[0001] The present invention relates to a collision-resistant structure for a side of a
ship's hull. Furthermore, the present invention relates to a ship's hull provided
with such a collision-resistant structure, and a ship comprising such a hull. The
present invention further comprises a method of configuring the collision-resistant
structure.
[0002] In recent decades, inland navigation ships particularly in Europe, in particular
chemical tankers and gas carriers, have overall increased in size due to an overall
increase of cargo tank sizes for commercial and operational reasons. If such a large
ship is involved in a collision, which can especially occur on inland waterways and
in ports, the hull and cargo tanks could be heavily damaged and, as a consequence,
the environment could be severely polluted or even, in some cases, an explosion risk
could arise. A considerable risk arises notably in the event of a side collision,
e.g., when another ship collides frontally with a lateral side of the hull. Therefore,
the safety of ships with increased cargo tank sizes in the case of side collisions
was to be increased. In particular, the impact resistance of shell structures of ships
had to be improved.
[0003] Lapsed
European patent No. 1 137 571 discloses a collision-resistant structure comprising a series of ducted sections
positioned above one another and attached to the inner surface of the outer wall.
The known collision-resistant structure has been applied in many ships with cargo
tanks having an increased capacity, with the purpose of providing a sufficient safety
when absorbing the impact from a side collision by another ship. An applied embodiment
of the structure comprises a so-called HAT-profile, wherein the ducted sections are
strengthened by means of built-up T-profiles, wherein these ducted, built-up structures
are welded to the inner surface of the outer wall.
[0004] The known collision-resistant structure nonetheless has numerous drawbacks. Overall,
the structure is relatively complex and adds considerable weight to the construction
of the ship. More specifically, the series of ducted profiles are relatively heavy
and complex to be constructed and to be welded to the wall such that the construction
time is increased considerably. Furthermore, once constructed and installed, the ducted
profiles complicate coating of the structure. The same applies to the repair of such
a construction after a collision, which repair is thus more expensive. Moreover, the
ducted profiles require to be tested for weathertightness after installation, as the
inside of the ducted profiles may be prone to corrosion. Testing each ducted profile
along the ship's cargo tank area at both port side and starboard side extends the
building time of the ship significantly.
[0005] It is therefore an object of the present invention, amongst other objects, to provide
an improved collision-resistant structure, in particular a collision-resistant structure
wherein at least one of the aforenoted drawbacks is at least partially alleviated,
preferably while providing the structure with a sufficient capability to absorb the
impact of a collision with another ship.
[0006] To that end, a collision-resistant structure for a side of a ship's hull is provided,
wherein the structure comprises:
- an outer shell having an inner surface and an outer surface;
- an array of web frames extending broadwise substantially perpendicular to the inner
surface of the outer shell and lengthwise transversely across the inner surface of
the outer shell, wherein the web frames are mutually spaced along the inner surface;
- an array of longitudinal stiffening profiles that extend lengthwise longitudinally
along at least part of the inner surface of the outer shell and are mutually spaced
across at least part of the inner surface of the outer shell;
- an array of intermediate transverse stiffening profiles that extend lengthwise transversely
across at least part of the inner surface of the outer shell and are mutually spaced
along at least part of the inner surface of the outer shell, wherein the web frames
and the intermediate transverse profiles are arranged in such an alternating manner
that, between neighbouring web frames in the array, at least one of the transverse
profiles is positioned, wherein the longitudinal profiles cross the web frames and
the intermediate transverse profiles such that the arrays together form a net-like
structure, wherein the net-like structure of the arrays is attached to the inner surface
of the outer shell.
[0007] Compared to the known collision-resistant ducted structure, the net-like structure
provides a more progressive resistance to the impact of a collision, which increases
the absorption capacity of the structure in case of a collision. The term "collision-resistant"
can be defined as, e.g., compliant with the regulations of the European Agreement
concerning the International Carriage of Dangerous Goods by Inland Waterways (ADN).
[0008] Furthermore, by forming a net-like structure, the construction can be significantly
simplified, and the weight and material use can be reduced, especially when the structure
essentially consists of only the outer shell, the web frames, the profiles and, optionally,
an inner shell as described further below. Preferably, between neighbouring web frames
in the array, only one transverse profile is positioned. In general, web frames for
a hull are substantially plate-like. The web frames extend further inwards, i.e.,
further away from the outer shell, than the stiffening profiles, in particular the
intermediate transverse profiles. Such web frames as such are a well-known structural
component in naval architecture and, in a further embodiment as described further
below, may be adjusted to allow the longitudinal profiles to cross.
