007] Accordingly, an object of the present invention is to provide a method for extracting
a flavor component with which the amount of time required for extracting a certain
amount of flavor component from a tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves
can be reduced compared with methods known in the related art and the TSNA concentration
in the collecting solution, in which a flavor component is collected, can be maintained
at a further low level and a method for producing a constituent element of processed
tobacco leaves which includes the above extraction method.
Solution to Problem
[0008] The inventor of the present invention conducted extensive studies and consequently
found that the above object can be achieved by, in a step of heating an alkali-treated
tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves in order to extract a flavor component,
limiting the initial moisture content in the alkali-treated tobacco raw material or
processed tobacco leaves to be equal to or more than a specific amount, subjecting
the alkali-treated tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves to a watering
treatment in the heating, and limiting the moisture content in the alkali-treated
tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves to be equal to or less than a specific
amount throughout the above step. Thus, the inventor conceived the present invention.
[0009] Specifically, the present invention is as follows.
- [1] A method for extracting a flavor component from a tobacco raw material or processed
tobacco leaves, the method including:
a step A of heating an alkali-treated tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves,
the alkali-treated tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves being treated
with an alkali; and
a step B of bringing a released component into contact with a collecting solvent,
the released component being released into a gas phase in the step A,
wherein, in the step A,
an initial moisture content in the alkali-treated tobacco raw material or processed
tobacco leaves is equal to or more than a minimum moisture content at which the alkali
can be completely dissolved,
in the heating, the alkali-treated tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves
are subjected to a watering treatment, and
a moisture content in the alkali-treated tobacco raw material or processed tobacco
leaves is 35% by weight or less of a total weight of the tobacco raw material or the
processed tobacco leaves throughout the step A.
- [2] The method for extracting a flavor component described in [1], wherein, in the
step A, the initial moisture content in the alkali-treated tobacco raw material or
processed tobacco leaves is more than 20% by weight of the total weight of the tobacco
raw material or the processed tobacco leaves.
- [3] The method for extracting a flavor component described in [1] or [2], wherein
the alkali-treated tobacco raw material has a pH of 9.5 or more.
- [4] The method for extracting a flavor component described in [1] to [3], wherein,
in the step A, the watering treatment is performed when a temperature of the alkali-treated
tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves reaches a temperature range of 100°C
or more and 150°C or less.
- [5] The method for extracting a flavor component described in [1] to [4], wherein,
in the step A, the watering treatment is performed when the moisture content in the
alkali-treated tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves reaches 20% by weight
or less of the total weight of the tobacco raw material or the processed tobacco leaves
for the first time.
- [6] The method for extracting a flavor component described in [1] to [5], wherein
the alkali is potassium carbonate or sodium carbonate.
- [7] The method for extracting a flavor component described in [1] to [6], wherein,
in the step B, a temperature of the collecting solvent is 5°C or more and 35°C or
less.
- [8] A method for producing a constituent element of processed tobacco leaves, the
method including:
a step A of heating an alkali-treated tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves,
the alkali-treated tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves being treated
with an alkali;
a step B of bringing a released component into contact with a collecting solvent,
the released component being released into a gas phase in the step A, to prepare a
collecting solution; and
a step C of adding the collecting solution to the constituent element,
wherein, in the step A,
an initial moisture content in the alkali-treated tobacco raw material or processed
tobacco leaves is equal to or more than a minimum moisture content at which the alkali
can be completely dissolved,
in the heating, the alkali-treated tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves
are subjected to a watering treatment, and
a moisture content in the alkali-treated tobacco raw material or processed tobacco
leaves is 35% by weight or less of a total weight of the tobacco raw material or the
processed tobacco leaves throughout the step A.
Advantageous Effects of Invention
[0010] According to the present invention, a method for extracting a flavor component with
which the amount of time required for extracting a certain amount of flavor component
from a tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves can be reduced compared with
methods known in the related art and the TSNA concentration in the collecting solution,
in which a flavor component is collected, can be maintained at a further low level
and a method for producing a constituent element of processed tobacco leaves can be
provided.
Brief Description of Drawings
[0011]
[Fig. 1] Fig. 1 is a diagram illustrating an example of an extraction device according
to an embodiment of the present invention.
[Fig. 2] Fig. 2 is a diagram illustrating an example of the extraction device according
to the embodiment of the present invention.
[Fig. 3] Fig. 3 is a diagram for explaining an application example of a flavor component.
[Fig. 4] Fig. 4 is a flowchart illustrating an extraction method according to the
embodiment of the present invention.
[Fig. 5] Fig. 5 includes graphs illustrating changes in the collection ratio of a
flavor component (in this case, nicotine) with respect to the amount of time during
which the heat treatment of a tobacco raw material is performed.
[Fig. 6] Fig. 6 includes graphs illustrating changes in the amount of TSNA collected
with respect to the amount of time during which the heat treatment of a tobacco raw
material is performed.
[Fig. 7] Fig. 7 includes graphs illustrating changes in the temperature of a tobacco
raw material with respect to the amount of time during which the heat treatment of
the tobacco raw material is performed.
[Fig. 8] Fig. 8 includes graphs illustrating changes in the moisture content in a
tobacco raw material with respect to the amount of time during which the heat treatment
of the tobacco raw material is performed.
Description of Embodiments
[0012] Details of embodiments of the present invention are described below. Note that the
following description is merely an example (typical example) of the embodiments of
the present invention and the present invention is not limited by the contents thereof
without departing from the summary thereof.
[0013] In the present specification, in the case where a range is expressed using "to" and
values or physical properties described before and after "to", it is considered that
the range includes the values described before and after "to". It should be noted
that the drawings are schematic and, for example, the proportions of dimensions are
different from the real one.
