[0001] The invention relates to a method for starting up a gas burning appliance. In addition,
the invention relates to a gas burning appliance, the use of such as gas burning appliance
and a computer program product.
[0002] Gas burning appliances are commonplace for heating purposes and for providing hot
domestic / tap water. Such appliances typically have a burning chamber, in which a
mixture of air and combustible gas, e.g. natural gas, is introduced. At start-up,
a spark electrode is activated to create ignition and a stable flame.
[0003] Delayed ignition is a known problem and occurs when ignition doesn't take place immediately,
while combustible gas continues to flow into the burning chamber causing a build-up
of combustible gas. A delayed ignition, i.e. ignition of the accumulated combustible
mixture, may cause an explosion with associated damage and noise. Delayed ignition
may have different reasons, such as a malfunctioning spark electrode, insufficient
flow of combustible gas or a nonoptimal air-natural gas ratio.
[0004] Delayed ignition is in particular a problem when the combustible gas comprises a
high amount of hydrogen, as an explosion caused by a delayed ignition of a combustible
air-hydrogen mixture may not only damage internal components of the appliance, but
also damage internal components, which may even be ejected from the boiler case of
the appliance. Moreover, the high sound levels that such an explosion produces, could
potentially lead to hearing damage of people who are in the vicinity of such an appliance.
[0005] To address the issue of delayed ignition, a controller may be provided that, at start
up, activates the spark electrode for ignition and opens the gas valve to allow the
fuel gas to flow into the burning chamber for a pre-set ignition safety time. The
gas valve remains open if ignition and a stable flame is achieved during the pre-set
ignition safety time. If not, the gas valve is closed, to prevent build-up of natural
gas in the burning chamber.
[0006] EP4015904A1 discloses a method and device for protecting a heater during the ignition of a mixture
of air and hydrogen-containing fuel gas. A method and corresponding device for igniting
a combustion process in a combustion chamber of a heating device is provided, which
is operated with hydrogen or a fuel gas containing hydrogen, and a flame monitor for
detecting a flame with a response time after the beginning of the supply of an ignitable
mixture of air and combustible gas to the combustion chamber. An ignition process
is triggered for a maximum of the duration of a predeterminable ignition time interval,
which is shorter than a safety time interval, after the end of which the supply of
an ignitable mixture is terminated if no flame has been detected up to this point.
According to this document this increases safety when starting a heating device operated
with hydrogen or a fuel gas containing hydrogen and enables particularly gentle and
safe ignition processes.
[0007] Since hydrogen molecules are smaller compared to for instance methane, there is an
increased chance of leakage of hydrogen into the burning chamber when the gas supply
is still closed. This may result in creation of an ignitable mixture, in particular
since hydrogen has a lower flammability limit and lower ignition energies compared
to natural gas.
[0008] This may also reduce in dangerous situations during ignition. Although a proper sealing
of the gas valve is required when gas supply is off, mal function of a gas valve could
result in leakage even when the valve is off.
[0009] Other approaches to safely ignite hydrogen burning appliances are provided by the
prior art.
[0010] EP3971475A describes an alternative manner of dealing with delayed ignition, i.e. by describing
an air-gas mixture burning appliance that comprises a burning unit for burning a combustible
air-gas mixture, a flame detector for sensing presence of a flame in the burning unit,
an air-gas mixing unit that is arranged upstream of the burning unit for mixing of
air and gas to form the combustible air-gas mixture, and a gas supply unit that is
arranged upstream of the air-gas mixing unit, wherein the gas supply unit is adapted
to regulating a flow of gas to the air-gas mixing unit such that the combustible air-gas
mixture has a variable equivalence ratio between gas and air that is based on whether
the flame detector senses the presence of the flame in the burning unit or fails to
sense the presence of a flame in the burning unit.
[0011] WO2021078949 relates to a surface stabilized fully premixed gas premix burner for burning hydrogen
gas, and method for starting such burner. A method is provided for starting a burner
wherein a premixed gas comprising a combustible gas and air is supplied, wherein the
combustible gas comprises at least 50% by volume of hydrogen. The method comprises
the following steps: during a start-up phase: supplying premixed gas having a first
lambda-value to the burner surface, wherein the first lambda-value is at least 1.85,
and igniting the supplied premixed gas having the first lambda-value using an ignition
source. During an operation phase after the premixed gas has been ignited: supplying
premixed gas having a second lambda-value to the burner surface, wherein the first
lambda-value is larger than the second lambda-value. The lambda-value is defined as
a ratio between an actually supplied quantity of air and the quantity of air required
for stoichiometric combustion of the premixed gas.
