FIELD OF THE INVENTION
[0001] The present disclosure relates to a liquid composition comprising nicotine and an
organic acid wherein the nicotine is presented in protonated form for improved toxicology
from decreased degradants, increased stability of nicotine, an extended shelf-life
of the composition, and for an optimized user experience.
BACKGROUND
[0002] Nicotine is a well-known and widely used chemical stimulant which is usually consumed
from various tobacco products typically by smoking. The biological effects of nicotine
include an increase in heart rate and blood pressure when provided to an individual
or animal. Nicotine is also addictive and is reported be associated with satisfying
physical and emotional sensations. However, nicotine has not been linked to carcinogenic
risk and is used in pharmaceutical nicotine replacement therapy with the aim of smokers
quitting cigarettes or switching to a safer consumer product.
[0003] Chemically nicotine comprises a pyridine and pyrrolidine ring which each contain
a nitrogen atom which can be protonated depending on the pH value of the solution.
Therefore, nicotine may be present in a solution in different protonation states.
The protonation states the free base form of Nicotine (i.e. unprotonated form), a
monoprotonated form with a protonation at the N-atom of the pyrrolidine ring and a
diprotonated form with an additional protonation at the N-atom of the pyridine ring
(see Figure 1). Different levels of protonation of nicotine affect both nicotine stability
and user experience during consumption. This is relevant for nicotine replacement
therapy (NRT) products which are used to assist patients in transitioning from traditional
tabaco products and smoking to address health impairment caused by smoking. For nicotine
replacement therapy, different formulations of delivering reduced amounts of nicotine
are used to alleviate a subject's withdrawal symptoms and improve the subject's mood.
These formulations include gums, patches, lozenges, inhalers, (un)metered dose inhalers
(MDI), nasal sprays or electronic cigarettes. The present application refers to nicotine
compositions which may be used in electronic devices such as electronic cigarettes,
inhalers, nebulizers, soft mist inhalers, and vaporizers to produce an aerosol comprising
nicotine.
[0004] One major challenge of such electronic delivery systems is providing consumers with
an acceptable experience, i.e., the vapor of the device has to comply with the consumer's
expectations regarding taste and other sensual impressions. The consumer's experience
needs to be close to their experience in consumption of traditional tobacco products,
as the new pharmaceutical and consumer products are supposed to replace them. Some
consumers prefer an aerosol/vapor that resembles the experience of a tobacco product
such as a cigarette. Aerosols from e-cigarettes and smoke from tobacco products provide
the user with different flavors and the sensations associated with nicotine absorption
in the mouth and throat, followed by nicotine absorption in the lungs. These various
aspects are described by users in terms of flavor, intensity/quality, impact, irritation/smoothness
and nicotine reward. Nicotine contributes to a number of these factors, and is strongly
associated with factors such as impact, irritation and smoothness; these are readily
perceived by consumers, and electronic delivery devices may offer too much or too
little of these parameters for consumers. Different individual preferences also require
certain variations of products to accommodate different consumers' expectations.
[0005] The amount of absorbed nicotine and the absorption speed from the lining of the mouth
and lungs affect the experience of the consumer. Nicotine absorption in the mouth
is typically obtained from nicotine in the vapor phase. In contrast nicotine absorbed
from the lungs is typically obtained from the particulate phase of the aerosol which
is inhaled. Each of these factors, and their balance, can strongly contribute to consumer
acceptability of an e- cigarette or another inhalation device. Providing means to
optimize the overall vaping experience is therefore desirable to e-cigarette manufacturers.
[0006] A further challenge of providing a nicotine composition is the instability of nicotine
and its volatility. Due to the vapor pressure of nicotine in solution as well as degradation
of nicotine by e.g. pyrolysis the nicotine content within the nicotine solution gradually
declines over time. Instead various nicotine degradation products accumulate in the
solution. Hence, manufacturers are interested in nicotine solutions with improved
stability and extended shelf life, i.e., nicotine composition which maintain a stable
or nearly stable nicotine concentration over an extended period. Furthermore, the
accumulation of nicotine degradation products also affects the safety and consumers'
experience as well as the potential regulatory approval of these products, as some
nicotine degradation products have undesired effects or toxicity.
[0007] Therefore, the present application presents a solution to the above problems by providing
a nicotine composition with improved safety through better toxicity levels measured
in harmful and potentially harmful chemicals testing, stability and extended shelf-life,
as well as an optimized consumer experience during consumption.
[0008] Both aspects of the solution can be achieved by optimizing the protonation state
of nicotine in the composition of the invention. Patent application
CA 2964829 discloses that by protonating at least some of the nicotine present in a solution,
the stability of the nicotine solution may be enhanced. By diprotonating at least,
a portion of the nicotine, and specifically at least 5 wt.% of the nicotine present,
loss of the nicotine during storage is reduced.
[0009] Protonation of nicotine also strongly affects the consumers' experience. For the
nicotine compositions which are used in e-cigarettes or other electrical delivery
devices the use of purified, free-base (unprotonated) nicotine is associated with
a consumption experience which at least some users consider insufficient and not satisfactory.
The experience from using combustion type tobacco products, such as cigarettes is
preferred by some tobacco users because they describe a perception of a "throat hit"
sensation in their respiratory tract. This "throat hit" experience does not occur
when free-base nicotine is provided in the composition. Nicotine in its free-base
has high electron density at the N-atoms, this causes a "harsh" sensation, which is
off-putting to many users, when introduced to the respiratory tract, or into the oral
cavity. Thus, this "harshness" can be mitigated and adjusted to a consumers' experience
that allows switching from combustion cigarettes to new safer products by protonation
of nicotine by a suitable pH of the composition or by salt formation which binds the
nicotine molecules.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION
[0010] In one aspect the present invention relates to a composition comprising a solution
of nicotine and lactic acid, wherein the solvent comprises non-aqueous solvents or
solutions with low water content, wherein the water content is less than 5% (w/w).
[0011] In another aspect the present invention relates to process for producing the composition
of the invention, wherein the process comprises the following steps:
- a. mixing lactic acid and nicotine in a predefined molar ratio,
- b. reaction of the components of the composition to form protonated nicotine.
[0012] In another aspect the invention relates to a method for delivering the composition
of the invention to subject, wherein the administration of the composition of the
invention involves inhalation of the vaporized composition of the invention.
[0013] In a further aspect the invention relates to a process for improving the user's sensation
of a vaporized nicotine solution, the process comprises:
- a. Mixing the composition of the invention comprising nicotine and lactic acid wherein
nicotine and lactic acid are present at molar ratio of about 1:2, wherein at least
5% of nicotine is present in a diprotonated form,
- b. Vaporizing the composition,
wherein the improvement of user's sensation is determined according to a VAS questionnaire.