[0014] In the present specification, the term "tobacco raw material" refers collectively
to tobacco leaves that have not been subjected to an aging treatment after being harvested
and tobacco leaves that have been subjected to an aging treatment which have not been
processed into a form in which the tobacco leaves are used in a tobacco product. Examples
thereof include fresh and dried leaves that have not been subjected to an aging treatment
and products obtained by grinding the above leaves; laminae that have been subjected
to an aging treatment and ground products thereof; and aging-treated midrib and ground
products thereof.
[0015] The term "processed tobacco leaves" used herein refers collectively to those obtained
by processing the tobacco raw materials into a form in which they are used in a tobacco
product. Examples thereof include shredded tobacco, a tobacco sheet, and tobacco granules.
The above processed tobacco leaves may be constituted only by the tobacco raw material
and may be constituted by the tobacco raw material and other materials. Thus, the
concept of the term "constituent element" of processed tobacco leaves includes the
tobacco raw material and the other materials.
[0016] A method for extracting a flavor component according to an embodiment of the present
invention is a method for extracting a flavor component from a tobacco raw material
or processed tobacco leaves. The extraction method includes a step A of heating an
alkali-treated tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves which have been treated
with an alkali and a step B of bringing a released component that has been released
into a gas phase in the step A into contact with a collecting solvent.
[0017] In the step A, the initial moisture content in the alkali-treated tobacco raw material
or processed tobacco leaves is equal to or more than the minimum moisture content
at which the alkali can be completely dissolved. Furthermore, in the heating, the
alkali-treated tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves are subjected to a
watering treatment. Moreover, the moisture content in the alkali-treated tobacco raw
material or processed tobacco leaves is 35% by weight or less of the total weight
of the tobacco raw material or the processed tobacco leaves throughout the step A.
[0018] Note that the "initial moisture content" in the alkali-treated tobacco raw material
or processed tobacco leaves is the moisture content in the alkali-treated tobacco
raw material or processed tobacco leaves which is measured after the alkali treatment
has been performed and before the heat treatment is performed. The above initial moisture
content can be expressed in percent by weight relative to the total weight of the
tobacco raw material or the processed tobacco leaves. The total weight of the tobacco
raw material or the processed tobacco leaves, which is used as a reference for calculating
moisture content, is the dry weight thereof. The same applies hereinafter.
[0019] In the above-described methods for extracting a flavor component known in the related
art, which are disclosed in Patent Documents 1 and 2, the initial moisture content
in the alkali-treated tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves is 39% ± 2%
of the total weight of the tobacco raw material or the processed tobacco leaves. One
of the reasons for which the initial moisture content is limited as described above
in the methods for extracting a flavor component known in the related art is that
this makes it possible to obtain a flavor component at an intended collection ratio
without performing any additional operation from the start to the end of the heating
operation performed after the tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves have
been charged into an extraction device and subjected to an alkali treatment.
[0020] However, in the above conventional method for extracting a flavor component, the
amount of time it takes from the start to the end of the heating operation, that is,
the amount of time required for obtaining a flavor component at an intended collection
ratio, is about 180 minutes, which makes up a relatively large amount of time among
the steps for producing a constituent element of processed tobacco leaves.
[0021] In addition, it is known that, in general, the larger the amount of time during which
heating is performed at high temperatures, the large the amount of TSNA released from
a tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves. Similarly, in the above-described
conventional method for extracting a flavor component, it is reported that the larger
the amount of time during which the heat treatment is performed in order to obtain
a flavor component at an intended collection ratio, the larger the amount of TSNA
collected.
[0022] The inventor of the present invention studied a method for reducing the amount of
time required for obtaining a flavor component at an intended collection ratio by
the method for extracting a flavor component and for suppressing the amount of TSNA
collected and consequently found the above conditions, that is, in the step A, the
initial moisture content in the alkali-treated tobacco raw material or processed tobacco
leaves is equal to or more than the minimum moisture content at which the alkali can
be completely dissolved; in the heating, the alkali-treated tobacco raw material or
processed tobacco leaves are subjected to a watering treatment; and the moisture content
in the alkali-treated tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves is 35% by weight
or less of the total weight of the tobacco raw material or the processed tobacco leaves
throughout the step A.
[0023] When the step A is conducted under the above conditions, compared with the above
conventional method, the amount of time required for obtaining a flavor component
at an intended collection ratio can be reduced and the amount of TSNA collected can
be suppressed.
[0024] The reasons for which the amount of time required for obtaining a flavor component
at an intended collection ratio can be reduced are presumably as follows. The initial
moisture content in the alkali-treated tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves
according to the embodiment of the present invention is set to be small compared with
the related art. Furthermore, even when a watering treatment is performed in the heat
treatment, the moisture content in the alkali-treated tobacco raw material or processed
tobacco leaves is controlled to be 35% by weight or less, which is lower than the
initial moisture content set in the conventional method. Therefore, the rate at which
the temperature of the alkali-treated tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves
increases is high and a flavor component can be released from the tobacco raw material
or processed tobacco leaves at an earlier timing than in the conventional method.
[0025] The reasons for which the amount of TSNA collected can be suppressed are presumably
as follows. Since the alkali-treated tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves
according to the embodiment of the present invention are subjected to a watering treatment
in the heat treatment, the temperature of the alkali-treated tobacco raw material
or processed tobacco leaves is reduced temporarily. This reduces the amount of time
during which the temperature of the tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves
is brought into a high-temperature state.
[0026] In the step A, the initial moisture content in the alkali-treated tobacco raw material
or processed tobacco leaves is preferably more than 20% by weight of the total weight
of the tobacco raw material or the processed tobacco leaves.
[0027] The initial moisture content in the alkali-treated tobacco raw material or processed
tobacco leaves is more preferably 25% by weight or more and is further preferably
30% by weight or more. The initial moisture content in the alkali-treated tobacco
raw material or processed tobacco leaves is preferably 35% by weight or less. When
the above initial moisture content falls within the above range, the rate at which
the temperature of the alkali-treated tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves
increases in the heat treatment is increased and, consequently, a flavor component
can be released from the tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves at an earlier
timing than in the conventional method.
