Technical field
[0001] The present disclosure relates to the field of precision agriculture and chlorophyll
concentration determination by means of remote spectral data, for example by means
of satellite or other remote imagery systems, for determining a fertilizer recommendation.
The present disclosure further relates to the combination of remote spectral data
and local measurements as well to the determination of suitable measurement regions
for determining local measurement devices to determine a chlorophyll concentration
of a crop. The present disclosure aims as well at determining fertilizer recommendations
and its further application on fields.
Background and Prior Art
[0002] Determining the appropriate amount of fertilizer a crop needs is one of the most
important decisions a farmer will encounter. Amongst the different methods for estimating
crop nutrient status in crops, the use of remote imagery generated by satellites or
other equivalent unmanned aerial vehicles has gained importance in the actual field
due to the readily available solutions from different providers. Remote sensing allows
determination of crop nutrient status of remote fields without the need of in-field
inspection.
[0003] However, remote imagery entails well-known disadvantages due to the nature of remote
observations, wherein the readings are affected by natural phenomena like weather
and atmospheric conditions. Moreover, remote methods are not able of precisely assessing
magnitudes wherein different factors may influence the readings. For example, typical
satellite observations measure chlorophyll content in an image (total chlorophyll
per ground area) and the reading is not only dependent of the concentrations of chlorophyll,
but as well dependent on the amount of dry-matter present in that ground area. In
view of different in-field variations of plant density and existing biomass, the determination
of chlorophyll concentration by remote means is a cumbersome task.
[0004] Chlorophyll is directly related to the amount of Nitrogen present in crops, wherein
Nitrogen represents one of the main nutrients plants need for growth and a precise
determination of the chlorophyll concentration is of great importance for determining
the fertilizer needs of a crop.
[0005] Further, approaches in the prior art combining remote and local sensing are known,
like for example from
EP3528608. However, no specific considerations of the importance of the chlorophyll levels
are present nor about the specific locations where direct local measurements should
be conducted.
[0006] Handheld devices for direct measurement of crop nutrient or nitrogen levels are well
known in the prior art, like for example as shown in
US7746452. Some of these devices usually determine the chlorophyll concentration or content
(directly related to nitrogen content) or other nutrients by means of optical measurements.
However, these devices can only determine the plant status of a single plant each
time, therefore rendering the determination of variable rate application of fertilizers
difficult. Previous approaches comprised as well collection of plant tissue and for
a laboratory analysis, with the associated time delays. While there are several approaches
for non-direct determination of the nitrogen content in plants via the special optical
properties of chlorophyll (N-Sensor
®, Greenseeker
®), wherein the sensing devices are integrated in agricultural machines which can be
transported continuously over the field, reaching a full determination of the crop
status over the whole field, these solutions are expensive, time intensive and therefore
not widely available or convenient for the average farmer.
Summary
[0007] Current approaches for determining remotely a crop chlorophyll amount or crop nutrient
status do not take into consideration the above-mentioned problems. The current disclosure
aims at providing solutions for such a remote determination of chlorophyll concentration
in crops by means of remote imagery. Moreover, a combination of said remote sensing
approaches with a direct local determination of chlorophyll concentration is intended
for a more accurate determination of the crop chlorophyll concentration and/or the
generation of fertilizer recommendations and their application on crops.
[0008] According to a first aspect of the current disclosure, this and other objectives
are achieved by a computer-implemented method for remotely determining a chlorophyll
concentration of a crop in an agricultural field, wherein the method comprises the
steps of receiving remote spectral data from a plurality of wavelengths of the agricultural
field, wherein the plurality of wavelengths comprises at least one wavelength from
a water absorption band and at least one from a chlorophyll absorption band; generating
a first index, wherein the first index is a chlorophyll related vegetation index based
on the at least one leaf pigment absorption band of said spectral data; generating
a second index, wherein the second index is a water related vegetation index based
on the at least one water absorption band of said spectral data; determining the chlorophyll
concentration of the crop based on the chlorophyll related vegetation index and the
water related vegetation index.
[0009] Following this approach, a chlorophyll concentration of the crop independent from
the present biomass is achieved.
[0010] According to a second embodiment, determining the chlorophyll concentration based
on the chlorophyll related vegetation index and the water related vegetation index
comprises determining a chlorophyll related biomass invariant vegetation index.
[0011] Following this approach, a vegetation index directly related to chlorophyll concentration
is achieved, hereby simplifying further processing and treatment of the chlorophyll
concentration data.
[0012] According to a third embodiment, determining a chlorophyll related biomass invariant
vegetation index comprises establishing a deviation from a determined relationship
between the first index and the second index, wherein at least one of the first vegetation
index and the second vegetation index has been offset and scaled by means of crop
dependent constants.
[0013] Following this approach, crop specific properties are taken into account.
[0014] According to a further embodiment, the water related vegetation index is based on
at least one additional wavelength outside water absorption bands.
[0015] Following this approach, the water content detection is improved.
[0016] According to a further embodiment, the at least one wavelength from a water absorption
band is chosen at the edge of the water absorption band.
[0017] Following this approach, the sensitivity of the water content detection is improved.
[0018] According to a further embodiment, the method further comprises the steps of receiving
at least one chlorophyll concentration measurement of the crop measured with a chlorophyll
concentration measurement device; determining the chlorophyll concentration of the
crop based on the remotely determined chlorophyll concentration and the received measured
crop chlorophyll concentration.
[0019] Following this approach, remote determination of the chlorophyll concentration is
improved by means of local sensing.
[0020] According to a second aspect, the method further comprises determining at least one
measurement region for carrying out at least one measurement with a crop nutrient
measurement device in said measurement region for providing a fertilizer recommendation
to a crop based on the determined chlorophyll concentration.
[0021] Following this approach, specific measurement regions are determined where the local
measurements can be conducted appropriately.
[0022] According to a further embodiment, the method further comprises receiving a crop
nutrient measurement and determining a fertilizer recommendation based on the crop
nutrient measurement and the determined chlorophyll concentration.
