TECHNICAL FIELD
[0001] The present disclosure relates to steel material suitable for steel structures such
as ships, marine structures, pressure vessels, line pipes, and offshore wind power
generators. In particular, with respect to steel plates having thicknesses exceeding
100 mm, the present disclosure relates to a thick, high tensile strength steel plate
that not only has excellent base metal strength and toughness but also has excellent
joint CTOD properties in multilayer fill welded portions, and a method of producing
same.
BACKGROUND
[0002] Conventionally, mainly Charpy tests have been used to evaluate steel toughness. In
recent years, crack tip opening displacement tests (hereinafter also referred to as
CTOD test) have been increasingly applied to steel plates used in steel structures
as a method to evaluate fracture resistance with higher precision.
[0003] The CTOD test evaluates resistance to occurrence of brittle cracks by introducing
a fatigue precrack into a test piece at the location to be evaluated for toughness,
subjecting the test piece to three-point bending at low temperature, and measuring
the amount of crack opening (plastic deformation) immediately before fracture.
[0004] When steel plates are applied to steel structures such as ships, marine structures,
pressure vessels, line pipes, wind power generators, and the like, as mentioned above,
multilayer fill welding is used. In the multilayer fill weld heat-affected zone (hereinafter
also referred to as "multilayer fill weld HAZ"), a zone in the vicinity of the weld
line where microstructure has become coarse-grained due to the preceding welding pass
(hereinafter also referred to as coarse grain heat-affected zone, or "CGHAZ") is reheated
to a two-phase region of ferrite and austenite by a subsequent welding pass, resulting
in martensite austenite constituent (hereinafter also referred to as "MA") being mixed
into a coarse matrix, resulting in a zone of significantly reduced toughness (hereinafter
also referred to as inter-critically reheated coarse grain heat-affected zone, or
"ICCGHAZ").
[0005] Here, CTOD testing of welded joints is basically performed on the full plate thickness,
and therefore when a multilayer fill weld HAZ is the target of evaluation, the region
where a fatigue precrack is introduced includes ICCGHAZ microstructure. Further, joint
CTOD properties obtained by a joint CTOD test depend on toughness of the most brittle
microstructure in the evaluation region, and therefore joint CTOD properties of a
multilayer fill weld HAZ reflect the toughness of ICCGHAZ microstructure as well as
CGHAZ microstructure.
[0006] Therefore, to improve joint CTOD properties of a multilayer fill weld HAZ, it is
necessary to improve not only toughness of CGHAZ microstructure but also ICCGHAZ microstructure.
[0007] Conventional toughness improvement techniques for the heat-affected zone (HAZ) have
been suppression of austenite grain coarsening in the CGHAZ by fine particle distribution
of TiN and the use of TiN as a ferrite nucleation site. Here, TiN is sometimes heated
to a temperature range where TiN melts in a bonded portion, and therefore when low-temperature
toughness requirements for a welded portion are strict, satisfying such requirements
has become difficult with only the effect of using TiN.
[0008] Further, a technique to suppress austenite grain growth through adding rare earth
metals (REM) and dispersing resulting REM acid sulfide, a technique to suppress austenite
grain growth through adding Ca and dispersing resulting Ca acid sulfide, and a technique
combining the ferrite nucleation capability of BN with oxide dispersion have been
used.
[0009] For example, Patent Literature (PTL) 1 and PTL 2 describe techniques to suppress
austenite grain growth and improve toughness of welded portions by adding REM in combination
with Ti and dispersing the fine particles in steel.
[0010] Further, PTL 3 proposes a technique for improving toughness of HAZ by using CaS and
a technique for improving toughness of base metal by hot rolling.
[0011] Further, as a measure for countering toughness decrease at the ICCGHAZ, a technique
to increase base metal strength by adding Cu after suppressing the formation of MA
by reducing C and Si is proposed in PTL 4.
[0012] In addition, in PTL 5, a technique is proposed using BN as a ferrite nucleation site
in the heat-affected zone of large-heat input welding to refine HAZ microstructure
and improve HAZ toughness.
[0013] In recent years, steel structures such as ships, marine structures, pressure vessels,
line pipes, and offshore wind power generators have tended to become larger, and steel
plates used in steel structures have become thicker and stronger accordingly. Increasing
the amount of alloying elements is necessary to achieve steel plates that are both
thicker and stronger, but adding large amounts of alloying elements makes securing
the toughness of multilayer fill weld HAZ more difficult. To address this problem,
PTL 6 describes a technique to improve low-temperature toughness by controlling hardness
of a central segregation area.
CITATION LIST
Patent Literature
SUMMARY
(Technical Problem)
[0015] CTOD specification temperature in standards that specify joint CTOD properties (for
example, American Petroleum Institute (API) Recommended Practice RP-2Z) is typically
-10 °C.
[0016] However, to secure new resources in response to growing energy demand in recent years,
the construction range of marine structures and the like has shifted to cold regions
and deep-sea regions where resource development has not previously been possible.
As a result, there is increasing demand for steel plates that are high-strength, thick-walled,
and capable of meeting CTOD specification temperatures that are even lower than those
specified by the API standard (for example, -40 °C).
[0017] According to investigation by the inventors, the conventional techniques described
in PTL 1 to PTL 6 are unable to fully satisfy joint CTOD properties required for multilayer-fill-welded
joints for low-temperature specifications in high-strength, thick-walled steel plates
having a thickness exceeding 100 mm, which are in high demand in recent years.
[0018] For example, PTL 1 and PTL 2 propose techniques for suppressing coarsening of austenite
microstructure in the HAZ by adding REM in combination with Ti and dispersing the
fine particles in steel. These techniques are intended for steels having relatively
low strength and low alloying element content, and therefore cannot be applied to
steel material having higher strength and higher alloying element content, because
such HAZ microstructure does not include ferrite.
[0019] The REM acid sulfide and the Ca acid sulfide in PTL 1 and PTL 2 are effective in
inhibiting austenite grain growth. However, the effect of improving toughness by inhibiting
austenite grain coarsening of the HAZ cannot alone achieve the joint CTOD properties
at the temperatures of low-temperature specifications.
[0020] Further, the technique proposed in PTL 3 can satisfy the joint CTOD properties at
normal operating temperatures (-10 °C). However, PTL 3 does not consider the joint
CTOD properties at the temperatures of low-temperature specifications as described
above.
[0021] Similarly, PTL 4 does not consider the joint CTOD properties at the temperatures
of low-temperature specifications, and it is conceivable that only improving toughness
of the ICCGHAZ by decreasing component content of the base metal cannot satisfy low-temperature
CTOD specifications. Further, decreasing the alloying element content of the base
metal to improve the toughness of the ICCGHAZ is a technical concept that conflicts
with securing strength for thicker walls, making it difficult to apply to steel plates
used in marine structures and the like.
[0022] The technique proposed in PTL 5 is effective when HAZ microstructure is mainly composed
of ferrite and a cooling rate of a heat-affected zone is slow, as in large-heat input
welding. However, in the case of steel plates exceeding 100 mm in thickness, the amount
of alloy components contained in the base metal is relatively high and the heat input
in multilayer fill welding is relatively small. Therefore, in multilayer fill welding
of steel plates, HAZ microstructure is mainly bainite, and therefore the effect, mentioned
above, of improving joint CTOD properties cannot be achieved.