[0028] If the initial moisture content in the alkali-treated tobacco raw material or processed
tobacco leaves is 20% by weight or less of the total weight of the tobacco raw material
or processed tobacco leaves, the alkali applied to the tobacco raw material or processed
tobacco leaves may fail to be dissolved completely and become precipitated.
[0029] The initial moisture content in the alkali-treated tobacco raw material or processed
tobacco leaves can be adjusted by changing the concentration of an aqueous alkaline
solution added to the tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves in the alkali
treatment described below.
[0030] The pH of the alkali-treated tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves is
preferably 9.5 or more. When the above pH is 9.5 or more, a flavor component can be
efficiently released from the tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves and,
consequently, the ratio at which the flavor component is collected is increased. If
the above pH is less than 9.5, the ratio at which the flavor component is collected
from the tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves may be reduced.
[0031] The upper limit for the pH of the alkali-treated tobacco raw material or processed
tobacco leaves is not set in particular; the upper limit is normally 12 or less and
is preferably 11 or less in consideration of the amount of treatment time required
for increasing pH.
[0032] The pH of the alkali-treated tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves can
be adjusted by changing the type of the alkali and the concentration of the aqueous
alkaline solution, the alkali or the aqueous alkaline solution being added to the
tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves in the alkali treatment described
below.
[0033] The alkali used in the alkali treatment is not limited in particular; any alkali
with which the pH of the tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves can be adjusted
to fall within the above range may be used. The alkali is preferably a substance that
can be used as a food additive. For example, potassium carbonate, sodium carbonate,
or a mixture thereof can be suitably used. Potassium carbonate and sodium carbonate
are preferable because they are readily soluble in water and it becomes easy to adjust
an aqueous alkaline solution which is to be sprayed to the tobacco raw material or
processed tobacco leaves.
[0034] In the step A, the watering treatment is preferably performed when the temperature
of the alkali-treated tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves reaches a temperature
range of 100°C or more and 150°C or less. The above temperature range is more preferably
100°C or more and 130°C or less and is further preferably 100°C or more and 110°C
or less. When the watering treatment is performed within the above temperature range,
the efficient release of a flavor component from the alkali-treated tobacco raw material
or processed tobacco leaves can be maintained. Furthermore, the amount of TSNA released
can be suppressed.
[0035] In the step A, the watering treatment is preferably performed when the moisture content
in the alkali-treated tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves reaches 20%
by weight or less of the total weight of the tobacco raw material or processed tobacco
leaves for the first time. When the watering treatment is performed at the above timing,
the efficient release of a flavor component from the alkali-treated tobacco raw material
or processed tobacco leaves can be maintained.
Furthermore, the amount of TSNA released can be suppressed.
[0036] In the step B, the temperature of the collecting solvent is preferably 5°C or more
and 35°C or less and is more preferably 10°C or more and 20°C or less. When the temperature
of the collecting solvent falls within the above temperature range, the solidification
of the collecting solvent can be avoided. Furthermore, the vaporization and diffusion
of a flavor component from the collecting solution can be suppressed. This enables
efficient collection of a flavor component.
[0037] A method for producing a constituent element of processed tobacco leaves according
to an embodiment of the present invention is a method for producing a constituent
element of processed tobacco leaves which includes the method for extracting a flavor
component from a tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves. Specifically, the
method for producing a constituent element of processed tobacco leaves according to
the embodiment of the present invention includes the step A of heating an alkali-treated
tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves, the alkali-treated tobacco raw material
or processed tobacco leaves being treated with an alkali; the step B of bringing a
released component into contact with a collecting solvent, the released component
being released into a gas phase in the step A, to prepare a collecting solution; and
a step C of adding the collecting solution to the constituent element of processed
tobacco leaves. In the step A, the initial moisture content in the alkali-treated
tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves is equal to or more than the minimum
moisture content at which the alkali can be completely dissolved. In the heating,
the alkali-treated tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves are subjected
to a watering treatment. The moisture content in the alkali-treated tobacco raw material
or processed tobacco leaves is 35% by weight or less of the total weight of the tobacco
raw material or the processed tobacco leaves throughout the step A.
[0038] Applying the method for extracting a flavor component from a tobacco raw material
or processed tobacco leaves to the method for producing a constituent element of processed
tobacco leaves reduces the amount of time required for producing a constituent element
of processed tobacco leaves. Furthermore, the amount of TSNA that may be included
in the constituent element can be suppressed.
(Extraction Device)
[0039] An extraction device according to an embodiment of the present invention is described
below. Figs. 1 and 2 are diagrams illustrating examples of the extraction device according
to the embodiment of the present invention.
[0040] First, an example of an alkali treatment device 10 is described with reference to
Fig. 1. The alkali treatment device 10 includes a container 11 and a sprayer 12.
[0041] The container 11 accommodates a tobacco raw material (or processed tobacco leaves)
50. The container 11 is composed of, for example, a member resistant to heat and pressure
(e.g., SUS; steel used stainless). The container 11 preferably provides an enclosed
space. Note that the term "enclosed space" used herein refers to a state in which
the intrusion of solid foreign matter is prevented during normal handling (e.g., transportation
or storage). This suppresses the likelihood of a flavor component included in the
tobacco raw material (or processed tobacco leaves) 50 vaporizing and diffusing to
the outside of the container 11.
[0042] The sprayer 12 applies an aqueous solution of the alkali to the tobacco raw material
(or processed tobacco leaves) 50 to perform an alkali treatment.
[0043] In a dry state, the initial content of a flavor component (in this embodiment, a
nicotine component) in the tobacco raw material (or processed tobacco leaves) 50 is
preferably 2.0% by weight or more and is more preferably 4.0% by weight or more with
the total weight of the tobacco raw material (or processed tobacco leaves) 50 being
100% by weight.
