[0001] The subject-matter of the invention is straightening roller for a roller straightening
machine, which is used in both horizontal and vertical straighteners intended for
straightening railway and tramway rails (grooved rails).
[0002] The requirements for the straightness of rails along their entire length are contained
in rail standards and define the maximum permissible deviations in vertical and horizontal
planes. Since rails after rolling do not meet this straightness requirement, they
must be subject to a straightening process, which is carried out in a unit comprising
vertical and horizontal roller straighteners. Mostly 7-roller or 9-roller straighteners
are used.
[0003] Solutions known in the state of the art are based on optimising the adjustments of
rollers in order to reduce the level of internal stresses.
[0004] The Chinese patent description
CN110538873A provides information on the method of controlling residual stresses in a foot of
100-metre steel rail - the invention belong to the field of steel rail production.
In accordance with the method provided for in the invention, the steel rail is straightened
after rolling and pre-bending, upper limit values of three process parameters: the
total pressure value of horizontal straightening rollers, the difference in the pressure
force of adjacent horizontal straightening rollers, and the straightening speed are
adjusted during the straightening process, wherein, during the straightening process,
the total pressure force of horizontal straightening rollers is adjusted so that it
is within 55 mm, the difference in the pressure force of adjacent horizontal straightening
rollers is adjusted, namely, the straightening force R2, R4, R6 and R8 is reduced
in sequence, the difference in straightening force value between R2 and R4, R4 and
R6, R6 and R8 is adjusted so that it is within 10 mm, 8 mm and 6 mm, respectively,
and the straightening speed is less than or equal to 2.0 m/s. This method has beneficial
effect due to the fact that residual stress - after straightening of a 100-metre steel
rail - can be effectively adjusted, and the residual stress of rail foot is adjusted
to be within 200 MPa.
[0005] Solutions involving the use of a set of additional rollers in a lateral and upper
position in relation to the axis of the rail or one additional straightening roller
with a smaller diameter in relation to main straightening rollers, which reduces lateral
bending of the material being straightened, and consequently reduces the length of
the non-straightened part, are known as well.
[0006] Optimising the adjustments of roller straightener can significantly worsen the straightness
parameter of rails as a result of using too small bends. On the other hand, increasing
the adjustment level of straightening rollers results in an increase in the pressure
force of the rollers, and, therefore, increase in the level of residual stresses in
the rail. This implies that, in practice, the optimisation of straightening roller
adjustments is difficult, requires a great deal of knowledge and has a severely limited
potential for lowering the level of residual stresses. Other solutions known from
the state of the art involve the use of additional rollers. However, this requires
alteration of the structure of straightening system, entails additional expenses and
can result in increased failure rates of the straightening unit due to increased complexity
of the equipment. The use of additional rollers makes it more difficult to find the
correct roller adjustment parameters due to the increased complexity of the system
and the need to predict the impact of additional elements acting on the rail during
the complex rail straightening process that depends on many conditions.
[0007] The aim of the invention was to develop straightening rollers allowing to reduce
the level of residual stress of rails being straightened while maintaining the required
straightness of rail after the straightening process without interfering with the
structure of straightening machines used in the state of the art.
[0008] The essence of the invention is a straightening roller for a roller straightening
machine intended specifically for straightening railway or tramway rails (grooved
rails), characterised in that the working surface of straightening roller is concave
over its entire length, while the level of concavity is variable from the extreme
points described by radii, which are also the maximum width of the working surface
of the straightening roller, up to the centre of the straightening roller's axis of
symmetry, where lines inclined towards each other at an obtuse angle between 178°
and 179.5° converge and are smoothly joined by a radius - in this area the roller
reaches its maximum difference in diameter at the extreme, most convex points and
at the straightening roller's axis of symmetry.
[0009] It is preferable that the width of the working surface of straightening roller is
between 50% and 55% of the width of the foot of the rail to be straightened.
[0010] The expression "working surface of straightening rollers" shall be understood as
surface of roller located on the foot side of the rail to be straightened.
[0011] The lines inclined towards each other at obtuse angles and joined by an arc at the
centre of the straightening roller's axis of symmetry are lines determining the inclination
of the foot of the rail being straightened. Such a design of straightening roller's
working surface minimises contact between the central surface of the rail foot and
the straightening roller during the straightening process.
[0012] In the straightening rollers used to date, no modification has been made to the shape
of their working surface over the entire range of contact between this surface and
the surface of the rail to be straightened, so that the working surface of straightening
rollers is described by inclined lines, passing into lines described by radii in important,
sensitive places.
[0013] The width of the working surface of the roller is selected to be more than 50% of
the width of the foot of the rail to be straightened, but not more than 55% of the
width of the rail foot. This ensures that the outer parts of the straightening roller
according to the invention are pressed against the corresponding length of the rail
foot, i.e. at a point where the first inclination of the upper surface of the rail
foot running from the web of the rail to the transition to the second inclination
ends. Such a shape of straightening roller selected according to the invention allows
to apply less force to straighten the rail, resulting in a reduced level of residual
stresses in the area of rail foot, and ensuring better straightening of the rail after
it leaves the straightening machine and greater control of the clamping of fishing
(chamber). The modified working surface of the straightening roller according to the
invention, which ensures smooth transitions described by radii between straight lines,
results in such a distribution of residual stresses in the foot of the rail to be
straightened that tensile stresses are introduced to a lesser extent, resulting in
a reduced level of total residual stresses of rails in this area. There are no sharp
edges at any point of the contact surface between the roller and the rail foot that
would damage the surface of the rail foot causing scratches and sharp dents.