[0023] Following this approach, a combined approach wherein different measurement devices
can be used and the fertilizer recommendation benefits from the combination of remote
and local measurement is achieved.
[0024] According to a further embodiment, the crop nutrient measurement device is a chlorophyll
concentration measurement device and the method further comprises the steps of receiving
a chlorophyll concentration measurement of the crop at the at least one measurement
region measured with the chlorophyll concentration measurement device and adjusting
the remotely determined chlorophyll concentration of the crop based on the received
chlorophyll concentration measurement.
[0025] Following this approach, the combination of local and remote sensing is improved.
[0026] According to a further embodiment, determining at least one measurement region comprises
determining at least one first measurement region and at least one second measurement
region; wherein the at least one first measurement region is selected amongst the
areas of the agricultural field wherein the crop chlorophyll concentration is within
a first predetermined threshold from a first predetermined value of the crop chlorophyll
concentration in the agricultural field and wherein the at least one second measurement
region is selected amongst the areas of the agricultural field wherein the crop chlorophyll
concentration is within a second predetermined threshold from a second predetermined
value of the crop chlorophyll concentration in the agricultural field.
[0027] Following this approach, further crop dependent parameters can be omitted for the
determination of the fertilization recommendation.
[0028] According to a further embodiment, the method further comprises receiving at least
one first crop nutrient measurement at the first measurement region; receiving at
least one second crop nutrient measurement at the second measurement region and determining
a fertilizer recommendation based on the at least one first and at least one second
crop nutrient measurements and/or the determined chlorophyll concentration.
[0029] Following this approach, different crop nutrient measurement devices may be employed
at the determined regions combined with the determined chlorophyll.
[0030] According to a further embodiment, the method further comprises determining a fertilizer
recommendation based on the at least one first and at least one second crop nutrient
measurements and/or the determined chlorophyll concentration.
[0031] According to a further embodiment, the crop nutrient measurement device is a crop
chlorophyll concentration measurement device.
[0032] Following this approach, a direct relation with the remotely determined crop chlorophyll
concentration and the measurements can be established.
[0033] According to a further embodiment, the method further comprises receiving at least
one first crop chlorophyll concentration measurement at the first measurement region;
receiving at least one second crop chlorophyll concentration measurement at the second
measurement region and determining a fertilizer recommendation based on the at least
one first and at least one second crop chlorophyll concentration measurements.
[0034] Following this approach, an improved combination of local and remote sensing for
the generation of a fertilizer recommendation is improved.
[0035] According to a further embodiment, a fertilizer recommendation is determined based
on the ratio of the first crop chlorophyll concentration and the second crop chlorophyll
concentration.
[0036] Following this approach, an improved fertilizer recommendation is achieved.
[0037] According to a further embodiment, the method further comprises carrying out a fertilizer
application based on the determined and/or adjusted chlorophyll concentration of the
crop.
[0038] According to a further embodiment, the method further comprises generating instructions
for an agricultural apparatus to carry out a fertilizer application based on the determined
and/or adjusted chlorophyll concentration of the crop.
[0039] Following these approaches, crop yield and quality is improved.
[0040] According to further aspects, a system, a data processing apparatus, a computer-readable
storage medium, and a computer program product configured to carry out the above discussed
methods are envisaged within the present disclosure.
[0041] According to a further aspect, the current application claims a (first) system for
determining a chlorophyll concentration configured to carry out the above discussed
method(s) according to the first aspect.
[0042] According to a further aspect, the current application claims a (second) system for
determining at least a measurement region for providing a fertilizer recommendation
to a crop configured to carry out the above-discussed method(s) according to the second
aspect.
[0043] According to a further embodiment, the (second) system further comprises a display
and an input unit, wherein the system further comprises a graphical user interface,
GUI, configured to display a plurality of measurement regions, wherein the graphical
user interface is further configured to receive an input for selecting one measurement
region from the plurality of measurement regions displayed.
[0044] It is noted that the first and second systems could form a combined system.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE FIGURES
[0045] The accompanying drawings, which are included to provide a further understanding
of the present disclosure and are incorporated in and constitute a part of this specification,
illustrate embodiments of the disclosure and together with the description serve to
explain the principles of the disclosure.
Figure 1 shows an agricultural field according to the field of application of the
present disclosure.
Figure 2 shows a schematic representation of a system according to an embodiment of
the present disclosure.
Figure 3 shows an example of an underlying problem in the detection of chlorophyll
concentration by means of remote sensing.
Figure 4 shows the different chlorophyll and water absorption bands present in light
spectrum.
Figure 5 shows a representation of how chlorophyll related biomass invariant index
according to the present disclosure can be interpreted.
Figures 6A to 6C show the values of the different vegetation indexes or coefficients
according to the present disclosure over an agricultural field.
Figure 7 shows a workflow according to one embodiment of the present disclosure.
Figure 8 shows a schematic representation of a system according to a further embodiment
of the present disclosure.
Figure 9 shows a system according to one of the embodiments of the present disclosure.
Figure 10 shows the measurement regions as determined following one embodiment of
the present disclosure.
Figure 11 shows the measurement regions as determined following another embodiment
of the present disclosure.
[0046] The accompanying drawings are used to help easily understand the technical idea of
the present disclosure and it should be understood that the idea of the present disclosure
is not limited by the accompanying drawings. The idea of the present disclosure should
be construed to extend to any alterations, equivalents and substitutes besides the
accompanying drawings. Reference will now be made in detail to several embodiments,
examples of which are illustrated in the accompanying figures.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0047] As used below in this text, the singular forms "a", "an", "the" include both the
singular and the plural, unless the context clearly indicates otherwise. The terms
"comprise", "comprises" as used below are synonymous with "including", "include" or
"contain", "contains" and are inclusive or open and do not exclude additional unmentioned
parts, elements or method steps. Where this description refers to a product or process
which "comprises" specific features, parts or steps, this refers to the possibility
that other features, parts or steps may also be present, but may also refer to embodiments
which only contain the listed features, parts or steps.