[0044] As a tobacco raw material (or processed tobacco leaves) 50, for example, tobacco
leaves of the Nicotiana genus, such as Nicotiana tabacum or Nicotiana rustica, which
have not been aged or have been aged or aged tobacco leaves processed into a form
in which the tobacco leaves are used in a tobacco product may be used. Examples of
type of Nicotiana tabacum include a Burley type and a flue-cured type. Note that,
as a tobacco raw material (or processed tobacco leaves) 50, tobacco leaves of a type
other than a Burley type or a flue-cured type which have not been aged or have been
aged or aged tobacco leaves processed into a form in which the tobacco leaves are
used in a tobacco product may also be used.
[0045] The tobacco raw material (or processed tobacco leaves) 50 is preferably composed
of shreds or granules of a tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves and is
more preferably composed of granules of a tobacco raw material or processed tobacco
leaves. In such a case, the grain size of the shreds or granules is normally 0.5 mm
or more and 10 mm or less and is preferably 0.5 mm or more and 5 mm or less. If the
above grain size is less than 0.5 mm, the amount of the tobacco raw material or processed
tobacco leaves adhered on the wall surface of the container 11 is large. Thus, it
is not preferable that the above grain size be less than 0.5 mm in terms of extraction
efficiency. When the above grain size is 10 mm or less, the surface area of the shreds
or granules is large and extraction efficiency is high accordingly. When the above
grain size is 5 mm or less, the surface area of the shreds or granules is further
large and extraction efficiency is further high accordingly. Note that the term "shreds"
used in the present specification refers to a material produced by shredding a tobacco
raw material or processed tobacco leaves and the term "granules" used in the present
specification refers to a material produced by crushing a tobacco raw material or
processed tobacco leaves.
[0046] Next, an example of the collection device 20 is described with reference to Fig.
2. The collection device 20 includes a container 21, an introduction pipe 22, a release
portion 23, and a delivery pipe 24.
[0047] The container 21 accommodates a collecting solvent 70. The container 21 is made of,
for example, glass. The container 21 preferably provides an enclosed space. Note that
the term "enclosed space" used herein refers to a state in which the intrusion of
solid foreign matter is prevented during normal handling (e.g., transportation or
storage).
[0048] The collecting solvent 70 is glycerol, water, ethanol, or the like. Among the above
collecting solvents 70, water is preferably used in consideration of ease of handling
and a suppression in costs. In order to prevent an inhaling flavor component trapped
by the collecting solvent 70 from again vaporizing and diffusing, an appropriate acid,
such as malic acid or citric acid, may be added to the collecting solvent 70. In order
to increase the efficiency with which the inhaling flavor component is trapped, a
component or substance, such as an aqueous citric acid solution, may be added to the
collecting solvent 70. That is, the collecting solvent 70 may be composed of a plurality
of types of components or substances. In order to increase the efficiency with which
the inhaling flavor component is trapped, the initial pH of the collecting solvent
70 is preferably lower than the pH of the tobacco raw material (or processed tobacco
leaves) 50 that has been alkali-treated.
[0049] The introduction pipe 22 guides a released component 61, which is released from the
tobacco raw material (or processed tobacco leaves) 50 into a gas phase upon the tobacco
raw material (or processed tobacco leaves) 50 being heated, to the collecting solvent
70. The released component 61 includes at least a nicotine component, which is an
index of a flavor component.
[0050] The release portion 23 is formed in the front end of the introduction pipe 22 and
is immersed in the collecting solvent 70. The release portion 23 has a plurality of
openings 23A formed therein. The released component 61 guided along the introduction
pipe 22 is released into the collecting solvent 70 through the openings 23A in the
form of a bubble-like released component 62.
[0051] The delivery pipe 24 guides a residual component 63 that is not trapped by the collecting
solvent 70 to the outside of the container 21.
[0052] Since the released component 62 is a component released into a gas phase upon the
tobacco raw material (or processed tobacco leaves) 50 being heated, the released component
62 may increase the temperature of the collecting solvent 70. Accordingly, the collection
device 20 may have a function of cooling the collecting solvent 70 in order to maintain
the temperature of the collecting solvent 70 to be normal temperature.
[0053] The collection device 20 may include Raschig rings in order to increase the area
of the surface at which the released component 62 is brought into contact with the
collecting solvent 70.
(Application Example)
[0054] An application example of the flavor component extracted from the tobacco raw material
(or processed tobacco leaves) 50 is described below. Fig. 3 is a diagram for explaining
the application example of the flavor component. For example, the flavor component
is applied to processed tobacco leaves or the like.
[0055] As illustrated in Fig. 3, a flavor inhaler 100 includes a holder 110, a carbon heat
source 120, processed tobacco leaves 130, and a filter 140.
[0056] The holder 110 is, for example, a paper tube having a cylindrical shape. The carbon
heat source 120 generates heat used for heating the processed tobacco leaves 130.
The processed tobacco leaves 130 are substances that generate a flavor and are examples
of a flavor source substrate to which an alkaloid including a nicotine component is
applied. The filter 140 suppresses the likelihood of foreign substances being guided
toward the inhalation port.
[0057] Although the flavor inhaler 100 is described above as an application example of the
flavor component, the embodiment is not limited to this.
[0058] The flavor component may be applied to another flavor inhaler. The flavor component
may be applied to a tobacco filler included in a tobacco rod that includes processed
tobacco leaves filled therein as a result of being wrapped in a wrapping paper with
the processed tobacco leaves being inside or a "non-combustion-heating-type tobacco
product" that generates a flavor by directly or indirectly heating, for example, a
tobacco cartridge that includes a container having an air inlet and an air outlet
and processed tobacco leaves filled in a channel formed in the container with a non-combustion
heat source, such as an electric heater. An example of the tobacco filler is a tobacco
sheet filled in the tobacco rod. Another example is tobacco granules filled in the
tobacco cartridge.
[0059] The flavor component may also be applied to an aerosol source (i.e., "E-liguid")
included in an electronic cigarette. The flavor component may be applied to a flavor
source substrate included in chewing gum, tablets, films, candies, or the like.