[0023] Although PTL 6 proposes a technique for satisfying joint CTOD properties in a low
temperature range for steel plates having a thickness of 100 mm or less, equivalent
mechanical properties for ultra-thick steel plates having a thickness exceeding 100
mm has not been achieved.
[0024] As described above, it is difficult to say that a technique has been established
to improve the toughness of the CGHAZ and the ICCGHAZ in the heat-affected zone of
multilayer fill welding of high-strength steel plates having a thickness of more than
100 mm. In other words, there was a problem to be solved in improving the CTOD properties
of the joint CTOD where a notch position is a bonded portion where the CGHAZ and the
ICCGHAZ are mixed.
[0025] The present disclosure is made in view of the above problems faced by conventional
technologies, and it would be helpful to provide a steel plate having a thickness
exceeding 100 mm and high strength, as well as excellent CTOD properties at a joint
where multilayer fill welding is applied (hereinafter also referred to as multilayer-fill-welded
joint CTOD properties), and a method of producing same.
[0026] Hereinafter, high strength refers to a yield stress of 320 MPa or more at the mid-thickness
position in a tensile test, and excellent multilayer-fill-welded joint CTOD properties
refers to a crack opening displacement of 0.30 mm or more at each of a notch position
CGHAZ and a sub-critically reheated / inter-critically reheated HAZ (SC/ICHAZ) boundary,
at a test temperature of -40 °C.
(Solution to Problem)
[0027] To solve the technical problems described, the inventors have conducted extensive
studies to improve joint CTOD properties. As a result, the inventors made the following
discoveries.
- (1) When pores generated in slab production remain without being closed during rolling,
the pores may become defects in the steel plate and become fracture origins. In particular,
in order to close pores of a mid-thickness part, it is necessary to appropriately
introduce strain into the mid-thickness part during rolling, but this becomes difficult
for steel plates having a thickness of more than 100 mm, and therefore remaining pores
are a problem. However, the inventors and others have found that when rolling is performed
at a high mid-thickness temperature of 950 °C or more, with an average deformation
resistance ratio between the mid-thickness part and the surface of a steel plate of
0.70 or less, a rolling reduction ratio of 3 % or more per pass, and a cumulative
rolling reduction ratio of 30 % or more, sufficient strain can be introduced into
the mid-thickness part, and pores can be sufficiently closed.
Hereinafter, the mid-thickness part is a region from the center in the thickness direction
to a thickness of 10 % of the slab or plate toward both main surfaces of the steel
slab or plate.
- (2) Further, the mid-thickness part of the slab has element segregation regions, and
concentration of alloying elements in these regions causes coarse inclusions to be
dispersed at low density. However, as described above, when rolling is performed at
a mid-thickness temperature of 950 °C or more, with an average deformation resistance
ratio between the mid-thickness part and the surface of the steel plate of 0.70 or
less, a rolling reduction ratio of 3 % or more per pass, and a cumulative rolling
reduction ratio of 30 % or more, the strain applied to the mid-thickness can be increased.
As a result, it was found that coarse inclusions could be elongated and broken up,
and fine inclusions could be dispersed to a high density. In addition, as a result
of such dispersion, it was found that the HAZ toughness-improving effect of inclusions
could be secured.
- (3) Further, in order to precipitate and finely disperse TiN in the steel, which is
effective in suppressing austenite grain growth, the inventors found that when the
composition of the steel plate contains Ti and N satisfying the relationship of 1.50
≤ Ti/N ≤ 5.00, and, in addition, the equivalent carbon content Ceq is controlled to
[C] + [Mn] / 6 + ([Cu] + [Ni]) / 15 + ([Cr] + [Mo] + [V]) / 5 ≤ 0.540 %, and the weld
cracking parameter Pcm is controlled to [C] + [Si] / 30 + ([Mn] + [Cu] + [Cr]) / 20
+ [Ni] / 60 + [Mo] / 15 + [V] / 10 + 5[B] ≤ 0.250 %, toughness of the matrix of HAZ
with multilayer fill welding (hereinafter also referred to as multilayer-fill-welded
joint HAZ) can be improved and good joint CTOD properties that can satisfy low-temperature
CTOD specifications can be obtained.
In addition, the inventors and others also studied joint CTOD properties at the sub-critically
reheated / inter-critically reheated HAZ (SC/ICHAZ) boundary, which is the boundary
between the transformed and untransformed regions of the base metal during welding,
as required by the British Standards (BS) EN10225 (2019) and API RP-2Z (2005), which
specify the joint CTOD test method. As a result, the inventors made the following
discoveries.
- (4) In order to satisfy the joint CTOD property requirements at the SC/ICHAZ boundary
at a test temperature of -40 °C, the toughness of base metal is dominant over the
joint CTOD properties at the SC/ICHAZ boundary, and therefore the inventors found
that crystal grain refinement so that the effective crystal grain size of the base
metal microstructure is 20 µm or less is required to improve toughness of the base
metal.
- (5) In steel plates having a thickness exceeding 100 mm, the cooling rate of the mid-thickness
part is smaller, resulting in coarsening of the crystal grains at this location. However,
the inventors found that by rolling so that the cumulative rolling reduction ratio
is 40 % or more under a set of conditions including an average deformation resistance
ratio between the mid-thickness part and the surface of the steel plate of 0.70 or
less at a mid-thickness temperature of less than 950 °C, sufficient strain can be
introduced to the mid-thickness part and crystal grain refinement to the crystal grain
size described above can be achieved.
[0028] The present disclosure is based on these findings and further studies. Primary features
of the present disclosure are as follows.
- 1. A steel plate comprising a chemical composition containing (consisting of), in
mass%, C: 0.02 % to 0.12 %, Si: 0.70 % or less, Mn: 0.3 % to 3.0 %, P: 0.050 % or
less, S: 0.0050 % or less, Al: 0.002 % to 0.100%, Ti: 0.002 % to 0.060 %, N: 0.0130
% or less, and O: 0.0100 % or less, the balance being Fe and inevitable impurity,
wherein the chemical composition satisfies Expressions (1) to (3) below,
average effective crystal grain size in a mid-thickness part is 20 µm or less, and
the number of pores in the steel plate having a circle equivalent diameter of 180
µm or more is 0.10 or less per mm2,

0.280 % ≤ Ceq (= [C] + [Mn] / 6 + ([Cu] + [Ni]) / 15 + ([Cr] + [Mo] + [V]) / 5) ≤
0.540 %
Pcm (= [C] + [Si] / 30 + ([Mn] + [Cu] + [Cr]) / 20 + [Ni] / 60 + [Mo] / 15 + [V] /
10 + 5[B]) ≤ 0.250 %
where the square brackets in Expressions (1) to (3) indicate content in mass% of an
element enclosed in the brackets and have a value of 0 when the element is not contained.
- 2. The steel plate according to 1, above, wherein the chemical composition further
contains, in mass%, at least one selected from the group consisting of Ni: 2.0 % or
less, Ca: 0.0180 % or less, Cu: 2.00 % or less, Cr: 2.00 % or less, Mo: 2.00 % or
less, Nb: 0.070 % or less, V: 0.20 % or less, W: 0.50 % or less, B: 0.0050 % or less,
REM: 0.030 % or less, and Mg: 0.0150 % or less.