[0048] The enumeration of numeric values by means of ranges of figures comprises all values
and fractions in these ranges, as well as the cited end points. The term "approximately"
as used when referring to a measurable value, such as a parameter, an amount, a time
period, and the like, is intended to include variations of +/- 10% or less, preferably
+/-5% or less, more preferably +/-1% or less, and still more preferably +/-0.1% or
less, of and from the specified value, in so far as the variations apply to the disclosure
disclosed herein. It should be understood that the value to which the term "approximately"
refers per se has also been disclosed.
[0049] Unless defined otherwise, all terms present in the current disclosure, including
technical and scientific terms, have the meaning which a person skilled in the art
usually gives them. For further guidance, definitions are included to further explain
terms which are used in the description of the disclosure.
[0050] Figure 1 depicts an agricultural field comprising at least one crop within an agricultural
region with other systems and apparatus with which the system 100 may interoperate.
In Figure 2, an example of a system 100 according to the present disclosure is represented.
System 100, according to the present disclosure, comprises several components such
as a memory unit 110, a processor 120, a wired/wireless communication unit 130, an
input/output unit 140. The system 100 may as well be operatively connected with a
personal or mobile device 200 by means of the communication unit 130.
[0051] System 100 comprises an agricultural recommendation engine 220 to which the system
may be remotely connected by means of the communication unit 130, may it be of a remote
nature. In this case, the agricultural recommendation engine 220 may be represented
by a computer, a remotely accessible server, other client-server architectures or
any other electronic devices usually encompassed under the term data processing apparatus.
System 100 does not need to be located within the vicinities of the agricultural field
where the recommendation is supposed to take place.
[0052] System 100 can be represented as well by a laptop computer or handheld device, with
an integrated agricultural recommendation engine 150 which can be fully operated at
the farm's location and may comprise a GPS unit 180 or any other suitable localization
means, as well as a fully remote computer or server configured to establish communication
with the further personal or mobile device 200 from which the users may operate the
system 100.
[0053] It is to be understood that the presence of remote and integrated recommendation
engines are not mutually excluding. Integrated agricultural recommendation engine
150 can be a local copy of remote agricultural recommendation engine 220 or a light
version of it to support periods of low network connectivity and offline work. Further,
mobile or personal device 200 is considered to be any state-of-the-art mobile computing
device which allows the input and ouput of data by the users and comprise the usual.
[0054] System 100 and/or remote or integrated agricultural recommendation engine 220 may
comprise field, farm data and external data, whereby external data comprises weather
data and further data provided by weather forecast providers or other third parties.
Field data may comprise amongst others, field and geographic identifiers regarding
the geometry of the boundaries of the agricultural field, including the presence of
areas within the agricultural field which are not managed, topographic data, crop
identifiers (crop variety and type, growth status, planting data and date, plant nutrition
and health status), harvest data (yield, value, product quality, estimated or recorded
historic values), soil data (type, pH, soil organic matter, SOM, and/or cation exchange
capacity, CEC) as well as historic series of the data. Farm data may comprise further
data regarding to planned and past tasks like field maintenance practices and agricultural
practices, fertilizer application data, pesticide application data, irrigation data
and other field reports as well as historic series of the data, allowing the comparison
of the data with past data, and further administrative data like work shifts, logs
and other organizational data. Planned and past tasks may comprise activities like
surveillance of plants and pests, application of pesticides, fungicides or crop nutrition
products, measurements of at least one farm or field parameter, maintenance and repair
of ground hardware and other similar activities.
[0055] The system 100 or agricultural recommendation engine 220 may be configured to receive
and/or retrieve soil data from available online soil databases like SoilGrids from
the World Soil Information, SSURGO (Soil Survey Geographic Database from the United
States Department of Agriculture) or any similar soil data repository.
[0056] System 100 may be further configured to receive any of the above-mentioned data and
further field data from a predetermined number of locations within or nearby the analyzed
region, inputted manually by the users/farmers by means of the input unit 140 or received
by the communication unit 120 from dedicated sensors 270. Further, system 100 and
agricultural recommendation engine 220 may be configured to receive weather data from
nearby weather stations 260 and/or external crop/farm sensors 270, as well as by means
of the input unit 140. Nearby weather stations 260 and/or external crop/farm sensors
270 are configured to communicate via one or more networks. In another embodiment,
weather data is provided by external weather forecast companies. Weather data may
further include present and past temperatures, accumulated precipitation, relative
humidity, wind speed, solar radiance, accumulated sun hours, etc.
[0057] System 100 may further be operatively connected to an agricultural apparatus 300.
Examples of agricultural apparatus 300 include tractors, combines, harvesters, planters,
trucks, fertilizer equipment, and any other item of physical machinery or hardware,
typically mobile machinery, and which may be used in tasks associated with agriculture.
In one embodiment, system 100 may be configured to communicate with the agricultural
apparatus 300 by means of wireless networks in order to carry out a fertilizer application.
System 100 may be further configured to produce a downloadable script file for the
agricultural apparatus 300 to carry out the fertilizer application on uniform or variable
rates across the field.
[0058] According to the main embodiment of the current disclosure, the method of the current
disclosure is a computer-implemented method for remotely determining a chlorophyll
concentration of a crop in an agricultural field, wherein the method comprises the
steps of receiving remote spectral data 1000 from a plurality of wavelengths of the
agricultural field, wherein the plurality of wavelengths comprises at least one wavelength
from a water absorption band and at least one from a chlorophyll absorption band,
generating a first index 2000, wherein the first index is a chlorophyll related vegetation
index based on the at least one leaf pigment absorption band of said spectral data,
generating a second index 3000, wherein the second index is a water related vegetation
index based on the at least one water absorption band of said spectral data, determining
the chlorophyll concentration of the crop 4000 based on the chlorophyll related vegetation
index and the water related vegetation index.