[0014] In addition, the use of the concave working surface of the straightening roller according
to the invention on the foot side of the rail to be straightened increases the working
surface area of the roller in comparison with rollers known from the state of the
art, causing the forces acting during rail straightening to be distributed over a
larger area and thus reducing unit stresses in all parts of the rail, i.e. foot, head
and web.
[0015] New design of straightening roller shape according to the invention intended for
use in roller straighteners also results in less roller action at the point where
residual stresses of the rail to be straightened are measured, i.e. at the centre
of symmetry of the rail foot, while at the same time, the increase in their working
surface area in comparison with rollers known from the state of the art results in
the distribution of the forces acting during straightening over a larger surface area
and thus reduces unit stresses. The use of rollers according to the invention with
newly developed design of their working surfaces results in the occurrence of compressive
or low tensile internal stresses near the rail axis in the direction parallel to the
rail axis. This allows to reduce residual tensile stresses measured during a rail
slice cutting test according to EN13674-1 to values well below 50% of the requirements
of EN13674-1, i.e. less than 125 MPa against a permissible level of 250 MPa. A suitable
combination of the positioning of profile rollers according to the invention in a
sequential arrangement on vertical straightening machine shafts even makes it possible
to achieve residual stress levels in the range of 30-50 MPa. This proves that the
use of rollers according to the invention with a modified shape of the working surface
influences the level and type of residual stresses of the rail to be straightened
and its distribution in the subsurface layer after straightening. Such a modification
of the stress level in the rail foot consequently leads to a reduction of longitudinal
tensile stresses in the whole foot volume.
[0016] By using straightening rollers for roller straightener machine according to the invention,
a several-fold (up to a maximum of almost six-fold) reduction in the level of internal
stresses in the rail foot was achieved compared to reference measurements (based on
available data in the literature).
Table 1. Average levels of residual stresses in the rail foot obtained using profile
rollers in different variants of their positioning.
| Requirements of the standard |
Conventional rollers (reference measurement) |
Profile rollers - variant 1 |
Profile rollers - variant 2 |
Profile rollers - variant 3 |
Profile rollers - variant 4 |
Profile rollers - variant 5 |
| 250 MPa |
190-230 MPa |
70 MPa |
30 MPa |
50 MPa |
125 MPa |
112 MPa |
[0017] The use of straightening rollers for a roller straightening machine also made it
possible to maintain a high degree of straightness of the rail along its entire length
in both vertical and horizontal planes after the straightening operation.
[0018] Straightening rollers installed in a straightening machine according to the invention
can be used without the need to develop new roller straightener adjustments. They
can also be used in straightening machines already in operation by replacing rollers
known from the state of the art that have a flat working surface with straightening
rollers according to the present invention.
[0019] Straightening rollers with a reshaped working surface can also be obtained by returning
of the existing straightening rollers in order to give their working surface appropriate
shape (pass design).
[0020] The use of rollers with a concave working surface has beneficial effect on railway
safety due to the increased operational reliability of rails and reduction in their
tendency to crack as a result of low levels of residual stresses from the manufacturing
process.
[0021] The object according to the invention in the form of a straightening roller is shown
in the figures:
Fig. 1 - drawing of a straightening roller according to the invention
Fig. 2 - example of the use of rollers according to the invention in a vertical straightener
in schematic view.
[0022] Fig. 1 shows a drawing of straightening roller according to the invention with a
width of W2, where the concave working surface of the roller is visible. The working
surface of the roller is characterised by a variable level of concavity starting from
the extreme points, described by the radius R2. The points of contact between R2 radii
and inclination lines located on both sides of the straightening roller also represent
the maximum width of the roller's working surface W1, up to the centre of the roller's
axis of symmetry, where the inclination lines of the foot of the rail to be straightened
converge and their smooth connection by the R1 radius is ensured. In this area W1,
the roller reaches a maximum difference in diameter (indicated in the figure as U1)
located at the extreme points - those most convex and in the axis of symmetry. The
design of the working surface of straightening rollers according to the invention
is described in the figure by two lines inclined towards each other at an obtuse angle.
[0023] Fig. 2 shows an example of the use of straightening rollers according to the invention
in a 7-roller vertical straightening machine. The rail to be straightened is fed into
the straightening machine via the UW input device and then moved between a series
of adjustable rollers R2, R4, R6 and a series of driven rollers R1, R3, R5 and R7.
Driven rollers R1, R3, R5 and R7 are rollers with a concave working surface and are
located on the foot side of the rail to be straightened. Then, the rail is then taken
out of the straightening machine by the RW vertical withdrawal roller.
1. Straightening roller for a roller straightening machine intended specifically for
straightening railway or tramway rails, characterised in that the working surface of straightening roller is concave over its entire length, while
the level of concavity is variable from the extreme points described by radii, which
are also the maximum width of the working surface of the straightening roller, up
to the centre of the straightening roller's axis of symmetry, where lines inclined
towards each other at an obtuse angle between 178° and 179.5° converge and are smoothly
joined by a radius - in this area the roller reaches its maximum difference in diameter
at the extreme, most convex points and at the straightening roller's axis of symmetry.
2. Straightening roller according to claim 1, characterised in that the width of the working surface of straightening roller is in the range of 50% to
55% of the width of the foot of the rail to be straightened.