[0014] In a further aspect the invention relates to a composition comprising a solution
of nicotine and a weak acid, wherein the solvent comprises non-aqueous solvents or
solutions with low water content, wherein the water content is less than 5%w/w, wherein
the weak acid is characterized by a pKa-value of less than 4.2.
DEFINTIONS
[0015] Unless otherwise defined, all technical and scientific terms used herein have the
same meaning as commonly understood by one skilled in the art to which this technology
belongs. Although all methods and materials similar or equivalent to those described
herein may be used in practice or in testing the present technology, the preferred
methods and materials are now described.
[0016] In the description of the methods of the present invention the use of terms for individual
steps of the methods such as "first", "second"; "i.", "ii" or "a", "b" etc. does not
necessarily imply a required succession of steps. Depending on the method and required
time intervals some of these steps may occur simultaneously or in different orders
than the listed succession.
[0017] The "bite" or "throat hit" of consumption of the nicotine composition of the invention
describes the sensation which is felt by the consumer during consumption of vaporized
nicotine compositions. The sensation is dependent on the individual subject and can
be recorded using consumer surveys. However, depending on the conditions before and
after vaporization in the nicotine composition the sensation can be adjusted, modified,
and altered. In particular, the chemistry of the functional groups of nicotine or
in nicotine complexes is of relevance for regulating sensation. The consumers' sensation
of "bite" or "throat hit" is affected by the protonation state of nicotine. The consumers'
sensation may be described as either "harsh" or "smooth".
[0018] The terms "harsh" and "harshness" of the "throat hit" are used synonymously herein
and according to the common understanding describe an unpleasant sensory reaction
in the respiratory tract of the consumer, including but not limited to burning or
itching sensations and/or other unpleasant or painful sensory reactions in the respiratory
tract. Harshness may be quantified, for example, with a visual analogue scale ("VAS"),
as well as with other quantification methodologies known in the art such as, for example,
where a study participant is asked to rate the level of physical and/or emotional
satisfaction he or she felt on a categorical scale, e.g., 0-5, 0-10, strongly like
to strongly dislike, etc. The opposite end of the scale of "harshness", i.e., a composition
which is not considered to be "harsh" is typically described as "smooth".
[0019] The term "visual analogue scale" ("VAS"), commonly describe a measurement technique
that measures a characteristic or attitude that is believed to range across a continuum
of values and cannot easily be directly measured. Often distinct categorial values
are used to describe, sort, and record the characteristic. It is often used in epidemiologic
and clinical research to measure the intensity or frequency of various symptoms. For
example, the amount of pain that a test subject feels ranges across a continuum from
none to an extreme amount of pain. Further, the applied scale for VAS can be a unidimensional
measure or alternatively a multidimensional scale. VAS can be presented in a number
of ways, including, but not limited to, scales with a middle point, graduations or
numbers (numerical rating scales), meter-shaped scales (curvilinear analogue scales),
"box-scales" consisting of circles equidistant from each other (one of which the subject
has to mark), and scales with descriptive terms at intervals along a line (graphic
rating scales or Likert scales). Such "VAS" scales are widely used and commonly accepted
in the field and the skilled person is aware of use and design of these scales.
[0020] The terms "deliver", "delivering", "administered" and "administering", are used synonymously
herein and refer to providing a quantifiable dose of nicotine in form of an inhalable
aerosol. Wherein the aerosol is generated from a liquid nicotine formulation with
an electronic cigarette or low temperature vaporizer.
[0021] Administration or exposure to nicotine elicits a well-described "nicotine-related
biological effect" which is experienced by the consumer (e.g. subject). The effect
includes, but is not limited to, a stimulating effect or a relaxing effect. A stimulating
effect may comprise an increased heart rate, an increased blood pressure, or a feeling
of satisfaction (e.g., physical satisfaction) of the subject. These nicotine-related
biological effects are a key reason keeping smokers addicted to cigarettes, and providing
comparable experience from safer nicotine products is imperative in switching smokers
to a healthier product.
[0022] "Degree of protonation of nicotine" refers within this application to the relative
fractions of nicotine protonation states, i.e., the relative ratios between free-base,
monoprotonated and diprotonated nicotine. A low degree of protonation refers to a
ratio with predominant free-base nicotine, in contrast a high degree of protonation
suggests predominance of diprotonated nicotine.
[0023] The terms "respiratory tract" or "respiratory organs" are used synonymously herein
and according to common medical understanding. "Respiratory tract" comprises the "upper
respiratory tract" and the "lower respiratory tract" of a subject. The "upper respiratory
tract" encompasses the nose, nasal cavities, sinuses, pharynx, and the upper portions
of the larynx above the vocal folds (e.g., also known as vocal cords or voice reeds.)
The "lower respiratory tract" encompasses the lower portion of the larynx below the
vocal folds, trachea, bronchi, bronchioles, and alveoli.
[0024] In the context of this invention "agitate" or "agitation" refer to various mechanical
methods of mixing of different substances which may include, but are not limited to,
rotating, vibrating, vortexing, swirling, shaking, ultrasonicating, stirring, or any
movement that causes mixing. Mechanical movements include movements performed by hand
or by a rotator.
[0025] The term "organic acid" as used herein, refers to an organic compound with acidic
properties (e.g., according to Bronsted-Lowry definition, or Lewis definition). A
common class of organic acid is group of carboxylic acids, whose acidity is associated
with their carboxyl group, i.e., -COOR. A dicarboxylic acid possesses two carboxylic
acid groups. The relative acidity of an organic is measured by its pKa value and one
of skill in the art knows how to determine the acidity of an organic acid based on
its given pKa value.
[0026] "Nicotine degradation products" herein refer to any and all nicotine degradation
products and byproducts which are derived from degradation of nicotine overtime to
various possible processes such as, but not limited to, pyrolysis, hydrolysis or similar
processes. This includes "minor tobacco alkaloids" as group of compounds which are
formed by nicotine degradation. Hence, "nicotine degradation products" does not include
other possible impurities from different sources.
[0027] Within this application "shelf life" refers to the storage period under recommended
storage conditions (stable cool temperature, low humidity, no exposure to UV-light)
during which at least 95% of the original nicotine amount is present in unmodified
or undegraded form within the storage container for pharmaceutical applications. Alternatively,
"shelf life" refers to the storage period under recommended storage conditions (stable
cool temperature, low humidity, no exposure to UV-light) during which at least 80%
of the original nicotine amount is present in unmodified or undegraded form within
the storage container for consumer applications.