(Extraction Method)
[0060] A method for extracting a flavor component according to an embodiment of the present
invention is described below. Fig. 4 is a flowchart illustrating the method for extracting
a flavor component.
[0061] As illustrated in Fig. 4, in Step S10, an alkali is applied to a tobacco raw material
(or processed tobacco leaves) 50 with the above-described alkali treatment device
10. Examples of the alkali include, as described above, potassium carbonate, sodium
carbonate, and a mixture thereof.
[0062] The tobacco raw material (or processed tobacco leaves) 50 is treated with an alkali
as a result of addition of an aqueous solution of the alkali.
[0063] In a dry state, the initial content of a flavor component (in this embodiment, a
nicotine component) in the tobacco raw material (or processed tobacco leaves) 50 is
preferably 2.0% by weight or more and is more preferably 4.0% by weight or more with
the total weight of the tobacco raw material (or processed tobacco leaves) 50 being
100% by weight.
[0064] The pH of the alkali-treated tobacco raw material (or processed tobacco leaves) 50
is preferably 9.5 or more as described above. When the above pH is 9.5 or more, a
flavor component can be efficiently released from the tobacco raw material (or processed
tobacco leaves) 50 and the collection ratio of the flavor component is increased.
However, if the above pH is less than 9.5, the ratio at which a flavor component is
collected from the tobacco raw material (or processed tobacco leaves) 50 is reduced.
The upper limit for the pH of the alkali-treated tobacco raw material (or processed
tobacco leaves) 50 is not set in particular. As described above, the above upper limit
is normally 12 or less and is preferably 11 or less in consideration of the amount
of treatment time required for increasing pH.
[0065] The moisture content in the alkali-treated tobacco raw material (or processed tobacco
leaves) 50 is preferably more than 20% by weight, is more preferably 25% by weight
or more, and is further preferably 30% by weight or more of the total weight of the
tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves. When the initial moisture content
falls within the above range, the rate at which the temperature of the alkali-treated
tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves increases in the heat treatment is
increased and a flavor component can be released from the tobacco raw material or
processed tobacco leaves at an earlier timing than in the conventional method. If
the initial moisture content in the alkali-treated tobacco raw material or processed
tobacco leaves is 20% by weight or less of the total weight of the tobacco raw material
or processed tobacco leaves, the alkali applied to the tobacco raw material may fail
to be dissolved completely and may become precipitated.
[0066] Note that the moisture content in the alkali-treated tobacco raw material (or processed
tobacco leaves) 50 is the initial moisture content in the alkali-treated tobacco raw
material (or processed tobacco leaves) 50 in the heat treatment performed in Step
20S.
[0067] In Step S20, the alkali-treated tobacco raw material (or processed tobacco leaves)
50 is heated. For example, in the heat treatment, while the tobacco raw material (or
processed tobacco leaves) 50 is accommodated in the container 11 of the alkali treatment
device 10, the tobacco raw material (or processed tobacco leaves) 50 can be heated
together with the container 11. It is needless to say that, in such a case, the introduction
pipe 22 of the collection device 20 is attached to the container 11.
[0068] The heating temperature at which the tobacco raw material (or processed tobacco leaves)
50 is heated is 80°C or more and 150°C or less. When the heating temperature of the
tobacco raw material (or processed tobacco leaves) 50 is 80°C or more, a sufficient
amount of flavor component can be released from the tobacco raw material (or processed
tobacco leaves) 50 at an earlier timing. On the other hand, when the heating temperature
of the tobacco raw material 50 is 150°C or less, the timing at which TSNA is released
from the tobacco raw material (or processed tobacco leaves) 50 can be delayed.
[0069] In Step S20, when the tobacco raw material (or processed tobacco leaves) 50 is heat-treated,
it is subjected to a watering treatment. When the tobacco raw material (or processed
tobacco leaves) 50 that is being heat-treated is subjected to a watering treatment,
the temperature thereof is temporarily reduced and the amount of TSNA collected can
be suppressed.
[0070] The moisture content in the heat-treated tobacco raw material (or processed tobacco
leaves) 50 is 35% by weight or less of the total weight of the tobacco raw material.
Therefore, the amount of water added is adjusted such that the moisture content in
the tobacco raw material (or processed tobacco leaves) 50 is 35% by weight or less
of the total weight of the tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves.
[0071] The number of times the tobacco raw material (or processed tobacco leaves) 50 that
is being heat-treated is subjected to the watering treatment is not limited in particular
and may be set such that the moisture content does not exceed the above upper limit.
The number of times the watering treatment is performed may be only one or two or
more. Alternatively, the tobacco raw material (or processed tobacco leaves) 50 may
be subjected to the watering treatment in a continuous manner.
[0072] The number of times the watering treatment is performed is preferably one. This is
because, the smaller the number of times the watering treatment is performed, the
smaller the time and effort for the work. Another reasons is that, since the temperature
of the tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves that are being heat-treated
is reduced each time the watering treatment is performed, the number of times the
watering treatment is performed is also preferably small in consideration of the efficiency
of extraction of a flavor component.
[0073] The timing at which the tobacco raw material (or processed tobacco leaves) 50 that
is being heat-treated is subjected to the watering treatment is preferably the timing
at which the temperature of the tobacco raw material (or processed tobacco leaves)
50 reaches a temperature range of 100°C or more and 150°C or less. The above temperature
range is more preferably 100°C or more and 130°C or less and is further preferably
100°C or more and 110°C or less. When the watering treatment is performed within the
above temperature range, the efficient release of a flavor component from the alkali-treated
tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves can be maintained and, simultaneously,
the amount of TSNA released can be suppressed.
[0074] The timing at which the tobacco raw material (or processed tobacco leaves) 50 that
is being heat-treated is subjected to the watering treatment is preferably the timing
at which the moisture content in the alkali-treated tobacco raw material or processed
tobacco leaves reaches 20% by weight or less of the total weight of the tobacco raw
material or processed tobacco leaves for the first time. When the watering treatment
is performed at the above timing, the efficient release of a flavor component from
the alkali-treated tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves can be maintained
and, simultaneously, the amount of TSNA released can be suppressed.