[0059] The present application makes use of suitable remote spectral data for determining
the in-field variability of the crop chlorophyll concentration. Remote data can be
referred to data provided by imaging satellites 250 or suitable manned or unmanned
imaging aerial vehicles 260. These satellite or vehicle systems are configured to
communicate by means of dedicated networks and usual methods which do not need being
disclosed herein. Amongst the different remote data available for use, satellite data
is nowadays widely available from numerous public (LANDSAT from NASA, SENTINEL from
ESA) and/or private providers. The present method is however not limited to a satellite
data platform, since the spectral bands which can be of use for the present method
are provided in a big range of the standard satellite platforms. While in active or
passive systems designed for imaging aerial vehicles the wavelengths can be determined
at will, due to the differences present across different satellite and optical sensor
platforms, it is hereby not intended to limit the support of the current disclosure
to exact and specific wavelengths and the given wavelengths are provided for orientation.
While different factors and corrections can be introduced to account for these variabilities,
the use of wavelengths proximate to the ones mentioned below should be understood
since the specifications of said platforms vary accordingly. Further specifications
of the required properties within the specific wavelengths are specified below.
[0060] As it is to be seen in Figure 4, as published in
Seelig et. al. (2008), "The assessment of leaf water content using leaf reflectance
ratios in the visible, near-, and short-wave-infrared", different wavelengths from the light spectrum can be selected in order to determine
a chlorophyll amount. The absorption spectrum of chlorophyll includes wavelengths
of blue and orange-red light, as is indicated by their peaks around 450-475 nm and
around 650-675 nm. In contrast, the five absorption bands in the SWIR range, centered
at about 970 nm, 1200 nm, 1450 nm, 1930 nm, and 2500nm, are mainly caused by water,
offering the possibility of assessing leaf water content remotely. Moreover, as it
can be clearly derived from Figure 4, the different bands have specific breadth and
reflectance properties for the different wavelengths, what will be used as well for
the advantageous method of the current disclosure.
[0061] While the peaks or centers of each band are defined at specific values, the current
disclosure makes use of the advantages entailed by measuring at the edge of the specific
wavelength bands.
[0062] A usual approach for the determination of crop chlorophyll amount by means of vegetation
indexes or coefficients used in the field of remote sensing for detecting chlorophyll
in the crop canopy of agricultural fields include the normalized difference vegetation
index (NDVI), which is computed as follows:

wherein NIR represents a reflectance value related to the Near Infrared wavelengths,
at about a wavelength range of 750-850nm and RED the reflectance measurements acquired
in the red visible spectrum, at about a wavelength range of 600-700 nm. While the
Near Infrared spectrum may comprise a broader wavelength spectrum, for the scope of
the current disclosure, the specific wavelengths which might be used are those like
above which are not affected by chlorophyll in this case, nor by water for the water-related
index as it will be seen below and depicted in Figure 4 and the values specified above
are orientative.
[0063] However, as already mentioned, NDVI and other typical satellite indexes measure chlorophyll
content, or total chlorophyll per ground area (abbreviated as Chl% x DM, wherein Chl%
represents the chlorophyll concentration and DM the dry matter amount of the crop
present in the image). As it is depicted in Figure 3, this presents the disadvantage
that certain combinations of dry matter and chlorophyll concentration may result in
similar values for the total chlorophyll per ground area. As it is to be seen in Figure
3, wherein different images of crops are presents, when plotting the dry matter content
in the horizontal axis over the chlorophyll concentration in the vertical axes, different
crop properties can be assessed. Images 3 and 4 have both a high chlorophyll concentration
(i.e., plants present a darker green) and images 1 and 2 present a low chlorophyll
concentration (i.e., plants display a lighter green). On the other side, images 1
and 3 present a lower dry matter amount (i.e., there is more ground visible since
the plants are not that developed and/or the plant density is inferior), whereas images
2 and 4 display crops with a higher dry matter. While at a closer look as depicted
in Figure 3 the differences are easy to be observed, in the case of remote sensing,
wherein the images are obtained from a much greater distance, images 2 and 3 are seen
as equivalents since the combination of dry matter and chlorophyll concentration results
in approximately the same value of chlorophyll content per ground area. As such, NDVI
is unable of determining a chlorophyll concentration measurement which is independent
from the dry biomass present in the displayed crops and the advantages of the current
application will be made clear below.
[0064] The method of the current disclosure comprises therefore receiving remote spectral
data from a plurality of wavelengths of the agricultural field, wherein the plurality
of wavelengths comprises at least one wavelength from a water absorption band as defined
above and at least one from a leaf pigment or chlorophyll absorption band as defined
above. The method of the current disclosure further comprises generating a first index,
wherein the first index is a chlorophyll related vegetation index (S
Chl% x DM) based on the at least one leaf pigment absorption band of said spectral data. Thanks
to the further processing present in the current application, said chlorophyll related
vegetation index may be an index which takes into account the amount of total chlorophyll
per ground area. As such, this generated chlorophyll related index may be one of the
known NDVI index or any other suitable chlorophyll related index (e.g. amongst others,
the following indices may as well be used: Normalized difference red edge (NDRE),
Simple ratio infrared to red (IR/R), Simple ratio infrared to green" (IR/G), Soil
adjusted vegetation index (SAVI), or any other equivalent chlorophyll related index).
[0065] The method of the current disclosure further comprises generating a second index,
wherein the second index is a water related vegetation index (S
W% x DM) based on at least one water absorption band of said spectral data. Examples of said
generated vegetation indexes or coefficient may be represented by the Normalized Difference
Water Index or any other suitable water related index. As mentioned before for the
chlorophyll related index, these indexes usually detect water content per ground area,
and they're influenced by the crop dry mass amount present in the field.
[0066] The Normalized Difference Water Index (NDWI), in one of the usual formulations, is
derived from the Near Infrared (NIR) and Short-Wave Infrared (SWIR) channels as follows:

[0067] This formula highlights the amount of water in water bodies and comprises at least
one water absorption band, since the five absorption bands SWIR range present in Sentinel-2,
centered at about 970 nm, 1200 nm, 1450 nm, 1930 nm, and 2500nm, are mainly caused
by water, offering the possibility of assessing leaf water content per ground area
remotely as mentioned above, and at least one band outside the water absorption band
(NIR). However, the current method is not limited to the above-mentioned NDWI, and
other water-related water indexes may be used (e.g., Modified NDWI (MNDWI), Weighted
Normalized Difference Water Index (WNDWI) or the Water Ratio Index (WRI), or any other
equivalent water related index).