[0028] The terms "electronic cigarette" or "e-cigarette" or "low temperature vaporization
device" are used herein, refers to an electronic inhaler that vaporizes a liquid solution
into an aerosol mist. These devices are used to simulate and replace the act of tobacco
smoking. The liquid solution comprises a formulation comprising nicotine. The design
of electronic cigarettes is varied and, in some cases, does not resemble conventional
cigarettes. In some cases, the consumer may choose and adjust the administered amount
of nicotine. There are generally three essential components of an electronic cigarette:
a cartridge that serves as a mouthpiece and a reservoir for liquid, an "atomizer"
that vaporizes the liquid, and a battery. Other embodiment electronic cigarettes include
a combined atomizer and reservoir, called a "cartomizer" that may or may not be disposable,
a mouthpiece that may be integrated with the cartomizer or not, and a battery.
[0029] The properties of the nicotine composition are relevant for use and administration.
This is includes "viscosity" of the composition, i.e., the measure of a fluid's resistance
to gradual deformation by shear stress or tensile stress.
[0030] "Water activity" is defined herein as the partial vapor pressure of water in a solution
divided by the standard state partial vapor pressure of water. The standard state
of water is defined as pure water at the same temperature as the solution, i.e., pure
distilled water has a water activity of one.
[0031] The liquid composition comprising nicotine which is used for nicotine administration
in electronic cigarettes are referred to as "e-liquid" herein.
[0032] The nicotine solution may also comprise flavoring components. In this case the carrier
may preferably be propylene glycol. As used herein, the terms "flavor" and "flavorant"
refer to compounds and materials which can be used to create a desired taste or aroma
in a product for adult consumers. Addition of such compounds may be subject to local
regulation and may require regulatory approval. Possible flavorants are selected form
the group comprising flavoring ingredients safe for human inhalation, flavor enhancers,
bitterness receptor site blockers, sensorial receptor site activators or stimulators,
sugars and/or sugar substitutes, and other. They may be synthetic or natural ingredients,
or blends thereof.
FIGURE CAPTIONS
[0033]
Figure 1 shows the structure and different possible protonation state of nicotine
including the free-base (unprotonated: Nic) form as well as the monoprotonated (Nic+) and diprotonated (Nic2+) forms of nicotine which are formed depending on the pH value of the composition.
Figure 2 shows basic chemical information for nicotine. Nicotine is a naturally occurring
alkaloid with a pyridine and a pyrrolidine group. It has two protonation sites on
each nitrogen atom.
Figure 3 shows basic chemical information for lactic acid. Lactic acid has a hydroxyl
group adjacent to a carboxylic group, making it an alpha hydroxy acid (AHA). Lactic
acid has a known high relative safety of any organic acids based on Permissible Daily
Exposure (PDE) data from inhalation studies, and provides a high Safety Factor.
Figure 4 presents a schematical representation of the heating coil. A nichrome coil
is wrapped around an organic cotton plant fiber wick in 6 wraps. The heating coil
is used for vaporization of the nicotine composition of the invention which is provided
within the wick as carrier material. The coil has a resistance of 1.7 ± 0.1 Ω and
a width of 3.5 mm.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION
[0034] The invention of the present application provides an improved composition comprising
nicotine for application in electronic cigarettes for both consumer and nicotine replacement
therapies. The composition of the invention shows increased stability of nicotine
and thus an extended shelf-life of the composition with optimized properties for consumer
satisfaction regarding the sensual experience during consumption, i.e., taste and
throat hit are optimized for according to consumer expectations.
[0035] In one embodiment the present invention relates to a composition comprising a solution
of nicotine (see Figure 2) and lactic acid (see Figure 3), wherein the solvent comprises
non-aqueous solvents or solutions with low water content, wherein the water content
is at least less than 5% (w/w), preferably less than 4% (w/w), more preferably less
than 3% (w/w), more preferably less than 2% (w/w), more preferably less than 1% (w/w),
even more preferably less than 0.5% (w/w) and most preferably less than 0.44% (w/w).
[0036] In an alternative embodiment of the composition of the invention the water content
is defined according to its water activity. In this embodiment of the invention the
water activity is at least below about 0.85, preferably below about 0.5, more preferably
below about 0.4 and most preferably below about 0.35.
[0037] Nicotine salts in solution often degrade via pyrolysis and oxidation into pyridine
and minor tobacco alkaloids. This makes it difficult to quantify the concentration
of nicotine and its minor tobacco alkaloids at a given time in vaporizer e-liquid,
making consistent repeatable dosing of nicotine delivery almost impossible under normal
use conditions.
[0038] Unwanted nicotine degradation may be addressed by improving device and tank design
and minimizing e-liquid exposure to air. Further, appropriate temperature, i.e., cool
storage conditions, are also helpful to control and reduce nicotine degradation. Limiting
airflow to systems using a blister pack or vacuum packaging may further decrease nicotine
degradation. However, these methods may address only part of the problem of degradation,
and none of these methods are currently implementable in a low-waste disposable/recyclable
device system.
[0039] Furthermore, small cartridges that minimize the surface area of the solution to interact
with air tend to improve nicotine stability, and the larger the cartridge or reservoir,
the more interaction and degradation will occur. However, this method of maintaining
stable and consistent nicotine delivery is slow, wasteful, cumbersome, and inconvenient,
potentially deterring users from switching to vaporizers from more harmful combustibles
such as cigarettes.
[0040] Nicotine is prone to oxidation in two locations: the nitrogen-atom within the pyridine
ring and the nitrogen-atom within the pyrrolidine ring. The inventors found that nicotine
degradation may be reduced by protonation of nicotine due to addition of lactic acid
at a 1:2 molar ratio of the nicotine to lactic acid. By adding two protons to the
nicotine molecule, oxidation becomes unfavorable, as electrons are tightly bonded
to protons donated from lactic acid, which is present in solution as lactate.
[0041] Hence, in the composition of the invention lactic acid is added as a stabilizing
agent which is well-known application of lactic acid in drug delivery systems such
as metered dose and dry powder inhalers. Lactic acid has both good stability and a
favorable toxicity profile, thus it is a well-suited stabilizing agent for administration.
Further, lactic acid is a weak acid which can achieve protonation of free-base nicotine
(see Figure 1). Preferably, the composition and the pH of the composition are adjusted
to achieve protonation of both available protonation sites of the nicotine molecule,
i.e., the two N-atoms of both ring structures of nicotine as shown in Figure 1. Lactic
acid is added to the composition in sufficient quantity to achieve significant diprotonation
of nicotine.