[0075] In Step S20, it is preferable to subject the tobacco raw material (or processed tobacco
leaves) 50 to a ventilation treatment. This increases the amount of the flavor component
included in the released component 61 released from the alkali-treated tobacco raw
material (or processed tobacco leaves) 50 into a gas phase. In the ventilation treatment,
for example, saturated water vapor at 80°C is brought into contact with the tobacco
raw material (or processed tobacco leaves) 50. The amount of ventilation time during
which ventilation is performed in the ventilation treatment cannot be determined unconditionally
because it varies by the device used for treating the tobacco raw material (or processed
tobacco leaves) 50 and the amount of the tobacco raw material (or processed tobacco
leaves) 50. For example, in the case where the amount of the tobacco raw material
(or processed tobacco leaves) 50 is 500 g, the amount of ventilation time is 90 minutes
or less. The total amount of ventilation performed in the ventilation treatment also
cannot be determined unconditionally because it varies by the device used for treating
the tobacco raw material (or processed tobacco leaves) 50 and the amount of the tobacco
raw material (or processed tobacco leaves) 50. For example, in the case where the
amount of the tobacco raw material (or processed tobacco leaves) 50 is 500 g, the
total amount of ventilation is about 3 L/g. The flow rate at which ventilation is
performed also cannot be determined unconditionally because it also varies by the
device used for treating the tobacco raw material (or processed tobacco leaves) 50
and the amount of the tobacco raw material (or processed tobacco leaves) 50. For example,
the flow rate at which ventilation is performed is about 15 L/min.
[0076] The air used in the ventilation treatment is not necessarily saturated water vapor.
The moisture content in the air used in the ventilation treatment may be adjusted
such that, for example, the moisture content in the tobacco raw material (or processed
tobacco leaves) 50 that has been heat-treated and the ventilation treatment falls
within a range of 35% by weight or less without moisturizing the tobacco raw material
(or processed tobacco leaves) 50 in particular. The gas used in the ventilation treatment
is not limited to air and may be an inert gas, such as nitrogen or argon.
[0077] In Step S30, the released component released into a gas phase in Step S20 is brought
into contact with the collecting solvent 70 by using the above-described collection
device 20. Although Steps S20 and S30 are illustrated as individual treatments in
Fig. 4 for the sake of simplicity of description, it should be noted that Steps S20
and S30 are treatments performed in parallel. The term "parallel" used herein means
that the period of time during which Step S30 is conducted overlaps the period of
time during which Step S20 is conducted. Note that Steps S20 and S30 do not necessarily
start and end at the same time.
[0078] In Steps S20 and S30, the pressure inside the container 11 of the alkali treatment
device 10 is equal to or less than normal pressure. Specifically, the upper limit
for the pressure inside the container 11 of the alkali treatment device 10 is +0.1
MPa or less in terms of gage pressure. The atmosphere inside the container 11 of the
alkali treatment device 10 may be a reduced-pressure atmosphere.
[0079] Examples of the collecting solvent 70 include glycerol, water, and ethanol as described
above. The temperature of the collecting solvent 70 is preferably 5°C or more and
35°C or less and is more preferably 10°C or more and 20°C or less as described above.
When the temperature of the collecting solvent falls within the above temperature
range, the solidification of the collecting solvent can be prevented. Furthermore,
the likelihood of a flavor component vaporizing and diffusing from the collecting
solution can be suppressed. This enables efficient collection of the flavor component.
[0080] In Step S40, the collecting solvent 70 (i.e., collecting solution) in which the flavor
component is trapped is subjected to a vacuum concentration treatment, a heat concentration
treatment, or a salting treatment in order to increase the concentration of the flavor
component in the collecting solution.
[0081] Since a vacuum concentration treatment is performed in an enclosed space, the collecting
solvent 70 is less likely to come into contact with air and it is not necessary to
increase the temperature of the collecting solvent 70 to a high level. Thus, in a
vacuum concentration treatment, the possibility of the degeneration of the component
is low. Therefore, the use of vacuum concentration increases the number of types of
available collecting solvents.
[0082] In the case where a heat concentration treatment is used, the degeneration of the
liquid, such as the oxidation of the flavor component, may occur. However, the flavor
may be increased. Note that the use of heat concentration reduces the number of types
of available collecting solvents compared with vacuum concentration. For example,
it may become impossible to use a collecting solvent having an ester structure, such
as medium chain triglyceride (MCT).
[0083] A salting treatment increases the concentration of a flavor component compared with
a vacuum concentration treatment. However, since a flavor component is included in
each of the liquid solvent phase and the water phase in a separate manner, the yield
of the flavor component is poor. In addition, it is considered that the use of a hydrophobic
substance (e.g., MCT) is necessary. Thus, salting may fail to occur depending on the
ratio between the collecting solvent, water, and the flavor component.
[0084] In Step S50, the collecting solution including a flavor component is added to a constituent
element of processed tobacco leaves. In other words, in Step S50, the flavor component
trapped in the collecting solvent 70 is supported on a flavor source substrate (a
constituent element of processed tobacco leaves).
[Other Embodiment]
[0085] The present invention is described in the foregoing embodiments. It should be understood
that the description and drawings that constitute a part of the present disclosure
do not limit the present invention. It will be readily apparent to those skilled in
the art that various alternative embodiments, examples, and operation techniques can
be conceived from the disclosure.