[0012] The object of the invention is therefore to provide a gas burning appliance and a
method of operating such a gas burning appliance with a reduced risk of uncontrolled
combustion or explosions. A further object is to reduce the risk of delayed ignition,
by reducing the chance of delayed ignition occurring and/or by reducing the consequences
of an unwanted delayed ignition.
[0013] The object is solved by a method for starting up a gas burning appliance, the gas
burning appliance comprising a burning chamber, a gas supply for supplying combustible
gas to the burning chamber, a flame detector for detecting the presence of a flame
in the burning chamber and an ignitor for igniting the combustible gas in the burning
chamber, wherein the method comprises an ignition sequence comprising:
- activating the igniter for a predetermined ignition time,
- opening the gas supply for a predetermined safety time to supply combustible gas to
the burning chamber,
- detecting the presence of a flame by means of the flame detector,
- closing the gas supply if no flame has been detected at the end of the predetermined
safety time,
wherein the combustible gas comprises more than 20 mol% of hydrogen and
wherein activation of the igniter commences at a predetermined pre-ignition time interval
before opening the gas supply.
[0014] It has been found that the chance of delayed ignition, as well as the consequences
of a delayed ignition, can be reduced for burning appliances that use hydrogen or
a hydrogen comprising combustible gas, in particular combustible gas that comprise
more than 20 mol% hydrogen.
[0015] By using a pre-ignition time as defined, a proper spark is ensured at the time the
gas supply opens and the risk of a delayed ignition is reduced since sparking is initiated
early. For instance, as a result of humidity, it may take time for the ignitor to
function properly. An ignitor creating sparks by ignition pulses may not generate
proper sparks at the first ignition pulses due to humidity. So, the margin for the
delay time is increased.
[0016] Hydrogen has a higher flammable range, higher flame speed and requires lower ignition
energies compared to natural gas. Therefore, lower safety times can be used to ignite
a hydrogen boiler. However delayed ignition is more problematic so reducing the chance
and severity of delayed ignition is preferred.
[0017] The safety time is the time that elapses between the order to open and the order
to close the gas supply, in particular the hydrogen supply, to the burner in the event
of ignition not taking place.
[0018] The pre-ignition time interval is the time interval in which the ignitor is activated
and the gas valve, in particular the hydrogen valve, is closed. The pre-ignition time
interval ends when the gas valve, in particular hydrogen valve, is opened. The predetermined
ignition time can consist of the pre-ignition time interval and a remaining time in
which the gas valve is open.
[0019] When using a predetermined pre-ignition time interval as described, the total sparking
time may be increased. So, in case of ignition delay, the moment of ignition will
be earlier with pre-ignition compared with the situation without pre-ignition. Therefore,
the volume of combustible gas containing (potentially explosive) H
2 is reduced as well since the opening of the gas supply is relatively short at the
moment of delayed ignition. Consequently, the impact thereof is reduced.
[0020] The chance of explosions caused by delayed ignition is thus reduced since the sparking
starts earlier, and therefore in case of delayed ignition, the ignition will take
place relatively earlier after opening of the gas supply.
[0021] Using a predetermined pre-ignition time interval in combination with hydrogen containing
combustible gas (i.e., more than 20 mol% of hydrogen) is especially advantageous as
with hydrogen the effects of a pre-ignition time interval is bigger since delayed
ignition is more critical for H
2 and shorter ignition and safety times may be used. Thus, a proper and stable spark
needs to be assured by starting sparking earlier even before the gas valve is opened
to assure proper ignition.
[0022] Furthermore, in case of a leak in the gas supply, causing hydrogen to leak into the
burning chamber before opening of the gas supply, the pre-ignition could be used to
detect such a leak, since this ignition could result in combustion and therefore a
detected flame before opening of the gas supply. A flame detected before opening of
the gas supply may cause switching to an alarm state, which may comprise the start-up
of the gas burning appliance to be aborded, switch to a blocking or locking state
and/or to generate an alarm, like a sound or a message.