[0042] The improved toxicity through reduced degradants and stability of the composition
of the invention is highly relevant for product quality assurance and therefore important
for regulatory approval. The degradation of nicotine salts over time can compromise
the quality of a vaporizer product or an e-liquid batch. Oxidation can induce, but
is not limited to, a color change, viscosity change, foul odor, and inhibit the absorption
of nicotine into the bloodstream, potentially deterring users from switching to vaporizers
from more harmful combustibles such as conventional cigarettes by creating a less
than satisfactory user experience. Moreover, changes in physical and chemical properties
of nicotine can cause problems with manufacturing, processing, storing, and using
nicotine vaporizers. Further, degradation of nicotine may inhibit the ability for
a particular nicotine device to qualify under pharmacopeia standards as a pharmaceutical
system.
[0043] In one embodiment the composition of the invention comprises protonated nicotine
wherein the nicotine is present in the composition in at least 5% diprotonated form
as determined by a suitable analytical procedure which is selected from, but not limited
to,
1H NMR spectrometry or calculation based on the pH value of the composition according
to Henderson-Hasselbalch equation. Preferably nicotine is present in the composition
of the invention in at least 10% diprotonated form, more preferably in at least 15%
diprotonated form, more preferably in at least 20% diprotonated form, more preferably
in at least 25% diprotonated form, more preferably in at least 30% diprotonated form,
more preferably in at least 35% diprotonated form, more preferably in at least 40%
diprotonated form, more preferably in at least 45% diprotonated form, more preferably
in at least 50% diprotonated form, more preferably in at least 55% diprotonated form,
more preferably in at least 60% diprotonated form, more preferably in at least 65%
diprotonated form, more preferably in at least 70% diprotonated form, more preferably
in at least 75% diprotonated form, more preferably in at least 80% diprotonated form,
more preferably in at least 85% diprotonated form, more preferably in at least 90%
diprotonated form, even more preferably in at least 95% diprotonated form and most
preferably in at least 99% diprotonated form.
[0044] Different analytical procedures are available to determine protonation state of the
nicotine within the composition. The skilled person in the field is aware of the available
methods and their application. As exemplary methods either
1H NMR spectrometry or calculation based on the pH value of the composition according
to Henderson-Hasselbalch equation may be used.
[0045] 1H NMR Spectroscopy as based on methodology by Duell et al. may be used to determine
nicotine protonation. Briefly, samples of e-liquids are prepared for different test
conditions and test compositions at the same nicotine concentrations. The control
e-liquid was prepared in propylene glycol : vegetable glycerin (PG : VG, 54 : 46,
v/v). Free-base, monoprotonated and diprotonated standards are prepared by combining
the aliquots of the control sample with suitable base (e.g. t-butylamine : nicotine,
1:1 mol : mol) or with a suitable acid (e.g. acetic acid : nicotine, 5 :1, mol : mol)
to adjust the pH values of the standard samples to achieve the required protonation
state.
[0046] NMR spectroscopy is carried out using precision coaxial NMR inserts with experimental
parameters as described by Duell et al. Nicotine protonation can be calculated based
on difference in chemical shifts between aromatic hydrogens and hydrogens of the methyl
(-CH3) group which connects to protonable nitrogen (N) atoms of the pyrrolidine ring
and pyridine ring. NMR will confirm the proportion of the lactic acid that is present
in its ionic form.
[0047] Alternatively, the relative fraction of different protonation states of nicotine
in solution can be calculated by using the Henderson-Hasselbalch equation based on
the pH determination of the composition of the invention. Henderson-Hasselbalch equation
is based on the following equilibrium between the protonated and unprotonated stats
of a general base:

[0048] The above equilibrium is dependent on pH value. Consequently, the fraction of non-protonated
nicotine will be predominant at high pH levels whilst a decrease in the pH will see
an increase of the fraction of protonated nicotine (mono- and diprotonated nicotine
depending on the pH).
[0049] The Henderson-Hasselbalch equation for the above equilibrium is:

[0050] Where [B] is the amount of non-protonated nicotine (i.e. free base), [BH+] the amount
of protonated nicotine and pKa is the reference pKa value for the pyrrolidine ring
nitrogen of nicotine (pKa=8.02). Nicotine is a diprotic base, wherein each of the
protonation states: unprotonated, monoprotonated and diprotonated have different bioavailability.
Hence, an analogous equilibrium and corresponding equation can be noted and calculated
for the equilibrium between the mono- and diprotonated forms of nicotine, which describes
protonation of pyridine ring nitrogen (pKa=3.12). Based on the above equation the
relative fractions of the available nicotine protonation states can be calculated
from the pH of the composition. If the relative fraction of protonated nicotine and
the total amount of nicotine in the sample are known, the absolute amount of each
nicotine protonation state can be calculated.
[0051] In one embodiment of the invention for the composition of the invention to achieve
a sufficient degree of protonation the molar mixing ratio between nicotine and lactic
acid has to be adjusted. Hence, the composition comprising nicotine according to the
invention comprises nicotine in a molar ratio to lactic acid is between about 0.5:2
and about 1.5:2, preferably between about 0.8:2 and about 1.2:2, more preferably between
about 0.9:2 and about 1.1:2 and most preferably about 1:2. Accordingly, the higher
mixing ration may be needed to achieve near total prevalence of the diprotonated form
and even future improved toxicity, stability, and end user acceptance. However, excess
lactic acid in the solution that does not bind to the nicotine molecule would be superfluously
be present in the composition.
[0052] In one embodiment the composition of the invention may contain different concentrations
of nicotine depending on application. The content of nicotine in the composition is
between about 1-100 mg/ml, preferably between 10-90 mg/ml, more preferably between
15-90 mg/ml, even more preferably between 30-75 mg/ml, even more preferably between
35-65 mg/ml and most preferably between 40-60 mg/ml. The present nicotine concentration
of the composition determines largely the amount of nicotine administered to the subject
with each puff of the electronic cigarettes. Thus, the nicotine concentration affects
the patient's/end user's experience.
[0053] In one embodiment the nicotine used in the invention may be obtained as an extract
from a natural tobacco product.