- 3. A method of producing the steel plate according to 1 or 2, above, the method comprising:
heating a slab having the chemical composition according to 1 or 2, above, to a temperature
range from 990 °C or more to 1200 °C or less; hot rolling the under a set of conditions
satisfying Expression (4) below, with a mid-thickness temperature of 950 °C or more,
a rolling reduction ratio of 3 % or more per pass, and a cumulative rolling reduction
ratio of 30 % or more; hot rolling at a mid-thickness temperature of less than 950
°C and a cumulative rolling reduction ratio of 40 % or more; then, when cooling to
a cooling stop temperature of 600 °C or less at an average cooling rate at mid-thickness
of 1.0 °C/s or more, when the cooling stop temperature is 500 °C or less, the average
value from 700 °C to 500 °C is the average cooling rate, and when the cooling stop
temperature is higher than 500 °C, the average value from 700 °C to the cooling stop
temperature that is higher than 500 °C is the average cooling rate,

where kfm is derived from Expression (5),
[Math. 1]

where ε is derived from Expression (6) and ε̇ is derived from Expression (7)
[Math. 2]

[Math. 3]

where, in Expressions (5) to (7), [C] is mass% of C, Tk is absolute temperature (K) at mid-thickness or steel plate surface, h0 is thickness on rolling entry, h1 is thickness on rolling delivery, n is the roller rotational speed (rpm), r is rolling
reduction, and R is roller radius (mm).
- 4. The method of producing a steel plate according to 3, above, wherein, after the
cooling to the cooling stop temperature, a tempering treatment is performed at a temperature
of 700 °C or less.
(Advantageous Effect)
[0029] According to the present disclosure, a steel plate having high strength and excellent
multilayer-fill-welded joint CTOD properties may be provided, even when thickness
exceeds 100 mm.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0030] The reasons for limitations placed on the features of the present disclosure are
explained below.
[Chemical composition]
[0031] First, the reasons for limiting the chemical composition of the steel plate and the
slab to the ranges of the present disclosure are described. Hereinafter, "%" of each
component means mass percentage unless otherwise specified.
C: 0.02 % to 0.12 %
[0032] C is an element that increases hardenability and improves strength of steel. C content
needs to be 0.02 % or more. However, the C content exceeding 0.12 % increases the
hardness of C-enriched portions and degrades joint CTOD properties. The C content
is therefore in the range from 0.02 % to 0.12 %. The lower limit is preferably 0.04
%. The upper limit is preferably 0.09 %.
Si: 0.70 % or less
[0033] Si is an element inevitably contained as an impurity and has an action of improving
strength. However, Si content exceeding 0.70 % degrades joint CTOD properties. The
Si content is therefore limited to an upper limit of 0.70 %. The upper limit is preferably
0.50 % or less. A lower limit is not particularly limited. The lower limit is preferably
about 0.04 %.
Mn: 0.3 % to 3.0 %
[0034] Mn is an element that has the effect of improving strength of the base metal and
welded portion through improvement of hardenability of steel. To obtain this effect,
addition of 0.3 % or more is required. Mn content is preferably 0.5 % or more. However,
addition exceeding 3.0 % not only decreases weldability, but also causes excessive
hardenability, which reduces toughness of the base metal and welded portion, resulting
in degradation of joint CTOD properties. The Mn content is therefore in the range
from 0.3 % to 3.0 %. The Mn content is preferably 2.8 % or less.
P: 0.050 % or less
[0035] P is an element that has a large effect of embrittling grain boundaries, and when
added in large amounts decreases HAZ toughness and degrades joint CTOD properties.
P content is therefore limited to 0.050 % or less. The P content is preferably 0.030
% or less. Decreasing P content as much as possible is desirable, and therefore a
lower limit of the P content is not particularly limited. However, excessively low
P content leads to increased refining time and higher costs. The P content is therefore
preferably 0.001 % or more.
S: 0.0050 % or less
[0036] S is an element that degrades joint CTOD properties, and therefore an upper limit
of S content is limited to 0.0050 %. The upper limit is preferably 0.0030 % or less.
Decreasing S content as much as possible is desirable, and therefore a lower limit
of the S content is not limited. However, excessively low S content leads to increased
refining time and higher costs. The S content is therefore preferably 0.0001 % or
more.
Al: 0.002 % to 0.100 %
[0037] Al is an element required for formation of inclusions to improve toughness of multilayer
fill weld HAZ and to improve joint CTOD properties, and needs to be added at 0.002
% or more. Al content is preferably 0.005 % or more. However, excessive addition of
more than 0.100 % degrades joint CTOD properties in a low temperature range. The Al
content is therefore in the range from 0.002 % to 0.100 %. The Al content is preferably
0.075 % or less.
Ti: 0.002 % to 0.060 %
[0038] Ti precipitates in steel as TiN. Precipitated TiN has an effect of inhibiting coarsening
of austenite grains in the base metal and HAZ, refining HAZ microstructure and improving
joint CTOD properties. To obtain these effects, addition of 0.002 % or more is required.
Ti content is preferably 0.005 % or more. However, when the Ti content exceeds 0.060
%, precipitation of solute Ti and coarse TiC decreases toughness of the heat-affected
zone and degrades joint CTOD properties. The Ti content is therefore in the range
from 0.002 % to 0.060 %. The Ti content is preferably 0.050 % or less.
N: 0.0130 % or less
[0039] N is an element that reduces HAZ toughness and degrades joint CTOD properties, and
therefore an upper limit of N content is limited to 0.0130 %. Decreasing N content
as much as possible is desirable, and therefore a lower limit of the N content is
not limited. However, excessively low N content leads to increased refining time and
higher costs. The N content is therefore preferably 0.0005 % or more.
O: 0.0100 % or less
[0040] O is an element that reduces HAZ toughness and degrades joint CTOD properties, and
therefore an upper limit of O content is limited to 0.0100 %. Decreasing O content
as much as possible is desirable, and therefore a lower limit of the O content is
not limited. However, excessively low O content leads to increased refining time and
higher costs. The O content is therefore preferably 0.0005 % or more.
[0041] The chemical composition of the steel plate according to an embodiment consists of
the elements described above, with the balance being Fe and inevitable impurity.
[0042] Further, according to another embodiment, for the purpose of further improving strength,
toughness of base metal, joint toughness, and the like, the chemical composition may
further optionally contain at least one element selected from the group consisting
of Ni, Ca, Cu, Cr, Mo, Nb, V, W, B, REM, and Mg, in a quantity indicated below.
Ni: 2.0 % or less
[0043] Ni is an element that can increase strength of steel plates without significantly
degrading toughness of either the base metal or joints, but Ni addition increases
production costs and environmental impact. Conventionally, Ni content was required
to secure toughness of base metal and joint toughness. However, rolling with a controlled
deformation resistance ratio makes it possible to produce high strength steel plates
having a thickness of more than 100 mm and excellent multilayer-fill-welded joint
CTOD properties without Ni content. On the other hand, Ni may be included to further
improve toughness. In such a case, Ni content exceeding 2.0 % increases production
costs and environmental impact. The Ni content is therefore limited to 2.0 % or less.