[0086] For example, to the tobacco raw material (or processed tobacco leaves) 50 from which
the flavor component has been released in Step S20 (extraction residue), the collecting
solvent (i.e., collecting solution), which includes a flavor component of the tobacco
raw material (or processed tobacco leaves) 50 as a result of being brought into contact
with the flavor component released from the tobacco raw material (or processed tobacco
leaves) 50 in Step S30, may be added (adding back treatment). Performing the adding
back treatment further removes the components (e.g., ammonium ions and TSNA) that
cause unwanted effects on a flavor or the like and enables the production of a tobacco
raw material or processed tobacco leaves in which the loss of a flavor component is
suppressed. In the adding back treatment, the collecting solution added to the extraction
residue may be neutralized. In the adding back treatment, after the collecting solution
has been added to the extraction residue, an extraction residue including a flavor
component may be neutralized. It should be noted that, in the adding back treatment,
the amount of the flavor component (in this embodiment, nicotine component) included
in the tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves prepared by adding back the
collecting solution to the extraction residue is equal to or less than the amount
of the flavor component (in this embodiment, nicotine component) included in the tobacco
raw material or processed tobacco leaves from which a flavor component has not been
released.
[0087] Prior to the above-described adding back treatment, the tobacco raw material (or
processed tobacco leaves) 50 from which a flavor component has been released in Step
S20 (extraction residue) may be cleaned with a cleaning solvent. Examples of the cleaning
solvent include an aqueous solvent. Specific examples thereof include pure water,
ultrapure water, and city water. This removes the substance that causes unwanted effects
on a flavor or the like, that may remain in the extraction residue. Accordingly, in
the case where the above-described adding back treatment is performed, the components
(e.g., ammonium ions and TSNA) that cause unwanted effects on a flavor or the like
can be further removed. This enables the production of a tobacco raw material or processed
tobacco leaves in which the loss of a flavor component is suppressed.
[Measuring Methods]
(Method for Measuring pH of Starting Tobacco Material or Processed Tobacco Leaves)
[0088] The pH of the alkali-treated tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves can
be measured with a pH meter (e.g., "IQ240" produced by IQ Scientific Instruments,
Inc.). For example, an amount of distilled water which is ten times by weight the
amount of the alkali-treated tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves is added
to 2 to 10 g of the alkali-treated tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves.
The resulting mixture of water and the tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves
is shaked at room temperature (e.g., 22°C) at 200 rpm for 10 minutes. Then, the mixture
is left to stand for 5 minutes. The pH of the resulting extract is measured with the
pH meter.
(Method for Measuring pH of Collecting Solution)
[0089] In a test chamber kept at room temperature (22°C), the collecting solution is left
to stand inside a closed container until the temperature reaches room temperature,
in order to perform temperature conditioning. After the conditioning has been performed,
the lid is removed and a glass electrode of a pH meter (e.g., "SevenEasy S20" produced
by METTLER TOLEDO) is immersed in the collecting solution. Then, the measurement is
started. The pH meter has been calibrated with pH meter calibration liquids having
a pH of 4.01, 6.87, and 9.21. The point at which fluctuations in the output of the
sensor are stabilized within 0.1 mV or less for 5 seconds is considered to be the
pH of the collecting solution.
(Method for Measuring Nicotine Content in Starting Tobacco Material or Processed Tobacco
Leaves)
[0090] The nicotine content in the tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves is measured
by the method adhering to German Institute for Standardization Registered Association
DIN 10373. Specifically, 250 mg of the tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves
is taken. To the tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves, 7.5 mL of a 11%-aqueous
sodium hydroxide solution and 10 mL of hexane are added. The resulting mixture is
subjected to shaking extraction for 60 minutes. Subsequent to the extraction, the
supernatant, that is, the hexane phase, is subjected to a gas chromatograph mass spectrometer
(GC/MS) in order to determine the weight of nicotine included in the tobacco raw material
or processed tobacco leaves.
(Method for Measuring Moisture Content in Starting Tobacco Material or Processed Tobacco
Leaves)
[0091] To 250 mg of the tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves, 10 mL of ethanol
is added. The resulting mixture is subjected to shaking extraction for 60 minutes.
Subsequent to the extraction, the extract is filtered through a 0.45-µm membrane filter
and then subjected to a gas chromatograph (GC/TCD) equipped with a thermal conductivity
detector in order to determine the moisture content in the tobacco raw material or
processed tobacco leaves.
[0092] The weight of the tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves in a dry state
can be calculated by subtracting the above moisture content from the total weight
of the tobacco raw material or processed tobacco leaves.
(Method for Measuring Nicotine Content in Collecting Solution)
[0093] The nicotine content in the collecting solution is measured by the method adhering
to German Institute for Standardization Registered Association DIN 10373 as in the
measurement of the nicotine content in the tobacco raw material or processed tobacco
leaves which is described above. Specifically, 250 mg of the collecting solution is
taken. To the collecting solution, 7.5 mL of a 11%-aqueous sodium hydroxide solution
and 10 mL of hexane are added. The resulting mixture is subjected to shaking extraction
for 60 minutes. Subsequent to the extraction, the supernatant, that is, the hexane
phase, is subjected to a gas chromatograph mass spectrometer (GC/MS) in order to determine
the weight of nicotine included in the collecting solution.
[0094] The nicotine collection ratio can be expressed as the percentage of the nicotine
content in the collecting solution with respect to the nicotine content in the tobacco
raw material or processed tobacco leaves that have not been subjected to the alkali
treatment or the heat treatment.
(Method for Measuring TSNA Content in Collecting Solution)
[0095] To 0.5 mL of the collecting solution sampled, 9.5 mL of a 0.1-M aqueous ammonium
acetate solution is added to perform dilution. Then, an analysis is performed using
a high-performance liquid-chromatograph-mass spectrometer (LC-MS/MS) to determine
the weight of TSNA included in the collecting solution.
(GC Analysis Conditions)
[0096] The conditions under which the GC analysis is performed in the measurement of the
contents of a nicotine component and moisture in the tobacco raw material or processed
tobacco leaves are as described in Table 1 below.
[Table 1]
[0097]
Table 1
| |
Nicotine |
Moisture |
| Apparatus model No. (Producer) |
Agilent 6890GC&5975MSD (Agilent Technologies) |
HP6890 (Hewlett Packard) |
| GC column |
DB-1ms |
DB-WAX |
EXAMPLES
[0098] The present invention is described specifically with reference to Examples below.