[0054] In a preferred embodiment of the invention the nicotine used in the invention is
synthetic S-nicotine which is obtained from artificial synthesis. Using synthetic
S-nicotine provides the advantage of higher purity of nicotine than can be obtained
from natural sources. Specifically, this reduces the initial amount of impurities
in form of the presence of minor tobacco alkaloids. Hence, using synthetic S-nicotine
the nicotine solution of the invention has an improved toxicology profile. Any minor
tobacco alkaloids present in the solution of the invention are the direct result of
nicotine degradation over time. Starting from a reduced initial amount of minor tobacco
alkaloids improves the shelf life of the solution of the invention. The purity of
the nicotine used in the composition can be determined by HPLC analysis. Typically,
HPLC analysis on anhydrous basis achieves between 99.0 % and 101.0 % of the nominal
nicotine amount. Analysis of impurities show a total amount of less than 1.0 %. The
composition of the invention comprises initial amounts of minor tobacco alkaloids
impurities of less than 0.1% (w/w), preferably less than 0.05% (w/w), more preferably
less than 0.01% (w/w), more preferably less than 0.005% (w/w), more preferably less
than 0.001% (w/w), even more preferably less than 0.0005% (w/w) and most preferably
less than 0.0001% (w/w). Further, an absence of minor tobacco alkaloids will inevitably
improve in vitro mutagenicity, cytotoxicity and genotoxicity testing results.
[0055] In one embodiment of the composition the carrier of the nicotine solution may be
any suitable solvent such that the nicotine solution can be aerosolized for use. In
one aspect the solvent is selected from glycerol, propylene glycol and mixtures thereof.
In one aspect the solvent is at least glycerol. In one aspect the solvent consists
essentially of glycerol. In one aspect the solvent consists of glycerol. In one aspect
the solvent is at least propylene glycol. In one aspect the solvent consists essentially
of propylene glycol. In one aspect the solvent consists of propylene glycol. In one
aspect the solvent is at least a mixture of propylene glycol and glycerol. In one
aspect the solvent consists essentially of a mixture of propylene glycol and glycerol.
In one aspect the solvent consists of a mixture of propylene glycol and glycerol.
[0056] In a preferred embodiment the composition of the invention comprising nicotine and
lactic acid or other organic acid uses organic solvents with suitable volatility as
commonly used for e-liquids. The solvents of the invention are selected from the group
comprising glycerol and propylene glycol. The skilled person in the field is aware
of different available solvents which may be used to substitute the above solvents.
[0057] In one embodiment the mixing ratio of the solvents of the composition of the invention
can be varied and adjusted depending on application. The ratio of glycerol to propylene
glycol in the composition of the invention is between about 80:20% (v/v) and about
20:80% (v/v).
[0058] In an alternative embodiment of the invention the composition of the invention may
not contain any solvents. The composition of the invention may comprise nicotine and
lactic in solid form as powders for extended storage and subsequent dissolution by
the consumer or patient at a later time.
[0059] As stated above the composition of the invention comprises at least 5% (w/w) of diprotonated
nicotine. This increases stability of nicotine and extends the storage time of the
composition, i.e., the composition the invention achieves an extended shelf life.
In one embodiment the shelf life of the composition of the invention is extended to
at least 1 month, at least 1.5 months, at least 2 months, at least 3 months, at least
4 months, at least 5 months, at least 6 months, at least 7 months, at least 8 months,
at least 9 months, at least 10 months, at least 11 months, at least 1 year, at least
1.5 years, at least 2 years, at least 2.5 years, or at least 3 years.
[0060] Half-life time of nicotine in the composition of the invention or shelf life of the
composition of the invention may be determined by measuring the detectable nicotine
concentration after predefined time intervals and thus determine the intermediate
loss of nicotine due to degradation. Alternatively, the accumulation of nicotine degradation
products may be determined. Accumulation of nicotine degradation products can be measured
by determining the amount of minor tobacco alkaloids. It is important to note that
if the nicotine used for the formulation is laboratory made S-nicotine, no minor tobacco
alkaloids are present at the starting point as very high purity can be achieved for
synthetic S-nicotine without natural impurities or degradation products which are
derived from nicotine extraction form natural sources. Determination of accumulation
minor tobacco alkaloids is in particular relevant to establish best before use dates
and for regulatory approval as these degradation products may cause harm to the patient
or consumer if present in concentrations exceeding the relevant acceptable thresholds.
The concentration of nicotine and minor tobacco alkaloids and other nicotine degradation
products can be determined using HPLC, gas chromatography, mass spectroscopy, spectroscopy
methods using fluorescence or absorption properties of nicotine and its degradation
product and any other suitable approach as known to the skilled person in the field.
[0061] In one embodiment of the composition of the invention the content of minor tobacco
alkaloids present is less than 0.01% (w/w) as determined by HPLC, mass spectroscopy
or other suitable detection method.
[0062] In one embodiment of the invention the increased stability of the composition of
the invention leads to a reduced loss over time of nicotine during storage of the
composition of the invention. Loss of nicotine over time is at least less than 8%/month,
preferably less than 6%/month, more preferably less than 4%/month, more preferably
less than 3%/month, more preferably less than 2%/month, more preferably less than
1.5%/month, more preferably less than 1.0%/month and most preferably less than 0.5%/month.
[0063] In one embodiment the composition of the invention is for use in nicotine replacement
therapy (NRT) wherein the composition is administered by inhalation. The composition
of the invention is administered using an electronic delivery system as such as an
electronic cigarette, a MDI or vaporizer. Wherein administration of the composition
involves vaporization by suitable method as known to the skilled person in the field.
Typically, vaporization is achieved by applying an electrical current to a wire within
a vaporizable solution. The resulting heat of the wire leads subsequently to vaporization
of the nicotine composition.
[0064] In one embodiment the composition of the invention achieves a sensorial experience
comprising an improved "bite" or throat hit when inhaled as determined according to
a VAS survey. As NRTs often lack this key behavioral aspect, and NRTs with this improved
experience will increase the quit rate thus making it a more efficacious quit-smoking
device.
[0065] A visual analog scale (VAS) assessment is commonly and widely used to record and
report a subject's sensations and provide a quantification for individual experience.
For instance, it is possible to record the sensation of smoothness/harshness of the
"bite" when administering the composition of the invention. In this case "very harsh"
and "very smooth" sensation could be defined as the extreme endpoints of a spectrum
of possible sensations. Between the defined endpoints the subjects can quantify their
sensation on a scale (e.g., 0-100 mm). In this instance higher scores, e.g., indicate
a harsher sensation associated with throat hit. Thus, an E-Cigarette Evaluation Questionnaire
(CEQ) is used for determining consumers' assessments of the composition of the invention.