[0068] Further, the method of the current disclosure comprises determining the chlorophyll
concentration of the crop based on the chlorophyll related vegetation index (S
Chl% x DM) and the water related vegetation index (S
W% x DM). As such, a chlorophyll concentration index is generated based on both indexes.
[0069] In a further embodiment, determining the chlorophyll concentration based on the chlorophyll-related
vegetation index and the water-related vegetation index comprises determining a chlorophyll-related
biomass-invariant vegetation index (S
Chl%).
[0070] In a further embodiment, determining a chlorophyll-related biomass-invariant or chlorophyll
concentration index comprises establishing a deviation from a determined relationship
between the first index and the second index, wherein at least one of the first index
and the second index has been offset and scaled by means of crop dependent constants.
[0071] For example, such a combination may be made by means of linear regression to generate
a linear relation between the chlorophyll related index and the water related index
as follows:

[0072] In the above-mentioned equation, a and b represent crop specific constants which
set up the specific relation of the indices used for a specific crop. While only a
linear regression and a direct subtraction of the chlorophyll related index and the
water related is shown above, non-linear approaches for fitting the expected relationship
between the different indices are envisaged within the scope of the present disclosure
in order to precisely determine it. Moreover, a ratio or quotient of the indices,
or a shifted ratio of the indices may as well be used in order to characterize the
chlorophyll related biomass invariant index according to the present disclosure.
[0073] The generated coefficient is therefore a chlorophyll-related biomass-invariant vegetation
index, hereby giving a direct indication of the chlorophyll concentration of the crop,
without being affected by the amount of dry mass or biomass present in the fields.
The meaning of such a regression function may be observed in Figure 5. The line represents
the determined relationship for a specific crop between the first (chlorophyll related)
index and the second (water related) index, wherein the points present in the figure
represent the specific values for each pixel within the field. As such, for a specific
pixel, if the pixel is above the line (as indicated by the bi-directional arrow present
in the figure), i.e., S
Chl% > 0, this gives an indication that the chlorophyll content in that pixel is bigger
than the water content. Analogously, if the pixel is below the line, S
Chl% < 0, this is a clear case when the water content in that pixel is greater than the
chlorophyll content, such that if the water concentration is regarded as constant,
the value of the chlorophyll-related biomass invariant vegetation index gives a direct
indication of the chlorophyll concentration. Since plants usually aim at maintaining
their water concentration by closing their stomata, such a conclusion is valid despite
the different soil moisture levels over the field.
[0074] In a further embodiment, the water-related vegetation index is based on at least
one additional wavelength outside water absorption bands.
[0075] In a further embodiment, the chlorophyll-related vegetation index is based on at
least one additional wavelength outside chlorophyll absorption bands.
[0076] In a further embodiment, the at least one wavelength from a water absorption band
is chosen at the edge of the water absorption band.
[0077] In a further embodiment, the at least one wavelength from a chlorophyll absorption
band is chosen at the edge of the chlorophyll absorption band.
[0078] When determining suitable bands, the choice is usually given by the available bands
at each satellite platform which fulfill the above-mentioned requirements. For example,
when using remote spectral data obtained from the Sentinel-2, in order to compute
the above mentioned NDVI, the relevant bands for the determination of the chlorophyll
related index may be B04 (665 nm) and B08 (842 nm). Analogously, band B11 (1610 nm)
and B08 (842 nm) can be used as SWIR and NIR bands as defined above for the water
related index. However, the disclosure of the current application is not limited to
satellite data and other approaches can be followed in which active, or passive systems,
with fully customizable wavelength selection can be designed to follow the approach
of the current disclosure. In this sense, when choosing a band outside of the respective
absorption bands, this "outside" band should be placed completely outside, but still
as close as possible to the absorption band. Regarding the choice at the edge, but
still "inside" the respective band, the choice depends on the application and the
material in focus, wherein the current disclosure is directed to the analysis of crop
canopy. Placing at the center of the band results in highest sensitivity at low concentrations,
but may lead to saturation at higher concentrations and render very difficult distinguishing
between high and very high concentrations. Hence, it is therefore advantageous to
place the "inside" band off-center at the edge of the absorption band as mentioned
above to overcome saturation.
[0079] The optimum wavelength of the "inside" band, located at the edge of the absorption
band, can be found experimentally by collecting data from crops that represent the
typical range of appearances in the relevant period of time, i. e. a dataset that
comprises crops at different fertilization levels and at the relevant growth stages.
For each analyzed waveband the index is calculated for the whole dataset, related
to the target quantity (here: amount of chlorophyll or water) and the (typically linear)
coefficient of determination (r
2) is calculated. The waveband which results in the highest r
2 is chosen.
[0080] As it can be seen in Figures 6A to 6C, the different indices are shown over the same
agricultural field. Figure 6A shows the values of the chlorophyll-related index (S
Chl% x DM), Figure 6B shows the water-related index (S
W) and Figure 6C shows the chlorophyll-related biomass-invariant index (S
Chl%). As it can be observed there is a high correlation between the different maps, since
chlorophyll concentration and chlorophyll amount normally correlate. However, when
analyzing the differences, it is clear to be seen that the chlorophyll level of the
crop is highest at the darkest points shown in Figure 6C as marked by regions 310
in Figure 6C, wherein the other remaining areas in darkest colors in Figure 6A are
deemed to not have that highest level of chlorophyll level of the crop despite the
high apparent chlorophyll content (see, e.g. region 315 in Figure 6C, wherein same
region in Figure 6A was apparently one of the regions with higher chlorophyll content).
Hence, discarding those areas where the biomass or dry matter present may influence
the observations from the satellite is of high importance for determining the chlorophyll
level in the crop, and as we will see below, determine suitable and relevant measurement
regions for a crop chlorophyll measurement device.