[0009] Moreover, the structure can be made using relatively standard profiles as opposed
to the specific ducted profiles that have been used previously. For example, the intermediate
transverse profiles are preferably H-profiles or I-profiles, or alternatively T-profiles
or L-profiles, or the array of intermediate transverse profiles may comprise a combination
of such profiles. Similarly, the longitudinal profiles are preferably L-profiles or
T-profiles, or alternatively flat bars or Holland profiles, or the array of longitudinal
profiles may comprise a combination of such profiles. Each or at least one of the
longitudinal profiles is preferably fixed lengthwise, via an outer edge thereof, to
the inner surface of the outer shell. The outer edge of the longitudinal profile may
be directly fixed to the inner surface of the outer shell.
[0010] A further advantage of the structure is that the coating of the profiles can be maintained
more easily such that corrosion risks can be reduced, and the structure may even be
suitable for corrosive conditions as in the case of ballast tanks.
[0011] As such, by providing any one of the above advantages, an improved collision-resistant
structure can be obtained for single-walled and double-walled ships. Furthermore,
applying the net-like structure instead of the known ducted structure can lower the
carbon footprint of the ship. In the net-like structure, it is preferred if the longitudinal
profiles cross the web frames and the transverse profiles perpendicularly, wherein
it is further preferred if the web frames and the transverse profiles are mutually
parallel, such that a substantially grid-like or raster-like structure is obtained
for an optimal impact absorption capacity of the structure. As such, the web frames
and the transverse profiles can be substantially vertical, while the longitudinal
profiles are substantially horizontal.
[0012] It is to be appreciated that the term "ship" is particularly understood to refer
to, inter alia, an inland navigation vessel or a sea-going ship, such as a tanker,
but may also refer to a pontoon or a tug-pushed barge. The term "transverse", as in
transverse profiles, relates herein to a direction perpendicular to the longitudinal
direction, or the direction of movement, of the ship.
[0013] According to a preferred embodiment of the collision-resistant structure, neighbouring
web frames and transverse profiles are arranged at equal mutual distances. This way,
an even more evenly configured grid-like or raster-like structure can be obtained,
such that the impact absorption capacity is substantially even across and along the
structure.
[0014] To obtain a responsive collision-resistant structure, the transverse profiles and
the longitudinal profiles are particularly made of a ductile material, preferably
steel, particularly shipbuilding-quality steel.
[0015] In case the longitudinal profiles are fixed to the inner surface of the outer shell,
it is preferred if the web frames and the transverse profiles are fixed to and across
the longitudinal profiles in an overlapping manner. Such an overlapping configuration
simplifies the construction of the collision-resistant structure since, conveniently,
the longitudinal profiles can be mounted to the outer shell first and the web frames
and the transverse profiles can be affixed in a subsequent step. The mounting, connecting
and attaching of the profiles is preferably done by means of welding. The overlapping
configuration may enhance the ability of the structure to progressively resist the
impact of a collision.
[0016] In the overlapping configuration, it is further preferred if each or at least one
transverse profile comprises a flange, wherein the transverse profile is fixed to
the longitudinal profiles via an outer face of the flange. For example, the transverse
profile may be an H-profile, an I-profile, a T-profile or an L-profile, each of which
comprises such a flange. Additionally, or alternatively, it is preferred if each or
at least one web frame is provided, preferably lengthwise along an outer edge thereof,
with a face bar, wherein the web frame is fixed to the longitudinal profiles via an
outer face of the face bar.
[0017] By fixing the transverse profile or the web frame to the longitudinal profiles via
a flange or a face bar, the respective member is affixed over a larger connection
area such that a sturdier connection can be obtained. Moreover, a larger connection
area may further enhance the impact absorption capacity of the structure, as the connection
enables the longitudinal profiles to push against the web frames and the transverse
profiles for an improved response of the structure to the impact of a collision.
[0018] It is then further preferred if each or at least one longitudinal profile comprises
a flange, wherein the longitudinal profile is fixed to the web frames and the transverse
profiles via an outer face of the flange. As such, the flange of the longitudinal
profile may be fixed to the flange of the transverse profile and to the face bar of
the web frame. This further enlarges each connection area. For example, the longitudinal
profile may be an L-profile, a T-profile, an I-profile or an H-profile, each of which
comprises such a flange.