The composition of the invention is optimized in accordance with the recorded consumers'
feedback for improved consumers' satisfaction. A VAS E-Cigarette Evaluation Questionnaire
may comprise the following domains: smoking satisfaction, psychological rewards, aversion,
enjoyment of respiratory tract sensations, and craving reduction among other domains
if required.
[0066] In one embodiment the composition of the invention when used in NRT administers an
amount of nicotine between about 0.00325 mg and about 0.325 mg, preferably between
about 0.05 mg and about 0.3 mg, more preferably between about 0.1 mg and about 0.2
mg, most preferably between about 0.13 and about 0.14mg per inhalation. The amount
of nicotine per inhalation is determined according to Coresta Recommended Method No
81 and ISO 20769:2018. Briefly the conditions of the method are set as follows: 3
second (+/- 0.1 s) duration, 55mL volume (+/- 0.6 mL), and at an interval of 30 seconds
(+/- 0.5 s), repeated 20 times. Further, cigarettes have about 1-2 mg of nicotine
that is actively absorbed by the user, and average inhalations have been reported
to be between 8-12. If assuming the same user behavior, the inhalation of the NRT
to have 0.13/0.14mg per 3 second inhalation equals 1.04/1.12mg (8 inhalations) to
1.56/1.68 mg (12 inhalations), roughly at parity with a cigarette and a likely effective
substitute tool for smokers.
[0067] In another aspect of the invention, it relates to a process for producing the composition
according to invention. The process of preparing the composition of the invention
involves firstly mixing lactic acid and nicotine in a predefined molar ratio according
to the above defined ranges (e.g. 2:1) in a dedicated vessel. No additional application
of heat or pressure is required for the desired reaction of combining the components
and protonation of nicotine to take place. Agitation/Mixing may be required to achieve
homogenous mixing and the desired protonation state. Different devices for mixing
may be used as required, e.g., contrarotating mixers. Nicotine and lactic acid may
be mixed as solid in powder form or as liquids in solution. The result after dissolution
of the mixture is a nicotine lactate solution, which is formed via protonation of
the nicotine molecule at two sites, the nitrogen molecule of the Pyroline group and
the nitrogen molecule of the Pyrrolidine group.
[0068] It is understood that the primary characteristic that would yield an e-liquid which
is incompatible with an ENDS (device) is the viscosity of the e-liquid. Propylene
glycol and glycerol are the primary compounds responsible for product viscosity; however,
an increased water or ethanol content may significantly decrease product viscosity.
E-liquids that are highly viscous may fail to wick to the heating coil at an appropriate
rate and, without safety protection in the device, may result in the formation of
carbonyls or other thermal degradants of the e-liquid.
[0069] Secondary to viscosity, the solvent properties of the e-liquid for both the device
and the primary packaging may result in leachables in the e-liquid. The risk of leachables
in e-liquid is thought to be less of a risk to the consumer unless those leachables
become aerosolized during use. Leachables of large molecular mass are less likely
to become volatile or carried in the aerosol formed during product use.
[0070] Further, the present invention also related to a composition comprising a solution
of nicotine and lactic acid, wherein the composition is obtained by the process described
above.
[0071] In a further aspect of the invention, it relates to a method for delivering the composition
of the invention to subject, wherein the administration of the composition of the
invention involves inhalation of the vaporized composition of the invention. As stated
above vaporization is achieved within an electrical device by applying heat to the
composition of invention and thus the composition is transformed into vapor.
[0072] In another aspect the invention relates to a process for improving the user's sensation
of a vaporized nicotine solution, the processes comprises:
- a. Mixing a composition of the invention comprising nicotine and lactic acid according
to claims wherein nicotine and lactic acid are present at molar ratio of about 1:2,
wherein at least 5% of nicotine is present in a diprotonated form,
- b. Vaporizing the composition,
wherein the improvement of user's sensation is determined according to a VAS questionnaire.
[0073] In another embodiment of the invention instead of lactic acid a different weak organic
acid is used in the composition of the invention to achieve protonation of nicotine.
The composition comprises a solution of nicotine and a weak acid, wherein the solvent
comprises non-aqueous solvents or solutions with low water content, wherein the water
content is less than 5%w/w, preferably less than 4%w/w, more preferably less than
3%w/w, even more preferably less than 2%w/w, even more preferably less than 1°/w/w,
even more preferably less than 0.5%w/w and most preferably less than 0.44%w/w, wherein
the weak acid is characterized by a pKa-value of less than 4.2, preferably less than
4.1, more preferably less than 4.0, even more preferably less than 3.9, even more
preferably less than 3.8, even more preferably less than 3.7, even more preferably
less than 3.6, even more preferably less than 3.5, even more preferably less than
3.4, even more preferably less than 3.3 and most preferably less than 3.2.
[0074] In an alternative embodiment of the composition of the invention the water content
is defined according to its water activity. In this embodiment of the invention the
water activity is at least below about 0.85, preferably below about 0.5, more preferably
below about 0.4 and most preferably below about 0.35.
[0075] In an embodiment of the invention the weak organic acid is selected from the group
comprising 1-hydroxy-2-naphthoic acid, 2,2-dichloroacetic acid, 2-hydroxyethanesulfonic
acid, 2-oxoglutaric acid, 4-acetamidobenzoic acid, 4-aminosalicylic acid, acetic acid,
adipic acid, ascorbic acid (L), aspartic acid (L), benzenesulfonic acid, benzoic acid,
camphoric acid (+), camphor-10-sulfonic acid (+), capric acid (decanoic acid), caproic
acid (hexanoic acid), caprylic acid (octanoic acid), carbonic acid, cinnamic acid,
citric acid, cyclamic acid, dodecyl sulfonic acid, ethane-1,2-disulfonic acid, ethanesulfonic
acid, formic acid, fumaric acid, galactaric acid, gentisic acid, glucoheptonic acid
(D), gluconic acid (D), glucuronic acid (D), glutamic acid, glutaric acid, glycerophosphoric
acid, glycolic acid, hippuric acid, isobutyric acid, lactic acid (DL), lactobionic
acid, lauric acid, maleic acid, malic acid (- L), malonic acid, mandelic acid (DL),
methanesulfonic acid, naphthalene-1,5-disulfonic acid, naphthalene-2-sulfonic acid,
nicotinic acid, oleic acid, oxalic acid, palmitic acid, pamoic acid, propionic acid,
pyroglutamic acid (- L), salicylic acid, sebacic acid, stearic acid, succinic acid,
tartaric acid (+ L), thiocyanic acid, toluenesulfonic acid (p), undecylenic acid or
combinations thereof as provided in patent application
WO2022/152529.