[0081] The current disclosure aims as well at improving the readings by a suitable combination
of remote sensing and local sensing. As such, in a further embodiment, the method
further comprises the steps of receiving at least one chlorophyll concentration of
the crop measured with a chlorophyll measurement device and determining the chlorophyll
level of the crop based on the remotely determined chlorophyll concentration and the
received measured crop chlorophyll concentration. Once the crop chlorophyll concentration
for the whole agricultural field has been determined based on the remote spectral
data, obtaining a "chlorophyll map" of the distribution of the chlorophyll concentration
of the crop in the agricultural field, the at least one direct measurement of the
chlorophyll concentration can be used to adjust the overall remotely determined chlorophyll
concentration of the crop. Remotely determined magnitudes might present a certain
offset due to the nature of remote sensing, by biasing the remotely determined chlorophyll
concentration by means of a local measurement, the accuracy of the determined chlorophyll
concentration is improved.
[0082] While it is clear from the current disclosure the advantages of using crop chlorophyll
concentration measurement devices which directly benefit from the remote determination,
the current disclosure envisages as well the approach with other crop nutrient measurement
devices, wherein the combination still produces improved crop knowledge and more accurate
fertilizer recommendations. As such, other possibilities include crop chlorophyll
content measurement devices, crop nitrogen measurement devices or crop nutrient measurement
devices and the like which can be related to chlorophyll concentration or which measurement
can be combined with the remotely determined crop chlorophyll concentration. For example,
laser induced breakdown spectroscopy measurement devices may directly measurement
nitrogen, directly related to chlorophyll, and/or other nutrients like Phosphorus
or Potassium. In any of those possible cases, the fertilizer recommendation can be
improved by introducing chlorophyll values expected throughout the field on top of
the possible Potassium or Phosphorus recommendation, or the Nitrogen level as determined
by the laser induced breakdown spectroscopy measurement devices may be directly related
to the chlorophyll concentration and with it the remotely determined crop chlorophyll
concentration used for producing "chlorophyll maps" which derive an improved determination
of the crop chlorophyll content and/or improved fertilizer recommendation. As such,
there is no strict limitation to crop chlorophyll concentration measurement devices
within the current disclosure, apart from the specific cases where the direct relation
can be exploited for improving the remote crop chlorophyll concentration determination.
[0083] While the advantages of a direct determination of chlorophyll levels in crops is
clear, further advantages of the application are to be seen in combination when a
direct local measurement of crop chlorophyll concentration content is carried out
by means of a crop chlorophyll concentration measurement device, or as mentioned above
with other crop nutrient measurement devices. As known from the PCT patent application
PCT/EP2022/056462, which is hereby incorporated by reference, determining measurement regions for crop
nutrient measurement devices presents the great advantage that relevant measurements
for obtaining a crop nutrient status of a crop can be achieved. While the general
link between nitrogen and chlorophyll is known, the effect of biomass (or dry matter)
as explained above on usual chlorophyll related vegetation indices is as well of great
importance for determining the measurement regions following the disclosure of
PCT/EP2022/056462 mentioned above when carrying out measurements with specific crop chlorophyll or
nutrient measurement devices. As such, determining these measurement regions based
on a specific chlorophyll-related biomass-invariant index as defined above is of great
advantage. As such, in a further embodiment, the method of the current disclosure
may further comprise determining at least one measurement region for carrying out
at least one measurement with a crop nutrient measurement device in said measurement
region for providing a fertilizer recommendation to a crop comprising the steps of
determining the at least one measurement region based on the remotely determined chlorophyll
concentration.
[0084] In a further embodiment, the crop nutrient measurement device is a crop chlorophyll
measurement device. In a further embodiment, the crop nutrient measurement is a crop
chlorophyll concentration measurement device.
[0085] A system according to the disclosure of
PCT/EP2022/056462 and as shown in the schematic representation of Figure 8 and as one of the possible
constructional embodiments according to the present disclosure in Figure 9 will be
described below. It is to be mentioned that a system as described from now on may
as well be configured to carry the method steps described above, since such a system
comprises the necessary processing and communication unit. However, the system may
be specially configured to carry out the local crop nutrient or chlorophyll measurements
as well as the measurement region determination and as such some reference signs are
shared amongst the different embodiments (e.g. memory unit 110, processor 120, ...).
Figure 8 shows a schematic representation of system 100 according to the following
embodiments, wherein system 100 comprises a crop nutrient measurement device or a
crop chlorophyll concentration measurement device 160 and a communication unit 130.
[0086] Crop nutrient measurement devices and crop chlorophyll measurement devices present
different constructional arrangements. Some embodiments of these devices comprise
an own communication unit 130 or are operably connected to a mobile communication
device like a laptop, smartphone or tablet or other mobile electronic device with
full processing capabilities which functions as communication unit, as it can be seen
in Figure 9. In other embodiments, the devices are peripherals attached to the mobile
communication device, using a camera of the mobile communication device as optical
detection unit, basing respectively the determination of the crop nutrient, chlorophyll
concentration or content on the reflectivity or transmissivity of the leaves at specific
wavelengths. However, no specific determination of the nutrient or chlorophyll detection
principle is intended for the goal of the current disclosure, since the neither the
specificities of the detecting principle nor the constructional arrangement of the
system are intrinsically related to the advantages provided by the current disclosure.
[0087] Communication unit 130 may therefore be an integral or dedicated unit integrated
with the crop nutrient or crop chlorophyll measurement device 160 or a separate electronic
communications device operably connected to the crop nutrient or chlorophyll measurement
device 160. In a further embodiment, system 100 may be a handheld mobile device. Different
examples of these embodiments would be represented by already existing devices, like
the N-Tester BT
® and the N-Tester Clip
®, which are incorporated herein by reference as direct crop chlorophyll concentration
measurement devices.
[0088] System 100 comprises several components such as a processor 120, a communication
unit 130, a location determining or GPS unit 180 or equivalent (Glonass, Beidou, Galileo...)
and a memory unit 110. System 100 may further comprise an input/output unit 140, which
might take form as separate devices (a display and a keyboard) or which might be combined
as a touch sensitive screen. System 100 is however not limited by these components
and may further comprise other elements as customary within the standard practice.