[0019] According to a further preferred embodiment of the collision-resistant structure,
the web frames extend to a bottom of the outer shell, wherein the transverse profiles
are spaced from the bottom of the outer shell. When another ship collides into the
side of the hull, the impact area is generally above the waterline. Hence, it may
generally suffice to arrange the net-like structure over only a part of the height
of the outer shell, specifically the part near the top of the outer shell. Therefore,
to further simplify the net-like structure, the lower ends of the transverse profiles
preferably do not extend all the way to the bottom of the outer shell but are located
at a distance above the bottom of the outer shell. In that case, it is preferred if
each or at least one transverse profile is provided with a bottom bracket arranged
to connect the transverse profile to the bottom of the outer shell.
[0020] A specific embodiment of the collision-resistant structure, more specifically a double-walled
structure, further comprises an inner shell spaced from the outer shell. The web frames
are arranged between the shells. Preferably, the web frames are connected to the inner
shell, wherein the inner shell is preferably spaced from the intermediate transverse
profiles. Such double-walled structures may be particularly applied in chemical tankers
and cryogen gas tankers. The outer surface of the inner shell, which faces the outer
shell, may be provided with an array of longitudinal stiffening profiles that extend
lengthwise longitudinally along, and are mutually spaced across, at least part of
the outer surface of the inner shell. These longitudinal profiles on the inner shell
may be L-profiles, T-profiles, flat bars or Holland profiles, or the array of longitudinal
profiles on the inner shell may comprise a combination of such profiles.
[0021] As such, according to a further aspect, a ship's hull is provided, wherein a side
of the hull, preferably a lateral side such as port side or starboard side, is provided
with a collision-resistant structure according to any of the embodiments described
above. Further provided is a ship, in particular a chemical tanker or a gas carrier,
wherein the ship comprises said hull. The ship preferably further comprises at least
one cargo tank. Each or at least one cargo tank may have a capacity volume exceeding
380 cubic metres, for instance a capacity volume of between 380 and 1000 cubic metres.
A risk can arise particularly in the event of a collision into the hull at the location
of the cargo tank. It is therefore preferred if the collision-resistant structure
is provided alongside of the cargo hold area, specifically the cargo tank, more preferably
along the entire cargo hold area.
[0022] According to yet another aspect, a method of configuring a collision-resistant structure
according to any of the embodiments described above is provided, wherein the method
comprises the step of determining distances between neighbouring web frames and transverse
profiles in dependence of the degree to which the web frames, the transverse profiles
and the longitudinal profiles absorb an impact on the outer surface of the outer shell.
[0023] The step of determining said distances may comprise the steps of:
- providing a finite element model of the collision-resistant structure, wherein the
model includes a cell length parameter representative for distances between neighbouring
web frames and transverse profiles in the array;
- simulating, for various values for the cell length parameter, an impact on the outer
surface of the outer shell;
- determining, for each simulated impact, an impact absorption parameter representative
for the degree to which the web frames, the transverse profiles and the longitudinal
profiles absorb the impact;
- selecting, from the various values for the cell length parameter, an optimal value
that maximises the impact absorption parameter.
[0024] The structure is hereinafter further elucidated with reference to the attached drawings,
wherein:
- Figure 1 represents an isometric view of a single-walled structure for a side of a
ship hull;
- Figure 2 represents a side view of the single-walled embodiment seen from inside the
hull;
- Figures 3 and 4 represent different cross-sectional views of a double-walled embodiment.
[0025] In Figures 1 and 2, a collision-resistant single-walled structure 1 for a side of
a hull of a ship, in particular a non-cryogenic gas carrier, is shown. The structure
1 comprises an outer shell 2 for forming part of the outer surface of the hull, and
a net-like structure 10 of arrays of stiffening members 3, 4, 5.
[0026] In Figures 3 and 4, a double-walled variant of the collision-resistant structure
1, in particular for a chemical tanker or a cryogenic gas carrier, is shown in cross-section,
which further comprises an inner shell 6. Throughout the drawings, corresponding elements
are indicated by corresponding reference signs.
[0027] The net-like structure 10 includes a vertical array of horizontal L-profiles 3 positioned
above one another. The horizontal L-profiles 3 form impact rows and are fixed lengthwise,
via an outer edge thereof, directly to the inner surface 20 of the outer shell 2.
Seen in cross-section, the opposite leg 31 of each L-profile 3 extends downwards from
the leg 32 that is fixed to the inner surface 20.