[0076] The composition of the invention can be achieved with a different selection of various
weak organic acids provided the acid may achieve protonation of both protonation sites
of nicotine and is provided in the composition in a sufficient molar ratio to ensure
protonation of nicotine according to the invention. Different weak organic acids will
further affect users' sensation when consuming the composition of the invention. For
optimized users' sensation appropriate VAS questionnaires need to be performed to
determine users' sensation and to adjust the compositions accordingly.
[0077] The increased degree of protonation of nicotine in the nicotine composition of the
invention achieves the improved stability and sensory properties for the consumer
as described above. Further, the improved stability as well as the use of synthetic
S-nicotine with very high purity improves the toxicology of the product as there are
less impurities some of which are toxic. However, toxicology is also affected by the
means of aerosolization of the nicotine composition of the invention. The key features
relevant to generating an aerosol comes from elements of the reservoir, the heating
chamber, and the heating element.
[0078] For the composition of the invention aerosolization was achieved using a Nichrome
coil with organic cotton plant fiber wick and a silicone coil holder. The coil has
a resistance of 1.7 ± 0.1 Ω. The width of the coil is 3.5 mm and the coil is wound
around the wick in 6 wraps. Each warp of the heating coils are arranged with a distance
of 1mm between neighboring wraps. This achieves sufficient distance between each wrap
to avoid overheating of the nicotine composition during aerosolization. Overheating
of the nicotine composition is an important contributor to the formation of toxic
compounds during aerosolization. Hence, the described heating coil also contributes
to the reduction of toxic components in the aerosol and the improved toxicological
properties of the nicotine composition of the invention. For aerosolization a polymer
lithium-ion battery is used with 3.7 V and 350 mAh. Further, a 2 ml PCTG liquid chamber
is used.
REFERENCES
EXAMPLES
Example 1: Formulation of test compositions
[0080] The composition of the invention was tested for two new tobacco products with distinct
formulations. The formulations are either RED TOBACCO or SMOOTH TOBACCO, which both
have relatively high glycerol content (table 1). Glycerol content is typically referred
to as a ratio of propylene glycol to glycerol or VG:PG.
Table 1: The glycerol to propylene glycol solvents ratio of the test compositions
FLAVOR |
VG:PG |
RED TOBACCO |
55:45 |
SMOOTH TOBACCO |
55:45 |
[0081] The components of the test composition are listed below in tables 2 and 3.
Table 2: Composition of Smooth Tobacco E-liquid
% w/w |
CAS |
FEMA # |
Ingredient |
Classification |
3.52 |
54-11-5 |
|
Nicotine |
Active |
3.9093 |
50-21-5 |
2611 |
Lactic Acid |
Stabilizer |
0.4344 |
7732-18-5 |
|
Water |
Excipient |
41.4504 |
57-55-6 |
2940 |
1,2-Propylene glycol |
Excipient |
50.3963 |
56-81-5 |
2525 |
Glycerin |
Excipient |
0.2896 |
|
|
Flavorants |
Flavor |
Table 3: Composition of Red Tobacco E-liquid
% w/w |
CAS |
FEMA # |
Ingredient |
Classification |
3.5200 |
54-11-5 |
|
Nicotine |
Active |
3.9093 |
50-21-5 |
2611 |
Lactic Acid |
Stabilizer |
0.4344 |
7732-18-5 |
|
Water |
Excipient |
39.4235 |
57-55-6 |
2940 |
1,2-Propylene glycol |
Excipient |
50.7900 |
56-81-5 |
2525 |
Glycerin |
Excipient |
1.9228 |
|
|
Flavorants |
Flavor |
[0082] The above listed compositions (table 2 and 3) according to the invention were characterized
by their physicochemical properties and tested for nicotine stability and shelf life
as well as for harmful or potentially harmful components according to FDA requirements.
[0083] Samples which are subject to stability testing have been stored in long term storage
conditions as detailed within ICH Q1A guidance at 25°C ± 2°C/65% RH ± 5% (relative
humidity). For each sample conditions different batches were prepared and all measurements
were at least performed in triplicates.
Example 2: Harmful and potentially harmful constituents
[0084] A harmful or potentially harmful constituents (HPHC) analysis was conducted to identify
a potential increase in degradants or leachables of the initially prepared composition
and after a 3 month storage period to test shelf-life. Analysis was performed on the
test solutions after aerosolization. Aerosolization was achieved using a Nichrome
coil with organic cotton plant fiber wick and a silicone coil holder. The coil has
a resistance of 1.7 ± 0.1 Ω. The width of the coil is 3.5 mm and the coil is wound
around the wick in 6 wraps. For aerosolization a polymer lithium-ion battery is used
with 3.7 V and 350 mAh. A schematical representation of the heating coil is shown
in Fig. 4.
[0085] In accordance with FDAs guidance to industry issued in June 2019 (
Premarket Tobacco Product Applications for Electronic Nicotine Delivery Systems, FDA
2019), the inventors evaluated the new tobacco products for the risk of harmful or potentially
harmful constituents. A number of FDA's indicative list of 31 compounds includes a
number of compounds which are added as part of the product formulations including;
glycerol, menthol, nicotine, propylene glycol and vanillin. Complete testing on all
of FDA's list of HPHCs were measured in the aerosol generated using the applicant's
device as disclosed in US provisional application
US 63/431,735 filed on September 19, 2022, and following the below standard regime. US provisional application
US 63/431,735 is hereby included by reference into the present application regarding the technical
specifications of the applied device for vaporization.
[0086] The amount of nicotine as well as harmful and potentially harmful constituents per
inhalation is determined according to Coresta Recommended Method No 81 and ISO 20769:2018.
Briefly the conditions of the method are set as follows: 3 second (+/- 0.1 s) duration,
55mL volume (+/- 0.6 mL), and at an interval of 30 seconds (+/- 0.5 s), repeated 20
times (Puffing regime see table 4).
[0087] As it stands, there are currently no accepted or recognized specifications/standards
for intense puffing regimes for ENDS products. The following justification; therefore,
draws on previously conducted studies relating to user topography. Belushkin et al.,
(2018) proposes that this regime is reasonable with regard to the robustness of the
product's aerosol emissions.