The Ni content is more preferably 1.8 % or less. On the other hand, when Ni is added,
0.1 % or more is desirable.
Ca: 0.0180 % or less
[0044] Ca is an element that improves toughness of multilayer fill weld HAZ by forming acid
sulfides having high stability at high temperatures, but content exceeding 0.0180
% instead degrades joint CTOD properties. The upper limit of Ca content is therefore
limited to 0.0180 %. The Ca content is more preferably 0.0160 % or less. On the other
hand, when Ca is added, 0.0002 % or more is desirable.
Cu: 2.00 % or less
[0045] Cu is an element that can increase strength of steel plates without significantly
degrading toughness of the base metal and joints. However, when Cu content exceeds
2.00 %, surface cracks caused by a Cu-enriched layer that forms just below scale become
a problem. The Cu content is therefore limited to 2.00 % or less. The Cu content is
more preferably 1.50 % or less. On the other hand, when Cu is added, 0.05 % or more
is desirable.
Cr: 2.00 % or less
[0046] Cr is an element that has an effect of increasing strength of steel through improving
hardenability. However, Cr content exceeding 2.00 % degrades joint CTOD properties,
and therefore the Cr content is limited to 2.00 % or less. The Cr content is more
preferably 1.50 % or less. On the other hand, when Cr is added, 0.05 % or more is
desirable.
Mo: 2.00 % or less
[0047] Mo is an element that has an effect of increasing strength of steel through improving
hardenability. However, Mo content exceeding 2.00 % degrades joint CTOD properties,
and therefore the Mo content is limited to 2.00 % or less. The Mo content is more
preferably 1.50 % or less. On the other hand, when Mo is added, 0.05 % or more is
desirable.
Nb: 0.070 % or less
[0048] Nb is an element that widens a non-recrystallization temperature range of austenite
phase. Therefore, the addition of Nb is effective for efficiently rolling a non-recrystallized
region to obtain a fine grain microstructure. When Nb is added, 0.005 % or more is
desirable. On the other hand, Nb addition exceeding 0.070 % reduces joint CTOD properties,
and therefore Nb content is limited to 0.070 % or less. The Nb content is more preferably
0.050 % or less.
V: 0.20 % or less
[0049] V is an element that improves strength of the base metal, and when V is added, 0.01
% or more is desirable. On the other hand, V content exceeding 0.20 % decreases HAZ
toughness and degrades joint CTOD properties, and therefore the V content is limited
to 0.20 % or less. The V content is more preferably 0.15 % or less.
W: 0.50 % or less
[0050] W is an element that improves strength of the base metal, and when W is added, 0.05
% or more is desirable. On the other hand, W content exceeding 0.50 % decreases HAZ
toughness and degrades joint CTOD properties, and therefore the W content is limited
to 0.50 % or less. The W content is more preferably 0.40 % or less.
B: 0.0050 % or less
[0051] B is an element that can improve hardenability and thereby strength of steel plates
with only a very small amount of B. When B is added, 0.0005 % or more is desirable.
On the other hand, B content exceeding 0.0050 % decreases HAZ toughness and degrades
joint CTOD properties, and therefore the B content is limited to 0.0050 % or less.
The B content is more preferably 0.0040 % or less.
REM: 0.030 % or less
[0052] Rare earth metals (REM) are elements that inhibit austenite grain growth in the HAZ
and improve HAZ toughness by forming acid sulfide inclusions. When REM is added, 0.001
% or more is desirable. On the other hand, REM content exceeding 0.030 % decreases
base metal toughness and HAZ toughness and degrades joint CTOD properties. The REM
content is therefore limited to 0.030 % or less. The REM content is more preferably
0.025 % or less.
Mg: 0.0150 % or less
[0053] Mg is an element that inhibits growth of austenite grains in the heat-affected zone
by forming oxide-based inclusions, improving toughness of the heat-affected zone.
When Mg is added, 0.0002 % or more is desirable. On the other hand, when the Mg content
exceeds 0.0150 %, the addition effect becomes saturated, and thus an effect commensurate
with the content cannot be expected, which becomes economically disadvantageous. The
Mg content is therefore limited to 0.0150 % or less. The Mg content is more preferably
0.0100 % or less.
[0054] According to the present disclosure, the chemical composition of the steel plate
and the slab is required to further satisfy the Ti/N, Ceq, and Pcm conditions, respectively,
as described below.

[0055] Ti/N controls the amount of solute N and the precipitation state of TiN in the HAZ.
When Ti/N is less than 1.50, HAZ toughness degrades due to the presence of solute
N that is not fixed as TiN, and joint CTOD properties degrade. On the other hand,
when Ti/N is more than 5.00, HAZ toughness degrades due to precipitation of coarse
TiN, and joint CTOD properties degrade. The Ti/N range is therefore 1.50 to 5.00.
The lower limit is preferably 1.80. The upper limit is preferably 4.50.
Ceq: 0.280 % or more and 0.540 % or less
[0056] When the equivalent carbon content Ceq, defined by the following Expression (2),
is increased, microstructure having poor toughness such as martensite austenite constituent
and bainite increases in HAZ microstructure, and therefore HAZ toughness degrades.
That is, when Ceq is more than 0.540 %, the HAZ matrix itself suffers toughness degradation,
and therefore even with HAZ toughness enhancement techniques through inclusions, the
required joint CTOD properties cannot be satisfied. On the other hand, when Ceq is
less than 0.280 %, the target strength cannot be secured. The Ceq range is therefore
0.280 % to 0.540 %. The lower limit is preferably 0.300 %. The upper limit is preferably
0.500 %.
Ceq (%) = [C] + [Mn] / 6 + ([Cu] + [Ni]) / 15 + ([Cr] + [Mo] + [V]) / 5
Pcm: 0.250 % or less
[0057] When the weld cracking parameter Pcm defined by the following Expression (3) is increased,
microstructure having poor toughness such as martensite austenite constituent and
bainite increases in HAZ microstructure, and therefore HAZ toughness degrades. When
Pcm exceeds 0.250 %, the HAZ matrix itself suffers toughness degradation, and therefore
the required joint CTOD properties cannot be obtained. Pcm is therefore 0.250 % or
less. Pcm is preferably 0.240 % or less. A lower limit is not particularly limited,
but excessive attempts to reduce Pcm result in too low a Ceq value, and therefore
about 0.140 % is preferred.
Pcm (%) = [C] + [Si] / 30 + ([Mn] + [Cu] + [Cr]) / 20 + [Ni] / 60 + [Mo] / 15 + [V]
/ 10 + 5[B]
[0058] The square brackets in Expressions (1) to (3) indicate content in mass% of an element
enclosed in the brackets and have a value of 0 when the element is not contained.
[Average effective crystal grain size]
[0059] Average effective crystal grain size at mid-thickness part: 20 µm or less
[0060] According to the present disclosure, average effective crystal grain size of microstructure
in the mid-thickness part of the steel plate having a thickness exceeding 100 mm is
20 µm or less. Crystal grains in the mid-thickness part in which segregation is easily
caused are refined as described above to improve toughness of the base metal, thereby
increasing joint CTOD properties at SC/ICHAZ boundaries. The smaller the average effective
crystal grain size, the more advantageous, and therefore the average effective crystal
grain size is not particularly limited. Typically, a lower limit is about 1 µm.