[0089] System 100 may further comprise an integrated agricultural recommendation engine
150 or a remote agricultural recommendation engine 210 (not shown in Figure 9) to
which the system may be remotely connected by means of the communication unit 130.
System 100 and/or agricultural recommendation engines 150 or 210 may be represented
by a single device or a distributed series of devices intercommunicated. As such,
each can be represented by computer, a remotely accessible server, other client-server
architectures or any other electronic devices usually encompassed under the term data
processing apparatus. As such, all steps within the method of the current disclosure
may be carried out (partly) separately or jointly in any of the processing units of
system 100 or agricultural recommendation engine 210.
[0090] Figure 9 shows an exemplary use according to one embodiment of the system of the
present disclosure wherein the communication unit 130 and the crop nutrient or chlorophyll
measurement device 160 are different elements. Crop nutrient or chlorophyll measurement
device 160 may be operatively connected to the communication unit 130 by means of
a suitable wired or wireless connection. However, other embodiments where the system
is formed by a mobile phone and a peripheral element operatively connected to the
mobile phone enables the mobile phone to determine the crop nutrient or chlorophyll
level based on the transmissivity of light are as well included within the current
disclosure. Farmers, when in a field, are able of determining the plant nutrient content
by directly analyzing one or more leaves of a plant present in the agricultural field.
Other embodiments within the scope of the current disclosure include other constructional
arrangements in which the crop nutrient or chlorophyll measurement device 110 and
the communication unit 120 may be integrally formed in a single device.
[0091] By choosing regions in the agricultural field wherein the chlorophyll concentration
is relevant and representative of the crop chlorophyll concentration distribution
over the field, a more precise fertilization recommendation can be achieved.
[0092] In a further embodiment, determining the at least one measurement region based on
the determined chlorophyll level comprises determining a measurement region within
the agricultural field wherein the crop chlorophyll content is within a predetermined
threshold of a first predetermined value of the chlorophyll content within the field.
[0093] In a further embodiment, the predetermined value is defined as the average value
of the chlorophyll concentration within the field, i.e., being S
Chl% the chlorophyll-related biomass-invariant index, determining the regions wherein
S
Chl% is chosen such that 0.8 Avg (S
Chl%) < S
Chl% < 1.2 Avg (S
Chl%), wherein Avg(S
Chl%) represents the average of the chlorophyll-related biomass-invariant index over the
agricultural field. In a further embodiment, S
Chl% is chosen such that 0.9 Avg (S
Chl%) < S
Chl% < 1.1 Avg (S
Chl%), more specifically such that 0.95 Avg (S
Chl%) < S
Chl% < 1.05 Avg (S
Chl%).
[0094] In a further embodiment, the predetermined value is defined as the maximum value
of the chlorophyll concentration within the field, i.e., S
Chl% is chosen such that S
Chl% > 0.8 max(S
Chl%), wherein max(S
Chl%) represents the maximum value of the chlorophyll-related biomass-invariant index
over the agricultural field. In a further embodiment, S
Chl% is chosen such that S
Chl% > 0.9 max(S
Chl%), more specifically such that S
Chl% > 0.95 max(S
Chl%).
[0095] In a further embodiment, the method further comprises receiving a chlorophyll concentration
measurement of the crop at the at least one measurement region and adjusting the determined
chlorophyll level of the crop based on the received chlorophyll concentration measurement.
Analogously to the previous embodiment, the direct measurement of the crop chlorophyll
concentration improves the remotely determined chlorophyll concentration determination
of the whole crop since a reliable measurement can be used to eliminate any offset
the remote spectral data might comprise due to the nature of remote measuring systems,
even more now that a specific region relevant for such a measurement has been determined.
[0096] In a further embodiment, determining at least one measurement region comprises determining
at least one first measurement region 301 and at least one second measurement region
302, as it is to be seen in Fig. 11, wherein the at least one first measurement region
is selected amongst the areas of the agricultural field wherein the crop chlorophyll
concentration is within a first predetermined threshold from a first predetermined
value of the crop chlorophyll concentration in the agricultural field and wherein
the at least one second measurement region is selected amongst the areas of the agricultural
field wherein the crop chlorophyll concentration is within a second predetermined
threshold from a second predetermined value of the crop chlorophyll concentration
in the agricultural field.
[0097] In a further embodiment, the first predetermined value may be a value representative
of the maximum value of the crop chlorophyll concentration and the second predetermined
value may be a value representative of the median, average or any other measure of
central tendency of the crop chlorophyll concentration.
[0098] That is, the first predetermined value, S
Chl% is chosen such that S
Chl% > 0.8 max(S
Chl%), wherein max(S
Chl%) represents the maximum value of the chlorophyll-related biomass-invariant index
over the agricultural field. In a further embodiment, S
Chl% is chosen such that S
Chl% > 0.9 max(S
Chl%), more specifically such that S
Chl% > 0.95 max(S
Chl%).
[0099] Regarding the second predetermined value being a value representative of the median
or the like, being S
Chl% the chlorophyll-related biomass-invariant index, determining the regions wherein
the second predetermined value may be a value representative of the median, average
or the like, S
Chl% is chosen such that 0.8 Avg (S
Chl%) < S
Chl% < 1.2 Avg (S
Chl%), wherein Avg(S
Chl%) represents the average of the chlorophyll-related biomass-invariant index over the
agricultural field. In a further embodiment, S
Chl% is chosen such that 0.9 Avg (S
Chl%) < S
Chl% < 1.1 Avg (S
Chl%), more specifically such that 0.95 Avg (S
Chl%) < S
Chl% < 1.05 Avg (S
Chl%). As mentioned above, any other measure of central tendency can be used instead of
the average function.
[0100] In a further embodiment, when the at least one first measurement region is chosen
amongst the areas within a certain threshold of the maximum value of the crop chlorophyll
concentration, and the at least one second measurement region is chosen amongst the
areas within a threshold of the average or the like values of the crop chlorophyll
concentration, a fertilizer recommendation may be determined based on the ratio of
the first crop chlorophyll concentration and the second crop chlorophyll concentration.