Table 4: Puffing regimes applied for aerosol sampling
REGIME |
VOLUME |
DURATION |
PERIOD |
NUMBER |
PROFILE |
STANDARD |
55mL |
3 see |
30 see |
20 |
Square wave |
± 0.6ml |
± 0.1 see |
± 0.5 see |
[0088] The standard regime represents an airflow of 1.1 l/min air
Example 3: Shelf-life verification (stability study) for compositions of invention
[0089] The purpose of the stability study is to establish, based on testing a minimum of
three (3) batches of the drug product, a shelf-life and label storage instructions
applicable to all future batches of the new tobacco product manufactured and packaged
under similar circumstances. The degree of variability of individual batches affects
the confidence that a production batch will remain within specification throughout
its shelf life.
[0090] A 3-month shelf-life study was performed to evaluate the quality of the applicant's
products over their intended shelf-life. Samples are to be assessed for; pH, appearance,
nicotine assay and nicotine-related substances at predefined intervals through shelf-life.
Additionally, water activity, total yeast and mold, total aerobic microbial count
and confirmation of absence of a number of microorganisms were performed at the start
and end of product shelf-life test periods. Due to the anti-microbial properties of
glycerol, propylene glycol and nicotine, and the absence of added water to the formulations
of the new tobacco products, it was anticipated that the microbial specification of
the product will be met without concern.
Physicochemical Properties of the Samples
[0091] Three attributes were assessed as part of the physical testing of the e-liquids during
stability: pH, water activity and appearance. Monitoring changes in pH over time can
indicate chemical change in the product as a result of degradation or leachable from
the packaging. Appearance was monitored at each timepoint to ensure no visible degradation
of the product occurs. Within a 3 month test period no degradation was observed all
test samples showed clear liquids which were free from any particles. The color of
the liquid was orange for Red Tobacco batches and yellow for Smooth Tobacco batches.
Quantified physicochemical information on the average of test batches are provided
below in table 5.
Table 5: Physical properties of sample formulations
|
Mean Nicotine Amount (mg/g) |
Mean pH-value |
Mean Water Activity |
Red Tobacco |
31.81±0.7172 |
4.14±0.0156 |
0.32±0.0133 |
Smooth Tobacco |
32.15±0.1205 |
4.11±0.0464 |
0.34±0.0097 |
Chemical Testing
[0092] Two primary chemical tests were conducted as part of the shelf-life study. An assay
of nicotine was performed to ensure that the product properties remain within an acceptable
tolerance throughout product shelf life. A significant decrease in nicotine assay
may indicate an increase in the level of related substances. Related substances will
also be monitored throughout product shelf life. Nicotine n oxide, cotinine and myosmine
are three nicotine degradants (due to oxidation, biological activity and reaction
with water respectively). Nicotine n oxide and cotinine are understood to be the major
related substances which are likely to form over the course of the products shelf-life.
According to the observed data, the data indicate clearly that there is no concern
of safety issues relating to an increase in nicotine related substances. Nicotine
impurities were certified as part of quality control and material sourcing/certification.
Nicotine complying with compendial specifications is used in the manufacture of the
new tobacco products. Additionally, evaluation of N-nitrosonornicotine (NNN) and 4-(methylnitrosamino)1-(3-pyridyl)-1-butanone
(NNK) levels in the aerosol were performed as part of the stability testing. NNN and
NNK are tobacco-specific nitrosamines (TSNAs) classified as carcinogenic chemicals.
The aim of the NNN and NNK assessment is to confirm the product safety.
[0093] Below tables 6 and 7 present the obtained stability data for tested nicotine formulations.
Nicotine degradants (nicotine n oxide, cotinine and myosmine) and TSNAs (NNN and NNK)
could not be detected in the samples. The data clearly indicate that the compositions
of the invention are at least stable for 3 months without detrimental loss of nicotine
or accumulation of toxic degradation products of nicotine. The presented data indicate
stable nicotine within the test samples with only minimal loss of nicotine over the
observation period.
Table 6: 3 months stability of Red Tobacco samples (40 mg/
ml Nicotine)
|
Nicotine (mg/g); t=0 |
Nicotine (mg/g); t= 3 months |
Loss after 3 months |
Average loss |
Sample 1 |
33.82 |
31.11 |
8.0 |
5.4%±0.0248 |
Sample 2 |
33.47 |
32.44 |
3.1 |
Sample 3 |
33.6 |
31.88 |
5.1 |
Table 7: 3 months stability of Smooth Tobacco samples (40 mg/
ml Nicotine)
|
Nicotine (mg/g); t=0 |
Nicotine (mg/g); t= 3 months |
Loss after 3 months |
Average loss |
Sample 1 |
32.42 |
32.07 |
1.1 |
2.8%±0.0175 |
Sample 2 |
33.66 |
32.12 |
4.6 |
Sample 3 |
33.14 |
32.26 |
2.7 |
[0094] Sample compositions were tested for further possible impurities, harmful or potentially
harmful constituents. The further tested constituents are listed below in table 8.
The constituents as listed in table 8 were either not detected within the sample compositions
or detected at below the relevant threshold level. Thus, the tested sample compositions
are acceptable according to the toxicology review.
Table 8: List of tested harmful or potentially harmful constituents
Acetaldehyde |
Acetyl propionyl |
Acrolein |
Acrylonitrile |
Benzene |
Benzaldehyde |
Benzyl acetate |
Butyraldehyde |
Cadmium |
Chromium |
Cinnamaldehyde |
Crotonaldehyde |
Diacetyl |
Diethylene glycol |
Ethyl acetate |
Ethyl acetoacetate |
Ethyl vanillin |
Ethylene glycol |
Formaldehyde |
Furfural |
Glycerol |
Glycidol |
Isopentyl acetate |
Isobutyl acetate |
Lead |
Menthol |
Methyl acetate |
N-Butanol |
Nickel |
Nicotine |
4-(methylnitrosamino)1-(3-pyridyl)-1-butanone (NNK) |
N-nitrosonornicotine (NNN) |
Propionic acid |
Propylene glycol |
Propylene oxide |
Toluene |
Vanillin |
|
|
|
Microbial testing
[0095] Water activity and evaluation of bioburden and confirmation of the absence of certain
microorganisms was performed at the start and end of product shelf-life test periods.
Compendial limits for TAMC, TYMC, an absence of S. Aureus, P. Aeruginosa and bile
tolerant gram-negative bacteria have been applied to the new tobacco products specifications.
It is understood that formulations comprising propylene glycol, glycerol and nicotine
have inherent antimicrobial properties, this may be due to the humectant properties
of propylene glycol and glycerol in combination with nicotine's antibacterial properties
for gram-negative bacteria. In contrast to other types of tobacco product, products
containing tobacco (as opposed to just nicotine) and which have a water activity greater
than 0.85 will likely present an increased risk of microbial viability.