[0061] Here, "effective crystal grain size" is defined as the circle equivalent diameter
of a crystal grain surrounded by grain boundaries of crystal grains having an orientation
difference of 15° or more, that is, large-angle grain boundaries. Further, the average
effective crystal grain size in the mid-thickness part can be measured by a method
described in the following EXAMPLES section.
[Pore number density]
Pore number density: 0.10/mm2 or less
[0062] As mentioned above, residual pores in the steel plates become fracture origins, which
degrade joint CTOD properties. In particular, when the number of pores having a circle
equivalent diameter of 180 µm or more per mm
2 (hereinafter also referred to simply as "pore number density") in the steel plate
exceeds 0.10, the possibility of insufficient crack opening displacement (δ) in the
joint CTOD test becomes extremely high. Further, as the pore number density increases,
the yield stress at the mid-thickness part of the base material decreases. Accordingly,
limiting the pore number density to 0.10/mm
2 or less is important.
[0063] Hereinafter, the pore number density means an average number density across full
thickness × full width in a cross-section parallel to the transverse direction of
a steel plate (cross section perpendicular to the rolling direction). The pore number
density may be measured by the method described in the EXAMPLES section below, but
the measurement method is not limited to the method described in the EXAMPLES section
and any known measurement method may be used for measurement.
[0064] Further, measurement frequency of the pore number density may be measuring one or
two cross-sections of any one steel plate among steel plates prepared from steel slabs
under the same steelmaking and rolling conditions. As long as the slab steelmaking
method and rolling conditions are not changed, the pore number density is highly reproducible,
and therefore measurement results at the above measurement frequency are representative
of the whole.
[Production method]
[0065] Next, the reasons for limiting each condition in the method of producing the steel
plate according to the present disclosure are explained below. In the following description,
"temperature" means temperature at the mid-thickness part, unless otherwise noted.
Temperature at the mid-thickness part may be measured as described in the following
EXAMPLES section. However, for example, on an actual production line, temperature
at a surface of a steel plate may be measured using a radiation thermometer and temperature
at the mid-thickness part may be determined by heat transfer calculation.
• Slab heating conditions
[0066] According to the present disclosure, a method of preparing the slab is not particularly
limited, and any known steelmaking method may be applied, such as a converter, an
electric furnace, a vacuum melting furnace, and the like. The slab may be produced,
for example, by a continuous casting method. Further, molten steel from which the
slab is produced may be further subjected to secondary refining such as ladle refining.
[0067] The slab produced as described above is heated to a temperature of 990 °C or more
and 1200 °C or less. When the heating temperature is lower than 990 °C, the following
conditions of hot rolling cannot be met, and a sufficient effect cannot be obtained.
On the other hand, when the heating temperature is higher than 1200 °C, austenite
grains become coarse and the desired fine grain microstructure cannot be obtained
after controlled rolling. For these reasons, the range of the heating temperature
is 990 °C or more to 1200 °C or less. The lower limit of temperature is preferably
990 °C, and the upper limit of temperature is preferably 1180 °C.
• Hot rolling conditions
[0068] During the hot rolling, it is important to control hot rolling conditions in both
a recrystallization temperature range and a non-recrystallization temperature range.
[0069] In the recrystallization temperature range, rolling is performed at 950 °C or more,
the rolling reduction ratio is 3 % or more per pass, and the cumulative rolling reduction
ratio is 30 % or more, under a set of conditions including the average deformation
resistance ratio between the mid-thickness part and the surface of the steel plate
being 0.70 or less.
[Deformation resistance ratio between mid-thickness part and surface of steel plate:
0.70 or less]
[0070] According to the present disclosure, the average value of the ratio of the deformation
resistance k
fm (mid-thickness) of the mid-thickness part to the deformation resistance k
fm (surface) of the surface of the steel plate, as defined by the following Expressions
(5) to (7), is 0.70 or less (Expression (4)). Specifically, the average deformation
resistance ratio between the mid-thickness part and the surface made to be 0.70 or
less by rolling at the timing when the temperature difference between mid-thickness
and surface is at an appropriate value according to the mass% of C, while adjusting
roller rotational speed, roller radius, and roll gap to appropriate values.

(Here, k
fm is derived from Expression (5))
[Math. 1]

where
ε is derived from Expression (6) and
ε̇ is derived from Expression (7)
[Math. 2]

[Math. 3]

[0071] In Expressions (5) to (7), [C] is mass% of C, T
k is absolute temperature (K) at the point where k
fm is determined, that is, the mid-thickness or steel plate surface, h
0 is thickness on rolling entry, h
1 is thickness on rolling delivery, n is the roller rotational speed (rpm), r is rolling
reduction, and R is roller radius (mm).
[0072] Temperature at the surface may be measured by a radiation thermometer, and temperature
at the mid-thickness part may be measured as described in the following EXAMPLES section.
However, for example, on an actual production line, temperature at a surface of a
steel plate may be measured using a radiation thermometer and temperature at the mid-thickness
part may be determined by heat transfer calculation.
[0073] Under conditions where the average value of the deformation resistance ratio between
the mid-thickness part and the surface of a steel plate according to Expression (4)
exceeds 0.70, sufficient strain cannot be introduced into the mid-thickness part of
a steel plate having a thickness exceeding 100 mm, and pores will remain. As a result,
the pore number density cannot be made to be 0.10/mm
2 or less. Therefore, the ratio of deformation resistance between the mid-thickness
part and the surface of the steel plate is 0.70 or less, the rolling reduction ratio
is 3 % or more per pass, and the cumulative rolling reduction ratio is 30 % or more.
[Rolling at 950 °C or more]
[0074] A purpose of rolling at 950 °C or more is to close pores in addition to refining
microstructure by recrystallization and refining and dispersing coarse inclusions.
That is, rolling at less than 950 °C makes it difficult for recrystallization to occur,
resulting in insufficient refinement of austenite grains.
[Rolling reduction ratio of 3 % or more per pass]
[0075] Rolling with a reduction ratio of less than 3 % per pass does not introduce sufficient
strain in the mid-thickness part, and even when rolling reduction ratio is 3 % or
more per pass, a cumulative rolling reduction ratio of less than 30 % does not sufficiently
close pores.
[Rolling at less than 950 °C]
[0076] In rolling at the non-recrystallization temperature range, that is, less than 950
°C, the cumulative rolling reduction ratio is 40 % or more, under the same condition
of the average deformation resistance ratio between the mid-thickness part and the
surface of the steel plate being 0.70 or less.
[0077] The steel according to the present disclosure is difficult to recrystallize when
rolled at temperatures less than 950 °C, and therefore the strain introduced by rolling
is not consumed by recrystallization but accumulates and acts as nucleation sites
in the subsequent cooling process. As a result, the finally obtained steel plate can
have a refined microstructure. However, the crystal grain refinement effect is insufficient
under conditions where the cumulative rolling reduction ratio in this temperature
range is less than 40 %. Further, in a steel plate having a thickness exceeding 100
mm, under a set of conditions where the average deformation resistance ratio between
the mid-thickness part and the surface of the steel plate exceeds 0.70, sufficient
strain cannot be introduced into the mid-thickness part, the refinement of the final
microstructure in the mid-thickness part becomes insufficient, and the average effective
crystal grain size in the mid-thickness part cannot be 20 µm or less.