[0023] Detection of pre-ignition is important in the case of hydrogen, as for hydrogen the
effects of pre-ignition are bigger since delayed ignition is more critical for hydrogen.
[0024] As combustible gas a mixture of air and fuel gas is understood. The fuel gas can
be hydrogen or comprise hydrogen. The combustible gas is the gas that is supplied
to the burner and burnt in the combustion chamber.
[0025] According to an embodiment the hydrogen comprising combustible gas comprises more
than 40 mol% of hydrogen or more than 80 mol% of hydrogen or more than 90 mol% of
hydrogen or more than 98 mol% of hydrogen.
[0026] Of course, when a flame has been detected before the end of the predetermined safety
time, the fuel gas supply is kept open and the gas burning appliance continues to
operate in a continuous operation modus.
[0027] According to an embodiment the predetermined pre-ignition time interval is at least
1,0 second, or at least 1,5 seconds, or at least 2,0 seconds, or at least 2,5 seconds,
or at least 3,0 seconds.
[0028] According to an embodiment the predetermined pre-ignition time interval is shorter
than a remaining part of the predetermined ignition time. This ensures that the igniter
is igniting at least during part of the safety time, i.e. the time the gas supply
is opened. The overlap may be at least 0,5 seconds, or 1.0 second, or 1,5 seconds
or at least 2,0 seconds. During this overlap the gas burner appliance can ignite.
[0029] According to an embodiment the pre-ignition time interval plus the remaining part
of the ignition time is greater than or equal to the safety time. In other words,
activation of the igniter is ended before the end of the safety time.
[0030] This is advantageous in situations when flame detection cannot take place during
the ignition time, as an active igniter disturbs the flame detector. This may for
instance be the case when using an ionisation-based flame detector or an UV-based
flame detector, as the igniter could cause false flame detection.
[0031] Alternatively, in some embodiments the flame detection and the ignition can overlap.
Thus, the flame can be detection during the ignition phase. This possible in gas burning
appliances which have an ionization pin and an ignition pin.
[0032] According to an embodiment the predetermined safety time is less than 3,0 seconds.
The predetermined safety time may be less than 2,5 seconds, less than 2,0 seconds,
less than 1,5 seconds, less than 1,0 second or less than 0,5 second.
[0033] When the predetermined safety time is reduced, the opening time of the gas valve
is reduced during ignition therefore the volume containing (potentially explosive)
H2 mixture is reduced as well. Therefore, the impact in case delayed ignition takes
place is reduced as less hydrogen or hydrogen comprising gas has built up in the burning
chamber.
[0034] When using a relatively short, predetermined safety time, it is especially advantageous
to use a pre-ignition time, as it is even more important to assure a proper and stable
spark during the safety time by starting sparking earlier, i.e. even before the gas
valve is opened to assure proper ignition.
[0035] According to an embodiment the ignition sequence comprises:
- obtaining an indication of the amount of hydrogen present in the combustible gas,
- setting the pre-ignition time interval and/or the safety time based on the obtained
amount of hydrogen present in the combustible gas.
[0036] In case a boiler is capable of combusting both natural gas and combustible gas comprising
more than 20 mol % hydrogen the control board is made such that it switches ignition
safety times (in the safety core of the control board) based on gas type selection
or gas type detection.
[0037] According to an embodiment the predetermined pre-ignition time interval and/or the
safety time depends on the composition of the combustible gas.
[0038] For instance, if the combustible gas comprises more than 20 mol% hydrogen, the predetermined
safety time is less than 3,0 seconds, less than 2,5 seconds, less than 2,0 seconds,
less than 1,5 seconds, less than 1,0 second or less than 0,5 second.
[0039] When the combustible gas comprises a certain amount of hydrogen, in particular gas
that comprise more than 20 mol% hydrogen, the predetermined safety time can be effectively
reduced by using pre-set hydrogen specific safety times, preferably less than 3,0
seconds.
[0040] When the predetermined safety time is reduced, the opening time of the gas supply
valve is reduced therefore the volume containing (potentially explosive) H
2 mixture is reduced as well. Therefore, the impact in case delayed ignition takes
place is reduced as less hydrogen or hydrogen comprising gas has built up in the burning
chamber.
[0041] It has been found that the chance of delayed ignition, as well as the consequences
of a delayed ignition, can be reduced for burning appliances by choosing a predetermined
safety time that depends on the composition of the combustible gas.