[0028] The net-like structure 10 further includes a horizontal array of vertical plate-like
web frames 4 for the hull, and of intermediate vertical H-profiles 5. The vertical
web frames 4 and H-profiles 5 form, respectively, primary and secondary impact columns
and are arranged in the array in such an alternating manner that, between neighbouring
web frames 4, one H-profile 5 is positioned. The profiles 3, 5 and the web frames
4 define cell-like spaces 7 therebetween. It has been found that the impact energy
absorption capacity of the structure 1 is particularly governed by the selected length
L of the cell-like spaces 7, which is thus preferably to be optimised for each design.
The cell-like spaces 7 are uniform.
[0029] Specifically, Figure 3 represents a cross-section at the location of a web frame
4, whereas Figure 4 represents a cross-section at the location of an H-profile 5.
For the horizontal L-profiles 3 to cross the vertical web frames 4 and H-profiles
5, each web frame 4 is provided with a passage 40 therethrough, whereas each vertical
H-profile 5 overlaps the horizontal L-profiles 3. Each web frame 4 and H-profile 5
is attached, via a respective face bar 41 or flange 51 thereof, onto the leg 31 of
each L-profile 3 that is spaced from the inner surface 20 of the outer shell 2. Such
flange-to-flange connections enable the L-profiles 3 to push against the web frames
4 and the H-profiles 5 in the event of a collision for an improved response of the
structure 1 to the impact of the collision. Each web frame 4 is furthermore provided
with a vertical array of horizontal flat bars 8 (indicated in Figures 1 and 2) extending
lengthwise transversely across the width of the web frame 4.
[0030] The part of the net-like structure 10 that includes the L-profiles 3 and the H-profiles
5 covers only an upper part of the inner surface 20 of the outer shell 2. This upper
part essentially corresponds to a potential impact zone in the event of a collision
by a cross-sectionally U- or V-shaped hull of another vessel as indicated by dashed
lines in Figure 2. The lower ends of the vertical H-profiles 5 are located at a height
H from the bottom of the outer shell 2 and are connected thereto by respective bilge
brackets 9. A lower part of the inner surface 20 of the outer shell 2, i.e., below
the horizontal L-profiles 3 of the net-like structure 10, is provided with horizontal
Holland profiles 21, also known as bulb profiles, extending lengthwise longitudinally
along the lower part of the inner surface 20. Similarly, in the double-walled structure
shown in Figures 3 and 4, the outer surface 60 of the inner shell 6 is provided with
horizontal L-profiles 61, extending lengthwise longitudinally along the outer surface
60 of the inner shell 6 in a similar manner as the L-profiles 3 along the inner surface
20 of the outer shell 2. These Holland profiles 21 and L-profiles 61 extend through
the web frames 4. The Holland profiles 21 furthermore extend through the bilge brackets
9.
[0031] The figures and the above description serve to illustrate specific embodiments of
the invention and do not limit the scope of protection defined by the following claims.
1. Collision-resistant structure for a side of a ship's hull, the structure comprising:
- an outer shell having an inner surface and an outer surface;
- an array of web frames extending broadwise substantially perpendicular to the inner
surface of the outer shell and lengthwise transversely across the inner surface of
the outer shell, wherein the web frames are mutually spaced along the inner surface;
- an array of longitudinal stiffening profiles that extend lengthwise longitudinally
along at least part of the inner surface of the outer shell and are mutually spaced
across at least part of the inner surface of the outer shell;
- an array of intermediate transverse stiffening profiles that extend lengthwise transversely
across at least part of the inner surface of the outer shell and are mutually spaced
along at least part of the inner surface of the outer shell, wherein the web frames
and the intermediate transverse profiles are arranged in such an alternating manner
that, between neighbouring web frames in the array, at least one of the transverse
profiles is positioned,
wherein the longitudinal profiles cross the web frames and the intermediate transverse
profiles such that the arrays together form a net-like structure, wherein the net-like
structure of the arrays is attached to the inner surface of the outer shell.
2. Collision-resistant structure according to claim 1, wherein neighbouring web frames
and transverse profiles are arranged at equal mutual distances.
3. Collision-resistant structure according to claim 1 or 2, wherein the transverse profiles
are H-profiles, I-profiles, T-profiles or L-profiles.