The present invention is not limited by the description of Examples below without
departing from the summary of the present invention.
[Test Example]
(Preparation of Starting Tobacco Material)
[0099] Aged Burley tobacco laminae were crushed to a grain size of 0.5 mm or more and 10
mm or less to prepare a tobacco raw material.
[0100] The flavor component (in this example, a nicotine component) included in the obtained
tobacco raw material was measured by the method adhering to German Institute for Standardization
Registered Association DIN 10373 above. The weight of nicotine included in the tobacco
raw material was 2.0% by weight of the total weight of the tobacco raw material.
(Alkali Treatment)
[0101] Into a container equipped with a sprayer (container rotating/rocking-type powder
vacuum dryer "Rocking Dryer" produced by Aichi Electric Co., Ltd., capacity: 10 L),
500 g of the tobacco raw material was charged. Subsequently, 270 g of an aqueous potassium
carbonate solution prepared by dissolving 90 g of potassium carbonate in 180 g of
water was sprayed to the tobacco raw material at a spray velocity of 55 g/min through
the sprayer. When the aqueous potassium carbonate solution was sprayed, the container
was rotated and rocked in order to apply the aqueous potassium carbonate solution
to the tobacco raw material. The pH of the alkali-treated tobacco raw material which
was measured by the above-described method was 9.6. The moisture content in the alkali-treated
tobacco raw material which was measured by the above-described method was 30% by weight
of the total weight of the tobacco raw material.
(Preparation of Heat Treatment and Collection Treatment)
[0102] The pressure inside the container of the rocking dryer in which the alkali-treated
tobacco raw material was present was reduced to create a vacuum state. A compressed
air (about 20°C, about 60%-RH) was introduced into the container of the rocking dryer.
Then, the container of the rocking dryer was connected to a container in which a collecting
solvent was present with an introduction pipe. The flow rate of the compressed air
was set to 15 L/min in order to create an air flow from the container of the rocking
dryer to the container in which the collecting solvent was present. The collecting
solvent used was water.
(Heat Treatment and Collection Treatment)
[0103] A j acket steam was introduced to the outer periphery of the container of the rocking
dryer in order to start the heat treatment of the alkali-treated tobacco raw material.
The component released from the tobacco raw material by heating was collected by the
collecting solvent through the introduction pipe.
[0104] The contents of nicotine and TSNA in the collecting solvent (i.e., collecting solution)
in which the component released from the tobacco raw material is collected were measured
by the above-described methods at predetermined intervals. Figs. 5 and 6 illustrate
changes in the amounts of nicotine and TSNA collected with time, which were calculated
on the basis of the above results.
[0105] In the heat treatment, temperature adjustment was performed as needed such that the
temperature of the alkali-treated tobacco raw material did not exceed 120°C by adjusting
the temperature or the flow rate of the jacket steam.
[0106] The temperature of the alkali-treated tobacco raw material was measured with a thermocouple
disposed inside the container of the rocking dryer at predetermined intervals. Fig.
7 illustrates the measurement results.
[0107] The moisture content in the alkali-treated tobacco raw material was measured by the
above-described method at predetermined intervals. Fig. 8 illustrates the measurement
results.
[0108] In the heat treatment, the container of the rocking dryer was rotated and rocked
such that the alkali-treated tobacco raw material included in the container could
be uniformly heated.
[0109] In the collection treatment, a cooling operation was performed as needed with a chiller
in order to maintain the temperature of the collecting solvent, that is, water, to
be 15°C ± 5°C.
(Watering Treatment)
[0110] When the temperature of the alkali-treated tobacco raw material reached 105°C in
the heat treatment for the first time, the tobacco raw material was subjected to a
watering treatment. The watering treatment was performed by spraying 220 g of water
at a spray velocity of 55 g/min through the sprayer included in the rocking dryer.
[0111] The moisture content in the alkali-treated tobacco raw material which was measured
immediately before the watering treatment was performed was 20% by weight of the total
weight of the tobacco raw material.
[0112] The moisture content in the alkali-treated tobacco raw material which was measured
immediately after the watering treatment was performed was 35% by weight of the total
weight of the tobacco raw material.
[0113] In the watering treatment, the container of the rocking dryer was rotated and rocked
such that the alkali-treated tobacco raw material included in the container was uniformly
watered.
[0114] A test example in which the above-described preparation and the above-described treatments
were all performed is considered as Example.
[0115] A test example in which, in the above-described preparation and the above-described
treatments, the step of "spraying 270 g of an aqueous potassium carbonate solution
prepared by dissolving 90 g of potassium carbonate in 180 g of water to the tobacco
raw material at a spray velocity of 55 g/min through the sprayer" as an (alkali treatment)
was changed to a step of "spraying 490 g of an aqueous potassium carbonate solution
prepared by dissolving 90 g of potassium carbonate in 400 g of water to the tobacco
raw material at a spray velocity of 55 g/min through the sprayer" and the (watering
treatment) was omitted is considered as Comparative Example.
[0116] As illustrated in Fig. 5, in Example, the nicotine collection ratio exceeded 60%
when the treatment time reached 90 minutes. In contrast, in Comparative Example, the
nicotine collection ratio finally exceeded 60% when the treatment time reached 160
minutes. Thus, in the present invention, a flavor component can be released from the
tobacco raw material at an earlier timing than in the conventional method.
[0117] As illustrated in Fig. 6, the integrated amount of TSNA collected in Example until
the treatment time reached 90 minutes was 8735.09 ng, while the integrated amount
of TSNA collected in Comparative Example until the treatment time reached 160 minutes
was 36608.27 ng. Thus, the amount of TSNA collected during the treatment time necessary
for collecting the same amount of nicotine was suppressed in Example.
[0118] In Comparative Example, when the treatment time exceeded 160 minutes, the amount
of TSNA collected was further increased. Thus, shortening the treatment time suppresses
the amount of TSNA collected.