[0042] By making the predetermined safety time depended on the composition of the combustible
gas, a gas burning appliance is provided that can deal with different gas compositions.
[0043] Having a higher hydrogen content results in higher flammable range, higher flame
speed and requires lower ignition energies. Therefore, the higher the hydrogen content,
the more the predetermined safety time can be effectively reduced. Also, higher hydrogen
contents could result in a higher impact of delayed ignition, making it even more
advantageous to make the predetermined safety time depended on the composition of
the combustible gas.
[0044] According to an embodiment the method further comprises switching to an alarm state
if a flame is detected during the predetermined pre-ignition time interval. The alarm
state may involve closing or not opening the gas supply, switching to a blocking or
locking state, generate an alarm (sound, message) and/or aborting the ignition.
[0045] According to an embodiment the combustible gas supplied to the burning chamber during
the predetermined safety time has a first lambda-value, wherein the method further
comprises when a flame has been detected by the flame detector before the end of the
predetermined safety time, the gas supply is kept open and the gas burning appliance
continues to operate in a continuous operation mode, wherein the continuous operation
mode comprises supplying combustible gas to the burning chamber having a second lambda-value,
the first lambda-value being larger than the second lambda-value.
[0046] The lambda-value is defined as a ratio between a quantity of air and a quantity of
fuel in the combustible gas. The first lambda-value may be at least 1.85. According
to an embodiment, the first lambda-value may be larger than 2, in particular between
2-6, preferably larger than 3, in particular between 3-5, more preferably larger than
4, in particular between 4-5. According to an embodiment the second lambda-value is
between 1-2, preferably between 1.05-1.5, more preferably between 1.05-1.3. According
to an embodiment, the first lambda-value is at least 1.5 times as large as the second
lambda-value, preferably at least 2 times as large, in particular at least 3 times
as large.
[0047] The load in the starting up phase can be lower than the load in an operation phase
of gas burning appliance. In the operation phase a flame is present. This embodiment
even further reduces the risk as starting with a lower load means introducing less
fuel into the burning chamber.
[0048] According to a further aspect there is provided a gas burning appliance comprising
a burning chamber, a gas supply for supplying combustible gas to the burning chamber,
a flame detector for detecting the presence of a flame in the burning chamber and
an ignitor for igniting the combustible gas in the burning chamber, wherein the gas
burning appliance comprises a controller configured to carry out the method according
to the above. Further provided is the use of such a gas burning appliance in a boiler
or water heater.
[0049] Additionally, an advantageous embodiment is a computer program product comprising
instructions which cause the gas burning appliance according to the above to execute
the steps of the method according to the above.
[0050] Furthermore, a data carrier is provided on which the computer program is stored and/or
data carrier signal is provided which transmits the computer program.
[0051] In the figures, the subject-matter of the invention is schematically shown, wherein
identical or similarly acting elements are usually provided with the same reference
signs.
- Figure 1
- shows a gas burning appliance according to an embodiment,
- Figure 2
- shows an ignition sequence according to an embodiment,
- Figure 3
- shows an ignition sequence according to an alternative embodiment.
[0052] Fig. 1 schematically shows a gas burning appliance 1. The gas burning appliance comprises
a burning chamber 2 with a burner 8. A gas supply 3 is provided to supply combustible
gas to the burner 8. In the gas supply 3 a gas supply control valve 4 is provided.
The gas flows in a pipe of the gas supply 3. Additionally, the gas supply 3 can comprise
a non-shown mixer for mixing the fuel gas, in particular hydrogen, with air.
[0053] A flame detector 5 is provided for detecting the presence of a flame in the burning
chamber 2. The flame detector 5 can be any suitable flame detector, such as an optical
flame detector, a temperature sensor, a thermocouple, a catalytic sensor or an O2/lambda
sensor.
[0054] Also, an ignitor 6 is provided for igniting the combustible gas in the burning chamber
to create a flame. The ignitor 6 may be a spark electrode, arranged to generate sparks
to ignite the combustible gas.
[0055] It will be understood that the gas burning appliance may comprise additional elements
which are omitted in Fig. 1. For instance, the gas burning appliance may further comprise
a heat exchanger to allow water to be heated by the heat generated in the burning
chamber 2.