4. Collision-resistant structure according to claim 1, 2 or 3, wherein the longitudinal
profiles are L-profiles, T-profiles, flat bars or Holland profiles, wherein each longitudinal
profile is fixed lengthwise, via an outer edge thereof, to the inner surface of the
outer shell.
5. Collision-resistant structure according to any of the preceding claims, wherein the
longitudinal profiles are fixed to the inner surface of the outer shell, wherein the
web frames and the transverse profiles are fixed to and across the longitudinal profiles
in an overlapping manner.
6. Collision-resistant structure according to claim 5, wherein each transverse profile
comprises a flange, wherein the transverse profile is fixed to the longitudinal profiles
via an outer face of the flange, and wherein each web frame is lengthwise along an
outer edge thereof provided with a face bar, wherein the web frame is fixed to the
longitudinal profiles via an outer face of the face bar.
7. Collision-resistant structure according to claim 5 or 6, wherein each longitudinal
profile comprises a flange, wherein the longitudinal profile is fixed to the web frames
and the transverse profiles via an outer face of the flange.
8. Collision-resistant structure according to any of the preceding claims, wherein the
web frames extend to a bottom of the outer shell, wherein the transverse profiles
are spaced from the bottom of the outer shell.
9. Collision-resistant structure according to claim 8, wherein each transverse profile
is provided with a bottom bracket arranged to connect the transverse profile to the
bottom of the outer shell.
10. Collision-resistant structure according to any of the preceding claims, further comprising
an inner shell spaced from the outer shell, wherein the web frames are connected to
the inner shell.
11. Ship's hull, wherein a lateral side of the hull is provided with a collision-resistant
structure according to any of the preceding claims.
12. Ship, in particular a chemical tanker or a gas carrier, wherein the ship comprises
a hull according to claim 11 and at least one cargo tank with a capacity volume exceeding
380 cubic metres, wherein the collision-resistant structure is provided alongside
of the cargo tank.
13. Method of configuring a collision-resistant structure according to any of the preceding
claims 1-10, wherein the method comprises the step of determining distances between
neighbouring web frames and transverse profiles in dependence of the degree to which
the web frames, the transverse profiles and the longitudinal profiles absorb an impact
on the outer surface of the outer shell.
14. Method according to claim 13, wherein the step of determining said distances comprises
the steps of:
- providing a finite element model of the collision-resistant structure, wherein the
model includes a cell length parameter representative for distances between neighbouring
web frames and transverse profiles in the array;
- simulating, for various values for the cell length parameter, an impact on the outer
surface of the outer shell;
- determining, for each simulated impact, an impact absorption parameter representative
for the degree to which the web frames, the transverse profiles and the longitudinal
profiles absorb the impact;
- selecting, from the various values for the cell length parameter, an optimal value
that maximises the impact absorption parameter.
Amended claims in accordance with Rule 137(2) EPC.
1. Collision-resistant structure (1) for a side of a ship's hull, the structure (1) comprising:
- an outer shell (2) having an inner surface (20) and an outer surface;
- an array of web frames (4) extending broadwise substantially perpendicular to the
inner surface (20) of the outer shell (2) and lengthwise transversely across the inner
surface (20) of the outer shell (2), wherein the web frames (4) are mutually spaced
along the inner surface (20);
- an array of longitudinal stiffening profiles (3) that extend lengthwise longitudinally
along at least part of the inner surface (20) of the outer shell (2) and are mutually
spaced across at least part of the inner surface (20) of the outer shell (2);
- an array of intermediate transverse stiffening profiles (5) that extend lengthwise
transversely across at least part of the inner surface (20) of the outer shell (2)
and are mutually spaced along at least part of the inner surface (20) of the outer
shell (2), wherein the web frames (4) and the intermediate transverse profiles (5)
are arranged in such an alternating manner that, between neighbouring web frames (4)
in the array, at least one of the transverse profiles (5) is positioned, wherein the
longitudinal profiles (3) cross the web frames (4) and the intermediate transverse
profiles (5) such that the arrays together form a net-like structure (10), wherein
the net-like structure (10) of the arrays is attached to the inner surface (20) of
the outer shell (2), wherein the longitudinal profiles (3) are fixed to the inner
surface (20) of the outer shell (2), wherein the web frames (4) and the transverse
profiles (5) are fixed to and across the longitudinal profiles (3) in an overlapping
manner.
2. Collision-resistant structure according to claim 1, wherein neighbouring web frames
(4) and transverse profiles (5) are arranged at equal mutual distances (L).