For example, based on the first crop chlorophyll concentration (Chl1) and the second
crop chlorophyll concentration (Chl2), a fertilizer blanket fertilizer application
for the whole field may be generated according to the following relation:

[0101] Wherein N
REC represents the amount of fertilizer needed generated by means of a suitable agronomic
function f. The value is of specific relevant when the ratio Chl2/Chl1 is below a
predetermined value which indicates the room for improvement in the nutrition of the
averagely nurtured areas, since this would indicate that the regions with an average
value of the coefficients, and those below it, will be benefitted from the fertilizer
application. In an embodiment, the predetermined value may be comprised between 0.7
and 1, more specifically between 0.8 and 1, more specifically between 0.9 and 1. As
mentioned above, while the specific chlorophyll concentration relation is shown here,
similar relations when estimating crop nutrients and/or chlorophyll content may be
established.
[0102] In a further embodiment, the method further comprises carrying out the fertilizer
application excepting at the areas amongst which the first measurement regions have
been chosen. When the first measurement regions have been chosen amongst the areas
where the first predetermined value may be a value representative of the maximum value
of the crop chlorophyll concentration, these regions are supposed to have no nutrient
stress and therefore have a lesser need of fertilizer.
[0103] According to a further embodiment, the method further comprises generating instructions
for an agricultural apparatus to carry out a fertilizer application based on the determined
and/or adjusted chlorophyll concentration of the crop.
[0104] In a further embodiment, generating instructions comprises producing a machine-readable
application prescription map based on the fertilizer recommendation to control the
agricultural apparatus. In a further embodiment, the method may comprise establishing
direct communication with an agricultural apparatus 300 over standard networks to
carry out the fertilizer application in an automatized manner. In a further embodiment,
the current method may be configured to generate a downloadable script or file, which
can be used for uploading such an application prescription map by physical means to
an agricultural apparatus.
[0105] In a further embodiment, the fertilizer recommendation is carried out by means of
a fertilizer application system, like a spreader or specially adapted agricultural
machinery.
[0106] System 100 may further comprise a dedicated Graphical User Interface as shown in
Figures 10 and 11 which assists the farmers in choosing the measurement regions. As
previously mentioned, the system may be configured to display a plurality of measurement
regions as determined by the different embodiments of the current disclosure to the
farmers by means of display unit 130 for the farmers to select by means of input unit
140 the best suitable option.
[0107] Although the system 100 is of a mobile nature, the Graphical User Interface may as
well be run on a laptop or desktop electronic device at the farm in preparation of
the daily activities, wherein it can be communicated with system 100 by means of usual
networks to transmit the determined measurement regions and the navigation possibilities.
[0108] In an embodiment as shown in the Figures, the current system 100 may comprise an
input unit 140 and display unit 130 combined as a touch sensitive display 135.
[0109] The farmers, when planning to carry out the measurements, may first select at least
one field from a plurality of agricultural fields to be inspected. The fields may
comprise crops of the same or different type and at least a part of the field may
be determined in which the crop for which the fertilizer recommendation is intended
is located. System 100 may be configured to display the at least one agricultural
field determined. System 100, when displaying the at least one field may further display
an icon 40 representative the location of the farmers if in the view.
[0110] Figure 10 shows the embodiment where a plurality of measurement regions 300 is displayed.
In this case, the farmers may select at least one of the measurement regions 300,
upon his convenience or based on further tasks planned on the field, wherein a measurement
may be conducted.
[0111] Figure 11 shows the embodiment where a plurality of first measurement regions 301
and a plurality of second measurement regions 302 are displayed. In this case, system
100 is further configured to display at least one first and at least one second measurement
regions within the agricultural field
[0112] System 100 may be configured to display first a plurality of first measurement regions
allowing the farmers to select their preferred first measurement region. Upon selection,
system 100 may display a plurality of second measurement regions. Based on the selection
of the first measurement region 301, the system is configured to show a plurality
of second measurement regions 302. These may be selected such that the plurality of
measurement regions which are within a predetermined distance from the first measurement
region 301 are displayed. While the example has been explained here in a predetermined
order, it is clear that the order can be reversed without departing from the scope
of the present disclosure and the measurement regions processed accordingly, achieving
herewith the same advantages.
[0113] Although the process steps, method steps, algorithms or the like may be described
in a sequential order or by the use or ordinal numbers, such processes, methods and
algorithms may be configured to work in alternate orders. In other words, any sequence
or order of steps that may be described does not necessarily indicate a requirement
that the steps be performed in that order. The steps of processes described herein
may be performed in any order practical. Further, some steps may be performed simultaneously,
in parallel, or concurrently. Various methods described herein may be practiced by
combining one or more machine-readable storage media containing the code according
to the present disclosure with appropriate standard computer hardware to execute the
code contained therein. An apparatus for practicing various embodiments of the present
disclosure may involve one or more computers (or one or more processors within a single
computer) and storage systems containing or having network access to computer program(s)
coded in accordance with various methods described herein, and the method steps of
the disclosure could be accomplished by modules, routines, subroutines, or subparts
of a computer program product. While the foregoing describes various embodiments of
the disclosure, other and further embodiments of the disclosure may be devised without
departing from the basic scope thereof. The scope of the disclosure is determined
by the claims that follow. The disclosure is not limited to the described embodiments,
versions or examples, which are included to enable a person having ordinary skill
in the art to make and use the disclosure when combined with information and knowledge
available to the person having ordinary skill in the art.
[0114] While the present disclosure has been illustrated by a description of various embodiments
and while these embodiments have been described in considerable detail, it is not
the intention of the applicant to restrict or in any way limit the scope of the appended
claims to such detail. Additional advantages and modifications will readily appear
to those skilled in the art. The disclosure in its broader aspects is therefore not
limited to the specific details, representative apparatus and method, and illustrative
example shown and described.
[0115] Accordingly, the detailed description thereof should not be construed as restrictive
in all aspects but considered as illustrative. The scope of the disclosure should
be determined by reasonable interpretation of the appended claims and all changes
that come within the equivalent scope are included in the scope of the current disclosure.