[0056] Furthermore, a controller 10 is provided. The controller 10 may be a dedicated piece
of hardware or a computer which can be programmed.
[0057] The controller 10 may control the igniter 6 to be active during a predetermined ignition
time. The controller 10 may also be arranged to switch the igniter 6 on and off when
needed. The controller may be arranged to receive input from the flame detector 5
indicating the presence or absence of a flame.
[0058] The controller 10 may control the gas supply 3 to supply combustible gas to the burning
chamber 2. The controller 10 may be arranged to control the flow rate of the combustible
gas flowing into the burning chamber 2. The flow rate may be expressed as m
3/s or kg/s.
[0059] The controller 10 is arranged to perform an ignition sequence comprising:
- activating the igniter 6 for a predetermined ignition time,
- opening the gas supply 3 for a predetermined safety time to supply combustible gas
to the burning chamber 2,
- detecting the presence of a flame by means of the flame detector 5,
- closing the combustible gas supply 3 if no flame has been detected at the end of the
predetermined safety time.
[0060] Opening and closing of the combustible gas supply 3 may be done by controlling the
combustible gas supply valve 4.
[0061] The combustible gas comprises more than 20 mol% of hydrogen. The activation of the
igniter commences at a predetermined pre-ignition time interval before opening the
gas supply.
[0062] With reference to the left-hand side of Fig. 2, an ignition sequence is depicted.
First, the igniter 6 is activated. After the predetermined pre-ignition time, indicated
by the double arrow P, the gas supply 3 is opened. This is schematically depicted
in the two top rows in Fig. 2. The gas supply 3 is opened for a predetermined safety
time indicated by the double arrow S in Fig. 2. In this embodiment, the ignitor 6
is activated during a predetermined ignition time equal, such that activation of the
ignitor ends before the end of the safety time. The predetermined ignition time consist
of the predetermined pre-ignition time and a remaining part of the predetermined ignition
time in which the gas valve is open.
[0063] During the safety time, the flame detector 5 detects the presence or absence of a
flame. The third line in Fig. 2 shows the actual presence of a flame in the burning
chamber 2, while the fourth line shows the detection of a flame by the flame detector
5.
[0064] As shown in Fig. 2, if no flame has been detected at the end of the predetermined
safety time, the gas supply 3 is closed. In that case, at the end of the predetermined
safety time, the ignitor 6 may be de-activated. Optionally, the gas chamber may be
purged to remove combustible gas from the gas chamber 2, before a new ignition sequence
is initiated.
[0065] Purging means the forced introduction of air through the combustion chamber and flue
passages in order to displace any remaining fuel/air mixture and/or products of combustion.
[0066] Purging may take place in between each ignition sequence. This is referred to as
an inter-purge. Inter-purge is done between ignition sequences or attempts.
[0067] Purging may also be done before the first ignition sequence, for instance in case
of flame loss during operation. This is referred to as a pre-purge. Pre-purge is a
purge which takes place between a start signal and energization or activation of the
igniter.
[0068] Ignition sequences may be initiated repeatedly, until the presence of a flame is
detected by the flame detector 5 before the end of the predetermined safety time.
The right-hand side of Fig. 2 shows a second ignition sequence. As shown, in this
case a flame is present and detected and the gas supply 3 remains open. Still, the
ignitor 6 is deactivated at the end of the predetermined ignition time.
[0069] The controller 10 may set the predetermined safety time and/or the predetermined
pre-ignition time based on information obtained regarding the composition of the combustible
gas, in particular the amount of hydrogen present in the combustible gas. This indication
may be obtained in different ways. According to the embodiment depicted in Fig. 1
the indication is obtained by means of a gas composition detector 7. Any suitable
gas composition detector 7 may be used, such as for instance a thermal conductivity
sensor configured to measure the thermal conductivity of the combustible gas or a
sensor measuring the speed of sound in the combustible gas. Based on the obtained
measurements, the composition of the combustible gas can be deduced. The gas composition
detector 7 is arranged to obtain an indication of the composition of the gas or at
least the amount of hydrogen present in the gas flowing through the gas supply 3 and
provide such to the controller 10. The controller 10 is arranged to set the safety
time and/or the predetermined pre-ignition time based on the received information.
Generally, a higher hydrogen content results in a shorter safety time interval and/or
a longer pre-ignition time.