3. Collision-resistant structure according to claim 1 or 2, wherein the transverse profiles
(5) are H-profiles, I-profiles, T-profiles or L-profiles.
4. Collision-resistant structure according to claim 1, 2 or 3, wherein the longitudinal
profiles (3) are L-profiles, T-profiles, flat bars or Holland profiles, wherein each
longitudinal profile (3) is fixed lengthwise, via an outer edge thereof, to the inner
surface (20) of the outer shell (2).
5. Collision-resistant structure according to any of the preceding claims, wherein each
transverse profile (5) comprises a flange (51), wherein the transverse profile (5)
is fixed to the longitudinal profiles (3) via an outer face of the flange (51), and
wherein each web frame (4) is lengthwise along an outer edge thereof provided with
a face bar (41), wherein the web frame (4) is fixed to the longitudinal profiles (3)
via an outer face of the face bar (41).
6. Collision-resistant structure according to any of the preceding claims, wherein each
longitudinal profile (3) comprises a flange (31), wherein the longitudinal profile
(3) is fixed to the web frames (4) and the transverse profiles (5) via an outer face
of the flange (31).
7. Collision-resistant structure according to any of the preceding claims, wherein the
web frames (4) extend to a bottom of the outer shell (2), wherein the transverse profiles
(5) are spaced from the bottom of the outer shell (2), wherein the part of the net-like
structure (10) that includes the longitudinal profiles (3) and the transverse profiles
(5) covers only an upper part of the inner surface (20) of the outer shell (2).
8. Collision-resistant structure according to claim 7, wherein each transverse profile
(5) is provided with a bottom bracket (9) arranged to connect the transverse profile
(5) to the bottom of the outer shell (5).
9. Collision-resistant structure according to any of the preceding claims, further comprising
an inner shell (6) spaced from the outer shell (2), wherein the web frames (4) are
connected to the inner shell (6).
10. Ship's hull, wherein a lateral side of the hull is provided with a collision-resistant
structure (1) according to any of the preceding claims.
11. Ship, in particular a chemical tanker or a gas carrier, wherein the ship comprises
a hull according to claim 10 and at least one cargo tank with a capacity volume exceeding
380 cubic metres, wherein the collision-resistant structure (1) is provided alongside
of the cargo tank.
12. Method of configuring a collision-resistant structure (1) for a side of a ship's hull,
the structure (1) comprising:
- an outer shell (2) having an inner surface (20) and an outer surface;
- an array of web frames (4) extending broadwise substantially perpendicular to the
inner surface (20) of the outer shell (2) and lengthwise transversely across the inner
surface (20) of the outer shell (2), wherein the web frames (4) are mutually spaced
along the inner surface (20);
- an array of longitudinal stiffening profiles (3) that extend lengthwise longitudinally
along at least part of the inner surface (20) of the outer shell (2) and are mutually
spaced across at least part of the inner surface (20) of the outer shell (2);
- an array of intermediate transverse stiffening profiles (5) that extend lengthwise
transversely across at least part of the inner surface (20) of the outer shell (2)
and are mutually spaced along at least part of the inner surface (20) of the outer
shell (2),
wherein the web frames (4) and the intermediate transverse profiles (5) are arranged
in such an alternating manner that, between neighbouring web frames (4) in the array,
at least one of the transverse profiles (5) is positioned, wherein the longitudinal
profiles (3) cross the web frames (4) and the intermediate transverse profiles (5)
such that the arrays together form a net-like structure (10), wherein the net-like
structure (10) of the arrays is attached to the inner surface (20) of the outer shell
(2), wherein the method comprises the step of determining distances (L) between neighbouring
web frames (4) and transverse profiles (5) in dependence of the degree to which the
web frames (4), the transverse profiles (5) and the longitudinal profiles (3) absorb
an impact on the outer surface of the outer shell (2).
13. Method according to claim 12, wherein the step of determining said distances (L) comprises
the steps of:
- providing a finite element model of the collision-resistant structure (1), wherein
the model includes a cell length parameter representative for distances (L) between
neighbouring web frames (4) and transverse profiles (5) in the array;
- simulating, for various values for the cell length parameter, an impact on the outer
surface of the outer shell (2);
- determining, for each simulated impact, an impact absorption parameter representative
for the degree to which the web frames (4), the transverse profiles (5) and the longitudinal
profiles (3) absorb the impact;
- selecting, from the various values for the cell length parameter, an optimal value
that maximises the impact absorption parameter.