[0078] Therefore, rolling at the non-recrystallization temperature range has a cumulative
rolling reduction ratio of 40 % or more, and the average deformation resistance ratio
between the mid-thickness part and the surface of the steel plate is 0.70 or less.
[Cooling]
[0079] After completion of the hot rolling, the obtained hot-rolled steel plate is cooled.
The cooling can be performed by any method as long as the following conditions are
met. For example, the cooling may be performed by water cooling.
Average cooling rate: 1.0 °C/s or more
[0080] When the average cooling rate at the mid-thickness temperature is less than 1.0 °C/s,
coarse ferrite phase occurs in the base metal microstructure, and therefore joint
CTOD properties of the SC/ICHAZ degrade. The average cooling rate at the mid-thickness
position is therefore 1.0 °C/s or more. On the other hand, when the average cooling
rate is greater than 50.0 °C/s, an increase in hard bainite phase increases strength
of the base metal and degrades joint CTOD properties of the SC/ICHAZ, and therefore
the cooling rate is preferably 50.0 °C/s or less.
[0081] According to the present disclosure, when the cooling stop temperature indicated
in the next paragraph is 500 °C or less, the average value from 700 °C to 500 °C is
the average cooling rate described above, and when the cooling stop temperature is
higher than 500 °C, the average value from 700 °C to the cooling stop temperature
higher than 500 °C is the average cooling rate described above.
Cooling stop temperature: 600 °C or less
[0082] In the cooling, the hot-rolled steel plate is cooled to a cooling stop temperature
that is 600 °C or less at mid-thickness temperature. When the cooling stop temperature
is higher than 600 °C, microstructure after transformation becomes coarse, resulting
in insufficient base metal strength and degradation of SC/ICHAZ joint CTOD properties.
The cooling stop temperature is therefore 600 °C or less.
[Tempering treatment]
Tempering Temperature: 700 °C or less
[0083] After the cooling stop, the steel plate may be subjected to tempering treatment.
Tempering treatment can further improve the toughness of base metal. At this time,
a tempering temperature higher than 700 °C generates a coarse ferrite phase, thus
degrading toughness of the SCHAZ. The tempering temperature is therefore preferably
700 °C or less. The tempering temperature is more preferably 650 °C or less. A lower
limit of the tempering temperature is not particularly limited. The lower limit may
be about 300 °C.
[0084] In the method of production according to the present disclosure, anything not described
herein may follow a conventional method.
EXAMPLES
[0085] More detailed description is given below based on examples. The following examples
merely represent preferred examples, and the present disclosure is not limited to
these examples.
[0086] Slabs having a chemical composition listed in Table 1 were used to produce steel
plates under the production conditions listed in Table 2. During hot rolling, a thermocouple
was attached in a central position in the longitudinal direction, width direction,
and thickness direction of each steel material to be hot rolled to measure the temperature
of the mid-thickness part. At the same time, surface temperature of the steel material
was measured with a radiation thermometer.
[0087] The average effective crystal grain size, the pore number density, and the yield
stress of each obtained steel plate were measured by the following methods.
[Average effective crystal grain size]
[0088] A sample was collected from each obtained steel plate so that a measurement position
was located at a central position in the longitudinal direction, width direction,
and thickness direction of the steel plate. Then, after mirror polishing a surface
of the sample, electron backscatter pattern (EBSP) analysis was performed under the
following conditions. From an obtained crystal orientation map, a circle equivalent
diameter of a microstructure surrounded by a large-angle grain boundary having an
orientation difference of 15° or more from adjacent crystal grains was determined,
and an average of the circle equivalent diameters in the following analysis region
was defined as an average effective crystal grain size.
EBSP Conditions
[0089]
- Analysis region: 1 mm × 1 mm area at mid-thickness
- Step size: 0.4 µm
[Pore number density]
[0090] For detection of defects inside of a steel plate, ultrasonic testing is often used
because ultrasonic testing can perform nondestructive inspection. However, to precisely
check the state of defects, the inside of the steel plates were directly observed
to measure the pore number density. First, a sample was taken in a thickness direction
cross-section parallel to the plate transverse direction (cross-section perpendicular
to the rolling direction) of the rolled material from a central position of the plate
length, for observation where the observation plane is the full thickness × full width
size, and finished with mirror polishing. Next, the mirror-polished sample was observed
using an optical microscope and image captured. The obtained images were subjected
to image analysis to determine the circle equivalent diameter of each pore found in
the image. The number of pores having a size of 180 µm or more was divided by the
measured area (plate thickness × plate width) to determine the number of pores having
a circle equivalent diameter of 180 µm or more per mm
2.
[Yield stress]
[0091] Tensile tests were conducted according to EN 10002-1 to determine yield stress (YS)
at 1/4 and 1/2 positions of thickness (t) of each steel plate. For each tensile test,
a round bar tensile test piece having a parallel portion diameter of 14 mm and a parallel
portion length of 70 mm was used, the test pieces being taken parallel to the plate
transverse direction from 1/4 and 1/2 positions of plate thickness. In the tensile
test, when an upper yield point appeared, the upper yield point was determined to
be yield stress. Further, when an upper yield point did not appear, a 0.2 % proof
stress was determined to be yield stress.
[0092] Next, each steel plate was used to produce a multilayer-fill-welded joint. Each obtained
multilayer-fill-welded joint was subjected to a joint CTOD test to measure the amount
of crack opening displacement in the CGHAZ and the amount of crack opening displacement
in the SC/ICHAZ. The conditions for production of the multilayer-fill-welded joints
and the conditions of the joint CTOD tests are described below.
[Joint CTOD test]
[0093] Welded joints used for the joint CTOD tests were produced by submerged arc welding
(multilayer fill welding) with K groove geometry and heat input of 5.0 kJ/mm. The
test method was based on BS EN10225 (2019), and the crack opening displacement [CTOD
value (δ)] was evaluated at the test temperature of -40 °C using test pieces each
having a square cross-section of t × t (where t is plate thickness).
[0094] In the joint CTOD tests described above, a test where the notch position was set
as the CGHAZ on the linear side of the K groove and a test where the notch position
was set at the SC/ICHAZ boundary were conducted, and the δ of the CGHAZ and the δ
of the SC/ICHAZ boundary were measured, respectively. For each steel plate, the test
was performed for three test pieces per notch position and the lowest value measured
was taken as δ.
[0095] After the tests, on a fracture surface of the test piece, the end of a fatigue precrack
was confirmed to be located both in the CGHAZ and at the SC/ICHAZ boundary specified
by EN10225 (2019). In the case of joint CTOD test of multilayer fill welding, even
when a notch position is located in the CGHAZ, a certain amount of the ICCGHAZ is
also included, and therefore the test result reflects toughness of both the CGHAZ
and the ICCGHAZ.
[0096] The measurement results are listed in Table 2.