[0070] In the embodiment described with reference to Fig. 2, the ignition time ends before
the safety time. This may be required in case the flame detector 5 cannot function
reliably during the ignition time. Fig. 3 shows an alternative ignition sequence in
which the ignition time ends at the same time as the safety time. In this embodiment
the flame detector 5 can function when the ignitor 6 is active.
[0071] Similar to Fig. 2, the left-hand side of Fig. 3 shows a failed ignition sequence,
the right-hand side shows a successful ignition sequence.
[0072] For the case that a flame is detected before the ignition time starts, the controller
10 determines that an alarm state is present, in particular due to hydrogen leakage.
The controller 10 acts on the combustible gas supply valve 4 to close so that no hydrogen
is supplied to the burner 8.
Reference Signs
[0073]
- 1.
- Gas burning appliance
- 2.
- Burning chamber
- 3.
- Gas supply
- 4.
- Gas supply control valve
- 5.
- Flame detector
- 6.
- Ignitor
- 7.
- Gas composition detector
- 8.
- Burning deck
- 10.
- Controller
1. Method for starting up a gas burning appliance (1), the gas burning appliance (1)
comprising a burning chamber (2), a gas supply (3) for supplying combustible gas to
the burning chamber (2), a flame detector (5) for detecting the presence of a flame
in the burning chamber (2) and an ignitor (6) for igniting the combustible gas in
the burning chamber (2), wherein the method comprises an ignition sequence comprising:
- activating the igniter (6) for a predetermined ignition time,
- opening the gas supply (3) for a predetermined safety time to supply combustible
gas to the burning chamber (2),
- detecting the presence of a flame by means of the flame detector (5),
- closing the gas supply (3) if no flame has been detected at the end of the predetermined
safety time,
wherein the combustible gas comprises more than 20 mol% of hydrogen and
wherein activation of the igniter (6) commences at a predetermined pre-ignition time
interval before opening the gas supply (3).
2. Method according to claim 1, wherein the predetermined pre-ignition time interval
is at least
- 1,0 second
- 1,5 seconds, or
- 2,0 seconds, or
- 2,5 seconds, or
- 3,0 seconds.
3. Method according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein the predetermined pre-ignition
time interval is shorter than a remaining part of the predetermined ignition time.
4. Method according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein the pre-ignition time
interval plus the remaining part of the predetermined ignition time is greater than
or equal to the safety time.
5. Method according to any of the claims 1-3, wherein the predetermined safety time is
less than 3,0 seconds.
6. Method according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein the combustible gas comprises
more than 40 mol% of hydrogen or more than 80 mol% of hydrogen or more than 90 mol%
of hydrogen or more than 98 mol% of hydrogen.
7. Method according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein the ignition sequence
comprises:
- obtaining an indication of the amount of hydrogen present in the combustible gas,
- setting the pre-ignition time interval and/or the safety time based on the obtained
amount of hydrogen present in the combustible gas.
8. Method according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein the pre-ignition time
interval and/or the safety time depends on the composition of the combustible gas.
9. Method according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein the method further comprises
switching to an alarm state if a flame is detected during the predetermined pre-ignition
time interval.
10. Method according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein the combustible gas supplied
to the burning chamber (2) during the predetermined safety time has a first lambda-value,
wherein the method further comprises when a flame has been detected by the flame detector
(5) before the end of the predetermined safety time, the gas supply (3) is kept open
and the gas burning appliance (1) continues to operate in a continuous operation mode,
wherein the continuous operation mode comprises supplying combustible gas to the burning
chamber (2) having a second lambda-value, the first lambda-value being larger than
the second lambda-value.
11. Gas burning appliance (1) comprising a burning chamber (2), a gas supply (3) for supplying
combustible gas to the burning chamber (2), a flame detector (5) for detecting the
presence of a flame in the burning chamber (2) and an ignitor (6) for igniting the
combustible gas in the burning chamber (2), wherein the gas burning appliance comprises
a controller (10) configured to carry out the method of one of the claims 1 - 10.
12. Use of a gas burning appliance (1) according to claim 11 in a boiler or a water heater.
13. Computer program product comprising instructions which cause the gas burning appliance
(1) of claim 10 to execute the steps of the method of any one of the claims 1 - 10.
14. Data carrier on which the computer program of claim 13 is stored or data carrier signal
transmitting the computer program according to claim 13.