[Table 2]
[0097]
Table 2
No. |
Steel sample ID |
Thickness (mm) |
Production conditions |
Measurement results |
Classification |
Heating |
Hot rolling |
Cooling |
Tempering |
Base metal properties |
Welded portion properties |
Heating temp. (°C) |
Cumulative rolling reduction ratio at 950 °C or more and rolling reduction of 3 %
or more per pass (%) |
Average deformation resistance ratio between mid-thickness part and surface for rolling
at 950 °C or more |
Cumulative rolling reduction ratio below 950 °C (%) |
Average deformation resistance ratio between mid-thickness part and surface for rolling
below 950 °C |
Average cooling rate* (°C/s) |
Cooling stop temp. (°C) |
Tempering temp. (°C) |
Average effective crystal grain size of mid-thickness part (µm) |
Pore number density (per mm2) |
YS at 1/4 position of base metal (MPa) |
YS at 1/2 position of base metal (MPa) |
δ of CGHAZ at -40°C (mm) |
δ of SC/ICHAZ boundary at -40 °C (mm) |
1 |
A |
118 |
1008 |
49 |
0.70 |
56 |
0.58 |
5.8 |
218 |
- |
14 |
0.04 |
518 |
513 |
0.84 |
1.18 |
Example |
2 |
A |
144 |
1108 |
39 |
0.68 |
51 |
0.58 |
9.4 |
512 |
750 |
39 |
0.02 |
522 |
519 |
0.39 |
0.31 |
Example |
3 |
B |
151 |
1005 |
41 |
0.67 |
45 |
0.59 |
8.9 |
379 |
500 |
10 |
0.08 |
337 |
326 |
0.58 |
0.66 |
Example |
4 |
B |
109 |
1126 |
49 |
0.79 |
60 |
0.54 |
6.4 |
203 |
- |
19 |
0.23 |
407 |
370 |
0.25 |
0.21 |
Comparative Example |
5 |
C |
142 |
976 |
19 |
0.61 |
48 |
0.63 |
1.4 |
541 |
- |
53 |
0.28 |
602 |
546 |
0.13 |
0.21 |
Comparative Example |
6 |
C |
109 |
1140 |
47 |
0.66 |
70 |
0.63 |
4.2 |
344 |
- |
14 |
0.09 |
548 |
536 |
0.55 |
0.41 |
Example |
7 |
D |
126 |
1095 |
26 |
0.69 |
57 |
0.67 |
3.8 |
463 |
- |
47 |
0.25 |
466 |
428 |
0.17 |
0.15 |
Comparative Example |
8 |
D |
133 |
1026 |
39 |
0.65 |
69 |
0.68 |
2.4 |
526 |
- |
20 |
0.05 |
440 |
435 |
0.43 |
0.36 |
Example |
9 |
E |
145 |
1190 |
30 |
0.58 |
59 |
0.66 |
9.6 |
315 |
600 |
15 |
0.01 |
543 |
541 |
1.16 |
0.74 |
Example |
10 |
E |
148 |
1070 |
43 |
0.69 |
33 |
0.70 |
4.8 |
504 |
- |
43 |
0.06 |
520 |
514 |
0.33 |
0.26 |
Comparative Example |
11 |
F |
140 |
1189 |
39 |
0.58 |
61 |
0.73 |
41.4 |
356 |
- |
36 |
0.10 |
545 |
528 |
0.49 |
0.29 |
Comparative Example |
12 |
F |
110 |
1179 |
31 |
0.56 |
47 |
0.65 |
28.2 |
379 |
- |
19 |
0.09 |
547 |
533 |
1.02 |
0.85 |
Example |
13 |
G |
147 |
1089 |
34 |
0.59 |
69 |
0.65 |
44.7 |
447 |
550 |
18 |
0.03 |
484 |
481 |
0.64 |
0.99 |
Example |
14 |
G |
124 |
1171 |
41 |
0.56 |
62 |
0.50 |
63.2 |
587 |
- |
14 |
0.08 |
620 |
611 |
0.52 |
0.28 |
Example |
15 |
H |
200 |
1050 |
37 |
0.53 |
57 |
0.60 |
49.0 |
560 |
600 |
19 |
0.02 |
526 |
523 |
0.72 |
0.61 |
Example |
16 |
H |
101 |
1270 |
35 |
0.57 |
46 |
0.51 |
9.3 |
306 |
- |
37 |
0.03 |
518 |
515 |
0.44 |
0.16 |
Comparative Example |
17 |
I |
175 |
1011 |
47 |
0.64 |
48 |
0.61 |
2.4 |
364 |
- |
14 |
0.02 |
491 |
487 |
0.52 |
0.93 |
Example |
18 |
I |
126 |
1046 |
40 |
0.51 |
48 |
0.53 |
0.8 |
244 |
- |
40 |
0.09 |
515 |
502 |
0.73 |
0.26 |
Comparative Example |
19 |
J |
115 |
1142 |
31 |
0.70 |
61 |
0.56 |
3.7 |
404 |
- |
19 |
0.04 |
364 |
359 |
0.63 |
1.07 |
Example |
20 |
J |
158 |
1013 |
45 |
0.50 |
43 |
0.63 |
11.9 |
625 |
- |
41 |
0.10 |
317 |
301 |
0.31 |
0.19 |
Comparative Example |
21 |
K |
144 |
1069 |
42 |
0.66 |
61 |
0.57 |
3.2 |
540 |
- |
15 |
0.08 |
514 |
504 |
0.63 |
0.94 |
Example |
22 |
L |
123 |
999 |
47 |
0.64 |
42 |
0.51 |
5.3 |
477 |
- |
13 |
0.09 |
562 |
544 |
0.60 |
0.59 |
Example |
23 |
M |
115 |
1155 |
44 |
0.60 |
60 |
0.55 |
6.6 |
600 |
- |
18 |
0.07 |
374 |
367 |
0.42 |
1.18 |
Example |
24 |
N |
101 |
1007 |
42 |
0.58 |
58 |
0.67 |
35.9 |
582 |
650 |
11 |
0.05 |
551 |
545 |
0.46 |
0.44 |
Example |
25 |
O |
123 |
1181 |
35 |
0.57 |
60 |
0.56 |
14.2 |
399 |
- |
19 |
0.06 |
527 |
521 |
0.26 |
0.20 |
Comparative Example |
26 |
P |
118 |
1053 |
31 |
0.54 |
58 |
0.60 |
2.9 |
588 |
- |
15 |
0.05 |
507 |
501 |
0.22 |
0.24 |
Comparative Example |
27 |
Q |
106 |
1018 |
43 |
0.57 |
52 |
0.53 |
8.5 |
425 |
- |
12 |
0.04 |
510 |
505 |
0.23 |
0.28 |
Comparative Example |
Heating |
Hot rolling |
Cooling |
Tempering |
Base metal |
properties |
Welded portion properties |
|
Heating temp. (°C) |
Cumulative rolling reduction ratio at 950 °C or more and rolling reduction of 3 %
or more per pass (%) |
Average deformation resistance ratio between mid-thickness part and surface for rolling
at 950 °C or more |
Cumulative rolling reduction ratio below 950 °C (%) |
Average deformation resistance ratio between mid-thickness part and surface for rolling
below 950 °C |
Average cooling rate* (°C/s) |
Cooling stop temp. (°C) |
Tempering temp. (°C) |
Average effective crystal grain size of mid-thickness part (µm) |
Pore number density (per mm2) |
YS at 1/4 position of base metal (MPa) |
YS at 1/2 position of base metal (MPa) |
δ of CGHAZ at -40 °C (mm) |
δ of SC/ICHAZ boundary at -40 °C (mm) |
|
|
|
|
28 |
R |
102 |
1196 |
31 |
0.64 |
68 |
0.67 |
24.6 |
557 |
- |
20 |
0.02 |
511 |
508 |
0.29 |
0.29 |
Comparative Example |
29 |
S |
107 |
1035 |
42 |
0.50 |
61 |
0.70 |
14.1 |
403 |
500 |
14 |
0.07 |
500 |
490 |
0.26 |
0.17 |
Comparative Example |
30 |
T |
103 |
992 |
32 |
0.51 |
62 |
0.60 |
6.5 |
481 |
- |
18 |
0.07 |
400 |
387 |
0.11 |
0.29 |
Comparative Example |
31 |
U |
143 |
1125 |
38 |
0.68 |
51 |
0.63 |
4.4 |
211 |
- |
19 |
0.07 |
501 |
488 |
0.25 |
0.21 |
Comparative Example |
32 |
V |
132 |
1036 |
33 |
0.51 |
44 |
0.66 |
4.1 |
473 |
- |
14 |
0.10 |
484 |
468 |
0.17 |
0.25 |
Comparative Example |
33 |
W |
105 |
1163 |
41 |
0.66 |
46 |
0.56 |
4.9 |
535 |
- |
20 |
0.02 |
461 |
458 |
0.18 |
0.23 |
Comparative Example |
34 |
X |
132 |
1156 |
43 |
0.65 |
64 |
0.52 |
21.7 |
467 |
500 |
20 |
0.06 |
529 |
517 |
0.19 |
0.26 |
Comparative Example |
35 |
Y |
147 |
1157 |
50 |
0.55 |
67 |
0.54 |
1.9 |
491 |
- |
13 |
0.02 |
550 |
547 |
0.22 |
0.29 |
Comparative Example |
36 |
Z |
111 |
1144 |
44 |
0.68 |
49 |
0.67 |
79 |
546 |
- |
12 |
0.05 |
497 |
490 |
0.14 |
0.29 |
Comparative Example |
37 |
AA |
136 |
1124 |
43 |
0.55 |
62 |
0.52 |
43.0 |
215 |
600 |
15 |
0.08 |
505 |
492 |
0.23 |
0.15 |
Comparative Example |
38 |
AB |
115 |
1084 |
34 |
0.59 |
60 |
0.53 |
6.6 |
491 |
- |
13 |
0.03 |
521 |
518 |
0.16 |
0.28 |
Comparative Example |
39 |
AC |
130 |
1097 |
35 |
0.57 |
70 |
0.69 |
36.4 |
328 |
- |
10 |
0.03 |
589 |
584 |
0.25 |
0.12 |
Comparative Example |
40 |
AD |
103 |
1027 |
39 |
0.62 |
40 |
0.55 |
7.3 |
530 |
- |
18 |
0.02 |
515 |
512 |
0.25 |
0.15 |
Comparative Example |
41 |
AE |
119 |
1019 |
42 |
0.63 |
54 |
0.50 |
6.5 |
524 |
- |
17 |
0.09 |
489 |
478 |
0.22 |
0.13 |
Comparative Example |
42 |
AF |
149 |
1054 |
34 |
0.64 |
63 |
0.59 |
30.9 |
540 |
650 |
19 |
0.02 |
295 |
292 |
0.32 |
0.41 |
Comparative Example |
43 |
AG |
120 |
1060 |
46 |
0.68 |
57 |
0.67 |
3.1 |
496 |
- |
16 |
0.02 |
291 |
287 |
0.40 |
0.39 |
Comparative Example |
44 |
AH |
127 |
1062 |
37 |
0.70 |
47 |
0.53 |
4.0 |
566 |
- |
24 |
0.08 |
493 |
479 |
0.23 |
0.27 |
Comparative Example |
45 |
AI |
133 |
1071 |
41 |
0.69 |
52 |
0.55 |
2.9 |
524 |
- |
19 |
0.02 |
447 |
444 |
0.18 |
0.24 |
Comparative Example |
46 |
AJ |
135 |
1056 |
44 |
0.55 |
53 |
0.54 |
2.8 |
488 |
500 |
15 |
0.02 |
435 |
432 |
0.19 |
0.28 |
Comparative Example |
47 |
AK |
108 |
1079 |
37 |
0.62 |
44 |
0.53 |
4.3 |
589 |
- |
15 |
0.05 |
265 |
258 |
0.37 |
0.42 |
Comparative Example |
48 |
AL |
137 |
1017 |
35 |
0.66 |
41 |
0.66 |
5.0 |
457 |
- |
18 |
0.05 |
616 |
609 |
0.23 |
0.20 |
Comparative Example |
49 |
AM |
105 |
1115 |
45 |
0.56 |
56 |
0.52 |
8.6 |
336 |
- |
13 |
0.09 |
544 |
527 |
0.17 |
0.20 |
Comparative Example |
50 |
AN |
145 |
999 |
33 |
0.52 |
67 |
0.53 |
7.2 |
553 |
- |
20 |
0.04 |
526 |
519 |
0.19 |
0.23 |
Comparative Example |
51 |
AO |
103 |
1100 |
44 |
0.63 |
50 |
0.63 |
3.0 |
503 |
- |
13 |
0.08 |
367 |
359 |
0.78 |
0.83 |
Example |
52 |
AO |
102 |
1100 |
46 |
0.84 |
50 |
0.64 |
3.2 |
498 |
- |
14 |
0.34 |
353 |
308 |
0.77 |
0.81 |
Comparative Example |
53 |
AP |
120 |
1050 |
48 |
0.60 |
50 |
0.59 |
2.8 |
451 |
- |
18 |
0.07 |
389 |
375 |
0.53 |
0.71 |
Example |
Note: underlining indicates value outside scope of present disclosure
* When cooling stop temperature is 500 °C or less, average value from 700 °C to 500
°C, and when cooling stop temperature is higher than 500 °C, average value from 700
°C to the cooling stop temperature higher than 500 °C. |
[0098] As can be seen in Table 2, the steel plates satisfying the conditions of the present
disclosure (Examples) had manufacturing conditions, effective crystal grain size of
the base metal, and pore number densities all within acceptable ranges, yield stress
at the 1/4 thickness position and at the mid-thickness position of 320 MPa or more,
CTOD values at the CGHAZ and CTOD values at the SC/ICHAZ boundary both 0.30 mm or
more at -40 °C, and combined high strength with excellent joint CTOD properties.
[0099] In contrast, among the steel plates that did not satisfy the conditions of the present
disclosure (Comparative Examples), No. 42, No. 43, and No. 47 each had a yield stress
of less than 320 MPa at the 1/4 thickness position and at the mid-thickness position.
No. 20 had a yield stress of less than 320 MPa at the 1/4 thickness position and at
the mid-thickness position and a CTOD value of less than 0.30 mm at the SC/ICHAZ boundary.
No. 52 had a yield strength of 320 MPa or more at the 1/4 thickness position, but
the yield stress at the mid-thickness position was less than 320 MPa. Other Comparative
Examples had one or both of the CTOD values of the CGHAZ and the SC/ICHAZ boundary
less than 0.30 mm. All of the Comparative Examples had inferior base metal strength
and joint CTOD properties compared to the Examples.